topamax discount get cheap speman work buy aricept france order flomax side cheap ortho tri cyclen reviews cheap prandin a prescription order nitroglycerin ointment order singulair fractional cheap brand cialis delivery buy crestor rosuvastatin cheap v gel intimate lubricant buy celebrex canadian pharmacy hair loss discount emedicine buy tamoxifen online buy zyvox malaysia pain relief discount back buy speman medicine buy seroquel quickly buy tretinoin 0,05 buy finast cheap brand levitra pills clomid discount card cheap hair loss keratin buy zovirax boots order erectile dysfunction low testosterone trazodone to buy buy ashwagandha leaves weight loss amitriptyline to buy online femara discount coupon cheap zanaflex prescription cheap ortho tri cyclen hair loss order remeron qtc buy levitra plus mg online buy clindamycin australia buy elocon online uk order effexor xr drug interactions buy rosuvastatin africa order v gel side effects buy yasmin usa shuddha guggulu discount for thyroid pain relief discount arthritis cialis soft discount sublingual cheap advair diskus half life zaditor discount online order rogaine 5 kirkland rogaine cheap viagra with prescription zantac discount generic order cialis super active vs professional buy clomid paypal order wellbutrin sr dosage range buy hcg clomid nolvadex buy olanzapine in nz buy glucotrol xl of action cheap viagra jelly canada online cheap cafergot get order vasotec australia cheap cleocin gel during pregnancy buy female cialis paypal buy revatio new york order pain relief with uti buy viagra professional information cheap retino-a cream 0,05 tretinoin order alphagan generic buying zyban thailand cheap generic imitrex men;s health subscription deals buy trazodone in thailand order cymbalta kong cheap cholesterol lowering quickly voltaren copay coupon cheap rental in florida tretinoin 0 05 discount prozent cheap levitra last cialis jelly discount mg generic zoloft by greenstone order zoloft rx order pilex express buy himalaya confido in india order synthroid brand ortho tri cyclen discount depression allopurinol discount get order innopran xl gsk ortho tri cyclen discount quick start method naprosyn discount vouchers ayurslim discount vouchers order remeron can buy viagra super active does it work cheap cialis super active and cialis professional buy cheap ventolin inhalers cheap clomid pills buy prometrium suppositories online order tadalis sx cena cheap cytotec the counter order cialis soft gel caps order finpecia legit buy unisom liquid men;s health discount week buy azulfidine tablets cheap cholesterol lowering exercise and diet order wellbutrin sr experiences order benfotiamine benefits buy revia the counter female cialis discount how does viagra professional discount price order dramamine video order meclizine illegal cheap effexor xr withdrawal where can i buy propecia yahoo order acyclovir online uk buy elocon generic diclofenac gel discount the counter buy floxin tablet order kamagra from india buy clindamycin phosphate gel order actoplus met warnings cheap cytoxan buy aricept eu buy januvia rx abilify savings program buy triamterene singapore buy viagra soft without consultation cheap kamagra gel buy ethionamide canada cheap flagyl er ute av kroppen buy arava vancouver cheap wellbutrin sr manufacturer coupons buy cialis jelly review sleep aid discount effective buy doxycycline for dogs order zetia in canada cheap lanoxin australia cheap vytorin australia buy men;s health pl buy strattera cheap synthroid discount voucher buy zenegra sk cheap viagra super active dosage buy men;s health deltafit order propecia online cheap viagra plus thailand buy zithromax at walgreens cheap viagra soft pills kamagra cheap generic pain relief discount carpal tunnel buy ortho tri cyclen reviews acne sumycin discount code cheap chewable kamagra buy cholesterol lowering exercise cheap lady era rock order revia prescription order hydrochlorothiazide side cheap viagra alternatives uk order terramycin chickens order arjuna mahabarata cheap rental cars buy cytotec malaysia buy inderal real buy prandin dogs buy viagra plus brisbane buy inderal quickly buy viagra levitra and cialis liv 52 discount syrup order skelaxin by mail cialis super active discount cialis cheap viagra super active x 10 pill order avapro online buy propranolol uk order pain relief shingles cheap zestril online order viagra soft tabs buy cystone procardia discount coupon alli buy buy cheap shuddha guggulu nadwaga buy famvir line cheap ortho tri cyclen vs yasmin buy nolvadex liquid buy tricor in thailand cheap azithromycin online buy real singulair cheap ortho tri cyclen as emergency contraception cheap zithromax online buy xenical weight loss pills order lisinopril side buy viagra plus jelly online cheap januvia version hair loss discount laser treatment buy purinethol line cheap apcalis sx fu"r frauen buy seroquel online australia order rogaine 5 biovea zoloft get high order hair loss from stress methotrexate discount voucher periactin discount voucher cheap kamagra gold opis cholesterol lowering discount natural supplements order requip line kamagra gold discount nebenwirkungen buy ginette 35 online cheap root canal new jersey nexium prescription savings card order prandin bula cheap capoten price imitrex discount program order motilium generic buy shallaki ayurveda buy tadalis sx where to buy cabergoline uk ponstel discount card order benfotiamine generic where can i buy zofran in the uk buy rhinocort aqua online cheap prandin work order hydrochlorothiazide buy orlistat canada cheapest lariam tablets cheap lasix rx buy ventolin for nebulizer buy amantadine online buy clomid 100mg online buy ginseng tea online buy viagra soft york city order requip high cleocin gel discount ingredients buy kamagra oral jelly dosage buy cholesterol lowering green smoothie phenergan discount code cheap provigil cheap viagra xanthi order crestor coupon buy ortho tri cyclen depression cheap revatio for sale cholesterol lowering discount naturally order benzaclin buy cefixime you buy abilify japan order femara rx buy elocon uk diclofenac gel discount dosage remeron discount prescription buy viagra professional dosage buy purinethol generic cheap pariet order revia online order hair loss while breastfeeding order benfotiamine malaysia buy cialis canada yahoo answers order hair loss help cheap plendil lek can i buy antivert over the counter order moduretic viagra soft discount under the tongue order vytorin bula buy triamterene for cheap order actoplus met medication guide buy ventolin germany order tinidazole herx cheap lisinopril side cheap viagra jelly review cheap atacand hct buy online mentat himalaya buy nimotop ulotka celebrex cost per month buy nitrofurantoin in europe order brand name cialis online order voveran sr daily dosage order abana insurance order erectile dysfunction supplements buy tenormin australia order anti fungal body soap cheap rosuvastatin generic buy amantadine kuala lumpur cheap ginette 35 online buy lamisil cream uk cheap shuddha guggulu for hypothyroidism order lopid dosage buy urispas korea cheap viagra generic 100mg cheap ceftin generation cheap lotensin bula buy revia liquid order weight loss calculator cheap isoptin retard buy avodart canada buy triamterene in thailand cheap atorlip 10 sirve buy aygestin levitra discount prices order zyvox prescription liv 52 discount side effects topamax mail order order lasix overnight delivery sustiva discount prescription order motilium xarope order propecia vancouver buy penegra tablet buy rogaine 2 solution cheap betapace cheap kamagra oral jelly malaysia order coreg order brands amoxicillin philippines buy singulair 10 mg order ginseng xertigny buy hydroxyurea online zoloft get you high rogaine 2 discount solution buy haldol buy rogaine 5 year study cheap effexor xr tapering buy premarin from canada buy viagra plus from boots buy periactin you cheap prednisolone eye buy xenical canada buy bupropion sr drug interactions order prednisone xanax cheap ortho tri cyclen missed period order reminyl retard isoptin discount code buy cozaar vidal buy cipro quin cheap viramune prescription cholesterol lowering discount alternatives to statins cheap chloramphenicol yeast rumalaya forte discount gout order naprosyn high cheap ophthacare cheap desyrel generic buy aldactone online buy triamterene uses buy celexa xanax order accutane now buy xenical yuen long buy tadalis sx von ajanta pharma buy innopran xl tremors order weight loss on paleo diet cheap zyvox work cheap brand levitra last cymbalta discount coupon cheap ginette 35 wiki discount for benicar hct order alesse 21 online buy men;s health problems cheap glucophage very buy lipitor online usa buy singulair dublin buy aricept bali buy propecia australia buy prandin vegas cheap rhinocort ulotka cheap advair diskus reviews kamagra gold discount tapasztalat buy zofran dosage cheap tegretol side cheap voveran sr tablet buy uroxatral dosage cheap crestor version order pilex tablet zyvox discount generic buy tretinoin 0 05 harga vitacid buy capoten prescription order pain relief of gout cheap actoplus met savings card imitrex discount vouchers buy viagra sublingual no brasil urispas discount get order diclofenac gel evaluation buy motilium suspension buy famvir best place kamagra gold discount side effects buy revatio vegas buy rosuvastatin for cheap buy myambutol can mobic discount order effexor xr birth defects cheap antabuse cheap unisom version order pain relief natural buy zetia us discount for celebrex pravachol discount card crestor discount prices stromectol discount benemid discount voucher buy crestor vidal buy alphagan wiki buy hydrochlorothiazide dosage cheap anti viral avg antivirus order premarin status buy l tryptophan libido order revia mail order apcalis sx oral jelly review buy amitriptyline you buy kamagra with paypal order metformin rx buy ginseng singapore effexor xr discount vs lexapro cheap viagra uk paypal order avalide buy nolvadex south africa buy olanzapine london order mircette libido order compazine dosage order paxil legal order alavert status buy gas x online buy prednisolone liquid cheap casodex buy cheap hytrin a prescription order cardizem in canada birth order food allergies urispas discount pharmacy bystolic discount card forest buy kamagra soft bestellen buy requip japan buy bupropion sr get you high buy levitra plus bayer order desyrel kilo buy seroquel japan order mircette lawsuit buy can can slip order diamox from india rumalaya forte discount review cheap lady era in waiting dutas discount generic order femara multiples where to buy real cytotec order of skincare products wellbutrin sr discount headaches kamagra gold discount dejstvo cheap cholesterol lowering vitamins seroquel xr prices cheap ortho tri cyclen cost without insurance order atorlip 20 tabletas 20 mg discount on provigil buy periactin online mango track order uk viagra jelly discount coupons online buy aygestin uses buy flonase 120 order v gel polish sleep aid discount lavender order decadron shot order v gel airway antabuse discount buy cozaar discount coupons buy viagra jelly online buy minipress nightmares order propecia queensferry order pain relief xanax cheap mevacor bula order protonix uses buy ditropan xl online buy benfotiamine powder buy kamagra oral jelly paypal buy propranolol zealand diclofenac gel discount and pregnancy order erythromycin dosage cholesterol lower discount it naturally noroxin discount voucher azulfidine discount program cheap crestor 10mg buy l tryptophan msds order coumadin levels buy malegra fxt fluoxetine 100 40 mg order mango singapore cheap ginette 35 you gain weight buy gasex himalaya buy tricor korea ortho tri cyclen discount acne reviews cheap neurontin buy amitriptyline 10mg online cheap paroxetine generic order rosuvastatin generic buy propecia dublin buy anti fungal eye drops buy capoten from usa prazosin order online depressive order cholesterol lowering discount ldl naturally mango languages discount code buy erythromycin houston cheap diclofenac gel online cheap propecia nz buy rhinocort generic cheap effexor xr forum buy mevacor have buy alavert d 12 order neurontin dosage buy hydrea at walmart order zanaflex safe buy minocycline uk buy mircette uk cheap hair loss cheap arimidex in usa buy alavert used order sinemet plus zeroth order kinetics pain relief discount kidney stones
Home All Articles Six Views on Former Commissioner Bowie Kuhn

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 835 guests online

Atom RSS

Six Views on Former Commissioner Bowie Kuhn PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 7
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Various Authors   
Thursday, 22 March 2007 07:28

Biz of Baseball ExclusiveLast Thursday, former commissioner Bowie Kuhn died at the age of 80 due to complications from pneumonia. Statements from both Commissioner Selig and Executive Director Fehr were released shortly thereafter remarking about Kuhn as a man and as former commissioner.

Kuhn ad The following day, the likes of Hal Bodley of USA Today, and Richard Goldstein of the NY Times talked of what Kuhn meant historically. MLB ran a full page ad in USA Today in his honor (see the image to the right, and click to see it in higher resolution)

Today, a selection of six notables that either knew Kuhn directly, or have studied him and his tenure will weigh in on his legacy. The list includes (in alphabetical order):

  • Buzzie Bavasi – Bavasi, who has been, and continues to be on the Hall of Fame ballot for the Veterans Committee, was a key player in the front offices of the Dodgers, Padres, and Angels. Bavasi’s tenure overlapped with Kuhn’s.
  • Maury Brown – Founder of BizOfBaseball.com, Maury Brown’s Biz of Sports, and an author for Baseball Prospectus. Brown is the former co-chair of SABR’s Business of Baseball committee.
  • Tim Lemke – Lemke is currently the sports business reporter for the Washington Times.
  • Roger Noll – Noll is Professor Emeritus of Economics, at Stanford University and has written extensively on baseball economics.
  • Tal Smith – Smith is the president of player development for the Houston Astros, and was at Kuhn’s funeral on Tuesday (read the Biz of Baseball interview with Smith).
  • Andrew Zimbalist – Zimbalist serves as the Robert A. Woods Professor of Economics at Smith College, and has written several books on sports economics, including the recently released, In the Best Interests of Baseball? The Revolutionary Reign of Bud Selig, which touches on Kuhn’s tenure. (read the Biz of Baseball interviews with Zimbalist from 2006 and 2004).

In compiling these thoughts on Kuhn, an interesting trend emerged: those that knew well of him personally had high praise for the former commissioner. Those that viewed him from an academic standpoint or knew of him only in passing, had views that were somewhat less flattering regarding his place in history.

Below are six views of former commissioner Bowie Kuhn. (select Read More for details)

Buzzie Bavasi - I put Bowie right behind Ford Frick and to me Ford was the best.

The day he was dismissed as commissioner, Bowie and Luisa (Kuhn’s wife) asked Evit, my wife, and myself out to dinner. Not once during that two hour period did Bowie say anything critical of the folks that dismissed him. However, I had plenty to say.

At the meeting (to dismiss Kuhn before the dinner), Ted Turner, went into a tirade about Bowie’s 15 years as commissioner. I interrupted and read a clipping that was in the N.Y. Daily news the week before. It read, "This is such a good TV package that I have changed my mind and am voting for Bowie". I asked who was being quoted. No one acknowledged the quote. I finally said to Ted, “This is your quote, Ted." "Yeah,” said Turner. “But I hadn't read the contract when I made that statement." Think that tells you everything.

Maury Brown – I was fortunate enough to interview Kuhn in 2005, and could count on one hand the number of phone calls I had with him. Sadly, I was left with a sense that he was not the warmest man, and my view of him historically is one of seeing a man at a particular place in history, rather than a man who proactively made history. Maybe that is due to my limited access to the man personally. Maybe my distance allows me to be unfettered by personal experience. Be that as it may, here are my views on the man’s tenure.

Much has been made of how player salaries escalated during his tenure. The AP in reporting his death mentioned that when his tenure started in February of 1969, the average salary was $19,000 and by the end of his tenure, the average salary was nearly $330,000. This was more the doing of Marvin Miller than anything as Kuhn fought through multiple legal channels to overturn the reserve clause, which allowed for the rapid escalation in salary growth. Yet, his actions actually worked in the players favor. As Miller said in his autobiography, “His inability to distinguish between reality and his prejudices, his lack of concern for the rights of players, sections of the press, and even the stray unpopular owner—all combined to make Kuhn a vital ingredient in the growth and strength of the union. To paraphrase Voltaire on God, if Bowie Kuhn had never existed, we would have had to invent him.”

Miller’s accounting of Kuhn seems to encapsulate my views on him: a man that was at some of the most important moments in baseball history, who was not the visionary of those moments, but rather a man that seemed to simply react to them, thereby creating history.

When I asked him if he had any regrets in life, his response seems to further this view of mine. “On Jim Bouton’s book, Ball Four, I expressed some reservations about his story in the clubhouse matters—which in baseball were considered sacrosanct—and I did nothing but sell the book,” Kuhn said. “I wouldn't do that again.”

In Kuhn’s defense, he viewed himself as an overseer of the great game of baseball, without the understanding that he was simply an employer of the owners—the CEO model with which Selig seems to embrace. There is little doubt in my mind that Kuhn cared deeply about baseball and acted in what he viewed in his mind was in its best interest. It seems the times changed around Kuhn, and he—and many of the owners of the day—simply did not grasp the fundamental shift that occurred when Miller and the Player’s Association made their ascension.

And in that, maybe I’m being too harsh on Kuhn. After all, he was a product of the owners and acting mostly on their behalf.

Kuhn’s undoing is that he not only fought back the players, but also fought with the owners. Certainly Finley despised him when he overturned the trades of Joe Rudi and Rollie Fingers to the Red Sox, along with Vida Blue to the Yankees—Finley’s infamous fire sale. And it wasn’t just Finley; Steinbrenner, and Ted Turner were others he alienated.

So, it was a sad day when Kuhn passed. But, it should be sad, for the reasons that the passing of any one person when they leave this mortal coil. For his family. For his friends. History, on the other hand, may view Kuhn as less of an imposing figure, than he was physically in life.

Tim Lemke - No baseball commissioner will ever be beloved by everyone. All of the game's top executives have left a bag of mixed reactions, and Bowie Kuhn is no exception. But there is really only one question you need to answer when evaluating a commissioner's career: was baseball in better shape at the end of his tenure than at the beginning of it? In Kuhn's case, it's clear that the answer is yes.

Kuhn oversaw one of the biggest explosions in the game's popularity, as attendance nearly doubled during his 16 years at the helm. Without Kuhn, prime-time baseball would have come along much later and the television contracts enjoyed by the league would be smaller in scale. Yes, the strike in 1981 was messy, but history will show that the stoppage of 1994 was considerably more damaging to baseball.

I never knew Kuhn, and was just a boy when he left the game. But I did have the pleasure of speaking to him last year when he openly campaigned--successfully--for baseball to select his former classmate Ted Lerner to be the new owner of the Nationals.

My favorite anecdote relates to his creation of a "lifetime baseball pass" for all 52 of the Iran hostages after they were brought home in 1981. Given the current world climate, that seems like an idea worth renewing. In fact, it's a pretty darn good idea no matter what the situation. Let's call it the Bowie Kuhn Pass, and hand out a few thousand of them with our thanks.

Roger Noll - Bowie Kuhn was a better Commissioner than most, which I admit is rather like declaring the nicest day in January in Duluth.

Baseball Commissioner is a tough job.  Superficially, the Commissioner has great power, but because the owners employ the Commissioner at will, no one can long survive in office without running the game in the interests of most owners as they perceive it at the time. And their perception of their own interest is not always accurate.  Just ask Fay Vincent.

Bowie Kuhn did many things that most regard as prudish or wrong-headed.  But he was an effective advocate and facilitator of the world view of owners in the 1960s and 1970s.  And sometimes he surprised people.

His most courageous act was ending the lock-out after the McNally-Messersmith decision threatened to make all players free agents within a year.  Whereas no one believed more deeply in the (incorrect) proposition that free-agency could destroy baseball, Kuhn also stood up to a majority of owners who were willing to shut down the sport if the players would not agree to give back what they had won in the arbitration process.  By ending the lock-out, Kuhn did more than save the start of the 1976 season, he also changed the terms of the debate between labor and management, and thereby ushered in the modern era of free agency.  Marvin Miller was the architect, but Kuhn cleared the site.

We do not know precisely why Kuhn lost his job, but the leading candidates were issues of principle: drugs and collusion.

Kuhn vigorously tried to cleanse baseball of hard drugs, which did not go down well with some owners when a valuable player was suspended.  While his policies and actions may have been excessively harsh, at least they were clear and fairly implemented, unlike baseball's current policies and practices regarding performance-enhancing drugs. Second, while he had as much distaste for high player salaries as any owner, he also favored playing by the rules.  His successor happily facilitated collusion over player salaries.  This lapse of judgment cost baseball dearly:  hundreds of millions in damages, plus poisoning the collective bargaining relationship that led to the debacle of 1994.

So farewell, Bowie.  You did a pretty fair job, given the times and the people that you worked for.

Tal Smith - I thought Bowie was a fine man and a good commissioner.

The landscape was far different during his administration.  They were trying times.  The union was flexing its muscles which resulted in a great deal of labor strife.  And Bowie's constituency - the clubs and their owners - was difficult and, in some case cases, irascible.

Bowie loved baseball and was well steeped in its history.  He governed so as to do everything in his power to preserve and protect the game's integrity and to foster its growth.  He served it well with class and dignity.

Andrew Zimbalist - One never wants to be disrespectful at such times, so it is uncomfortable when the imperative  for truth is so strong. As I said to Gordon Edes of the Boston Globe on the matter, I think Bowie established a pattern of antagonism and acrimony and distrust between the owners and players in the 1970s that took baseball 25-plus years to work through.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?