generic viagra testimonial viagra 100mg sideeffect stopping lexapro 5mg prezzi cialis generico cheap viagra substitutes viagra femenino generico buy some cialis viagra 500mg. zoloft 5omg generic prednisone names ebay clomid 100mg compare levitra 20 mg augmentin 375 mg cena 25 mg zoloft effective lexapro 10mg pregnant buy liquid prednisone kamagra 160 mg bactrim 200 40 mg dosis farmaco levitra 5 mg cheap viagra made buy sertraline zoloft kamagra 50mg erowid buy viagra abroad lexapro cheap india nexium generic there augmentin 875 mg indicatii levitra 10 mg dispersable lexapro generic oval lisinopril 40 mg erfahrungsberichte cialis 20mg cialis 40mg prescriptions generic zovirax buy generic 24 cialis 20mg cialis splitting augmentin 400 mg fiyat viagra original online amoxil 200 mg zithromax 500mg online buy 20 mg cialis buy kamagra 7 days glucophage metformin 850 mg diflucan fluconazol 50 mg nexium sobres 2.5 mg doxycycline 100 mg palu nolvadex 20 mg uk order levitra pills medicine lisinopril 10 mg webmd generic cialis strattera online order xenical philippines buy kamagra soft 50mg viagra 12.5 mg enough augmentin 875 125 mg pret erythromycin 500 mg pills augmentin 625 mg dawkowanie cialis 5 mgm tabs craigslist generic viagra zoloft 50 mg quit buy clomid quick lexapro cheap generic 400 mg celebrex safe online propecia review order Cialis Jelly 60 teva wellbutrin generic 6generic propecia alternative celebrex 220 mg buy amoxil antibiotic nexium 40 mg english generic diflucan online levitra 20mg directions 75 mg zoloft lot cipro 4 mg generic viagra wirkung viagra 8000mg najlepsza viagra 150 mg cheap meltabs viagra buy invisible viagra lexapro mg dose lexapro generic withdraws buying merk propecia buy authintic viagra viagra buy it lexapro generic canada buy viagra 10 mg lisinopril 10 or 20 mg viagra 150 mg safe order propecia online 150mg. viagra cialis tabletas 20 mg. vibramycin 100 mg doxycycline levitra 20 mg yahoo buy clomid dublin prednisone 50mg 5 days viagra cheap 20mg 1000 mg zithromax bestellen cialis reviews generic cialis tadalafil 100 mg phenergan 10mg sleep lisinopril 10 mg scored cheap viagra 120mg amoxil 500 mg capsulas cheap viagra canada buy brand nexium buy nexium astrazeneca opinioni cialis 20 mg viagra online bankeinzug online viagra drug propecia cheaper alternative clomid 100mg buy buy viagra plus .05 mg of synthroid generic viagra proffessional forum cialis 5 mg lisinopril mylan 20 mg clomid dosage 25 mg cialis 10 mg buy pink viagra 50mg generic cialis canada cialis 20 mg gebrauchsanweisung xenical 120 mg nedir buy lab nolvadex kamagra 25mg levitra 100mg tablets generic zovirax cream supergeneric viagra propranolol 40 mg effects kamagra online paypal buy lisinopril 2.5 thuoc nexium 10 mg levitra 20 mg cheap viagra toronto online 25mg viagra experiences green generic wellbutrin lexapro 20 mg dose buy nolvadex injections wellbutrin generic pills viagra and 500mg cheapest propecia generic 360 augmentin 500mg tabs viagra 100mg 40 199 propecia 1mg walmart generic viagra express viagra generic 200 mg viagra deutschland online lisinopril fatigue 20mg glucophage 1000 mg overdose buy cipro online bijwerkingen nexium 40 mg kamagra 100 mg sobres kamagra 100mg dosierung thuoc zoloft 500mg generic meltabs viagra doxycycline 200 uk buy order doxycycline 100 mg cialis online viagra efficacia cialis 10 mg cheapest online propecia prednisone 50mg asthma tarif levitra 20 mg 5mg cialis walmart metformin 1000 mg einnahme buying viagra victoria cialis 40mg efahrung get synthroid online vendo viagra generico prednisone eg 20 mg generico viagra now phenergan 25 mg cost assunzione viagra 25 mg buy cialis spain generic strattera .80 mg nexium generico ultrafarma doxycycline online 40mg 50 mg viagra lasts lisinopril 10 mg w929 precio cialis 5 mg doxycycline bp 100 mg lexapro generico prednisone buy canada cipro online order cialis perfect generics augmentin 650 mg dosage buy propecia now clomid injections online buy viagra soho synthroid 88 mg 10mg generic levitra 500 mg cipro candida glucophage xr 750mg augmentin 5oo mg lexapro 20mg generic lexapro online reviews buspar sleep disorder componentes celebrex 200 mg generic augmentin 500mg 600 mg herbal viagra viagra online nongeneric 5mg cialis generic diflucan 150 mg 1 capsula viagra tabs 150mg lisinopril 20 mg day viagra 25mg timing nexium generic 80mg. zithromax 500mg indonesia buspar order online order generic zithromax thuoc cialis 10mg aventis clomid online zithromax 500 mg fungsinya cheapest cialis overnight kamagra 8000mg lisinopril 30 mg color nexium 120mg nexium 20mg notice celebrex 200mg caps 30 kamagra buy lisinopril 40 mg buy 40 mg of prednisone buy viagra 100g generico de viagra buy liquid propecia glucophage forte 850mg generic viagra xl 5 mg 36 hour cialis amoxil online pharmacy cialis 15 mg mexico lisinopril 5 mg reviews viagra buy price wellbutrin 600 mg xl valtrex 500mg philippines professional cialis 20mg zovirax acyclovir 200mg 150 generic cialis softtabs online cialis sales order nexium cheap viagra coupons online cheap zoloft online costo cialis 5 mg buy viagra separately erythromycin bp 250 mg buy zithromax 500 nexium dr 40 mg reichen 25 mg viagra buy celebrex cyprus sinoretik lisinopril 20 mg doxycycline 75 mg 30 days manfaat cialis 20 mg viagra 100 mg break order cialis 10mg lexapro 10 mg tabletas buying cipro online kamagra 100mg ajania hongkong buy cialis mg viagra 60 mg prednisone injection buying viagra beijing cialis 40 mg online wellbutrin generic issues cialis daily generic generic cialis availability 40 mg celexa wellbutrin cialis 800mg reviews cheapest cialis 20mg zovirax buying cheap kamagra 100mg viagra 100mg english lisinopril de 20 mg strattera 25mg generic 1000 mg cipro gonnorhea viagra canada cheap lasix 40 mg apoteka zithromax generic cheap price viagra 50mg buy propecia generic propecia online thailand lisinopril 2.5 mg dosage viagra online us levitra 5 mg effetti generic valtrex manufacturers generic zovirax capsules zoloft 100 mg cost levitra 20 mg doses strattera 25 mg dosage where buy cytotec valtrex 1 mg caplet clomid 100 mg ervaringen generic cialis work cialis dosage 2.5 mg lisinopril kidney disorder glucophage 500 mg posologie viagra gel online thai generic cialis thuoc periactin 4mg buy true viagra buy cialis bulgaria strattera 40 mg street cialis 10 mg sulit lexapro generic contraindications buy propecia tablets lisinopril generic 10 mg metformin teva 1000 mg viagra online generic kamagra order paypal buy levitra withpaypal 100 mg levitra online ordering viagra sample order clomid overnight dosage doxycycline 100mg cialis 5 mg ucuz zithromax 100mg nexium 40 mg drug cialis 20 mg nederland buy doxycycline no diflucan medication buy cheapest super cialis cialis 5mg infarmed generic lexapro tmj order original cialis clomid 50mg infertility nolvadex 10mg price prednisone 20 mg medication zovirax suspension 200 mg cialis cheap usa cialis tab 20mg augmentin 750mg priligy generico online viagra 150 order online buy kamagra wholesale zithromax buy generic amoxil 875 mg dosage nexium 40 mg vaistai cheapest branded viagra propecia dosage 2mg zoloft mg amounts cialis canadian generic remedio cipro 500 mg cheap uk nolvadex buy zovirax budapest 20 mg prednisone jittery buy nolvadex brown cialis generic lexapro 50mg clomid buy clomid 25 mg zoloft wellbutrin prix kamagra 100mg buy strattera pills metformin pills 500 mg durata cialis 10 mg online zovirax buy lexapro 75 mg buy original kamagra diflucan 100 mg harga generic lexapro australia lasix 20 mg tabs half cialis 20mg hyperstimulation clomid 50mg online canadian viagra canadian dapoxetine online buy 5mg cialis dosage zoloft 100mg 100mg. vardenafil levitra order augmentin online apo propranolol 40mg amoxil capsules 250mg cialis 40mg 18 old buy zithromax antibiotic prednisone 5mg liquid cialis uk online lisinopril 20 mg bijwerkingen cheap propecia 5 mg 800 mg zovirax lisinopril 20 mg wirkstoff zithromax dosering 250mg gbl viagra order buy bactrim generic nebenwirkungen propranolol 10 mg ordering clomid canada strattera 10 mg nonstimulant buy viagra where cialis generico 10 mg cheap cialis au buy lisinopril 40mg cialis 20 mg hakkinda ran metformin 850 mg cialis generique 20mg nexium generic release generic levitra safe cialis 5mg dose buy levitra sale buy cipra cialis vancouver viagra buy xenical 120 mg used doxycycline generic manufacturer online pharmacies propecia 50mg viagra reviews nexium 40mg bula discount viagra generic propranolol 40 mg retard buy 50mg viagra cialis buy ont levitra 20 mg zararlari strattera 100 mg buy 300 mg zoloft dosage prijs cialis 10mg zithromax 250 mg pfizer cheap cialis from buy augmentin tablets webmd metformin 500mg que prednisone 50 mg order cialis professional nexium 40 mg prescription generic viagra coupon zoloft 350 mg celebrex 100mg nebenwirkungen clomid de 50 mg buy cialis powder buy generic augmentin buy cialis eu lexapro 50 mg ulotka buy xenical online prednisone 2.5 mg pregnancy prospect celebrex 100 mg cialis 4 mg 20 mg doxycycline cheap zovirax 400 mg cialis 20 mg info cheapest cialis viagra generic cialis 20mg cialis generic 10 mg cialis 5mg works viagra sublingual 20mg canada cialis 2.5 mg generic augmentin chewable generic lexapro good abra viagra online farmaco generico zithromax generic levitra de wellbutrin xr 100mg generic metformin 500 mg propranolol 40 mg la strattera price 100 mg kamagra guarenteed cheapest bactrim online india cialis 2.5 mg cukup makes generic cialis mustang generic viagra propecia buy prescription generic cialis discount cialis generic image viagra acquista online cialis online info viagra cheap drugs buy sildenafil dapoxetine augmentin generico amoxicillina order viagra malaysia viagra 100 mg use metformin tablets 500 mg india viagra buy cheapest australian cialis 30mg of levitra viagra order review generic viagra opinion viagra 100mg brand 50mg zoloft breastfeeding viagra pro 50 mg buy 1 diflucan pill australian generics cialis viagra 110mg paypal clomid de 50mg levitra dispersible 5 mg synthroid 25mg chepest 800 mg viagra buy prednisone 10 mg generic doxycycline 50 mg cytotec generico precio cialis online legitimate doxycycline hyclate 100 mg lisinopril 5 mg cena lasix 500mg tabs vand viagra 100mg cheap 20mg levitra cialis zomg tadalafil buy diflucan cheap viagra generica 25 generic zovirax pill cialis pattaya buy doxycycline 300 mg std cialis 40 mg kaufen ndc cialis 5 mg viagra generico mastercard 10 mg viagra cost 300 mg prednisone generic wellbutrin odor prednisone 20mg 54760 generic zoloft identification 50mg kamagra online cialis 50 mg prezzo synthroid .025 mg werking viagra 100mg 1000 mg cipro zn
Home BoB Documents Cleveland Indians v US (US Court of Appeals)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1112 guests online

Atom RSS

Cleveland Indians v US (US Court of Appeals) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Thursday, 09 May 2002 12:00

CLEVELAND INDIANS BASEBALL

COMPANY,Plaintiff-Appellee,

v.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Defendant-Appellant.


May 10, 2000, Filed

JUDGES: Before: SUHRHEINRICH, COLE, Circuit Judges; and QUIST, District Judge. *

* The Honorable Gordon J. Quist, United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan, sitting by designation.

OPINION: PER CURIAM. The United States appeals from the judgment of the district court in which the court found that an award of back wages is taxed for the purposes of the Federal Insurance Contribution Act (FICA), 26 U.S.C. §§ 3101-3128, and Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA), 26 U.S.C. §§ 3301-3311, in the year in which those wages were earned rather than the year in which the award of back wages was actually paid. For the following reasons, we AFFIRM the district court's judgment.

I.

The parties stipulated to the facts of this case before the district court, which we briefly summarize here. Major League Baseball Clubs (the "Clubs") and the Major League Baseball Players Association ("MLBPA") were involved in three separate grievances in 1990, wherein the MLBPA claimed that the Clubs breached the Collective Bargaining Agreement ("CBA") with respect to free agency rights of the baseball players in 1986, 1987 and 1988. After an arbitration panel issued a series of rulings adverse to the Clubs, the Clubs and the MLBPA settled their grievances on December 21, 1990. The settlement required the Clubs to contribute $ 280 million to a custodial account for distribution to affected players according to the MLBPA framework approved by the arbitration panel.

The Cleveland Indians Baseball Company's ("Indians") share of the settlement fund was $ 610,000 for the 1986 season and $ 1,457,848 for the 1987 season. The Indians received the funds in 1994 and distributed those funds to the affected players -- eight players who were employed in 1986 and fifteen players who were employed in 1987. Unsure as to the tax treatment of these distributions, the Indians paid FICA and FUTA taxes on the total funds as if the payments were wages for services rendered in 1994. In other words, the Indians paid FICA and FUTA taxes on the funds as if they were actually wages received by the players in 1994, the year of distribution. The Indians paid these tax obligations in April 1994 and January 1995. None of the affected players, however, performed services for the Indians in 1994 or 1995. The Indians filed this instant action seeking reimbursement of the FICA and FUTA taxes paid to the United States.

The Indians sought a refund of FICA and FUTA taxes claiming that, (1) a portion of the funds paid to the Indians and disbursed to its former players constituted non-taxable interest; and (2) the non-interest portion was not taxable because the funds were damages for the wrongful breach of the CBA and not wages for services rendered. Finally, even if the payments constituted wages for services rendered rather than interest and damages, the Indians argued that they should have paid taxes at the 1986 and 1987 tax rates applicable when the services were rendered. Because the 1986 and 1987 FICA and FUTA taxes of each of the affected players were already paid to the maximum required amount, the Indians asserted that they are entitled to a full refund if the payments were determined to be wages for services rendered in 1986 and 1987.

The government initially disputed the Indians's claims. Both parties eventually agreed, however, that $ 629,000 of the payments from the settlement fund to affected players constituted interest and were not subject to FICA and FUTA taxes. Thus, the Indians were entitled to a refund for taxes paid on the interest portion of the settlement. The parties also agreed that the remaining portion of the payments, approximately $ 2 million, constituted back-wage payments, earnings that would have been paid in 1986 and 1987 but for the Clubs' breach of the CBA. The issue presented to this court is the tax year applicable to these back-wage payments made in 1994 for services rendered in the 1986 and 1987 baseball seasons.

In the district court, the government and the Indians agreed that our decision in Bowman v. United States, 824 F.2d 528 (6th Cir. 1987) directly addressed this precise issue. The Bowman court held that "a settlement for back wages should not be allocated to the period when the employer finally pays but 'should be allocated to the periods when the regular wages were not paid as usual.'" 824 F.2d at 530 (quoting Social Security Bd. v. Nierotko, 327 U.S. 358, 370, 90 L. Ed. 718, 66 S. Ct. 637 (1946)). Following Bowman, the district court entered judgment in favor of the Indians and ordered the United States to refund the FICA and FUTA taxes paid on the settlement disbursements designated as back wages, including interest from the dates on which the payments were made.

The United States sought en banc reversal of the Bowman decision. This court declined the en banc petition and the case was referred to this panel.

II.

Typically, statutory interpretations such as those presented in this appeal are reviewed de novo. See Williams v. Coyle, 167 F.3d 1036, 1038 (6th Cir. 1999).

Here, our precedent clearly indicates that the statutory provision in question requires settlements for back wages to be allocated to the period in which they were earned or should have been paid, and not to the period in which the back wages were actually disbursed. See Bowman, 824 F.2d at 530. The government contends that Bowman was wrongly decided, arguing that the plain language, legislative history and applicable FICA and FUTA Treasury Regulations demonstrate that back wages are subject to tax in the year in which payment is made and not in which the services were rendered. In addition, the government cites cases from our sister circuits that are at odds with our Bowman holding. Despite these arguments, the government "agrees with taxpayer that the issue presented in this case was decided in Bowman." Appellant Reply Br. at 1.

Even if we were persuaded by the government's argument, we are bound by the Bowman decision. It is firmly established that one panel of this court cannot overturn a decision of another panel; only the court sitting en banc can overturn such a decision. See United States v. Smith, 73 F.3d 1414, 1418 (6th Cir. 1996). "The earlier determination is binding authority unless a decision of the United States Supreme Court mandates modification or this Court sitting en banc overrules the prior decision." United States. v. Moody, 206 F.3d 609, 615 (6th Cir. 2000) (citing Salmi v. Secretary of HHS, 774 F.2d 685, 689 (6th Cir. 1985)). Accordingly, following Bowman, we reject the government's argument and affirm the district court's judgment that FUTA and FICA taxes paid on the back wage disbursements should have been paid as if earned in 1986 and 1987.

III.

For the foregoing reasons, we AFFIRM the district court's judgment.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?