credit cards apply online instant approval can i apply for a walmart credit card and use it the same day hsbc credit card apply philippines bad credit credit card best capital one student credit card virgin america credit card sign in quick personal loans online loans for bad credit direct lenders list of all credit cards for bad credit instant online payday loans no credit check best credit cards for low income earners cash back credit cards 2013 first cash advance huntsville tx icici credit card apply online in coimbatore apply for halifax clarity credit card how to use canadian credit cards at us gas stations sbi credit card 3d secure registration wells fargo virtual credit card number air miles credit card uk how to accept credit card payments on iphone visa card canada post chase first usa credit card aqua credit card limit increase td canada trust credit card login compare cashback credit cards canada quick bad credit loans south africa best credit card reward programs 2012 how to get a us credit card outside us best citibank credit card offer travel rewards credit card comparison discover credit card credit score compare credit cards with cashback calculate the monthly interest rate on a credit card that charges 18 annual interest mastercard credit card payment protection pay as you go credit card processing canada legitimate cash advance lenders standard chartered bank uae credit card should i pay off credit card debt with a loan best iphone app for credit card transactions pay off your credit card debt calculator no fee air miles credit cards canada legitimate credit card consolidation companies what is the best credit card terminal company disney world reward credit card visa credit cards with no international fees united chase visa card login best visa or mastercard credit cards low credit credit cards paying off all credit cards at once free visa credit card number with csc why do i need a credit card for free apps on itunes credit union credit card consolidation loan credit cards with cashback for gas purchases canadian travel rewards cards what is cash advance limit easiest credit card approval singapore wells fargo secured credit card iphone 5 credit card charger easy cash loans online south africa need a credit card fast in india victoria secret credit card payment best travel credit cards october 2013 no foreign transaction fee credit card citibank 0 interest rate credit card offer how to transfer chase credit card balance to another card best rewards credit card 2013 bankamericard platinum plus visa secured credit card american express rewards credit card uk credit card merchant agreement mastercard hsbc bank apply online for credit card wells fargo debit visa card balance credit score applying for credit cards best online credit card processing canada best credit card canada no annual fee what credit cards can i apply for online 0 credit card balance transfer payday loans no credit check instant approval hdfc credit cards payment gateway british airways credit card 100 000 points apply for lane bryant credit card transfer balance credit cards canada care credit uk small business loans based on credit card sales bad credit loan direct lender track lloyds tsb credit card application comparison of usaa credit cards credit card reward offers 2012 best cash rewards credit card 2012 good credit cards for first timers credit card swipe app for windows phone company credit card policy for employees can i use a target visa card anywhere how to get a 30000 credit card limit prepaid credit card 5000 limit cash advance calculator canada catalogues for bad credit pay monthly number activate cibc credit card 10 best credit cards for students how to get a cash advance on a visa credit card credit card visa number + security code iphone credit card case best buy capital one credit cards for first timers amazon credit card visa login how do i find out the status of my walmart credit card application metal business card chase /credit card holder how to load paper in verifone credit card machine apply for a walmart credit card online best credit cards for not so good credit where to get prepaid visa cards canada rak bank credit card payment machine 57x40 thermal credit card machine rolls gas rewards credit card reviews itunes please enter valid credit card information credit card payoff calculator dave ramsey clark howard free credit report household bank credit card square iphone credit card system fake visa credit card numbers with security code hdfc credit card online payment through netbanking credit cards with cashback bonus bad credit credit card instant approval top credit card processing companies bank of america corporate credit card phone number rewards canada credit cards 2011 random credit card number and cvv first premier bank credit card reviews low interest credit card offers for fair credit good credit cards uk compare credit cards cash back td bank visa debit card balance why do i need a credit card for my apple id halifax credit card deals for existing customers free reloadable virtual credit cards how do manual credit card machines work storing credit card information law canada the best travel credit card in canada virgin credit cards online stolen credit card numbers with cvv 2013 instant cash loans no upfront fees calculate credit card interest on balance bank of america merchant services credit card rates prepaid canadian credit cards should i transfer my credit card balance to a new card online application for bob credit cards online credit card application hsbc philippines apple id credit card declined best business credit cards no foreign transaction fees the best credit card balance transfer deals reclaim credit card charges 2011 visa platinum credit card offers india icici credit card payment through neft ifsc code can preloaded credit cards be used online felony credit card fraud sentence should you apply for credit cards online gold credit card hsbc uk contacting capital one credit card uk prepaid credit cards uk euro best credit card interest free balance transfers tesco credit card online log on interest free balance transfer credit card australia gold bullion uk credit card freedom credit card login sears credit card rewards hsbc best international travel credit card best credit card rates 2012 compare interest free credit cards uk credit card debt settlement australia biggest credit card issuers uk hsbc credit card insurance claim what is a balance transfer wells fargo credit card african bank credit card limit increase online application best credit card debt consolidation companies low interest credit card no transfer fee sbi credit card offers best no fee credit cards 2013 reloadable prepaid credit card usa request credit limit increase capital one apple credit card scanner cibc prepaid credit card canada credit one bank credit card agreement cancel pre approved credit card offers chase credit card balance transfer to checking account hdfc credit card charges for irctc what are reward points on credit cards how to build your credit rating with a credit card british airways credit card charges obc sbi credit card application status rfid credit card protector case unsecured bad credit card loans credit card bank rakyat credit cards canada visa business credit cards cash back no annual fee qxl online payday loan address best credit cards for college students with low interest rates best cashback credit card offers list of all uk payday lenders how soon after chapter 13 bankruptcy can you get a credit card top credit card deals 2012 0 credit card transfer balance bank credit card interest rates cash advance online columbus ohio payday loans online bad credit no fax easy credit card application no requirements philippines issue number on credit card visa barclays top ten credit cards low apr apply for bad credit loan canada how to negotiate with credit card companies to reduce debt credit card ratings canada get credit card numbers download best virtual credit card usa td canada trust visa gift cards best transfer balance credit cards natwest business credit card registration ge credit card contact number credit limit increase capital one canada comenity pay lane bryant credit card apply for personal loan with bad credit 100 guaranteed secured credit cards hsbc sears credit card customer service how to calculate credit card interest charges valero gas credit card i have no credit score and i want a credit card best airline credit card points guy credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date bank of america credit cards customer service credit card 5 cashback calendar multiple interest rate credit card calculator visa credit card fees for australia credit cards visa signature new payday loan lenders uk 2013 do i need to have a credit card to apply for paypal apply for capital one business credit card delta credit card deal new york and company credit card payment number cibc canada credit card login pay off credit card debt with student loans major bank secured credit cards ge capital credit card apply airline credit card rewards comparison how to pay off high interest rate credit cards payday advance cash converters cape town best credit cards for balance transfers 2013 balance transfer credit cards for bad credit rating best credit cards for cash back rewards 2013 tesco credit card protection plan does walmart canada sell prepaid credit cards credit card rewards canada comparison can i apply for business credit card without a business how to get credit card with bad credit history in india what is a good credit card apr 2012 history first credit card issued guaranteed payday loans orchard bank credit card payment phone number lowest apr credit card available lifetime free credit card hsbc icici bank credit card limit calculator american express credit card settlement offer 12 month payday loans direct lenders hsbc credit card promotions sri lanka discover credit card student aqua credit card limit starting security bank online application for credit cards pay aqua credit card online free prepaid credit cards post office how long does it take to get a natwest credit card how long does it take to get a credit card natwest idbi credit card apply online in delhi suntrust delta skymiles credit card metal credit card protector best credit cards in canada for travel pre approved credit card offer opt out best credit card for balance transfers for bad credit small business credit cards instant approval pre-guaranteed credit cards australia sign up for credit card wells fargo apply for small business credit card online hdfc corporate credit card offers verify paypal prepaid credit card free bad credit bank accounts accept credit cards by phone no credit check free visa credit card numbers that work 2013 halifax credit card minimum payment rate i want to apply for a sears credit card online cheapest credit card rates us disney credit card reward dollars nationwide credit card insurance cover discover credit cards compare virgin credit cards now mbna legalsounds not accepting credit cards best uk credit cards for airmiles standard chartered credit card india login compare icici and citibank credit card amscot cash advance tampa fl business secured credit card bank of america how to confirm paypal credit card buy prepaid uk credit card bank of america student credit card credit score secured credit card for bad credit bank of america instant 12 month loan bad credit credit card services natwest contact best travel credit cards 2013 chase credit card visa customer service hsbc premier credit card benefits axis bank credit card reward points for platinum card hdfc credit card customer care toll free number hbc mastercard points discover cashback bonus credit card review american express corporate credit card customer care number prepaid credit card australian dollars balance transfer barclaycard to halifax chase credit card application credit card transfer balance no fee low interest credit cards for students cibc credit cards online mastercard debit card benefits best buy credit card app how to apply credit card online in icici hdfc online credit card payment login anz credit card travel insurance platinum priceline visa rewards card virgin credit card mbna ppi discover credit card score requirements corporate credit card policy guidelines natwest student credit card increase limit chase bank credit cards for poor credit bank of ireland credit card balance transfers visa credit card travel insurance coverage payday loan lenders uk new southwest credit card application status chase credit card business login are my credit card rewards taxable credit cards and rewards apply for home loan with bad credit online which credit card is best for college students reloadable prepaid canadian credit cards best visa card fake credit card numbers with security code 2011 uk credit cards for bad credit chase credit card cashback calendar 0 credit card offers balance transfers capital one secured credit card application status rewards credit card reviews 2011 unsecured bad credit loan calculator free prepaid credit card no fees best buy reward credit card hsbc walmart credit cards account best iphone credit card reader canada capital one credit cards uk apply for a credit card credit card rewards canada capital 1 credit card login credit card comparison chart singapore link southwest rapid rewards credit card speedy cash loans oldham valid visa credit card number 2011 best online cash advance yahoo answers usaa credit card benefits best cash back credit card offers in india western union gold card hdfc credit card search best car loans with bad credit secure credit card chase prepaid credit card bank of ireland tesco credit card cash advance limit where can i get a bad credit credit card how to apply for hsbc credit card online in india cheap online credit card processing rbc debit visa card apply for credit card with no credit credit card credit limit singapore buy visa prepaid card with cash 10 000 credit card debt relief canada credit card transfer deals nz virgin money low rate credit card citibank business credit cards with rewards does applying for a store credit card hurt your credit temporary credit card number visa calculate credit card interest formula mbna virgin credit card customer services credit card charges abroad natwest best hotel rewards credit card 2013 how do i get a credit card sign up for a free prepaid credit card aspire credit card login the visa prepaid debit card with 1-2-3 rewards platinum credit card icici bank capitec personal loan online application american express platinum card need us credit card for itunes direct payday lenders no fees car loan payment calculator bad credit how to get a visa credit card with bad credit pay bank of america credit card bill online credit card credit rating minimum payment 5 top credit card companies credit expert score which credit card is easiest to get with bad credit major credit cards accepted in australia mastercard exchange rate bmo barclay credit card mobile app mobile credit card processing reviews uk discover credit card payment site citibank platinum credit card singapore best small business credit card for new business how does apr work on a secured credit card benefits of a business accepting credit cards from their customers chase credit card for business virgin low rate credit card review discover student credit card instant approval rbc cash back visa vs mastercard nationwide credit card limit reduced icici credit card rewards points catalogue capital one canada credit cards things you need to know before getting a credit card easiest cheapest way to accept credit cards what is a good cash back credit card calculate interest paid on credit card debt instant cash loans online south africa best iphone credit card machine is it easy to get a capital one secured credit card free fake valid credit card numbers pcs advance travel pay maximum credit card interest rates canada shell gas credit card application status pay best buy credit card hrsa gas station credit cards for no credit visa credit card number hack visa card uk contact number instant fast payday loans how can i increase my absa credit card limit 0 credit card balance transfer no fee credit card processing fees uk list of valid credit card numbers 2012 hsbc credit card settlement department murphy usa credit card account usa credit card virtual how to get real credit card numbers that work best credit cards for bad credit unsecured where can i pay my bestbuy credit card hdfc bank credit card visa verification best unsecured credit card after bankruptcy discharge nab credit card insurance christian credit card debt help best credit card advice chase marriott rewards credit card benefits unsecured bad credit loans auckland 0 credit card offers for good credit credit card score ranges westpac platinum credit card insurance how do they calculate credit card interest aadvantage credit card uk mbna credit card with no annual fee and low interest rate in india capital one credit card payment address city of industry apply visa credit card philippines sbi irctc credit card online payment new payday loan direct lender uk top reward credit cards uk hsbc credit card review australia where can i pay my orchard bank credit card halifax clarity credit card foreign exchange rate no credit check credit cards nz usaa credit card cash advance limit best usaa credit card uk best credit card rate cash back credit cards india 2012 interest free credit card transfer uk visa rewards card points how to get the best credit card rate credit card protection plan singapore premier first credit card payment cash back credit card malaysia direct online payday cash advance lender short term bad credit loans nz what credit score do you need for a paypal credit card best credit cards bad credit 2011 accept credit cards free paypal pay advance army pcs blank credit card payment authorization form barclays credit card can;t pay how do credit debit card machines work credit card number and security code and expiration date zero interest credit card canada compare credit cards canada government fbi credit card fraud statistics current credit card rates how does chase apply credit card payments when will aib issue visa debit cards canada cash back credit cards 2011 orchard bank credit card application under review credit card payment calculator uk punishment for credit card fraud uk compare frequent flyer credit cards australia credit card with rewards australia visa credit card student canada what does referred mean on a credit card application hdfc bank credit card bill payment old navy visa card login credit cards with rewards for gas average credit card rate 2011 credit card reviews fair credit major credit card companies in the world
Home BoB Documents Cleveland Indians v US (US Court of Appeals)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1400 guests online

Atom RSS

Cleveland Indians v US (US Court of Appeals) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Thursday, 09 May 2002 12:00

CLEVELAND INDIANS BASEBALL

COMPANY,Plaintiff-Appellee,

v.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

Defendant-Appellant.


May 10, 2000, Filed

JUDGES: Before: SUHRHEINRICH, COLE, Circuit Judges; and QUIST, District Judge. *

* The Honorable Gordon J. Quist, United States District Court for the Western District of Michigan, sitting by designation.

OPINION: PER CURIAM. The United States appeals from the judgment of the district court in which the court found that an award of back wages is taxed for the purposes of the Federal Insurance Contribution Act (FICA), 26 U.S.C. §§ 3101-3128, and Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA), 26 U.S.C. §§ 3301-3311, in the year in which those wages were earned rather than the year in which the award of back wages was actually paid. For the following reasons, we AFFIRM the district court's judgment.

I.

The parties stipulated to the facts of this case before the district court, which we briefly summarize here. Major League Baseball Clubs (the "Clubs") and the Major League Baseball Players Association ("MLBPA") were involved in three separate grievances in 1990, wherein the MLBPA claimed that the Clubs breached the Collective Bargaining Agreement ("CBA") with respect to free agency rights of the baseball players in 1986, 1987 and 1988. After an arbitration panel issued a series of rulings adverse to the Clubs, the Clubs and the MLBPA settled their grievances on December 21, 1990. The settlement required the Clubs to contribute $ 280 million to a custodial account for distribution to affected players according to the MLBPA framework approved by the arbitration panel.

The Cleveland Indians Baseball Company's ("Indians") share of the settlement fund was $ 610,000 for the 1986 season and $ 1,457,848 for the 1987 season. The Indians received the funds in 1994 and distributed those funds to the affected players -- eight players who were employed in 1986 and fifteen players who were employed in 1987. Unsure as to the tax treatment of these distributions, the Indians paid FICA and FUTA taxes on the total funds as if the payments were wages for services rendered in 1994. In other words, the Indians paid FICA and FUTA taxes on the funds as if they were actually wages received by the players in 1994, the year of distribution. The Indians paid these tax obligations in April 1994 and January 1995. None of the affected players, however, performed services for the Indians in 1994 or 1995. The Indians filed this instant action seeking reimbursement of the FICA and FUTA taxes paid to the United States.

The Indians sought a refund of FICA and FUTA taxes claiming that, (1) a portion of the funds paid to the Indians and disbursed to its former players constituted non-taxable interest; and (2) the non-interest portion was not taxable because the funds were damages for the wrongful breach of the CBA and not wages for services rendered. Finally, even if the payments constituted wages for services rendered rather than interest and damages, the Indians argued that they should have paid taxes at the 1986 and 1987 tax rates applicable when the services were rendered. Because the 1986 and 1987 FICA and FUTA taxes of each of the affected players were already paid to the maximum required amount, the Indians asserted that they are entitled to a full refund if the payments were determined to be wages for services rendered in 1986 and 1987.

The government initially disputed the Indians's claims. Both parties eventually agreed, however, that $ 629,000 of the payments from the settlement fund to affected players constituted interest and were not subject to FICA and FUTA taxes. Thus, the Indians were entitled to a refund for taxes paid on the interest portion of the settlement. The parties also agreed that the remaining portion of the payments, approximately $ 2 million, constituted back-wage payments, earnings that would have been paid in 1986 and 1987 but for the Clubs' breach of the CBA. The issue presented to this court is the tax year applicable to these back-wage payments made in 1994 for services rendered in the 1986 and 1987 baseball seasons.

In the district court, the government and the Indians agreed that our decision in Bowman v. United States, 824 F.2d 528 (6th Cir. 1987) directly addressed this precise issue. The Bowman court held that "a settlement for back wages should not be allocated to the period when the employer finally pays but 'should be allocated to the periods when the regular wages were not paid as usual.'" 824 F.2d at 530 (quoting Social Security Bd. v. Nierotko, 327 U.S. 358, 370, 90 L. Ed. 718, 66 S. Ct. 637 (1946)). Following Bowman, the district court entered judgment in favor of the Indians and ordered the United States to refund the FICA and FUTA taxes paid on the settlement disbursements designated as back wages, including interest from the dates on which the payments were made.

The United States sought en banc reversal of the Bowman decision. This court declined the en banc petition and the case was referred to this panel.

II.

Typically, statutory interpretations such as those presented in this appeal are reviewed de novo. See Williams v. Coyle, 167 F.3d 1036, 1038 (6th Cir. 1999).

Here, our precedent clearly indicates that the statutory provision in question requires settlements for back wages to be allocated to the period in which they were earned or should have been paid, and not to the period in which the back wages were actually disbursed. See Bowman, 824 F.2d at 530. The government contends that Bowman was wrongly decided, arguing that the plain language, legislative history and applicable FICA and FUTA Treasury Regulations demonstrate that back wages are subject to tax in the year in which payment is made and not in which the services were rendered. In addition, the government cites cases from our sister circuits that are at odds with our Bowman holding. Despite these arguments, the government "agrees with taxpayer that the issue presented in this case was decided in Bowman." Appellant Reply Br. at 1.

Even if we were persuaded by the government's argument, we are bound by the Bowman decision. It is firmly established that one panel of this court cannot overturn a decision of another panel; only the court sitting en banc can overturn such a decision. See United States v. Smith, 73 F.3d 1414, 1418 (6th Cir. 1996). "The earlier determination is binding authority unless a decision of the United States Supreme Court mandates modification or this Court sitting en banc overrules the prior decision." United States. v. Moody, 206 F.3d 609, 615 (6th Cir. 2000) (citing Salmi v. Secretary of HHS, 774 F.2d 685, 689 (6th Cir. 1985)). Accordingly, following Bowman, we reject the government's argument and affirm the district court's judgment that FUTA and FICA taxes paid on the back wage disbursements should have been paid as if earned in 1986 and 1987.

III.

For the foregoing reasons, we AFFIRM the district court's judgment.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?