Home Arbitration Scorecard

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1401 guests online

Atom RSS

MLB Salary Arbitration Scorecard PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 117
PoorBest 
Salary Arbitration
Written by Maury Brown   
Saturday, 10 February 2007 16:24

The Biz of Baseball

RELATED CONTENT:

Detailed Salary Arbitration Reports:

2009 Detailed Report

The following is a scorecard outlining how arbitration panels have ruled on respective hearings.

(UPDATED - 2/15/14 - Josh Tomlin loses hearing with Indians)

Listed by:

Date of hearing, Player, Player Figure, Club Figure, Who Won, Arbitrators (use this page in conjunction to the Arbitration Figures page, which lists who has been signed ahead of arbitration, links to articles on each signing or ruling, player service time, and other salary information).

Overall Scorecard to Date:

2014 Scorecard: Clubs 2 | Players 1

Final 2013 Scorecard: Clubs - 0 | Players - 0 (first time since '74 that no hearings)

Final 2012 Scorecard: Clubs - 5 | Players - 2

Final 2011 Scorecard: Clubs - 1 | Players - 2

Final 2010 Scorecard: Clubs - 5 | Players - 3

Final 2009 Scorecard: Clubs - 1 | Players - 2

Final 2008 Scorecard: Clubs - 6 | Players - 2

Final 2007 Scorecard: Clubs - 4 | Players - 3

Final 2006 Scorecard: Clubs - 4 | Players - 2

Final 2005 Scorecard: Clubs - 2 | Players - 1

Historical Scorecard (current to 2014): Owners - 292 | Players - 215

Historical Arbitration Results - 1974 - 2004 (PDF)

2014 Results

Date Player Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
02/08/14 Andrew Cashnew
(RHP)
Padres
$2,400,000 $2,275,000 Player
Gil Vernon
Elizabeth Neumeier
Robert Herzog
02/08/14 Vinnie Pestano
(RHP)
Indians
$1,450,000 $975,000 Club Matt Irvings
Matt Goldberg
Steven Wolf
02/15/14 Josh Tomlin
(RHP)
Indians
$975,000 $800,000 Club Josh Sands
Dennis Archer
Marlene Gold

2013 Results

NO HEARINGS FOR THIS YEAR. FIRST TIME SINCE 1974 THAT NO HEARINGS

2012 Results

Date Player Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
02/01/12 John Lannan
(LHP)
Nationals
$5,700,000 $5,000,000 Club
Robert Hurzog
Elizabeth Neumeier
John Skonier
02/02/12 Jeff Niemann
(RHP)
Rays
$3,200,000 $2,750,000 Club James Oldham
Howard Edelman
Matt Irvings
02/03/12 Anibal Sanchez
(RHP)
Marlins
$8,000,000 $6,900,000 Player Elizabeth Neumeier
James Oldham
Gil Vernon
02/07/12 Emillo Bonifacio
(SS)
Marlins
$2,200,000 $1,950,000 Player Steven Wolf
Mark Burstein
Sylvia Skratek
02/08/12 Brad Bergesen
(RHP)
Orioles
$1,200,000 $800,000 Club Robert Hurzog
Mark Burstein
Elizabeth Neumeier
2/13/2012 Jose Veras
(RP)
Brewers
$2,375,000 $2,000,000 Club Dan Brent
Marlene Gold
John Sands
2/15/2012 Garrett Jones
(OF)
Pirates
$2,500,000 $2,250,000 Club Margaret Brogan
Dan Brent
Matt Goldberg

 

2011 Results

Date Player Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
02/08/11 Ross Ohlendorf
(RHP)
Pirates
$2,025,000 $1,400,000 PLAYER Steven Wolf
Fredric Horowitz
Robert Hurzog

02/10/11 Jered Weaver
(RHP)
Angels
$8,800,000 $7,365,000 CLUB Steven Wolf
James Oldham
Fredric Horowitz
02/18/11 Hunter Pence
(OF)
Astros
$6,900,000
$5,150,000
PLAYER
Roobert Herzog
Margaret Brogan
Fredric Horowitz

 

Final 2010 Results

Date Player Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
2/12/10 Cory Hart
(OF)
Brewers
$4,800,000
$4,150,000 Player Elizabeth Neumeier
John Sands
Sylvia Skratek
2/13/10 B.J. Upton
(OF)
Rays
$3,300,000
$3,000,000 Club Gil Vernon
Elizabeth Neumeier
Elliott Shriftman
2/15/10 Cody Ross
(OF)
Marlins
$4,450,000
$4,200,000 Player James Oldham
Margaret Brogan
Howard Edelman
2/17/10 Brian Bruney
(RP)
Nationals
$1,850,000
$1,500,000 Club Steven Wolf
Sylvia Skratek
Dan Brent
2/18/10 Wandy Rodriguez
(SP)
Astros
$7,000,000
$5,000,000 Club Richard Bloch
Elizabeth Neumeier
Fredric Horowitz
2/19/10 Jeff Mathis
(C)
Angels
$1,300,000
$700,00 Player Elliott Shiftman
Steven Wolf
Margaret Brogan
2/19/10 Sean Burnett
(RP)
Nationals
$925,000
$775,000 Club Robert Bailey
Robert Herzog
Fredric Horowitz
2/20/10 Ryan Theriot
(SS)
Cubs
$3,400,000
$2,600,000 Club John Kagel
Margaret Brogan
Elliott Shriftman

 

Final 2009 Results

Date Player Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
2/07/09 Shawn Hill
(SP)
Nationals
$775,000
$500,000 Player Elizabeth Neumeier
Robert Bailey
Fredric Horowitz
2/10/09 Dioner Navarro
(Catcher)
Rays
$2,500,000 $2,100,000 Club Elizabeth Neumeier
James Oldham
Steven Wolf
2/12/09 Dan Uggla
(2B)
Marlins
$5,350,000 $4,400,000 Player Richard Bloch
Fredric Horowitz
Steven Wolf

Final 2008 Results

Date
Player
Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
2/13/08
Felipe Lopez
(SS)
Nationals
$5.2 Million
$4.9
Million
Club
Christine Knowlton
Elliott Shriftman
Steven Wolf
2/15/08
(SP)
Yankees
$4.6
Million
$4
Million
Club
Stephen Goldberg
Jack Clarke
Christine Knowlton
2/15/08
(RP)
Astros
$6.2
Million
$4.7
Million
Club

Christine Knowlton
Stephen Goldberg
Sylvia Skratek

2/15/08
(RP)
Rockies
$6.5
Million
$5.05 Million
Club
Robert Bailey
Dan Brent
Elliott Shriftman
2/19/08
(SS)
Astros
$4.9
Million
$2.75
Million
Club
Margaret Brogan
Stephen Goldberg
Fredric Horowitz
2/21/08
(1B)
Phillies
$10
Million
$7
Million
Player
Stephen Goldberg
Robert Bailey
Jack Clarke
2/22/08
(SP)
Mets
$6.5
Million
$4.725
Million
Player
Steven Wolf
Robert Bailey
Elizabeth Neumeier
2/22/08
(RP)
Angels
$12.5
Million
$10
Million
Club
Stephen Goldberg
Elizabeth Neumeier
Steven Wolf

Final 2007 Results

Date
Player
Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
2/10/07
Josh Paul
(Catcher)
Devil Rays
$940k
$625k
Club
Richard Bloch
Robert Bailey
Christine Knowlton
2/10/07
(Pitcher)
Dodgers
$1.250
Million
$912.5k
Club
Stephen Goldberg
Elizabeth Neumeier
John Sands
2/13/07
(Pitcher)
Nationals
$1.85
Million
$850k Club Elliott Shriftman
Dan Brent
Stephen Goldberg
2/13/07
(Pitcher)
Marlins
$700k $575k Club Jack Clarke
Elizabeth Neumeier
Stephen Goldberg
2/17/07
(3rd)
Marlins
$7.4
Million
$6.7
Million
Player Howard Brock
Elliott Shriftman
Stephen Goldberg
2/21/07
(Closer)
Nationals
$4.15
Million
$3.65
Million
Player Margaret Brogan
Elizabeth Neumeier
Stephen Goldberg
2/21/07
(2nd)
Padres
$3.95
Million
$2.75
Million
Player Margaret Brogan
Jack Clarke
Steven Wolf

Final 2006 Results

Date
Player
Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
2/6/06
Sunny Kim
(Pitcher)
Rockies
$800k
$600k
Club
Stephen Goldberg
Gil Vernon
John Sands
2/8/06
Emil Brown
(RF)
Royals
$1.775
Million
$1.4
Million
Player
Margaret Brogan
Gil Vernon

John Sands
2/10/06
Alfonso Soriano
(2B)
Nationals
$12
Million
$10
Million
Club
Richard Bloch
Elizabeth Neumeier
Elliott Shriftman
2/15/06
Kyle Lohse
(Pitcher)
Twins
$3.95
Million
$3.4
Million
Player
Dan Brent
Stephen Goldberg
Steven Wolf
2/15/06
Rodrigo Lopez
(Pitcher)
Orioles
$4.5
Million
$3.75
Million
Club
Margaret Brogan
Elizabeth Neumeier
Elliott Shriftman
2/16/06
Josh Paul
(Catcher)
Devil Rays
$750k
$475k
Club
Dan Brent
Margaret Brogan
Elliott Shriftman

Final 2005 Results

Date
Player
Player
Figure
Club
Figure
Who
Won
Arbitrators
2/11/05
Kyle Lohse
(Pitcher)
Twins
Agent - S. Boras
$2.4 Million
$2.150 Million
Player
Christine Knowlton
Robert Bailey
Elliott Shriftman
2/12/05
(Pitcher)
Royals
Agent - M. Moye
$1.2 Million
$950k
Club
Christine Knowlton
Steven Wolf
Elliott Shriftman
2/15/05
(Pitcher)
Athletics
$860k $600K
Club Stephen Goldberg
Janet Gaunt
Jack Clarke


Arbitrator highlighted bold denotes panel chair

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?