credit report analysis online run credit report tenant help rebuild my credit credit cards the first free credit report song reporting disputed debt credit reporting agency free credit report with no credit card required donnie negative information on credit reports stays how long report bad tenant credit bureau free report uk only credit score free credit report irs how do i get free credit report online credit report letter how to fix credit report free view annual credit report 30 days names guys free credit report commercial violette read cbc credit report remove late payment my credit report section 2.8 of the credit reporting code of conduct free credit report wisconsin transunion credit report for business credit bureau report singpost who is the free credit report dot com guy place security freeze your credit report credit identity theft in queens what are the three major credit report companies where cane i see my credit report for free anderson financial credit report how do you remove negative items from your credit report how long credit report debt how long is an eviction on your credit report how long does a debt collection stay on your credit report free credit reports government site contest a credit report entry freeze credit reports how to get free credit score and report get all three credit reports free bureaus what you learned about credit in general and what type of information is in your credit report card credit reporting experian credit cards for fair credit score the only free credit report website fair get free report canada without card credit history ftc free credit report score reliable credit reports personal solutions agency check my credit score lloyds bank state of colorado free credit report how long does negative information stay on your credit report mni credit report annual credit report service po box atlanta check my credit score report buy home foreclosure credit report credit report canada tenant what is the best consumer credit reporting company what personal information goes on a credit report how long does it take for paid debts to be removed from credit report report to credit bureau about identity theft dispute incorrect info credit report alert on credit report new credit file overnight free credit report.com baby lyrics how to get a business credit report for free need see my credit report free understanding your credit report annual credit report request service commercial credit reports inc hendersonville tn what is the best 3 bureau report credit scores what information do i need to get my credit report debt charged off credit report what shows up on your credit report canadian credit reporting limited toronto h&r block loan advance how to dispute credit report canada consumer report credit card companies checking my child s credit report kid;s equifax consumer credit report update can employer request your credit report where do i find my credit score on my credit report small business credit reports free company report all three bureau credit scores credit report 3 in 1 free one time yearly free credit report collection agency credit reporting eviction on credit report free credit report three allowed 1 free credit report per year how do i get a free visa report if i was denied credit annual credit report fraud fair credit reporting act debt validation credit report transunion dispute free annual report small business credit scores how do i get a freeze off my credit report where is a safe place to get my credit report how do i look at my credit report for free blue blue beacon credit repair government agency for free credit report dispute information on credit report credit reports one time only credit report ?2 online what is collection charge off on credit report how do i get my free annual credit reports false credit reporting damages check credit report with itin fico annual credit report ratings many years does chapter 7 bankruptcy stay credit report landlord credit report search engines maryland law credit report where can i get my free credit report annually free credit report.com car commercial lyrics equifax view credit report new free credit report commercial 201 fair credit reporting act consumer disclosure and authorization ohio law free credit report us government approved credit reports top credit reporting sites reporting stolen credit cards to credit agencies get free credit report from experian best way to get credit reports free get my credit report for ?2 project report on credit appraisal in pnb check all 3 credit reports free millennium credit repair oklahoma city ok dispute old addresses credit report get one free credit report a year trans union credit report canada remove hsbc credit report capital one doesn;t report credit limit ovation credit report repair reviews credit credit karma complaints there any truly free credit reports does mean your credit report says charged off bad debt credit report service business three credit reports fico scores dispute credit report errors canada request a free copy of my credit report credit suisse usa inc annual report how to check how to read your credit score equifax obtaining credit reports for tenants 3 credit reports and scores credit report from all 3 bureaus how to remove credit report information equifax canada credit report business free credit report from credit bureau long does serious delinquency stay credit report best place get 3 credit reports scores cosign auto loan credit report dispute something your credit report online law enforcement systems on credit report remove payment after charge off collection credit report how to order my annual free credit report free report 3 reporting agencies credit score i want my free yearly credit report annualcreditreport obtaining how to update credit report information get transunion credit report only experian credit report mailing address equifax codes for guide to reading a credit report free credit report for small business transunion usa credit report canadian company credit reports free trial credit report equifax best company best credit card for fixing credit pulling credit reports without permission consumer report canada tv get my annual credit report free phone number to transunion credit agency free annual credit report for business considered hard inquiry your credit report transunion credit score ratings chart get transunion capital report denied credit three bureau credit report credit report attorney miami where can i get a free credit report no strings attached view my credit report free online purchase a credit report fix bad credit report contesting credit report entry transunion free credit report yearly how to check credit get credit score without credit card best credit report service 2011 free credit report non fico score define the purpose of a credit reporting agency fico score credit report all 3 credit reports credit repair oil security companies in houston tx us government gov free annual credit report do insurance companies check credit report where can you get your yearly free credit report credit repair business for sale how long does bad debt stay on credit report uk my annual free credit report score letter remove negative credit report unlimited credit reports credit reporting act bc cma 2010 cma global sovereign credit risk report how do you check a business credit report your credit union org what shows on a credit report need check my credit report free federal trade commission credit report free annual credit report contact info free credit report federal govt scores where to get a copy of your credit report remove late credit card payment credit report free 3 annual credit reports credit cards that report to transunion only how long is a foreclosure on your credit report online payday loans no faxing direct lender names guys free credit report commercial like how do you put a judgment on a credit report how can consumers obtain free copies of credit reports i have too many inquiries on my credit report free credit report major agencies credit score reports sample how do you get your free annual credit report transunion how doo i remove a freeze on my credit report credit history canada landamerica credit reports how many times can i dispute my credit report inaccuracies your credit report can corrected free yearly credit report 2013 get best report service free personal solutions credit obtaining credit report online checking account credit report does closing 2. credit report. what does a credit report contain why is this important to college students australian central credit union annual report 2009 long chapter 7 bankruptcy stays credit report free report usa online annual credit free credit report hard inquiry how to improve your credit report quickly reading equifax credit report canada dispute credit report texas how to get something taken off of your credit report complaints cic ce credit report unauthorized which credit report what graft is best to use for acl reconstruction my credit report free without credit card free sample dispute letter for credit report does walmart credit card report to credit bureau best credit score report website 200 free credit report with no credit card required free credit report without signing up get credit report mailed to me does free credit report affect score items removed from credit report after 7 years who uses consumer credit reports help in making decisions remove incorrect information your credit report free credit report free once a year credit card late fees credit report 3 companies for credit report how to rebuild credit after chapter 7 free credit repair for dummies credit repair kit fair credit reporting act uk equivalent free credit report with no credit card required uk free credit report access get free credit report yearly how to get a free credit report from experian free detailed credit report no credit card the best credit report online what are the 3 major credit reporting companies free debt report if denied credit how can i get my free credit report online common credit report inaccuracies repair credit after bankruptcy canada remove items from credit report before 7 years getting rid hard inquiry credit report how to get a free credit report from your bank e renter credit report credit reporting law uk phone numbers for credit reporting agencies how to make a credit report fake free experian credit report login does checking your credit report affect your credit score how to get accurate negative information off credit report why did the free credit report band leave credit report repair services bbb first usa bank my credit report request free credit report mail canada what is the free credit reporting act repairing bad credit report best free credit history repair does checking your report hurt your score own credit are credit are credit repair companies worth it address for experian credit reporting bureau difference between consumer reports credit reports quizzles credit report give all 3 free credit report score can creditor remove negative item credit report new credit card reporting rules 2011 cbcinnovis sample credit report how to remove bad credit reports first free credit report band safe place get credit report us consumer credit report how to get credit report from equifax remove charge off credit report letter reading credit reports canada request free credit report equifax canada cbc credit report rent a center commercial credit check service free credit auto repair los angeles ca how to get something removed from your credit report after 7 years get free copy my equifax credit report long do collections stay credit report canada remove judgement my credit report south africa phone number all 3 credit reports transunion which is the official free credit report free credit report cancel subscription how can i request a copy of my credit report credit report dispute samples free credit report commercial band is back cash in hand loans uk how to unfreeze my credit report equifax icr who is the best credit repair company how to report rental history to credit bureau credit report free for life business credit report experian credit report without credit card information union loans 24 hour credit repair names of list of free credit report companies request my free yearly credit report online how to read a credit report 3 1 credit report 3 scores federal reporting period credit report anual credit report sample letters to remove inquiries from credit report how can i cancel my experian credit report letters to creditors examples credit reports free australia how long does credit card debt stay on my credit report is national credit report a legit site what kind of information is found on a credit report remove account in dispute from credit report credit report totally free meridian credit union annual report 2011 how do i run a credit report on a company top three major credit reporting agencies experian repair credit report uk free online credit free credit check without credit card information annual credit report request by mail free canadian credit report review kroll credit report codes access equifax free credit report experian credit report government sponsored free annual credit report many items can you dispute your credit report how to get rid of defaults on credit report adding consumer statement credit report paid collection on credit report what does a credit repair what does a corporate lawyer do free visa report after denied credit experian equifax free credit report for dispute how can i get my credit report and score for free does checking your own credit report hurt you score free credit report commercial band members fan fix too many inquiries credit report how to get free credit report from all 3 bureaus false reporting to credit bureau fair credit reporting act fcra 1970 free credit repair report request copy credit report free hard inquiry vs soft inquiry on credit report car loans with bad how to get a loan with bad credit and no cosigner truly free tri merge credit report with scores landlord credit reports for tenants judgement credit report removed get free copy credit report trans union is free credit report accurate removal of inquiry on credit report company online credit check report mastercard companies report all three credit bureaus free credit report uk free prepaid cell phones no credit card required free report ads consumers credit history get collection account off credit report free credit report score 3 agencies credit report request form canada credit report federal free fcra how to get a free credit report and credit score best credit card rewards program 2010 consumer reports does credit report list previous addresses insurance company does not use credit reports my free credit report fico score myfico how to improve get your credit score free free credit report search new band credit scoring and its applications pdf free experian credit report colorado i need to fix my credit score get free credit report from all three how do i order all three credit reports does mean credit report says charge off obtain your credit report free annualcreditreport get free equifax credit report online personal solutions how long do collections accounts stay on your credit report credit report with credit score all three does kd nd mean your credit report free credit report service canada how can i fix errors on my credit report how to remove bankruptcy from credit report after 7 years how to view credit report pulling credit reports vermont annual credit report opt out free company credit report uk how long does a short sale appear on your credit report how do i correct my name on my credit report free annual credit report federal law copy annual report credit free kroll credit report my credit report free once year charged off accounts on your credit report remedies violations fair credit reporting act fcra how to get a free credit report for my business fair credit reporting act forms tsa airport shared national credit review report best way review credit report what is a charge off on your credit report mean get your full credit report free credit suisse wealth report world do checking accounts show up credit report factoring company account credit report by law free credit report how to put credit freeze on credit report free credit report band actors clear credit report free starting a credit how to start a computer repair business from home what is credit insurance for a car free annual government credit reports yearly free report experian credit scores federal agency enforces fair credit reporting act if a debt is not on my credit report do i have to pay it mall credit report companies sample letter remove judgment credit report bank america credit report lawsuit 3in1 credit report free trial email address for credit reporting agencies sue violations fair credit reporting act agencies long does bad credit history stay your report experian dispute credit report mail how do you find your credit report legit credit report ordering credit report mail experian free credit report cancel how to lift security freeze on credit reports temporarily reviews on reviews on dsi solutions credit repair fair credit reporting act laws free credit report contact fair credit reporting act definition consumer complaints agency definition of charge off on credit report run credit report rental tenant best credit score reporting experian what type of information is in a credit report how long does a bad credit report last credit reports for companies long does take bankruptcy clear credit report filing disputes on credit report how to get free credit score report online 3 credit reporting agency when do credit cards report late payments to credit bureau fair credit reporting act consumer report definition prbc? a national credit reporting agency can payday loan report your credit only free credit report government collection accounts on your credit report my fico credit reports free credit report ads lyrics pirate dispute something your credit report transunion annual credit report mail form victim of identity theft free credit report federal credit reporting act certification equifax credit report phone number canada fixing your credit report yourself three credit reporting agencies they important how to credit an invoice using credit report for employment how to correct credit report experian top credit report companies free annual credit card report pull credit report without authorization what information is not in a credit report government website annual credit reports what is visa citibank login credit card best place to get credit report for freeware checking credit report flowers score how to remove a derogatory item from a credit report government mandated free credit report site credit report do auto lenders use lyrics to new free credit report commercial when do credit cards reported to bureaus how often get all three credit reports once how to understand your 3 credit reports and scores free credit report georgians does mean my credit report says account charged off veda free credit history australia toll free numbers credit reporting agencies how long is a hard inquiry on my credit report credit report application download reading a credit report class action how to receive your free credit report how to remove paid collections on credit report hard inquiry credit report without permission how to remove a judgment on my credit report pay collection agency remove from credit report annual credit report for a business on line credit reports for landlords getting my free annual credit report best secured credit cards that report to the credit bureau does citibank report authorized users credit bureaus
Home Maury Brown The Definitive Case of Whether the A’s or Giants Once Controlled San Jose

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 504 guests online

Atom RSS

The Definitive Case of Whether the A’s or Giants Once Controlled San Jose PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 136
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 25 June 2013 22:44

The Battle for San Jose

The story is convoluted and obscured over time. The principles in the story have moved on, or passed away. The clubs at the heart of the debate have nearly shifted 180 degrees from where they once were, and the structure of Major League Baseball is under an entirely different organizational structure.

The story of who once controlled or gave away control of Santa Clara Co. has taken on new meaning now that the City of San Jose is suing the Office of the Commissioner saying that they are being aggrieved by the league’s arcane rules by disallowing the Athletics to move there. A large part of their case that challenges Major League Baseball’s antitrust exemption rests on the telling of how the San Francisco Giants acquired the now coveted region from the A’s.

On page 5 of the complaint (read it here), the plaintiffs claim:

In 1990, when the San Francisco Giants were considering selling the team and moving to Florida, Bob Lurie, the then-owner of the Giants, expressed interest in moving to San José. To accommodate the Giants, Walter Haas, the Athletics then-owner, gave his consent for the Giants to relocate to San José for no consideration paid to the Athletics. As a result, the MLB Constitution was amended to provide that the Giants hold territorial rights to the County of Santa Clara, which includes the City of San José. The Giants twice were unsuccessful in their attempt to obtain a publicly-funded stadium in the South Bay and although the Giants did not move, the Giants continued to claim the territorial rights to the County of Santa Clara.

The problem with this is it’s not the simple and it’s not as clear as it would be made out to be.

Two Leagues, Different Rules

A problem in the telling of the story of who controlled Santa Clara Co. is that unlike the filing by San Jose, the league was not under one set of rules—one Constitution that guided matters such as the territories of each of the clubs. At the time of Bob Lurie’s attempt to gain access to Santa Clara Co., the National League and American League were separate leagues. It was not until 2000 that Major League Baseball (under Bud Selig) determined a unified set of rules that governed territories based upon counties, rather than distance by radius, would become how to prevent potential land grabs, such as was seen in the 1960s during the Expansion Era. So, the plaintiff’s claim that, “As a result, the MLB Constitution was amended to provide that the Giants hold territorial rights to the County of Santa Clara, which includes the City of San José.” Is not quite correct. At least, not based upon the timeline provided. That would occur later. That would occur, not by one that owned rights or even shared rights relinquished control of Santa Clara Co., but rather, a discussion around something not controlled by either.

No Man’s Land

Here’s the truth of the matter: in the late ‘80s when Lurie failed to get a new ballpark built in San Francisco, and later when he saw not one, but two referendums fail to allow the Giants to move to Santa Clara Co., neither the Giants or the A’s controlled the area. It was, for lack of a better term, “no man’s land.” Remember, this is before Silicon Valley would explode into a major source of sponsors, and season ticket holders with deep wells of disposable income. At the time, the location was not nearly as fertile as it is seen now. The A’s had swept the Giants in the 1989 “Earthquake” World Series. The Giants played in Candlestick Park, and while not entirely new, the A’s were enjoying Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum before Al Davis would build in 1996 what would called “Mt. Davis”, blocking the view of the Oakland Hills. As John Shea of the San Francisco Chronicle wrote in 2009:

As Wally Haas tells the story, the A's were approached by Giants exec Corey Busch requesting exclusive rights to the area before the Giants' proposed ballparks in Santa Clara and San Jose.

The A's said OK, and the transfer became official when baseball owners granted approval.

That was it.

"We shared the territorial rights up to that point, the Giants and the A's," Haas said on the set of "Chronicle Live" on Thursday. "They asked if we would cede those rights to them so they could go through the referendum, and we felt that was fine."

Except that wasn’t quite it. Yes, Busch approached Haas. Yes, Haas agreed to give the Giants access to Santa Clara Co., but it was because no one controlled the area. It was a case of, “Since neither one of us own this location, you mind if we take it?”

The problem was, there was nothing memorialized that said that if the Giants didn’t get the referendums passed the territory would go back to being neutral or even co-controlled in the truest sense as many clubs that reside in single-large markets now share. As the Shea story adds, "Once the referendums failed, one could say, 'Well, maybe you should have gone back to a shared situation,' " said Haas, son of the late owner Walter Haas Jr. "We didn't ask for it. We weren't looking to build a new stadium. That's just the way it stood."

And since then, the issue has changed. The Giants will say that they’ve cultivated the market and it was a wholly different time when sponsorship dollars were not as hotly contested as they were prior. The A’s will say that the Giants aren’t truly forced into the situation, but that they’re not exactly moving the karma meter forward, and that technicalities be damned, it’s the right thing to do. Look at what’s occurred. It’s come to the league’s antitrust status being challenged.

The Legal Case Has Holes, but It Could Force the Issue

The San Jose case has serious holes in it. For one, the complaint tries to make claim that on Dec. 31 of 2012, the league’s constitution expired, and MLB is ostensibly running around without one in place. This would be like saying that the CBA between the league and the MLBPA was about to expire and no one was paying attention. There is of course one in place, however gaining access to a copy is likely only going to surface through the power of subpoena. As to a subpoena, a recent San Francisco Chronicle column made it sound like Bud Selig had been hiding in closets for 3 days, terrified at the San Jose’s case challenging MLB’s antitrust status. The papers were served at the New York offices of the league, not Milwaukee where Selig retains his office. That’s why there was a delay. It’s not as if the league hasn’t been subpoenaed.

All the positioning aside, the matter of relocation to San Jose—either by brute force by the courts or the league’s owners voting in favor—comes with serious barbs. In either of those scenarios, the precedent would be set to allow other clubs to move about more freely. Don’t think Stu Sternberg wouldn’t consider moving the Rays to Newark, NJ after the A’s got into San Jose?

And then there’s the potential lawsuit by the Giants, although in Article VI (Arbitration), Section 2 of the June 2005 copy of the Major League Constitution reads (bolding by author):

The Major League Clubs recognize that it is in the best interests of Baseball that all actions taken by the Commissioner under the authority of this Constitution, including, without limitation, Article II and this Article VI, be accepted and complied with by the Clubs, and that the Clubs not otherwise engage in any form of litigation between or among themselves or with any Major League Baseball entity, but resolve their differences pursuant to the provisions of this Constitution. In furtherance thereof, the Clubs (on their own behalf and including, without limitation, on behalf of their owners, officers, directors and employees) severally agree to be finally and unappealably bound by actions of the Commissioner and all other actions, decisions or interpretations taken or reached pursuant to the provisions of this Constitution and severally waive such right of recourse to the courts as would otherwise have existed in their favor. In the event of any legal action other than as prescribed by Section 1 of this Article VI by any Club (including, without limitation, their owners, officers, directors  and employees) in connection with any dispute or controversy related in any way to  professional baseball, or in the event of noncompliance with any action of the Commissioner, with any action or decision taken or reached pursuant to the provisions  of this Constitution, or with the terms or intent of this Article VI, in addition to any other remedy that may be available to the Commissioner, the Commissioner may direct that the costs, including attorneys' fees, to the Office of the Commissioner or any other Baseball entity, whether as plaintiff or defendant, of any court proceeding or other form of litigation resulting therefrom be reimbursed to the Office of the Commissioner or such other Baseball entity by such non-complying Club (on its own behalf and including, without limitation, on behalf of its owners, officers, directors and employees). Nothing herein shall be construed to limit any rights of indemnity that the Major League Clubs or any Major League Baseball entity may have against any Club.

There is truth that the league sees powers that they wish to retain, especially as it pertains to territorial movement of the clubs. This is not unique to baseball. All the major sports leagues have held this interest. In that, the change from the time when Bob Lurie approached Walter Haas has changed dramatically. That move in 2000 that united the National and American Leagues, the umpires and the overarching facets that now make Major League Baseball one entity have changed. The constitution has been altered to where this mess (yes, that’s what we will call it) between the A’s and Giants would have never occurred. Now, 75 percent of the league’s owners must approve relocation or expansion, which would tie into a vote to amend the league constitution to redefine who controls (or co-controls) a territory. In that, there could be a historic sense of the ironic involved. While it is impossible to see what the final outcome of the legal case by San Jose, or whether Commissioner Selig and the owners finally move on the matter by their own accord, the possibility that one part of the solution would see the A’s and the Giants co-control Santa Clara Co. It seems unfathomable that the Giants would relinquish it entirely. Not that Corey Busch didn’t approach Walter Haas on behalf of Bob Lurie and say, “Walter, you mind if we take this land… if you’re not?” In the end, Santa Clara Co. will never become no man’s land again… but it could certainly be something that both the A’s and Giants would have a vested controlling interest in.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on TwitterTwitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?