remove late payment from credit report letter credit cards reporting irs fair credit reporting act amendments 2010 what does charged off on credit report mean how to run a credit report on yourself how to get your credit score from credit report safe place get credit report how do i get free credit reports authorization to pull credit report form one time free credit report per year often can you dispute your credit report what does a credit reporting analyst do how to get my credit report for free online credit report free government site free credit report government online credit reporting code of conduct 2.7 dispute experian credit report through mail credit report letters of explanation credit report repair letters register all 3 national business credit reporting agencies free best place to get credit reports get free credit reports government free credit reports all 3 agencies what information cannot be legally included in your credit reports name all credit reporting agencies experian removing bad debt from credit report does mean credit report says charged off bad debt free annual credit reports gov experian lock credit report credit score reporting agency do collection agencies have access credit reports the only really free credit report authorized cheap credit report tenant transunion credit report phone number first community credit union credit report credit reporting scores annual credit report vs score fair credit reporting act consumer report privacy info do you need credit report get your credit history report free absolutely free credit reports no trial credit report.com cancel account gao report credit card interchange fees how to make corrections to a credit report review equifax credit report online correct wrong address credit report how often are you entitled to a free credit report reasons for disputing credit report items eviction on credit report how long best credit score reporting agency bureaus go free credit report phone number disputing credit report online vs mail how doo i freeze my report free credit reporting late rent payments to a credit bureau credit consumer report detailed credit report without credit card free credit report checks online how long can collections stay on credit report 11 credit bureau report monitoring how can i get my credit report for free online experian how long does bad debt stay on your credit report how would you report a lost or stolen credit card free credit report band net worth equifax freeze credit report how do i remove negative items from my credit report how to remove collection agency from credit report new york state fair credit reporting act ways to improve your credit report get your free credit report online without a credit card credit report america how to get a free annual credit report in canada experian annual credit report uk safe 3 top credit reporting agencies experian how can i get a public record off my credit report long do credit inquiries stay your credit report remove court judgment credit report free annual credit report service consumers us company credit reports best credit report sites for free credit report 2 the only free annual credit report they how long does chapter 13 stay on credit report new free credit report commercial saw get all 3 credit report scores free annual 5 credit bureau reports how long is a bankruptcy on your credit report in canada which is best credit report equifax experian or transunion credit report after bankruptcy discharge canada experian credit report copy how to report to a credit agency best website checking credit report citi monitoring credit report mini credit report contact us cheapest way to get my credit report official site get annual free credit report fair free credit report cancellation fee new york state credit reporting laws free 3 bureau credit report and fico score business credit reporting bureaus credit reports ?2 how do i clear up my credit report how bad are inquiries on your credit report my free annual credit report online where do i get my official free credit report fair and accurate credit report act correct my credit report after bankruptcy can get credit report bank where can you get your free yearly credit report fico credit reporting agencies free credit report no card details required uk what personal information goes on your credit report free credit report usaa fair equifax credit free report disputing credit report equifax online equifax credit report confirmation number don;t i get 1 free credit report a year how do i get my free credit report canada best credit cards with rewards consumer report free credit report.com bike song lyrics credit report reporting deceased time bankruptcy stays credit report most widely used credit reporting agency can i get a free visa report if i have been denied credit how to remove an error on my credit report consumer report on credit cards get credit report free transunion phone numbers for three credit reporting agencies transunion commercial credit report experian credit report access how to pull credit report for free illegal pull someone else;s credit report help me clean my credit report credit score and report free all 3 credit reports why can;t i see my credit report mail credit report dispute experian the only free credit report website small business reporting to the credit bureaus lock mall credit reports charge off credit report long pay collections remove credit report credit union 5300 call reports credit report best place credit report codes receive my free credit reports free credit report score annual credit card reporting laws how can i obtain a free copy of my credit report secured credit card reports all three how to report bad credit canada should request all 3 reports same time credit bureaus negative information credit reports experian capital report if denied credit mni credit report services unauthorized free credit report songs wikipedia federal free credit report program free sample credit report dispute letter obtaining a credit report on tenant screening card companies all 3 bureaus personal solutions credit reports credit report 1 time charge equifax free credit report fico score letter to credit report disputing free credit report and score band how to report a death to the credit bureau credit report delinquency report lost target visa credit card negative items removed my credit report getting a free credit report in canada equifax free credit report by phone what is fair credit reporting act disclosure how to obtain free annual credit report government free annual credit report canada equifax current employer credit report getting credit report renter get fico credit report credit report rental history band search free credit report 3 free credit report score credit reporting agency fair credit reporting act under section how to get rid of charge offs on credit report my credit report government phone numbers all 3 credit reporting agencies top sites check credit report access how can you order a copy of your credit report will checking your own credit report lower my score the purpose of the fair credit reporting act (fcra) is to is one credit reporting agency better than another free annual experian credit report is annual online safe free credit report get credit report prospective tenant correcting a credit report get credit report for ?2 credit report contact us best free credit reports review how to get free report and score credit bureaus reporting stolen credit card free credit report without giving credit card information loans remove hard inquiry on credit report download credit union call report credit reporting services comparison how do i run a credit report on a company 3 credit reports free how to get a sealed credit report credit report consumer affairs difference between credit report and credit score canada long does negative credit report stay get once a year credit report best site to pull your credit report can you remove charge offs your credit report free tenant screening credit report credit report how to dispute what is considered a bad credit report free credit report commercial renaissance fair lyrics how to report a death to credit bureaus free report uk only credit score free 10 year credit report padlock all credit reports what is your credit report clear your credit report credit report job application how do i get a credit report free how do you get your credit report fixed equifax canada phone number free credit report bank of america remove from credit report free credit report 31.95 charge how long does it take to get a late payment off your credit report view free credit report experian credit report scoring models how to obtain your free yearly credit report obtain free credit report online completely free no credit card needed credit report best way get copy your credit report credit report federal gov ftc does requesting a free credit report hurt my credit foreclosure credit report how long free 3 credit reports annual freeze my credit report california how to access my experian credit report what are the three credit reporting agencies get 1 free credit report improve credit report after bankruptcy sample equifax credit report canada best way to get free credit report credit union call report information free credit report government score how to figure out your credit score from your credit report remove collections from credit report 1 credit report free credit report guide freecreditreport.com get your free credit report mail 3 free credit report scores check my free credit report online collections agency report credit bureau long will chapter 7 bankruptcy stay your credit report where do you get free annual credit report long hard inquiries credit report credit report without credit card information loans payday owing irs credit report obligations imposed upon employer fair credit reporting act 1968 credit report and score one time payment how do you challenge your credit report extended alert on credit report fixing your credit report score long does take debt clear your credit report how dog you clean up your credit report for free secret security clearance credit report get free credit report score without credit card experian 3 credit report score georgia free credit report law certified copy my credit report report stolen credit cards bank america tricks improving credit report how long does it take to get a good credit report your one free credit report per year best place get free annual credit report credit report transunion free free credit report and credit score from government state of iowa free credit report fair credit reporting act regulations cfr free credit report by transunion transunion enhanced credit report user guide arizona state free credit report impact foreclosure your credit report commonwealth massachusetts credit report how to find collection agency on your credit report delete medical collections credit report free credit report equifax ca check definition consumer protection agency under fair credit reporting act free report gov canada credit score what is the most popular credit reporting agency my free credit report equifax how can i get a free credit report online can you get your credit report freeware transunion online free credit report lyrics to free credit report dot com commercial fair accurate credit reporting act section 114 cancel free credit report phone number where can i go to get a free copy of my credit report rels credit reporting service what happens when you dispute your credit report reliable credit reports agency consumer sovereign bank report lost credit card free credit score report no charge credit report rating india where to go to get free annual credit report how often does my credit report get updated foreign credit reporting system michigan government free credit report ce credit report 800 free credit report commercial song freeze your credit report clark howard download credit report experian understanding equifax credit reports how long does bankruptcy take to come off credit report state tax lien credit report released help with credit report repair get free credit report ga removing a charge off from your credit report free credit report without paying dime free report gov us credit score government sponsored free annual credit report online indiana gov free credit report which is the better credit reporting agency ftc free report score personal solutions credit cibil credit report india erase inquiries off credit report understanding your credit report uk credit score reports experian credit report address disputes cost of annual credit report credit check report canada georgia state tax lien credit report ftc credit report dispute letter how do i print out my credit report for free credit report fix letters chexsystems vs credit report how to get copy of credit report free massachusetts credit report free free canadian credit report how to read credit report canada is credit report and credit score the same thing get your free credit report online now experian fair credit report background check consumer protection agency credit reports secure free annual credit report best 3 bureau report credit card ordering credit report free credit report all 3 companies experian get derogatory accounts off credit report where to get credit report and score dispute a credit report experian false reporting to credit bureau statistics fair credit reporting act violations getting credit reports from all 3 difference between free credit score and free credit report good credit report sample remove paid tax lien my credit report report federal reporting period my credit best place get canadian credit report which credit reports are free project report credit risk analysis first advantage credco credit report many points inquiry credit report lock credit report free how do you correct a bad credit report annual credit report uk free credit report.com cell phone song and lyrics order experian credit report ?2 when does equifax update credit report new free credit report website dispute collections credit report canada government free credit reports once a year clean my credit report fast top ten credit report websites free credit report from all 4 bureaus best site check credit report derogatory information your credit report there free credit report without debit card information how to clean up my credit report for free where to get annual free credit report free credit report virginia run tenant credit report free report under fair reporting act credit rating free trimerge credit report scores how can i get a copy of my credit report online reserve annual credit report federal law free yearly credit report request myspace free credit report dot com roller coaster lyrics free credit report guys wiki how to clear a judgement in your credit report order innovis credit report r9 rating on your credit report best way to view free credit report free annual credit report with credit score best place to purchase credit report experian debt report due to denied credit small business jobs and credit act 1099 reporting is employment history on credit report order credit report from transunion on phone my credit report online free credit report tenant screening wrong information credit report canada credit suisse report on indian banks remove paid public record credit report bank america credit report service how to get credit report without credit card one time fee credit report how to get a paid collection removed from credit report instant free credit report score forms for disputing items on credit report credit report monitoring services free credit report state maryland residents letter to correct credit report business credit reporting laws does bell canada report credit bureau how to report lost credit card wells fargo what is the fair credit reporting act of 1970 credit report clean up services dispute experian credit report by phone how to cancel free credit report dcom service get a free credit report online credit report all three bureaus does mean your credit report charged off get free credit score report canada can you dispute an inquiry on your credit report addresses credit reporting agencies disputes free report online instantly credit history best credit report service future free credit report online instantly new 1099 reporting requirements credit card payments free report through irs credit scores free us government credit reports government official credit report site score debt credit reporting agency remove closed accounts my credit report credit report mailed equifax visa report if denied credit free all in one credit report ofac alert on credit report how often does equifax update credit report difference between credit score and report how to find out my credit report for free read my transunion credit report free credit report.com new car lyrics free credit report scores no credit card request free credit report denied credit negative information credit report how to unfreeze my equifax a credit report 3 credit reporting agencies pennsylvania credit reporting laws federal government free credit report place lock credit report free credit report band back together freeze your credit report transunion medical collections credit report removal how do you contest your credit report cheapest credit report service obtain all 3 credit reports free how to report a delinquency to credit bureau agencies experian denied credit report freeware expert credit report how to report good renters to credit bureau what is the best site to get your free credit report reporting a tenant to credit bureau fair credit reporting act state laws free bank of america credit report project report credit risk management bank verbal authorization to obtain credit report order experian credit report by mail fair credit reporting act of 1970 how do i get my canadian credit report how do i file a dispute on my credit report remove paid judgment credit report top three reporting bureaus credit score do business credit cards show up on credit report three in one credit report with scores bureaus county court judgements on credit report credit report cost does checking credit report affect credit score how do i view my credit report uk credit report free credit card what shows on your credit report after a bankruptcy collection paid in full credit report equifax credit score report free advantus mortgage credit reports free credit report rights where should i get my free credit report from consumer;s guide credit reports credit scores free credit report commercial videos report to credit agencies derogatory items in credit report credit reporting score privacy 123 credit report calculate your credit score credit report review my credit report free online credit reports canada does a free credit report include credit score credit check fair credit reporting act how to get the credit report in india cbc credit bureau reports
Home Maury Brown The Sports World Loses an Icon in Marvin Miller While the HOF Looks the Other Way

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 983 guests online

Atom RSS

The Sports World Loses an Icon in Marvin Miller While the HOF Looks the Other Way PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 7
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 27 November 2012 16:32
Marvin Miller

Former MLBPA Executive Director Marvin Miller passed away today at 95, but long before today, I have been thinking of Miller. His presence on professional sports has been so indelible that even if he was “before my time” his shadow has been felt as greatly today as it was yesterday. All you have to do is look at how labor negotiations between the NFLPA and NFL, NBPA and NBA, or more recently the NHL and NHLPA to feel Miller’s reach. As the great Italian philosopher George Santayana said, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” At the time of the NFL lockout, Roger Goodell and the owners seemed to forget that. NFLPA Executive Director DeMaurice Smith met with Miller on more than one occasion before and during the lockout… clearly, De knew his history.

Miller was selected by the players as their union head in 1966 and led the players until 1982. From the beginning, he set about to do the unthinkable: challenge MLB on the grounds of  labor law, something he was exceptionally versed in during his time as a negotiator for the United Steelworkers union. The owners, and then commissioner Bowie Kuhn were incensed. Instead of being judge, jury, and executioner, now they had to deal with this guy and the players’ then general counsel, Dick Moss.

Miller delved out huge dose of the truth and the owners repeatedly spit it out. It created an acerbic, volatile relationship in the labor relationship that created three strikes during his tenure.

To understand the difference in the relationship back then, I interviewed not only Miller, but Moss, as well. In the interview with Moss in 2007, we had this exchange:

Maury Brown: Can you recall what the first meetings between you and Miller were about once you were installed as general council?

Dick Moss: Well, the first thing that was to be done after Marvin was retained was the negotiations regarding the Pension Agreement. In December, 1966, there was a Board meeting to be held in Pittsburgh. Marvin invited me to that meeting and introduced me to the players’ representatives at that time, as the new general counsel.

Brown: For those that may not understand the differences between how the relationship between management and labor were in early years of the Players Association to how they are today, can you go over how some of the initial disputes, such as management’s issues over the players’ pension plan in 1966?

Moss: There was a general issue that they were accepting it as a labor union – accepting the legitimacy of it. It was as if they were treating it as if we were meddlers – outsiders in the business of baseball. That’s not right.

I remember in one of the early meetings, Joe Cronin, who was then the President of the American League, became very upset when we were talking about scheduling problems. Joe said, “This is none of the players’ business. This is our business.” And he got up and walked out of the meeting. It was little things like that that would happen.

Brown: If there was a word to describe what management probably thought of Miller and you when it was clear you would not be simply “going along for the ride”, what do you think it was?

Moss: Well, Marvin tells the story about his first involvement when he went to the All-Star Game in 1966 – I think it was with Joe Cronin again. It was just after it was announced that he was the new Executive Director of the Players’ Association. And Joe said to him, “Marvin there’s something you’ve got to remember. Players come and go, but the owners are there forever.”

It wasn’t until 2002 that the union and league learned that working collectively would be the only way to get to labor peace. That while there would be differences, working together as partners was going to be in everyone’s best interest and all would reap the benefits (it's not surprising that MLB's extensive growth has come during labor peace). The NFL, NBA, and NHL still aren’t there yet.

So, it’s no surprise that a wave of comments have spilled forth today about Miller. Those on the union side of things were lengthy in their feelings.

 “It is with profound sorrow that we announce the passing of Marvin Miller,” said current MLBPA Executive Director, Michael Weiner. “All players – past, present and future – owe a debt of gratitude to Marvin, and his influence transcends baseball. Marvin, without question, is largely responsible for ushering in the modern era of sports, which has resulted in tremendous benefits to players, owners and fans of all sports.

“It was an honor and a privilege to have known Marvin. The industry has never witnessed a more honorable man, and his passion for helping others and his principled resolve serve as the foundation of the MLBPA to this day. On behalf of all Major Leaguers and MLBPA staff, I extend my heartfelt sympathies to Marvin’s daughter, Susan, son, Peter, their families and Marvin’s many friends and admirers. Marvin was a champion among champions, and his legacy will live on forever.”

“Marvin possessed a combination of integrity, intelligence, eloquence, courage and grace that is simply unmatched in my experience,” said former MLBPA Executive Director, Don Fehr, who worked under Miller as General Counsel from 1977-82 and is now mired in the lockout of the National Hockey League as the Executive Director of the NHLPA. “Without question, Marvin had more positive influence on Major League Baseball than any other person in the last half of the 20th century. It was a rare privilege for me to be able to work for him and with him. All of us who knew him will miss him enormously.”

“Marvin exemplified guts, tenacity and an undying love for the players he represented,” said NFLPA Executive Director DeMaurice Smith. “He was a mentor to me, and we spoke often and at length. His most powerful message was that players would remain unified during labor strife if they remembered the sacrifices made by previous generations to make the game better. His passion for the players never faltered, and men and women across all sports are in a better place thanks to his tireless work.”

“Marvin was the definition of a leader,” said NFLPA President Domonique Foxworth. “By challenging team owners and league commissioners and successfully protecting and enhancing the rights of players, he proved that labor unions were necessary in sports.”

On the owners’ side, Commissioner Selig was more Spartan in his statement:

“Marvin Miller was a highly accomplished executive and a very influential figure in baseball history.  He made a distinct impact on this sport, which is reflected in the state of the game today, and surely the Major League players of the last half-century have greatly benefited from his contributions.  On behalf of Major League Baseball and the 30 Clubs, I extend my deepest condolences to Marvin’s family, friends and colleagues.”

Yet, for all Miller meant, not only to baseball, but to every other professional sports league where there is union representation, he has yet to be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. The man that brought about independent arbitration, minimum wage, advancement in benefits,  and most importantly, free agency, breaking the Reserve Clause, in 1975 when Andy Messermith and Dave McNally held out renewing contracts and arbitrator Peter Seitz ruled in their favor, is not in the HOF while the likes of a bumbling Bowie Kuhn, is. That highlights the flaws in those that have comprised the voters in different committee formats over the years that have clearly, gotten it wrong.

As I covered today for Baseball Prospectus, Miller was never one to mince words, which is largely why the voters didn’t get the percentages big enough for inclusion, something that is a glaring omission.

When Jay Jaffe interviewed him in 2008 for BP, Miller said, “[T]hey abolished that [first Veterans Committee I was eligible for in 1982] which had kind of been scandal-ridden in the sense that the only way they could elect anybody was to engage in vote trading. You support my guy and I'll support your guy, and out the window went merit. So they abolished that committee and that was understandable. Then they created a new one, this time composed of all of the living members of the Hall of Fame. For the first time I was put on a ballot in 2003, and my vote was far short of the 75 percent needed, and that was OK.” When the committee structure changed, it was again a case of owners that Miller had raised the ire of having a key stake in blocking his induction.

Miller added, “Nine out of 12 people were management people and what few if any people have commented about is that among the nine people...”

Jaffe: Three legacies? [Bill DeWitt Jr., Andy MacPhail, Bill Giles]

Miller: No, three who were among the leaders of the collusion movement against players [DeWitt, MacPhail, and John Harrington]. Let's remember that I was the negotiator of the anti-collusion language, and let's also remember that I was the lead witness in the collusion case against the owners. As you may know, there were two separate cases, and both impartial arbitrators rejected the sworn testimony of these now-former general managers that there was no such thing as collusion. In other words, without even using the word "perjury," in effect that's what two impartial arbitrators found, that the testimony before them represented. And these were to be my judges. The whole thing is absurd.

Indeed, Miller’s sharp words were not just for those former executives, he had them for the writers when I interviewed him in 2004:

“And then there are members of the press who vote who are the newspaper reporters wing of the Hall of Fame,” said Miller. “While some of those might vote for me many would not. There were a lot of them who were,  if not in the owners’ pockets, at least on their laps. There are the radio and TV announcers who interestingly enough in almost every case cannot be announcers in radio and TV unless the clubs that they are telecasting or broadcasting agree. They hold the veto power over them.”

So, it should come as no surprise that Miller, ever a man to stand on principles over horse trading, took the unprecedented stand in 2008 of telling the Hall of Fame to, basically, kiss off.

Paradoxically, I'm writing to thank you and your associates for your part in nominating me for Hall of Fame consideration, and, at the same time, to ask that you not do this again... The anti-union bias of the powers who control the Hall has consistently prevented recognition of the historic significance of the changes to baseball brought about by collective bargaining.

As former executive director of the players' union that negotiated these changes, I find myself unwilling to contemplate one more rigged Veterans Committee whose members are handpicked to reach a particular outcome while offering a pretense of a democratic vote. It is an insult to baseball fans, historians, sports writers, and especially to those baseball players who sacrificed and brought the game into the 21st century. At the age of 91 I can do without a farce.

And yet today when I reached former commissioner Fay Vincent and asked whether he should be inducted, he simply replied, “He should be in.”

He should be. If you’re going to allow executives to be part of the Hall of Fame, and in my opinion, they should, then Miller should be there. In the sports world, it’s criminal that he didn’t make it in his lifetime, and it will be bittersweet if he somehow makes it posthumously.

But, I reflect more humanly on Miller today with his passing. True, he still held to his early unionized ways, something that seems out of touch in the here and now (he was dead set against drug testing, etc. in baseball). But, even in his elderly state, he was one of the smartest people that you could talk to. He had this incredible ability to take complex labor matters and present it in a wholly digestible format, which was one of his endearing strengths.

Beyond that, there was his life, and if you knew him, his love of tennis was one of them. Beyond being with his wife, I hope that somewhere in the afterlife, he’s playing tennis with Arthur Ashe. For those of us here, at least for every player that collects a paycheck in professional sports, one can hope all heads are bowed in respect for Miller’s passing. Until he’s inducted into the Hall of Fame, I and others will keep his fire burning. Farewell, Marvin.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes. He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network (select his name in the dropdown provided).

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on TwitterTwitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?