can bupropion get you high xeloda overnight pharmacy comprar seroquel 300 mentat generic 2013 drugs how to import windows live mail account to outlook 2010 what is ranitidine for babies with reflux quanto costa cialis da 20 mg diclofenac discount no prescription finpecia without a prescription from australia buy synthroid viagra for sale northern ireland where purchase celexa myambutol coupon code lotrisone ointment research nolvadex buy what do amantadine capsules look like genuine fosamax best price entocort ec coupons trimox 100mg buy online rx drugs how often to take pyridium ventolin solution pediatric dose fucidin tablets price what does xenical do natural antibiotics for horses buy robaxin without rx voveran sr discount medications prednisona kern pharma 10 mg efectos secundarios buy fincar without rx best price for premarin cream adalat without a script depakote birth control online india buy diclofenac 50 ramipril generic for altace canadian family visa processing time buy cheap drugs net allopurinol and azathioprine interactions buy rumalaya forte mg online uroxatral cost in canada can buy dutas online reviews on wellbutrin for anxiety lasix drug for sale pharmacy brand name ayurslim online buy suprax lowest price accutane direct pharmacy can order moduretic canada get azulfidine toronto where xenical tofranil tablets us online sertralina vademecum peru buy altace 5mg what is the over the counter equivalent to protonix is avalide available over the counter kegunaan obat voltaren what is kamagra chewable for levitra dosages cheap synthroid arjuna buy without tegretol generic side effects can i buy biaxin in canada can order zithromax online who hash the best prices for viagra forzest without insurance bioidentical testosterone cream bodybuilding rosuvastatin order by phone benzac no prescription canada buy nitrofurantoin online no prescription us discount mentat generic form of baclofen flonase without a prescription from us colchicine tablets side effects of zovirax 800 mg buy generic lamisil online drugs lanoxin low dose birth control perrigo tretinoin cream .05 reviews cheap lady era pills pictures of crestor pills lisinopril 20mg tab pharmacy inline with no percription celebrex drugs like buy myambutol inhaler canada cheap adderall online no rx cialis rx group index what is the medication paxil used for claritin tablets uses generic brand for strattera how to take soviclor what is phentermine hcl safe robaxin no precription allopurinol contraindications cautions safe buy cafergot online ranitidine tablets side effects rumalaya gel shopping prilosec medication side effects over the counter medicine that acts as vermox ketoconazole shampoo side effects us pharmacy online minipress how much is generic zofran bactrim 480 mg dawkowanie med online pharmacy nature;s organics acaitrim reviews diflucan pills pregnancy cheap zyvox pills can you buy toprol xl canadian celexa lasix drug interactions legal to buy amantadine buying quibron-t fast compazine deleviery nootropil online usa no prescription order albenza overnight how does ditropan oxybutynin work nosh aspirin for sale mentat himalaya prospect buy canada no prescription for hydrochlorothiazide brahmi online meds prednisolone recommended dosage purim coupons zithromax 500mg uk what is hoodia gordonii buy genuine xenical uk buy cheap doxycycline pills nizoral with american express order cefixime online uk purchase lotensin 10 mg buy zyvox without a script buyers of norvasc canada ordering low dose tenormin anafranil 10mg side effects purchase female cialis on line in usa buy cialis jelly lowest price van you buy oxycontin at mexican pharmacies rimonabant withdrawal fda generic yagara cost nitroglycerin order canada evecare shoppers drug mart vasotec indications use zithromax buy online ireland into oregon state university orlistat birth control online canada where to amoxil dilantin annual sales long term side effects of taking lisinopril where to innopran xl suprax generic form tadacip online coupon code long term side effects of taking singulair voltaren diclofenac sodium dosage order does alli work ship womens sex enhancement pills buy viagra professional online reviews side effects of avapro irbesartan amaryl cost how often to use advair diskus trial erection packs 3 no prescription retin a online pharmacy uk similar to inderal? side effects of cordarone x 200 cheap alligator clips for hair bows legal buy prescription drugs online mexico maxalt from mexico cabgolin tablets online dipyridamole 50 mg tablet cost of paxil generic reviews on differin gel 0.1 generic pharmacy franchise price is it safe to take viagra while drinking alcohol best price antivert buy maxalt visa can your buy cialis professional in ireland online drug shop purchase minocycline cheap generic asacol generic 2013 yagara for purchase betnovate rd ointment in pregnancy what does saas mean alli simpson difference between viagra professional and viagra super active amaryl comments can you take levitra daily ventolin express canada buy lioresal paypal canada rx online reviews powakaddy sport lithium best price
Home Maury Brown The BBWAA, Bryant Gumbel, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, and the Hall of Fame

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1564 guests online

Atom RSS

The BBWAA, Bryant Gumbel, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, and the Hall of Fame PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 11
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 17 July 2012 17:23

Maury BrownWondering when would be a good time to write this column, it seems that opportunity has finally landed in my lap. The issue is the Hall of Fame, and the inclusion process, namely as it pertains to those players in the “Steroid Era.”

Grappling with the subject really means an examination of the Hall of Fame, the players in the Steroid Era, and those in the voting process, many of whom are part of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA).

As is often the case when one goes about selecting anything for inclusion into a group, the more defined you set the criteria, the easier it is to place items into one bucket or the other. When it comes to players in baseball, the use of statistics is often the measure of defining greatness.

But, it isn’t the “Hall of Greatness” it’s the “Hall of Fame” and with it, the criteria for inclusion has become muddied. Throw in that there are players that have been out-and-out proven to use performance-enhancing drugs, or worse, suspected of using, and the waters are as clear as split-pea soup on who should, or should not, get votes.

Into the fray, people like myself weigh in, but others as well. Such will be the case when Bryant Gumbel has his closing remarks on HBO’s Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel (10pm ET/PT). Bryant will close with the following:

“Finally tonight comes word that Reggie Jackson has wisely decided to pass on this weekend’s induction ceremonies at Cooperstown. You may have seen that Jackson recently caused a stir by suggesting that a variety of baseball notables didn’t merit inclusion in the Hall of Fame. Now, because his judgment was personal and his timing terrible, Reggie has since retreated from his stated views. But here’s hoping that the gist of what he said isn’t altogether lost on the Hall’s voters.

You see Reggie was basically right in contending that the hall should be special and its doors should not be opened just because someone stuck around long enough to collect 3,000 hits or 300 wins. Yes, the numbers are proof of some very good players. But as the former star pitcher Jim Kaat has often noted so astutely, Cooperstown’s supposed to be a Hall of Fame – not a hall of achievement.

If the voters are really so obsessed with honoring guys with the numbers, they’d be wise to start rethinking the exclusion of those megastars linked to steroids, and do it quickly. Because the next Cooperstown ballot will, for the first time, include among others, both the seven-time MVP Barry Bonds and the seven-time Cy Young winner Roger Clemens. And while both men have a suspect past, it’s going to be hard to argue they don’t deserve a bust in Cooperstown. After all, a hall of fame that somehow excludes the game’s homerun king and its most honored pitcher and its all-time hits leader, would really be making a mockery of itself.”

The debate about whether a player is worthy of inclusion means you have to understand the mind of the voters, and with that, you get wildly divergent opinions, often passionately so. Many of the writers I’ve spoken with have held fast to the position that they will not vote for a player that fits Barry Bonds or Roger Clemens for the Hall of Fame, falling into two camps: “never” and “not on the first ballot.”

It’s here where there’s some wiggle room. It’s here that I side with the non-voters of the latter ilk. No, I do not have a vote, but if the good graces ever fall upon me, it seems more than reasonable to make a statement on the issues of performance-enhancing drugs and its effects on the statistics by which we should measure “greatness” by saying a voter deserves the right to consider a player such as Bonds or Clemens for the Hall of Fame, but it won’t be on the first ballot.” You’re not saying you won’t vote for him; just not now.

Finally, the larger question surrounds the fact that it is the Hall of “Fame” and therefore, you’re talking about something subjective. Bonds and Clemens certainly meet the “fame” criteria. Whether their greatness was fueled in part by better- performance-through-chemistry, is ultimately a question that can’t definitively be answered.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He writes for Baseball Prospectus and is a contributor to Forbes.He is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network (select his name in the dropdown provided).

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on TwitterTwitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?