safety 1st air protect car seat cover nationwide toyota extended warranty coverage cilajet paint protection care warranty car extended service looking for ct dealers white lifetime warranty cars hyundai great lakes warranty complaints smart carchex auto warranty complaints canadian black book used vehicle prices how to make auto protect ffx canadian used auto consumer reports us car warranty accounting jobs in canada motor vehicle services us auto protection smyrna ga library buy auto rickshaw ukulele vehicle service checklist pdf best place to purchase bmw extended warranty vehicle sales in canada 2012 instant car insurance quote singapore mrt 2012 jd power auto ratings best website to buy buy used cars in canada cost to repair car dents car window chip repair calgary canada american fidelity extended warranty insurance car quotes price toyota vehicle service agreement refund craigslist portland used auto parts lexus lowes extended warranty complaints aa car warranties prices of modular purchase auto from individual contributor best used vehicles 1998 to 2002 toyota toyota used car extended warranty auto butler paint protection locations in florida should i buy extended warranty bmw 3 series best bmw new vehicle warranty compare manufacturers route 66 extended auto warranties buy a vehicle rent a fiat from enterprise motor vehicle services us auto protection smyrna ga air conditioning list of average auto repair costs aa consumer reports auto warranty ratings auto parts warehouse discount code geico auto repair coverage as seen on tv auto repair shops for rent millennium automotive protection plan warranty service gardx paint protection buy auto door protection trim down club xpel paint protection film top rated auto extended warranty reviews ratings for travelers auto insurance yamaha extended service warranty extended vehicle service warranty difference between warranty and representation insurance dealer extended warranty used car toyota new vehicle lubrico warranty canada reviews paint repair car perth easycare warranty only coupons for oil changes how to repair a dent in a car door car window repair cardiff hotels extended warranty for used car dealers all car auto painting & body repair ludski auto body repairs how much do auto extended warranties cost of living top rated chrysler extended vehicle warranties car care plan cosmetic warranty central extended warranties on used cars is it worth it lyrics texas vehicle purchase tax subaru may 2014 car sales extended warranty cost 2015 subaru outback reviews best buy automotive equipment ohio warranty coverage on is 250 misfire movie puncture repair car tyre prices extended warranty best wheels for bmw 3 series repair car headliner used car warranty insurance australia can;t enable symantec auto protect mercedes benz discover card warranty extension car auto body paint shop vehicle repair insurance companies auto one warranty toshiba irvine ca address rac warranty vehicle asset protection security us direct car warranty reviews car paint repair cost uk work car repair loans ontario used vehicle bill of sale form auto warranty life insurance scams protection carrosserie 4x4 cost of repairing car scratches uk athletics body shop car repair calgary news auto repair shops open on sunday in orlando warranty extension hard drive for hp laptop guardian warranty auto insurance warranty extended electronics warranty cars warranty murrysville pa zip code gmpp car extended warranty reviews auto consumer protection agency crossword used vehicles 4 next sale co uk samsung manufacturer warranty what is the best extended car warranty in canada video certified pre owned dealerships near medina xzilon paint protection application extended warranty for vehicles in canada milk how much do ford extended warranties cost complete auto repair west seattle walmart black friday guarantee card 2007 mini cooper heritage extended warranty auto extended california best home warranty companies reviews auto warranty plans low cost isp providers the best auto repair insurance used car extended warranty is it worth it how to repair cop cars in gta 4 mercedes benz extended warranty prices service warranty contract template honda care new car warranty warranty autocar truck pictures consumer reports auto reliability records best warranty on used cars is it bad to buy a vehicle with a rebuilt title dealership warranty administrator pay plan auto repair service homes for sale in warner robins ga respray car cost same colours bumper repair leeds city are extended warranties for is investing in classic cars a good idea auto service warranty albums inc. ohio kia bumper to bumper warranty explained warranty on used cars in massachusetts under $3000 are used car infiniti extended warranty worth it providence auto used cars for sale used car cost of ownership lowest mortgage nearest car repair shop extended cars designed for comfort and luxury fidelity car repair insurance companies hyundai 5 year warranty review whats the best used car warranty best extended auto after market best warranty for used cars respray car cost brisbane california warranty autotrader used cars uk car body shops nottingham nh premier efg auto warranty complaints chrome bumper repair atlanta ga gateway auto protection alliance scam extended warranty used car canada ontario smart diamond auto warranty complaints best buy warranty ipad no receipt new porsche warranty coverage direct auto warranty deck 84 delray beach canada warranty solutions management corporation honda certified pre-owned vehicles philippines extended cars used car warranty company easy care rv extended warranty reviews purchase extended warranty for used car gta sa auto gta sa car repair mod california car extended warranty reviews costco national auto extended warranty reviews best extended warranties on used cars best diesel truck warranty scratch car repair brisbane times statutory motor vehicle warranty victoria justice aa auto protection bbb rating car scratch repair cost singapore weather best extended auto warranty in california auto body repairs saltney junction discover card extended warranty benefit factory extended warranty audi q5 auto armor rust protection electronic evans halshaw used car warranty problems cheap zurich extended car warranty insurance zurich direct automobile extended warranties review consumer reviews of auto warranty agency review auto extended warranty quote car window repairs sacramento ca news ge auto warranty utility services coverage audi extended warranty what covered custom car paint shops in atlanta ga honda nationwide auto warranty coverage auto theft protection dealership reviews should i purchase an extended warranty for my tv auto body repair estimate appraisal cost wynns total care auto warranty coverage new vehicle extended warranty advice columns protect auto close gate by munchkin long best warranty cars motor vehicle insurance and repair industry code of conduct diy auto body repair rust holes ge auto warranty solutions wells fargo car scratch repair cost uk work portfolio extended auto warranty coverage how much does a good used car cost canada extended auto warranty direct reviews car window scratch repair kit halfords bikes reviews of automobile extended warranties as is dealer warranty disclaimer form bernardi acura care extended warranty mobile body car repairs how long is a 2013 smart car warranty average price for a car cost of purchase audi extended warranty reviews of aa auto protection nj 2008 chevy silverado bumper to bumper warranty best auto extended compare home warranties in florida bmw extended vehicle protection cost best aftermarket extended warranty bmw 750i car repair shops in east troy kia warranty transferable 2013 car scratch repair cost sydney weather used car home repair insurance companies lifetime engine warranty reviews a auto service car electrical repair shops in los angeles house warranty insurance texas guardian protection services address warranty auto sales jobs in scarborough ontario car leather upholstery repair toronto maple window repair carbondale il movie vehicle one american express extended warranty program car body repair belfast northern aa auto protection bbb reviews online auto repair service manuals electric car window repair cost ukraine automobile used car extended warranty reviews salvage repairable cars gumtree cape auto reviews 2014 acura tl bmw x5 extended warranty coverage is it worth it to when to buy extended car warranty new home purchase warranty for used car top gear car ratings 2014 car window repair downtown toronto map car ac repair costs first automotive warranty albuquerque craigslist aa warranty motorway direct plc buy used cars with warranty ventura college after warranty automotive sackville school interstate used car warranty company toyota certified pre owned vehicles balintawak canada car sales march 2014 body shop car repair salford mennonite best extended best used car warranty programs protect car hire excess ireland customer protect car warranty harlow motor vehicle warranty and repair disputes clause consumer reports car reviews free auto direct excess protection claim all prices repair car windows in chicago area 60629 ward costco auto warranty insurance legal protection car insurance is it worth it nac extended auto warranty insurance top rated convertible car seats 2012 auto reviews 2014 indiana state fair schedule how long does it take to repair a broken car window dealer warranty on new kias body shop car repairs skegness scratch and dent car repairs canberra primary used vehicle prices south africa vehicle ratings and reviews japanese used vehicles jeep extended warranty purchase extended warranty cost audi kia honda extended warranty coverage used car extended warranty jobs that pay over 100k a year members choice best extended auto warranty auto service asc warranty company cheap car repair sydney service warranty business contract templates should i purchase extended warranty motor vehicle services 2-10 home warranty complaints best buy iphone manufacturer warranty petrol vs diesel car maintenance cost auto extended warranty diesel fuel prices in canada vehicle ratings cartridge comparison guide mastria subaru extended warranty plans how to repair car paint scratches removal are extended warranties for cars worth it racv edmunds new car ratings premier auto sales victoria tx american auto protection cincinnati ohio airport mankato wal mart car repair services warranty prices for carrier furnaces millenium direct buy auto warranty reviews repair cars dayz mod gm crate engine warranty ecp auto armor paint protection review used auto body repair parts how to check buy car warranty online roto subaru extended warranty plans extended warranty refund car totaled best auto automotive repair shop management software mn dvs vehicle services used cars used car warranty laws buy warranty for car uk to malta guardian protection services reviews az audi toyota platinum extended warranty coverage new car paint protection brisbane olathe subaru lifetime warranty what is a powertrain warranty volkswagen instant car insurance quotes in britain magazine best vehicle for family of nfl spreads week 5 2014 us fidelity auto warranty services plastic bumper repair orange county ca car shops in avon indiana ymca tata cars extended warranty buy extended car warranty reviews zurich extended car warranties automobile warranty companies in indiana ohio state mazda cx 5 bmw extended warranty cost best used vehicle for the money fabolous lyrics easy care warranty convertible top coverage bridgeview il carmax maxcare carchex auto warranty rust protection car toronto purchase autocad 2014 software best extended auto hyundai elantra warranty 2013 repair rust spot on car roof jd power used vehicle ratings ez care warranty phone number mercedes benz extended warranty coverage usa car window repair kit cracked windows motor vehicle services old republic home warranty bbb aftermarket car warranty scams car door scratch and dent repair cost are new car are toyota extended warranties worth it usaa fidelity automobile extended warranty honda care extended warranty prices paintless dent repair carmel indiana homes brandywine auto parts used tires america;s best warranty cars buying a car warranty in ireland what does green fidelity warranty cancellation form auto sales uk london dodge dart bumper to bumper warranty scratch car repair costs motor trend compact car ratings 2014 body repair carrickfergus borough auto armor fabric protection sprays resource automotive warranty services of florida extended warranty car insurance quotes are dealer extended warranties worth it consumer reports best auto warranty companies auto warranty direct reviews car warranties auto warranty canada usa hockey hershman pre owned auto sales elkins wv zurich first automotive extended warranty best website to buy best used cars in canada bmw easy care warranty phone number extended used auto warranty prices hero honda engine warranty toyota new vehicle global warranty canada mitsubishi vehicle extended warranty reviews pre owned auto sales city of overland park employment auto body repair estimate template auto repair denver co aspen auto clinic colorado 3m car protection edmonton what is the best after market auto warranty choice home warranty reviews and complaints car body repairs lodge farm northampton top rated sports cars under 50000 automotive extended warranty apple market share rust repair on cars in nashville for sale scratch repair for cars raleigh nc jobs rust repair on cars pittsburgh pa zip code good best rated extended car warranty companies repair shop for rear end cars advance auto warehouse phone number auto extended warranty vehicle one toyota platinum extended warranty coverage car air conditioning leak repair cost for cars second hand car warranty ireland currency cheap auto parts ottawa ont cost of car repairs guidestone car repair shops sioux city community guaranteed financing car columbus ohio car review 2014 subaru outback reviews consumer car ratings what to look for when used car shopping best extended extended warranties for mercedes benz best awd vehicle 2014 cheap extended car warranty quotes online repair car tyre nail used cars guaranteed credit hattiesburg ms movie forward facing car seat ratings 2014 nissan honda new car warranty information best buy auto starter installation auto body repair shop slogans about drugs minimum 30 day warranty on used cars 2012 auto virgin mobile reviews canada vehicle nissan juke reviews 2011 average annual compare auto repair costs kia extended extended warranty on used cars motor warranty on ntl091072 repair cars yourself acura extended warranty review american classic car insurance new jersey auto assure warranty mobile phone review australia subaru new car warranty 2012 car respray cost ukraine third party endurance auto warranty reviews cheap car window repairs first chrysler extended service contracts instant car insurance quote and comparison chart purchase autocad inventor software car ratings 2012 canada car body repair tools italy tours auto glass repair shops in houston audi extended warranty cost q5 audi insurance car quotes car ratings thanksgiving canada 2014 allstate extended vehicle warranty prices montgomery car body repairs belfast car warranty real estate company names mazda canada extended warranty cost honda should you buy an extended warranty for a car auto service warranty corporate responsibility best extended car warranty 2013 extended warranty 2006 mercedes benz e350 sedan consumer reports best top used car warranty companies new 2014 vehicle reviews and ratings dodge extended gm bumper to bumper warranty scratch car repairs brisbane ca car door dent repair clermont florida restaurants heavy duty truck body repair shops metal bumper repair san diego guaranteed used car finance uk minor car body repairs sheffield do extended warranties on cars things that don't make sense car amplifier repair shop texas powertrain warranty coverage honda automotive warranty protection services discount auto protection o'fallon movie theater cheap auto body repair dallas tx craigslist auto warehouse parts new albany in classic car insurance agencies costco extended car warranty reviews extended automobile warranties louisiana lottery guardian warranty fax japanese used vehicles in japan members choice reliable protection auto warranty best warranty for iphone 5s how to check if bmw is still under warranty nissan auto warranty services inc auto sales canada million biker march 2013 auto repair shops for rent in wisconsin recreational vehicle repair indiana warranty auto sales kijiji ottawa automotive service protection 63129 is it worth buying extended warranty on new car advantage administration plus auto warranty instant car insurance quote nzt protective advantage aa auto warranty reviews car repair customer service at home jobs bosch automotive battery warranty motor vehicle repair industry council ffx auto protect light curtain cheap extended warranty for cars are they worth it mercedes benz ford new car warranty 2010 can i buy a warranty for my car check my autozone warranty records can you tax your vehicle over the phone used motor vehicle limited warranty state of new york best merlin auto repair coupons protective portfolio car warranty company mercury insurance aa auto warranty reviews fidelity auto automotive warranty audit should you buy extended warranty car scratch remover repaired salvage cars for sale in illinois facebook aami car insurance free quote auto extended warranties online degrees are they worth it used car dealer warranty forms credit union auto warranty plans vernon auto group rv warranty forever complaints sun protection cary nc insurance car winn sales grand prairie tx extended automobile compare extended auto warranty companies is the car is an extended warranty worth it best aftermarket warranty for ford nationwide flex subaru gold plus extended warranty gmpp costco extended auto warranty should i get an extended warranty for a used car 2013 mazda cx-5 warranty 2007 mercedes benz warranty coverage canada wide impex auto sales reviews volvo extended warranty australia time camper tow vehicle ratings used rv warranty insurance scratch and dent car repair dorset echo best vehicle extended service contracts car dent repair tools shop address first automotive warranty by southwestre re extended warranty for cars refund advantage auto bumper repair nashville tn zip code ge best auto extended warranty plans used cars honda extended warranty reviews kia toyota extended warranty prices best car insurance ratings consumer reports kia ford extended warranty canada extended auto accounting for warranty costs hyundai used car warranty for 2011 track vehicle repairer resume reviews on advantage auto warranty company repairable cars indiana auto glass comwave canada reviews best buy auto inc how much is porsche extended warranty cost how to cancel how much is mercedes extended warranty japanese used vehicles beforward auto aul zurich extended service contracts reviews repairable car salvage north west birthday costco buy extended warranty car truck body repair shops laurel md 20723 mercedes benz new car warranty coverage extended warranties best oil additive for your car 2012 bmw x5 extended warranty cost ford direct warranty contact number 2007 ford powertrain warranty coverage car repair paint job prices extended vehicle nissan warranty canada car power window repair san antonio automobile extended warranties worth it extended warranty on used cars from gullo yamaha scratch and dent car repair phoenixville direct buy auto warranty renaissance hotel iselin nj best auto extended mazda warranty 2012 xpel paint protection warranty on used cars free credit report by law toyota used car warranties get a car insurance quote quick acura ford extended warranty plans nationwide extended auto warranty scams auto protection alliance bbb new york nationwide old republic home warranty reviews crazy 88 auto electric vehicles reviews warranty auto sales kijiji calgary auto repair service jobs in warner robins ga aa auto protection bbb review auto repair rainbow tree service st. paul mn average cost of extended car warranties how long is the warranty on a carrier furnace texas direct auto sales review fidelity warranty services bmw best car ratings best tires for 2009 honda crv omnisure auto extended warranty prices best buy auto mart orlando florida appliance repair care wanganui paint protection film for cars reviews ge auto warranty services inc auto service american home warranty company cheap car repair cincinnati ohio extended warranty for auto repairs car warranties on used cars automotive protection systems inc schertz tx zip code car insurance quotes online florida what is bumper to bumper auto warranty auto repair warranty reviews usaa extended vehicle protection program reviews reputable top 10 extended car warranty companies car tyre puncture repair kit review sinnott auto sales ltd finance auto sales hawthorne ca zurich extended auto warranty coverage plans fidelity warranty cancellation scratch and dent car repair adelaide university extended warranty cost based accounting aa guarantee car giant willesden amazon purchase warranty on used car riyasewana buy registration of motor vehicles in sri lanka top 10 extended car warranty companies reviews honda vehicle warranty information buy extended car warranty australia map 3m paint protection film bulk roll mazda extended warranty chevrolet total confidence extended auto warranty new car prices bmw austin direct auto sales hours car body repair shop near norwalk ca police mercury what is the best extended auto warranty company car guaranteed credit approval wilmington nc zip code quote line direct car insurance contact how to sell should you buy extended warranties on cars repairable salvage cars for sale ukraine map pre owned environmental impacts of electric vehicles in south africa car consumer winter tire reviews canada stratstone used car guarantee premier extended auto warranty scams route 66 auto warranty reviews main street grill mitsubishi mercedes extended warranty cost body repair jobs manchester jaguar online extended warranty quotes auto warranty insurance for used cars zurich vehicle service contract extended warranty review great american auto warranty car purchase auto purchase auto online purchase motor vehicle services honda warranty extension cheap auto body repair cypress texas zip code interstate aa auto warranty complaints extended warranty abc canada tv car leather upholstery repair toronto stock car insurance quotes compare the market california allstate extended warranty auto best way to get multiple car insurance quotes maintenance plus vehicle service plan nissan car window repair indianapolis extended auto warranty garcinia cambogia and consumer reports car electric window repair birmingham top ten extended warranty for cars best choice home warranty reviews best vehicle deals september 2014 direct buy auto warranty lexington law bbb review safety 1st sentinel air protect convertible car seat reviews auto one warranty information on my coverage info audi extended warranty cost selling coins to dealers bmw used aa car warranty uk extended warranty aa insurance nz average car repair costs consumers extended warranty automatic start for cars prices should you buy mercedes benz extended warranty grand theft auto liberty city repair car cheat auto repair service belleville il fairgrounds paint protection film installation cost jd powers auto ratings 2007 air conditioner car repair costs repair car scratches costco.com audi factory extended warranty cost aa car warranty quotes is extended warranty on is gap insurance on new cars worth it 2 if parts are replaced when you have work done on your vehicle __ sal protection plan premium auto program plan f questions to ask when buying a used vehicle from a private owner auto loan for private seller purchase old republic vehicle new home warranty canada mortein auto protect review center consumer reports aul auto warranty extended warranty dupli color body paint repair kit car scratch remover salvage repaired cars for sale uk auto body repairs shaftesbury hyde should i purchase a home warranty cobra multiman mobile fall protection cart what does nissan powertrain warranty cover maxcare auto warranty website vehicle ratings and online pharmacy reviews canada vauxhall nissan certified used cars warranty repair shop for rc cars bankrate;s car insurance quote comparison tool bmw extended warranty platinum coverage automobile extended warranty prices dupont automotive protection package review 21st century auto extended warranty plans auto extra ford extended warranty plans intent to purchase vehicle agreement car warranty granite transformation reviews and cost state farm after market extended vehicle warranty car warranty swinton car insurance quote uk best rated list of extended auto warranty companies auto warranty free internet leads auto repair warranty company clear car protection film installers buying an extended car warranty for dodge avenger new car warranty compact suv comparison 2014 auto one subaru extended warranty refund porsche good sam extended warranty reviews best classic car insurance uk consumer direct warranty services fraud how much does truecar costa how to repair rust damage on car body extended warranty coverage honda generators trs vehicle repair centre cheap windshield replacement phoenix arizona weather warranty used car dealers in michigan best rated carpet cleaning machines 2012 united auto care extended warranty platinum coverage second hand car guaranteed used car shop london best buy extended warranty customer service best vehicle for family of 5 2010 car window repair north county san diego warranty extension letter format direct buy best used car warranty reviews zurich auto extended warranty claims extended used car warranties palmerton buy auto insurance online with checking account car body shops in laguna niguel owner's name scott direct auto extended warranty buy back gm extended warranty loaner car car window repair liverpool cheap used car parts free shipping apple ipod touch repair warranty mercedes extended warranty jobs in australia zurich extended auto warranty insurance amerigard old republic auto warranty company 08 09 smart car warranty used cars costa rica grecia buy extended warranty on used car nrma yardsport ys200 4x2 gas utility vehicle reviews kindle fire hd honda crv manufacturers warranty best used vehicles under 10000$ new toyota warranty coverage auto total protect warranty complaints samsung extended warranty laptop vw new car paint protection car guaranteed finance best vehicle for snow mountain driving sears auto repair near me auto repair car insurance state farm should you buy extended warranty for cars reviews deep scratch repair on car kit car cover repair kit discount auto protection better business bureau wisconsin lexus is250 gm extended warranty cost ford used car warranty over 36000 purchase warranty for my vehicle extended service contract toyota cars superior auto care extended warranty fisker msn auto consumer reports protection for car paintwork design extended truck nissan extended warranty plans used car extended warranty company reviews car stereo repair shop 64068 car protect sheffield reviews of movies best buy computer protection plans the car body repair shop eastbourne cinema mercedes benz how to locate previously owned vehicles discover extended warranty protection busted car window repair costa get car insurance quotes now vehicle repair health care costs canada mazda cx 5 standard warranty tr group ryder used vehicle sales common estimate vehicle repair costs top rated cars 2015 purchase mercedes benz extended warranty car window repair downtown toronto apartments old republic home warranty reviews florida consumer reports malaysia car review 2014 vehicle warranties nzb how to auto body repair youtube extended warranty best life insurance companies 2014 automobile extended warranty insurance warranty epo insurance definition scratch and dent car repairs canberra hospital mini cooper g e extended warranty plans ac car repair costs mercury extended warranty auto review gmpp extended warranty aol cancellation phone number consumer auto liquidators spokane reviews motor extended warranty insurance semi auto shotgun fitbit reviews 2014 best vehicle dodge lubrico warranty canada reviews 2006 mazda rx8 engine warranty nissan extended warranty canada omnisure best auto extended warranty review imperial auto protection address finder best bmw aftermarket warranty body car repair shops sw ranches fl map consumer reports palmer extended car warranty reviews calliden home warranty insurance consumer reports car bottled water ratings 2011 warranty extension letter sample used car consumer rv reviews and ratings car warranty tv reviews uk porsche buying warranty on used car best vehicles for towing horses 2011 audi a5 warranty used car cost per mile how much does car air conditioning repair cost estimates electric edmunds car review 2014 xpel paint protection film reviews repairable salvage cars for sale uk scratched paint on car repair cost extended warranty 2005 mercedes sl600 dodge gm used vehicle extended warranty aaa auto repair shops sacramento extended car auto extended warranties ratings mercedes warranty plan cost estimator is it worth buying extended warranty on cars opc porsche warranty extension auto extended warranty insurance lexus car warranty reviews mobile car window repair riverside ca what is the best rust protection for new cars fidelity extended warranty services aaa rated car repair shops national car warranty company vehicle repair is easy care warranty goodmanmfg .com registration extended car warranty protection vehicle sales in canada briggs and stratton engine specs by model number best stock off road vehicle 2014 direct buy smart auto warranty complaints easy care extended warranty bmw 750i extended automobile extended vehicle warranties in california classic car insurance how old is ariana grande opinions on extended warranties for cars best extended warranty for porsche aftermarket auto warranty quotes ge extended auto warranty insurance buy vehicles in australia ge auto extended warranty service contract costco american express card extended warranty respray car cost melbourne aaa auto repair chandler how to repair scratches on car interior detailing guardian extended warranty for vehicles over 100k miles service gold key stanley auto warranty complaints auto repair extended warranty templates ge extended auto warranty types of contract claims aa extended auto car warranty examples of child protection plans smart car review 2014 auto armor paint protection teflon tubing auto direct car insurance quotes extended warranty calculating opportunity cost calculation aa auto warranty bbb reviews auto parts warehouse online pharmacies canada reviews 2009 audi warranty information motor vehicle services walmart extended warranty website buy warranty for used car ireland aftermarket how much do extended warranties for cars cost cracked bumper repairs car bumper repair kit canadian tire auto repair coverage spin mop as seen on tv repair scratch car paint auto review eastern canada cruises direct auto sales midland texas used car shop in wayanad tourist audio warehouse extended warranty buzz car insurance quick quote subaru warranty 2012 extended car warranty car prices for used cars mepco mercury extended auto warranty consumer reports on extended warranties for appliances car consumer reviews 4 runners toyota asus warranty repair usa extended truck factory warranty ford porsche warranty transfer uk car warranty lifestyle lift reviews and cost usaa bumper to bumper extended warranty for auto air conditioning typical auto repair costs toco direct buy car warranty reviews alpha warranty services dealer login five allied star auto warranty car scratch repair pen whitening what does htc manufacturer warranty cover consumer reviews cars edmunds the mechanic auto warranty fax how to become extended auto warranty brokers extended semi truck warranty companies applecare vs best buy warranty iphone cna route 66 extended auto warranties guardian protection force sacramento ca auto assure old republic home warranty complaints luther auto best used car warranty companies where to purchase extended warranty for vehicle repair scratches on car paint in mde what is a manufacturers warranty on car your vehicle must have a horn which can be heard from a distance of _____ feet consumer car consumer review guide warranty card templates how to repair car paint scuffs and scratches in horses previously owned department of motor vehicles in staten island return kindle warranty repair how to protect car paint from snow infiniti extended warranty pricing should i buy an best extended automobile warranty cna route 66 auto warranty coverage cost to repair scratch on care services jaguar extended car warranty for used cars custom car paint shops in michigan cheap auto parts with free shipping faulkner car repair shops near me auto warehouse in indiana cigna auto extended auto warranties for used cars american pre owned auto sales in little rock second hand cars warranty company protection plus best used vehicles to purchase goods extended warranty for cars insurance claim procedures canadian car repair estimator magnetic auto body protection nationwide aa auto warranty scam protection card not found vygis installer used auto prevagen reviews consumer reports cire protection carrosserie voiture repairable car salvage scotland vote guardian auto glass warranty buying car warranty in canada what is the nhl mobile auto paint repair san antonio used vehicle warranties nzdating american guardian warranty services inc review broken car window repair brooklyn car repair social services in harrisburg pa new car nissan extended warranty cancellation ge auto warranty barton protective services lakewood co the best extended auto warranty companies automotive general motors extended warranty plans do it yourself auto body repair tips salvage repairable cars scotland county classic car body shop california consumer reviews blue book value used cars canada how to repair car paint scratches best time of year to buy a vehicle rome pre owned auto sales extended warranty carmax used cars used vehicles broken car window repair montreal hotels home protection plans with ac coverage mercedes benz audi warranty extension your vehicle needs a current motorcycle loan interest rates warranty for rental car uk extended warranty for used cars cost more to ship allstate auto warranty quotes auto body repair birmingham al mercury extended warranty gold plan best used cars where houses to buy in canada extended warranty insurance comet electrical goods dj auto motor vehicle importers in sri lanka cheap car paint chip repair auto used car co uk used car extended warranty consumer reports purchase extended car warranty toco vehicle warranty reviews cheap best used car warranty used car repair insurance cost of extended honda bumper to bumper warranty top 10 rated r cartoon movies warranty registration card template consumer reviews rental cars canada buy extended auto warranty leads repair car paintwork scratches on car scratch repair for cars youtube video best vehicle warranty canada map mazda bumper to bumper extended warranty bent car axle repair costs body car repairs glasgow herald should i buy mercedes extended warranty top rated carpet cleaners for pets extended warranty pricing chrysler 20 gmc bmw certified pre owned vehicles repairable car salvage yorkshire england 2012 mazda 5 factory warranty national auto extended warranty plus top car extended warranty companies repair car scratches microsuede sofas mercury fidelity auto warranty services inc how to repair rust bubbles in car paint rust repair on cars in nashville tennessee go naviss car warranty review cheap car parts free shipping canada salvage repairable cars wisconsin rapids body repair shop exeter hp laptop mercedes benz warranty extension windsor hershman pre owned auto sales elkins wv dealer auto protect net login how does wax seal protect a car from rusting best aftermarket car warranty auto extended extended car warranty for used cars average cost of car repairs from deer impacts is the car extended warranty worth it tesco used car warranty quote canadian tire best extended auto repair warranty nationwide auto warranty att authorized dealers what company has the list of best extended car warranty sbc pump 2010 mercedes warranty bmw gm extended warranty used cars auto repair insurance for used cars warranty on used cars uk repair deep scratches on cars the top best rated auto warranty companies 2010 chevy powertrain warranty car repair cost estimator canada weather ineffective protection care plan for newborn average yearly average car repair costs car carpet protection spray car scratches repair cost philippines wedding car rust repair glasgow mazda is ford extended warranty worth it auto repair shop insurance coverage audi extended warranty cost 2012 toyota repairing car rust with bondo wood common national average vehicle repair costs buy car warranty how to buy used car from dealer precision auto protection clearwater fl car warranty service requirements for toyota best used vehicle under 5000 car warranty broadband comparison uk vehicle warranty company reviews auto repair insurance usaa gravois auto repair on tesson ferry protect car hire excess waiver lenovo warranty extension auto extended bfs home warranty companies in texas what is the best time of year to how to buy a new vehicle free car repair help saskatchewan used car dealer warranty care warranty jaguar auto extended warranty reviews bmw extended warranty how much does a funeral cost uk best rated auto extended warranties automotive warranty services inc aws.org dent repair carlisle cullen car bumper repairs durban automotive extended warranty browser market share easiest cars to repair yourself lg phones manufacturers warranty aaa used car warranties prices chicken car consumer reviews grand cherokee jeep car mats protect car paint from rock chips body repair shops orange county ca sheriff fidelity carmax extended warranty coverage repair used cars in palm bay fl mazda cx 5 hyundai extended warranty cost buy autodesk inventor 2011 car protection plus luxury extended cars warranty for used cars with high mileage discount tire see wheels on your vehicle motor vehicle services worsted lodge nationwide car warranty australia which car make has best warranty precise auto protection complaints advantage preferred auto warranty company auto repair reviews portland oregon repair car dent crease repair auto mack extended warranty reviews rental 2015 car ratings and reviews car repair services hemel hempstead top ten car warranty companies ez care warranty company car safety ratings uk leather upholstery car repair easy care warranty costs carefree car protection refund check extended warranty bmw canada head office efg map best auto warranty coverage aami car insurance quote australia walmart home car repair service good works pep boys auto repair reviews indian 2014 car ratings and reviews mercedes extended warranty pricing e350 convertible xtraride rv warranty reviews aa extended car warranty costs reputable consumer reports auto extended warranty companies extended vehicle auto warranty programs should i buy used car extended warranty car body repair shop in cuddebackville ny campgrounds best extended warranty on cars extended automobile home warranty plans best used car warranty canadian drug companies canada subaru extended warranty refundable where to purchase extended warranty for mercedes e350 do it yourself car body rust repair how to purchase vehicle insurance car dents repair by plungerhead car scratch repair pen indiana old republic ge auto warranty quote nissan auto repair shops in san pedro auto air pur water filter reviews consumer reports best third party used car warranty insurance extended warranty rental car indianapolis repair car scratches malaysia chronicle chevy extended warranty plans allstate auto repair insurance reviews 3m xpel paint protection film scratch repair on car bumper purchase autocad civil 3d 2012 release latest free consumer reports car ratings maaco car repair paint hyundai used car warranty information rex auto sales junction city ks mercedes chrysler extended warranty refund ge auto warranty solutions extended warranty best used cars consumer reports customs and border protection careers auto bumper repair austin texas news cheap car repair shops near 32244 weather car paint scratch repair pen nzymes auto source home warranty reviews auto car iphone repair in whittier ca top 5 top rated extended auto warranty companies extended warranties for autos certified pre owned jaguar warranty are mercedes benz warranties transferable or transferable car protective coatings motor oil and used car warranty best used cars where things to buy in canada paintless dent repair car medic abita how to repair a dent in a car hood decals lexus extended warranty platinum cost per gram best extended warranty for cars in canada trucks ford extended new car warranty price consumer reports extended warranties car car warranty first for women insurance south africa classic car auto shopper body repair shops near henderson nc top rated cars 2014 models extended auto warranty canada glass car repair mario's auto repair carson city nv automotive protection systems inc schertz tx weather bmw extended warranty current gold price per ounce discount auto protection o'fallon 15 cinema best used car warranty companies uk top best way to repair car paint scratches remover repairable car salvage north west pics best new list all car warranty companies how to purchase vehicle with no credit mercedes benz extended warranty tour de france tv coverage usa national carmax car care warranty 2007 audi a8 extended warranty auto window repair in chicago il house warranty insurance autotrader ca used vehicle used cars used autos audi extended warranty how much does a bugatti cost 2013 bumper repair san marcos ca restaurants best extended warranty car canada cambridge hp warranty extension for laptop car dent repair cardiff castle car scratches repair shop marikina city health auto paint repair mobile service does vehicle warranty cover windshield used automobile warranties pinnacle american mercury insurance company extended auto warranty front bumper repair melbourne is a car are extended warranty worth it worth buying extended warranty used car list of vehicle warranties repair shops for cars isuzu rodeo accessories customer protect car warranty review order cheap auto parts online jaguar warranty 2013 kia extended warranty transferable skills do i need to buy extended car warranty leather car seat repair toronto stock mazda warranty coverage extended warranty book prices for used cars kbb edmunds used car consumer reviews scratch repair for cars raleigh nc zip code auto one warranty amtrak station irvine ca address buy car extended auto warranty used car warranties extended vehicle square trade warranties reviews salvage repairable cars scotland yard premier costco extended auto warranty gm engine warranty form keyed car paint repair cost motor new car extended warranty prices average cost to repair car bumper utility vehicle reviews 2011 warranty auto shop chino roces makati map toyota used car warranty uk what is the best car warranty best stocks to buy extended warranty insurance malaysia wikipedia paint protection film for cars amazon auto protection alliance reviews on vigrx best car warranty protection car repair aami insurance australia auto repair for dummies epub true car costs dealers license private used car warranty insurance company rv extended warranty seed companies canada porsche apple warranty terms and conditions keyed car repair cost insurance car used car sales in south africa any good best aftermarket warranties us fidelity auto warranty alberta new home warranty purchase contract ford car aftermarket warranties total care auto warranty reviews auto shield paint protection for cars powertrain warranty one penny doubled for 30 days samsung galaxy s4 samsung galaxy s3 manufacturers warranty automotive extended auto warranties reviews protection car wash car repair catering services dubai extended warranty cost toyota highlander 2014 car repair social services hemel hempstead easy care extended warranty company best new car warranty 2013 canada superman how to purchase car warranty auto protect premier certainteed surestart plus warranty evans halshaw second hand car warranty extended new car warranty ford taurus route 66 auto warranty cost warranty repair amazon the car body repair shop eastbourne hotels volvo fidelity extended warranty reviews evans halshaw used car extended warranty guardian vehicle extended warranty what is us auto protection all american auto protection azusa campgrounds aftermarket extended vehicle warranty mechanic inspection used car cost comparison car window repair houston 77095 4wd vehicle reviews australia fidelity car repair insurance plans subaru extended service contract cost express warranty insurance definition auto body repairs shaftesbury england best vehicle truck body repair shops 85213 mercedes warranty plans should buy warranty used car dealership used car warranties extended warranties are they worth it toyota extended service contract worth it best auto repair estimate software used vehicle prices uk using fiberglass to repair car body mercedes benz new vehicle warranty repair graco car seat frame extended warranty plans rated g cheyenne auto repair and service rental car company used vehicle sales international truck warranty new car warranty small suv comparison 2014 auto breakdown protection usa wide e-mail body repair panels toyota corolla best extended warranty company for bmw 2006 kia sportage warranty information best used car warranties buy buy napa auto parts warehouse indianapolis texas direct auto sales stafford how to remove 3m invisishield paint protection film best product to protect car paint best used auto reviews royal portfolio car warranty company purchase vehicles with bad credit protection for car paintwork restorer best vehicle 2014 best used vehicle for the money honey western diversified allstate best extended auto warranties pen scratch repair for cars car insurance quotes pa wrecked salvage repairable cars and trucks cost to repair car door window how to extend car warranty auto repair denver co aspen auto clinic littleton fidelity auto extended warranty cancellation best top auto repair insurance companies repairing car scratches rustic furniture bmw new car warranty usa nissan rogue 2011 reliability car ratings rust repair on car with jb weld water leasing certified previously owned vehicles auto reviews 2014 acura tlx consumer reports costco car buying service reviews american home shield warranty service number hyundai extended warranty coverage details best warranty companies bumper to bumper used auto warranty companies extended vehicle lexus toyota extended warranty prices purchase kia extended warranty review top rated car alarms consumer reports body repair parts ford f150 cars gm extended warranty plans zurich best used auto warranty how much does a gm extended warranty cost auto insurance reviews 2012 is it best to lease or buy a vehicle car door dent repair houston tx airport 2014 new side by side utility vehicle reviews audi a8 extended warranty price warranty on carrier furnaces extended auto warranty companies ratings should you get are extended warranties on cars worth the money how to repair car headliners auto paint protection calgary ab route 66 extended sensible home warranty bbb evans halshaw used car price guarantee buds auto sales st marys ohio services warranty contract car repair help for single mothers 2002 mercedes benz warranty information us car warranty current time in canada how to repair car rust with fiberglass nada used car values used vehicle values 3m auto bumper repair car body repairs glasgow west aaa extended extended auto warranty prices direct warranty services st peters mo police 2015 2006 mazda warranty information how much does a vehicle extended warranty cost for bmw free invoice template for auto car repair shops best buy warranty for tv maintenance costs for cars india maruti electric car window repair las vegas car dent repair fort collins colorado used car protection in colorado auto armor interior car protection best rated carpet spot cleaning machines extended warranty for used cars cost used vehicles for sale in sri lanka auto armor interior protection review nissan new car warranty 2010 how to repair dent in car lowes protection plans registration best warranty honda cars in india identity auto theft protection insurance car paint repair columbus ohio newspaper engine repair cost buy a new vehicle online warranty auto dan's bike shop makati usaa continental extended auto warranty reviews what is smart car warranty period extended bumper to bumper extended warranty acura auto paint repair shops in charlotte nc extended warranty discount advantage rent a car canada cleargard auto protection alliance llc porsche factory warranty transfer warranty direct reliability american community survey 2013 auto paint repairs exeter airport dodge vehicle service record european car repair toronto stock car window seal repair perth amboy get a quick car insurance quote extended care facility definition free vehicle repair guides aftermarket extended auto warranty for used cars car repair finance company how much does a kia extended warranty cost fidelity warranty carefree extended warranty company comparison aa gm extended car warranty prices bmw extended warranty cost 2014 bmw 5 series 2014 honda crv extended warranty prices extended used car warranty victoria osteen luxury small car review 2014 mercury insurance best extended auto warranty reviews buy extended car warranty online car warranty flight comparison australia how to repair scratch on car clearcoat repair car scratch remover t cut car 2007 dodge powertrain warranty information extended vehicle warranty worth it best auto cheap auto warranties for used cars phone repair shop carrickfergus chords 2011 car reviews consumer reports vehicle history health republic insurance of new york reviews costco national auto service warranty car warranty service requirements for boy how to repair car leather seats how much to repair car dent singapore portfolio pre-owned portfolio new and premium vehicle extended coverage 3m car scratch remover kit cancel acura extended warranty coverage extended warranties cash for cars reviews consumer reviews safest cars 2011 auto repair estimator how to purchase costco american mercury insurance company extended auto warranty how to repair deep scratches in car paint air conditioning aaa car repair service used car warranty companies for dealers all american auto protection azusa ca best used cars cheapest things things to buy in canada dealer services aftermarket auto warranty reviews repairable salvage cars for sale uk cheap cost of a gold bmw extended warranty mercury extended auto warranty copper mountain tesco multiple car insurance quotes car bumper repair stockton ca audi car maintenance costs repair car paint chips scratches best small car ratings 2013 nikon warranty repair locations consumers guarantee act cars for sale car bumper repair stockton ca bank mantrans used vehicle sales pty ltd florida motor vehicle repair act requirements average cost of owning a car per month duthrs body car repair zanesville ohio movie damaged repairable salvage cars ireland best buy warranty laptop policy best buy auto start remote porsche ford extended warranty plans best cost of audi extended warranty honda auto glass uv protection kia good sam extended warranty reviews are extended warranties worth it on tvs auto repair monetary help for the disabled toyota certified used vehicle home warranty canada pre purchase auto inspection charlotte nc how much is the mercedes benz extended warranty vernon auto group otterbox lifetime warranty warranty on cars over 100k miles bmw drivers auto repair reviews in humble vw polaris extended warranty prices purchase mazda extended warranty price best car travel ratings websites used car warranty pay monthly best warranty upcoming games for ps4 ge warranty services automotive touch free carfax reports used vehicle vehicle history reports car window repair costa mesa ca 92627 body car repairs glasgow auto warranty canada used cars mini cooper toyota extended warranty review nissan auto repair shops history auto protect gold warranty what covered first automotive extended warranty reviews average used car costs car extended warranties extended warranties are they worth it extended warranty antique car insurance companies aaa approved auto repair network cars protection plus murrysville pa auto ventshade craftsman lifetime warranty pinnacle auto protection plan cheap car repairs brisbane tennis how to repair a scratch on a car with touch up national auto warranty plus best online top rated auto warranty companies auto saver corrosion protection coatings honda new car warranty terms american guardian warranty review cost of extended best extended warranty for used cars should i buy a extended warranty on a used car car body repair shops lubbock texas car scratch remover products used car shops in orlando florida extended used car warranty victoria justice good sam rv warranty coverage beat that quote car insurance car insurance express mobile body repair classic car insurance uk definition bear bond body repair kit second hand car warranty south australia news best buy extended extended warranty on cameras elite auto sales jonesboro arkansas 1st automotive extended warranty ford motor company protective extended service contracts easycare warranty chrysler 2.7 engine diagram best buy warranty service plan extended warranties bmw 335i extended warranty worth it fidelity extended car warranty insurance warranties for used cars buying a car with no warranty auto glass repair churchill car insurance quote uk protect your bubble car hire excess purchase list of extended auto warranty companies average cost to repair a car window first automotive master tech warranty company extended 2012 lamborghini factory warranty car ratings and kindle fire reviews 2012 best car warranty company top auto service purchase autocad civil 3d 2012 volkswagen extended warranty vehicle are there any good extended auto warranties reviews average cost of car insurance for 18 year old male interior car repair indianapolis toyota auto repair training motor vehicle repair shop registration act what are the best car warranties ford motor company extended service contract extended service warranty for jm automotive davie repairable car salvage north west baby best way to repair rust on car dealer warranty direct auto warranty reviews consumer jd power car reviews new car mazda new car warranty 2011 best used cars what garcinia cambogia where to buy in canada ford extended car warranty prices what company has the best extended car warranty consumer how to repair car scratches deep blue consumer reports extended warranty tvs vehicle extended warranty fnb south africa car dealer warranty obligations d free auto repair estimates forms auto one warranty premium financing specialists inc alldata auto repair software free download used vehicle reviews ratings buying car warranty leadstreet washing machine motor warranties definition which car has the best warranty 2014 protection carrosserie de meester used car vehicle leasing file system auto-protect is malfunctioning windows 2008 respray car cost brisbane australia coverage capital one auto warranty protective asset protection carchex auto warranty reviews body repair shops near me 40509 free auto warranty quote car repair costs carrier capacitor replacement by model mercedes benz certified pre owned extended warranty cost bmw nissan extended warranty coverage auto ads netflix canada review amex purchase warranty for iphone warranty iphone screen repair amazon should you buy extended manufacturer warranty on used cars hp service warranty extension honda warranty extension 04-027.pdf auto protection department reviews of movies steel river pre-owned auto sales salem ma home warranty services of america consumer reports small car review 2014 what does apple manufacturer warranty cover repair shop for foreign cars largo fl vehicle ar-15 reviews and comparisons car repair car warranty for older cars instant car insurance quotes singapore air best used vehicle warranty how to repair a dent in a car with filler neck used car warranty medicare what does it cover extended used car warranty companies mobile auto kitchenaid repair service california wright auto metal sales warranty staples protection plans reviews 2014 consumer review used cars canada cost to own a car canada phone anaheim cars complete auto repair services w phillips st conroe tx how much is a best buy extended warranty nationwide auto warranty dishwasher reviews canada efg circle auto warranty reviews car repair estimates for body work used vehicle inspection checklist cheap auto body repair sacramento rock auto xikar warranty returns camarillo tucson auto repair reviews cheap car repairs bristol mountain portfolio car warranty company audi a6 extended warranty costco how much should a decent used car cost lg g2 manufacturers warranty used car warranty reviews canada richard insurance car ding's auto sales & salvage continental protective auto warranty company route 66 mazda extended warranty prices protection plans for cell phones mazda extended warranty refund find my car warranty information how much does a used mercedes extended warranty cost best aftermarket auto warranty tax credit for hybrid vehicles warranty coverage for automobiles 3m paint chip protection for cars direct auto protection fraud cases acura extended warranty marvin saccucci cost of bmw x3 extended warranty iphone repair under warranty easy care warranty dealers electrical supply how much are are extended warranties on cars worth it car warranty extended coverage dry sidewall best auto body repair shop reviews in poway us army 91h track vehicle repairer used car warranty employment law uk employees car sears appliance repair service plans motor vehicle beer sales in canada should i purchase an auto extended warranty best auto kia warranty 2014 best buy warranty for xbox one how to do auto body repairs yourself bmw extended warranty geico commercials consumer auto protection agency bbb auto body repair tools shop equipment extended automobile home warranty companies serving texas kia toyota extended warranty coverage best car warranties ugg australia small car review 2014 australia best buy auto inc reviews aa used car warranty cost comparison paint protection film ebay go endurance car warranty reviews auto used parts chicago us car warranty living in canada who are the best top ten auto extended warranty companies interstate nationwide auto warranty complaints costco canada auto battery warranty how much is extended warranty for bmw x3 2010 car body repair course birmingham hyundai warranty information vehicle auto window repair south jersey magazine electronics extended warranty providers at walmart auto truck trader vehicles extended warranty for automobiles review how to protect autographs from fading car warranty insurance uk car auto saver corrosion protection products auto reviews in india auto ads big mountain drugs canada reviews portfolio protection auto warranty extended warranty automotive inspections corpus welding car repair panels extended warranties for appliances/washer/dryer extended service contract 2010 vw jetta furniture stores in nj aftermarket warranty south african boerboel costco continental extended auto warranty reviews auto consumer reports 2014 car warranty used car dealers top rated extended used car warranties average cost of a car respray semi auto shotgun wireless router reviews 2014 buy vehicle kids paint online best car seat protector for dogs best car body shops in baton rouge vehicle one allstate extended auto warranty reviews your vehicle is parked on the road at night. when must you use sidelights total cost to own cars paint protection car dealer magic pen car scratch remover extended warranty rent a car canada jaguar genuine toyota extended warranty prices zurich extended auto warranties car heated rear window repair kit auto repair service apartments in northeast san antonio geico zurich auto warranty review bumper to bumper extended warranty toyota nationwide circle aa auto warranty reviews executive protection careers international nikon europe service warranty card gta 5 vehicle war commander instant repair cheat century auto warranty service ontario goodbuy auto auction mini cooper ford extended warranty reviews car warranty bath fitter reviews and prices extended car warranty napa car prices for used cars average maintenance cost for hybrid car used extended auto warranty comparison how to buy a how to get a vehicle with bad credit new car safety ratings 2012 chevrolet dealer warranty honda factory warranty extended service software warranty language vehicle body repair tools warranty the carphone warehouse second hand car warranty qld school quixx car paint scratch repair/removal system mechanic scratch repair cardiff hotels auto extra warranty auto butler warranty phone number craigslist mpls minneapolis st paul best auto extended stanley warranty reviews bbb best vehicle mazda warranty 2014 buy car warranty tires stolen from dealership hyundai platinum extended warranty quote for car scratches repair shops car dealer warranty refund check hybrid vehicle repair costs cheap car repairs brisbane airport auto window repair austin acura extended warranty cost hyundai warranty what does it cover find local auto body repair shops how much does car dent repair costs new car extended warranty yes or no oracle extended warranty for mercedes benz is netflix worth it california auto repair federal emission warranty law california arkansas used vehicle sales tax protection car charms rear honda new car warranty 2014 vehicle extended service plans estimates on building auto repair costs trenton nj train station honda care warranty price new top rated cars under 20000 cancel mazda extended warranty cost mazda total care extended warranty price warranty extension a/c 2008 crv tire size best aftermarket extended car warranty canada apple iphone 4s manufacturers warranty endurance direct extended warranty mazda new mepco car warranty service national warranty insurance company lawsuit ge car warranty ge auto warranty services inc ontario insurance car quotes best rated compare auto warranty plans warranty coverage on alcatel evolve phone case ford new nissan vehicle warranty information car repair manuals free download pdf vehicle edmunds safety ratings used cars fidelity warranty services carefree car protection service calgary auto body repair shops air conditioning vehicle repair log mercedes benz subaru warranty 2010 third party vehicle home warranty canada consumer reports auto vitamin manufacturer ratings cancel zurich auto warranty us car warranty live and work in canada permanent resident quick free car insurance quote kohler command engine warranty acura new car factory warranty allstate extended warranty for cars companies 2013 subaru warranty and maintenance booklet true auto protection fort worth tx newspaper honda bumper bumper to bumper extended warranty for used cars pre owned stars auto sales gastonia nc nissan new car extended warranty canada car repair help for the disabled us auto warranty st peters mo real estate new 2014 car ratings bmw extended warranty current stamp price 2014 rome pre owned auto sales floyd ave rome ny extended care facilities in indiana exclusionary auto warranty for quality used cars in california auto repair loans vehicle aaa direct repair network
Home All Articles 32 Voices on the State of the Game

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1128 guests online

Atom RSS

32 Voices on the State of the Game PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 15
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Various Authors   
Thursday, 14 December 2006 17:25

A Biz of Baseball ExclusiveOf all the comments made for this article, maybe Will Carroll of Baseball Prospectus put it best:

"Saying what's right and wrong with the game is an exercise in hubris and futility."

True, but that doesn't mean we can't try, right?

As we approach the end of 2006, Biz of Baseball contacted 32 notable individuals that cover, or work in the business of baseball to get their comments on what is both right and wrong with MLB today. The list of those that responded is as diverse as the answers they gave. We also have selected one reader response by Brian Dupont from the Biz of Baseball forums on the topic that we thought merted inclusion into this compilation (you can continue to add to the forum topic, as well).

Biz of Baseball and I would like to thank all of these individuals for taking time and effort out of their busy schedules to take part in this fantastic compilation. I admire and respect them all, and I hope you do too. -- Maury Brown, editor of The Biz of Baseball

Those that comment in alphabetical order are:

  • Jeff Angus - Author of Management by Baseball
  • Chuck Armstrong - President of the Seattle Mariners
  • Buzzie Bavasi - Long-time general manager for the Brooklyn and Los Angeles Dodgers (1951-67), president of the San Diego Padres (1968-77), and executive vice president of the California Angels (1978-99)
  • Alex Belth - Author, and writer for SI.com
  • Maury Brown - Author for Baseball Prospectus and editor of The Biz of Baseball
  • Will Carroll - Author for Baseball Prospectus and ESPN
  • Fred Claire - Former VP and GM of the Dodgers, Author, and MLB.com
  • Jerry Crasnick - Author, and writer for ESPN
  • Neil deMause - Author, Field of Schemes, and Baseball Prospectus
  • Eric Fisher - MLB reporter for the Sports Business Journal
  • Rodney Fort - Sports Economist
  • Gary Gillette - ESPN Insider, Co-Chair of SABR's Business of Baseball committee
  • Chris Isidore - Senior writer for CNN/Money
  • King Kaufman - Sports columnist for Salon.com
  • Jonah Keri - ESPN Page 2, YESNetwork.com, author
  • Tim Lemke - Sports business reporter for the Washington Times
  • Rob Neyer - Author and Senior baseball writer for ESPN
  • Roger Noll - Sports Economist
  • Jeff Passan - National baseball writer for Yahoo! Sports
  • Bill Shanks - Braves radio personality, author, and TheBravesShow.com
  • Joe Sheehan - Senior writer for Baseball Prospectus
  • Nate Silver - Author and Executive VP of Baseball Prospectus
  • Michael Silverman - The Boston Herald
  • Tal Smith - President of Baseball Operations for the Houston Astros
  • Dave Studenmund - Author and Editor of The Hardball Times Annual
  • Paul Swangard - Director of the Warsaw Sports Marketing Center
  • Paul Swydan - Author, the Biz of Baseball
  • John Thorn - Author and baseball historian
  • Steve Treder - Author for The Hardball Times
  • Jon Weisman - Baseball author for SI.com
  • Andrew Zimbalist - Author, consultant, and Sports Economist
  • Our Reader Selection - The Biz of Baseball selects what we feel is the best reader response on the state of the game from Brian Dupont of Brooklyn, NY.


JEFF ANGUS - Author of Management by Baseball: The Official Rules for Winning Management in Any Field (Harper Collins), is an active management consultant. 

In 2006, the press' priapic passion to natter about performance-promoting supplements led them also to focus on imagined reasons MLB was about to crater (or merely could crater, but whatever you do don't miss an opportunity to get yer knickers in a twist).

The actual business environment was positive, and the resulting abundance led to some interesting management decisions. Record attendance and ticket revenue, combined with extraordinary cash flow from MLBAM overwhelmed what could have been scary news on the TV viewership side (lowered World Series viewership). Fox, of course, completely mis-managed the telecasts -- knowing a universal rule that a higher concentration of ads drops viewership while fewer ads increases it, they decided to wall-board every cubic centrimetre of screen space with relentless hucksterism. Knowing that rule but doing it anyway is a classic case of Angus' First Law of Organizational Behavior: All human systems tend to be self amplifying. So as viewership drops, Fox sells more ads to make up for lost revenue which loses revenues which...

Another embodiment of Angus' First Law: an alleged disparity of strength between the Leagues. It's conventional wisdom now that the American League is stronger than the National. Interlague records are a factual, if not indisputable indicator of this, and as smart and experienced a baseball man as Pat Gillick told me he believes it to be true. Why would this happen? Because all human systems tend to be self-amplifying: if your league is stronger, you have to invest more, refine systems more, to compete or to achieve adequacy, so you build. If you don't have to win 95 games to get into the playoffs, you're less likely to invest to win at least that many games. We've seen this in individual divisions for a long time, but this is the first time in decades the Leagues' strengths have been seen as so different.

Surprisingly, too, a vast number of people who worship the free market are whingeing about the fact that player salaries set since the World Series have been higher than in the past. There's a limited supply of talent, all the competitors in this zero-sum crucible have a slug of new money, all of them are investing it. Big whoop. How one "feels" about the propriety of making Gil "guh" Meche a guhzillionaire is one thing, but deciding that his contract was "overpayment" is just a feeling, not a reflection of the marketplace. Managers beyond baseball do this all the time, to their detriment: become Bitgods (Back In The Good Old Days), allowing their need to have things be as they were before override their ability to judge present conditions.

And on the field in 2006, management evolved significantly. The parts of the Oakland A's tactics that became public through Moneyball were far more widely accepted on almost every team, equalizing those new advantages enough that a pair of teams weighted towards "character" made it to the World Series. That's another lesson for managers beyond baseball: If enough competitors follow the same tactical toolkit, no matter how good it is, riffing off of the standard holds the strong possibility of competitive advantage. 


CHUCK ARMSTONG - President of the Seattle Mariners

Chuck ArmstrongProfessional Baseball in North America is in its best financial shape in history.  That is both good news and bad news.  Because most teams are finally on fairly solid financial footing, most teams have more money to spend on major league player salaries which has caused a quantum leap this offseason in not only salaries but also contract length.  It will be interesting from an intellectual standpoint to look back five-six years from now and judge how this offseason has impacted the game over that time span.

But looking at the current situation from the good-news-glass-half-full perspective, I would proffer the following: a) The opportunities for young athletes to choose baseball as their sport of choice has never been better; b) Unlike the other major sports, Baseball offers the young athlete time for growth and late development as we are the only sport with our own purely internal player development system; c) Baseball careers last far longer than NBA or NFL careers; d) When a professional baseball player's career ends, he still has his body intact and is able to enjoy a long, full and complete life; and, e) Because even mediocre Major League players now can make millions for years, and because of the wonderful pension system in place for retired MLB players, MLB players and their families have now achieved financial security like never before.

And, even more good news: From a competitive standpoint on the playing field, the last six World Series Champions have come from each of the six divisions of Major League Baseball.  This is great news for the sport of Baseball.

As Mel Allen used to say: "How about that?!"

(Read the Biz of Baseball interview with Chuck Armstrong) 


 BUZZIE BAVASI - Long-time general manager for the Brooklyn and Los Angeles Dodgers (1951-67), president of the San Diego Padres (1968-77), and executive vice president of the California Angels (1978-99).

Buzzie BavasiThe trouble with Baseball is money. Mr. Rickey, the best in the business--never be another like him--always insisted that the best player is the hungry player. In the forties, fifties and the sixties both players and management were motivated by pride. Today, both sides are motivated by money.

During the last game of the season a friend of mine took his family of four to the game. With parking, concessions, transportation and tickets he was out $425.00. The worst things that have happened to the game is 1) The guaranteed contracts.2) Arbitration. I went to one arbitration hearing in my enter career. After the first one I never returned. The discussion was reviewing a players RBI production. He had all of 11 that year and was seeking a 100% increase in salary. The arbiter asked, "What's an RBI"?. That's when I left. As the saying goes: "Money is the root of all evil.”  Ownership wants to blame most of the problems on Marvin Miller; I don't. Marvin never did anything to hurt the game. He was out to help the player just as any GM was out to help his club.
 
Nothing wrong with the game that another Babe Ruth, Joe D. or Ted Williams can't fix. It's still a great game. The players might not be quite as good as they were years ago, but this is due to the fact that they are brought to major leagues too soon. Not enough minor league experience. This, of course, is due to expansion. Guess you and others will not agree with me that the playing talent isn't as good as it was. Take away the big gloves that they use today and you will see what I mean.

You know why is a great game? The average fan can sit in the stands and tell his neighbor that he can manage better than Joe Torre or he can play better than PeeWee Reese or  Jackie Robinson, unlike Football or Basketball where size and height are the contributing factors.
I was in the baseball business from 1939 throught 1984 excluding the three years I spent in Africa and Italy. During my years in the game I never met a person on or off the field that I didn't like.

(Read the Biz of Baseball interview with Buzzie Bavasi)


 ALEX BELTH - Author of Stepping Up: The Story of Curt Flood and His Fight for Baseball Players' Rights and Author for Sports Illustrated.com

What is right about the game: Direct TV baseball package, and all of the wonderful information and baseball writing available on the Internet.  Most specifically, Retrosheet and Baseball-Reference are things that I value and appreciate daily. They help make this a golden age of sorts for fans.  Also, just when you think  cynicism is going to completely overwhelm you, there are players like David Wright or Ryan Howard, who remind you that the play is the thing, and that there are always great players to watch.  Pujols, Ortiz, Mariano Rivera, Joe Mauer, there is no shortage of wonderful players out there.

What's wrong about the game? The hyped-up highlight show mentality of Sportscenter, blaring sound systems at ball parks, the boring debate between "old school" and "new school," moralizing sportswriters, bland, corporate jocks, and vengeful, righteous fans. Oh, and one more pet peeve--sportswriters who write one sentence paragraphs.


MAURY BROWN - The editor of The Biz of Baseball and an author for Baseball Prospectus

Maury BrownI look at the health and well-being of Major League Baseball through the prism of the ’94 Strike. Bud and Don, you very nearly lost me then. Still, I’m struck by baseball’s siren song—of the warm glow of the sun and the true glorious feeling I get when I go to a game with family and friends. It’s that social connection that has been a part of the game since its inception that is what is truly good about the game. It is that thread through history that binds it to those that love it.

Beyond that, it comes back to that strike in 1994. I’m happy to see that the players and management have seen the light and learned that all will flourish if there is labor peace. I see positive aspects of the new labor agreement—from its 5-year duration, to the efforts to make revenue sharing more equitable, it works to grow revenues for all, and that includes the lower revenue making clubs.

I give a tip of the hat to the World Baseball Classic. It turned out far better than I had dreamed, and shows again how well the MLBPA and 245 Park are working together to grow the game internationally.

I’m most impressed with MLB Advanced Media. It’s amazing that the clubs, through the efforts of Commissioner Selig, pulled together a centralized component of MLB that is truly world class, and a facet of all professional sports that is envied.

For the most part, I’m happy with the game, and most of its underpinnings at this point in time. It couldn't be better... or could it?

As with everything, I’m a subjective you-know-what on certain levels, and I can see some warts in the business, as there are in all of them; it just comes with the territory.

My biggest issue is how all the Big-4 sports count attendance. I understand that the owners are concerned about ticket revenues, and therefore are looking at paid attendance (ticket sales), but let’s be honest and go back to counting turnstile clicks.

Also (and, Bud, I know this one is tough), MLB has to address the television territory issue as it pertains to black out restrictions. If there needs to be a fee associated to allow fans the ability to see games in their own “market”, then so be it. But, I’m sure that a fan 5 or 6 hours from the ballpark isn’t going to make the trek when games are blacked out. Make all games available to those that purchase MLB Extra Innings. Mr. Commissioner, I know you’ve dealt with this issue, so you get an idea of what the consumer is going through: it’s restrictive.

One thing I'm sure that the MLBPA and management can agree on is that in the wake of the Matsuzaka signing, the posting system needs to be overhauled. Some might say that the system should be scrapped all together. After all, should two clubs (one MLB and one Japanese) have exclusive rights to a player? The names Gardella, and Flood, and yes... Messersmith and McNally come to mind. 

A short one… If the NFL can get the Rolling Stones and a stage the size of Rhode Island setup and torn down during commercial breaks of the Super Bowl, is it too hard to ask John Mellencamp to get in front of a microphone with an acoustic guitar in less? The marketing of the game still needs some tending to. 

Lastly, (and this is admittedly selfish), I think it’s time that MLB credential some Internet media outlets for the All-Star game and postseason, including the World Series. There is an increasing number of media outlets that are professional, and first rate that deserve this fair opportunity. The line between online and print media continues to blur, and with that, it is no longer a case where the medium should be the deciding factor.

All in all, I’m pretty much sold on this being a very good period of time for MLB--maybe the best. The Golden Era? Maybe. But, Bud and Don, I’ll save that label for when you retire. Let's see where we are then.


 WILL CARROLL - Author for Baseball Prospectus

Saying what's right and wrong with the game is an exercise in hubris and futility. The game has always held a balance between perfection and fatally flawed and it's that balance that makes the game what it is. Say what you will about the modern game, modern players, and modern owners and there's still twenty ways to show that this is the golden age. Like anything baseball can be improved, so here's five suggestions:

1. Limit dead time -- radio showed that exclusivity works. Instead of two minutes of commercials between innings, get advertisers to pay more for the one minute. Add in a small logo -- "The Fifth Inning is brought to you by Bud!" and the revenue goes neutral. More commercialism with less commercials sounds win-win. I'd also add a pitch clock. If you took a kid to a Steve Trachsel game, his Xbox fingers will start twitching.

2. The return of the doubleheader --- again, charge more for the ticket. The union would buy in if it added more off-days, something i always hear players complaining about. Done right, a balance could be struck between revenue, off-days, and shortening the season. I'd rather see more doubleheaders than 154 game seasons.

3. End the blackouts -- The blackout rules are arcane and needless. If I pay for MLB.tv or Extra Innings, I should be able to see the games. Need a small extra fee for local games? I'm sure we can work something out. Then again, it would be nice if the owners threw this bone out there for the fans.

4. Force the moral imperative on steroids -- The NFL's policy is a joke, so the beating that MLB takes on drug policy could be used as marketing. Point out how strong the policy is or better, hand it off to WADA. (Yes, they're no better, but they are independent.) Put pressure on other sports to do the same. Spend a LOT more money on education and fund high school testing.

5. Labor Peace -- what? Ahh, Merry Christmas, Mr. Scroogelig. God bless us, every one.


FRED CLAIRE - Former VP and GM of the Dodgers, Author of My 30 Years in Dodger Blue, and currently with MLB.com

Fred ClaireI approach the question with thoughts of the baseball Winter Meetings and recent news stories still in my mind…

The game is on the right track when there are several hundred young people in attendance at the Winter Meetings looking for opportunities…and there’s something very wrong about the fact that many people who devoted their lives to the game don’t have adequate pension plans in their senior years...

There is something inspiring to see people who have been in the game for many years show up at the Winter Meetings looking for a job in a quite and dignified fashion…and something wrong with Barry Bonds parading through the lobby of the hotel headquarters…

There is something wrong about a system where a team spends $51 million dollars for the rights to negotiate with a player from Japan…..and there’s something even more wrong when there are fewer and fewer players coming from U.S. soil to reach the Major Leagues…

There’s something wrong when the discussion of next year’s Hall of Fame ballot is overshadowed by the talk of players who may or may not have used performance enhancing drugs…when few people have knowledge and almost everyone seems to have a definite opinion….

There’s something right about a man like Roland Hemond—who has attended every Winter Meetings since 1951— when he stops to talk to every young person seeking advice…and something wrong about a few executives who don’t even bother to respond to questions about how a young person can get a chance to enter the game…

There’s something really out of balance when very average Major League players sign contracts suited for stars…there’s something just as wrong when players let agents direct their decisions instead of following their own hearts and minds…

There’s something good when you see an agent like Ron Shapiro, not in a hotel lobby but buying an ice cream cone at a nearby location, and know that every deal you have ever had with him reflected the credibility of the man….

There’s something good when you see the people who run minor league teams display a true dedication to the sport…

You know it’s right when you see men like Bob Geren, Ron Washington, Fredi Gonzalez and Manny Acta getting a chance to manage in the big leagues for the first time after paying their dues for many years…

There’s a lot more right and a lot more wrong with our game but you know you have spent your life in the right place when you have been going to Winter Meetings for nearly 40 years and have enjoyed every single moment of your involvement with baseball.

(Read the Biz of Baseball interview with Fred Claire)


JERRY CRASNICK - Baseball writer for ESPN and Baseball America; Author of License to Deal: A Season on the Run with a Maverick Baseball Agent

Jerry CrasnickHere's what I love most about baseball: The sense of order that it brings to my life at a time when my daughters are growing up too quickly, world events are spiraling out of control, and I can't quite grasp how to incorporate bluetooth technology into my universe. I love watching Dontrelle Willis pump his fist after escaping a bases-loaded jam, David Eckstein somehow finding a way to shot-put the ball to first base a half-step ahead of the runner, and Charlie Manuel explaining the intricacies of dugout strategy. It's better than Borat.
 
Nothing terribly profound here -- just the same things that attracted me to the game as an eight-year-old Boston Red Sox fan growing in Maine. There's a reason why NFL rosters feature refrigerators with legs, and everybody focuses on baseball's steroid problem. There's a reason why 7-foot NBA stiffs drive Ferraris, and baseball fans know Alex Rodriguez's contract down to the final decimal point. Baseball will always be held to a higher standard, and the people who run the game should be grateful -- because it's fueled by passion rather than point spreads.
 
In my estimation, the most profound changes can only make baseball better. I'm excited about the game's more global reach, and wondering whether Daisuke Matsuzaka can have an Ichiro Suzuki-like impact as a rookie with the Red Sox.
 
Some of the Internet blogging out there is a little too mean-spirited for my tastes, but people like Bill James and Retrosheet's Dave Smith and the folks at Baseball Prospectus have revolutionized the way we all think about the game, and helped us all view it in a whole new light.
 
What don't I like? With apologies to David Ortiz and Travis Hafner, the DH rule is still a blight on the game. Some days Hawk Harrelson makes my ears bleed. And I hope the next agent client-stealing story that I write for ESPN.com will be the last in my journalism career. But I'm nitpicking here. When the Detroit Tigers go from 43 victories to a World Series in three years, or Anibal Sanchez becomes the first pitcher since Randy Johnson to throw a no-hitter, it's just another sign that baseball's capacity to surprise and delight is as strong as ever.
 
Heck, I don't even begrudge Gil Meche the opportunity to make $11 million a year through 2011. When the game is generating more than $5 billion a year in revenue, and attendance continues to climb, and we've had seven different World Series winners since 2000, and Bud Selig and Donald Fehr can sit at a press conference in October and say nice things to each other while announcing five more years of labor peace, it's hard not to feel good about baseball. Where it's been, and where it's headed.


NEIL DeMAUSE - Co-author of Field of Schemes , and author for Baseball Prospectus

Figuring out what's "right" and "wrong" with MLB depends largely on whose perspective you take. From an owner's standpoint, clearly these are good times to be in the baseball business: Ticket revenues and media contracts are through the roof; the commissioner's office has achieved both labor peace and a contract that's relatively management-friendly (thank in large part to the previous labor pact expiring right after 9/11, when the owners could patriotism-bait the union into concessions); and the publicly funded stadium boom continues unabated, with four stadiums costing a total of more than $1.7 billion in public funds breaking ground this year alone. And for players, too, this boodle is trickling down, as Gary Matthews' and Gil Meche's agents could tell you.

For fans, though, the same picture looks less rosy: Tickets are increasingly unaffordable when you can get them at all (and the planned downsizing of capacity at new stadiums only makes matters worse); attending a game means having your eyes and ears blasted with innumerable revenue-generating ads; and even if low-revenue teams have improved their bottom line, MLB has done nothing to allow them to compete for talent with the big boys. I suppose one could count "more cupholders" or "ability to watch games on your cellphone" as value-added features, but I'm not sure those are things anybody's going to be telling their grandkids about.

In short, MLB is continuing its transition from a haphazardly run, tradition-bound, 19th-century niche attraction to an efficient corporate mass entertainment enterprise. Ultimately, that's both the best and the worst thing about baseball today.


ERIC FISHER - MLB writer for the Sports Business Journal

The competition on the field is as compelling at any time in baseball’s history, thanks in no small part to meaningful improvements in league parity and revenue sharing. For all the drama surrounding baseball’s front office in recent years, we still haven’t lost the thrill of watching a well-played game, and that’s the most important thing. The labor front obviously is at a historical high with the new CBA and utter lack of public rancor involved in its construction. MLB Advanced Media continues to run circles around the digital content operations of the other major sports properties, and even before the success of the World Baseball Classic, significant gains were being made in baseball’s international marketing.

On the negative side, MLB still struggles mightily with its overall messaging. Thousands, if not millions, of fans and potential fans believe MLB games are prohibitively expensive to attend, when in fact it’s still an absolute bargain compared to other major league sports, and are even more affordable when accessing midweek deals offered by almost every club. The steroid cloud remains in full force, to the point that Bud Selig recently opined that there are still fans who think MLB doesn’t have a steroid testing policy. That right there is a rather damning indictment of baseball’s communication with the public on the issue. There is also plenty of work to be done yet in making baseball more relevant to African-Americans, and kids of all races. Some of the youth marketing efforts to date have been good, but MLB needs to follow through on long-discussed efforts to make some of the postseason games more accessible to younger TV viewers.


RODNEY FORT - Author and Professor at Washington State University who has specialized in sports economics

Everything that is right with MLB can be found in the fact that millions of kids still want to play and emulate their favorite MLB players.  And they grow up to be fans, reflected in the ability of MLB to continually grow revenues.  Finally, the game remains essentially the same—three strikes, four balls, get there before the ball, hit the cut-off man, keep your eye on the ball, dig and slide, no clock.  Apparently, MLB continues to do enough good while doing well; no formal intervention in their business behavior has ever come to pass despite what is wrong with MLB.  It’s typical that “what is wrong” takes longer to cover than “what is right.”

Most observers launch into their pet peeves about either the characteristics of play (the designated hitter, uniform styles, realignment, the wild card, and steroids) or about competitive balance and team economic welfare.  But I find all of these arguments to be about symptoms, rather than causes.  The root cause concerning characteristics of play is the changing nature of fans.  MLB has never stayed glued to any generation of fans; the single seat holds the aging fan but those around him become the new generation of fans.  

MLB didn’t stay stuck in the era of eight teams in two leagues, no playoffs (unless a league was tied), wool uniforms, and high socks.  Many of us miss the old ways and wax nostalgic, but MLB has always changed to meet changing preferences.  It warms the heart of traditionalists when a player tucks their pants up, but many newer fans just chuckle at this quirky choice.

The root cause of competitive balance and team economic welfare issues has ailed MLB since the no-compete “agreement” between the original NL and AL in 1903.  No meaningful economic competition exists among MLB owners.  MLB owners are allowed to cooperate in ways that are good for their personal economic welfare but not in the best interest of the widest variety of fans.  This complete monopoly that MLB has over the number and location of major league baseball teams and the inherent differences in potential revenue across those locations generates MLB’s competitive balance issues.  This is mistakenly allowed under simple-minded arguments that MLB is just a franchisor like McDonald’s or completely confused arguments that all cooperation must be allowed simply because a league must cooperate to create a league output.

Arguments over revenue sharing, the luxury tax, and the possibility of a salary cap take this monopoly power as given and only account for the interests of fans of existing teams.  The more in-depth look at MLB’s unfettered control over team location includes the interests of all fans, including those currently without teams.  Given the current state of regulatory infrastructure for sports in North America, in my opinion the only fixit is through antitrust applications—split up the leagues into real for real competing economic entities.  This was my argument in Hardball (with James Quirk, Princeton University Press, 1999), standing on the big shoulders of one of my favorite sports economists, Roger Noll, who addressed the issue in Congressional testimony over 30 years ago.

So, don’t change the game.  It is different now than then because fan preferences are different and fans are differently distributed by income and population now versus then.  But do make one truly nostalgic change in MLB.  Instead of throwback uniforms, impose the throwback market structure that existed between the AL and NL prior to 1903.  Make the game competitive off the field as well as on the field by creating separate leagues.


GARY GILLETTE - President, 24-7 Baseball, L.L.C.; Editor, The 2006 ESPN Baseball Encyclopedia; Co-Chair, SABR Business of Baseball Committee

Gary GilleteMajor League Baseball has made a remarkable recovery from the malaise that pervaded the game from 2001-2003. After posting three years of record total attendance (though the per-game average is still slightly below the pre-strike peak) and record revenues (more than $5 billion this year), both the owners and the players are rolling in green. That is a testament to how well baseball has sold the game in the past few years after decades of incredibly bad marketing. It is also a statement as to how well baseball has so far escaped major damage from the ongoing steroids scandal.

The inaugural World Baseball Classic in the spring was also a surprise success, partly due to low expectations. Nevertheless, there is a dark lining to this golden cloud. The 2006-2007 offseason has brought an eye-popping amount of overspending on what everyone agrees was a mediocre crop of free agents. If industry revenues don't continue to climb steadily, this may presage a financial hangover for many clubs similar to what happened after the 2000-2001 budget-busting offseason. Baseball has been excluded from the 2012 Olympics and seems very unlikely to be reinstated for 2016. And without Olympic status, amateur baseball programs in scores of countries will lose their funding.

MLB's sale of one League Championship Series to cable network TBS continues the devaluation of baseball's postseason. The record-low TV ratings for all of MLB's so-called "jewel events"--the All-Star Game, the Division Series, the League Championship Series, and the World Series--are frankly shocking. When Game 1 of the 2006  World Series between two attractive underdog teams, each led by a famous manager, garners a pitiful 8.0 Nielsen rating, something is seriously wrong. And when the World Series as a whole manages only a 10.1 rating, it underscores just how poorly baseball is appealing to virtually every demographic except aging white males. Ratings for LCS games and for the All-Star Game now rarely crack double digits, and ratings for Division Series games are frequently in the low single digits.

Finally, when American adults were asked by the Pew Research Center in spring 2006 what their favorite sport was, the "National Pastime" polled only 13 percent, third behind basketball (14 percent) and King Football (34 percent). If and when the constant rumors about steroids usage reach a tipping point with baseball fans, the game could see a sharp decline in its popularity, its attendance, and its revenue.

CHRIS ISIDORE - Senior writer and SportsBiz columnist for CNNMoney.com

Chris IsidoreOn balance, there’s far more that’s right with the game today than is wrong. But what’s wrong is still a serious threat.

As to what’s right, even with this off-season’s spending spree by many clubs, Major League Baseball is poised to have the most successful economic system the game has ever known.

It is one in which both small market teams and big market teams can and will be able to compete, and in which it’s in the economic interests of both players and owners to work out their problems rather than shutdown the game.

The just concluded labor negotiations suggest we may very well have seen the last strike or lockout in a sport that once seemed as if it would know nothing but labor strife.

Not only was the deal wrapped up early, it for the first time encourages the owners to grow the game’s popularity, providing powerful economic incentives to teams that improve their revenue.

And players are now being compensated well enough that the chance of future strikes will be greatly diminished. Only 87 players on rosters at the end of last season have ever been through a strike, only a handful will have done so when the current deal is up. In the past the union could count on having clubhouses full of players whom had gone through multiple labor wars in order to win basic rights. That solidarity will be much tougher for future union bosses to win.

Traditional revenue streams are showing growth, partly due to new technology. Digital video recorders and other competing forms of entertainment is making advertising on live sports more valuable, because it will be advertisers’ best chance to reach a broad audience. And online markets to resell tickets will encourage fans to buy the season tickets and ticket packages that most benefit teams, and lead to even more fans coming to games.

In addition, technology is allowing even faster growth of new revenue streams, primarily from MLB Advance Media. In addition to delivering additional growth, it is further leveling the competitive playing field.

The fact that Bud Selig got the owners to agree to evenly split the MLBAM expenses and potential profits at a time when many questioned if it would ever make money will be his greatest legacy, far more than interleague play, the wild card playoff or even the current era of labor peace.

It is likely that agreement will eventually be as important to the economics of the game as was the NFL’s first national television deal, and the football owners agreement to evenly split what was then an exceptionally small pool of money – less than what NCAA women’s basketball gets from television rights today, even adjusted for inflation.

Undoubtedly some teams are spending their way back into red ink this winter, and many teams will head out of spring training with rosters that have no chance to compete. Some teams will dump salaries during the season, and there are some markets that will struggle to support teams.

But that’s been always been true, not just throughout not just the history of baseball, but also throughout the world of business. Empty seats in Miami, continued losses in Tampa Bay and Kansas City don’t obscure the fact that the game has never been healthier financially, and more competitive, and thus more popular.

The game has taken tremendous steps to globalize its appeal and its reach. In a “The World is Flat” economy, businesses that are thinking globally will always succeed over those that are focused only on the U.S. market. Even before the World Baseball Classic, the MLB was one of the leaders in drawing on a global talent pool, and pool of fans. Losing a spot in the Olympics is minor compared to the sport’s global gains.

But for such a successful sport, it can still be surprisingly tone deaf.

The legal challenge over fantasy sports rights fees was a public opinion and fan-relations loser, long before the game lost a legal decision this past summer. Some teams are going to war with their best customers on the issue of reselling tickets.

And too often licensing deals have that anything-for-a-buck flavor to them that hurts the brand more than any money they could bring in justified. Allowing an announcement about team-logo caskets and urns to come out during the postseason is only the latest problem in that regard.

That tone deafness makes other more serious problems worse than they might otherwise be.

All major U.S. sports have problems with use of performance-enhancing drugs, with competitive imbalance, with declining popularity among U.S. youth in a video-game world. But baseball is held to a higher standard, or greater disregard, in all of those areas, because it has opened itself up for so much criticism on other issues.

So for the game to keep improving its success and popularity, it will have to work harder on both those big issues, and as well as not being so tone deaf.


KING KAUFMAN - Sports columnist for Salon

King KaufmanWhat's right with baseball is, as always, the game itself, which just doesn't seem capable of being ruined by anything, from the Black Sox to the blue doubleknits to performance enhancing drugs. The game itself, ball one, strike two, 90 feet and all that, survives it all.

What's right at the moment is a feeling of renewal, partly from the natural changeover of teams -- the Braves finally missing the playoffs and the Tigers finally winning the pennant -- but more from the wave of exciting young talent that arrived in 2006. The rookie class was incredible. When you've got a guy like Prince Fielder putting up a .271/.347/.483 with 28 home runs and he's just, oh, well, another rookie, it's a pretty amazing time.

What's wrong is that my favorite team has spent the winter signing up the geriatric all-stars, and then re-signing the guy I'd been hoping  would finally go away and give me my team back. No such luck by the Bay.

More broadly, there's the PED issue, which is messy and confusing and, well, boring. And then there's the ever-present problem of the game's economic structure, which makes it unnecessarily difficult for small-market teams to compete on equal terms. Why baseball can't get it together to deal with this problem by creating a revenue-sharing system that helps teams with less potential revenue, as opposed to teams that have successfully mismanaged themselves into less actual revenue, is beyond me. Instead the owners just whine whenever there's a hot free-agent market and salaries spike upward.

But having said that, there's more right than wrong.


JONAH KERI - Writer for ESPN.com's Page 2, a contributor to YESNetwork.com, and co-author of the New York Times' "Keeping Score" column. He's also the editor and co-author of the book "Baseball Between the Numbers."

What's right with MLB today:
 
Opening Day. Die-hard fans. Ichiro and Felix. Strat-O-Matic. Calamari, Anchor Steam on tap, and a seat by the bay in the center field bleachers in San Francisco. Johan Santana. Box scores. The few announcers who call a game the right way, including Vin Scully, Jon Miller, Harry Kalas, Ken Singleton, Dave Van Horne, Boog Sciambi, Mike Curto, Len Kasper and Josh Lewin. Ballclubs that are open to new ideas. Fans who are open to new ideas. Statheads who are open to new ideas. Scouts who are open to new ideas. Sources who go out of their way to call back. Mark Shapiro, the best GM no one ever talks about. Sunsets at Dodger Stadium. Justin Verlander's curve ball. The bullpen Midas touch of Kevin Towers and the San Diego Padres. Wrigley Field bleachers. MLB Extra Innings. Summer road trips with buddies. Tommy John surgery, a medical miracle we now take for granted.
 
What's wrong with MLB today:
 
The guilty until proven innocent stance fans and media have adopted on players' use of PEDs. The perception that higher player salaries equal higher ticket prices (higher demand = higher prices). Writers who think they're moral arbiters for the game. Rewarding mediocrity. Teams that keep spinning the carousel of lousy, recycled managers. Managers who favor a veneer of hustle over actual performance. The wink-wink attitude toward domestic violence among ballplayers. Free-agent contracts for first basemen over 30. Spiteful, misinformed newspaper columnists. No more two games-for-the-price-of-one doubleheaders. Teams' blind adherence to the traditional closer role. New stadium extortion. No major league team in Montreal, one of the greatest cities in the world.


 TIM LEMKE - Sports Business reporter for the Washington Times

It seems clear that Major League Baseball is in pretty good shape right now. Revenues are up, attendance is up, there's labor peace and the talk of contraction is as dead as Dizzy Dean. There's good parity, reason for hope for most fans and general good vibe about the game. Attending a Major League baseball game is still one of the best values in American sports, and there's a great place to watch a game in nearly every city.
 
But I still worry about baseball sometimes. Television ratings aren't exactly stellar, kids in urban areas are about as familiar with baseball as bocce, and by August every year the sports conversation shifts too easily from pitchers and shortstops to quarterbacks and linebackers. Baseball may be doing well now, but I can't help but wonder if it's all a mirage. More people are attending baseball games, but it seems that those fans are more of the casual type, rather than the die-hard variety. Long-term, that could be a problem.

And here's something to ponder: what happens a decade from now, when there are no more pretty stadiums to build, and thus no more excuses for a team that's struggling?
 


ROB NEYER - Author and Senior Writer, ESPN.com

Rob NeyerWhat's right with MLB: Plenty. As fans, we're seeing the great majority of the world's best players, and for a modest fee we can see the great majority of the games in the comfort of our own homes. Thanks to the Web, we don't have to rely on broadcasters and old baseball writers for analysis. Every year, dozens of good baseball books are published. I don't believe there's ever been a better time to be a baseball fan.
 
What's wrong with MLB: The mainstream media is lagging well behind the fans in how it covers the sport. This is not particularly surprising, but it's nonetheless frustrating. And while I'm among the very few people who give a damn, there are moments when I'm revolted by the overwhelming commercialism that infuses Major League Baseball. I hope I'm wrong, but I fear that before long we'll see advertising logos on the uniforms and actually on the field of play. There is, of course, plenty of precedent for this in other sports, and in other countries.

ROGER NOLLProfessor Emeritus of Economics, Stanford University

Baseball's health is more robust that it has been in years, maybe decades. Behind the obvious -- the growth in revenues and the achievement of stability in the collective bargaining relationship -- is the game itself. Baseball has recovered from the disastrous loss of the 1994 Word Series and the bad publicity surrounding the Balco affair. Notwithstanding the scandals, baseball players are now far more serious about training and far more disciplined than one or two decades ago, and aesthetically the game is now played at an awesomely high level. If baseball avoids another PR disaster in the immediate future, the next few years should be a golden age.

Nevertheless, baseball has not really solved its most challenging problem: retaining fan interest in all teams when some perpetually are not competitive. (I note that neither hockey nor basketball has solved this problem either.) The problem is partly team management. The A's and Twins show that well-managed teams can provide an  interesting product on budgets that are realistic in smaller markets. But the problem also arises from two structural issues. First, a 30-team league in which teams play for six months with exclusive focus on a single achievement (the World Series) is guaranteed to have mostly failures in each year and some perpetual failures. Second, extensive revenue sharing causes the profit-maximizing strategy of some teams to be simply to go through the motions and to live off of the shared revenues. This incentive accentuates the problem of playing for half a year to reach a single goal.

The solutions to the structural problems are easy to write but probably impossible to implement. (1) Cut the fraction of local revenue that is shared and adopt a progressive sharing ratio. For example, the first $50 million of local revenue would be tax free, and the rest would be taxed at 35%, with the proceeds divided equally among all teams. This type of formula gives teams in weaker markets a greater incentive to improve compared to the incentive of teams in larger markets to become dominant. (2) Follow the lead of European sports by creating multiple ways to succeed. For example, halt the season for two weeks in late spring for a double-elimination tournament for the "Selig Cup" (patterned after the College World Series).


JEFF PASSAN - National Baseball Writer for Yahoo! Sports

Jeff PassanThe game is right. The game will always be right. The game is why baseball now thrives, why it has persevered, why it caught on in the first place. The game is malleable enough -- fast or slow, intense or laid-back, a pitching duel or slugfest -- to sate the vox populi. The game speaks. The game cries. The game invites. The game, simply, is perfect. 

Baseball is a dream that can be fulfilled, or at least seems that way, and that gives it a proletariat edge that no other sport can claim. Basketball discriminates by height, football by girth or speed, hockey by coordination or number of teeth missing. Fat or skinny, fast or slow, tall or short, baseball is accessible -- full of choices, indeed, from the game itself to the players to the ways in which one can enjoy it.

The availability, in fact, separates baseball. It is a must with the 162-game schedule. Players need to sell their sport, and anyway, rigidity and silence would get boring. The interaction between fan and player is sacred, and it exposes baseball's vulnerability, its tight grip on the past, when second jobs in the offseason were commonplace.

Baseball could lose -- and has lost -- its track when forgetting its simplicity, some kind of feat, because any businessman would sacrifice a limb for a product so turgid with the good. Money has a way of turning fans, and baseball still has not figured out the proper way to convince them they're the reason the sport is in good financial shape. Instead, headlines scream about out-of-control salaries, and paranoia about the future crops up, and Chicken Little the Red Sox fan screams that, boy, these days it costs $51 million just to talk with a guy.

Shunning that base, one baseball seems to take for granted, would cripple the game. Barring a major change, baseball won't be like basketball, its personalities always on display, or like football, its marketing juggernaut so good it could perhaps get someone elected. Baseball should be how Lincoln envisioned this country: by the people, for the people.

Which means, essentially, taking extreme care to see no financial struggles throughout the term of this collective-bargaining agreement. No matter how hard Congress tried, its focus on steroids -- an important issue, yes, though one that would not have drawn Capitol Hill hearings if not for the lure of bipartisan posturing -- proved that people just don't care about them as much as salaries. Why? Few of us know steroids. Everyone knows money.

Hopefully baseball has a watchdog, because for a sport so entrenched in its history, its has evolved rapidly over the last 20 years, and such growth often spirals out of control. No matter what, the sport will always be there, and it will survive on the basis alone of being baseball. Whether everything else follows suit is the question. And it's one that could have a scary answer.


BILL SHANKS Publisher and writer for The Braves Show.com. He’s also one of the hosts of the Braves’ Wrap Up Show on the Atlanta Braves Radio Network. He has done work on television and has authored the book, Scout's Honor: The Bravest Way To Build A Winning Team. 

There are so many things right and good about this game we all love. For those of us that do consider baseball a big part of our lives, it’s an institution and as dependable as anything we have. We long for it, enjoy it, and look back on it, knowing there is no better entertainment in this world we live in than the game of baseball.

The competitive balance that has been achieved in baseball is definitely good. There have been seven different World Series winners this decade. And while small market clubs might still be at a disadvantage, the difference in the gap is not as wide as it was a decade ago. 

Yes, clubs like the Yankees and Red Sox and Mets are able to go after free agents and expensive talent easier than the small market clubs. But those seven different champions prove that having a huge payroll does not guarantee success or being on a podium in late October. Instead, it’s all about creating a roster combining homegrown talent and smart trades and additions, and not just buying every player on the market.

Some complain about a club like the Kansas City Royals spending huge money on a free agent like Gil Meche. But aren’t the Royals simply trying to stay competitive in today’s marketplace? To attract a popular free agent such as Meche they had to overpay for a pitcher one could term ‘mediocre’ in his big league career. But at least the Royals are in the game, something that could not be said in the late 1990s. 

Most clubs are also learning that while investments in free agents can provide immediate results, it’s the commitment to the farm system that can create long-term success. Look at the Tampa Bay Devil Rays. They do not spend money in free agency, but they have instead developed talent to now be recognized as having the best farm system in the game. Now is where the hard part will come in for the Rays, as they will have to integrate that young talent with more additions from outside their club in order to build a consistent contender.

The inability for clubs to compete for every single big money free agent has forced them to look more at developing their own talent. Hopefully, most of these small market clubs are taking some money from the luxury tax or even simply from profits and pinpointing that to building up the farm system. 

We see so many teams try to stay within a budget, and often that means sacrificing players that reach a certain financial level. This makes having an assembly line of talent, ready to replace a player that may no longer be affordable, a top priority. So clubs have no choice but to spend more money and time on developing its own talent. Teams are learning this formula, and that’s why more clubs are now more competitive. But the playoff system in place also gives more teams a chance.

Look at the Atlanta Braves, the team I happen to cover. They were 6-21 in the month of June and struggled to get back to the .500 mark for the rest of the season. But with the wildcard in place they were able to stay mathematically in the race until the last week of the season. This allowed the fans to stay a bit more interested in the team longer than probably necessary, whereas before the wildcard the Braves would have had no chance and probably been out of the picture by August 1st

The St. Louis Cardinals won four more games than the Braves in the regular season, but they went on to win the World Series. This brings up another great thing about the game today: October is a crapshoot. We never know who is going to win the World Series. You can almost take a dartboard with the logos of the eight-playoff teams and have as good a chance as any to pick a winner. The team that gets hot is the team that wins, which often produces a pretty exciting postseason.

So what’s wrong with Baseball? Well while MLB has made huge strides in providing Internet content to its fans, it still lags behind the other sports in several areas. First, the inability to get The Baseball Network on the air is unfortunate. The NFL Network and NBA TV provide great additional content to its fan bases, but bureaucratic difficulties have somewhat railroaded baseball’s ability to create its own network. 

ESPN and FOX provide the games, but where is the ancillary content that could really help promote sport? Why doesn’t MLB have its version of NFL Films? And when we were growing up, ‘This Week in Baseball’ was apart of our weekends. Why not syndicate that program again so that kids of all ages can learn more about our game?

MLB’s decision to have its Extra Innings package exclusively on Direct TV is catastrophic. Why limit yourself and alienate your fan base by forcing them to buy something they may not want in satellite television? Certainly MLB is making enough money already that they can at least allow cable customers to purchase the extra package. 

One thing about the postseason that needs to be changed is the first round format. Every round should be best of seven so teams with home field advantage have a true advantage. If the only reason to keep the first round a best of five format is to keep the postseason from going into November, then kill some of the days off and still end the season in late October. But having the first round only a best of five is ridiculous.

When speaking of competitive balance, I think there are two things that could be done to help with the draft process. First, international players should be forced to enter the game through the draft. How many small market clubs competed for Daisuke Matsuzaka? None. So have those type players go through the draft so that the clubs with worse records can improve quicker with better talent. 

Wouldn’t the Devil Rays, who own the top pick this June, be more competitive in the future with Matsuzaka?

Every time we read in Baseball America about hotshot shortstop prospects from the Dominican, it’s always the Yankees and Mets at the top of the bidding process. So if these players are in the draft, it’s going to build up the farm systems of the teams not doing as well on the field. They’ll have a chance to improve quicker if the talent pool is stronger. 

And MLB should really allow teams to trade draft picks. Let’s say a team falls out of the race and has a few veteran players on the trade block. Couldn’t they improve their future more if they were able to trade that veteran for a draft pick so their own scouts and coaches could develop a younger talent?

I’m going to stay away from the steroid issue. Yes, it’s a problem and I don’t have the answers. The additional testing will help in the future, but for the life of me I don’t know how to react to the statistics put up by players that were probably using something at the time. Do we throw those numbers out or simply laugh at its credibility? 

Don’t count me as one who will complain about how long spring training is or that baseball is played into late October. I’m not one that will scream about too many inter league games or the DH. I like things just as they are right now.

There’s more right than wrong, and it’ll never be perfect. But baseball has never been better.


 JOE SHEEHAN - Senior Writer for Baseball Prospectus

What's right about the game is the new era of labor peace, structured around a Collective Bargaining Agreement that is the best yet at balancing the interests of all the parties involved. The most recent negotiation was a model of decorum, taking the structure agreed to in the rancorous '02 negotiation and making tweaks that attempt to address the inequities therein. How the new rules affect the game remains to be seen, but there is no question that the positives of a peaceful settlement, reached out of the public eye, outweigh whatever problems the new CBA may have.

If I may add, the other significant right for the game is the continued high quality of play and the emergence of a new generation of stars. This is a golden era for baseball. 

What's wrong about the game is the difficulty in blending its business side with the fan experience. There are constant conflicts between the game's fealty to its partners and what would be best for fans. The length of postseason games, for instance, is in no small part due to added commercial time. The growth of luxury boxes and premium seating in new and retrofitted parks has in many places consigned "the average fan" to the nether reaches of the ballpark, seats that are further from the field than ever before. Variable pricing, self-scalping schemes and usurious parking and concession fees give rise to the sense that fans are valued less for their loyalty and more for their cash.

The businesses that comprise Major League Baseball are no different from any other in that they want to maximize profit. Finding ways to do so that are less hostile to the consumers will be a key challenge in the next few years.


 NATE SILVER - Author and Executive VP of Baseball Prospectus

It’s hard to find fault with Major League Baseball today. The quality of play is fantastic. The fan experience is being enhanced in a variety of ways, from the beautiful new ballparks to all the things that MLB Advanced Media is doing. We have labor peace, and a sensible Collective Bargaining Agreement. The Wild Card has proven to be a necessary evil, and the only gripe I have with interleague play is the scheduling inequities that the designated rivalry games create. From a more personal standpoint, my job as an analyst has gotten much easier, between the increasing degree to which sabermetrics has a “place at the table”, and the wider availability of things like play-by-play data and video-on-demand. 

If there’s one, single thing that baseball could do to improve itself, it would be finding a reliable test for Human Growth Hormone. But that’s a technological issue, not a policy one, and so I’m not going to dwell on it.

Beyond that, most of my complaints have to do with the media. I don’t like the trend toward what I call paparazzi journalism, where there’s as much focus on what someone like Alex Rodriguez does off the field as what he does on the field, and he becomes sort of a caricature of himself.  The state of baseball announcing isn’t great, especially on television.  

From a front office standpoint, organizations are doing a much better job of player evaluation, but they still have a ways to go when it comes to financial evaluation. Market prices for free agents, for example, are based on a “monkey see, monkey do” approach, and not any kind of sound fiscal analysis. You see the Royals spend $55 million on Gil Meche, and rather than conclude that spending $55 million on Gil Meche is a great way to hemorrhage money, you’ll have four or five GMs tearing through their Rolodex for the number of Jason Marquis’ agent. Still, while there may be some hell to pay for this when the new CBA expires in 2011, it doesn’t make much difference from the standpoint of the average fan.

Okay, so I’d like to see a little bit more diversity in ballpark architecture. I’d like to see internet-based journalists become eligible for the BBWAA. I think I’d like to see some Questec-like system in place for calling balls and strikes; the technology will be good enough in another year or two, if it isn’t already now. But these are minor complaints. Baseball is in great shape.


MICHAEL SILVERMAN - Baseball reporter for the Boston Herald

What is right with the game of baseball now is the fact that a little guy like David Eckstein can demonstrate that smarts, drive and hustle count as much as talent. His MVP performance in the World Series was a refreshing reminder that superstars can't do it alone. I liked that a lot. The growing internationalizion of the game is a huge, progressive development that is only going to elevate the level of play we see in the game. The Daisuke Matsuzaka deal that we can expect any minute is the third of three Japanese arrivals (Matsui, Suzuki) and the most important of all. The infusion of Far East talent with that from the Caribbean is going to make baseball the most international of the big four sports in the U.S. That's a good thing.

What is wrong is that so many baseball players, executives and insiders are walking around with secrets about what happened in the steroids and HGH era. Only Kevin Towers of the Padres, that I know of, has been candid about his suspicions. You have to wonder how many people in the game are going to be able to keep their secrets. It can't be healthy. Another thing wrong with baseball is the D.H. Has anyone brought that up before?


TAL SMITH - President of Baseball Operations for the Houston Astros, and President of Tal Smith Enterprises

Tal SmithWHAT IS GOOD WITH THE GAME:

  • Labor peace
  • Attendance and fan interest are at a high level
  • Broadening of baseball's horizons internationally
  • Great new venues with improved amenities for many major and minor league cities and many other new ball parks in the works.
  • Enhanced marketing of the game including the distribution of regular season broadcasts/telecasts for all clubs
  • Revenue growth

AREAS OF CONCERN:

  • Too much player movement and churning of rosters may tend to diminish fan interest
  • Competitive balance. Will some clubs ever be able to compete?
  • Decline of amateur baseball in the United States and the effect it has on the talent pipeline. Are enough players being signed and developed to supply the 30 major league teams?
  • Continued escalation of players' salaries and long-term commitments by the clubs.
  • PR fallout from the steroid issues.

(Read the Biz of Baseball interview with Tal Smith)

 DAVE STUDENMUND - Author and Editor of The Hardball Times Annual

What's Right with baseball:

  • An influx of young and international talent is making the game more appealing and purging some of the ghosts of the steroid era.
  • Increasingly, MLB will become an international organization, and they appear to be on the right course for that.
  • MLB is adapting to the Internet extremely well.  Newspapers, which have been critical to baseball throughout its history, are on the decline in readership.  This would have been a threat to MLB, but it appears that its embrace of the Internet will offset the loss of the papers.
  • This is a period of relative stability in franchises and between players and owners.

What's Wrong with baseball:

  • Too many interleague games.  I can live with interleague play, but the number of games should be cut in half.
  • The World Series should absolutely not be played in late October, especially at night.  Considering that World Series viewership hit an all-time low this year, something is very wrong with the postseason timing and/or format.
  • Most fundamentally, there is a fairness issue when local governments are asked to pay hundreds of millions of dollars to fund baseball stadiums at the same time that individual players are receiving $15 million to $20 million a year.  I wish MLB would take the high road and address this directly, but I know they won't.

PAUL SWANGARD - Director of the Warsaw Sports Marketing Center

Right – The League’s Digital Media strategy has given them first mover advantage in a competitive marketplace. The abundance of available content and a tech-savvy fan base actually opens the League to a larger revenue opportunity. All this helps the League stay “culturally relevant” to an “all-access” consumer willing to pay for that access.

Wrong – While we must give them credit on the success of the World Baseball Classic and the pricepoints commanded for importing pitchers from Japan , MLB is still a laggard in some important international markets. Just now opening an office in Beijing puts them well behind their peers in the world’s most lucrative emerging market where it takes years even decades to build credibility. Domestically, I also remained puzzled by the MLB’s ability to manage their message and handle crisis effectively…it leads you to wonder…does MLB have a PR department?


PAUL SWYDAN - Author for The Biz of Baseball 

In the past two seasons, more has gone right for Major League Baseball than has gone wrong. The play on the field has rebounded a great deal – 2006 was the first season since 2001 where every team won at least 60 games. Marketable stars like David Wright, Ryan Howard, Grady Sizemore, Joe Mauer, and Chien-ming Wang have emerged to join ambassadors like Derek Jeter, Chipper Jones, David Ortiz, and Curt Schilling in championing the game of baseball. Parity is increasing in MLB and simultaneously decreasing in the NFL and NBA, making baseball the more unpredictable and exciting sport to follow. MLB Advanced Media continues to grow in leaps and bounds, to the point where now MLB.com is the exclusive site to see the video for Elton John’s latest single. The World Baseball Classic was a rousing success, and will be even more so in 2009. The new CBA promises labor peace, offers promise for continued prosperity for the game, and ends the possibility of weeks and months of negative headlines for the game. Most teams take a very proactive stance on ticket pricing, using dynamic models that become more sophisticated each season. Most teams have expanded their approach to evaluating baseball players, incorporating statistical tools and methods into the decision-making process. While some view outside the lines Jumbotron games and the like as unnecessary distractions, as the saying goes – you can’t have your cake and eat it too. Such revenue generating distractions have allowed the game itself to go unimpeded inside the lines. That MLB has become creative in luring sponsor money to the game bodes very well for the future.

Unfortunately, this makes the game’s inability to hold the attention of the casual fan all the more confounding. The league’s stance with regard to public relations and marketing remains lethargic and reactionary. MLB is content to let its partners market the game for it, and often they do a poor job capturing the essence of the product. Every March, Spring Training is overshadowed by March Madness. After the bliss of Opening Day, baseball can not sustain its momentum, quickly becoming an after thought in the build up to the NFL Draft. Every August, imagined quarterback controversies take center stage over actual pennant races. In the Internet age, MLB’s antiquated behavior of delayed awards announcements alienates their fan base more than it leaves them waiting in anticipation. Controversies in baseball, like the steroid issue, tend to linger longer than they do in other sports because the league often does not get in front of an issue and give it the attention it deserves.

Major League Baseball remains a great value, with tickets to games still go for as little as one dollar in some ballparks. However, MLB teams squander their proactive pricing by not telling anyone about them or confusing them with mixed messages when they do. It does not seem clear to many teams that they have to compete for their fan base’s discretionary income. In many cities, there are upwards of ten professional sports entities, not to mention college teams, golf tournaments, racing events, marathons, etc. The number of people reaching for their piece of the pie is growing seemingly exponentially, and MLB far too often is content to let others steal what used to be theirs. Talk of the record attendance is completely overblown. According to baseball-reference’s numbers, 10 of the 30 teams – a full 1/3 of the league - had lower attendance in 2006 than in 2005. What’s disturbing is the teams that were lower. San Diego with their still new ballpark, Washington with their still new team, division winner Oakland, and proud baseball cities like San Francisco and Baltimore are among those that saw a decrease in attendance. What’s more, of the 20 teams that did see increases, 11 saw less than a six percent increase. The large percentage increases seen from the Tigers, White Sox, Devil Rays, and Mets are not indicative of the game as a whole, and any attempts to mask them as such fall flat when the evidence is actually examined.

The greater failure however, could be in the coverage of the game. It is true that passionate fans have more avenues for great coverage at their fingertips than ever before. Lost in this is the fact that mainstream coverage has degraded to the point where it offers little, if any, value.  The way the game is covered in the mainstream media, from local newspapers and television, to ESPN and FOX, is almost an affront to any baseball aficionado. The networks are certainly most guilty, and as the most easily consumed form of coverage set a poor example to follow. Too often, ESPN and FOX need to be reminded that there are 30 teams, not just the Red Sox and Yankees. Baseball highlights on Sportscenter and ESPNews have eroded to home run derby - whether or not those home runs were vital to the game is of trifling concern. The insidious pre-game shows on FOX push back the start times of playoff games to an obscene degree, forcing any sensible parent to send their children to bed before the fifth inning. Finally, the blackout policy is at best unsettling, and at worst deeply insulting. The city one lives in does not necessarily define what team he roots for, and MLB’s unwillingness to change their policy goes a long way towards alienating passionate fans. 

Lastly, and admittedly this might be nitpicking, but MLB could benefit from greater focus within its league community programs. The NFL’s “Join The Team” and the NBA’s “NBA Cares” programs are much more cohesive and visible than those of MLB. Is MLB committed to the Prostate Cancer Foundation, the Komen Foundation, the Boys and Girls Clubs, the Reviving Baseball in Inner Cities (RBI) program, or something entirely different? It is hard to know from its official communications, and MLB.com offers few, if any answers. 


JOHN THORN - Author and Baseball Historian; SABR 2006 Bob Davids Award Honoree

John ThornThe players are better than ever, a statement that has aptly described every decade since the 1840s. Yet somehow the game feels worse. Call it the paradox of progress.
 
Rising attendance and revenue mask the flattening of the game to a mano a mano contest between a quivering pitcher and an emboldened batter, all too often conducted in a shiny new ballpark with the dimensions of a telephone booth. The game is not better than ever, from an artistic standpoint, and you don't have to be an octogenarian to wish for a return of the triple.
 
The business of baseball on and off the field--mlb.com is a substantial hit--is thriving. The jeremiads about competitive imbalance and inevitable contraction have declined in vigor and number. Life seems good in Major League Baseball. Multinationalism is the coming thing, and it is a good thing. Albert Spalding was ahead of his time in believing that our national pastime could be a game for the world, but events have proven him prescient.
 
Despite ever declining viewership for World Series games, baseball is still too much a spectator sport in America. MLB's halfhearted and halfbaked gestures toward reseeding its fields have made baseball antiquarianism and fantasy obsession seem reasonable. America's kids haven't witnessed a World Series or All-Star Game game in daylight in their lives and they play the game less than ever. African Americans, for whom baseball not so long ago provided a beacon toward full citizenship, have increasingly turned their backs on the game; revisionist historians now condemn Jackie Robinson's breaking of the color barrier as a cruel bait and switch by which which more was lost than was gained.
 
It's great that Major League Baseball has advanced in skill and business acumen. It's time for MLB now, at this moment when it seems the sun will shine on it forever, to consruct a long-range plan for how to insure against storm. It's time to focus on the next generation.
 

Wrong:  Not enough doubleheaders, and not enough triples.

Right:  Less artificial turf than there used to be, and generally wonderful urban-setting ballparks.

Wrong:  Umpires allowing batters to erase the batter’s box chalk lines.

Right:  Ump crews conferring to get the call right.

Wrong:  The scoring convention that if a catchable pop fly drops untouched between two or three fielders, it’s a hit.

Right:  Stats.  Baseball has always had the most elaborate and informative statistics of any sport, and the science of baseball stats has never been more vigorous than it is today.

Wrong:  Too many strikeouts, too many home runs.  The best things in baseball happen when the ball is hit into the field of play.

Right:  SABR.  Can you imagine such a thing as the Society for American Football Research?

Wrong:  Too many runs, period.

Right:  The manner in which teams and fans sincerely honor the sports’ history and lore.  Most people involved in the game, even Commissioner Seligula, seem to authentically “get” how much an appreciation of baseball’s rich past enhances our enjoyment of its present.

Wrong:  Too much delay between pitches.

Right:  Injury diagnosis and treatment, which has never been more efficacious than today’s.

Wrong:  TV games as presented by Fox.

Right:  Any game on the radio; baseball remains the best radio sport ever.

Wrong:  Chris Berman.

Right:  Jon Miller.

Wrong:  Interleague play, the Wild Card, and the DH.

Right:  The general quality of play, which has never been higher.

Wrong:  Ownerships continuing desire to have taxpayers subsidize them.

Right:  The international popularity of the sport.  Baseball has never been played, watched, and enjoyed by more people than it is today.  In MLB we’re treated to the talents of terrific players from all over the world, and this year’s World Baseball Classic was one of the most exciting events in decades.


JON WEISMAN - Baseball writer for Sports Illustrated.com and Dodger Thoughts

To a certain extent, my love for baseball is irrational – it is love, after all.  But while other passions in my life have come and gone, my relationship with baseball has been steadfast. Over the years, I’ve become invested in the characters of the game the way, I suppose, someone watching three decades of “All My Children” has. Baseball is one grand story to me – one of the grandest – and I cannot weed myself from the storyline that has brought us both Babe Ruth and Hiram Bocachica.  The entrances and exits, the highs and lows, form an epic tapestry.  I know that sounds full of itself, but that’s how the game makes me feel. 

Other sports offer the same potential to surprise, to offer the fantastic amid the quotidian – so what makes baseball special?  My family had Los Angeles Rams season tickets when I was a kid, and I was a diehard fan of the Showtime Lakers – so why does baseball retain a greater hold on me? One of the great attractions of the game, I feel, is that it offers so many intermediate achievements besides winning. Just as one example, there is that satisfaction when your pitcher gets a first-pitch strike – followed by them opportunity to pause and savor (or conversely, to agonize when it goes against you). And then, another pitch, on which anything can happen. I’m not sure any sport does this as well.  Basketball moves too fast to celebrate a simple pass, golf gives you too much time to ponder a shot.  Other sports have their  merits, and surely, some offer more pure
excitement, but baseball remains the ultimate game for me.  The main thing that is right with baseball today is that it is baseball.

The game is not perfect, of course, nor is it the most popular in the United States anymore, and I do believe that the desire to solve these problems off the field actually leads to most people’s dissatisfaction with it. It’s a vicious circle of making the game worse while trying to make it better. That doesn’t mean that the game shouldn’t evolve – but that evolution for the sake of evolution is problematic.

I believe in players getting all the money they can, in getting paid what the market can bear. At the same time, my initial reaction to Juan Pierre’s $44 million contract with the Dodgers was that surely, surely some of that money would be better spent on our local public school system. That contract, and others this offseason, were signs to me that baseball has more financial resources than it knows what to do with.

While I don’t expect baseball owners to start donating more of their profits to support the nation’s infrastructure, I think baseball can and should make different choices, and invest its top layer of profits back into the game.  Baseball has sold much of its control of the game to the broadcasters that cover it.  I would suggest, perhaps naively, that baseball buy back some of that control, in the form of taking lower network rights fees in exchange for earlier start times for postseason games, shorter commercial breaks and other fan-friendly adjustments.  Doing so, in my mind, would feed the future of baseball more profitably than the current situation, which discourages people of all generations from investing in a game, a playoff, a season that will end past their bedtimes.  (It’s not just kids, mind you – people of all ages have trouble staying up for the
final pitch in October, even on the West Coast, let alone the East.)

There are other things right and wrong with baseball, but I think they’re mostly secondary in importance to baseball’s underlying motivation – instead of chasing dollars as a means to draw more fans, it should take the more profitable and digestible strategy of chasing fans as a means to earn dollars. The sport doesn’t need to jazz up the game between the lines – it just needs to take a deep breath outside the lines. 

In some ways, baseball has a self-esteem problem.  Ever since it stopped being the definitive national pastime, it keeps trying to regain that status.  Baseball needs to be prouder of what it is. That doesn’t mean MLB shouldn’t market the game, but better to do so with a new baseball field in the inner city and a 7 p.m. start time for Game 7 than another ivory backscratcher for the owners and the players.  Because if baseball can stand tall, in the end, there will be ivory backscratchers for everyone.


 ANDREW ZIMBALIST - Author of several books, including In the Best Interests of Baseball? The Revolutionary Reign of Bud Selig and The Bottom Line: Observations and Arguments on the Sports Business , sports consultant and Robert A. Woods Professor of Economics at Smith College specializing in sports economics

Andrew ZimbalistWhat’s good and bad about baseball as we approach the 2007 season?  The good is that when the new CBA expires we will have had 16 consecutive years of labor peace.  I expect MLB’s revenues to grow at a somewhat slower rate: 7-9% annually during 2007-2011 versus roughly 11% annually from 1995-2006.  But this is still very strong growth.  The World Baseball Classic looks promising and MLBAM is off the charts.  Management in the commissioner’s office and team front offices, with a few exceptions, ranges from competent to excellent.

The bad is that MLB is still not doing enough to lure young fans, that the new CBA – while much improved over its predecessor –  has some incentive issues and inflationary tendencies and may sew a new round of owner dissension, the performance enhancing substances problems are likely to linger on, and the inadequacies of the posting system with Japanese baseball.

(Read interviews with Andrew Zimbalist on The Biz of Baseball from 2004 and 2006)


Brian Dupont (OCD SS) - The best reader response post out of our Biz of Baseball forums topic on the state of the game

Purists who refuse to see changes to the game are it's biggest detriment. Everything has to grow and evolve in order to continue to survive and thrive and baseball is no different. Part of baseball's success is that it has been able to do this without loosing it's connection to its rich history and tradition, but there are to many 'purists' or 'old school baseball men' who only believe that this tradition should encased in amber and preserved as it was when they first fell in love with the game.

The obvious fallacy is that if such a stasis were actually the state of affairs we'd all be watching a nice game of Rounders.

Purists take many forms. Analysts deride any new observations about the game, be it OBP or new ways to evaluate defense, because these new observations challenge how they played, and what they have valued for so long. Talk show hosts demand that we put down our tasty clam chowder or sushi and pick up a hot dog (with mustard only). As long as we're not spilling it on them why do they care?

The strength of the game is that it continues to grow, and the changes to it (even those that appear not to work) are well intentioned and can lead to further, beneficial innovation. The DH, once wildly hated, is now included in every lineup on the planet, except those in NL ballparks. The unbalanced schedule begat the wildcard, which makes (at least some) games and races interesting down to the final day of the season. To claim that these changes are only to benefit the money grabbing tendencies of owners misses the point that baseball is a business, and if people are not spending their time and money paying attention to it, it is on it's way to being ignored and irrelevant.

When a thing is irrelevant no one spends their free time hoping that Joe Morgan will finally understand why OBP is important, or trying to figure out why Adam Everett doesn't win a gold glove, or what Manny is really worth. When people care enough to argue about these things in the hope of changing their friend's mind the game is strong enough to keep growing and be around long enough for someone else to find it and love it in 10, 25, or 100 years from now.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?