hdfc credit card indigo offer 2013 paypal merchant credit card fees get pre approved for capital one credit card icici credit card interest rates calculator best corporate credit card for small business worldpay test credit card numbers mastercard credit cards lowest rate credit cards 2012 pay day loans online direct lenders quick cash loans for unemployed hdfc credit card fraud online transaction teachers credit union balance transfer credit cards uk cancel commonwealth bank credit card insurance online application for credit card bpi toyota rewards visa credit card website fast bad credit loans online virtual credit card generator pre-guaranteed credit cards australia victorias secret credit card number location standard chartered credit card payment india online cash advances payday loans canada loans with bad credit same day walmart credit card cash back policy tesco clubcard credit card for balance transfers credit card processing fees law fast cash loans with bad credit what is the security code on your credit card how do i apply for a visa credit card online get credit card with bad credit no deposit what credit cards are owned by mbna falcon credit card fraud detection system best interest free credit card uk itunes visa card security code credit card payments for small business payday loans no credit check no guarantor no fees no brokers best reward credit cards for travel credit card holder wallet ebay new credit card rules 2013 best credit cards to get with bad credit sams discover credit card lost tesco credit card online log on first national cash advance icici credit card bill payment through sbi debit card delta airlines credit card no annual fee td canada trust gold visa card best secured credit cards uk credit cards for bad credit scores personal loan to reduce credit card debt cash back credit cards no annual fee uk major bank secured credit cards first direct credit card uk credit check report credit card insurance cover how to obtain a secured credit card with bad credit how to get pre approved bdo credit card chase credit card 15 months no interest can international students apply for credit card in uk square the iphone credit card machine goes mainstream credit card bank rakyat indonesia halifax credit card address ppi fast loans with bad credit and no job walmart credit card canada phone number hsbc credit cards application online fake credit card numbers with cvv visa credit card bill payment online best cash rewards credit card canada 2013 credit card travel points credit card payoff calculator interest paid banks that offer credit cards for no credit how to get a bad credit loan without a bank account compare credit cards rewards uk quick cash loans to your door where to get prepaid credit cards in canada check visa cash card balance credit card online abn amro nl standard credit card fees for businesses high limit easy to get credit cards aarp chase visa credit cards jetstar mastercard credit card login aqua credit card cash withdrawal limit credit card prepaid online credit cards for really bad credit instant approval best cash reward business credit card monthly credit card interest calculator miles and more credit card swiss air ez payday advance credit card validator java program first time credit cards no credit history standard chartered bank credit card customer care how to pay icici credit card payment online credit card debt settlement companies in india chase canada credit card processing online credit card application instant approval in the philippines icici instant titanium credit card benefits hsbc premier credit card points easy approval credit cards unsecured low interest no annual fee credit cards can you use prepaid credit cards online how to pay sbi credit card bill online from citibank payday lenders uk no credit check apply for joint credit card application credit card application checker best buy rewards visa card credit card fraud bust in ny get online loan bad credit how do you transfer credit card balance to another credit card walmart prepaid credit card usa low interest transfer balance credit cards canada credit card rate reduction letter credit card with no credit city bank credit card status tracking halifax credit card services postal address tesco credit card protection policy if i apply for a walmart credit card can i use it today which credit card has the best rewards system lowest apr credit card available do i need a credit card to rent a car in florida how does chase apply credit card payments unsecured personal loans instant decision online cash advance payday loans columbus ohio bank of america partially secured credit card review pay monthly loans unemployed staples business credit card account tata sbi credit card apply online no credit history check credit cards australia prepaid credit card paypal top up credit card online services rbs post office credit card balance transfer existing customers post office credit card balance transfers how to apply visa credit card in the philippines cash advance rate commonwealth bank how to make standard chartered credit card online payment capital one secured credit card status formula to calculate credit card interest rate home trust secured credit card canada virgin credit cards ppi claims best options for consolidating credit card debt can i buy a visa gift card with a walmart credit card pre qualified credit cards offers courtyard marriott credit card authorization form southwest airline credit card application free prepaid credit cards that build credit cheapest cash advance credit card uk costco credit card processing uk one time credit card numbers uk can a credit card company sue you in another state best credit card deals 0 balance transfer will a secured credit card help my credit score credit card 0 apr cash back best cashback credit card singapore natwest student credit card increase limit credit cards after bankruptcy uk how can i get a credit card with no credit score how do you get a cash advance from a bank of america credit card best buy reward zone credit card usa what is credit card number on visa electron cards credit card reward miles 12 month payday loans compare secured credit card to build credit fast lloyds tsb airmiles duo credit card sort code gap credit card services online apply first credit card student new direct payday loan lenders td debit visa cards low income credit cards in india virtual credit card paypal free hrsaccount best buy credit card login black card visa uk sbi advantage credit card how to cancel standard chartered credit card india pay advance agreement form sears credit card services customer service disney rewards credit card canada credit card processing software free american airline credit card promotions obama credit card debt relief act credit card scanner for computer fast payday loans no credit check credit report uk southwest credit card business 50000 prepaid visa card reloadable online credit card terminal fd100ti wifi secured credit card for bad credit canada what is the best secured credit card to get apply credit cards hdfc credit card reward points catalogue 2013 fast cash online loans why do i need a credit card for free apps on itunes store credit cards easy to get 2011 virgin media account credit limit best cash rewards credit cards 2013 pay a walmart credit card payment visa credit card payment online best 0 intro apr credit cards bad credit loan companies paypal credit card processing reviews apply for a sears mastercard online what credit card should i get yahoo credit card to build credit for bad credit how to get mastercard securecode prepaid visa credit card no fees walmart credit card cash advance policy costco credit card processing fees maurices credit card balance phone number amazon credit card payment mailing address td rebate rewards visa card online application hyatt credit card offer review joint credit card application bad credit good store credit cards for bad credit hdfc bank credit cards helpline declined credit card credit rating best credit card offers for international travel credit card number validation test cases pay orchard credit card by phone how to increase credit card limit chase best credit card for business canada what age can you get a credit card in canada do you need a credit card number for paypal free valid visa credit card information black cardigan zara how to use a credit card machine manually do you still pay credit card fees with square get online loan without bank account citi aadvantage visa credit card login bank of america credit card fraud protection phone number delta community credit union should i get credit card protection first premier credit card cash advance limit can you transfer a personal loan to a credit card instant online loans unemployed rbs credit card services telephone apple support apple id without credit card first credit card limit 0 purchase credit cards explained diy iphone credit card stand real credit card numbers and security codes that work online quick credit card approval online best small business credit card with travel rewards top credit card companies reclaim credit card protection insurance charges amazon credit card apr marriott rewards credit cards reviews visa cards for bad credit canada reward cards for stores list air miles credit card uk fake credit card information that works online how many different types of credit cards are there citibank transfer credit card balance credit cards for no credit students canada post office visa gift card free credit card reader for android phones how do you get a credit card with no credit history best spg credit card deal fha loans with bad credit score tesco credit card 0 balance transfer unsecured bank credit cards for bad credit debit visa card mobile credit card processing for blackberry torch help with credit card debt australia ace cash advance online credit cards for fair credit instant approval uk federal bank credit cards india virgin credit card payment problems check citibank credit card online statement best credit card rates in ireland the best credit card to have now vanilla prepaid visa card canada td canada trust visa lost credit card chase credit card fraud alert best gas credit card rebates the best department store credit cards to get credit card transfer fee calculator credit card services for small business canada can i get a balance transfer credit card with bad credit sears credit cards rewards credit card consolidation services reviews bank of america world mastercard credit card with worldpoints rewards and paypass check status of chase credit card app first premier bank credit card account rewards credit cards 2013 rbc student visa cash back delta air miles credit card canada prepaid reloadable credit cards australia payday loans online no phone calls hdfc credit card rewards catalogue platinum tesco clubcard credit card minimum payment do i need a credit card to build credit open sky secured visa card public savings barclay us credit card login aib visa credit card services chase marriott rewards credit card costco wireless credit card machine how to pick a door lock with a credit card how can i get a credit card with bad credit australia anz low rate credit card fees nedbank american express gold credit card printable visa credit card applications what is the best credit card for airline miles 2011 0 credit card transfer balance where to find credit card number on visa what is a good credit card apr credit card bank account transfer top 5 best credit card companies ge capital credit card amazon student credit cards with no credit instant approval chase joint credit card account secured credit cards with low apr apply online credit card sbi india usa prepaid credit card online mbna credit card 5 cash back credit card bad credit no deposit chase credit card services login shell credit cards gas what is a good apr percentage for a credit card goodyear tire credit card phone number discovery credit card benefits what the best secured credit card to rebuild credit visa credit card information 2013 how to get rid of credit card debt without paying how to buy a house with bad credit black leather credit card holder credit card holder uk bad credit credit cards no deposit instant approval tata capital credit card payment list of credit card company names best credit cards for low credit rating top ten credit cards 2013 online payday loans instant approval no credit check icici credit card charges aqua reward card credit limit i need an unsecured bad credit loan bank of america cash advance fee barclays credit card approval quick payday loans for bad credit cabelas visa credit card phone number legitimate cash advance lenders small cash loans online how do i get approved for a credit card with no credit blank credit card authorization form doc aeroplan credit card cibc canada credit card debt statute limitations best bad credit credit cards canada best credit card to build credit history credit card interest rates 2013 new credit card fees retailers small business loans with bad credit capital one credit card reviews 2012 payday lenders uk 2012 best credit card interest rates south africa best low apr credit cards best credit cards in canada for students natwest black card travel insurance average us credit card interest rates instant cash loans online in sa icici credit card reward points scheme the best credit cards to have 2013 orchard bank credit card application by phone best visa credit card for bad credit online cash advance direct lenders only use us credit card in uk psn mastercard credit cards with rewards credit card scanner apple store hsbc credit card apply for credit card reloadable prepaid credit cards in canada how to pay icici credit card bill online through icici us credit rating high credit limit credit cards for excellent credit natwest student credit card interest free natwest platinum credit card rewards virtual us credit card with us billing address best airline credit card offers 2013 halifax 0 interest credit card sbi credit card emi charges accept credit card payments mobile transfer balance credit cards for average credit credit cards no interest for 12 months what is the best credit card on the market best business credit card for travel rewards where can i use my bestbuy credit card icici credit card status online does paypal accept visa debit gift cards clark howard best rewards credit cards direct payday loan lenders online apply for a credit card online with instant approval standard credit card approval form capital one secured credit card uk reviews martin lewis credit cards deals best new credit card free credit card machine for cell phones wells fargo virtual credit card number icici virtual credit card emi chase marriott rewards credit card benefits credit card number and cvv2 generator business credit cards travel rewards best credit cards to establish good credit get free virtual credit cards visa card security code india best online loan companies usa credit card shopping club when was the first credit card invented credit card to build credit for students us fast cash payday loans mba credit card canada td visa credit card login bad credit card debt australia balance transfer credit cards for average credit rating credit card reward program comparison canada can i pay with 2 credit cards on walmart com best cashback credit card calculator vanilla visa prepaid online shopping card what to know when applying for credit card how do i sign up for an amazon credit card stolen credit card numbers list free credit card terminal iphone delta credit card cash back credit card deals 0 balance transfers valid credit card numbers and security codes and expiration dates pc credit card 76 gas credit card login payday loan direct lender only easiest gas credit card for bad credit best credit card apr 2013 hdfc bank credit cards status check best credit cards for college students with low interest rates low interest rate credit card for students pre approved credit cards capital one premier hsbc credit card rewards how to get a credit card under 18 hsbc transfer money from credit card to current account best student credit card 2013 best credit card processing companies for small business payday loans no credit check credit card charges ge credit card login loan sharks online uk nab flybuys credit card travel insurance 200 cash back credit card chase easy cash loans no credit checks chase visa credit card phone number how to get a platinum card american express lower usaa credit card interest rate cash loans uk bad credit canadian cash back credit cards comparison interest free credit cards for 18 months on purchases credit card banks in india chase credit card with disney rewards compare credit cards balance transfer offers instant online cash advance south africa help i need a loan with bad credit uk halifax credit card deals for existing customers best rate credit cards 2013 easy to get credit cards canada credit card fraud bust nj best credit card transfer deals nz citibank credit card promotion marriott rewards credit cards review top 10 best credit card deals payday loans cash advance for bad credit 02 pay as you go credit card best fast cash payday loans low interest rate credit card comparison what is the best credit card to apply for to build credit change apple id country without credit card is it smart to pay off credit card debt with student loans intuit accept credit cards online fast online payday advance journey capital one credit card reviews consolidate credit card and student loan debt how does apr work on a secured credit card credit card balance transfer no fee bank of america virtual credit card debit credit card calculator apr interest rewards cards for department stores capital one visa platinum credit cards quick cash loans bad credit can you still file bankruptcy on credit cards best way to accept credit cards online for small business instant online payday loans how to get rid of credit card debt without hurting your credit score paypal pro test credit card numbers credit card limit increase without permission credit cards apply online instant approval in india natwest black credit card application long term cash advance loans best credit card offers for students 2012 secure credit card bank of america barclay credit card application india how to apply citibank credit card philippines compare bad credit loans instant decision balance transfer offers halifax existing customers ebay buyer requirements credit card on file complaints against capital one credit card company united chase visa card login are air mile credit cards worth it what is the best credit card to have yahoo answers pay sears credit card hsbc axis bank credit card online application online loan application instant decision ambank credit card cashback 20
Home Rob Smith Bochy's Bias Exposes Systemic Flaw in MLB All-Star Selection Process

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 737 guests online

Atom RSS

Bochy's Bias Exposes Systemic Flaw in MLB All-Star Selection Process PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 27
PoorBest 
Rob Smith Article Archive
Written by Rob Smith   
Tuesday, 12 July 2011 16:12

Bochy

In little league, the coach's kid always bats cleanup and pitches, even if he's not good at either. In pop warner, he inevitably winds up playing quarterback. As unfair as everyone knows it is, nepotism has always been present in youth sports, a time-honored rite of passage that every youngster must confront at one time or another. As the level of competition progresses (middle school, travel ball, high school, college), favoritism is eradicated and replaced by a more ideal meritocracy. Recently, though, the practice of giving preferential treatment to those close to you has reared its' ugly head in an unusual place: the selection process for the MLB All-Star game.

While fans voting in starters leads to popular, past-their-prime players such as Derek Jeter being recognized as all-stars, MLB is wise to allow the consumers of its' product to have a say in what they're watching. The problem in the process arises when the managers of each league's defending champions are allowed to fill in a large number of the remaining roster spots seemingly arbitrarily. The San Francisco Giants are sending their largest all-star contingent since 1966, due largely to the fact that their manager, Bruce Bochy, spent 3 of his 14 selections passing over more worthy candidates in favor of Giants players who have had solid, yet unspectacular seasons.

Giants' third baseman Pablo Sandoval missed the entire month of May, and has played in slightly more than half of his team's games this year. Sure, he's hitting .302 with an .844 OPS, but those numbers mean less when he's not putting them up on a regular basis. Neil Walker, meanwhile, has played 2nd base for the Pittsburgh Pirates in all but two of their games this year. His 59 RBI are more than double the amount (29) totaled by Sandoval thus far, and his 47 runs scored are nearly twice as much as Sandoval's 26. Bochy claims that Sandoval "has the numbers. I know he's missed a lot of time, but he's got a 21-game hitting streak, and with our third-base situation...it makes all the sense."

Well, I suppose it WOULD make sense if Walker didn't have experience playing third base in the big leagues (which he does). Even though Sandoval is a full-time third baseman, whereas Walker has been used exclusively at second base this year, it's not as if Sandoval's glove evokes images of Brooks Robinson in the minds of baseball fans. If "he's not really a third baseman" is Bochy's excuse for snubbing Walker, I'd be interested to hear his reason for passing over Diamondbacks third baseman Ryan Roberts. Roberts plays multiple positions, but he's manned the hot corner in 59 of the 80 games he's played in. Over that time, the undersized utility player has put up an impressive .779 OPS, stolen 13 bases, scored 47 runs, and hit 11 homeruns. Roberts washed out in Toronto and Texas before finding a home in the Diamondbacks organization, which coincidentally is hosting tonight's All-Star Game. How great of a story would it have been to see a scrappy, hard-nosed player overcome his past failures to earn an All-Star berth playing in front of his own team's fans? We'll never know because Bochy ably took on the role of overbearing father and gave "his" guy, who has missed almost half the season, the nod over Roberts and Walker, two players responsible in a big way for their respective teams being in contention for a playoff spot at the All-Star break.

In Sandoval's defense, his selection is probably the least-egregious example of Bochy showing bias towards his own players. Giants co-aces Tim Lincecum and Matt Cain both received manager's selections over Atlanta Braves hurler Tommy Hanson, and the numbers unequivocally indicate that they shouldn't have. Lincecum and Cain have nearly identical numbers, both sporting a 3.06 ERA and Cain having a slight edge in WHIP (1.10 to Lincecum's 1.20). Meanwhile, Hanson sports a 2.44 ERA which is lower than that of Roy Halladay, who will be the starting pitcher for the NL in tonight's game, and good for 3rd lowest in the National League. His 1.02 WHIP is tied with Halladay for 2nd lowest in the NL, and his .190 batting average against is tops in the NL and 3rd lowest in MLB. Hanson has more wins (10) than both Cain (8) and Lincecum (7).

Bochy didn't hide the fact that he selected his guys because, well, they're his guys, even though their performance this season is inferior to Hanson's. When pressed about snubbing Hanson, Bochy said, “I obviously wanted to get some of my guys [Giants pitchers] there. But I do feel bad, because he certainly deserves to be here."

Bochy's faux sympathy for Hanson is not going to be worth anything when Hanson goes to arbitration or attempts to negotiate an extension with Atlanta. It's not like he can tell the arbiter, "Well, you see, everybody knows I deserved to be an all-star, it's just that the guy picking the team wanted his own players instead." The connotation that comes from having the words "all-star" in front of your name can be quite lucrative come contract time, especially for an up-and-coming ace like Hanson. Bochy has essentially reached into Hanson's wallet for the sole purpose of keeping his own players happy, and that fact should not go unnoticed.

Bochy should undoubtedly be admonished for snubbing Hanson, but the decision should have never belonged to him in the first place. In the modern environment of professional sports, where the designation of "all-star" can be worth hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of dollars, players fighting for spots on the team should not have to worry about favoritism entering the equation. At the very least, MLB could implement a committee, made up of GMs or scouts from every team, who would be responsible for selecting all of the players not voted in by fans. There wouldn't be a ton of work involved. It's the job of team executives and scouts to know who the best players are, and I doubt that it would take them too long to determine that Hanson has unquestionably had a better season than both Cain and Lincecum. A contingency of GMs from teams without a dog in the fight would be far less likely to make the type of biased selections that Bochy was allowed to institute. Instead, the coach's kids get to pitch and play quarterback, while Hanson, Walker, and Roberts are left behind to watch the game in anonymity. Consider it the last vestige of favoritism in an industry that normally shuns such behavior.


Rob Smith is a contributing writer for the Business of Sports Network. He can be reached on Twitter @RobSmithUSF or on his personal blog, http://smithersports.blogspot.com/

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?