kamagra king uk kamagra gel srbija kamagra 100 efectos kamagra womens kamagra boltok kamagra lagligt kamagra essen buy kamagra 25mg kamagra vafameg kamagra kopen legaal kamagra ervaringen deutsche kamagra cumpar kamagra bucuresti buy kamagra budapest kamagra halbe kamagra sales melbourne kamagra sol kamagra 200 ceny kamagra eczanede var kamagra 100 nebenwirkung super kamagra original kamagra waar bestellen soft chewable kamagra kamagra jel yorumlar fake kamagra bangkok kamagra plus weekender mixing kamagra alcohol kamagra 50gr kamagra kgr 100 wikipedia kamagra forum hrvat super kamagra rezeptfrei kamagra ile przed anyone bought kamagra carrying kamagra abroad kamagra paypal nl chem. kamagra cesky viagra vs kamagra 2013 kamagra och cannabis kamagra fizz kamagra 100 mg etkisi test kamagra jelly kamagra legale kamagra fonctionne pas kamagra ajanta pordorimi i kamagra kamagra pills ireland qiuck kamagra uk kamagra compresse kamagra ceneo kamagra 100mg berichte kamagra dawki google payment kamagra kamagra shops manchester free kamagra sample ebay kamagra polo kamagra rode ogen kamagra ohlasy official kamagra website pharmacy 365 kamagra sleep store kamagra kamagra najszybciej kamagra gold 100 key kamagra acheter kamagra 100 teilen gen kamagra 150 mg kamagra em portugal kamagra prices mumbai kamagra bremen kamagra gel erekcija kamagra aus uk kamagra doping jeli kamagra stetna levitra kamagra uk kamagra manila kamagra plus tadalafil kamagra jelly flavours kamagra navod kamagra in manchester forum on kamagra liquid viagra kamagra kamagra rzeszow kamagra thailand illegal kamagra overdose kamagra police kamagra on paypal kamagra temoignage kamagra zulassung symptoms kamagra sildenafil kamagra liquid kamagra ebay.de apteka internetowa kamagra kamagra jelly test kamagra cipla uk kamagra soho uk kamagra 4 me the kamagra kamagra chat kamagra online paypal 20 exact pharma kamagra kamagra fizz chennai kamagra bestellen schweiz speed and kamagra acheter kamagra paris kamagra gel stockists gdje ima kamagra kamagra dead kamagra singapur kamagra 600 kamagra seeshell flomax kamagra together kamagra silverd srbija kamagra bhp posologie du kamagra kamagra mit paypal kamagra tablete iskustva info om kamagra girls kamagra kamagra strip craigslist kamagra hapi tadacip vs kamagra originele kamagra pillen kamagra jelly price kamagra tania opinie acheter kamagra kamagra cheap supplier forum kamagra 2011 kamagra dosage 300 mg kamagra australia review kamagra betablocker kamagra kautabletten forum price comparison kamagra kamagra nebenwirkungen herz kamagra malaysia dealer kamagra berlin kaufen e20 kamagra kamagra z hologramem kamagra ile kosztuje brighton kamagra kamagra or women kamagra df kamagra testrapport uitwerking kamagra ta med kamagra kamagra wien kaufen ajanta kamagra uk kamagra bez receptu wholesale super kamagra kamagra jelly malaysia kamagra abgelaufen just kt kamagra kamagra jelly 100 cola kamagra us legal freedom kamagra kamagra fast . com shops selling kamagra kamagra bestellen wo viagra kamagra cheap kamagra com paypal kamagra am billigsten amar pharmaceuticals kamagra super kamagra dosis funda ticaret kamagra kamagra into bali max dose kamagra kamagra saturday delivery msh for kamagra kamagra jell greece cialis kamagra kombinieren kamagra oral vendre du kamagra generic kamagra palace kamagra 247.co.uk kamagra ideal cialis vs kamagra kamagra slaskie kamagra with paypal kamagra for men kamagra jelly shots kamagra chewable 100 kaufen kamagra gold tablet vand kamagra 100 kamagra 100 gold australia kamagra dostawa kamagra kaufen phuket kamagra 247 uk kamagra allegro kamagra gel slike kamagra jel avis wszystko o kamagra potenzmittel kamagra erfahrung kamagra sales online overnight kamagra tania kamagra 100mg kamagra proefpakket buy gel kamagra article kamagra kamagra dijabetes elke dag kamagra kamagra kopen eindhoven kamagra wanneer innemen hoofdpijn van kamagra kamagra index kamagra europe bestellen kamagra single kamagra stetna dejstva kamagra 100 pills kamagra through customs site kamagra doctissimo kamagra kako koristiti kamagra overnight kamagra met drank kamagra tablete cena kamagra wechselwirkungen kamagra primjena kamagra st kamagra 7 flavor kamagra in store kamagra aus berlin kamagra dlugosc dzialania kamagra uk fast kamagra ile dziala kamagra uk stockists alcohol and kamagra super kamagra eu paypal kamagra jelly kamagra biz kamagra gel info cheap kamagra australia kamagra fast review kamagra gel uk super kamagra tablets kamagra dosaggio kamagra super kaufen kamagra huisarts kamagra 100mg informatie kamagra pzn kamagra thailand gel viagra kamagra unterschied kamagra porto kamagra 150 mg uk kamagra affect women vijagra kamagra san francisco kamagra using kamagra forum kamagra woman effects thailand pharmacy kamagra kamagra viagra generika viagra kamagra kamagra testosteron kamagra jeden tag kamagra users kamagra 100 dauer kamagra bomboni kamagra consultation uk kamagra with lisinopril cheapest kamagra csv kamagra gegenmittel kamagra gel woman kamagra skin super kamagra jelly kamagra 100mg ajanta kamagra viagra preis kamagra vartojimas side effects kamagra kamagra sprawdzony sklep buying kamagra pilule kamagra sedefil kamagra till sverige kamagra gel beograd kamagra mort buy blue kamagra kamagra no effect kamagra oral venezuela kamagra now closed kamagra legal kamagra nederlands kamagra apotheke holland kamagra bielsko kamagra uk 247 kamagra in copenhagen kamagra jelly erfahrungsbericht kamagra jelly pris kamagra gel org kamagra banane kamagra and go kamagra gel predaj kamagra sildenafil 100mg vanzare kamagra kamagra sites uk kamagra on uk kamagra reviews super kamagra packungsbeilage kamagra import australia kamagra in spanje kamagra in houston kamagra bestellen rembours kamagra sage pay kamagra predaj nitra wanneer kamagra innemen kamagra 100mg montreal bericht super kamagra kamagra i spanien kamagra angeles city kamagra gel better kamagra usa sales buy kamagra nz avis sur kamagra comprar super kamagra kamagra gel koristenje kamagra vragen ajanta kamagra 100 chewable kamagra amlodopine ramapril commander kamagra 100mg fakta om kamagra kamagra girls kamagra 100 djelovanja kamagra jelly tablet india super kamagra kamagra red opinions kamagra 100 kamagra 100 mg tablets kamagra directions use kamagra distributors kamagra gold diskusia kamagra sildenafil jelly kamagra jelly single ebay kamagra forsale jelly kamagra thailand kamagra gel uso kamagra women uk kamagra sicher einkaufen kamagra doesnt work kamagra for females kamagra 100 7 tabs uk kamagra in dubai kamagra pro poland kamagra results intimax or kamagra anwendung von kamagra kamagra.nl recensie kamagra ucuz kamagra avec paypal kamagra tabletki opinie kamagra preisvergleich verschil kamagra viagra kauwbare kamagra kamagra verschreiben lassen kamagra pill splitter kamagra advarsel kamagra 4er kamagra gel zagreb kamagrafast kamagra plus kamagra pharma limited kamagra stockists uk cheapest kamagra 100mg kamagra tablete hrvatska ebay kamagra jelly kamagra sites gone kamagra oral sly replika kamagra kamagra onde comprar kamagra 100mg belfast kamagra for sell kamagra prodaja beograd kamagra recension kamagra tablet nedir kamagra ingredienten super kamagra predaj czy kamagra uzaleznia kamagra taken guaranteed cheapest kamagra ceneo kamagra kamagra alcohol heartburn cheap kamagra pills american kamagra low cost kamagra kamagra in hannover levitra vs. kamagra kamagra viagra callis buy levitra kamagra kamagra verkopen kamagra diazepam kamagra wholesale usa super kamagra tabletten kamagra tea kamagra gel paypal cialis und kamagra ervaring kamagra bestellen kamagra 100mgoral jelly uk kamagra cialis low price kamagra wirkung super kamagra kamagra tablets dosage liquid kamagra discount kamagra uk paypal uk kamagra kamagra beograd kamagra zeit cialis v kamagra vendita kamagra italia kamagra a hong kamagra in aberdeen was macht kamagra kamagra over nettet kamagra jellys uk kamagra wirkungseintritt kamagra en zwangerschap kamagra for girl kamagra uk spain free kamagra jelly forocoches kamagra kamagra 100 sale bg kamagra cheap kamagra china kamagra bringt nichts kamagra polo tablets kamagra cadiz kamagra bestellen betrouwbaar super kamagra online kamagra for fun affiliate program kamagra kamagra thailand passagen acquisto kamagra italia kamagra ede chiang mai kamagra kamagra wanted kamagra paypal ch is kamagra safe kamagra to buy kamagra weekender uk kamagra jaune kamagra 4 er paypal kamagra ksr 100 kamagra okazii kamagra kroatien kamagra liege kamagra now sibutramine apcalis oral kamagra kamagra xxl kamagra jelly billig kamagra descripcion kamagra pharmacyy kamagra low price kamagra indonesia find kamagra nigeria kamagra jel english kamagra sklad chemiczny kamagra xlpharmacy forum kamagra kamagra gold bula kamagra shop tallinn kamagra 4 cialis kamagra 100 mg sobres kamagra for women kamagra jelly vrouw kamagra preise kamagra valor panvel kamagra cipla reviews kamagra significado lloyds pharmacy kamagra kamagra packung kamagra apoteke sarajevo kamagra medicament kamagra 50 gel oral spot fake kamagra buy kamagra australia female kamagra 100mg cheap fast kamagra kamagra jelly nebenwirkungen kamagra ebay kamagra. fast kamagra venlo kamagra guardian malaysia cialis czy kamagra ajanta kamagra kamagra neben kamagra 50 gold cheap kamagra forum dangers du kamagra kamagra kopen nijmegen kamagra kosten kamagra stockists glasgow kamagra creams dr kamagra kamagra birmingham uk kamagra afhalen rotterdam kamagra kaufen berlin kamagra leeds uk kamagra czech republic kamagra turquoise kamagra generic uk buy kamagra spain kamagra a levitra kamagra schweiz zoll cena kamagra kamagra heart attack kamagra es kamagra pirkti kamagra london 247 upustvo kamagra gel
Home All Articles The Matsuzaka Dilemma

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1003 guests online

Atom RSS

The Matsuzaka Dilemma PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by John Thorn   
Tuesday, 12 December 2006 08:15

Article

John Thorn is a contributing writer for The Biz of Baseball 

From "Play's the Thing," Woodstock Times: 

This whole swirl may be over by the time you read this, but the meaning is the same, no matter how it comes out, and so is the moral. I’m talking about the sequence in which the Boston Red Sox were revealed to have outbid other baseball clubs for the thirty-day negotiating rights to “posted” Seibu Lion pitcher Daisuke Matsuzaka, who wishes to pitch in the United States but is not, under Nippon Professional Baseball (NPB) regulations, eligible for free agency until 2008. This Thursday night at midnight, when December 14 becomes December 15, is the witching hour.

As I write, Boston Red Sox executives have just landed the owner’s plane on the West Coast to plant themselves on agent Scott Boras’s doorstep. His Japanese client is mum on the seeming breakdown in negotiations, but as he has not fired his representative one may deduce that he is in on the game. It is a game designed by Major League Baseball (MLB) and the NPB, but as they seem only dimly to have understood their own rules, D-Mat and his designated hitter have made their own—or rather, as we shall see, correctly fathomed the implicit rule structure of the posting system. Bottom line: no matter how this shakes out, while D-Mat is not exactly the reincarnation of Curt Flood, Scott Boras has taken the mantle of Marvin Miller, and is my new hero. 

Yesterday I had lunch at the local Chinese restaurant where, despite my better judgment, I ate my customary sacramental portion of the stale fortune cookie and read its message. “It is better to have a hen tomorrow than an egg today” was the word from on high. Wait, I thought; this reverses the more commonly expressed wisdom that not only is an egg today better than a hen tomorrow, but also its avian corrolary about birds in hand and those in the bush. I wondered: might Boras have received the same, seemingly counterintuitive message?

Let’s back up for a moment and see how we got here. In the system by which a player is to be posted, both the team and player must agree on the posting. The team then notifies the NPB Commissioner’s Office that the player will be posted, which then notifies MLB, which notifies all of its teams. The MLB teams then have four days to submit a closed bid for the right to negotiate a contract with the player. If the high bid is accepted by the NPB team holding the player’s rights, the winning MLB team has thirty days to reach an agreement with the player. If the bid is rejected, the player is not “posted.” If the player signs a contract with the MLB team by the end of the signing period, then the NPB team receives the bid money. If the player does not sign a contract with the MLB team by the end of the signing period, the player is returned to the NPB team and the NPB team receives nothing.

Whoever designed this may have had in mind that classic scenario of game theory called the “Prisoner’s Dilemma.” It is a mathematical and psychological game illustrating how rational actions by individuals may not always lead to positive outcomes for either the individuals or the group. The Prisoner’s Dilemma is described neatly in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:

“Tanya and Cinque have been arrested for robbing the Hibernia Savings Bank and placed in separate isolation cells. Both care much more about their personal freedom than about the welfare of their accomplice. A clever prosecutor makes the following offer to each. ‘You may choose to confess or remain silent. If you confess and your accomplice remains silent I will drop all charges against you and use your testimony to ensure that your accomplice does serious time. Likewise, if your accomplice confesses while you remain silent, they will go free while you do the time. If you both confess I get two convictions, but I’ll see to it that you both get early parole. If you both remain silent, I’ll have to settle for token sentences on firearms possession charges. If you wish to confess, you must leave a note with the jailer before my return tomorrow morning.’

“The ‘dilemma’ faced by the prisoners here is that, whatever the other does, each is better off confessing than remaining silent. But the outcome obtained when both confess is worse for each than the outcome they would have obtained had both remained silent. A common view is that the puzzle illustrates a conflict between individual and group rationality. A group whose members pursue rational self-interest may all end up worse off than a group whose members act contrary to rational self-interest. More generally, if the payoffs are not assumed to represent self-interest, a group whose members rationally pursue any goals may all meet less success than if they had not rationally pursued their goals individually. Puzzles with this structure were devised and discussed by Merrill Flood and Melvin Dresher in 1950, as part of the Rand Corporation’s investigations into game theory (which Rand pursued because of possible applications to global nuclear strategy).” 

So, the underlying scheme of Prisoner’s Dilemma is to have the two prisoners collaborate wittingly or unwittingly against their own interest, with the outcome weighted to benefit the sate as represented by the police and prosecutor. The dilemma resides in the fact that each prisoner has a choice between only two options, but cannot make a good decision without knowing what the other one will do.

I suggest that the posting system was created along these lines to benefit the “state”—each league and each team involved. Think of MLB and Boston as the police and prosecutor in the above scenario, knowing that the salutary actions of Prisoner A (NPB and Seibu) and Prisoner B (Matsuzaka and Boras) are necessary to prevent the mutually assured destruction (M.A.D.) of MLB. That was the prospect some owners envisioned in 1973-74, at the dawn of free agency: that in an auction scenario, dollars would pursue scarce/unique assets in an irrationally exuberant way that would effectively transfer control of the game into the players’ hands. Marvin Miller cleverly assuaged the owners’ fears while assuring high prices for his players’ union by restricting free agency to those with six years’ service in the major leagues; had he opted for universal free agency, as he might have, the flood of talent onto the market each year would have depressed salaries. 

The design problem in the Prisoner’s Dilemma game above is that Prisoner Seibu has its deal in hand and is (ostensibly) denied the option of contributing some of its $51.1 million posting fee from Boston toward Prisoner Matsuzaka’s new contract. Indeed, without flexibility the fortunes of Seibu/NPB are more closely tied to the Police/Prosecutor than to Matsuzaka despite the pitcher’s total control over Seibu’s posting windfall. Boston, which stands ready to pay the sum and call it a bargain, instead feels aggrieved because its $51.1 million in expense is counted as nothing by Boras, who is looking to obtain $100 million for a six-year contract, pretty much in line with what his client would fetch in an unrestricted market. Boston had intended to pay out $100 million, all right, but had figured that Boras would give the club credit for half of that for “liberating” his client. No such luck, nor should there have been.

The posting system entices Boston (and other bidding clubs) with the lure of paying for a free agent in a tangential way that would not increase its exposure to luxury tax. The Red Sox are further compensated by considering the payment to Seibu as an inexpensive licensing or entry fee to market their brand vigorously in Japan. Additionally, the exclusivity that came with their winning bid permitted them not only to pursue Matsuzaka, but also to defend against the Yankees landing him. 

With its $51.1 million sugarplum, Seibu thought it was being rewarded for having nurtured Matsuzaka’s talent to the point that he was one of the top five pitchers in the world, and for graciously letting him go to America two years before NPB regulations would otherwise allow. In fact Seibu was also being pulled out of a very considerable financial hole, as the posting fee hits up on their bottom line as pure net income ... plus they gain at least $12 million in the amount they would otherwise have had to pay Matsuzaka for 2007 and 2008, the last years of his contract with the Lions.

MLB/Boston is in effect attempting to coerce a “confession” from Prisoner Matsuzaka because he risks embarrassment by returning to pitch for Seibu after 36,000 fans bade him farewell at the Lions’ Stadium, and because Seibu doesn’t want him back at the forfeiture of $63 million it is already counting on. 

What did MLB and the 29 teams not in the running for D-Mat’s services gain by the posting system? A presumptive lid on D-Mat’s demands and their escalating effect on pitcher salaries, already heightened by the ineffectual Adam Eaton and the awful Justin Marquis, each of whom received multiyear contracts at about $8 million per. With Matsuzaka wearing carmine hose, MLB will gain a new hero to promote its brand in Japan as well as the USA, just as Ichiro proved a marketing windfall. In fact this posting system is a nostalgic throwback, recreating for owners a glimpse of the paradise they enjoyed prior to free agency, when they owned the market and could say “take it or leave it” to the players. While the posting system may have been born of a genuine wish to protect Japanese baseball and avoid the appearance of American cultural imperialism, it has played out as an exercise in “Who will rule.”

As Boras has evidently surmised, even though MLB and NPB thought they had boxed in Prisoner Matsuzaka, it turned out that he and his client were not locked in behind iron bars but instead, like Br’er Rabbit, had been thrown into a briar patch from which they could easily escape. Boras has recognized that while the game is structured like Prisoner’s Dilemma, counting upon Seibu and his client to act independently in their perceived self-interest to the benefit of Organized Baseball, there is in fact only one prisoner, and without his yielding, there is no palatable outcome. 

If MLB and NPB had a game theory for how this would play itself out, it was the wrong one ... styled as Prisoner’s Dilemma but quickly revealing itself to be the “Dollar Auction,” another, even more vicious game, in which each of two contestants seeks to overpay for an asset in order to avoid being the second-place bidder whose money will have been utterly wasted.

In the Dollar Auction someone offers to sell a dollar bill to the highest bidder. The highest bidder will get the dollar, but the second-highest must also pay what he bid yet get nothing in return. Think here of “throwing good money after bad,” of “saving face,” of “having too much invested to cut and run,” of “staying the course.” If you can buy a dollar for a dime, this looks like a good deal. Even as the bidding rises in ten-cent increments to the 50-cent level, it still seems a bargain. At the 70-cent level, one may expect that all but two bidders will have fallen off the chase. When the dollar-mark is reached, the underbidder, rather than accepting defeat, will tend to bid ten cents more so as not to lose 90 cents. 

“People escalate their commitment both to justify their earlier bids and to prevent the financial and ego loss of coming in second,” Max H. Bazerman wrote in Psychology Today twenty years ago. “No specific bid is clearly wrong, since it is rational to bid ‘just another 10 cents,’ if the other party is about to quit bidding. But when both parties think this way, an escalatory spiral emerges that is very reminiscent of the Vietnam War and other international and industrial failures in which both competitors get trapped by their previous commitments.”

At first blush the winner in the Matsuzaka Dilemma appeared to be Boston; if the Mets were second, at $13 million less, they felt no ill consequence of their bid. Had the posting system had been a true Dollar Auction, with succesive rounds of bidding,  rather than a veiled Prisoner’s Dilemma with closed bids, the price for D-Mat might have gone much higher, as the underbidder would have been highly motivated to stay in the game. But now Boston’s inadvertent partner has been revealed not to be MLB but Seibu, which unlike Boston—which will retain the defensive benefit of its bid—will lose everything, as if it had been the underbidder in a Dollar Auction. And Br’er Boras and D-Mat, if they do not prevail this year, can play again only with more bargaining clout. 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?