credit card reform act 2014 wiki does the itunes store need credit card credit card swipe for home computer how to apply credit card from sbi peoples credit card info credit cards that are easy to obtain pay sams credit card walmart avoid credit card cloning low limit credit card for bad credit apply first saving credit card mileage plus credit card offers pay sear credit card online closing credit card accounts credit score bowflex credit card interest rate using credit card paypal without account credit cards credit score 550 paypal vs credit card protection lowest interest credit cards in usa chase credit card with disney rewards hsbc portable credit card machine what is a judgement from a credit card company standard chartered credit card reviews india credit card balance transfer apr calculator considered high apr credit card starter credit cards students no credit marathon credit card payment center best intro apr credit card first national credit card legacy visa ripoff best credit card debt solution how do i update my credit card info on itunes credit card chargeback time limit hypercom credit card machine not printing does paypal verify credit card address top up credit card from post office virtual terminal credit card delete credit card details groupon continental chase credit card perks credit card foreign transaction fee bank america new millenium credit card online credit card instant approval canada citibank credit card american airlines when is it best to pay credit card bill best credit card india 2010 is the chase amazon credit card good southwest credit card cancellation fee credit card negotiation letter sample credit card holders leather women cant add prepaid credit card paypal natwest credit card international number buy car credit card canada where can i buy prepaid credit cards in ottawa bad credit store cards bank of america chip credit card amazon credit card account sign in approval credit card calculator payment interest use paypal newegg without credit card york university credit card payments first national credit card legacy visa phone number citibank credit card foreign exchange rate first four digits mastercard credit card credit card banks make money credit card numbers that work with security codes free prepaid credit card with no monthly fees us dollar credit cards in canada lic premium online payment through citibank credit card rbs credit card services co uk cell phone credit card reader canada swipe credit card iphone 4 citibank choice credit card application form top credit card processors 2012 credit card balance transfer offers life loan paying 2 credit cards amazon bank america credit card payment login bank of america credit card account online credit card flash drive - 8gb average credit card debt per person 2011 southwest airlines visa business credit card get credit card credit score 500 if your credit card declined does affect your credit score negotiate credit card debt sample letter department store credit cards low credit scores credit card mileage bonuses hotel credit card offers prepaid credit cards no credit check canada credit cards banks india british airlines visa credit card what credit card has the best rewards apply first credit card canada hsbc teamsters credit card natwest credit card contact number services partners federal credit union credit card payment how to get a credit card company to lower my interest rate cenex credit card payment citifinancial credit cards for bad credit american airlines miles credit card mypoints visa credit card intuit credit card processing canada low rate student credit card fidelity credit card processing secured credit cards from bank of america hdfc bank platinum plus credit card reward points catalogue platinum plus credit card review first national credit card application pay tax with credit card website i need a loan to pay off my credit cards military star card exchange credit central at&t credit cards university credit card fees bank of new york credit card best credit card sign up bonus miles offers bluegreen rci credit card credit card payment systems llc minimum credit score for credit card canada cash credit card out make small credit card holder post office preloaded credit card no credit cards for people under 21 tesco clubcard credit card best way to consolidate credit card debts 1st bank to introduce credit card in india capital one joint credit card credit card machine cell phone adapter visa credit card helpline number hsbc premier credit card uk capital one journey credit card application lucky credit card american express credit card application southwest airlines free flight credit card reclaim credit card payment protection insurance 1st financial bank usa credit card o balance transfer credit cards poor credit secured credit cards to start credit does secured credit card build credit history prepaid travel credit card virgin credit card miles how to send money from credit card to debit card can you rent a car with a prepaid credit card in toronto american express prepaid credit cards reviews westpac credit card travel insurance policy how to change credit card paypal my credit card account number bank america credit cards frequent flyer miles no annual fee rei visa credit card login household credit card apply marshalls credit card status use paypal accept credit cards online what is the best airline credit card rewards number of credit cards issued in australia freeze credit card in ice hhonors credit card american express how to get a european credit card in the us hdfc credit card investment plans best rewards credit card 2010 us credit cards for business dubai first credit card statement can you pay chase credit card bank chase credit card cash advance without pin pay with 2 credit cards best buy clear credit card free fake credit card numbers and cvv2 credit card companies offer joint accounts iphone credit card reader application apply for unsecured credit cards with bad credit best mastercard credit cards canada credit card check java code online shopping credit card number ge money bank credit cards phone number citi aadvantage credit card logon quick and easy credit card approval hdfc credit card gold coin credit card scams in chicago case-mate id credit card slim case for iphone 4 / 4s how long to pay off credit card chart credit card balance transfers uk shell credit card secure login sunoco credit card application can a credit card company garnish my wages in georgia can international students get credit card in uk law credit card collection philippines wamu credit cards log online access my credit card cc metro style flash drive cheap credit card conveniently how can i get preapproved for a credit card what is an annual fee on a credit card mean partners first business credit card my credit card interest tax deductible secured canadian credit cards credit card with air miles comparison gemoney bank credit card login mobile credit card swipe machine standard chartered credit card malaysia redemption bin credit card number funny quotes credit card debt cancel victoria;s secret credit card online canceling a credit card affect score credit card debt repayment stories best no transfer fee credit cards create itune account without credit card 2012 cimb credit card online password real credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date online credit card payment for citibank india rebuilding your credit secured credit card accept credit card payments my website remove credit card amazon uk how to find cvv on credit card credit cards with best rewards programs 2011 credit cards use hsbc best skymiles credit card offers credit card number generator with cvv and expiration date 2011 better settle debt credit card company collection agency jcpenney credit card number credit card with no interest for 18 months natwest world credit card review payment using credit card paypal where do i go to pay my shell credit card online credit card offers for minors first progress platinum secured mastercard credit card best secured bank credit cards top 5 credit card rewards programs does secured credit card build credit canada procedure applying credit card sbi citi credit card sears what to know about credit cards disney credit card with points use my bridgestone credit card first savings credit card citibank credit card payment centers philippines baby r us credit card hdfc mastercard credit card offers what is my citibank credit card account number google play update credit card square credit card reader fees younkers credit card customer service number check credit card application status navy federal capital one secured credit card online banking how to pay via paypal with credit card credit card act advertising rules unsecured major credit cards for bad credit bank of america visa credit card online payment cimb credit card centre fax number credit card machine printer tape chase mastercard credit card login credit and debit card processing fees best credit card rewards scheme slate chase credit card log sunoco credit card accountonline bbva compass credit card bill pay where is the credit card number on a visa debit card visa credit cards college students blue dog credit card processing guaranty bank credit card processing credit card number list with cvv visa credit card apr cash advances hsbc credit card phone banking number pc richards credit card phone number 0 interest credit card tesco online access my credit card ashley stewart best credit card purchase rates apply canadian tire credit card online citizens bank small business credit card fake credit card number and security code make payment my orchard credit card nba platinum credit card amex platinum cashback credit card review sbi card credit cards faces pages credit card otp login fast way to reduce credit card debt citi credit card payment mailing address credit card transfer balance 0 apr change credit card pin hsbc ipad credit card reader app sams credit card at walmart credit card cvc2 number miles and more credit card travel insurance indusind bank american express costco credit card canada compare credit cards offers in india accepting credit card payments at craft fairs usaa college start credit card application discover credit card signup bonus small business credit cards cash back test visa credit card number cvv2 can use debit card credit online virgin credit card application time onepass plus credit card review how to pay off a 10000 credit card debt best 0 balance transfer credit cards 12 months uk passport renewal credit card form square credit card reader app pay my gape credit card bill online pay my lloyds tsb credit card online arco gas no credit card bitcoin credit card uk are credit-card balances considered money why or why not wells fargo credit card picture why was my credit card denied in paypal hdfc credit card terms and conditions can i upgrade my capital one credit card fast response credit card applications o balance transfer credit cards canada apply online for wells fargo credit card credit card debt lawyer california best credit card rewards program 2011 citi visa credit card customer service citi credit card application status phone number need card now have bad credit score high limit credit cards for excellent credit php credit card format pc richards credit card ge jp morgan select credit card review aspca credit card hdfc bank credit card credit card best rewards program 2011 ann taylor credit card site credit card surcharges legal uk credit card starting with 36 valid credit card visa number wallets prevent credit card scanning how to get 1 month free trial netflix without credit card hsbc premier credit card rewards program need credit card bad credit home depot credit card contact number fake credit card websites will magnetic money clip ruin credit card 1st financial bank credit card log in can your wages be garnished for credit card debt in georgia check credit card balance online hdfc marriott reward business credit card manhattan credit card singapore standard chartered do you need a credit card to rent a car 2011 best credit card for travel points mophie marketplace credit card reader for intuit gopayment review royal bank scotland credit card application form catos credit card how can i pay my rent with a credit card create hdfc credit card online account travel reward credit cards canada comparison what credit cards help build credit axis bank credit card statement get dates citi bank american airlines credit card providian bank credit card bad credit best way use your credit card build credit gulf oil credit card visa credit cards poor credit allied bank mastercard credit card application credit card processing company comparisons my credit card access case mate id & credit card holder for iphone 3g 3gs wells fargo value city furniture credit card credit card debt consolidation loans unsecured intuit automatic credit card billing authorization form credit card amazon bank america barclays credit card india online payment visa credit card covers car insurance cash advance from credit card without pin phone insurance through credit card ana credit card visa best balance transfer credit cards for average credit credit card cash bonuses legalsounds not accepting credit cards takes goodyear credit cards zero percent balance transfer credit cards 2011 virgin black card credit card review capitol one credit card sign in credit card agencies mumbai how to lower credit card interest rate bank of america need fake valid credit card number stolen bank of america credit card debt forgiveness first direct credit card interest rate sears credit card sign on jcpenney rewards credit card customer service fake working credit card numbers itunes does us bank have secured credit cards how is purchase interest on credit cards calculated can i go over my capital one credit card limit southwest airlines rapid rewards credit card 50000 best credit card programs best credit cards small business rewards need abn amro credit card online payment can you use credit card money order credit card programs credit unions what are balance transfers on a credit card wachovia platinum credit card payment how do i stop getting credit card offers from chase credit card best rewards 2012 visa rechargeable credit card hilton hhonors amex surpass credit card how to change credit card information on playstation store pink credit card wallet best buy credit card annual fee gap credit card payment login netflix foreign credit card should pay off credit card student loan first how much to offer credit card companies to settle debt best way to pay off credit cards to improve credit score credit card protection plan hsbc credit card checksum msdn credit card issuers ranking prepaid credit card for kids canada credit card for college students american express ing credit card canada credit card cash back bonus good credit card first time user credit card for bad debt uk apply for credit card with bad credit hsbc sears credit card online best credits cards for college students free flight credit cards activate us bank visa credit card home depot business credit card rewards 0 apr credit cards for 24 months first data wireless credit card reader napa auto care easy pay credit card lloyds air miles credit card review best buy online multiple credit cards boa pay online credit cards best credit cards apply bad credit names of credit cards brand name where can i pay my target credit card how credit card cloning works nordstrom credit cards login hsbc credit card rewards philippines ivy tech credit card fifth third credit card customer service phone number credit card type free credit card debt consolidation best prepaid credit cards bj;s barclay credit card log in no credit card shopping online best credit card to use on cruise ships hdfc platinum credit card reward points value credit cards for starters virgin money credit cards uk a free credit card number that works credit cards bad credit no fees deposit credit card law in uae uob credit cards singapore promotions pay amazon credit card payment can i pay lowes credit card with gift card best credit cards for balance transfer my first premier credit card consolidate credit cards low interest leather iphone 4 case credit cards sears credit card payment locations best credit card for medical bills cvc credit card number chase credit card awards chase bank lostpedia credit card phone number how to get rid of high interest credit card debt starwood preferred guest credit card promotion credit cards for military veterans toys r us store credit card credit card advertising compliance shell credit cards welcome to shell credit cards..url how do i accept credit cards on my iphone credit card debt written off on death chase united credit card first credit cards invented pay tire choice credit card statefarm credit card reviews citibank credit card toll free number india aventium credit card customer service number first premier bank credit cards for bad credit star credit card printer how to switch from bank account to credit card on paypal polo ralph lauren wallet burnished credit card case with money clip application credit card bank america mbna american express credit card uk quick trip credit card pay online student credit cards for bad or no credit students chase amazon credit card application status credit card no foreign transaction fee uk ge farm fleet credit card can i pay rent with credit card hsbc costco credit card online credit card for people with no credit history phone number activate wells fargo credit card rechargeable credit cards uk pay my chase toys r us credit card apply online business credit card paypal credit cards credit card counseling services dallas credit card icons set virtual terminal credit card processing free credit card rewards no annual fee credit card college student india barclays online credit card application costco canada credit cards accepted best cash back credit card canada 2010 credit card transaction settlement process what is credit card skimming can;t find security code on credit card mtvu credit card points good grades best no fee credit card canada 2011 virgin credit card points shop credit card number with cvv2 generator balance on credit cards credit score manage my chase credit card online time get refund credit card ge money universal credit card cost credit cards merchant obama credit card donor scandal
Home All Articles The Matsuzaka Dilemma

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 577 guests online

Atom RSS

The Matsuzaka Dilemma PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by John Thorn   
Tuesday, 12 December 2006 08:15

Article

John Thorn is a contributing writer for The Biz of Baseball 

From "Play's the Thing," Woodstock Times: 

This whole swirl may be over by the time you read this, but the meaning is the same, no matter how it comes out, and so is the moral. I’m talking about the sequence in which the Boston Red Sox were revealed to have outbid other baseball clubs for the thirty-day negotiating rights to “posted” Seibu Lion pitcher Daisuke Matsuzaka, who wishes to pitch in the United States but is not, under Nippon Professional Baseball (NPB) regulations, eligible for free agency until 2008. This Thursday night at midnight, when December 14 becomes December 15, is the witching hour.

As I write, Boston Red Sox executives have just landed the owner’s plane on the West Coast to plant themselves on agent Scott Boras’s doorstep. His Japanese client is mum on the seeming breakdown in negotiations, but as he has not fired his representative one may deduce that he is in on the game. It is a game designed by Major League Baseball (MLB) and the NPB, but as they seem only dimly to have understood their own rules, D-Mat and his designated hitter have made their own—or rather, as we shall see, correctly fathomed the implicit rule structure of the posting system. Bottom line: no matter how this shakes out, while D-Mat is not exactly the reincarnation of Curt Flood, Scott Boras has taken the mantle of Marvin Miller, and is my new hero. 

Yesterday I had lunch at the local Chinese restaurant where, despite my better judgment, I ate my customary sacramental portion of the stale fortune cookie and read its message. “It is better to have a hen tomorrow than an egg today” was the word from on high. Wait, I thought; this reverses the more commonly expressed wisdom that not only is an egg today better than a hen tomorrow, but also its avian corrolary about birds in hand and those in the bush. I wondered: might Boras have received the same, seemingly counterintuitive message?

Let’s back up for a moment and see how we got here. In the system by which a player is to be posted, both the team and player must agree on the posting. The team then notifies the NPB Commissioner’s Office that the player will be posted, which then notifies MLB, which notifies all of its teams. The MLB teams then have four days to submit a closed bid for the right to negotiate a contract with the player. If the high bid is accepted by the NPB team holding the player’s rights, the winning MLB team has thirty days to reach an agreement with the player. If the bid is rejected, the player is not “posted.” If the player signs a contract with the MLB team by the end of the signing period, then the NPB team receives the bid money. If the player does not sign a contract with the MLB team by the end of the signing period, the player is returned to the NPB team and the NPB team receives nothing.

Whoever designed this may have had in mind that classic scenario of game theory called the “Prisoner’s Dilemma.” It is a mathematical and psychological game illustrating how rational actions by individuals may not always lead to positive outcomes for either the individuals or the group. The Prisoner’s Dilemma is described neatly in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:

“Tanya and Cinque have been arrested for robbing the Hibernia Savings Bank and placed in separate isolation cells. Both care much more about their personal freedom than about the welfare of their accomplice. A clever prosecutor makes the following offer to each. ‘You may choose to confess or remain silent. If you confess and your accomplice remains silent I will drop all charges against you and use your testimony to ensure that your accomplice does serious time. Likewise, if your accomplice confesses while you remain silent, they will go free while you do the time. If you both confess I get two convictions, but I’ll see to it that you both get early parole. If you both remain silent, I’ll have to settle for token sentences on firearms possession charges. If you wish to confess, you must leave a note with the jailer before my return tomorrow morning.’

“The ‘dilemma’ faced by the prisoners here is that, whatever the other does, each is better off confessing than remaining silent. But the outcome obtained when both confess is worse for each than the outcome they would have obtained had both remained silent. A common view is that the puzzle illustrates a conflict between individual and group rationality. A group whose members pursue rational self-interest may all end up worse off than a group whose members act contrary to rational self-interest. More generally, if the payoffs are not assumed to represent self-interest, a group whose members rationally pursue any goals may all meet less success than if they had not rationally pursued their goals individually. Puzzles with this structure were devised and discussed by Merrill Flood and Melvin Dresher in 1950, as part of the Rand Corporation’s investigations into game theory (which Rand pursued because of possible applications to global nuclear strategy).” 

So, the underlying scheme of Prisoner’s Dilemma is to have the two prisoners collaborate wittingly or unwittingly against their own interest, with the outcome weighted to benefit the sate as represented by the police and prosecutor. The dilemma resides in the fact that each prisoner has a choice between only two options, but cannot make a good decision without knowing what the other one will do.

I suggest that the posting system was created along these lines to benefit the “state”—each league and each team involved. Think of MLB and Boston as the police and prosecutor in the above scenario, knowing that the salutary actions of Prisoner A (NPB and Seibu) and Prisoner B (Matsuzaka and Boras) are necessary to prevent the mutually assured destruction (M.A.D.) of MLB. That was the prospect some owners envisioned in 1973-74, at the dawn of free agency: that in an auction scenario, dollars would pursue scarce/unique assets in an irrationally exuberant way that would effectively transfer control of the game into the players’ hands. Marvin Miller cleverly assuaged the owners’ fears while assuring high prices for his players’ union by restricting free agency to those with six years’ service in the major leagues; had he opted for universal free agency, as he might have, the flood of talent onto the market each year would have depressed salaries. 

The design problem in the Prisoner’s Dilemma game above is that Prisoner Seibu has its deal in hand and is (ostensibly) denied the option of contributing some of its $51.1 million posting fee from Boston toward Prisoner Matsuzaka’s new contract. Indeed, without flexibility the fortunes of Seibu/NPB are more closely tied to the Police/Prosecutor than to Matsuzaka despite the pitcher’s total control over Seibu’s posting windfall. Boston, which stands ready to pay the sum and call it a bargain, instead feels aggrieved because its $51.1 million in expense is counted as nothing by Boras, who is looking to obtain $100 million for a six-year contract, pretty much in line with what his client would fetch in an unrestricted market. Boston had intended to pay out $100 million, all right, but had figured that Boras would give the club credit for half of that for “liberating” his client. No such luck, nor should there have been.

The posting system entices Boston (and other bidding clubs) with the lure of paying for a free agent in a tangential way that would not increase its exposure to luxury tax. The Red Sox are further compensated by considering the payment to Seibu as an inexpensive licensing or entry fee to market their brand vigorously in Japan. Additionally, the exclusivity that came with their winning bid permitted them not only to pursue Matsuzaka, but also to defend against the Yankees landing him. 

With its $51.1 million sugarplum, Seibu thought it was being rewarded for having nurtured Matsuzaka’s talent to the point that he was one of the top five pitchers in the world, and for graciously letting him go to America two years before NPB regulations would otherwise allow. In fact Seibu was also being pulled out of a very considerable financial hole, as the posting fee hits up on their bottom line as pure net income ... plus they gain at least $12 million in the amount they would otherwise have had to pay Matsuzaka for 2007 and 2008, the last years of his contract with the Lions.

MLB/Boston is in effect attempting to coerce a “confession” from Prisoner Matsuzaka because he risks embarrassment by returning to pitch for Seibu after 36,000 fans bade him farewell at the Lions’ Stadium, and because Seibu doesn’t want him back at the forfeiture of $63 million it is already counting on. 

What did MLB and the 29 teams not in the running for D-Mat’s services gain by the posting system? A presumptive lid on D-Mat’s demands and their escalating effect on pitcher salaries, already heightened by the ineffectual Adam Eaton and the awful Justin Marquis, each of whom received multiyear contracts at about $8 million per. With Matsuzaka wearing carmine hose, MLB will gain a new hero to promote its brand in Japan as well as the USA, just as Ichiro proved a marketing windfall. In fact this posting system is a nostalgic throwback, recreating for owners a glimpse of the paradise they enjoyed prior to free agency, when they owned the market and could say “take it or leave it” to the players. While the posting system may have been born of a genuine wish to protect Japanese baseball and avoid the appearance of American cultural imperialism, it has played out as an exercise in “Who will rule.”

As Boras has evidently surmised, even though MLB and NPB thought they had boxed in Prisoner Matsuzaka, it turned out that he and his client were not locked in behind iron bars but instead, like Br’er Rabbit, had been thrown into a briar patch from which they could easily escape. Boras has recognized that while the game is structured like Prisoner’s Dilemma, counting upon Seibu and his client to act independently in their perceived self-interest to the benefit of Organized Baseball, there is in fact only one prisoner, and without his yielding, there is no palatable outcome. 

If MLB and NPB had a game theory for how this would play itself out, it was the wrong one ... styled as Prisoner’s Dilemma but quickly revealing itself to be the “Dollar Auction,” another, even more vicious game, in which each of two contestants seeks to overpay for an asset in order to avoid being the second-place bidder whose money will have been utterly wasted.

In the Dollar Auction someone offers to sell a dollar bill to the highest bidder. The highest bidder will get the dollar, but the second-highest must also pay what he bid yet get nothing in return. Think here of “throwing good money after bad,” of “saving face,” of “having too much invested to cut and run,” of “staying the course.” If you can buy a dollar for a dime, this looks like a good deal. Even as the bidding rises in ten-cent increments to the 50-cent level, it still seems a bargain. At the 70-cent level, one may expect that all but two bidders will have fallen off the chase. When the dollar-mark is reached, the underbidder, rather than accepting defeat, will tend to bid ten cents more so as not to lose 90 cents. 

“People escalate their commitment both to justify their earlier bids and to prevent the financial and ego loss of coming in second,” Max H. Bazerman wrote in Psychology Today twenty years ago. “No specific bid is clearly wrong, since it is rational to bid ‘just another 10 cents,’ if the other party is about to quit bidding. But when both parties think this way, an escalatory spiral emerges that is very reminiscent of the Vietnam War and other international and industrial failures in which both competitors get trapped by their previous commitments.”

At first blush the winner in the Matsuzaka Dilemma appeared to be Boston; if the Mets were second, at $13 million less, they felt no ill consequence of their bid. Had the posting system had been a true Dollar Auction, with succesive rounds of bidding,  rather than a veiled Prisoner’s Dilemma with closed bids, the price for D-Mat might have gone much higher, as the underbidder would have been highly motivated to stay in the game. But now Boston’s inadvertent partner has been revealed not to be MLB but Seibu, which unlike Boston—which will retain the defensive benefit of its bid—will lose everything, as if it had been the underbidder in a Dollar Auction. And Br’er Boras and D-Mat, if they do not prevail this year, can play again only with more bargaining clout. 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?