bank of america credit card insurance coverage fast credit card virgin balance transfer credit card review accept credit cards iphone free dave ramsey getting rid of credit card debt sears online credit card login credit card processing machine no credit check what is overdraft protection on credit card credit card harassment calls philippines virgin credit card offer tv bank of america credit card services contact us walmart application for credit card how long does it take to get a credit card after approval cvv number american express credit cards hsbc credit card processing uk 12 months no apr credit cards emirates air miles credit card uk lowest credit card interest rates australia pay off student loan credit card then file bankruptcy credit card number length 16 average credit card interest rate 2011 what if i can;t pay credit card bills interest free credit cards natwest american bank of texas credit card buy greendot moneypak with credit card government credit card login citibank marshalls credit card score offers credit card india how to find out credit card account number online credit card application philippines ofw market america credit card review credit cards business canada credit cards best airline rewards programs cancel my macy;s credit card account connect cell phone credit card machine bank issued first credit card india rfid protective sleeves for credit cards best credit card deals 2011 rewards get free fake credit card numbers chase disney credit login in visa card can use my walmart credit card vision center no interest credit cards canada free credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date and name elan visa credit card apply for chase credit card student credit card with cashback rewards best way to pay off credit card to build credit apply for credit card citibank device used merchants process credit card transactions low interest student credit cards canada merrick credit card application hsbc best buy credit card online bill pay why was my credit card application denied international credit card services abn amro what is the most popular credit card in usa delta skymiles credit card platinum credit cards with ok credit swa credit card phone number kotak mahindra credit cards online apply bank india online application credit cards wfnnb credit card herbergers take credit cards with paypal wells fargo visa signature credit card benefits gottschalks credit card payment online pay ann taylor loft credit card bill does closing credit cards hurt my credit score credit cards numbers free work er diagram for credit card system pay off credit cards fast cnn no fee us credit card canada bac credit card payment bank america visa credit card customer service phone number discover credit card jcb best buy credit card sign in account chase credit cards online login current credit card apr rates hsbc credit card india online bill pay psn change credit card number hdfc credit card payment visa money transfer not paying credit cards texas paypal credit card login credit card promotion buffet town credit union credit card offers credit card 5 cash back gas united refining company kwik fill credit card exxon mobil credit cards credit card limits calculated credit card offers low interest rates geek wallet credit card sign up visa credit card canada chase freedom credit card travel insurance can you make irs payment credit card cancel regions credit card credit card calculator interest india credit card number starting with 43 rbs credit card application process best credit card for overseas travel pay target credit card with gift card first federal savings bank credit card capital one credit card customer service contact best prepaid credit cards online poker graduate school credit cards corporate credit card individual liability bank first credit card account credit card fees quickbooks why can;t you buy money orders with a credit card can use paypal process credit cards credit card promotions november 2012 secured credit cards build credit order credit card slips pre qualified credit card application credit card sentinel uk ltd can you use atm credit card good credit cards help rebuild credit what does credit card billing zip code mean best unsecured credit cards poor credit make payment my dell credit card hdfc platinum plus credit card reward points redeem get credit card no cosigner how do green dot credit cards work credit card problem philippines forum can pay my kohls credit card credit card ll bean credit card application credit cards best deals australia credit cards free air miles consumer credit card debt us cash rewards credit card taxable low annual fee credit cards lost credit cards chase can pay my chase credit card bank can you get a walmart credit card with bad credit need invalid visa credit card number signing back of credit card rfid protection credit card sleeve is everyone approved for a secured credit card where can i pay my discover credit card bill does pnc offer secured credit cards bank of america platinum plus credit card benefits pay barclay credit card payment best banks credit card debt consolidation old navy credit card visa payment how do i process credit cards online disney world credit cards rewards how to consolidate credit card debt in malaysia hello kitty credit card bank of america accept credit card payments on your iphone low rate credit card commonwealth bank credit cards for those with limited credit history zero percent interest credit cards for 24 months student credit card gas rebate best hilton honors credit cards got denied my first credit card credit card issuers market share bad credit secured credit card best credit cards for college graduates capital one journey card credit tracker ways get free credit card miles credit card blacklist philippines angel esata usb credit card flash drive the square credit card machine what are the various types of credit cards shell credit cards - my accounts boa ncl credit card exxon mobil credit card login sallie mae 5 percent credit card credit card payment form change credit card info psn american express blue credit card application credit card lock pick set review 0 balance transfer cards for poor credit application credit card indian bank amway credit card application not paying credit cards uk chase credit card report lost card get double miles with delta credit card best canadian credit card rates first equity credit card - complaints best credit card low rate interest paul smith leather credit card wallet cant add prepaid credit card paypal what to do when you cannot pay your credit card bills out pan credit card promotion pier 1 imports credit card customer service credit card reward points comparison india how to find a credit card number online best buy credit card debt cancellation fee mercedes benz credit card visa american express cathay pacific credit card taiwan how to pay your federal taxes by credit card kwik star credit card how do i cancel my first premier credit card do i need a credit card for an apple id pay avon customer credit card use case diagram credit card processing system how much do i need to pay off my credit card gap visa credit card payments applying for a credit card online safe credit card with 0 apr on purchases chase credit card mailing address chase sapphire preferred credit card offer avoid credit card cloning what is the best business credit card for airline miles best credit card cash transfer pay my credit care card mbna fidelity 529 credit card best cash back credit card schwab first credit cards invented citibank singapore credit card balance transfer texas capital bank credit cards tips for paying off credit card malaysia credit card minimum age standard chartered master credit card payment online fastest way build credit credit card the children;s place credit card payment online standard chartered bank credit card promotion philippines gm credit card payment address free credit card codes online mobile credit card terminal iphone hsbc credit card online payment other bank account do you need to use a credit card for xbox live credit cards no credit history chase pay sallie mae loan credit card 0 interest credit cards virgin internet based credit card processing credit card manual imprinter uk how to use cash advance on credit card poor credit credit cards no deposit chase credit card online help do you need enterprise credit card number itunes capital one credit card 0 apr what kind of credit score do you need to get a walmart credit card credit card ppi claim calculator instant decision credit card application chase credit cards people bad credit best buy reward zone credit card online payment cheap interest credit cards nz credit card checksum invalid error specifically amazon credit card rewards good credit cards to rebuild your credit free online instant psychic readings with no credit cards needed apply free credit cards india do car dealers take credit cards online credit card money transfer lilly pulitzer credit card iphone case icici bank credit card customer care number pune credit card companies not reporting credit limits how can i order stuff online without a credit card wholesale mini credit card skimmer does credit card refund process work third party credit card processors australia credit card payoff loan should you apply amazon credit card hilton hhonors platinum credit card login free credit report without a credit card credit card checker download free what do i need to open a credit card valid cvv credit card number credit card privacy laws california bmi credit card review credit cards in india ppt zero percent no transfer fee credit cards citicards credit card customer service phone number www orchardbank com credit card payment best rate credit cards ireland can refinance credit card debt first bank of omaha credit card canadian credit cards for fair credit sear credit card pay bill online office ally credit card processing is it illegal to charge a credit card processing fee the use of credit cards in paraguay capital one credit card miles review apply for disney rewards credit card citi cards credit card customer service change playstation credit card info case mate iphone 4 case credit card citibank credit card complaints 2009 icici bank credit card payment options banana republic credit card account sign in credit cards for credit scores below 600 hsbc gold credit card benefits uk cheapest iphone credit card terminal citibank credit card payment options tesco credit card balance transfer deals horizon credit card review hsbc credit card pantip apply bj credit card credit cards no fee balance transfers 0 apr balance transfers manual credit card processing in x-cart credit card forgiveness letter aqua credit card login online credit card payment gateway india wyndham credit card review credit card numbers starting 4147 how to get cash with a credit card number federal credit card debt relief act best credit card for international travel 2010 tesco 0 percent credit card juniper credit card bill pay credit card api + android easy credit cards to get approved for uk gold credit card natwest credit card advertising spend information needed open credit card account credit card avs discover student credit card or citi student credit card credit rebuilding credit cards canada applying for credit card online chase visa credit card services online mobil gas station credit card application chase ultimate rewards credit cards apple support itunes without credit card elan credit card services contact earn hilton points credit card chase british airways credit card phone number instant virtual credit cards chadwick credit card how to pay off 20000 in credit card debt credit card no foreign transaction fee australia best credit card offers miles applying for first credit card canada credit card statement balance account balance disney rewards credit card visa premier one credit card phone number credit card terminal app for iphone uk credit card charge dispute time secure sleeves for credit cards canada hollister credit card which credit cards don;t charge fees in europe how can i get a credit card with a bad credit rating sbi credit card statement ebay place your credit card on file random peoples credit card numbers credit card processing no monthly fee iphone rfid chip in your credit cards best credit card with rewards 2012 credit cards to build bad credit how to settle old credit card debts emirates credit card booking fee best student visa credit cards zero percent balance transfer credit cards no transfer fee citibank credit card pre qualify boston college alumni credit card best credit card air miles deals best aviation fuel credit card santander credit card no balance transfer fee offer flying blue klm credit card spyderco credit card knife review credit card minimum payment calculator citibank credit cards points best hdfc bank visa signature credit card american express platinum credit card benefits extra payment credit card calculator best interest free credit cards purchases student discover card bad credit how old do you have to be to sign up for a credit card bank of america credit card offers prepaid virtual credit cards visa british air credit card 50 000 chase credit card hardship program phone number stop aadvantage credit card offers best way to get credit card with no credit credit card numbers that work online with cvv2 sears credit card sign on page pre-authorization credit card forms tesco credit card log on best mileage plan credit cards chase credit card international exchange rate jewelry credit cards for bad credit chase british airways credit cards best credit card earning frequent flyer miles settle credit card debt your own best transfer balance credit cards 2012 chase credit card with 500 cash back how to cancel a lost chase credit card wells fargo credit card overnight payment address qantas frequent flyer best credit card points hdfc credit card online shopping offers how to payoff credit cards faster 2 cash back credit card no annual fee personal credit card reader iphone credit card bin checker top credit cards with rewards providian credit card apply lower credit card debt without affecting credit score priceline visa credit card payments what happens if you default on a credit card uk chase credit card bad credit cathay pacific american express elite credit card us bank visa credit card flexperks where to get a prepaid credit card in alberta apply visa credit card india low interest credit cards for first timers make pnc credit card payment how to pay your amazon credit card iphone credit card uk app miles rewards credit cards best best banks secured credit cards fingerhut credit card payment ny company credit card online credit card sleeve security pay student loan with credit card declare bankruptcy rbs india credit card bill online payment guaranteed credit card approval bad credit unsecured best ipad credit card reader world market card credit card change payment credit card paypal ebay can i buy a certificate of deposit with a credit card credit card imprint machine how do you take a credit card off amazon can i use one credit card to pay off another shell credit card account login hsbc classic credit card online application shell gas station credit card hold credit card identity theft stories detecting credit card type number saks fifth avenue credit card pay online check credit history without credit card easy credit cards to get approved 2011 phone numbers to report stolen credit cards incipio technologies stowaway credit card case for iphone 4 cash back bonus credit card united credit cards business us credit card with chip for europe can i use my debit card as a credit card for online purchases how safe to apply for amazon credit card online american express credit card benefits reestablish credit card canada can i get cash out from my credit card credit cards small business no personal guarantee transferring balances on credit cards cimb niaga gold credit card can pay kohls credit card online negotiate credit card payoff bank of america quickbooks merchant services credit card fees what is the best credit card for airline miles balance transfers on credit cards australia chase secured credit card rebuild credit bac credit card login guaranteed non secured credit cards apply for apple credit card juniper how does a credit card work yahoo capital credit cards log list of department stores with credit cards federal credit union credit card fuel credit cards uk fidelity investment credit card login instant credit card approval use pay my newegg credit card can credit card companies garnish my wages in texas citi bank credit cards sign in chase freedom credit card review 2011 new laws credit cards canada aft union plus credit card how to get government help with credit card debt credit card low balance transfer rate credit card processing glossary cash register with credit card processing xbox credit card not authorized credit card requirements citibank singapore nfl extra pointstm platinum plus? visa? credit card from bank of america company credit cards for employees premier credit cards no credit citibank visa credit card online statement catherines credit card services verify paypal without credit card or. bank credit card best benefits check my credit card balance mastercard business credit card with airline miles credit card comparison interest free period best credit card rewards program in canada compare credit cards india 2012 instant payment with paypal without credit card best credit card rewards 2 cash back buy skype credit visa gift card us bank government credit card login wells fargo financial national bank slumberland credit card advanta small business credit cards and services.url best travel rewards credit card canada 2011 bank america credit card pre qualification best rewards credit card chase freedom free business credit cards uk fleet bank credit cards comerica credit card online account 5 best ways get credit card rewards what is the interest rate on a best buy credit card dental credit card canada citibank credit cards in india apply credit card discover business hsbc secured credit cards how to apply for target credit card online chase credit card cash advance without pin westpac credit card travel insurance cover secret history of credit cards transcript can you withdraw cash from a chase credit card how to get student credit cards with no credit carters credit card login credit card goodies peter flur how do i remove credit card from amazon best credit card for low credit score
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB Revenue-Sharing is Bad, Plus Tidbits

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 896 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB Revenue-Sharing is Bad, Plus Tidbits PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 07 March 2011 15:13

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in “Last Week in BizBall, revenue sharing is bad, plus tidbits.

REVENUE SHARING IS BAD

Last year, the “leaked financial docs” was a big story amongst us baseball biz watchers. And rightfully so. The leaked financial statements of 6 clubs (their veracity never challenged by MLB) confirmed what had been widely assumed for years. That is, revenue sharing payees’ Marlins and Pirates are profitable and the reason they are profitable is revenue sharing. This led to speculation amongst the punditry of whether the large revenue “payor” franchises would insist on a future decrease in league-wide revenue sharing. After all, the Marlins and Pirates ostensibly are in receipt of revenue sharing dollars to improve the on-field performance of their franchises. The “leaked financial docs” made it difficult for both those clubs to argue that they were using the entirety of their revenue sharing proceeds to improve their ball clubs. At the time I was one of a minority writing that the “leaked financial docs” was pretty much a non-story. While us pundits and journalists now had the “smoking gun”, certainly none of this was a surprise to any MLB owner, club president, CFO, or at the senior levels of the PA. My conclusion that this was a non-story was also informed by the public silence amongst MLB owners and front office personnel on the subject. I don’t recall anybody speaking out against the current revenue-sharing structure, particularly notable because this story afforded the perfect opportunity for “payors” to discredit the system.

But six months later, I think I got it wrong. LWIB, Red Sox owner John Henry made public that he was fined $500,000 in 09 for speaking out against revenue sharing in an interview with the Boston Globe. In that interview Mr. Henry said, “Over a billion dollars has been paid to seven chronically uncompetitive teams, five of whom have had baseball's highest operating profits. Who, except these teams, can think this is a good idea? LWIB, Mr. Henry said, "The large markets aren't allowed to give their opinions," "I made statements which turned out to be true, or at least there were various documents that were leaked after that. But anyway, the large clubs are not allowed to talk about it." Hindsight being 20-20, I’ve changed my opinion. The public silence from “payors” to the “leaked financial docs” was not a sign of tacit acceptance but instead evidence of commissioner Selig’s ability to muzzle the owners. After different comments earlier this year comparing revenue sharing to socialism/communism and challenging Rangers owner Chuck Greenberg to “get off welfare”, Yankees owner Hank Steinbrenner has also been silenced on the subject by Selig. This being a year when the CBA is set for expiration, MLB forbids owners from speaking publicly about such matters. So, the more things change….despite a decline in the amount of dollars redistributed via revenue sharing last year over 09 (approx $400 million versus approx $433 million), the large revenue owners evidently still believe the system is unfair to them.

I don’t know what amount of revenue sharing would appease the large revenue franchises and I don’t care. I’m sick of revenue sharing and have been for years. MLB would be more entertaining without it. Sadly, there has never been less reward/incentive to win games in MLB than there is today. Where is the fun in that? A long, long time ago, maximizing profits in MLB was simple, win more games. sell more tickets, beer and hot dogs. Not so much today. Win more games, sell more tickets, beer, hot dogs, sushi AND put about a third of those in a pot to share with your competitors. Plus, more and more local revenue is generated from guaranteed, long- term local TV rights deals with RSNs. That revenue is the same amount whether a club wins 62 or 102 games. Plus, MLB has centralized more and more revenue, again unrelated to club on field performance. Along with the traditional national TV contracts, increasingly lucrative digital rights are also centralized at BAM along with secondary ticketing. MLB owners each receive an equal share in the profits generated by the MLB Network cable TV channel. The value in franchise ownership is more and more frequently associated with the property development rights surrounding the ballpark, again entirely unrelated to winning.

And I don’t believe that revenue sharing is key to improving competitive balance. Before I get to why I dislike mediocrity (woops, parity, woops competitive balance) in MLB , there is no evidence that revenue sharing has resulted in more competitive balance. (The illusion of greater competitive balance in MLB is a result of the expanded playoffs and realignment) Revenue sharing is about limiting labour costs, not “hope“ for small revenue franchises. In November 09, Stanford economist Roger Noll told the Biz of Baseball:

The only way to have equally balanced teams is to ban trades and sales of players and to have periodic drafts of managers, coaches and directors of player personnel. The methods that leagues use to create balance have been shown to have little or no effect on the distribution of quality among teams. The logic behind it is that it is not in the interests of owners as well as players to have balanced competition. If all teams were of the same strength, total league revenues would go up if the best player in KC were traded for the worst player in NYC. In a regime of salary caps and no free agency, the KC owner will be richer if he sells his underpaid star to NY.

Another of the sports economists, Andrew Zimbalist (who has consulted for both the MLBPA and MLB) wrote in his 2003 book, May the Best Team Win, Baseball Economics and Public Policy:

While owners have claimed that they want more revenue sharing and a luxury tax on high payrolls in order to level the playing field, it is apparent that they are also seeking to control the growth in player salaries. Higher revenue sharing taxes lower the net marginal revenue product of players, and, other things equal, lower their salaries.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE MORE ON MLB REVENUE SHARING, PLUS TIDBITS

 

And why should parity, ok mediocrity, amongst teams be orchestrated by MLB? While polls consistently conclude that competitive imbalance in MLB is perceived as a problem amongst fans, some academics think there is no evidence to support those findings. Another of the sports economists, Dave Berri, wrote in 07:

 

….the link between competitive balance and attendance has been extensively studied…..

And what does this literature indicate? Competitive balance does impact demand, but it doesn’t appear to be very “important.” At least, dramatic changes in balance do not seem to have a very dramatic impact on league attendance. Given this result, I am not sure the “optimal level of balance” is something leagues should actively seek…

And aren’t great teams, dynasties, more fun for fans than the annual overturn in the crop of mediocre teams qualifying for the postseason? Yankees lover or Yankees hater (the only two types of MLB fans), their run of four WS championships from 96-00 was an important factor in bringing fans back to MLB post 94. And isn’t business booming in the EPL, where both payroll and competitive disparities dwarf those in MLB?

Maybe I’m just disgruntled because the team I root for hasn’t competed in the postseason since 93. And ultimately I think the cause of that is corporate ownership that has concluded (no doubt rightfully) that the prudent approach to owning an MLB franchise is a cautious one. They understand that the central fund revenues are always there, in a down year revenue sharing will prop you up and even if you lose a little money on paper, you control a lot (162 games) of cheap programming for your cable TV sports channels. Maybe if you had to win to make money Rogers Communications Inc. would field a better baseball team. I suspect the Red Sox might be more profitable if they spent less but John Henry is more concerned with winning than profiting. Winning = profits? Not necessarily in this era. Look at the “leaked financial docs”.

TIDBITS

  • LWIB, Ben Badler at Baseball America reviewed the 2010 year in the international free agent market. Ben’s discussions with MLB international scouting directors led him to conclude that while there were no elite talents in last year’s free agent crop, there was an abundance of “mid-level” talent signed. The Jays awarded the highest bonus at $2.8 million (the fourth highest ever to an intl free agent), to Venezuelan RH Adonys Cardona. Rounding out the Top 5 signing bonuses were the Pirates ($2.6 million for RH Luis Heredia Mexico), Astros ($2.6 million for OF Ariel Ovando DR), Mariners ($2.2 million for OF Phillips Castillo DR) and A’s ($2.2 million for 3B Renato Nunez Venezuala). Excluding the burgeoning market for Cuban players, clubs doled out about $73 million in signing bonuses. Dominican players received approximately $44 million of that total, while Venezuelan players received approximately $20 million. Ben also tells us that clubs are recruiting more aggressively in Colombia.
  • The Padres recently purchased the Triple A franchise formerly located in Portland. All along the Padres plan was to eventually locate the club in the SD suburb of Escondido once a new ballpark was constructed. In the interim, the club is situated in Tucson. In order to finance the construction of the ballpark, Escondido is following the same plan that many, many other municipalities have used. That is, establishing a “redevelopment agency” (aka entertainment district) which would raise funds for the construction backed by future tax revenues generated from the development (aka Tax Increment Financing). CA governor Jerry Brown might outlaw such redevelopment agencies in his state (see Neil DeMause). LWIB, Josh Leventhal reported for Baseball America that if Escondido’s financing plan for the ballpark is scuttled by the state government, the Padres might be forced to put their Triple A franchise back on the market.
  • How would you like to watch as much of this baseball season as you possibly can, live in NYC (though I don’t know if you’d have time to leave your apartment), blog every day about it, plus vlog (a verb that I was previously unfamiliar with) and tweet and… LWIB, The Hollywood Reporter (HT Fang’s Bites) reported on a joint venture between MLB.com and Endemol to produce a web series starring the winner of the contest to be “The Biggest Geek” (my term, not theirs). Seriously, this is a great opportunity for the contest winner to launch a career as a baseball pundit/blogger/vlogger. It might also be an interesting experiment. How immersed, and for how long, can you be in a baseball season before it drives you nuts?


Pete Toms is senior writer for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?