tesco pharmacy speman to buy pill nolvadex online fda approved online pet pharmacies prednisone 1000mg nexium alternatives cheaper what is cephalexin 500mg used for in humans acticin no prescription maximum prevacid dose for babies 1500 mg of valtrex powder zithromax 300 mg buy generic altace speman discounts codes pregnant prednisone 60 mg cipro hc rxlist metformin 500 mg benefits brand cialis 40mg buy nootropil 5 order genuine cialis medrol 4 mg tablet viagra generic hersteller brand hyzaar buy cheapest cialis australia 250 mg doxycycline acne viagra 300 mg online authentic viagra cialis generic 5 mg cialis 100 mg pills can i order buspar no prescription in the usa generico viagra yahoo cipro xl 1000mg lexapro 20 mg efficacy online cheap viagra doxycycline online shop augmentin 625 mg prospect zithromax 500 mg info phenergan tablets 25mg cheapest clomid 100mg pregnant viagra generic alternative online viagra tablet generic cialis ray buspar for anxiety attacks 365 pills coupon code lexapro patent generic taking two claritin pills generic buy cheap levothyroxine sodium lexapro 20mg bula teva generic lexapro propranolol sleep disorders sustiva non perscription countries pyridium canadian pharmacy do you need rx evista buy dapoxetine thailand xenical 120 mg wirkung advair online no prescription geriforte buy online ireland buy ditropan 40 zoloft 50 mg precio order liv 52 online uk cialis 5 mg o 10 viagra dosage 100mg onlinefarmacy generic speman overnite shipping buy zoloft america can you buy viagra over the counter in the uk generic nexium cheapest cialis australia 5mg fast wellbutrin sr deleviery soft cialis generic clomiphene citrate low testosterone buy viagra brisbane buy betnovate scalp application 100ml can you buy viagra soft in ireland canadian cialis online 1.00 prednisone 20 mg bid lexapro 10mg engorda januvia side effects weight gain zithromax 500 mg sport where can i buy nolvadex from in uk endep order by phone augmentin xr 1 mg 62.5 zoloft 50 mg recreational discount lioresal 12 generic sildenafil viagra generic viagra professional buy 50 mg clomid what does carafate have in it lisinopril tablets 20 mg chloramphenicol medication online is it safe to order nizagara metformin 1000 mg pills valtrex canadian medications without prescription compare prices zantac kemasan cialis 80mg pomegranate smoothie vitamix no generic premarin tricor uk online tricor discount card valtrex 500 mg glaxosmithkline lexapro generic escitalopram bactrim mg kg levitra 20 mg generic zocor paypal botanical slimming tablets gel order crestor online uk keppra cost canadian medicament xenical 120 mg cialis 10 mg etkisi buy nolvadex forum medrol dose pack common side effects prescription xenical online cheap zestril uk strattera 40 mg generic cheapest synthetic viagra is glucotrol xl a prescription drug purchase neurontin online aciphex drug classification femara letrozole buy no prescription taking trazodone without food nitroglycerin tablets rxlist prednisone 8 mg buy flagyl over the counter order florinef costo cialis generico buy strattera line lexapro 20mg canada what is the correct dosage of brand cialis can you buy minocin over the counter viagra online bulgaria indomethacin 50mg cap cheap generic cialis xenical uk cheapest order bactrim overnight inderal 40 mg propranolol buy viagra cheap buy colchicine next day diflucan 100 mg capsule cipro bayer 500 mg precio lipitor 20 mg mexico phenergan order order proscar online uk clomid 50mg metformin cephalexin pills sweat prednisone 10mg pregnancy cheap viagra usa isoniazid medication where to buy antivert 25mg tablets side effects triplets clomid 50mg actoplus metformin generic buy minocycline singapore canada buy proscar without prescription suprax cost without insurance cymbalta prices costco get levlen toronto fluoxetine prescription only vasotec from usa pharmacy acai berry purchase online dosage augmentin 500mg buy nexium argentina increasing libido in men supplements minocin legal us indian pharmacy mycelex-g nexium tablets spc nolvadex buy pct synthroid side effects joint pain levitra 10mg tablets levitra generic canada 1mg or 5mg finasteride for hairloss? generic diflucan 150 mg acquisto diamox sicuro online viagra prescription only approved pharmacy periactin tablets 4mg que precio tiene las pastillas redustat cialis 20 mg originale viagra 5mg buy western drug plendil lipitor atorvastatin muscle spasms synthroid generic medication generic viagra cumming buy cheap canadian drugs gulf of mexico alliance all hands where to buy acai berry fruit orlistat 20mg tab femara 10 mg cost coversyl pct buy dapoxetine generic antabuse implant nhs exelon stock buy or sell glucophage 850 mg dosage glyset side effects uk current price kamagra elimite for men sale in uk actos medicine coupons premarin shop order lipitor from canada asian generic viagra lipitor $4 copay participating pharmacies walgreens cialis 5 or 10 mg letrozole nolvadex buy lexapro generic dosages can we trust baclofen online buy liquid viagra mentat comanda online cheap glucophage can you order atarax canadian pharmacy finasteride propecia generic nolvadex non perscription countries viagra generico nome lexapro dosage 5mg cheapest place to buy pariet what is risperdal medication used for generic levitra fda prednisone 5 mg canada buy prednisolone online canada generic lexapro 2012 march snovitra super power medicine online no prescription uk antibiotics list buy lisinopril 20 mg information funciona cialis generico buy promethazine 15mg online narrow and broad spectrum antibiotics purchase protonix cheap 100 mg levitra pharmacy starting buy accutane online what is januvia for suprax antibiotic reviews where can i get clomid pills prednisone 30 mg 5 days naprosyn sr 1000 use web pharmacy uk prezzo lasix 25 mg 80 mg prednisone lot ebay cialis generico online viagra rezept bali buy viagra 10mg lexapro costco hoodia dosage instructions canadian zestoretic tablet glifor 850 mg metformin lexapro generic pap ram nexium 40 mg cheap hydrochlorothiazide sale uk valtrex 500 mg 42 tablet cheap us aceon online overnight avapro western australia buy zofran online canada buy kamagra 100mg cialis tadafil 50mg pan american lithium corporation viagra cheap country nolvadex research buy generic prograf usa pharmacy generic zoloft medication buy dapoxetine 60mg abilify cost with insurance augmentin 1000 mg fiyat 14 cialis 20mg 30er propecia 1 mg 28 comprimidos viagra online cheapest retin-a ge weight gain diflucan capsules 150mg nexium esomeprazole 20 mg much does generic aricept cost viagra online meds taking 2 viagra pills xenical 120mg india viagra 100mg substitute original purinethol online donde comprar finasteride en peru levitra en generico avodart usage viagra 100mg generic uk drugs classification table 5 m mg cialis buy viagra 50mg diclofenac online bestellen zonder recept zovirax tabletas 1000 mg levitra 20 mg bijsluiter propranolol 40 mg bijsluiter periactin online bestellen amitriptyline sold over counter buy nolvadex genox prednisone 10mg buy how long does it take for lexapro to leave your system fungsi cialis 20mg phenergan generic promethazine tomar viagra 100mg robaxin cheap uk pharmacy generic viagra super active uk paypal online viagra rating diflucan pill 100mg hydrea mg buy buyers cialis mexican pharmacy no prescription actonel levitra bayer buy generic celebrex reviews buy benemid online overnight online viagra ireland buying viagra amsterdam generic bactrim ointment 5mg lexapro effectiveness ordering brand levitra bayer cheap buspar medication order generic viagra less cialis cheap canadqa buy lasuna cheap nonprecription generic cialis cheap prednisone 10mg diflucan 50 mg prospecto generic metformin 500 mg really cheap viagra how to get viagra over the counter buying zithromax 1 gram kamagra 100 mg price med-rx protein powder kegunaan nexium 40 mg pharmacy phd admission 2011 europe viagra buyer usa viagra rx online furosemide tablets 40mg used where to purchase isoptin zyrtec canada head office coumadin tablets dosage pet allies show low az directions round 10mg levitra canadian online pharmacy for chloroquine switching propecia generic 50 mg viagra generic amoxil 500mg paypal generic lasix pills baclofen drug store online aldactone noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy generic lexapro medicine diflucan online cheap cheapest viagra 100 mg doxycycline for cheap buy plavix online usa buy tetracycline 500 mg 100mg doxycycline dosage geriforte prescription only clomid 100mg chances cialis 5 mg enough zithromax online order ralista supplier in uk zoloft 50 mg erowid order propecia bosley buy strattera uses no prescription diabetes cheap actos lisinopril 2 5 mg pilex tablets for purchase buy ginseng with paypal viagra order ireland generic wellbutrin safe order abilify online no prescription with a mastercard generic phenergan medication buy zantac online amazon kamagra buy online purchase desyrel cheap viagras cena where to ashwagandha buy generic diflucan keflex dosage for cystitis buy skelaxin online reviews generic lexapro medication zyvox online pharmacy uk desi tashan veera nexium 10 mg granulat viagra cheap india overnight shipping buy generic clomid online strattera sublinguals buy buy prednisone asthma zithromax generic name prescriptions cheap vermox order bystolic 20 mg metformin tablet 500mg price increase prilosec buying viagra lanzarote 28x 5mg cialis vitamin d deficiency causes erectile dysfunction med cab levaquin cheap price nexium buy levitra 1.84 metformin 500mg pcos levitra 20 mg. tabletas atrovent nebulizer dosage pediatric cialis prescribtion online buy metformin nz cipro woldwide shipping suppliers of lipothin in us viagra 800 mg how to buy fml forte in london brand mycelex-g buy buy cialis vancouver indinavir paypal zoloft buying can you buy things on itunes with paypal cialis super active non perscription countries roxithromycin online shipping fertomid refills endep medication reviews allies web canadian forces links buy nizagara from india orlistat uk supply billig isoniazid online kaufen current lithium price chart generic strattera 25 mg albendazole rxlist tijuana pharmacy hours flovent drug class zovirax online order levitra order usa strattera going generic buy viagra houston purchase bentyl canada is zyban sold over the counter buy cheap atorlip 10 where to purchase cardizem generic rosuvastatin in canada generico de lexapro viagra online free kamagra jel cheap cialis onlinesouy cialis becoming generic buy doxycycline suspension wellbutrin generic online indian generics online sominex what is atrovent nasal spray big blue pill hzt nizoral shampoo australia price generic viagra ingrediants cialis 100mg pills 60 mg strattera overdose generico viagra curitiba cialis 80 mgr compare prices imitrex generic for amoxil erfahrungsbericht levitra 10mg is plavix generic available viagra super 100mg zovirax 800 mg precio bula propranolol 10mg cialis online 5mil buy zaditor next day buy viagra wien cheap quick viagra take cialis 40 mg xenical generic cost coupon discount cymbalta finast 40 mg pharmacy nolvadex 20 mg kaufen precio generico zovirax recommended dosage for prometrium cheap geninue viagra diflucan 200 mg prospect buspar 5 mg tablets buy medrol tablets lasix online fedex how much will crestor cost generic strattera 80 mg buying generic cialis buy clomid cheap cialis generic dosage lexapro buy line nolvadex shop online generic lexapro walmart motrin 100 what illnesses does biaxin treat celebrex 200 mg canada shuddha guggulu online cheap admiral insurance company viagra online manly glucophage xr generico tofranil 10 mg cost abilify tablets oral solution innopran xl tablets side effects buy caverta mg buy ditropan pills online generic lexapro available lidocaine spray otc gabapentin 100mg neurontin an anticonvulsant viagra generic 150 mg order viagra reviews doxycycline hydrochloride 100 mg keppra price in canada cialis shop online low price indinavir uk cheapest cialis 20mg uk cozaar on the internet buy casodex perth australia propranolol 40 mg grossesse buy silagra hong kong 40mg cheap cialis atacand mg price viagra vs generic cheap brahmi powder generic viagra 26 cialis buy actos 60 mg cialis online vendita generic proventil paypal dosierung xenical 120 mg
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB Revenue-Sharing is Bad, Plus Tidbits

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 614 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB Revenue-Sharing is Bad, Plus Tidbits PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 07 March 2011 15:13

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in “Last Week in BizBall, revenue sharing is bad, plus tidbits.

REVENUE SHARING IS BAD

Last year, the “leaked financial docs” was a big story amongst us baseball biz watchers. And rightfully so. The leaked financial statements of 6 clubs (their veracity never challenged by MLB) confirmed what had been widely assumed for years. That is, revenue sharing payees’ Marlins and Pirates are profitable and the reason they are profitable is revenue sharing. This led to speculation amongst the punditry of whether the large revenue “payor” franchises would insist on a future decrease in league-wide revenue sharing. After all, the Marlins and Pirates ostensibly are in receipt of revenue sharing dollars to improve the on-field performance of their franchises. The “leaked financial docs” made it difficult for both those clubs to argue that they were using the entirety of their revenue sharing proceeds to improve their ball clubs. At the time I was one of a minority writing that the “leaked financial docs” was pretty much a non-story. While us pundits and journalists now had the “smoking gun”, certainly none of this was a surprise to any MLB owner, club president, CFO, or at the senior levels of the PA. My conclusion that this was a non-story was also informed by the public silence amongst MLB owners and front office personnel on the subject. I don’t recall anybody speaking out against the current revenue-sharing structure, particularly notable because this story afforded the perfect opportunity for “payors” to discredit the system.

But six months later, I think I got it wrong. LWIB, Red Sox owner John Henry made public that he was fined $500,000 in 09 for speaking out against revenue sharing in an interview with the Boston Globe. In that interview Mr. Henry said, “Over a billion dollars has been paid to seven chronically uncompetitive teams, five of whom have had baseball's highest operating profits. Who, except these teams, can think this is a good idea? LWIB, Mr. Henry said, "The large markets aren't allowed to give their opinions," "I made statements which turned out to be true, or at least there were various documents that were leaked after that. But anyway, the large clubs are not allowed to talk about it." Hindsight being 20-20, I’ve changed my opinion. The public silence from “payors” to the “leaked financial docs” was not a sign of tacit acceptance but instead evidence of commissioner Selig’s ability to muzzle the owners. After different comments earlier this year comparing revenue sharing to socialism/communism and challenging Rangers owner Chuck Greenberg to “get off welfare”, Yankees owner Hank Steinbrenner has also been silenced on the subject by Selig. This being a year when the CBA is set for expiration, MLB forbids owners from speaking publicly about such matters. So, the more things change….despite a decline in the amount of dollars redistributed via revenue sharing last year over 09 (approx $400 million versus approx $433 million), the large revenue owners evidently still believe the system is unfair to them.

I don’t know what amount of revenue sharing would appease the large revenue franchises and I don’t care. I’m sick of revenue sharing and have been for years. MLB would be more entertaining without it. Sadly, there has never been less reward/incentive to win games in MLB than there is today. Where is the fun in that? A long, long time ago, maximizing profits in MLB was simple, win more games. sell more tickets, beer and hot dogs. Not so much today. Win more games, sell more tickets, beer, hot dogs, sushi AND put about a third of those in a pot to share with your competitors. Plus, more and more local revenue is generated from guaranteed, long- term local TV rights deals with RSNs. That revenue is the same amount whether a club wins 62 or 102 games. Plus, MLB has centralized more and more revenue, again unrelated to club on field performance. Along with the traditional national TV contracts, increasingly lucrative digital rights are also centralized at BAM along with secondary ticketing. MLB owners each receive an equal share in the profits generated by the MLB Network cable TV channel. The value in franchise ownership is more and more frequently associated with the property development rights surrounding the ballpark, again entirely unrelated to winning.

And I don’t believe that revenue sharing is key to improving competitive balance. Before I get to why I dislike mediocrity (woops, parity, woops competitive balance) in MLB , there is no evidence that revenue sharing has resulted in more competitive balance. (The illusion of greater competitive balance in MLB is a result of the expanded playoffs and realignment) Revenue sharing is about limiting labour costs, not “hope“ for small revenue franchises. In November 09, Stanford economist Roger Noll told the Biz of Baseball:

The only way to have equally balanced teams is to ban trades and sales of players and to have periodic drafts of managers, coaches and directors of player personnel. The methods that leagues use to create balance have been shown to have little or no effect on the distribution of quality among teams. The logic behind it is that it is not in the interests of owners as well as players to have balanced competition. If all teams were of the same strength, total league revenues would go up if the best player in KC were traded for the worst player in NYC. In a regime of salary caps and no free agency, the KC owner will be richer if he sells his underpaid star to NY.

Another of the sports economists, Andrew Zimbalist (who has consulted for both the MLBPA and MLB) wrote in his 2003 book, May the Best Team Win, Baseball Economics and Public Policy:

While owners have claimed that they want more revenue sharing and a luxury tax on high payrolls in order to level the playing field, it is apparent that they are also seeking to control the growth in player salaries. Higher revenue sharing taxes lower the net marginal revenue product of players, and, other things equal, lower their salaries.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE MORE ON MLB REVENUE SHARING, PLUS TIDBITS

 

And why should parity, ok mediocrity, amongst teams be orchestrated by MLB? While polls consistently conclude that competitive imbalance in MLB is perceived as a problem amongst fans, some academics think there is no evidence to support those findings. Another of the sports economists, Dave Berri, wrote in 07:

 

….the link between competitive balance and attendance has been extensively studied…..

And what does this literature indicate? Competitive balance does impact demand, but it doesn’t appear to be very “important.” At least, dramatic changes in balance do not seem to have a very dramatic impact on league attendance. Given this result, I am not sure the “optimal level of balance” is something leagues should actively seek…

And aren’t great teams, dynasties, more fun for fans than the annual overturn in the crop of mediocre teams qualifying for the postseason? Yankees lover or Yankees hater (the only two types of MLB fans), their run of four WS championships from 96-00 was an important factor in bringing fans back to MLB post 94. And isn’t business booming in the EPL, where both payroll and competitive disparities dwarf those in MLB?

Maybe I’m just disgruntled because the team I root for hasn’t competed in the postseason since 93. And ultimately I think the cause of that is corporate ownership that has concluded (no doubt rightfully) that the prudent approach to owning an MLB franchise is a cautious one. They understand that the central fund revenues are always there, in a down year revenue sharing will prop you up and even if you lose a little money on paper, you control a lot (162 games) of cheap programming for your cable TV sports channels. Maybe if you had to win to make money Rogers Communications Inc. would field a better baseball team. I suspect the Red Sox might be more profitable if they spent less but John Henry is more concerned with winning than profiting. Winning = profits? Not necessarily in this era. Look at the “leaked financial docs”.

TIDBITS

  • LWIB, Ben Badler at Baseball America reviewed the 2010 year in the international free agent market. Ben’s discussions with MLB international scouting directors led him to conclude that while there were no elite talents in last year’s free agent crop, there was an abundance of “mid-level” talent signed. The Jays awarded the highest bonus at $2.8 million (the fourth highest ever to an intl free agent), to Venezuelan RH Adonys Cardona. Rounding out the Top 5 signing bonuses were the Pirates ($2.6 million for RH Luis Heredia Mexico), Astros ($2.6 million for OF Ariel Ovando DR), Mariners ($2.2 million for OF Phillips Castillo DR) and A’s ($2.2 million for 3B Renato Nunez Venezuala). Excluding the burgeoning market for Cuban players, clubs doled out about $73 million in signing bonuses. Dominican players received approximately $44 million of that total, while Venezuelan players received approximately $20 million. Ben also tells us that clubs are recruiting more aggressively in Colombia.
  • The Padres recently purchased the Triple A franchise formerly located in Portland. All along the Padres plan was to eventually locate the club in the SD suburb of Escondido once a new ballpark was constructed. In the interim, the club is situated in Tucson. In order to finance the construction of the ballpark, Escondido is following the same plan that many, many other municipalities have used. That is, establishing a “redevelopment agency” (aka entertainment district) which would raise funds for the construction backed by future tax revenues generated from the development (aka Tax Increment Financing). CA governor Jerry Brown might outlaw such redevelopment agencies in his state (see Neil DeMause). LWIB, Josh Leventhal reported for Baseball America that if Escondido’s financing plan for the ballpark is scuttled by the state government, the Padres might be forced to put their Triple A franchise back on the market.
  • How would you like to watch as much of this baseball season as you possibly can, live in NYC (though I don’t know if you’d have time to leave your apartment), blog every day about it, plus vlog (a verb that I was previously unfamiliar with) and tweet and… LWIB, The Hollywood Reporter (HT Fang’s Bites) reported on a joint venture between MLB.com and Endemol to produce a web series starring the winner of the contest to be “The Biggest Geek” (my term, not theirs). Seriously, this is a great opportunity for the contest winner to launch a career as a baseball pundit/blogger/vlogger. It might also be an interesting experiment. How immersed, and for how long, can you be in a baseball season before it drives you nuts?


Pete Toms is senior writer for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?