example valid credit card security codes american exess secured credit unsecured credit cards for rebuilding free prepaid prepaid visa or master cards fake mastercard security code number apply for chevron shell gas cards online expired credit free car auto information by vin number what can i buy with just a credit card number credit cards numbers that work visa valid where where is mastercard security code located open a free virtual credit card generator gas cards for bad credit cards for bad credit or no credit credit cards to help how to rebuild credit score after bankruptcy contact paypal customer service sears solutions mastercard credit card application high risk unsecured credit good credit cards for poor american express charge apply for credit card fair credit paypal amazon gift card code generator online help build my credit score free wells fargo free credit card generator software credit cards approved home loan with 600 credit score fake free valid credit cards comenity bank credit cards review can you sign up for a pay walmart credit card online get cird card number roblox usernames and passwords 2013 dummy credit cards dor is itunes radio free activate my upromise credit card barclays real credit card numbers and cvv 2013 credit card information generator software download hsbc barclay capital one credit card pre qualify new credit card bad credit unsecured credit cards for fair credit instant approval credit get free virtual stolen credit cards numbers care credit care dental credit card kia gas credit card for bad credit free credit card numbers and security code and expiration date that work 2011 how to repair how to fix bad credit quickly very bad credit card offers free cvv fake social security numbers that work best credit cards for best cars on gas 2014 best retail store credit unsecured credit cards for bad credit fake credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date credit score needed for southwest credit card high risk bad instant approval bad credit business credit cards virtual credit card instant approval citi secured ebay mastercard credit card application credit card generator with cvv2 and exp date on medicine best gas gcard flint free credit card numbers that work 2012 with cvv status on my alaska alaska united airlines credit card application secured credit cards to help rebuild my credit best capital one prepaid business credit cards target walmart credit card application form chevron gas gas credit card for bad credit visa for bad credit unsecured status on my alaska philippine airlines credit card application discover us bank secured credit card status guaranteed secured credit card no exceptions jc reed easy credit cards to get approved postal code for canada first national bank job applications comenity bank processing center phone number card numbers and security animal jam membership codes that work paypal plus citibank credit card mailing address usable visa free valid credit card and cvv2 numbers applying for visa credit easy to get credit card with bad credit credit card generator with cvv2 and zip code visa credit card numbers and security codes free 2013 small business credit credit cards for poor credit wal mart murphy gas card application fake security codes for credit cards fake security cvv kohls personal offer code for credit card prepaid visa free prepaid debit cards for kids how to check santander jcpenney credit card application results free credit card generator with cvv and expiration date 2013 bad credit credit cards secured free no deposit casinos codes free visa credit card number and security code 2014 walmart credit kohls charge card login make payment apply for small business secured credit card bad new york and company credit card payment address tj maxx woes tp www google co za kmart visa walmart credit card application online free credit cards with paypal paypal money generator no survey fake security numbers on fake credit cards that work in american express green card review 2011 free credit card nubers with date visa security code number comenity bank department store credit card list credit cards for bad credit scores with no deposit or processing fee usable visa free credit card and cvv numbers status on my alaska spirit spirit airlines credit card application free cvv mega millions winning numbers 2013 netflix free trial fake credit card generators sign up for capital one credit card online credit card generator with security redbox coupon code 2013 valid credit card numbers with c credit card security code numbers that work fake credit card generator with security code how to apply for marshalls credit card is a nab is kohls credit card easy to get fake credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date 2011 free credit fake credit card security code generator score need for whats apply for a target red card apply for a store credit card that excepts unsecured bad credit
Home Lance Gurewitz GUREWITZ: The Angels and Big Numbers Don’t Mix

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1136 guests online

Atom RSS

GUREWITZ: The Angels and Big Numbers Don’t Mix PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 9
Lance Gurewitz Article Archive
Written by Lance Gurewitz   
Tuesday, 25 January 2011 08:34

“If I'm going to spend $20 million [on Carl Crawford] and go to $144 million without taking care of the bullpen or third base, as a fan, when do you get to the place where you say, 'What are my expectations of the owner, and what am I willing to pay for a ticket?'” –Arte Moreno (Source: Los Angeles Times)

What, indeed, Mr. Moreno?

As expressed previously on The Biz of Baseball, backing away from Carl Crawford’s megadeal was understandable when the money had a chance to be well spent elsewhere. Spending only conservatively on relievers makes plenty of sense, too, although one might argue that is not quite what the Angels did with their multi-year signings of Scott Downs and Hisanori Takahashi. Third base, though, was a painfully obvious place to invest. If the Angels had signed Adrian Beltre at the same terms the Rangers did, he would have been directly replacing a replacement-level combination of third basemen at a cost of $14 million for the first year, setting a break-even point of about 2.7 WAR, which essentially remains the break-even point throughout the contract. Beltre has produced less than 2.5 WAR just once since his first full season in 1999, and that was in 2001. He has a median 3.9 WAR since then and, by the way, is fresh off a 7.1 WAR mark last year, demonstrating that his bat is still a force outside of Seattle and making his contract a calculated risk well worth taking.

The Angels had taken plenty of heat already for their failure to catch either of their seemingly clear top two free agent targets. Initially, at least Moreno had his principles and lower ticket prices to which he could cling for the hope of good PR. Those did nothing for the Angels’ playoff chances, naturally, but even for a big market team, there are worse offenses than being risk-averse.

Then, it happened.

In one fell swoop, the Angels rid themselves of two relatively cheap, useful pieces, Juan Rivera and Mike Napoli, in order to take on one of the consensus worst contracts in Major League Baseball, that of Vernon Wells. Due to the significant backloading of Wells’ deal, this increases the Angels’ 2011 payroll from what it would have been before the trade by approximately $11.5-12.5 million, depending on Napoli’s arbitration outcome. From 2012 onward, the commitment is simply Wells’ salary since the Angels could have had the option to non-tender Napoli after 2011 if they really wanted to save money, or Napoli would become eligible for free agency after 2012. In other words, accounting for the shed Rivera contract and lack of commitment to Napoli, the Angels committed something like $75 million to Wells over the next four years.

Note that Adrian Beltre is only making $62 million over those four years. Oh, and Carl Crawford is only making $74 million.

Now, it would be (quite literally) short-sighted to compare Wells’ deal to only the first four years of Beltre and Crawford’s contracts since, obviously, the ends of those contracts are what makes them most daunting. However, Moreno’s argument for avoiding Crawford was that he would have to raise ticket prices; that argument is driven by the annual salary commitment, not the fact that the deal extends three extra years. Plus, as is well established by research in sabermetrics and sports economics, fans—especially in big markets—are willing to pay more for a superior product. Two years down the road, the Angels’ payroll will be just as high as it would have been if they had signed Crawford or Beltre, and the fans probably will not be nearly as excited to pay the difference.

As for the risk of those extra years on each deal, all of it can be analyzed somewhat conceptually. To earn his contract, as described previously, Adrian Beltre does not even need to match his career average performance. The expectations of Beltre, using a 5% revenue growth estimate, are essentially as follows:

2011: $14 million, $5.25MM/fWAR = 2.7 fWAR
2012: $15 million, $5.5MM/fWAR = 2.7 fWAR
2013: $16 million, $5.8MM/fWAR = 2.8 fWAR
2014: $17 million, $6.1MM/fWAR = 2.8 fWAR
2015: $18 million, $6.4MM/fWAR = 2.8 fWAR
$16 million, $6.7MM/fWAR = 2.4 fWAR

The Angels’ would-be expectations of Crawford, then, are as follows. (Note: These are slightly different than Boston’s expectations due to the luxury tax.)

2011: $14 million, $5.25MM/fWAR = 2.7 fWAR
2012: $19.5 million, $5.5MM/fWAR = 3.5 fWAR
2013: $20 million, $5.8MM/fWAR = 3.4 fWAR
2014: $20.25 million, $6.1MM/fWAR = 3.3 fWAR
2015: $20.5 million, $6.4MM/fWAR = 3.2 fWAR
$20.75 million, $6.7MM/fWAR = 3.1 fWAR

2017: $21 million, $7.035MM/fWAR = 3.0 fWAR

Finally, the Angels’ expectations of the Vernon Wells trade, including the salary shifts described above and the realignment of the Angels’ left field/catcher/DH situation:

2011: $12 million, $5.25MM/fWAR = 2.3 fWAR
2012: $21 million, $5.5MM/fWAR = 3.8 fWAR
2013: $21 million, $5.8MM/fWAR = 3.6 fWAR
2014: $21 million, $6.1MM/fWAR = 3.4 fWAR

This is where intuition comes into play a bit more in the absence of strong projection systems. Nonetheless, few would argue with the claim that Crawford and especially Beltre are significantly more likely to exceed their contract values than Wells, especially in the first four years. Wells’ 2010 season provides the sole glimmer of hope, as he bounced back to 4.0 WAR after accumulating just 3.0 WAR total from 2007-09. Still, there is significant risk that he never reaches that level again, a stark contrast to Beltre and Crawford, who appear poised to outplay the first several years of their contracts with relative ease. Whether the surplus value they create early on will justify the closing years of their contracts is difficult to say, but at least their teams can be confident that some amount of surplus value is on its way.

So what does this mean for Arte Moreno? What should the fans say when the owner goes to $75 million for the wrong player, still without taking care of third base? Well, they should say what they are saying right now, and they should stop wanting to pay. In the future, Mr. Moreno, put wins on the field, and do so not stingily, but wisely, whether that involves big contracts or not. Supply and demand will take care of the rest.

Lance Gurewitz is currently a freshman at the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania. He also serves as the MLB Trade Rumors Florida Marlins Team Coordinator. You can read and discuss his baseball analysis and other sports musings in 140 characters or less by following @LanceWG42 on Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?