norfloxacin prospect mortgage cialis for women free sample revatio generic viramune manufacturer refurbished no prescription aciphex can you get levitra cheap strongest viagra available zyban information http unholymess blog beer brewi canada pharmacy viagra no prescription zyloprim medication allopurinol caffeine in coffee vs red bull zestril generic form retirides otc sleep get lisinopril can i take two cialis oracef antibiotics purchase cialis from canada buspar buspirone reviews rimadyl 25mg for dogs buy promethiazine from out of usa how to bay save viagra warfarin side effects diazepam 5mg side effects tadalafil worldwide reductil diet pills doctor proventil mexico non prescription bactrim viagra from canada by mail lotrel side effects allergic reaction ampicillin for acne side effects accutane buy us unisom natural nights pregnancy low price from china eriacta diarex pro series silicone spray xlpharmacy complaints board forzest ranbaxy pharmaceuticals allopurinol 300 mg tablets picture liposafe ingredients for lasagna usa direct pharmacy milnacipran generic drugs cheap non prescription propecia cardizem drip max dose medazole 500 internal server farmacia online famciclovir 250mg for cats viagra for men price in chennai cialis side effects on women sureway weight loss clinic trinidad lesofat pills viagra details in hindi get valtrex overnight prevacid solutab cost donde puedo conseguir cytotec en panama temovate scalp application novolog 70/30 brand levitra online usa pharmacy cialis not working orabet soccer predictions anxiety definition dictionary sibutramine weight loss results prometrium 200 mg cost adipex weight loss results diprosone 0.05 donormyl ingredients in cigarettes decadron side effects dexamethasone for cats arcoxia 120mg tablets diovan hct medication relafen nabumetone medication guide sildenafil 100mg dapoxetine 60mgsildenafilosildenatilsinequanone vitamix costco 6300 vitamix coupon code bed bath and beyond furolin dosage of tylenol zantac side effects zantac 150 meprate dosage calculations cialis schweiz best online penicillin cytotec pour avorter isotrinion sale quinine side effects tonic water benazepril 10 mg prices asacol 400 replacementaspirin viagra avec ou sans ordonnance aggrenox 25 200 coupons aldactone 50 mg bid where to buy propecia vendita di viagra online prazosin minipress medication estrace estradiol dose cholesterol lowering diet plan mayo clinic viagra vendita on line in italia hoodia diet pills review online medicines photos of flomax side effects medication free overnight viagra shipping propanolol next day delivery pentrexyl dosage information moduretic purchase without prescription tetracycline sale buspar side effects with alcohol advair diskus generic no prescription ampicillin and pregnancy clomipramine tablets online indocin 50 mg indomethacin lisinopril without prescription famvir 500mg for cold sores alzytec medicine cabinets euroclinix reviews on vigrx duloxetine hcl lisinopril side effects shop cialis zithromax and alcohol interaction il viagra della mente vip rx sales consell esportiu lidocaine hydrochloride jelly for hemorrhoids erection pills walgreens etodolac medication side effects temovate gel how supplied ketrel cream use flomax by mail femara buy elimite 5 otc xlpharmacy vip seroquel 25mg dosage trusted viagra sites cialis 100mg online lergigan compuserve phenamax reviews on apidexin antibiotics forsale on line metallica black album torrent walmart viagra cost citalopram cost where to buy man 1 man oil potassium deficiency in plants eszopiclone tablets 2 mg pflanzliches viagra kaufen fasigyn tinidazole infections cialis pills original sifrol pramipexole treatment for bronchitis online pharmacy 47 bystolic supply shortage astelin nasal spray antihistamine biaxin clarithromycin and alcohol axyclovoir in canada metrotab facebook contempt lisinopril no prescription buy neurontin no prescription buy clonidine online overnight delivery aurochem india discount valtrex lawrence walter in india indinavir crixivan/indinavir premarin 1 25 tadalafil 20 mg from india prednisone over the counter equivalent mtabscom blog how much does it cost for amo anxiety attacks and pregnancy stanozolol tablets meds india where can i get clomid in johannesburg buy progynova 2mg tabletspromethazine budesonide side effects medication and alcohol orlistat 120mg capsules side effects generic cialis paypal payment metazole 5 mg how to take megalis 20 tablet walgreens take care clinics locations neurontin medication interactions tamsulosin side effects women lexapro weight loss depression tylenol and motrin recall 2015 pletal medication taking roxifen gelato klopidogrel price chlamydia trachomatis la esquina cabo san lucas minomycin 50mg demerol stromectol bestellen etodolac 300mg capsules generic xenical chinese herbal viagra uk buy zofran uk provera and clomid and metformin lamisil tablete levitra professional 40 mg viagra online spain saroten 25mg sertraline benazepril hydrochloride indian viagra name review acai sambazon rhinathiol infant canada pharmacy discount prescription keppra xr generic where can i buy viagra using paypal online prescription free pharmacy jasmine mickael jordan famvir information trimox 500mg amoxicillin buspar for anxiety attacks viagra red robaxin 500mg for dogs buy spironolactone online no rx flonase coupons free side effects of alfuzosin hcl er 10 mg tablet buy epogen for cats benemid dosage of aspirin progesterone side effects during pregnancy cialis buy greece effexor side effects effexor withdrawal tadalafil 5 mg low cost furosemide cialis want buy precio del viagra en farmacias exelon careers openings dermasone 0.1 cost of valproic acid in uk do low cost viagara pills work walgreens cytotec over the counter macrobid side effects eulexin and pcos symptoms generic staxyn cycline enterprise rental car united states no prescription pharmacy adalat oros side effects lodine online without precription arthrotec 50 diflucan side effects medication rizatriptan benzoate 10 mg side effects buy promethazine w codeine syrup how to used cytitec pill for abortion stromectol doses content analysis research furosemide medication side effects in dogs mirtazapine medication uses accutane canadian pharmacy avalide recalls female viagra without a doctor prescription synthroid vs levothyroxine thyroid cipla seroflo marcumar alternative energy levitra vardenafil side effects voltaren gel dose card print chewable visgra wo bekomme ich viagra cymbalta and weight gain pregnant with twins week by week bystolic 10 mg and grapefruit otc tenormin morphine withdrawal symptoms pheromones for women to women walgreens photo promo code peut on maigrir avec dulcolax 2014 viasek 50mg anavar zofran for children generic viagra dosage recommendations foreign phamacy online doxepin hcl and weight gain tetracyclinein canada zyrtec dosage for dogs allergies cialis commercial actors vicodin withdrawal symptoms opioid clonidine medication for children ciprodex sterile otic suspension for eyes purchase topamax without a prescription adderall withdrawal help lamotrigine withdrawal symptoms online pharmacy escrow buy clomid no prescription uk lortab withdrawal symptoms how long metoprolol side effects metoprolol tartrate buy finasteride 1 mg online indomethacin 50 mg and alcohol zestril side effects dose terbutaline injection canadian drugstore no prescription glucophage 500mg price kamagra jelly ebay uk my ebay phenergan side effects during pregnancy comprar viagra en barcelona dopareel 10 mg hydrocodone glucovance medication drug viagra venta en usa apertium uoc of usa propecia dosage for women toprol xl 50mg medication viagra without credit card buspirone 15 mg information best discounts rx in canada ramipril side effects forum merck stromectol ivermectin come ropinirole hcl 0.5 mg tablet tapiales hoyt voltaren retard 100 catafast dosage for amoxicillin lanoxin generic name irbesartan generic approval cialis preise xanax side effects symptom psicofarmaci online lesofat price manila generika logo philippines pyridium 200mg dose kamagrafast crooksville antivert uk xylocaine injection for knee januvia generic hydrea flower picture primox tablets for toddlers diarex pro series silicone babies orlistat diet pill for sale pravachol generic cost xenical 120 mg buy online microcidal tablets for sale reputable pharmacy in canada chigualos ejemplos de curriculum synthroid side effects forum propranolol side effects beta blockers avanafil stendra antabuse side effects disulfiram like effect buy levothyroxine 75 levobiotic 500 mg buy resperidone no perscrpyion sildenafil cheapest price thyroxine hormone functions buy cheap amoxicillin online duetact for diabetes praziquantel side effects on dogs prevacid dosage for adults where to buy 5 mg cialis luvox generic name cefixime paypal low cost cialis 20mg buy estrogen ramipril 10mg capsules lady era pills reviews da narucim cialis buy candy echeck viagra tablet price frumil fortesta buy fucidin cream canada adalat xl 30 mirtazapine 15 mg dose mail order prescriptions from canada fastest viagra uk delivery cialis in canada online xalatan generic trazodone without a prescription fin vicenza fitness diamox 500 mg price generic daily cialis how to get narcotics online aprovel 300mg side effect bactrim ordering information without rx cockapoo rescue indiana ativan medication for seizures buspar reviews depression augmentin 875 mg and alcohol using latisse for eyebrows flovent side effects in cats venlafaxine xr without a prescription eprex injection subcutaneous anastrozole 1 mg men viagra jelly drugs eye products terramycin malegra 50 buy letrozole online levofloxacin antibiotic alcohol acyclovir zovirax ru torsemide dosage for adults comprar cytotec en usa serophene 50mg ranitidine medication for dogs nexium coupons 90 day esquina famosa puerto rico doxazosin mesylate side effects in women anafranil dosages online pharmacy for viagra to china snorting buspirone to get high keftab infolanka blycolin groep t kann man kamagra in der apotheke kaufen deltasone 20mg ambien can you use cephalexin for sinus infection puretone music shop vilches radio asthma action plan template amikacin antibiotic side effects bestliferx pharmacy orderpharma reviews 50 combivent inhaler discount coupons pharmacy direct viagra keppra level monitoring sotalol side effects betapace side diarex stone tools viagra brazil buy levofloxacin donepezil hcl classificationdormidina buy kamagra next day delivery finpecia pharmacy metoprolol tartrate side effects water retention application form format in word compra de floxet sin receta depakote er 500mg medication side effects dostinex india obat nizoral estrace cream coupon irbesartan 150 mg picture actos diabetes medication side effects baclofen 20 mg street value avapro dosage levels careprost eyelash $10 viagra pill price naproxen sodium 550 mg informacion en espanol digoxin therapeutic levels for heart failure costco catalog letrozole gynecomastia review cardinal community credit union credit card tadacip 20 mg cipro tinidazole 500mg duphaston 10mg indication post cycle therapy nolvadex slimex reviews buy viagra shopping online in europe buy viagra online in ca usa inderal for migraines in children azulfidine sulfasalazine dosage forms maxolon injection amoxicillin 875 mg uses captopril capoten dosage zyrtec d side effects taking astelin spray dosage price of janumet mexico diamox side effects acetazolamide 500 mail order cialis generic over the counter permethrin cream 200mg viagra bactrim ds/septra ds side effects jasmine waltz david arquette ampicilina mexapin wholesale viagra pills www buycialisonlinecheap cephalexin dosage for dogs escitalopram 20 mg picture wo kann ich kamagra oral jelly kaufen purchase alli sialis tablets for kids progesterone suppositories cost progesterone cream and fertility order cialis online in canada reviews cialis sublingual cheap tadalafil 10 mg rezeptfrei order online synthroid with master card ventolin evohaler 100 micrograms genetic viagra using mastercard anxiety and depression in teens fedex viagra generic kamagra oral jelly uk delivery 270 terramycin antibiotic ophthalmic ointment viagra replacement over the counter sertraline 50mg tablets dianabol steroids for sale cialis 5mg online kaufen potassium permanganate boiling point rizatriptan 10 mg what is zestoretic 20 12.5 mg generic cialis fedex zithromax dosage for children by weight free sample of viagra can you get high off trazodone viagra south africa next day viagra uk order roboxin on line garrigue wines mex select viagra products kemadrin discontinued davids bridal dresses xenical weight loss success stories sublingual nitroglycerin administration kamagra uk co levitra on line sale tetracycline purchase canada viagra online pharmacy 150 mg buy finasteride online kamagra mumbai online rx without prescription arava side effects side effects aciclovir crema tratament tantalum metal suppliers tantalum long beach restaurant great online pharmacy india kamagra best rx pill ciplafield eas req status epilepticus venlafaxine er 75mg chlamydia pneumoniae causes buy wellbutrin online best online levitra desogen birth control and acne buy valium from indian pharmacist
Home Maury Brown Saying Kevin Brown's 7-Year Deal with the Dodgers was Bad Shouldn't Be Mystifying

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 765 guests online

Atom RSS

Saying Kevin Brown's 7-Year Deal with the Dodgers was Bad Shouldn't Be Mystifying PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 53
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 04 January 2011 01:16

Kevin BrownNOTE: This article has now been featured in The New York Times "Bats" blog (see Kevin Brown’s Contract: Another View)


Uncle Moneybags has busted open the purse-strings this off-season. Be it Jayson Werth, Carl Crawford, or Cliff Lee, lucrative multi-year deals far in excess of $100 million have been inked as if money were going out of style.

Be it the Yankees losing the ALCS. Be it the Rangers looking to keep what was already there, the bidding war that was occurring between the two clubs for Cliff Lee’s services had offers on the table that could have ranged as long as seven years and $150 million.

As I said during the time leading up to Lee’s decision, which landed him not in New York or Arlington, but Philadelphia, it was all reminiscent of Kevin Brown’s contract.

On Monday, Dan Rosenheck wrote a piece in The New York Times’ "Keeping Score" column (see For Critics of Lee’s Contract, Brown Deal Is Not Supporting Evidence). In it, Rosenheck opines:

As the dollars and years mounted in the offers to Cliff Lee this off-season, many pessimistic observers invoked the specter of the game’s most infamous pitching contract: the seven-year, $105 million deal signed in 1998 by the surly sinkerballer Kevin Brown. His name has become synonymous with free-agent excess, and serves as a cautionary tale for any general manager contemplating a long-term contract with a pitcher.

“All I could think of was Kevin Brown,” Maury Brown, who runs the Web site The Biz of Baseball, wrote at the height of the bidding war for Lee. He warned that Lee’s suitors were “setting themselves up for a bad contract” and risked losing “all sense of common sense.”

There’s no doubting that seven-year deals for pitchers in their 30s are often bad bets. However, the choice of Brown to personify this is mystifying...

Rosenheck may not be singling me out for the piece (I am, however, the only one quoted in the article). Dan is someone that I have been interviewed by prior through The NY Times, as well as The Economist. It’s likely that he was just using me as a straw man for his position. Be that as it may, here’s some numbers that “demystifies” my position on the Kevin Brown deal.

In fairness, the contract that former Dodgers GM Kevin Malone brokered with Brown may not be the worst long-term deal ever offered a pitcher, but it’s remembered as the beginning of them. Mike Hampton... Barry Zito... there have been others. The point is, any GM worth their salt wouldn’t engage in contracts of such length unless that was an exit plan, or at the very least options that include the bullpen.

The Brown deal with the Dodgers was for 7-years with $105 million as the base salary, an eye-popper at the time, and for good reason. When accounting for inflation, that would translate to $141 million in 2010 dollars. But that was just the base. There was also a $10 million bonus, 8 premium season tickets; 12 private jet round trip, and ground transportation to his home in Macon, GA or selected games in season, plus private jet round trips with ground transportation to post-season away games. He also was afforded a suite on the road. In terms of perks, the Brown deal is consider one of -- if not the – granddaddy of them all.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE THE REST OF THIS ARTICLE

 

 

Scott Boras represented Brown when he signed in the 1998 off-season at the age of 33. Boras had represented Greg Maddux in his 5-year deal that had exceeded its value, and that likely played into talks with Malone. While Brown was coming off a spectacular season in 1997 with the Padres, by the time the long-term deal with the Dodgers would end, he would be 40, which posed risk in terms of performance decline and possible injury.

While the market in terms of dollars and years for position players were running extraordinarily high, pitchers are not position players. In salary arbitration, MLB’s method for assigning salary value to players in a certain service time level, you compare apples to apples. Comparing pitchers to position players would be a non-starter. Comparables to Brown might be Randy Johnson in 1997 ($6,325,000), but that had been the year he had come in second in Cy Young voting and two years after he won the AL Cy Young. Johnson would not earn more than Brown in the deal’s yearly salary (minus the 1999 salary that was $10 million, plus) until 2004 with the Diamondbacks. By then, he had won four Cy Young awards and was a World Series co-MVP. Another comp would be Pedro Martinez. For Martinez, who won 3 Cy Youngs and came in second in the voting twice, he only had one season (2004) when he earned more than all but the first year of the Brown contract ($17,500,000).

In 1999, the first year of the deal, Brown made $10,714,286, ranked 3rd in strikeouts (221) behind Johnson, and Pedro; 2nd in IP (252.1) over 35 games behind only Johnson; 5th in ERA (3.00) behind Pedro Martinez, Johnson, Kevin Millwood, and Mike Hampton. He landed 3rd in Cy Young voting, was an All-Star, and garnered 16th in MVP voting. His Value Over Replacement Player (VORP) was 71.6, ranking him 5th in the league, while his Wins Above Replacement (WAR) was 5.8, down from 8.4 the year prior. It was one of Brown’s best years under the Dodgers’ deal, and one that surely had the club thinking that they made a great deal. He goes 18-9, while the Dodgers finish third in the NL West, going 77-85 (.475)

He followed up 1999 with another strong season in 2000, garnering 6th in NL Cy Young voting and an All-Star selection, his WAR jumped to 6.5, and his VORP moved up to 82.6 behind only Johnson, and Pedro’s season that is considered one of the best all-time.

But it’s here that the wheels fall off, and why looking at long-term pitcher contracts from selected years often runs into a wall.

In 2001, Brown injures his neck and then in July tears his flexor muscle in his right elbow. Because of it, he winds up throwing almost half the innings pitched from the year prior (115.2) over 19 games. His salary, locked in at $15,714,286 over the remainder of the seven year deal hangs with Brown through 2002 where he musters just 63.2 IP over 10 games where his WAR drops into negative numbers (-0.4).

Brown bounces back in 2003, landing an All-Star selection, goes 14-9 with a 2.39 ERA, which lands him 3rd best in the league over 211 IP, not as great as he was early on in the contract, but still 26th overall in Innings Pitched.

In the off-season, the Dodgers, wisely seeing that Brown has gained at least some value back after his elbow injury, trade him to the Yankees who are looking for someone to fill-in for the departed Andy Pettitte. The trade saved Malone from not being the only one smitten with a career spike. The Bombers give the Dodgers Jeff Weaver and two minor league prospects. To add, the Yankees throw in $3 million cash in the deal and agree to pay $1.5 million a year on the remainder of Weaver’s $9.25 million contract.

It turns into a disappointment for the Yankees. At 39, Brown goes 10-6 with a 4.09 ERA in 122 IP, 79 fewer than he threw the year prior in his final year with the Yankees. It wasn’t terrible but far from worth close to $16 million. His WAR is now 2.5.

His final year in the Majors, he has 13 game starts, goes 4-7 with a 6.50 ERA and a -0.9 WAR.

Breaking it down, what you get with Kevin Brown is really 3.5 exceptional years (1999 thru July of ’01 and 2003) and 3.5 years of injury and decline.  His 7-year, $105 million deal winds up looking like this:

72-45 (.585) with a 3.72 ERA over 172 games and 1076.2 IP.

To wrap this up…

There’s a reason the Phillies had only given 3-year deals to pitchers… Until Cliff Lee’s 5-year contract this off-season.  It was due to risk.

The Dodgers didn’t ink the deal with Brown thinking about only getting half of the years in value. And remember, this is during the steroid era. While Brown never tested positive, he was linked to the Mitchell Report (see page 263 – PDF) through Kirk Radomski who said Brown contacted him after the injuries in 2001 asking about hGH. According to Radomski, over the next two or three years he sold performance-enhancing substances to Brown five or six times.

Maybe the best person to speak about whether the Kevin Brown deal was good or bad was the man who made the deal for Kevin Brown in the first place.

“Did it make sense?” Kevin Malone said to The New York Times in early Dec. “No. Seven years for a pitcher is a lifetime. It’s just scary, and any general manager who tells you it isn’t, well, I’m not sure what calculations they are going by.”

When you want to talk bad pitcher contracts, you start with the Kevin Brown deal with the Dodgers due to it being a shining example of the risks (and high salary) associated with it. That shouldn’t be mystifying.

NOTE: Kevin Brown should never be considered a bad pitcher by any stretch due to the Dodgers signing him to a long contract. Indeed, Brown is on the Hall of Fame ballot for the first time this year. The announcement of who is elected to the HOF will take place Weds. at 2pm ET.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey, as well as a contributor to FanGraphs and Forbes SportsMoney. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?