prednisone 100 mg day order effexor xr 150mg brand levitra sale 100mg online pharmacy how to get plavix aspirin max dose rogaine 2 for men sale in uk buy augmentin no prescription infections safe buy prilosec online best prandin prices drugs prescription buy zyban patch rosuvastatin on line does viagra work for young men cheap amaryllis bulbs uk where to buy tamoxifen in australia canadian bupropion where to buy in canada atorvastatin calcium tablets spc +buy brand viagra in us us online pharmacy no rx keflex prices usa order atarax grifulvin v cost in canada side effects of serevent inhaler menosan usa sale buy geriforte syrup hong kong zyrtec 10mg twice a day going off lexapro weight loss lasix retard capsules comprar prograf portugal ventolin cost ireland mirapex withdrawal symptoms liposafe rx cheapest dipyridamole in the uk xbox live price increase activision amaryl canadian medications without prescription starlix reviews where is baclofen metabolized proscar roche precio argentina abilify tablets supplied acheter etodolac pas cher order neurontin 300mg online inderal 10 mg migraine erection packs 2 discount prescription over the counter antibiotic cream for boils new coumadin medicine rumalaya forte overnight pharmacy generic for prevacid not working cialis without a doctor seroquel us sales hyzaar generic ingredients ventolin side effects in children puerto rico restaurant puerto rico levitra side effects vision liquid geriforte review coreg cr rxlist zyban reviews 2011 is there a generic prevacid switching from paxil to zoloft forum generic cytotec switzerland long term side effects of taking mobic nike air max 2012 men sale buy lamictal astrailia cialis canada cheap do i need a prescription for vermox certificated indian pharmacy strattera billig nitroglycerin online kaufen seroflo over counter uk augmentin mexico companies only aciphex coupons printable viagra super active cheap canada pharmacy best place to buy voltaren in uk how long does it take for tegretol to leave your system where to buy alligator meat in orlando calan over the counter generic pills for dilantin half price wellbutrin tinidazole woldwide shipping cheap online pharmacy usa nolvadex dosage for men pharmacy express canada reviews can you get high off wellbutrin do you need rx anafranil all types cytotec pills cheap aceon us overnight delivery buy flovent online cheap side effects of urispas tablet rogaine 5 sublingual dosage erexin-v for sale australia what type of medicine is diflucan zanaflex online pharmacy store abilify tablets and oral solution how to get levaquin on line doxycycline for dogs dosage viagra rhine inc x-wing alliance purchase non generic mircette purchase generic skelaxin benzac generic 2013 drugs floxin sold over counter order premarin 120 mg compare prices yagara overseas pharmacy no prescription cabgolin gabapentin dosage bnf cheap genuine eldepryl online vpxl for sale australia purchase medrol in australia is generic viagra available now adalat overnight florinef brands india ranitidine liquid price comprare nolvadex online buy alli 140 refill can you cut wellbutrin xl tablets half brand biaxin buy snovitra super power pas cher canadian pharmasudicals where can i get zestril order depakote online no prescription with a amex cheap rumalaya liniment pills buy dostinex paypal accepted mirapex discount card glass in generic lipitor levitra without prescriptions uk purchase sinemet pills buy cabgolin in india online purchasing furosemide online what is the dose for cardizem bupropion smoking cessation dosage dangers of too much thyroid medication mexican hydrochlorothiazide para que se usa trental ranitidine italiano geneza pharmaceuticals nolvadex reviews order birth control online texas drugstore coupon code 10 order differin cream online discount non prescription chloromycetin pharmacy buy lithium carbonate uk forzest online kaufen pharmacy abilify overnight delivery cod buy albuterol sulfate inhalation solution 0.083 ceftin without a prescription from us discount coversyl of canada when will plavix be available in generic form get a prescription for propecia what is the dosage for nexium costco pharmacy crestor what is cialis medicine used for buy bactrim online canada no prescription all types benadryl pills buy acivir pills 20 effexor xr price comparison mexican pharmacy no prescription ashwagandha generic minocin safe plavix prescription help azulfidine cost in canada candida pharmacy zofran coupons how to take aceon mg provera mexico companies only bupropion hcl xl 300 mg tablet picture amoxil dosage calculator best price for omnicef wellbutrin side effects long term use how much is diamox tablets olanzapine order on web bayer low dose aspirin coupons generic viagra jelly cost cholestoplex order by phone ciplox limited india dipyridamole weight gain zithromax chlamydia dutas online usa is generic zyprexa available in usa buy brand levitra greece western drug biaxin side effects of yasmin pill weight zebeta with paypal payment buy xeloda.500 mg leukeran drug classification ceftin no prescription compare prices vermox from amoxil in canada allegra where to purchase comprar unisom pela internet lotensin dosage route will i buy viagra over the counter in canada where to buy online drugs in the netherlands ? 24h pharmacy east london aceon mg buy digoxin delivery uk cyproheptadine periactin 4 mg emsam shortage buy citalopram 20mg uk kolla pa* filmer online gratis one guy one jar video side effects of zyprexa in elderly redustat capsulas dosis safe brand levitra buy evecare buy on line what is diflucan tablets used for uk version of chloramphenicol what pain medicine does not contain aspirin megalis 20 tab fastest brand amoxil uk delivery prednisone legal in england nature;s way hydraplenish hyaluronic acid serum reviews buy alphagan brimonidine tartrate bactrim australia companies only diltiazem tablets side effects tamoxifen buy digoxin purchase strattera 40 mg price where to buy ceftin ointment how to buy differin online buy furosemide for daily use medrol dosepak drug interactions keflex dosage for strep throat triamterene online store prescription drugs online without prescriptions prednisone over the counter dog alli diet pills out of stock order albendazole on line india fucidin h buy toradol order on web over the counter pills to kill you without a transcript order desyrel how to order female viagra online lotrisone discount voucher where can i buy abortion pills in stores buy alesse pills in the canada prilosec supplier in uk doxycycline acne effectiveness best site for bactrim comprar avodart portugal cialis cheap generic spironolactone hirsutism mechanism prograf 5 mg price nexium otc dosage ndc code for depo medrol 40 mg buy terramycin hong kong premarin on the internet nexium store generic pharmacy near mercy hospital speman suppliers overseas wellbutrin sr generic release date cheap atorlip-5 pills most reliable place to buy lotensin online hydrochlorothiazide generic form valsartan buy keflex in india online cheap per pill actos online voveran sr online price can i make ciplox over the counter medicine celebrex clomid over counter medicine phenergan tablets us online cheap coversyl canada can i buy advair diskus in canada buy endep xr without prescription hoodia without prescription long bactrim shelf life viagra soft woldwide shipping pan american lithium stock dramamine tablets price diamox prescription pletal drug schedule cleocin tablets 40mg antivert maximum dose suppliers of elimite in us generic pills for atorlip-10 acai in the uk now what does zyrtec liquid gels look like how to use nizoral shampoo for acne low amitriptyline back pain why is there a shortage of finpecia where to buy alligator clips canada recently generic propecia us mastercard where to buy cheap generic urispas orlistat without perscription uk cabergoline during ivf buying wellbutrin xl online purchase kamagra india proventil hfa coupons buy cheap fincar using pay pal american cialis jelly is mail order cytoxan safe buy cheap levitra from china fastest cephalexin uk delivery cialis 72 hour coumadin online uk how do i get viagra in australia nitrofurantoin 100 mg and monohydrate macrocrystals what is amitriptyline hcl prescribed for where buy viagra in singapore canadian-pharmacy-femara buy cozaar no prescription fast delivery phenamax uk buy women viagra for sale can get accutane over counter high blood pressure medication prices is there a generic form for cymbalta online phexin india buy albendazol without prescrition generic betnovate uk paypal propranolol drugstore.com waheed alli diamox tablets 250mg prevacid generico online can you crush bactrim pills where to buy viagra from online cheap prilosec buy online cheap lotrel 40 mg side effects of florinef fludrocortisone how to use zovirax herbal sex pill reviews mexican online pharmacy percocet purchase generic rumalaya forte methotrexate side effects skin glucotrol xl store cvs rx pharmacy order maxalt antibiotics products norco bikes 2012 cheap antibiotics online cost where can i buy prednisone for my dog what is colchicine tablets pharmaceutical society ireland ayurslim price singapore buy tenormin generic can i make estrace reglan prices usa lukol from usa us pharmacy online brand levitra how to order alligator meat guarantee generic allegra paypal vermox for discount venlor prescription coupon amaryllis south florida actoplus met over counter uk purchase deltasone pills tofranil from usa nitrofurantoin patient reviews pill genuine discount viagra online levitra can you buy order aceon online chloramphenicol capsules dosage online cipro purchase comprar periactin en argentina insulin pen uk artane castle opening hours to buy lamisil reviews on acai berry slim 500 mg doxycycline viagra vs cialis vs levitra 2012 elocon ointment coupons generic drug to replace benicar can benadryl make you sleepy the next day generic brand amoxil where can i get rabeprazole buy trimox 50 diclofenac during breastfeeding what is levothroid prescribed for where to buy alligator clips for making hair bows mircette birth control pills side effects of medrol pack cheapest procardia to buy what is estrace cream buy cheap cabana online buy florinef cheap over the counter substitute for premarin liquid fertomid review zyloprim over the couter lopressor iv dose how to get a prescription without a doctor cheap one buy diflucan xeloda where to get generic viagra jelly us what are the side effects of endep 10 losartan potassium & hydrochlorothiazide tablets lithium orotate buy uk buy cordarone discount minocycline tablets for sale best healthy mango smoothie generic name for albenza metformin drugs like dispersible aspirin overdose effects of augmentin in pregnancy purchase prednisolone online zofran coupon code amitriptyline migraine prevention aristocort prescription only cytotec canada overnight delivery actos cost at walmart best online pharmacy generic colospa purchase suhagra on line in usa side effects of long term prednisone use for asthma cost of baclofen without insurance actoplus met drug schedule cost of seroquel without insurance propecia pris femara tablets 40mg indocin pregnancy class medrol 16mg tab generic silagra comprar brand viagra online buying rumalaya forte for dogs plendil tablets for purchase what is accutane therapy safe to buy generic compazine from canada how to buy nolvadex in australia order cialis with prescription motilium barato viagra soft sale generic synthroid overnight pharmacy order buy deltasone online pharmacy strattera without a script prezzo levitra in italia buying penegra using paypal synthroid pills wiki cialis super active india companies only buy propecia finpecia can you order rhinocort allergy symptoms diabecon canadian pharmacy naprosyn for sale online discount pharmacy kingston jamaica accutane no prescription uk rumalaya forte with american express can you buy cialis professional in ireland 20mg tadalafil ephedraxin uses medication buy advair online without prescription diclofenac medication orlistat canada over the counter cheap hytrin what does celexa do for depression neurontin discount para q se usa el zantac buy clomid online no prescription usa aldactone 25mg bodybuilding can i get pregnant on tegretol generic venlor no prescription venlor online bestellen buy sertraline online no prescription uk medicine cholestoplex online pharmacy vytorin coupons allegra-d side effects constipation ordering propecia online is a pain free experience comprar remedio allegra cheap buy ampicillin online prices buy pariet pills amoxil buy generic buy accutane without a script cheap robaxin free delivery what does ranbaxy lipitor look like motrin supplier in uk can order atacand canada ayurslim drugstore.com where to buy cheap generic colchicine dove aquistre cialis ipledge accutane canada best diet to lose weight fast without pills pictures of digoxin pills generic version of differin gel is mail order aciphex safe adalat usa cvs prices buy benicar 100 buyers of midamor canada western drug baclofen best place to order deltasone in us neurontin price australia online sale of allopurinol nitroglycerin shortage 2009 acivir pills pharmacies canadian online how much will lotrisone cost the heart rate of a healthy young male or female is is zantac available over the counter in canada suhagra online bestellen original prazosin online over the counter ventolin australia prinivil sale order proscar fedex tadacip best price synthroid doses 50 mcg asacol side effects weight loss zyloprim generic name orlistat women buy keftab delivery london is mail order xeloda safe cialis de 5 mg en mexico bactrim lawsuit settlements bystolic buy cheap best place buy septilin pct sale dostinex robaxin medication canada doryx acne worse order minipress online no prescription with a echeck buy generic v-gel online bactroban pediatric dose flomax relief launch bbc s order non generic fincar how to be a healthy man can you get diflucan otc ventolin delivery london strattera in the uk now nombre generico zyloprim pastillas para tener ereccion duradera flomax generic cost without prescription cost comparison cod cheap stromectol micardis plus 40 12.5 mg side effects can i make zofran indian pharmacy aspirin orlistat fast india trental no prescription reviews online pharmacy uk brand levitra alli weight loss pill in australia propranolol medication where to buy purchase cheap fexofenadine generic allegra etodolac brand positioning fucidin sale where can i get zovirax pills order cipro uk pharmacy side effects of asacol 400mg Purchase cephalexin 250mg capsules phenergan prescription coupon isoniazid canadian source buying serophene using paypal mirapex class action lawsuit canada aspirin shop net buy nizagara canadian what does synthroid 100 mcg look like where can i buy zovirax online rogaine 5 shop net canadian levothroid tablet how to take brahmi powder for memory hytrin uses medication cialis professional buy india buy nymphomax quick endep for sleep tablet viagra cialis trial pack where do i lexapro in usa cy cialis how to buy clomid without rx best place buy cordarone zoloft 50 mg tablet how to order myambutol what is clonidine hcl 0.1 mg prescribed for order mestinon online uk neurontin lawsuit 2010 insulin pen instructions fucidin h shelf life brahmi over the couter forum despre viagra acheter requip tenormin 50mg side effects elocon generic name cheap glucophage uk reviews on brahmi amla hair oil purchase abilify 5mg prescription where to buy acai products revatio 20 mg tid acheter depakote pas cher antibiotics alcohol nhs uk version of floxin cheap digoxin 0.1 mg generic dipyridamole uk paypal order voltaren 100mg online generic for diclofenac sodium buy aceon 50 buy actos online amazon adalat echeck trental nome generico research grade decadron ceftin side effects dizziness tenormin buy online canada cheap avalide 300 25mg
Home All Articles Carroll: Voting Buster

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 966 guests online

Atom RSS

Carroll: Voting Buster PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 9
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Will Carroll   
Monday, 15 November 2010 14:57

Will CarrollEDITORS NOTE: The BBWAA has announced that Buster Posey wins the NL ROY award, while Neftali Feliz wisn the AL ROY


Special to BizofBaseball.com

Since being invited to join the BBWAA in 2008, I've been given the honor of voting for three awards. I think that while the BBWAA awards aren't perfect, I do believe that it's a solid system that is taken seriously by all voters. Sure, I'd like to see broadcasters eligible to vote, but this is a writers organization, so that's not changing any time soon. Last year, I had a controversial vote for the NL Cy Young, casting what many thought was the vote that cost Chris Carpenter the award. Cardinals fans still haven't forgiven me, despite the fact that I voted Adam Wainwright #1 over eventual winner Tim Lincecum.

My NL Rookie of the Year vote is unlikely to be as controversial, but I do think it will be more key, in the sense that I believe it will be an extremely close vote. Last season, I didn't even include the eventual winner, Chris Coghlan, on my three-man ballot. This year, it was a two man race for most of the second half. Once Jaime Garcia went down, it was pretty clear that the award would come down to Buster Posey and Jason Heyward. I cast my vote for Posey and as announced, Posey has won. The vote wasn't as close as I expected with Posey getting 20 first place votes and 9 second place votes, with Heyward getting a mirror of 9 and 20.

I think its fine that there are many different methodologies for how various voters make their selections, as long as those voters are also willing to "show their work." Mine was based on three factors: defensive position, opportunity, and results. Yes, for me, if all things were equal - and they were pretty close to that - then I feel playing catcher creates a "degree of difficulty" that would be worthy of tipping the results. Posey is not a great catcher by any measure, statistical or scouting, but he was good enough to not need a defensive caddy. He managed a solid but erratic pitching staff on a playoff contender and that has some value.

The argument on the last two are intertwined. Jason Heyward has the better counting stats, due in part to the fact that the Braves elected to have him start on Opening Day. Posey, held back either for "defensive seasoning" or for financial reasons, didn't have as much of an opportunity, but made the most of the time he had. Heyward had a higher "WAR" than Posey (5.0 to 3.9), but again, this is largely on the basis of opportunity. Posey didn't ask to be sent back down and it's hard to argue he could have done much more than what he did during his time in the minors to force his way up.

Posey had the better rate stats for the most part, making the most of his opportunities. Posey was healthier as well, showing no obvious slumps during his season. Admittedly, more time behind the plate might have caused problems, but it seemed that Bruce Bochy was able to spot Posey into the 1B slot as needed, keeping his bat while not exposing him to the physical problems catchers get with extensive time behind the plate. While Posey only played catcher about half the time of a normal, full season starter, I can't hold that against him. As someone who's called for players like Joe Mauer to be moved from behind the plate, it would be hypocritical to devalue the protection of Posey.

I also spoke to scouts, players, and executives, putting a special emphasis on those that had seen them play more than just a handful of times. While I saw a lot of video, that's hardly the same thing. Almost to a man, they couldn't put much differentiation between the two. The words "special" and "superstar" kept coming up, and it's hard to disagree. Both Posey and Heyward are the types of players, on and off the field, that a franchise can build around. They're similar ages, though two years will likely help Heyward when it comes to the career numbers and gives him a bit more projectability than Posey, who scouts think "is what he is." One said, "he's not going to get much better, but that's not a bad thing. He's one of the top catchers in the NL right now and if he gets better behind the plate, he could be in the conversation with [Joe] Mauer."

One NL Central pitcher who faced both couldn't add much. "They're both tough outs and seem to come to the plate with a plan. Heyward can hurt you more with the power, but he seemed to get exposed a bit more as the season went on. I think some of that was the physical toll. Posey just seemed to learn and get better. Now that they're both getting some playoff experience now makes me wonder if he'll go another level next year." (Note that the vote was turned in before the playoffs.)

If it was possible to cast a tied ballot, I would have seriously considered that. This was, for me, a very difficult decision, one I considered and reconsidered, writing it each way before finally hitting send on my emailed ballot to Jack O'Connell. Both Posey and Heyward will be getting plenty of awards as they move through what look to be great baseball careers. Congratulations to Buster Posey on the NL Rookie of the Year Award and to all the other BBWAA award winners to be announced over the week.

One final note: I considered voting for Neil Walker over Jaime Garcia. Walker has been in Indianapolis for a while and is a guy I rooted for once he finally got the chance with the Pirates. I couldn't make an objective case for him and don't believe that personal interests should enter into these awards, so I didn't. Interestingly, someone voted for Walker with a second place vote. I'd be very curious to hear the reasoning for that one. I don't know if the BBWAA will release the voting the way they did with the NL Cy Young last year.


Will Carroll is a member of both the BBWAA and the PFWA. He writes about fantasy football at SI.com and resides near Indianapolis. You can follow him at @injuryexpert on Twitter.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?