kamagra online cheapest 50 mg viagra online heavy mg viagra viagra genuine online lisinopril 2.5 mg used where viagra buy safe generic cialis cialis 5 mg dailyreviews cialis generico foro viagra online ecuador zithromax 250 mg 6 kaps levitra online malaysia cheap quality viagra clomid 50 mg iui generic lisinopril appearance antidepressants citalopram 20mg medicamento generico celebrex cialis 20 mg pills wellbutrin 150 mgs viagra 60 mg prednisone 10 mg cost generic propecia finasteride viagra online germany viagra 50 mg etkisi xenical online review medikament nexium 20mg cialis super generic pret viagra 50mg viagra online.pl levitra 10mg bayer buy clomid 150mg generic viagra tablets levitra buy toronto propranolol hcl 60 mg cialis 10mg lilly prednisone 40 mg tablets buy amoxil amoxicillin 10 mg cialis online malaysia buying cialis augmentin 250 mg thuoc levitra 2.5 mg feedback doxycycline acne 200 mg generic zithromax walmart lexapro 5 mg insomnia cialis 2.5mg cheap gen lexapro 20 mg online viagra 25 mg lisinopril 20 mg identification cheap kamagra fast glucophage forte 850 mg metformin abz 500 mg levitra wiki mg xenical generic name about zoloft 50mg achat cialis 10mg generic medication propecia buying 2.5 mg cialis viagra 100mg poveikis cheap propecia 5 mg viagra cheap fast take cialis 20mg cialis dosage 30 mg lisinopril 40 mg walmart online order valtrex 150mg buy viagra 50mg viagra tablets lexapro tablets 20mg order propecia finasteride purchase 2.5 mg cialis augmentin 600 mg dosis online propecia subscription viagra 100 mg tab buy doxycycline generique cheap viagra store periactin online bestellen buy viagra belgium viagra online secure cheapest propecia buy cialis 20mg e20 150 mg viagra at prednisone 120 mg daily doxycycline dose 100 mg cheap cialis 10mg generic celebrex reviews cheap viagra overnight buy propecia cheapest doxycycline onlineamerica nolvadex buy canada viagra generico bogota zoloft at 50 mg 1cheap generic cialis cheap viagra generic propecia 1 mg cost zovirax buy generic lexapro 10 mg opinie generic antidepressant lexapro propecia generic pharmacy nexium 20 mg kaina buy viagra clenbuterol online cialis prices lexapro 10mg us thuoc kamagra 5omg viagra 100 mg pdr lasix 40mg shop clomid 3 months 50 mg lisinopril 5 mg tabletas metformin stada 1000 mg doxycycline 75 mg capsules augmentin 500 mg dosage tetracycline online kaufen generic viagra capsuals cialis 10mg potecy buying viagra kl canada cialis 20 mg viagra 150 mg buy cialis everyday online cipro 500 mg alcohol 150mg clomid follicles wellbutrin generic issues viagra ireland buy prednisone online 5 mlg cialis 10mg hinta 20mg levitra price ivax lisinopril 40mg nexium 40 mg sale generic valtrex usa zovirax 400 mg dosis generic cialis 5 milligrams prednisone 20mg rash lexapro online india lexapro order online prospect viagra 50 mg safest viagra online cialis 20 mg lily forum cialis 40 mg doxycycline 100mg sunlight augmentin 625mg pregnancy viagra montreal cheap strattera 100mg cost diflucan 100mg pret order viagra plus viagra online ua glucophage xr 1500 mg levitra 5 mg schmelztabletten metformin 750 mg levitra bucodispersable 5 mg amoxil 100 mg piqure metformin 500 mg order cialis 20mg valor buy propecia 5 mg clomid 200 mg cheap tadalafil cialis cialis 12 20 mg nexium 20 mg haitat doxycycline 20mg generic propranolol 40 mg used propranolol de 20 mg generic viagra greece cialis 2.5mg cheaper propranolol 1mg augmentin 156 mg ulotka buy generic nexium sildenafil 100 mg viagra kamagra 100mg sk viagra and 500mg clomid canada buy cialis 5 mgr belgie zithromax 600mg packet buy propecia edmonton order cialis mexico nexium online buy bactrim 500 mg bula 75 mg viagra generic cialis 10 ili 20 mg pastile cialis 20mg celebrex capsule 400 mg harga levitra 10 mg buy nexium 40 mg prednisone dog potent 20mg levitra buy clomid dallas priligy generico foro buy synthroid online cap augmentin 625mg diflucan 1540 mg prednisone 2omg clomid proviron online buy viagra onlines propranolol online pharmacy buy nolvadex generic cialis day 5 mg xenical 120mg wikipedia zithromax 1200 mg suspension pill zoloft 50 mg levitra 10 pills online cheap malaysia cialis 50 mg viagra wellbutrin hcl generic cipro generic walgreens buy viagra korea viagra 100mg nl viagra generic eu propecia cheapest buy buy cialis florida wellbutrin generic target viagra 100mg buying cytotec 100 mg cipro 1000 mg bula medication cipro 500 mg metformin gsk 500mg buy prednisone prescription cheap viagra discount augmentin 200 mg suspension lisinopril dosage 60 mg buy cialis bangalore zovirax 400 mg cialis de 5mgs cialis 5 mg einnahme lexapro 20 mg ml viagra 100 mg wikipedia generic wellbutrin bloating celebrex online uk cialis generic walmart istanbulbuy viagra vibramycin doxycycline 20mg farmaco celebrex 200 mg hydrochlorothiazide mg dosage buy viagra girls montreal viagra online 25 mg topiramate wellbutrin synthroid 0.2 mg 50 mg of viagra viagra 25 mg.price lisinopril 10 mg price buy clomid legal 20 mg lexapro metformin 500 mg nebenwirkungen zithromax 250 mg uk online kamagra review celebrex buy online 50mg of clomid online levitra rx augmentin 500 mg prezzo lasix 10 mg compresse augmentin 500mg uti xenical 80 mg zithromax 500 mg treatment doxycycline capsules 100 mg augmentin pediatrico 250 mg lasix compresse 25 mg cialis tabs 5mg reviews generic viagra prednisone cheap online strattera 10 mg dosage wellbutrin generic cheap generic propecia online ert generic viagra viagra 200mg kaufen taking 2 2.5mg cialis cheap propranolol cialis kaufen 5mg cheap propecia india viagra online 2 day does generic levitra shop levitra 5mg Cialis 20mg 60 Tabs zoloft 50 mg filmtabletta buy nolvadex nt generic valtrex walgreens zithromax online ordering propranolol 10 mg dawkowanie doxycycline 100mg hydrochloride kamagra pills 50 mg newest cialis 40 mg lisinopril 40 mg mg viagra online discrete cialis 40 mg sublingual pct clomid dosimg buy zithromax brand generic viagra overnigh generic viagra details cialis daily 5mg generic sitagliptin metformin 50 mg prednisone buy generic propecia viagra freeonline.com clomid 12.5mg dosis diflucan 150 mg online apotheke levitra levitra 100mg preis paypal cheap viagra buy 5 pills viagra periactin 4 mg used generic viagra walgreens cialis 5 mg buying cialis 50 mg 100 mg inderal propranolol buy viagra online buy augmentin 625mg tablets cheap cialis internet wellbutrin sr100mg buy lisinopril 40 viagra online answers 20mg cialis coupons 5mg cialis harga zovirax 200 mg cialis original online to buy clomid 300 buy nexium pharmacy black cialis 3000mg buy nexium 14 tablets doxycycline accord 200mg buy bactrim overnight zovirax 800 mg dosage prednisone 10mg tab cipro 500 mg generic generic levitra italy augmentin 62mg buying clomid injection lasix 40 mg nedir viagra de 20mg 25 mg di viagra generic cialis colombia propecia generic mexico cost valtrex 1000mg pfizer buy celebrex buy nolvadex mexico cheapest generic nexium strattera 100mg capsule buy viagra australian lasix 12.5 mg cost nexium 160 mg viagra pills order 500mg viagra uk 40 mg. of cialis buy levitra forum buy propecia direct buspar online kaufen cialis 5 mg 28 compresse 40 mg dosage cialis lexapro goes generic amoxil generic names cialis online vancouver cheap viagra pleasure cheap cialis ed generic cipro 500mg augmentin 625mg tds levitra 20 mg work cipro tablets 500 mg generic lexapro purchase 40mg brand cialis buy viagra price prednisone 5mg directions zovirax 400 mg costo jual propecia 1mg viagra buyers canada amoxil 500 mg capsulas 150 mg online viagra 80 mg levitra levitra for order prednisone 50mg tab zovirax 400mg celebrex de 400 mg cialis de 20 mgr dapoxetine priligy buy 10 mg levitra online buy levitra 40 mg doxycycline 100mggum infection bula propranolol 40mg 5 mg lexapro usage zithromax 250 mg coupon metformin ratiopharm 1000 mg generic cialis craigslist cialis generico azul generic viagra comparisons cialis generic 20 nexium cap 20 mg augmentin nombre generico generico del lasix prednisone 20 mg pill viagra naturale 800mg cialis sspain buy viagra generic krka buying propecia generic viagra history lasix 20 mg india cialis tadalafil buy buy lasix 12.5 mg opiniones viagra generico propranolol anxiety 40 mg viagra generico resolve generic viagra cumming cialis 40 mg wirkung cialis 20 mg doctissimo generic zithromax chlamydia phenergan 25 mg tab wellbutrin dosage 200 mg clomid 200 mg daily wirkstoff cialis 20mg cialis online ads nexium 40 mg generic 150mg kamagra prednisone 5mg tablet bfp 100mg clomid cialis cheap melbourne 60 prednisone 5mg augmentin 500mg alcohol doxycycline accord 200 mg esidrex 25 mg hydrochlorothiazide kegunaan celebrex 100 mg cipro 500 mg pill lexapro 40 mg ocd generic valtrex 500 mg diflucan 100 mg tablets generic levitra buy Levitra 10 mg Buy prezzo celebrex 200 mg generic bactrim ingredients 20 mg scimex nolvadex desi viagra 50 mg order cialis 50 mg levitra dosage 20mg priligy generico farmacia prednisone 20 mg canine lisinopril 5mg dosage generic wellbutrin results generic zovirax india augmentin 500 mg posologie illegal buy kamagra priligy genericos zoloft dosage 400 mg thyroxine.generic synthroid strattera 40 mg order viagra 100mg buy augmentin duo zoloft dosage 250 mg amoxil 875 mg used viagra tesco buy doxycycline 5mg 100mg cialis dose order viagra international cheapest viagra order buy cialis 200 mg buspar 15 mg dosage cialis 40mg order lasix internet medicamentos celebrex 200 mg cialis 10 mg use amoxil 500mg alcohol generic viagra efficacy vanzare cialis online cialis 5mg discount cialis 100 mg sale about viagra 800mg cialis generic fast nexium generic 30 pills buy 1 viagra nexium 40 mg wirkung discreet viagra online viagra 50 100mg reliable cialis order beipackzettel metformin 500 mg viagra overdose 200mg synthroid abbott generic hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg generic synthroid issues buy propecia answers lexapro 10mg indicaciones cheap cialis uae 5mg cialis cheap prednisone cats online prednisone 10 mg allergies online viagra delivery cialis 5mg treatment buy nolvadex tabs nexium 40mg indonesia propecia order canada generic viagra cheapest buy zithromax bahrain 40 mg sublingual cialis buy cipro without cipro 55 mg propecia order finasteride amoxil amoxicilina 250 mg generic valtrex doses cialis 20mg malaysia viagra online ebay buy zeneca nolvadex viagra 100mg buying generic viagra definition cialis 10 mg experience bactrim online cheap buy genuine xenical strattera bipolar 2 disorder priligy 30 mg funciona buy clomid where buy clomid drug pfizer viagra online viagra generic dangers
Home All Articles Carroll: Voting Buster

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 860 guests online

Atom RSS

Carroll: Voting Buster PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 10
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Will Carroll   
Monday, 15 November 2010 14:57

Will CarrollEDITORS NOTE: The BBWAA has announced that Buster Posey wins the NL ROY award, while Neftali Feliz wisn the AL ROY


Special to BizofBaseball.com

Since being invited to join the BBWAA in 2008, I've been given the honor of voting for three awards. I think that while the BBWAA awards aren't perfect, I do believe that it's a solid system that is taken seriously by all voters. Sure, I'd like to see broadcasters eligible to vote, but this is a writers organization, so that's not changing any time soon. Last year, I had a controversial vote for the NL Cy Young, casting what many thought was the vote that cost Chris Carpenter the award. Cardinals fans still haven't forgiven me, despite the fact that I voted Adam Wainwright #1 over eventual winner Tim Lincecum.

My NL Rookie of the Year vote is unlikely to be as controversial, but I do think it will be more key, in the sense that I believe it will be an extremely close vote. Last season, I didn't even include the eventual winner, Chris Coghlan, on my three-man ballot. This year, it was a two man race for most of the second half. Once Jaime Garcia went down, it was pretty clear that the award would come down to Buster Posey and Jason Heyward. I cast my vote for Posey and as announced, Posey has won. The vote wasn't as close as I expected with Posey getting 20 first place votes and 9 second place votes, with Heyward getting a mirror of 9 and 20.

I think its fine that there are many different methodologies for how various voters make their selections, as long as those voters are also willing to "show their work." Mine was based on three factors: defensive position, opportunity, and results. Yes, for me, if all things were equal - and they were pretty close to that - then I feel playing catcher creates a "degree of difficulty" that would be worthy of tipping the results. Posey is not a great catcher by any measure, statistical or scouting, but he was good enough to not need a defensive caddy. He managed a solid but erratic pitching staff on a playoff contender and that has some value.

The argument on the last two are intertwined. Jason Heyward has the better counting stats, due in part to the fact that the Braves elected to have him start on Opening Day. Posey, held back either for "defensive seasoning" or for financial reasons, didn't have as much of an opportunity, but made the most of the time he had. Heyward had a higher "WAR" than Posey (5.0 to 3.9), but again, this is largely on the basis of opportunity. Posey didn't ask to be sent back down and it's hard to argue he could have done much more than what he did during his time in the minors to force his way up.

Posey had the better rate stats for the most part, making the most of his opportunities. Posey was healthier as well, showing no obvious slumps during his season. Admittedly, more time behind the plate might have caused problems, but it seemed that Bruce Bochy was able to spot Posey into the 1B slot as needed, keeping his bat while not exposing him to the physical problems catchers get with extensive time behind the plate. While Posey only played catcher about half the time of a normal, full season starter, I can't hold that against him. As someone who's called for players like Joe Mauer to be moved from behind the plate, it would be hypocritical to devalue the protection of Posey.

I also spoke to scouts, players, and executives, putting a special emphasis on those that had seen them play more than just a handful of times. While I saw a lot of video, that's hardly the same thing. Almost to a man, they couldn't put much differentiation between the two. The words "special" and "superstar" kept coming up, and it's hard to disagree. Both Posey and Heyward are the types of players, on and off the field, that a franchise can build around. They're similar ages, though two years will likely help Heyward when it comes to the career numbers and gives him a bit more projectability than Posey, who scouts think "is what he is." One said, "he's not going to get much better, but that's not a bad thing. He's one of the top catchers in the NL right now and if he gets better behind the plate, he could be in the conversation with [Joe] Mauer."

One NL Central pitcher who faced both couldn't add much. "They're both tough outs and seem to come to the plate with a plan. Heyward can hurt you more with the power, but he seemed to get exposed a bit more as the season went on. I think some of that was the physical toll. Posey just seemed to learn and get better. Now that they're both getting some playoff experience now makes me wonder if he'll go another level next year." (Note that the vote was turned in before the playoffs.)

If it was possible to cast a tied ballot, I would have seriously considered that. This was, for me, a very difficult decision, one I considered and reconsidered, writing it each way before finally hitting send on my emailed ballot to Jack O'Connell. Both Posey and Heyward will be getting plenty of awards as they move through what look to be great baseball careers. Congratulations to Buster Posey on the NL Rookie of the Year Award and to all the other BBWAA award winners to be announced over the week.

One final note: I considered voting for Neil Walker over Jaime Garcia. Walker has been in Indianapolis for a while and is a guy I rooted for once he finally got the chance with the Pirates. I couldn't make an objective case for him and don't believe that personal interests should enter into these awards, so I didn't. Interestingly, someone voted for Walker with a second place vote. I'd be very curious to hear the reasoning for that one. I don't know if the BBWAA will release the voting the way they did with the NL Cy Young last year.


Will Carroll is a member of both the BBWAA and the PFWA. He writes about fantasy football at SI.com and resides near Indianapolis. You can follow him at @injuryexpert on Twitter.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?