abilify 15 mg cost buy clomid from uk xenical not losing weight atorvastatin 10 mg tablets medication trazodone 50 mg doxycycline veterinary uses buy cialis canadian pharmacy buy dapoxetine safely buying avodart in canada cost of actonel generic viagra online pharmacy no prescription estrofem 2mg buying cialis on line safe website proscar price comparison buy synthroid levothyroxine online uk ventolin price nz pill with amoxicillin buy generic ventolin tablets prednisone tablet for dogs generic viagra mexico wholesale wellbutrin generic and weight loss viagra use vacuum pump buy generic crestor online celebrex cost usa cheap cialis without prescription nexium 20 mg getting clomid from gp cost norvasc medication prozac online australia viagra canadian health valtrex price walmart tamoxifen cost drug how to buy clomid online no prescription uk simvastatin generic crestor order lipitor in canada buy zyrtec d online cheap generic viagra no prescription buy voltaren online clomid buy cheap without prescriptions woman and viagra buy clomid 100mg 5 mg levitra price of ventolin inhaler in singapore celexa 60 mg dosage cialis 36 hour price amoxil 500 mg price voltaren 25 mg dosage cheap prednisone 20mg buy clomid generic letrozole for sale bactrim antibiotic buy online strattera in generic form buy zithromax from canada buy metformin pills buy valtrex line yasmin cost get accutane out cheap paxil prescription cipro buy clomid 150 mg days 4 8 finasteride tablet sale buy wellbutrin online pharmacy valtrex tablets buy online discount yasmin birth control desyrel 300 nexium price help buy cheap doxycycline online with no prescription canadian online pharmacies india nizoral 2 acyclovir no prescription overnight shipping augmentin cream buy online buy valtrex antifungal cream generic brand for accutane buying tamoxifen citrate buy accutane england zovirax 5 mg fosamax generic version allegra d cost at cvs zithromax 500 mg gonorrhea avodart drug cialis online pharmacy carisoprodol buy viagra super active online doxycycline sale ketoconazole for sale generic levaquin when will cialis be available as a generic lexapro 10 mg dosage wholesale cialis paid with paypal buy wellbutrin us phenergan get you high viagra dosage 100mg ciprofloxacin pill ear infection buy promethazine online no prescription estradiol order raclet allegra for sale buy antibiotics for sore throat ambilfy without prescription fda approves cialis supremesuppliers levitra coupons pharmacy orlistat cheap fosamax plus d generic name levitra tablets online tetracycline antibiotics buy online valtrex to get rid of cold sores furosemide 80 mg i.v omeprazole generic store cialis online canada paypal phenergan overnight delivery femara tablet price metformin buy cheap online prilosec 10 mg otc doxycycline 100mg price philippines children's allegra on sale augmentin tablet muadili accutane order pharmacy buy xenical united states cost clomid south africa how much does clomid cost pct levitra 20mg tablets mfg gsk buy levaquin antibiotic clalis 20mg vs clalis 40mg trazodone hci 50mg when did zoloft go generic doxycycline dosage for sinus infection pill crestor 10 clomid 50 mg and ovidrel cialis dosage information bactrim ds without an rx where to buy proscar gel plavix generic purchase ciprofloxacin 500 mg hcl tab where to buy augmentin once crestor japan zithromax tablets used for canadian pharmacy cheap viagra www7.usa pharmacy.usa ventolin inhaler gsk wellbutrin xl 300 mg buy valtrex retail price costco propecia generic sildenafil citrate online pharmacy pill lisinopril 5mg metformin pills from asia generic form of prednisone buy lexapro online au order voltaren emulgel canada diflucan duo price where to buy viagra for cheap buy valacyclovir fedex price protonix price fosamax dutasteride no prescription accutane buy online us rosuvastatin 10 mg tablet where to buy sildenafil gel buy fexofenadine 180 levitra 10 mg generic nexium discount with insurance buy cyclotec acyclovir in canada nolvadex online ireland crestor payment assistance canada wellbutrin generic list should you buy accutane online order lamictal from canada simvastatin canada femara order levaquin pills viagra uk buy order doxycycline cream salmeterol 100 mcg lipitor canada generic buy wellbutrin 300 xl buy nolvadex granules wellbutrin 200 mg a day where can i buy naproxen buy valtrex men buy cheap naproxen 500 mg generic cialis samples promethazine getting high amoxicillin cream buy online order valacyclovir canada low cost cialis 20mg norvasc canada price cheap cialis sale online no prescription ciprofloxacin 500mg dosage for chlamydia cheap levetiracetam doxycycline monohydrate online buy cialis in us cheap xenical does nexium get rid of gas donepezil price india cialis 20 mg 10 pills accutane acne uk cost accutane acne buy yasmin online australia promethazine 25 mg vs zofran buy dapoxetine sildenafil (super p force) buy prednisone pills augmentin dosage for sinus infection vytorin generic prices prednisone without prescription canada does accutane get you drunk faster buy clomid australia online promethazine pill drug test abilify price without insurance diflucan tablets online finasteride canada cost allegra d tablet buy lasix no rx online viagra ventolin inhaler without rx cheap fosamax online bupropion generic medicine allegra 50mg propecia at finpecia low price avodart sale canada where to buy levaquin once buy singulair 4mg do i need a subscription for dapoxetine plavix savings accutane get rid of acne permanently canadian internet pharmacies buy prednisone online now promethazine average price buy obestat 10 mg price seroquel mexico buy fluoxetine prescription buy levitra oral amazon stromectol furosemide canada price allegra online order cost claritin lexapro generic 20 mg dutasteride sperm count cheap 100mg viagra diflucan 150 mg buy online topamax generic price nolvadex online paypal buy imitrex from mexico cost voltaren emulgel 20g dapoxetine in jordan nolvadex uses bodybuilding generic diflucan buy avodart 0.5 mg softgel viagra cheap generic finasteride 1mg online nexium generic ranbaxy canadian viagra online viagra tips use generic abilify pills doxycycline hydrochloride tablet paxil canada pharmacy cheap cialis generic trazodone pain pill buy hcg nolvadex naproxen order buy viagra online shop real viagra online canada buying nolvadex in canada online pharmacies to avoid cheap estradiol pills metformin price in us tadalafil canadian pharmacy lasix 500mg tablet cialis for women nexium getting off doxycycline orange tablet augmentin antibiyotik tablet levitra paypal purple pill synthroid 175 lexapro getting off of it safely can you get metformin in australia price lexapro prescription rosuvastatin 10 mg price generic zyrtec walmart lexapro generic ireland proscar 10 mg cost quetiapine xr topiramate 25 mg zoloft buy online no prescription get flomax norvasc generic buy ventolin price in india nolvadex once online-apotheke buy omeprazole australia buying clomid online australia lipitor white pill canada pharmacy viagra overnight online canadian pharmacy levitra lexapro available canada price crestor us generic citalopram hydrobromide 10 mg online lexapro no prescription cost clomid 50 cialis professional testimonials simvastatin tab 20mg buy allegra tablets generic claritin brands cipro purchase online tablet augmentin 625mg price in india buy finasteride online pharmacy buy alli ebay canada nexium purple pill discount valsartan 80 mg diovan buy celebrex cream prednisone without a scrip india esomeprazole augmentin 228 mg 5ml dosage fexofenadine 180 mg voltaren gel canadian pharmacy is there generic accutane cymbalta online canadian price orlistat capsule india proscar no prescription uk nexium 40 mg ingredients cialis online canadian pharmacy viagra 100mg price without rx india nexium order metformin generic tadalafil, sale fexofenadine costco crestor cost drug how to get advair cheap cheap diflucan online generic rogaine women accutane pictures claritin _ manufacturer lexapro 5 mg generic cialis cymbalta from canada wellbutrin 435 pill generic zyprexa drug aciclovir 200 mg jarabe precio celebrex generic in india gabapentin 400 nexium cost uk online levitra canada lowest price cialis canada nolvadex buy in australia deltasone ra simvastatin 80 the cheapest viagra online paxil pill identification generic valtrex herpes forum buy nolvadex pills online cost lisinopril 20 mg avodart 0.5 mg daily estradiol 45 pg ml health viagra orlistat buy canada phenergan 50 mg dosage free viagras nolvadex 20 mg bijsluiter cheap protonix online buy isotretinoin mexico nexium price comparison costco cialis 5 mg proscar price canada trazodone hcl 50mg cheap dapoxetine uk get cymbalta cheaper nexium 10 mg powder cialis (tadalafil)no presciption needed accutane trial buy cialis with dapoxetine online crestor settlement generic lexapro 5 mg ocd clomid pill broke in half buy paxil online prozac price japan furosemide white pill order no online prescription clomid xenical 84 cap 120mg flomax 30 mg dutasteride buy online pharmacy protonix tablet topamax online price synthroid price india buy valacyclovir in uk tips for buying viagra online drugs without prescription buying prednisone order ciprofloxacin low cost wellbutrin wellbutrin 150 sr buy glucophage sr doxycycline hyclate for sale generic finasteride safety lipitor generic 80 mg ventolin tablets buy online buy ventolin inhaler cost of crestor 5mg buy promethazine internet pharmacies legal tetracycline and pill discount rogaine foam uk fluoxetine capsules wellbutrin generic pill generic cialis tadalafil buying protonix on the www pill yasmin safe buy finpecia india sex pills for women, canada lexapro 20mg/ml order diflucan canada pharmacy propecia causing acne buying phenergan for babies accutane cost in mexico paxil online shopping order clomid amoxil 400 mg chewable prozac price malaysia esomeprazole online fluoxetine buy cheap femara no cervical mucus buy antibiotics online uk buy doxycycline spray online generic lipitor by watson buy paxil cr online viagra soft 20 mg cost of celebrex without insurance generic synthroid price where to buy singulair cheap buy cheap prednisone purchase keppra online zyprexa generic form crestor online shop zovirax canada pharmacy buy sildenafil mexico buy ventolin online cheap discount abilify card can nolvadex get rid of gyno order xenical cheap canada cialis mastercard accepted buying prednisone in canada cost wellbutrin sr generic no rx brand viagra when will dapoxetine be available? buying amoxicillin online safe cialis philippines phenergan 60 generic propecia tablets purchase imitrex online allegra 120 price buy doxycycline online uk order methyl prenisone without rx prescription viagra cost canada accutane acne buy avodart tablets no prescription sandoz pramipexole 0.25 generic cialis soft tablet clomid joint pain buy nexium esomeprazole magnesium buy accutane online india flomax 20 mg cheapest price for cialis cheap viagra online canada eva pills levitra availability for caffergot how much does cialis cost in thailand accutane generic good diflucan 200 mg tablets ampicillin sulbactam generic name purchase crestor no prescription buy xenical online philippines buying xenical in canada cialis ordering from canada cialis online india buy lexapro online ireland augmentin es cost stieva a gel 0.025 promethazine 25 mg for cough get rogaine canada amoxicillin 500mg grossesse levaquin purchase amoxicillin 500mg how many days nolvadex pct dosage synthroid blue tablet cost of allegra d at walmart clomid cheap online can i get viagra without a doctor paroxetine 40 synthroid 0.088 mg tab generic alternative to diovan can crestor get you high buy plavix australia expired cialis still safe canada levitra pills cost prednisone uk zithromax 500 mg vidal buy synthroid from canada buy simvastatin drug nizagra sildenafil crestor full price lexapro dosage 60 mg price xenical us phenergan cost walmart
Home Maury Brown Who Got the Biggest Bang for the Bucks in MLB for 2010?

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 675 guests online

Atom RSS

Who Got the Biggest Bang for the Bucks in MLB for 2010? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 21
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 18 October 2010 19:51
Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll data
Select the image above to see details for
all 30 clubs in MLB by Marginal Wins and
Marginal Payroll

Everybody likes to get a great deal. Ads pummel you daily touting how this outlet or that offers you a product that another charges more for more.

But, if you run a business, the chief objective is getting the best performance for the lowest price – you’re looking for efficiency and effectivity.

In Major League Baseball, it can be much the same. Some of the variables can shift, namely efficiency can be thrown out the window if you have high levels of revenues to compensate. After all, paying more – if you’ve got the green to spend – to win a World Series can be overlooked (that’s you, New York Yankees).

Over the past several years, I have broken down who got the biggest bang for their buck in MLB. With the league functioning without a hard cap, and the softest of the soft cap systems in the Big-4 (the league’s Luxury Tax system), the outcome of who performs best with the least has extra weight. As witnessed with the leaked MLB documents recently, questions surrounding the revenue-sharing system and the aforementioned Luxury Tax become more relevant as we get closer to the expiration of the current collective bargaining agreement.

To measure how well teams spent compared to their wins, we can use a metric created by the late, great Doug Pappas called Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll.

(Select the image above to see complete 2010 Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll data)

What is Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins?

As a baseline, we’ll create a fictitious marginal team. Even the worst teams made up of near minor league players would not lose every game. So, we’ll say that a truly mediocre team would win only 30 percent of their games. For salary, we’ll set every players at the league minimum, which for 2010 was $400,000 . And finally, we’ll make the roster 25, plus 3 replacement players to allow for the DL.

Using each team’s winning percentage, along with the Opening Day payroll we can determine a team’s “marginal payroll”. Using Opening Day payroll gives you the “intent” of a club at the beginning of the season. When adding in how many games a team won over the course of the regular season, we can then determine how much it cost for each marginal win.

The formula works as such:

(club payroll - (28 x major league minimum) / ((winning percentage - .300) x 162)

So, the lower the cost per marginal win that is derived out of this formula, the better. You’re striving to get your cost per marginal win low, thereby spending less per win – you’re efficient.

How did this year fare? For Bud Selig, it may be his shining moment for saying that there is parity in MLB (the postseason still needs to completely play out, as this look is just for the regular season). 2010 will go down as having the lowest average cost per marginal win ($1,731,901) than any other over the last 5 years. A game here or there, and the figure could have changed dramatically. If the Padres had been able to get their way in, as opposed to the Giants in the NL West, the number would have dropped further still ($1,503,188). If the Yankees had won the AL East, then 2010 doesn’t see the 5-year low cost per marginal win by jumping to $2,219,297. Still, we saw only one club win a Division with an Opening Day payroll above $100 million (Philles). Compared to 4 last year(Yankees, Angels, Phillies, Dodgers), 4 in 2008 (White Sox, Angels, Cubs, Dodgers), 2 in 2007 (Red Sox, Dodgers), and 2 in 2006 (Yankees, Mets). There was one club (Yankees) above $100 million in 2005, but remember… These Opening Day payroll figures don’t account for inflation making 2010 all that more impressive from a cost efficiency perspective.

Playoff Teams (Cost Per Margainal Win)

Playoff Teams Margin Wins Cost per Maginal Win
Tampa Bay 47 $1,281,086
y-NY Yankees 46 $4,205,461
Minnesota 45 $1,902,184
Texas 41 $1,064,023
Philadelphia 48 $2,701,000
y-Atlanta 42 $1,726,973
Cincinnati 42 $1,428,338
San Francisco 43 $2,014,777

y - Won Wild Card

Leading the way for all playoff teams was the Texas Rangers. Their $55,250,544 ranked as the 27th lowest in Opening Day payroll ahead of only the A’s, Padres, and Pirates. Based on Marginal Payroll/Marginal Wins (MP/MW), the Rangers had a marginal payroll of $44,050,544 and 41 marginal wins culminating in $1,064,023 per marginal win. Compare that to the Phillies who spent $2,701,000 per 48 marginal wins. The other efficiency experts for getting the most out of the least goes to the Tampa Bay Rays who paid $1,281,086 per each of their 47 marginal wins.

But, if we can offer up the biggest hat tip for a club that missed the postseason, yet got incredible success with such a stingy payroll, the San Diego Padres win, hands down. Barely missing the postseason fielding a 90-72 (.556) record, the Friars had the 29th lowest Opening Day payroll for 2010 ($37,799,300) which translates to a $26,599,300 marginal payroll, or an incredible $642,495 per each of their 41 marginal wins. The only club that had better player payroll efficiency over the last 5 years was the Tampa Bay Rays in 2008 ($679,764 per marginal win).

In terms of losers in the efficiency and effectivity categories, the Seattle Mariners are this year’s winner, or rather loser. With an abysmal 61-101 record (.377), and an Opening Day payroll of $104,963,866, the Mariners spent a staggering $6,073,387 per each of their 12 marginal wins. In spending so much for so little, the Mariners now have the dubious distinction of having the two worst MW/MP ratio since 2005. This year’s figure ranks second only the M’s cost per marginal win figure of $8,634,999 in 2008.

Other losers this year include the Cubs ($5,129,129 per marginal win), and Mets ($4,053,386 per marginal win).

But, what may be of most interest is how the clubs that are in the LCS are faring. While a case for parity can be made in regular season play, how does MW/MP stack up once the playoffs get started?

LCS Marginal Wins/Cost Per Marginal Win

If the Phillies and Yankees make it to the World Series (again), it would pit the highest payroll (Yankees at $206,333,389 Opening Day payroll) against the fourth-highest ($141,928,379). The Giants are still in the top 10 in Opening Day payroll (ranked #9 at $98,641,333), while the Rangers are the at 27th (represent efficiency and effectivity’s best hope ($55,250,544). To place this in perspective, in terms of cost per marginal win, the Yankees spent 4 times as much per MW than the Rangers.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE A BREAKDOWN BY DIVISION

FOR EACH CHART, GREEN COLUMNS DENOTE PLAYOFF CLUBS

AL EAST

As was the case in 2008, the 2010 regular season the AL East saw a case of David vs Goliath. The Rays won the Division posting a belt tightening $1,281,086 cost per each of their 47 marginal wins. The scary thing, at least for the Orioles… they spent almost as much per marginal win as the Yankees but posted only 17 marginal wins, a sign of being ineffective and inefficient.

AL East Cost Per Marginal Win

AL EAST

Marginal Wins

Cost per MW

*-Tampa Bay

47

$1,281,086

y-NY Yankees

46

$4,205,461

Boston

40

$3,743,746

Toronto

36

$1,402,033

Baltimore

17

$4,046,695

* - Won the Division
y - AL Wild Card winner

AL CENTRAL

The Twins didn’t get out of the first round of the playoffs (again) due to the Yankees, but there was a slight difference from this year to last: Target Field opened which trickled down to getting Joe Mauer wrapped up into a long term contract, which bumped the Twins from being ranked 24th in Opening Day payroll last year to 10th in 2010. In terms of cost per marginal win, the Twins spent $1,419,928 for each of their 38 marginal wins last season, compared to $1,902,184 per the 45 marginal wins they racked up during the 2010 regular season. Not bad considering the extra wins they racked up.

On the downside, the Tigers wound up underachieving with a high-level of player payroll. Ranked at 6th in Opening Day payroll ($122,864,928), the club spent $3,446,448 per each of their 32 marginal wins. If it’s any solace to Mike Illitch and the Tigers, the Royals, perennial cellar-dwellers, spent nearly as much per marginal win ($3,272,022)

AL Central Cost Per Marginal Win

AL CENTRAL

Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win

x-Minnesota

45

$1,902,184

Chicago Sox

39

$2,394,162

Detroit

32

$3,446,448

Cleveland

20

$2,451,175

Kansas City

18

$3,272,022

x - Won the Division

AL WEST

The AL West wound up being a study in extremes. Jon Daniels and the Rangers became a model of efficiency and effectivity while the Mariners plans for a defensive-minded roster that wound up having all the power of a 15-watt bulb was the polar opposite; a case of high-spending with nothing to show for it. This is one of those times when a picture is worth a thousand words.

AL West Cost per Marginal Wins

AL WEST

Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win

x-Texas

41

$1,064,023

Oakland

32

$1,248,608

LA Angels

31

$2,986,110

Seattle

12

$6,073,387

x - Won the Division

NL EAST

There wasn’t a case of wise spending trumping poor-thinking, overspending in the NL East. Sure, there was a prime case of “spending doesn’t always mean winning” with the Mets, but Phillies had a steep Opening Day payroll. The Braves, who won the NL Wild Card had an Opening Day payroll of $84,423,666, right smack-dab in the middle of MLB’s payroll rankings at 15th.

NL East Cost Per Marginal Win

NL EAST

Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win

*-Philadelphia

48

$2,701,000

y-Atlanta

42

$1,726,973

Florida

31

$1,459,704

NY Mets

30

$4,053,386

Washington

20

$2,460,784

* - Won the Division

NL CENTRAL

How good is Walt Jocketty? How bad do the Pirates continue to be? How badly did the Cubs spend without having anything to show for it? Consider… The Pirates spent nearly twice as much as the Reds per marginal win. But, it could have been worse (at least if this year were the only year the Pirates stunk up the standings). The Cubs finished 5th in the Division, just ahead of the lowly Pirates, spending 3.6 times as much per marginal win as the Reds did. Ouch.

 

NL Central Cost Per Marginal Win

NL CENTRAL

Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win

x-Cincinnati

42

$1,428,338

St. Louis

37

$2,201,624

Milwaukee

28

$2,461,559

Houston

27

$2,961,880

Chicago Cubs

26

$5,129,129

Pittsburgh

8

$2,826,548

x - Won the Division

NL WEST

“If only…” That has to be what was on the lips of Jed Hoyer and every San Diego Padres fan. Barely missing the postseason, when Spring Training ended, few – if any – baseball “experts” would have the Padres as contenders for a moment, let alone the entire season. With an Opening Day payroll of $37,799,300, they, along with the Pirates, were the only clubs with payroll under $50 million. They wound up overachieving, well beyond expectations and would have been the perennial example of “smarts over expensive players”… if only they had made it to the playoffs. Not to make the likes of the Mariners and Cubs cry but the Padres posted an insanely effiencent and effective $642,495 per marginal win. Bravo, Padres. You’re Bud Selig’s new hero.

NL West Cost Per Marginal Win

NL WEST

Marginal Wins

Cost per Maginal Win

x-San Francisco

43

$2,014,777

San Diego

41

$642,495

Colorado

34

$2,122,878

LA Dodgers

31

$2,680,192

Arizona

16

$3,019,400

x - Won the Division


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey, as well as a contributor to FanGraphs and Forbes SportsMoney. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?