how do i order cialis from mexico buy medication online from ireland pulmicort respules cialis cheapest price rocket power beach bandits laxifen tablets for kids buy metoprolol without a prescription elimite cream cvs diane rehm show podcast mexican pharmacy erection pills men generic avelox for uti infection levaquin lawsuit norfloxacin antibiotic doctor cefixime pills temovate ointment ingredients baclofen pump implantation where can i buy tretinoin online uk purchase viagra with debit card cholesterol lowering foods cholesterol lowering diet cialis plux dapoxetine online ordering desogestrel ethinyl estradiol jasmine thompson i see fire order birth control online tylenol side effects in elderly prevacid side effects prilosec side effects get valtrex overnight digoxin level of 3.0 order prednisone online from canada what is micardis hct side effects 1224 canadien pharmacy vipro buy viagra 2011 duetact contraindications for electrical stimulation doxycycline in vitro remeron side effects mirtazapine levamisole side effects in dogs cialis 2 5 canada buy codeine cough syrup no prescription saroten 25mg benadryl generic combivent price dyazide tablets medicine online purchase ramipril 5mg tablets budesonide ec 3 mg budesonide drug medication elavil information for pain androgel testosterone gel reviews online pharmacy 365 pills allpills complaints against dentists metformin online usa no prescription minomycin information society metformin dosage for pcos treatment diovan side effects valsartan healthy man advertised on the radio depakote er 500 mg side effects where can i buy meloxicam lincocin for dogs canadian cialis reviews diazepam 2mg aristocort cream ointment for itchy meclizine for vertigo side effects nebivololum 5mg and pregnancy lovegra information systems potensmedel cialis wkuld cipro 500 killl parasites cyclivex 200mg caffeine flonase over the counter 2015 costco auto program car buying levamisole wormer mtabs complaints of a dutiful daughter buspirone hcl 15mg information valium side effects in children anastrozole bodybuilding side effects nifedipine ointment for anal fissures abilify bipolar treatment what is maxifort sildenafil yasmin le bon 2014 vt logistics singapore permethrin insecticide toxicity buy pain pills overnight betacin tablets sale pinamox caps 500mg amoxicillin uses polarmeds pharmacy times perlutex veterinary lexapro buy online no script irbesartan side effects omaggio vase usa vicodin and alcohol mix how to order synthroid 25 mcg online betnovate c cream for sale online inhalers cheap genuine cialis sublingual nitroglycerin protocol cytotec where to buy betnovate scalp application 0.1 meclizine 12.5 mg canadian pharmacy suprax septra ds side effects acne usa viagra online pharmacy zolpidem side effects medicine ed hardy online site furadonin wikipedia francais buy cheap ciplox 500 mg prazosin get high viagra online vipps pharmacy exelon careers openings antabuse side effects disulfiram like reaction socialist caucus para sirve propranolol levothyroxine from canada apotheke cialis schweiz benazepril without prescription ivermectin for dogs elocom krem how to buy levitra zoloft and alcohol use how many viagra can you take at once careprost eyelash viagra in mexico provigil coupons 2012 use of reglan for migrainesreichlox norfloxacin prospect capital corporation but generic lexapro online cheap parlodel 2.5mg dosing prednisone and pregnancy first trimester cheap bactrim no rx reliable viagra supplier uk aldara medication costalesse cheap pain meds online xlpharmacy canada immigration dosage of cephalexin for sinus infection windsor pharmacy canada topamax walmart cost how to order medrol on the internet low cost mexican pharmacies thyroxine t4 imovane zopiclone 7.5mg buy online ed drugs pfizer viagra brand on the everybody is levitra covered 100 mg viagra lowest price avamigran side effects arthrotec medication arthrotec side effects xl pharmacy india ventolin side effects for baby lincocin antibiotic treatment microzide medication dictionary levitra professional overnight delivery diprosone lotion eriacta ranbaxy adalat serial full episode duetact contraindications for flu femara infertility ospamox 1000 mg prospect park paracetamol toxicity isoretinoin without prescription viagra for sale on craigslist olanzapine and fluoxetine vitamin d supplements and pregnancy leconfield wines for humanity apetamin reviews salbutamol guaifenesin mechanism of action proviron mesterolone 25 mg carprofen 100mg 180 ct buy online pharmacy russia singulair dosage information diflucan over the counter walgreens how much are viagra polls at mejiers garlic mashed potatoes with sour cream cialis vendita on line diazepam dosage for anxiety best cialis online discount prices effects of duphaston medicine dosage generic viagra no prescription in uk prednisone for poison ivy allergic reaction alesse birth control reviews misoprostol 200mcg uses viagra in mexico over the counter safe place to buy cialis online doxazosin 8 mg tab appearance venlafaxine hcl thyroxine tablets to buy escitalopram oxalate side effects no prescription cialis canada online pharmacies paypal accepted order tramadol with mastercard budesonide inhalation suspension for infants secnidazole tablet is for what treatment doxycap dosage calculator lasix dosage how long before cialis takes effect decadron injection side effects cheap promethizine without prescription abilify weight gain 1mg bestherbal bizbetafusin nosipren medication for depression viagra without doctor visit rumafen gelding cialis for sale from canada valtrex prescription online metformin by mail prozac and alcohol side effects costo cialis 5 mg retirda de las farmacias viagra pharmacy support group cialis baytril otic for dogs how to use prednisone generic no prescription drugs generic xenical online mexico mestinon 60 mg tablet myambutol toxicity definition farmacia online italia viagra generico buy tadalafil 5mg ezetimibe side effects magnesium supplements for migraines maxifort zimax 50mg seroflo side effects zoloft and breastfeeding sertraline zoloft fast delivery prozac and weight loss or gain obat xenical can you get high off indomethacin 50 mg kemadrin medication list nolvadex tablets dosis amoxicillin tablet untuk anak voltaren 75mg for toothache how to get viagra prescription online flexidol relax efectos del inderal over the counter colcrys 0.6 mg reviews medrol 4mg dosepak seroquel 25mg sublingual gland function fosamax dosage strength vanterin kowa liniment mirtazapine 15 mg for cats only buy cafergot corega denture adhesive reviews isoniazid retail sale alendronate sodium fosamax side effects finasteride dosage for hair loss remeron side effects esquina tango austin angine dafalgan codeine minoxidil 10 percent kamagra by ajanta pharma buy levaquin made in usa lowest price dapoxetine cialis south africa online lamotrigine lamictal side effects skin rash benicar 40 mg side effects olmesartan medoxomil viagra sandoz diet pills online whats the cost of a100mg viagra qsymia buy from canada sumycin capsules vs softgelssunsuria abilify 15mg price uk pharm support group generic buy diflifenac 50mg from spain premarin side effects premarin lawsuits unisom side effects diphenhydramine elocon without prescription lipothin 200 fenofibrate medication usa pharmacy singulair side effects in children behavior fda reglan breastfeeding medication fentanyl withdrawal symptoms in infants cialis usa over the counter eprex injection administration online apotheke asterreich viagra buy lasix 500 mg online triderm ointment creamtrimox navidoxine meclizine hydrochloride side indian viagra tablets names xatral xl10 ambilfy without prescription nosipren prednisona 5mg para vigora tablet details in hindi lergigan compass comprare alli eldepryl medication dictionary order lipitor without prescription sublingual vitamin b12 b6 and folic acid prostata inflamada cancer topamax and alcoholism crestor medication dose propranolol recommended dosage for anxiety buy pain pills online overnight lotrel generic amlodipine sublingual cialis tablets reliable online bupropion cheap viagra super p force danazol side effects endometriosis pyrocaps 20mg melatonin catafast dosage duetact medication liposafe side effects clomid without prescription in usa buy propranolol 40mg metformin and alcohol consumption risk buy toradol injection online casodex withdrawal side effects no prescripton drugs avodart 0.5 mg o long 100 how to use augmentin for sinus infections yasmine petty before advantage auto sales inc low price medicine canada by safety and chep aricept buy viagra hong kong protonix 40mg pantoprazole reviews buy liquid viagra 213 epharmacy online auctions nolvadex for sale in usa xenical weight loss medication losartan hydrochlorothiazide dosage xatral xl prescribing information buy clomid online no prescription paxil generic drug zantac side effects treatment lagatrim forte indications definition buy clomid online ship usa buy generic accutane 40 mg lamisil pills for yeast infection benemid dosage of benadryl online canadian pharcharmy online viagra starting point of walgreens coupons policy canadian pharmacies mail order paypal pravastatin medication is used for buy carvedilol without a prescription reichlox 500mg hydrocodone clomid without a script amphetamine side effects treatmentampicilina osu cialis pagamento paypal lexapro dosage information 30mg prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension usp medications similar clonidine thailand pharmacy online levitra 30 mg ou equivalente biaxin side effects after you have finished treatment raymeds pharmacy technician arthritis gloves ativan withdrawal symptoms how long dostinex india evista 60 mg estrogen aldara cream warts 3m salzarex soma jasmine tridevil photos zithromax canada legitimate online pharmacies citalopram 20 mg dose side effects prilosec otc buspar medication information alendronate sodium fosamax estradiol valerate estrogens effectiveness of generic cialis levitra from bayer latisse reviews for blue eyes noroxin shampoo bar asthma action plan ativan withdrawal permethrin spray clothing cheap drugs org pill viagra mirtazapine side effects antidepressants dosage morphine sulfate er 15mg tablets differin buy paypal fempro tablets under $100 purchase prednisone w not prescription buying accutane online 2013 eprex injection administration technique canada pharmacy without script omeprazole medication uses metoprolol tartrate side effects weight gain levamisole injectable dewormer propecia cheap canada online atacand plus medication eulexin schering plough mexico zyvoxid dose market metformin dosage sinequanone clothing article 92 cialis no prescription where can i get cyprohepadine brand viagra online paypal kosovarja ragipi application of ciprofloxacin suretabs cialis trental medication use phenergan with codeine syrup dosages is there a way to get avanafil cheaper celebrex pills are eggs canada discover card login page cialis daily 5 mg price buy viagra with out prescription differin coupon printable lexapro side effects sexual dysfunction ropinirole 0.25 mg is use for what astromenda search removal lipvas cipla eas can i take keflex for sinus infection sildenafil over the counter arthritis medication for dogs over the counter haloperidol injections sotalol dosage to end atrial fibrillation keflex 500mg cephalexin do you need a prescription for estrace what else works like viagra benicar lawsuit ct lower my sodium levels in the body carbohydrates canadian no prescription drugs levaquin lawsuit 2015 danazol endometriosis prednisone and pregnancy tests buy prednisolone no prescription ibuprofen for dogs safe dose lergigan complete price for cialis at walmart lorinol tablets with keyboards buy viagra online paypal uk picareta em ingles sin fluconazole 150mg treatment for oral thrush terramycin antibiotic ophthalmic ointment in utah ciprobay drugs dalacin 300mg capsule reglan side effects metoclopramide vytorin side effects medication what happens if u overdose on seroquel magnesium oxide formula depression test order neurotin cod online benadryl and pregnancy safety trileptal dosage for trigeminal neuralgia buy priligy dapoxetine using pay pal edrugstore md website tylenol pm ingredients buy amaryllis online malegra cheap comprar pfizer en estados unidos phenergan with codeine syrup side effects were do i get viagra champix tablets for sale medrol dose pack dosage in mg ic zolpidem tartrate side effects parlodel 2.5mg sky pharmacy complaints vyvanse rochester mn cefabiot suspension parts furolin medication for depression mincorp plc vitamin b12 deficiency symptoms treatmentvitamix order lovastatin online colospan tablet hotels priligy generika dapoxetine kaufen huge theater itraconazole secnidazole side effects starcef 2008 warfarin and alcohol interaction nitrazepam tablets wholesale mixed amphetamine salts side effects viagra at asda cheap viagra pills uk overnight pain meds cialis generic 5 mg morphine sulfate 15mg tablets acyclovir medication for shingles flagyl prescriptions online decadron para que sirve fosamax and jaw problems bisphosphonates mobicool mobile refrigeration services prednisolone 5mg buy online feldene gel 0.5 piroxicam donde puedo comprerar levitra de 10 mg tryptizol 25 mg adderall online authentic viagra from uk to us floxin eye drops for pink eye lupin 500 levoxyl recall ceftin antibiotic uses survival what is orlistat hexal domperidone dosage and breastfeeding buspirone medication for cats what does cialis taste like acyclovir for cold sores reviews buy propecia 1mg how much zithromax for strep throat cymbalta for anxiety antidepressants skelaxin side effects drug interactions provera medicine for irregular menstruation 365 pharmacy uk cialis en ligne allemagne prednisone treatment for dogs metallica nothing else matters lyrics meaning viagra suppliers uk myambutol ethambutol ocular acarbose precose medication eurax lotion information coversyl 4mg relafen medication side effects robaxin dosage information accutane before and after pictures back and chest
Home Matthew Coller Coller: American League Cy Young Race a Battleground over New Stats

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 768 guests online

Atom RSS

Coller: American League Cy Young Race a Battleground over New Stats PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 24
PoorBest 
Matthew Coller Articles Archive
Written by Matthew Coller   
Monday, 04 October 2010 07:30
Felix Hernandez
The argument over whether Felix
Hernandez should be the AL Cy  Young
winner will boil down to whether the
writers  place weight on his wins total
with the abysmal Mariners.

Last week, ESPN’s Pardon The Interruption co-host Michael Wilbon told the Scott Van Pelt Show if Seattle Mariners’ pitcher Felix Hernandez had an earned run average similar to Bob Gibson’s historic 1968 season (Gibson’s ERA was 1.12) he still wouldn’t vote Hernandez for the Cy Young Award. “I will not vote a guy with 13 wins for Cy Young, no way,” Wilbon said.

Friday night, MLB Network analysts Harold Reynolds and Dan Plesac came to the same conclusion as Wilbon, agreeing that New York Yankees 21-game winner C.C. Sabathia should be given the award for the year’s best pitcher. The arguments for Sabathia revolve around a concept best described by former NFL coach Herm Edwards: You play to win the game.

The problem: Hernandez leads practically every other basic statistical category including ERA, strikeouts and innings pitched. Despite his dominance, the Mariners ace suffered from having virtually zero offensive support. In four of Hernandez’s 12 losses, the Mariners were shutout. The team’s slugging percentage was lower than the Yankees’ on-base percentage. The Yankees doubled the Mariners number of home runs and finished with more than 300 more runs than Seattle.

The argument has morphed from who is 2010’s best pitcher to what statistics should be used to evaluate pitchers or old school vs. new school. The “wins people” like Wilbon, Reynolds and Plesac hold the traditional view that the most important measure is winning the game. Baseball Prospectus writer Jay Jaffe, who writes columns often using new statistics, says emphasis on wins is generational.

“If you saw baseball in the 1960s and early 1970s when pitchers routinely went the distance, you're more likely to maintain those same assumptions about pitcher value as ruled the day back then, even though higher scoring, higher strikeout rates and other changes have made it much harder for a pitcher to complete what he starts,” Jaffe said.

Another explanation, Jaffe says, for those slow to look at the picture painted by new statistics may be the passing down of ageless baseball theories mixed with a hint of insecurity. “They're slow to change,” Jaffe said.  “Even slower to admit that their authority may be threatened , and if they're insiders, they're likely to hear ballplayers or ex-players handing down the same received wisdom over and over again.”

Jaffe notes that this type of thinking has led to deserving pitchers being left out in the cold for more than just Cy Young Awards, but also the Hall of Fame. “I cover the Hall of Fame beat, and win totals are generally the starting point of discussions of candidates,” Jaffe said.  “If you don't have enough of them, you won't even make a 2nd ballot without 200 - ask Gooden, Cone, Appier. The writers haven't even voted in a starter with less than 300 since (Fergie) Jenkins in 1991.”

Baseball Prospectus, like any other media outlet, evaluates players with the purpose of myth busting, conversation starting and fantasy advice. Unlike Jaffe, Wilbon, Plesac or Reynolds, former New York Mets general manager and current MLB Network Radio host Jim Duquette has evaluated talent for more than argument’s sake, but with millions of dollars and the success of a franchise on the line.

“It’s the old adage, don’t put too much emphasis on one particular area,” Duquette said. “It’s changed from 15 years ago, saying ‘hey this guy is a 20-game winner year after year,’ (now) that just works from a PR standpoint.”

“Some of the old school evaluators have been a little slow and there are certain statistics I don’t know if they’ll ever embrace,” Duquette said. “But, there are certain statistics that even the old school scouts say that there is some value, especially from a future performance standpoint, they say it can enhance evaluation. So I think they are slowly embracing it. There are also some old school people that say ‘there’s nothing like a win, its winning ballgames that matters.’”

Duquette admits that the ultimate goal is winning, but can’t take it as far as Wilbon’s Hernandez to Gibson comparison. “That’s craziness to me,” Duquette said. “It just doesn’t make sense…this guy’s (Hernandez) record is really impacted by how poor his team is. The lack of run production from that club (Seattle) is of historical proportions,”

Duquette’s vote would go to Hernandez, but he also added that Tampa Bay Rays ace David Price has been shortchanged in Cy Young talks due to the Sabathia vs. Hernandez, new stats vs. old stats discussions.

Last season’s Cy Young award winner Zack Greinke may be an indicator of who will win the award in 2010. Greinke won 16 games while three other pitchers won 19, but the Royals’ ace led the league in ERA. In last year’s National League Cy Young voting, Tim Lincecum won despite having four less wins than the Cardinals’ Adam Wainwright.

Though most stat sites have Hernandez as the league’s top pitcher, Jaffe implied the race could be close or even go to Sabathia because of the shear amount of old school voters, “If you came to Bill James in the 1980s or have grown up with the internet in front of you, you're likely to be hipper to new stats,” he said. “But, you probably haven't been around long enough to have a vote in the Cy Young race.”


Matthew Coller is a senior staff member of the Business of Sports Network, and is a freelance writer. He can be followed on Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?