best business credit cards for bad credit no credit check credit cards south africa credit card online shopping cash back comparison how credit card processing works wiki credit card after bankruptcy discharge 2012 how to get a credit card with bad credit airmiles credit card td free prepaid credit cards no monthly fee vanilla visa card declined fha loans with bad credit score credit card number checker free download low interest rate credit cards uk poor credit credit cards no deposit instant approval best buy credit cards review easiest way to get a credit card with no credit comparing travel rewards credit cards canada best buy credit card canada application halifax clarity credit card exchange rates amex costco credit card login cash advance calculator credit card $5000 bad credit loan australia best credit cards canada 2011 where to buy prepaid credit cards uk how to get a cash advance on your credit card without a pin can you sign up for netflix free trial without credit card ge money bank walmart credit card phone number irctc sbi credit card login lord and taylor credit card services number balance transfer natwest credit cards with low interest rates canada premium credit cards 2013 best credit card debt consolidation companies state bank of india new credit card apply african bank personal loans online prepaid travel credit cards uk bad credit car loans low interest free credit card machine for cell phones best way to build credit fast with credit card best rewards credit card 2011 australia credit card compliance regulations canada quick payday loans no credit check uk chase starbucks credit card aspire visa credit card payments where do i send my belk credit card payment pay lic premium using credit cards personal loans with bad credit direct lenders household credit card debt 2011 can i use visa debit cards online credit card rewards programs what do cardholders think hdfc credit card login reward points how do i pay back a direct deposit advance from wells fargo short term loans online direct lenders agreed credit limit virgin mobile capital one no credit credit card chase bank student credit card payday advance no credit check south africa hdfc bank add on credit card application form online loan lenders only apply for marriott credit card uk which credit card is easiest to get in india post office pay as you go credit cards how does tesco credit card points work best travel reward credit card 2011 toys r us credit card ge phone number consolidate your credit cards debt credit card for no credit capital one first modern credit card introduced 1950s hsbc starbucks credit card promo consolidate credit card debt into one loan easy credit cards to apply for online title loans online best travel credit card 2012 india credit card protection insurance uk use credit card to build credit rating luma credit card reviews what is a secured credit card yahoo walmart credit cards online application get unsecured credit card poor credit staples credit card business aqua credit card contact details bank of america credit card 0 interest balance transfer personal loans online direct lenders does aldi accept credit cards credit card minimum payment calculator uk does paying the minimum payment on a credit card affect your credit score walmart credit card review 2013 speedy cash payday loans online secured business credit cards to rebuild credit how to apply credit card online discover student more card credit limit cibc credit card insurance certificate southwest airlines no annual fee credit card standard chartered credit card customer care number singapore credit card protection under ?100 ace online cash advance maximum credit card interest rates canada is the capital one credit card a good card bank of america prepaid debit visa card credit building credit cards bank of america bad credit loan lenders no brokers top credit card processing credit card emi calculator hdfc bank how do i accept credit card payments canada best credit cards 2013 department stores that are easy to get credit cards pnc visa credit card online services credit card numbers for testing credit card verification code should i get an amazon credit card sam;s club business discover credit card login capital one credit card student disputing international credit card charges how many ba gold card holders are there can you sign up for a walmart credit card online amazon store credit card reviews pay chase online credit cards top credit card rewards 2013 quickbooks online processing credit cards santander credit card rate increase tesco credit card joint application planet fitness black card cancellation fee texas business free credit card machine apple credit card swiper for ipad iphone credit card machine canada reputable credit card debt settlement companies how much does it cost to use tesco credit card abroad credit card bank of ireland lost list of credit card companies capital one low interest rate credit cards need a credit card with a high limit how to get a business loan with bad credit in canada credit cards with cashback united chase visa credit card pay off credit card debt or save pay victoria secret credit card do i need a credit card for paypal unsecured credit card debt collection business credit cards comparison shopping tips top ten best credit cards for students secured personal loans with bad credit best credit cards with cash back offers guaranteed payday loan lenders only how to open hdfc credit card statement 0 balance transfer credit card offers australia do i need a credit card number to make an itunes account top 10 best student credit cards icici credit card apply eligibility platinum card concierge australia does costco accept mastercard credit cards pay advance loans online credit card authorization form pdf template chase credit card rewards center long term online loans for bad credit what are credit cards points us banks that offer credit cards chase apply for credit card by phone retail store credit cards after bankruptcy best bad credit loans no fees paypal charges for using credit card top credit card payment processors chase best buy credit card application cibc aeroplan miles credit card easy credit card checker 1.2 best low interest credit card balance transfer best gas credit card rebates bank of america credit card 0 apr balance transfer do you need a credit card for itunes gift card gap visa card services 0 interest balance transfer credit cards australia airtel balance transfer procedure how to apply for visa credit card with no credit unsecured credit card consolidation loan how to get a credit card online visa sbi corporate credit card customer care how to get mastercard securecode zero interest credit cards canada free visa credit card numbers with cvv 2013 recurring credit card authorization form intuit best mobile credit card terminal target debit visa card balance citi freedom credit card login credit card machines for small business costco line of credit loans for bad credit disney visa rewards card reviews should i opt out of credit card offers how can i apply for a firestone credit card kohls credit card online low interest rate credit card canada consumer reports best credit card rewards best travel credit cards in india credit card ppi interest calculator mbna credit card instant decision entropay virtual credit card generator hdfc credit card points redemption form how to use a credit card to build credit mastercard careers middle east what business credit card has the best rewards virgin credit card ppi check how to change credit card on ebay for buyers hsbc discover credit card list of payday lenders no brokers calculate interest paid on credit card debt free credit card generator and validator hsbc online credit card payments credit card application no existing credit card best fast cash payday loans zurich credit card insurance excess how to get a cash advance on your credit card standard chartered credit card offers on flipkart chase credit card with travel rewards check my visa gift card balance online sign up for a visa credit card canada instant cash loans online in south africa how to get small business loans with bad credit is bank of america secured credit card good compare credit card rewards singapore track hsbc credit card application status india best interest free credit card transfers black card amex replica air canada credit card aeroplan credit card rates ireland compare orchard credit card review contact barclay bank credit card what is a credit card issue number visa barclay credit card login india cash payday loans visa credit card services contact compare prepaid credit cards canada replacement gold card derbyshire no fee american express air miles credit card business credit cards comparison merchant visa credit card fees td visa debit card review citibank credit card reward points catalogue 2011 what types of credits would best describe credit cards lufthansa miles and more credit card switzerland pay sears credit card hsbc mastercard uk twitter can i use my sears credit card at kmart online payday loans no phone calls hsbc visa credit card online registration capital one secured credit card guaranteed approval should i cancel low limit credit cards virgin credit card balance transfer offers good and bad credit cards does paypal accept visa debit cards best low rate credit card pay sears credit card citibank credit card processing rates explained credit card comparison chart singapore remove apple credit card why do i need a credit card for my apple id chase government travel credit card free credit card numbers generator download all unsecured credit cards bad credit prepaid credit card visa what is the best store credit card to apply for with bad credit instant response credit cards uk how do you sign up for netflix without a credit card government small business loans with bad credit ecommerce credit card fraud statistics payday loan online instant macally secure credit card terminal for iphone best credit card abroad halifax all credit cards available unsecured personal loans bad credit short term bad credit loan lenders unsecured personal loans instant decision online sss online loan application credit score needed for sams club discover card alaska usa credit card login standard chartered credit card login uae virgin prepaid credit card ambank credit card balance transfer promotion us credit card debt hdfc credit card online payment through debit card fake valid credit card numbers with security code visa debit gift card cash back consumer reports best credit card to rebuild credit fnb online loan calculator how to use a credit card to build up credit best credit card interest rates canada how to sign up for credit card offers in the mail credit score for discover card approval credit card debt consolidation long black cardigan sweater register free virtual credit card credit cards for good credit scores chase credit card 500 cash back petro canada gas credit card chase wireless credit card machines ann taylor credit card review icici virtual credit card track icici credit card application status sample uk credit card number corporate credit card credit score go ge capital credit card department store credit cards usa how to get a car loan with bad credit and no job credit card for business start up best credit card rate malaysia report credit card fraud to police alaska airlines credit card visa canada costco credit card merchant processing chase advantage credit card login best fixed rate credit card deals fixed rate credit card balance transfers td canada trust visa gold cashback payday advance in corona ca bank of ireland credit card apply online axis bank credit card apply now net pay advance contact hdfc corporate credit card offers discover credit card payment site best prepaid credit cards for business business credit card bank of america cash back visa cards canada top 10 rewards credit cards canada cash advance online reviews make free virtual credit cards building credit and credit cards first premier secured credit card application how to pay off cash advance loans secured vs unsecured credit card amazon credit card security breach barclays platinum credit card uk new horizon bad credit card credit card travel notification easy approval credit cards unsecured mortgages for bad credit scotland student loans with bad credit history 2 cash back credit cards post office credit card abroad review td canada trust credit card interest rates bank of ireland credit card insurance on purchases best credit card deals rewards credit cards apply online ireland apply for student credit card online canada commonwealth bank credit cards contact aircel to vodafone balance transfer best american airlines credit card deals credit card rewards uk best rewards credit cards reviews best buy credit card no interest offers icici coral credit card apply online payday lenders not brokers uk ge money bank credit cards care credit all of the following are limitations of the existing online credit card payment system except loans you can pay back weekly im 18 should i get a credit card which bank gives the highest credit card limit credit cards with gas and grocery rewards virtual credit card number bank of america discover credit card activation phone number prepaid reloadable credit cards no monthly fees credit card 0 interest halifax credit card ppi payouts redbus offer code for hdfc credit card 0 credit cards bad credit rating hdfc credit card reward points offer how to use credit card payment machine credit card interest rate calculator online business credit cards for poor credit car loan with bad credit philippines citibank credit card application compare credit cards rewards travel pc credit card reader how to get a us credit card from overseas mortgages for bad credit payday lenders no credit check apply for wells fargo secured credit card credit card debt relief company reviews bad credit loans instant decision direct lenders td canada trust visa travel instant unsecured credit card approval for poor credit how to use a hdfc credit card axis bank online credit card application status first usa credit card application free credit report without credit card major credit cards for bad credit pay orchard bank credit card best visa credit cards for students what credit cards are good for bad credit global credit card fraud statistics circuit city credit card login store credit cards after bankruptcy paypal virtual terminal credit card reader premier credit card pay online icici credit card charges for irctc ticket booking best business credit cards 2013 no annual fee instant approval credit card canada credit cards no interest no payments amazon chase credit card no interest apple square credit card reader canada gas reward cards program va loan with bad credit score get a payday loan online direct lender ebay buyer protection paypal credit card does applying for a credit card affect your credit rating city bank credit card customer care toll free number best short term cash loans pay my toys r us credit card online nationwide credit card balance transfer fee us airways mastercard secure login rbc visa low interest credit card credit card consolidation loan companies fast cash loans with bad credit hsbc costco credit card account applying for a credit card in canada with bad credit peoples credit card numbers real 2013 credit card numbers 2013 hacked how do best buy credit cards work hsbc credit card online apply where can i use my go mastercard can i apply for a visa credit card online report lost credit card hdfc bank super balance transfer to current account corporate platinum credit card hdfc best 0 credit cards rewards credit cards canada comparison belk credit card payment options does td bank have prepaid visa cards business credit card comparison australia how to get a business loan with bad credit and no money best credit card for purchases 2012 halifax credit card 0 prepaid credit card post office uk fixed rate credit cards 2013 best credit card 2012 usa visa cards start with 44 payday cash advance loans missouri credit card logos british airways airmiles credit card uk how to pay advance income tax online starwood credit card australia good credit cards for building credit best credit card processing companies canada check credit score for free no credit cards required how many credit cards should i have open for a good credit score barclays credit card contact best buy credit card accounthdfc credit card settlement process india hdfc credit card limit platinum cards credit card merchant agreement id best business cash back credit card 2013 axis bank credit card login 100 guaranteed credit cards tesco credit card application contact number gm household credit card login what is the easiest credit card to get approved for uk marriott rewards credit cards in uk credit card issuers in singapore can you use a balance transfer credit card to pay off an overdraft credit card zero interest balance transfer offer check the status of my toys r us credit card application credit card protection ach and credit card merchant account processing for small businesses best site to compare credit cards credit card debt settlement letter example credit card promotions nov 2013 free balance transfer credit card canada sears kmart credit card login good unsecured credit cards for rebuilding credit cash reward credit cards review balance transfer credit card student loan government travel credit card login credit cards with zero percent interest on balance transfers which credit card is the easiest to get approval in canada what is the best cash back credit card for business sbi credit card application process walmart credit card number customer service max out credit cards then declare bankruptcy easy credit cards to get approved for business best secured credit cards to rebuild credit 2011 best online credit card processing fees apply for small business credit card online hdfc credit card apply online in bangalore credit card verification service chase toys r us credit card mailing address best secured credit cards 2013 credit card approval formula best portable credit card scanner secured credit cards to rebuild credit halifax credit card minimum payment amount what is the best credit card for me easy application for credit cards interest free balance transfer credit card uae bad credit credit cards no credit check uk bad credit car finance essex credit card payment calculator excel spreadsheet consolidate credit card debt calculator paying off credit card debt fast city bank credit card emi offers visa black card credit score how to get credit card cash advance top 0 credit card offers spg amex credit card offer best credit card for no credit or bad credit online credit cards instant approval credit limit increase wells fargo standard merchant credit card fees
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews Interview - Andrew Zimbalist - New CBA

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 960 guests online

Atom RSS

Interview - Andrew Zimbalist - New CBA PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 19 November 2006 11:00
Andrew ZimbalistBaseball knows a good thing when they see it. When the 2002-2006 CBA was brokered at the 11th hour, it marked the first time since the formation of the MLBPA and the collective bargaining process that some form of work stoppage did not occur. Because there was labor peace, and because provisions such as revenue-sharing were adjusted and the Luxury Tax introduced, MLB has flourished. So much so that this year sees projections in excess of $5.2 billion in revenues--a staggering figure.

2007 will mark the beginning of a new Basic Agreement that will further work to extend this unparalleled growth. There were inadequacies in certain aspects of the last Basic Agreement, namely the revenue-sharing component.

One person who has worked on the economics of the new agreement--specifically the revenue-sharing component--is sports economist and author, Andrew Zimbalist. Zimbalist serves as Robert A. Woods Professor of Economics at Smith College, and has written several books on sports economics, including the recently released The Bottom Line: Observations and Arguments on the Sports Business and In the Best Interests of Baseball? The Revolutionary Reign of Bud Selig.

I interviewed Zimbalist in 2004 and have stayed in contact with him since. With the new CBA, the increased interest in the posting process and the Red Sox bidding $51.1 million for the rights to negotiate with Japanese pitching sensation Daisuke Matsuzaka, as well as other economic factors in baseball that have occurred since first interviewing Zimbalist then, I thought it was time to talk to him again, given his work on the new CBA.

In this interview Zimbalist talks of his overall impression of the new agreement, why the agreement was reached well in advance of the Dec. 19th deadline, whether new stadium development impacts revenue-sharing, his thoughts on possible expansion, whether revenue-sharing has been the catalyst for competitive balance, and much more.

Maury Brown for Biz of Baseball: What is your overall impression of the new Basic Agreement?  

Zimbalist QuoteAndrew Zimbalist: It is a significant improvement over its predecessor.  It lowers marginal tax rates for all teams.  It also realigns the marginal rates so the low revenue teams now pay basically the same rate as the high revenue teams (in practice the marginal rates now will vary between 30 percent and 32.5 percent).  Together, these two changes will undo the perverse incentives in the last CBA which should minimize the behavior of some teams not using their transfers to improve their onfield performance.  Moreover, a part of the sharing will be based on a fixed concept of revenue, so that the tendency to reward teams for their lack of success will be diminished.   These modifications should result in improved competitive balance and improved incentives to grow the league.  The new deal also eliminates the so-called cliff problem or mean discontinuity, whereby a team just above the mean revenue before sharing could end up with less net revenue after sharing than the team just below the mean before sharing.

BizBall: Much has been made of how smooth the new labor agreement was reached and how far in advance of the December 19th the sides came together to announce the memorandum of understanding. How much of this can be attributed to key deadlines, such as the expiration of the Luxury Tax and the rollback of penalties within the Joint Drug Agreement, compared to overall goodwill?

Zimbalist: I’m not sure I like either of your choices.  I think the main factors behind the smooth process this time were: (1) the unparalleled economic success of MLB in recent years; (2) the growing ability of the negotiators on each side to understand the concerns and priorities of the other side; (3) the success of Bud Selig in fashioning a functional degree of coherence among the owners; and (4) the lasting effects of the chastening of both sides from the devastation of the 1994-95 work stoppage.

BizBall: The Yankees, Mets, and now it appears, the A’s will all have new facilities that will come online during this new agreement. Given the fact that clubs can still write off a portion of their revenue-sharing obligation by constructing new facilities, is this a concern that the total amount collected for revenue-sharing purposes will be lessened?

Zimbalist QuoteZimbalist: Again, there is a false premise in your question.  The total amount of revenue sharing should increase with the new stadiums.  The total sum shared is based on what would be shared under a straight pool distribution at 48 percent, given the level of net defined local revenue (NDLR).  NDLR basically is local revenue minus local team stadium expenses (with some tricky accounting rules along the way).  A team would not invest in a new stadium unless it expected its new revenues to exceed its new expenses.  So new stadiums should result in higher NDLR, and, hence, higher sharing.  

The new deal actually has a special provision that, in effect, reduces the deduction allowed to teams with new stadiums, but it is too complex to go into here.

BizBall: The longest stretch between expansions in the modern era has been 11-years. Given the unparalleled growth in MLB, is it possible that expansion might be a consideration for the league within timeframe of the new Basic Agreement?

Zimbalist: I would like to see expansion, but I think that the growth of revenue sharing has made the owners even more leery of it than before.  High-revenue team owners now see new teams as potential claimants on their revenue.  Low-revenue team owners see new teams as diluting the pool of revenue transfers.  My sense is that expansion would come only after the application of effective political pressure and I don’t see that materializing anytime soon.

BizBall: The league has said that revenue-sharing is a chief catalyst for the competitive balance we have been seeing over the past several seasons. How much of this balance is attributed to revenue-sharing, and how much of it can be attributed to factors such as the introduction of the Wild Card?

Zimbalist: I think that the bulk of the improvement since the late nineties to the present is attributable to the Wild Card and other factors.

MatsuzakaBizBall: This off-season sees far more interest in the posting process given the Red Sox submitting a bid figure of $51.1 million, simply for the right to negotiate for his services. Many fans may wonder if the posting process impacts overall player payroll, which in turn relates to the luxury tax thresholds, etc. What, if any, impacts come with the posting process?

Zimbalist: The net impact of the posting system is probably inflationary for two reasons.  First, it brings more of the world’s top players into MLB.  Some GMs say Matsuzaka might be the best pitcher in baseball next year.  Second, the total price the Sox will pay for Matsuzaka, if they sign him, will be $51.1 million plus his salary.  The bid of $51.1 million does not count as payroll for purposes of the luxury tax.  Although the posting system structurally is set up so as not to grant free agency rights to the posted player, it is likely that Scott Boras will be seeking free agent type money for his client.  In a free agent environment, Matsuzaka would be worth roughly as much as some of the top salaried pitchers today (e.g., Randy Johnson at $16 million a year).   But let's say since teams are not bidding against each other, Boras would settle for $48.9 million over four years.  If the Red Sox went along (and I doubt they would),  the team's total payment for his services is $100 million over four years, putting him in A-Rod territory.  But only the $48.9 million (or $12.225 million per year) will be potentially subject to the 40 percent luxury tax.  This is a bargain, in a sense, and induces the Sox to offer more money for the player.

BizBall: Finally, will baseball be able to sustain its 11 percent annual growth rate during the coming CBA?

Zimbalist: This is a good question.  On the one hand, many of the structural sources of growth have weakened: the appearance of Fox as a national network bidding for sports rights; the emergence of ESPN and RSNs bidding for sports rights; the construction of gentrified ballparks in city centers with the attendant explosion of corporate Zimbalist Quoterevenues, and, the growth of the internet and the associated streaming of games and merchandising.  On the other hand, MLB’s new CBA will better incentivize teams to innovate and grow revenues, the Yankees, Mets, Nationals and the A’s promise to have new ballparks in two to three years, MLBAM growth continues to be explosive, yield management ticketing strategies are being developed, and the overall management of the game continues to improve.  There is also the issue of how baseball’s changing accounting procedures will recognize the revenues of related parties.  Finally, part of the revenue picture will be determined by factors outside MLB’s control, such as the performance of the national economy – a matter about which I am not terribly sanguine over the intermediate term.  If I had to make a projection, it would be for industry growth rates on the order of 8 to 10 percent annually over the term of the new CBA.

  • Interview conducted by Maury Brown

To read other interviews on The Biz of Baseball with the likes of Jayson Stark, Ken Rosenthal, Stan Kasten, Marvin Miller, Bowie Kuhn, Bob Costas, and others, select the Interviews navigation element to the left on any page.



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?