can you get high off amantadine viagra pricing costco shuddha guggulu where can i buy it periactin syrup ingredients buy suhagra online buy eulexin online with mastercard procardia medication online imiquimod side effects skin cancer tesco ireland pharmacy jobs where can i order clonidine calcium carbonate in the uk generic hoodia safe long term effects prednisone cats can u buy clomid over the counter brand viagra precio mexico buy tofranil fast shipping sustiva for sale philippines cialis professional online bestellen luvox online without prescription tadacip rx gonorrhea treatment zithromax dosage cognitive enhancement drugs in the workplace lithium online sales canadian alliance for community service learning website csl pariet price india cleocin tablet sale how long to use fosamax can you get high off benadryl liquid gels crestor in italia what are the side effects of proventil hfa florida voveran sr what is amoxil used for where can i buy cephalexin tablets where cane i buy clomid from protonix reviews for men vipps certified online pharmacy generic name for atrovent evecare legal in england sinequan tablets on line to buy toprol xl discount medications benicar prescription assistance program propecia with no prescription levitra 10 mg for sale viagra preisvergleich generika elavil online bestellen sinequan dosage instructions comprar levitra plus original en madrid crestor commercial beach purchase vasotec on line in usa make liquid viagra drink mail-order isoptin allopurinol drugstore.com dipyridamole to buy from europe aldactone side effects in men zithromax on line purchase metformin pills smell like fish eric harris columbine luvox cheap fluoxetine hydrochloride cialis 40 mg generic cheap allopurinol pills gout is generic viagra available in the united states do i need a prescription for oxytrol levitra reviews vardenafil zovirax price india what does deltasone dog aldactone for dogs buy astelin nasal spray generic order allegra online no prescription pharmacy metronidazole 500mg tab dosage can you buy accutane from canada buy remeron without a script what is ranitidine used for in babies prescription aciphex cost where can i buy baby alligators buy motilium online with mastercard wellbutrin sr drug schedule cholestoplex medication pharmacy generic generic isoniazid in usa revia on line for sale no script where propecia grows hair where can i get some zyprexa ranitidine mg no prescription abilify dosage for bipolar 2 roche xenical 120 mg side effects acheter du viagra en ligne can you buy revatio discount counter healthy diet 30 year old man propranolol tablets 10mg patient information what does mean allegra name zentel prospect copii alesse usa cvs prices risperdal free shipping cheap viagra paypal payment lipitor mexico prescription buy cheap generic abana buy zenegra from mexico online venta viagra generica best price for flonase sinequan drug classification evista com coupon best place order viagra online canada buy cheap aciclovir medication order kamagra gold spain costco milton keynes opticians without a script cabana online buy moduretic paypal maxifort zimax sildenafil efectos secundarios order reglan oral solution compare prescription prices cvs walgreens tetracycline without a prescription from australia colospa overnight shipping cheap cytotec echeck chloramphenicol generico italiano legal buy altace online canada buy zovirax online india no prescription is there a drug comparative to aldactone fertomid women buy what is ginseng tablets good for prometrium to buy in england generic flagyl er buy canada buy diakof online india actonel india methotrexate pharmacy buy fml forte online pharmacy janssen cilag pipeline oncology how to get off lisinopril safely prednisone 5mg dose pack 48 renova black toilet paper case what is the generic name for trileptal shatavari online pharmacy uk what are the side effects of clonidine 0.1mg seroflo medication where to buy buyers of trazodone canada seroquel price australia buy cleocin gel inhaler canada to buy mevacor comprar topamax pela internet clomid on line uk accutane dosage instructions asacol where to get oxytrol tablets best site to buy desyrel what does viagra feel like yahoo actonel where to get purchase vytorin pills buying lipitor herbal blue pill uk xenical free shipping augmentin without a prescription from india suhagra 100 review claritin australia price coversyl ;cough medicines; order etodolac online generic elimite buy canada buy renagel from india laura spain exelon ciprofloxacin health canada side effects bystolic on line purchase long term side effects of female viagra safe anafranil buy betoptic buy online ireland eldepryl maximum dosage levitra professional generic canada rosuvastatin 100mg cheep switching from zoloft to remeron buy cipro tablets online buy medrol online india store prescription cheap zanaflex comprar imitrex original en madrid cvs natural water pills over the counter liposafe where to buy ciproxin carafate tablets prescribing information medicine back pain natural best place to order pariet in us prandin 0.5 mg tablet ranitidine order canada help prescription medicine costs xanax europe no prescription blopress on line no script glycomet drugs online purchases qsymia consumer reviews levitra precio mexico anafranil online forum is generic prilosec effective what is hoodia cactus alternative to doxycycline hyclate glycomet for sale online buy cabana neurosis what are erythromycin tablets used for clomid ovulation predictor female cialis cheap does levitra work for premature ejaculation purchase nexium in usa imitrex injection sale rimonabant weight loss drug amantadine in croatia apcalis tadalafil tablets how to import minipress trileptal how to buy viagra supply como usar la crema benzac doxycycline side effects pregnancy cheap tamoxifen pills uk online pharmacy non generic taco cabana order cephalexin line to buy extendaquin acai medication cheap toradol 100 mg online pharmacy canada no prescription diovan user reviews costco web pharmacy zebeta over the counter usa purchase shatavari pills will clomid prevent miscarriage singulair medication side effects flomax shoppers drug mart switching from lexapro to paxil avodart price malaysia dilantin from india nootropil ordering online pharmacy voveran sr without prescription tretinoin 0,025 india remeron tablets for sale what is the best dose of citalopram for anxiety ginette-35 coupons why has atrovent been discontinued carafate drug schedule famvir medication shingles celebrex brand positioning abilify where can i buy discount trazodone mg pyridium tablets 200 mg prevacid make you gain weight is plavix being discontinued serpina mg canadian rx emsam in canada where cane i buy trimethoprim tablets thyroxine hormone levels dapoxetine online ordering piroxicam gel atacand discount voucher order rumalaya forte medication by mail female cialis billig kaufen generic viagra me uk kamagra tablets info order erection packs 11 from generic mail order generic atorlip-5 robaxin for discount azathioprine and 6 mercaptopurine bactroban nasal mupirocin calcium ointment 2 to buy astelin canadian generic what is actos buy anafranil buy provera 100mg online cialis sublingual on line for sale no script zyban recommended dose is remeron better than ambien where to spend honor points alliance dalaran herpes medication zovirax fincar australia generic avandamet advair diskus effects mouth possible side buy valtrex pills in the canada indinavir legal in england most common medication for anxiety and depression eurax discounts codes liquid nimotop review terramycin canada prescription lynoral online forum forum review prescription merck propecia finasteride buy prescription drugs mexico current price lithium buy baclofen without rx can you mix celebrex and alcohol midamor overseas can you buy differin gel over the counter indian generics online ampicillin atarax medication definition levitra super active from mexico propecia results months estradiol testosterone cream zofran better than promethazine liposafe prices usa lekaren on line viagra celadrin buy canada triamterene order online synthroid discount drug wellbutrin 10 mg cost what does a 50 mg zoloft pill look like indocin online from usa viagra professional tablets us online ayurslim tablets online buy hydrocodone online no prescription cheap bupropion xl price walgreens medline india cefixime robaxin without a prescription buy minocycline new zealand online aspirin online kaufen current price cialis soft brand levitra australia pharmacy zolpidem tartrate dosage what is hydrochlorothiazide medication for stats counter html us pharmacies online that sell provera side effects of dutas cheap sarafem 40 mg lioresal pharmacy prices list ordering soft viagra online drug benicar 80 mg tablet amitriptyline hydrochloride for pain neurontin cost canada use alphagan coupon online como comprar aciclovir nos estados unidos diamox sequels medication prescription drug sales data flonase cataracts lawsuit differin coupons 35 cashback buy revia medication cheap aleve baclofen online in usa do i need a prescription for skelaxin can you take nexium twice daily comprar rosuvastatin original order amaryllis plant healthy weight 40 year old man kamagra oral jelly usage what do mobic pills look like order xanax online uk diamox order on web buy valacyclovir valtrex is generic zaditor available in usa how much is propecia at walgreens crestor 10 mg pret disgrasil precio penegra mg buy do i need viagra i pill serophene website cheapest drug ditropan where to buy cheap generic lukol how to import kamagra oral jelly online pharmacy uk aleve abilify coupons and discounts purchase atorlip-5 mg cost of advair diskus 500/50 pharmacy that sells viagra professional getting periactin in australia strattera adhd wikipedia ampicillin online antibiotics buy seroflo hong kong copd obstructive terramycin tablets from buy tinidazole wanted online review buy dostinex india zocor shoppers drug mart vytorin brands india generic for valtrex 1gm www bystolic side effects trandate supplier in uk sertralina 50 mg genfar viagra price 100mg where can i buy citalopram in the uk astelin no prescription reviews meds online no script accutane dosage order viagra plus in prescriptions fertomid medication where to buy andros sildenafil side effects flovent hfa coupon cost of protonix cb-1 weight gain pills reviews bayas de acai comprar do i need a prescription for bentyl cytotec labor and delivery low cost eurax cipla pharmaceuticals careers tesco pharmacy opening times swansea arimidex pct side effects pms-amantadine side effects best place to buy albendazole in uk can i make pletal can you get high from snorting paxil what is hyaluronic acid good for skin depakote 40 mg dose naprosyn tablets price we transfer not working where is downton abbey wedding filmed buy clozaril 100mg online pletal brand positioning nymphomax canada prescription buy proscar online no prescription seroquel without a prescription free shipping acheter decadron pas cher itunes 12 days of christmas prevacid order levitra plus medicine canadian pharmacy pill shop nike air max men sale blood pressure medication tenormin over counter promethazine order buy actos online discount cardizem tablets purchase on line acai mg tablet atrovent australia price where can i buy ceftin risperdal buy on line elocon on line in the canada norvasc 5mg price philippines generic colospa in usa how to take tenormin prinivil lawsuit canada finast no rx detrol without insurance accutane second month over the counter amoxil buy asacol mg online what is the function of liv 52 best place to buy lipitor in india bupropion uk online how many claritin d can you buy where to buy cheap generic aciclovir costco pharmacy speman price what is tricor pills used for toprol xl generic cost medicine digoxina prescription drug micronase how to take mentax mg purchase celebrex no prescription low price what is wellbutrin sr prescribed for ordering flagyl india pfizer viagra 50mg vs 100mg is it illegal to order generic zerit how to order diamox online lasix delivery uk prevacid without a prescription from canada lowest premarin dose order strattera 40 mg buying lipitor in spain mentat ds syrup prescription coupon haloperidol (haldol serenace) acai berry detox capsules side effects viagra professional medication supreme commander forged alliance purchase can men take metronidazole biaxin generic equivalent zofran drugs nausea low cost clomid levitra erfahrung kauf online arimidex price nhs repeat prescriptions online can i get moduretic ampicillin pediatric dose meningitis Purchase vermox 500mg amoxil capsules side effects reglan no prrescription generic drug atacand hct potatoes not prozac recipes zoloft pills online in the india generic combivent for sale on line generic prazosin for sale on line promethazine w codeine syrup over the counter exelon medication price why can i find alli diet pills in stores generic cefixime price order lotrisone 120 mg order cabgolin online propecia generic date 2012 buy antabuse 500mg buspar no rx discontinued use of paxil cialis super active drug in canada pharmacy cardura drugs com order purim cheap antifludes jarabe adulto amsterdam pharmacy airport weight gain after nolvadex traditional chinese medicine back pain cialis 20 mg time no prescription carbozyne sale where to buy qsymia cefixime uk brand name can you buy zovirax drugstore generic aciphex overnite shipping norvasc canada prescription low cost astelin can you buy lopressor blood pressure cholesterol drug clomid pct after anavar can we trust lynoral online what is acai berry online sale of cardizem best price prednisolone can i get pregnant while on synthroid cheap pills finasteride buy proscar best place to buy prograf synthroid vs levoxyl vs levothroid where to buy allegra d over the counter antihistamine blue pill with watson 349 on it online doctor prescriptions xanax atarax pills effects what are some generic drug names for synthroid buy benzac singapore buy generic cialis professional the drugstore cowboys rockabilly probalan shopping herbal raw material suppliers in india requip tablets price lamisil cream prices amaryl over the counter 1mg drugs online how much is viagra in thailand safe place order zyban is there a generic drug for arimidex order dulcolax buy phenergan online with mastercard indian glucotrol xl what is crestor medication used for trazodone where can i buy it purchase norvasc canada buy trental cheap what does maxalt contain order zyloprim 120 mg where to buy pet meds online purchase cephalexin oral suspension avodart birth control online us finax uk buy what is the signs of digoxin toxicity abilify without antidepressant treatment original zetia online is generic atacand available in usa kamagra oral jelly prescription coupon can you buy cytoxan drug propecia recommended dosage low vitamin d erectile dysfunction cane you buy lamisil canadian pharmacy fertility drugs for men treatment seroquel uk pharmacy best pharmacy to order skelaxin methotrexate combination humira premarin from canada mobic online canada amoxil where can i buy zyrtec 10 mg ml solution buvable en gouttes feldene online overnight cheapest brand name viagra buy viagra las vegas nv comprar atorlip-10 original en madrid on line pharmacy for brand name 100 mg viagra order pariet on line mexico alli pct buy dostinex how long to take effect oregon state parks cabins doxycycline 10mg tablets shuddha guggulu order in the us glucophage dosage too high viagra generic wikipedia drugs what is unisom buy brand advair diskus 20 buy cipro discount discount canadian pharmacy lincocin cialis for daily use coupon pak newspapers online free female pink viagra 100 mg pills is zyrtec better than claritin d ophthacare italiano pulmicort sold over counter mail-order motrin alli diet pills canada can you buy cialis over counter mexico cheap genuine combivent online huge weight gain on methotrexate actos shipping overseas yasmin contraceptive pills instructions cheap purinethol buy online paroxetine from zydus can your buy levitra professional in ireland tablets omnicef for purchase what are the long term side effects of taking metformin desyrel for sleep aid what is the color and shape of pyridium tablets where to buy viramune pharmacy from india to usa long term side effects of vantin buy geriforte mexican pharmacies cleocin no prescription compare prices can you get voveran over the counter dilantin level check where can you buy ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution viagra generic online uk deltasone western australia prometrium lowest price my himcolin coupons oxytrol price roxithromycin dosage for acne calcium carbonate with vitamin d drug classification prices for viagra at walmart generic gasex in usa is there viagra for ladies order famvir online no prescription zaditor eye drops india viagra not covered by medicare remeron over counter uk order celexa pill buy elocon australia donde comprar trazodone cheap ortho tri-cyclen birth control viagra australia buy online propecia online store cheap xbox live gold order parlodel online uk zyban uk antidepressant best blood pressure medication for black men pletal medication dose buy terramycin 20 promethazine shop net precose cheap price cheap metformin 500 mg late ovulation on clomid living pcos finpecia no rx wellbutrin withdrawal nausea can you buy mevacor online all types sominex pills vancouver british columbia pharmacies where is the love lyrics busted best nexium prices nizagara western australia doxycycline 100mg capsule compazine tablets price combivent canada vente de acai au quebec priligy 30mg side effects aricept roche precio argentina cheap aciclovir buy online hydrea generic wikipedia drugs
Home All Articles Dosh: MLB's Revenue-Sharing and the Luxury Tax Are Not One in the Same

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 838 guests online

Atom RSS

Dosh: MLB's Revenue-Sharing and the Luxury Tax Are Not One in the Same PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 37
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Kristi Dosh   
Monday, 19 April 2010 11:48

The Biz of BaseballWhile we have run a prior article on this subject, guest author Kristi Dosh of It's a Swing and a Miss has gone into further detail on how revenue-sharing and the Competitve Balance Tax (Luxury Tax) functions in Major League Baseball. Enjoy. -- Maury Brown, President, Business of Sports Network, BizofBaseball.com


I’ve spent the past four years studying, writing and guest lecturing on revenue sharing and internal taxation in Major League Baseball. Accordingly, I’m fascinated by the debate raging in the media between Randy Levine, President of the Yankees, and Mark Attanasio, the owner of the Brewers. What really caught my eye though was the confusion between revenue sharing and the competitive balance tax. As I’ve guest lectured on these topics over the past four years, I’ve found that even your most avid baseball fan doesn’t generally know or understand the difference.

So, before I explain the difference, let me set the stage for you…

It all started with this comment to USA Today by Mark Attanasio, owner of the Milwaukee Brewers:

“We’re struggling to sign Prince Fielder, and the Yankees infield is making more than our team.”

Enter Randy Levine, President of the Yankees, who said this to ESPNNewYork.com:

“I’m sorry that my friend Mark continues to whine about his running the Brewers. We play by all the rules and there doesn’t seem to be any complaints when teams such as the Brewers receive hundreds of millions of dollars that they get from us in revenue sharing the last few years. Take some of that money that you get from us and use that to sign your players.”

“The question that should be asked is: Where has the hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue sharing gone?”

Ok, I’m on board so far. It’s the same old David versus the Yankees story as always in baseball. The real problem comes in how the story has been framed by many media outlets.

Gabe Lacques, who wrote the USA Today piece, wrote this in his article:

“According to the Biz of Baseball, the Yankees have accounted for $175 million – or 92% – of all revenue-sharing payments since revenue sharing was instituted.”

Andrew Marchand, who wrote the ESPNNewYork.com story, similarly stated:

“In the initial seven years of the luxury tax, the Yankees have paid teams nearly $175 million in revenue sharing, according to the BizofBaseball.com. That is 92 percent of the total revenue sharing that has been doled out.”

Enter confusion, stage right. Revenue sharing and the luxury tax (which, by the way, was renamed the “competitive balance tax” in the 2002 CBA, which covered 2003-2006) are two completely separate concepts. Aside from the Yankees having to pay both, they have very little in common.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE DETAILS ON REVENUE SHARING AND THE LUXURY TAX

Revenue Sharing

Revenue sharing was first approved by the owners in 1994 and included in the 1996-2000 Collective Bargaining Agreement, presumably as an alternative to a salary cap, which was ruled out by the MLBPA. Revenue sharing is based on a club’s Net Local Revenue for a given year. Understanding what Net Local Revenue is takes the reading of no less than five definitions in the CBA, but I’m going to provide you the overly simplified version. Net Local Revenue is Local Revenue (gross revenue from all revenue areas like ticket sales, concessions, etc. minus Central Revenue, which is national television and radio, etc.) minus Actual Stadium Expense (which is exactly what it sounds like, the actual monies paid out by a club for its stadium).

The 1996-2000 CBA phased in revenue sharing with the use of three different plans:

Split Pool Plan: each club put in 20% of their Net Local Revenue. Those monies were then divided 75/25, with 75% being split evenly amongst all clubs and 25% being split only between those clubs with a Net Local Revenue below the mean for all clubs. The 25% was not split evenly between those clubs below the mean, but based on their distance from the mean.

Straight Pool Plan: each club put in 39% of their Net Local Revenue and it was split evenly with all clubs.

Hybrid Plan: evaluated the result each club would have under each of the above plans and then assigned the plan that was better for that club as a payor/payee. So, if the Yankees would pay out less under the Split Pool Plan, they were assigned that plan. If the Royals would receive more under the Straight Pool Plan, they were assigned that plan.

Then, to make it even more confusing, the plan was implemented on a percentage basis:

  • 1996: 60% Hybrid Plan
  • 1997: 60% Hybrid Plan
  • 1998: 80% Split Pool Plan
  • 1999: 85% Split Pool Plan
  • 2000: 100% Split Pool Plan

So, in 1996, a club received or paid 60% of the total result under the Hybrid Plan. The result was that $50 million was moved around in 1996. By 2002, that number would be $169 million.

In 2002, revenue sharing was simplified under the next CBA. The Straight Pool Plan was in effect for the length of the CBA at a rate of 34%. So, each club put in 34% of their Net Local Revenue each year, and then the pool was divided evenly between all of the clubs. A Central Fund component was added, which called for 41.066% of the total amount transferred from payor clubs to payee clubs to be pulled from baseball’s Central Fund and divided between payee clubs whose average Net Local Revenue over the past three years fell below the average for all clubs over that same time period. The amount distributed was to be deduced from distributions to be made to payor clubs at the end of the season. There’s a very specific mathematical formula for this in the CBA, but I won’t go into it here.

I know you’ve all heard the grumblings about teams receiving more in revenue sharing than the spend (*cough* Marlins *cough*). An example I use in my lectures is the 2005 Florida Marlins. Payroll was cut by nearly 75% to a league-leading low of $14,998,500, more than $20 million below the next lowest payroll. Meanwhile, their cut of revenue sharing was reported to be $31 million, leaving them $16 million for other “baseball-related” activities. That’s the only parameter given in the CBA for spending revenue sharing dollars, by the way: that it be used for “baseball-related activities.”

The 2006 CBA contained a revenue sharing provision very similar to the 2002 CBA. The percentage was decreased from 34% to 31% because of increased revenues league-wide, but the other provisions remain mostly unchanged.

Time for another example I use in my lectures. The Royals revenue sharing receipts doubled from 2002-2007, but payroll only rose by 6%. Meanwhile, the team value has risen from $96m to $282m. Just food for thought.

Need dessert to go with that? Consider this quote by Mr. Attanasio:

“We do get a piece of revenue sharing, and we appreciate it, and we need it, and we use it. We put it to use. It’s a matter of record that we use our revenue sharing dollars pretty much every year in our budget.”

First off, I’m bothered by the use of “pretty much,” which makes me wonder why not always? Second, when he says it’s a matter of record, don’t be fooled into thinking it’s a matter of public record. It’s not. Every club in MLB guards its numbers very closely, and you will never see the Brewers budget and be able to ascertain for yourself just where that revenue sharing money is going.

As if that weren’t enough, another issue with revenue sharing is the Net Local Revenue calculation, which is easily manipulated. Picture this…Club A’s owner is also the owner of ABC, Corp., which provides concession services. Club A hires ABC, Corp to provide concessions at its ballpark. Club A’s owner overpays ABC, Corp in order to decrease Club A’s Net Local Revenue number, thus increasing Club A’s share of revenue sharing distributions.

Haven’t had enough yet? Another example…Club B’s owner also owns XYZ Media, Inc., which airs Club B’s games locally. Club B negotiates a contract with XYZ Media, Inc. where XYZ Media, Inc. underpays for its contract to air Club B’s games locally, thus lowering its Net Local Revenue number and increasing its share of revenue sharing distributions.

Oh, and if you’re still feeling bad for the Brewers and the other small market teams, consider this: in 2002 three teams were sold and bought. The Red Sox, who are obviously in a large market, sold for $380m (taking on about $40m in debt). The New York Mets, another large market team, sold for $391m. The Marlins, the poster child for small market teams, sold for $158m. Ever heard you get what you pay for?

Luxury Tax

After the infamous strike of 1994, the owners also managed to introduced the luxury tax after being defeated on the salary cap by the MLBPA. Most people think it was aimed directly at Steinbrenner and his seemingly endless wallet, and most people are right.

The only thing the luxury tax has in common with revenue sharing, aside from hitting the Yankees wallet the hardest, is that they made it way too complicated in the 1996 CBA. The luxury tax was only implemented under that CBA for 1997, 1998 and 1999. Thresholds were set and any team who exceed the threshold paid the tax:

  • 1997: $51 million threshold (35% tax on amount over threshold)
  • 1998: $55 million threshold (35% tax on amount over threshold)
  • 1999: $58.9 million threshold (34% tax on amount over threshold)

Simple, right? Yep, so they had to make it a little more complex. Enter the “floating threshold” concept. At the end of each season, if the midpoint between the fifth and sixth highest payrolls was more than the threshold, then that became the new threshold. Then, the threshold for the next year would be adjusted based on that number.

Now even if you can grasp all that, the definition of Actual Club Payroll is sneaking in at stage left to really complicate matters. Actual Club Payroll is 1/28th (there were only 28 clubs then) of player benefit costs, player salaries and other amounts like bonuses and deferred compensation. Throw in that some players are only with the team for part of the year, or have a contract that doesn’t specify amounts for each individual year, and you really have a mess on your hands.

Requests can be made within MLB or by the MLBPA with regards to how the acquisition of a player might affect a club’s payroll total. This was meant to make the luxury tax figure into a club’s decision to sign a player. It was assumed most clubs would try to avoid the penalty. However, the floating threshold concept got in the way in the beginning. The very first year the tax was in effect, 13 clubs were over the midpoint between the fifth and sixth highest payroll and were hit with the tax.

Before I get into how the tax has evolved, I should clarify where the money goes. Under the 1996 CBA, the first $10m went to compensate for any issues with the revenus sharing plan (such as running short under the Hybrid Plan), the next $7m went to the 5 AL clubs and 5 NL clubs with the lowest Local Revenue, the next $3m went to the Industry Growth Fund (which funds training camps and other baseball development activities domestically and internationally), and the next $2.5m went to fund a reserve for any overpayments made into the system. In the end, $30.9m was collected under the 1996 CBA.

The 2002 CBA saw the luxury tax become the competitive balance tax and introduced a somewhat new system. Much higher thresholds were set for 2003-2006:

  • 2003: $117m
  • 2004: $120.5m
  • 2005: $128m
  • 2006: $136.5m

Increasing penalties for repeats offenders was also introduced, making it clear that the tax was meant as a deterrent and a penalty:

  • 2002 First-Time Offenders: 17.5%
  • 2003 First-Time Offenders: 22.5%
  • Second-Time Offenders: 30%
  • Third-Time Offenders: 40%

The distribution of funds also evolved, no longer providing for funding to low revenue clubs, thus distinguishing it entirely from revenue sharing. The first $5m would go to refund for any miscalculaations, then 50% would go to player benefits, 25% to the Industry Growth Fund, and 25% to developing baseball in countries without high school programs.

The 2006 CBA kept the basic model of the 2002 CBA with adjustments for thresholds and taxation amounts:

  • 2007: $148m
  • 2008: $155m
  • 2009: $162m
  • 2010: $170m
  • 2011: $178m

Penalties also increased:

  • First-Time Offenders: 22.5%
  • Second-Time Offenders: 30%
  • Third-Time Offenders: 40%

Distributions remain roughly the same and continued the trend towards fudning player benefits with the tax money. The first $2.5m is set aside for refunds, then 75% for player benefits and 25$ to the Industry Growth Fund. Thus, the tax is not distributed to low revenue clubs.

Now back to the statements by Mr. Lacques and Mr. Marchand. The Yankees have not paid 92% of the total amount of revenue sharing distributed. They have, however, paid 92% of the luxury/competitive balance tax over the years. They are the only club to have paid the tax each and every year since its inception.

If you want to understand more about these provisions and how they evolved, you can check out my article in the University of Denver Sports and Entertainment Law Journal here. I’m also covering all of this in my book, which is coming soon!


Kristi DoshKristi Dosh runs It's a Swing and a Miss, and is both an attorney and a student of the game of baseball.  For the past three years, Kristi has contributed to the Braves blog Chop ‘n Change.  Kristi is also the author of Can Money Still Buy the Postseason in Major League Baseball?: a 10-year retrospective on revenue sharing and the luxury tax, published by the University of Denver Sports & Entertainment Law Review (2007).  Currently, Kristi is working on a book that will expand upon the ideas considered in her previous legal journal article.

Kristi guest lectures on the topics of revenue development, revenue sharing, collective bargaining and various other topics related to administration and economics in Major League Baseball to both undergradute and graduate students on a regular basis.

Kristi holds a Bachelor of Arts in Politics from Oglethorpe University and  Juris Doctor from the University of Florida.  Kristi resides in Atlanta, where she can easily attend Atlanta Braves, Gwinnett Braves and Rome Braves games.  She is on a number of boards, including the Advisory Board for L.E.A.D.,  a revolutionary inner-city baseball program in Atlanta.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?