köpa Etodolac flashback 2014 vart kan man beställa Nizagara Prevacid 10 mg köpa Adalat bästa pris köpa Hytrin inom eu eljo Lariam uttag pris köpa Bestina i spanien pris Saw Palmetto apotek hjärtat pris på Vasotec med recept köpa Prednisolone patong köpa äkta Buspar Prometrium usa köpa Anafranil dosering migrän köpa Gasex gran canaria kan man köpa Prometrium i spanien kan man köpa Hoodia i italien beställa Levitra online flashback köpa Arcoxia i estland för hög dos Ciplox köpa Lioresal i spanien Top Avana nervositet dosering köpa Diclofenac polen bästa pris Seroquel Cardizem recept Purim beställa container Aciphex hexal köpa Cardura flytande dosering lagligt att köpa Pamelor viagra Clozaril köpa vilka länder kan man köpa Omnicef receptfritt köpa Tadacip internet köpa generisk Nimotop köpa Liv 52 köpenhamn var kan man köpa Dutas receptfritt tips köpa Anacin Forzest hur stor dos köpa Astelin i sverige Mestinon dosering sömn köp billig Alli är det lagligt köpa Celexa på nätet köpa Aceon på kanarieöarna vad är generisk Styplon Adalat utan recept spanien bästa stället att köpa Periactin Ranitidine dosering lunginflammation försäljning Remeron kan man köpa Lincocin på ica var kan man köpa Zaditor kan man köpa Singulair på ica köpa Mobic turkiet vågar man köpa Prilosec på nätet hur kan man köpa Motrin köpa Bactroban i turkiet köpa Buspar i barcelona kan man köpa Fertomid i kroatien Brahmi pris apotek sverige bra ställe att köpa Chloramphenicol köpa Allopurinol i phuket att köpa Finax i sverige vad kostar Yasmin med recept köpa Diarex på kanarieöarna köpa Eurax lagligt på nätet köpa Anafranil inom eu köpa Sumycin över disk beställa hem Reglan köpa Cipro på nätet olagligt apoteket Clarina pris lagligt köpa Aldactone köpa Pilex olagligt lägsta pris Imuran Sildalis dosering föredrag köpa Trileptal online lagligt är det lagligt att köpa Lioresal på nätet Actoplus dosering föredrag köpa Baclofen usa köpa Atorlip-10 i vietnam Protonix snabb leverans sverige köpa laglig Methotrexate kan man köpa Shatavari på gran canaria Alli strömställare pris Avalide dos första gången köpa Serpina mot faktura att köpa Finpecia i sverige köpa Exelon på kanarieöarna Zoloft dosering till katt i vilka länder kan man köpa Dilantin receptfritt Digoxin utan recept i sverige flytande Skelaxin dos köpa Hyzaar var vad kostar Proventil på recept köpa Chloromycetin i riga flytande Prednisone dos är det recept på Bystolic olagligt att beställa Lithium på nätet köpa billiga Ciplox Glucovance op recept köpa Bentyl phuket är det recept på Penegra Aciclovir dosering sömn köpa Tadacip i helsingborg Benemid receptfritt pris billig Coreg sverige köpa Styplon i kina köp generisk Trimox köpa blå Aciphex köpa Bactrim flashback var köpa Amaryl billigt köpa Caverta i italien Penegra pris på gatan köpa Actonel på postförskott Norvasc beställa container kan man köpa Azulfidine på ica var ska man köpa Toprol beställa Lozol i sverige är det olagligt att köpa Tadapox på nätet köpa Septilin i indien vill du köpa Rogaine 5 köpa Lariam på nätet köpa Brahmi 2013 eljo Xenical bästa pris försäljning Olanzapine kan man köpa Aygestin på gran canaria köpa Vantin flashback köpa Florinef från sverige var beställa Differin köpa Plaquenil för kvinnor kan man köpa Liv 52 spanien köpa Augmentin spanien köpa Zocor grekland apotekets pris på Proscar kan man köpa Grifulvin V i kroatien bra ställe att köpa Yougara Shatavari kapslar pris beställa Himcocid england billig Minocin snabb leverans Tretinoin dosering första gången beställa Coreg på faktura köpa Chloromycetin i amsterdam bästa pris Renagel Premarin oral jelly billig bra ställe o köpa Avapro köpa Decadron på ica pris på Eulexin i sverige kan man köpa Trandate i sverige pris för Cafergot Zestoretic dosering halsfluss beställa Imitrex på nätet lagligt lagligt köpa Seroflo beställa Myambutol på faktura vad kan man köpa Zenegra var köpa Alesse flashback Roxithromycin nervositet dosering köp billig Levothroid billig Bonnispaz sverige Viramune säker leverans köpa Nitrofurantoin stockholm köpa Lipitor i vietnam pasteta od Zestril recept köpa Mestinon från england Orlistat rekommenderad dos köpa Colospa på nätet billigt köpa Yasmin gran canaria Flonase vet dosering vart kan man beställa Betapace pris på Tadalis i sverige kan man köpa Exelon på mallorca köpa Saw Palmetto receptfritt var köper man Norvasc utan recept beställa blå Pariet Proscar pris apoteket generisk Minomycin sverige hur ska man köpa Speman Antivert flytande dosering pris på Topamax sverige köpa Nitrofurantoin teneriffa kan man köpa Dulcolax på apoteket utan recept sänkt pris Nizagara köpa Norvasc på gatan köpa riktig Olanzapine Sarafem utan recept i sverige var köpa Aciclovir billigt beställa Ponstel sverige köpa Keppra i göteborg Bonnispaz migrän dosering vill du köpa Zoloft beställa Cefadroxil på faktura köpa Pamelor gel i vilka länder kan man köpa Reglan receptfritt köpa Benfotiamine var kan man köpa Actos receptfritt i spanien köpa Metoclopramide i helsingborg lagligt att köpa Lamisil för hög dos Lipitor snabb leverans Vermox eljo Benadryl uttag pris köpa Tadacip säkert online Cleocin hög dos köpa blå Flomax beställa Luvox online flashback generisk Omnicef sverige lagligt köpa Cefadroxil var kan man köpa Amaryl duo köpa Aceon på nätet flashback pasteta od Pilex recept Trazodone första dos Furosemide pris apoteket beställa Cardura billigt beställa Venlor sverige köp Fucidin snabb leverans köpa Endep i helsingborg Fincar dosering sömn var köpa Lamisil på nätet köp billig Erexor köpa Sarafem på nätet lagligt Aricept säker leverans kan man köpa Celexa i england köpa Lanoxin sverige 2012 Kytril dos första gången Finpecia pris på apoteket köpa Ponstel i london köpa Baclofen i tyskland beställa billig Altace försäljning Dutas fungerar generisk Deltasone köpa Diovan nätet kan man köpa Myambutol på nätet köpa Lithium patong köpa Zenegra vad kostar Sominex med recept köpa Avalide i thailand köpa Deltasone tyskland köpa Haldol mot postförskott pris Aspirin på apoteket Temovate turkiet pris behövs recept för Premarin apotekets pris på Aygestin rekommenderad dos Elimite Reglan migrän dos hur får man recept på Mestinon Glucovance köpa apoteket Dipyridamole usa köpa kan man köpa Accutane utan recept beställa Tadacip från thailand Unisom dosering till hund köpa Finax flashback 2014 köpa Duphalac för tjejer köpa Fluoxetine seriöst köpa Malegra i barcelona köpa Ventolin 20mg beställa Nasonex på internet köpa Atrovent sverige är det lagligt att köpa Rumalaya på nätet kan man köpa Tadalis på mallorca pris Lamictal turkiet köpa Yasmin bangkok Seroquel oral lösning dosering Protonix dosering sömn vart kan jag köpa Menosan eljo Zebeta dimmer pris köpa Colospa prag köpa Ditropan från turkiet Finpecia utan recept Mycelex-g dosering urinvägsinfektion Diabecon dosering ångest Mentat dos migrän köpa Diabecon 20mg köpa Panmycin original köpa Slim Tea på teneriffa kan man köpa Urispas på mallorca vad kan man köpa Cardizem var kan man köpa äkta Lasix kan man köpa Gyne-lotrimin i england köpa jord Amantadine beställa Plavix var kan man köpa Caverta duo pris på Antivert apoteket köpa Alavert på rhodos kan man köpa Danazol på gran canaria eljo Noroxin bästa pris Ciplox vägguttag pris köpa Lariam flashback 2014 köpa Bactroban usa kan man köpa Cholestoplex på apoteket utan recept Actoplus med snabb leverans köpa Rogaine 5 internet är det farligt att köpa Prilosec på nätet pris på Erythromycin i turkiet köpa Amoxil danmark köpa Chloromycetin i vietnam köpa Albendazole inrikes köpa Eulexin i prag Silvitra k dosering generisk Calan sverige är generisk Roxithromycin farligt köpa Feldene online lagligt kan man köpa Eldepryl receptfritt på apoteket eljo Requip dimmer pris Actoplus vet dosering Methotrexate beställa köpa Tricor säkert måste man ha recept på Glucovance beställa Aygestin flashback köpa Elimite var generisk Torsemide snabb leverans våga köpa Sominex på nätet Atarax hexal köpa Bonnispaz utan recept Toprol pris sverige köpa Slim Tea kina Pilex usa köpa generisk Zaditor snabb leverans var kan man köpa äkta Lioresal köpa Erythromycin säkert Maxalt dosering urinvägsinfektion köpa Sinequan apotek flytande Abana dos lagligt beställa Meclizine Flagyl ER dos urinvägsinfektion Lioresal dosering till hund försäljning Omnicef Zaditor köpa apoteket Ophthacare utan recept Paroxetine kräm köpa Unisom dos urinvägsinfektion vad kostar Methotrexate på recept apoteket hjärtat Aldactone pris beställa Chloramphenicol Prinivil köpa online kan man köpa Avana på apoteket i sverige Maxalt mot ångest dos kan man köpa Lincocin receptfritt i danmark kan man köpa Valtrex i frankrike beställa Plavix 2012 lagligt att köpa Proscar tips köpa Atrovent säkra sidor att köpa Silagra köpa Tinidazole på teneriffa köpa Eurax duo beställa container Plavix göteborg kan man köpa Baclofen spanien köpa Dipyridamole internet köpa Cipro lagligt köpa Voveran online 2013 kan man köpa Diflucan på teneriffa köpa Ayurslim online billigt köpa Ralista snabb leverans flytande Decadron dosering beställa container Omnicef göteborg köpa Differin i butik stockholm köpa Trandate tjeckien Pilex oral jelly billig Erexin-V vägguttag pris köpa Lipothin 2013 köpa Ranitidine från england Ampicillin migrän dosering Cyklokapron rapid recept vart ska man köpa Methotrexate Eulexin dosering vuxen Penegra mot nervositet dos lägre pris på Inderal köp Claritin snabb leverans köpa Celadrin postförskott köpa Mircette i bangkok Roxithromycin dos migrän kan man köpa Colospa i grekland beställa Amaryl 2012 köpa Provera för tjejer Estrace usa köpa Naltrexone köpa online köpa Buspar på ica köpa Premarin 50mg köpa Acivir köpenhamn var köpa Elavil billigt var kan man köpa äkta Big Appeal köpa Avapro prag köpa Celadrin spanien vad är generisk Arcoxia Aceon pris i sverige bra sida att köpa Shatavari pris på Doxazosin med recept var köpa äkta Alesse Liv 52 pulver köpa köpa Erexor alanya Unisom duo leverans var ska man köpa Rizact svårt att få recept på Aciclovir köpa Charboleps på nätet säkert köpa Lithium på ica hur få recept på Nitrofurantoin köpa Ditropan patong försäljning Sominex köpa Elimite snabb leverans Fincar utan recept i sverige köpa Duetact online flashback köpa Effexor tallinn bra ställe o köpa Coreg Keppra med snabb leverans kan man köpa Aceon på gran canaria köpa Tetracycline på gatan Flomax flashback köpa i vilka länder kan man köpa Avalide receptfritt dosering Clonidine till hund lägsta pris Yasmin Endep utan recept spanien kan man köpa Zovirax utan recept köpa Desyrel i spanien Mircette strömställare pris Fucidin billig olagligt att köpa Keftab köpa Bupropion säkert på nätet flytande Cleocin dosering Aldara migrän dosering kan man köpa Femara i tyskland köpa Venlor 50mg funkar generisk Prometrium är det olagligt att beställa Kamagra Mestinon i sverige utan recept köpa Indinavir i usa pris på Elavil i turkiet måste man ha recept för att köpa Carafate kan man köpa V-gel i italien köpa Singulair säkert Toprol plåster pris Differin på nätet utan recept köpa Exelon tallinn köpa Big Appeal budapest köpa Zoloft billig köpa Noroxin billigt Alavert gel recept Vytorin dos första gången Acivir snabbast leverans köpa Evista prag köpa Metoclopramide 20mg fungerar generisk Serevent skillnad mellan generisk Acivir beställa Dramamine 2012 köpa Emsam postförskott köpa Hydrea i ryssland köpa Dulcolax i filippinerna köpa Propecia i lettland Mycelex-g bra pris Stromectol med snabb leverans köpa generisk Diakof i sverige snabb leverans på Celexa Allegra migrän dos lägsta pris på Hydrochlorothiazide Vantin köpa flashback måste man ha recept för att köpa Cardizem Cabgolin vägguttag pris var kan man köpa Shatavari på nätet säkra sidor att köpa Innopran köpa Micardis egypten köpa Shallaki apoteket köpa Roxithromycin butik köpa Reminyl apotek pris på Probalan apoteket billig Hyzaar snabb leverans köpa äkta Probalan vågar man köpa Bactrim på nätet Entocort pris gatan Meclizine gel pris apoteket kan man köpa Levothroid i turkiet Periactin oral lösning dosering kan man köpa Aciclovir thailand köp Himplasia snabb leverans beställa Myambutol england kan man köpa Pristiq receptfritt på apoteket dödlig dos Femara beställa Lioresal från sverige bästa pris Rocaltrol köpa Zetia stockholm Shuddha jelly snabb leverans köpa Furosemide internet sänkt pris Luvox hur får man recept på Nootropil är det olagligt att köpa Amitriptyline på nätet Zestril dos migrän lagligt att köpa Mircette köpa Aygestin gel köpa Pyridium i usa köpa Tofranil i egypten kan man köpa Meclizine på apotek Provera att köpa V-gel pris på gatan kan man köpa Hyzaar receptfritt köpa concerta Motilium Pristiq första dos bästa sidan att köpa Antivert köpa Minocin på kanarieöarna Keflex snabbast leverans köpa Ciplox i spanien hur få recept på Aricept köpa Kytril i spanien köpa Zyban i bulgarien köpa Keppra online flashback köpa Phexin online sverige köpa Luvox duo säkra sidor att köpa FML Forte lägsta pris på Suhagra köpa Lopressor i frankrike
Home All Articles Dosh: MLB's Revenue-Sharing and the Luxury Tax Are Not One in the Same

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 672 guests online

Atom RSS

Dosh: MLB's Revenue-Sharing and the Luxury Tax Are Not One in the Same PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 118
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Kristi Dosh   
Monday, 19 April 2010 11:48

The Biz of BaseballWhile we have run a prior article on this subject, guest author Kristi Dosh of It's a Swing and a Miss has gone into further detail on how revenue-sharing and the Competitve Balance Tax (Luxury Tax) functions in Major League Baseball. Enjoy. -- Maury Brown, President, Business of Sports Network, BizofBaseball.com


I’ve spent the past four years studying, writing and guest lecturing on revenue sharing and internal taxation in Major League Baseball. Accordingly, I’m fascinated by the debate raging in the media between Randy Levine, President of the Yankees, and Mark Attanasio, the owner of the Brewers. What really caught my eye though was the confusion between revenue sharing and the competitive balance tax. As I’ve guest lectured on these topics over the past four years, I’ve found that even your most avid baseball fan doesn’t generally know or understand the difference.

So, before I explain the difference, let me set the stage for you…

It all started with this comment to USA Today by Mark Attanasio, owner of the Milwaukee Brewers:

“We’re struggling to sign Prince Fielder, and the Yankees infield is making more than our team.”

Enter Randy Levine, President of the Yankees, who said this to ESPNNewYork.com:

“I’m sorry that my friend Mark continues to whine about his running the Brewers. We play by all the rules and there doesn’t seem to be any complaints when teams such as the Brewers receive hundreds of millions of dollars that they get from us in revenue sharing the last few years. Take some of that money that you get from us and use that to sign your players.”

“The question that should be asked is: Where has the hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue sharing gone?”

Ok, I’m on board so far. It’s the same old David versus the Yankees story as always in baseball. The real problem comes in how the story has been framed by many media outlets.

Gabe Lacques, who wrote the USA Today piece, wrote this in his article:

“According to the Biz of Baseball, the Yankees have accounted for $175 million – or 92% – of all revenue-sharing payments since revenue sharing was instituted.”

Andrew Marchand, who wrote the ESPNNewYork.com story, similarly stated:

“In the initial seven years of the luxury tax, the Yankees have paid teams nearly $175 million in revenue sharing, according to the BizofBaseball.com. That is 92 percent of the total revenue sharing that has been doled out.”

Enter confusion, stage right. Revenue sharing and the luxury tax (which, by the way, was renamed the “competitive balance tax” in the 2002 CBA, which covered 2003-2006) are two completely separate concepts. Aside from the Yankees having to pay both, they have very little in common.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE DETAILS ON REVENUE SHARING AND THE LUXURY TAX

Revenue Sharing

Revenue sharing was first approved by the owners in 1994 and included in the 1996-2000 Collective Bargaining Agreement, presumably as an alternative to a salary cap, which was ruled out by the MLBPA. Revenue sharing is based on a club’s Net Local Revenue for a given year. Understanding what Net Local Revenue is takes the reading of no less than five definitions in the CBA, but I’m going to provide you the overly simplified version. Net Local Revenue is Local Revenue (gross revenue from all revenue areas like ticket sales, concessions, etc. minus Central Revenue, which is national television and radio, etc.) minus Actual Stadium Expense (which is exactly what it sounds like, the actual monies paid out by a club for its stadium).

The 1996-2000 CBA phased in revenue sharing with the use of three different plans:

Split Pool Plan: each club put in 20% of their Net Local Revenue. Those monies were then divided 75/25, with 75% being split evenly amongst all clubs and 25% being split only between those clubs with a Net Local Revenue below the mean for all clubs. The 25% was not split evenly between those clubs below the mean, but based on their distance from the mean.

Straight Pool Plan: each club put in 39% of their Net Local Revenue and it was split evenly with all clubs.

Hybrid Plan: evaluated the result each club would have under each of the above plans and then assigned the plan that was better for that club as a payor/payee. So, if the Yankees would pay out less under the Split Pool Plan, they were assigned that plan. If the Royals would receive more under the Straight Pool Plan, they were assigned that plan.

Then, to make it even more confusing, the plan was implemented on a percentage basis:

  • 1996: 60% Hybrid Plan
  • 1997: 60% Hybrid Plan
  • 1998: 80% Split Pool Plan
  • 1999: 85% Split Pool Plan
  • 2000: 100% Split Pool Plan

So, in 1996, a club received or paid 60% of the total result under the Hybrid Plan. The result was that $50 million was moved around in 1996. By 2002, that number would be $169 million.

In 2002, revenue sharing was simplified under the next CBA. The Straight Pool Plan was in effect for the length of the CBA at a rate of 34%. So, each club put in 34% of their Net Local Revenue each year, and then the pool was divided evenly between all of the clubs. A Central Fund component was added, which called for 41.066% of the total amount transferred from payor clubs to payee clubs to be pulled from baseball’s Central Fund and divided between payee clubs whose average Net Local Revenue over the past three years fell below the average for all clubs over that same time period. The amount distributed was to be deduced from distributions to be made to payor clubs at the end of the season. There’s a very specific mathematical formula for this in the CBA, but I won’t go into it here.

I know you’ve all heard the grumblings about teams receiving more in revenue sharing than the spend (*cough* Marlins *cough*). An example I use in my lectures is the 2005 Florida Marlins. Payroll was cut by nearly 75% to a league-leading low of $14,998,500, more than $20 million below the next lowest payroll. Meanwhile, their cut of revenue sharing was reported to be $31 million, leaving them $16 million for other “baseball-related” activities. That’s the only parameter given in the CBA for spending revenue sharing dollars, by the way: that it be used for “baseball-related activities.”

The 2006 CBA contained a revenue sharing provision very similar to the 2002 CBA. The percentage was decreased from 34% to 31% because of increased revenues league-wide, but the other provisions remain mostly unchanged.

Time for another example I use in my lectures. The Royals revenue sharing receipts doubled from 2002-2007, but payroll only rose by 6%. Meanwhile, the team value has risen from $96m to $282m. Just food for thought.

Need dessert to go with that? Consider this quote by Mr. Attanasio:

“We do get a piece of revenue sharing, and we appreciate it, and we need it, and we use it. We put it to use. It’s a matter of record that we use our revenue sharing dollars pretty much every year in our budget.”

First off, I’m bothered by the use of “pretty much,” which makes me wonder why not always? Second, when he says it’s a matter of record, don’t be fooled into thinking it’s a matter of public record. It’s not. Every club in MLB guards its numbers very closely, and you will never see the Brewers budget and be able to ascertain for yourself just where that revenue sharing money is going.

As if that weren’t enough, another issue with revenue sharing is the Net Local Revenue calculation, which is easily manipulated. Picture this…Club A’s owner is also the owner of ABC, Corp., which provides concession services. Club A hires ABC, Corp to provide concessions at its ballpark. Club A’s owner overpays ABC, Corp in order to decrease Club A’s Net Local Revenue number, thus increasing Club A’s share of revenue sharing distributions.

Haven’t had enough yet? Another example…Club B’s owner also owns XYZ Media, Inc., which airs Club B’s games locally. Club B negotiates a contract with XYZ Media, Inc. where XYZ Media, Inc. underpays for its contract to air Club B’s games locally, thus lowering its Net Local Revenue number and increasing its share of revenue sharing distributions.

Oh, and if you’re still feeling bad for the Brewers and the other small market teams, consider this: in 2002 three teams were sold and bought. The Red Sox, who are obviously in a large market, sold for $380m (taking on about $40m in debt). The New York Mets, another large market team, sold for $391m. The Marlins, the poster child for small market teams, sold for $158m. Ever heard you get what you pay for?

Luxury Tax

After the infamous strike of 1994, the owners also managed to introduced the luxury tax after being defeated on the salary cap by the MLBPA. Most people think it was aimed directly at Steinbrenner and his seemingly endless wallet, and most people are right.

The only thing the luxury tax has in common with revenue sharing, aside from hitting the Yankees wallet the hardest, is that they made it way too complicated in the 1996 CBA. The luxury tax was only implemented under that CBA for 1997, 1998 and 1999. Thresholds were set and any team who exceed the threshold paid the tax:

  • 1997: $51 million threshold (35% tax on amount over threshold)
  • 1998: $55 million threshold (35% tax on amount over threshold)
  • 1999: $58.9 million threshold (34% tax on amount over threshold)

Simple, right? Yep, so they had to make it a little more complex. Enter the “floating threshold” concept. At the end of each season, if the midpoint between the fifth and sixth highest payrolls was more than the threshold, then that became the new threshold. Then, the threshold for the next year would be adjusted based on that number.

Now even if you can grasp all that, the definition of Actual Club Payroll is sneaking in at stage left to really complicate matters. Actual Club Payroll is 1/28th (there were only 28 clubs then) of player benefit costs, player salaries and other amounts like bonuses and deferred compensation. Throw in that some players are only with the team for part of the year, or have a contract that doesn’t specify amounts for each individual year, and you really have a mess on your hands.

Requests can be made within MLB or by the MLBPA with regards to how the acquisition of a player might affect a club’s payroll total. This was meant to make the luxury tax figure into a club’s decision to sign a player. It was assumed most clubs would try to avoid the penalty. However, the floating threshold concept got in the way in the beginning. The very first year the tax was in effect, 13 clubs were over the midpoint between the fifth and sixth highest payroll and were hit with the tax.

Before I get into how the tax has evolved, I should clarify where the money goes. Under the 1996 CBA, the first $10m went to compensate for any issues with the revenus sharing plan (such as running short under the Hybrid Plan), the next $7m went to the 5 AL clubs and 5 NL clubs with the lowest Local Revenue, the next $3m went to the Industry Growth Fund (which funds training camps and other baseball development activities domestically and internationally), and the next $2.5m went to fund a reserve for any overpayments made into the system. In the end, $30.9m was collected under the 1996 CBA.

The 2002 CBA saw the luxury tax become the competitive balance tax and introduced a somewhat new system. Much higher thresholds were set for 2003-2006:

  • 2003: $117m
  • 2004: $120.5m
  • 2005: $128m
  • 2006: $136.5m

Increasing penalties for repeats offenders was also introduced, making it clear that the tax was meant as a deterrent and a penalty:

  • 2002 First-Time Offenders: 17.5%
  • 2003 First-Time Offenders: 22.5%
  • Second-Time Offenders: 30%
  • Third-Time Offenders: 40%

The distribution of funds also evolved, no longer providing for funding to low revenue clubs, thus distinguishing it entirely from revenue sharing. The first $5m would go to refund for any miscalculaations, then 50% would go to player benefits, 25% to the Industry Growth Fund, and 25% to developing baseball in countries without high school programs.

The 2006 CBA kept the basic model of the 2002 CBA with adjustments for thresholds and taxation amounts:

  • 2007: $148m
  • 2008: $155m
  • 2009: $162m
  • 2010: $170m
  • 2011: $178m

Penalties also increased:

  • First-Time Offenders: 22.5%
  • Second-Time Offenders: 30%
  • Third-Time Offenders: 40%

Distributions remain roughly the same and continued the trend towards fudning player benefits with the tax money. The first $2.5m is set aside for refunds, then 75% for player benefits and 25$ to the Industry Growth Fund. Thus, the tax is not distributed to low revenue clubs.

Now back to the statements by Mr. Lacques and Mr. Marchand. The Yankees have not paid 92% of the total amount of revenue sharing distributed. They have, however, paid 92% of the luxury/competitive balance tax over the years. They are the only club to have paid the tax each and every year since its inception.

If you want to understand more about these provisions and how they evolved, you can check out my article in the University of Denver Sports and Entertainment Law Journal here. I’m also covering all of this in my book, which is coming soon!


Kristi DoshKristi Dosh runs It's a Swing and a Miss, and is both an attorney and a student of the game of baseball.  For the past three years, Kristi has contributed to the Braves blog Chop ‘n Change.  Kristi is also the author of Can Money Still Buy the Postseason in Major League Baseball?: a 10-year retrospective on revenue sharing and the luxury tax, published by the University of Denver Sports & Entertainment Law Review (2007).  Currently, Kristi is working on a book that will expand upon the ideas considered in her previous legal journal article.

Kristi guest lectures on the topics of revenue development, revenue sharing, collective bargaining and various other topics related to administration and economics in Major League Baseball to both undergradute and graduate students on a regular basis.

Kristi holds a Bachelor of Arts in Politics from Oglethorpe University and  Juris Doctor from the University of Florida.  Kristi resides in Atlanta, where she can easily attend Atlanta Braves, Gwinnett Braves and Rome Braves games.  She is on a number of boards, including the Advisory Board for L.E.A.D.,  a revolutionary inner-city baseball program in Atlanta.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?