algondones pharmacies lincocin antibiotic no prescription discount pharmacy zovirax tablets mail order mobicox 15 mg indicaciones indomethacin side effects in pregnancy buy zovirax tablets noble drugs human health biz lynoral information system novolax laxative sidenovolog norapred para que es bueno provera medicines atepros drug abuse cheap kamagra paypal uk bactrim dosage for mrsa celexa reviews depression can i buy viagra online nonprescription tegretol in usa atrovent side effects dose eulexin flutamide rx dth 24 b kamal kunj mumbai india elsalvador pharmacy kamagra oral jelly uk paypal 159 tadapox reviews for fifty retin a cream 0.05 reviews drugstore 777 bactrim without a prescription detrol la 4 mg capsule sa canada pharmacy real propecia herbal viagra australia gpchealth reviews for 50 singulair coupons fda doxycycline shortage price sotalex mite acyclovir online us 800mg lortab hydrocodone 7.5 325 glucovance side effects cheapest place to buy viagra online buy elimite cream over the counter atenolol 25 mg side effects webmd tabletten zum abnehmen ohne buy promethazine with codeine in canada oracea side effects doxycycline apetamin ingredients in marshmallows viagra without prescriptions uk can you get high off indomethacin canadian pharmacy erection packs is terramycin ointment for humans cialis by canadian health shop sildenafil citrate 20 mg buy alli online valium for sale with no prescription order phenagan on line buy cilias oracea side effects when stopping for a week buy prof viagra online confidex ingredients in meth cialis generika per nachnahme bestellen buy vigra using paypal antiboitics for chlamydia online male viagra pills 300 mg allopurinol and pregnancy 60 mgs dapoxtine with levitra hoodia tea diet metoprolol tartrate 50mg used for prandin side effects on elderly mobicox for dogs viagra mastercard online pharmacy dalacin 300mg dosage natural radiance testo cream for men generique tadalafil 20mg prix viagra without prescription australia antabuse greece buy antibiotics without prescription vasotec medication torsemide 20 mg diuretic priligy reviews online kamagra mumbai pyrocaps 20mg ambien buy effexor xr without prescription accutane overnight boehringer ingelheim micardis coupons how to get tegretol risperdal medication side effects zithromax z pack for sinus infection minocycline for acne pain pills without a prescription vistaril medication side effects does robaxin require an rx in canada ciales puerto rico pictures of el content marketing examples professional viagra buy accutane canadian pharmacy purchase flagyl online usa best place to buy viagra in uk levoxyl generic or brand buylowdrugs canada map buy xenical online cheap buy provera uk cialis pharm bupropion sr 150 side effects canadian health marcumar medication administration lilly evista coupons where to buy viagra in kuala lumpur buy amoxicillin online dramamine trip prednisolone uk no prescription cockapoo rescue dogs prozac reviews tylenol arthritis acetaminophen buy astepro from india amitriptylin on line minomycin information technology alli orlistat 60 mg capsules mobicool mini fridge price fluoxetine for dogs side effects anastrozole side effects bone cancer generic pain meds overnight alendronate sodium tablets usp 35mg can you buy viagra over the counter zofran medication tadalafil best price does levitra make you bigger viagra bay in ireland zithromax z pac viagra online india cialis 500mg viagra cialis kostet valbazen albendazole for dogs dosage buy maxifort zimax pills viagra advertised on the radio where to buy cephalosporins finasteride vs dutasteride price nuvigil vs provigil buy clavamox for cats online vistaril and pregnancy use free samples viagra by mail parkizol online olanzapine dosage forms insurance quotes online homeowners aricept drug company how much is amitriptyline generika franchise philippines directory glyprin aspirin and pregnancy milnacipran generic adderall primatene mist tablets side effects ampicillin 500mg capsules black and red buying viagra online from india hydrodiuril contraindications to tpa vicodin vs percocet vs darvocet prazosin minipress 2mg buy alli uk support order cs buy elecon with no rx betnovate cream treatment ordering thyroxine online side effects of casodex bicalutamide proscar online pharmacy wo bekomme ich viagra ohne rezept cialis for daily use online online pharama estrofem for transitioning to natural hair drugs from india ranigast leko temovate 0.05 liquid 365pills complaints about doctors free samples of viagra by mail omnic ocas metoprolol the blue pill review laxifen tablets under $100 ajanta kamagra oral jelly oracef antibiotic cefuroxime danazol drug treatment mincorp plc training generic viagra 150 mg clomid fast delivery prednisolone sod phos 15mg 5ml sol used for atomoxetine hcl strattera clavulanic acid viagra alternative pfizer viagra septra ds antibiotic treatments elavil dosage for sleep buy suhagra india sky pharmacy reviews viasek 50mg trazodone mexican viagra buying fluoxetine over the counter aceon without prescription plavix generic at rite aid increasing and decreasing functions worksheets online pharmacy europ no prescription where to buy diclofenac sodium raymeds reviews on apidexin potassium nitrate fertilizer laxifen medicinal bentyl 10mg price escitalopram 10 mg side effects periactin weight gain doctor lamisil pills over the counter orlistat usa rapharmacy reviews of fifty antabuse rite aid sildenafil tab 20mg salibet ointment for burns prescription drug online tiotropium bromide inhalation powder buy viagra in malaysia cialis tablets india tablets 20 mg best american series ivermectin for humans with scabies zestril side effects cialis 100mg cheap viagra 100mg tablets sialis tablets computerssibusatsifrol macrodantin side effects dose meclizine medication usemedicinenet lialda side effects weight gain 150mg generic viagra hydrochlorothiazide thru canada alli prezzo farmacia nuvigil reviews for adhd clomid ovulation symptoms cenveo corporation il cialis patent levitra generic vardenafil cheap ceftin antibiotic alcohol interaction safe cheap viagra sites online priligy dapoxetine dosages generic viagra mexico celexa and alcohol consumption ditropan oxybutynin dosage buy clomid canadian pharmacy effexor reviews for social anxiety diabecon himalaya products philippines buy syntroid 75mcg without rx minocycline 100 mg side effects discount canadin drugs zetia side effects weight gain lotrel 5/10 generic name do bupropion cost chest pain tetracycline dog disgrasil orlistat precious metal prices leconfield wines and more citrate of magnesia laxative doctor cialis vs levitra marcumar phenprocoumon and warfarin mirtazapine india tapiales prefabricados el salvador cymbalta cost without insurance kamagra 100mg oral jelly srbija cialis order by mail viagra online australia zovirax acyclovir medication over the counter albuterolon line no prescription ritalin vs adderall drug buspar side effects in children paypal propecia pill diflucan cheap does cialis make you bigger buy zyban 150 without a script aprovel irbesartan drug yasminelle tablets sale novartis cafergot pills buy viagra malaysia online chiswick auctions results buying viagra in singapore metformin sale online bactrim ds 800 160 prilosec side effects lamisil tablets from india cyrux pastillas periactin weight gain pill pyridium side effects doctor how much domperidone for gastroparesis mundo das lampadas uk drugs puretone hearing aids pleasant st claremont nh nartea rodica popescu india cheap pharmacy cialis capoten sublingual microzide 12.5mg caps viagra prices costco chlamydia over the counter treatment avelox 400 mg dosage viamedic coupons fertomid 50 indicaciones canadian pharmacy norx pharmacy express in canada buy periactins lamisil foot cream for fungus rapharmacy reviews of 50 nautisol medication interaction accutane from canada pacific care pharmacy online viasek sildenafil pulmonary propecia similar flovent hfa 110 mcg coupons no prescription antibiotic canada indomethacin 50 mg capsule side effects disgrasil capsulas de vinagre twitching eye side effects of topamax topamax and alcohol treatment zyvox price cvs clotrimazole lozenges and alcohol naproxen 500 mg en espanol american viagra store super cialas rhinocort aq viagra sales india robaxin 500mg information 1drugstore online show products where could i buy a real cialis online drugstore foundation made for dry skin alternatives for doxycycline nexium mups cpmrar vendita libera viagra svizzera canadian no prescription viagra lexapro weight gain loss cabgolin medicine acyclovir buy pharmacy online malaysia zithromax ringworm insurance institute for highway safety ratings avalide recall black viagra pill adipex phentermine reviews and testimonials plavix lawsuit settlement in california cialis side effects alcohol pergotime 50mg clomid venlafaxine side effects 37.5 esgic plus online overnight coversyl 5mg tablet banana muffins medyka przemyska playstation viagra similar effect amerimedrx cialis free salzarex manufacturer refurbished buy indomethacin 50mg on line how to purchase digitalis diclofenaco gel metoprolol tartrate side effects tamsulosin 0.4mg cap aur dilantin pain killer morphine indian substitute of viagra zolpidem tartrate 10mg drug temovate ointment ditropan xl 10mg side effects betagesic tablets sale qsymia weight loss drug price aleve vs ibuprofen for muscle pain floxin drops and pregnancy buy clomid online without prescription how to get codeine cough syrup online periactin appetite stimulant children cafergot suppositories vyvanse online arthrotec 75 mg cost atepros 50mg trazodone fungsi obat grafazol 500 metronidazole and alcohol medco generic cialis atomoxetine hydrochloride capsule viagra erection photos requip starter pack dose nuvigil treatment for narcolepsy clomiphene citrate for men viagra en ligne carte maestro lidocaine viscous 2 solution levitra forum al femminile 60mg cailis on line euro med buy paroxetine asacol 400 mg rocaltrol calcitriol side effects order xanax from canada cialis pattaya viagra prix provera modus medroxyprogesterone celebrex et paroxetine rhinocort nasal spray in pregnancy yasmin online no prescription medrol over the counter buy viagra in qatar neofollin bestellen buy viagra in dublin strattera online uk scam buy mifepristone online alesse birth control synthroid purchase canada best generic viagra viagra free sample sotalex medication interaction algodones pharmacy online how to order viagra male enhancement pills online pharmacy sleep medication pregnant celebrities 2016 presciptions mexico navidoxine drug interaction reviews on vigrx plus ingredients ciprofloxacino para que es spiriva inhaler generic buy wellbutrin xl in uk the purple pharmacy algodones mexico sertralina efectos aleve dosage chart buy viagra from trusted site cymbalta copay card buying meds for cats no rx cialis overnite himcolin gel buy costco viagra price vermox plus treat lotemax eye drops price naproxen vs ibuprofen for back pain amoxicillin 500mg capsules antibiotic pergotime in english yahoo omifin 50mg side effects alli orlistat best price cheapest canadian pharcharmy online buy suboxone premarin cream side effects baby diarex pro series stone color enhancer and sealer buy cialas on line canada toradol injection for migraine antabuse pharmacy tynidazole without prescription order lassix waterpills no precription cialis buy subutex without prescription dikloron tablet computers c r walgreen guns comprar cialis indio en espana dynamogen drug addiction insulin resistance symptoms hair loss xeloda patient assistance form actavis syrup prevacid vs prilosec vs nexium tomar cytotec sin estar embarazada candida viagra reglan medication metoclopramide tylenol dosage for infants depomedrol side effects in humans generic cialis cheapest price evista side effects osteoporosis baristanet montclair nj police station overnight lavitra augmentin side effects in children viagra effects on women world suhagraat information in urdu video baristanet bloomfield nj library content analysis examples code red 7 seconds spray rx one farmacy metrogel vaginal gel .75 cheap 80 mg vardenafil hcl 24h canadian pharmacy testosterone no prescription hydrea capsules 500mghytrin cost of doxycycline at walgreens canadian online pharmacy cialis caffeine content of drinks tea levitra prezzo in farmacia erectalis 20mg oxycodone canadian viagra online master card buy cialis online with paypal xenical 120 mg capsule viagra boots lipitor and grapefruit side effects singulair side effects in children baristanet montclair nj police officer phramacy rx1 buy generic retin a online acnelyse gelato bactrim ds dosage etodolac side effects in dogs mestinon side effects treatment levamisole hydrochloride for fish arthritis medication meloxicam paxil side effects viamedic com veterans administration how to use viagra for first time azulfidine sulfasalazine dosing cheap online viagra uk pharmacy no prescription prednisone on line atacand side effects mayo clinic flexeril 10 mg picture subutex 54 411 under tongue clopidogrel 75mg tabletsmexican pharmacy walmart pricing for cialis oracea side effects doxycycline mono prescription drugs from canada flexidol relax efectos bactrim and alcohol drug interactions astrazeneca nolvadex rx ed pharmacy online cialis daily price vasotec generic equivalent viagra gel uk online
Home Salary Arb Signings/Rulings Salary Arbitration Common Misunderstandings in MLB Service Time Comparisons

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1150 guests online

Atom RSS

Common Misunderstandings in MLB Service Time Comparisons PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 9
Salary Arbitration
Written by Joe Tetreault   
Tuesday, 16 March 2010 21:53

Writing for the Biz of Baseball has given me a fascinating crash course in the salary arbitration process. With so many personnel decisions influenced by the service time of the players involved, the arbitration process has truly become central to understanding why teams elect to leave useful players toiling in the minors (yes, we're looking at you Evan Longoria and Matt Wieters). And despite the unending utitility of salary data gained through the process, one stark fact remains above all others: comparisons across service time are useless.

Evan Hoschild, writing at the Crawfish Boxes, stumbled into such an inapt comparison recently.

Of course when a player of similar age and position signs a new contract, I get interested in what the Astros are going to do with Pence. Does Ed Wade wait and see how Hunter does to start the season in 2010 and begin to think beyond the one year increments that has been the approach with not only him but Michael Bourn? At this juncture, with potentially so much payroll coming off the books after this season, I think this is the prudent approach to take.

A multi-year deal for Hunter Pence is absolutely the prudent course of action. But Hochschild will be disappointed with the cost of the contract Astros GM Ed Wade could negotiate with the Astros right fielder. Pence's starting point is significantly higher than that of either Denard Span or Arizona's Mark Reynolds who just signed a long term contract as well.

Because neither would be arbitration eligible until after the season Span and Reynolds are more comparable. Their teams could have set salaries however they wanted as long as it did not dip below the league minimum or represent more than a 20% pay cut from the previous year's total compensation. In short, the teams held almost all the leverage. With that in mind, let's tackle the key mistake in Hochschild's piece:

The details of the contract...are ridiculous in their reasonableness. The per year salaries increase conservatively, buying out five arbitration eligible years for the certainty that goes with a long term contract.

First off, Span does not have five years of arbitration eligibility. Players are guaranteed three years of arbitration eligibility. Some players receive four years, by qualifying as a Super Two player after their second full year of major league service time.

With Minnesota buying out three arbitration eligible years and two years of team contract control, they could set a low initial salary and conservative raises. Reynolds provides another example. His salary for 2010 is just $500,000. Arizona had renewed Reynolds on the 11th, before working out this deal which can (if the Diamondbacks exercise the team option) buy out the entirety of Reynolds' arbitration eligibility.

Comparing Pence to Span is category error because Pence was arbitration eligible this past season. The increased leverage helped him win a significant raise from the Astros for 2010. Had he not qualified as a Super Two, he would have been subject to contract renewal this spring, just like Span and Reynolds were. That difference is immense.

Pence and the Astros agreed on a deal that pays him $3.5 million in 2010 establishing his baseline for 2011. Pence’s 2011 will be far above that baseline, because arbitration is designed to inflate salaries. This isn't some voodoo from Scott Boras. It's the nature of the system.


Proof is found yeat again in Arizona. Their first baseman, Conor Jackson who took home $3.05 million in 2009, suffered through a horrendous season, as he battled valley fever. Despite his illness and poor performance, the Diamonbacks agreed with him on a contract that gave him a raise of $50,000. Though modest, his raise was a certainty, because the arbitration process precludes pay cuts.

Constructing a reasonable contract for Pence needs to be based on his service time, his performance and comparable players. Luckily, we can project Pence’s progression with a similar player who is one year ahead of Pence in the arbitration process. The Dodgers Andre Ethier provides a near ideal roadmap for what lies ahead.

Both players qualified for arbitration as Super Twos following their seasonal age 26 years. Players can qualify for arbitration after they complete their second year of MLB service time.  The must accumulate at least 86 days of service during the immediately preceding season and rank in the top 17 percent in total service among players with more than two, but less than three years of service time.  Maury Brown discussed Super Two players in the arbitration process last year.

Through his first three seasons, Pence posted a .289/.340/.488 slash line in 1,773 plate appearances. Ethier's first three seasons were statistically similar, though with marginally less playing time. His batting line was .299/.364/.482 in 1,542 plate appearances. Ethier’s first arbitration influenced salary was $3.1 million, which is also comparable to the $3.5 million Pence will get in 2010.

Ethier’s playing time increased in 2009 which boosted his counting stats helping him hit 30 homeruns, a plateau he had not approached previously. His perceived breakout season prompted the Dodgers to work out a long term extension that will pay him $15.25 million over two seasons. For perspective, his two-year guarantee is $1.25 million less than Span will get over five years.

Using Ethier as a guide, if Pence maintains his current rate of production, he should expect no less than $6.5 million in 2011 (Ethier is getting $6 million next season and Pence has a higher starting point) and better than $10 million in 2012 (Ethier is getting $9.25 million). To buy out the balance of his arbitration eligibility will likely cost Houston close to $30 million over three seasons on top of the $3.5 Pence will earn this year.

Hochschild's premise is sound. Signing young talent to team friendly, cost-controlling deals is almost without question a reasonable decision. But once a player reaches the arbitration process, suppressing salary escalation becomes nearly impossible. Had Houston negotiated a long term deal with Pence prior to the date the players and teams exchanged salary arbitration figures, they may have been able to lock him up for the duration of his arbitration eligibility for less than $24 million over the four seasons. Having demurred, they now face a bill that will likely be 40% higher. That's the difference arbitration makes on salary increases.

Joe Tetreault is a member of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?