escitalopram 10 mg lexapro ic propranolol 60 mg 50mg generic viagra erythromycin online bestellen propecia cheapest buy depression lexapro 40 mg prednisone 5 mg qualitest wellbutrin tablets mg prednisone 14 yo 75mg viagra 50mg cp sc100 viagra generic cialis 100 mg australia 40 mg lasix iv buy propecia philippines lisinopril arrow 20 mg lexapro 20 mg forum singapore online viagra lexapro buy online 200 mg wellbutrin xl purchase kamagra online lexapro 20mg phenergan 25 mg tablets cipro 500 mg 7 days medicine glucophage 500 mg celebrex generic availability xenical 120 mg posologie cialis generico culiacan doxycycline 50 mg mpc generic viagra rxmeds xenical medicine buy cipro 500mg 3 days viagra jet online genericos viagra baratos chinese viagra 800mg 2.5mg cialis online 40mg cialis cheap buy zithromax 500 mg bactrim ds 300 mg 40 mg cialis dose buy cialis re lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide 20 25 mg 100 mg of phenergan buy viagra professional order kamagra ireland order xenical us doxycycline order online 10mg of lisinopril zovirax dispersable 800 mg lasix 40 mg packungsbeilage viagra online quality levitra 20mg frankreich zoloft 50 mg pill tetracycline mk 250 mg viagra 100mg tablets 4 generic zoloft issues wellbutrin generic study diflucan 150 mg ringworm kamagra 100 mg uk wellbutrin 150mg buying viagra melbourne lisinopril 20 mg manufacturer valtrex 1000 mg tablets celebrex 200 mg directions thuoc periactin 4mg nexium 40 mg bivirkninger 40mg cialis priaprism wellbutrin canada cheap buy viagra johannesburg prednisone 40 mg pregnant prednisone 20 mg sinusitis efeitos viagra 100mg generic lexapro coupon buy kamagra liverpool chinese viagra online strattera 60 mg dosage prednisone 10 mg pack cheap strattera augmentin 625 mg uses buy clomid nolva viagra 100 mg efectos 10mg cialis take lexapro cheap online viagra online saudiarabia cheapest viagra australia buy amoxil 875 cheapest nexium buy usa strattera syrup online cialis .at online zithromax sirop 200mg generic wellbutrin pharmacy generic viagra alternative cheap propecia nz 10 mg prednisone taper propecia generico 1 mg 25mg of cialis bipolar disorder doxycycline osta cialis 5mg buy flagyl er generic valtrex rx 904 lasix 500 buy gia nexium 40mg viagra 100mg brand doxycycline generic for buy amoxil 50 mg is 40 mg cialis lasix 25mg cialis tablets 20mg nexium 40 mg oral testing generic viagra nolvadex tamoxifen 10mg prednisone online generic doxycycline hyclate 500mg cialis pills 20mg celebrex cap 200 mg zoloft pfizer generic diflucan online shopping online marketing viagra metformin generic form cipro 250 mg uses augmentin 500 mg presentacion prednisone 20mg bula cipro 1a 250 mg 40mg cialis canada celebrex 200mg coupons prednisone 5 mg 21 pack medicamento lasix 20 mg propranolol buy uk viagra online tabs doxycycline 10 mg buy celebrex tablets levitra generico effetti nexium 20mg wellbutrin 150 mg online kamagra 100mg hap 1000 mg wellbutrin brand 5 mg cialis prednisone 20 mg hives nexium purchase online australia viagra online find generic lexapro generic lexapro approval apo prednisone 5mg clomid nolvadex online administrare augmentin 625mg xenical for cheap buy kamagra shops priligy farmacia online viagra online netherlands kamagra 100mg pills priligy buy uk buy doxycycline 500 mg viagra 50 mg bijsluiter levitra 20 mg precios viagra 50 mg 4 tabletten online celebrex kamagra 100 gold 100 mg buy cheap wellbutrin buy zovirax aciclovir zoloft 30mg cytotec 2mg 5mg cialis before sublingual cialis 20 mg 50mg de clomid online zoloft wellbutrin sr 150 generic viagra shopping online 40 mg lasix furosemide using 80mg cialis xenical cheap price 1000 mg glucophage xr lisinopril 40 mg lupi precio viagra 25 mg lexapro 2.5 mg conversion cheapest 150mg. viagra order viagra professional prednisone 40 mg constipation lowest propecia 1 mg online viagra discount nolvadex 40mg tablets viagra generica 50 gramos lisinopril hctz 12.5 mg buy cialis store levitra 10 mgrs efectos cialis 5 mg augmentin bustine 400 mg clomid 50mg pregnancy order nexium 40mg ondoes levitramakeagenericline levitra buy prednisone 20mg 5 mg lexapro works zoloft 100 mg viagra 100 mg billig clomid tablets 50 mg lisinopril 10mg coupon augmentin 600 mg inj generic viagra revue generic kamagra paypal xenical buy canada cialis dose 30mg metformin 500 mg coupons cipro purchase online buy discount levitra buy strattera 60 mg cialis 5 mg cupon buy kamagra plus nolvadex online europe erythromycin 40 mg cialis 20 mg indications metformin 850 mg gewichtsabnahme female viagra 100mg xenical 120mg pcos cialis 20mg split prednisone 60mg sidefects wiki viagra generic zovirax online australia amoxil capsule 500mg buy viagra onlinereviews generic viagra 10mg levitra going generic hydrochlorothiazide generic name xenical 120 mg austria cialis 20mg schweiz zovirax uk buy 40 mg cialis diflucan generic price generic cialis prescriptions celebrex 100 mg nebenwirkungen buy viagra walgreens strattera online india nexium generic replacement cialis price online phenergan 12.5 mg levitra mg strengths 025 mg propecia generico cipro xr 1000 kamagra 100mg cheap bactrim mg available viagra kaufen 25 mg augmentin buy online diflucan philippines buy buy priligy singapore order cialis telephone doxycycline succinate 25 mg buy strattera adhd hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg price xenical 120 mg 42 tablets doxycycline 100mg gerd generica da zovirax buspar generic buy xenical turkey strattera uses 40 mg amoxil capsules 250 mg cialis 2.5 mg cost buy viagra berllino cialis 5mg usage cialis 50 mg tablets kamagra cheapest online online viagra inc discount cialis 40mg 20 mg cialis experiences doxycycline 100mg twice viagra 12.5mg effective comprare viagra generico 100mg doxycycline wound generic viagra england metformin online prescription viagra 50mg sales zithromax online usa celebrex 200 mg cost prospect augmentin 500 mg amoxil buy augmentin 500mg tab cheap 5mg cialis augmentin 625 mg wiki levitra 5mg pris levitra online fake zithromax 1000 mg uk buy cialis vegas periactin 4 mg cyproheptadine metformin hcl 500 mgs metformin 500 mg pregnancy generic cialis france cipro neurological disorders metformin pfizer 500 mg medication doxycycline 100mg tadalafila cialis 5 mg order viagra viagra taking 20mg lexapro 2 5 mg di levitra amoxil suspension 125 mg discount viagra 150 mg amoxil 875 mg generic buying viagra counter buy zithromax iv generic cialis secure glucophage 1000 mg fiyat xenical 120 mg niderlande valtrex generic cvs clomid 100mg discharge cialis marke 20mg cheapest synthetic viagra doxycycline mg malaria 1000 mg augmentin xr buy green viagra strattera generic price omeprazole 20 mg nexium clomid 25 mg online cialis online store cialis 50mg buy wellbutrin 75 mg cost propranolol er 60mg zithromax 250 mg prospecto cialis 20mg prodaja priligy 30 mg x 3 strattera 10 mg price doxycycline 100mg sti generic cialis test online viagra france le nexium 20mg buy nolvadex 20mg zoloft 50mg zithromax antibiotic1000mg cheap fast levitra gold viagra 800mg zovirax tablets 200 mg nolvadex 60mg start doxycycline 100 mg treatment generic propecia prescription lexapro 20mg price doxycycline 500 mg tablet nexium 40 mg tablets synthroid 0.125 mg 25 mg of strattera viagra 200mg india prednisone 10 mg instructions lasix 20 mg canine cialis dose 30 mg viagra buying online zovirax cream cheap generic celebrex canada buy generic wellbutrin cialis 20 mg efeitos cialis generic china clomid buy nhs lexapro 30 mg dosage buy viagra sweden nexium generic omeprazole lexapro 20 mg drowsy cialis 5 mg erfahrungsberichte zoloft 50 mg doctissimo amoxil 500 mg dosierung kamagra canada 50mg xenical en generico discount nexium online invagen generic zoloft buy cialis europe prix cialis 10 mg cytotec online canada nexium 20 mg packets buy viagra switzerland nexium esomeprazole generic periactin 4 mg uses diflucan de 150 mg metformin 500 mg packungsbeilage generic drugs lisinopril generic cialis clips glucophage xr generico cost propecia 1mg viagra onlineresources buy now viagra 8080 unbeatable cheap cialis generic 36hr cialis overnite cialis cheap viagra buy cialis generic lexapro fedex levitra 0.5 mg discreetly buying cialis lasix dog online 50mg cialis generic levitra 12 mg generic to lexapro cialis 100mg. price cialis 20mg fta 4 levitra line order hf cialis 50 mg wellbutrin xl 150 mg 30 viagra buyers srilanka preis viagra 50 mg achat cialis 20mg blueberry 100 mg viagra cialis 20mg bula losartan hydrochlorothiazide generic buy viagra 20 mg 150mg gineric viagra 60 mg nexium buy cialis urope 5mg lexapro dose viagra online legal levitra generico india lily cialis 20mg viagra soft cheap cytotec buy usa pregnant 50 mg clomid cialis 20mg axicorp nexium 40mg reacoes prohormones clomid 50 mg lexapro 70 mg reductil order xenical cheap 40mg cialis generic propecia australia buy levitra london viagra over 100 mg lasix tablet 20 mg buspar 600 mg overdose switching propecia generic cipro levaquin 500mg levitra mg 5 medicamento xenical 120mg propranolol 40mg ansiedade order lexapro discount cialis 20mg boots cialis 40 mg reviews cialis 50mg espanol viagra 100mg 8 buying viagra glasgow cialis, 40mg, india generic of glucophage cialis 20 mg torrinomedica buy levitra 100mg viagra generico europa buying cialis australia cialis 5 mg sublingual cialis generico espanha merck metformin 500 mg levitra 5mg mexico lexapro 3 mg pirple generic viagra medikament nexium 40 mg cialis 3000 mg synthroid tabs generic viagra buy sydney generic viagra bali viagra online europa cheap authentic viagra kegunaan cytotec 400 mg viagra dosage 200mg cipro 500mg 5ml doxycycline 50 mg tabs buy strattera 100mg zithromax 1000 mg daily buy lisinopril hctz precio cytotec 800 mg kamagra 100 mg contrareembolso 30 mg of lexapro prospect diflucan 50 mg viagra 200 online zoloft what mg order viagra 100 mg diflucan tablets 100mg 400mg de viagra prednisone 200 mg generic propecia buy doxycycline dci 100 mg 800 mg zovirax online buy xenical au buspar 90 mg viagra generic 2012 hsa viagra online xenical 120 mg costo preis viagra 100mg clomid online apotheek celebrex pfizer 200 mg generic cialis capsules strattera 10 mg used cheapest prednisone cialis 50mg bestellen strattera 80 mg mexico levitra 5 mg erfahrung lasix 40 mg dosierung cialis 20 mg 2 tablets buy clomid canada prix viagra 25 mg generic levitra cipla online viagra delhi cialis 5 mg indicaciones cipro siprofloksasin 500 mg zovirax suspension 200 mg phenergan liquid buy bactrim online cheap viagra generico laboratorio lasix 5 mg online buy cialis 40online valtrex generic dose cialis 40mg day zoloft 25 mgs uk generic clomid clomiphene buy levitra sydney levitra 5mg buy cialis 20mg anwendung lexapro 30 mgs
Home Salary Arb Signings/Rulings Salary Arbitration Common Misunderstandings in MLB Service Time Comparisons

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 909 guests online

Atom RSS

Common Misunderstandings in MLB Service Time Comparisons PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 9
PoorBest 
Salary Arbitration
Written by Joe Tetreault   
Tuesday, 16 March 2010 21:53

Writing for the Biz of Baseball has given me a fascinating crash course in the salary arbitration process. With so many personnel decisions influenced by the service time of the players involved, the arbitration process has truly become central to understanding why teams elect to leave useful players toiling in the minors (yes, we're looking at you Evan Longoria and Matt Wieters). And despite the unending utitility of salary data gained through the process, one stark fact remains above all others: comparisons across service time are useless.

Evan Hoschild, writing at the Crawfish Boxes, stumbled into such an inapt comparison recently.

Of course when a player of similar age and position signs a new contract, I get interested in what the Astros are going to do with Pence. Does Ed Wade wait and see how Hunter does to start the season in 2010 and begin to think beyond the one year increments that has been the approach with not only him but Michael Bourn? At this juncture, with potentially so much payroll coming off the books after this season, I think this is the prudent approach to take.

A multi-year deal for Hunter Pence is absolutely the prudent course of action. But Hochschild will be disappointed with the cost of the contract Astros GM Ed Wade could negotiate with the Astros right fielder. Pence's starting point is significantly higher than that of either Denard Span or Arizona's Mark Reynolds who just signed a long term contract as well.

Because neither would be arbitration eligible until after the season Span and Reynolds are more comparable. Their teams could have set salaries however they wanted as long as it did not dip below the league minimum or represent more than a 20% pay cut from the previous year's total compensation. In short, the teams held almost all the leverage. With that in mind, let's tackle the key mistake in Hochschild's piece:

The details of the contract...are ridiculous in their reasonableness. The per year salaries increase conservatively, buying out five arbitration eligible years for the certainty that goes with a long term contract.

First off, Span does not have five years of arbitration eligibility. Players are guaranteed three years of arbitration eligibility. Some players receive four years, by qualifying as a Super Two player after their second full year of major league service time.

With Minnesota buying out three arbitration eligible years and two years of team contract control, they could set a low initial salary and conservative raises. Reynolds provides another example. His salary for 2010 is just $500,000. Arizona had renewed Reynolds on the 11th, before working out this deal which can (if the Diamondbacks exercise the team option) buy out the entirety of Reynolds' arbitration eligibility.

Comparing Pence to Span is category error because Pence was arbitration eligible this past season. The increased leverage helped him win a significant raise from the Astros for 2010. Had he not qualified as a Super Two, he would have been subject to contract renewal this spring, just like Span and Reynolds were. That difference is immense.

Pence and the Astros agreed on a deal that pays him $3.5 million in 2010 establishing his baseline for 2011. Pence’s 2011 will be far above that baseline, because arbitration is designed to inflate salaries. This isn't some voodoo from Scott Boras. It's the nature of the system.

SELECT READ MORE TO SEE THE REST OF THIS ARTICLE

Proof is found yeat again in Arizona. Their first baseman, Conor Jackson who took home $3.05 million in 2009, suffered through a horrendous season, as he battled valley fever. Despite his illness and poor performance, the Diamonbacks agreed with him on a contract that gave him a raise of $50,000. Though modest, his raise was a certainty, because the arbitration process precludes pay cuts.

Constructing a reasonable contract for Pence needs to be based on his service time, his performance and comparable players. Luckily, we can project Pence’s progression with a similar player who is one year ahead of Pence in the arbitration process. The Dodgers Andre Ethier provides a near ideal roadmap for what lies ahead.

Both players qualified for arbitration as Super Twos following their seasonal age 26 years. Players can qualify for arbitration after they complete their second year of MLB service time.  The must accumulate at least 86 days of service during the immediately preceding season and rank in the top 17 percent in total service among players with more than two, but less than three years of service time.  Maury Brown discussed Super Two players in the arbitration process last year.

Through his first three seasons, Pence posted a .289/.340/.488 slash line in 1,773 plate appearances. Ethier's first three seasons were statistically similar, though with marginally less playing time. His batting line was .299/.364/.482 in 1,542 plate appearances. Ethier’s first arbitration influenced salary was $3.1 million, which is also comparable to the $3.5 million Pence will get in 2010.

Ethier’s playing time increased in 2009 which boosted his counting stats helping him hit 30 homeruns, a plateau he had not approached previously. His perceived breakout season prompted the Dodgers to work out a long term extension that will pay him $15.25 million over two seasons. For perspective, his two-year guarantee is $1.25 million less than Span will get over five years.

Using Ethier as a guide, if Pence maintains his current rate of production, he should expect no less than $6.5 million in 2011 (Ethier is getting $6 million next season and Pence has a higher starting point) and better than $10 million in 2012 (Ethier is getting $9.25 million). To buy out the balance of his arbitration eligibility will likely cost Houston close to $30 million over three seasons on top of the $3.5 Pence will earn this year.

Hochschild's premise is sound. Signing young talent to team friendly, cost-controlling deals is almost without question a reasonable decision. But once a player reaches the arbitration process, suppressing salary escalation becomes nearly impossible. Had Houston negotiated a long term deal with Pence prior to the date the players and teams exchanged salary arbitration figures, they may have been able to lock him up for the duration of his arbitration eligibility for less than $24 million over the four seasons. Having demurred, they now face a bill that will likely be 40% higher. That's the difference arbitration makes on salary increases.


Joe Tetreault is a member of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?