famvir 1000 mg order alli online buy buy cytotec uae orlistat guidelines buy acticin in ireland what is acai extract used for requip drugs online purchases generic viagra cipla buy premarin paypal accepted viagra professional buy on line street price dilantin premarin billig kaufen noroxin norfloxacin tablets apple discount drugs clinton endep 10 mg buy revia without a prescription from canadian pharmacy is there a generic form of benicar elocon cream over the counter original artane online cleocin brands india buy erection packs 1 with ordering ampicillin what is hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg for chloramphenicol eye drops price seroquel in croatia meclizine 10 mg roxithromycin tablets ip 300 mg can you get lisinopril over the counter neurontin 100 mg 20 capsule round gray pill abg 100 how long does it take for asacol to start working viagra professional generic mexico buy frumil generic safe place order lynoral benadryl now comprar clonidine portugal american suprax singulair discount medications side effects of trandate 200 mg best place to buy arimidex in india rumalaya forte pills drugstore lov cost erexor most reliable place to buy zyvox online what does casodex look like coumadin on line for sale no script esomeprazole tablets or capsules buy cardizem cd online what is plendil used for buy vermox capsules ranitidine 150 mg tablet side effects buy amoxil 500 250mg prednisone shortage june 2012 yasmin discount buy accutane online where lipitor 40 mg cost purchase claritin d online cialis price in uae buy toprol xl 80 mg online what does deltasone doo drugstore band london bentyl without rx does methotrexate cause you to gain weight is there a generic for bactroban nasal ointment fast hydrea deleviery best generic evista sites acne medication similar to differin best online meds no prescription billig calan online kaufen buy dipyridamole astrailia buy cheap allegra using pay pal pharmacy support technologies inc erexin uk zithromax from purchase advair diskus 250mcg 50mcg pharmacy cost of hgh injections for weight loss finpecia online altace with no rx tenormin overnight shipping cheap combivent uk buy how many claritin tablets to take valtrex generic canada generic low price fluoxetine uk most reliable place to buy lopressor online zoloft maximum dosage anxiety triamterene without a prescription is micardis available over the counter is it illegal to order generic zetia lamisil ordering online pharmacy is it safe to buy tadalafil online cloridrato de ciprofloxacina bula we are young youtube long time side effects arava where to buy elimite in canada safely buy cleocin gel online cheap valtrex pills side effects what is remeron good for leukeran usa purchase synthroid 200 tablets cost of lamictal in canada how to order minocin online cheap tenormin sale uk buy fertomid with no rx research grade deltasone generic probalan buy canada purchase plendil 5 mg costo de dostinex en mexico 100mg clomid iui twins actonel results forum reglan no prescription compare prices vermox discount canadian mebendazole cefadroxil usa cvs prices resources for inderal methotrexate canada overnight delivery viagra patent expiration dates ophthacare sale imitrex coupon card buy avalide in india online buy revatio with new allies transport buy olanzapine patch otc generic for prevacid antiboitics for chlamydia online colchicine weight gain order minocycline medication by mail lozol usa safe drugs for depression and anxiety buy prazosin online cheap generic saw palmetto pills that make you get hard elavil dose for chronic pain viagra free samples canada lopid discount medications tamoxifen echeck generic liv 52 suprax from usa pharmacy how much does lexapro cost without insurance delmar;s pharmacy technician certification exam review online digoxin pills vytorin generic version haldol delivery doxycycline dose for canine kennel cough buy cheap reglan using pay pal desyrel canada head office what is atorlip-10 pills used for ventoline pour homme buy zyloprim no prescription fast delivery cipro prescriptions india pharmacies online that sell tetracycline thailand government closing online pharmacies singulair discounted cialis 20 mg cut in half bactroban costco what is flovent hfa 220 mcg lisinopril 40 mg pharmacy generic brand cialis for sale on line buy arava australia the road to competitive generic drug prices in canada alli weight loss coupon alli diet pill to buy revatio in uk xenical forums message board pariet looking for brahmi oil reviews order protonix overnight what is femcare made of januvia discounts buy viagra soft in australia omifin en hombres dosis betamethasone valerate cream where do i furosemide in uk cipro 500mg twice a day for 10 days aciclovir over the counter what date is lexapro going generic augmentin mexico no prescription where to buy unisom drugs online elimite drugs james prescription glucophage dosage instructions cordarone to buy in australia purchase apcalis sx order cialis uk american femcare caverta lawsuit canada buy viagra cialis online canada aa lithium battery price in india sildenafil citrate generic viagra amantadina vademecum.es buy meloxicam for dogs canada fluoxetine medication weight gain generic retin-a 0,05 buy canada brand levitra buy zofran pregnancy dose brand viagra cheap mexico pharmacy what does claritin d look like propecia delivery flonase in the uk lisinopril 10 mg w929 brafix pills acivir pills looking for chloromycetin billig kaufen femara generic drug us pharmacies online no prescription order ranitidine online decadron no prescription eulexin ships from india naproxen side effects nhs where to buy exelon mg spironolactone hair loss success brand viagra price buspar maximum dosage birth control pills paxil ordering fluoxetine online can you take brand cialis daily how do i get viagra benicar hct buying actoplus met from canada no prescription differin cream sale canadian online pharmacy for cozaar phenergan gel dose for children can i order zenegra no prescription in the usa nitrofurantoin wanted online review generic compazine buy canada how much is viagra tablets how to buy avapro in london taking clomid after miscarriage current price minocycline cheap haldol pills cialis professional online overnight shipping buy bystolic online canada que es kamagra gel oral can amoxil be used for uti buy cheap glycomet using pay pal levaquin over counter drug cheap actonel usa propecia roche precio argentina side effects doxycycline hyclate 100mg acne buy procardia online us no prescription buy provera in uk tretinoin cream amazon.uk buy haldol hong kong online pharmacy discount dulcolax 10 mg tablet buy mifepristone no prescription cystone for kidney stones reviews purchase lioresal pills cialis soft 120 pills buy isoniazid greece buy brand levitra 10 over the counter alternative to flomax doxazosin without prescription canada birth control pills olanzapine provera 100mg cheap buy dramamine in india online ventolin dosage for kids levothroid prix en pharmacie en france can you order astelin online prescription sumycin online usa no prescription metoclopramide annual sales anafranil for ocd dosage how much does valtrex cost what is pamelor 10 mg cheapest flagyl er in the uk donde comprar viagra generico en mexico american indian law alliance doctrine of discovery buy cheap female viagra viagra jet pfizer how to take cytotec pill buy clomiphene citrate uk online forum generic buy aristocort para que serve o remedio sertralina 50mg ordering valtrex online is it safe to order hoodia buy prednisolone online thru paypals is generic periactin effective dilantin prices rhine auto inc lopid generico italiano intravitreal triamcinolone for diabetic macular edema list of tesco stores selling probalan suppliers of avandamet in us ordering low dose cardura toradol medication guide singulair prices usa cheapest hydrochlorothiazide paypal sarafem for sale philippines amoxil chewable tablets dosage tadalafil 20mg preis side effects of ditropan xl is it illegal to order generic acticin best site get diarex genuine cleocin gel 100mg buy crestor 10 mg where can i buy flomax albenza dose children pulmicort budesonide information wellbutrin sr tablets uses cheap lithium lisinopril 20 mg 12.5 levlen for sale buy zyvox online from usa acquistare kytril in italia what is azithromycin 250mg tablets cialis daily use formulary tadalafil no prescription and bactrim flagyl 400 dosage a^??clomiphene for women in store what is keftab drugs buy bactroban ointment without prescription zocor coupon discount is there a drug comparative to methotrexate buy proscar with januvia generic wikipedia drugs can order allegra canada buy prozac fluoxetine online best generic pariet review lipitor sale ireland buy furosemide online from mexico buy furosemide without rx altace hct effects body purchase phenergan online what is lortab high like walgreens discount prescription drugs orlistat mail order india nolvadex women buy serophene 50 mg fertility malegra dxt sold over counter lipitor comprare order cymbalta online uk amoxicillin side effects rxlist injectable ivermectin for pigs canada buy diflucan online prescription billig diclofenac gel online kaufen diflucan fluconazole buy online cardizem medication where to buy teva atorvastatin canada resources for independent living inc what is the chemical formula for calcium hydrogen carbonate resources for nexium decadron discounted buy cephalexin mexican pharmacies how to identify counterfeit viagra synthroid australia pharmacy voveran sr by mail order what is effexor xr 75 kamagra without generic viagra super active india buy benfotiamine bulk phenergan where to purchase treatment of asymptomatic rectal chlamydia trachomatis is single-dose azithromycin effective sertralina prec,o 50mg best fosamax prices acyclovir cream costco online uk photos indian generics online detrol purchase mobic cheap buy cialis sublingual 40 better take synthroid levothyroxine low cost albendazole mg uk what is betapace used for where to buy anacin drugs online flagyl metronidazole 400mg levaquin to buy in australia tamoxifen mg price stromectol prescription drug where can i buy water pills nature;s bounty acai berry 1000 mg softgels reviews china viagra sale how to get viagra jelly on line buy periactin with e check fast precose deleviery canadian pharmacy online flonase lioresal online cheap where danazol can i buy clomid uk best prices cheapest levitra canadian buy clomid next day delivery azulfidine order in the us where can i buy seroquel in canada low dose topamax and birth control levitra super active roche precio argentina chi ha usato atarax purchase robaxin lowest price buy daily dose cialis ordering micronase here in canada percentage of drugs in america from mexico low cost overnight lithium amaryl diabetes med purinethol pills sweat cheapest emsam tablets uk buy aricept mg online for paxil reviews for social phobia cheap kamagra uk reviews cialis nolvadex tablet sale what does generic plavix look like where to buy zyrtec d online brand viagra from china why is there a shortage of depakote himcolin order in the us best place to buy trazodone in india lasix drug order online trust org compra viagra italy nombre de pharmacie france amlodipine simvastatin interaction 2011 sildenafil citrate buy cheap canadian on line pharmcay hydroxyzine amantadina dosis y via de administracion bactroban nasale generico viagra soft 100mg cheap avalide tablets uses can you buy zebeta online what is the correct dosage of asacol list of drugs with sulfa in them albendazole through treatment patients comprar rumalaya pela internet medrol comprare buy protonix 40 uk pharmacies online that sell cipro prednisone uk online how much will cholestoplex cost pastillas para ereccion cialis levaquin 500 mg para que sirve cheap nolvadex buy acheter kytril generic for actos 5 mg nymphomax for sale usa canada order cabgolin sale zoloft zetia pharmacy vardenafil hcl generic levitra order finpecia pill free pharmacy store software what type of benadryl is safe for dogs how fast does viagra work approved purchase cheap doxazosin mesylate dostinex delivery uk where can i order ventolin can i make naprosyn ceftin generic for levlen online cheap is trazodone a prescription drug metoclopramide cheap lisinopril buy online no prescription buy propecia in india what is aspirin drugs actos shortage 2012 tienda online viagra can you get high off motrin ib cheap valtrex online no prescription diltiazem in veterinary medicine lasuna dosage too high overnight pharmacy avalide propecia walgreens suprax 400 mg 5 tablet side effects of lopid tablets tofranil to buy in australia order estrace on line purchase fluoxetine cheap bystolic pharmacy online anxiety evecare lawsuit settlements lopressor prescription coupon brand name cialis for sale buy mycelex-g cheap viagra plus generic levitra pill shop discount code for acai atarax drug oversea buy elocon cream from canada list of tesco stores selling ditropan plendil no prescription needed buy erection pills online calan india shallaki tablets price generic form of antivert what kind of medicine is strattera lamisil terbinafine cream what is it for promethazine online order buy over the counter brand viagra online buy lipitor 80 mg online ayurslim delivery london alli coupons walmart side effects clomid success stories what is lariam medication purchasing ortho tri-cyclen online uk buy lipitor mg online for cialis for sale australia wellbutrin now co uk abana herbal medicine himalaya ranitidine over counter equivalent acheter livre d;occasion pas cher lipitor tablets price metmorfin diabetes side effects of methotrexate injection buy valium uk online zoloft no script prevacid cost amantadine in usa non prescription pletal pharmacy lopid generic viagra uk delivery generic levlen buy pharmacy has best price topamax motilium and other medication how to get biaxin drug how to get off prednisone weight obat voltaren long term side effects finasteride what does xalatan treat legal buy micronase online canada depakote without script ezetimibe mechanism of action can you get imitrex generic benfotiamine paxil online purchase sito italiano cialis betnovate cream psoriasis acheter biaxin pas cher inderal without prescription generic finast in usa purchase viagra super active mg clotrimazole and betamethasone dipropionate cream usp 1 0.05 side effects buy alligators uk canadian buy nizoral in ireland micardis 160 mg dose erythromycin cheap australia pharmacy buyers of arimidex canada mexico buy metoclopramide 10mg lasuna order in the us over the counter weight loss pills for teenagers is it safe to order cytoxan proventil brand positioning cleocin gel refills cafergot usa cvs prices order ventolin hfa fincar without script xenical roche precio colombia periactin cats side effects himplasia side effects long term use order prescription medicine online buy carafate sucralfate dulcolax dosage too high 50 advair coupon printable low acticin buy purchase progaine 5 cheap oz bentyl uses side effects mirapex side effects long term use flexeril 10mg tab protonix prescription medicine mobic price australia revatio delivery buy voveran australia claritin d online pharmacy citalopram without prescription best places to buy non persciption haldol non persciption alli is generic malegra fxt effective iv haldol max dose why was alesse discontinued what is the medication protonix for online pharmacy no prescription needed tadacip rico rico shanghai tenormin medicine used omnicef spain viagra cena srbija levothroid without prescriptions brand advair diskus costco finpecia pharmacy2home.com free coupon for eldepryl aetna rx online pharmacy where to inject methotrexate injection for ectopic danazol from india abilify brand order how can i buy birth control pill online glucotrol xl package insert is zyprexa legal in uk cipa certified online pharmacy how to use cefixime chlamydia symptoms men pics prescription cheap stromectol 6mg cheap painkillers online actonel brands india effects of low-dose prednisone on bone metabolism acquistare ciplox in italia suppliers of betnovate in us innopran xl no prescription code phone in order for pamelor advair diskus tablets us online free coupon for desyrel finpecia (generic propecia finasteride 1mg) buy imuran online usa mail-order malegra fxt where to get rumalaya forte legit viagra site retino-a cream 0,05 drug schedule levitra generic safety cheap doxycycline 100-mg capsule slimquick hoodia customer reviews motilium safe during pregnancy cialis at optum rx hydrochlorothiazide drug in canada pharmacy prograf mg buy haringey turkish pharmacy fast tretinoin 0,05 deleviery retin-a 0,025 price india generic phenergan suppositories rosuvastatin to buy in the canada without a prescription orlistat tablets purchase on line
Home Maury Brown Precedent-Setting Deal With Florida Marlins Over Revenue-Sharing Has Broad Implications

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 692 guests online

Atom RSS

Precedent-Setting Deal With Florida Marlins Over Revenue-Sharing Has Broad Implications PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 30
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 12 January 2010 22:05

Florida MarlinsFor years now, there have been questions surrounding whether MLB’s collectively bargained revenue-sharing policy has had a loophole in it as wide as centerfield at Minute Maid Park. The loophole in question is based upon Article XXIV(B)(5)(a) of the current Basic Agreement (see the latest Basic Agreement) . That section reads, in part:

A principal objective of the Revenue Sharing Plan is to promote the growth of the Game and the industry on an individual Club and on an aggregate basis. Accordingly, each Club shall use its revenue sharing receipts (from the Base Plan, the Central Fund Component and the Commissioner’s Discretionary Fund) in an effort to improve its performance on the field.

It is the end of this provision that has been where questions as to whether some clubs are not taking revenue-sharing dollars and using them as the CBA specifies.

Additionally, XXIV(B)(5)(b) reads:

The Clubs and the Association recognize that the participation of two Clubs is necessary for the production of the on-field competition that the Clubs sell to the public.

While the league does not release the figures, owners of clubs such as the Marlins, Pirates, and Royals have reportedly received revenue-sharing figures that surpass their Major League payroll levels, and thus the question is asked, “Where is the money going?”

The answer has been, “To improving performance on the field,” but, according to these clubs, through player development, not within the spirit of the provision which, to the MLBPA has been, “major league player payroll.”

Each year, the union for the players has said that they are monitoring these clubs that seemed to be skirling precariously close to what might be construed as pocketing revenue-sharing funds, and each year, the league has said that the MLBPA has every right to act on anything that seems out of line with the provision. That’s because the union can request receipts from the Administrator of the program, and file a grievance if they feel the numbers don’t jive with what the revenue-sharing program outlines in Article XXIV(B)(5)(a) above. And, each year, the MLBPA has not filed such a grievance,

And while the MLBPA did not file a grievance today over the revenue-sharing provision, they came about as close as they have, yet. In a joint statement from MLB, the MLBPA, and the Florida Marlins, the following was announced:

In recent years, the Union has had concerns that certain Clubs have not lived up to this requirement, and has consulted regularly with the Commissioner’s Office about those concerns. The Florida Marlins are one of a number of Clubs that have been discussed.

Adding to the statement, MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner added:

“In response to our concerns that revenue sharing proceeds have not been used as required, the Marlins have assured the Union and the Commissioner’s Office that they plan to use such proceeds to increase player payroll annually as they move toward the opening of their new ballpark. Today’s agreement, which covers the period 2010 through 2012, calls for ongoing communication among the Marlins, the Commissioner’s Office and the Union as the Marlins proceed with that plan.”

After extensive discussions, the three parties are pleased to announce that they have reached an agreement regarding the Florida Marlins’ continued compliance with Article XXIV(B)(5)(a) of the Basic Agreement.

Beyond the Marlins: Timing; the Pirates, Royals, Rays, and Others; And Labor Negotiations

Today’s news was seen as a public flogging of the Marlins. The MLBPA clearly had information that would have allowed them to file a grievance that, it appears, they would have won. Otherwise, why would MLB and the Marlins buckle?

But, what should be looked at closely are a number of pieces in a far broader context:

Sending A Message to Others - While the MLBPA has the right to continue to look closely at the manner in which revenue-sharing is spent, don’t expect them to immediately chase after the Pirates or the Royals, or the Rays... any other clubs that could be on their radar at any given time. That’s because the precedent-setting agreement that singles out the Marlins should echo in those other markets. The MLBPA has been talking of doing something, and now they have. The message is clear: we’re more than watching, we’re willing to act. Beware.

Going after the Marlins Was Also About “When” – Go back and read what Michael Weiner said. “[The Marlins] plan to use such proceeds to increase player payroll annually as they move toward the opening of their new ballpark.” The opening of the new ballpark by the Marlins in 2012 gives them new revenues from which to work from, so in some senses, while slapping them on the wrist, the MLBPA simply asked that they spend above what they have been doing while playing in the same home of the Miami Dolphins. That deal has the Marlins not collecting all revenue sources that they would otherwise be doing in their own ballpark. By reaching the deal, the Marlins won’t scream as loud as they would have if they weren’t going into their own stadium. The MLBPA surely took this into account.

Going after the Marlins Was Also About “When” (the Labor Side) – The timing of Marlins agreement also has a great deal to do with upcoming labor negotiations. With the current Basic Agreement expiring in 2011, the MLBPA had to pick their spot to move on the Marlins. Doing so much later would have been seen as a negotiating tactic for the upcoming rounds of collective bargaining.

Reaching An Agreement Is a Good Sign (Labor Peace) – It’s very early on, but by the MLBPA and MLB willing to strong-arm the Marlins, the signs point to calm waters on the labor front. If MLB (with the Marlins pushing) had wanted to make a labor statement, they could have dug their heels in, and told the MLBPA, “Go file your grievance.” They didn’t, which shows that the relationship between MLB and the MLBPA continues to move forward past the labor strife that occurred prior to the 2002 CBA.

An Agreement Allows the Marlins to Save Face (sort of) - Make no mistake, Jeffery Loria and the Marlins can’t be happy campers today. It appears they got caught with their hands in the cookie jar, and the MLBPA finally decided to reach out and smack it. But, with the parties agreeing to a “self-policing” deal, the Marlins get to publically stick to their guns and say they did nothing wrong. As Marlins President David Samson said in the statement, “Throughout the discussions, the Marlins maintained that there had been no violation of the Basic Agreement at any time.” As mentioned, if the league was willing to go down the road of a forced agreement with the Marlins, then “maintaining innocence” doesn’t mean that the MLBPA didn’t find money hidden under a rock. Ultimately, by not losing in a grievance hearing, Commissioner Selig isn’t put in the uncomfortable position of having to deal with this nasty little section of the CBA, as it pertains to revenue-sharing violations: Consistent with his authority under the Major League Constitution, the Commissioner may impose penalties on any Club that violates this obligation

Could the Marlins Be a Scapegoat? – More than one today has asked, “Do you think the Marlins were targeted because the league wasn’t going to go toe-to-toe with Pirates president Frank Coonelly?” Maybe. As mentioned, there is the timing of the new Marlins stadium coming online, the exceptionally low levels of player payroll in the past, and… well, more than a few in the industry have said that they don’t really rate Loria very highly; he’s not well liked. Prior to working for the Pirates, Coonelly was Senior Vice President and General Counsel of Labor in the Office of the Commissioner of Baseball where he negotiated and administered collective bargaining agreements with the MLBPA. As reported earlier (see The Pirates: Improving the Team, or Just Their Bottom Line?), one might look at the Pirates as being a potentially more egregious violator of the revenue-sharing clause that the Marlins are being held to. The Marlins low player payroll, the timing of the new stadium, and yes… the MLBPA seeing something in the Marlins’ revenue-sharing report that every team is required to file that requests revenue-sharing, stands out. Even so, if there would have been a slight change in circumstances, it could have been the Pirates, rather than the Marlins, who got their wrists slapped on Tuesday.

Chalk Up a Big Win for Michael Weiner – The MLBPA has to feel good, not only because they got the Marlins to increase player payroll, but because it’s the first labor victory for Michael Weiner after being approved as the new Exec. Director in December. Now, will MLB use the agreement as a bargaining chip in the future…?

How Much Will the Marlins Raise Payroll? – This is the biggest question tied to Tuesday’s announcement. There’s little knowing how much using “such proceeds to increase player payroll annually as they move toward the opening of their new ballpark” is. The end of year payroll for the Marlins in 2009 was $37,532,482. The league has guarded revenue-sharing figures closely in recent years. But, here’s what is known… Based upon revenue-sharing figures that were published in 2002-’03, as well as 2005, there is the following. The difference figure shows how much the Marlins needed to cover for a given year before one game is played that garnered any local revenues (includes gate, local/regional television deals, concessions, etc). As displayed, the player payroll figures were higher then than last season, and most assuredly, revenue-sharing for the Marlins is higher. The combination is, at least in large part, the reason the MLBPA acted on the club.

Florida Marlins Rev-Sharing - Payroll

Year

Rev-Sharing

EOY Payroll

Diff

2002

$20,946,573

$40,822,536

$19,875,963

2003

$21,030,000

$63,281,152

$42,251,152

2005

$31,000,000

$56,273,212

$25,273,212

 

See complete revenue-sharing figures for all 30 clubs for 2002-’03 and 2005


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?