rush cialis online buy lotrisone lotion online viagra online rezept diprosone hair growth female viagra tablets us online red cialis 200 mg online chemist propecia us pharmacies online that sell luvox india meds rx generic xenical australia side effects doxycycline hyclate acne 30 mg of buspar topamax next day delivery innopran xl drugs dosage nexium 40 mg buy buspar boots evista pharmacies cialis 10mg cpr4 viagra buy online no prescription uk viagra 150 mg canada serophene shop net generic indian cialis crestor 10 mg precio en mexico zyloprim no prescription reviews wellbutrin 300 mg bijwerkingen 120 mg of lasix comprimidos cialis 20mg cialis cost 10mg buy citalopram online at canada pharmacy viagra 50 mg percocet fertomid discount medications how long does xeloda take to work propecia results 5mg buy nolvadex england take 50 mg clomid cialis 10 mg cheap nexium 40 mg prospecto lithium weight gain forum buy weekend cialis viagra competitors online viagra 40 mg buy symptoms of too high synthroid dose propecia msd online can buy rumalaya online lozol on line for sale no script buy diamox singapore celebrex capsule 400 mg is there a real generic levitra buy prinivil online amazon 150 mg zoloft actos suppositories buy lexapro 10 mg 14 comprimidos propecia and generic indications zoloft 100 mg buy kytril 20 to buy prandin in uk vytorin for sale how much does generic fenofibrate cost kamagra sildenafil 50mg cheap kamagra sale generic cipro buy nolvadex without nexium 40 mg effects buy dapoxetine online at canada pharmacy suprax discount card can you order flonase sure generic cialis black 200 mg doxycycline natural alternatives buy viagra cancun buy nexium ireland wellbutrin mg amounts fast kytril deleviery skelaxin prices usa generic cialis 30mg xenical alli viagra generico costo pet meds canada online viagra generic dose baclofen 10 mg tabletki viagra 50mg buying vytorin price philippines propecia hair loss dosage cialis vs viagra blog zoloft order prozac half price baclofen abra generic viagra beat way to order brand viagra azithromycin zithromax buy viagra 150mg peppermint zyban brands india nexium tablets spc order generic clomid exelon online bestellen buy acai berry pills ontario buy anacin boots pharmacy generic zovirax sale lasix best online non prescription pharmacy coreg for sale philippines fast mircette deleviery viamedic model best generic lotensin review toradol barato bactrim f 400 mg genuine bentyl 100mg how to order allopurinol drugs without prescriptions online viagra generic fake order 2.5 mg cialis lexapro equivalent generic diuretic aldactone buy prednisone 2.5mg what is neurontin used for and what are the side effects online generic voveran sr where to buy malegra fxt bactrim ds tablet dose generic cialis usa american express canada my account login cheap viagra generic buying brahmi in manchester prednisone 5mg dosage overnight delivery buy trazodone next day aciclovir mg buy cialis lilly 800mg lasix cheap online generic propecia sales cheap alternative to prevacid wellbutrin 125 mg cialis 10 o 20 mg nolvadex tabs cheap cialis online site lotensin generic reviews bystolic woldwide shipping viagra genericcanada nexium 40 mg bivirkninger generic coumadin pictures metoclopramide medication overnight delivery lamisil cream for thrush is canadian healthcare free for americans cheapest cialis 20mg uk generic lexapro 40 mil diflucan 150 mg kapsula trazodone fast usa triamcinolone hexacetonide vs triamcinolone acetonide viagra generico foro beconase aq with no rx remeron medication order cheap viagra 50 mg buy levitra super cefixime 400 mg no prescription nexium generic online clomid 50mg provera atrovent medication online viagra canada orders why did charles and alli go to spain rumalaya forte legal in england cialis generico roma buy real kamagra can phenergan make you gain weight cytotec pills online in the canada doxycycline 100mg dawkowanie norvasc tablets pfizer can you buy coreg over the counter in germany nexium 20 mg interactions 50mg cialis brand viagra tablets capoten online ordering toradol maximum iv dose priligy 30mg generic lexapro hair bayer vs. generic aspirin is parlodel available over the counter generico de wellbutrin reglan generic image dosage 200 mg celebrex buy medication online canada azithromycin 250 mg uses priligy 30 mg hinta can you order promethazine codeine online buy zyprexa from canada lov cost chloramphenicol hydrochlorothiazide online canada generic cordarone us reditabs buy viagra maximum effexor xr dose 60 mg lexapro ocd viagra 50 mg drug online vantin overnight delivery diflucan 150 mg prescription nexium online best benicar hct 40 25 coupons buying viagra us clomid online usa better than blopress online suppliers viagra online lexapro pharmacy 600 mg of celebrex walmart buy cialis florida decadron cialis 50 mg fiyat buy cialis toronto 8000 mg viagra buy kamagra spain silagra 40mg levitra 10mg australia prednisone 20 mg efectos 30 mg nolvadex donde puedo comprar stromectol dosage forms ampicillin trihydrate tadalafil cialis 5 mg long term side effects of taking zoloft buy diclofenac pills online generic lexapro antidepressants doxycycline 500mg buying buy cialis 80mg diflucan 50 mg capsules buy pilex with visa dosage phenergan 25mg generic viagra kolkata cytotec abortion cost where purchase depakote 20mg lexapro diahoerra order generic propecia viagra online pharmacy india himcolin in croatia retin a wrinkles reviews compare prices cholestoplex metformin online ordering thuoc roxithromycin tablets 150mg best pharmacy to order provera cheap viagra se5 line no prescription cheap levitra vardenafil buy clomid germany metformin 500 mg dose online pharmacy alphagan levitra 20 mg 8 compr buy tricor 200 prescription viagra online buy cialis italy xlpharmacy generic cialis pharmacy mexico steroids tadapox brand positioning abilify 5mg tabletten buy prednisone pills 400mg zovirax med cab tadalis sx beneficios lexapro 10 mg doxycycline 40 mg mr torsemide brands india buy genuine cialis jelly uk emsam where to purchase generic of metformin pharmacy escrow hcg mixing is generic zocor effective viagra 100mg nebenwirkungen discount zestoretic mg retin online order strattera 18 mg saudi does propecia work for hair loss cytotec philippines order which uk site to buy isoptin cheap kamagra sale viagra usa generic viagra prednisone 20mg pregnancy purchase fertomid pills lipitor drug store online propranolol 10 mg migraine viagra generic wallmart onde comprar xeloda 500mg buy plavix online usa clomid 50 mg kopen fluoxetine generic 2013 drugs generic viagra does alli tablets lloyds can you use abilify to get high soma online no prescription overnight delivery buy bactrim overnight viagra 100mg compare cheap viagra onaline medicamento lisinopril 20 mg why has ophthacare been discontinued 20 mg prednisone lot amoxil 500 mg sirop buy cheap exelon using pay pal buy wellbutrin 150 buy cialis pills online cheapest 20mg cialis phenergan 10mg tab buy zithromax pfizer viagra 200mg buy kamagra 100mg erfahrungsbericht kamagra 100mg ervaring glucophage uk buy cialis pill lokk like 10 mg di cialis gyne-lotrimin for sale uk cialis 20 mg free is there a drug comparative to forzest levitra 30mg etkisi methotrexate prices pharmacy half inderal 80 mg propecia 1mg tab generic sildenafil citrate vs viagra bayer levitra 10 mg wellbutrin generic problems can you buy valtrex at walgreens medicine order buspar 5mg 5mg cialis enough overnight lioresal noroxin generico online pharmacy keftab viagra 300mg dose price increase prilosec propranolol 10mg generic lexapro issues clarithromycin 500mg tablets side effects propranolol 1 mg 1ml order erection packs 11 online without paxil dosages for ocd synthroid 0.075mg levothyroxine lexapro 10mg alcohol buy viagra fourm genericdrugs levitra generic doxycycline malaria what is the generic for cozaar diclofenac tablets dosage prednisone dogs order purchase strattera 100 mg buy ginseng 50 50 mg strattera keftab tablets 150 mg generic bupropion xl canada bactrim online buy order periactin synthroid 0.05mg daily zithromax pill online low income housing alliance conference washington state tegretol cheap hydrochlorothiazide 12.5mg tablets cialis 5mg holland robaxin 750 mg get you high colospa without prescription canada how to live cheaply and save money kamagra brausetabletten 100mg viagra 50 mg fiyat vente de dramamine au quebec best price childrens claritin kamagra 100mg upotreba 500mg zithromax chlamydia prospect viagra 50 mg purchase furosemide order antivert 12.5 mg cialis 5mg cost 5 levitra 20 mg tablet generic viagra usps cost of cymbalta in australia order lexapro discount generic for actoplus met 15 800 prijs viagra 25 mg lasix 20 mg tabletten viagra 100mg original propecia generic reviews long time side effects levaquin viagra cheap 100mg trileptal tablets 600 mg cheapest valtrex generic baclofen medication info norfloxacin & tinidazole with beta cyclodextrin tablets lexapro 10 mg ambien buy cipro pills in the india unisom sleeptabs australia can you only get revia on prescription how to use antabuse proscar drug in germany pharmacy clomid 50mg miscarriage kupim cialis generic acheter viagra 50mg strattera 20mg amitriptyline and alcohol consumption cialis uk online oder mg tablets of nitrofurantoin cialis 5 mg fun antibiotics for uti in children buying cialis london cialis online pharmacist 20 mg of lexapro bactrim forte 800 mg zebeta mg buy seroquel xl 50mg tablets cialis overnight generic buy kamagra soft cheap foro levitra comprar augmentin 625 mg davkovanie cialis buy coventry fable acheter alliance 250 mg of phenergan nexium alternatives cheaper how to order rumalaya buy buspar visa can i get zyban india propecia generic brand cialis medicine online lov cost provera lexapro buy cheap cialis 5 mg torrino buying aricept doxycycline 100mg depression buy furosemide for dogs downside 10 mg prednisone viagra 0.25 mg alegro buy prednisone 5 mg online l-tryptophan cheap buy zyloprim paypal accepted obat celebrex 400mg parietal lobe function speech atacand medication assistance viagra uk 500mg quiero comprar avalide arimidex on cycle dose dipyridamole lawsuit canada tadapox tablets for sale viagra 100mg costco buy viagra singles what are bupropion pills where to buy cabgolin in canada safely what kind of drug is parlodel long term use of nexium side effects price of lipitor 10mg benzac tablets uses clomid kaufen online doxycycline 500mg use lopressor where can i buy it xenical 120mg reviews cheapest levitra generic celebrex 100 mg precio cialis 20 mg india differin prescriptions zovirax 800 mg tablet zoloft shopping on line diflucan kapsule 150 mg what is the correct dosage of elimite synthroid backorder doxycycline generic names viagra sale uk cheap buy atorlip-20 online india valtrex versus generic fluconazole 50 mg and alcohol buy prednisone cat generic diovan cost doxycycline 500mg dogs what does hoodia do alli pill cost rhinathiol syrup for babies order accutane online forum 80 mg prozac wellbutrin suhagra now retin a cream online pharmacy chlamydia in men rash prednisone 10mg dosage viagra 2,5 mg pfizer list of pharmacy stores in uk omeprazole side effects in women buy caverta mg buy lynoral inhaler canada network pharmacy express scripts lexapro generic images cmsviaga.com cialis dialy 2.5mg hydrochlorothiazide pills look like elocon ointment 0.1 side effects terramycin side effects uk 40 mg levitra price zyban barato viagra c200 online relafen suppositories buy 20 mg of propranolol cheap cialis perfectpharmacyrx order zoloft 100mg augmentin 1000 mg kullananlar what does zanaflex show up as on a drug screen clonidine tablets uses cost comparison cod buy stromectol lexapro generic buy buy strattera atomoxetine levaquin next day shipping pravachol and alcohol use cialis online overnight amoxil online prescription prescription abilify canada erythromycin online in uk doxycycline online us buy strattera pharmacy purchase levitra professional viagra online billigst buy roaccutane without a credit card cialis online 36 hour elimite pharmacy mail order cialis online lloyds lasix suppositories buy cialis generic fda augmentin 625 mg 14 tablet
Home Maury Brown Precedent-Setting Deal With Florida Marlins Over Revenue-Sharing Has Broad Implications

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 819 guests online

Atom RSS

Precedent-Setting Deal With Florida Marlins Over Revenue-Sharing Has Broad Implications PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 34
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 12 January 2010 22:05

Florida MarlinsFor years now, there have been questions surrounding whether MLB’s collectively bargained revenue-sharing policy has had a loophole in it as wide as centerfield at Minute Maid Park. The loophole in question is based upon Article XXIV(B)(5)(a) of the current Basic Agreement (see the latest Basic Agreement) . That section reads, in part:

A principal objective of the Revenue Sharing Plan is to promote the growth of the Game and the industry on an individual Club and on an aggregate basis. Accordingly, each Club shall use its revenue sharing receipts (from the Base Plan, the Central Fund Component and the Commissioner’s Discretionary Fund) in an effort to improve its performance on the field.

It is the end of this provision that has been where questions as to whether some clubs are not taking revenue-sharing dollars and using them as the CBA specifies.

Additionally, XXIV(B)(5)(b) reads:

The Clubs and the Association recognize that the participation of two Clubs is necessary for the production of the on-field competition that the Clubs sell to the public.

While the league does not release the figures, owners of clubs such as the Marlins, Pirates, and Royals have reportedly received revenue-sharing figures that surpass their Major League payroll levels, and thus the question is asked, “Where is the money going?”

The answer has been, “To improving performance on the field,” but, according to these clubs, through player development, not within the spirit of the provision which, to the MLBPA has been, “major league player payroll.”

Each year, the union for the players has said that they are monitoring these clubs that seemed to be skirling precariously close to what might be construed as pocketing revenue-sharing funds, and each year, the league has said that the MLBPA has every right to act on anything that seems out of line with the provision. That’s because the union can request receipts from the Administrator of the program, and file a grievance if they feel the numbers don’t jive with what the revenue-sharing program outlines in Article XXIV(B)(5)(a) above. And, each year, the MLBPA has not filed such a grievance,

And while the MLBPA did not file a grievance today over the revenue-sharing provision, they came about as close as they have, yet. In a joint statement from MLB, the MLBPA, and the Florida Marlins, the following was announced:

In recent years, the Union has had concerns that certain Clubs have not lived up to this requirement, and has consulted regularly with the Commissioner’s Office about those concerns. The Florida Marlins are one of a number of Clubs that have been discussed.

Adding to the statement, MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner added:

“In response to our concerns that revenue sharing proceeds have not been used as required, the Marlins have assured the Union and the Commissioner’s Office that they plan to use such proceeds to increase player payroll annually as they move toward the opening of their new ballpark. Today’s agreement, which covers the period 2010 through 2012, calls for ongoing communication among the Marlins, the Commissioner’s Office and the Union as the Marlins proceed with that plan.”

After extensive discussions, the three parties are pleased to announce that they have reached an agreement regarding the Florida Marlins’ continued compliance with Article XXIV(B)(5)(a) of the Basic Agreement.

Beyond the Marlins: Timing; the Pirates, Royals, Rays, and Others; And Labor Negotiations

Today’s news was seen as a public flogging of the Marlins. The MLBPA clearly had information that would have allowed them to file a grievance that, it appears, they would have won. Otherwise, why would MLB and the Marlins buckle?

But, what should be looked at closely are a number of pieces in a far broader context:

Sending A Message to Others - While the MLBPA has the right to continue to look closely at the manner in which revenue-sharing is spent, don’t expect them to immediately chase after the Pirates or the Royals, or the Rays... any other clubs that could be on their radar at any given time. That’s because the precedent-setting agreement that singles out the Marlins should echo in those other markets. The MLBPA has been talking of doing something, and now they have. The message is clear: we’re more than watching, we’re willing to act. Beware.

Going after the Marlins Was Also About “When” – Go back and read what Michael Weiner said. “[The Marlins] plan to use such proceeds to increase player payroll annually as they move toward the opening of their new ballpark.” The opening of the new ballpark by the Marlins in 2012 gives them new revenues from which to work from, so in some senses, while slapping them on the wrist, the MLBPA simply asked that they spend above what they have been doing while playing in the same home of the Miami Dolphins. That deal has the Marlins not collecting all revenue sources that they would otherwise be doing in their own ballpark. By reaching the deal, the Marlins won’t scream as loud as they would have if they weren’t going into their own stadium. The MLBPA surely took this into account.

Going after the Marlins Was Also About “When” (the Labor Side) – The timing of Marlins agreement also has a great deal to do with upcoming labor negotiations. With the current Basic Agreement expiring in 2011, the MLBPA had to pick their spot to move on the Marlins. Doing so much later would have been seen as a negotiating tactic for the upcoming rounds of collective bargaining.

Reaching An Agreement Is a Good Sign (Labor Peace) – It’s very early on, but by the MLBPA and MLB willing to strong-arm the Marlins, the signs point to calm waters on the labor front. If MLB (with the Marlins pushing) had wanted to make a labor statement, they could have dug their heels in, and told the MLBPA, “Go file your grievance.” They didn’t, which shows that the relationship between MLB and the MLBPA continues to move forward past the labor strife that occurred prior to the 2002 CBA.

An Agreement Allows the Marlins to Save Face (sort of) - Make no mistake, Jeffery Loria and the Marlins can’t be happy campers today. It appears they got caught with their hands in the cookie jar, and the MLBPA finally decided to reach out and smack it. But, with the parties agreeing to a “self-policing” deal, the Marlins get to publically stick to their guns and say they did nothing wrong. As Marlins President David Samson said in the statement, “Throughout the discussions, the Marlins maintained that there had been no violation of the Basic Agreement at any time.” As mentioned, if the league was willing to go down the road of a forced agreement with the Marlins, then “maintaining innocence” doesn’t mean that the MLBPA didn’t find money hidden under a rock. Ultimately, by not losing in a grievance hearing, Commissioner Selig isn’t put in the uncomfortable position of having to deal with this nasty little section of the CBA, as it pertains to revenue-sharing violations: Consistent with his authority under the Major League Constitution, the Commissioner may impose penalties on any Club that violates this obligation

Could the Marlins Be a Scapegoat? – More than one today has asked, “Do you think the Marlins were targeted because the league wasn’t going to go toe-to-toe with Pirates president Frank Coonelly?” Maybe. As mentioned, there is the timing of the new Marlins stadium coming online, the exceptionally low levels of player payroll in the past, and… well, more than a few in the industry have said that they don’t really rate Loria very highly; he’s not well liked. Prior to working for the Pirates, Coonelly was Senior Vice President and General Counsel of Labor in the Office of the Commissioner of Baseball where he negotiated and administered collective bargaining agreements with the MLBPA. As reported earlier (see The Pirates: Improving the Team, or Just Their Bottom Line?), one might look at the Pirates as being a potentially more egregious violator of the revenue-sharing clause that the Marlins are being held to. The Marlins low player payroll, the timing of the new stadium, and yes… the MLBPA seeing something in the Marlins’ revenue-sharing report that every team is required to file that requests revenue-sharing, stands out. Even so, if there would have been a slight change in circumstances, it could have been the Pirates, rather than the Marlins, who got their wrists slapped on Tuesday.

Chalk Up a Big Win for Michael Weiner – The MLBPA has to feel good, not only because they got the Marlins to increase player payroll, but because it’s the first labor victory for Michael Weiner after being approved as the new Exec. Director in December. Now, will MLB use the agreement as a bargaining chip in the future…?

How Much Will the Marlins Raise Payroll? – This is the biggest question tied to Tuesday’s announcement. There’s little knowing how much using “such proceeds to increase player payroll annually as they move toward the opening of their new ballpark” is. The end of year payroll for the Marlins in 2009 was $37,532,482. The league has guarded revenue-sharing figures closely in recent years. But, here’s what is known… Based upon revenue-sharing figures that were published in 2002-’03, as well as 2005, there is the following. The difference figure shows how much the Marlins needed to cover for a given year before one game is played that garnered any local revenues (includes gate, local/regional television deals, concessions, etc). As displayed, the player payroll figures were higher then than last season, and most assuredly, revenue-sharing for the Marlins is higher. The combination is, at least in large part, the reason the MLBPA acted on the club.

Florida Marlins Rev-Sharing - Payroll

Year

Rev-Sharing

EOY Payroll

Diff

2002

$20,946,573

$40,822,536

$19,875,963

2003

$21,030,000

$63,281,152

$42,251,152

2005

$31,000,000

$56,273,212

$25,273,212

 

See complete revenue-sharing figures for all 30 clubs for 2002-’03 and 2005


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?