grifulvin v online bestellen deutschland rogaine 5 medikamente online eulexin online apotheke wien furosemide online bestellen deutschland metoclopramide generika preisvergleich fucidin pille online zoloft price uk feldene pille rabatt vantin balma finasterid generika erfahrungen motilium online bestellen günstig sarafem preis adalat generika liste neurontin online bestellen generic nizoral online apotheke yokebe elavil bestellen online lariam durchschnittliche kosten malariaprophylaxe hydrea generika bupropion sr rezeptfrei quitting smoking alavert verkauf kaufen cipro venedig rabatt shallaki tablets rabatt pamelor reviews dutas generika preisvergleich voltaren rabatt online köpa keppra preis filmtabletten urispas bestellen online kosten indocin xenical generika indien test tulsi rabatt online buy forzest online bestellen calcium carbonate verkauf ld50 avana online apotheke cymbalta preisvergleich orlistat online apotheke in uk dramamine durchschnittliche kosten precose generika hersteller actos online apotheke ejercicios baclofen ähnliche medikamente bupropion sr medikamente tablets bactroban online apotheke cream imitrex online apotheke order silvitra rezeptfrei länder fertomid online bestellen online doxycycline rezeptfrei wo ginseng preisvergleich yokebe astelin online bestellen vergleich grifulvin v medikamente information plavix 75 preisvergleich xeloda generika kaufen ciprofloxacin pille evaluna viagra pillen bij vrouwen rabatt zetia coupon eldepryl durchschnittliche kosten qm dapoxetine online bestellen xxl rabatt etodolac zyprexa generika erfahrungen zyban pillen astelin online bestellen test atrovent rezeptfrei wien confido verkauf coreg online apotheke paxil online apotheke canada big appeal generika indien xbox arimidex kaufen online kosten epivir hbv cost isoptin kosten xeloda generika erfahrungen doxycyclin und pille schwanger lady era preis nova furosemide bestellen mg zebeta rezeptfrei apotheke allegra online bestellen buy rabatt cialis online periactin rabatt online prescription yougara bestellen online xenical kaufen apotheke nexium generika indien sinemet rabatt online free rabatt nasonex tadalis generika schweiz premarin generika kaufen tinidazole online bestellen günstig nitrofurantoin pille online preis viagra schweiz kaufen ditropan online billig rogaine 5 effects norvasc 5mg generika nizagara rezeptfrei viagra rabatt hyzaar reviews calcium carbonate preis gras bupropion sr pille tablets calcium carbonate preis wikipedia olanzapine rabatt online alesse generika rezeptfrei precose rezeptfrei viagra bactrim medikamente liste bupropion sr rezeptfrei kaufen voltaren schmerzgel kaufen kosten vytorin lamictal rezeptfrei bestellen bactrim generika indien youtube urispas generika kaufen celebrex rezeptfrei holland penegra rabatt online youtube caverta online apotheke ranbaxy benfotiamine bestellen online altace durchschnittliche kosten führerschein billig tetracycline sonne diltiazem rabatt online buy albenza preis ginseng rabatt online order ashwagandha generika preisvergleich himcolin generika zoll rabatt doxazosin mesylate kosten lasix nebenwirkungen flexisyn rabatt online shop bupropion sr bestellen for smoking cessation bactroban rezeptfrei schweiz npxl generika indien ashwagandha generika schweiz allegra rabatt online store keppra pille antibabypille reglan rezeptfrei billig celebrex kaufen colospa online bestellen xenos eurax pille betapace generika coumadin rabatt online prescription rabatt wellbutrin vs beconase aq medikamente term use unisom preis qm fml forte pille fml aldara rezeptfrei kaufen zoloft rabatt online uk cephalexin verkauf bupropion sr verkauf difference allegra online apotheke buy generic lipothin online bestellen online calcium carbonate preis structure fertomid online bestellen günstig metformin rabatt online usa serevent generika indien youtube kaufen gyne lotrimin vs monistat bactroban rezeptfrei usa glucovance rezeptfrei niederlande zocor online bestellen deutschland chloramphenicol preis orlistat generika hersteller aceon online apotheke schweiz kaufen yasmin günstig aldactone online bestellen nederland calcium carbonate preis in pregnancy endep online apotheke zürich imuran online bestellen ikea zestoretic generika apotheke myambutol online bestellen brahmi rezeptfrei frankreich aceton kaufen nägel mycelex-g online bestellen vergleich rabatt accutane erfahrung avalide rezeptfrei günstig lasix online apotheke niederlande haldol online bestellen test glycomet online apotheke testsieger kosten tegretol er kaufen billig silagra cipla allegra rabatt online learning kosten saw palmetto kaufen billig paxil haldol online bestellen xxl billig rogaine 5 nebenwirkungen depakote rezeptfrei bestellen protonix generika schweiz colospa rezeptfrei deutschland lithium preischart dulcolax online apotheke tropfen orlistat online apotheke order cafergot rabatt online suppository kaufen billig cipro venedig protonix preis qm motilium online apotheke zealand keftab generika tabelle paroxetine rezeptfrei wien depakote rezeptfrei schweiz paxil online apotheke for sale propecia andere medikamente zofran tabletten preis aciclovir kaufen vasotec generika deutschland azulfidine rezeptfrei holland kamagra tabletten erfahrung aldara online bestellen europe billig rogaine 5 amazon clomid online bestellen usa bupropion medikamente kosten antabuse billig lady era vergine kaufen billig zovirax online zyprexa rezeptfrei usa lasix rabatt online mg anafranil rabatt online apotheke femara generika günstig mobic rabatt online youtube saw palmetto generika günstig clarina online bestellen damenmode charboleps online bestellen xenos kosten liv 52 himalaya nebenwirkungen flagyl er verkauf tablets bettina was kosten die kondome charboleps online bestellen xxl preis voltaren dolo emulgel wohnung kaufen detroit vytorin preisvergleich yokebe kann man cialis holland rezeptfrei kaufen plendil rezeptfrei wien ashwagandha generika zulassung bupropion sr bestellen zyban kaufen minocin recept grifulvin v medikamente tablet augmentin online apotheke comanda kaufen billig seroquel indikation estrace rabatt online pills rogaine 5 medikamente foam minoxidil malegra online apotheke billig england vorwahl viagra rezeptfrei china kaufen billig zyprexa medikament dutas pille bactrim online bestellen ds buy rabatt toradol dosing periactin rezeptfrei insektenstich kosten saw palmetto libido precose durchschnittliche kosten billig trandate clindamycin generika deutschland diltiazem online bestellen vergleich furosemide rezeptfrei usa rabatt trileptal dosage rabatt hyzaar lek fml forte pille side effects bupropion preisvergleich zyban lukol generika indien kaufen billig viagra auf rechnung zanaflex preis kaufen zyrtec kaufen actos zulassung arava online kaufen myambutol online apotheke holland kaufen billig forzest ranbaxy generika zu yasmin zithromax online apotheke azithromycin rabatt elavil overdose augmentin rezeptfrei schweiz nasonex nasenspray rezeptfrei pletal generika hersteller bupropion sr bestellen nausea glucovance rezeptfrei bestellen viagra rezeptfrei berlin promethazine durchschnittliche kosten implantat combivent rabatt online h&m kamagra online bestellen the uk proscar pille vergessen erexor online apotheke juvalis bupropion sr bestellen by mylan slimex bestellen flexisyn generika günstig singulair medikament preis bupropion sr rezeptfrei anxiety kaufen billig endep parfüm zyprexa rabatt online comprar lady era preis jane xalatan 0 005 preis kaufen bupropion sr to take bactroban salbe kaufen beconase aq medikamente dose hytrin rezeptfrei viagra bupropion sr bestellen ingredients preis alli kapseln ashwagandha generika hersteller malegra online bestellen fxt glucovance online apotheke niederlande rogaine 5 generika minoxidil reviews gyne lotrimin price erfahrung kamagra online apotheke rabatt crestor generic fincar pille vergessen npxl rabatt online berechnen pariet generika indien china diclofenac online apotheke wien rogaine 5 preisvergleich weeks dramamine generika indien youtube kamagra online kaufen ohne rezept chloromycetin rezeptfrei insektenstich alesse pill price rabatt zanaflex dosage rabatt zovirax ointment terramycin rezeptfrei niederlande prograf verkauf minocin generika suche kosten rogaine 5 using zyban preise apotheke lozol generika indien reisen viagra rezeptfrei spanien ashwagandha online apotheke capsules zanaflex price us atarax online bestellen test danazol medikamente synthroid rezeptfrei schweiz zyvox rezeptfrei bestellen ciprofloxacin preis ratiopharm suhagra tablet price clarinex preis qm tofranil generika deutschland kaufen fml forte vs lotemax bupron sr online apotheke wien slim tea online bestellen xbox 360 billig rogaine 5 does it work kosten atorlip 5 side effects micardis generika tabelle micardis generika indien mg beconase aq verkauf does bupropion rezeptfrei günstig billig rogaine 5 dosage yasmin online apotheke movie billig england reisen beconase aqueous preisvergleich ears pamelor pille preis kytril online bestellen vergleich levitra generika günstig pixel verkaufen kosten singulair nebenwirkungen levitra kaufen billig strattera rabatt online europe phenergan rezeptfrei wo allegra preis qm rabatt nizagara pills uroxatral durchschnittliche kosten chloroquine malaria price omnicef pille vergessen top avana pille preis colospa online bestellen medikament aldara nebenwirkungen lynoral generika zulassung allopurinol 100 preisvergleich xalatan online bestellen oogdruppels ditropan generika lipitor price mercury drug cholestoplex online bestellen nederland zofran rezeptfrei insektenstich cyklokapron rabatt online zestoretic generika viagra kaufen billig xalatan cymbalta verkaufen codein kaufen rogaine 5 preisvergleich anwendung hydrochlorothiazide online apotheke juvalis viagra pille zijn viagrapillen gevaarlijk amitriptyline durchschnittliche kosten lebensmittel ashwagandha generika viagra femara online bestellen xenos arimidex generika günstig exelon generika zoll estrace rabatt online price vytorin rabatt online shop astelin online apotheke günstig mycelex-g rabatt online free kamagra online bestellen günstig betapace rezeptfrei kaufen glycomet rabatt online free elavil online bestellen ikea kaufen albendazole fosamax rabatt online beipackzettel aristocort generika schweiz rabatt nizagara tablets nizoral online apotheke pills kaufen erexin-v orlistat kopen belgie lasix rabatt online h&m azulfidine rezeptfrei kaufen billig liv 52 gdje kupiti dulcolax medikamente mestinon rezeptfrei holland bupropion sr preis mg meclizine rabatt online omnicef pille provera rabatt online comtrade forzest generika zoll cytotec generika zithromax online apotheke legit requip online apotheke schweiz silvitra rezeptfrei italien rabatt big appeal denied ethionamide generika erfahrungen requip pille danach voltaren preis österreich pletal online bestellen order endep online apotheke paypal dulcolax online apotheke ireland skelaxin generika indien china billig lady era gaga es hermafrodita imdur medikamente aciclovir preis tabletten kaufen billig cytotec geburt slim tea preisvergleich germany rabatt wellbutrin alkohol calcium carbonate verkauf xylitol zoloft preis mg aricept verkauf vasotec generika suche bupropion sr preis doses fluoxetine online apotheke kaufen zyprexa rabatt online youtube beconase aq verkauf flonase top avana generika indien bupropion sr medikamente by mylan unisom generika zoll gyne-lotrimin generika suche rabatt fucidin hund grifulvin v bestellen zoloft rabatt online purchase bupropion sr bestellen by actavis slimming tea preisvergleich japanese lotrisone generika preisvergleich kosten lithium batterie naprosyn generika kaufen vasotec generika rezeptfrei kaufen crestor kaufen fertomid styplon durchschnittliche kosten führerschein viramune verkauf zyban rezeptfrei usa dapoxetine online bestellen sale tamoxifen generika indien boutique aspirin kaufen unter 18 prograf online apotheke preisvergleich renagel online apotheke deutschland dapoxetine preisvergleich rabatt cialis bestellen vytorin rabatt online order orlistat online apotheke tablets lamisil pills cost lithium medikament kaufen diclofenac online apotheke ratiopharm liv 52 rabatt online ds buy aygestin online bestellen günstig kaufen billig proscar türkei combivent rabatt online inhalers xenical online bestellen schweiz altace rezeptfrei test aciclovir durchschnittliche kosten führerschein ginseng kosten clomid online bestellen got pregnant rabatt crestor kaufen levothroid preis qm reglan rezeptfrei online kosten atorlip 20 mg side effects kaufen flagyl er tablets cafergot zäpfchen kaufen kosten saw palmetto kaufen septilin generika indien china erexor rezeptfrei insektenstich kaufen billig aspirin complex zanaflex rezeptfrei niederlande kosten arcoxia indikation diovan online apotheke bestellen vasodilan verkauf ciplox preis n1 kaufen flagyl er generic ender;s game kosten kosten arcoxia ibuprofen alli bestellen schweiz vermox forte kaufen eldepryl online bestellen xxl premarin online apotheke wien calcium carbonate preis organic or inorganic pletal generika günstig furosemide online bestellen mims lamisil once nagelpilz preis silvitra pille danach reminyl durchschnittliche kosten führerschein saw palmetto durchschnittliche kosten führerschein paxil rezeptfrei grifulvin v bestellen oral norvasc online apotheke testsieger rogaine 5 generika yan etkileri kosten erexin v mega tulsi online bestellen booking calcium carbonate medikamente structure nizagara online bestellen prevacid rezeptfrei wo mobic generika indien reisen aciclovir online bestellen xenos peni large verkauf arimidex generika deutschland calcium carbonate verkauf bone graft valentin online bestellen anne et ciplox rezeptfrei italien pilex generika erfahrungen bupron sr pille mg side effects
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB's Anti-Trust Exemption and Franchise Relocation

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 976 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB's Anti-Trust Exemption and Franchise Relocation PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 7
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 04 January 2010 00:40

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

2010 will probably be the pivotal year in determining whether the Oakland A’s relocate to San Jose. In March of last year, Commissioner Selig announced the formation of a three member committee which has been studying the options available to the A’s in their quest for a new baseball stadiium in northern California. The committee’s recommendations should be made public early this year. The latter part of 2009 saw an escalation in the rhetoric amongst the potentially affected parties in Oakland, San Francisco and San Jose over the fate of the A’s. In November LWIB reported on the stepped up media campaign of A’s owners John Fisher and Lewis Wolff to bring local attention to their courtship of San Jose. Grassroots groups either advocating for, or opposing, a move of the A’s to San Jose ramped up their campaigns as the year progressed (the Giants are the driving force behind one of the groups). Likewise, public officials in all three cities (and at the state level) raised their public profiles on the issue late in 2009 (amongst them, mayors Dellums (Oakland) and Reed (San Jose) plus SF City Attorney Dennis Herrera and CA Senator Barbara Boxer). As is always the case when franchise relocation in MLB is discussed, baseball’s antitrust exemption is an important part of the debate. Can the Giants prevent the A’s from moving into “their” territory (as defined by MLB)? Do the A’s need the “permission” of MLB to relocate? Does anybody know for certain?

LWIB Evan Weiner wrote for examiner.com:

To all those prognosticators, and you know who you are, who are trying to predict the top business sports stories of 2010, you have missed what is going to be the biggest fight. Oakland Athletics owner Lewis Wolff and the city of San Jose against the San Francisco Giants, the San Jose Giants, the city of San Francisco and Major League Baseball and the battle will center on the 1922 United States Supreme Court decision that gave the National League and the American League of baseball an antitrust exemption.

Wolff, whose lease with the Oakland Coliseum ends in 2013, would like to locate his baseball business in San Jose. Because of the 1922 Supreme Court decision that baseball was a game not a business, he has many hurdles to climb in his quest, hurdles that would not be there without the SCOTUS ruling.

AND

The stage is being set right now and a fierce territorial battle may shape the future of baseball and determine whether or not San Jose can become the home of Lewis Wolff’s baseball team. Wolff has to decide whether he really wants to fight this war and the implications may be felt far beyond the Bay Area.

AND

This could be a battle that extends to Congress but would the former San Francisco Mayor, Senator Diane Feinstein along with her colleague Barbara Boxer and the House Speaker, Nancy Pelosi of San Francisco want to get involved in the issue? Congress squawks about antitrust issues in sports but does nothing to correct inequities.

Last month, aforementioned SF City Attorney Dennis Herrera made public his threats to sue MLB should they allow the A’s to move to San Jose. The city of SF argues that the revenues they receive from the Giants would be threatened by the A’s move. The revenues received from the Giants are used to pay down debt on city issued bonds which financed infrastructure improvements around AT&T Park. Most pundits saw Mr. Herrera’s letter to MLB as nothing but sabre rattling given that MLB’s antitrust exemption allows them to control the location of “their” franchises. Last month, Nathaniel Grow wrote about Mr. Herrera’s threats at the Sports Law Blog. Mr. Grow points out that should the city of SF attempt to force MLB to enforce their territorial rights it would be a new twist on previous legal challenges.

On first impression, the threatened suit by the city of San Francisco seems problematic on several fronts. First, the city would have to convince a court that its interest in protecting its tax revenues from the Giants gives it sufficient standing to legally challenge MLB's approval of the relocation of another franchise into the Giants' assigned territory.

However, even if San Francisco is able to establish standing, such a suit would also place the city in the awkward position of effectively asking a court to enforce MLB's anticompetitive territory allocation system. While professional baseball's practice of granting franchises exclusive rights to certain geographic territories has previously been challenged by those seeking to enter a restricted market -- suits which have historically been dismissed pursuant to MLB's antitrust exemption (see, e.g., New Orleans Pelicans Baseball, Inc. v. National Association of Professional Baseball Leagues, Inc., Case No. 93-253, 1994 WL 631144 (E.D.La. March 1, 1994)) -- a suit by San Francisco would mark the first time that MLB has faced a lawsuit seeking to require the league to enforce this restriction. The optics of such a suit, being filed by a municipality no less, would be less than ideal. I suspect most courts would be uncomfortable issuing an order requiring baseball to enforce its territory restriction, especially in a case where MLB had already decided to set aside its long-standing anticompetitive policy.

Eighty seven years after the “federal baseball” decision by The Supreme Court created baseball’s antitrust exemption, do we know conclusively that it allows MLB to dictate franchise location? In November of last year, the aforementioned Nathaniel Grow published, Defining the 'Business of Baseball' - A Proposed Framework for Determining the Scope of Professional Baseball's Antitrust Exemption (read here in PDF).

No doubt due to the peculiarity of the exemption, as well as baseball’s standing as the “national pastime,” baseball’s antitrust exemption has generated substantial consideration over the years from both courts and commentators. Despite this voluminous analysis, no consensus has been reached regarding the extent to which baseball’s operations are protected under the antitrust exemption. The Supreme Court itself has never specifically addressed the scope of the baseball exemption, but instead has only generally held that the “business of baseball” is exempt from antitrust law. Based on this language, some lower courts have broadly interpreted the Supreme Court’s precedent as providing an exemption for the entire “business of baseball.” Meanwhile, other courts have concluded that the exemption is more limited, with some courts and commentators arguing that the exemption should be restricted solely to the facts of the Supreme Court’s most recent affirmance in Flood v. Kuhn.

Mr. Grow is not alone in his opinion that baseball’s ability to control franchise relocation as a result of it’s antitrust exemption is uncertain. Roger Noll, professor of economics emeritus at Stanford University told the Biz of Baseball in November, “The status of franchise location antitrust in MLB is uncertain – there has never been a case that was litigated to completion.” In his 2003 book, May the Best Team Win Baseball Economics and Public Policy, economist Andrew Zimbalist wrote that it is unclear if baseball’s antitrust exemption extends to control of franchise relocation. However, Mr. Zimbalist notes that MLB perhaps can control franchise relocation under a rule-of-reason defense. On Oakland Raiders owner Al Davis’s successful legal battle with the NFL over relocating his franchise to Los Angeles in the 1980’s Mr. Zimbalist wrote;

The courts did not rule that a sporting league could not exercise some controls over a team’s location; rather, they made it clear that such controls, when properly exercised , fall under a rule-of-reason defense. That is, there are good reasons why a league would want its teams to be both geographically stable and geographically dispersed. These reasons must be considered and offset against the negatives connected to prohibiting an owner from moving his or her team. The negatives include a reduction in an owner’s rights of free trade and the possible retention of a team in a city with less interest in the sport than a prospective host city.

AND

…..MLB’s presumed exemption may shield it from owner antitrust challenges and make it more difficult for teams to move. It should be noted, however, that where such moves are not in the public interest, team relocations could be prevented under a rule-of-reason defense even without an exemption.

2010 will tell us much, or all, about the eventual fate of the A’s franchise. Either San Jose or Oakland will make the most enticing offer to the A‘s owners. Should it be the former, the Giants will be “indemnified” for their territorial rights. But eventually, won’t somebody or some city challenge MLB over relocation and clarify exactly what the “exemption” really means?


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

Follow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?