shadow credit limit definition hack valid credit card information credit card charges to retailers southwest airlines rapid rewards credit card chase review horizon gold credit card customer service pnc points visa credit card rewards paypal not accepting indian credit cards transfer balance credit cards for average credit citi aadvantage credit card review president choice credit card lost discovery credit card statement sbi credit card offers on samsung mobiles reloadable prepaid credit cards india getting a credit card machine for small business best student credit cards travel can credit card companies garnish your wages in california small business options for accepting credit card payments pay hdfc credit card online payment major credit cards companies hsbc credit card offers uae paypal credit card fees for merchants square credit card fees review gold card balance how to pay off credit card debt canada fast cash loans uk td visa debit card activation capital one online credit card application capital city bank credit card online payments standard uk credit card size walmart credit card a pre approved credit card application philippines best credit card for bad credit unsecured credit card numbers list with csc barclays us airways mastercard apply chase secured credit card best cashback credit card offers online credit card payment system best 0 intro apr credit cards online payday loan direct lenders reviews credit card fraud penalties utah sbi credit card application status customer care number weekly credit card payment calculator can applying for credit cards hurt my credit score care credit application virtual credit cards using paypal virgin 0 credit card balance transfers credit card settlement india bp gas credit card phone number credit card student loan debt credit card settlement process how to activate cibc visa debit card hdfc credit card rewards catalogue 2013 virgin credit card payment best buy household bank credit card login pay my orchard bank credit card bill online usaa credit card benefits chase international travel credit card student loan debt exceeds credit card debt in usa walmart credit card payment login page mastercard credit cards for fair credit best cash back rewards credit cards 2011 visa credit card issuers in canada black card magazine us best secured credit card usaa variable apr credit card calculator cibc prepaid credit card canada easy payday advance online best canadian cash back credit card 2013 easy credit card approval for bad credit bad credit card offers unsecured hsbc online credit card payment malaysia credit card review 2012 what;s the best credit card company cara membuat virtual credit card indonesia prepaid visa debit cards canada bank of america student credit card application how to apply credit card online in hdfc visa credit american express compare credit cards prepaid credit card bank transfer jetstar mastercard credit card login list of all chase credit cards instant payday loans bad credit emirates air miles credit card uk free visa credit card number and expiration date 2013 wells fargo health advantage credit card payment i want a credit card travel rewards credit card for average credit pay lane bryant credit card online open sky secured visa card contact best reward credit card canada 2011 chase secured credit card application how can i get a credit card with bad credit history no fax payday loans online instant approval check walmart credit card application status standard chartered credit card india login 0 interest credit cards balance transfers 24 months best business credit card offers 2013 fake visa card numbers canada small business credit card processing reviews hdfc master credit card reward points axis bank credit cards offers does best buy accept visa debit cards online fnb gold credit card call centre compare credit cards travel insurance best cash back reward credit cards 2012 report credit card fraud to credit bureau credit cards instant approval and use going over credit limit free rewards cards for stores list payday loans bad credit prepaid card chase business credit cards online low interest rate credit cards fixed apr apply for ge money bank credit cards mbna virgin credit card login vanilla mastercard balance cash back offers on hdfc credit cards student visa credit card southwest credit card free flight after first purchase how to get bpi credit card cash advance pin 0 percent balance transfer offers credit cards credit card debt settlement canada bmo mastercard contact visa debit card credit history bad credit car leasing toronto check application status for walmart credit card bad credit small business loans payday loans for bad credit instant cash direct lender payday loans for bad credit td debit visa cards us airways credit card 40000 miles no annual fee td visa card registry renewal best low interest rate credit card canada credit card machine rental costs mastercard gift card pin best way to build credit with first credit card best credit cards rewards program chase amazon visa rewards card credit card charges for paying holidays paypal credit card number generator hdfc online credit card payment billdesk credit card rewards taxable income cash back credit card malaysia lowest credit card rate in usa what credit card has the lowest interest rate in the philippines intuit credit card reader android canada virgin credit card free wine deal where do you get prepaid credit cards in canada apply for credit union credit cards store credit cards for bad credit canada how do i set up a credit card merchant account icici credit card charges gift visa card canada webster first usa credit card redeeming hdfc credit cards reward points can you get a joint secured credit card low interest credit cards canada student small business credit card reviews best credit cards with no annual fee for fair credit chase online visa card credit card online validator v2.11 what are the best credit cards to earn points wells fargo credit card cash advance fees best air miles rewards credit card canada best cashback credit cards october 2011 post office credit card customer reviews how to pay off credit card debt on a budget credit cards and cash back prepaid virtual credit card us top 10 credit cards 2012 uk credit card limits are included in m1 or m2 credit card cashback taxable income check in cash advance payday loan center best types of credit cards to get 0 balance transfer and purchases credit cards no credit loans fast american express credit card customer service number uk size of credit card business in india wireless credit card terminal reviews link southwest rapid rewards credit card which credit card has the best cash back program singapore online cash loans no credit check i need a unsecured credit card for bad credit credit card size emergency iphone charger best no annual fee no foreign transaction fee credit card whats a valid visa credit card number chase canada credit card mastercard college student credit cards credit card fraud punishment pennsylvania cheapest credit card processing uk capital one aspire world credit card black cardigan next new york and company credit card payment number prepaid travel credit cards best credit card for purchases pay my household credit card online apply for nationwide credit card online apply for barclays credit card us fake credit card numbers for itunes statute of limitations on credit card debt in india natwest black credit card rewards hsbc black credit card uk fixed rate credit card definition citibank corporate credit card online payment bank of ireland lost visa debit card do any credit cards offer free travel insurance kickstarter iphone credit card charger orchard credit card contact number mba credit card processing visa card canada post bank of america world mastercard credit card with worldpoints rewards and paypass compare credit cards with travel rewards nationwide credit card charges overseas online loans uk bad credit mbna 0 interest credit card canada jp morgan chase credit card fraud 0 financing credit card offers does cibc have prepaid credit cards credit card balance transfer offers no fee hdfc credit card settlement office city bank credit card application virgin credit card contact details first premier credit card pay by phone credit card offers for bad credit instant approval credit card fraud for dummies full anz debit visa card credit card payments over the phone low interest credit cards canada visa apply online for a credit card in south africa credit card loan calculator payments lowest interest credit card in canada jp morgan chase business credit card barclay apple card credit score credit card interest rates calculator monthly mobile credit card processing iphone paypal walmart prepaid debit visa card cheap payday loans uk online credit card consolidation loans united chase visa credit card phone number travel reward credit cards 2012 credit card interest rate per month calculator best secured credit card uk credit card processing what to look out for when applying for a credit card need to apply for walmart credit card money clip credit card business card holder cancel virgin credit card online best credit card interest rates australia random credit card number yahoo generate valid credit card number help with credit card debt from the federal government credit cards for bad credit history in ireland $5000 unsecured bad credit loan credit card cash advance limit how to view my hdfc credit card statement best credit card apply for no credit check credit cards united credit card premier status fast cash payday loans canada capital 1 credit card payment address apply for a 76 gas credit card best credit card debt consolidation loan starbucks gold card benefits soy travel rewards credit card comparison corporate credit cards for business travel pay national city credit card icici credit card reward points mint hdfc credit cards offers in india best credit cards canada 2011 halifax credit card login online credit card search engine india top business credit cards uk icici credit card bill payment best no-fee credit card with rewards program travel rewards credit cards review best american express rewards cards free iphone applications without credit card corporate platinum credit card hdfc new credit card offers for bad credit guaranteed bad credit loan uk business credit card machines cost chase freedom credit card international fees best credit card offers $300 cash back how to pay advance income tax online in india can you use a prepaid credit card on paypal best cash rewards credit card for average credit blue sky credit card review canada where can i pay my orchard bank credit card ebay credit card payment processing absa gold credit card limit increase chase visa credit card logon tesco credit card ppi claims can you get business credit card bad credit irctc sbi credit card status hilton uk credit card free visa credit card numbers that work prepaid visa gift card td canada trust eligibility for sbi advantage credit card compare credit card processing canada bank of ireland visa credit card services i have no credit history and i need a credit card payday loan lenders only uk top credit card consolidation companies free online loan calculator key bank credit card processing standard chartered platinum credit card apply online how to get credit card in hdfc bank bad credit unsecured credit cards no deposit credit cards for college students under 18 best business credit cards rewards programs best way to get credit card with no credit does american express gold card build credit td canada trust visa debit verified by visa best rewards cards with no annual fee how to apply for a credit card with no credit bank of america no social security credit card walmart credit cards online account african bank online loan application best visa infinite card singapore online credit card payment gateway india can you use best buy gift cards to pay credit card guaranteed payday loan no credit check uk rbs credit cards online india central bank of india visa debit cards premier credit card for bad credit nordstrom visa credit card phone number online application for credit card hsbc best credit cards travel rewards 2013 standard chartered credit card bill payment india sainsburys credit card bank of scotland child care credit ba credit card payment charges hdfc credit card reward points catalogue 2013 citicard aadvantage credit card login same day cash loans to your door best reward credit cards for students bank of america amazon credit card terms and conditions capital one credit card reviews 2010 small business credit card machine portable apply for a credit card bank of scotland cash loan with bad credit online city bank credit card customer care number gujarat credit card emi calculator hdfc bank tj maxx credit card information stolen jobar security credit card wallet citibank business credit card online login secure credit card capital one park hyatt credit card authorization form chase 200 cash back credit card credit limits international what banks offer secured credit cards in canada best travel reward cards can you get a credit card the same day you apply can you use credit cards abroad ge capital credit card apply ?ă5000 loan with bad credit and no guarantor standard chartered credit card customer care number bangalore gsa government travel credit card how often can you apply for chase credit cards ipad credit card app canada how to pay hdfc credit card payment online from other bank apply for alaska airlines credit card canada united chase credit card cash advance united chase credit card business best credit card company for bad credit sbi credit card online payment link best cashback credit card canada 2012 wells fargo credit card transfer fee icici credit card payment using debit card icici credit card insurance benefits credit cards offers 0 balance transfers wonga cash loans uk how to check my citibank credit card reward points cash canada payday loans grande prairie credit card limit increase good or bad australia;s lowest rate credit card credit cards for newcomers to canada prepaid credit cards available at shoppers drug mart best credit card deals uk hdfc corporate credit card status credit card online application south africa capital one visa card application how to accept credit cards online small business credit card transfer offers australia what can i do about unauthorized credit card charges amex credit card merchant fees best cash back visa credit card how do i check my credit card history credit card logos intuit renew credit card bank of ireland does wi dmv accept credit cards get free credit card details jetstar credit card international transaction fees average first credit card limit hsbc credit card online payment options us bank credit card payment calculator check into cash payday loans online company won;t refund credit card fast online payday loans uk new york and company credit card phone number does chase offer a credit card for bad credit should you apply for credit cards online pay weekly doorstep loans low interest credit card balance transfer life how to do online credit card fraud top student credit cards canada random credit card number for itunes how to apply visa credit card in the philippines best business credit cards 2012 uk login into sears credit card what is the minimum payment on a virgin credit card best credit cards cash back rewards credit card transfer balance for bad credit online prepaid credit card number unsecured visa credit cards for poor credit mastercard prepaid credit cards ireland visa card generator with security code sign up for walmart credit card online amazon credit card review nerdwallet suze orman best secured credit card bad credit credit card instant approval applying for credit cards with no credit checks unsecured credit card applications online cibc petro canada credit card login dillards lost credit card phone number orchard bank credit card bad credit air canada credit card aeroplan compare credit cards with low interest rates apply for student credit card natwest best secured credit card in india best buy credit card application by phone online loan application sss apple credit card reader for ipad credit card holder leather payday loans cash advance no credit check credit card information free hacked android app for store reward cards chase cash advance credit card fees can a credit card company sue you in california billdesk hdfc credit card login best cashback credit cards for small business legit payday online loans black visa card requirements apply credit card poor credit history barclays credit card apple visa credit card information system how to get credit card details toys r us store credit card uk hdfc bank credit card login page best no fee credit card canada 2013 credit card apps credit card machines for small business best rates bank of america merchant services credit card machines get pre-approved for chase credit card mastercard credit card number hack bad credit car finance bristol how to install free apps on ipad without credit card best reward credit card offers 2013 credit card number location chase freedom student credit card top 10 business credit cards uk unsecured gas credit cards for bad credit christian credit card debt relief programs transfer credit card balance 0 interest australia axis bank gold credit card online apply business loans against credit card sales debit visa card rbc mastercard premium credit cards profinity prepaid card free credit score free download easy credit card checker 1.2 marriott rewards premier credit card from chase review list of credit card issuers in canada chase no credit credit card independent payday loan lenders uk ebay credit card review chase visa card phone number how to apply for barclays credit card online does td canada trust have visa debit cards 76 gas credit card sign in usa credit card for foreigners discover student credit card cosigner top 10 credit cards with low interest rates credit card online barclays uob credit card rewards redemption thailand city bank credit card customer care number bangalore free list of valid credit card numbers cash payday loans canada no fee american express air miles credit card icici bank add on credit card application form orchard bank credit card application by phone best credit card interest rates 2011 what is the best credit card to apply for credit card repayment calculator minimum payment natwest credit cards online login will paying off credit card debt help my credit score hdfc bank credit card helpline no kolkata bank of america credit card cash advance limit free prepaid credit card ireland icici platinum chip credit card best cashback credit cards usa
Home Maury Brown Inside The Numbers: Tim Lincecum's Possible Record Contract

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1362 guests online

Atom RSS

Inside The Numbers: Tim Lincecum's Possible Record Contract PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 52
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 30 November 2009 13:25
Tim Lincecum
Tim Lincecum is in store for an incredible
salary via arbitration. How high it will
be is the question.

EDITOR'S NOTE - This article was originally published in Nov. of 2009. With Lincecum filing for salary arbitration, the topic was worth reviewing.


That’s what Giants starting pitcher Tim Lincecum made last season; the last season before “The Freak” hits salary arbitration. Now, it is not a matter of whether Lincecum will make more money next season, but how much. Lincecum will almost assuredly be getting a record-setting deal, but which “record” will be broken is the question.

On Jan. 5-15, players that have between 3-6 years of major league service time are eligible for salary arbitration, and can file for it. Lincecum falls into a small sub-set of players called a “Super 2”.

To qualify as a Super 2, a player must:

  • Have at least 2 years of service, but less than 3, and;
  • Have accumulated at least 86 days of service in the previous year, and;
  • Rank in the top 17% of all 2-year players in service time.

The cutoff point generally falls between 2 years, 128 days of service and 2 years, 140 days. How much ML service time does Lincecum have? 2.148, or 8 days over the threshold for the classification.

Cutting to the chase, the salary arbitration process is designed to come to an agreement – a contract reached by the club and the player, mostly of the single-year variety. After filing for eligibility, a player with his agent, file a salary figure that they are seeking as salary for the upcoming season. In turn, the club the player plays for files their salary figure that they believe the player is worth for the same period; the upcoming season. After the figures are filed, there is a period of time in which negotiations occur to reach a contract ahead of a hearing to determine one figure or the other – there is no middle ground.

Based upon the exchange, the salary point in-between player and club figures are a major focus. This “mid-point” is where compromise would be met.  A player and his agent gets too cocky and files a salary figure too high or club files too low, and it can have consequences. At the least, it can force the sides to not reach a contract on their own, and the case goes to “hearing.” At the worst, millions of dollars can be lost when a side wins or loses in the hearing process. So, the figures that are filed are given incredible amounts of attention, not only by the players and clubs, but by the MLBPA and the Commissioner’s Office. The outcome for a case sets the market for players in salary arbitration, not only for his class of players, but in future years. As we’ll see, this has a large bearing on Lincecum’s case.

As background on the process, it is the last bastion in MLB where advanced statistics are not used. The reason is simple: a player’s “case” if it goes to hearing is heard by a 3 member arbitration panel from the American Arbitration Association; they are not “baseball people”. While the panel members are familiar with baseball statistics, the “old reliables” are still the focus. No WHIP. No VORP. No WAR. Instead, ERA, AVG, IP, Ks, BBs, etc. are the focus. In plain terms, simple is better in salary arbitration.

What Is In-Bounds and Out-of-Bounds in Salary Arbitration

Salary Arb Criteria
Select the image above to read the
criteria for salary arbitration in MLB

The rules for engagement in salary arbitration are centered on common sense. For example, it doesn’t make much sense to try and compare a pitcher to a first baseman. You’re looking to make a case that the player is like similar players. You can make a case that corner outfielders are similar. But, beyond that it’s really position for position.

It also makes sense that, for the most part, you need to compare players at their same point in terms of experience. You don’t want to use age as players enter the Major Leagues at differing rates. So, the focus here is on the Major League Service Time discussed prior in groups and the salaries they make. The premise is simple: make a case that a player is worth the salary of another player with the same amount of MLB experience, with some exemptions. (Select the image to the right to see the criteria as it is presented in the latest CBA)

The Exception

As the CBA defines it, there are exceptions to the rules. When there are players that an agent believes is so extraordinary as to have to no comparable players within his class to use within the process, they can make a case, as the CBA specifies that the criteria “shall not limit the ability of a Player or his representative, because of special accomplishment, to argue the equal relevance of salaries of Players without regard to service, and the arbitration panel shall give whatever weight to such argument as is deemed appropriate.

The Stare Down

As mentioned, the arbitration process is designed to reach a contract agreement. There is the possibility that the Giants could offer multi-year contract in the hopes of wrapping up Lincecum through his arbitration eligible years, and possibly early free agency. That would benefit the Giants, and could give Lincecum financial security, should he find himself injured. On the flip side, he’s in an incredible position to receive a record-setting arbitration deal, thus maximizing the ability of the arb process. That would mean a much higher salary in 2010 than he would get in a multi-year deal, and set the bar higher in the arbitration market for years to come, something that the MLBPA would like to see.

So, there are pluses and minuses depending on how Lincecum holds up. Continue to be of Cy Young caliber, and he will reap extraordinary salary increases each year through the arb process. If he falls apart; loses his stuff, or is injured next season, the guaranteed money in a multi-year contract dwindles.

Select Read More to see how career stats details for Lincecum, how much he may be asking in arbitration, how much the Giants could offer, and ultimately, what type of one-year salary Lincecum could recieve

Making the Case for Lincecum (The Pitcher)

Lincecum Career Stats
Select the image to see Lincecum's stats

Lincecum will be a rare case in the salary arbitration process – that exception – a player that falls outside of the bounds of his peers within his service time group.

(Select the image to the left to see Lincecum’s career game-by-game stats)

Lincecum won his first Cy Young in his second season, something that had not been done since Dwight Gooden and Bret Saberhagen both won in 1985. Lincecum just won his second Cy Young, going back-to-back. He is one of only 15 players in history to win the award more than once. As a comparison, Tom Seaver won his first Cy Young in his third season, and his 2nd CY Young in his fifth season. Lincecum has won two Cy Youngs in his two seasons and change, an accomplishment no other pitcher has done. He is the first pitcher to go back-to-back as an NL Cy Young winner since Randy Johnson won four straight (1999-2002).

Selected stats that back up Lincecum as an“exception”:

  • Led the league in strikeouts (second consecutive year)
  • Had the third lowest ERA in the league (second consecutive year)
  • Has a .702 winning percentage in his third season, ranking him close to Dwight Gooden (.756), who is considered to have had one of, if not the greatest early pitching careers in history.
  • Lincecum’s career 10.2 Ks per 9 is better than Gooden’s after his first three seasons (9.1)

Awards Beyond Cy Young:

  • 2009 All-Star Game starting pitcher
  • NL Sporting News Pitcher of the Year (second consecutive year)

Based on research by Ari Kaplan of, Lincecum in 2009:

  • Holds batters to 22% less batting average, 18% less OBP, and 28% less SLG, and 43% less ISOP (“Isolated Power”).
  • Has greater overall dominance with his 3.83 K/BB ratio (2.54 is avg). He is the strikeout leader with 261.
  • Strikes out batters 50% more often (per 9 IP), and walks batters 7% less often (per 9 IP).
  • Attempts pickoffs 23% more often, yet 30% fewer consecutively (2 or more in a row).
  • Allows 60% fewer HR per 9 IP, 25% fewer hits per 9 IP, 37% fewer TB per 9 IP.

Making the Case for Lincecum (The Star)

Lincecum is unorthodox in his delivery. His gangly frame contorts. His stride to the plate is of incredible length compared to his relative size… he’s “The Freak”, one that gets attention due to his uniqueness coupled with his pitching. It is his talent, his style (both on and off the field) that have made Lincecum a star, something sorely needed by the Giants after Barry Bonds left in a cloud of PED suspicion.

Last season, the Giants averaged 35,322 in attendance, compared to 36,708 when Lincecum started, a difference 1,386 more in paid attendance per game. Using Team Marketing Report’s Fan Cost Index for 2009, the Giants had an average ticket price of $23.28. When you place the figures against his 16 starts at AT&T Park, it translates to over a half-a-million dollars extra ($516,280.56) in additional ticket revenue alone each year that is potentially related to Lincecum. Taken further, if one uses TMR’s Fan Cost Index, which looks at the prices of two (2) adult average-price tickets, two (2) child average-price tickets, two (2) small draft beers, four (4) small soft drinks, four (4) regular-size hot dogs, parking for one (1) car, two (2) game programs and two (2) least expensive, adult-size adjustable caps, the FCI for the Giants was $222.63. If we were to say a 1/4 of the 1,386 that attended on days Lincecum pitched were part of the FCI, approx.  $77,000 more potential revenue related to Lincecum went to the Giants’ coffers this past season based on days he was up in the rotation compared to days when he was not.

While not wholly related to Lincecum, television ratings for the Giants were up 39% from the year prior on CSN Bay Area, the third highest regional sports network ratings increase in all of MLB for the 2009 season, a new record for the organization.

What Might Lincecum’s Filing Figure Be

Rick Thurman of the Beverly Hills Sports Council represents Lincecum, and you can bet he and the staff at BHSC have been crunching data and working to place the highest salary filing figure without going too far. Remember, the CBA says, the “arbitration panel shall give whatever weight to such argument as is deemed appropriate.”

There’s been talk that "The Freak", BHSC, and the MLBPA have discussed an asking figure of $23 million, plus one-dollar. The significance of the “$1” is that it would exceed C.C. Sabathia’s salary by a buck that he will receive next season as part of his 7-year, $161 million deal with the Yankees; a record salary for a pitcher in the league.

If that figure is filed, and the case were to go before an arbitration hearing, chances are exceptionally high that the panel would shoot down Lincecum’s case in favor of the Giants offering figure (provided the Giants weren’t foolish from filing exceptionally low).

There are several arbitration filing and contract figures to focus on:

  • In his second year of salary arbitration eligibility, the Philles’ first baseman Ryan Howard filed an $18 million asking figure, the third highest ever. That came on top of his $10 million award that he gained by winning his salary arbitration case at hearing the year prior. Howard, at the time, had a RoY award in 2005 and was NL MVP in 2006. The $18 million filing figure was the third highest ever.
  • In 2001, Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter filed an $18.5 million asking figure compared to the Yankees $14.25 million in his second year of salary arbitration eligibility. The year prior Jeter asked for a then record $10.5 million to the Yankees $9.5 million offering figure. The 2001 figure by Jeter was a reaction to Alex Rodriguez record setting 10-year, $252 million contract signed as a free agent with the Texas Rangers the month before. Jeter’s $18.5 million asking figure ranks 2nd all-time.
  • Roger Clemens considered retirement before the 2005 season, but held off after the Astros offered salary arbitration as a free agent. The Astros submitted an offering figure of $13.5 million compared to Clemens’ $22 million asking figure, the highest asking figure ever to date. On January 21, 2005, Clemens and the Astros agreed to a one-year, $18,000,022 contract, thus avoiding arbitration. The deal gave Clemens the highest yearly salary earned by a pitcher in league history. But remember, Clemens’ salary arb deal is different in that he was a free agent offered salary arbitration.
  • In terms of recent salary arb deals, Dontrelle Willis reached a $4.35 million deal with the Marlins in 2006 and avoided arbitration. Willis’ $4.35 million is the highest salary reached for a starting pitcher that was first time eligible. This past year, closer Jonathan Papelbon reached a one-year, $6.2 million agreement with the Red Sox as a first-time salary arbitration eligible player. It is the highest salary arbitration related contract for a pitcher within the normal 3-6 years of ML service time, as well as the most for a closer.

Based upon the historic figures, we can reach the following:

The Clemens figure, much like the Sabathia number, is unrealistic. The $22 million filing figure would be $4-$4.5 million over Howard and Jeter’s figures, and remember… Clemens was a free agent with 7 Cy Young awards under his belt at that stage who was offered salary arbitration by the Astros. However, the back-to-back Cy Youngs along with other career stats does not make an attempt at surpassing Howard’s $18 million filing figure out of the question.  Maybe $18.5 million? It would be risky, and bold. Howard is an everyday positional player, while Lincecum would be up in a rotation, most likely every 4 days. Lincecum, as a pitcher, would offer more value. While WAR is not used in the salary arbitration process, over Lincecum’s first three seasons he has amassed 18.9 wins above replacement compared to Howard’s 9.2 at the same ML service time.

What Would the Giants Offer?

The Giants are going to be looking at the figures mentioned prior, as well as seeing a couple of possible chinks in Lincecum’s armor.

The Giants will most assuredly point to Lincecum having issues with his back last season. Based upon data from

  • On September 8th, Lincecum had back problems "due to spasms and inflammation in the lower left side of his back"
  • His fastball velocity dropped from 92 to 90mph and changeup from 83 to 82. His slider and curveball stayed the same velocity.
  • He consistently threw first-pitch strikes 57% of the time, although it steadily went down from about 50% just before the injury that led to the missed starts. He threw just 40% first-pitch strikes after the back spasm and inflammation.
  • Before the injury he threw fastballs 60% of pitches, while after the injury he threw them 50%. Curveball usage went up from 20% to 28% of pitches, changeup down from 20% to 16%, and slider down from 10% to 8%.
  • After the injury, his slider, fastball, and changeup release points went up 1-2 inches and his curveball down an inch. Also all of his release points were 2-3 inches towards first base.
  • For comparison purposes, he threw 57% first-pitch strikes in 2008, and 60% in 2007.

See the chart below to see how Lincecum’s pitching was over the course of last season with the back injury.

Lincecum Chart
Select the image above to see details on Lincecum's
pitching velocity across his pitches over the course of  the
2009 season (courtesy AriBall)

The Giants could – repeat could – bring up Lincecum’s now infamous pot bust this off-season. This is the first known brush with pot for Lincecum, but then MLB doesn’t report positive tests for marijuana; players are only fined and it is not publically disclosed. The Business of Sports Network has never heard of Lincecum having any other dealings with pot, but let’s say in some scenario, he did. Thurman and BHSC could point to Lincecum’s stats and awards and say, “And, marijuana is adversely affecting Tim’s pitching, how?” The pot issue would seem a desperate move without pointing to anything damaging his performance.

So, based upon Papelbon’s $6.2 million deal last year as a closer, and Lincecum’s value, both on and off the mound, an $8 million offering figure by Brian Sabean and the Giants seems possible. The figure is not outlandishly low; it would be a record setter for a starter and $1.8 million higher than Papelbon’s record setter last season. Based upon the fact that Sabean and the Giants haven’t been in these uncharted waters before in salary arbitration, the $8 million the figure would most likely look good to arbitrators, should they go to hearing. With offering and asking in place, the sides can then focus on the real matter at hand, the mid-point.

What Could The Final Lincecum Salary Figure Be

Based upon an $8 million offering figure and an $18.5 million asking figure you get a $13.25 million mid-point, a staggering record-setter. The key factor will be the asking figure by Thurman and the BHSC. If the idea is to set the bar by asking for a figure over Howard’s asking figure last year in his second year of eligibility, then something over $18 million will be in play… risky given a possible $10 million gap with the hypothetical $8 million offer by the Giants.

What seem s more likely would be starting with Papelbon’s record-setting deal, and working upward.

Thurman, and the Beverly Hills Sports Council could file a $16.8 million asking figure, which while not a record setter compared to Howard’s second-year arb eligible filing, would make a statement when looking at the mid-point with our hypothetical Giants offering figure. The mid-point between $8 million and $16.8 million is $12.4 million, or double Papelbon’s record setter. The figure would make a statement, but not be as risky as the $18.5 million figure.

So, that’s our mock target: Lincecum’s asking salary will be $16.8 million and the Giants will offer $8 million with a mid-point of $12.4 million. Thurman will meet with the Giants at the Baseball Winter Meetings in Indianapolis, which start on Monday. Thurman has said that they are looking for a one-year deal for Lincecum, and the Giants have said they won’t make any major moves until after the year.

"In Lincecum's case, it's Howard-like in terms of where this could go as a first-time eligible player," Sabean said. "Secondarily, because of the potential number that it could go to, we may be guarded, not wanting to talk about a long-term situation until you know the range. We could get something done in and around filling in the numbers."

Salary Numbers, Compared to 2009

The following would be increases in salary compared to Lincecum’s salary (both last year, and career)

  • If $13.25 million mid-point - 1938% higher than 2009 salary of $650,000
  • If $12.4 million mid-point - 1808% higher than 2009 salary of $650,000
  • Lincecum’s total career earnings total $3,080,000 (signing bonus of $2.025 million, salaries of $405,000 in 2008 and $650,000 in 2009. If he were to land the $12.4 million figure he would earn more than 4 times his career earnings in 2010, alone.

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?