high risk credit cards td canada trust visa debit security code american express delta credit card offers iphone credit card case best buy virgin credit card log on black card points natwest purple discovery credit card apply for visa credit card no credit history best credit card to get for someone with no credit citibank credit card settlement process in india apply mbna credit card canada rate credit card reward programs payday loan online instant short term cash loans online best canadian credit cards for travel rewards citi government travel credit card can credit card companies sue you in pa credit card fraud online orders top 10 best payday loan lenders 0 interest credit cards purchases free balance transfer credit card canada comments amazon credit card review apply citibank credit card online india how to bypass credit card verification paypal cash advance instant approval online hdfc instant credit card on fd credit card debt mortgage best airline credit cards for fair credit walmart canada credit card apply united cash loans online unsecured credit cards for bad credit compare citibank and standard chartered credit card best airline rewards credit cards best credit cards after filing bankruptcy credit limit calculator for hdfc credit card best prepaid canadian credit cards best iphone credit card app 2011 fast easy cash loans for unemployed best credit card advice hdfc credit card payment online easiest department store credit cards for bad credit consumer reports best credit card balance transfers visa credit cards canada td bank visa debit card balance how do i get a credit card with no credit credit card ratings hsbc international credit card charges credit card fees for business owners chevron texaco credit card login page costco american express platinum card benefits how to cancel a chase credit card online credit cards cash back or points hsbc credit card business reply envelope best reward travel credit card canada credit card calculator excel uk credit card finder google aqua credit card payment no fee credit cards with travel rewards is magnum cash advance legal in ohio lowest rate credit cards 2012 real credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date 2012 what is the best credit card to have with no credit how do you use a manual credit card machine starwood credit card standard chartered credit card online payment india citibank credit card application best types of credit cards to get best student credit cards no credit bank of america credit card 5 cash back chase credit card fraud call hdfc bank credit cards redeem reward points visa cards canada post payday loans lenders only paypal prepaid mastercard uk orchard bank credit card payments online best 0 credit card offers 2012 best credit cards to have with fair credit free credit score check uk no credit card instant online loans bad credit canadian low interest rate credit cards compare hdfc gold and titanium credit card how to get an american express platinum card bank of america credit card cash advance transaction fee disputing international credit card charges discount payday advance loans standard chartered credit card personal loan prepaid visa debit cards online us credit card number for kindle fire new payday lenders hdfc credit card apply online in jaipur tj maxx credit card information stolen sign up for credit card with no credit secure credit card holder sbi online credit card rewards where can i use my gap visa credit card united chase credit card cash advance credit card number and security code 2013 free credit card bin number search hdfc credit card charges abroad chase credit card credit limit increase free visa credit card details 2012 best visa travel rewards card 0 interest rate credit card offer credit card for college students with no job rewards cards uk home depot canada credit card application alaska air miles credit card consolidate credit cards into one loan apply for credit card canada online barclays credit card ppi phone number credit card processing rates explained platinum credit card hdfc minimum limit free real visa credit card numbers credit card fraud for dummies watch online credit card information security policy template hack visa credit card 2011 updated sbi credit card online application virtual credit card generator post office platinum card online credit card travel promotion gap credit card services login check best buy credit card application can i get a cash advance on my usaa credit card sears mastercard payment bank of america credit card business login how to get credit card company to increase limit accepting credit cards payments over the phone how to apply credit card in icici jcpenney credit card login what is cash advance fee td usaa credit card cash advance rate easiest credit card to get in canada with bad credit super premium credit cards australia credit card helpline no fake credit card number and cvv visa debit card application form pdf can international students apply for credit cards using lloyds tsb platinum credit card abroad data mining techniques for credit card fraud detection bad credit loans online no brokers credit card for no credit score prepaid visa cards with no fees canada anz credit card balance transfer application united credit card offer 60000 us bank secured credit card phone number how to redeem my icici bank credit card points best 0 apr credit cards canada best visa credit cards with rewards how to redeem axis bank credit card points hdfc credit card emi offer credit suisse internship credit card rewards programs hdfc credit card toll free number from mobile free credit card apps for iphone freedom credit card review payday loan lender guaranteed approval hsbc credit card charges abroad zero percent balance transfer credit cards 2012 pay icici credit card bill online through debit card singapore credit cards comparison 2011 how to become a credit card merchant global credit card fraud statistics where do i mail my us bank credit card payment best value credit cards 2013 0 credit card transfer offers barclays lost credit card usa citi corporate credit cards uk mastercard amazon 10 off 100 how to get your first credit card 2011 iphone credit card processing lowest rate click to pay icici bank credit cards first premier credit card online login credit card travel miles blog view axis bank credit card statement paypal virtual credit card download wells fargo credit card rewards review barclays apple credit card phone number best credit cards 2013 for students credit cards explained uk pre approved credit card opt out stores that offer cashback on credit cards online payday loans direct lenders no teletrack how to use black cardamom credit cards with gas and grocery rewards tesco clubcard credit card minimum payment free master credit card numbers best credit card to get in canada no credit credit cards visa citibank online credit card generator discover student credit cards review natwest online credit card disappeared online sbi credit card registration best credit card offer april 2013 when was the first credit card invented high acceptance payday loan lenders only credit cards with cashback rewards best credit card bad credit unsecured home loan with bad credit score airline credit cards comparison top credit cards usa best credit card company for students starwood preferred guest credit card business what store credit cards can i get after bankruptcy cancel pre approved credit card offers apply hsbc credit card online singapore suze orman best secured credit card do aib do a visa debit card american first cash advance apply for first credit card with no credit black cardamom powder small business credit cards for bad credit chase generate virtual credit card first horizon credit card online online payday loans for bad credit direct lenders chase credit card services jobs prepaid credit cards walmart paypal credit score for best buy credit card approval can add funds paypal credit card prepaid mastercard uk iphone credit card payments australia how to use credit card machine for business credit card with no credit check uk td gold elite visa cash back staples business credit card account bad credit loan companies online can a credit card company garnish your wages in california barclays credit card apply in hyderabad discover bank credit card phone number credit card processing companies uk cash loans today with no bank account list of payday lenders australia usaa credit card travel notification what are the benefits and disadvantages to the small business of accepting credit cards unsecured credit cards for bad credit 2013 top 50 credit cards quick and easy online loans in south africa discover student credit card bad credit low interest credit card with no balance transfer fee how to make standard chartered credit card online payment best gas credit card to get payday loans direct lenders uk no credit check how to activate sbi platinum credit card how to apply for visa credit card philippines hugo boss black credit card holder credit card comparison frequent flyer points credit card in canada for international students prepaid credit card in canada cibc visa credit card online banking home depot credit card canada login apply for credit cards with bad credit history how to pay icici credit card payment online hdfc online credit card payment through debit card easy credit cards to apply for online free prepaid visa card sears credit card application status phone number irs credit limit worksheet 2011 icici platinum credit card charges citibank credit card rewards malaysia credit cards visa mastercard how to transfer money from hdfc master credit card to bank account state employees credit union dillards credit card going over credit limit barclaycard credit card cash advance calculator chase visa credit card for students credit score range for best buy credit card does it hurt your credit to apply for multiple credit cards pay walmart credit card bill online american express credit card with no annual fee in india hdfc credit card loan preclosure longest interest free credit cards on purchases paying off credit card debt in full credit score how do criminals get credit card numbers credit card verification process india bank of america credit card 0 apr balance transfer does paypal accept visa electron debit cards credit card holder leather citibank college student credit card sbi credit card eligibility chennai bank of america debit and credit cards post office credit card payment address credit card debt reduction calculator for excel credit card bin search australia 5 best credit cards for travel american express platinum cashback credit card travel insurance excel formula to calculate monthly credit card interest credit card balance transfer calculator compare hsbc credit card apply online in india best credit card to get cash advance comparing credit cards worksheet citibank credit card cash advance rate credit card report date best no fee credit card canada bpi credit cards application status nationwide credit card balance transfer to current account alaska airlines credit card canada login new look black cropped cardigan no credit check credit cards no deposit holiday gas station credit card offers credit card credit score needed monthly interest rate credit card calculator citibank credit card no annual fee singapore 0 interest credit cards balance transfers 24 months easy to get credit cards canada fast cash online loans how does credit card debt consolidation work grand hyatt credit card authorization form capital one credit cards banking auto loans checking fast online payday loans best credit card points program canada 2011 bank of america credit card settlement letter belk credit card payment options rci bank of america credit card login how do you change your credit card details on ebay can i use my sears credit card at kmart bank of america merchant services credit card rates rbc cash back visa redeem how do credit card companies make money on 0 top secured credit cards for bad credit best visa card brandsmart usa credit card login credit card protection plan review analysis on credit card fraud detection methods project - java 0 balance transfer credit card for poor credit rating reputable credit card debt settlement companies american express no annual fee credit card i want to apply for a hsbc credit card hdfc credit card limit enhancement online credit cards with no interest and no balance transfer fees cash back credit card malaysia 2013 apply dbs debit visa card credit card authorization form word template how do i apply for a visa credit card online online merchant credit card processing companies virgin business credit card uk uk credit card number direct payday advance loans credit cards for college students with cosigner easiest bad credit credit card get variable apr credit card calculator credit cards for bad credit no credit check emerald td visa card gift visa card india how will applying for a new credit card affect my credit score anz debit visa card nz bank of america power rewards visa signature card compare icici bank credit cards how long does it take to get credit card in mail free virtual visa credit cards when do chase credit card payments post bank of america credit card uk contact sears mastercard credit card review hsbc credit card online application form philippines credit cards with 0 apr and rewards online loan lenders uk who has the most secure credit card cash back visa card apply for mastercard free what to know when applying for your first credit card barclays premier credit card limit annual gold card south west trains instant online loans no credit check compare payday lenders not brokers how to buy a house with bad credit and low income citibank corporate credit card statement delta mastercard credit card canada kohls credit card payments address icici credit card offers on jewellery credit card calculator payoff date free prepaid visa debit cards best airmiles credit cards 2012 mastercard credit cards with rewards top 10 credit cards to have how to apply credit card in bdo philippines apply for capital 1 credit card best buy credit cards review spg credit card bonus points 0 balance transfer credit cards for good credit best way to rebuild credit with a secured credit card credit card protectors from scanners va loans with bad credit score credit card instant decision online bad credit capital one venture business credit card apply for simmons first credit card chase credit card protection insurance guaranteed credit cards canada no interest credit cards orchard credit card bank virgin credit card ppi reclaim bad credit secured loan calculator top credit card processing providers best credit cards for bad credit rebuild horizon gold card services online payday loan easy approval sears credit card rewards hsbc bank credit card comparison malaysia hdfc credit cards online apply interest free credit cards bad credit rating free business credit cards uk jc penny credit card old navy visa credit card payment address best credit card offers 2013 for travel credit card debt advice uk credit card machine hire uk rfid credit card scanner theft who offers secured credit cards in australia chase visa reward cards disney premier visa credit card from chase 0 credit cards transfer balance new online payday loan lenders cash advances payday loans canada best reward credit cards with no annual fee 2013 instant cash advance uk credit cards - compare credit card offers at creditcards.com unsecured credit cards for bad credit not prepaid rbc bank visa debit card virtual credit card generator 2010 ge low rate credit card dubai first credit card review credit cards for bad credit credit card promotions malaysia can you apply for a walmart credit card over the phone travel rewards credit cards review balance transfer fee free credit cards uk credit card travel insurance tips to reduce credit card debt quickly instant credit cards for bad credit approval best secured credit card to rebuild credit fast fha loans with bad credit score best credit cards canada cash back citibank credit cards for bad credit how to organize store reward cards us bank credit card approval rates hdfc gold credit card reward points redemption catalogue credit cards for college students with low apr 0 percent credit card balance transfer free equifax credit score no credit card southwest air credit card deals rental car no credit card credit check lowest apr credit card cheap credit cards for bad credit history air miles credit card comparison uk discover credit card application phone number payday online loan lenders login into sears credit card legit fast cash loans online how to calculate interest rate on credit card balance best rate credit cards canada how to avoid paypal credit card fees icici online credit card application status first premier bank credit card review new direct payday loan lenders 2013 balance transfer credit card offers westpac apple credit card payment application what are black credit cards made of chase disney credit card review visa debit card credit history top 10 credit cards 2012 uk largest credit card issuers in the world free credit card numbers with cvv code hsbc black credit card uk credit card payment applied to highest interest rate do company credit cards affect credit score pay as you go credit card lost td visa card say no to 0870 natwest credit card how to get hdfc new credit card types of credit cards brands best online cash advances reviews easy credit cards to get approved for with no credit credit card cash advance charge calculator wyndham rewards credit card canada business loan quote online how to use hdfc credit card rewards points post office credit card contact number from abroad anz platinum credit card travel insurance australia prepaid credit cards post office canada delta credit card offer 50000 best rewards credit card 2011 paypal credit card fees ebay what is cash advance interest charge loan with bad credit uk delta skymiles credit card deal free online loan calculator generic recurring credit card authorization form credit card service providers uk how to apply for a credit card if you have no credit pay firestone credit card online i need a credit card with bad credit canada top credit card deals uk credit cards 101 what are credit cards personal online loans no credit check quick ways to pay off student loans jetstar international credit card fees bad credit credit cards no credit check uk credit card credit rating minimum payment easy online payday loans ontario get a credit card with bad credit history what is a good credit card rates apr what is considered a cash advance on a credit card
Home Maury Brown MLB Can't Have Their Cake and Eat it Too (Revenue-Sharing)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 625 guests online

Atom RSS

MLB Can't Have Their Cake and Eat it Too (Revenue-Sharing) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 52
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 24 November 2009 14:10
Scott Boras
Scott Boras' message on money being transferred
between the haves and have-nots in MLB is self-
serving, but that doesn't mean the message isn't

The tension between management and labor in Major League Baseball continues to rise as agents and some in the MLBPA believe that collusion to keep player salaries down is afoot, while those in the league office and within the individual clubs vehemently deny it. At the center of the dispute is how much (or little) the downturn in the economy has impacted MLB.

On the final day of the owners meetings last week in Chicago, Commissioner Selig said that there was no question some clubs lost money this year.

"I think of all the heartache that's in the world,” Selig said. “We live in this environment. We don't live in a bubble. And so, I think the clubs in some areas have been hit a lot harder than others."

But, in the overall, baseball is weathering the recession better than expected.

Major League Baseball had three attendance projections at the beginning of season that ranged from flat, compared to 2008, down 10 percent, or down 20 percent. Selig and Co. were more than pleased by the end of the regular season. Total attendance for 2009 was 73,418,529, down 6.58 percent from a total of 78,591,116 in 2008. The total regular season attendance figure ranks as the fifth highest in MLB history. In another measure of attendance, ballparks saw an average of 30,338 over 2,420 games, down 6.77 percent from the 32,543 in average attendance over 2,415 games last season.

While the league is still crunching numbers, the MLBPA has projected that total revenues for MLB should be $6.3 billion, down 3.17 percent compared to the record-setting $6.5 billion last year.

Into this mix steps baseball’s most powerful and polarizing agent, Scott Boras, and MLB Executive VP or Labor Relations Rob Manfred.

Boras, citing a report by Bill Madden of New York Daily News in August, claimed that due to revenue-sharing and centralized funds, some low-revenue making clubs were pulling in-between $80 million-$90 million before a single ticket was taken at the gate, concession sold, or parking paid (he later clarified to say that the figures were between $70-$80 million). As Liz Mullen and Eric Fisher of the SportsBusiness Daily reported, Manfred said of Boras, "He completely made those numbers up." Manfred made similar statements to other media, including telling the Boston Globe that Boras' comments "have no basis in reality" and said Boras was living in "fantasy land."

Since then, Boras has been on ESPN and Jayson Stark has looked into the figures. As Stark wrote of the Pirates, and Marlins:

Your team collected more money this season -- before it ever sold one ticket -- than it spent on its entire major league payroll. In fact, it collected more than it spent on its major league payroll and its player-development system combined.

Stark, using sources, finds that when combining revenue-sharing, central funds (national television, MLB Advanced Media, MLB Network, Luxury Tax etc.), and local media rights for television and radio, finds that $80 million to $90 million is not out of the question.

Looking At Revenue-Sharing

Determining whether the centralized funds or local revenues are correct is a matter of how solid Stark’s sources are. I’m not going to debate that (for the record, they appear solid), but you can bet, some in the league don’t like what they see, so let’s remove everything but the revenue-sharing.

This year, approx. $400 million will be distributed from high revenue making clubs such as the Yankees and Red Sox to those at the low end of the spectrum, such as the Marlins, Pirates, Rays, and Royals.

Revenue-sharing figures for each of the 30 clubs have not been leaked to the media since 2002-2003, and 2005 (see the complete set of figures), which saw revenue transfers of $169 million, $220 million, and $308.4 million respectively.

So, just over $190 million more in revenues will move between payors and payees this year compared to the last year that full figures were available in 2005, an increase of 22.9 percent.

Looking back at the figures from 2005, the Rays had the highest level of revenue-sharing funds come their way at $33 million. Since 2005, the revenue-sharing formula has become far more complex than in the prior CBA, using a system that looks at trailing years of revenues, and other factors. But, for discussion sake, if we look at the largest receiver of revenue-sharing funds over the life of the data we have (Expos for 2002-2003, and Rays in 2005), we could apply an approx. 3 percent increase from then to now. That would give the team receiving the most revenue-sharing in 2009 (likely, the Marlins), $42.9 million in revenue-sharing funds. So, if we were to add Stark’s central fund average, minus pension fund of $30 million, the idea that a club received between $70-$75 million in revenue-sharing and centralized funds is not out of the question.

With that, here's some Opening Day player payroll figures (minus bonuses, deferred payments and incentive clauses, or, money paid or received in trades or for players who have been released). to digest:

  • Marlins - $36,834,000
  • Pirates - $48,693,000
  • A's - $62,310,000
  • Royals - $70,519,333
  • Padres - $43,734,200
  • Nationals - $60,328,000
  • Rays - $63,313,034

Why Is MLB So Defensive?

Ken Rosenthal of FOXSports.com also reported on the war of words between Manfred and Boras over the figures cited, with Manfred highlighting management’s concerns over the messenger of the figures.

"Just like when he does a player negotiation he lies about the numbers in order to get the price up, now he's taken that to the macro-economic level and lying about industry numbers in order to get player (contract) numbers up," Manfred said. "There is no one club getting $80 or $90 million in combination from revenue sharing and Central Baseball. Not one."

Boras cast doubt on Manfred's statements generally, saying he "has never disclosed information about funds that teams get from Central Baseball or revenue sharing."

"Rob Manfred works for the owners, has always worked for the owners," Boras said. "The information I've gathered is from documented, substantive sources — the Daily News, the SportsBusiness Journal. I stand on the record of documented information, not on the basis of information of someone who is biased due to his employment."

When sports economist Andrew Zimbalist was made aware of the figures Boras cited, he said, "It should surprise no one to learn that Boras is blowing hot air again and that Manfred is correct."

As mentioned, above, Boras clarified that the figures were closer to between $70-$80 million, but Manfred and Zimbalist are focusing on Boras, rather than the overall message.

It should surprise no one that Boras has an agenda, and that agenda is to get the most out of the free agent market as possible. Manfred is, of course, looking to thwart Boras’ efforts. The defensive tone simply shows that this battle between high-profile agent and management has been raging for some time.

But, Manfred and Zimbalist focus on the figures, rather than the message, which is while some clubs may have suffered at the local level due to the economy, revenue-sharing and centralized funds have buffeted them to an extent against the decline.

Select Read More to see the solution MLB doesn't want you to have

The Solution MLB Doesn’t Want

There is, of course, a solution to this dilemma, but MLB wants no part of it: release the revenue-sharing figures, as was the case in 2002-’03, and 2005. The difference between then and now is that leaking the figures doesn't serves MLB any purpose. In ’02-’03 it was to show that Selig’s revenue-sharing system was working, while 2005 was to solidify the system leading up to negotiations for the current CBA.

As I noted, revenue-sharing figures leaked to the media have dried up over the last few years, which is by design, and completely within MLB’s rights as a private industry to withhold the data. As Zimbalist noted, “This is a product of private ownership and proprietary information.”

Zimbalist is correct, of course, but then MLB, through Manfred or any other representative, has no leg to stand on when I, or Stark, or Madden, or for that matter, Boras, talk about what the figures most likely are.

Major League Baseball can’t have their cake and eat it too. If the league wishes to stand on the grounds of the revenue-sharing figures being proprietary – a lack of transparency – so be it. But, don’t get defensive if column after column there are questions as to how some clubs are receiving considerable funds to assist them in competing with large revenue-makers only to claim that, woe is me, we’re losing money due to the recession. If MLB wants that discussion to dry-up, simply release the figures.

Whether a method to address clubs spending too little on player payroll involves a luxury tax in reverse, as Stark has suggested, or that there are stiffer penalties for those that breaking the luxury tax threshold repeatedly, such as the Yankees have, to achieve a greater sense of economic parity, as I have suggested, the debate will continue to rage. Baseball can choose to make the discussion difficult or easier, as is their prerogative.  But, Manfred shouldn’t get defensive at Boras, despite his transparent selfish needs. If the league has decided to stonewall on the topic of funds being transferred to and from clubs to achieve economic parity, then live with the chatter.






Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?