discount coupons for propecia cheap viramune pills buy sporanox online diflucan requip for sale usa buy atrovent fast shipping use ventolin accuhaler what types of aciclovir are there paroxetine 20mg for sale antivert delivery uk buy kamagra chewable cheap cialis viagra combo pack buy voveran sr astrailia unisom billig kaufen can you buy diovan buy bupron sr from mexico online what is the generic for proscar acyclovir mechanism of action animation very cheap grifulvin metformin dosage in pregnancy buy finpecia overseas best price for vasotec accutane isotretinoin forum nizoral over the counter buy arjuna lowest price cheap accutane 40 mg without online risperdal india is it safe to use out of date viagra is there a generic drug for maxalt craigslist manchester massage how long to take tetracycline for acne coreg medication on line retino-a cream 0,025 order by phone what is amantadine medicine half price sinemet como conseguir viagra sin receta medica anti anxiety drugs with least side effects what is the therapeutic serum level for digoxin buy finax cheap albendazole reviews for men what is furosemide medication used for aspirin medicinenet prilosec otc canada buy generic furosemide with bonus how to take levitra mg bupropion pharmacy coupons does costco sell allegra levaquin medicinenet american diabetes association guidelines aspirin use safe sites for canadian viagra mirapex discount voucher levitra orodispersible (vardenafil) new retino-a cream 0,025 coupons erythromycin refill pack where to buy benadryl iv maxifort zimax sildenafil para que sirve buy carafate hong kong when will generic singulair be available in the us how to take minocin mg rio rico pharmacy reviews what is trazodone pills used for medrol tablets buy best online pharmacy generic casodex buy genuine cephalexin uk pravachol weight gain get nolvadex australia generic name for ciprodex sinemet reviews patients remeron order online combivent coupons online www.canadapharmacy 24 fucidin cream ointment medicine where to parlodel adverse side effects of levaquin cheapest place to buy neurontin synthroid ships from india terramycin reviews birth control alesse generic forms drugs from india pharmaceutical companies lexapro mais barato without a script purchase accutane mg mastercard paxil mg price seroflo inhaler for kids buy keppra online overnight can you buy avalide comprar kamagra espaУБa contrareembolso malegra fxt plus review brand cialis without a prescription from uk cleocin shipping overseas kamagra now co uk index 100mg sinemet pills pictures fasigyn tinidazole 500mg eldepryl drugstore.com what is the drug amantadine used for mestinon legal in england cipro pills buy online clomid online pharmacy overseas pharmacy no prescription hytrin pharmacy has best price cephalexin side effects of januvia medication levitra super active discounts codes confido online evecare roche precio argentina what is depakote er used for viramune uk next day delivery cheap 250mg buy amoxil xenical online bestellen what types of florinef are there prescription testosterone cream reviews buy aciphex online offers why is there a shortage of allopurinol buy isoniazid online no prescription acheter pas cher brand levitra rash from flagyl como comprar zenegra beat way to order yasmin minocin online no prescription buy lantus online no prescription usa deltasone generic cheap costs generic zerit cost lisinopril cost costco buy ephedraxin no prescription fast delivery cheap generic zebeta azithromycin tablets is used for hoodia shortage cheapest keppra to buy the online drugstore avodart viagra para la mujer en mexico ceftin australia price the fruit that works like viagra hytrin spain over counter tadacip uk tri-cyclen side effects no viagra for sex offenders zithromax price at walgreens lowest price fosamax levothroid now atarax pills online in the india cialis uk express delivery voltaren echeck safe place order purim order zyloprim online lowest price for nexium es legal usar cytotec buy tegretol pills gout pill colchicine where can i get quibron-t pills how do i lnow if need viagra when is plavix generic available can i get high off valtrex clomid ovulation induction protocol toprol xl drug schedule buy elavil tablets mexico phenergan how to buy pharmacy near tijuana mexico order clomid online with visa buy canada no prescription for plendil best place to buy silagra 100 generic name prinivil low cost avandamet buy biaxin online amazon pulmicort medication cytotec for sale in baguio forzest overnight shipping cheap tenormin syrup patient information leaflet himplasia over counter medrol generic canada epivir-hbv uses medication mambo 36 horas mexico pharmacy testosterone flagyl without prescription pills aldactone online from canada viagra purchase online canada metronidazole side effects urine can buy cialis online exelon patch side effects shatavari price online pharmacy codeine linctus liquid brand cialis review western drug diltiazem diltiazem iv max dose colchicine online from uk prescription abilify coupons nizoral antifungal drug does viagra work for everyone price 20 mg levitra how to use confido tablets cheap aygestin sale uk what is synthroid 88 mcg used for can you buy minomycin over the counter best place to order artane in us buy aciclovir in india online can order hyzaar online buy cheap cialis in australia zantac 150 prices motilium paypal cymbalta over the counter where to get celexa diarex online cheap can you buy albenza can you buy fucidin online best all natural erectile dysfunction pills online sale of tamoxifen purchase female viagra lowest price caverta for dogs buy clomid complications metformin tablets uk buy accutane 25 mg imuran uk brand name over the counter atacand indian prednisone canada drugs sumycin with prescription what is the difference in zyrtec and zyrtec d how long do the side effects of coming off citalopram last cheap xbox live points acetonide triamcinolone side effects nitroglycerin pills abuse cheap promethazine sale uk bactrim ds side effects rash mail-order omnicef purchase prednisolone in canada zoloft buy online canada prescription drug trazodone used cheap generic viagra online canada buying crestor using paypal floxin generic cheap costs is it illegal to order generic lasix acheter kytril floxin ships from india latest levaquin lawsuit news buying duetact ventolin inhaler online uk online pharmacy in us for diflucan mobic drugstore.com super kamagra next day best slimming tablets that work can you only get carafate on prescription detrol suppositories buy real life viagra stories cymbalta price zetia price check vpxl online price safe generic ampicillin online lopid 300 mg рИ„рИЗрИ­ celexa online canada nitrofurantoin (furadantin macrodantin others) generic zyvox available prescription carbozyne buy canada no rx keftab online viramune online order where can i order amitriptyline no prescription pharmacy ambein cod buying geriforte syrup using paypal zopiclone for sale best medicine for depression and anxiety in women mentat himalaya drugs buy himcolin with paypal kamagra now cheapest uk version of propranolol dostinex for dogs buy order xanax online no prescription mastercard buy aricept cheap quinine sulphate overdose buy levitra plus with visa is it illegal to order generic innopran xl generic actos availability zentel sirop pt copii pret sony adalat online watch glimepiride metformin brands india clomid tablets side effects norvasc canada price order proventil on line canada methotrexate toxicity treatment guidelines generic ed packs no rx trandate online pet allies show low az seroquel pharmacy mail order cheap alesse pills mtabs.com astelin without script cod taking viagra age 30 order depression medication online us pharmacy online cialis sublingual azulfidine online order carafate tablets for dogs is bystolic better than lisinopril buy aspirin no prescription cialis sublingual online pay paypal online pharmacy antivert delivery topic buy premarin online best price for real finpecia micardis over the couter penegra 100 dosage discount coupons for lexapro buy tamoxifen citrate australia prescription Purchase diovan 320 mg levothyroxine side effects nhs doxycycline suppliers overseas campylobacter azithromycin dosage zenegra prices cvs fluconazole 200 mg side effects why has betoptic been discontinued order hydrea overnight para que se usa omnicef best price mentat generic pyridium buy canada i want to buy gabapentin from canada buy online topamax generic american dental association coumadin worldwide pharmacy eurax buy cleocin t lotion getting xeloda in australia cost of adderall prescription without insurance plendil 100mg cheap buy tadacip with paypal can you get pregnant after methotrexate buy trimox 40 india kamagra gold price where purchase relafen cialis price greece elimite on line +ordering cialis online genuine buspar 100mg trandate online usa no prescription ampicillin side effects in infants digoxin tablets ip buy carbozyne order nolvadex pill atacand no prescription needed sale diakof diet pill alli dangers should i take malaria pills for india buy diclofenac sodium canada arimidex generic cost para que se usa la crema lotrisone cleocin cream dosage cleocin mg buy buy generic abilify online order strattera dosage recommended abilify noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy prednisone 5 mg tablet paroxetine ships from india levitra professional maximum dosage compare prices of levitra viagra cialis buy omnicef no prescription buy generic requip buy lamictal astrailia evista 20 mg can you drink on erythromycin antibiotics suppliers of rumalaya forte in us do i need a prescription for inderal comprar liv 52 en argentina dutas discount voucher acheter pas cher lamisil buy meclizine pills what is septilin used for what is lisinopril hctz used for 25 mg viagra work diovan from canada acheter atacand pas cher viramune coupon code what does amitriptyline do to the body kamagra chewable cheap vermox over counter drug buy decadron 200 cheap lasix uk azithromycin dihydrate uses buy oxytrol boots pharmacy order ranitidine lowest price nymphomax shortage 2012 online forum zyrtec order allegra how much does celexa cost buy kamagra oral jelly paypal himcolin maximum dosage prednisone patient package insert aciclovir perth australia clonidine drugs forum allegra pills for allergy vicodin online without prescriptions alesse contraceptive pill review buying depo provera cialis online without prescription amex meta analysis of dose response characteristics of hydrochlorothiazide healthy gingerbread man cookie recipes order propecia 5mg australia walgreens pharmacy benicar price donde puedo comprar ginseng coreano reviews on clonidine retin-a ge billig kaufen maxalt without a script valtrex prices australia motrin pm printable coupons lithium tablet sale online pharmacy no prescription needed revia amlodipine no script where to buy baytril for snakes what are the side effects of zoloft coming off of it quick shipping pharmacy zoloft drugs like diamox without rx sinequan without prescription maximum dose of doxycycline for dogs doxycycline reviews for chlamydia oregon state beavers can you get off plavix billig evecare online kaufen mircette no prescription canada online pharmacy uk deltasone best place buy cytotec pct quality of drugs made in india erythromycin ophthalmic ointment what is it used for canadian pharmacy erection packs 10 effets secondaires de cialis 20mg is it legal to buy prescription drugs online in australia finasteride cost per month speman capsules lisinopril australia pharmacy why does elavil cause weight gain soft cialis india inderal 40 mg for migraines betnovate available over counter finpecia tablet review is there a generic for actos pharmacy buy dramamine without a script snovitra super power capsules generic confido switzerland what is quinine in lipitor 4 copay card participating pharmacies uk version of tetracycline is generic shallaki available in usa buy rosuvastatin pills online prednisone generic drug allegra over the counter results anafranil non perscription countries hoodia online usa confido on line no script how to take clomid clomiphene citrate aricept price walmart buy tadacip lowest price where do i diovan in uk maximum dosage of lexapro toradol drug shortage what are fertility drugs and how do they work order estrace on line canada what is trandate pills used for zyban drug class generic for keppra medication haridra canada head office is toradol a good pain medicine albuterol inhaler price walmart where to buy unisom free online buy brand amoxil new zealand online allegra by mail order clomid pregnancy success rates pulmicort budesonide information buying chloromycetin in manchester buy voltaren mg online legal requirements emergency sale ventolin prescription cost comparison roxithromycin mg discount o que УЉ tadalafila how to purchase danazol online generic rumalaya forte overnite shipping how much is nitroglycerin tablets 1 cup in grams sugar levothroid tablets us online malegra fxt overnight delivery minoxidil 5 foam nolvadex best price aspirin prix en pharmacie en france adalat 10 mg para embarazadas generic zebeta us silagra online forum femara ttc success ciplox usa sale where to get generic valtrex valtrex canada no prescription discount requip caverta online store l-tryptophan user reviews bactrim dosage instructions cheap artane usa buy hong kong compazine pills buy fluoxetine tablets fluconazole 200 mg tablets dosage canadian pharmacy liposafe lexapro reviews side effects buy evecare 50 exelon patch canada pharmacy coreg new zealand sildenafil citrate tablets patients viagra deaths per year clomid dose male fertility anacin sale alli discounts or coupons how much benadryl 100 lb dog inderal uses medication bayer aspirin class action lawsuit cardura xl 4mg side effects wal-mart pharmacy prices viagra cytoxan without insurance erexin-v phone orders discounted 100 mg clomid lasuna reviews how to take antivert zofran brand order lortab 5 500 mg 10mg flexeril high depakote bipolar drugs i pill zestoretic website drug diuretic metformin com au fastest acticin uk delivery can you buy cream over the counter lamisil tablets common side effects of isoniazid in children amoxil prix en pharmacie en france lexapro prescription information products hyaluronic acid over counter disfuncion erectil por diabetes tratamiento blopress cost in canada canadian pharmacy vermox buy isoptin 10 warfarin interactions cheap cabgolin free delivery periactin coupons order atarax online canada reglan for men in usa elavil class action lawsuit yasmin express canada prescription viagra canada neurontin online without prescription citalopram 40 mg tablets side effects pastillas omifin para sirven coreg generic for cozaar non perscription countries is omnaris better than flonase is it illegal to buy the abortion pill online order pain pills online florida we are young we are free lyrics nph insulin dosing atarax to buy in the canada without a prescription order prescription drugs online india cheap azulfidine no prescription comprar suprax pela internet over the counter buy actos overnight the online drugstore asacol culturismo sin tonterias pdf descargar celexa by mail order fluoxetine generic manufacturers zyloprim tablets four pack viagra vigra flyplass service what over the counter drug works like viagra what does ventolin do to your body requip pharmacy order atacand in india bromocriptine prolactin pregnancy suppliers of synthroid in us where to buy retin-a ge ointment pediatric losec dosage aldactone usa buy brahmi mg online buy premarin hong kong canadian online viagraplus generic uk paypal himcocid can you get addicted to strattera what does prevacid cure levitra super active reviews rumalaya forte for dogs buy viagra sublingual shop net bhagavad gita what is arjuna;s dilemma difference between viagra nizagara where do i luvox in mexico buy himplasia bulk regenon retard prospect lioresal prices cheap abilify 5mg online viagra se vende sin receta medica retino-a cream 0,05 non perscription countries ramipril alcohol side effects indian pharmacy aristocort seroxat withdrawal discount code for paxil i pill paxil website medication levitra viagra online billig kaufen atrovent pas cher accutane overnight mastercard online no prescription glaxosmithkline paxil lawsuit 2012 current price aristocort quais os efeitos do cloridrato de sertralina pharmacy one amman phone number buy female cialis for daily use coreg drug store online walmart pharmacy lithium brand amoxil no prescription does viagra still work with alcohol mentax over counter uk ketoconazole tablets for dogs side effects donde comprar xenical mexico online pharmacy brand levitra trimix gel side effects buy paxil in singapore bystolic and african american can order lopressor canada baytril 2.5 dosage rabbit voltaren 100mg side effects donde comprar haldol tinidazole longer duration of action lowest price propranolol order isoniazid lowest price buy generic cialis jelly with bonus buy liposafe perth australia buy tadacip 20 india best way to get high off pills cheap buy generic zyvox lithium online price can i order depakote online como se llama el viagra para mujer aciphex for sale usa atenolol 25 mg uses canadian online pharmacy for decadron original prednisolone buy online levitra sydney buy coreg tablets online buy vytorin 10 20 minocycline online meds dulcolax dosage rxlist pharmacy that sells floxin trandate on line for sale no script mylan-paroxetine 20 mg tablet kamagra rx sildenafil citrate lowest price imuran viagra professional canada pharmacy ventolin evohaler buy viagra professional buy australia phenazopyridine hydrochloride pyridium india sertraline hcl normal dosage warfarin alcohol inr user reviews on celexa order phenamax tablets albendazole generic for gout allopurinol side effects reliable pharmacy rx hcg super walmart alliance ohio valacyclovir 500 mg prices mail order desyrel orlistat lesofat price safe to buy generic strattera from uk get carbozyne las vegas lupus prednisone dosage buy zoloft from mexico online most common side effects of fluoxetine viagra sublingual pill canadian buy sumycin tetracycline pharmacy no prescription zyrtec discount canadian pharmacy purim side effects of penegra 25 malegra fxt tablet sale cheap generic vytorin chlamydia doxycycline treatment dosage what is celadrin pills used for maximum safe dose of motrin diamox for men sale in uk benicar hct for sale how to use cialis jelly avalide discounts viagra american express canada femara 100mg tablet to buy geriforte syrup in uk diabecon overnight delivery korean ginseng capsules (500mg) order non generic forzest discount program actos coupon cialis sales 2010 buy betapace bulk taking toprol for anxiety online cordarone india online medicine store in kolkata cialis tablet sale trandate prices usa canada drugs tadalis sx with prescription compare prices mevacor cipralex weight gain pill rx health order tenormin products buy doxycycline next day rhine company india can you get pregnant on danazol top 10 online aygestin sites paxil allegra with no rx where can i order live fireflies online cheap nimotop sale uk casodex pharmacy order mobic shortage 2012 buy cheap lithium over the counter aspirin brands can you get emsam over the counter use zyban coupon online safe zovirax no prescription viagra soft without a prescription from australia brand coumadin buy erection packs 3 pills online in the usa triamterene order to buy starlix cialis online contrassegno where to buy viagra in bangkok pfizer vgr100 щ‡‘ш‰В voltaren retard 100mg tablets generic reminyl buy canada metoprolol dose for performance anxiety why has florinef been discontinued aspirin a day not good how to get desyrel on line procardia online in usa bactrim f preУЇo where to lopid kamagra gold online in usa can you buy vasotec pick prescription viagra japanese nexium safe dose range generic norvasc usa cialis italiano sinemet dose reduction sinemet medication manufacturer vente de lipitor au quebec canada pharmacies online that sell citalopram dutas billig kaufen medicine paroxetine hcl is propecia for women zofran dose for nausea disfuncion erectil causas jovenes buy xalatan usa buy antivert vertigo tetracycline generic drug buy albendazole lowest price what is the generic substitute for lipitor tamoxifen price india aldactone dosage chf haridra australia pharmacy average cost of cymbalta topamax medication assistance program flagyl antibiotic pregnancy medrol over the counter existe un viagra para la mujer genuine buspar best price buy brand cialis without a subscription rumalaya gel medication nizoral now co uk buy tesco viagra voveran online legally mentat syrup for children taking augmentin in pregnancy lexapro com savings card xanax bars high buy lantus insulin my cat cheap dramamine india ginseng express canada viagra plus shortage 2012 order alphagan online in usa buy altace online from usa risperdal quicklet side effects effexor xr supplier in uk ephedraxin bonus pills order vytorin cheap accutane where can i buy it buy imitrex overseas lotrisone medicine pariet prescription buy elimite in australia discount canadian pharmacy procardia buy estrofem with paypal walgreens pharmacy discount medications buy rumalaya uk ondansetron mechanism of action buy synthroid online no prescription us best site to buy paroxetine zebeta online overnight shipping rosuvastatin calcium tablets ip buy atorlip-20 online no prescription us minocin trusted online drug stores in canada generic pills for isoptin kosovarja revista e fundit horoskopi risperdal maximum daily dose does medicare cover viagra 2010 order nolvadex australia los tucanes de tijuana la viagra lyrics effects of drinking alcohol while taking zithromax generic drug manufacturers in usa what does levothroid buy mg aricept online toradol tablets interactions buy singulair from india can u get viagra free on nhs buy saw palmetto mexican pharmacies cipa approved online canadian pharmacies cheapest chloroquine in the uk how much will hoodia cost to buy entocort comprare cialis generico online forum finasteride tablets ip 5mg cheap lamisil usa order cordarone online canada buy painkillers online forum free morning after pill london what type of medication is toradol pret atacand 8 mg order domperidone from canada side effects of azithromycin 500mg order non generic celebrex order medication online prescription how much does zyprexa zydis cost buy voveran sr without a script safe place order citalopram indian pharmacy rumalaya forte amitriptyline 10 mg nitrofurantoin shoppers drug mart prazosin phone orders where do i ditropan in canada drugstore band wiki canadian vasotec tablet zerit over the couter donde comprar cytotec en chile medicine prescription buy cholestoplex bromocriptine pregnancy class where can i buy cytotec over the counter zyrtec cost at target citalopram hbr 20 mg images iui clomid success rates 2011 med cab lipothin clozaril price india voveran pharmacy prices list canadian family physician college absolut vodka berri acai price overnight cod brand advair diskus tegretol side effects in men ditropan from canadian pharmacy buy anafranil next day ultra low dose minocin safe cialis professional no precription himcolin prix en pharmacie en france list of tesco stores selling depakote hctz 25 triamterene 37.5mg tab generic remeron pictures can order cleocin gel canada plendil tablets for purchase current price sominex difference between wellbutrin and generic bupropion what does biaxin do buy neo medrol uk is there a generic for zovirax cream super power viagra order acai berry juice cheap genuine bystolic online buy genuine cytotec uk can we trust liv 52 online augmentin bid 1000 mg tablet tadapox sale cialis with dapoxetine pharmacy examining boards of canada certification azithromycin and alcohol pfizer accutane buy online canada isotretinoin withdrawelmedicinesnoscript alli online overnight shipping flagyl generic alcohol comprar bystolic original en madrid we transfer it como se toma el amsa fast air new zealand lithium batteries accutane costco price do i need a prescription for baby zantac imuran tablets side effects zyvox 500 mg cost cheap kamagra gold india toradol reviews and dosage nitrofurantoin macro 100mg breastfeeding drug market order alesse safe plavix no prescription order minocin 50mg side effects of zyprexa medication cheapest price for nizoral shampoo buying cephalexin for dogs prometrium australia price generic unisom safe quibron-t suppositories buy clomid and prometrium infertility cost of xeloda in australia swanson shatavari reviews aldactone overnight very cheap nexium lotensin side effects weight gain buy actos paypal accepted what is epivir-hbv pills used for online forum order periactin overnight buy online himcolin generic what is metoprolol tartrate reglan without food stomach buy cialis online paypal pravachol online shipping what is aristocort ointment used for what does femara do for fertility cost of protonix at walgreens cipro and low blood sugar order mentat ds syrup overnight tetracycline antibiotics interfere with what types of adalat are there where to buy nizoral anti-dandruff shampoo generic mevacor no prescription can you order tadacip what is craigslist posting ventolin salbutamol bp triamterene brand order what are the side effects of thyroid medication cheap evecare pills leads vendor in usa for pharmacy purchase zestril online ultra low dose brahmi how to order valtrex online female cialis order online uroxatral for dogs buy floxin pharmacies fluoxetine cheap uk buy diakof hong kong syrup estrace online meds top pharmacy schools in canada valtrex online fast delivery order decadron online in usa what is alesse drugs what does fluoxetine treat order alphagan overnight can you buy viagra switzerland desyrel no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy why has retino-a cream 0,025 been discontinued where do i colchicine in usa accutane class action lawsuit 2010 tv live in italia canada order viagra jelly what does the drug ceftin do indocin indications usage depakote 1000 mg er how long does it take for sinemet to be effective best cialis soft prices discount 10mg prednisolone to buy in australia where to buy doxycycline with no prescription buy pilex for daily use buy ponstel in ireland pictures generic sinemet order adalat online with visa how much is arimidex tablets american express login to accounts post cycle therapy sinemet prinivil with no rx long term side effects of benicar express delivery online pharmacy levitra and pain medication generic aceon 4 mg differin prices usa can you get a buzz from baclofen is nexium better than aciphex order omnicef online with visa buy retino a cream 0 05 online viagra jelly phone orders no prescription saw palmetto fml forte daily use reviews levitra professional without prescription medication cost of renagel in australia order leukeran canada where propecia works arthrotec 75 clomid symptoms after ovulation levitra without prescription canada can you buy altace drugs ramipril is metformin generic for glucophage generic kamagra gold safe buying eldepryl in manchester guadalajara pharmacy algodones mexico cordarone pharmacy coupons to buy nizoral shampoo glyburide mechanism of action torsemide order canada order generic cholestoplex comprar vermox online canadian tadapox tablet heartburn medicine prevacid buy clonidine paypal accepted best price on levitra overseas pharmacy no prescription paroxetine keflex 500 mg price at walmart dulcolax reviews philippines canadian rx drugs legitimate what is voveran 50 used for buyclomidhereonline stats football365 xanax wiki can you buy over the counter order allegra where can i get wellbutrin sr cheap generic lexapro online geriforte syrup roche precio argentina purchase zetia cheap what does cephalexin treat danazol capsulas 100 mg para que sirve albendazole without prescription how much topamax to take for weight loss glucotrol xl without rx how to take medrol pack can you take kamagra oral jelly daily ordering metformin online low prices to buy orlistat online metformin glibenclamide spc prometrium canada price what is allopurinol made of lasix diuretic drug what is cleocin ovules used for prednisone tablets usp certificate buy nolvadex online us health trusted pharmacy tablets net to buy differin in uk cozaar tablets 40mg ibuprofen methocarbamol tablets diclofenac gel drug class what does promethazine codeine do to your body most reliable place to buy cordarone online what are the long term side effects of taking zoloft where to buy live yogurt culture depakote mail order generic zestoretic switzerland online pharmacy seroquel no prescription antidepressant celexa reviews actonel suppliers overseas over the counter viagra substitute compare natural dutas t capsules phenergan cheap price pariet 10 mg cost is it safe to order avodart free or low cost ditropan no rx brand advair diskus online atorlip-10 prescription only zyprexa side effects uk renagel canada drug store discover stratford children can you buy plavix over the counter nootropil canada overnight delivery grapefruit juice and high blood pressure medication very cheap xenical buy micardis hct generic best site to buy vasodilan female cialis mail order india zyloprim 100 mg generic avalide usa pharmacy over the counter motrin 800 ciprofloxacino para que sirve 500 mg can you order pulmicort without generic what does cymbalta 60 mg look like buy prozac fluoxetine wellbutrin for sale australia malarone tablets tesco pharmacy what aspirin is good for dogs nimotop dosage too high indinavir legal us furosemide for dogs overdose baclofen on line pharmacy erythromycin and drinking alcohol cheap generic suprax buy zofran online india what is viagra jelly medications buspar tablets effects where can i buy trileptal in canada buy hydrochlorothiazide 10 mg buy tegretol online usa herbal tea suppliers in india take 2 zyrtec pills allegra commercial kristen dalton side effects of lisinopril hctz 20 mg can you use cialis and viagra together prednisone side effects dogs i pill ciplox website order lipitor online uk amlodipine besylate tablets 10mg no prescription drugs buy antibiotics online canadian pharmacy bactrim ds purchase suprax online buy alesse hong kong isoniazid discount where to purchase betnovate price omnicef liquid best place buy keftab pct buy sumycin online in usa buy artane cheap pharmacy cod buy alesse online bula bactrim 200mg 40mg atarax pills what is it for mexican pharmacy no prescription finast best price for viagra professional zofran usage yasmin boland usa eurax ltd cirencester viagra jelly over counter uk where can your buy zovirax buy brand retin-a ge order cymbalta online in usa lotensin ordering no prescription suhagra shoppers drug mart trental medication cost celebrex dosage per day loratadine 10 mg and benadryl lithium medicine names comprar xbox live gold online chile levitra bayer 10 mg prezzo buy paroxetine online from india half price floxin buy vermox canada buy vermox patch purchase propranolol 20mg omnicef brand order arava israel bike ride luvox delivery london orlistat alli costco how long does it take for reglan to increase milk production diflucan next day delivery kamagra wiki nederlands erythromycin cream over the counter strattera brand order fluoxetine store buy reglan online india prescription drug albendazole can you take keftab daily buy fml forte cheap actonel combi dose ashwagandha uses medication buy aleve online pharmacy brand advair diskus max dose buy online no prescription cheap lexapro symptoms of too much synthroid medication can you buy xenical uk anafranil and luvox for ocd ethionamide uses medication doxycycline 100 mg to treat uti can i buy abilify online can i buy zofran over the counter uk avodart how to buy sialis lutaria larve can you get high off antivert bula cloridrato sertralina 25 mg voveran sr italiano pharmacy has best price paxil prevacid solutab delayed-release orally disintegrating tablets can i get nolvadex in australia hyzaar price india what is the generic name for ceftin allegra drugstore canadian leading online generic geriforte syrup buy canada cost of xenical in nz avodart rxlist what is lopressor used for how long erythromycin take to work acne what is the purpose of alliteration in poetry best otc inhaler comprar rumalaya portugal to buy cialis in uk order elocon lowest price nexium prospect 20mg diclofenac chirmis 10mg g gel bupropion reviews for men buy mircette online from usa avapro no prescription reviews brand viagra uk no prescription cheap genuine vasodilan online methotrexate shortage pill form amaryl tablets buy mail order hoodia leukeran mg tablet buy generic cialis sublingual with bonus side effects of lariam order flomax pills where can you get antabuse claritin side effects in women where can i buy viagra super active tablets brafix prices usa online pharmacy zestril bupropion india ampicillin pharmacy coupons what is nifedipine used for in pregnancy pharmacy expense report fast trimox deleviery buy leukeran online amazon what are the side effects of coming off abilify how much does zyrtec cost at walgreens proventil hfa 90 mcg inhaler coupon actoplus met canada head office bystolic comprare purchasing aciclovir online uk fertomid shelf life buy amitriptyline 10mg pharmacy elavil online in canada order suprax cheap procardia usa sale avodart drug classification does medicaid cover viagra safe diovan no prescription betnovate not working what does allegra fexofenadine symptoms where can i buy actoplus met online without a prescription lotensin buy canada accutane price suhagra pharmacy buy vermox generic viagra billig what is the drug atacand used for in what class of medicine does aspirin belong india viagra alternative canada atarax purchase ginette-35 cheap what is the generic for tricor 145 mg how to get viagra soft on line how to buy allied laptop wild grown ginseng price propranolol for migraines dosage tretinoin uk to buy actonel generico online triamterene hctz without prescription generic combivent for sale on line search recruitment crawley buy lithium over counter legitimate canadian drug companies rogaine 5 prescription coupon xenical prix en parapharmacie actonel medication online tadapox generic name elocom lotion hoodia diet pills in india prescription drug antivert geriforte over counter uk legal buy tinidazole online canada price of generic zyrtec d get slim acai in canada risperdal online forum health canada acticin depo medrol online promethazine dm syrup how much to take legal buy antidepressants online how long does it take for clonidine to work buy malegra dxt in india online aciphex fedex delivery buy cheap lowest priced flagyl er buy pamelor singapore what is the ipledge for accutane what does lamisil cure without a script cheap compazine buy wellbutrin sr with visa what is tinidazole made of better than acticin safe zanaflex no prescription penegra price india can i buy viagra from overseas diarex with paypal payment what is viagra for the brain vytorin purchase in canada no prescription common asthma triggers allegra d prices walgreens chloramphenicol tablets msds where to buy clozaril with mastercard speman online coupon code torsemide doctors online buy viagra without prescriptions approved pharmacies in amantadine without zyvox online from canada can order entocort canada genuine vytorin best price components healthy weight management plan is it illegal to order generic cymbalta trileptal coupons capoten perth australia how much does fluoxetine cost without insurance what is the generic name for fosamax ventolin hfa albuterol sulfate 90 mcg accutane cheap uk cheapest place to buy zebeta does rogaine work better than propecia buy nizoral shampoo 2 order cod cheap diarex birth control pills flonase can i buy clomid uk brand calan for sale florinef visa association deans pharmacy canada generic vs brand name lipitor albenza golf bergamo buy paroxetine tablets online over the counter tadalis sx generic available for zetia renagel sale buy cabgolin discount homeopathic medicine back pain toronto drug store pharmacy genuine minocycline 100mg how much does zithromax cost without insurance pulmicort for dogs buy tetracycline mode of action pdf roxithromycin sandoz cialis usage tips acquistare prandin in italia propranolol medication for anxiety propecia dosage recommended propecia usa sale can you buy prednisolone over the counter prograf online buy viagra dapoxetine online can buy fluoxetine online cheap genuine xenical online abilify medication interactions prescription tulasi shop net ic ciprofloxacin hcl 250 mg tab what is desyrel used to treat buy antivert capsules snorting skelaxin 800 mg high ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg side effects can i make roxithromycin low price plendil uk deltasone buy uk buy dostinex next day buy serm pct uk tetracycline for rosacea dosage revista veja on line grУЁtis erythromycin stearate tablets acne xenical online overnight cheap diamox uk trihexyphenidyl dosage administration proventil online pharmacy shipped to canada lisinopril (prinivil) 10 mg oral tablet canadian cheap buy glucotrol xl celebrex shortage cozaar generic side effects prednisone dosage for hives prazosin overseas bactroban without canada prescription drugs reviews proscar buy uk what does allegra doo for allergies how much will amitriptyline cost is there a generic for levaquin viagra tablets best price order prometrium pill buy cheap sarafem actos women buy sleeping pills without prescription minipress mg price telmisartan 40 mg hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg tablets generic haldol us indian pharmacy lotrisone buying propranolol online coming off zoloft brain zaps brand cialis 50mg tablets adalat cc generic equivalent cheap metformin medicine glucophage allegra versace boyfriend how to get rid of tetracycline stains on teeth donde comprar pletal gpchealth com where can i get atorlip-10 cost of astelin buy generic cialis online europe buy retin a micro gel mail order nymphomax can you buy levothyroxine online cheap Purchase methotrexate 10mg tablets buy synthroid canada buy pulmicort hong kong order cheapest cafergot interactions other drugs nymphomax echeck neo medrol acne lotion uk what are the side effects of the medication bystolic buying amaryllis how to get brand levitra drug generic for medrol natural water pills do they work are there generics for cialis can you buy requip over the counter in germany plavix drugs in age of personalized medicine is there a generic viagra 2010 deltasone 20 mg tablet doxycycline hyclate dosage pyridium no prescription canada apcalis sx tablets for sale brands propranolol india yasmin shopping mall baku albendazole cost comparison us pharmacy online viagra soft how long does it take for buspar to start working nizoral for dogs buy anxiety symptoms test buy calan singapore amoxil shortage buy prilosec doxycycline acne medication what is zyrtec medicine used for where can i buy primatene mist now order zentel online remeron without prescription canada where can i get zyloprim buy motilium greece geriforte syrup prices usa where can i order proscar buy alli 60mg online to buy shallaki buy detrol inhaler canada buy gasex discount where can i buy clomid online in the uk buy generic zyloprim online how much is revia tablets ralista next day buy diltiazem paypal buy finast visa best place to buy levothroid in canada azithromycin 250mg tablets 6-pack teva quiero comprar ventolin can buy prilosec canada does seroquel 100 mg get you high synthroid user reviews im decadron dosage what types of pain pills are there ceftin 500 mg price buspar noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy remeron comprare chloramphenicol ordering no prescription zoloft costco citalopram india what is the half life of prograf cost of generic allegra d buy tofranil online usa proventil side effects liver red korean ginseng dose viagra and poppers at the same time what is alavert tablets indian pharmacy buy trandate what is lisinopril-hctz 10/12.5mg lasuna online cheap buy actoplus met 11 mg purchase actoplus met on line in australia medrol for dogs buy best sex enhancement drugs in india where can i purchase keppra buy fucidin h online watch online pak news channel femcare shortage discount buspar otc levothroid generic or brand getting allopurinol in australia best drugstore powder foundation what is the difference between mircette and kariva lotrisone in canada actos 50mg tablets triamterene from usa pharmacy taking thyroid medication and iron atenolol 25 mg for anxiety buy kamagra jelly uk generic cialis scam ventolin evohaler how to use meloxicam for cats uk what is the brand name for hydrochlorothiazide combivent nebules indication buy meclizine seroquel tablets they how effective is a second round of accutane zestril spain coversyl 4mg 5mg are ventolin and salbutamol inhalers the same buy imitrex 20 propecia generic costco i pill zestoretic website diuretic buy mentat uk where to buy isoniazid online without rx buy venlor visa lloyds pharmacy head office address metformin pcos weight loss tips order ventolin tablets forum buy phenergan online order buy cheap viagra generic online where cane i buy alligator tail viagra levitra and cialis price comparison buy diabecon no prescription abilify cost appareil photo numerique batterie lithium pas cher canadian pharmacy without prescrition mastercard aciphex over the counter reflux disease ivermectin horse wormer vermox mebendazole 500 order prevacid lowest price purchase acai berry cheapest cordarone in the uk buy lipitor with buy zovirax online australia no prescription betneval pommade sans ordonnance what do valtrex pills look like buy actos mexican pharmacies what are the side effects of methotrexate treatment chlamydia doxycycline dosage prescription cipro i.v zyprexa and sleeping pills lexapro prescription online generic flomax generic tegretol 100 mg efectos secundarios buy evecare with paypal craigslist usa search tempest organic pharmacy hangover pills online tinidazole overnight delivery buy valtrex online no prescription mycelex-g online cheap vardenafil 20 mg dosage where to buy celebrex uk where to buy flagyl with amex uroxatral prescription only better than tretinoin 0,025 cheap combivent entocort enema colitis buy anacin from canada what is the active ingredient in zantac 150 buy exelon 3 mg wild ginseng prices ky india pyridium price is it safe to order zyprexa plavix coupons 2012 order delivery diovan cod best prices viagra online guaranteed cheap malegra fxt usa can you buy beconase aq over the counter in germany muscle relaxant tablets in india lowest price for viagra online valtrex generic coupons buying aspirin with codeine in canada buy neurontin with no rx fluconazole tablets prescribing information low cost amantadine online view topic amitriptyline through coversyl side effects cough antivert maximum dose best price leukeran levaquin.com how much does lisinopril cost at walgreens cost of probalan without insurance lisinopril 40 mg dose what is insulin dependent diabetes viagra commercial blues song safe frumil no prescription norvasc online store fluoxetine overseas plendil without prescription hyzaar shortage 2012 doxycycline hyclate dosage sinus infection actos dosage amount generic fincar uk paypal finasteride 5 mg hair loss women voltaren from mexico what does snorting dramamine do awam ki adalat shahi syed eye infections from heroin national socialist movement united kingdom antibiotics online sales birth control pills rumalaya forte where purchase midamor pyridium for sale online buy lamictal 200mg augmentin duo for children norvasc for men in usa suprax price to buy amoxil efectos secundarios del estrotab buy depakote online canada no prescription accutane and alcohol consumption combivent inhaler for asthma how long does it take for chlamydia symptoms to appear in men acivir pills pill shortage roxithromycin side effects long term use flomax precio mexico children;s motrin chewable tablets recall discount viagra canadian pharmacy promethazine pills 25 mg help clomid cost cvs buy cholestoplex diabetes y disfuncion erectil nitroglycerin spain buy voltaren canada cialis sale cheap how much is adderall prescription without insurance amitriptyline buy usa sale retino-a cream 0,05 lansoprazole pregnancy nhs buy ephedrine caffeine aspirin uk what does synthroid treat birth control pills lasix ordering robaxin here in canada paroxetine rx list best place to buy tinidazole in usa erection pills at gnc worldwide pharmacy carafate is zetia a prescription drug seroquel where to buy in canada common side effects of bactrim ds non prescription ed drugs 2016 birth control oral lamisil side effects viagra sites atorlip-5 generico italiano celebrex delivery uk aspirin without a script online prescriptions in australia generic viagra can you get midamor over the counter atacand blood pressure medicine buy cholestoplex bulk billig ventolin online kaufen generic pills for moduretic generic levitra plus overnite shipping can you buy cipro over the counter in mexico cymbalta from mexico cefixime pharmacy order aristocort overnight shipping cheap novartis valsartan and hydrochlorothiazide best site get vytorin mexican pharmacy no prescription benadryl ciprofloxacin health canada warnings ventolin salbutamol tablet dosage lozol medicine children can flonase cause weight gain cialis soft fast mexico where to buy haldol in canada safely order cafergot tablets altace mg price how to use benzac wash 10 us pharmacy online actos doxazosin now buy actoplus met tablets uk generic serophene uk paypal long term side effects of aygestin where can i buy benemid ranitidine order canada what is korean ginseng used for mirapex delivery london diovan 40 mg cost st nirvana herbal slimming tablets can i take birth control pills with prednisone can you get venlor buy prograf 1 mg prozac online canada trimox delivered to your home chest pain from propranolol famvir tablets from buy cheap kamagra oral jelly pills buy chloramphenicol without a prescription from canadian pharmacy cheap zyprexa online asacol 400 mg discount what is ponstel tablets is there a generic available for nexium metronidazole in pregnancy and breastfeeding cytotec for abortion dose lexapro pill shop discount code hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg triamterene 37.5 mg quickest trazodone digoxin tablets online buy grifulvin v without rx valacyclovir tablets uk low price atorlip-5 uk how to order erythromycin online
Home Biz of Baseball - Interviews The Economics of Sports: An Interview with Roger Noll

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 513 guests online

Atom RSS

The Economics of Sports: An Interview with Roger Noll PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 22
PoorBest 
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 23 November 2009 00:00

Roger NollThe biggest story in all of sports (and beyond) over the last year and a half has been the influence of the economy on sports properties. The NFL, NBA, NHL, and Major League Baseball have not been impervious to the lashings that every sector in business has taken, and that has trickled down the fan, who has had to decide whether to attend games, or save their money.

With the recession playing such a key role in professional sports, sports economics has moved from the background to front page news.

Roger Noll, professor of economics emeritus at Stanford University and a Senior Fellow at the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, has been one to have their pulse on economics, including sports.

He’s been the author or co-author of twelve books and over three hundred articles and reviews. His primary research interests include technology policy; antitrust, regulation and privatization policies in both advanced and developing economies; the economic approach to public law (administrative law, the judiciary, and statutory interpretation); and yes, the economics of sports and entertainment.

Staff author Pete Toms caught up with Noll recently for a broad ranging interview that runs from leagues as a single entity; competitive balance in MLB after the Yankees winning the World Series, which includes his takes on salary caps in U.S. pro sports; possible relocation of franchises ranging from the Athletics to the Niners; the debate over public subsidies for stadium development; and much more – Maury Brown

Select Read More for the interview with Roger Noll

Pete Toms for the Business of Sports Network: You are amongst a group of sports economists who recently filed an Amicus Curiae brief with the Supreme Court in American Needle. At stake in this case is the status of professional sports leagues as single entities. This same issue was at the core of Jim Balsille's recently failed attempt to purchase and relocate the Phoenix Coyotes without the permission of the NHL. Why are you and the other sports economists opposed to single entity status for these leagues? Why did the NFL ask the Supreme Court to rule on this matter when the lower courts had already sided with them? Why should sports fans be interested in this case? If the Supreme Court rules that single entity status does not extend into the realm of labor relations (as has been speculated), is the case of less importance? Would you care to handicap the outcome?

Roger Noll: The opposition to single entity status is partly that leagues are not "single entities" (organizations that have a unity of purpose) and partly that leagues should not be exempt from any specific antitrust complaint without having to prove that centralizing decisions in the league is more efficient than decentralizing them with teams, given that the former eliminates competition.

The NFL did not appeal the decision -- American Needle appealed. When they did, the NFL sought to broaden the case. Having been found to be a single entity with respect to licensing caps that bear team logos, they seek to be declared a single entity with respect to everything. Obviously this would be a great result for the NFL as it would reverse fifty years of adverse antitrust decisions.

Sports fans should be interested because the outcome will affect whether players can be free agents or the conditions under which the NFL (or any other league) can control the location of teams.

The narrower the decision of the Supreme Court, the less important is the case. I don't think team logo caps are a very big deal, although even here I do not think that the courts were correct in exempting the NFL from having to prove that their joint licensing arrangement was efficient and did not harm consumers.

I do not handicap the Supreme Court.

Toms: The World Series victory of the New York Yankees has baseball's chattering classes in an uproar over the state of competitive balance in MLB. Ostensibly (according to some), MLB has increased revenue sharing and implemented a competitive balance tax (aka the luxury tax) in their efforts to achieve greater on field parity. Some Sports Economists argue that the real purpose of these initiatives is to suppress player compensation. The same proponents of this argument believe that these same league policies contribute nothing to competitive balance (this argument is presented in the aforementioned brief submitted to The Supreme Court in American Needle). Can you explain this logic to baseball fans in Pittsburgh and Kansas City who believe that the key to fielding competitive teams in their markets is some combination of a salary cap/floor, increased revenue sharing, more punitive payroll taxes etc.?

Noll quoteNoll: The only way to have equally balanced teams is to ban trades and sales of players and to have periodic drafts of managers, coaches and directors of player personnel. The methods that leagues use to create balance have been shown to have little or no effect on the distribution of quality among teams. The logic behind it is that it is not in the interests of owners as well as players to have balanced competition. If all teams were of the same strength, total league revenues would go up if the best player in KC were traded for the worst player in NYC. In a regime of salary caps and no free agency, the KC owner will be richer if he sells his underpaid star to NY.

Check out last year's NHL standings. The NHL has the toughest salary cap in all sports. Was the league more balanced (e.g., the gap between the best and worst teams in W-L records) smaller than before the cap was established? The NHL cap reduced payrolls, but even if the payroll were zero in the poorest drawing markets, those teams would still lose money.

Toms: Is the era of the salary cap in US pro sports nearing its end? There is much conjecture that many NFL owners (both large and small market) would prefer to operate without a salary cap/floor. Increasingly, NFL teams are finding ways to circumvent both the cap and the floor, contributing to greater on field competitive imbalance this season. The NHL forewent an entire season in their successful battle with the NHLPA to implement a salary cap. Many NHL observers argue that the cap in the NHL has caused more problems than it has resolved. Sun Belt franchises have incurred large payroll increases as the salary floor has risen, meanwhile the revenues of these franchises haven' kept pace. The salary cap has historically been favored by owners because it limits player compensation yet the only uncapped league - MLB - is paying out the smallest percentage of league revenues to its players. With the CBAs in all the sick and ball leagues potentially expiring in 2011, are salary caps on the way out?

Noll: You misread the NFL. They are willing to let the current CBA expire and have one uncapped year in return for imposing on the players the old system (no free agency, no agents) -- if the Supreme Court declares them to be a single entity. The players would never agree to a CBA that eliminates free agency, so enduring an uncapped year and imposing it is the only option available to the owners.

The MLB comparison is not quite right because it does not take into account the amounts MLB pays to support minor league teams.

Obviously, if leagues are single entities, they do not need a CBA and can impose restrictions on players that vastly reduce their salaries. A cap is not important in this regime. But I doubt that this will happen.

Toms: If economics is fundamentally the study of how markets allocate resources, what impact will the expansion of the amateur draft internationally have on the player/labour market? Some argue that the introduction of the draft to Puerto Rico has directly resulted in a diminished number of players being recruited from that country. Those same people are concerned that the introduction of a player draft to the Dominican Republic will have the same effect. There is also an argument that a draft in Latin America will not result in lower player acquisition costs for MLB, that in fact, the present buscone system is very efficient. Assuming that MLB successfully negotiates these changes with the MLBPA in the next CBA negotiations, what long term effects do you foresee?

Noll: I do not think that this is terribly important. A few foreign players will be drafted high, but the rest will not, and after the first few rounds draft picks are not paid very much, just as most teenagers signed from the Caribbean are not paid very much. I see no reason to believe that many fewer will be signed -- and even if that happens, it will not matter very much because the vast majority of foreign minor leaguers never make the majors.

Toms: On the subject of revenue-sharing in MLB. In 2007 you told The Biz of Baseball, "Under the old agreement, teams in low-revenue markets were rewarded financially for making their teams weaker." MLB attempted to address that problem by changing the revenue sharing marginal tax rates in the current CBA. Have those changes resulted in greater incentives for small revenue franchises to field competitive teams? On the same subject, Commissioner Selig is sometimes criticized for not disciplining clubs that do not invest all of their revenue sharing proceeds in their on the field product. (I.E. Their revenue sharing receipts exceed their big league payroll). Is that a fair criticism?

Noll quoteNoll: The new revenue sharing formula is much better in giving teams more incentive to win. And as for the "criticism" by the Commissioner, it has no effect. The point is that paying a lot for players is a losing proposition in several markets. As witnessed by salary floors in other sports, forcing people to spend money does not really do very much.

Toms: Are there any US markets without MLB capable of supporting a franchise? Put another way, can Tampa Bay or Oakland make a credible argument that if they don't get public cooperation in constructing a new baseball stadium that they will relocate their franchise? What would have to happen before a third or fourth MLB franchise set up shop in New Jersey or Brooklyn? Does this bring us back to the significance of American Needle?

Noll: Yes, there are markets where teams would succeed if given a free stadium, and the threat to move is credible. Even in the NHL, the threat to move is credible if the league would let Sunbelt teams move to Canada. To get another team in NYC requires bribing the Yankees and the Mets, just as the Mets bribed the Yankees to let them in when the Mets were created. The status of franchise location antitrust in MLB is uncertain – there has never been a case that was litigated to completion. Thus, American Needle may not be important for MLB.

But more generally, the two Raiders cases do say that leagues cannot block relocation just to protect the team that is already there from competition. If the NFL wins its argument before the Supreme Court, the Raiders decision will be reversed.

Toms: At present, the MLBPA does not share in the wealth generated by MLBAM. Maury Brown and Jayson Stark, amongst others, have speculated that at some point the MLBPA will request that this changes. Also, this year saw MLB launch the MLBN, where again the players do not share in the profits. Both media enterprises are considered very successful by the sports business pundits. MLBAM was rumoured to be valued in excess of $2 billion in 2005 by Goldman Sachs when an IPO was reportedly under consideration. MLBN, at inception, launched into 50 million homes. (A record amount for a new cable channel.) How important are these media companies to the overall financial health of MLB and do you foresee the players asking to share in the profits soon?

Noll: The players do share -- if team revenues go up, so do salaries. I do not think that MLBPA should given this much priority. Anything that increases revenues will be good for the players.

I also suspect that league-controlled new media entities are likely to be a bad idea. Leagues do not generally do a good job running them. Remember the Baseball Network? They could make more money licensing it to someone else.

Toms: MLB attendance declined approximately 7% in 2009 from 2008. Twenty-two of 30 franchises reported a decline in attendance. There was also widespread ticket discounting and sponsorship revenues were under pressure due to the recession and the collapse of the banking and auto sectors (traditionally the two most important sponsorship categories). At the same time, MLB COO Bob DuPuy has stated that revenues were flat in 2009. Are the reported flat revenues a sole result of the increased dollars generated by the two new ballparks in NYC or are there other factors?

Noll quoteNoll: I have not seen a breakdown of the revenues, so I do not really know the answer. But in-stadium revenues are less than half of all revenues, and TV audiences are up (which happens in a recession).

I am not sure that "price discounts" are the full story. If the discounts are off of higher prices, the net effect could even be positive. Economists have always wondered why pro sports teams do not engage in more price variability than they do. It makes sense economically to have the sticker price be the price that is appropriate for the weekend, and to offer discounts for week days, especially if the opposition is weak.

Toms: Credible media sources (including Liz Mullen at The SportsBusiness Journal) have reported that the NFL has presented a proposal to the NFLPA which includes expense credits that owners will deduct from revenues that determine the amount of the salary cap. The owners have contended all along that their principal problem with the current CBA is that the players do not share in the risk and costs associated with constructing new stadiums. The same proposal includes a rookie wage scale, as opposed to the current rookie cap. Both sides are refusing to comment on the media reports, fuelling speculation that the proposal is under serious consideration. Do you see this proposal forming the foundation of a new agreement? Why is a rookie compensation a labor issue in both the NFL and MLB? Will the NFL and the NFLPA agree to a CBA before March and avoid the much talked about uncapped 2010?

Noll: I have no idea what is going on in the NFL-NFLPA bargaining. The "expense credit" idea is just another way to cut salaries. I doubt that this makes much sense because of the differences among teams in the expenses that they could deduct. Tighter controls on wages for drafted players are much more likely because that does not hurt existing NFLPA members. And the reason that rookies salaries are on the agenda is that wages are a mandatory issue for bargaining -- if either side wants to discuss them, the other side is required to engage.

Finally, I have no insight about whether a CBA will be agreed by March, but I have strong doubts. If the NFLPA believes that it must settle for a bad deal, it will wait to get one good year out of it.

Toms: I put together a piece for The Biz of Baseball in March entitled Sports Marketing is the Recession's New Whipping Boy. The political and populist backlash against corporate sponsorship of professional sports (particularly against banks that received TARP money) was severe. CitiBank and the Mets were reviled in the NY press for their naming rights deal. At the last minute, BofA backed out of a major sponsorship deal for the new Yankee Stadium. Barney Frank expressed outrage in a series of interviews and TV appearances. The PGA suffered. Jerry Jones opened his new football stadium without a naming rights deal. There are countless other examples. Recently there are reports that sports marketing dollars are rebounding. Do you see that trend in your research? Will the sports marketing dollars return in the same levels previous to the financial meltdown or has there been a more permanent shift?

Noll: I do not know whether sponsorship revenues and other revenues from corporations have started to rebound, but I see no reason to believe that they will not rebound as soon as executives believe that the recession is over.

Toms: Many sports economists (including yourself) have long been vocal in their opposition to investment of public dollars in stadiums/arenas constructed to house professional sports teams. I sense that there has been a shift in public attitudes towards these initiatives, that more and more people agree that the economic benefits promised by proponents of these projects are false. In turn, we have seen a change in the tactics of stadium proponents, where arenas/stadiums are promoted as the key component in urban renewal projects aka entertainment districts. Governments and developers have also become more sophisticated in how they funnel public money into these projects, often now via financing. (I.E. Tax Increment Financing aka TIFs and Payments in Lieu of Taxes aka PILOTS) What does your data reveal, as a percentage, is there less public money being invested in these projects as opposed to 10 or 20 years ago? Do you think the Sports Economists have had an impact in influencing public policy in this area?

Noll quoteNoll: Yes, public subsidies of sports teams are declining. Yes, sports economics research probably has had some effect. But, the bigger effect is that state and local governments are on the verge of bankruptcy. Look for some revival in subsidies in a couple of years.

Toms: A hot topic in the baseball media has been collusion. Michael Weiner has been making some thinly veiled and very public allusions on the matter. Those who argue that there is evidence of collusion claim that the diminished demand for free agent players precedes the recession by a couple of seasons. These same people will point to stable (and historically high) industry revenues. On the other side is the argument that there has been a fundamental change in how the management of the clubs values veteran talent. The rationale being that the now industry wide emphasis on objective analysis has resulted in less demand for veterans and increased demand for young players. As well, there is a belief that veteran players are less productive in the latter stages of their careers in the post steroids era. Do you see any evidence of collusion in the MLB free agent market the past handful of seasons? Whether there is, or isn't, collusion, what are the chances that the MLBPA could successfully argue their position before an arbitrator?

Noll: I would need to see the books of the teams to know whether collusion is plausible. The alternative explanations need to be tested using real data on salary budgets, revenues, and other costs. The speculation that career are shorter due to steroids is clearly not true, but the notion that teams have over-valued older players in the free agent market may be true -- but research has not yet proved it.

Toms: Being a resident of the Golden State, please give us a California sports business update. There is a lot of speculation that Ed Roski will attract an NFL franchise to the City of Industry. (a suburb of Los Angeles) All three California NFL clubs are agitating for new stadiums, with Santa Clara courting the 49ers. Is the NFL coming to the City of Industry and if so, will it be a franchise currently in the state or one from outside? Might the Raiders and 49ers have to agree to share a stadium in order to see a new one constructed? What is the future of the Chargers? Are the Oakland A's moving to San Jose? Why has California been largely absent (SF has AT&T park but it was mostly privately financed) from the nationwide trend of new stadium construction?

Noll: I think it is doubtful that Santa Clara will approve a stadium for the 49ers -- could happen, but probably won't. I also do not think the Raiders are likely to get a new stadium anywhere in the Bay Area because they have become unpopular as an organization. And I doubt that the two teams will share a stadium because they probably would prefer to move.

[City of] Industry is a better chance, although the legal challenges will drag on for a long time.

The A's are more likely to move to San Jose than the 49ers to Santa Clara. But they still must bribe the Giants for the territory. Politically San Jose is more favorable for a stadium subsidy, but it will still be a fight.

California is not "absent" from stadiums -- remember the financial disaster that is San Diego? The important point is that in the Bay Area and LA, voters have been rejecting these things fairly regularly. We will see how long this lasts, but the 2006 votes in Pasadena and Sacramento were before the recession hit.

Toms: At the Baseball Winter Meetings, the fate of Marvin Miller's candidacy for the Hall of Fame is up again, and the media has been discussing it (see Maury Brown’s take). There is agreement that Mr. Miller had a seismic impact on MLB but there is debate about the worthiness of the changes he fought for. From a fan perspective, was Marvin Miller a positive force in MLB?

Noll quoteNoll: First, I am not sure that the appropriate criterion is whether Marvin benefited fans. Once one goes beyond players and managers (where the issue is playing field success), the criteria should include owners, players, and the business side of the sport.

Beyond this, Marvin Miller is a giant in the history of baseball. He is responsible for the existence of a strong union and thereby the existence of free agency. One cannot imagine writing a history of baseball in the second half of the 20th Century in which he would not play a central role. And the argument that he caused damage to the sport is obviously false -- all of the predictions of disaster at the time of the McNally-Messersmith case have been proven by time to be false. Most of the complaints about the way that baseball was affected by transferring more power to the players are based on false premises about how the business side of baseball works. Of course, some owners would be a lot richer if baseball's institutions were the same now as they were in 1965.

Keeping him out of the Hall of Fame for this reason would be a travesty.


  • Interview conducted by Pete Toms
  • Editied by Maury Brown


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?