plavix drugs cheapest nizoral shampoo online buy sildenafil citrate tablets canadian prescriptions mail vermox mg buy how to take combivent proventil prescription assistance program buy digoxin without a script american voveran sr overseas foreign pharmacy legit how much does prandin cost exelon share price history bactrim on line low price estrace uk low dose amitriptyline weight generic liv paypal is there any ayurvedic medicine for abortion online pharmacies south africa phexin pas cher zebeta to buy in australia bromocriptine mesylate tablets stieva-a side effects buy bentyl 20 mg safe place order ophthacare propecia legal us cheap clozaril usa online forum prednisolone cod next day metformin canada product monograph luvox tablets dosage usa pharmacy cialis brand levitra sale cialis pill best site to buy dilantin cheap acticin us order aceon tablets buy cabgolin 0.5 mg dilantin uses and side effects common birth control pills brand names best price for real cymbalta best india online pharmacy dostinex bonus pills cephalexin online store doxycycline tablets and alcohol ciplox generico online mirapex shopping how to take proventil mg flovent coupons gsk menosan online pharmacy uk singulair 10mg wiki fucidin crema 2 i pill allopurinol website allopurinol refill pack percentage serious side effects accutane where do i buy luvox going off strattera side effects valtrex herpes simplex keratitis buy acivir pills us drugs approved avodart vs propecia tesco slimming aid tablets vytorin for men sale in uk zyprexa 5 mg tablet how to buy with paypal with credit card missed sustiva dose noroxin uk buy triamcinolone acetonide cream usp 0.1 ringworm lozol generic wikipedia drugs buy abilify 20 mg prescription viagra cialis levitra from canada cabgolin legal in england minocin ordering no prescription hytrin spain how to by cordarone online fluconazole over the counter us what kind of medicine is zyprexa buy generic claritin d 24 hour side effects of abilify withdrawal albendazole pill shortage no prescription zestril ortho tri cyclen on line in the canada diabecon canada prescription medrol dose nitrofurantoin macro 100mg cialis store will etodolac get you high exelon capsules can you take brand viagra daily buy cleocin gel 40 albuterol sulfate side effects babies atorlip-5 mg tablet where does synthroid come from flagyl to treat diarrhea dogs cheap levitra from canada nizoral shampoo shelf life buy kamagra online india pharmacy buy femcare in singapore buy penicillin online no prescription uk order aristocort 120 mg buy kamagra gold 15mg online better than ashwagandha meclizine pas cher italie ultra low dose viagra plus lexapro 20 mg cost walmart betapace generic 2013 drugs what does too much zyrtec do provera fast usa cheap accutane uk what is cozaar drugs canadian criminal code controlled drugs and substances act can buy accutane online viagra cialis trial packs caverta cost of viagra in indian market viagra tablet price in dubai prescription estrace what kind of medicine is biaxin birth control pills emsam where to buy spacers for inhalers atacand 8 mg prospect buy remeron 100 1 corinthians 13 nrsv metformin rxp do you need rx betapace mas'c' elocom ulotka houses for sale in pinebrook artane buy cymbalta mg online for what is saw palmetto called in hindi can cialis and viagra be taken together buy mentax online from usa lopid order in the us zyrtec from india hydrea usa tenormin pills buy micardis 80 mg cost how much is a prescription of adderall without insurance propecia safe take what is bismuth citrate used for can we trust himcocid online no prescription antibiotics for cats requip drug store online zovirax pump reviews ethionamide generic reviews buy lopid tablets us pharmacy mexico lipothin what is norvasc nizoral 2 no prescription what part of the scalp does propecia work on long term side effects of aciclovir herpes zoster valtrex dosage buy amaryllis plants prescription accutane comprar kamagra gold original en madrid acheter prednisolone ordering grifulvin v here in canada how long does it take for cipro to cure a uti side effects of reglan in babies brafix tablets uses is erythromycin ointment over the counter cost of allegra d at walmart cost of depo provera planned parenthood what are the side effects of pulmicort buy cialis in usa online claritin reditabs c10 generic moduretic safe blue pill red pill tumblr best site for prilosec topamax vs generic for weight loss walmart actos prices cheap aciphex 20 mg diovan on the internet overnight generic buy metoclopramide online atacand plus doses ambien cr side effects fertility pills for women in south africa buy zyban without rx routine use of mebendazole in pregnancy will alcohol affect zithromax zoloft price per pill celexa 10mg for anxiety what is metformin pills high dose lasix in acute renal failure cheapest actoplus met paypal does medrol dose pack help back pain cheap rx glasses nyc are hungry man meals healthy tronchetti provera 1920s 100 mg zyvox where do i buy viagra over the counter best betapace prices buy carafate online usa desyrel recommended dose ordering yasmin seroquel xr drug classification hydrocortisone tablets 10mg side effects buy zestril online india estradiol gel weight gain images remeron pills purchase code supplied by value pharmaceuticals hay viagra natural para mujeres where to buy feldene with mastercard methotrexate 10 mg week rumalaya forte online bestellen lioresal next day delivery allopurinol pills asacol mail order india buying luvox in manchester how much does augmentin cost order lipitor online without rx buy pariet inhaler canada find a vet vipps online pharmacy buy amaryl 20 how much is generic singulair at walmart chloramphenicol australia price canadadian healthcare reviews coumadin pills color necesito comprar cytotec en venezuela ms in pharmacy in canada universities parlodel online usa diprosone lotion for hair growth buy nolvadex 200 angela women;s ginseng usa billig kytril online kaufen order plavix without prescription healthcare alliance prescription card scam can you buy abilify over the counter in germany purchase effexor xr on line in uk best pain meds for shingles clomid without prescription serevent pills sweat diclofenac paracetamol tablets india buy phenamax boots aldactone online with out prescription relafen 750 reviews generic plavix us zyrtec d and alcohol buy betapace mg order v-gel online how to use imitrex nasal clomid supplier in uk levothroid lawsuit buy amitriptyline have no prescription cardura medicine isoniazid uk online buy bupropion sr india ordering minomycin buy liposafe online from usa buy indian viagra online uae mevacor maximum dosage how to by albenza online keflex 500mg used for online pharmacy without prescriptions reviews minocin order by phone buy protonix quick what are the side effects of long term use of citalopram isoptin tablets buy buy cozaar online with mastercard cheap luvox online cheapest place to buy met rx deltasone reviews and dosage anafranil drugstore buy benemid with paypal what type of seizures is keppra used for medicine augmentin duo forte how to buy bentyl terbinafine 250mg side effects prednisolone 5mg tablets asthma purchase hydrochlorothiazide in mexico como comprar livros eletronicos na amazon buy allegra d generic indian viagra name is it safe to order suhagra lopid tablets for purchase brand advair diskus without prescription canada where can i get pills for chlamydia is mail order nitroglycerin safe what for glycomet tablets used what is the daily dosage for propecia generic aricept price bactrim 480 mg how can i get doxycycline over the counter amantadine 100 review long term side effects of elocon buy furosemide 500mg online aristocort online forum low dose birth control mircette glucotrol xl maximum dosage furosemide spain viagra generika per nachnahme bestellen hoodia shoppers drug mart crestor interaction with other drugs twitter alli trippy where is lithium found in afghanistan flonase 100mg cheep prednisone for dogs dosage for allergy sex pills for women over the counter cost of emsam purchase rogaine 5 online does alli work diet pill discount coupons price of femara tablets zyprexa for men sale in uk erectile dysfunction viagra generic for zetia 10 mg ethionamide on line no script tricor from europe levitra without prescription walmart cheap viagra sublingual 40 mg retin a 0.1 janssen cilag order meds online no prescription florida trandate fish antibiotics doxycycline tamsulosin 0.4mg capsule can you buy zovirax tablets over the counter discount elimite discount no prescription order carafate online non prescription cytotec much does generic accutane cost canada drugs avalide with prescription without purchase abilify online us online pharmacy no prescription femcare shatavari shelf life low dose cialis safe buy lamisil 50 donde puedo comprar hydrochlorothiazide donde comprar viagra en colombia buy aricept in australia best place to order nolvadex in us generic drug for avapro when will diovan hct become generic discount alphagan tung shueh pills cow;s head brand buy keftab online from usa overnight 500mg brand amoxil accutane class action lawsuit canada can you get high off omnicef target discount pharmacy card order zoloft online no prescription with a visa fluoxetine online ordering order ciprofloxacin 500 mg luvox dosage forms alli 84 price comparison que es sulfato de amantadina buy lexapro 200 alli over the counter diet pill how to import revia no prescription needed kamagra purchase lamictal coupons epilepsy zithromax 100mg tablet what is the safest generic viagra canada buy accutane without prescription order nizoral online no presctiption tetracycline price online viagra prescription generic uk paypal ashwagandha can you get high off doxycycline hyclate 100mg can you buy domperidone usa compare prices zestoretic buy snovitra super power australia albendazole where can i buy it citalopram how long do they take to work genuine trazodone 100mg comprar evista en argentina can u buy alli in canada champix and alcohol side effects quanto costa elocon pomata citalopram pas cher endep side effects australia what does motrin do cheap plavix 75mg online cialis on line pricing in canada buy tramadol online overnight delivery buy doxazosin with visa canadian lamictal tablet ditropan 100 review betamethasone buy norvasc singapore how to buy hydrochlorothiazide in london buy lithium 5 cialis super active drug in usa pharmacy can you buy over the counter in australia zovirax online como comprar levitra sin receta retin-a 0,05 buy uk viagra canada head office prices tadapox without script clomid usa no prescription finally erection medication where can i buy abortion pill in the philippines lioresal 40mg Purchase cozaar 12.5 mg comprar capoten en argentina resources for vytorin amoxicillin pregnancy dosage revatio vs viagra cost pletal 50 mg 60 tablet fast cefixime delivery stieva-a 0.050 para que sirve what drug category is norvasc compazine generics levoxyl side effects como usar serophene 50 mg glimepiride 4 mg picture erythromycin discount no prescription aleve generic brand cheap viagra pills generic generic name for sarafem sawyer permethrin uk lisinopril on line purchase risperdal tablets uses propecia generico in italia buy venlor online cheapest price on bupropion side effects of voveran d buy cardizem mg online for drug market order lithium asthma inhaler with prescription motilium and breastfeeding zofran 100 canadian elimite cream best price female viagra purchasing compazine online uk torsemide pas cher italie sominex limited india order non generic benzac starting topamax at 100 mg western drug gyne-lotrimin buying pulmicort in manchester uses of tegretol tablets cost of cialis south africa mail order generic aceon albenza capsules sildenafilo teva 50 mg best piracetam dosage kamagra chewable online pharmacy uk how to order rumalaya forte online low price cialis professional uk purchase tetracycline cheap antibiotics cheap crestor united states kamagranow.co.uk where to buy cheap generic lipothin price increase emsam can order premarin canada penegra 50 generic colospa buy canada anafranil prescriptions order aricept cheap augmentin dds dosage for children lortab 5 vs 7.5 to buy maxaman in uk cialis jelly suppliers overseas best place buy hydrochlorothiazide buy norvasc online reviews buy dutas mg online buy nootropil 1200 mg buy dramamine liquid depakote online pharmacy shipped to canada cleocin medication online ampicillin stock concentration vermox for dogs buy what is best for back pain aleve or advil retino-a cream 0,05 where to get low combivent comprar keftab portugal buy cheap prescription abilify online overseas pharmacy no prescription sinequan levitra plus pharmacy vente de flagyl er au quebec albuterol sulfate inhalation aerosol side effects robaxin online pay paypal florida minomycin dapoxetine tablets in india ovary pain after ovulation on clomid sale probalan mgb prinivil express canada buy generic differin gel elocom buy uk desyrel drug schedule levofloxacin generic for levaquin dosage fluconazole thrush how to order wellbutrin sr online legal buy amoxil online canada levlen coupons buy amantadine perth australia canadian pharmacy cephalexin metoclopramide lowest price triamterene india legal buy capoten online canada pcos clomid weight gain prednisona dosis adultos ginseng next day delivery vytorin weight gain buy prednisone online mexico no prescription nizagara capsules buy propecia online canada no prescription capoten sold over counter pfizer zyvox assistance rsvp program what does generic bentyl look like paxil cost in canada valacyclovir hcl generic generic from fluoxetine purchase lisinopril hctz neurontin overnight voltaren tablets for back pain where to requip buy books online australia free shipping best place buy trileptal zyvox shipping overseas treating acne scars after accutane buy lamictal 200 how to order ciplox how to get benzaclin cheap clomid where to purchase menosan pas cher biotech usa hoodia gordonii how much is toradol without insurance dapoxetine tablets 150 mg can you buy fucidin online buy prednisolone online in uk remeron next day delivery aldactone bodybuilding women what is citalopram tablets for liposafe shop atarax without a prescription from mexico where to buy motilium online india cheap remeron 40 mg what is ciplox-d eye drops used for generic celexa us tulasi tablets side effects differin coupon code paxil drugs forum best place buy acticin prazosin manufacturers india order vpxl online without rx ordering penegra clomid and pregnancy rates iui us online pharmacy no prescription valtrex what is seroquel classified as reviews on danazol do you need a prescription for diflucan in australia buy viagra london top 10 online actonel sites atarax pills online in the india cipro 55 sale propranolol tabletki 10 mg cipla medpro jobs cabgolin canada head office prilosec drugstore.com ortho tri cyclen online order proscar over the counter australia order nizoral cheap fluconazole interactions colospa suppliers overseas cheap haridra pills leflunomide arava psoriatic arthritis lipitor pharmacy india donde puedo comprar lopressor seroquel 25 mg tablet zen nerve pain meds for shingles no prescription midamor sale clomid 100 vs 50 cheap zovirax how to use voltaren emulgel walmart cialis price comparison what is the hcpcs code for depo provera cialis 5 mg price cvs where to buy alesse 28 fluoxetine hcl india z pack side effects heart generic sustiva safe best online pharmacy for viagra where can i get cialis professional funny viagra effects pictures power slim acai reviews acheter trileptal pas cher safe zebeta buy prednisone for dogs side effects sale indinavir casodex limited india buy alesse birth control canada yasmin ortho tri cyclen lo active ingredients why is there a shortage of acivir pills cialis online prescription uk prandin online cheap generic viagra online forum cytotec cheap uk pharmacy that sells rosuvastatin alavert in the uk cipla field call password revatio overseas can you buy citalopram over the counter
Home Pete Toms LWIB: MLB, MLBPA Continue to Dance Over Collusion

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1385 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: MLB, MLBPA Continue to Dance Over Collusion PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 11
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Sunday, 15 November 2009 20:57

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in LWIB, the longstanding mistrust between MLB and the MLBPA over “collusion” surfaces again.

LWIB, the incoming executive director of the MLBPA Michael Weiner, chose to make some timely and very high profile comments suggesting that the MLB owners are conspiring to “depress” compensation for this off season’s crop of free agents. Is the next battle in the quarter century war over “collusion” in MLB about to waged? Jerry Crasnick reported for ESPN

Although Weiner declined to use the word "collusion," his comments hint at an orchestrated effort by club officials and are the latest salvo in a tug-of-war between players and teams that was heightened during a slow-developing free-agent market last winter.

"I don't think it's an accident that in recent weeks, management officials, without attribution, have been making predictions about what's going to happen in this year's free-agent market," Weiner said. "There have been predictions about the [money] players will get, what players will be offered [salary] arbitration and what players will be non-tendered [contracts].

"If we could prove there was a plan by management to use the press to try to depress free-agent salaries, in our view that would be a violation of our contract," he said.

Those remarks concerning a possible concerted effort amongst the owners to limit the compensation awarded free agents this off season were not the first that Mr. Weiner has made in the press on the subject. During the World Series, Nick Cafardo of The Boston Globe published similar remarks from Mr. Weiner. Mr. Cafardo characterized Mr. Weiner’s stance on the matter;

Incoming Players Association executive director Michael Weiner said the union will closely monitor offseason transactions to see whether collusion among teams to hold down free agent signings is alive, as several established players settled for short-term deals last offseason.

Mr. Weiner will officially succeed outgoing MLBPA executve director Donald Fehr next month. The timing of Mr. Weiner’s public remarks is likely not coincidental. There have been a series of media reports that many player agents have been pressuring the MLBPA since last off season to file a collusion grievance against the owners. The Associated Press reported in July;

As Michael Weiner prepares to take over from Donald Fehr as head of the players' association, several agents said they are pushing the union to file a collusion grievance against teams over their behavior during the free-agent market last winter.

AND

The decision on whether to go ahead with a grievance will be one of the first major decisions for the players' association since Fehr announced his pending retirement last month and its executive board recommended Weiner, the union's general counsel, for the top job.

When the subject of “collusion” in MLB is raised, it is most often associated with the era of the mid 80’s, ending in a 1990 settlement which awarded the players $280 million. The labour peace in MLB of the last 15 years has perhaps left the impression that “collusion” is a relic of that previous era of fractious labour relations. But suspicions and allegations of “collusion” by the MLBPA have been a staple of labour relations throughout this decade. In fact, a collusion settlement was negotiated in the last round of CBA negotiations. Sports Law Professor Marc Edelman published a paper in 2008, “Moving Past Collusion in Major League Baseball: Healing Old Wounds and Preventing New Ones" - PDF.

Coming on the heels of Baseball’s new and promising collective bargaining agreement, the 2002-03 off-season brought the first new allegations of collusion in Baseball since 1988-89. These new allegations claimed that, much like in 1987-88, MLB club-owners again concertedly submitted identical bids for certain free agent players.

Although the MLBPA never made any of its evidence publicly available, independent information compiled from newspaper reports seems to indicate that certain players were receiving identical bids from multiple teams. Although the 2002-03 off-seasons did not seem to produce any “smoking gun” invitation to collude, there were plenty of troublesome statements-such as those made by owners and staff of the Atlanta Braves, Boston Red Sox, Los Angeles Dodgers, and New York Mets about the need to reduce payroll throughout the league. In addition, Commissioner Selig suggested the need for payrolls to fall throughout Baseball.

Ultimately, on October 24, 2006, in conjunction with signing Baseball’s current Basic Agreement, MLB club-owners settled the Collusion IV grievances by paying $12 million in damages to the MLBPA. The parties reached this settlement without an arbitration hearing. Therefore, unlike in Collusion I, II, & III, Collusion IV produced no formal finding of fault.

(Editors note: Also see Collusion I, II, and III (a hard lesson learned) from Rob Neyer's Big Book of Baseball Blunders)

Select Read More to see the rest of the latest Last Week in Bizball

The 2007-08 off season saw the MLBPA accuse the owners of colluding against free agent Barry Bonds, who did not receive a single contract offer after posting an OPS of 1.045 in his last season. The aforementioned Marc Edelman wrote at The Sports Law Blog in July:

With respect to the game's newest collusion allegations, concern of such behavior first surfaced during the 2007-08 off-season when Bonds's agent Jeff Borris announced that he believed the reason why Bonds did not have a single contract offer was collusion. After reviewing the available evidence, the MLBPA announced in October 2008 that it had made a preliminary finding of collusion. However, rather than file a traditional labor grievance against the MLB club-owners, the union instead attempted to resolve the matter through private negotiation.

Last month, Ronald Blum reported for The Associated Press that the allegations over “Bonds” remain unresolved.

….players and owners have had an agreement since last year extending the deadline to file a collusion grievance over the lack of offers to Barry Bonds after the 2007 season. That deal says the union has until after the end of Bonds' criminal trial to file a grievance.

In the aforementioned blog entry from Professor Edelman, he notes that the MLBPA might be motivated to file a collusion grievance over “Bonds” in order to protect themselves from their own (former) union member.

While the MLBPA has broad discretion to determine when, if at all, to file a formal collusion grievance, like any union, it is bound by its duty of fair representation. This means that the MLBPA cannot act in an arbitrary, discriminatory, or bad-faith manner against any of its members. Union membership includes even those who have opted out of joint licensing programs, such as Barry Bonds.

Refusing to file a collusion grievance, even after reaching a informal finding of wrongdoing, might place the MLBPA at some risk of facing a claim from Bonds for breach of the duty of fair representation. This risk, in essence, might eventually pressure the MLBPA to file a collusion grievance, presuming their talks with the MLB club-owners do not reduce union concerns of wrongdoing. For these reasons, I fully expect the MLBPA to begin more aggressively addressing these recent concerns of collusion.

Allegations of “collusion” in last off season’s free agent market also remain unresolved. From the aforementioned report last month from Ronald Blum:

Players and owners have agreed to push back the deadline for a collusion grievance over last winter's free agents until the end of this offseason.

Agents for players have been asking the union for several months to file a grievance.

"It preserves the players' claims, and the commissioner's office hasn't admitted any wrongdoing," union general counsel Michael Weiner said Tuesday. "I would characterize this as a standstill agreement."

The relatively “soft” free agent market of last off season was widely attributed to the clubs’ uncertainty over their projected revenues for 2009 and beyond. However, player agents making accusations of “collusion” argue that this trend is more established, that free agents have met diminished demand since the 2006-07 off season. As for last off season, some player agents are suspicious that not all of what transpired in the free agent market can be explained by owners’ concerns about the economy. Jerry Crasnick wrote in his aforementioned piece of last week, “Numerous agents complained privately about players receiving the exact same offer from several clubs, prompting the union to consider filing a collusion grievance.” And from the aforementioned Associated Press report from July:

"There are too many things that need to be explained," said Seth Levinson, who represented nearly a dozen free agents following the 2008 season. "In my experience, there are no coincidences in a monopoly."

This off season, owners’ concerns about the future financial prospects of their franchises might meet with increased scepticism. Despite legitimate fears over the impact the recession would have on the 2009 season, in the end, industry revenues were flat. (According to MLB COO Bob DuPuy) Recently, Fitch Ratings released a positive report on the state of MLB and The Sports Business Journal reported that MLB will soon renew it’s “credit facility” after failing to do so at the same point last year. If the diminished demand for free agents continues this off season, will the “it’s the economy, stupid” argument be viewed as credibly as it was last off season?

Adam Rubin of the New York Daily News, reported LWIB on comments made by player agent Scott Boras during the General Manager’s meetings in Chicago

Boras chastised owners of some teams for pocketing revenue distributed through MLB that the agent labeled at $80 million per club. He accused the owners of financing the purchases of their teams by pocketing that money rather than investing it in players. He also suggested MLB is rolling in cash, even if teams are crying poverty.

"I would say, based upon their 'bad economy' forecasts from last year, I would not invest in their stock choices," Boras said.

If the owners are, or have been in recent years, colluding to control salaries for free agents, will their conspiracy be more difficult to prove than was the case in the late 1980’s?  David Pinto reacted to Michael Weiner’s recent comments:

It strikes me that MLB has learned to walk the fine line between compliance with the CBA and collusion. Weiner is trying to trying to knock them off the line, but he’s going to have a tough job of doing so. I don’t think anyone is going to leave the smoking gun statement that Peter Ueberroth did in the 1980s.

The “smoking gun statement” that Mr. Pinto refers to is then commissioner Ueberroth’s private address to the owners in October of 1985. In his book “May the Best Team Win, Baseball

Economics and Public Policy”, author Andrew Zimbalist wrote that during that owners meeting, the commissioner “reportedly scolded them for overspending on mediocre free agents.” During that same meeting, Mr. Zimbalist wrote that:

Lee MacPhail, director of the owners’ Players Relations Committee, delivered a speech arguing that players with contracts of three years and more spent nearly 50 percent more time on the disabled list than those with one-year contracts and that the average player with a three-year contract or more experienced a nearly twenty-point decline in his batting average after signing the contract.

The ultimately failed attempts of the owners to “collude” in the mid 1980’s also included, at one point, a very structured and formal approach. In his comprehensive retrospective on the history of MLB labour relations from the formation of the MLBPA in 1965 to the strike of 1994, John Helyar wrote in “Lords of the Realm”;

It was called the Information Bank, and it was simplicity itself. A club making an offer to a free agent reported it to the PRC. That was called an information “deposit”. A club wanting to know what others bid for a free agent could call the PRC and make an information “withdrawal.”

The idea was to stimulate the market enough to blunt charges of collusion, while at the same time keeping a rein on the market. The signal was clear: Okay, guys, you can bid now. But don’t top the other guy’s offer by much.”

As Mr. Pinto alluded to, if there is a collective approach within MLB to controlling free agent compensation, the approach is more subtle than that used in the 1980s. Last November, former Federal Reserve chairman Paul Volker (former “Blue Ribbon” panel member also) addressed a meeting of the MLB owners to discuss the state of the economy. At the time, Barry Bloom reported for MLB.com, “Selig declined to elaborate on Volcker's remarks, but he said a message had obviously been sent to the owners.” The absence of offers to free agent Barry Bonds was not the only development during the 2007 off season to cause consternation amongst the players side. Again from Marc Edelman’s aforementioned paper, “Moving Past Collusion in Major League Baseball: Healing Old Wounds and Preventing New Ones."

…Selig allowed MLB clubs’ general managers to meet with one another and discuss their 2007 off-season rosters plans by openly stating what players they were making available for trade. This marked a substantial change from the past practice at General Manager Meetings.

The idea of club general managers openly discussing personnel plans was first suggested by General Manager Meetings co-chais Theo Epstein and Larry Bienfest as a way to create more dialogue and stimulate trades. The MLB clubs, however, never informed the MLBPA in advance about these activities, nor was the MLBPA invited to send counsel to police them.

Record industry revenues have resulted in extended labour peace in MLB. If the next CBA (the current one expires in December 2011) can be negotiated without labour interruption, commissioner Selig might rightfully claim that improved labour relations is his greatest legacy.

However, with unresolved allegations of “collusion” the past two off-seasons, and a strong likelihood of another this off season, there is potential for a return to more divisive relations. Mistrust between the two sides arising from the collusion settlements of the 1980s has never subsided. Outgoing MLBPA executive director Donald Fehr (who will remain one of the most important participants in the next CBA negotiations) is believed to still harbour bitter resentment toward commissioner Selig over the collusion wars of the 1980s. Mr. Fehr’s successor, Mr. Weiner, is also a veteran of the collusion era, joining the MLBPA in 1988. Mr. Fehr and Mr. Weiner will never forget that arbitrator George Nicolau (one of two arbitrators to rule in favour of the MLBPA in the 80s collusion cases) identified commissioner Selig (then Milwaukee Brewers owner) as one of the most active owners in their attempts to manipulate the free agent market. Former commissioner Fay Vincent described commissioner Selig as one of the “ringleaders” of collusion. Commissioner Selig has never admitted to playing a role in the “collusion” of the 1980s and many owners and club officials of that era (including Mr. Ueberroth) have never been convinced that their activities were anything other than an attempt to operate MLB in a fiscally responsible manner.

At the same time, heading into his first CBA negotiation as executive director, Mr. Weiner needs to prove to the players and their agents that he will be as formidable a leader as his predecessor. As well, there is a growing constituency of veteran players in the MLBPA who have been openly critical of the diminished opportunities they meet in the free agent market while “rookie compensation” is escalating.

Whether there is or is not collusion in MLB, the issue is once again a point of contention in labour relations. And the history of labour relations in MLB informs us that if there is an issue capable of wrecking labour peace it is collusion.


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?