seroflo usa cvs prices purchase gold cheap kamagra jellyfish pregnancy after taking accutane buy coversyl generic mifepristone and misoprostol buy online uk sumycin suspension best place to buy levitra professional in uk common side effects of zyloprim buy stilnox online generic seroquel safe lexapro coupons doxycycline hyclate drug classification gabapentin withdrawal estrace drugstore com can you buy tadalis sx discount canadian pharmacy himplasia pharmacy has best price grifulvin v premarin pills where do i atorlip-5 in usa quetiapine 100 mg seroquel actoplus medication overnight delivery is aspirin better than tylenol for pain buy buspar with visa emsam reviews for men buy generic serophene suppliers of keflex in us can you buy unisom online generic for amoxil side effects of finasteride 1mg low cost metoclopramide safe to buy generic seroquel from canada quiero comprar lotensin celebrex no prrescription brahmi no prescription compare prices buy cheap canadian drugs buy zofran 200 best generic viagra site forum carafate pills online in the usa buy lidocaine injection dessicated thyroid medication uk zaditor from canada is it safe to order drugs from canada deltasone refill pack what is chlamydia in women online pharmacy birth control no prescription when will alli diet pills be available again what is the dosage of diamox for altitude sickness seroquel dosage for schizophrenia risperdal price india piracetam powder bulk buy medication online canada altace user reviews pilex tablets for sale estrace tablets levitra coupon free trial canadian what does zyrtec 10mg do how to live cheaply in london is there a generic combivent inhaler is it safe to order atrovent brand viagra legal in england terramycin 100mg buy vermox pharmacy prices list ordering acticin click here where to buy clomid online for cheap sale tadalis sx buy elavil perth australia avalide manufacturer coupons buy mirapex cheap can you buy canadian pharmacy proventil hfa exelon corp stock price history hoodia no prescription reviews lowest priced viagra plus cost comparison cod buy stromectol aceon shortage 2012 amantadine used fatigue metoclopramide cost uroxatral daily use reviews order flovent 120 mg where to skelaxin cheap uk buy order depakote online side effects of dipyridamole injection cipro xr 100 amitriptyline best online non prescription pharmacy to buy prandin in uk unisom coupons 2013 doxycycline by mail order celexa 20 mg tablet where can i get desyrel pills there walgreens stores canada premarin price increase order female viagra online with visa synthroid vs natural thyroid medication viagra 25 mg vs 50 mg purchase himcocid online where can i buy xenical pills rumalaya gel next day delivery valtrex comprare discover egypt reviews prescription canada generic vermox side effects of sibutramine cheapest generic zithromax cheap menosan is there a generic brand for abilify order fertomid cheap buy zyprexa online cheap generic astelin canada lov cost speman meclizine 25 mg wikipedia can we trust purinethol online mycelex-g online bestellen over the counter promethazine cheapest cialis soft paypal what is etodolac 400 mg tablets drugstore princess primer vente de dramamine au quebec permethrin spray for furniture flomax daily use reviews other uses for protonix rumalaya gel online coupon code how to take amoxicillin 500mg actos generic wikipedia drugs como usar las pastillas alli viagra soft on the internet inderal la 80 half life eutirox efectos secundarios en perros what is maxalt-mlt used for pyridium canadian pharmacy allopurinol online in us diprosone hair growth purchase actos online canadian pharmacy keflex dose for skin infection can order triamterene canada aristocort cream 0.02 partnership prescription assistance plavix buy flagyl xr without prescription hoodia medicine oder mg tablets of nitrofurantoin dulcolax sold over counter lupron casodex side effects 10 day weather forecast leeds viagra cheap online uk estrofem tablet fiyat? us online pharmacy no prescription himcocid crestor medication mail-order cozaar discount tamoxifen buy canada no prescription for elimite mirapex express canada prinivil 10 mg buy aleve d cheapest sarafem tablets uk how to get stromectol on line endep wanted online review abilify dosage wiki online prazosin india endep brands india no prescription needed website review buy menosan pills online seroxat wiki side effects of revatio tablets where to get glucophage how to get glycomet drug do i need a prescription for urispas where to buy promethazine w codeine syrup sale arjuna caps generic rosuvastatin in canada bystolic price comparison diabecon online pay paypal tetracycline over the counter for cats lotrel over the counter nexium discounts codes purchase asacol pills olanzapine cost pharmacy jobs in dubai injecting benadryl capsules plant vigra pills motilium from propranolol reviews uk buy research chemicals ship to usa ciprofloxacin ear drops spc generic cardizem cd 120 mg losartan hydrochlorothiazide drug which uk site to buy arimidex plavix going generic 2012 ventolin generic drug female cialis costco donde puedo comprar tadacip ultra low dose venlor can i take 2 benadryl pills buy percocet online no prescription needed no membership zetia pharmacies cvs cialis price how to take zithromax 250 mg for chlamydia cardura xl max dose what is the correct dosage of rumalaya forte buy live fish direct buy remeron from canada imuran and birth control pills buy online chloroquine generic aygestin in croatia ciprofloxacin and tinidazole dose where to buy cheap generic zocor when is aricept going generic buy femara online from india mobic meloxicam 7.5 mg tablets glucophage uk buy penegra supplier in uk low dose aspirin uk ranitidine powder for horses viagra jelly tablet sale generic uk paypal colchicine where do i ditropan in canada what does alliance mean in world war 1 what is the cost of zovirax cream naprosyn generic buy diflucan generic how to take acai berry and colon cleanse together alliance theater atlanta discount tickets cialis soft no prescription lipitor online overnight why is there a shortage of tofranil where to buy roche accutane buy clomid no prescription canada buying finast for dogs hyzaar paypal prednisone fast canada alesse where to purchase cialis viagra levitra review fastest starlix uk delivery suprax canada price buy advair diskus online canada drugs levlen uk next day delivery chloramphenicol perth australia nitrofurantoin in usa medications similar to risperdal what is allegra k clothing baclofen 10 mg tabletki discount canadian pharmacy kamagra oral jelly cheap female cialis sale uk cardizem usage purchase toradol lowest price erfahrungsbericht kamagra oral jelly forum bactrim reviews for a oregon state beavers baseball scores order diflucan medication by mail lexapro available in india comprar tetracycline pela internet florinef acetate side effects what does baclofen make you feel like buy nitroglycerin without a script naprosyn how many to take purim pharmacy prices list lov cost celexa zolpidem tartrate 5mg tab accutane settlements ibd buy pyridium 100 mg where to buy zyrtec d online cheap best place to buy bentyl discount pharmacy drugs hydro-chlorothiazide buying noroxin for dogs get medication next day online purchasing kamagra gold online canadian 80 cialis generic tri-cyclen 28 indocin buy uk lipothin pill shortage cleocin gel for daily use canada lopressor generic maxalt side effects memory loss paxil 40 mg tablet my uroxatral coupons buy avalide paypal accepted legal buy albenza online canada dipyridamole maximum dosage where can i get topamax to buy noroxin in uk zithromax single dose packet side effects order zenegra medication by mail Purchase cephalexin 500mg canada pharmaceutical companies india jobs robaxin 750 and alcohol buy revia from canada didronel non perscription countries printable alli coupon side effects of antibiotics for babies buy cialis soft mg discount premarin mg safe places to buy viagra prescription valtrex cold sores generic zyvox medication pharmacy where can i buy avandamet cialis no prescription needed how to use arimidex on cycle will gabapentin get you high where parietal temporal and occipital bones meet ceftin from india prograf medication online order brand cialis 120 mg cheap zyprexa canada pharmacy what is the generic name for amitriptyline diclofenac sodium dosage pediatric indian pharmacy moduretic can you get albendazole in canada what is proscar 5 mg used for will i gain weight if i take prednisone for 5 days is it safe to order flovent comprar atrovent original en madrid order lotrisone without rx styplon generico italiano purchase generic vermox anacin where to purchase safe place order mentat ds syrup januvia usa sale aciclovir side effects uk levaquin cost per pill buy abilify from canada pharmacy suprax online uk needed buy order micardis lowest price kamagra brand positioning viagra australia pbs comprar baterias lithium is it illegal to order generic liv 52 celebrex rebate coupons seroquel uk no prescription prevacid coupons 2012 cipla pharma company india buy generic wellbutrin online naprosyn 500mg tablets how to use eldepryl reviews on atarax doxazosin shopping apcalis sx bonus pills drinking on zoloft side effects staxyn review generic depakote er cost there generic yasmin birth control buy kamagra online uk paypal finax comprare elimite canada sale which uk site to buy pyridium buy luvox with no script where to buy kamagra oral jelly in bangkok is it legal to buy generic cialis where can i get avapro buy liposafe usa genuine apcalis sx best price vente de procardia au quebec insulin resistance buy cheap zyprexa online diovan next day delivery brahmi prices bupropion licensed antidepressant uk discount ciplox mg nizagara generic for parlodel supplier in uk no prescription buy maxalt online what type of medicine is ciprofloxacin xenical lawsuit canada acivir pills generic wikipedia drugs amantadine women buy generic glyset no prescription buy serophene 15mg online buy sinequan no prescription fast delivery can buy nitrofurantoin online antivert meclizine tablets sunrise tadalafil review india propecia generic doxazosin order canada order acyclovir online amantadine over the counter treat doctor captopril capoten tablets pharmacy express shrewsbury buy cleocin uk pariet drug generic what class of drugs is cymbalta class a alli buy online ireland pills torsemide precio mexico zoloft prescription coupons buy bentyl in ireland ceftin order canada purchase cleocin pills generic cialis super active usa pharmacy cardizem cd price myambutol supplier in uk triamterene canada overnight delivery phenergan online bestellen where to buy accutane no prescription discreet how do i know if my lexapro dose is too high half sinemet cr tablets ordering apcalis sx prescription what is viagras effect on women buy etodolac 500 mg can i use generic benadryl for my dog premarin maximum dosage buy rogaine 5 boots doxycycine on sale in the us where to buy korean ginseng in hong kong clomid clearblue fertility monitor comprar ventolin pela internet order aricept 10mg online generic lincocin cost brahmi from india overnight pharmacy strattera online fast pharmacy nizoral calcium carbonate where to get research grade astelin buy geriforte online india propranolol uses medication discount prescriptions without insurance relafen uses medication buy primatene mist canada on medrol 4mg tablets what are the side effects cialis pharmacie en ligne luxembourg voltaren mg usa olanzapine depot injection uk where to buy tamoxifen in australia prescription orlistat cost comparison order xenical online australia sildenafil citrate usa atarax shortage 2012 can you buy alavert best place to order zyban in us where can you get clonidine vytorin tablets us online what causes tetracycline staining nootropil sold over counter cafe rico rico methotrexate dosage for ra generic toprol side effects canadian pharmacy 24h reviews live tv in italian zyloprim rx korean ginseng tablets side effects pharmacy mexico exelon can you buy ventolin inhalers over counter uk costco pharmacy metoclopramide price medication similar to maxalt canadian online pharmacy cipa buy claritin hong kong internet prescription sinequan drugstore.com mevacor pharmacy prices list tinidazole prices usa generic propranolol 20mg prescription minocycline 100mg lasuna prices cvs orlistat availability roche existe viagra para mujeres funciona cialis sublingual sale 5mg retin a micro gel vs retin a cream buy 20 mg accutane how to buy bactrim online comprar flovent original buy lukol online can you buy pravachol how to get a free trial of cialis buy zoloft online without prescription in the us effexor xr 75mg tablets buy nimotop boots generic for pravachol genuine premarin 100mg aciclovir creme buy mifeprex online uk order bactroban ointment sandoz finasteride vs proscar lithium discount mail order rx medco valtrex online fastest delivery valtrex 1000mg uk version of evecare brand shallaki buy proventil hfa buy generic tetracycline with bonus what are the side effects of taking lithium celexa cheap uk cheap aceon 2 pharmacy pariet express canada can you buy premarin over the counter in germany what does ciplox 500 do where to buy phexin ointment buy midamor cheap buying allopurinol online buy ed drugs here no prescription best generic prednisolone sites order generic himplasia viagra without prescriptions illegal cheapest glucophage 1000 mg sr patient reviews on zyprexa erectalis tadacip 20 cipla how to order amitriptyline online how to get viagra 50 mg synthroid discounts codes levitra for sale uk order alesse online no prescription how long does it take for premarin tablets to work genuine proventil 100mg periostat buy retin a 0.05%mg how to get off celexa safely reviews coumadin cost in canada elocom mast upotreba buy kamagra jelly cheap generic viagra med cab xenical allegra d generic for sale research grade lincocin doxycycline dogs cancer retin-a 0,025 supplier in uk can you buy periactin over counter haldol drug information discount glucophage neurontin to buy in australia cheap diclofenac sodium 50mg sinequan without script cialis generico spedizione gratuita buy pamelor cheap can you take celexa daily buy actoplus met xr fda buy sarafem from mexico online cheap hyzaar no prescription buy apcalis sx next day buy diclofenac sodium enteric-coated tablets norvasc usa cvs prices do you need rx evista much does propecia cost ireland where can i buy levoxyl fast eulexin generic release date buy amitriptyline mg low cost topamax lexapro prescription coupon zanaflex buy online australia penegra online nootropil limited india escitalopram no prescription uk online pill tetracycline echeck avapro dosage increase buy topamax 10 alesse in italia brahmi with paypal payment cost ondansetron odt 8 mg can we trust motrin online diakof discount compazine without a transcript fedex long term side effects of eldepryl prilosec mg price side effects of ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets elimite reviews and dosage super active reload mutator order viagra professional 100mg best fucidin prices acheter beconase aq buy generic levothroid pulmicort shop net order mevacor lowest price why has cefadroxil been discontinued tadacip pill shortage buy genuine cardura uk non prescription ciplox pharmacy buy viagra jelly cheap viagra for sale philippines can i order buspar no prescription in the usa tenormin by mail order erection packs 1 no rx coumadin on line how long does inderal take to work for migraines viagra drink alcohol citalopram drug schedule cleocin tablets uk desyrel for sale uk ondansetron hcl 8 mg tablet during pregnancy ashwagandha tea sale where to buy alligator meat in texas lortab dosage pediatric order antabuse disulfiram 3 types of intermolecular forces from weakest to strongest cheapest alphagan in the uk order fucidin without prescription skelaxin overnight delivery ajanta pharma products kamagra all types wellbutrin pills brand advair diskus for sale online us online pharmacy no prescription arava florida cytotec treatment of dilantin toxicity uk version of kamagra gold travel insurance compare maxalt 10 mg prices voveran coupons apcalis sx price india order seroflo online in usa acai by mail order xenical sale canada buy cialis professional pills in the mexico tretinoin 0,05 next day delivery generic pilex uk paypal cialis maximum dosage viagra in pakistan lahore metformin generic for avodart can you buy primatene mist online zithromax chlamydia cure time tramadol for dogs same for humans retin-a 0,05 online meds free or low cost dipyridamole voltaren 100 retard packungsbeilage nexium 40 mg gastro-resistant tablets genuine clomid 100mg why is there a shortage of sominex alli tablets boots suhagra with no perscription can you buy saw palmetto malegra fxt price india overseas pharmacy no prescription levitra professional anti anxiety medication herbal para que se usa el medicamento abilify blue pill 100 buy kamagra oral jelly 15mg online buy viagra online org uk anticipated cost generic lipitor roxithromycin online pay paypal betnovate composition promethazine as a preoperative medication erexin noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy buy generic synthroid without prescription buy nexium online canada buy lamictal in singapore what is amlodipine norvasc used for phenergan suppository online avodart uk brand name asacol buy online ireland how long to take clomid for pct meclizine mg buy can order colospa online what is zoloft like xanax cipro antibiotic side effects cheap drugs band fucidin buy online us apcalis sx free shipping cheap atrovent free delivery zovirax 100mg buy propranolol usado what are the side effects of amitriptyline 10mg indian generics online mentax ordering fml forte german remedies pharma-products online no prescription uk for viagra get starlix las vegas fda approved viagra what are lithium tablets used for how much is cialis at costco wellbutrin online australia ou acheter du cialis en ligne forum comprar pravachol online cuanto cuestan las pastillas para abortar what is allegra 180 used for order amitriptyline 10mg 10 day weather forecast new york cialis soft without a script buy nootropil 5 can you order flonase spray allergy can we trust baclofen online
Home Pete Toms LWIB: StarCaps & MLB, Poll on Competitive Balance, Credit Facility, World Series Start Times

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1135 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: StarCaps & MLB, Poll on Competitive Balance, Credit Facility, World Series Start Times PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 13
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 09 November 2009 09:51

Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in LWIB, Rob Manfred and Michael Weiner from MLB and the MLBPA testify before Congress concerning “StarCaps”, a new poll reveals widespread concern amongst fans about competitive balance, positive signs for MLB as they negotiate a new “credit facility” and earlier World Series start times yield positive results.

STARCAPS & MLB

LWIB both Rob Manfred, MLB’s Executive Vice President, Labor and Human Resources and Michael Weiner, the MLBPA‘s General Counsel (and soon to be Executive Director) were two of the witnesses to appear before a hearing of The Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection. The subject of the hearing was, "The NFL StarCaps Case: Are Sports' Anti-Doping Programs At A Legal Crossroads?". Why are two of the most important and influential men in MLB labour relations involved in a dispute over the legality of some NFL players testing positive for a banned diuretic (Bumetanide)? The reason is that “StarCaps” has the potential to nullify the drug testing policies in place in all the “stick and ball” leagues.

A quick summary of the history of “StarCaps”: Two Minnesota Vikings players tested positive last season for the aforementioned “Bumetanide” as a result of their consumption of an over the counter weight loss supplement “StarCaps”. (no longer on the market) . The players contested their suspension in Minnesota state court, arguing that it violated state workplace laws. The court sided with the players, who have continued to play amidst a series of ongoing appeals. Last week’s hearing came at the request of the NFL, who argued that Congress should exempt professional sports’ collectively bargained drug testing policies from state labour laws. Northeastern University Law Professor Roger Abrams wrote in July for The Huffington Post:

The resulting litigation has been a sports law professor's dream. It is filled with questions of the supremacy of federal law, collective bargaining, the rights of states to regulate aspects of drug testing, the role of a non-neutral "arbitrator" and that is just for starters.

T.J. Quinn reported on the hearing last week for ESPN:

Their lawsuit against the NFL over their positive drug tests exposed a weakness in the league's antidoping policy -- in all professional American sports' drug policies, for that matter. The leagues knew the loophole was there and hoped no one would try to wriggle through.

AND

Which brings us to Tuesday. The NFL felt the latest court decision is enough of a threat to its drug policy that it asked for a hearing before the House Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade and Consumer Protection, where it asked Congress to pass a law that would exempt sports from state labor laws. The league's point: If a state can pass a law that overrides a collectively bargained drug policy, a player in one state could take drugs that a player in another state couldn't.

John R. Parkinson quoted some of Commissioner Goodell’s testimony in a report on the hearing for ABC News:

"Professional athletes and their collective bargaining representatives should not be permitted to manipulate state statutes as a means to gain a competitive advantage," Goodell told lawmakers. "The professional sports leagues cannot operate properly and maintain even competition on the field if players in one state are subject to rules in this area that vary from state to state."

Rob Manfred, MLB’s Executive Vice President, Labor and Human Resources testified that MLB is supportive of the NFL’s request for Congressional intervention in exempting professional sports’ drug testing policies from state labour laws. Ken Belson quoted Mr. Manfred in a report for the New York Times:

Major League Baseball and other professional sports leagues, as well as the United States Anti-Doping Agency, have stood behind the N.F.L.’s request that Congress amend federal labor laws to prevent challenges in state courts.

Rob Manfred, M.L.B.’s executive vice president for labor relations, told the subcommittee that his league and the baseball players union probably did not “have the legal power to waive in advance state law claims of individual union members.”

As a result, Manfred said, “a narrowly drafted statute could solve the problem faced by professional sports while avoiding undue interference with the prerogatives of the states.”

Cynthia Dizikes quoted some of Mr. Manfred’s remarks in her report on the hearing for The Minnesota Post (HT The Sports Law Blog):

“Uniformity of enforcement is an essential element of any drug testing program in the context of professional sports,” Manfred said in prepared testimony. “The essence of sport is fair competition. The use of performance-enhancing drugs undermines fair competition. In a nation-wide sport such as professional baseball, athletes must be held to a single standard of clean competition.”

MLBPA General Counsel Michael Weiner testified in support of the NFLPA’s stance that congressional intervention is unnecessary. Both NFLPA Executive Director DeMaurice Smith and Mr.Weiner asserted that a resolution to this dispute should and can be negotiated by the PA and the league. Ms. Dizikes also quoted from some of Michael Weiner’s remarks before the hearing:

“Nothing we have seen — in this litigation, or in Minnesota law, or elsewhere — suggests that Congress needs to take such extraordinary action,” Weiner added.

In prepared testimony, Weiner said that such action by Congress could lead to “the unusual proposition that parties to a collective bargaining agreement can contract for that which is illegal under state law.”0

Reaction from Committee members to Commissioner Goodell’s request for government intervention were mixed. Anti-steroid crusader, Rep. Henry Waxman, always vocal on the subject of drug testing in professional sports, was typically overblown. (Mr. Waxman chaired congressional hearings on the use of PEDs in MLB in 2005 and 2008) From the aforementioned report from John R. Parkinson:

Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., the chairman of the House Energy and Commerce committee, warned that if the state laws prevail and trump federal law, the ensuing result would complicate enforcement of suspensions and would threaten progress on steroids in sports at all levels of competition.

"If the rulings are taken to their logical conclusions, players on one team could be allowed to use drugs that would subject players on another team to suspensions and fines," Waxman said. "These new legal interpretations could render the NFL and Major League Baseball drug testing programs unenforceable, loophole-ridden and unacceptably weak and ineffective."

Waxman said if the courts do not rule that collective bargained drug policies can stand against state laws, congressional action could be necessary.

"We should not allow the drug policies that the NFL, Major League Baseball and other sports leagues have put in place to be rendered null and void," Waxman said. "That is an invitation to steroid abuse in professional sports. And it will inevitably lead to more steroid use."

And Cynthia Dizikes also quoted Mr. Waxman in her aforementioned report:

“The federal district court in Minnesota has ruled — and been upheld by the Court of Appeals — that the state laws governing workplace drug testing may trump the collectively bargained agreements of the NFL, Major League Baseball, and other sports leagues,” Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., said today in prepared testimony at a hearing of the Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection Subcommittee. “This is a serious problem because some state laws undermine the stringent sanctions established by the sports leagues and their players associations.”

Not all members of the committee were as activist in their reactions as Mr. Waxman. From T.J. Quinn’s aforementioned report:

Subcommittee chairman Bobby Rush, D-Ill., made it clear in Tuesday's hearing that he wants the NFL and the NFL Players Association to work out their differences on their own and that legislation would be a "last resort."

The AP reported that the general mood of the committee during the hearing was rather apathetic:

Tuesday's session was hardly a meaty hearing. At times, no more than three lawmakers were present: Waxman was among those who didn't stick around to question the panel of witnesses.

And again from T.J. Quinn, who speculates that the likelihood of federal intervention is remote:

Federal legislation, though, looks unlikely in the near future, and some observers Tuesday questioned whether the NFL truly even wants it. Once Congress gets involved a little, they said, it might get involved a lot in the league's business.

Gabriel A. Feldman, the director for the Tulane sports law program, testified before the hearing. Mr. Feldman argued that there are a number of alternatives to federal intervention that should be pursued before Congress legislates on this matter. Again from Cynthia Dizikes report:

“It is important to emphasize that the Eighth Circuit did not hold that the NFL [Performance Enhancing Drug] Policy violates Minnesota law,” he said in prepared testimony. “Instead, the court only held that the Williamses may challenge their suspensions in Minnesota state court under state law.”

Thus, Feldman concluded that it was only a “potential” problem. And even if the court did ultimately rule in favor of the Williamses, it was still a “narrow” problem because only three states, including Minnesota, currently have drug-testing laws that might conflict with the NFL policy.

“This narrow potential problem warrants a very narrow solution, and many steps should be taken before Congress intervenes,” said Feldman. “The most appropriate — and simple — solution is for the NFL to litigate the case in state court and convince the court that the Minnesota Laws were not intended to apply to the NFL [Performance Enhancing Drug] Policy and that suspensions do not violate the Minnesota Laws. If that suit is unsuccessful, the NFL should seek an exemption from the state Legislature that makes it clear that the Minnesota Laws do not apply … If that fails, the NFL and the players association should try to bargain around the Minnesota Laws. If that fails, then, only as a last resort, Congress should consider passing a narrow federal law that will protect” the NFL policy.

The NFL’s appeal of the decision of the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit will be heard in March.

Select Read More to see details on a poll regarding competitive balance, MLB's negotiations for a new “credit facility” and earlier World Series start times yielding positive results

NEW POLL REVEALS FAN CONCERNS OVER COMPETITIVE BALANCE

The New York Yankees World Series victory has exacerbated the debate amongst baseball pundits over the issue of competitive balance in MLB. Maury Brown wrote about the vitriolic response to the Yankees’ championship in a post at his Sports Bash blog. Jeff Passan of Yahoo Sports wrote a column titled “Yankees widen baseball’s chasm”. Peter Gammons of ESPN wrote a column titled “Blame the System, not the Yankees.”

But there is more to the competitive balance issue than the size of the Yankees payroll and how frequently they make the playoffs and win the World Series. While 2009 regular season attendance was down a very respectable 7% (the recession) from 2008, perhaps more important was that attendance declined for 22 of the 30 franchises. Is there a correlation between declining attendance in more than 2/3 of MLB markets and the relative on field dominance of “large payroll“ franchises this season? LWIB, a Seton Hall Sports Poll (read details of the poll - Word Doc) revealed that many fans in small markets are increasingly cynical about the prospects of “their” teams’ ability to field competitive teams. The poll was conducted last week, during the World Series. From the poll:

Sixty percent of Americans who follow sports feel that teams located in bigger markets have an advantage in producing winning seasons…

Seventy percent of fans feel that Major League Baseball should make a bigger effort to equalize revenue for all teams, as the NFL has done.

“While occasionally a small market team like Minnesota or Tampa Bay will break through and win a division or a playoff round, the big markets continue to prevail in the later rounds, and the fans clearly link that success to the ability to generate bigger revenue,” noted Rick Gentile, director of the Seton Hall Sports Poll, conducted by The Sharkey Institute.

Specifically addressing the Yankees, 56% of respondents felt that their ability to generate more income gave them an unfair advantage.

The poll was conducted among a random sampling of 858 adults 18 and older.

Commissioner Selig has acknowledged that the current model in place to promote competitive balance requires “tweaking”. Mr. Selig’s commitment to implementing both mandatory slotting in the amateur draft and expanding the draft internationally are, in part, motivated by the desire to “level the playing field”. Whether or not greater revenue sharing and a more punitive “luxury tax” (both would be opposed by the MLBPA and large revenue franchises) will also be required in order to placate “small revenue” franchises and their fan bases remains to be seen.

MORE GOOD NEWS FOR MLB FROM CREDIT MARKETS

Last week, LWIB reported that Fitch Ratings is very optimistic about the present and future prospects of MLB. LWIB brought more good news for MLB from the credit markets. Daniel Kaplan reported for The SportsBusiness Journal that MLB is close to re-establishing it’s “credit facility” aka “”loan pool” after failing to do so last fall during the worst period of the “credit crisis”. From Mr. Kaplan’s report:

Major League Baseball, less than a year after turmoil in the financial markets prevented the league from refinancing its $1.2 billion loan pool, is back in the market, fully confident it can now obtain better terms.

Baseball’s lead lender, Bank of America, hosted financial institutions at MLB headquarters before Game 2 of the World Series last Thursday and expects to get a new deal done soon, banking sources said.

That would be good news for the 22 teams that borrow from the loan pool, or credit facility, because the inability to refinance last year triggered about $30 million in amortization costs that had not been budgeted for. About $39 million of amortization is scheduled to come due next month, but MLB would eliminate that cost, as well as much steeper bills in future years, with the desired refinancing.

AND

“The more people I talk to now, people are pretty sanguine compared to where they were five or seven years ago on baseball,” said Rob Tilliss, founder of sports financial adviser Inner Circle Sports. “People view it as recession-resistant.”

Last fall, when the credit markets seized up, MLB and the NFL were faced with refinancing their credit facilities. Historically, these pools of loans had been tremendous successes in delivering credit to teams at far cheaper rates than they could have secured on their own. In MLB’s case, it uses its national media contract as collateral and borrows most of the money through short-term markets.

MLB appears to have come through the recession (has it ended?) suffering relatively little damage. Concerns about disparities between large and small markets will likely never be entirely resolved but league wide revenues were stable in 2009 (a notable feat for obvious reasons) and the fundamentals of the industry remain strong.

EARLIER WORLD SERIES START TIMES YIELD POSITIVE RESULTS

By now we should all understand that despite the annual complaining of east coast baseball pundits that postseason games end too late, in fact, TV audiences grow as the evening progresses. Nonetheless, MLB and FOX did implement earlier start times for World Series games this year and the results were positive. Michael Hiestand reported LWIB for USA Today:

There were lots of variables behind this year's World Series boffo TV box office — like having a super-big budget cast in the New York Yankees— but this seems at least pretty clear: Earlier Series start times helped build late-night viewing.

Four of the six Series games started slightly before 8 p.m. ET, which was the earliest start time ever for primetime Series games. Sunday's Game 4 had a slightly later scheduled start — to fit in with Fox's NFL action — while only Saturday's Game 3 started later than scheduled, due to rain delay.

The result: Ratings increases for viewing after 11 p.m. ET.

In the four games that started on schedule, ratings after 11 p.m. ET was 6% higher than viewing before that time. Last year, ratings were 3% lower after 11 p.m. ET.


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?