cheap trazodone free delivery order triamterene beconase aq sublingual dosage what genetic disorder is caused by an extra sex chromosome safe pain meds for cats swiss legend trimix review erection packs 1 without methylprednisolone acetate injectable the chepest cleocin where to spend honor points alliance mop danazol mg buy erythromycin to buy from europe canadian ortho tri cyclen amoxicillin 875 mg for uti where purchase l-tryptophan buy pravachol in australia cheap cialis 20mg online stieva-a 0.025 uses singulair cost with insurance can you only get haridra on prescription fucidin h cream acne reviews mirapex sale viagra soft online india aldactone 50 mg tablet american phenergan buy cheap proscar prednisone prices at costco how to take lasix bodybuilding buy zofran online canada cialis canadian prices mirtazapine withdrawal side effects lukol without script canadian online pharmacy safe generic precose switzerland glycomet usa zoloft order online carafate canada head office where can i buy cleocin purchase fertomid pills atomoxetine hcl mechanism of action z pack antibiotics during pregnancy zantac generic reviews what does generic hyzaar look like tesco pharmacy slough opening times penegra uk next day delivery trusted medstore online best medicine for abortion in pakistan lipitor canadian source generic name alesse 28 paxil withdrawal symptoms lawsuit kamagra 100 mg (generic viagra) how to take periactin to gain weight is flonase nasal spray safe during pregnancy buying drugs from canada pros and cons how much does maxalt mlt cost prilosec alternative medicine triamcinolone hexacetonide injection ordering protonix zestril ordering no prescription 1001 nacht basel allegra what is fluoxetine medication purchase abilify 15 mg toprol xl canada prescription atacand tablets for sale cost of serevent diskus over the counter prilosec generic new depression medication 2012 viibryd levitra 10 mg 4 film tablet prospektu"s buy generic acyclovir can cymbalta cause weight gain seroquel on line in the canada dostinex tablet price cheap albendazole buy online how to take brand advair diskus where to buy pain meds online zaditor canadian pharmacy cheap clonidine us fast rumalaya deleviery is seroquel a prescription drug order finpecia without prescription doryx side effects acne low cost pharmacy indianapolis madison prometrium prices at costco metoprolol dose for hypertension indian pharmacy effexor xr buy cialis super active lowest price where can i buy cardizem mg anastrozole get rid of gyno diflucan canadian source buy cafergot suppositories online canadian health act principles buying strattera online no prescription buy online probalan generic purchase elocon in mexico where is alligator alley restaurant who has prilosec on sale ketoconazole cream what does vc mean in phenergan vc fluoxetine tablets us online order generic xenical aceon 10 mg cost methotrexate and cough medicine levothroid pharmacy online lanoxin cheap uk keppra weight gain how to take clomiphene citrate for women what strength does mirapex come in order generic micronase where to diamox elavil lawsuit settlements malegra dxt canada overnight delivery generic propecia safe to use buying generic viagra in the us can you buy avalide in ireland long term effects of accutane on women what is lisinopril 10mg tablets raclet allegra for sale all types clozaril pills top 10 online anacin sites no prescription buy hyzaar order how much does zovirax cream cost para que se usa baclofen western drug zithromax resources for capoten is it legal for americans to buy drugs from canada finast medicine biaxin dosage instructions buy generic diamox lov cost vpxl order bactrim online no presctiption how to take caverta 100 aristocort where can i buy it fineviagra com br remeron capsules robaxin medication order harder erection pills for men torsemide 5 mg tablets indocin generic release date wellbutrin cheap uk caverta canada head office generic imitrex no prescription atarax 25mg tabs aspirin dosage too high que pastilla es mejor viagra o cialis where to buy cialis online forum depakote without a prescription from australia generic lipitor ranbaxy cleocin gel shortage liver damage from methotrexate chloromycetin eye drops micronase wanted online review side effects of bentyl 10 mg watson 540 blue oval pill dosage buy omnicef suspension buy purinethol capsules methotrexate psoriasis alcohol buy accutane with cheap bystolic online reviews on dapoxetine buy flonase hong kong nasal spray lisinopril interactions with other drugs can you buy anacin in ireland diltiazem hydrochloride cream canadian online pharmacy for tadalis sx crestor prescription assistance program best cialis professional prices cheapest methotrexate how to buy ordering nimotop dolonex dt piroxicam tablets elocon side effects ointment gold vigra review to buy aciphex generique lopressor 100 mg proscar birth control online us pilex no prescription canada compare prices adalat billig lozol online kaufen ciplox oz tablets buy skelaxin generic average daily dose of wellbutrin how to use provera and clomid together prescription nausea medicine during pregnancy elavil from europe alli para adelgazar precio generic avapro drug xanax erowid dose buy dapoxetine online at canada pharmacy cost of zofran iv viagra tables for sale australia order nootropil pill florinef best price what conditions does ceftin treat can you get differin over counter auto rx buy buy nitrofurantoin 100mg online prazosin by mail order what type of seizures does keppra treat where prometrium furosemide combination product buy diflucan online reviews luvox cr online buyers of sumycin canada cialis vs viagra uk canadian pharmacy avapro all types clonidine pills overnight pharmacy order deltasone hytrin spain over counter buy snovitra super power 15mg online nexium side effects dizziness cheap lynoral buy online rumalaya reviews and dosage donde comprar finasteride madrid prevacid discount code finpecia prescription coupon alphagan medicine online evista overseas buy online menosan generic avapro tablets 300 mg side effects of depakote er 500mg strattera india companies only advair diskus online usa no prescription nizagara birth control online mexico unisom drugs for sale online sale of yasmin low price clozaril uk how much is my prescription without insurance rosuvastatin generic available acheter prandin prometrium generic brand stats counterbalancing what is levothroid 50 mcg tenormin on line in the mexico can you order promethazine with codeine online drugs similar to crestor high blood pressure medication bystolic tesco viagra stores augmentin 100mg pharmacies depakote online what does olanzapine help with how to take topamax for weight loss can you buy a generic singulair where to buy malegra fxt what are the most common side effects of depo provera online diakof india no prescription antibiotics canada micronase pas cher italie cialis sublingual 40mg norvasc delivery uk danazol no prescription compare prices mail order generic roxithromycin zyvox 600 mg price online pharmacy cost of generic lexapro does viagra do healthy man over the counter order augmentin online order naprosyn overnight lamisil without prescription canada olanzapine withdrawal hell get cleocin toronto valtrex 500 mg 10 tablet fiyat? where accutane canada dapoxetine generic cheap costs i want to pay some strattera viagra plus from usa pharmacy tamoxifen tablets buy where to buy cheap generic female cialis cheap yasmin birth control australia femcare legal us can you buy lamisil online drugstore terbinafine buy lozol online in usa american alliance of museums members where alli how to use omnicef what does flonase help with allergies stromectol online buy liv cost comparison prescription drugs online canada order viagra soft online uk avalide with no perscription side effects of maxalt 10 mg premarin cost canadian order exelon tablets tadacip sale fda approved cod female cialis tablets online how to use nymphomax social anxiety medication weight loss how much is sinequan tablets pharmacy has best price methotrexate buy lexapro 50 motrin online bestellen where to get famvir pct dulcolax without prescription florida viagra professional to buy viagra a t superdrug what is seroquel good for use of inderal medicine flomax how to buy buy bystolic generic nitroglycerin dosage chest pain achat de cialis pas cher is it legal to buy viagra acquisto lamictal sicuro online order generic fosamax atorvastatin vs simvastatin dosage epivir-hbv tablets side effects arimidex max dose purchase lasix 500mg augmentin pill shortage non persciption erythromycin quiero comprar doxycycline toprol side effects generic phone in order for amitriptyline order singulair 10mg how to use cytotec abortion how much does viagra cost in tijuana naprosyn delivery uk can i buy antibiotics for my dog online drugs dose flagyl dogs tamoxifen menstrual cramps symptoms of withdrawal from trazodone insomnia buy accutane with isotretinoin generic heartworm meds for dogs no prescription atorlip-5 max dose nimotop from canada purchase cheap order zithromax macrolide levitra plus by mail paxil for sale online compare prices benemid buy shatavari australia depakote phone orders is anafranil a prescription drug buy skelaxin online india viagra without prescriptions uk aciclovir mg buy buy tetracycline online with bacterial augmentin australia companies only zanaflex drugstore.com zyprexa overdose fatal how often to use benzaclin buy online prednisolone generic current lithium price all types shatavari pills where to get plavix levitra pills free buy trileptal quick top 10 online ginette-35 sites colchicine generico online buy atorlip-20 online india generic medrol uk paypal buy ampicillin online from australia how to use singulair effexor xr pharmacy coupons getting keppra in australia ayurslim cost in canada buy antivert online without a prescription anacin from europe where to get phenergan over counter paxil buy abilify us discount long time side effects dostinex what does digoxin do to the heart sarafem 100mg cheep inderal without a script discount canadian pharmacy ditropan flagyl oral tablet 500 mg ou acheter du viagra sur internet forum is there a drug comparative to femara clorfenamina tabletas 4mg can you get inhalers over the counter uk comprar protonix pela internet buy actos uk diet buy canada no prescription for digoxin what does trazodone 150 mg look like orlistat nhs prescription price xenical ireland canadian glucotrol xl xenical online in stock actonel prices costco cheap cialis trial packs cost of alli pills buy lantus online cheap order bupropion online us arava prescription only cheap amoxil usa pharmacy is zyban funded in new zealand metformin hydrochloride tablets i.p 850 mg research grade requip medicine online no prescription needed cost of yagara without insurance alli diet pills discount voucher codes canadian lariam without script moduretic tablet sale serpina perth australia buy ginseng in bulk strattera daily use reviews how to get amaryl suppliers of caverta in us trandate usa pharmacy femara comprar compare prices artane alli capsules 42 pack generic uk paypal alli atorlip-5 dose nizagara india where can you buy nizoral easy buy amaryl for daily use cheapest prices nizoral tablets online online pharmacy without a prescription aldactone dosage pre contest nolvadex for sale philippines minomycin pas cher buy erexin v mg citalopram hbr 20 mg generic z pack antibiotics sinus infection zebeta mg buy sildenafil citrate tablets uk xenical generic available singulair 10mg side effects research grade cialis professional cheap cardizem 100 mg discount medrol keflex paypal robaxin from europe where to buy robaxin without a prescription buy online alli medicine in alberta ca mixing zithromax alcohol how much is indinavir tablets very cheap ortho tri-cyclen cheap zerit buy online retin a cream online pharmacy diovan online canada how to use viagra properly bupropion usa sale cheap atarax my diflucan coupons purchase vermox in mexico how much is albenza tablets where was broadchurch filmed itv donde puedo comprar una membresia xbox live gold maxaman prescription coupon cheap generic promethazine zentel preturi cefadroxil side effects joint pain buy livestock chickens buy levaquin 10 what are the side effects of stopping fosamax order drugs from canada with prescription how much will benadryl cost buy cefadroxil hong kong viagra online deutschland bestellen buy lozol no prescription fast delivery viagra originally heart medication tenormin 25 mg where to buy in usa what is pfizer vgr 100 used for aspirin 500 mg price holistic medicine low back pain generic glucophage manufacturers safe buy nitrofurantoin online ventolin otc uk buy kamagra online no prescription us femcare to buy in england best generic cialis prices cipro cheapest rate zyban reviews weight loss can i make fml forte phone in order for strattera qsymia belviq why does levothyroxine need to be taken on an empty stomach biaxin birth control online mexico ordering alesse here in canada ciproxin 750 mg tablets trimox for sale discount duetact mg pukka shatavari reviews dove comprare abilify original diclofenac gel online altace pharmacies discount ramipril prevacid 42 count lowest price danazol tablets for sale cost comparison order roxithromycin view topic cheap prices celebrex carbozyne over counter uk can you buy trental in ireland cephalexin cost comprar clomid online how to take nolvadex seroflo cheap price viagra plus order buying capoten for dogs doxazosin mist canada generic equivalent for toprol xl alli tablets in spanish how to use avandamet can order pyridium online motrin 100 thalidomide disaster in germany in 1958 ampicillin tr 500mg for acne chloramphenicol legal in england exelon patch discounts brand levitra pharmacy how to order lariam online cheap anafranil prices discount zentel 200 mg 10 tabletas amoxil 500 mg price pakistan where purchase tretinoin 0,025 cytotec precio mexico 2013 where is bora bora from uk accutane treatment for acne regenon retard effet secondaire where to buy allopurinol ointment hoodia dosage instructions celexa 100mg tablet g8 new alliance insurance jobs uk get best results using cialis como curar la disfuncion erectil psicologica canadian alli online needed buy safe colospa buy buy cialis jelly paypal seroflo 100 review how long does it take for benadryl to leave your system lipitor 80 mg price philippines flomax results forum zithromax z-pak order online comprar forzest original buyers of ethionamide canada use propecia coupon online luvox pill shortage best site to buy maxaman prilosec australia price order viagra online canada pill wellbutrin sr western australia minomycin prices where to buy celadrin drugs online over the counter menosan doxazosin cardura dose top 10 online tofranil sites luvox discount card european pharmacy students association discount feldene of canada over counter cytotec ordering low dose procardia viagra sublingual 20 mg finpecia overnight drugs from canada no prescription permethrin 5 percent elimite otc order actoplus met online with visa snovitra super power brand order exelon drug interactions kroger pharmacy richmond ky phone number bactrim order is generic lipitor available now where to buy live crawfish in austin what is cm roxithromycin used for lozol usa pharmacy comprar viagra generico portugal periactin online prescription buy wellbutrin 100 where to buy unisom in canada buy cheap pyridium using pay pal protonix 20 mg tablets listen to purim music online levaquin lawsuit settlements finpecia medicine effects coreg 100 review what is cymbalta tablets cheap generic torsemide como comprar lamisil voltaren discount code order alligator pharmacy seroflo tablets uses does tricare pay for viagra order inderal on line usa gonorrhea treatment guidelines 2011 do you need rx zocor purchase kamagra soft cheap jelly
Home Maury Brown Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 282 guests online

Atom RSS

Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 45
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 06 November 2009 15:30
Yankees
Should talk of a salary cap  be
about the Yankees, or a far
broader topic?

As soon as the Yankees won the World Series, the conversation broke into a chorus. There had been discussions about it before, but once the moniker “27th World Series Champion” was attached to the Bronx Bombers, the conversation kicked into high gear… and it hasn’t stopped.

Whether it was Baseball Daily Digest (and Baseball Prospectus’) Joe Hamrahi, or the New York Post’s Bart Hubbuch, calls for a salary cap in Major League Baseball sang out, and that’s just on Twitter.

First of all, I’m not one to say that baseball’s system is perfect; far from it. It’s that a salary cap is (mostly) a reaction to the Yankees, and doesn’t move much beyond that (Hamrahi offers up great conversation on the overall salary cap topic via Twitter, if you look through his posts)

There is lots of talk of a cap, but then, there's little about how to implement it. What there really is a lot of talk about the Yankees being the problem, but a salary floor is needed, as well (keep the Marlins, Royals, and Pirates from living off welfare).

Give me a number for the cap. Or, give me a system for a cap. It’s one thing to complain, it’s another to say the system stinks, and here’s a possible solution.

I’ve written about why a cap is, at best, difficult and create a host of issues, to understanding that perfect parity is a far off notion (some statistical details are within Ranking Who in MLB Got the Biggest Bang For the Buck in 2009). Here’s what I mean.

As mentioned, a floor is need, I believe, more than a ceiling. The Marlins expose the revenue-sharing flaw each and every year and that’s that they take in more in revenue-sharing than they spend on MLB player payroll. That’s certainly not the spirit of the provision within the CBA that says revenue-sharing should be used to improve the on-the-field product (the MLB roster).

But, if you create a floor to address the Marlins, it can create issues for others that really seem to be making a go of it with very little (i.e. the Athletics). So, if you set the floor, to say, $70 million, or around $18 million below the league average for Open Day player payroll for 2009 (actual average, $88,513,173), you’d currently have eight teams below the threshold (Texas, Baltimore, Minnesota, Tampa Bay, Oakland, Washington, Pittsburgh, San Diego, and Florida). So, let’s throw out Florida and Pittsburgh, clubs that have historically collected large amounts in player payroll, but not used it to the best effort with MLB player payroll. I can’t speak for the six other clubs that would be forced to increase player payroll, but they would most assuredly say that it would place them under duress. Possible solution? A system by which club revenues are tied to player payroll, but even that is a flawed model. After all, you do have to invest in prospects… drafting and developing players, just not to the extent that the Marlins use that as a cover for taking in boat loads of revenue-sharing dollars.

On developing and scouting players, one way of “capping” expenditures is to allow for a hard slotting system for the amateur draft, and create an international draft. This keeps costs down for bonuses in the amateur draft and gives clubs that have limited resources to scout internationally a leg up with an international draft.

As for a cap, well… Nine clubs had player payroll over $100 million. The Yankees spent over $200 million and the Mets were just under $150 million. Five of the nine made the playoffs, while four did not (Mets, Cubs, Tigers, Astros). So, what’s the proper level? $110 million? More? Less? Could it be that all a cap would do is undervalue talent? It may prevent the Yankees from gobbling up all the talent by offering more than others could offer, or… Would it?

Ask yourself if the cap has prevented conversation about players such as Labron James leaving Cleveland and going to the Lakers or the Knicks (large media markets). Or, if NFL players would prefer playing in New York due to the media market size there.

MLB is no different. A player that would look to choose between Kansas City or New York, given the same salary offering, where do you think they will look to play? New York where they can garner the most in sponsorship activity.

So, if this is about grossly overspending for free agent talent (cornering them), why not simply do this...

Make the Luxury Tax have teeth. Set the penalty so that it's a dollar for dollar figure (for every dollar over the threshold, the club pays in), or make the tax escalate the higher a club goes over.

In the history of the Luxury Tax (or, as it is more properly called, the [ahem] Competitive Balance Tax), the Yankees have busted through the threshold each year. The Red Sox were the same, until recently, the Angels have done so once, as the Tigers did so this last year. As those that follow this stuff will tell you, the Luxury Tax was designed to go directly after the Yankees. So, if the problem is the Yankees, the Yankees don't seem to care; they simply keep breaking through the soft cap and pay the penalties. So, apparently (at least for the Yankees) the thresholds don’t work (while it does seem to work for the other 29 clubs to one extent or another).

But, the notion of a salary cap is unneeded. MLB has the least amout of revenues going to player payroll ithan any other sport (52% compared to 56.7% for the NHL, 57% for the NBA, and 59% for the NFL), a sign that the uncapped league functions in a "cap-like fashion" better than capped leagues; a cap does not stop high revenue making clubs from having advantage, it is politically challenging (see '94 work stoppage), and if you have a ceiling you need a floor (which could have consequences for clubs that run into economic head winds).

So, the talk of a salary cap should remain that: talk. The system is not perfect, but taking a wrecking ball to it is not the solution. Put in a hard-slotting system for the amateur draft. Create an international draft. Make breaking through the Luxury Tax threshold painful – very financially painful – for those clubs that dare to flirt with it.

And finally, there’s this: Remember that no matter what system you put in place, you are not going to get parity nirvana. You can create an ability to retain talent, but in the end remember… The smartest team will win given the right circumstances. Money or no, there will always be inadequacies due to market size, which attracts talent looking for the most coverage. So, even if every red cent were centralized – shared between each club evenly – players would gravitate to the New Yorks, Bostons, Chicagos, and Los Angeleses of the sports world. Sorry, Kansas City, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland, no salary cap will fix that.

ADDED COMMENTARY:

SPORTS BASH: Yankees Make Some Want to Eat the Rich


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?