alfuzosin uroxatral eulexin schering rimonabant acomplia purchase florinef doses ciprobay 500 mg tablets canadian medshop reviews furosemide for sale buy estradiol online where can i buy fluconazole forzest 20 tadalafil puretone stethoscope company of heroes how long to get bystolic out of system vermox mebendazole vitamin shoppe coupon code 20 quinine sulfate for leg cramps diflucan information for men keflex side effects cephalexin zithromax nc is cialis over the counter oxazepam dosage available hemofarm cardiologica actos canda finasteride 1mg best price viapro reviews 30 minutes vegetal vigra warning mercury drug doxazosin no prescription roxifen gel stain tofranil pm lidocaine patch abuse dicyclomine 20 mg tablets uses aciphex generic alternative acyclovir zovirax ru buy local viagra professional 100 mg clonidine classification drugs kamagra netherlands provera and clomid and metformin generic nexium without prescription rapidtabs wikipedia free viagra cost maxalt migraine metoprolol er 25 mg tantalum carbide crucible ospamox 1000mg sandoz malegra 100 price antibiotics for std online pramipexole side effects weight gain magnesium citrate side effects benefits flagyl 400 used for viagra india price gb finoecia prescription flurazepam medication dalmane real viagra india efectos de la metoprolol succ er anacin syrup macrodantin dosage for uti cheap leagal backtrim anastrozole 1 mg in bodybuilding pharmacy cheapest reviews zoloft dosages medication purchase methotrexate no prescription novolog flexpen crestor price in philippines benazepril hydrochloride side effects cailis mechanical davie viagra howard stern thuoc renapril lopid gemfibrozil can gabapentin get you high antivert side effects meclizine white discharge after depo provera isoptin sr migraine buy cheap brand cialis online doxycycline hyclate 100 mg buy online viagra cijena ljekarna cordarone shot side effects vardenafil dosage amount diclofenac 75mg dr cefamor 250 games vistaril 25mg cap cost of cialis walmart water pill online purchase metoprolol tartrate metoprolol succinate pregnant celebrities due in 2016 order levitra online cheap lavestra sleeping pill cialis 5 mg online discount donormyl ingredients in marshmallows floxin antibiotics side effects generic cialis online oxybutynin chloride 5mg cost letrozole 2.5 mg cost tiotropium bromide monohydrate capsule sildenafil generico in farmacia clamoxyl will it kill gonorrhea zestril 10 mg side effects viamedic coupon code viagra samples lotrisone cream for yeast infection roxifen capsules vs tablets zetia side effects cialis 20 mg lilly tadalafil 40 mg cost per pill viagra online canada pharmacy is fake generic vs real cialis erection medicines for diabetics ramipril side effects weight gain is levlen the same as seasonique oxazepam drug vimax pills in saudi arabia levlen ingredients kemadrin tablets with keyboards stilnox side effects medicines to take boner pills at walmart dormidina 12.5 viagra model digoxin purchase folcres 5mg ambien therapy dogs for sale sumycin tetracycline dosage canadian pharmacies clavamix seroflo diskusi kamagra in pakistan order advairhfa without prescription coversyl and viagra adipex diet pills prescription fosamax side effects osteoporosis drug orlistat 120mg capsules purchase side effects for morphine sulfate side effects buy cefixime online no prescription avedox fc rabeprazole 20mg pariet misoprostol 200 mcg online remeron side effects withdrawal cymbalta without prescription buy mobic no prescription can you drink alcohol with azithromycin cipralex side effects twitching why is there an alli shortage alesse generic equivalents strattera reviews in teens is victosa sold in mexican pharmacies osprey project levitra cheap viagra 200 mg for sale salzarex manufacturer abbreviation picareta em ingles markets prazosin hcl where to buy generic viagra sildenafil senza ricetta albendazole 400 mg chewable peppermint voltarol 100mg no prescription albendazole over the counter uk famciclovir side effects for cats piroxicam for dogs with nasal cancer flagyl antibiotic for sinus infection septra suspension generic shop online food pay with echeck buy cheap generic viagra berifen 100 para que sirve erexin capsules yohimbe for women celecoxib capsules 0.2g flomax side effects flomax medication micardis generic date online viagra paypal accepted zithromax antibiotic and alcohol where can i buy kamagra online order amoxicillin from canada percocet dosage for severe pain reviews on vigrx plus side effects prevacid vs nexium drug free sample valtrex insurance company ratings am best ceftin for sinus infection tips for using viagra most effectively cabgolin cabergoline and weight zoloft and breastfeeding baby cheaper alternative to nexium lynoral ethinyl estradiol and norethindrone viagra every day equivalent au viagra sans ordonnance diane ladd young doxycap dosage calculations buy finax online india xenical kullananlar canada pharmacy online sialis de 5mg viagra vs cialis vs levitra comparison le repaire bart cefadroxil 500mg uses deltasone 20mg oxycontin xalatan eye drops generic finasteride cvs pharmacy metrogel coupons galderma pyridium for uti extenze review information forum how much is atorvastatin usonline viagra levitra generic online viagra generico on line septrin dosage syrup potassium levels in the body where generic propecia manufactured manfaat flagyl forte where can i buy valtrex without rx euthyrox 100 buy buy viagra cheap zinoxime 750 wsb cephalexin 250mg capsules for cats haldol decanoate injection price robaxin 500mg suppliers lergigan forte singing fluoxetine capsules for sale v herbal viagra lamictal rash picture lamictal side effects what class of drug is digoxin lisinipril without a prescription terbutaline for dogs avapro blood pressure medicine dosing non prescption gabapentin napflam tablets computers ramipril capsules 10mg/what are they used for viagra online paypal payments carprofen 100mg chewable ampicillin sulbactam pillhouse pharmacy amlodipine besylate 5mg side effects patient reviews how to buy viagra without prescription medstore biz review websites cyprofloxacin sales diclofenaco dosis maxima ramipril medication 10 mg 1channel how i met your mother hydrodiuril dosage of aspirin permethrin cream for scabies side effects walgreens pharmacy 365 nitrazepam prospect high school levofloxacin antibiotics generic for lo ovral 28 warfarin rat poison for sale skelaxin abuse high ditropan side effects confusion snort cialis flomaxtra xl tablets clomid over the internet xenical online non prescription cialis canada prozac dosage amounts antibiotics for pneumonia decadron steroid shot side effects canada pharmacy fast shipping bactrim cost without insurance reductil diet pills philippines price of viagra in sri lanka leukeran side effects canine generic viagra uk europe cvs viagra atacand hct medication viagra generico consegna rapida viagra paypal login enhanced vegetal vigra 200mg best price for ed drugs amitriptyline to buy online uk adderall xr side effects depression viagra50mg soft permethrin side effects on cats fentanyl patch dosage 12mcg synthroid medication for thyroid canada drug pharmacy free shipping code omeprazole dr 20 mg capsule image tadalafil citrate dosage piroxicam side effects dog pravachol without prescription morphine sulfate ir 15 mg tamiflu existe t il au maroc metronidazole 200mg ttc cialis order levitra online pharmacy buylowdrugs comcast customer doxycycline 100mg tadalafil 10mg canada irbesartan side effects long term duloxetine hydrochloride prices buy clomid and provera 100mg in the uk cheap meds4u buy prednisone for poison ivy viagra nz xenical male enhancement acticin on line comprare vardenafil discount fildena protonix medication pantoprazole cytotec next day xanax withdrawal jasmine villegas and justin bieber amiloride hcl hctz diroton 20mg ambien orlistat over the counter from canada que son los paratextos losartan potassium 25mg what color tablets where to order ampicillin triamterene hctz dyazide medication prednisolone india costco superstore costco wholesale sifrol for parkinson cipro price pharmacy mentat tablets simplotan tablets metallica nothing else matters lyrics chords lanoxin dosage range meloxicam high if snorted voltaren 75mg ec albendazole 400mg stat how long do baclofen withdrawal symptoms last metallica lyrics enter sandman buy clonidine 400 wintomylon bulawayo24 pharmacy support team canada terramycin ophthalmic ointment for cats sildenafil buy uk lasuna plant phentermine 37.5mg adipex p results canadian rx connection buy tinydazole in the uk gynopharm estrotab omnicef side effects rash atosil nebenwirkungen chemotherapie mens home health viagra doxycap doxycycline for acne slimming tablets that work fast medameds reviews 50 generic male enhancement pills cialis lieferanten virgin girl crixivan/indinavir stones walgreens pharmacy number publix pharmacy drug prices cheap drugs online produit 205 prazosin 1mg capsule where to buy salvent inhaler in canada online tetracyline no presp prevacid side effects lansoprazole dry throat lergigan fasst kamagra oral jelly next day delivery cialis 20 mg amphetamine salts er tylenol 3 codeine dosage pfizer pharmaceuticals prescription medicines prednisone for dogs treatment probenecid drug class baytril otic side effects in cats vermox rezeptfrei deutschland nizoral shampoo reviews for hair loss order viagra 100 mg without trazodone hcl 50 mg para dormir low dose levitra prednisolone nextday cheapest indian prices for nizagara doxycap tablets on sale i want to buy doxycycline 100mg can i take viagra abroad buy viagra best palce to salbutamol information medication how to spot fake viagra reductil slimming pill philippines femara side effects fertility antibiotics online paypal lisinopril hctz side effects men licodexon obat tradisional hyzaar side effects erectile dysfunction buy betnovate n diflucan yeast infection over the counter acyclovir without insurance kosovarja numri me iringer how many viagra can you take aldara side effects pictures meclizine 12.5mg tablets side effects viagra perdorimi perdorimi i viagrave famciclovir drug interactions compazine without prescription motilium instant yan etkisi 100mg cialis to buy in uk florinef acetate side effects cialis for women does it work letrozole 2.5mg for fertility go chewable erection omifin clomifeno 50 mg insulin resistance and weight loss buy moduretic viagra side effects alcohol buying finax produit 1 nebivolol 5mg replacement canadian viagra no prescription buy citalopram mail online uk motilium dosage for adults tretionin with out a perscription avalide recalls suhagraat hindi movie online claritin dosage by weight grifulvin v 500mg information security what is lanoxin medication is zovirax for cold sores mesalamine medication prices wholesale viagra chaina cialis lowest price free suprax coupon aspirin 81mg 1000s stilnox 10mg sleep zolpidem er himalaya mentat syrup geniune accutane flagyl for dogs antibiotic drug sales tegretol side effects pregnancy liposafe bagram polarmeds pharmacy tech picareta de diamante minecraft mods cheapest dutasteride can you get viagra otc nizoral 2 shampoo walgreens bluepill canada farmacy 1mg finasteride no prescription ivermectin pills online no prescription needed canada fucidin h keflex dosage for dogs femail creations catalog leconfield hotel bonchurch isle of wight 30 syndol propranolol hydrochloride 10mg lincocin 500mg tab viagra delivery france lortab 10mg probenecid for gout faridexon fortegames flovent no prescription trazodone overdose long term effectstrental imigran gelap di pekanbaru vimax detox pills orlistat mail order buy viagra tesco online neurontin and weight gain medication vitamin shoppe coupons discounts revista jugon 77 glipzide without prescription sale priligy online purchase cialis online buy ceftin prescription for viagra omaggio olive oil private reserve furniture viagra britain florinef 0.1 mg uses cialis tablete renagel medication doctor orden de pizza en linea online anastrozole arimidex vigria sold from canada sertraline hcl 50 mg costo orlistat generico vermox plus chlamydia symptoms men infection nosipren prednisone 20mg information acheter rohypnol en ligne buy diflucan online linezolid zyvox cost zyloprim contraindications for ultrasound rogaine or latisse for eyebrows how to get a prescription for paxil cholesterol guidelines 2014 mesterolone bodybuilding pictures phenergan dm syrup side effects need diamox 250mg in middle east examples of a cialis prescription viagra per nachnahme bezahlen lipitor and grapefruit juice medications floxin otic drops coupon cialis without doctor buy best quality of minocycline yasminelle tablets under $100 vicodin withdrawal condyline pdf download antibiotics quick online canada healthcare mall brand name cialas online dalacin cream priligy online australia tramadol 50 mg without a script buy real viagra not generic kemadrin discontinued davids bridal dresses nisone pillsnizagara avis combitic global caplet avodart side effects dutasteride results adderall uk buy diovan side effects simvastatin side effects uk cheap amoxicillin where can i order cilais online pain medications with no prescription nexium without prescription ovral l pill same time daily sports
Home Maury Brown Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 275 guests online

Atom RSS

Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 63
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 06 November 2009 15:30
Should talk of a salary cap  be
about the Yankees, or a far
broader topic?

As soon as the Yankees won the World Series, the conversation broke into a chorus. There had been discussions about it before, but once the moniker “27th World Series Champion” was attached to the Bronx Bombers, the conversation kicked into high gear… and it hasn’t stopped.

Whether it was Baseball Daily Digest (and Baseball Prospectus’) Joe Hamrahi, or the New York Post’s Bart Hubbuch, calls for a salary cap in Major League Baseball sang out, and that’s just on Twitter.

First of all, I’m not one to say that baseball’s system is perfect; far from it. It’s that a salary cap is (mostly) a reaction to the Yankees, and doesn’t move much beyond that (Hamrahi offers up great conversation on the overall salary cap topic via Twitter, if you look through his posts)

There is lots of talk of a cap, but then, there's little about how to implement it. What there really is a lot of talk about the Yankees being the problem, but a salary floor is needed, as well (keep the Marlins, Royals, and Pirates from living off welfare).

Give me a number for the cap. Or, give me a system for a cap. It’s one thing to complain, it’s another to say the system stinks, and here’s a possible solution.

I’ve written about why a cap is, at best, difficult and create a host of issues, to understanding that perfect parity is a far off notion (some statistical details are within Ranking Who in MLB Got the Biggest Bang For the Buck in 2009). Here’s what I mean.

As mentioned, a floor is need, I believe, more than a ceiling. The Marlins expose the revenue-sharing flaw each and every year and that’s that they take in more in revenue-sharing than they spend on MLB player payroll. That’s certainly not the spirit of the provision within the CBA that says revenue-sharing should be used to improve the on-the-field product (the MLB roster).

But, if you create a floor to address the Marlins, it can create issues for others that really seem to be making a go of it with very little (i.e. the Athletics). So, if you set the floor, to say, $70 million, or around $18 million below the league average for Open Day player payroll for 2009 (actual average, $88,513,173), you’d currently have eight teams below the threshold (Texas, Baltimore, Minnesota, Tampa Bay, Oakland, Washington, Pittsburgh, San Diego, and Florida). So, let’s throw out Florida and Pittsburgh, clubs that have historically collected large amounts in player payroll, but not used it to the best effort with MLB player payroll. I can’t speak for the six other clubs that would be forced to increase player payroll, but they would most assuredly say that it would place them under duress. Possible solution? A system by which club revenues are tied to player payroll, but even that is a flawed model. After all, you do have to invest in prospects… drafting and developing players, just not to the extent that the Marlins use that as a cover for taking in boat loads of revenue-sharing dollars.

On developing and scouting players, one way of “capping” expenditures is to allow for a hard slotting system for the amateur draft, and create an international draft. This keeps costs down for bonuses in the amateur draft and gives clubs that have limited resources to scout internationally a leg up with an international draft.

As for a cap, well… Nine clubs had player payroll over $100 million. The Yankees spent over $200 million and the Mets were just under $150 million. Five of the nine made the playoffs, while four did not (Mets, Cubs, Tigers, Astros). So, what’s the proper level? $110 million? More? Less? Could it be that all a cap would do is undervalue talent? It may prevent the Yankees from gobbling up all the talent by offering more than others could offer, or… Would it?

Ask yourself if the cap has prevented conversation about players such as Labron James leaving Cleveland and going to the Lakers or the Knicks (large media markets). Or, if NFL players would prefer playing in New York due to the media market size there.

MLB is no different. A player that would look to choose between Kansas City or New York, given the same salary offering, where do you think they will look to play? New York where they can garner the most in sponsorship activity.

So, if this is about grossly overspending for free agent talent (cornering them), why not simply do this...

Make the Luxury Tax have teeth. Set the penalty so that it's a dollar for dollar figure (for every dollar over the threshold, the club pays in), or make the tax escalate the higher a club goes over.

In the history of the Luxury Tax (or, as it is more properly called, the [ahem] Competitive Balance Tax), the Yankees have busted through the threshold each year. The Red Sox were the same, until recently, the Angels have done so once, as the Tigers did so this last year. As those that follow this stuff will tell you, the Luxury Tax was designed to go directly after the Yankees. So, if the problem is the Yankees, the Yankees don't seem to care; they simply keep breaking through the soft cap and pay the penalties. So, apparently (at least for the Yankees) the thresholds don’t work (while it does seem to work for the other 29 clubs to one extent or another).

But, the notion of a salary cap is unneeded. MLB has the least amout of revenues going to player payroll ithan any other sport (52% compared to 56.7% for the NHL, 57% for the NBA, and 59% for the NFL), a sign that the uncapped league functions in a "cap-like fashion" better than capped leagues; a cap does not stop high revenue making clubs from having advantage, it is politically challenging (see '94 work stoppage), and if you have a ceiling you need a floor (which could have consequences for clubs that run into economic head winds).

So, the talk of a salary cap should remain that: talk. The system is not perfect, but taking a wrecking ball to it is not the solution. Put in a hard-slotting system for the amateur draft. Create an international draft. Make breaking through the Luxury Tax threshold painful – very financially painful – for those clubs that dare to flirt with it.

And finally, there’s this: Remember that no matter what system you put in place, you are not going to get parity nirvana. You can create an ability to retain talent, but in the end remember… The smartest team will win given the right circumstances. Money or no, there will always be inadequacies due to market size, which attracts talent looking for the most coverage. So, even if every red cent were centralized – shared between each club evenly – players would gravitate to the New Yorks, Bostons, Chicagos, and Los Angeleses of the sports world. Sorry, Kansas City, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland, no salary cap will fix that.


SPORTS BASH: Yankees Make Some Want to Eat the Rich






Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?