most popular credit cards in usa best platinum credit cards 2012 top 10 zero interest credit cards everest cash advance payday loan login visa black card login can a credit card company garnish a joint bank account first gulf bank credit card loan interest rate credit card rewards instant payday loan no credit check best low rate credit card uk statute of limitations on credit card debt in india best free visa credit card canada secured credit cards to rebuild credit wells fargo business credit cards online application top credit card deals 2013 gold platinum or reserve delta skymiles credit card from american express best credit card business canada credit card offers for someone with no credit bank of america launches three new travel rewards credit cards different types of credit cards in south africa compare air miles credit cards credit card fees best no foreign transaction fee credit card 2013 woolworths prepaid credit card check balance instant direct payday loan lender get credit card with bad credit rating sentinel credit card protection insurance google credit card search what does a black credit card mean credit card 0 interest paypal credit card payment limit online cash advance direct lenders only intuit ipad credit card reader chase credit cards application status dubai first credit card review american express credit card reviews uk best travel reward credit cards 2012 canada low intrest credit cards bank of america visa credit card fees apply for a halifax clarity credit card apply for credit card with bad credit and no checking account best cashback credit cards october 2011 visa black card requirements sbi credit card helpline chennai stolen credit card numbers with cvv 2013 how to apply for hsbc credit card online how to transfer chase credit card balance to another card i don want to use a credit card on itunes cash advance direct lenders only no teletrack ebay paypal vs credit card no fax no credit check payday loans online cash advance online lenders uk hsbc credit card balance transfer malaysia best travel credit card canada 2012 pay best buy rewards credit card online hdfc bank credit card visa verification square ipad credit card reader guaranteed cash loans for bad credit credit card cash advance paypal orbitz capital one credit card review real loan sharks online top rated credit cards with travel rewards zero interest rate credit card offers poor credit credit cards balance transfer easy store credit cards to get approved gulf oil company credit cards credit card holder ebay sbi credit card helpline mumbai free prepaid credit cards credit cards with no credit check pay hdfc credit card online payment bank of america online credit card processing for small business compare travel rewards credit cards in canada spread the cost catalogues for bad credit credit card merchant services malaysia 5 major credit card companies discovery credit card benefits business credit cards comparison free reloadable prepaid credit cards best american airlines credit card offers 2011 online credit card consolidation loans nab platinum card concierge icici credit card customer care number ahmedabad is an amazon credit card a good idea no interest balance transfer credit card canada usaa student credit card review hsbc card services credit bureau verification apply for a sears canada credit card apply for a sears hsbc credit card prepaid credit cards canada bankruptcy easy approval credit cards best buy credit card canada application us bank credit cards reviews hdfc credit card application form pdf best business credit cards for bad credit best student credit cards 2013 uk bank of america credit card rates 2011 black credit cards wiki hsbc student credit card limit standard chartered singapore student credit card 3d pin icici bank credit cards everyday rewards credit card australia fast cash loans online lenders amex credit card merchant fees easiest credit card to get best cash back reward credit cards 2013 best travel rewards credit cards canada cash back offer on icici credit cards difference between secured and unsecured credit cards credit cards no income students how to do online credit card fraud best travel reward credit card offers how to get a credit card merchant account us credit card issuers list va mortgage loans with bad credit pay shell oil credit card online how to encash icici credit card reward points good unsecured credit cards for bad credit can you use prepaid visa credit cards online what is cash advance fee td ace cash advance memphis tn best iphone credit card machine get quick loans online bnz gold card travel insurance barclays credit card lost us walmart credit card payment login page no credit check payday lenders direct free virtual credit cards to verify paypal apply for a visa credit card for students is nab credit card travel insurance good orchard park credit card login credit card validator java program quick online cash loans 30 day payday loans chase cash advance credit card fees suze orman pay off credit card debt or save how do i get a cash advance on my american express credit card best visa debit card for students whats the average credit card limit best prepaid visa credit card credit cards bad credit instant approval australia 12 months interest free credit card australia how to activate hsbc debit visa card real credit card numbers that work 2013 best buy rewards credit cards login citibank credit cards contact bank of america student credit card no credit history credit cards no credit check canada the best credit cards 2013 malaysia paypal vs credit card rates hsbc credit card promotions sri lanka online credit cards instant approval chase freedom credit card after bankruptcy which credit card is best for me singapore banks that offer credit cards for no credit e application for sbi credit card next payday advance scams citibank credit card customer service number usa us bank platinum credit card reviews how can i accept credit cards over the phone pay belk rewards credit card chase credit card minimum payment interest personal car loans with bad credit miles and more credit card switzerland visa credit cards with no international fees applying for credit cards and getting denied no annual fee travel credit cards canada apply for personal loan with bad credit free credit check no credit card needed uk child care credit how do i stop pre approved credit card offers how to get a 30000 credit card limit airasia credit card payment charges citifinancial credit card payment address online long term loans no credit check mbna credit card canada review cheapest way to get a credit card machine best buy credit card canada apply sign online payday loan uk pay standard chartered credit card bill through billdesk credit card companies visa mastercard discover citibank credit card loan calculator do i need a credit card to build credit natwest black card benefits 24 months interest free credit card on purchases hdfc credit card personal loan emi calculator citibank secured credit card visa rbs credit card offers for existing customers walmart credit card application status online american express secured credit card 2012 prepaid credit cards for overseas travel credit card loan calculator amortization amazon credit card reviews 2012 chase freedom credit card customer reviews independent payday loan lenders best citi credit cards bad credit payday loan lender uk credit card repayment calculator australia sbi platinum card annual fee credit card logos vector how do you get pre approved for a credit card hdfc credit card login reward points new york and company credit card approval chase credit cards customer service choosing a credit card comparing all the options halo reach credit limit offline hdfc credit card limit platinum cards marriott rewards credit cards in uk best credit card consolidation loan companies how to pay off high interest credit cards sign up for a credit card top rated secured credit cards for bad credit amazon credit card uk login where can i pay my barclay credit card credit card minimum payment calculator spreadsheet chase credit card business hours credit card information not valid psn ways to pay off credit card debt faster how to calculate credit card interest on a purchase chase credit card protection bank of ireland credit card insurance on purchases how to eliminate credit card debt quickly how to pay off cash advance loans 30 000 spg point american express credit card student credit cards lloyds 0 percent interest business credit card can you get a walmart credit card with no credit history how to remove halo reach credit limit online stores that accept international credit cards three contract credit limit pay citifinancial credit card bill online visa credit card 5000 limit online credit card processing best practices calculate credit card interest rate excel credit cards after bankruptcy discharge canada credit cards with no application fee for bad credit credit card score chart platinum nab credit card travel insurance sears credit cards free credit card numbers and security code where to buy prepaid visa cards bank of america credit card apply by phone free virtual credit card generator icici credit card apply online in bangalore how do i get a credit card with bad or no credit best credit card deal blog the best credit card to have yahoo answers secured mastercard credit card review credit card companies uk visa low apr credit cards capital one secured mastercard credit card quick cash payday loans san antonio visa card security code free pay victoria secret credit card best credit card approval hdfc gold credit card free gas reward cards best online credit card merchant services credit card fraud punishment can range payday loans online direct lenders online loan lenders for the unemployed best bank to get a student credit card apply for a credit card bank of scotland visa card canada td free online credit card verification best prepaid canadian credit cards virgin mastercard uk want to apply for sbi credit card online icici credit card online payment from other bank credit card online payday loans instant approval south africa hdfc credit card helpline chandigarh how many ba gold card holders are there discover virtual credit card number best credit card offers low interest rate online credit card processing for small business uk apple square credit card reader canada set up credit card payment processing secured credit cards bad credit uk jcpenney ge money bank credit cards how to pay off student credit card lloyds loans for single moms with bad credit and no bank account standard bank credit card protection policy best credit card offers for students 2013 belk stores credit card payment best way to use a credit card to build your credit what happened to fixed rate credit cards payday loans for bad credit instant cash credit suisse internship how long does it take to get credit card approved real credit card numbers and cvv codes citibank credit card cash advance rate bbb list of payday lenders (consider this) credits cards are what is a credit card issue number mastercard hsbc classic credit card online application when was the first credit card issued in the united states hack visa credit card number 2012 bad credit credit cards instant approval no deposit online credit card payment sbi low interest credit cards canada rbc best buy rewards master credit card the best credit cards to have 2013 platinum card emirates best credit card promotions 2011 unsecured personal loans online speedy cash loans croydon starbucks gold card membership benefits paypal credit card payments uk who has the best credit card interest rate mobile credit card payments uk chase credit card comparisons sbi online credit card rewards best way to rebuild credit with a secured credit card international merchant services credit card processing does my corporate credit card affect my credit score secure credit card holder prepaid credit card bank of ireland how to pay sbi credit card bill online from hdfc simmons first credit card limit bad credit loans online uk usaa credit card cash advance interest old orchard bank credit card application american airlines aadvantage credit card uk top 10 credit card issuers 2011 first premier bank credit card processing fee easy credit cards to apply for online household bank credit card bill pay best cash back visa or mastercard lost td visa debit card square iphone credit card service chase credit card app status number best credit card to build credit score fast first premier bank secured credit card reviews coach credit card holder teachers platinum credit card hdfc business credit card with low interest rate how to change credit card on iphone 4s credit card frauds statistics online loan lenders only credit card application form pdf largest credit card issuers in the world good credit cards for rebuilding your credit comments amazon credit card review icici credit card late payment charges ebay credit card payment problems pay chase credit card online bank of america credit card phone number uk free usa virtual credit card balance transfer offers credit card cash advance fees explained best way to build credit with first credit card citibank credit card settlement 2012 should i get a credit card or loan best rewards credit cards with no annual fee payday online loans no credit check barclays credit card apply online in india hdfc credit card bank chennai dbs black card amex citi aadvantage uk credit card approved macy;s credit card review how do credit card rewards programs work best credit card offers usa capital credit card login page money saving expert credit card charges refund victoria secret credit card payment visa credit card number starts with easy credit cards to get approved for with no credit walmart credit card canada manage your account best credit cards to rebuild credit after bankruptcy axis bank credit card reward points for platinum card advantages of accepting credit cards online best credit card review sites online credit card payment gateway india do company credit cards affect credit business credit card for new business with no credit sbi credit card verification process student credit card lloyds tsb citibank titanium cash back credit card offers us airways credit card offer no annual fee credit card application form icici bank swarovski hello kitty credit card holder how to use a credit card swipe machine payday loans on benefits no brokers iphone credit card processing canada credit card reviews most popular secured credit cards how to prevent credit card fraud as a merchant hdfc credit card rewards catalogue signature alaska airlines visa?î business credit card no fee american airlines credit card natwest black card login easy fast payday loans no faxing hsbc credit card minimum payment percentage tata sbi credit card online payment how can i sign up for credit card payday loans online bad credit no fax visa credit card fraud insurance credit card debt settlement uk united airlines credit card promotion 2012 starter credit cards to help rebuild credit cash advance rate hdfc gold credit card rate of interest hdfc credit card points redemption form visa cash back credit cards best need a credit card to build credit credit cards no annual fee no foreign transaction fee credit card with no international exchange fees credit card loans valid sample credit card number dbs visa credit card exchange rate payday cash advance loans online chase credit card customer service best visa credit cards for young adults paypal credit card processing problems prepaid vanilla visa card lloyds tsb airmiles duo credit card sort code track sbi credit card status american airlines credit card offers american express do visa debit cards work in europe credit card terminal rolls banks that accept american express cash advance how to get a credit card with no credit yahoo answers credit card payment protection paypal virtual terminal credit card reader credit card information security policy template rbs credit cards online payment how to use sbi credit card reward points emi offers on hdfc bank credit cards guaranteed credit card approval australia best credit card for college students with no credit 2011 credit card minimum payment formula platinum delta credit card benefits credit check services pay belk credit card payday loans bad credit direct lender uk credit card debt after death california best credit card bad credit score which bank offer best credit card in malaysia apply for visa credit card online instant approval starbucks credit card promotion hong kong amex black card points credit card credit rating check pay my amazon ge credit card no credit loans alberta paypal buyer credit card login business credit card balance transfer offers credit card processing comparison tool nhs black card code pc america credit card processing credit card in canada for international students go mastercard rewards square up credit card logos virtual credit card generator how to organize store reward cards department store credit cards usa hdfc credit card emi offer app for accepting credit cards payday lenders list uk compare charity credit cards uk redwood credit union secured credit cards suntrust delta skymiles credit card axis bank new credit card apply best low interest credit cards for balance transfers cash back business credit cards canada online application for bpi credit card can i use visa debit cards online chevron credit card reference number increasing chase freedom credit limit alaska air miles credit card reviews marriott rewards credit card review mastercard debit card canada credit card applications instant approval philippines banks with visa debit cards in india visa student credit card with no credit payday loan lenders uk not brokers credit card bank of america lost 0 percent credit cards what are some easy credit cards to get approved for credit limit td emerald visa card mbna low interest credit card canada pay sears credit card account online easy credit card approval for students easy payday loan online citibank balance transfer sign up for a credit card with money on it apply for a joint capital one credit card how do credit cards work interest rates does best buy accept visa debit cards online blank credit card authorization form free new credit card charges law unsecured credit card after bankruptcy no annual fee credit cards application process radley credit card holder square credit card business model paypal credit card processing app payday loans online no phone calls is there a charge for using credit cards in canada the best rewards credit card in canada 2012 direct payday loan lenders no third party new payday loan direct lender uk
Home Maury Brown Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 690 guests online

Atom RSS

Reasons for Not Having a Salary Cap in MLB Are Numerous PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 63
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 06 November 2009 15:30
Yankees
Should talk of a salary cap  be
about the Yankees, or a far
broader topic?

As soon as the Yankees won the World Series, the conversation broke into a chorus. There had been discussions about it before, but once the moniker “27th World Series Champion” was attached to the Bronx Bombers, the conversation kicked into high gear… and it hasn’t stopped.

Whether it was Baseball Daily Digest (and Baseball Prospectus’) Joe Hamrahi, or the New York Post’s Bart Hubbuch, calls for a salary cap in Major League Baseball sang out, and that’s just on Twitter.

First of all, I’m not one to say that baseball’s system is perfect; far from it. It’s that a salary cap is (mostly) a reaction to the Yankees, and doesn’t move much beyond that (Hamrahi offers up great conversation on the overall salary cap topic via Twitter, if you look through his posts)

There is lots of talk of a cap, but then, there's little about how to implement it. What there really is a lot of talk about the Yankees being the problem, but a salary floor is needed, as well (keep the Marlins, Royals, and Pirates from living off welfare).

Give me a number for the cap. Or, give me a system for a cap. It’s one thing to complain, it’s another to say the system stinks, and here’s a possible solution.

I’ve written about why a cap is, at best, difficult and create a host of issues, to understanding that perfect parity is a far off notion (some statistical details are within Ranking Who in MLB Got the Biggest Bang For the Buck in 2009). Here’s what I mean.

As mentioned, a floor is need, I believe, more than a ceiling. The Marlins expose the revenue-sharing flaw each and every year and that’s that they take in more in revenue-sharing than they spend on MLB player payroll. That’s certainly not the spirit of the provision within the CBA that says revenue-sharing should be used to improve the on-the-field product (the MLB roster).

But, if you create a floor to address the Marlins, it can create issues for others that really seem to be making a go of it with very little (i.e. the Athletics). So, if you set the floor, to say, $70 million, or around $18 million below the league average for Open Day player payroll for 2009 (actual average, $88,513,173), you’d currently have eight teams below the threshold (Texas, Baltimore, Minnesota, Tampa Bay, Oakland, Washington, Pittsburgh, San Diego, and Florida). So, let’s throw out Florida and Pittsburgh, clubs that have historically collected large amounts in player payroll, but not used it to the best effort with MLB player payroll. I can’t speak for the six other clubs that would be forced to increase player payroll, but they would most assuredly say that it would place them under duress. Possible solution? A system by which club revenues are tied to player payroll, but even that is a flawed model. After all, you do have to invest in prospects… drafting and developing players, just not to the extent that the Marlins use that as a cover for taking in boat loads of revenue-sharing dollars.

On developing and scouting players, one way of “capping” expenditures is to allow for a hard slotting system for the amateur draft, and create an international draft. This keeps costs down for bonuses in the amateur draft and gives clubs that have limited resources to scout internationally a leg up with an international draft.

As for a cap, well… Nine clubs had player payroll over $100 million. The Yankees spent over $200 million and the Mets were just under $150 million. Five of the nine made the playoffs, while four did not (Mets, Cubs, Tigers, Astros). So, what’s the proper level? $110 million? More? Less? Could it be that all a cap would do is undervalue talent? It may prevent the Yankees from gobbling up all the talent by offering more than others could offer, or… Would it?

Ask yourself if the cap has prevented conversation about players such as Labron James leaving Cleveland and going to the Lakers or the Knicks (large media markets). Or, if NFL players would prefer playing in New York due to the media market size there.

MLB is no different. A player that would look to choose between Kansas City or New York, given the same salary offering, where do you think they will look to play? New York where they can garner the most in sponsorship activity.

So, if this is about grossly overspending for free agent talent (cornering them), why not simply do this...

Make the Luxury Tax have teeth. Set the penalty so that it's a dollar for dollar figure (for every dollar over the threshold, the club pays in), or make the tax escalate the higher a club goes over.

In the history of the Luxury Tax (or, as it is more properly called, the [ahem] Competitive Balance Tax), the Yankees have busted through the threshold each year. The Red Sox were the same, until recently, the Angels have done so once, as the Tigers did so this last year. As those that follow this stuff will tell you, the Luxury Tax was designed to go directly after the Yankees. So, if the problem is the Yankees, the Yankees don't seem to care; they simply keep breaking through the soft cap and pay the penalties. So, apparently (at least for the Yankees) the thresholds don’t work (while it does seem to work for the other 29 clubs to one extent or another).

But, the notion of a salary cap is unneeded. MLB has the least amout of revenues going to player payroll ithan any other sport (52% compared to 56.7% for the NHL, 57% for the NBA, and 59% for the NFL), a sign that the uncapped league functions in a "cap-like fashion" better than capped leagues; a cap does not stop high revenue making clubs from having advantage, it is politically challenging (see '94 work stoppage), and if you have a ceiling you need a floor (which could have consequences for clubs that run into economic head winds).

So, the talk of a salary cap should remain that: talk. The system is not perfect, but taking a wrecking ball to it is not the solution. Put in a hard-slotting system for the amateur draft. Create an international draft. Make breaking through the Luxury Tax threshold painful – very financially painful – for those clubs that dare to flirt with it.

And finally, there’s this: Remember that no matter what system you put in place, you are not going to get parity nirvana. You can create an ability to retain talent, but in the end remember… The smartest team will win given the right circumstances. Money or no, there will always be inadequacies due to market size, which attracts talent looking for the most coverage. So, even if every red cent were centralized – shared between each club evenly – players would gravitate to the New Yorks, Bostons, Chicagos, and Los Angeleses of the sports world. Sorry, Kansas City, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland, no salary cap will fix that.

ADDED COMMENTARY:

SPORTS BASH: Yankees Make Some Want to Eat the Rich


OTHER NEWS FROM THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(SPORTS BASH)


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?