prescription acivir pills online pharmacy canadian best generic remeron sites plavix drugs best site to buy carbozyne seroflo online pay paypal singulair medicine for sale uk pharmacies online that sell doxycycline buy sildenafil citrate tablets accutane acne treatment wiki trileptal for sale viagra generic date 2012 overseas foreign pharmacy legit arava tablets price tamoxifen buy online canada bactrim on line canada drugs tadalis sx with prescription donde puedo comprar mobic aleve reviews and dosage buy generic finasteride online abana limited india innopran xl online forum where to purchase fluoxetine side effects of citalopram 10mg order alligator lizards in the air ginseng prices cvs where do i buy hytrin clomid no rx cabgolin 0.5 mg non persciption torsemide common birth control pills brand names aciclovir echeck best price for real cymbalta menosan online pharmacy uk hyzaar 100 mg+12.5 mg egyptian pharmacy online best diet pills india estrace prescription coupon aldactone medication zyprexa 5 mg tablet decadron 100mg cheep nizoral for daily use canada acheter cialis original en france can you order flonase drug florida azulfidine cost viagra thailand isotretinoin accutane rosacea rumalaya liniment over the counter why has brafix been discontinued aciphex barato lopressor on the internet to buy skelaxin indian pharmacy beconase aq generic name for zovirax prednisone 10mg dose pack side effects levaquin drug in mexico pharmacy buy metoclopramide boots detrol drug side effects pharmacy buy drugs acivir cleocin 40 mg pharmacy cialis daily use formulary canadian lov cost myambutol how to by diltiazem online ibuprofen lysine migraine seroquel xr 50 mg tablet expired aleve pills what is the dosage for decadron rumalaya for men in usa etodolac australia buy cleocin gel 40 requip 20mg tab order cleocin medication by mail order bactrim on line mexico motrin 800 mg ingredients aleve ordering no prescription where to get lipothin pct cheap levitra from canada hydrochlorothiazide consumer reviews arava drug reviews community resources for independent living inc finax online meds what is korean red ginseng good for can i get florinef buy alli 160 mg imitrex costco olmesartan side effects kidneys la finasteride propecia proscar finasteride where to buy fluoxetine fertility drugs over the counter tamoxifen side effects steroids provera fast usa what is cozaar drugs celexa weight loss medication viagra cialis trial packs caverta low cost cholestoplex buy cheap viagra uk side effects of prednisone on fetus can you buy vasotec online went off topamax gained weight best place to buy amoxil in uk safe abana no precription xalatan price canada revatio generic equivalent prilosec no prrescription methylprednisolone injection price in india buy minocin with no rx buying medication online canada order finpecia overnight plendil online australia prevacid recall 2012 walmart mobic cost renagel in usa cheap viagra paypal eldepryl no prrescription coming off fluoxetine 20 mg rumalaya suppliers overseas celexa citalopram medication cheap glucophage free delivery where can i buy acai berry supplements in canada get lotensin toronto where to get menosan pct seroquel 100mg street value buy prevacid patch zestril roche precio argentina simvastatin amlodipine interaction tenormin pills buy buy lamisil tablets mexico buy doxycycline from mexico online buy cialis with visa requip drug store online seroquel cialis 5 mg tabletta prednisolone pregnancy asthma online paroxetine india buy actos online with mastercard what is levaquin 750 mg used for bad side effects of trazodone capoten cheap where can i buy alli diet pills in england what is norvasc where can i purchase ampicillin amitriptyline tablets 10mg pregnancy legal research chemicals usa 2012 buy trandate quick buy amaryllis plants cvs pharmacy voltaren gel discount buy viagra super active online us no prescription tamoxifen order in the us what is the j code for cytoxan erectile dysfunction drugs otc order prometrium on line usa zyloprim buy canada accutane lawsuits avapro over the counter high blood pressure ethionamide online canadian lotensin overseas is erythromycin ointment over the counter what strength does norvasc come in cheap calan bosch villas quickest fluoxetine buy pyridium in ireland atorlip-5 order online cialis sublingual 20 mg cialis professional australia ralista over the counter how to by proscar online purchase cabgolin in us how to get zenegra in australia aspirin side effects bruising buy goldshield eltroxin online buy dapoxetine priligy europe walmart actos prices low cost roxithromycin baclofen dosage strengths list of tesco stores selling brand amoxil can you buy viagra soft in ireland prescription pfizer ambien cr side effects olanzapine refill pack routine use of mebendazole in pregnancy topomax at us pharmacy best place to buy zithromax in usa buy levitra mg online for beta blockers online pharmacy levitra rite aid alli diet pills generic synthroid premarin medication price pharmacy buy drugs triamterene best site get chloromycetin
Home Maury Brown "Experienced" Umpires for World Series Simply Window Dressing

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 832 guests online

Atom RSS

"Experienced" Umpires for World Series Simply Window Dressing PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 13
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 25 October 2009 12:49
Bud Selig
Bud Selig prides himself as being a man of tradtion.
Time for him to become a man of the present on
MLB's umpiring woes.

You have to give it to Major League Baseball. When “tradition” bumps into “reality”, you can always count on spin to make you feel better.

There were no bad calls by the umpires on Saturday, a rare feat this postseason. Of course,  Game 6 of the ALCS was postponed yesterday due to rain.

We’re made to believe that the World Series will be better, as the league will be going with “experienced” umpires. As The AP reported, “Major League Baseball is breaking tradition and sticking with only experienced umpires for the World Series.” For baseball’s premier event, is breaking its longstanding tradition, and will not have one umpire working the event for the first time.

One umpire. Well, we can all breath much easier now, can’t we?

Here’s the real deal: there is no change. It’s a PR ploy. Window dressing.

With each postseason, MLB sends out press releases before each series announcing the umpire crews, and at the center of the releases is this: the umpires making the calls have (you guessed it), a vast well of experience. Take this from the release for the LCS umpires (emphisis, by author):

Tim McClelland, who is in his 28th year as a Major League Umpire, will be the crew chief in the 2009 ALCS, which will be the 18th postseason series of his career, including his ninth LCS.


Randy Marsh will serve as the crew chief during the 2009 NLCS. The 28-year veteran umpire will work his 19th postseason assignment, including his ninth LCS.

Lest we all remind you of how well McClelland did in Game 4 of the ALCS; a call that at least one is calling “the worst call of all time.”

And, so, you – the dedicated baseball fan – are led to believe that somehow Joe West, Dana DeMuth and Gerry Davis, along with Brian Gorman, Jeff Nelson and Mike Everitt will change matters.

As if.

What Bud Selig and others in baseball need is a dose of smelling salts to break them out of their coma. At the very least, put umpires on a strict rating system, and tenure be damned, don’t let “experience” be the barometer, but instead, quality.

All that aside, expanded replay is needed, which seems to run counter to Commissioner Selig’s traditionalist blood. In 2005, Selig said, "Yes, we had some incidents that certainly need to be looked at. So I'm not minimizing them. But do I believe in instant replay? No, I do not." He then added, "Human error is part of our sport."

Well, sure “human error” has been part of the game, but leaning on the tradition is kind of like saying (as this MLB steering committee doc and Ford Frick did in 1946), keeping men of color out of MLB was holding up the game’s “tradition.” Somehow, the Lords of Baseball learned then to mature then over a far more serious matter, and so should it be now.

Until there are clear changes in how umpiring is conducted and getting calls right, don’t let any minor tweaks fool you, it’s just window dressing.

Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is available for hire or freelance. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown on Twitter Twitter

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

FacebookFollow the Business of Sports Network on Facebook



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?