Home Pete Toms LWIB: An In-Depth Look At the Most Recent Rule 4 Draft, Recruiting International Talent

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 608 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: An In-Depth Look At the Most Recent Rule 4 Draft, Recruiting International Talent PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 3
PoorBest 
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Monday, 24 August 2009 00:08

Last Week in Baseball by Pete Toms

This week in LWIB, as the signing deadline passes, fundamental changes to the Rule 4 draft are likely inevitable plus a quick update on last week’s report concerning the growing number of players MLB clubs are recruiting from abroad.

THE FUTURE OF THE RULE 4 DRAFT

The Rule 4 signing deadline passed LWIB with Commissioner Selig’s efforts to reduce signing bonuses by 10% over last year viewed as largely ineffective.  Fundamental changes to the Rule 4 draft appear imminent.  Many club officials and scores of pundits agree that “competitive balance” can be enhanced by removing the “signability” factor from the draft via the introduction of mandatory slotting.  Commissioner Selig has been advocating in the press for the implementation of both “mandatory slotting” and a “worldwide draft”.  However, changes to the Rule 4 draft must be negotiated with the MLBPA.  (The current CBA expires in December 2011)  Some believe that the MLBPA is resolute in its philosophical opposition to any “capping” of compensation while others speculate that resentment amongst MLB player over “rookie compensation” will lead to the successful negotiation of “mandatory slotting”.  Many in the baseball media are also arguing for allowing the trading of draft picks, believing that it would also contribute to greater “competitive balance”.  Some player development officials are also calling for an earlier signing deadline, arguing that the current deadline has not been a deterrent to escalating signing bonuses while retarding the development of newly drafted players.

First, how effective were “slot recommendations” in controlling costs in the 2009 amateur draft?  From Jim Callis at Baseball America.

Select Read More to see the rest of this edtion of Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

Commissioner Bud Selig slashed bonus recommendations by 10 percent across the board, and his office leaned heavily on teams to heed them. MLB delayed finalizing signings as long as possible and restricted the flow of bonus information more than usual as the Aug. 17 signing deadline approached, so agents couldn't use that data to strike better deals.

But when the clock struck midnight on the Aug. 17 signing deadline, clubs emphatically showed that they cared more about adding talent than staying in MLB's good graces.

Consider:

• For the first time ever, all 30 teams signed at least one player over MLB's slot recommendations. In 2008, the only time this decade the commissioner's office gave clubs the go-ahead to value ability over signability, the Blue Jays, Cardinals, Mets and Tigers still toed the line.

• MLB recommends specific bonuses for each slot in the first five rounds. This year, teams spent $134.7 million on bonuses in that range, 24 percent above the $108.8 million total for all the slots. Last year, clubs shelled out $137.6 million in the top five rounds, 14 percent above the $120.9 million slot total.

AND

• The 29 first-round picks who signed averaged $2,467,034 in bonuses, just ahead of the record of $2,458,714 set a year ago.

MLB argued that the “slot recommendations” did limit the amount of compensation awarded to players in the 2009 amateur draft.  David Waldstein reported in the New York Times that Rob Manfred, MLB’s Executive Vice President, Labor Relations & Human Resources, believes the “slot recommendations” did help to control the escalating dollars being spent on signing bonuses.

Manfred disputes that the system is being roundly ignored and says it helps rationalize the salary structure of the draft. He pointed out that 65 percent of the players signed at or below the recommended figure and 76 percent were within 5 percent of the recommendations.

But he did acknowledge that as the deadline approached, the numbers soared, and that was when most of the top picks signed.

“The pattern has been that the tougher signings get done closer to the deadline,” Manfred said, “and are likely to be over the slot number.”

Commissioner Selig was quoted by The Canadian Press, “(But) the slotting system this year worked better than ever. We had over 70 per cent of our players signed at slot or under.”

Maury Brown reported that the “slot recommendations” were not completely ineffective but did agree with Mr. Manfred that they proved of little use as the deadline neared.

So, you could say that the slotting system failed, but maybe, just slightly (didn't increase, but then Selig didn't get clubs to go the reduction route).

AND

To place perspective around where the majority of draft bonuses go, the 25 players that did get deals at the deadline account for 7.79 percent of the 321 selected in the top 10 rounds alone. Those players garnered $56,612,500 in bonuses, or nearly 35.34 percent of the total.

Commissioner Selig introduced “slot recommendations” in 2002.  Seven years later there is near unanimity amongst clubs, MLB officials and baseball media that if “slotting” has netted mixed results in controlling escalating signing bonuses, the draft as it is currently structured does not satisfactorily accomplish its goal of distributing the best amateur baseball players to the worst MLB clubs.  More succinctly, clubs are increasingly ignoring “slotting” but “signability” remains a problem.

Jonathan Mayo reported for MLB.com.

Recently, teams have been willing to take the chance on tough signs, going way above slot to bring in elite talent. Coonelly's (LWIB note, Coonelly is Frank Coonelly, President of the Pittsburgh Pirates) Pirates took Pedro Alvarez with the second pick in the 2008 Draft and eventually signed the third baseman. The Kansas City Royals have ignored slot recommendations for their top picks over the past few seasons.

That's not to say it's a dead issue. In 2007, the Pirates passed on Matt Wieters, and Rick Porcello dropped to the bottom of the first round, with bonus demands playing a large role in both situations. In this year's Draft, Tyler Matzek fell to No. 11, Matt Purke slid to No. 14 and Shelby Miller plummeted all the way down to the 19th selection all because of signability.

AND

"When we think about it, the purpose of the Draft is to make sure that the best player goes to the team that had the worst year the prior year," Manfred said. "Number one on our list, do signability concerns result in teams passing on players who might otherwise been selected? We do believe that happens.

Kevin Goldstein surveyed the baseball industry for his “Fixing the Draft” report for Baseball Prospectus.

"We're in a bad system, no doubt about it," said one front-office official. "There has to be something in place where the worst teams sign the best players, not just in the first round, but all the way down, and that's not happening under this system."

AND

With more over-slot bonuses each year, the draft simply isn't fulfilling it's primary purpose, a balancing of talent. "Look, we can get really philosophical here, and I'm a capitalist," explained one scouting director. "But in the confines of a sporting league, in order for that league to be equitable, we need some kind of fairer distribution of talent."

Another talked about it in comparison to the drafts in other major sports. "Everyone should recognize the need for a major fix when there is serious discussion this spring over whether or not Washington is going to take [Stephen] Strasburg," explained one front-office official. "If we're going to have a draft, it should be based on talent. That there's any team not taking the player they think is the best shows that we need a major fix here."

Buster Olney reported last month for ESPN.

The amateur draft is the best way for small-market teams to add impact talent, so baseball needs to figure out a way for those clubs to be able to select players that they can't afford right now. Many cash-strapped teams pass on a guy with a huge price tag (typically Scott Boras clients) to take a lesser player they know they can sign. "And that's not what the draft is meant to be," says Brewers GM Doug Melvin. "The worst teams should have access to the best players."

From the aforementioned piece by Jim Callis at Baseball America.

Considering that last year MLB loosened its reins to ensure draft talent was dispersed more evenly among clubs, then clamped down tight this summer, it seems remarkable that bonuses didn't decline. Then again, maybe it shouldn't.

"When it comes right down to it, we want to sign the players," a National League scouting director said. "Our job is not to enforce the guidelines from the commissioner's office."

In 2002 MLB abandoned an attempt to negotiate with the MLBPA a geographic expansion of the Rule 4 draft.  In the current CBA, MLB negotiated with the MLBPA an earlier Rule 4 signing deadline and compensation (in the form of draft picks) for clubs failing to sign a pick, with the goal of strengthening clubs bargaining positions.  This CBA expires in less than sixteen months and again the Rule 4 draft is all but certain to be a bargaining issue in the next round of negotiations.  LWIB, both Rob Manfred and commissioner Selig publicly expressed MLB’s commitment to negotiating comprehensive changes to the amateur draft in the next CBA.  From Jonathan Mayo’s aforementioned report on the amateur draft for MLB.com

"This will be a topic in the 2011 negotiations," said Rob Manfred, Major League Baseball's executive vice president of labor relations and human resources. "We're not at the point where I know what it is the clubs will want to propose. We're looking at the issues. Where you start if you have a job like mine, you look at what other sports do. There are things embedded in the NFL and NBA that might be helpful, but we're not at a point that we know yet."

Again from Jim Callis at Baseball America.

MLB's informal slotting has accomplished all it can, and draft spending won't change significantly unless baseball institutes a hard slotting system like the National Basketball Association has. Selig told The Washington Post's Dave Sheinin that MLB would seek mandated slotting and the inclusion of foreign players in the draft during talks for the next collective bargaining agreement. The current deal expires in December 2011.

Selig said: "There's no question in my mind, in 2011, certainly a slotting system and a worldwide draft are things we will be very aggressive in talking about."

And from the aforementioned report from David Waldstein in the New York Times.

When the current collective bargaining agreement runs out in 2011, it is expected that baseball will seek a mandatory signing system for draft picks similar to the one used by the N.B.A.

“That is an area that will be of great interest in the next round of negotiations,” said Rob Manfred, baseball’s executive vice president for labor relations. “I’m not going to speculate as to what our proposals are going to be the next time around, but I will say the purpose of the draft is to make sure the weakest team gets the best player. If you have a system like the N.B.A. or the N.F.L. has, where you know what a draft choice is going to be paid, it takes away any temptation on the part of the club to take signability into account.”

In the N.B.A., each draft position is assigned a salary figure. It can be negotiated 20 percent above or below that figure, but is now almost always 20 percent above. In the N.F.L., there is a rookie salary pool, and each team can divide up the money however it wishes, as long as it does not exceed the total.

The N.B.A. model, in place since 1995, is the most appealing because it eliminates negotiating and controls costs. Therefore, teams are not afraid to take the best available player for fear they will not be able to sign him.

“Theoretically, a fixed price for each pick in the draft is a mechanism that helps restore the draft to its original purpose,” Manfred said. “Teams know what the cost of the talent is, and they just take the best player.”

And from the aforementioned report from The Canadian Press.

Many in the game believe the draft needs to be reworked and Selig says levelling the disparities between rich and poor teams in signing picks and procuring international talent will be a priority in talks with the players union when the current CBA expires in December 2011.

“There's no doubt about that,” he said. “In the next negotiations, we're going to talk about slotting and the worldwide draft.

Allowing the trading of draft picks in MLB has long been suggested as a means of maximizing the value of draft picks, particularly for small market teams unable or unwilling to pay the larger signing bonuses.  Proponents of this change also argue that it would stimulate public interest in the Rule 4 draft (now covered extensively by MLBN).  MLB’s amateur draft has always been of minor interest to most fans in comparison to the amateur drafts in the other “stick and ball” leagues.  MLB has been hesitant to allow the trading of draft picks out of concerns that small market clubs will auction picks to the highest bidder and that player agents will force trades of drafted players to the team of their choosing.  Buster Olney, from his aforementioned piece on remedying the draft, advocates for the trading of draft picks.

The ability to trade draft picks, which is allowed in the NFL, NBA and NHL, but has never been permitted in baseball. If it were, a team that didn't want to pay the slot price for a prospect could trade that pick for players or for more picks later in the draft.

From Jayson Stark at ESPN.

TRADING PICKS -- Now here's a concept the union is in favor of. So it seems just about inevitable that this is a new draft wrinkle that's coming soon. If you have the first pick and you don't want the price tag that comes with Stephen Strasburg, or you don't want the migraine that comes from dealing with Scott Boras, you pick him anyway and then dangle him on the open market. Amazingly, it's always been small-market owners who have opposed the idea of dealing picks. And what's their argument? That it would allow Boras to manipulate the draft. Huh? He manipulates it just fine now.

From Part II of Kevin Goldstein’s “Fixing the Draft” at Baseball Prospectus.

Surprisingly, nearly all people within baseball supported the idea of trading picks, with more than one person mentioning the excitement factor. "One of the most exciting things during the NFL and NBA drafts is when a trade goes down," said one scouting director. "I'd love to add that to baseball."

While everyone has their concerns about the idea, especially with teams just dumping picks, nearly everyone had a solution to that, or just plain didn't care. "Teams are big boys," said another official. "If they're silly enough to give their pick away for nothing, that's their problem."

The biggest concern would be where teams would simply sell their picks to increase revenue, and basically turn into modern versions of the Kansas City A's by selling off their picks every summer. One team simply suggested a system in which picks could be traded, but draft picks could not be included in any deal that includes monetary compensation, with an official saying, "I wouldn't want to see teams simply trading talent, or potential talent, for money they pocket."

Agents were also in favor of some kind of trading system, but one noted that while the general feeling would be that teams willing to spend money would end up with the most picks, he also felt like such trades would be rare. "If you're the Rays and you're loaded in the farm and gunning for a playoff spot, why not see if you could move that pick to a team out of it that can help you now?" he asked, while also suggesting a limit to the number of picks a team can deal.

And from Maury Brown’s aforementioned report for The Biz of Baseball.

There will, unquestionably, be looks at adjusting the draft process. One adjustment that on the face of it comes with little pain in implementing would be the ability to trade draft positions. This would add excitement as seen in the NBA and NFL. An issue with the concept is that it could setup disparity. Clubs that cannot afford bonuses or major league deals for top picks would trade to the likes of the Yankees, Red Sox, Dodgers… clubs in large markets with high revenue levels.

As one agent, who conceptually opposes a slotting system, but discussed the concept, said today, “If you have hard slots, you remove the need to trade picks. The system would prevent going drastically over, which is the problem for some clubs today.”

Prior to the current CBA, the signing deadline for a drafted player extended to one week prior to the next draft.  MLB negotiated the current signing deadline of August 15 with the intent that it would strengthen the clubs hand in negotiations with player agents.  While MLB appears intent on negotiating “mandatory slotting”, some club officials are calling for an earlier signing deadline and perhaps an earlier date for the draft itself to accelerate the development of their draft picks.

Again from Kevin Goldstein at Baseball Prospectus.

Most team officials are willing to give in to the costs of the current system, but it's the loss of development time that is the most jarring. "With the August 15th deadline, all we're getting out of kids this year is an instructional league," said one scouting director. "Every year now, we have more and more kids who can't have a meaningful summer."

Moving the date back one month to July 15th seems to be the most reasonable solution here, as it would get kids the all-important adjustment period out of the way, and it wouldn't change the money aspect in any way. "We're not accomplishing anything this month, and neither are the players," said one team official. "It's just a month of us staring at each other so if we're going to pay the kid anyway, and least we can get them out there playing."

There is also some thought about keeping the signing deadline as-is, but moving the draft back one month to the All-Star break. "Let's face it, we draft before the college season is over, and we're always scrambling around late to get more looks at kids in the northeast," said one scouting director. "I'd love to move it back a month, as we'd just get more information." In order to address the late signings, various insiders had some radical ideas, including extending the seasons of short-season leagues into the end of September. One general manager who discussed taking an advanced circuit like the New York-Penn and Northwest leagues to 110-game seasons that begin in May for players who sign late and aren't ready for current full-season leagues.

From the aforementioned Jonathan Mayo report on the amateur draft for MLB.com.

Some thought should also be given to the timing of the signing deadline. August 15 was agreed on as a time before college classes began, a point important to the clubs because players had used the "Classes start tomorrow" line to force what was then an artificial deadline. August 1 was proposed initially, but the union wanted it moved to Aug. 15 to provide more time for negotiations.

In truth, though, most of the big negotiations don't take place until right before the deadline hits. It's an arbitrary wall, one that could just as easily be on July 1 as it is currently placed. Moving it up would enable any signed player to still get two months of work in with his new organization. Even if he didn't pitch, imagine how ahead of the game Strasburg would be having that time to work out with his new instructors. "It does make sense. I don't see the downside to it," Coonelly agreed. "It doesn't take time to negotiate these contracts, so there's no reason it can't be as early as July 1 and the players would have the opportunity to play somewhat sooner."

Will “mandatory slotting” become a reality in MLB?  Can the MLBPA be enticed in the upcoming round of CBA negotiations to consent to such?  Isn’t the MLBPA philosophically opposed to any “capping” of compensaton?  (MLB is the only “cap free” “stick and ball” league)  Why should the MLBPA agree to “mandatory slotting” when record amounts of dollars are being awarded to players chosen in the draft?  As clubs increase the amount of money they invest in young players (Rule 4, international free agents, long term deals “buying out” arbitration eligible years and early years of free agency), veteran players are finding diminished demand for their services.  Will “rookie compensation” be an important issue in the upcoming CBA negotiations?  Will the current members of the MLBPA “sell out” the future members?  Is MLB agitating on the issue of “rookie compensation” with the intent of influencing MLBPA members to lobby their leadership to accept “mandatory slotting”?

Once more, from Kevin Goldstein at Baseball Prospectus.

The problem all along of course has been that the Players Association has never been open to any idea of mandatory slots or spending limits, believing that any talk on that level begins the slippery slope to a true salary cap. However, recent developments in the way teams are spending may be lining up a change in stance by the players. "The impetus for change is definitely going to come from the big leaguers," said one official. "These zero through six[-year] guys [in terms of service time] are so valuable, and that's where teams are spending all of their money," he explained. "The issue here is that the economic model now encourages teams to spend on player procurement instead of on established big leaguers. What we're seeing is a collapse of the middle class, and the union is likely understandably concerned by it."

Again from Jayson Stark at ESPN.

SLOTTING -- Baseball is now the only major sport that doesn't have some sort of system that regulates how much drafted players can get paid. And that can't go on. Not just because the clubs want slotting, either. It's because players want it. We've polled a bunch of them. And big league players want those $15 million deals going to them, not to kids who have never played a professional baseball game.

Again from Buster Olney at ESPN.

A negotiated system of draft bonuses on a descending scale, like the NBA has, as opposed to the current MLB system that recommends a bonus for each slot. This way, there would be no holdouts, and drafted players would know what they were getting. "The union might go for it because then they could determine how big a slice of the pie the drafted players will get," says one executive. "As time goes on, those guys are getting a bigger slice, and it's cutting into what the veterans are making."

Sam Mellinger reported for the Kansas City Star on the veteran backlash against “rookie compensation”.

There are baseball players who will say similar things privately, but the wrath and strength of the union in that sport is such that Ryan Howard’s words to ESPN.com are about as strong as you’ll hear publicly:

“It’s a crazy process. Obviously, (Strasburg’s) got a rare talent, to be able to throw as hard as he does. But the bottom line is, you’re not proven...Even when you get to the big leagues, you’ve got to prove you’re worth whatever you’re trying to get.”

Reminds me of Billy Butler’s words two years ago when talking about the negotiations of Mike Moustakas, which ran just minutes before the deadline.

“Kids don’t understand you don’t make your money on your signing bonus. You make it by establishing yourself in the big leagues. The more you hold out, you’re wasting a year of your career, I think.”

Craig Calcaterra wrote at NBC Sports that he doesn’t foresee the MLBPA opposing “mandatory slotting” with much vigour.

...Most people don't realize this, but draftees aren't union members -- you don't become eligible to join the union until you're on a 40-man roster -- yet the members have the power to negotiate the terms of the draft.  As such, giving the owners a hard slotting system doesn't truly take anything off the union's plate.

Sure, they don't want to be seen as laying down to ownership so they'll demand something in return, but make no mistake: current players aren't fans of rapidly-escalating amateur signing bonuses, and the sorts of things they'll likely take from ownership in exchange for a hard slotting system fall on the "better lunch meat on the postgame spread" end of the spectrum than on the end where things of real value reside.  It's certainly not work-stoppage material.

In Jonathan Mayo’s report on the amateur draft for MLB.com, Pirates President Frank Coonelly argued that curtailing the amount of dollars being spent on signing bonuses would increase the amount of money spent on veteran players’ salaries.  Mr. Mayo also reports that at least one retired player disagrees with Mr. Coonelly’s assertion, the same former player questioning if “slotting” naturally leads to the implementation of a salary cap.

"Is it broken?" Coonelly asked. "It certainly needs to be adjusted in my view in a manner that not only helps clubs in giving them the ability and capacity to select the best player, but also helps Major League players, because every dollar that's spent in the Draft is not spent on Major League players."

If there wasn't a resounding "Amen" from the players choir on that last point, there at least seemed to be some interest in hearing more. Players, both past and current, were more willing to publicly talk about the exploding bonuses. On MLB Network, players-turned-analysts like Harold Reynolds took umbrage over how down the free-agent market for established veterans was (see Abreu, Bobby) while Draft bonuses continued to climb.

The natural extension from that, it stands to reason, would be a willingness to consider things like a hard slotting system. Get that structure under control, the logic follows, and there would be an infusion of dollars into the Major League market, right? Maybe not.

"Your premise would be correct, except that it would be tough to suggest that just because money wouldn't be spent in one area, it would be spent in another," said recently retired Tony Clark, a former associate player representative on the Major League Baseball Players Association Executive Board and now an analyst with MLB Network. "It's an interesting proposition. If it was simply that cut and dry, then I think there would be an opportunity to discuss things moving forward. It never is that simple. Every group is connected."

Clark's point is that how draftees get paid impacts how Minor Leaguers get paid and on up to established veterans in a trickle-up manner. Putting a cap on Draft bonuses,he feels, could lead to changes in the entire salary structure for professional players.

“It has been fought for decades in our game, affording our players an opportunity to maximize their earning potential in as free a market as possible," Clark explained. "If you look at a lot of the other sports leagues, they each have a 'slotting system' in place and they also have rookie caps and veteran caps and team caps, assuming one decision has led to another based on what I mentioned.

In May, Liz Mullen reported in The Sports Business Journal on comments made by now outgoing MLBPA Executive Director Donald Fehr on the subject of “rookie compensation”.

“One of the things you have to be wary of, when you talk about the issues that were just raised, is in collective bargaining generally, and sports is certainly no exception to this, very often people will look, on the other side, will look for wedge issues.”

Fehr said the “classic example of a wedge issue” is one in which one group in a union is told another group is getting too much money “and you should all go and squabble with one another.”

“Now I don’t know if that is involved in this circumstance here, but on this side of the table we are all very conscious of such issues and where the instigation of raising such an issue comes from. If it comes from the players’ side, you don’t have to worry about it, because it will come with a proposed solution.”

The resentment over “rookie compensation” amongst MLBPA veterans is understandable but perhaps unreasonable.  The now widespread use of “objective analysis” in evaluating players has resulted in clubs reaping better results from the Rule 4 draft.  (Fewer busts)  Simultaneously, “objective analysis” has diminished the value of veteran players. (Historically often overpaid in the last years of long-term contracts)  Questions (justified or not) concerning the ability of veteran players to maintain performance levels late into their careers in the “post PED” era have also diminished their value.

Erik Manning argued at FANGRAPHS (HT Rob Neyer) that amateur draft picks (at least first round picks) are a great investment even at today’s record prices.

The general feeling seems to be that draft picks need to prove something before they get paid, and that handing out big dollars to a player who hasn’t done anything in the big leagues is a huge waste of resources. After all, even first round draft picks bust all the time. But are they really overpaid?

AND

Even with the relatively high failure rate, first round draft picks are incredibly valuable and actually have proven to be quite a bargain. For example, recommended slot for the first overall pick is this year was $3.6M. While it’s only a group of ten players, 1st overall picks from ’90-’99 produced on average $51.5 million worth of value that a team would normally pay for on the free agent market, or about roughly 14 times today’s recommended bonus!

Even with his record deal, Stephen Strasburg is a great value. If you don’t think so, just imagine the bidding war that would go on between large market teams if he were a free agent. Dump the slots. Let teams do whatever they want. If they can’t do their homework on what a kid’s asking price is before the draft him, that’s their own failure.

Ultimately, there is no question that MLB clubs are spending record amounts of money developing players while the percentage of industry revenues being paid out to MLB players has been steadily diminishing.  Could a decrease in the former amount and an increase in the latter amount lead MLB and the MLBPA to common ground on the “mandatory slotting” issue?

Eric Fisher reported for The Sports Business Journal in June.

And it has not gone unnoticed in the players’ camp how their percentage of overall industry revenue, standing at 52 percent in 2008, has slipped slightly in recent years as baseball has grown to unprecedented heights. MLB players in the early part of the decade saw their salaries represent a percentage of league revenue that was in the high 50s to low 60s.

While comparisons with other leagues can be difficult — MLB is the only major league without a salary cap, and MLB clubs spend millions of dollars on player development for players in the minor leagues — the percentage for MLB players now trails comparable player marks in the other major U.S. professional sports.

The Biz of Baseball reported in January.

Annual player development costs have risen to an average of approximately $20 million per club. Boston Red Sox Chairman Tom Werner addressed the subject in March with Sports Business Daily. "Every major league club spends about $20 million a year on growing their talent," Werner said. "We have a minor league system and coaches and trainers and all kinds of personnel that just aren't equivalent in football or in basketball, where you have the college system as a way of being their minor league."

In March, Andrew Zimbalist wrote in The SportsBusiness Journal.

...MLB teams have to cover very substantial minor league player costs, while the NBA (NBA Development League) and the NHL (AHL and a few players in the ECHL) have modest minor league player costs and the NFL has none.

Moreover, the NBA D-League and AHL also generate revenue that helps to defray the player costs. The minor league MLB teams are mostly independently owned and, in any case, the revenue earned does not go to major league teams. Yet the major league team pays the salaries of all the players on affiliated clubs.

In 2007, the average MLB team spent more than $20 million on its player development system. Of this, over $11.5 million went to pay the salaries of the minor league players.

Generally, each MLB team has six minor league affiliates. Teams also run fall and winter development camps and leagues. Together, an average of 6.2 percent of MLB revenue went toward these minor league salaries.

The player salary and benefit share of NFL revenue in 2006-07 were 58.4 percent. The respective shares in the NBA, NHL and MLB (2007) were 57 percent, 55.6 percent and 51 percent.

If we add the 6.2 percent that goes to minor league baseball players (without generating revenue for the major league club), the total player share in MLB revenue rises to 57.2 percent, putting it ahead of the NBA and NHL shares.

Some form of “mandatory slotting” is likely to be introduced for the 2011 draft (an expansion of the draft into Latin America and perhaps elsewhere is also a real possibility).  In return, look for the MLBPA to bargain for changes that will benefit their existing membership in the areas of free agency, salary arbitration and perhaps increased roster size.

MORE ON MLB RECRUITING GLOBALLY

Last week’s edition of LWIB focused on the growing number of MLB players being recruited from a growing number of countries outside the US.  The increased number of Japanese players coming to the US and perhaps more importantly, leaving Japan at earlier ages (Junichi Tazawa) was a focal point of the report.  This week in LWIB, Stuart Biggs reported for Bloomberg that an 18 year old Japanese pitcher who reportedly throws a 94 mph fastball will decide by October whether to forego Japanese professional baseball in favour of playing in the US.  Mr. Biggs reports that if the 18 year old – Yusei Kikuchi – opts for the US it could greatly accelerate the trend, started by Tazawa, of Japanese players coming to the US at younger ages.

Fifty thousand people packed into Koshien Stadium watch Yusei Kikuchi throw 94 mile-an-hour fastballs in Japan’s biggest sporting event: the summer high school baseball tournament. It may be their last chance.

By October, the 18-year-old must choose Japan or the U.S. for a career he’s dreamed about since primary school. Signing at home would rule Kikuchi out of a U.S. move for as many as nine years, while choosing Major League Baseball may open the door to a stream of amateurs spurning Japan for a chance to play alongside countrymen like Ichiro Suzuki and Daisuke Matsuzaka.

“Kikuchi would open things up completely,” Danny MacLeith, a scout for the Chicago Cubs, said in an Aug. 17 interview behind home plate at Koshien, in Nishinomiya city west of Osaka. “If he’s available and wants to go, he needs to say so because the Japanese draft is two months away. It’s time.”

AND

Nippon Professional Baseball in 1998 introduced a system mandating that players with less than nine years of experience can go to the U.S. only if their team auctions their rights. The Red Sox paid Seibu $51 million just to negotiate with Matsuzaka.

Kikuchi’s departure would be different. As a senior at Hanamaki Higashi High School in the northern prefecture of Iwate, he’s not subject to those rules.

MLB teams have mostly avoided amateurs because the agreement between the two countries is vague and players have been unwilling to risk a U.S. move without professional experience in Japan, MacLeith said.

Red Sox Signing

That changed last year when the Red Sox signed pitcher Junichi Tazawa, to a three-year, $3 million contract. Tazawa had asked Japanese pro teams not to draft him out of the amateur corporate leagues, a step between high school and the NPB, because he favored going to the U.S.

“After Tazawa, more Japanese players may feel they can make the jump,” John Cox, the San Francisco Giants’ director of scouting for the Pacific Rim, said in an Aug. 17 interview at Koshien before watching Kikuchi pitch. “Sometimes when a small hole appears in the dam, the water comes gushing out.”


OTHER NEWS ACROSS THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK

(THE BIZ OF BASKETBALL)

(THE BIZ OF FOOTBALL)

(THE BIZ OF HOCKEY)


Pete Toms is an author for the Business of Sports Network, most notably, The Biz of Baseball. He looks forward to your comments and can be contacted through The Biz of Baseball.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow The Biz of Baseball on Twitter Twitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?
 


long time side effects proventil buying cialis professional in manchester cardura pills online in the india online fluss 40 overnight delivery order cialis on line uk alli uk companies only purchase atomoxetin in australia artane online with out prescription phone in order for flovent sildenafil citrate canada online no prescription tretinoin 0,025 pricing brand isotretin buy trileptal without rx best place buy probalan pct mobic on line in the india order depakine chrono on line canada buyers of levitra plus canada buy nitrofurantoin low cheap price evista drug class buy amoxiline pills in the canada flucazole online ordering flucazole canada companies only how to use lisinopril levitra coupon cheap cialis fast where to buy feldene with amex best place to buy curacne in canada orlistat uk no prescription cost of tizanidina is mail order lady era safe original cabaser online dilantin from mexico cost of mail diovan indian generics online cialis professional ivenox india sale deltasone for sale philippines order misoprost online no prescription with a amex list of tesco stores selling ampicillin flagyl for dogs buy where to buy nitrofurantoin with mastercard microzide no prescription overnight delivery better than vagifem amoxil online india doksazosin lek birth control online india buy glucofage hong kong vytorin drug in canada pharmacy fluticanose prices at costco minomycin order online zebeta spain movalis trusted online drug stores in canada torsemide usa cvs prices maxalt limited india bupropion mail order where could i buy medrol dosepak without prescription kamagra on line in the india tamoxifen online mexico purchase emoquette on line in india calan canada companies only zydis trusted online drug stores in canada buy cialis super active online from uk provera for sale buy pyridium online no prescription order exelon uk pharmacy online pharmacy misoprost where to buy tadalis with amex best site to buy diclofenac gel retin a 0,05 shopping what drug category is aviane 28 buy lamisilate with paypal curacne noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy yasmin buy canada retin a 0,05 fast usa vistaril fast mexico furosemide usa cvs prices buy lopressor perth australia fastest curacne uk delivery raloxifeno for sale australia order benadryl online no presctiption minomycin mg buy best site get voveran sr where do i actoplus met in mexico celapram legal us chloromycetin where to get c ratioph online ordering acai birth control online india viagra jelly birth control online us paxil tablets from buy online no prescription uk for fasigyn serophene generic wikipedia drugs buy glucofage mexican pharmacies thyroxine from india metoclopramide uk next day delivery zanaflex online purchase levoxyl medication order wellbutrin online uk buy isoniazid in ireland comprar percocet original comprar cialis soft original en madrid tadacip drug class buy malegra dxt hong kong zyloprim results forum us online pharmacy no prescription viagra soft is generic l thyroxine available in usa cipla canada where can i buy neurontin tablets acai mg tablet pill rx health levitra products buy zestoretic without rx order nexium overnight renova online with out prescription azithromycin uses buy apo clopidogrel with a mastercard uk buy celebrex without prescription oder mg tablets of kamagra oral jelly biaxin tablets uses decadron express canada oxybutyninum without a prescription from mexico buy generic amaryl online no prescription long term side effects of requip canada pharmacies online that sell keflex speman results forum elimite usa pharmacy lopid drug in canada pharmacy serevent without prescrip generic evista canada lansoprazol where can i buy it buy generic aricept online no prescription suppliers of triamterenum in us etabus mg canadian rx what is prinivil used for raciper for sale australia best place buy lopid pct what is cipro tablets biaxin for sale quetiapinum to buy in the uk without a prescription elocon buy australia cialis professional to buy from europe evista india sale discount plendil otc what is cilest pravachol from china viagra otc cardizem brand positioning maxalt over counter ordering retino a cream 0,05 on line quibron t online coupon code buy probalan online from australia requip weight gain lisinopril fast canada cheap fasigyne mg lotrel canada prescription buy over the counter wellbutrin sr online sumycin buy diarex online pharmacy furosemide mexico no prescription buy olanzapine online overnight zetia no prescription needed depakote canadian medications without prescription do i need a prescription for allopurinol cheap novo digoxin prinivil mexico pharmacy purchase cytotec on line in india order ciplox tablets no prescription cytotec sale phenergan shortage buy roaccutane low cheap price generic lipitor india costco pharmacy renova price sildenafila trusted online drug stores in canada generic zedd usa ordering procardia canada orlistar coupon code is there a shortage of toprol xl quibron t shop net where do i metronidazol in india mentat without a prescription from canada vistaril express canada order desyrel on line india comprar hydrochlorothiazide portugal cost of benicar motrin india sale generic frumil buy canada albuterol next day delivery probalan uk brand name brand viagra generic uk where to buy curacne with amex alli without a prescription from australia cheap strattera mg sumycin no prescription cheapest microzide tablets uk plendil mexico no prescription skelaxin in croatia brand cialis drugstore.com seasonique cheap australia pharmacy buy silagra tablets uk purchase lopid in uk can order tadalis sx canada how to order fucidin online pharmacy buy drugs cefixime where to buy duphalac with amex med cab benicar where can i buy amoxiline mg suppliers of rogaine 5 in us where to buy remeron online canada estradiol valerate prices usa generic pills for zofran order exelon online uk buy apo furosemida online imitrex uk online cheapest cafergot paypal curacne delivered to your home imitrex daily use reviews celapram over the counter uk frumil from canada without rx buy colchicine online no prescription usa cialis no prescription canada female viagra on line in the mexico online adalat india amoxiline purchase indian generics online vardenafilum purchase levitra professional in mexico ayurslim buy india med cab oxybutyninum over counter flucazole suprax without a prescription from india buy levitra hong kong can order viagra professional online fluticanose cheap uk pharmacy safe to buy generic accutane from uk buy valtrex online no prescription usa amlodipinbesilat australia companies only canadian pharmacy online simvastatina order propranolol online without rx minomycin canada drug store zoloft drugstore.com buy carbozyne tablets usa best place to buy lamisilate in australia citalopram from australia baridium supplier in uk aloprim tablets from buy over the counter medicine that acts as diamox buy mentax low cheap price buy aldactone online augmentin 625 duo deltasone buy uk celexa medication overnight delivery buy retino a cream 0,05 online no prescription pravachol from canada purchase colchicina in australia is lipitor available over the counter costco pharmacy moduretic price what is venlafaxina for florinef buy india buy lantus online from usa bentyl order online no prescription the chepest metoclopramide safe to buy generic rythmol sr from usa flomax from canada buy biaxin boots order deltasone from canada without prescription tadalis buy online india safe to buy generic janumet from usa vagifem mg mexico buy oristal online overnight how to order amoxycillin online frumil tablets tinidazolum online in uk v gel pharmacy prices list vasotec roche precio argentina usa buy elocom without prescription elimite canada overnight delivery order cialis sublingual without rx ditropan perth australia do i need a prescription for carvedilolo ayurslim uk brand name can you take lanoxin daily klipal codeine sublingual dosage can you buy amoxil over the counter in germany how much will trandate cost erection packs 2 for men sale in uk buy levitra plus online from australia indian generics online ortho cyclen discount albenza from usa claravis online pharmacy shipped to canada buy pravachol inhaler canada clincin mexico pharmacy tindamax over counter uk cefixime generic india promethazine no script buy sepibest pills in the us order microzide from canada without prescription side effects of aciphex tizanidina india imitrex legal us canada mentax tablets online costco pharmacy raloxifeno price shuddha guggulu without prescription pills voveran sr prescription only order fluss 40 online without rx bystolic mg mexico oratane pills online in the india ordering aricept uk ordering ephedraxin mexico tegretol on line in the mexico viagra professional canada companies only eldepryl fast mexico buy wigraine online from usa do you need rx zithromax cymbalta suppositories buy apo furosemida no prescription overnight delivery order fucidin from canada without prescription ortho cyclen pill shortage prednisone prices at costco get viagra online in canada where to buy retin a 0,025 without a prescription sarafem mexico no prescription oracea generic reviews canadian drug company lisinopril toprol buy online mexico quetiapinum mg tablet fluconazol pharmacy mail order norvasc prescription only crestor without prescription valtrex canada online no prescription how to purchase salbumol drugs no prescription needed best site for orlistatum buy advair pills in the uk low price zyvox uk best place to buy bupropion online brand cialis over the counter usa propranolol drug in canada pharmacy minomycin lowest price online medrol dosepak fast uk buy snovitra super power tablets canada buy diprosone online no prescription us detrol mg buy purchase cefixime in us himcolin birth control online canada is it safe to order ditropan triamterenum discount where can i get amantadine can order tretinoin 0,025 canada how to order aldactone how to take obelit mg baclofen online pay paypal estrofem discount revatio generic 2013 drugs where to buy acai online without rx purchase cozaar in australia where can i buy alli online without a prescription mexican pharmacy no prescription promethazine india pharmacies online that sell ivenox buy amaryl online without prescription nexium on line in the usa can you buy cipro online purchase dutasterid in mexico ordering zyrtec uk allopurinol to purchase without a prescription safe to buy generic flonase from usa orlistato online canadian claravis uses medication viagra sublingual where can i buy ventolin online pharmacy uk generic levitra super active us cost of mail hyzaar venlafaxina where can i buy buy over the counter key pred online estradiol valerate usa pharmacy moduretic canada overnight delivery buy elavil pills in the mexico best place to buy toprol in australia cheapest zanaflex tablets uk minipress pills online in the usa where do i isotretin in india coversyl with paypal payment florinef over the counter drugs lady era online canadian buy avapro online with no prescription snovitra super power australia pharmacy how much will dutasterid cost how to buy cephalexin application of ciprofloxacin seasonique tablets from buy best place to buy desyrel in usa roxithromycin order canada discount tetracycline from canada zantac without subscription atorlip 10 over the counter drugs buy ivenox tablets india buy risperdal australia exelon over the counter usa ordering pariet ondansetrona online usa no prescription ginette 35 generic australia thyrohormone medication overnight delivery comprar zedd original en madrid alavert pricing beta val from canada order bentyl online without rx flunil from canada with no prescription buy anafranil online canada yasmin uses medication quibron t online legally oxybutyninum from canada without rx tretinoin 0,05 usa no prescription yagara for sale philippines cialis sears pharmacy a good web page to buy eurax with no script pill rx health order minocin products zenegra online mexico best place buy baridium pct vpxl uk buy adalat birth control online canada buy femara online with out prescription trial erection packs 2 for men in usa best place to buy meloxicam enolat online what drug category is doxi 1 methotrexate buy no prescription can you buy tetracycline online bactrim drug in mexico pharmacy best place to buy cafergot without a prescription tadapox no prescription overnight delivery what types of erection packs 3 are there how to take depakote mg generic propranolol safe glucofage with prescription motrin prix en pharmacie en france indocin usa cvs prices ordering vistaril mexico buy rogaine 2 mg online purchase serevent on line in australia evista online from uk sale celapram best place to buy tinidazole without a prescription cafergot over the counter uk dapoxetine sold over counter how to use estro toprol drug in germany pharmacy brand name zovirax online rosuvastatin canada kamagra order canada buy percocet online from usa get skelaxin toronto medazole to buy in the usa without a prescription buy brand coreg buy trileptal capsules half price mentax generic medazole canada cialis professional prices cvs best place to buy trimox buy tofranil tablets usa purchase tadalis sx pills buy rythmol sr online reviews wellbutrin no prescription triamterenum medication on line minocin buy online canada where to buy prednisona with amex buy zocor online from usa what types of beta val are there differin without subscription canadian drug company hoodia clavamox india canada and flagyl where to buy actoplus drugs online estrofem prix en pharmacie en france buy zoloft tablets india purchase dutasterid on line in australia avapro shortage tadacip birth control online australia purchase buspar on line in canada buy minocin pills in the india lisinopril to buy in the canada without a prescription retino a cream prescription coupon prinivil india pharmacy estradiol valerate india no prescription naprosyn mg india zetia generico italiano online azitromicina with no prescription colchicine on line in the india strattera buy no prescription where to buy prednisone mg nootropil birth control online india buy avalide online without prescription propecia brands india buy zestoretic online with no prescription estrace pharmacy mail order thyrohormone generic india clomifene order online no prescription plendil with no subscription best place to buy novo digoxin in usa can you only get valaciclovir on prescription cialis no prescription needed trandate uses medication atarax no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy emsam generic 2013 drugs safe yasmin no precription purchase alfa flucon in uk prandin online ordering cheap ciprofloxacina zocor medication overnight delivery buy acticin online no prescription zovirax side effects uk feldene where to get cipralex online forum where to buy cialis sublingual drugs online bentyl tablets from buy buy bupron sr uk where can i buy seroquel mg ciplox drug in uk pharmacy lithium prices duphalac over the counter buy trial erection packs 1 no prescription aloprim buy without thyrox fast canada yaz canada online no prescription singulair to buy in the usa without a prescription top 10 online cardizem sites half price methotrexate provera online from uk cialis jelly in usa canada and pyridium buy hytrin online india no prescription buy aldactone with no script riperdal without prescription pills how much is hyzaar tablets canadian lamisilate cheapest minocycline paypal canada buy flagyl without prescription order seroflo online uk tofranil drug in fr pharmacy buy prednisona tablets usa buy frusemide online albenda buy online mexico canada eurax tablets online buy zydis in india online cost of mail asacol where do i fluoxetina in india pravachol online without prescription inderal over counter duetact where to buy in canada v gel coupon code ranitidine reviews for men aldactone without a prescription from india zanaflex fast india where can i buy actos mg is albenda available on line in canada accutane discount tinidazolum uk next day delivery flucazole online lopid over counter elocon drug in usa pharmacy mometasona prices at costco purchase nitroglycerin in uk ordering levoxyl usa indian pharmacy metronidazol online lopressor with no prescription lexapro from india pill rx health order flonase products mevacor birth control online canada prednisolona for purchase without a prescription proventil buy uk buy duetact boots pharmacy yagara phone orders bactroban legal us uk pharmacies online that sell zithromax microzide mg mexico isoptin without a prescription from us shallaki generico italiano quetiapinum buy online mexico how to identify fake cialis where do i lipothin in usa azurette for sale australia shuddha guggulu without a prescription wigraine india pharmacy nizagara order actoplus met buy india can you get toradol levoxyl over the counter india thyrox buy online canada where to buy pilex without a prescription differin generic wikipedia drugs medrol suppositories buy online zocor india zocor mexico no prescription probalan non perscription countries aleve online uk comprar colchicina original en madrid can buy phenergan online cheap aciclovir uk amoxiline next day levlen online ordering probalan over the counter australia lopressor delivery uk where to purchase viagra plus prednisone lawsuit do you need rx ampicilina purchase zyrtec in usa canadian seroflo buy allegra singapore is cafergot legal in uk lipitor doctors online depakine chrono generic canada requip birth control online australia best place to buy carvedilolo cheapest valaciclovir paypal generic nizoral canada reglan cheap uk pharmacy oder mg tablets of estrofem uk buy tadalis sx without prescription deltasone drugstore com pricing comprar diclofenac original en madrid best place to buy methotrexate in usa floxin over the counter australia vagifem phone orders online zofran overnight delivery amaryl order in the us discount arjuna otc how to take procardia mg detrol without script where can i buy janumet can i buy medrol dosepak in canada roxithromycin reviews for men prevacid perth australia where to buy pulmicort online india how to purchase seroflo online wellbutrin overnight delivery can you only get erection packs 3 on prescription buy albenda pills in the mexico order buspar online no prescription with a mastercard cialis sublingual without a script amantadine canada head office levoxyl fast mexico purchasing almetec online pulmicort with prescription online zestoretic purchase thyrohormone online from usa nexium online from india cost of lisinopril without insurance list of tesco stores selling prednisolone serophene cheap canada pharmacy buy cipro mg online buy tretinoin 0,025 online reviews where do i avodart in mexico is generic amitriptyline available in usa is mail order accutane safe generic erythromycin for sale on line fluconazol doctors online buy serophene mg online for safe place order maxalt xenical prices tamsulozin australia pharmacy 50mg doxycycline for acne flagyl pills online in the canada astelin tablets uses procardia delivery renova dosage instructions astelin cheap us pharmacy alti doxycycline fda approved to buy without prescription tamsulozin without prescription pills januvia italiano anastrozolo mexico pharmacy how to buy metocarbamol online cheap bactroban free delivery erection packs 3 generic canada tadalis online canadian purchase generic cialis super active purchase tegretol in canada microzide medication beta val generico italiano fastest glucophage uk delivery how to get himcocid in australia is carvedilolo available over the counter proscar cheap us pharmacy alfa flucon pills online in the australia omnicef pills sweat minomycin cheapest rate medrol dosepak without rx india pharmacies online that sell zantac best site get betnovate order frusemide on line usa anastrozolo tablets price online pharmacy paypal purchase ditropan in australia order crestor online canada purchase clopidogrelum pills all types zyban pills geriforte without script depakine chrono generico italiano diarex online in us trental results forum suppliers of dostinex in us ditropan trusted online drug stores in canada omnicef india sale silagra usa sale fasigyn with paypal payment sale cardizem amoxycillin pills online in the uk ciprofloksacin from usa best place to buy keppra online disulfiramum uk no prescription simvastatina online no prescription where to buy prinivil in canada safely compazine mexico companies only cilest from canada without rx best price mircette norvasc results forum pharmacy buy drugs wigraine cymbalta us companies only cheap genuine trial erection packs 3 online buy eltroxin mg toradol dose himcolin drug in germany pharmacy generic uk paypal duphalac altace canada prescription buy zofran pills in the us where can i get levothyroxin comprar premarin original buy silagra uk online erection packs 3 overnight delivery altace drugstore.com purchase aldactone in india tricor buy australia seroflo medicine children albenza delivery uk zithromax canadian online overnight pharmacy apo clopidogrel online in us purchase trial erection packs 3 lowest price leukeran with no rx permethrinum without rx generic lanoxin us purchase yasmin on line in australia online pharmacy acai is kamagra legal in uk order amlodipin online without rx fastest cialis sublingual uk delivery cheapest nitrofurantoin paypal zyloprim weight gain indian pharmacy colchicina buying furosemide liv 52 lawsuit canada online bupron sr purchase combivent cheap uk arjuna pills lotrel over the counter india floxin online in usa cheapest branded drugs cabaser online usa canadian drug company sildenafil citrate best place buy hyzaar pct order triamterene online no presctiption feldene in croatia maxalt from china pariet birth control online us vasotec without a prescription from us ginseng without prescription medication serophene tablets price promethazine canada cleocin discount no prescription tegretol online in usa canada buy risperdal without prescription ginette 35 to buy in the uk without a prescription permethrinum online canada seroquel online coupon code pill rx health order propranolol products hydrochlorothiazide daily use reviews discount klipal codeine from usa order apo furosemida from uk without prescription order trial erection packs 2 from india without prescription generic innopran xl no prescription zitromax fast mexico order beconase aq on line usa is almetec available over the counter what does roaccutan prometrium next day can i make elocon ortho cyclen fast usa lamisil pharmacy mail order how to order estrofem online riperdal overnight delivery buy olanzapine online uk no prescription buy over the counter tetracycline online raciper prices at costco dyazide women buy can i buy bentyl in canada order bupropion on line mexico purchase brafix on line in the uk buy propranolol xr without prescription avapro on line in the india where to buy shallaki with mastercard buy antivert online no prescription usa fluticanose lowest price online triamterenum from uk med cab cafergot anafranil buy india provera medication overnight delivery purchase erythromycin on line in mexico comprar hydrodiuril original online imitrex with no prescription trileptal over the counter no script grifulvin v mg order estrofem from mexico without prescription buy pariet in singapore dostinex lowest price online buy wellbutrin sr pills in the india ayurslim delivery best wellbutrin sr prices proventil uk sale clozaril without a prescription from canada himcolin legal in england ivenox australia pharmacy buy generic mircette online with prescription what types of himcolin are there billig grifulvin v online kaufen unisom online mexico buspar buy usa buy aricept usa lithium order by phone cephalexin by mastercard long time side effects meclizine allegra discount no prescription purchase moduretic in india buy innopran xl uk buy ortho tri cyclen with paypal cheap canadian caffeine ergotamine no prescription buy oracea online no prescription usa hytrin order online order retin a 0,05 pills buy remeron online no prescription riperdal lowest price buy revatio online no prescription uk ordering zofran canada percocet canadian online overnight pharmacy diflucan suppositories buy aceon order sepibest online pharmacy uk buy cephalexin online from canada what is esperal mg used to treat buy tizanidinum online pharmacy amoxil with no rx cozaar without script thyroxine canada drug store purchase acnetane online no prescription zocor uk companies only buy bupropion online without rx compare prices exelon buy antara online reviews ordering toprol xl canada metformin medicine online buy lotrisone online thru paypals finpecia cheap canada pharmacy moduretic on line no script buy brand amoxil tablets canada toprol online pharmacy shipped to canada purchase lady era on line in canada florida oracea vagifem mexico companies only order glucovance online no presctiption estrofem mg no prescription safe to buy generic eldepryl from canada buy lozol pills online is mail order glucofage safe where can i buy zetia tablets canadian pharmacy online klipal codeine seroflo prices order zocor on line india ordering mometasona on line ephedraxin australia companies only buy bystolic online india no prescription diflucan online without prescription ordering key pred albenza without a prescription from uk wigraine mg buy liposafe generic canada pill rx health tadalis sx products order esperal from canada without prescription trimox canada head office cheapest remeron tablets uk tinidazolum to buy in england order mentax online no prescription with a amex alti doxycycline pharmacy mail order cymbalta canada companies only best place to buy aciphex online canada prilosec tablets online mometasona buy canada ciplox maximum dosage ordering levothyroxin mexico where can i buy salvent mg buying motilium buy phenamax online pharmacy where to get ginette 35 pct buy motilium online canada generic rogaine 5 buy canada florida retino a cream accuran phone orders where do i trial erection packs 2 in usa diprolene canadian medications without prescription florida zedd best place to buy estradiol valerate online clomid in usa generic biaxin usa pharmacy metocarbamol purchase l thyroxine drug in fr pharmacy shallaki canada head office celebrex fast mexico cialis professional india pharmacy order aleve without rx accutane without prescription pills albendazole italiano can you order albenda antivert tablets minocycline uk no prescription generic stieva a switzerland zofran medicine online discount omnicef otc buy malegra dxt online without a prescription wigraine online from canada better than ayurslim retin a gel 0,1 supplier in uk furosemide australia pharmacy buy mobic australia where can i buy viagra tablets online ondansetrona purchase buy brafix xr without prescription best place to buy fluconazol in canada research grade isotretin can you buy percocet online over the counter drugs similar to cardizem buy thyroxine tablets australia do i need a prescription for zydis nitroglycerin to purchase without a prescription buy lithium orotate canada do i need a prescription for paroxetine lady era generic 2013 drugs doxycycline legal us ordering kamagra india buy endep tablets us where can i buy bupron sr online without a prescription himcocid usa no prescription canadian pharmacy ciprofloksacin acai without a prescription from australia list of tesco stores selling tamsulozin best price for real atomoxetin uk buy lansoprazol without prescription levitra mg mexico discount viagra of canada buy florinef with a mastercard baridium delivery uk best price viagra super active online viagra sublingual india where to buy snovitra super power mg what is aricept mg used to treat what does priligy tenormin tablets price aloprim over the counter geriforte tablets buy neurontin pills online in the mexico buy levaquin low cheap price tizanidina for dogs buy do you need rx flucazole albenza medication zenegra over the counter india methotrexate india companies only oratane canada prescription order colchicine overnight cheap retino a cream no prescription usa buy lansoprazol without prescription buy adalat greece non prescription bystolic pharmacy percocet prix en pharmacie en france cialis soft uses medication cialis professional online no prescription purchase vermox online no prescription where do i acnetane in india order retino a cream 0,05 from australia without prescription best place to buy cipralex in canada buy female cialis online overnight delivery tenormin buy online uk order prandin without prescription indian pharmacy arzomicin microzide in usa seasonique without a prescription from us lexapro without a prescription from mexico trileptal generic name artane buy india how to buy shuddha guggulu in london is pyridium available on line in canada purchase kamagra in usa alfa flucon discount no prescription fasigyn cheap canada pharmacy can you order provera non prescription citalopram pharmacy can you buy brafix over the counter in germany buy sumycin tablets mexico torsemide pills online in the india buy propecia online from mexico femara usa pharmacy diclofenac no prescription fedex ups order advair online ditropan drug in usa pharmacy suprax with no subscription citalopram without prescription medication where can i get skelaxin from leukeran without a script canadian pharmacy online predalone l thyroxine legal us over the counter drugs similar to alli minipress from usa pharmacy searchbox coversyl drug class buy raciper usa exelon roche precio argentina unisom mg no prescription order metronidazol online without rx where to buy retin a gel 0,1 mg levlen generico italiano stromectol next day delivery buy retino a cream 0,05 tablets australia torsemide canada prescription lithium carbonate without rx diclofenac for sale where to buy detrol ointment can you buy diprosone carafate reviews januvia on line no script cost of celapram buy claravis with no script pharmacy has best price flunil protonix over the counter usa order claravis from mexico without prescription minomycin online purchase order revatio online no prescription with a mastercard prozac from usa pharmacy prevacid no prescription overnight delivery topamax generic usa usa buy lamisil without prescription mobic medicine online buy brand viagra online no prescription us imitrex over counter alfa flucon online pharmacy uk triamterenum on line in the canada is generic amoxil available in usa non prescription atacand benicar usa sale generic pills for cipralex how much will nolvadex cost buy elocon australia buy glucofage online with no prescription buy flomax without rx eldepryl dosage instructions can you take zertalin daily tretinoin 0,025 phone orders cialis over the counter australia geriforte online with out prescription zantac drug in usa pharmacy buy orlistat reviews no script glucofage mg duphalac from canada without rx how to buy erexin v curacne online ordering buying metocarbamol using paypal online pharmacy uk speman is generic anafranil available in usa buy carbozyne online canada no prescription alti doxycycline pct buy research grade zebeta buy acai without rx fast levlen deleviery flagyl er uk no prescription lady era coupons almetec lawsuit buy bystolic online australia no prescription buy orlistat capsules comprar misoprost portugal asacol shop net buy etodolac pills in the canada where do i glucovance in australia where to buy chloromycetin in canada safely pill rx health mevacor products cheap antabuse no prescription purchase nizagara lowest price how to order zertalin online propranolol mg india motrin no rx how to order moduretic esperal order in the us where can i get vytorin from prednisolone pills online in the canada everyone graduates center provera canada pharmacy my snovitra super power coupons amoxicilina to purchase without a prescription zetia prices cvs billig kamagra online kaufen ciplox drug in usa pharmacy how to order prandin levoxyl pas cher bisoprololi fumaras cheap canada pharmacy order prinivil on line canada purchase meclizine on line in canada low price flunil uk discount trimox otc amoxycillin online bestellen order colchicina online what is zentel used for is it safe to order lexapro cheapest retino a cream tablets uk endep uk online buy mometasona online canada do you need rx keppra why has oxybutyninum been discontinued flovent online india midamor fda approved to buy without prescription order tofranil without prescription clomifene online order glucophage australia companies only buy diprolene perth australia best place to buy viagra jelly online best place to buy roaccutan in india purchase valaciclovir mg what types of liv 52 are there levitra uk buy nexium from mexico viagra online china to china over the counter drugs similar to capoten do i need a prescription for cymbalta doxazosin trusted online drug stores in canada buy lotrel 10 20 biaxin next day delivery cialis sublingual limited india buy viagra professional australia klipal codeine dosage too high protonix prices at costco micronase without a script order kelnor on line uk tadacip without a prescription from us metocarbamol fast india order dyazide on line canada viagra jelly mg buy purchase lotrel on line in uk liquid motilium review colchicine sublingual dosage lansoprazol over the counter drugs ciplox without prescription medication how to purchase cipro order prinivil from usa without prescription tadalis sx pharmacy prices list tadalis sx fast india buy amoxiline online thru paypals lipothin buy online australia rogaine 5 australia pharmacy where to buy ginette 35 drugs online order wellbutrin sr online canada vasotec from canada lozol shopping cipro with prescription colchicina canada pharmacy sildenafil citrate delivery uk feldene with no subscription buy valaciclovir xr without prescription buy generic zenegra online with prescription fucidin weight gain where to buy vytorin without a prescription grifulvin v purchase i want to pay some risperdal how much will tegretol cost zyloprim birth control online australia research grade extendaquin zithromax capsules no prescription canadian augmentin where to buy requip with mastercard buy generic dostinex online zitromax online from uk very cheap trial erection packs 2 buy over the counter zyrtec online promethazine online ordering indian pharmacy ciplox what is maxalt for how to order sertralina online bystolic mg order online pariet india a good web page to buy vagifem with no script brand name revia online motilium over the counter australia aviane 28 drugstore com pricing cheap genuine proventil online oder mg tablets of actoplus digoxin usa pharmacy cialis super active from australia dutas with no perscription oestrogel fast mexico delta cortef delivered to your home very cheap toprol antabuse india pharmacy oracea buy no prescription flunil dosage instructions buy levaquin online from mexico vermox buy canada ordering clozaril india etabus india canadian pharmacy orlistatum canada buy acai without prescription diprolene pas cher purchasing januvia online zovirax generic reviews unisom drugstore com pricing ayurslim order by phone tizanidina order in the us anastrozolo usa cvs prices top 10 online lasilix sites i pill lotrisone website oestrogel overnight pharmacy roaccutan with no perscription order estradiol valerate online without rx safe buy trazodone online alfa flucon uk brand name vistaril on line in the canada how to buy bactrim online us pharmacies online that sell elavil indian pharmacy altace sale retino a cream 0,05 cost of mail valaciclovir tizanidinum online uk where do i vpxl in usa diclofenac online in uk purchase alfa flucon online where do i azitromicina in india canada pharmacies online that sell renova amaryl to buy in the uk without a prescription canadian drug company carafate online depakote india can you buy bupron sr over the counter what is estrofem tablets comprar valtrex original where can i purchase metrogel safe to buy generic raciper from usa rogaine 2 medicine children safe place order colchicina bupron trusted online drug stores in canada order ginseng rx coversyl over the counter uk trial erection packs 2 online legally amaryl no prescription needed sale ceftin midamor legal us tetracycline billig kaufen buy dapoxetine capsules pariet with no subscription hydrochlorothiazide mg india generic florinef safe pharmacy buy drugs cleocin order omnicef without rx dilantin legal in england fluticanose without insurance zenegra cheap uk trial erection packs 2 on line no script over the counter drugs similar to advair brand amoxil without script januvia mail order how to take acivir pills mg best place to buy calan in mexico retin a 0,025 buy online ireland can you buy hydrochlorothiazide online buy exelon online safely can i order novo digoxin online purchase triamterenum in usa glucofage roche precio argentina glucofage on line no script cheap actoplus met free delivery simvastatina prices at costco dramamine without a prescription from australia lipitor pills online in the mexico cheap canadian hytrin no prescription purchase esperal in india cheap haldol no prescription buy accuran inhaler canada nootropil delivery the chepest protonix where to buy aygestin drugs online minomycin no rx buy ciplox pills in the uk silagra online in usa best price for real actos forced feminization buy zanaflex online mexico no prescription generic skelaxin safe can you buy ponstel over the counter in germany best price for real keftab prednisona online with out prescription cheap revia pills zedd order digoxin reviews safe to buy generic indocin from canada oder mg tablets of micronase india pharmacies online that sell roaccutan can you take lansoprazol daily ordering disulfiramum hoodia with no rx advair to buy in england ondansetrona order online no prescription is mail order claravis safe floxin over the counter where can i get mometasona from buy paroxetine online australia no prescription albuterol uk no prescription erection packs 3 generico italiano buy brand levitra pills in the mexico buy sertralina online artane pas cher why has toradol been discontinued zyloprim drug in germany pharmacy viagra sublingual drug class buy trimox tablets canada accutane without script aviane 28 price india canada and desyrel buy benadryl online no prescription uk vpxl no prescription tretinoin 0,05 mg uk buy antabuse tablets canada can i order trial erection packs 1 online amitriptyline without prescription pills generic ondansetrona safe discount lamisilate from canada nootropil mg order indian generics online rosuvastatin strattera spain doxycycline non perscription countries what types of plendil are there purchase nizagara in usa levitra professional online in canada ditropan without prescription pills quetiapinum online mexico bupropion india no prescription diprosone lawsuit tretinoin 0,05 mail order chloromycetin canadian online is bupropion available on line in canada hydrochlorothiazide order online no prescription generic citalopram us viagra 6 free samples low price erection packs 1 uk orlistat without a prescription erexin v mg order buy furosemide online india where do i synthroid in usa online ephedraxin with no prescription esperal online from usa doxi 1 where to get where purchase wellbutrin estrace from canada without rx order erexin v from india without prescription liquid obelit review reviews on lozol fluticanose in croatia buy sildenafila online no prescription us parlodel mexico companies only purchase metronidazole on line in usa thyrohormone fda approved to buy without prescription naprosyn generic uk lozol cheap us pharmacy order apo clopidogrel online no prescription with a amex ovral l mg tablet buy probalan australia order meloxicam enolat uk pharmacy can you get abilify order erection packs 2 uk pharmacy levoxyl generic reviews order cipro online no prescription with a amex western drug tetracycline order stromectol online uk mometasona medicine children viagra plus drug canadian pharmacy compare prices cialis super active costco pharmacy diprolene price azurette buy online us erection packs 3 mg buy acivir pills buy online ireland best site to buy kamagra oral jelly where do i dyazide in australia metrogel pct buy where to buy liposafe online uk order esperal from australia without prescription where can i get zydis pills maxaman online from india generic nexium india my tofranil coupons generic citalopram uk paypal atorlip 10 fast canada how to take amantadine mg cleocin gel to buy in the canada without a prescription buy glucovance tablets uk cilest cheap mexico pharmacy buy generic motrin online no prescription order mentax online canada uk buy acai without prescription mini jeux baclofen to buy in the canada without a prescription pill rx health order chloromycetin products order doxi 1 overnight can i order orlistato online orlistar where can i buy buy trental online from uk ordering tricor on line tadacip on line no script order metoclopramide without rx cialis soft over the counter usa erection packs 1 mg mexico is generic atarax effective yaz over the counter uk maxaman fast canada lopid with no subscription buy orlistatum online from mexico buying norvasc buy silagra inhaler canada order amoxicilina overnight sale triamterenum metformin to buy in england cheap lamisilate uk purchase strattera on line in the uk nitroglycerin canada sale buy deltasone online no prescription us prevacid next day naprosyn express canada doksazosin lek online from usa cotrim kaufen ohne rezept purchase keflex on line in the uk canada and ceftin amantadine drug in canada pharmacy purchase generic dutas where do i omnicef in usa tamsulozin noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy hydrodiuril pas cher mevacor overnight pharmacy bactroban billig kaufen ordering wellbutrin sr india what is dipyridamole pills used for buying cleocin gel from canada no prescription what is diprosone pills used for how to order arimidex purchase alavert in mexico baclofen lowest price buy elocon have no prescription tretinoin 0,025 in croatia how to buy arzomicin in london purchase dutasterid on line in uk cost of flunil without insurance allegra cheap uk pharmacy ginette 35 in croatia buy aristocort greece tegretol medication on line oratane canada drug store buy elocon pills in the india apo furosemida medicine online dipyridamole tablets uses erection packs 1 online order buy generic pulmicort online no prescription buy amoxycillin with no script half price claravis leukeran drug in germany pharmacy dilantin coupon code generic doksazosin lek india is there a shortage of etabus azurette lawsuit duphalac buy no prescription is it safe to order proventil ortho tri cyclen no prescription fedex ups get stediril toronto best place to buy buspar buy retino a cream 0,05 greece what does pulmicort order ovral l on line usa list of tesco stores selling renagel l thyroxine over the counter australia indocin on line in the uk innopran xl in croatia purchase amlodipinbesilat in australia lisinopril birth control online canada glucofage mg mexico get acai las vegas how much is viagra super active tablets cialis soft mg india buy roaccutan online cheap buy neurontin capsules drugs similar to micardis metrogel mg mexico purchase fasigyne on line in australia cialis uk 40mg voltaren prices at costco long time side effects doxi 1 order detrol from mexico without prescription where can i get asacol viagra daily dose medrol dosepak prices order tamoxifen without rx zyrtec pills online in the uk clomid cheap canada pharmacy deltasone side effects uk can buy disulfiramo online unisom drug in mexico pharmacy albuterol drug in germany pharmacy buy motrin online from australia safe to buy generic flagyl er from canada tegretol online ordering buy duetact usa buy permethrinum online canada viagra delayed ejaculation atarax 25mg tablets is it illegal to order generic toprol buy aloprim online without a prescription over the counter medicine erection packs 3 mentat online australia discount dilantin from usa key pred uk brand name motilium drug in fr pharmacy what is viagra tablets almetec birth control online india skelaxin online in canada benadryl cheapest rate buy cafergot boots emsam online order zanaflex to buy in the canada without a prescription ordering zanaflex india simvastatina uk no prescription canadian drug company bactrim where to buy cheap generic ciprofloxacina order ciprofloxacina rx ortho tri cyclen medication overnight delivery tegretol online in canada bupropionum over the counter usa can order astelin online discount elocom mg over the counter medicine that acts as brand cialis flagyl er online from usa pharmacy buy drugs ortho tri cyclen research grade nordette dapoxetine where to buy in canada get toprol las vegas misoprost roche precio argentina generic ampicilina safe purchase generic diarex microzide to buy in the usa without a prescription dipyridamole discount voucher hytrin mg mexico betnovate drug in germany pharmacy salbumol refills original moduretic online best isotretin prices lipitor side effects long term use best place to buy singulair without a prescription purchase avapro lowest price can order oracea canada viagra sildenafil citrate eldepryl medication side effects tretinoin 0,05 from canada without rx mircette doctors online pill rx health oratane products allopurinol buy no prescription levothyroid buy online australia buy sominex online amazon where to purchase ortho cyclen canadian carafate buy glucotrol in singapore minipress sold over counter order cozaar online uk maxalt without insurance flucazole canada canadian drug company isotretin zyvox cheap canada pharmacy furosemide from canada mexican pharmacy no prescription erection packs 2 gabapentine pill shortage how to use isotretin buy generic duprost online no prescription levothyroid drug canadian pharmacy is generic lady era effective purchase minocin pills nordette uk no prescription c ratioph mg canada warafin birth control online uk acivir pills mg usa where to buy flunil without a prescription methotrexate tablets buy buy generic atacand online no prescription is generic elimite effective otomax australia pharmacy brand name medrol online can you buy probalan in ireland buy generic tinidazolum online with prescription eltroxin prices usa discount speman from usa buy medazole online with out prescription pill rx health order cymbalta products can order mircette online asacol mg order low price combivent uk where could i buy lasilix without prescription prevacid drug in germany pharmacy best clincin prices shuddha guggulu best online non prescription pharmacy vagifem generic uk best place to buy medazole in mexico furosemide roche precio argentina atomoxetin generic reviews elocom online usa no prescription buyers of erection packs 2 canada how much is aristocort tablets generic retino a cream no prescription buy phenergan online from australia buying acnetane using paypal what happens if i take two cialis vagifem supplier in uk where to buy evista ointment ranitidine express canada depakote side effects long term use clincin without prescription pills snovitra super power purchase buying caprysin using paypal demadex buy online canada buy delta cortef online from canada is ampicillin available on line in canada albenda mg canada clomifene buy online us disulfiramum pricing geriforte results forum cost of mail femara ciplox to buy from europe online flunil with no prescription buy antabuse online india where do i celebrex in australia accutane tablets atorlip 10 canadian online buy topamax uk etabus prescription only clonidine mg tablet emsam order by phone genuine flagyl best price zertalin discount purchase colospa in australia buy generic renagel online klipal codeine cheap uk janumet without a prescription from uk generic fluticanose buy canada can order erythromycin online finpecia tablets buy brand isoptin ordering trileptal canada what does cipralex paxil online usa ephedraxin generic 2013 drugs best place to buy adalat in uk order aceon on line india camping noord holland periactin without prescription buy generic levothyroxin online with prescription where to buy actos mg purchase cardura on line in uk aleve online usa no prescription eurax for sale order retin a gel 0,1 online no prescription with a echeck purchase thyroxin in us list of tesco stores selling anteovin phenergan india where can i purchase disulfiramum buy abilify online cheap where do i disulfiramo in uk aldactone on line in the uk do i need a prescription for clopidogrelum micardis cheapest rate noroxin birth control online us buy antivert without a subscription is it safe to order inderal shallaki australia price buy nolvadex online overnight suprax cheap uk pharmacy haldol online canadian can you get prilosec comprar eurax portugal otomax prescription only order zertalin without rx safe to buy generic levlen from uk safe fasigyne no prescription klipal codeine online legally best place to buy protonix in usa tegretol online usa no prescription buy yasmin bulk arjuna buy online ireland sildenafil citrate tablets buy januvia over the counter india generic gabapentine cost tretinoin 0,05 without a prescription from india over the counter medicine amantadine buy indocin online from uk retino a cream 0,05 spain rogaine 2 prices cvs generic uk paypal caffeine ergotamine lasix pills buy online buying zofran from canada no prescription ponstel drug in usa pharmacy bactroban mg order midamor uk sale bupron delivery uk how much is lipothin tablets maxaman order amoxycillin with prescription estrace shop net aripiprazola online pharmacy shipped to canada viagra jelly buy without can i buy tinidazole in canada triamterene online purchase best site to buy pravachol generic amaryl cost eurax uk sale costco pharmacy singulair price sale disulfiramo genuine norvasc best price roxithromycin dosage instructions can buy ginseng online purchasing seroflo online uk online indocin purchase trimox without prescription medication acnetane order over counter triamterene buy generic gabapentine online no prescription sominex online in uk generic apo furosemida us cheap genuine advair online lantus price india benicar usa no prescription can order cialis sublingual canada albenda prices cvs ciplox buy online ireland vardenafilum pills online in the usa tretinoin mg buy suprax delivery london maxaman pct buy caffeine ergotamine online no prescription female viagra online from usa diamox canada companies only where to buy eurax online usa elimite rx isoptin pills online in the usa levitra super active daily use reviews purchase ephedraxin online no prescription best place to buy risperdal in canada a good web page to buy aricept with no script ordering toprol xl usa antivert over counter uk antivert canadian online can buy prinivil online trial erection packs 1 mail order nitrofurantoin online from canada actoplus met on line no script diflucan order by phone how to buy clavamox in canada can you get compazine order retino a cream online no prescription with a visa cheap canadian predalone no prescription