benicar sale on line furosemide law suits buy nolvadex boots elavil no prescription nexium overnight reviews for viagra super active european pharmacy discount online cheap diflucan online uk discount viagra fast shipping cheapest cilais uk buy orlistat usa no prescription doctor free viagra levitra trial voucher obat flagyl kamatra order cialis vs viagra aciclovir 400 mg tabletten celebrex 100 mg obat apa lipitor patient assistance canada cheap cialis in the united states low cost propecia on line pharmacy's orlistat online in the uk iwant to bay cialis acitab www.kamagra.ie cheap wellbutrin without prescriptions flonase vs generic clomid dosage for men betnovate gm order ventolin clomid calculator uk buy tadalafil india propecia in bulk buy predisone minocycline shortage buy simvastatin 10 low dose levitra can i trust canadian viagra online taking wellbutrin without depression pet meds without prescription buy promethazine in uk professional viagra next day cialis en ligne allemagne dth viaga generic cialis 4-pack watson's hong kong online store levitra brand thailand pharmacy lipitor generic drug cost paxil european tablets but lexapro without a script www.rayhhealthcarepvtltd need cialis today speedy rx meds tetracyclinein canada clomid x stories ordine levitra buy mircette without prescription long time sex medicine name doxycycline hyclate sale nexium buying buy valacyclovir with no prescription buying viagra with paypal mexican drug store omeprazole without canada drugs online claritin price costco buy domperidone with out a perscription generic wellbutrin sr price valium xenical 120 mg capsulas son buenas order cheap tinadozle ortho tri cyclen online how do buy viagra in dublin watch aripiprazole cialis generico prezzi pharmacy nuevo progreso imitrex effectiveness cymbalta discount price acyclovir (zovirax) 400 mg tablet priligy dubai lipitor online bestellen rhine inc. india in india name of female vigra safe dose of cialas z pak without prescription gabapentin 600 mg no script very fast delivery on viagra to uk buy accutane 30 lamictal online no prescription tricor 145 mg regenon pret does gabapentin get you high cialis times buy augmentin fast shipping metformin buy in uk indian drugstores tamoxifen alternatives premenopausal generic levitra fake low dosage levitra canadian drug pharmacy online can i take 3 5mg cialis buy trazodone nexium 40 mg tablets used buy methylphenidate er 10 mg zyprexa sale in us cialisis 20mg online purchase mirapex without a prescription buying diovan canada plavix generic make from:"canadian pharacy" phamacy best generic viagra visa only orlistat price online albenza 400mg viagra and cialis online order low cost cialis 2.5 mg where to buy penicillin vk online? ciprolet 500 para que sirve domperidone no prescription canada get tamoxifen uk order accutane online canada cialis daily use online buy elavil online without prescription buy viagra in australia what is viagra used for buy fincar diflucan prescription uk viagra150mg nolvadex 20 mg para sirve soft super viagara cheap plavix to buy order 60 mg cialis online baclofen without prescriptions il farmacista online cialis canada vente de viagra en ligne colchicine substitute for valtrex price advair cymbalta price with insurance genereic viagara xenical price lebanon levitra tablets generic fosamax china sexdrug voltaren 25mg celexa medication testosterone cream reviews femara canada prescription orlistat canada over the counter can u buy viagra at walmart doxycycline generic where to buy amoxicillin canada buy meds online with no script diflucan tablet strength cheap mexican pharmacy neurontin amoxicillin mg by weight augmentin brand name india keppra xr clom buy propranolol 10 mg buy ortho tri cy without prescription online meds without a prescription cialis online 50mg valtrex cost buy allegra generic cipro mail order zyrtec pill 10 generic viagra houston tx buy bactrim online cheap allegra 120 cost india 5 mg cialis with no prescription abilify 10 mg bijsluiter dyna doxycycline price prednisone 21 pack directions generic diclofenac potassium t allegra tablet order zoloft 100mg allegra for sale cheap can you die from lisinopril overnight seroquel does fucidin cream get rid of spots trazodone 50mg codeine promethazine syrup buy online dotur sildenafil citrate review nizoral 7 fl oz amoxil 12h cost of levitra at savon pharmacy canada pharmacy online sildenafil 100mg in usa 2.5mg cialis canadian obat piroxicam where to buy anafranil capsules ampicillin 500 mg cheap online levitra on rogaine 60ml viagra tablets for sale uk accutane 30 mg sales where to buy viagra online and cheap cipro 750 mg. for uti buy diflucan generic canadian pill identifier generic nexium in canada cialisonline4all online pharmacy review stratteraat buy uk buy tretinoin cream 0.025 where to buy cialis with mastercard how to take cialis 10mg cheap alegria shoes over the counter topamax viagra alternitive non percription mobic viagra bc canada best price propecia clomid illegal us buy safe cialis dexamethasone grossir wellbutrin generic 300 mg propeciatablets cost of femara in india buy orlistat 120mg malaysia buy female cialis protonix generic brand anti-biotic drugs without prescriptions mexican prednisone generic cialis professional 20 mg buy duloxetine india fedex viagra no prescription phenergan dosage 10 year old levothyroxine 25 mcg buy online metformin 40 mg metformin online no prescription rx sales viagra venlafaxine by mail avana order cialis online pharmacy testosterone cream generic ethinyl estradiol drospirenone buy flagyl over the counter buy avodart online canada pharmacy price crestor generic can you buy bactrim over the counter buying actonel online nizagara 100mg brand cialis 20mg best price generic viagra pills for sale diflucan cena kariva without prescription miglior prezzo cialis generico nizoral generic dapoxetine review 2013 accessrx prescription drugs buy celebrex pills canada canadian drugs without prescription lasix 25 mg 30 cpr discount aricept 10 mg levaquin lawsuit settlements amounts synthroid dosage .075 sotalex prescription drug buyer price budesonide nasal spray generic viagra sales generic avodart 5mg online generic cialis tadalafil phenergan tablet india order valtrex generic online canada pharmacy cialis 2.5 mg cyproheptadine ed buy raloxifene uk buy discount cialis online avodart canada price non precription xanax plant viagra real ambien 10mg without prescription order amoxicillin online uk buy cialis online without presciption viagra precio finasteride 1 mg prices nexium canada pharmacy price augmentin sales india order augmentin online sleepgay flow max where to buy claritin generic cheap amazon generic cialis vera pelle uk clomid sale best 10 online pharmacies sky pharmacy online drugstore review where can i purchase generic cialis accutane amazon uk aciclovir tablets bp 400mg alli cheap zithromax purchase online diovan went generic plavix generic competitor alli cheap uk brand vioagra from mexico next day express delivery for viagra clomid 12 tabl viagra cost per pill 2012 is periactin available in canada sertraline generic for zoloft fluticasone 220 mcg inhaler buy sibustat online red viagra 10 tablet 200 mg nexium over counter price hytrin azithromax zovirax mg generic cialis without prescriptions how to order topamax clomid sales australia fexofenadine prescription online clomid reviews buy twin fertility drugs online trusted rx place celebrex cost rite aid cost protonix prescription trazodone getting off buy cheap naproxen uk generic drospirenone ethinyl estradiol maxifort tomato seeds 40 pills for 99 buy diflucan cream prescriptions online is something similar to cialis for women femara 30 mg buy generic drugs buy cheap simvastatin 40 mg diflucan 150 mg online finestiride5mg pharmacy topiramate 41 tretionin with out a perscription herbal viagra wholesale dietalar buy lithium cr2032 how much does clomid cost without insurance 2013 cialis generika preiswert viagra buy in canada gneric viagra how much is a viagra pill buy pantoprazole online shop echeck buy clomid 250mg buy amoxicillin uk no prescription free samples of estrogen pills isoptin viagra uk suppliers effexor uk buy viagra forum let me watch this channel 1 furosemide brands in india list of online pharmacies in india metformin mg/kg buy alli pills now metformin with or without food cost desyrel drug taladafil 20mg miami buy lasix potassium onlin pharmacy india no prescription buy qsymia without a prescription isotretinoin 40 mg capsule rogaine where to buy fungsi clobetasol propionate tadacip-20 get clomid free wanted to buy tadalafil pills quick ship cialis revatio 20 mg order online buy clomid bodybuilding no prescription 10mg levitra better than viagra penis on viagra imagenes y frases de futbol oxazepam generic lipitor or recall generic version of cymbalta alli weight loss australia how to buy viagra pills voltaren buy online pill identifier crestor 20 indian pharmacy silagra 100 oracea order cipro online express delivery ampicillin injection cost buy biotechnica tadalifil generic version of abilify buy anafranil online cost plavix uk chewable levitra lamictal cost meds how much is crestor without insurance kwikmed competitors buy keppra 1000 mg singulair price generic prilosec from india helthy man lovcost azithromycin cause constipation buy isotretinoin 20mg acheter du viagras paxil tablet order salbutamol express shipping buy viagra online echeck viagra advair prices at walmart cipro epocrates online nexium from uk gabapentin 300 mg cap amn levothyroxine "mexico" phenamax pill id crestor 10 real viagra pfizer online levaquin healtyman. com withdrawal symptoms of prilosec cialis india generic generic diflucan 50 mg farmacia online levitra crestor canada buy propecia in canada voltaren gel shortage buy antibiotics online legal prozac pill capsule where to buy fincar zithromax buy online australia buy alesse online no prescription buying tadalafil diclofenac cheapest viagra canadian pharmacy online diflucan (fluconazole) allegra pill shape cipro 500 mg tid canada pharmacy viagra pacak diovan 40mg cgv online pharmacy nexium over counter versus prescription supreme suppliers india cheap generic drugs from india cheap alli pills buy cipla online where to buy clomid in the us i missed 2 dosage id clomid buy clomid canada finax generic propecia cheap buspirone augmentin zovirax in the usa levitra dose where to buy generic celebrex order periactin augmentin purchase online risperidal without prescription buy clomid online uk buy plavix online usa viagra echeck cialis cheapest where to buy levitra antifungal cream us lasix pfizer and viagra eastern canada pharmacy for levitra buy online doxycycline nexium generic equivalent south africa on line pharmacies us based oral lamisil over the counter regenon altace next day delivery for toradol cost of generic sildenafil generic viagra 100mg india valacyclovir hcl 1 cialis legally cialis pills 20 mg buy non perscription elavil viagra kaufen paypal bezahlen buy effexor canada online nexium discount card ciprofloxacin 500 mg pill cialis femenino ventolin inhaler cost topamax 500 mg ezetimibe tablets no prescripton medications what is the cost of viagra yasmin pill yasminelle mantadix vente en ligne buy plavix generic 40mg nolvadex promethazine 25 mg recreational how does viagra work video difference between flomax and generic buy perlutal cost of cialis at walmart trazodone (desyrel) 50 mg tablet canada pharmacy that ships overnight generic propecia australia
Home Maury Brown The Battle Over Content Fair Use Places "Aggregators" in the Crosshairs

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 385 guests online

Atom RSS

The Battle Over Content Fair Use Places "Aggregators" in the Crosshairs PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 28
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 04 August 2009 03:27

The Biz of Baseball - ExclusiveCORRECTION: Within the article, Bart Hubbuch of the New York Post referenced ESPN's Buster Olney as someone that he believes links "properly." The article then went on to reference an article/video piece with Olney that has references to the Washington Post without linking back.

Olney contacted me to say that he only was involved in the video piece, and the cooresponding article is an ESPN news service piece, based largely on what Pedro Gomez reported and augmented by the info from the Washington Post.

The article has been corrected to reflect this.


If you follow sports on the web, you most likely read ESPN, or SI, or The New York Times. And just as likely as you are to read those traditional media outlets, you might be just as likely to make Baseball Think Factory, MLB Trade Rumors, or MetsBlog your daily stop.

 

Both types of sites are exceptionally popular.

Both, for the most part, are very different.

The new media sites mentioned have been called by some as "aggregators", sites that sweep the web, find the best stories for their given audience, and either copy and paste a paragraph or two of article with a link back, or describe the gist of the article in total and link back.

The value of these sites is that they make it easy to go to a single location and get information from a broad range of sites and then engage in commentary with others in a blog format.

For some that write for the larger traditional sites that get linked to – at least for some of the writers – aggregators are stealing content.

What is Fair Use?

At the heart of the debate is what is deemed as fair use of content. At its extreme, if you copy>paste an entire article in a blog, and don’t link back, it’s a clear sign of copyright infringement. But, from there, it becomes a case of interpretation.

For example, if an article is three paragraphs long, and a blog lifts two paragraphs, you can make a solid case that it does not fall within the “fair use” boundaries. But, what if the article is 5 or 6 paragraphs, the blogger lifts two paragraphs, and then writes a lengthy commentary around what was pulled and links back? What then? At that point, you have what has been considered traditional blogging since, well… blogging pretty much began.

But, there are a writers that see that method as over-stepping the boundaries. The argument goes, if the entire gist of the article is republished, why would anyone feel the need to actually click to the originating content?

This past Sunday, Ian Shapira of the Washington Post bemoaned the aggregating of content in an article entitled, The Death of Journalism (Gawker Edition). That caught the eye of Bart Hubbuch, the Mets beat writer of the New York Post, who said on Twitter that if you replaced “Gawker” with “metsblog.com” you’ll know exactly how Mets beat writers feel. As Hubbuch continued, “Beat writers object when aggregators cut and paste large sections and quotes from stories.”

Aggregators as Bloggers and Traditional Media Outlets

Hubbuch made a clear point that he views aggregators as different from bloggers, saying, “I have no objections whatsoever to bloggers who do their own work.”

The problem is, the lines can get particularly gray in this regard.

A good example is the SportsBusiness Daily, an extension of the SportsBusiness Journal, who is owned by American City Business Journals. The site is considered an electronic trade magazine, and is rarely, if ever, called a blog or aggregator. The SBD, is a subscription based site, that not only reports on news from other outlets, it provides an extensive amount of information researched and reported from the SportsBusiness Journal staff. They are considered the premiere sports business media outlet. As mentioned, they are a subscription based outlet. As an example, a single user, six month (26 weeks) rate is $700. (see an example of a page from the SportsBusiness Daily – PDF).

Yet, when I asked Hubbuch if he sees the SportsBusiness Daily as being guilty of aggregating content, he said, “Yes it is, in my opinion. Especially with how much the [SportsBusiness Journal] charges for that. I wonder how many publications are aware of SBD…” adding, “…and how freely they cut and paste. I see SBD, and there isn't even that many links in there.”

What About Referencing Without Linking In Mainstream Articles?

Pressed for what Hubbuch sees as the proper method for linking back to content, he cited Buster Olney’s blogging technique of a “one-sentence tease” with a link as being “spot on” – fair use.

However, a search of ESPN brought up this video/article on the Nationals and efforts to sign Stephen Strasburg.

Olney is only within the video, and did not contribute to the corresponding article. It is published as an ESPN News Service piece by Pedro Gomez. The total length of the article is six paragraphs tied to a video clip. Of the six paragraphs, three contain details with the reference, “according to the Washington Post.” There is no link to the Washington Post, simply the citation. Is this fair use? It is unknown whether ESPN has any agreements with the Washington Post, but if not, it points to another instance of how content is republished across media outlets.

That aside, referencing other news sources does occur in mainstream media, through lucrative content agreements. An example of this can be seen in this The Associated Press article from Monday in regards to The Boston Globe story on two security staffers with the Red Sox being fired after being linked to steroid use. The AP agreements allow not only licensed outlets to publish AP stories, but The AP has the right to reference the content of those that license content of The AP.

Fair Use Will Move Beyond Just Opinion

The issue of fair use of content is moving out of the sphere of personal opinion between those that provide original content, and those that aggregate that news. In June of 2008, a blogger was sued by The AP over six disputed blog entries, one of which had “18 words from the story and a 32-word quote by Hillary Clinton.”

The Associated Press Board of Directors voted this past March that “it would launch an industry initiative to protect news content from misappropriation online.”

In a statement at the time, AP Chairman Dean Singleton said the news cooperative would work with portals and other partners who properly license content – and would pursue legal and legislative actions against those who don‘t.
“We can no longer stand by and watch others walk off with our work under misguided legal theories,“ Singleton said at the AP annual meeting, in San Diego. As part of the initiative, AP will develop a system to track content distributed online to determine if it is being legally used.

Standards For Fair Use Sets Up a Likely Court Challenge

While The AP seems to be drawing a clear line in the sand, other media outlets have yet to follow suit, although it may be simply a matter of time. Legal challenges seem a near certainty as the statements give way to practice.

As mentioned, one of the aggregators Hubbuch takes issue with is Matthew Cerrone’s MetsBlog.com, one of, if not the most popular Mets outlets on the web. As Cerrone was pulled into the Twitter conversation on fair use, he said in one Tweet, “WFAN just cited a newspaper report on air. I tried to click the link, but it was radio, so I guess I can't read the original report.”

While comedic, it begs the question: What news can be re-reported without crossing the “copyright infringement line?” It’s an extreme example but will Re-Tweets on Twitter become simply aggregating? If content is going to be policed, then there will need to be standards by which all will be held, a difficult legal matter that is bound to touch on copyright use.

Finally, One Might Consider the Following...

The newspaper industry has seen collapse after collapse due to waning revenues as news becomes readily available across multiple platforms. With newspaper website ad revenues becoming critical to their bottom line, playing hardball with aggregators could present a case of the aggregators finding less stringent sources to follow, which in turn lowers page views to stories once linked to, which, in turn lowers critical revenues, which, in the end, could lead to more layoffs and shutdowns in the print industry. While aggregating content may rub some writers raw, they are, in many ways, supplementing their paychecks. There needs to be a proper line between fair use, and cutting the flow of revenues off at the spigot by cutting aggregators off entirely. I'm reminded of the old saying... Don’t bite the hand that feeds.

Normal 0 false false false MicrosoftInternetExplorer4

If you follow sports on the web, you most likely read ESPN, or SI, or The New York Times. And just as likely as you read those traditional media outlets, you might be just as likely to make Baseball Think Factory, MLB Trade Rumors, or MetsBlog your daily stop.

Both types of sites are exceptionally. Both, for the most part, are very different.

The new media sites mentioned have been called by some as aggregators, sites that sweep the web, find the best stories for their given audience, and either copy and paste a paragraph or two of article with a link back, or describe the gist of the article in total and link back.

The value of these sites, is that they make it easy to go to a single location and get information from a broad range of sites and then engage in commentary with others in a blog format.

For some that write for the larger traditional sites that get linked to – at least for some of the writers – is that they view aggregators as stealing content.

What is Fair Use?

At the heart of the debate is what is deemed as fair use of content. At its extreme, if you copy>paste an entire article in a blog, and don’t link back, it’s a clear sign of copyright infringement. But, from there, it becomes a case of interpretation.

For example, if an article is three paragraphs long, and a blog lifts two paragraphs, you can make a solid case that it does not fall within the “fair use” boundaries. But, what if the article is 5 or 6 paragraphs, the blogger lifts two paragraphs, and then writes a lengthy commentary around what was pulled? What then? At that point, you have what has been considered traditional blogging since, well… blogging pretty much began.

But, there are a writers that see that method as over-stepping the boundaries. If the entire gist of the article is republished, why would anyone feel the need to actually click to the originating content?

This past Sunday, Ian Shapira of the Washington Post bemoaned the aggregating of content in an article entitled, The Death of Journalism (Gawker Edition). That caught the eye of Bart Hubbuch, the Mets beat writer of the New York Post, who said on Twitter that if you replaced “Gawker” with “metsblog.com” you’ll know exactly how Mets beat writers feel. As Hubbuch continued,Beat writers object when aggregators cut and paste large sections and quotes from stories.”

Aggregators as Bloggers and Traditional Media Outlets

Hubbuch made a clear point that he views aggregators as different from bloggers, saying, “I have no objections whatsoever to bloggers who do their own work.”

The problem is, the lines can get particularly gray in this regard.

A good example is the SportsBusiness Daily, an extension of the SportsBusiness Journal, who is owned by American City Business Journals. The site is considered an electronic trade magazine, and is rarely, if ever, called a blog or aggregator. The SBD, is a subscription based site. As an example, a single user, six month (26 weeks) rate is $700. (see an example of a page from the SportsBusiness Daily – PDF).

Yet, when I asked Hubbuch if he sees the SportsBusiness Daily as being guilty of aggregator of content, he said, “Yes it is, in my opinion. Especially with how much the [SportsBusiness Journal] charges for that. I wonder how many publications are aware of SBD…” adding, “…and how freely they cut and paste. I see SBD, and there isn't even that many links in there.”

What About Referencing Without Linking In Mainstream Articles?

Pressed for what Hubbuch sees as the proper method for linking back to content, he cited Buster Olney’s blogging technique of a “one-sentence tease” with a link as being “spot on.” – fair use.

However, a search of ESPN brought up this article by Olney on the Nationals and efforts to sign Stephen Strasburg.

The total length of the article is six paragraphs tied to a video clip. Of the six paragraphs, three contain details with the reference, “according to the Washington Post.” There is no link to the Washington Post, simply the citation. Is this fair use? Without placing words in Hubbuch’s mouth, the difference may be that Olney’s referencing of the Washington Post story is a rare exception, not the rule. Olney is considered one of the best in the baseball business for breaking news. He’s hardly an “aggregator”.

But, the point being made here is it’s difficult to say that it’s unacceptable for a new media outlet to aggregate news, when traditional news sources do it almost daily. A quick search finds that gold standard news organizations such as The Associated Press did so on Monday in regards to The Boston Globe story on two security staffers with the Red Sox being fired after being linked to steroid use.

Fair Use Will Move Beyond Just Opinion

The issue of fair use of content is moving out of the sphere of personal opinion between those that provide original content, and those that aggregate that news. In June of 2008, a blogger was sued by The AP over six disputed blog entries, one of which had “18 words from the story and a 32-word quote by Hillary Clinton.”

The Associated Press Board of Directors voted this past March that “it would launch an industry initiative to protect news content from misappropriation online.”

In a statement at the time, AP Chairman Dean Singleton said the news cooperative would work with portals and other partners who properly license content – and would pursue legal and legislative actions against those who don‘t.
“We can no longer stand by and watch others walk off with our work under misguided legal theories,“ Singleton said at the AP annual meeting, in San Diego.
As part of the initiative, AP will develop a system to track content distributed online to determine if it is being legally used.

Standards For Fair Use Make a Likely Court Challenge

While The AP seems to be drawing a clear line in the sand, other media outlets have yet to follow suit, although it may be simply a matter of time. Legal challenges seem a near certainty.

As mentioned, one of the aggregators mentioned Hubbuch takes issue with is Matthew Cerrone’s MetsBlog.com, one of, if not the most popular Mets outlets on the web. As Cerrone was pulled into the Twitter conversation on fair use, he said in one Tweet, “WFAN just cited a newspaper report on air. I tried to click the link, but it was radio, so I guess I can't read the original report.”

While comedic, it begs the question: What news can be re-reported without crossing the “copyright infringement line?” It’s an extreme example but will Re-Tweets on Twitter become simply aggregating? If content is going to be policed, then there will need to be standards by which all will be held, a difficult legal matter that is bound to touch on copyright use.

Finally, One Might Consider the Following…

The newspaper industry has seen collapse after collapse due to waning revenues as news becomes readily available across multiple platforms. With newspaper website ad revenues becoming critical to their bottom line, playing hardball with aggregators could present a case of the aggregators finding less stringent sources to follow, which in turn lowers page views to stories once linked to, which, in turn lowers critical revenues, which, in the end, could lead to more layoffs and shutdowns in the print industry. While aggregating content may rub some writers raw, they are, in many ways, supplementing their paychecks. There needs to be a proper line between fair use, and cutting the flow of revenues off at the spigot. As they say, don’t bite the hand that feeds.


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network (select his name in the dropdown provided).

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow Maury Brown and the Business of Sports Network on Twitter Twitter

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?