zero percent interest credit cards balance transfer lowest interest rate credit card india which credit card is easiest to get approved for with bad credit how to pay canada student loans compare credit cards with free travel insurance victoria secret credit card reviews legit cash advances online list of credit card companies bad credit loans no credit check top 10 unsecured credit cards bad credit rewards credit card for average credit credit card loan definition credit card transfer offers australia freedom chase visa credit card legitimate online payday loans can you use a visa gift card to get cash back sample visa card number cancel hsbc credit card insurance premium how old to get a credit card in uk duplicate hdfc credit card statement tesco credit card ppi credit cards instant approval for bad credit bad credit cards unsecured hdfc titanium credit card information unsecured instant approval credit cards secured credit cards after bankruptcy canada usaa credit card cash advance limit wells fargo credit card payment plan how to apply citibank credit card philippines pay sears credit card account online 0 interest credit card offers uk british airways visa credit card usa online credit card apply hdfc bank my tesco credit card login united airlines credit card phone number does western union accept credit cards united credit card offer flyertalk credit card reviews australia cash back offer on icici credit cards unsecured credit cards for low credit scores interest charge on cash advances us bank credit card rewards canada 2011 credit card payment gateway singapore 7 best credit cards for bad credit best uk credit card balance transfer new credit card offers bad credit what does it mean if a credit card is secured visa credit card applications for fair credit best mobile credit card processing canada compare prepaid credit cards us track lloyds tsb credit card application credit card compare uae payday loan lenders uk bad credit best airmiles credit card canada 2011 how to use a mastercard gift card online virgin credit card online chat merchant cash advance leads capital one credit card business rewards compare citibank credit cards hsbc household bank credit card best gas credit card for students best no annual fee credit card with reward i need a credit card fast best visa credit cards 2011 canada car finance bad credit uk hsbc personal loan against credit card best cashback credit card on the market first time credit card holder advice axis bank credit cards customer care number average credit card apr bank of america alaska airlines credit card business instant online loans unemployed woolworths everyday rewards credit card travel insurance hdfc credit card points redemption form free credit card numbers list bank of canada credit card debt payday loans cash advance for bad credit online cash advance direct lenders bad credit unsecured credit cards no deposit buy virtual credit card with bitcoin small business credit card processing reviews how to stop pre approved credit cards credit card fraud statistics uk how to register a hdfc credit card online merchantware mobile credit card terminal falcon credit card fraud detection system hdfc credit card helpline number kolkata credit card approval with no credit hdfc credit card charges for irctc vodafone to airtel balance transfer code can i pay my us bank mortgage with a credit card prepaid credit cards visa international use new credit card offers october 2013 starwood hotels credit card uk how to build credit with your first credit card hdfc credit card offers on air travel contact rbs credit card services hdfc credit card easy emi offer store credit cards easy to get approved cash back credit card comparison 2013 credit card 0 apr no annual fee hdfc credit cards offers india sample uk credit card number td canada trust pre approved credit card college student credit cards visa citibank credit card travel insurance zurich apply for lifetime free credit card paypal credit card fees ebay best rewards credit card canada how to credit card a door lock credit card reader for small business uk hack valid credit card information student discover credit card review virtual credit card number uk credit limit definition wikipedia icici credit card with no annual fee in india best travel credit cards review us banks that offer credit cards what banks offer secured credit cards in canada how to get a secured credit card with no credit visa credit card number generator with cvv belk credit card services phone number post office credit card contact address fake credit card numbers for itunes fake visa credit card number and cvv best cash back cards canada 2012 online prepaid credit card chase best buy credit card application mastercard careers london how to set up a small business to accept credit cards halo reach credit limit bypass what happens to my credit score if i cancel a credit card are secured credit cards good for rebuilding credit cash loans uk online icici coral credit card application status best business credit card 2013 transunion free annual credit report check my visa credit card application status webster first usa credit card western union gold card uk credit card canada review best credit card processing companies to work for best gas credit cards for students get quick loans online online loan calculator india best 0 apr balance transfer credit card halifax credit card contact centre virtual prepaid credit card uk hdfc gold credit card withdrawal limit credit score check bank of india credit card apply online in india 200 cash back credit card chase whats a good first credit card capital one credit cards login list of online payday lenders icici hpcl platinum credit card offer natwest visa card issue number tesco credit card points petrol hdfc international credit card payment credit card information security policy template best credit card rates australia nhs black card code hsbc credit card loan singapore do you need a credit card to rent a hotel room in canada track barclay credit card application hsbc orchard credit card phone number petro canada credit card cibc getting out of a credit card machine lease uk credit cards accepted in cuba barclaycard business credit cards online what is the best credit card rewards program best credit card to get uk best unsecured credit cards for poor credit best credit card apply online aeroplan credit cards canada no fee phone number for bank of america business credit card everyday rewards cards registration cpp credit card protection insurance credit cards for bad credit uk best rewards credit card us bank credit card travel rewards reviews best buy credit cards hsbc horrible paypal credit card scanner for iphone current mastercard exchange rate can international students apply for credit card in uk benefits of visa signature credit cards payday loans lenders not brokers no credit check consumer reports best reward cards lord and taylor credit card contact info natwest your points credit card review barclay credit card approval best united mileage credit card offer british airways credit card offer review loan companies for bad credit no brokers credit card app iphone canada sign up for a visa credit card canada chase bank first credit card credit card after bankruptcy discharge canada interest free credit cards with bad credit uk credit card debt 2011 hdfc credit card deals on flights credit card limit increase credit score shell gas credit card capitec online loan application form credit card credit agreement best credit card for business canada standard chartered credit card customer care number singapore lic online payment through sbi credit card compare credit card rewards canada setup paypal virtual credit card generator pc mastercard sign on government credit card debt relief act goodyear credit card consolidating credit card debt with personal loan how do i know which credit card is best for me online credit card processing for small business short term cash loans for unemployed hdfc offer credit card holder are orchard bank credit cards good no fee balance transfer credit cards hsbc canada credit card sold list of all hsbc credit cards citibank virtual credit card mobile sbi credit card emi charges top credit card companies in usa gold card hostelworld store credit cards uk african bank credit card limit increase online credit card reader for ipad iphone 4 iphone 4s credit card numbers for testing purpose air canada credit card offer payday lenders uk 2012 air miles credit card uk apply for best buy credit card hsbc credit cards online australia credit card for bad credit no annual fee no deposit dbs debit visa card secured orchard bank credit card macally secured credit card terminal for iphone and ipod touch canada business credit card comparison citifinancial credit card payment address mlc nab credit card insurance walmart visa credit card application credit card payment protection fnb gold credit card design natwest credit card fees and charges which is the best credit card for students with no credit history gas reward cards best virgin credit card uk sign in 0 balance transfer credit card for poor credit rating barclays credit card application india ge capital retail bank credit cards amazon gas credit card for bad credit axis bank gold credit card online apply small banks that offer credit cards 0 credit cards online decision free sim card with credit for pay as you go credit card with bad credit canada royal bank of scotland student credit card city bank credit card customer care phone number singapore best buy credit card interest free no transfer fee credit cards 0 interest travel pay advance army payday loans online direct lender only best credit cards for poor credit low interest rate credit card canada instant credit card temporary number sss member loan application online discover card credit score tracker blank standard credit card authorization form hdfc credit card limit eligibility journey capital one credit card reviews rewards credit cards cash advance fee vanquis credit score needed for valero gas card vanilla visa prepaid debit cards business credit cards comparison virtual credit card uk free best credit card after bankruptcy best small business credit card reviews bp gas credit card balance pay tesco credit card bank transfer visa card application status credit limit calculator java program credit card number search tool citibank credit cards for fair credit american express black card uk credit card cash advance without pin number credit union credit cards online banking lloyds tsb student credit cards mastercard prepaid credit card uk hdfc credit card login for non account holders 3d secure credit card icici bank icici titanium instant credit card chevron texaco credit card address delta skymiles credit card deal how do i pay my lane bryant credit card on line credit card with bad credit no deposit no deposit no credit check credit cards chase disney credit card login best credit cards for students with no annual fee travel credit card uk i want to apply for a sears credit card online typical m&s credit card limit free credit card numbers and security code and expiration date that work 2012 check your standard chartered credit card status online credit card payment sbi holiday gas station credit card offers i need a loan with bad credit not a payday loan citibank credit card apply online in india icici international visa credit card apply for old orchard credit card credit card points guy history of growth and development of credit card in india discover credit card payment site apple credit card machine for iphone how to transfer balance to new credit card business card credit analyst salary experian credit card fraud alert android app for store reward cards online credit card fraud statistics best 2 cash back cards platinum card concierge review long term personal loans online how to apply credit card in icici bank online credit card for no credit rating unsecured credit cards after bankruptcy discharge canada no credit credit cards instant approval uk what is the best credit card for rewards uk capital one secured credit card application status hdfc credit card loan offer disney chase credit card rewards citibank small business credit card credit card terminal rental ireland loans online instant approval nz cash advance rate commonwealth bank best travel rewards credit card lifehacker prepaid credit card 5000 limit letter to credit card company can;t pay chase secured credit card review best prepaid credit card in canada credit card transfer balance offers 0 interest american express credit limit decrease pre approved credit cards offers cash advance reviews paypal credit card numbers generator i have lost my barclays credit card my premier credit card pay online compare credit card protection insurance standard chartered credit card bank disney rewards credit card phone number how to activate sbi platinum credit card 0 credit card offers neiman marcus credit cards accepted visa prepaid credit card no fees icici platinum credit card charges how to prevent credit card fraud online ge card services care credit best canada credit cards list of payday loan lenders uk bank of america instant credit card approval number average credit card fees for merchants credit card payment calculator uk direct payday advance loans legitimate cash advance lenders personal loans with bad credit in florida how do credit card companies make money payday loans uk same day no credit check credit card number verification online citibank secured credit card visa chase visa card login discover credit cards fair credit gas credit cards bad credit shell us credit card for itunes chase business credit card logon credit card debt settlement agreement credit card fraud detection techniques pdf commonwealth bank credit card travel insurance review how to review apple id without credit card 2013 renew credit card bank of ireland new debit visa card canada what banks offer visa debit cards canada credit card settlement process secured credit cards to rebuild credit reviews does applying for store credit cards affect your credit how do i setup a pin for my usaa credit card best credit card advice best credit card for balance transfers and purchases aspire visa credit card payments credit score required for credit card canada starwood credit card australia southwest rapid rewards credit card upgrade can i receive credit card payments via paypal how can i accept credit cards over the phone best credit card for purchases 2012 citibank credit card types india visa gold credit card which credit card credit cards for bad credit online approval apple app store credit card declined standard chartered credit card customer care number malaysia no fee air miles credit cards canada payday loan lenders online uk icici instant credit card activation time bad credit payday loans online capital one credit card cash advances getting a credit card machine for a business america first credit union apply credit cards online india first cash advance does applying for credit cards hurt credit score credit card promotions in dubai southwest credit card with no annual fee home depot credit card application for business can i get a personal loan with bad credit and no bank account list of online loan sharks 10 best credit cards for bad credit cash loans to your door uk three types of credit card fraud how do i get a us credit card in uk hsbc credit card application online status online virtual credit cards uk sears citi mastercard credit card login whats the average credit card apr is it easy to get approved for a walmart credit card capital one credit cards cash rewards average zara black cashmere cardigan lowest interest credit card 2013 hdfc bank credit card login best credit card with bad credit rating canadian visa credit card personal loans with bad credit and no job united cash loans login page natwest gold card travel insurance instant approval student credit cards zero percent interest credit cards for 12 months halifax credit card 0800 how to get a us credit card in canada new york and company credit card approval why do i get pre approved credit card cibc credit card comparison free background search no credit card united credit card offer apply chase credit card visa how to get a credit card at 18 canada uk credit card size where can i pay my bestbuy credit card pay loans faster how long halifax credit card application westpac credit card rewards programs free download easy credit card checker 1.2 payday loans online instant approval tips on how to pay off credit card debt fast can i pay my wells fargo student loan with a credit card credit cards with low apr for life virtual credit card terminal paypal cibc credit card lost navy federal credit union business credit cards need a loan with bad credit and no job credit cards for low income earners with bad credit lane bryant credit card address cash advance lenders only highest credit card limit possible credit card low interest rate canada best free credit cards canada 2013 incircle neiman marcus credit card gas credit card best credit card payment gateway australia tips for getting a secured credit card printable visa credit card applications does murphy usa take walmart credit cards which credit card has the best rewards system guaranteed credit card approval for no credit instant payday loans direct lenders no credit check cashback payday advance in corona ca united club credit card review visa debit cards india denied wells fargo secured credit card payday loans no credit check no upfront fees no guarantor best balance transfer credit card in malaysia icici credit card bill payment are cash reward credit cards worth it best credit cards for travel rewards canada bank of america sign up for credit card bad credit mortgage credit score for best buy credit card approval icici credit card helpline mumbai american express canada low interest credit card billdesk hdfc credit cards payment best credit card company philippines credit card compare malaysia hsbc credit card application bank of america credit card balance transfer offers visa canada credit card exchange rate credit card settlement letter format new payday lenders no credit check prepaid credit cards in canada walmart capital one credit card visa signature what store credit cards use comenity bank discover more card no credit history
Home Pete Toms LWIB: Civil Rights Game Highlights The Demise of the Negro Leagues

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1618 guests online

Atom RSS

LWIB: Civil Rights Game Highlights The Demise of the Negro Leagues PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 14
Pete Toms Article Archive
Written by Pete Toms   
Tuesday, 23 June 2009 01:07
Last Week in Bizball by Pete Toms

This week in LWIB, MLB celebrates and advocates for Civil Rights. LWIB reviews an alternative perspective on the integration of the American pastime.


This past week MLB presented “Civil Rights Game” weekend in Cincinnati.  This year’s edition of the Civil Rights Game was the third (the first in '07 commemorating the 60th anniversary of the integration of MLB) in the brief history of the event and the first to occur during the regular season. The weekend serves a number of purposes, honouring individuals (this year, Hank Aaron, Muhammad Ali and Bill Cosby) who have strived for societal racial equality, promoting increased participation in baseball amongst African American youth and bringing attention to the importance of Civil Rights.    

The annual Civil Rights game and surrounding events also focus attention on the integration of MLB in 1947, widely regarded as a vitally important event in the evolution of the Civil Rights Movement. Baseball historian Norman L. Macht wrote in a recently published article, “Landis and Baseball Before Jackie Robinson” (see in PDF).

Baseball led the nation, integrating ten months before Harry Truman became the first president to send a civil-rights message to Congress, a year before integration of the armed forces, three years before the first black player was taken in the NBA draft, and way ahead of the nation’s political mood. Washington was still sharply segregated. Throughout Jackie Robinson’s first year with the Dodgers, there was not a single mention in any Washington newspaper of any statement by any congressman – from anywhere- that was critical of segregation policies still in effect in the capital. Baseball....deserves recognition for leading-dragging-the rest of America a little closer to the ultimate goal of equality and opportunity.

Mike Bauman at, reported from the Civil Rights Game weekend.

The legacy of Jackie Robinson is what sets this game apart from not only other sports, but from plenty of other social institutions that were white-only in 1947 and well beyond.


As Commissioner of Baseball Bud Selig often says, Jackie Robinson breaking the race barrier was "baseball's proudest moment and its most important moment."

Mark Newman at reported on the aforementioned Friday “Beacon Awards” gala honouring Mr.’s Aaron, Ali and Cosby. Mr. Newman quoted from commissioner Selig ‘s address to the attendees.

Baseball is a social institution with very important social responsibilities, and on behalf of baseball I am proud to honor those who fight for civil rights and improve our society. I'm proud of the role baseball has played in giving people of all creeds, races and colors the chance to enjoy the life that freedom brings.

Former President Bill Clinton delivered a speech to the same gathering and made this remark.

The great essayist Jacques Barzun once wrote that whoever wants to know the heart and mind of America had better learn baseball. And if you have followed America's modern struggle for civil rights from Jackie to Hank and beyond, Barzun was a pretty smart fellow.

While LWIB does not question the importance of the Civil Rights Movement and the value of the sacrifices made by Jackie Robinson in contributing to the accomplishments of that movement, there is a less popular and more controversial interpretation of MLB’s motives for integrating. This same interpretation posits that integration destroyed the Negro Leagues to the detriment of African Americans and that the negative impacts resonate to this day.

Select Read More to see the rest of this original article

One chapter of “Forty Million Dollar Slaves” is devoted to chronicling the successes and ultimate demise of the Negro Leagues via the story of Negro National League founder Rube Foster. Author and New York Times columnist William Rhoden argues that the Negro Leagues, organized by, managed by, largely owned by, supported by and reported on by African Americans was a source of pride and unity for African Americans. Mr. Rhoden argues that the integration of MLB was a defeat for African Americans whereupon they resumed their traditional role in American society as suppliers of the “muscle” to MLB while being denied entry to ownership and management.

By the late 1940’s, Major League Baseball was hungry for new blood, fresh blood. Black blood. Negro League owners had failed to grasp the implications of Major League Baseball’s manpower shortage, its slumping attendance, and its desperate need for new talent, which the black leagues held in abundance.

In the lore and legend of baseball integration, Rickey, like Robinson, has become a legend of mythic proportions. There are all manner of stories about Rickey, schools of thought about who he was, and debate whether his motives were social or economic.

The reality is that Rickey was a baseball man; he was also a shark. The Brooklyn Dodgers’ board of directors quietly authorized Rickey to go after the most lucrative pool of untapped talent; the Negro Leagues...


Black baseball owners could not agree on a strategy. The owners were torn between wanting integration and wanting to remain a viable business. These latter-day owners of Negro League baseball mistakenly felt that they would be involved – in a profitable way- with the “integration” process. Some felt that their teams might be purchased and incorporated into the Major League Baseball minor-league system.

That was not part of the plan, however. The treatment of the Negro Leagues was brutal and disrespectful.

The Negro Leagues were invaded for talent much as Africa was invaded for human labor.

In 1948, Effa Manley, then sole owner (she had previously been co-owner and business manager) of the second Negro National League’s Newark Eagles and the first woman inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, wrote.

Gullible Negro fans who think white owners take on colored players through any altruistic pangs of democracy had better quit kidding themselves. There’s a potential two million Negro fans to draw from. Any baseball businessman would be looney (sic) not to see that.

From the Rodney Fort and Joel Maxcy article “The Demise of African American Baseball Leagues. A Rival League Explanation.” (see in PDF)

Organized African American baseball (AAB), the longest lived rival to Major League Baseball (MLB) in history, thrived from the 1920s through the early 1940s. Although integration in 1947 focused attention on MLB and the American experience, the impact on AAB receives only passing, somewhat wistful notice. From the economic perspective, the unabashed talent raiding by MLB killed AAB a couple of years after integration began...... Competitive baseball was lost to countless thousands of fans throughout the South and Midwest, profitable businesses were lost to African American and White AAB team owners, and hundreds of African American players were denied a "big league" livelihood as the result of integration. The general perception is that integration was a positive thing but costly to many.

The research of Mr. Fort and Mr. Maxcy leads them to conclude that the popularity of the Negro Leagues subtracted from MLB’s bottom line.

Despite the paucity of data, we demonstrate two simple relationships that are indicative of the AAB economic threat to MLB. First, it appears that the presence of AAB competition did harm MLB attendance. Second, MLB expanded into previously held AAB territories immediately following the end of those leagues. Thus, although no proof of intent exists, it would have been economically advantageous for MLB to eliminate an attendance threat and wrestle viable team locations away from AAB.

Professors Fort and Maxcy argue that the integration of MLB ended the professional careers of hundreds of African American players while often decreasing the compensation paid former Negro League players who signed with MLB clubs.

In its heyday, AAB typically included 12 to 15 teams. Fielding 20 to 25 players, there were at least 240 players in AAB and probably more like 300......By 1949, there were 36 former AAB players in organized White baseball at the ML and MLB levels (Peterson, 1970, p. 202). Simple subtraction reveals that the demise of AAB ended the big league careers of well over 200 players.


And MLB’s monopsony power limited the economic reward even for those AAB players who were signed. Monte Irvin was paid $6,500 his last year in Newark but made $5,000 with the Giants. Except for Jackie Robinson, all of the former AAB stars joining the Dodgers (Don Newcombe, Roy Campanella, and John Wright) took a pay cut moving from AAB to MLB (Ribowsky, 1995, p. 283).

This same research paper supports Mr. Rhoden’s comment that, “The treatment of the Negro Leagues was brutal and disrespectful.” Mr. Fort and Mr. Maxcy provide quotes from “Shadow Ball”.

Most of the big league clubs didn’t pay the Negro league teams by buying up the players’ contracts, as they did when they hired away from a major or minor league team. Even Branch Rickey, who signed up to sixteen players for the Brooklyn organization, had an excuse for this theft of talent. Many of the Negro league owners were numbers runners, Rickey told reporters. That made the league a “racket” that wasn’t entitled to compensation. (p. 68-71)

Effa Manley, manager of the Newark Eagles, put a different spin on Rickey’s “racket” angle: “He took players from the Negro leagues and didn’t even pay for the. I’d call that a racket” (Ward et al., 1994, p, 71).

Mr. Rhoden acknowledges the gambling connections of some Negro Leagues owners and how Mr. Rickey exploited the situation.

Some owners eagerly sold players; others watched helplessly as players were signed and snatched away, their biggest stars snapped up and absorbed into white baseball with no compensation for the team. Worse, there was not respect for the leagues that had produced Jackie Robinson, Satchel Paige, and other great players.Rickey brazenly snatched Robinson from the Kansas City Monarchs, saying, “There is no Negro League as such as far as I’m concerned.” Rickey said that black baseball was under the control of “rackets,” referring to the several Eastern owners with gambling associations. Rickey insisted that Negro Leagues “are not leagues and have no right to expect organized baseball to respect them.”

Mr. Fort and Mr. Maxcy explain that Mr. Rickey and MLB had a more tangible and important justification in denying the existence of Negro League baseball than its connections to gambling.

AAB had no working relationship with MLB. The Professional Baseball Agreement (PBA) had governed the relationship between all levels of White professional baseball since the time of the American and National League “agreement” of 1903. The PBA specified territorial restrictions between leagues, franchise location transfer in minor league baseball, player transfer rules between teams at the various levels of play, compensation requirements, and arbitration in the event of dispute. But AAB never was included in the PBA.


Because AAB was not covered by the PBA, the dispute over compensation was between the AAB owners and players, not between AAB and MLB owners.


Initially, AAB owners hoped they might begin a lucrative business selling players to MLB (Fort & Maxcy, 2000). And the history of MLB treatment of rival leagues seemed consistent with such hopes, MLB’s economic treatment of earlier rival leagues was replete with buyouts, expansion to make room for owners of previous rival league teams, and artificially low-priced franchises to facilitate their assimilation into MLB (Quirk & Fort, 1992). But such was not to be for AAB owners and their players.....Furthermore, no AAB owners were offered any chance to either buy an existing MLB team or enter the league with their previous AAB franchise intact. The lack of any chance at cheap entry into MLB clearly distinguishes the relationship between MLB and AAB from MLB’s treatment of all other rival leagues.

Mr. Fort and Mr. Maxcy also explain that the Negro Leagues exclusion from the PBA was not the sole reason that they had no response to the “raiding” of their players by MLB.

...unlike all previous rival league episodes, AAB had no ability to respond to MLB talent raiding with its own counterattack...full-scale talent wars simply could not occur.So AAB could not gain the leverage through the competitive talent process that other rival leagues had used to bring MLB to the bargaining table.

The second factor was MLB’s lock-hold over ML baseball at the time....the existing ML structure was pretty well locked up by affiliation with MLB during the period of integration and the subsequent demise of AAB. Thus, AAB owners and players had nowhere else to go. They were trapped between the MLB domination of ML baseball and an inability to force any sort of bargaining situation in the talent-raiding arena. In the end, the best that AAB could do was to cultivate cheap talent for MLB. The results were painful. Little was paid for Hall of Fame talent, and AAB met its end.

The concluding remarks from Mr. Fort and Mr. Maxcy.

Perhaps the clearest insight into the racism of that period is that so few African American stars entered MLB, and so many fans, owners, and other players were harmed. A cynical view would be that integration happened, when it did, because AAB was a threat to the monopoly league status of MLB. It is too bad that we do not have any MLB meeting records to help us sort the issue out. Instead, Ward et al. (1994) quote Buck Leonard: “It (integration) was the death knell for our baseball. But who cared? Who cared?” (p. 71) We wonder if the 54 other star-caliber players left behind would have said the same, let alone the rest of the AAB players and their fans who lost big league baseball altogether.

Some of Mr. Rhoden’s comments on the impacts of the end of the Negro Leagues.

The final blow for the Negro Leagues came in 1951 when the Southern-based network of minor-league baseball teams was desegregated. Now the major leagues had no use for the Negro Leagues, and they slowly died. Major League Baseball had no use for any competing leagues, and was not interested in allowing African Americans to sit collectively at the ownership table. By the 1960’s, black baseball was effectively dead; Major League Baseball had prevailed.

Historians and journalists would spend the next thirty years sifting through the ruins of Negro League baseball, finding survivors, reconstructing records, and establishing a segregated wing of the Baseball Hall of Fame. Foster was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1981. But the deed – and the damage-was done, and a pattern was set. A black institution was dead, while a white institution grew richer and stronger. This was the end result of integration.


The life and death of black baseball is symbolized by the lives of Rube Foster and Jackie Robinson. Foster built black baseball and Robinson, inadvertently, helped tear it down. Like Foster, Robinson was a pioneer. Although a generation and different approaches separated them, the two men represented the same general ideals: integration and empowerment. But Robinson did not realize the complex effects of segregation on black and white communities, and failed to balance the goals of integration and empowerment. In the end, he achieved one without the other.


Fifty-nine years from Jackie Robinson’s debut and seventy-six years after Rube Foster’s death, black athletes today represent a majority in professional football and basketball and a smaller but significant number in Major League Baseball. Yet, decades after the demise of Negro Leagues, African Americans are largely excluded from the managerial hierarchy of baseball in particular and professional sports in general.

By the beginning of the 2006 Major League Baseball season, four of thirty big league managers were African American. There were no African American owners. The most alarming statistic is that the percentage of black baseball players in the majors had dropped to 9 percent. They are largely excluded from ownership, which creates a domino effect. As sports became a multibillion-dollar global enterprise, African Americans were largely shut out-shut out of front-office positions, presidencies, vice presidencies, and a wide variety of positions that flow into sports. “America’s destructiveness,” in Robinson’s phrase, had worked its magic on what was once a thriving, black-owned industry, stealing its talent base and laying waste to its power. Foster would be appalled at how completely his dream had crumbled.

The subject of the diminishing percentage of African Americans playing baseball (children, college level and professionally) has been much debated in the media the past handful of years. Typically the causes cited are expense (equipment, travel teams), lack of infrastructure in “urban” communities, the relatively small number of baseball scholarships (in comparison to football and basketball) combined with the increasing number of professionals being recruited from colleges, the longer apprenticeship usually required in baseball (again, relative to football and basketball) before an athlete is able to command substantial compensation, MLB’s competitors (NBA and NFL) were slower to integrate and less popular in earlier eras and MLB has found it is more efficient to develop baseball players in Latin America than domestically.

MLB has responded with their “RBI” (Reviving Baseball in Inner Cities) and “Wanna Play?” initiatives. Professor David Ogden believes that the end of the Negro Leagues was the beginning of the en masse disassociation of African Americans from baseball. Mr. Ogden is the author of the paper, “The Demise of African American Participation in Baseball: A Cultural Backlash from the Negro Leagues”.

In 1942, 51,000 spectators, most of them African Americans, filled Comiskey Park in Chicago to see the East-West Game, the Negro Leagues’ version of the major league All Star Game (Rader, 1994). Today the percentage of spectators and the percentage of major league players who are African-American have dropped to single digits (Anderson, Trail, & Robinson, 2005; Flanagan, 1999; Lapchick, 2005; Ogden & Warneke, 2005). Such low numbers, some writers claim (i.e. Early, 2000; Flanagan, 1999), signify a fragile connection between African-Americans and baseball, a connectin that was rooted in the Negro Leagues.

The Negro Leagues and other all-black baseball organizations became part of the core of African American culture during the first half of the 20th century and embodied African Americans’ cultural ownership of a game whose major national organization banned black participation (Peterson, 1970; Rader, 1994; Ribowsky, 1995). With the demise of the Negro Leagues and the absorption of some of its star players by the major leagues, baseball’s drift from African American culture began.This paper will provide evidence tying this decades-long drift to the abandonment of the all-black game and will explore how the long-desired and awaited desegregation of major league baseball has led to a cultural selfsegregation by African Americans.


Despite the death of the Negro Leagues and black professional baseball just after 1960, African Americans continued to make an impact at the highest level of competition, despite being denied entrance to that competition for the first 75 years. By 1970 23% of those on major league rosters were African Americans, players who as children witnessed the first of the Negro Leaguers to enter the major leagues. In 1975 those ranks had swelled to more than 30% (Gmelch, 2005). But as that generation of African American players who followed Hank Aaron, Monte Irvin, Ernie Banks, Willie Mays and other Negro League stars, began retiring, there were considerably fewer to fill their ranks. By 1985 the number had dropped to approximately 23% and by 2000 to 12% (Gmelch, 2005). In 2004 African Americans comprised 9% of major league players (Lapchick, 2005) and the percentage of African Americans playing NCAA Division I baseball in 2002 was lower -7% (Lapchick, 2003). Even lower was the percentage of African Americans on traveling youth teams-4% (Ogden & Warneke, 2005).

While the initial drop in major league participation coincided with the disappearance of the last vestiges of the Negro Leagues, today’s African American major league players are confounded by the lack of impact they’ve had on black interest in the game (Verducci, 2003). Today’s African American stars, most notably Barry Bonds, do not have the same cultural legitimacy that the Negro Leagues gave the first generation of African Americans entering the major leagues. The Negro Leagues afforded such legitimacy because African Americans played with and against each other in a social environment that forced them to form their own brand of baseball and institutions that supported that brand of baseball. History and social research have shown the cultural resonance of baseball when it is played among a common social group (see, for example, Riess, 1999). Artisans in the mid-19th century used the game as a fraternal community builder, as did fire companies and other professions (Riess, 1989, 1999). Different ethnicities and races have rallied around the game, and African Americans were no exception. African Americans played the game because their peers did, and because the game sustained a culture. Now African Americans don’t see their peers playing baseball in nearly the same numbers as they do in basketball or football.

If it is true that “whoever wants to know the heart and mind of America had better learn baseball” then equally as important is whose version of the history of baseball we believe.

Editor's Note: Next week there will be no LWIB, but will return on July 6th.

Pete Toms is an author for The Biz of Baseball and a staff member of the Business of Sports Network. He can be contacted at \n This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Follow the Business of Sports Network on Twitter Twitter



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?