apply visa low apr credit card offers best cash rebate credit card in malaysia 2012 credit cards interest free 6 months square credit cards app rebuild credit card free virtual credit card 2012 bank of hawaii hawaiian airline credit card can you pay capital one auto loan with credit card personal credit cards uk non profit credit card debt settlement credit card gateway providers india pay my office max credit card officemax visa mbna america credit card payment chevron and texaco credit card account upromise credit card change to barclays best airline credit cards for miles student loan credit card bankruptcy chase credit card protection insurance 0 interest credit card for balance transfer 0 balance transfer credit cards uk student credit card money saving expert ps3 credit card hack best credit card for airmiles 2012 get 1st credit card how do i find out what credit cards are open in my name best cashback credit cards for students credit cards for no credit with no deposit required barcode scanner and credit card reader for iphone quick credit cards canada amazon credit card instant approval instant approval credit cards for bad credit no deposit stop credit card interest virgin credit card ppi best credit cards to get approved update my credit card google market best business credit cards points totally free background check no credit card required us bank credit card payment options deposit credit card bank america use your smartphone credit card annual fee credit card bank america pay for car down payment with credit card does state farm take credit cards credit card surcharge laws australia itunes account no credit card setup easiest unsecured credit card to get approved for with bad credit find your credit card routing number getting a credit card machine for small business credit card pci when did credit cards start being used first citizens credit card centre trinidad macys credit card payment customer service best buy credit card zero interest default credit card consequences uk credit cards zero interest balance transfers 12 months global gateway credit card processing first hawaiian bank credit card application where can i get a free credit report online without a credit card i can;t pay my credit card bills what should i do continental one pass credit card chase google update credit card information mcu credit card login ameriprise credit card login does cancelling creditcards hurt your credit score 2 cash back reward credit card southwest business credit card credit card garnishment laws georgia credit card for fair credit score delta airlines skymiles credit cards card review ge money bank credit card customer service credit card risk management ppt get prepaid credit card us billing address how to negotiate credit card debt on your own cash back credit card offers india uob credit card application status malaysia credit cards 5 percent cash back can you freeze credit card interest ge money usa credit cards centon 32gb datastick credit card usb flash drive tigerdirect best 0 credit card offers irish government credit card levy best credit card for international travel easiest to get approved credit cards apply credit card instant approval online can we get credit card without ssn pay my best buy credit card payment best credit cards 2012 india steinmart credit card payment online paypal pay with credit card without account jcpenney credit card payments online international credit cards authorize.net amazon credit card deal need make payment walmart credit card apply ge bank credit card debit card vs credit cards exxon mobil credit cards online payments legal have minimum charge use credit card using debit card credit gas station how to change paper roll on credit card machine westpac visa credit card interest rate american express credit card levels pnc secured credit card application hsbc credit card complaint number wells fargo make mortgage payment credit card experian charges on my credit card best american express business credit card javascript regex credit card type pay m and t bank credit card apply credit card philippine national bank can you use credit card pay irs fake canadian credit card numbers how do you get a cash advance on your credit card how soon can i get a secured credit card after bankruptcy child support credit card florida vystar prepaid credit cards negotiating credit card debt blog tesco credit card protection best airline credit card signup bonus how to get visa credit card change credit card playstation 3 0 interest rate credit card offer credit card details generator 2010 chase marriott visa credit card sams credit card balance computer based credit card reader credit card act 2010 gift card gas credit card people bad credit credit card statements sufficient irs audit alaska airlines credit card free miles what is a security code on a credit card for a visa example credit card application form best place buy credit card terminals hdfc credit card statement payment online jal credit card us beginner credit card application can i get a credit card in 2 days best international credit cards india charge credit card online discover credit card news ge medical credit card accept credit cards payment ebay accepting credit cards with iphone global credit card processing services can you use credit card through paypal rbs credit card points dubai big o tires credit card like us zero balance transfer credit card australia does it help your credit score to pay off credit cards credit one bank card us bank credit card customer service number airline rewards credit cards fair credit iphone credit card accepting best credit card cash back purchases credit card printing services macy;s credit card denied united airlines chase credit card 1 miles buy credit card machines small business credit card india compare where can i buy a visa gift card with a credit card barclay bank credit card apply taking credit cards for small business ge money credit card dental standard merchant credit card processing fees citi secured credit card apply online secured credit cards for people with bad credit bank of america how to pay credit card online sony credit card uk 0 apr credit cards with no balance transfer fees royal caribbean credit card points redeem gas station credit cards canada credit cards that use experian score square credit card reviews hacked credit card numbers that work with cvv credit card number and expiration date 2012 american express prepaid credit card review recharge airtel prepaid online through hdfc credit card vs angel credit card ge money payments online by credit card recommended credit cards for students military credit card rates credit card interest rates in usa low apr no annual fee credit cards fair credit 0 intro apr credit cards apply for credit card hsbc india credit cards for rebuilding credit score how many numbers on a credit card amex farm bureau credit card address lloyds tsb credit card services contact money order credit card 7 11 chip and pin credit cards in the usa uob credit card contact us visa amazon credit card customer service us bank credit card payment address credit cards for people with limited credit history national city bank credit cards online chase credit card minimum balance increase us banks offer secured credit cards next millenium credit card review small business credit cards rewards hdfc platinum credit card offers canadian credit cards with airmiles how to pay hsbc credit card payment by cheque us bank credit card processing services load netspend credit card first credit card college graduate capital one credit card log on how do you pay a credit card with another credit card prepaid virtual credit card usa lowest apr credit cards 2012 chase credit card sign in page nordstrom credit cards log can i pay my capital one credit card over the phone best credit cards cash advance atm hsbc credit card india payment online credit cards does paypal take how to get money from credit card without cash advance 0 interest credit cards free balance transfer rebuild credit card no annual fee instant decision credit cards 0 credit card machine rental for events best wallet for credit cards credit card manual imprinter canada vanquis bank credit card customer services chase student credit card 1 fake but working credit card number how do i check the status of a chase credit card application increase my fnb credit card limit citi mortgage credit card payment visa credit card numbers leaked get a free cell phone with no credit card rbs credit card online payment neft report stolen credit cards to credit agencies bestbuy credit card payment login credit card reform act of 2010 pay david;s bridal credit card capital one credit card services address marks and spencer credit card contact address iphone 4 leather case with credit card holder best credit cards rewards 2011 pay citibank credit card bill using dbs credit card statement balance current balance what credit cards does dillards accept what is a secured credit card canada what are some of the best secured credit cards credit card swipe accessory for iphone chase marriott rewards credit card benefits credit card comparison bad credit my credit card declined online apply no limit credit card can you use a credit card at any atm which credit cards have rfid chips in theme frontline the secret history of credit cards average consumer credit card debt united states medical credit card dental discover student credit card credit score irs estimated payments by credit card ge money lenscrafters credit card 0 apr credit cards for 12 months chip credit cards canada united airlines credit card foreign transaction fee peach direct credit card payment best credit card bonuses planet x disney credit card 200 gift card code credit card machine for small business bank of america credit cards free balance transfer offers 2co.com credit card charge should i stop paying mortgage or credit cards barclay apple credit card review best credit cards rewards airline all credit card numbers different commercial credit cards sri lanka wells fargo visa credit card customer service shell ca code products consumer services credit card most accepted credit cards in italy pay arhaus credit card bank student credit cards your credit card may soon be worthless here;s why citibank secured credit card reviews abuse paypal prepaid credit card natwest credit card international fees axis bank credit card statement credit card ranking 2011 what are the best credit cards for people with bad credit discover credit card payment mailing address online credit card processing api how long to dispute credit card transactions tesco credit card balance transfers promotional code apply mastercard student credit card fnb platinum credit card contact low rates credit cards canada gas card application for bad credit email address of hsbc credit cards credit cards for new small businesses with no credit car rental las vegas no credit card pay shell credit card account first credit card five key tips for college students blue cash american express credit card review credit card help canada does chase offer virtual credit card numbers hdfc credit card statement online login hotel credit card pre-authorisation taking credit card payments on ipad who has the lowest interest rate credit card best credit card for graduate students 2011 how to get credit card swiping machine in india check mbna credit card application status citi bank credit card thank you points credit card payment calculator formula offers on sbi credit cards in india 1st millenium platinum credit card credit cards with 0 interest on balance transfers for 24 months best credit to get for first credit card credit card types visa mastercard settle credit card debt charge off how to pay off a maxed out credit card where to get prepaid credit cards in australia toys r us credit card offers credit card with airline miles no annual fee small business accept credit cards paypal finding a credit card with fair credit credit card machine for small business uk 0 apr credit cards 15 months i can;t pay my credit cards what do i do top rated credit cards for airline miles first national bank of omaha american express credit card check status of bank of america secured credit card apply for sears credit card by phone nationwide credit card insurance purchases affinity credit card programs canada credit card numbers and cvv code should i close my store credit card account best low balance credit cards stop airline credit cards offers virgin credit card uk login state farm bank credit card payments online chase bank online credit card processing bank of america visa worldpoints credit card uk credit cards 0 balance transfer hdfc titanium edge credit card rewards lodis audrey credit card case amazon credit card review 2012 best credit card without annual fee can credit card company continue charge interest charged off account credit card free use abroad prepaid credit cards pictures att credit cards login are gas station credit cards worth it unsecured credit cards for poor credit rating online credit card application cosigner federal regulations regarding credit card billing practices citi us government credit card mobil oil credit card online hdfc bank credit card offers makemytrip apply visa credit card apr low rates bank of america credit card activation number gas credit card one pass miles credit card barclaycard credit card services address no more credit card offers bank of america foreign transaction fee credit card who has the best interest rates for credit cards how can i create an apple account on itunes without a credit card sears credit card online login list gemb issued credit cards best secured credit cards for bad credit 2013 hdfc platinum credit cards reward points redemption macy;s credit card annual fee capital one secured mastercard credit card cardiff credit union county hall credit card visa number example make credit card costume apply credit card terminals singapore section 75 consumer credit act debit card natwest gold credit card online fake valid visa credit card numbers cvv cid credit card security number union plus credit card log in miles credit cards for average credit negotiating with credit card companies to lower interest rates can merchant charge credit card processing fees credit card market share canada credit card merchant processing company which are the best secured credit cards pay lic premium online through citibank credit card shell personal credit card - login to your account online citibank credit card indian oil apply victoria secret credit card canada banana republic credit card signin credit card forms templates free order food online with credit card american credit card collectors society apply for capital one credit card phone number monopoly credit card edition instructions name 3 major credit card companies setup apple id without credit card info claim back ppi virgin credit card accept credit cards my iphone 4 credit card offers for bad credit with no deposit citibank credit card payment customer care credit card debt management services are secured credit cards a good way to build credit can you add prepaid credit card paypal account where to buy money order with credit card best credit card apply first credit card new millenium bank credit card login where can i pay capital one credit card bill government credit card citibank online statement equal payment plan credit cards using a credit card to buy a gift card best credit card for people with low credit score best offers credit card transfers credit card processing comparison fees what is considered a good credit score for a credit card annual credit card fees tax deductible third party credit card processing services how to freeze your credit card what is the average credit card limit apply for credit cards online with bad credit chase credit card account activity accept credit cards through paypal on iphone credit card debts u.s. government credit card debt program credit card delinquency laws how do i check the balance on my chase credit card mobile credit card processing comparison shop online stolen credit cards credit card capital one customer service best no fee prepaid credit cards king size direct credit card charge off credit card company should i pay off 10 year old credit card debt 0 interest on purchases credit cards fixed rate credit cards for life of balance gift credit cards online credit card irs reporting fee benefits of using a credit card online walmart receipt lookup credit card credit card opt out form pay off victoria secret credit card long will take pay my credit card off how do i find out what credit cards i have had authorized credit card systems austin chase credit card website do pay mortgage credit cards what dept store credit cards are easy to get bad credit unsecured credit cards no processing fee google checkout credit card authorization difference between debit cards and credit cards cheapest way small business accept credit cards best balance transfer deals for credit cards halifax credit card ppi bealls credit card balance who has the best credit card rates reform of credit card schemes in australia avs credit card number pretend credit card for kids capital one venture credit card log axis bank titanium credit card customer care can you use a debit card as a credit card on paypal rcbc bankard jcb credit card valid random credit card numbers visa credit card online president obama credit card act credit gift cards no fee volkswagen credit card points can you get a secured business credit card sbi bank credit card customer care number bangalore intuit credit card processing for ipad lifetime free credit card offer leather credit card holder with plastic inserts barclays credit card ppi claim can you use credit card get chips casino answer credit card lawsuit texas hsn credit card payment mailing address 5178 credit card prefix late fees on credit cards new laws credit cards holder metal best credits cards 2012 security code credit card back my first credit card no credit history can i use my student loan to pay off credit cards jewelry stores that offer credit cards compare contrast credit cards paying cash where do i send my capital one credit card payment how to get a credit card as a stay at home mom credit card online payment citibank wells fargo credit card phone contact union bank credit card apply online swipe credit cards on iphone free physic reading no credit card required new credit cards hurt credit score compare platinum credit cards in india easiest store credit cards to get with bad credit good secured credit cards bad credit christian credit card help icici bank credit card payment through other bank credit card credit card acceptance logo capital one small business credit cards list of citibank retail credit cards citibank credit card reward points redemption online unsecured credit cards for those with bad credit can you get credit cards with no credit chase credit card log iin credit card minimum payment amortization calculator recent credit card law changes can credit card companies garnish wages in georgia government help with credit card debt cancel jjill credit card score do need get visa black card excellent credit nova credit card processing les schwab credit card application credit one credit card reviews forum best credit card cash back 2012 southwest airlines credit card bonus miles pay taxes with credit card free best value credit card singapore credit card payment forms template fred was persuaded to open a credit card account how do you pay off a credit card with another credit card fifth third bank secured credit card long will take pay off credit cards calculator aa credit card citi bank cartoon picture of a credit card credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date 2011 how to get your credit cards paid off credit card travel notification bank america get free netflix trial without credit card barclays credit card complaints address consumer credit cards kohls credit card customer service number how to pay off capital one credit card credit card dispute rules uk vanquis bank credit card letter how to rebuild your credit with a secured credit card top travel credit cards canada can i get cash back at the store with a credit card credit card one time use universal studios credit card application 0 transfer credit card deals instant use prepaid credit card change credit card associated my apple id first premier bank gold mastercard credit card reviews compare credit cards united states honda credit card online consolidating credit cards barclaycard credit card charges abroad hsbc credit card online account india cimb credit card installment plan malaysia bbva compass credit card online login spg points credit card canada citi credit cards payment 1 year interest free credit card multiple purchases best buy credit card paypal not accepting credit card number capital one credit card check status credit card fidelity retirement credit card review hsbc mastercard credit card online change credit card information app store hawaiian credit card miles apply maybank islamic credit card how to get credit card limits increased capital one credit card customer agreement credit card best rewards canada can you get a sears credit card with bad credit orchard bank credit card address payments loan payment calculator credit card make orchard bank credit card payment credit cards.com calculator how long after bankruptcy can i get a chase credit card what is the best rewards credit card for travel 12 months interest free on credit cards uk credit cards hdfc credit card settlement letter bank of america bass pro shop credit card payment update my google credit card information city bank credit card customer care mail id phone swipe credit card terminal corporate credit card policy .pdf best credit cards for travel miles top points credit cards standard chartered credit card one time password citibank aa credit card offers hsbc credit card customer service phone number uk platinum credit card benefits best credit card consolidation plan credit card swiper for android phone credit card checks use debt top 5 most prestigious credit cards where can i get my free credit score without a credit card merchant credit card processing service get cash advance chase credit card first financial bank credit card login free credit card number generator 2012 no survey stop credit card phone calls southwest airlines credit cards accepted credit card reform act of 2009 bill effect unenforceable credit card agreements egg walmart credit card pay online bill credit card repayment calculator excel working credit card number with cvv2 top ten best business credit cards chase credit card bill pay address capital one credit card frequently asked questions wells fargo credit card application phone free credit check without credit card uk how can i process credit card payments standard chartered credit card online payment from icici cach build credit card alaska airlines credit card 40000 bonus miles consolidating student loans credit cards bank of america credit card college savings natwest credit card reward points consumer agency canada credit cards pc richards credit card payment center help with credit card debt 2010 negotiating with credit card companies debt settlement prepaid reloadable credit card kids good credit cards for bad credit history talbots credit card address consumer credit agreement credit card how do you cancel credit card payment credit card pci compliance rules discover card credit card login stolen credit card checker reward zone credit card best buy hsbc netflix without credit card info bank of america grace period credit card long after bankruptcy can get credit card canada circuit city rewards credit card payment check citibank credit card status of application northridge chase visa student credit card chrysler credit card login credit card 0 transfer no fee wells fargo credit card contact credit card 0 balance transfer no transfer fee credit card processing lawsuit credit card collections laws gap credit cards payment address credit cards india best swiss miles more credit card where can i get a prepaid credit card in canada pc richards credit card make payment using mbna credit card abroad safe put credit card xbox live free credit card number validator credit card from sbi bank southwest rapid rewards credit card points apply for store credit card with bad credit can you send money western union using a credit card credit cards that earn continental miles canada credit card processing company chase credit card access account online easy to get gas cards/bad credit how to change apple store credit card new hsbc credit card apply credit card refund time frame citi cards credit report webster bank credit card rate can someone cosign credit card reclaim credit card charges letter juniper bank credit card logon secure eon bank credit card redemption catalogue 2011 pay my yamaha motor credit card manhattan standard chartered credit card online payment best credit cards 0 purchases compass bank credit card activation i need a mastercard fast but i have bad credit credit card transaction costs businesses can credit cards garnish wages canada apply for credit card no credit delta credit card miles offer $2000 credit card need credit card number netflix advantages credit cards banks hdfc credit card customer care contact number bangalore credit card magnetic strip protector get free stuff online without credit card best credit card for bad credit rating hdfc world credit card reward points redemption visa card for bad credit sainsburys finance nectar credit card does chase do instant credit card approval can i get credit card with cosigner pay off credit card debt fastest way credit repair credit cards how can i view my hdfc credit card statement verifone credit card machines manual how can i pay off my credit card sooner need mastercard but have bad credit australia orchard bank credit card customer service phone pin and chip credit card us sunoco gas credit card application credit card swipe for ipad 2 card chase continental credit republic bank credit card center address credit card reform act of concept wiki check my credit card balance online visa can use credit card casino get virtual credit card number chase best type of credit card some safety tips using credit card choosing the right credit card credit card for gas purchases a valid credit card number that works online aaa credit card bonus points ge credit card payment online login barclays credit card account number make payments best buy credit cards student credit card citi easy credit card online application open close credit card credit score retail services credit card online credit card processing companies reviews bank of america credit card counseling first debit card no credit score best unsecured credit card for rebuilding credit i phone 4 case with credit card holder stop southwest credit card offers credit cards with 0 balance transfer interest pre qualify credit card chase credit card login for abn amro bank average credit score for credit cards best credit card for qantas frequent flyer points 2012 itunes account no credit card 2011 0 apr no fee balance transfer credit card home depot credit card online bill pay customer reviews chase credit cards chase marriott credit card foreign transaction fee visa credit card number that works with security code deposit credit card alertpay frontier credit card points best buy credit card chase apply mobile phone credit card app buy imvu credits debit card master credit cards for college students what is the grace period on a visa credit card citi forward credit card approval protect your credit cards rfid prepaid credit card rebuild credit do us credit cards work in canada how to pay citi credit card online sunoco credit cards online how do i make a payment on my bestbuy credit card how to apply credit card machine in malaysia validate credit card expiry date javascript credit card debit cards same hawaiian airlines credit card login wells fargo financial credit card login how to get credit card payments lowered deposit money into paypal account credit card american signature credit card login tesco credit card customer services no apr credit card students citi credit card american airlines login can you write off credit card debt taxes can you pay your taxes online credit card paypal credit card declined itunes key bank business credit card login standard chartered credit card customer care no bangalore small business credit card offers no credit raymour and flanigan credit card phone number best small business credit card processing company what is available balance on credit cards nova credit card processing complaints low fixed rate credit cards for students american express charge card credit history citibank philippines credit card application form 0 percent interest credit card for 24 months 3 major credit card companies check status walmart application credit card victoria secret credit card lost stolen what are the best airline reward credit cards citibank credit card contact singapore quickbooks credit card payments online hhonors credit card offer costco credit card payment processing credit card processing for trade show merchants lowest interest rate credit card philippines credit card interest new purchases credit card swipe hsbc bank credit card address dubai taxi take credit card citibank visa credit card philippines credit card with chip credit card companies offer 0 balance transfer best credit cards for international college students credit card travel rewards comparison chase blue credit card commercial chase credit card interest rates paypal fees vs credit card fees american express costco cash rebate credit card chase student credit card requirements overseas credit card commonwealth online hsbc credit card bill payment india bank america credit card europe do department store credit cards hurt your credit avon credit card imprinter mbna smart cash platinum plus mastercard credit card review best credit card for free flights 2012 credit cards for bankruptcy people business loans credit card sales how to calculate monthly interest charges on credit card vanquis credit card limit interest credit card maybank continental one pass credit card login barclays credit card customer service india online prepaid credit card us best low credit score credit cards credit card reward point hdfc what is a cvv security code on your credit card how low can your credit score be to get a credit card american airline citi credit card login mbna cash back credit card review paypal virtual terminal credit card reader chase credit card cash advance checks payday free credit card gateway india deutsche credit card customer care hsbc credit card status enquiry india can rent credit card machine how do you get a credit card if you have bad credit us online stores that accept international credit cards green dot credit card phone number highest credit card limits commonwealth bank student credit card review cheapest credit card terminal providers best credit cards travelling abroad emv credit card reader major banks offer secured credit cards protection using credit card online square credit card iphone app working credit card security numbers has lowest apr credit cards capital one credit card rental insurance student credit card protection act 2009 credit card unlock code on your nook library page rbs credit card payment through other bank barclays platinum credit card india how to pay citibank credit card by cheque credit card numbers generator 2011 herbergers credit card payment center 0 credit cards for people with bad credit bloomingdale credit card discount pnb global credit card best credit cards for students to build credit top 0 balance transfer credit cards credit card late payment interest calculator easy credit cards get approved bad credit interest paid on credit cards calculator can i make a credit card payment with paypal credit score do you need get visa black card qualify what is a horizon credit card best credit card rewards apr low interest rate i have bad credit and need a credit card in canada rbs credit card citizens bank credit card type by first digits credit card interest calculation india capital one small business credit card sign apply sam;s credit card navy federal credit union credit card offers secret history of the credit card transcript how to check walmart credit card balance zero interest rate credit card transfers how to get credit card affiliate links best company to open a credit card with average amount credit cards per person american signature credit card customer service ink bold credit card will american credit cards work in the uk are american express credit cards accepted in europe best low rate credit card australia amway credit card bank america best credit cards mileage points prepaid credit cards build your credit secured credit cards to build credit how long can i use my old navy card credit card at gap card company checks transunion credit score carte blanche credit card history usc credit union debit card matrix unsecured credit card review royal bank credit cards compare how do i calculate credit card interest rate hsbc best buy credit card mailing address redstone federal credit union credit card login best credit cards building credit rating asia miles credit card hk can you verify paypal without credit card teamsters privilege credit card irs pay taxes by credit or debit card american express cancel credit card australia mcu credit card services alaska airlines credit cards american express platinum cash rebate credit card godaddy pay with paypal without credit card best credit card offers with airline miles make irs payment via credit card big lots credit card customer service phone number best credit card car rental insurance credit cards for people with low credit rating natwest platinum credit card benefits boker plus credit card knife ??? hdfc bank credit card payment through neft lucky credit card stolen worldpoints credit card sign optimum credit card credit card exchange rate class action icici titanium credit card purchase limit credit card size envelopes marriott credit card offers 2012 credit card company has judgement against you best credit card deals ireland best airfare reward credit cards how can i apply for a credit card change my apple id credit card info how soon should i apply for a credit card after bankruptcy apply online prepaid credit card canada valero gas credit card login rogers jewelers credit card account online amazon credit card reward points 0 interest balance transfer credit cards canada chase credit card 50000 united mileageplus explorer best international credit cards for students chevron texaco credit card bill pay vista services credit card what are the benefits of a credit card internet credit card processing fees credit cards airline rewards no annual fee alliance leicester business credit cards online service credit card cost of capital credit cards to build up bad credit what is the best way of getting rid of credit card debt how fast can i get a capital one credit card suntrust credit cards rewards can you purchase money order credit card post office credit card starting with 4430 toys r us credit card login ge capital best us airways credit card offers credit card debt relief services pros and cons of debit and credit cards hdfc credit card bill payment status credit card advantages business santander credit card contact abroad claiming back credit card charges uk bp oil credit card chase what happens if i can;t pay my credit cards uk student credit cards bad credit no cosigner chase credit card offer $300 check my credit score without having credit card do need secured card credit history federation small business credit card machine credit cards does nordstrom accept calculate interest on credit card bill stop junk mail credit card offers paying off credit card debt with personal loan thomas cook credit card online banking average apr chase credit cards for the merchant bank credit card sales are treated in a manner similar to best credit card to have to build credit kotak mahindra bank credit card online payment best mobile credit card readers credit card backdoor numbers itune account without credit card 2011 direct merchants credit card bank company can block payment credit card lowes 5 credit card cancellation of credit card debt form 982 are prepaid credit cards anonymous halifax visa credit card protection maybank credit card promotion 2011 how to calculate interest rate on credit cards bmo harris bank credit card need a credit card today money clip credit card holder metal apply for a best buy credit card best secured credit cards without credit check pay my credit card online wells fargo how do i pay my bealls credit card consolidating my credit cards debt can i get a walmart credit card with bad credit address mail my chase credit card payment can you make money selling credit card processing micro center credit card wells fargo financial national bank best buy credit card limits how to find security code on credit card visa best apr credit cards uk how to pay off my credit card debt faster ufcw credit card barclays platinum credit card online banking hdfc bank credit card customer care toll free number chennai how do i cancel my first premier bank credit card credit card receipts record retention fnb omaha credit card payment credit cards with 0 interest on balance transfers and purchases can you pay your old navy credit card bill in store accept credit cards w free processing machine lost my credit card but need number credit card annual fees refundable do your credit card info stolen change app store credit card littman jewelers credit card apply use credit cards help credit score citi aadvantage credit card 75000 bonus miles art van credit card online credit card complaints ombudsman does mean credit card has been charged off how can i get credit card with no credit chase bp credit cards rapid rewards credit card annual fee credit cards generator numbers ge summit credit card credit card cvv generator free download sap credit card encryption decryption credit card expense report policy gift card credit card act hdfc silver credit card reward points redemption can i settle my credit card debt for less credit cards with benefits comparison apply bp personal credit card quickest way to pay off credit cards pay off credit card balance each month best credit cards for international travel points serve credit card limit dbs credit card travel promotion bp amoco credit card payment online penalty for paying off credit card early easy ways to get out of credit card debt best credit cards foreign transaction fee credit cards gas rewards canada best rebuild credit credit cards cost rent credit card machine visa annual percentage rate credit card citibank titanium credit card benefits klm credit card deal credit cards with 0 percent balance transfer fees choice rewards credit card login long receive credit card payments paypal credit card application people bad credit how to use a different credit card on ebay make costco credit card payment credit card customer service bank of america applying for credit card with no credit citi american airlines credit card review credit card collection agency settlement elan credit cards log in no credit card foreclosure listings theoretical analysis credit card reform australia apply for gas credit card online accept credit cards no merchant account best hotel credit cards 2011 target credit card payment protection can withdraw cash credit card good credit card deals australia iphone 4 credit card reader uk american express blue credit card business credit cards rewards no annual fee compare m&t credit card cost of cash advance on credit card fake credit card number that works with security code platinum credit cards canada hsbc prepaid credit card singapore online credit card payment solutions best secured credit cards clark howard best airmiles credit cards canada 2010 is it illegal to charge credit card processing fees virgin credit card 6 months interest free dell support credit card processing delta skymile credit card reviews square up credit card processor free annual credit report without credit card needed cash advance from mastercard credit score visa credit cards with 0 interest on balance transfers chase small business credit cards managing credit card debt uk i need a unsecured credit card for bad credit what credit cards are not accepted in cuba virgin credit card minimum payment fnb legal department credit cards applying for credit cards with bad credit rating citibank credit cards online uk secure credit card processing software use cell phone to accept credit card payments cash back fuel credit card india barclay bank apple credit card stop bank of america credit card checks account number ann taylor loft credit card customer service phone number credit card paper machine best rate for life credit card how do i know what my minimum credit card payment will be credit cards with cash advance checks load amex prepaid with credit card zero interest rate credit card offers best first credit cards 2 credit cards from same bank best credit card 0 apr southwest chase credit card application status airline mileage credit card comparison credit cards that don;t use experian online application credit card standard chartered iphone credit card processing printer credit card insurance against theft virgin prepaid credit cards uk how do i pay my new regions credit card best buy credit card payment center abn amro credit cards online victoria secret credit card application online bank of america credit card worldpoints rewards single use credit card number wells fargo schwab bank credit card review pottery barn credit card online payment special best corporate credit cards united chase online credit card payment hsbc best buy credit card payment website how to hack someones credit card info capital one platinum credit card credit limit cash back credit cards best business how much are prepaid credit cards at walmart credit card interest rate uk citibank silver credit card limit sample credit card arbitration agreement best credit card internet purchases should you get business credit card student credit card with no credit history pay down credit card debt fastest free credit score without credit card uk best restaurant cash back credit cards capital one credit card atm locations credit cards with instant approval and use gap visa credit card payment online low interest credit cards people fair credit credit card reader machine wiki why does it say my credit card number is invalid usb credit card credit card log in first premier bank i need credit card processing merchant asiana airlines credit card review credit cards zero interest balance transfers no transfer fee first usa bank credit card login can you pay your mortgage with a credit card wells fargo apply for juniper credit card what is a credit card issue number visa aeon credit service etc card apply for credit card bank of america chase bank credit card payment protector credit card activation number hsbc test credit card numbers for paypal visa credit card features can nri apply credit card india guaranteed credit card usa credit cards for travel benefits best credit card for poor credit score free virtual credit card number credit score needed for a sears credit card approval california credit card privacy laws fixed apr credit card peoples credit card numbers best credit cards for earning free flights prepaid credit card versus debit card qantas credit union visa debit card walmart credit card customer service hours apply chase british airways credit card avon credit card machine opt out credit cards pay off student loans with credit card can you pay your walmart credit card in store how much does it cost to draw money on a credit card how often should i apply for a credit card us airways credit card 60000 how to cut credit card debt website pay davids bridal credit card can i activate my walmart credit card online credit card guide for beginners centurion credit card benefits american express credit cards with best rates for balance transfers amazon default credit card balance transfer credit cards discover pay chevron credit card phone homedepot credit card credit card hsbc credit card holograms work credit card iphone 4 case clark howard credit cards overseas apple account without credit card 2012 how good is credit one credit card bank of america credit card payment address delaware gap silver credit card benefits top 5 credit cards in philippines does autozone have a credit card rbc visa credit card login credit card hardship letter example alaska airlines credit card signup bonus best buy hsbc credit card contact us credit card agreement request credit card magnetic strip information list retail store credit cards get visa card bad credit canada charge credit card with ipad best travel credit cards in india virtual credit card paypal verification india disney visa credit card online payment pay kirklands credit card american eagle credit card interest rate credit card skimming equipment credit card processing options for small business wireless credit card processing no monthly fee shell gas station credit card westpac overseas credit card charges credit card apply online sbi best hilton credit cards fake credit card number that works 2012 square credit card hack capital one credit card login in page walmart credit card phone numbers unsecured instant approval credit cards for bad credit credit one bank credit card reviews pay irs taxes by credit card online long after you file bankruptcy can you get credit cards equifax score without credit card is using a credit card online safe lowest interest credit cards 2012 update credit card details playstation network buy a credit card number with paypal how to accept credit card payments without paypal valid credit card number and expiration date best credit card promotions august 2012 us bank corporate credit card visa visa credit card for bad credit unsecured is it better to pay with bank account or credit card on paypal charge card vs credit card fico score verifone omni 3740 credit card terminal freedom credit card debt relief pay united credit card fee with miles accept credit card payments by mobile phone best citibank credit card in india phone number for capital 1 credit cards pre approved credit card offers best credit card offers college student credit card does not charge international fees cool credit cards canada new credit card legislation australia fake credit card numbers and security codes 2012 credit card breach august 2012 wells fargo student credit card interest rate credit cards rebuild credit best canadian credit card for travel insurance iphone 4 cases credit cards chase pay credit card savings account best airline reward credit card 2011 credit card merchant fee calculator taking credit card payments on iphone apply online for a credit card with bad credit average credit card debt college students 2009 shell gas credit card 5 pbs frontline secret history credit card transcript what are the four major credit card companies prepaid credit card minimum age credit card receipt template word manual credit card imprint machines direct merchant credit card online payment credit card offers no credit bad credit pay rc willey credit card american signature credit card sign my credit card android app secured credit card offers bank america credit cards with bad credit rating in australia us capital one credit cards login the best credit card sign-up bonus ever first citizens bank business credit card no fee prepaid credit cards canada credit card calculator payoff date comparison credit card reward programs canada sam;s discover card login credit cards free credit cards for people with no credit history credit card horror stories united states chase rewards credit card login credit card air miles offers wow credit card error how can you pay off credit cards faster eliminate unsecured credit card debt best capital one credit card for bad credit chase credit card dispute charge test credit card number visa vs angels credit card visa chase credit card rewards apply for chase credit card for students best credit card reward program 2010 can you make down payment car credit card credit card no deposit required secured credit cards to rebuild credit chase buy diablo 3 gold with credit card pay hsbc credit card bill india average credit card transaction fees for businesses what is the best prepaid credit card to get fleet credit card online qantas frequent flyer credit card bonus points how to take credit card payments small business lowest interest rate credit card balance transfer marriott chase rewards credit card what is the best credit card to have for me ameriquest credit card login credit card machine ink cartridge why do i need credit card info for free apps itunes chase mastercard poor credit credit cards that earn airline miles credit card utilization ratio credit score security bank online application credit cards christian credit card debt help hsbc credit card bonus points redemption what is the best american airlines credit card offer credit cards issued by hsbc bank nevada n.a list of major credit cards in the philippines prepaid credit card airline miles canadian reward credit cards comparison student credit cards very poor credit city bank credit card payment billdesk credit cards debt write off mobile credit card swiper for blackberry boa credit card login page credit cards interest free for 12 months the best travel credit cards in canada rent credit card terminal uk city bank credit card online india hsbc credit card payment charges how do i pay credit card bills online low interest rate credit cards for people with good credit will a secured credit card build credit best buy online credit card payment walmart discover credit card sign in amazon credit card extended warranty student loan credit card pay off first united mileage plus credit card red carpet club credit card no international exchange fees old navy coupons credit card holders remove credit card information playstation network how do i cancel my express credit card best way for small business to accept credit cards get free credit report without credit card uk halifax credit card minimum monthly payment credit card applications for bad credit for free government travel credit card regulations credit card relief act of 2010 credit card refund policy example pay by credit card through paypal without paypal schwab 2 rewards credit card american express charge cards vs credit cards continental credit card review credit card processors online penfed credit card login what is the best credit card for travel rewards 2011 home equity loan payoff credit cards ford service or quick lane credit card hdfc credit card net banking online credit card smartphone square hyatt credit card two free nights ulster bank credit card charges can;t use credit card with paypal marriott visa credit card create free apple id without credit card iphone how long will it take to pay my credit card debt how to make a credit card holder out of fabric virgin atlantic credit card reviews eclipse credit card terminal paper pay bank of american mortgage with credit card carte blanche credit card no annual fee credit card india nfl extra points credit card from barclays 5/3 bank credit card payment address best reward credit cards canada world;s most exclusive credit card using a credit card to repair credit vw credit card log apply for meijer credit card fred meyer credit card average interest rate credit card does apple charge credit card pre order no interest credit card canada wells fargo commercial credit card login hsbc credit card phone number philippines check hsbc credit card application status philippines how can i stop receiving credit card offers in the mail rbs credit card india reward points average credit card limit best business cash back credit card 2010 credit card payoff template bank credit card processing fees total interest credit card calculator credit cards citibank pakistan mobile credit card processing iphone canada credit card education for students 0 percent credit card balance transfer disputing credit card charges for poor service new credit card laws australia how to pay tj maxx credit card bill online how do i pay my toys r us credit card online paypal credit card payment fee quickbooks credit card refund from vendor uk credit card industry case credit card no foreign transaction fee canada credit score affected by closing credit card good credit cards for miles can you buy gift card with credit card how hard is it to get approved for a walmart credit card apply for torrid credit card online payment for citibank credit card from other bank not paying credit cards consequences 2010 philippines best air miles credit card reviews top ten reviews secured credit cards wells fargo financial bank credit cards login halifax credit card statement date standard chartered credit card singapore manhattan home depot credit card login account how to cancel xbox live credit card online nelly swipe credit card song free credit card checker software disadvantages of using a credit card 25 free dating site no credit card required how long does it take to cancel a stolen credit card leather money credit card clip lufthansa miles more credit card canada american airline credit card benefits jc penny credit cards login lane bryant credit card payment retail credit card fee settlement i don;t want to enter a credit card on itunes capital one credit card rental car benefits discover credit card routing number harley davidson credit card wallet can get credit card bad credit wells fargo credit card dispute charge canadian credit cards travel insurance chase credit card college student advantages of a credit card can you only use walmart credit card walmart pay off credit card debt or invest using credit card online protection best rewards credit card 2010 india much does chase credit card charge cash advance apply for visa credit card with no credit credit card rules capital 1 credit card ppi credit card reader software free netspend prepaid visa prepaid mastercard prepaid credit cards prepaid debit credit score needed get best buy card discover credit card 100 bonus pay new york and company credit card online cancel uob credit card singapore lexus financial services credit card check rbs credit card statement slate credit card 200 offer free verizon phones no credit card bad credit visa credit cards instant approval citibank secured credit cards review holiday inn express credit card authorization form cash advance credit cards work how to pay someone through paypal with credit card what will it take to pay off my credit card credit cards for bankruptcy canada manage credit card google play report stolen credit cards canada how credit card skimmers work can i purchase money order with credit card debt consolidation credit card companies intuit credit card reader for pc ing direct secured credit cards american express credit card payment billdesk platinum credit cards australia accept credit cards using google checkout security deposit credit card bank america capital one credit card insurance some expired credit card numbers american express revolving credit card diners club test credit card number wellsfargo credit card online access stop bank of america credit card checks cash advance new millenium bank secured credit card application how to fake a credit card number make duct tape wallet credit card holders can you pay kohls credit card store credit card offers best travel miles bonus banks provide secured credit cards salute credit card address does capital one credit card charge international fees platinum visa credit card benefits hdfc credit card offer on flight booking check your credit score for free without credit card iphone 4 credit card reader australia hdfc bank credit cards customer care cute credit cards designs make payment on ny and company credit card account washington mutual credit card payment online low credit score credit cards no annual fee difference credit card debit card rei visa card credit score citibank credit card contact number delhi american express travel rewards credit card why accept credit cards for payment flight credit card offer ipad credit card swiper paypal american airline credit card bonus miles 50000 fnb omaha credit card customer service citibank credit card travel insurance claim form fidelity investment rewards visa credit card how to instantly eliminate credit card debt without bankruptcy or credit counseling best credit cards to take travelling mobile credit card payments uk first citizen citibank platinum credit card capital one bank credit card reviews paypal credit card number stolen ikea credit card application canada bad credit credit card loan cibc credit card phone number household credit cards consolidating credit card debt into loan 10 best credit cards in india how much does hertz hold on your credit card requirements applying rcbc credit card aadvantage credit card icici credit card offers on movies kohls credit card login discover student card credit limit increase check your credit report free without credit card compare the market credit card balance transfers credit card approval credit score 650 credit card fraud/theft news pay for student loans with a credit card figure out credit card type from number metallic bungee cord credit card case wallet amazon credit card bank elavon credit card processing travel points credit cards capital one credit card prepaid major credit card issuers average us household credit card debt capital one credit card settlement address rbc credit card insurance steinmart credit card sign farm bureau credit card log suntrust online credit card processing how much do i need to pay monthly to pay off my credit card chase credit card home.url disney credit card offers 200 gift card credit card reform act 2009 wikipedia congress chase credit card with miles rewards credit card authorization form for british passport jp morgan chase credit card login sbi credit card toll free number ahmedabad capital one credit card statement sent new government credit card rules how to pay mortgage with credit card 2012 do you need a credit card to hire a car in uk canceling a credit card cancellation of business credit card debt is it easy to get a walmart credit card with bad credit gas credit card for poor credit best travel credit cards canada pay citibank credit card by cheque credit cards rewards travel people united bank student credit card credit cards bad credit no activation fee business credit cards company logo barclay bank credit card log in apply for credit card bad credit no deposit credit card type jcb interest free credit cards on purchases paypal plus credit card login lufthansa miles credit card usa citibank government travel card credit limit citifinancial credit card application canada rbs credit card customer service india how do i accept credit card payments apply mastercard first time no credit best credit card interest rates south africa credit card commercial priceless 2 broke girls and the pre approved credit card watch wells fargo credit card services payment address bank ireland credit card balance transfers amazon credit cards accepted best credit card for qantas frequent flyer points 2011 credit card phone open credit card for rewards natwest activate credit card online is it better to pay with credit card or debit card accept credit card your cell phone credit card for students with no credit clear plastic credit card wallet delete credit card information amazon account travel offers on icici credit cards credit cards hsbc australia how can i check how many credit cards i have freeze credit card debt credit card 5 cash back on everything pay my bp credit card online credit cards for people who been bankrupt does walmart offer its own credit card apply for home depot consumer credit card do you good credit secured credit card ll need indusind bank credit cards online apply apply credit card online decision business credit card processing leads need help paying credit card debt retriever credit card fees sbi credit cards customer care does boa offer a secured credit card bad my credit close credit card accounts use jcpenney rewards credit card pay credit card online bpi where can i pay my capital one credit card in person business credit cards reward points credit cards with no annual fee and no credit history can you buy car tax with a credit card burlington coat factory credit card application
Home BoB Documents National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 813 guests online

Atom RSS

National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 39
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Judge Sonia Sotomayor   
Wednesday, 27 May 2009 01:38

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

No. 1999 August Term, 1994

(Argued: May 11, 1995) Decided: September 29, 1995

Docket No. 95-6048

------------------------------------------

DANIEL SILVERMAN, Regional Director

for Region 2 of the National Labor

Relations Board, for and on behalf

of the National Labor Relations Board,

Petitioner-Appellee ,

v.

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYER RELATIONS

COMMITTEE, INC. and THE CONSTITUENT MEMBER

CLUBS OF MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL,

Respondents-Appellants .

------------------------------------------

B e f o r e: NEWMAN, Chief Judge , WINTER, and MAHONEY, Circuit

Judges .

Appeal from an order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (Sonia Sotomayor, Judge ) enjoining appellants to restore the terms and conditions of employment provided under an expired collective bargaining agreement. We affirm.

DOUGLAS L. LESLIE, Charlottesville, Virginia (Lisa Klein Wager, Francis L. Casey, III, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, New York, New York, of counsel), for Respondents-Appellants .

ELLEN A. FARRELL, Assistant General Counsel (Frederick L. Feinstein, General Counsel, Mary Joyce Carlson, Assistant General Counsel, Robert E. Allen, Associate General Counsel, Donald B. Zavelo, Ian M. Penny, of counsel, National Labor Relations Board, Washington, D.C.), for Petitioner-Appellee .

GEORGE M. COHEN (Virginia A. Seitz, Bredhoff & Kaiser, Washington, D.C., of counsel), for Amicus Curiae Major League Baseball Players Association .

WINTER, Circuit Judge :

This is an appeal by the Major League Baseball Player Relations Committee, Inc. ("PRC") and the constituent member clubs of Major League Baseball ("Clubs") from a temporary injunction issued by Judge Sotomayor pursuant to section 10(j) of the National Labor Relations Act ("NLRA"), 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). The PRC is the collective bargaining representative for the twenty-eight Clubs. The Major League Baseball Players Association is a union that is the exclusive bargaining representative for the forty-man rosters of each major league club. The injunction is based on the district court's conclusion that appellants violated NLRA §§ 8(a)(1) and (5), 29 U.S.C. §§ 158(a)(1) and (5), by unilaterally implementing terms and conditions of employment that differed from those in the last collective agreement. It orders the PRC and the Clubs to: (i) abide by the terms of an expired collective agreement, (ii) rescind any actions taken that are inconsistent with that agreement and (iii) bargain in good faith with the Players Association. See Silverman v. Major League Baseball Player Relations Comm., Inc. , 880 F. Supp. 246, 261 (S.D.N.Y. 1995). The injunction is to remain in effect until either (i) the expired agreement is replaced by a new collective bargaining agreement, (ii) the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") renders a final disposition of the matters pending before it in the related administrative case, or (iii) the district court finds, upon petition of either of the parties, that an impasse has occurred. See id. We affirm.

BACKGROUND

On January 1, 1990, the most recent collective agreement ("Basic Agreement") between appellants and the Players Association became effective. It contained provisions implementing a combination of free agency and a reserve system -- that is, a compromise between free competitive bidding for a player's services and an individual club's exclusive rights to those services.

Free agency, in its purest form, is a status in which the rights to a player's athletic services are not owned by a club and may be shopped around by the player in a quest for the most attractive bid. However, for more than a century, Major League Baseball has had a reserve system that to one degree or another affords individual clubs exclusive property rights to the athletic services of certain players. Before the players were organized and a collective bargaining relationship was established, the standard players contract with a club reserved to the club exclusive rights to a player's services and provided for an annual right of renewal of the contract by the club in question. The Clubs interpreted the contract as allowing the club in question to renew all of an individual player's contract, including the right of renewal provision. So interpreted, this provision -- known generally as the "reserve clause" -- bound a player to one club in perpetuity until traded or released. After the Clubs recognized the Players Association and entered into a collective agreement with it, an arbitrator held in a grievance proceeding that the reserve clause allowed a renewal for only one year rather than a succession of years. See National & American League Professional Baseball Clubs v. Major League Baseball Players Ass'n , 66 Lab. Arb. (BNA) 101 (1976) (Seitz, Arb.). Since then, appellants and the Players Association have struggled to accommodate their conflicting interests in the free agency and reserve issues, and a variety of compromises have from time to time been reached. However, relations have been acrimonious, and several strikes and lockouts have occurred. This appeal itself arises out of a strike that terminated the 1994 season before the playoffs and World Series.

Article XX of the Basic Agreement that became effective in 1990 contains a series of provisions that govern free agency and reserve rights. Players with six or more years of major league service are free agents and may seek competing bids in an effort to obtain the best contract, which may of course give exclusive rights to the club for a stipulated number of years. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 250. Free agency is guaranteed by an anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F), which prohibits the Clubs from acting in concert with each other with respect to the exercise of rights under Article XX. See id. Article XX(F) thus prevents the Clubs from agreeing either to refuse to bid for the services of free agents or to offer only low bids to them. Article XX(F) also prohibits players from acting in concert with regard to Article XX rights. See id.

Players with less than six years of service remain under reserve to their individual clubs, although a club may reserve a player only once. Although a minimum annual salary is provided, players with less than three years of major league service must negotiate with their clubs to determine their salary for the coming season. Article XX allows certain reserved players -- generally those with more than three but less than six years of service -- to demand salary arbitration. See id. at 251. Salary arbitration is a mechanism for determining the individual salaries for that group of reserved players if they cannot arrive at an agreement with their clubs. The player and the club each present the arbitrator with a suggested salary figure for a new one-year contract. The arbitrator then inserts either the player's or the club's figure into a blank uniform contract that the parties have already signed. See id. Article VI(F)(12) provides the following with regard to the criteria to be used, and the evidence to be heard, by the arbitrator:

(12) Criteria . (a) The Criteria will be the quality of the Player's contribution to his Club during the past season (including but not limited to his overall performance, special qualities of leadership and public appeal), the length and consistency of his career contribution, the record of the Player's past compensation, comparative baseball salaries . . . , the existence of any physical or mental defects on the part of the Player, and the recent performance record of the Club including but not limited to its League standing and attendance as an indication of public acceptance (subject to the exclusion stated in subparagraph(b)(i) below). Any evidence may be submitted which is relevant to the above criteria, and the arbitrator shall assign such weight to the evidence as shall to him appear appropriate under the circumstances. The arbitrator shall, except for a Player with five or more years of Major League service, give particular attention, for comparative salary purposes, to the contracts of Players with Major League service not exceeding one annual service group above the Player's annual service group. This shall not limit the ability of a Player or his representative, because of special accomplishment, to argue the equal relevance of salaries of Players without regard to service, and the arbitrator shall give whatever weight to such argument as he deems appropriate.

 

(b) Evidence of the following shall not be admissible:

(i) The financial position of the Player and the Club;

(ii) Press comments, testimonials or similar material bearing on the performance of either the Player or the Club, except that recognized annual Player awards for playing excellence shall not be excluded;

(iii) Offers made by either Player or Club prior to arbitration;

 

(iv) The cost to the parties of their representatives, attorneys, etc.;

 

(v) Salaries in other sports or occupations.

The Basic Agreement expired on December 31, 1993, pursuant to the PRC's notice of termination. Although negotiations for a successor agreement did not get underway until March 1994, the PRC and the Players Association continued to observe the terms of the expired Basic Agreement. Prior to the commencement of negotiations, the Clubs and the Players Association had completed individual salary arbitration hearings and had entered into individual player contracts for the 1994 baseball season, which began in April 1994. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 251.

Negotiations for a new collective bargaining agreement continued unsuccessfully. The PRC offered its first formal economic proposal to the Players Association at a meeting on June 14, 1994. It included a "salary cap," a mechanism that establishes a ceiling on the total player salaries paid by each club. The ceiling may allow some flexibility, depending on the details. Generally, the aggregate salaries of each team are determined by an agreed upon formula and must remain above a minimum percentage of industry revenues, also determined by an agreed upon formula, but below a maximum percentage of those revenues. See Wood v. National Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954, 957 (2d Cir. 1987). The PRC proposal also eliminated the salary arbitration system and substituted restricted free agency rights for those reserved players previously eligible for salary arbitration. As an alternative to the PRC's proposed salary cap, the Players Association suggested a revenue sharing and luxury "tax" plan that would impose a tax on high-paying clubs. Subsequent proposals reflected disagreement over appropriate tax rates and payroll thresholds above which clubs would be subject to the tax. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 251-52.

The players struck on August 12, and the 1994 baseball season never resumed. On December 22, 1994, the PRC declared an impasse in negotiations and stated that it intended unilaterally to impose a salary cap and to implement other changes in the terms and conditions of employment, including the elimination of salary arbitration. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 252. The Players Association responded with a unilateral ban on players signing individual contracts with the Clubs.

Thereafter, cross-charges of unfair labor practices were filed with the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") by the Players Association and the Clubs. The Players Association alleged that the Clubs had engaged in unfair labor practices by unilaterally implementing the salary cap and other terms because the parties were not at an impasse.

On February 3, 1995, counsel for the PRC notified the NLRB General Counsel that the PRC would revoke the implementation of unilateral changes and restore the status quo ante. The General Counsel indicated that the Players Association charges would be dismissed as a result. Counsel for the PRC informed the General Counsel, however, that the PRC did not believe itself obligated to maintain provisions of the Basic Agreement that involved non-mandatory subjects of bargaining. He mentioned salary arbitration in that regard and also suggested that the Clubs might decide to bargain exclusively through the PRC. The NLRB General Counsel declined to offer an advisory opinion on these matters.

Three days later, by memorandum dated February 6, counsel for the PRC notified the Clubs that, until a new collective bargaining agreement was ratified or until further notice, individual clubs had no authority to negotiate contracts with individual players because the PRC was now the Clubs' exclusive bargaining representative. This amounted to an agreement among the Clubs not to hire free agents and thus was a departure from the anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F) of the Basic Agreement. It also amounted to an elimination of salary arbitration, because salary arbitration is a method of arriving at a wage for an individual player contract with a club.

The Players Association thereupon filed a new unfair labor practice charge, and the General Counsel issued a complaint alleging, inter alia , that the Clubs and the PRC had violated Sections 8(a)(1) and (5) of the NLRA by unilaterally eliminating, before an impasse had been reached, competitive bidding for the services of free agents, the anti-collusion provision, and salary arbitration for certain reserved players. The NLRB found that these matters were related to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment and were therefore mandatory subjects for collective bargaining. It then authorized its General Counsel to seek an injunction under NLRA §10(j). On March 27, the NLRB Regional Director filed a petition seeking a temporary injunction restraining the alleged unfair labor practices.

The district court agreed that the NLRB had reasonable cause to conclude that free agency and salary arbitration were mandatory subjects of bargaining and that the Clubs' unilateral actions constituted an unfair labor practice. The district court also concluded that injunctive relief was warranted. This appeal followed. We denied a stay on April 4.

DISCUSSION

The NLRB is authorized under Section 10(j) of the NLRA to petition for temporary injunctive relief from a district court to enjoin ongoing unfair labor practices. 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). If the court has reasonable cause to believe that an unfair labor practice has occurred and that injunctive relief would be just and proper, it should grant appropriate relief. Kaynard v. MMIC, Inc. , 734 F.2d 950, 953 (2d Cir. 1984). The court need not make a final determination that the conduct in question is an unfair labor practice. Kaynard v. Mego Corp. , 633 F.2d 1026, 1033 (2d Cir. 1980). It need find only reasonable cause to support such a conclusion. See id. ; MMIC , 734 F.2d at 953. Appropriate deference must be shown to the judgment of the NLRB, and a district court should decline to grant relief only if convinced that the NLRB's legal or factual theories are fatally flawed. See Mego , 633 F.2d at 1031, 1033; Kaynard v. Palby Lingerie, Inc. , 625 F.2d 1047, 1051 (2d Cir. 1980). In reviewing a district court's grant of injunctive relief pursuant to Section 10(j), a court of appeals must also accord deference to the district court's decision, at least with regard to those aspects that are traditionally left to the district court's discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030.

We turn now to the merits of the regional director's petition. The petition invokes basic principles of labor law. Section 8(d) of the NLRA mandates that employers and unions bargain in good faith over "wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment." 29 U.S.C. § 158(d). These are so-called mandatory subjects of bargaining. Under caselaw, the parties may propose and bargain over, but may not insist upon, permissive subjects of bargaining. NLRB v. Wooster Div. of Borg-Warner Corp. , 356 U.S. 342, 349 (1958). When a collective agreement expires, an employer may not alter terms and conditions of employment involving mandatory subjects until it has bargained to an impasse over new terms. NLRB v. Katz , 369 U.S. 736, 741-43 (1962). Thereafter, it may implement the new terms. Generally, when an agreement expires, an employer need not bargain to an impasse over terms and conditions involving permissive subjects but may alter them upon expiration. Allied Chem. & Alkali Workers v. Pittsburgh Plate Glass Co. , 404 U.S. 157, 187-88 (1971).

Many of the usual issues that arise in impasse cases are not disputed in the instant matter. The parties agree that the PRC, in directing the Clubs to decline to bargain individually with free agents, unilaterally departed from much of Article XX, which provides for a limited form of free agency and forbids collusive behavior by the Clubs in negotiating with free agents. It is also undisputed that the PRC unilaterally departed from the Basic Agreement's provisions with regard to salary arbitration. The PRC does not claim that it had bargained to an impasse over the free agency, the anti-collusion, or the salary arbitration provisions. Finally, it is also agreed that, if those provisions involved mandatory subjects of bargaining, their unilateral abrogation before impasse was a refusal to bargain in good faith. The PRC and the Clubs argue that the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement do not involve mandatory subjects of bargaining and are therefore not subject to the Katz rule that unilateral implementation of new terms is an unfair labor practice unless the employer has bargained to an impasse over these new terms. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 254. The PRC and the Clubs contend that an injunction compelling them to maintain the free agency and anti-collusion provisions undermines their right as a multiemployer group to bargain collectively through an exclusive representative. If so, they would be permissive subjects of bargaining. See Borg Warner , 356 U.S. at 349 . With regard to salary arbitration, the PRC and the Clubs argue that it is the equivalent of interest arbitration -- arbitration of the terms of a new collective agreement -- and thus not a mandatory subject of bargaining. See International Bhd. of Elec. Workers (Collier Elec. Co.) , 296 N.L.R.B. 1095, 1098 (1989).

We are unpersuaded that an injunction compelling the PRC and the Clubs to observe the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement infringes on their right as a multiemployer group to bargain through an exclusive representative. Free agency and the ban on collusion are one part of a complex method -- agreed upon in collective bargaining -- by which each major league player's salary is determined under the Basic Agreement. They are analogous to the use of seniority, hours of work, merit increases, or piece work to determine salaries in an industrial context. The PRC and the Clubs describe free agency and the ban on collusion as provisions undermining their right to select a joint bargaining representative because those provisions entail individual contracts with clubs. However, the argument ignores the fact that free agency is simply a collectively bargained method of determining individual salaries for one group of players. The anti-collusion provision is not designed to prevent the PRC from representing the Clubs. Rather, that provision guarantees that free agency will be a reality when permitted by the Basic Agreement. The injunction thus does not in any way prevent the PRC from bargaining as the Clubs' exclusive representative with the Players Association over the elimination of free agency in its entirety or for a modified version of the same, and thereafter from implementing any proposals incorporated into a collective bargaining agreement.

The question, therefore, is whether the free agency, anti-collusion, and reserve issues are -- or there is reasonable cause to believe they are -- otherwise mandatory subjects of bargaining. Section 8(d) of the NLRA defines the duty to bargain as "the obligation . . . to meet . . . and confer in good faith with respect to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment . . . ." In Wood v. Nat'l Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954 (2d Cir. 1987), we noted that free agency and reserve issues are "at the center of collective bargaining in much of the professional sports industry," id. at 961, and that "it is precisely because of [free agency's] direct relationship to wages and conditions of employment that [it is] so controversial and so much the focus of bargaining in professional sports." Id. at 962.

Wood noted that collective bargaining between professional athletes and leagues raises "numerous problems with little or no precedent in standard industrial relations." Id. at 961. Such is the case with a free agency and reserve system. For the most part, unionized employees in the industrial sector may leave one employer for another without restriction. The employee may have no bargaining rights with regard to the terms of hire by the new employer, which may be set by a collective agreement, but is nevertheless generally free to go from one unionized job to another. [1]  

The professional sports industry has a very different history and very different economic imperatives. Most professional sports leagues have always had some form of what has become known as the reserve system. See Flood v. Kuhn , 407 U.S. 258, 259 n.1 (1972) (baseball); Robertson v. National Basketball Ass'n , 556 F.2d 682, 686 n.6 (2d Cir. 1977) (basketball); Mackey v. National Football League , 543 F.2d 606, 610 (8th Cir. 1976) (football), cert. dismissed , 434 U.S. 801 (1977); McCourt v. California Sports, Inc. , 600 F.2d 1193, 1194 (6th Cir. 1979) (hockey). As noted, this is a system by which the right to a player's services becomes the property of a particular club with limited freedom for the player to seek employment with another club. The reserve system in one form or another has been used in major league baseball for over a century. Until the arbitration decision in 1976, the reserve system prevented players from offering their athletic services to competing teams. A player's services were thus the property of a single team until he was traded or released. In enforcing a complete reserve system, Major League Baseball was exercising monopsony power -- a buyer's monopoly.

However, there are many reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues from players to clubs, why reserve systems exist within professional sports. Fans might not be interested in games between teams that had entirely new lineups for every contest. Moreover, high quality play may require that individuals practice and play with the same teammates for at least some period of time. Teams may also want to recoup what they regard as training costs invested in players while they gained experience. In antitrust litigation, the leagues perennially argue that some form of reserve system is necessary for competitive balance. See Mackey , 543 F.2d at 611. Indeed, even in a system of complete free agency, one would expect to see many long-term agreements binding individual players to particular clubs.

There are also reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues to players, why a union of professional athletes would seek free agency. It is very difficult to set individual salaries in professional sports through collective bargaining. Although unions of professional athletes may bargain for uniform benefits and minimum salaries, they do not usually follow their industrial counterparts and seek relatively fixed salaries by job description, seniority, or other formulae. Players often play positions requiring very different skills. Moreover, the level of performance and value to a team in attracting fans differs radically among players, with star athletes or popular players being far more valuable than sub-par or nondescript players. Usually, therefore, players unions seek some form of free agency as a relatively simple method of setting individual salaries.

Most importantly, however, both the leagues and the players unions view free agency and reserve issues as questions of what share of revenues go to the clubs or to the players. The more restrictive the reserve system is, the greater the clubs' share. The greater the role of free agency, the greater the players' share.

To hold that there is no reasonable cause for the NLRB to conclude that free agency and reserve issues are mandatory subjects of bargaining would be virtually to ignore the history and economic imperatives of collective bargaining in professional sports. A mix of free agency and reserve clauses combined with other provisions is the universal method by which leagues and players unions set individual salaries in professional sports. Free agency for veteran players may thus be combined with a reserve system, as in baseball, or a rookie draft, as in basketball, see Wood , 809 F.2d at 957, for newer players. A salary cap may or may not be included. See id. To hold that any of these items, or others that make up the mix in a particular sport, is merely a permissive subject of bargaining would ignore the reality of collective bargaining in sports.

Indeed, free agency is in many ways nothing but the flip side of the reserve system. A full reserve system does not eliminate individual bargaining between teams and players. It simply limits that bargaining to one team. If free agency were a permissive subject of collective bargaining, then so would be the reserve system.

With regard to salary arbitration, we will assume, but not decide, that if it is a form of interest arbitration, it may be unilaterally eliminated. See George Koch & Sons, Inc. , 306 N.L.R.B. 834, 839 (1992) (interest arbitration permissive subject of bargaining). Interest arbitration is a method by which an employer and union reach new agreements by sending disputed issues to an arbitrator rather than settling them through collective bargaining and economic force. See New York Typographical Union No. 6 v. Printers League , 919 F.2d 3 n.2 (2d Cir. 1990). The salary arbitration provisions of the Basic Agreement are a method by which salaries for some players who are not eligible for free agency -- those with three to six years of major league service -- are set. The Basic Agreement sets forth criteria by which the arbitrator is to reach a decision. These criteria include the player's performance in the prior year, the length and consistency of career contribution, physical or mental defects, recent performance of the team on the field and at the gate, and salaries of certain comparable players. The Basic Agreement also forbids the arbitrator from considering certain facts that might otherwise be relevant. Finally, the Basic Agreement requires that the arbitrator pick either the club's suggested salary or the player's.

We decline to analogize Article VI(f) of the Basic Agreement to interest arbitration. Salary arbitration provides limited discretion to the arbitrator to set salaries for designated players who are not eligible for free agency. The discretion afforded the arbitrator is arguably less than the discretion afforded arbitrators in grievance arbitration involving disputes arising under an existing collective agreement, which is beyond question a mandatory subject of bargaining. In grievance arbitration, an arbitrator may permissibly imply a term even though the term has no explicit support in the text of the collective agreement. See United Steelworkers of America v. Warrior & Gulf Navigation Co. , 363 U.S. 574, 581-82 (1960) ("The labor arbitrator's source of law is not confined to the express provisions of the contract, as the industrial common law -- the practices of the industry and the shop -- is equally a part of the collective bargaining agreement although not expressed in it."); see also Holly Sugar Corp. v. Distillery, Rectifying, Wine & Allied Workers Int'l Union , 412 F.2d 899, 903 (9th Cir. 1969). Similarly, a term may be implied from past practices even though somewhat inconsistent with the agreement. See International Chem. Workers Union, Local No. 278 v. Imco Container Co. , 78 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2014 (S.D. Ind. 1971). We thus decline to analogize salary arbitration to interest arbitration, and, therefore, we hold that there is reasonable cause to believe that it is a mandatory subject of bargaining.

With regard to whether the granting of relief was "just and proper," 29 U.S.C. § 160(j), we review the district court's determination only for abuse of discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030; Palby Lingerie , 625 F.2d at 1051. We see no such abuse in the present matter. Given the short careers of professional athletes and the deterioration of physical abilities through aging, the irreparable harm requirement has been met. The unilateral elimination of free agency and salary arbitration followed by just three days a promise to restore the status quo. The PRC decided to settle the original unfair labor practice charges while embarking on a course of action based on a fallacious view of the duty to bargain. We see no reason to relieve it of the consequences of that course.

We therefore affirm.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?