vermox new zealand pharmacy purchase dilantin in mexico levitra plus for sale australia lithium uk no prescription albendazole side effects dogs is clomid available in india can you buy luvox over the counter in germany cheapest vagifem tablets uk cialis without prescription canada foreign pharmacies online side effects of losartan tablets omnicef for sale acquistare motrin in italia atorlip 10 tablets side effects is generic paxil the same buy brand zentel buy janumet inhaler canada best place to buy quibron t in india what difference among viagra cialis or levitra cheap renova pills mylan clarithromycin alcohol shuddha guggulu australia pharmacy buy pulmicort online canada no prescription clorfenamina compuesta ky6 para que sirve best place to buy midamor in india buy serpina generic ordering priligy canada order hytrin without rx lotrisone on line in the mexico flagyl in pregnancy third trimester buy carvedilolo without rx nexium store order prednisone 120 mg levothyroid on line in the india buy cheap lexapro olanzapine buy india safe pills for erectile dysfunction buy cialis tablets canada best price for real lotrisone usa buy mircette without prescription what are the side effects of bactrim is there a generic form for aciphex is aygestin available over the counter blopress delivery generic pills for frumil long term side effects of thyroxine tablets order erection packs 1 on line canada duetact from china order zydis overnight best place buy lexapro what is celapram pills used for levitra professional billig kaufen where to buy cheap generic vardenafilum online silagra with no prescription order diovan from canada without prescription ciprofloxacina from usa yasmin pill buy online u.k mobic tablets 40mg metformin hcl 500 mg tablet solco buy sarafem tablets usa elavil use in pregnancy current price wellbutrin what is the classification of rocaltrol over the counter medicine that acts as trileptal online perscription drugs research grade clopidogrelum omnicef tablets 40mg diclofenac india buy generic cialis uk buy anteovin boots pharmacy order misoprost on line canada eutirox 50 mcg 84 comprimidos purchase geriforte in india artane prices where do i aprovel in australia is decadron over the counter celebrex dose for rheumatoid arthritis finast buy from england how to buy luvox ayurslim over the counter india buy dutas online from australia low price robaxin uk how to order retin a online online doxycycline with no prescription nolvadex gaspari reviews lopid online purchase ampicillin generics safe prometrium buy buy olistat online overnight what does propranolol hydrochloride treat diovan no script cialis pas cher pharmacie paris speman online store buy cheap kamagra gold pills purchase nordette on line in india esperal usa grifulvin v online legally how to by cialis jelly online order nimotop online uk can you buy cialis at walmart best site for aceon evista mexico no prescription buy atarax online reviews mexican pharmacy no prescription oratane generic zenegra paypal comprar rumalaya portugal cheapest etabus tablets uk where do i cipro in australia buy viagra jelly for daily use pill rx health silagra products fluticanose india no prescription alti doxycycline tablets relafen prices at costco retin a gel 0,1 prices cvs wellbutrin sr over the counter usa buy online amantadine generic order cialis super active medication by mail actos birth control online us proscar lawsuit generic celebrex price levlen over the counter canada buy acai boots pharmacy buy demadex online no prescription usa levitra professional by mail order online phexin tablets purchase on line overseas pharmacy no prescription tretinoin 0,025 acheter effexor xr what is the classification of tenormin purinethol weight gain there generic bactrim ds combivent supplier in uk no script medazole mg buy clomid perth australia cozaar 25 mg tablets is apo clopidogrel available over the counter purchase ginette 35 in canada rumalaya gel online usa no prescription erection packs 1 birth control online india where is allegra k from what is novo digoxin tablets purchasing tindamax online uk buy genuine aristocort uk floxin next day delivery best place to buy torsemide in mexico piroxicam capsules 10mg buy ayurslim with paypal order septilin cheap messi stats 2011 12 bystolic dose conversion paroxetine perth australia sertraline dosage 200 mg generic hydrochlorothiazide safe how to use chloromycetin eye ointment what is voltaren gel for prednisolona from usa erectile dysunction pills for sale online pharmacy uk yaz aceon weight gain lopressor 20 mg where to buy tadalafil online drug 10mg colchicine medication dose where to buy medazole online mexico where to buy tamsulozin mg list of strongest pain pills fertomid with paypal payment india cipro resistance prevacid dose for babies usa buy coreg without prescription phenergan cheap us pharmacy atarax over the counter drugs prescription where to buy toprol without a prescription us pharmacies online that sell levothroid buy stilnox australia dramamine best price thyroxin canada prescription diabecon drugstore.com zantac online mexico 100 mg cialis professional is it safe to order meloxicam enolat uk buy hydrochlorothiazide without prescription propranolol online pharmacy tadalis sx drug in canada pharmacy actos uk no prescription generic lexapro us nitroglycerin 20mg tab levitra generika purchase levothyroid on line in usa buy viagra sublingual boots pharmacy medrol dosage information beconase aq fast mexico where to purchase bupron sr i want to buy pariet emsam not generic side effects of valtrex discount clopidogrelum otc cheap levitra sale uk buy compazine hong kong mg cheapest meloxicam enolat over the counter canada endep on line flomax drugstore.com ordering combivent dutasterid side effects long term use unisom price list of tesco stores selling isoniazid purchase nizagara online no prescription buy alavert mg orlistat side effects forum where can i buy viagra in malaysia stieva a to purchase without a prescription roaccutane shop net xenical in the uk now nymphomax online cheap fexofenadine hcl and alcohol best ayurslim prices can you buy bactroban over the counter what is the recommended dosage for viagra mircette cost canadian what does augmentin duo forte treat best site for pravachol cymbalta 40mg is generic floxin effective birth control pills venlor buy sumycin paypal can you buy viagra in the uk neurontin birth control online us pharmacy mexico lipothin wellbutrin xr 150 mg buying zetia using paypal buy florinef without a prescription from canadian pharmacy buy brand c ratioph buy viagra online with out prescription best place to buy depakine chrono erythromycin 250mg tablets acne mentax generic substitute half price vagifem buy albenza online apcalis sx medication order buy isotretin singapore generic ophthacare no prescription canada order betnovate hannah s club 7 generic seroflo switzerland buy viagra professional online reviews overstock drugstore coupon code how to use albuterol inhaler for weight loss canadian pharmacy celebrex and fast ship can you use fucidin h cream acne where do i tadalis in mexico lansoprazol brands india buy ginseng online us no prescription plavix maximum dosage provera nhs how to buy remeron maxalt wholesale desyrel over the counter uk rhinocort pills sweat tallest healthy man what is flexeril 5 mg used for buy over the counter yaz online clomifene no prescription fedex ups eltroxin without a prescription from us ortho tri cyclen side effects zyrtec online with out prescription is oxytrol legal in uk vistaril cheap mexico pharmacy no prescription furosemide brand amoxil cheap canada pharmacy over the counter ovral l why cant i get orlistat capsules how much does it cost to live in a hotel zyloprim drug canadian pharmacy buy ortho cyclen online in the united states without a prescription ciprofloxacina delivery london zovirax side effects diarrhea where to buy prednisona online canada where can i buy disulphiram mg bentyl shipping overseas is there a generic for revatio wellbutrin online overnight shipping roaccutan pill shortage trial erection packs 3 order canada white russian drugs safe to buy generic advair from usa isoptin rx where can i order keflex buy tetracycline fda usa online pharmacy brand cialis drug canadian pharmacy qsymia canada pharmacy cheapest zoloft online research grade evecare side effects of bactrim can i take levitra and viagra at the same time cost of prevacid at walmart purchase seasonique pills zithromax mail order cefixime in the uk now propranolol er cost generic viagra plus safe discount reglan from canada best site get bentyl online generic bactrim cheap tretinoin 0 025 free delivery triderm ointment albuterol inhaler price comparison where do i coversyl in uk generic pills for elavil paxil australia price pfizer zyvox assistance rsvp program original keflex online i pill clonidine website buy viagra boots london buy vantin boots buy januvia without prescription alesse pills online in the uk gyne lotrimin cheap much does propecia cost canada buy cozaar with no script where amaryllis grow tadalis buy no prescription where to buy tadapox mg is it safe to order antibiotics online maxalt 10 mg tabletten tadalafil generic alternative to cialis 10mg 24 what is the drug olanzapine used for zoloft drugs information buy haldol cheap buy liposafe canada fincar barato where to buy clomid online uk what is valacyclovir hcl 1 gram where to purchase levothyroid buy esperal greece doxycycline price increase lotensin in usa retino a cream 0 05 in croatia ampicillin online australia tamoxifen best price coreg discount card where to buy viagra online in the uk cialis 5mg best price australia indian pharmacy imitrex zaca med cabinets discount canadian pharmacy ashwagandha fucidin coupons can you get sominex over the counter how to take furosemide flagyl canada head office valtrex discount biaxin direct pharmacy canada buy metronidazol without prescription finax from usa legal buy voveran sr online canada ventolin order online no prescription buy brand zantac purchase lotrisone on line in uk can i order januvia online legal buy quetiapinum online canada fastest kamagra oral jelly uk delivery duetact online forum geriforte syrup on line what is uroxatral tablets compare prices claravis nizoral buy india coversyl 10mg generic tetracycline antibiotics reviews buy mirapex in uk max benadryl dose for sleep what is generic wellbutrin called riperdal generic name doxi 1 online canadian herbal viagra melbourne canada and colchicine allopurinol no prrescription viagra products is mail order retin a 0 025 safe trandate buy online mexico sarafem 100mg buy atrovent online overnight shipping buy duprost tablets us med cab methotrexate is 20mg of lexapro a high dose safe to buy generic aygestin from uk how to purchase plendil resources for yagara order zyloprim rx simplotan tablets 500mg montelukast granules shortage confido medication where to buy buy generic micardis online no prescription silagra cheap canada pharmacy lioresal online in usa buy lady era hong kong achilles tendonitis from levaquin combivent dose pediatric online oestrogel with no prescription how to take retino a cream 0,025 mg 100mg ml ampicillin solution himcocid pills online in the usa order ashwagandha canada zovirax to buy from europe what is doxycycline hyclate 100mg tablets what is kelnor accutane journal 2006 where starlix suhagra 100 for women difference between synthroid generic levothyroxine compazine medicine online prescription cost allopurinol 300mg buy nootropil online no prescription uk cialis professional cost canadian generic vagifem for sale on line diflucan generic over the counter prozac online order best price levaquin medication online mestinon top rated online pharmacies reviews accuran usa cvs prices zofran melt 8 mg cost of mail revia purchase avalide lowest price vistaril max dose purchase zovirax in canada levitra plus online in uk what happens if you take two cialis where do i ampicillin in mexico can i get high off claritin d buy arava online india no prescription does alli work by mail order how to take levaquin 750 mg orlistatum canada overnight delivery pharmacy that sells zoloft levaquin medicine interactions order tadapox online no prescription with a echeck no rx retino a cream 0 025 online cordarone lawsuit canada order lipitor online no presctiption india pharmacies online that sell aristocort best site for albenza pariet discount zollinger ellison syndrome duodenal ulcers demadex drugstore com pricing purchasing ondansetrona online purchase propranolol in mexico antibusedrug viagra sublingual sale generic pills top 10 online acticin sites buying fluoxetine using paypal protonix now co uk mail order discount prescriptions where to get erection packs 3 pct penegra uk synthroid to buy in the usa without a prescription fucking with viagra male fertility drugs for men comprare cialis originale online donde comprar viagra femenino en buenos aires order cleocin 300 mg order augmentin powder discount thyrox from usa lioresal with paypal payment purchase janumet in australia top 10 online thyroxine sites cost of mail anafranil minomycin order on web buy suhagra boots pharmacy canada and carvedilolo purchasing medrol online uk buy lotrisone online click here order predalone online canada duetact india sale shoppers drug mart store hours canada day arimidex to purchase without a prescription eldepryl side effects long term use where to buy v gel with echeck mentax with no subscription valacyclovir uk price dostinex on line in the usa isoptin no prescription cheap suprax uk buy hyzaar with a mastercard cheapest dyazide paypal buy clonidine hcl certified amaryl online no prescription fluss 40 without script thambi arjuna movie online free how to by lopid online order allegra overnight can allegra cause you to gain weight pariet in the uk genuine ventolin best price diflucan without prescription pills is evista a prescription drug purchase promethazine cheap costco pharmacy trial erection packs 2 price best price for real wellbutrin sr safe buy anastrozolo online prednisone 10mg tablets side effects lithium fda approved to buy without prescription can you get high off zyrtec syrup arjuna medicine online periactin without prescription miami mevacor no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy buy cefixime capsules arjuna buy uk combivent to buy safe malegra fxt buy costa rica pharmacy where do i arzomicin in usa anacin with out a prescription best place to buy flagyl er qsymia diet drug price cialis soft online from canada calan uk companies only how to use lopressor where is prevacid made apo clopidogrel usa sale diabecon for sale australia atarax paypal zyloprim without a prescription from mexico tadalafil generic reviews buy femara without rx health canada tretinoin quetiapinum no script retino a cream online in usa can you take 40mg of aciphex new anti depression medication 2012 is generic innopran xl effective no prescription cilest buy cleocin gel pills in the uk bactroban nasal ointment over counter sirius xm viagra commercial where can i get zocor pills purchase viagra professional on line in uk order colchicine on line usa order exelon uk pharmacy generic cialis super active tadalafil 20mg quality meclizine pills online in the australia zyrtec pills allergy atorlip 10 usa pharmacy sotalol and viagra buy levitra plus mg importing prescription drugs from india yourgeneric order glucophage medication by mail buy olanzapine online thru paypals ventolin overseas metrogel without a prescription why cant i get my orlistat buy risperdal with a mastercard best online pharmacy generic thyroxin stromectol without a prescription from canada can i buy ventolin in canada tretinoin tablets buy order diovan from india without prescription buy lanoxin tablets canada where can i buy hoodia in ireland fast phexin deleviery benzac comprare arava generic uk viagra where to buy over the counter sepibest max dose purchase rythmol sr on line in the uk elavil over the counter uk buy warafin online from mexico where to buy quibron t normal free thyroxine levels alesse from canada with no prescription how much is pyridium tablets low cost atarax can you buy delta cortef online online pharmacy adderall no prescription no rx protonix online side effects of biaxin xl 500mg nootropil generic uk buy arjuna online australia no prescription paxil weight gain side effects buy tenormin xr without prescription genuine methotrexate 100mg estrace fast uk diovan on line in the mexico levitra professional phone orders januvia no prescription overnight delivery order singulair in acai berry sales canada cystone online uk fenofibrate 200 mg side effects purchase zydis on line in canada cleocin gel buy canada mifepristone and misoprostol cost uk best place to order levitra in us where to buy synthroid online india apo clopidogrel online in us how to take singulair oral granules buying aciphex from canada no prescription half price lotrisone neurontin discount no prescription buy genuine pfizer viagra uk can you get a blood clot while on coumadin purchasing gabapentine online side effects of omnicef bactroban mg india asmanex coupon buy fincar online canada no prescription buy ciplox online from canada finasteride generico colombia online shallaki overnight delivery 24h pharmacy dubai speman drug in fr pharmacy is generic baclofen available in usa what is keflex mg used to treat cialis kopen den haag where can i buy pct steroids to buy diabecon levoxyl inactive ingredients side effects online mentat india mexican pharmacy no prescription plendil best place to buy prescriptions drugs online order zocor on line canada medrol where can i buy it buy apo clopidogrel online from australia real viagra for sale online erythromycin and its effects on birth control pills vpxl generic cheap costs order lotrisone medication by mail buy nizagara overseas aldactone new zealand exelon overnight pharmacy dipyridamole online in usa comprar albenda original en madrid order paroxetine protonix 40 mg buy genuine ceftin best price nootropil discount health canada arava buy rocaltrol online azithromycin z pack 5 day dose cost of actonel once a month vpxl dosage probalan uk brand name buy diamox in china where can i buy anacin in canada toradol for sale canada usa buy zenegra without prescription canada and cleocin gel styplon precio mexico plendil with prescription generic thyrohormone canada dilantin overnight shipping order erection packs 3 online in usa buy betamethasone valerate cream how to buy haldol in canada where can i buy torsemide in canada revia looking for uk pharmacies online that sell elocom online tenormin overnight delivery accutane long term benefits mirapex results forum tretinoin birth control online canada what are the side effects of crestor medication order lipitor uk pharmacy buy carafate with visa order estrace from india without prescription speman canada online no prescription nootropil tablets proscar delivered to your home evecare suppliers overseas dapoxetine no prescription overnight delivery buy glucovance without a subscription where to buy amoxil with visa order chloromycetin no rx canadian pharmacy dramamine discount voucher clonazepam generic pill identifier thyrox order in the us where can i buy wellbutrin online without a prescription buy viagra 10 simplotan tinidazole 500mg can atacand cause weight gain buy advair online india finast online shipping generic amaryl canada discount prescriptions cvs onlain filmek mail order cafergot online propecia en europa buy alli international shipping alli daily use reviews eltroxin next day where do i viagra soft in uk generic flonase costco clomid multiple births rates non prescription oxytrol order sominex online no presctiption drug market order calan canadian pharmacy zaditor actos pharmacies baclofen pump australia express scripts specialty pharmacy network glucotrol xl classification where to buy carafate online without rx where can i buy isotretin online without a prescription effexor and alcohol cravings unisom sleep aid overdose arjuna buy online india where to buy dostinex in canada safely metronidazol online ordering safe eulexin buy tinidazole usage is there a drug comparative to ceftin stromectol online purchase spironolactone hirsutism mechanism pamelor prescription only antibiotics no prescription canada suprax 100 side effects biaxin usa cvs prices generic disulfiramo buy canada generic differin teva brand viagra sale approved lansoprazol buy mexico buy advair diskus cheap prescription flonase drug oversea anafranil canadian online overnight pharmacy skelaxin on line in the mexico efectos secundarios pastillas xerograx prolactin medication dostinex how to buy celebrex zovirax where to purchase what does viagra do to females frusemide where to buy in canada buy carvedilolo online can you take cholestoplex daily what does lisinopril do to the heart cheapest place to buy shallaki frusemide mg uk real cialis sale generic post cycle liquid clomid dosage nexium online mexico how to buy lipitor cheap can you buy allegra over the counter became buy nizoral shampoo online india oder mg tablets of antabuse buy over the counter cytoxan online ordering aricept mexico us pharmacies online that sell micronase free youtube mp3 converter alavert d 12 generic methotrexate 10 mg weekly consumer reviews of canadian pharmacies buy disulfiramo online australia no prescription order valtrex online in usa adalat over the counter generic order aygestin rx safe to buy generic albenda from uk sominex coupon code buy brand viagra without a subscription pharmacy has best price lipitor side effects of indocin capsules malegra fxt ships from india yagara generic mexico viagra type medicine in india meloxicam for cats dose aspirin lawsuit canada online no prescription generic antibiotics can order zyloprim canada best place to order bystolic in us glucotrol xl india companies only innopran xl fast mexico vermox meds no prescripion discount zebeta of canada stromectol prices at costco order flucazole from uk without prescription blopress canadian pharmacy purchase alavert lowest price ann summers original blue pill reviews tizanidina usa alfa flucon canada companies only where can i get amantadine from online generic vpxl order myambutol tablets best place to buy requip in uk fasigyn mail order flomax fast india where to buy erythromycin online india lamisil weight gain bupropion on line in the india tretinoin medication side effects brand cialis on line in the uk cialis super active limited india buy allopurinol perth australia relafen india suppliers ordering dipyridamole india where to buy finpecia with echeck how to take female viagra mg klipal codeine buy uk precio trental mexico male viagra pills keppra xr and birth control pills canadian health and safety regulations is ciplox available on line in canada lanoxin from australia levitra plus overnight delivery buy atorlip 20 usa buy propecia low cheap price generic entocort usa pharmacy where to buy glucophage with mastercard amoxil discount code buying cipralex from canada no prescription 800 mg motrin over counter order calan online no prescription with a echeck pill identifier lisinopril 20 mg probalan coupons order prednisona online zertalin where to get infant motrin buy klipal codeine online mexico no prescription can you buy propecia uk online pharmacy schools in texas detrol us companies only buy cordarone without a script over the counter lasilix where do i ampicilina in india where to buy clavamox online mexico side effects of zyrtec cheap microzide pills buy med s with paypal buy amantadine online usa where to buy accutane prescription super p force viagra dapoxetine coumadin toxicity treatment vitamin k promethazine prices cvs online bupron india how to take prograf buy nolvadex pills in the uk trileptal annual sales discount paxil avapro buy online uk reviews on thyrox avandamet drug store online what is the correct dosage of acticin beta val mg uk ralista cheap fast rumalaya liniment deleviery 100 mg prazosin elocon cream buy uk is mail order menosan safe can i buy retin in canada prescription drug crestor safe sarafem buy doxycycline dose for chlamydia buy tamoxifen citrate nolvadex drug anastrozole price why is there a shortage of viagra sublingual what is doxycycline hyclate tablets used for best price for real ranitidine anti anxiety drugs side effects weight loss purchase plavix pills get eltroxin las vegas seroquel medication alcohol how to by voveran canadian pharmacy d cheap allegra dutas phone orders where to buy acai berry in london topamax tabletas 25 mg search mp3 free music download purchase brand amoxil on line in canada orlistat 120 generico pulmicort over the counter india sale pulmicort to buy azurette prinivil daily use reviews what is diflucan tablets levitra super active prix en pharmacie en france order nexium 40mg azithromycin zithromax price philippines chlamydia treatment pills for men tamoxifen price sigma cheap abilify canada drugs orlistatum weight gain no prescription aciclovir sale bystolic medication cost aciclovir crema precio colombia xalatan generic wikipedia drugs generic bupron sr uk indocin noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy medication online order buy shuddha guggulu cheap how to order arimidex online apo furosemida limited india original januvia online can you buy hytrin over the counter in germany levofloxacin alcohol drink alternative to celebrex medication propranolol hydrochloride 10mg side effects levoxyl generic usa carvedilolo results forum retino a cream 0 025 drug class where can i purchase abilify retin a no rx purchase zanaflex on line in usa buy estradiol patches online trazodone retail price where to get lady era canadian drug company lasilix flucazole online pay paypal buy chlamydia antibiotics legal to buy tinidazole serophene legal us stromectol discount buy anafranil online mexico no prescription betnovate discontinued medrol tablets buy buy cialis professional hong kong generic minocycline uk paypal c ratioph generic australia buy mobicarte sim safe pravachol no precription keppra generic pills buy anti anxiety pills online pharmacy has best price l tryptophan best aricept prices furosemide tablet sale purchase proscar on line in mexico no prescription doxycycline dogs oder mg tablets of parlodel kamagra paypal uk a? mupirocin nasal application where to buy glucovance drugs online purchase synthroid in uk what is zoloft 100mg used for serevent dysk 100 buy kamagra uk com sildenafil isoptin over the counter canada prazosin cheap uk how to get prometh with codeine cough syrup most reliable place to buy ephedraxin online retino a cream 0 05 dosage too high over counter percocet generic chloramphenicol switzerland atorvastatin 40 mg recall 2012 betnovate without rx cheapest place to buy mobic buy flunil pills online fluss 40 birth control online mexico can i make viagra plus ordering online pharmacy starlix mg cipro dosage diarrhea low cost pharmacy vancouver bc missed actonel dose get antabuse las vegas levothyroxin to buy from europe purchase diprosone on line in uk thyroxine tablets uk pill rx health order clozaril products what is rocaltrol made of purchasing levothroid online como comprar motrin vitamin shoppe printable coupons december 2012 what is the real name for viagra buy betnovate visa medrol dosepak over counter viagra super active where to get generic entocort for sale on line clomid tablets uk buy doxycycline no prescription in uk fastest thyroxine uk delivery where could i buy cialis professional without prescription is zofran available over the counter buy erexin v mg what is the dose of prevacid for an infant phone in order for elavil how much will atorlip 5 cost side effects of metoclopramide in children accutane 40mg from canada is crestor legal in uk buy flovent next day what else is elavil used for purchase baclofen on line in usa where to buy livestrong bracelets toronto buy janumet greece online pharmacy uk sepibest side effects of crestor cholesterol tablets l thyroxine shopping where to buy cheap generic albendazole arzomicin weight gain lowest price sarafem cheap gyne lotrimin free delivery get zoloft legal purchase cardura on line in the uk how to buy keftab online free or low cost super avana claritin gel capsules nizoral order on web xenical for purchase without a prescription overseas pharmacy no prescription cleocin abilify online canadian safe quetiapinum no precription how much does aldactone cost pyridium generic reviews trustedmedsnextday levitra professional generic equivalent rocaltrol pill shortage can i order lotrel online order adalat online no prescription money tamoxifen cough medicine buy diakof singapore how to buy doxi 1 in london ditropan from bupron sr usa sale fasigyne to buy from europe adalat from usa how to get motilium in australia lamictal vs depakote bipolar order trimox online no prescription with a mastercard buy sumycin online with mastercard safe order pills online differin phone orders suprax on line in the uk to buy cheap prednisone click here lipo weight loss injections side effects where can i get benadryl for dogs buy anacin online lipothin without prescription pills buy ivenox tablets usa olanzapine dosage recommended buy cheap plendil using pay pal cheap finasteride uk tadacip drug in fr pharmacy viagra without prescriptions uk canadian canadian online pharmacy for flonase can buy lasuna online what are diclofenac sodium enteric coated tablets used for pet rx canada buy alli diet pills canada decided side effects of metronidazole 500mg tablets health canada combivent hyzaar trusted online drug stores in canada pharmacy online uk erythromycin non prescription micardis pharmacy no prescription salbutamol sale is generic reminyl available in usa pharmacy has best price sominex duprost noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy lloyds pharmacy online uk purchasing mirapex online uk india compazine price how to take micronase mg buy levitra plus paypal alli generic wikipedia drugs nexium prescription herbal is dapoxetine a prescription drug use zenegra coupon online tesco pharmacy viagra prices keftab mg buy generic viagra soft tabs uk comprar key pred en argentina clincin max dose micronase ships from india zetia 2008 sales beat way to order zestoretic meclizine fda approved to buy without prescription buy antara with paypal mobic generic names next day cialis delivery uk baridium without insurance januvia birth control online canada otomax india no prescription bentyl dosage order lopid online in usa can i order grifulvin v no prescription in the usa vasotec rxlist buy asacol canada order no prescription buy deltasone pharmacy mexico online buy florinef online canada no prescription advair diskus australia companies only online arzomicin purchase flucazole from usa pharmacy onde comprar hoodia ciprofloxacin tinidazole dosage ortho cyclen discount no prescription get styplon toronto viagra holanda what is rogaine 5 made of anacin shortage canada indian version of viagra lipitor cheaper buy allium bulbs online drugs xenical discount cheap amaryllis for sale order orlistar online no presctiption ampicillin dose for uti in children ventolin overnight pharmacy purchase sinequan online buy bupron pills in the us buy dramamine online canada no prescription buy adhd medicine online buy motrin 80 mg online what does amaryllis smell like terramycin buy online us buy eulexin paypal accepted common serious side effects accutane disgrasil 120 mg lafrancol pantoprazole side effects weight loss can i order nizagara no prescription in the usa buy over the counter pariet online online albenda with no prescription cardura best online non prescription pharmacy neurontin online cheap can you take levitra daily women taking viagra reviews mometasona from australia where do i seroquel in canada is atarax over the counter approved pain pills for sale what does mirapex adalat blood pressure medication side effects levlen birth control pills side effects where to buy triamterene drugs online florida ondansetrona generic drug for nexium 40 mg purchase clozaril on line in canada how to order atomoxetin online buy lynoral mg can you buy viagra overseas is generic levitra professional available in usa side effects of tegretol cr 400 where to buy lasix online uk buy liposafe online overnight tadalis sx india sale generic viagra reviews forum pharmacy pill buy metronidazol with paypal florinef tablets for dogs tinidazole trusted online drug stores in canada vytorin drugs com number pharmacies sri lanka best place buy albendazole pct cheap celapram mg erectile dysfunction ayurvedic drugs in india colospan usage ciprofloxacina medication side effects oxybutyninum from canada with no prescription tizanidina to buy buy zestoretic with no script capoten drug schedule is albendazole good for dogs metoclopramide 100mg buy lantus reviews lov cost diltiazem metocarbamol over the counter india side effects of benicar blood pressure medication procardia uk buy revia cheap mexico pharmacy is generic snovitra super power available in usa safe place order seroquel acnetane drug in germany pharmacy wellbutrin buy canada order albenza no prescription side effects of voltaren pills asacol weight gain calan fast mexico very cheap prednisone purchasing roaccutane online order shuddha guggulu from mexico without prescription warafin with paypal payment seroquel 40 mg aciclovir daily use reviews buying amoxicilina in manchester to buy estro liposafe no prescription needed best site get tinidazolum dose of cefixime in enteric fever in adults prazosin medicine online no rx aristocort online motrin mg order how long does it take for bystolic to get out of your system how long does aspirin last on the shelf online meds from canada no prescription how can you get promethazine prescribed lopid over the counter drugs estearato eritromicina 500 mg purchasing uroxatral online uk lantus delivery uk compazine suppository frequency atacand discount medications acai sale stores much does propecia cost boots salvent women buy orlistato canada pharmacy grand court order calanthe ordering meclizine india viagra definition yahoo nexium in the uk now where fincar drugs similar to erection packs 3 how to buy erection packs 2 in london buy alli 60mg uk cost of ciprofloxacin in canada is generic beconase aq available in usa baclofen generic name best prices for zantac aricept uk nice caverta 100 mg reviews buy glucotrol have no prescription benadryl dose for dogs to sleep price of zoloft in canada orlistat dose information where could i buy sumycin without prescription zocor online uk brand advair diskus for sale venlor cheap uk health canada beconase aq noroxin dosage for uti caverta western australia support citizens united ruling sildenafil citrate no script can order dyazide canada buy clonidine without a script buy generic zestoretic with bonus zydis uk buy levitra plus legal us purchase xeloda online buy flomax greece lower prices on prescription drugs cvs pharmacy lexapro vs celexa cost buy stediril online from uk bupropion drugstore.com discount canadian pharmacy compazine olmesartan medoxomilo order avodart on line mexico find tamoxifen in florida buy cialis professional online thru paypals montelukast side effects depression azurette limited india buy sinequan mg nitrofurantoin uk online safe stieva a no precription alli with no rx levitra 5mg rezeptfrei where to buy combivent cheap alli mg where to buy cheap generic zithromax amlodipinbesilat no script oracea tablets where to get generic valtrex detrol dosage instructions buy cheap indocin side effects of long term use of alli sinemet cheap uk clonidine cheap us pharmacy no rx norvasc aloprim to buy in the canada without a prescription augmentin xr prices prednisolone overnight pharmacy buy prevacid tablets australia compare prices sominex wellbutrin sr generic canada buy combivent us zebeta pills online in the uk aygestin canada companies only purchase aldactone mg generic trileptal suspension cost of movalis without insurance aspirin suppositories buy buy lasilix greece meclizine online pharmacy shipped to canada cheapest xenical online diflucan thrush dosage order phenamax on line canada what is the correct dosage of allopurinol where can i buy dapoxetine hydrochloride ordering atorlip certain there elimite sale where to purchase stromectol indinavir weight gain how to import avalide cialis generic online order buy brand myambutol cheap diovan hct buy biaxin cheap generic drugs estro phone orders where can i buy astelin mg v gel canadian medications without prescription grapefruit and blood pressure medication ventolin online no prescription uk order aviane 28 on line usa buy procardia have no prescription what types of sildenafila are there buy leukeran have no prescription where to buy zertalin mg cialis generico brasil comprar bactrim cheap uk best generic prednisolone sites doxycycline dosage for anti malaria buy zithromax tablets online purchase retin a on line in uk generic minocin 100 mg cabgolin without rx minomycin to buy in the canada without a prescription discount levothyroid of canada keppra generic cost canada keftab tablets online kelnor dose mircette birth control online india buy generic zestoretic lozol canada pharmacy buy tricorn hat uk cheap clomifene sale uk health canada rhinocort malegra dxt lawsuit saw palmetto hair growth reviews how much does a viagra prescription cost fast zocor deleviery buy celebrex online pharmacy cytotec precio colombia medellin order tamoxifen online in usa cheapest voveran sr paypal lithium noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy fincar overnight shipping cheap big blue pill 3597 diclofenac gel shipping overseas estrace tablets uses buy brand cialis online without prescription allie brosh dead generic femcare cost ginette 35 medicine children vermox 30 day free trial frumil online no prescription yasmin canadian online wild ginseng prices illinois best place to buy probalan in usa buy flagyl online in the united states without a prescription lortab 7.5 high nymphomax australia can buy diarex online endep online overnight shipping crestor statins side effects silagra 100 md half price lady era western drug oracea non prescription fasigyne pharmacy crestor refills long term side effects of lansoprazol minocin generic usa finasteride side effects nhs digoxin sent to spain ordering cialis professional 20mg pharmacy betapace no prescription compare prices kytril woldwide shipping arava drug in canada pharmacy what does liv 52 contain kamagra now net approved buy generic beconase aq with bonus buy confido pills in the canada buy advair diskus online from usa tretinoin cream 0.1 reviews for acne ordering rogaine 5 india what is doxazosin tablets what is the correct dosage of yagara order dyazide uk pharmacy buy aristocort new zealand online plavix without insurance promethazine us companies only buy beconase aq online no prescription generic hydrodiuril cost duloxetine spc emc viagra paysafecard doxycycline antibiotic ear infections bactrim medicine online buy imovane online in usa prescription cabana online voveran sr online bestellen keflex for uti suppression sumycin canadian online pletal roche precio argentina fucidin without script best online pharmacy no prescription adderall viagra super active billig kaufen online raciper with no prescription metoclopramide no prescription compare prices what is cialis soft pills used for where to buy isoniazid online india combivent inhaler for sale how to by bactrim online depo medrol pills for dogs viagra sublingual doctors online comprar viagra farmacias ahumada buy female viagra quick cipro tablets 500mg geriforte syrup buy online ireland how to buy elocon in london can you get viagra from minute clinic how to take carafate suspension viagra para la mujer casero retin a 0,05 tablets online buy lynoral online pharmacy is baridium a prescription drug buy ditropan online no prescription us aceon medication where to buy how to buy sumycin online birth defects from zofran ashwagandha canada prescription imodium coupons 2012 over the counter buy order avapro what is wellbutrin prescribed for adhd aviane 28 online legally usa buy indocin without prescription pharmacy buy drugs estro metformin contraindications needed for now vardenafilum from china levothroid buy online canada fucidin tablets spc didronel for sale canada what is a therapeutic depakote level lov cost alesse buy robaxin online canada no prescription himalaya brahmi online buy antivert cheap discount on singulair the best over the counter viagra modafinil united pharmacies review how to use chloromycetin ointment order amoxicilina online no prescription with a echeck buy wellbutrin low cheap price toprol buy online australia tetracycline 500 mg dosage adalat order online no prescription billig zyban online kaufen ciplox mg order order clopidogrelum from uk without prescription buy crestor low cheap price where to buy alfa flucon without a prescription noroxin from usa ordering azurette licensed pharmacy doxycycline where to buy dostinex online mexico dipyridamole tablets for sale can i make tretinoin 0 025 buy etodolac mexican pharmacies brand cialis without a prescription buy cleocin online canada no prescription lopid canadian pharmacy trandate online uk where do i toprol xl in australia albuterol cycle length order generic mometasona pravachol generic canada buy finast astrailia how long does luvox stay in body best place to buy digoxin in australia can you buy viagra over the counter in thailand bayer levitra 20 raciper supplier in uk mirapex fast mexico strattera discount vouchers i want to pay some coumadin didronel meds no prescripion order generic pulmicort isoptin next day delivery viagra soft cost comparison online medrol overnight delivery cytotec 20mg tab list of muscle relaxant tablets brand albenda buy ordering lopressor uk revatio medication dosage prednisone dosepak dosage buy arzomicin online from uk effexor xr paypal asacol online ordering prazosin manufacturers india genuine maxalt 100mg clomid reviews for women is almetec legal in uk reviews on strattera for adults buy protonix have no prescription glyburide gestational diabetes 2012 zithromax without rx generic grifulvin v overnite shipping sinequan medicine children best place to buy maxalt in canada all types novo digoxin pills clomifene medicine children iui clomid success rates buy doxycycline in bangkok cialis professional without a script levitra generico vs original best otc erectile dysfunction drugs elocom online bestellen best price artane lansoprazol no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy buy erythromycin cream to buy finpecia in uk amlodipin mg canadian rx levlen generic wikipedia drugs order online no prescription cheap adalat purchase eltroxin in mexico brand name evista online where to buy predalone buy nexium online paypal brand levitra australia walgreens discount rx card viramune refills cheap minomycin 100 mg inhouse pharmacy uk reliable no prescription prednisone sale aripiprazola online in us coumadin dosage 10 mg meclizine cost per month non persciption abilify quibron t over the counter canada revista online moda bupropion to buy in the usa without a prescription zyloprim drug classification uk pharmacies online that sell prednisona what are the common side effects of abilify zetia drug in fr pharmacy periactin buy no prescription cvs pharmacy near ft meade cialis vs viagra 2008 prescription only medicines list how to buy brafix in canada ciprobay 1000mg best place to buy revatio online glucotrol xl overnight buy zofran online from india buy betnovate pills in the canada buy aciclovir tablets 400mg without perscription discount vermox online canadian canadian avodart viagra in delhi medical store buy ciplox online with no prescription alphagan uk online teva pfizer viagra canada indian generics online retin a gel 0,1 purchase aleve mg chloramphenicol direct pharmacy mevacor canada companies only negative side effects of wellbutrin sr evista 3days delivery micardis wholesale comprar diprosone portugal buy ketoconazole nizoral tablets where to buy motrin without a prescription what is cleocin 150 mg used for trandate sale picrolax suppliers overseas acheter pas cher ventolin diprosone on line in the usa generic albenza uk motrin no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy artane offshore pharmacy discount meclizine from usa where to buy bupron sr without a prescription generic amantadine no prescription generic microzide in usa what is the correct dosage of vytorin what is cozaar comp amoxil online forum normal cipro dose for uti where to buy legal drugs online where can i get tretinoin 0,05 over the counter medicine wellbutrin hoodia best price mexico pharmacies online that sell orlistar best viagra super active prices generic sumycin supplier in uk buy trial erection packs 1 online no prescription canada can you only get elocon on prescription what does clonidine do for opiate withdrawal keftab cost comparison overnight flomax code shipping overnight erection packs 16 can ortho tri cyclen side effects flagyl er online australia ordering ortho tri cyclen usa phentermine side effects in men doxycycline 100 mg acne viagra type products what are the side effects of sibutramine discount oratane from usa much does cialis daily use cost pharmacy where can you buy bite rx overseas pharmacy no prescription torsemide ordering duetact mexico fosamax germany cipla product list 2010 buy valtrex uk where can i order prednisone order caverta pill serevent weight gain buy benicar canada where do i disulphiram in australia where can i buy exelon online without a prescription astelin cost comparison where to buy parlodel fenazopiridina helicobacter pylori ciproxin suspension auriculaire cheap canadian omnicef no prescription side effects of coumadin therapy russian pharmacy online store celebrex medicine purchase generic doxazosin non prescription lipothin pharmacy atarax hydroxyzine hydrochloride zocor shopping celexa vs paxil weight gain order citalopram on line usa micardis 100mg buy erythromycin pregnancy safe best price for real femcare tizanidinum from usa elimite delivery uk depakote online in us comprar snovitra super power portugal how to take trial erection packs 1 mg hydrochlorothiazide online without rx pill rx health order eldepryl products where to buy hydroxyzine methotrexate pharmaceutical company buy atorlip 20 boots pharmacy mavi umut anaokulu veliefendi side effects of meclizine hci generic zetia buy canada
Home BoB Documents National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 414 guests online

Atom RSS

National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 43
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Judge Sonia Sotomayor   
Wednesday, 27 May 2009 01:38

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

No. 1999 August Term, 1994

(Argued: May 11, 1995) Decided: September 29, 1995

Docket No. 95-6048

------------------------------------------

DANIEL SILVERMAN, Regional Director

for Region 2 of the National Labor

Relations Board, for and on behalf

of the National Labor Relations Board,

Petitioner-Appellee ,

v.

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYER RELATIONS

COMMITTEE, INC. and THE CONSTITUENT MEMBER

CLUBS OF MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL,

Respondents-Appellants .

------------------------------------------

B e f o r e: NEWMAN, Chief Judge , WINTER, and MAHONEY, Circuit

Judges .

Appeal from an order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (Sonia Sotomayor, Judge ) enjoining appellants to restore the terms and conditions of employment provided under an expired collective bargaining agreement. We affirm.

DOUGLAS L. LESLIE, Charlottesville, Virginia (Lisa Klein Wager, Francis L. Casey, III, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, New York, New York, of counsel), for Respondents-Appellants .

ELLEN A. FARRELL, Assistant General Counsel (Frederick L. Feinstein, General Counsel, Mary Joyce Carlson, Assistant General Counsel, Robert E. Allen, Associate General Counsel, Donald B. Zavelo, Ian M. Penny, of counsel, National Labor Relations Board, Washington, D.C.), for Petitioner-Appellee .

GEORGE M. COHEN (Virginia A. Seitz, Bredhoff & Kaiser, Washington, D.C., of counsel), for Amicus Curiae Major League Baseball Players Association .

WINTER, Circuit Judge :

This is an appeal by the Major League Baseball Player Relations Committee, Inc. ("PRC") and the constituent member clubs of Major League Baseball ("Clubs") from a temporary injunction issued by Judge Sotomayor pursuant to section 10(j) of the National Labor Relations Act ("NLRA"), 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). The PRC is the collective bargaining representative for the twenty-eight Clubs. The Major League Baseball Players Association is a union that is the exclusive bargaining representative for the forty-man rosters of each major league club. The injunction is based on the district court's conclusion that appellants violated NLRA §§ 8(a)(1) and (5), 29 U.S.C. §§ 158(a)(1) and (5), by unilaterally implementing terms and conditions of employment that differed from those in the last collective agreement. It orders the PRC and the Clubs to: (i) abide by the terms of an expired collective agreement, (ii) rescind any actions taken that are inconsistent with that agreement and (iii) bargain in good faith with the Players Association. See Silverman v. Major League Baseball Player Relations Comm., Inc. , 880 F. Supp. 246, 261 (S.D.N.Y. 1995). The injunction is to remain in effect until either (i) the expired agreement is replaced by a new collective bargaining agreement, (ii) the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") renders a final disposition of the matters pending before it in the related administrative case, or (iii) the district court finds, upon petition of either of the parties, that an impasse has occurred. See id. We affirm.

BACKGROUND

On January 1, 1990, the most recent collective agreement ("Basic Agreement") between appellants and the Players Association became effective. It contained provisions implementing a combination of free agency and a reserve system -- that is, a compromise between free competitive bidding for a player's services and an individual club's exclusive rights to those services.

Free agency, in its purest form, is a status in which the rights to a player's athletic services are not owned by a club and may be shopped around by the player in a quest for the most attractive bid. However, for more than a century, Major League Baseball has had a reserve system that to one degree or another affords individual clubs exclusive property rights to the athletic services of certain players. Before the players were organized and a collective bargaining relationship was established, the standard players contract with a club reserved to the club exclusive rights to a player's services and provided for an annual right of renewal of the contract by the club in question. The Clubs interpreted the contract as allowing the club in question to renew all of an individual player's contract, including the right of renewal provision. So interpreted, this provision -- known generally as the "reserve clause" -- bound a player to one club in perpetuity until traded or released. After the Clubs recognized the Players Association and entered into a collective agreement with it, an arbitrator held in a grievance proceeding that the reserve clause allowed a renewal for only one year rather than a succession of years. See National & American League Professional Baseball Clubs v. Major League Baseball Players Ass'n , 66 Lab. Arb. (BNA) 101 (1976) (Seitz, Arb.). Since then, appellants and the Players Association have struggled to accommodate their conflicting interests in the free agency and reserve issues, and a variety of compromises have from time to time been reached. However, relations have been acrimonious, and several strikes and lockouts have occurred. This appeal itself arises out of a strike that terminated the 1994 season before the playoffs and World Series.

Article XX of the Basic Agreement that became effective in 1990 contains a series of provisions that govern free agency and reserve rights. Players with six or more years of major league service are free agents and may seek competing bids in an effort to obtain the best contract, which may of course give exclusive rights to the club for a stipulated number of years. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 250. Free agency is guaranteed by an anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F), which prohibits the Clubs from acting in concert with each other with respect to the exercise of rights under Article XX. See id. Article XX(F) thus prevents the Clubs from agreeing either to refuse to bid for the services of free agents or to offer only low bids to them. Article XX(F) also prohibits players from acting in concert with regard to Article XX rights. See id.

Players with less than six years of service remain under reserve to their individual clubs, although a club may reserve a player only once. Although a minimum annual salary is provided, players with less than three years of major league service must negotiate with their clubs to determine their salary for the coming season. Article XX allows certain reserved players -- generally those with more than three but less than six years of service -- to demand salary arbitration. See id. at 251. Salary arbitration is a mechanism for determining the individual salaries for that group of reserved players if they cannot arrive at an agreement with their clubs. The player and the club each present the arbitrator with a suggested salary figure for a new one-year contract. The arbitrator then inserts either the player's or the club's figure into a blank uniform contract that the parties have already signed. See id. Article VI(F)(12) provides the following with regard to the criteria to be used, and the evidence to be heard, by the arbitrator:

(12) Criteria . (a) The Criteria will be the quality of the Player's contribution to his Club during the past season (including but not limited to his overall performance, special qualities of leadership and public appeal), the length and consistency of his career contribution, the record of the Player's past compensation, comparative baseball salaries . . . , the existence of any physical or mental defects on the part of the Player, and the recent performance record of the Club including but not limited to its League standing and attendance as an indication of public acceptance (subject to the exclusion stated in subparagraph(b)(i) below). Any evidence may be submitted which is relevant to the above criteria, and the arbitrator shall assign such weight to the evidence as shall to him appear appropriate under the circumstances. The arbitrator shall, except for a Player with five or more years of Major League service, give particular attention, for comparative salary purposes, to the contracts of Players with Major League service not exceeding one annual service group above the Player's annual service group. This shall not limit the ability of a Player or his representative, because of special accomplishment, to argue the equal relevance of salaries of Players without regard to service, and the arbitrator shall give whatever weight to such argument as he deems appropriate.

 

(b) Evidence of the following shall not be admissible:

(i) The financial position of the Player and the Club;

(ii) Press comments, testimonials or similar material bearing on the performance of either the Player or the Club, except that recognized annual Player awards for playing excellence shall not be excluded;

(iii) Offers made by either Player or Club prior to arbitration;

 

(iv) The cost to the parties of their representatives, attorneys, etc.;

 

(v) Salaries in other sports or occupations.

The Basic Agreement expired on December 31, 1993, pursuant to the PRC's notice of termination. Although negotiations for a successor agreement did not get underway until March 1994, the PRC and the Players Association continued to observe the terms of the expired Basic Agreement. Prior to the commencement of negotiations, the Clubs and the Players Association had completed individual salary arbitration hearings and had entered into individual player contracts for the 1994 baseball season, which began in April 1994. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 251.

Negotiations for a new collective bargaining agreement continued unsuccessfully. The PRC offered its first formal economic proposal to the Players Association at a meeting on June 14, 1994. It included a "salary cap," a mechanism that establishes a ceiling on the total player salaries paid by each club. The ceiling may allow some flexibility, depending on the details. Generally, the aggregate salaries of each team are determined by an agreed upon formula and must remain above a minimum percentage of industry revenues, also determined by an agreed upon formula, but below a maximum percentage of those revenues. See Wood v. National Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954, 957 (2d Cir. 1987). The PRC proposal also eliminated the salary arbitration system and substituted restricted free agency rights for those reserved players previously eligible for salary arbitration. As an alternative to the PRC's proposed salary cap, the Players Association suggested a revenue sharing and luxury "tax" plan that would impose a tax on high-paying clubs. Subsequent proposals reflected disagreement over appropriate tax rates and payroll thresholds above which clubs would be subject to the tax. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 251-52.

The players struck on August 12, and the 1994 baseball season never resumed. On December 22, 1994, the PRC declared an impasse in negotiations and stated that it intended unilaterally to impose a salary cap and to implement other changes in the terms and conditions of employment, including the elimination of salary arbitration. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 252. The Players Association responded with a unilateral ban on players signing individual contracts with the Clubs.

Thereafter, cross-charges of unfair labor practices were filed with the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") by the Players Association and the Clubs. The Players Association alleged that the Clubs had engaged in unfair labor practices by unilaterally implementing the salary cap and other terms because the parties were not at an impasse.

On February 3, 1995, counsel for the PRC notified the NLRB General Counsel that the PRC would revoke the implementation of unilateral changes and restore the status quo ante. The General Counsel indicated that the Players Association charges would be dismissed as a result. Counsel for the PRC informed the General Counsel, however, that the PRC did not believe itself obligated to maintain provisions of the Basic Agreement that involved non-mandatory subjects of bargaining. He mentioned salary arbitration in that regard and also suggested that the Clubs might decide to bargain exclusively through the PRC. The NLRB General Counsel declined to offer an advisory opinion on these matters.

Three days later, by memorandum dated February 6, counsel for the PRC notified the Clubs that, until a new collective bargaining agreement was ratified or until further notice, individual clubs had no authority to negotiate contracts with individual players because the PRC was now the Clubs' exclusive bargaining representative. This amounted to an agreement among the Clubs not to hire free agents and thus was a departure from the anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F) of the Basic Agreement. It also amounted to an elimination of salary arbitration, because salary arbitration is a method of arriving at a wage for an individual player contract with a club.

The Players Association thereupon filed a new unfair labor practice charge, and the General Counsel issued a complaint alleging, inter alia , that the Clubs and the PRC had violated Sections 8(a)(1) and (5) of the NLRA by unilaterally eliminating, before an impasse had been reached, competitive bidding for the services of free agents, the anti-collusion provision, and salary arbitration for certain reserved players. The NLRB found that these matters were related to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment and were therefore mandatory subjects for collective bargaining. It then authorized its General Counsel to seek an injunction under NLRA §10(j). On March 27, the NLRB Regional Director filed a petition seeking a temporary injunction restraining the alleged unfair labor practices.

The district court agreed that the NLRB had reasonable cause to conclude that free agency and salary arbitration were mandatory subjects of bargaining and that the Clubs' unilateral actions constituted an unfair labor practice. The district court also concluded that injunctive relief was warranted. This appeal followed. We denied a stay on April 4.

DISCUSSION

The NLRB is authorized under Section 10(j) of the NLRA to petition for temporary injunctive relief from a district court to enjoin ongoing unfair labor practices. 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). If the court has reasonable cause to believe that an unfair labor practice has occurred and that injunctive relief would be just and proper, it should grant appropriate relief. Kaynard v. MMIC, Inc. , 734 F.2d 950, 953 (2d Cir. 1984). The court need not make a final determination that the conduct in question is an unfair labor practice. Kaynard v. Mego Corp. , 633 F.2d 1026, 1033 (2d Cir. 1980). It need find only reasonable cause to support such a conclusion. See id. ; MMIC , 734 F.2d at 953. Appropriate deference must be shown to the judgment of the NLRB, and a district court should decline to grant relief only if convinced that the NLRB's legal or factual theories are fatally flawed. See Mego , 633 F.2d at 1031, 1033; Kaynard v. Palby Lingerie, Inc. , 625 F.2d 1047, 1051 (2d Cir. 1980). In reviewing a district court's grant of injunctive relief pursuant to Section 10(j), a court of appeals must also accord deference to the district court's decision, at least with regard to those aspects that are traditionally left to the district court's discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030.

We turn now to the merits of the regional director's petition. The petition invokes basic principles of labor law. Section 8(d) of the NLRA mandates that employers and unions bargain in good faith over "wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment." 29 U.S.C. § 158(d). These are so-called mandatory subjects of bargaining. Under caselaw, the parties may propose and bargain over, but may not insist upon, permissive subjects of bargaining. NLRB v. Wooster Div. of Borg-Warner Corp. , 356 U.S. 342, 349 (1958). When a collective agreement expires, an employer may not alter terms and conditions of employment involving mandatory subjects until it has bargained to an impasse over new terms. NLRB v. Katz , 369 U.S. 736, 741-43 (1962). Thereafter, it may implement the new terms. Generally, when an agreement expires, an employer need not bargain to an impasse over terms and conditions involving permissive subjects but may alter them upon expiration. Allied Chem. & Alkali Workers v. Pittsburgh Plate Glass Co. , 404 U.S. 157, 187-88 (1971).

Many of the usual issues that arise in impasse cases are not disputed in the instant matter. The parties agree that the PRC, in directing the Clubs to decline to bargain individually with free agents, unilaterally departed from much of Article XX, which provides for a limited form of free agency and forbids collusive behavior by the Clubs in negotiating with free agents. It is also undisputed that the PRC unilaterally departed from the Basic Agreement's provisions with regard to salary arbitration. The PRC does not claim that it had bargained to an impasse over the free agency, the anti-collusion, or the salary arbitration provisions. Finally, it is also agreed that, if those provisions involved mandatory subjects of bargaining, their unilateral abrogation before impasse was a refusal to bargain in good faith. The PRC and the Clubs argue that the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement do not involve mandatory subjects of bargaining and are therefore not subject to the Katz rule that unilateral implementation of new terms is an unfair labor practice unless the employer has bargained to an impasse over these new terms. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 254. The PRC and the Clubs contend that an injunction compelling them to maintain the free agency and anti-collusion provisions undermines their right as a multiemployer group to bargain collectively through an exclusive representative. If so, they would be permissive subjects of bargaining. See Borg Warner , 356 U.S. at 349 . With regard to salary arbitration, the PRC and the Clubs argue that it is the equivalent of interest arbitration -- arbitration of the terms of a new collective agreement -- and thus not a mandatory subject of bargaining. See International Bhd. of Elec. Workers (Collier Elec. Co.) , 296 N.L.R.B. 1095, 1098 (1989).

We are unpersuaded that an injunction compelling the PRC and the Clubs to observe the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement infringes on their right as a multiemployer group to bargain through an exclusive representative. Free agency and the ban on collusion are one part of a complex method -- agreed upon in collective bargaining -- by which each major league player's salary is determined under the Basic Agreement. They are analogous to the use of seniority, hours of work, merit increases, or piece work to determine salaries in an industrial context. The PRC and the Clubs describe free agency and the ban on collusion as provisions undermining their right to select a joint bargaining representative because those provisions entail individual contracts with clubs. However, the argument ignores the fact that free agency is simply a collectively bargained method of determining individual salaries for one group of players. The anti-collusion provision is not designed to prevent the PRC from representing the Clubs. Rather, that provision guarantees that free agency will be a reality when permitted by the Basic Agreement. The injunction thus does not in any way prevent the PRC from bargaining as the Clubs' exclusive representative with the Players Association over the elimination of free agency in its entirety or for a modified version of the same, and thereafter from implementing any proposals incorporated into a collective bargaining agreement.

The question, therefore, is whether the free agency, anti-collusion, and reserve issues are -- or there is reasonable cause to believe they are -- otherwise mandatory subjects of bargaining. Section 8(d) of the NLRA defines the duty to bargain as "the obligation . . . to meet . . . and confer in good faith with respect to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment . . . ." In Wood v. Nat'l Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954 (2d Cir. 1987), we noted that free agency and reserve issues are "at the center of collective bargaining in much of the professional sports industry," id. at 961, and that "it is precisely because of [free agency's] direct relationship to wages and conditions of employment that [it is] so controversial and so much the focus of bargaining in professional sports." Id. at 962.

Wood noted that collective bargaining between professional athletes and leagues raises "numerous problems with little or no precedent in standard industrial relations." Id. at 961. Such is the case with a free agency and reserve system. For the most part, unionized employees in the industrial sector may leave one employer for another without restriction. The employee may have no bargaining rights with regard to the terms of hire by the new employer, which may be set by a collective agreement, but is nevertheless generally free to go from one unionized job to another. [1]  

The professional sports industry has a very different history and very different economic imperatives. Most professional sports leagues have always had some form of what has become known as the reserve system. See Flood v. Kuhn , 407 U.S. 258, 259 n.1 (1972) (baseball); Robertson v. National Basketball Ass'n , 556 F.2d 682, 686 n.6 (2d Cir. 1977) (basketball); Mackey v. National Football League , 543 F.2d 606, 610 (8th Cir. 1976) (football), cert. dismissed , 434 U.S. 801 (1977); McCourt v. California Sports, Inc. , 600 F.2d 1193, 1194 (6th Cir. 1979) (hockey). As noted, this is a system by which the right to a player's services becomes the property of a particular club with limited freedom for the player to seek employment with another club. The reserve system in one form or another has been used in major league baseball for over a century. Until the arbitration decision in 1976, the reserve system prevented players from offering their athletic services to competing teams. A player's services were thus the property of a single team until he was traded or released. In enforcing a complete reserve system, Major League Baseball was exercising monopsony power -- a buyer's monopoly.

However, there are many reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues from players to clubs, why reserve systems exist within professional sports. Fans might not be interested in games between teams that had entirely new lineups for every contest. Moreover, high quality play may require that individuals practice and play with the same teammates for at least some period of time. Teams may also want to recoup what they regard as training costs invested in players while they gained experience. In antitrust litigation, the leagues perennially argue that some form of reserve system is necessary for competitive balance. See Mackey , 543 F.2d at 611. Indeed, even in a system of complete free agency, one would expect to see many long-term agreements binding individual players to particular clubs.

There are also reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues to players, why a union of professional athletes would seek free agency. It is very difficult to set individual salaries in professional sports through collective bargaining. Although unions of professional athletes may bargain for uniform benefits and minimum salaries, they do not usually follow their industrial counterparts and seek relatively fixed salaries by job description, seniority, or other formulae. Players often play positions requiring very different skills. Moreover, the level of performance and value to a team in attracting fans differs radically among players, with star athletes or popular players being far more valuable than sub-par or nondescript players. Usually, therefore, players unions seek some form of free agency as a relatively simple method of setting individual salaries.

Most importantly, however, both the leagues and the players unions view free agency and reserve issues as questions of what share of revenues go to the clubs or to the players. The more restrictive the reserve system is, the greater the clubs' share. The greater the role of free agency, the greater the players' share.

To hold that there is no reasonable cause for the NLRB to conclude that free agency and reserve issues are mandatory subjects of bargaining would be virtually to ignore the history and economic imperatives of collective bargaining in professional sports. A mix of free agency and reserve clauses combined with other provisions is the universal method by which leagues and players unions set individual salaries in professional sports. Free agency for veteran players may thus be combined with a reserve system, as in baseball, or a rookie draft, as in basketball, see Wood , 809 F.2d at 957, for newer players. A salary cap may or may not be included. See id. To hold that any of these items, or others that make up the mix in a particular sport, is merely a permissive subject of bargaining would ignore the reality of collective bargaining in sports.

Indeed, free agency is in many ways nothing but the flip side of the reserve system. A full reserve system does not eliminate individual bargaining between teams and players. It simply limits that bargaining to one team. If free agency were a permissive subject of collective bargaining, then so would be the reserve system.

With regard to salary arbitration, we will assume, but not decide, that if it is a form of interest arbitration, it may be unilaterally eliminated. See George Koch & Sons, Inc. , 306 N.L.R.B. 834, 839 (1992) (interest arbitration permissive subject of bargaining). Interest arbitration is a method by which an employer and union reach new agreements by sending disputed issues to an arbitrator rather than settling them through collective bargaining and economic force. See New York Typographical Union No. 6 v. Printers League , 919 F.2d 3 n.2 (2d Cir. 1990). The salary arbitration provisions of the Basic Agreement are a method by which salaries for some players who are not eligible for free agency -- those with three to six years of major league service -- are set. The Basic Agreement sets forth criteria by which the arbitrator is to reach a decision. These criteria include the player's performance in the prior year, the length and consistency of career contribution, physical or mental defects, recent performance of the team on the field and at the gate, and salaries of certain comparable players. The Basic Agreement also forbids the arbitrator from considering certain facts that might otherwise be relevant. Finally, the Basic Agreement requires that the arbitrator pick either the club's suggested salary or the player's.

We decline to analogize Article VI(f) of the Basic Agreement to interest arbitration. Salary arbitration provides limited discretion to the arbitrator to set salaries for designated players who are not eligible for free agency. The discretion afforded the arbitrator is arguably less than the discretion afforded arbitrators in grievance arbitration involving disputes arising under an existing collective agreement, which is beyond question a mandatory subject of bargaining. In grievance arbitration, an arbitrator may permissibly imply a term even though the term has no explicit support in the text of the collective agreement. See United Steelworkers of America v. Warrior & Gulf Navigation Co. , 363 U.S. 574, 581-82 (1960) ("The labor arbitrator's source of law is not confined to the express provisions of the contract, as the industrial common law -- the practices of the industry and the shop -- is equally a part of the collective bargaining agreement although not expressed in it."); see also Holly Sugar Corp. v. Distillery, Rectifying, Wine & Allied Workers Int'l Union , 412 F.2d 899, 903 (9th Cir. 1969). Similarly, a term may be implied from past practices even though somewhat inconsistent with the agreement. See International Chem. Workers Union, Local No. 278 v. Imco Container Co. , 78 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2014 (S.D. Ind. 1971). We thus decline to analogize salary arbitration to interest arbitration, and, therefore, we hold that there is reasonable cause to believe that it is a mandatory subject of bargaining.

With regard to whether the granting of relief was "just and proper," 29 U.S.C. § 160(j), we review the district court's determination only for abuse of discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030; Palby Lingerie , 625 F.2d at 1051. We see no such abuse in the present matter. Given the short careers of professional athletes and the deterioration of physical abilities through aging, the irreparable harm requirement has been met. The unilateral elimination of free agency and salary arbitration followed by just three days a promise to restore the status quo. The PRC decided to settle the original unfair labor practice charges while embarking on a course of action based on a fallacious view of the duty to bargain. We see no reason to relieve it of the consequences of that course.

We therefore affirm.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?