abilify sales us best place buy prevacid order alli online no prescription with a echeck how to get lipitor pariet mg mexico delivery without buy abilify florinef buy online us alfa flucon uk sale biaxin drug class buy casodex boots pharmacy aldactone buy online uk womenra sildenafil citrate paroxetine to buy in australia benfotiamine best price flucazole tablets side effects best online pharmacy generic parlodel ventolin inhalers sale uk guaranteed get sominex las vegas buy zenegra online no prescription uk amitriptyline 150 mg side effects can you order lanoxin buy cymbalta 10 hyzaar uk sale best place to buy pariet in canada hytrin uk next day delivery cheap evista usa buy beconase aq tablets uk why has chloroquine been discontinued zanaflex tablets purchase on line zyvox drug classification flonase shortage padre chelo fundacion buy floxin pills in the india bystolic online uk tegretol costco cytotec abortion pill price arava tablets on line to buy lipothin for dogs buy valtrex prescription only where can i buy furosemide lasix serpina uk no prescription adalat crono costo mexican pharmacy no prescription aleve orlistatum india companies only allegra tablets us online healthy mango bread triamterenum side effects uk zenegra medication side effects buy brand levitra australia liv 52 en mexico buy avapro 50 requip supplies ltd buy himplasia online amazon what is meclizine hcl bisoprololi fumaras canada head office buy 50 mg viagra lowest price for arimidex is there a generic for medrol buy cozaar 50mg online isoniazid side effects weight gain over the counter medicine l thyroxine where can i buy exelon tablets pharmacy rx one legit eltroxin online india generic wellbutrin sr bupropion aciclovir pills buy himcocid best online non prescription pharmacy overnight free consultation buy astelin ordering albuterol on line buy bupron sr tablets asacol online without rx diarex brand pills for sale silagra 25 mg price american tricor patient reviews on cipro emoquette from australia where can i get erexin v from cheap haldol india skyrim hearthfire how to buy livestock chloroquine to buy in england billig dramamine online kaufen female cialis on line in the usa comprar biaxin portugal buy augmentin tablets canada mail order generic stromectol who makes generic lipitor nootropil on line in the usa diflucan price in india requip 40 mg dose sleep anxiety in children benicar cheap uk cheap generic chloroquine order 1 pharmacy adalat online can you get colospa claravis for purchase without a prescription fast rosuvastatin delivery zyloprim without script order orlistat on line usa duloxetine side effects uk reglan drugs for sale buy alesse birth control online generic billig casodex online kaufen worldwide pharmacy deltasone diprosone online legally metronidazole gel contraindications buy xenical online south africa suppliers of alesse in us skelaxin over the counter where to buy cheap generic penegra medicine allied health praziquantel side effects in horses generic voltaren usa billig trial erection packs 2 online kaufen zertalin cheap canada pharmacy aripiprazola where can i buy what is zantac relief cyproheptadine 4mg female viagra mail order bactrim over counter uk alfa flucon order online novo digoxin canada pharmacy long term side effects of sertralina adalat where to purchase femara fast usa kamagra chewable cost sarafem user reviews what does flovent treat no rx viagra buy suprax online in the united states without a prescription generic orlistat 120mg erythromycin without prescriptio generic uk paypal clozaril ginseng over the counter india ordering shuddha guggulu india oratane on line in the mexico flomax dosage medication clonidine 0.1 mg trimox comprare tramadol overdose seizure bystolic pharmacy online meclizine tablets price salvent generic india prednisone canada overnight delivery prednisone 10 mg tablet wat zebeta tablets price diflucan over the counter alternative buy doxycycline capsules order lamisil cream lasix reviews and dosage cipro for sale uk indian pharmacy stediril legal viagra australia reviews on estrace cream worldwide pharmacy ampicillin knee arthritis treatment injections buy zithromax online sno prescription uk anastrozolo side effects uk predalone without insurance ordering low dose kytril buy pravachol tablets australia half price serophene buy betoptic hong kong apo furosemida online in uk what is ciprofloxacin hcl 500 used for como comprar diflucan advair diskus drugs online purchases zoloft usa erection packs 2 medication side effects mifeprex and misoprostol online kamagra dosage recommended buy mircette online from australia no prescription amoxycillin sale lexapro drugs similar to atacand hct 16 mg generico robaxin shop net liv 52 discount voucher can you buy protonix over the counter indocin uk online where do i accutane in canada zedd next day cheap pharma greens nootropil user reviews buy isoptin paypal remeron 100mg cheap isotretinoin 40 mg canada can order myambutol canada buy genuine olanzapine uk indian viagra tablets names lioresal for dogs buy medrol gonflement visage is keppra generic plavix canada overnight delivery meclizine 12.5 mg price voltaren not generic no prescription caverta sale endep medicine children generic uk approved viagra pharmacy buy drugs ciplox colospa shop net benzac canada prescription what is calan bosch like buspar dosage for children purchase norvasc mg zaditor generic 2013 drugs can i take zyrtec 10mg twice a day order zyvox from mexico without prescription lexapro maximum daily dosage no prescription cipro sale can you get fluss 40 cheap diflucan free delivery purchase oestrogel in mexico online pharmacy levoxyl best place to buy torsemide in uk disgrasil 120 mg buy differin 3 online generic casodex price sinequan now ondansetron odt 8 mg price is there a generic drug for lamisil online plendil with no prescription uk buy altace online generic where to buy cleocin gel online india isoptin pills sweat discount drugs inc glucotrol xl over the counter drugs half price malegra fxt zitromax coupon code purchase liposafe cheap buy requip tablets canada buy colchicine online pharmacy order detrol on line mexico atarax cheap mexico pharmacy metformin maximum safe dose order diprosone uk pharmacy claravis prices purchase otomax on line in uk buy generic lotensin online with prescription buy indocin online india maximum levothyroxine dosage best non prescription pills to get you high permethrinum uk buy coumadin blood thinner medication antivert in the uk now where to buy pct serm purchase iv benadryl online pharmacy cabgolin buy alavert pills in the mexico toradol pills online in the canada bonnispaz ships from india where to buy evista with visa generic brand viagra uk cheap viagra perth where to buy voltaren gel 1 billig isoniazid online kaufen cost of citalopram walgreens free alli diet plan floxin eye drops top 10 online beta val sites half inderal la 80 mg anxiety how to by zyprexa online what is calcium carbonate used for hoodia fast india indian generics online keppra quickest silagra hong kong buy mesalamine asacol mg order actos online type diabetes zovirax 5 cream generic cheap sepibest mg where to buy disulphiram online canada viagra jelly sale 100mg discount size of bactrim pills biaxin reviews and dosage allopurinol online in us what types of toradol are there azithromycin z pack breastfeeding what drug category is venlor order plavix usa female cialis overseas phone in order for percocet uk version of doxazosin ditropan generic canada paroxetine buy mexico order non generic erythromycin geriforte without a prescription from uk cialis professional with no rx colchicina pills buy online generic zestoretic dramamine dose for 3 year old comprar salbumol portugal buy generic snovitra super power how to get pilex on line over the counter medicine tretinoin 0,025 order generic vistaril where can i get tadalis pills purchase citalopram in india starlix without a prescription amitriptyline medication cats realo discount drugs new bern how to buy oxybutyninum in canada generic robaxin images where do i mevacor in canada buy flovent tablets uk generic finax buy canada levitra for sale philippines is plavix generic drug aldactone for sale in the uk nolvadex overnight pharmacy vistaril australia pharmacy med cab ampicilina desyrel cheap mexico pharmacy vytorin medication use prescriptions in australia generic buy viagra online how to get minocin in australia generic serevent us serpina online from india colospa generic mexico canada buy trial erection packs 1 without prescription purchase omnicef on line in mexico generic pills for glucovance libido edge labs testosterone cream for women rhinocort aqua best price bupron sr overnight where to buy hoodia with mastercard health canada calcium carbonate where to buy fucidin drugs online uk pharmacies online that sell celebrex online lisinopril purchase can you crush zithromax tablets pharmacy that sells snovitra super power acai berry site coupons zydis without a prescription from india generic cleocin cost buy demadex australia where to buy nizagara online india hotel villa carparis cipro azurette buy online australia floxin mexico flonase online order famciclovir price canada generic purinethol usa pharmacy comprar kamagra en mano en madrid lotrisone without a perscription viagra cheap india pharmacy prednisolone for dogs itching buy decadron with no rx is flagyl available over the counter metrogel india pharmacy purchase generic adalat erectile dysfunction viagra doesnt help reviews on carvedilolo 100 mg nolvadex zoloft canada drugs how to use yagara diclofenac 40mg terramycin supplier in uk aygestin lowest price online raciper cheap canada pharmacy how much will penegra cost penegra can you buy unique hoodia at walmart glucophage tablets for sale clomid with paypal payment advair diskus order nootropil usa cvs prices micronase to buy in england viagra prescription only approved pharmacy tadalis india companies only getting minocycline in australia nordette cheap uk pharmacy best place to order zyban in us legal to buy advair diskus mometasona buy online mexico cialis soft phone orders periactin buy canada eltroxin shoppers drug mart to buy ivenox in uk canada post shoppers drug mart hours calgary cheap generic benemid clomifene shelf life benadryl after delivery retin a ge side effects long term use order zestoretic online no prescription with a echeck feldene order on web no prescription rumalaya forte sale ivenox with paypal payment differin 0.3 on sale buy raloxifeno in india online discount brand viagra from usa cialis jelly pills buy no prescription serpina sale newsletter viagra glucotrol reviews for men purchase cardizem pills buy levothroid online with no prescription ordering compazine here in canada prometrium drugstore.com order non generic vantin buy ranitidine online without a prescription arimidex tablets 1mg levitra ed medication oristal no rx vasotec mg canada buy brahmi 15mg online zanaflex uk buy buy nizagara patch generic cialis 10 mg depakine chrono pill shortage generic paroxetine manufacturers viagra plus cheap uk pharmacy ciprofloksacin from canada without rx zestoretic pills online in the australia isoptin drug in canada pharmacy amitriptyline discount voucher generika viagra per nachnahme fast tamsulozin deleviery vagifem no rx actoplus met buy online uk seroflo usa no prescription sepibest without a prescription from uk vet vipps approved pharmacy brand prednisolone buy propecia 5mg buy generic for valtrex cost cheap brahmi pills over the counter calcium carbonate motilium dosage suspension oristal usa requip magic zoloft how to buy buy fluss 40 tablets uk order etodolac from australia without prescription can order rythmol sr online purchase metformin motrin pill shortage how to by cialis super active online purchase cialis in us viagra without prescriptions illegal pure hoodia gordonii diet pills generic name for shatavari side effects of nitrofurantoin monohydrate zydis without prescrip where can i purchase arava acquistare lotensin in italia ayurslim without prescription medication aricept pill shop discount code colospa no prescription overnight delivery reviews on children claritin how to counteract sexual side effects of lexapro 7 compare the generic names of prevacid and nexium bentyl cheapest rate etabus drug in usa pharmacy c ratioph noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy max mendelsohn buy cheap cytotec pills what types of zoloft are there tamsulozin india sale geriforte syrup prices oder mg tablets of mentax digoxin from uk himplasia uk buy antabuse order online no prescription how to by prandin online probalan canada prescription benzac over counter where purchase lynoral buy astelin greece buy zoloft tablets us us pharmacies online that sell dapoxetine cheap luvox free delivery trial erection packs 1 cheap uk pharmacy what is prescription lamisil for buy ralista in uk generic acnetane uk testosterone therapy for men cons exelon careers sign in phenamax pills online in the australia what is diprolene tablets ayurslim on line in the india florida renagel red ginseng cost where to buy aripiprazola online mexico predalone tablets uses ventolin evohaler price malaysia acivir pills usa cvs prices hydrodiuril sold over counter bupropion no prescription compare prices buy maxaman boots prevacid discount prices where to buy januvia in canada safely brand name lopressor online do people abuse skelaxin purchasing ciplox online 100 mg revatio actonel paypal how to get tretinoin 0 05 on line astelin online forum viagra reviews testimonials order levothyroxin on line usa order cafergot 1mg canada cheap actos 100 mg buy cheap diet pills online acheter cefixime pas cher order brand amoxil from australia without prescription will viagra ever otc buy triamterene without prescription order ephedraxin without rx buy prescriptions online cheaper where to buy revia with mastercard norvasc looking for prandin to purchase without a prescription purchase tricor on line in the uk buying tizanidina using paypal un rey en la habana online gratis augmentin 500mg 125mg film coated tablets klipal codeine trusted online drug stores in canada buy trazodone tablets anteovin generic canada there generic pill valtrex asacol online canada prednisone drug schedule generic renagel india what type of medication is bystolic what is prednisone steroid used for trimox new zealand amoxil online sales buy snovitra super power have no prescription what is arimidex anastrozole steroids skelaxin looking for no prescription proventil sale cefadroxil next day voltaren canada companies only zenegra 100 review where abilify disorder cefixime western australia amoxicillin capsules 500 mg in pregnancy indian pharmacy retin a 0 025 methotrexate uses medication discount trial erection packs 2 mg zestril lawsuit dapoxetine india no prescription phenergan uk online purchase medrol dosepak in us buy alli australia lowest price lexapro 20 mg buy bactrim ds 160 800 generic atomoxetin uk paypal erection packs 1 online canadian buy amoxil $500 there any difference between propecia finasteride finasteride 1mg costco plendil over counter cytotec prescription drug purchase baridium on line in india buy atorlip 10 online canada cipla cialis 5mg is generic flagyl available in usa gazeta kosovarja horoskopi online no prescription uk for movalis bystolic in croatia erexor non perscription countries purchase plavix in usa best site get flomax best place to buy tofranil in usa over the counter drugs similar to evista levitra plus pct buy get atomoxetin toronto roaccutane where to buy in canada buy l tryptophan in new zealand what types of cialis soft are there mail order deltasone online the online drugstore lotensin actos online purchase where could i buy flagyl er without prescription buy mometasona online cheap flunil canada pharmacy where can you buy pain pills online unisom pills buy generic clomid cost does protonix cause weight gain what are the side effects of prevacid solutabs health canada tenormin leukeran max dose online doctor prescription uk buy aspirin patch best place to buy naprosyn online what is the drug classification for diovan metronidazole over the counter equivalent nombre generico de toradol the online drugstore reviews trial erection packs 1 lowest price online safe place order mobic emsam uk brand name order voveran sr online with visa buy doxazosin tablets esomeprazole omeprazole comparison serpina mexico no prescription can you only get aricept on prescription buy xenical online uk where can i buy geriforte tablets medicinebestpharmacy does lipitor now have a generic over the counter drugs similar to deltasone order phenamax online no prescription with a echeck vpxl discounted where to buy mometasona without a prescription bactroban by mail risperdal consta usa buy ampicilina online us no prescription pravachol buy on line frumil canada companies only purchase isoniazid on line in india is generic zantac effective lopid over the counter usa walgreens canada lambert tucson az mircette medicine online lipitor pills lower cholesterol buy generic citalopram where is the spemann organizer buy zenegra online from india canadianpharmsupport. discount coreg mg cheap ventolin inhalers online buying apcalis sx express where to buy simvastatina online without rx serevent to buy nizoral tablets canada how long does it take for zovirax to work on cold sores acai prescription only detrol drug what does speman cephalexin for sale uk para que sirve nosipren prednisona canadian online pharmacy for antivert snovitra super power online shipping medicine for gout allopurinol safe to buy generic ginseng from uk probalan cheap india pharmacy abilify reviews by users zyloprim mail order india flomax drug class without a script cheap chloramphenicol speman where to purchase cheap zetia sale uk buy cheap rumalaya using pay pal how long will it take accutane to start working comprar digoxin original buy quetiapinum online in the united states without a prescription oracea cheap india pharmacy topamax coupons 2011 famciclovir tablets 500mg where to buy ashwagandha plants disulfiramum online ordering orlistar buy no prescription phenergan mg order evista medicine children key pred buy india orlistat drug in usa pharmacy keftab 20mg tab where can i get dapoxetine accutane mexican pharmacies losartan dose max buy himcolin gel in bangladesh next day delivery viagra uk drug market order micardis tamsulozin from uk buy finpecia online no prescription endep lowest price atacand for men in usa ordering amaryl here in canada 100mg doxycycline ranitidine dosage calculator cialis sublingual online shipping cuanto cuestan las pastillas cytotec en colombia ordering unisom uk over the counter drugs similar to riperdal valtrex dosage for herpes simplex what is prednisolone tablets 25mg cialis sublingual on line in the usa brand amoxil lowest price female viagra price india comprar cialis seguro elimite online in usa buy retin a gel 0,1 uk vistaril buy usa mexico pharmacies online that sell keflex pilex online forum safe dutasterid no prescription prilosec generic cvs cleocin price lantus without script safe caffeine ergotamine no prescription buying nymphomax from canada no prescription what is minipress drugs generic zyrtec not as good cheap viagra uk uk discount code for dipyridamole best pharmacy to order ephedraxin inderal mg buy sale clozaril prilosec from uk how much nolva for pct trimox to buy in the usa without a prescription janumet generic australia oder mg tablets of vardenafilum zithromax chlamydia treatment time purchase lantus on line in mexico kamagra oral jelly paypal uk serevent buy online us where diarex airmail online side effects of brand amoxil buy advair diskus asthma voltaren without a perscription buy tulasi online overnight prednisona with no subscription reviews on taking clomid buy sibustat in usa what are elavil tablets do i need a prescription for carvedilolo buy viagra soft 100 vermox 100mg chewable tablets how much will clomifene cost where to buy rosuvastatin mg order ondansetrona from usa without prescription can i use eurax cream for thrush tamsulozin without prescription med cab detrol medicine for abortion of 1 month pregnancy in philippines cheap cleocin us doxazosin without rx how to purchase procardia online licensed pharmacy toradol terbinafine 250 mg tab cam defenac gel lotrel without a perscription xalatan without prescription ciplox western australia voltaren tablets uses buy cilest online india no prescription benicar tablets olmesartan medoxomil where to get dapoxetine in india best place to buy acnetane in usa robaxin overnight free proscar drug store online order aldactone online no prescription with a visa order ceftin online uk assert cloridrato de sertralina engorda indian generics online apcalis sx cheapest pletal to buy discount generic viagra from canada is there a generic for luvox atorlip 5 online legally how long does diovan take to work buy acticin online from canada order ivenox online canada celapram for sale uk pyridium for uti side effects cheap prilosec elocon on line phone in order for orlistatum probalan online in usa diovan weight gain cheap nolvadex tamoxifen where to buy cipro mg ordering bupropionum florinef acetate 0.1 mg canadian healthcare network login lantus buy australia do need prescription viagra canada you tube jack box viagra doxazosin tablets discount buy finpecia pharmacy acquistare tetracycline in italia hydrodiuril uk buy atarax from mexico zitromax usa pharmacy cleocin free shipping safe florinef no precription prednisone buy online uk how to purchase cialis online buy levothyroid capsules ordering brand amoxil trandate online order cipro class action lawsuit 2011 lasilix legal in england ginseng capsules india diflucan rx info where can i buy qnexa diet pills glucophage without a prescription mentat noprescrition needed usa online pharmacy risperdal pill shop discount code buy toradol new zealand online fluoxetine hcl 20 mg cap how to take cytotec orally purchase zebeta online probalan doctors online buy keflex perth australia atorlip 10 online pay paypal pyridium doctors online order diclofenac online no prescription with a echeck herbal medicine suppliers south africa buy bupropion usa alphagan no prescription reviews alti doxycycline results forum buy lotrisone online overnight is atorlip 5 a prescription drug dostinex 2 tablet creme diprosone phimosis how much do viagra cost buy abilify tablets best price for generic allegra d how to order diclofenac gel florida albuterol where to buy valaciclovir drugs online taking 2 diflucan pills brand viagra pills online in the mexico betapace cost in canada buy diclofenac gel online thru paypals order diamox online no prescription with a visa cheap orlistat philippines elimite online pay paypal buy levaquin online at canada pharmacy costco pharmacy zovirax price india generic viagra reviews order generic ephedraxin viramune generic buy brafix paypal where cane i buy accutane aspirin discontinued prior to surgery can i get lexapro inhousepharmacy.com can you order eurax viagra jelly without prescription canada where can i buy diltiazem cream hoodia buying guide buy cialis sublingual pills in the us where can i buy cabergoline buy purinethol uk prescription for propecia over counter drug comparable protonix liv 52 buy online us ambasciatore di cipro in italia estrace online order glucotrol xl pills drugstore aricept delivery uk cheap cipro ordering aripiprazola alti doxycycline uk sale buy xanax online canada buy birth control online from canada buy codeine promethazine cough syrup novo digoxin online without rx canadian erection packs 3 levitra shortage viagra online no prescriptions roaccutane overnight pharmacy my microzide coupons propranolol cost comparison amex accept visa metoclopramide tablets 150 mg fertility pills revatio shop net ondansetrona medication side effects haldol tablets purchase on line best generic dramamine review zantac in canada cipro australia pharmacy stromectol india companies only is there a generic for actos accutane 5 mg day can you order salbutamol best site for sinequan rogaine 5 uk buy what does zyprexa zydis do dipyridamole from mexico prednisone steroids for dogs augmentin side effects fatigue can you buy viagra jelly in ireland bulk online drug order methotrexate pill where to buy albenza online mexico order alavert from uk without prescription price increase naprosyn baclofen discount what is azithromycin 250mg used to treat alfa flucon mg india what is celebrex tablets cheap propecia delivered overnight online sale of ayurslim uk buy lopressor without prescription online erection packs 1 overnight delivery order toradol online no prescription with a amex emsam shoppers drug mart fucidin overnight shipping cheap cost of meloxicam enolat without insurance digoxin online from canada 50mg clomid online canada cheap prednisone online side effects of antivert free viagra free before buying can you buy ephedraxin synthroid online england o floxin drops sominex limited india prevacid over counter 30 mg testosterone cream men facial hair zenegra delivery donde comprar celexa lady era uk buy shatavari roche precio argentina there difference synthroid levothyroxine what does brand amoxil what is atenolol tablets for celexa warning above 40 mg indian pharmacy exelon billig calan online kaufen chlamydia pills gave me diarrhea levaquin online prices fluss 40 delivery uk over counter geriforte syrup generic glucophage xr online tinidazolum overnight delivery order hyzaar online ceftin without prescription pills how much is kytril tablets liv 52 over the couter flomax canada prices cytotec philippines 2012 what types of zyvox are there promethazine online coupon code cheap gabapentine mg feldene capsules 10mg buy online viagra usa best price cordarone exelon dosage forms discount topamax 50mg desyrel tablets on line to buy non prescription diarex pharmacy cheap penegra sale uk list of sulfa drugs how to take rumalaya liniment mg maxalt prices walgreens no prescription viagra order buy promethazine in australia rythmol sr buy canada lioresal perth australia comprar aygestin original en madrid buy trial erection packs 3 online ireland xeloda on line no script legal buy oxytrol online canada what does depakote er do generic rosuvastatin usa pharmacy what does coumadin mean order procardia pills buy diprolene pills in the canada where to get hoodia gordonii legal buy eldepryl online canada cialis erfahrungen what does lotrisone cheap mobicosa pharmacy get viagra professional toronto zedd delivery uk over counter tadalis sx gyne lotrimin pill shortage lithium to buy brand levitra online bestellen order maxaman overnight trental online cheap lamisilate where can i buy it how to buy lantus buy endep tablets online combivent inhaler dosage singulair online pharmacy purchase actonel on line in usa zetia without a prescription from mexico claritin weight gain cialis pills for sale canada purchase kelnor in uk buy klipal codeine online without a prescription can you buy trandate over the counter obelit best online non prescription pharmacy what does calcium carbonate and hydrochloric acid make mail order generic bentyl where to buy vardenafilum ointment brand name isoniazid online lotrisone from canada with no prescription hydrea max dose actos online order innopran xl canada online no prescription safe to buy generic ephedraxin from usa where can i get apo clopidogrel from decadron tablets dose i pill bactroban website cheap amitriptyline buy online cheapest revia paypal use capoten coupon online suppliers of ethionamide in us acai without subscription cipro from usa i want to pay some tadapox olanzapine prescription coupon can you buy viagra over the counter in dubai pharmacies detrol from canada what is phenergan injection used for is it legal to buy viagra order lisinopril online no prescription with a mastercard alfa flucon over counter buy tetracycline 250mg hyaluronic acid serum buy uk long time side effects famvir cost of beta val without insurance riperdal without insurance uk pharmacies online that sell lopressor how to take hoodia p57 buy cialis professional perth australia neurotin sold in canada xenical pearl chemist london i want to pay some hydrochlorothiazide over the counter compazine cheap liverpool apartments short stay betnovate prix en pharmacie en france cytotec mexico no prescription hytrin spain purchasing biaxin online uk best homeopathic medicine back pain buy viagra in ireland micronase pill shortage alti doxycycline us companies only micronase birth control online india buy keflex hong kong buy etabus have no prescription acyclovir valacyclovir and famciclovir side effects advair pills treatment of lyme disease doxycycline dose diovan online cheap desyrel online meds air max 1 leopard ebay retail cost of bystolic furosemide over the counter equivalent revia australia pharmacy pharmacy mexico danazol all types mobic pills pfizer pfriends viagra discount prescription fluoxetine limited india avalide refills can you get prednisone where to buy nolvadex serm buy clavamox capsules drugs similar to zentel proventil in us buy medrol online canada priligy dapoxetine best price glucophage generic cafergot overnite shipping silagra buy australia donde conseguir viagra sin receta argentina flagyl 500 mg during pregnancy albendazole mexican pharmacies banana muffins how to purchase cefixime what is clozaril tablets purchase dilantin in us clopidogrelum over the counter usa lozol online bestellen riperdal buy usa buy tadacip online from usa drugs similar to serophene no prescription aloprim generic keppra manufacturers evecare doctors online buy amlodipin online from mexico sildenafil citrate buy uk fluconazole 200 mg capsules mevacor mg tablet how to get a canadian health card generic suprax uk paypal albendazole to purchase without a prescription clavamox canada companies only what is zovirax pills used for remeron non perscription countries skelaxin pas cher there generic relafen cordarone medication guide effects order accutane no rx canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy online speman avalide no script zithromax without prescription medication periactin low cost buy zyrtec patch duetact prescription only diovan hct in canadian pharmacies buy estrace line what is aripiprazola pills used for buy venlor usa can i import cialis into australia buy brafix for daily use diclofenac online in us actoplus met shelf life over the counter medicine bupron sr aldactone from europe buy meloxicam enolat singapore keflex order in the us albenza generic usa mens meds online review stromectol online bestellen abilify low blood pressure januvia generic wikipedia drugs generic name for torsemide buy brand septilin canada renova tablets online india pharmacies online that sell doxazosin ambasciata italiana in cipro medicine like asacol where to buy allison cabinet pulls pills tamoxifen noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy mevacor prices at costco doxazosin tablets 4mg estrofem canada sale accutane forum indian online pharmacy buy permethrinum tablets mexico buy cheap propecia online forum klipal codeine suppositories buy is minocycline available on line in canada retin a 0,025 for sale philippines clomid ovulation calendar cycle is there a shortage of elocom list of tesco stores selling lasix long time side effects mirapex vajinismus can you get mentat buy deltasone online canada cialis over the counter singapore buy biaxin tablets online pantoprazole generic otc generic name for benzaclin gel how to import desyrel serophene medication online flomax for sale philippines bulk buy allium bulbs neurontin 5mg tablets order rumalaya liniment online uk alli weight loss aid refill 120ea thyrox tablets uses tenormin sale discount betnovate online cheap how to use finasteride 5mg innopran xl birth control online mexico diclofenac misoprostol bioequivalence revatio drug in fr pharmacy coversyl without a script fedex drugs similar to retino a cream 0,05 buy erexin v pills in the india safe to buy generic phenamax from uk can you drink on amoxicillin nhs my valtrex coupons purchase metrogel lowest price use maxaman coupon online when will alli diet pills be available again retin a 0,025 where to buy in canada where levlen vita cost hoodia buy entocort 100 buy alesse online in the united states without a prescription names of oral contraceptive pills available in india brand name viagra soft online pulmicort respules prices generic antivert us minocycline fast mexico cialis jelly without prescription medication purchase probalan pills accutane online pay paypal pramipexole mirapex dosage mail order pharmacy reviews buy artane in uk free or low cost amoxil pills cheap dapoxetine online sildenafil citrate us pharmacies online that sell lisinopril fast lioresal delivery original arava online glucophage 1000 mg merck bisoprololi fumaras mg no prescription generic luvox switzerland zentel reviews for men pravachol to buy in australia cialis vs viagra 2008 online buy to buy zenegra cheap phexin pills geriforte syrup reviews cheap kamagra online uk zydis without subscription over the counter antibiotics for bacterial conjunctivitis novo digoxin medicine children what dosage does zithromax come in ephedraxin prices usa generic viagra canada prescription buy aricept 5 lov cost purim brand eulexin buy isoptin without prescription pills how much is zestoretic tablets low price mircette uk elocon without a prescription from us zitromax canada drug store where to buy feldene online without rx discount duprost of canada cipralex cheap india pharmacy citalopram mexico no prescription pure hyaluronic acid capsules top 10 erection pills where to get promethazine syrup anacin delivery london my vardenafilum coupons diclofenac not generic is there a real generic cialis feldene buy usa flovent over the counter uk ivenox canada companies only mexican prescription propranolol online where purchase lantus where to buy cialis super active online usa where purchase simvastatina discount lipitor pharmacy valaciclovir for sale uk sildenafila prices at costco viagra 100mg canadian pharmacy better than ondansetrona buy viagra generic canada buy lipitor capsules order fluoxetine no rx canadian pharmacy amitriptyline buy mexico dapoxetine fast mexico donde comprar suhagra en colombia buy famvir perth australia depakine chrono generic usa acquistare lasix in italia femcare medication side effects lipothin comprare lotensin canada pharmacy donde comprar abilify buy rogaine 2 online pharmacy nootropil no prescription needed dogs buy bupropionum greece generic finast us buy noroxin online from australia mail order crestor levitra and blood pressure medication the online drugstore atrovent arimidex 1 mg tablet tofranil pm uses what does deltasone treat effects atorlip 5 pills online in the canada long term side effects of quetiapinum lowest price voveran indian pharmacy mastercard sale microzide prednisolone for dogs buy order wellbutrin sr medication by mail mobic dosage recommended where to buy lanoxin online canada suppliers of celadrin in us metrogel with no perscription ventolin inhalers sale percocet perth australia tadapox online pharmacy uk depo provera shot prices buy frumil online reviews ventolin syrup salbutamol sulphate safe to buy generic caprysin from uk birth control pills terramycin best place to buy aldactone in australia buy alti doxycycline mexican pharmacies misoprost birth control online mexico buy differin gel 45g can you buy purim over the counter buy benicar pills in the us price increase tadacip order mobic from buy singulair 5 mg canada buy tinidazolum without prescription generic form of bupropion luvox buy india buy ceftin tablets india effexor xr dosage increase side effects buy prescriptions online australia evista mg india copegus tablets 150 mg bactroban weight gain pulmicort next day what does zovirax vente de skelaxin au quebec citalopram on line for sale no script levlen tablets for sale mirapex india sale buy over the counter cefadroxil online retino a cream 0,025 from uk key pred side effects uk usa buy actonel without prescription cabgolin noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy clomid prescriptions australia ordering viagra customer support delivery purchase lukol pill shortage buy advair diskus paypal trial erection packs 1 buy online mexico buy antara tablets mexico online pharmacy amoxil walmart medical expense report canadian pharmacy malegra dxt safe place order dyazide sertralina over the counter usa what is pulmicort for pharmacies amoxil yagara medication overnight delivery flonase uk companies only canadian drug company albuterol pyridium without a prescription from us buy naprosyn without a script viagra soft precio mexico voice in abilify commercial lamisilate on line in the india onlain filmer generic plavix made in india skelaxin on line in the india what does astelin treat allergic rhinitis fluconazol from china nordette noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy uses for bactroban ointment detrol online australia where can i get ashwagandha pills medrol canada companies only order pravachol no rx canadian pharmacy innopran xl overnight pharmacy amoxicillin over the counter uk over the counter drugs similar to trileptal cheapest place to buy stediril snovitra super power tablets uses alavert children dose use augmentin coupon online biaxin pill shortage where can i order clomid lopid canada sale where can i purchase alfa flucon medrol dosepak fast usa comprar evecare online where to buy aciclovir mg furosemide sale uk how to get promethazine codeine syrup without a prescription order skelaxin online no prescription with a visa benemid for sale uk flunil over the counter india without a script purchase accutane mg mastercard diflucan canada drug store buy avapro 150 mg oristal order online no prescription allie brosh twitter xenical best price australia ordering liposafe canada safe place order bactrim terramycin on line purchase buy alli over the counter picture of diltiazem pills rogaine 2 online pharmacies with out prescription what is dramamine mg used to treat can i buy permethrin 5 cream over the counter buy cialis sublingual online india best pills for water retention can you buy lansoprazol over the counter in germany hydrea prix en pharmacie en france side effects of celebrex 100mg levitra prices at costco to buy periactin prescription medicine buy female cialis in australia purchase flagyl er in uk xenical buy online does alesse 21 cause weight gain average topamax dosage fast nimotop delivery dune mentat speech curacne generic name tegaserod maxalt usage there generic drug evista order generic nolvadex zoloft generic manufacturers vibrox capsules 100mg prescription drug dutas how to buy ampicillin in canada is arava available on line in canada buy celadrin with no script eurax in croatia phenergan tablets 25mg dosage what does risperdal do best online pharmacy generic brand levitra cheapest orlistat tablets uk ayurslim generic uk what is atomoxetin mg used to treat ordering amoxycillin usa is it legal to buy prescription drugs online in the uk fosamax online in usa generic paroxetine uk paypal doxycycline price increase why buy danazol from india coumadin prices purchase indocin in india oestrogel maximum dosage buy suprax online from australia cialis professional 20mg pills wellbutrin pill canadian buy duphalac uk buy risperdal online mexico no prescription donde puedo comprar membresia xbox live en mexico celebrex coupons promotions suprax generic buy generic claravis online purchase elocon online buy isotretin without a subscription where to buy rocaltrol in canada safely ciprofloxacina medicine children is mail order levitra super active safe salbutamol birth control online mexico diovan tablets 320 mg buy eltroxin online overnight lamictal legal in england triamterenum tablets side effects raloxifeno on line in the uk cheap pariet 20mg online doksazosin lek over the counter india emoquette no prescription compare prices buy advair diskus online overnight alli usa sale what does hyzaar look like price of prilosec at walgreens health canada estrace ordering glucofage mexico where purchase amoxicilina post cycle therapy trimox endep medicine side effects abilify dosage increase canadian pharmacy online frusemide zovirax online from india rank from strongest to weakest repulsion lp medazole mg order purchase methotrexate on line in mexico what does neurontin do to your brain best drugstore makeup blog metronidazole online india ranitidine spain buy bupropion pills in the us buy actos online usa pioglitazone crestor tablet sale buy real albenza buy pravachol online us no prescription discount erection packs 2 of canada order diarex online discount buspar from canada side effects of esomeprazole tablets low dose pravachol etodolac limited india seroquel dose for insomnia is kamagra legal in the uk zydis india pharmacy what class of medication is omnicef roacutan generico onde comprar how do i get tamoxifen uk etodolac uk buy list of tesco stores selling chloroquine order antabuse without rx arimidex drugs diflucan thrush tablet buy cordarone generic metronidazole flagyl forte medication buy lantus online australia no prescription robaxin pills online in the uk furosemide pill fast delivery starlix paypal benadryl cheapest rate fast claritin deleviery can skelaxin cause weight gain v gel side effects long term use amantadine side effects humans tetracycline 500mg dosage frumil online without prescription dapoxetine mg price med cab evecare buy avalide tablets india metoprolol side effects heartburn prescription discount card bupropion where to get c ratioph pct cyproheptadine tablets dosage minomycin medication janumet legal us buy birth control pills online uk adhd for adults medication strattera how to use aloprim order tofranil on line usa what is tetracycline fasigyne cheap india pharmacy actoplus met new zealand price of nexium in mexico uk pharmacies online that sell xenical shelf life of ampicillin capsules order vardenafilum without rx evista online australia zetia no prescription overnight delivery what is clomiphene clomid altace from canada with no prescription what is actonel monthly dose long term side effects of elocom suhagra without a prescription how long does ceftin stay in your body best price for real noroxin canada order terramycin what is the drug paroxetine for acheter du viagra en suisse plendil buy online canada buy generic levitra plus online no prescription strongest over the counter antibiotic ointment generic plavix release can you buy movalis parlodel cost per month where purchase septilin side effects of lisinopril 20 mg tadacip shop net cialis super active lawsuit canada order prevacid online no prescription almetec dosage too high buy dramamine online in the united states without a prescription retin a 0,05 canada buy flucazole without prescription zoloft without a prescription mentat no rx what is cipralex 20mg used for healthy male waist hip flomax dosage instructions cheapest isoniazid in the uk yaz no rx generic sinemet uk paypal roaccutan dose generic fluconazol buy canada american propecia viagra brazil praziquantel dosage for schistosomiasis non prescription dapoxetine generic erexor uk paypal health canada effexor xr buy cialis professional online uk no prescription thyrohormone trusted online drug stores in canada is it legal to order prescription drugs online buy levitra mg online for artane italiano health canada advisory actos does accutane help seborrheic dermatitis buy bentyl tablets us como comprar bayas de acai buy emsam perth australia amitriptyline and alcohol effects can you buy hoodia canada what are the side effects of sildenafil citrate buy duprost online without a prescription can you buy exelon buy alphagan in uk buy combivent online amazon buy artane in singapore buy fincar online india no prescription what are the side effects of stopping prednisone order estrofem on line usa cardura fast uk erection packs 3 india mirapex generic india oder mg tablets of micardis ordering low dose kamagra oral jelly leukeran online pay paypal where can you buy generic lamisil buy snovitra super power mg online bentyl 10 mg cap where to buy detrol with amex buy lisinopril canada buy vistaril online without prescription entocort ec coupon combivent coupons online canadian pharmacy online micardis order estro online uk nitrofurantoin monoh 100mg side effects hydrodiuril pills buy online buying deltasone express generic mentax in usa what does prednisolone 5mg look like keppra rx buy estrace online no prescription canadian what if sinemet does not work ciprofloxacina posologia pediatrica can you take augmentin daily can you buy brimonidine alphagan eye drops tegretol cheap canada pharmacy where do i citalopram in india levitra sex pill seroflo legal us what does alli alli oxen free mean comprar lotrel original cefadroxil online from india what is the generic form of cephalexin indian pharmacy tretinoin 0,025 diclofenac 75 mg price lisinopril fast india buy thyroxine online from mexico buy generic unisom online with prescription most reliable place to buy tetracycline online boots beconase allergy nasal spray lamisil looking for buy etodolac tablets us over the counter medicine that acts as duphalac duprost online in us codeine promethazine cough syrup for sale sinemet 100 25 side effects of albendazole tablet where can i buy meclizine over the counter retino a cream 0,05 with prescription order acticin from australia without prescription best place to buy retino a cream in canada costco membership card order levothyroxin from uk without prescription generic viagra super active cost natural viagras mail order generic glucofage can you buy generic viagra in canada buy genuine bactroban online can you order flonase spray symptoms is generic valtrex as effective as brand name oracea spain reviews on estro floxin perth australia ralista capsules side effects of naprosyn 250mg class action lawsuit against synthroid generic aldactone cost can zetia cause weight gain is generic entocort effective mometasona generic reviews non prescription allegra pharmacy order viagra sublingual online no prescription with a mastercard isoniazid mail order india anastrozolo where can i buy it order haldol online uk what is olanzapine primarily used for florida female viagra cheap azulfidine sale uk low cost trandate where can i buy erythromycine metronidazole gel rosacea buy frusemide without a subscription buy viagra online legally how to order prescription drugs online buy diflucan without a subscription what types of naprosyn are there acnetane usa no prescription why isnt viagra covered by medicare buying levothroid in manchester good reviews on arimidex no prescription cheap methotrexate thyrox over the counter canada ordering dramamine on line order diovan pharmacy hct order cialis on line mexico is there a generic drug for propecia arjuna canadian online list of top 10 pharmaceutical companies in india 2011
Home BoB Documents National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1241 guests online

Atom RSS

National Labor Relations Board vs. Major League Baseball, 880 F. Supp. 246 (1995) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 39
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Judge Sonia Sotomayor   
Wednesday, 27 May 2009 01:38

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

No. 1999 August Term, 1994

(Argued: May 11, 1995) Decided: September 29, 1995

Docket No. 95-6048

------------------------------------------

DANIEL SILVERMAN, Regional Director

for Region 2 of the National Labor

Relations Board, for and on behalf

of the National Labor Relations Board,

Petitioner-Appellee ,

v.

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYER RELATIONS

COMMITTEE, INC. and THE CONSTITUENT MEMBER

CLUBS OF MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL,

Respondents-Appellants .

------------------------------------------

B e f o r e: NEWMAN, Chief Judge , WINTER, and MAHONEY, Circuit

Judges .

Appeal from an order of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (Sonia Sotomayor, Judge ) enjoining appellants to restore the terms and conditions of employment provided under an expired collective bargaining agreement. We affirm.

DOUGLAS L. LESLIE, Charlottesville, Virginia (Lisa Klein Wager, Francis L. Casey, III, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, New York, New York, of counsel), for Respondents-Appellants .

ELLEN A. FARRELL, Assistant General Counsel (Frederick L. Feinstein, General Counsel, Mary Joyce Carlson, Assistant General Counsel, Robert E. Allen, Associate General Counsel, Donald B. Zavelo, Ian M. Penny, of counsel, National Labor Relations Board, Washington, D.C.), for Petitioner-Appellee .

GEORGE M. COHEN (Virginia A. Seitz, Bredhoff & Kaiser, Washington, D.C., of counsel), for Amicus Curiae Major League Baseball Players Association .

WINTER, Circuit Judge :

This is an appeal by the Major League Baseball Player Relations Committee, Inc. ("PRC") and the constituent member clubs of Major League Baseball ("Clubs") from a temporary injunction issued by Judge Sotomayor pursuant to section 10(j) of the National Labor Relations Act ("NLRA"), 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). The PRC is the collective bargaining representative for the twenty-eight Clubs. The Major League Baseball Players Association is a union that is the exclusive bargaining representative for the forty-man rosters of each major league club. The injunction is based on the district court's conclusion that appellants violated NLRA §§ 8(a)(1) and (5), 29 U.S.C. §§ 158(a)(1) and (5), by unilaterally implementing terms and conditions of employment that differed from those in the last collective agreement. It orders the PRC and the Clubs to: (i) abide by the terms of an expired collective agreement, (ii) rescind any actions taken that are inconsistent with that agreement and (iii) bargain in good faith with the Players Association. See Silverman v. Major League Baseball Player Relations Comm., Inc. , 880 F. Supp. 246, 261 (S.D.N.Y. 1995). The injunction is to remain in effect until either (i) the expired agreement is replaced by a new collective bargaining agreement, (ii) the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") renders a final disposition of the matters pending before it in the related administrative case, or (iii) the district court finds, upon petition of either of the parties, that an impasse has occurred. See id. We affirm.

BACKGROUND

On January 1, 1990, the most recent collective agreement ("Basic Agreement") between appellants and the Players Association became effective. It contained provisions implementing a combination of free agency and a reserve system -- that is, a compromise between free competitive bidding for a player's services and an individual club's exclusive rights to those services.

Free agency, in its purest form, is a status in which the rights to a player's athletic services are not owned by a club and may be shopped around by the player in a quest for the most attractive bid. However, for more than a century, Major League Baseball has had a reserve system that to one degree or another affords individual clubs exclusive property rights to the athletic services of certain players. Before the players were organized and a collective bargaining relationship was established, the standard players contract with a club reserved to the club exclusive rights to a player's services and provided for an annual right of renewal of the contract by the club in question. The Clubs interpreted the contract as allowing the club in question to renew all of an individual player's contract, including the right of renewal provision. So interpreted, this provision -- known generally as the "reserve clause" -- bound a player to one club in perpetuity until traded or released. After the Clubs recognized the Players Association and entered into a collective agreement with it, an arbitrator held in a grievance proceeding that the reserve clause allowed a renewal for only one year rather than a succession of years. See National & American League Professional Baseball Clubs v. Major League Baseball Players Ass'n , 66 Lab. Arb. (BNA) 101 (1976) (Seitz, Arb.). Since then, appellants and the Players Association have struggled to accommodate their conflicting interests in the free agency and reserve issues, and a variety of compromises have from time to time been reached. However, relations have been acrimonious, and several strikes and lockouts have occurred. This appeal itself arises out of a strike that terminated the 1994 season before the playoffs and World Series.

Article XX of the Basic Agreement that became effective in 1990 contains a series of provisions that govern free agency and reserve rights. Players with six or more years of major league service are free agents and may seek competing bids in an effort to obtain the best contract, which may of course give exclusive rights to the club for a stipulated number of years. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 250. Free agency is guaranteed by an anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F), which prohibits the Clubs from acting in concert with each other with respect to the exercise of rights under Article XX. See id. Article XX(F) thus prevents the Clubs from agreeing either to refuse to bid for the services of free agents or to offer only low bids to them. Article XX(F) also prohibits players from acting in concert with regard to Article XX rights. See id.

Players with less than six years of service remain under reserve to their individual clubs, although a club may reserve a player only once. Although a minimum annual salary is provided, players with less than three years of major league service must negotiate with their clubs to determine their salary for the coming season. Article XX allows certain reserved players -- generally those with more than three but less than six years of service -- to demand salary arbitration. See id. at 251. Salary arbitration is a mechanism for determining the individual salaries for that group of reserved players if they cannot arrive at an agreement with their clubs. The player and the club each present the arbitrator with a suggested salary figure for a new one-year contract. The arbitrator then inserts either the player's or the club's figure into a blank uniform contract that the parties have already signed. See id. Article VI(F)(12) provides the following with regard to the criteria to be used, and the evidence to be heard, by the arbitrator:

(12) Criteria . (a) The Criteria will be the quality of the Player's contribution to his Club during the past season (including but not limited to his overall performance, special qualities of leadership and public appeal), the length and consistency of his career contribution, the record of the Player's past compensation, comparative baseball salaries . . . , the existence of any physical or mental defects on the part of the Player, and the recent performance record of the Club including but not limited to its League standing and attendance as an indication of public acceptance (subject to the exclusion stated in subparagraph(b)(i) below). Any evidence may be submitted which is relevant to the above criteria, and the arbitrator shall assign such weight to the evidence as shall to him appear appropriate under the circumstances. The arbitrator shall, except for a Player with five or more years of Major League service, give particular attention, for comparative salary purposes, to the contracts of Players with Major League service not exceeding one annual service group above the Player's annual service group. This shall not limit the ability of a Player or his representative, because of special accomplishment, to argue the equal relevance of salaries of Players without regard to service, and the arbitrator shall give whatever weight to such argument as he deems appropriate.

 

(b) Evidence of the following shall not be admissible:

(i) The financial position of the Player and the Club;

(ii) Press comments, testimonials or similar material bearing on the performance of either the Player or the Club, except that recognized annual Player awards for playing excellence shall not be excluded;

(iii) Offers made by either Player or Club prior to arbitration;

 

(iv) The cost to the parties of their representatives, attorneys, etc.;

 

(v) Salaries in other sports or occupations.

The Basic Agreement expired on December 31, 1993, pursuant to the PRC's notice of termination. Although negotiations for a successor agreement did not get underway until March 1994, the PRC and the Players Association continued to observe the terms of the expired Basic Agreement. Prior to the commencement of negotiations, the Clubs and the Players Association had completed individual salary arbitration hearings and had entered into individual player contracts for the 1994 baseball season, which began in April 1994. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 251.

Negotiations for a new collective bargaining agreement continued unsuccessfully. The PRC offered its first formal economic proposal to the Players Association at a meeting on June 14, 1994. It included a "salary cap," a mechanism that establishes a ceiling on the total player salaries paid by each club. The ceiling may allow some flexibility, depending on the details. Generally, the aggregate salaries of each team are determined by an agreed upon formula and must remain above a minimum percentage of industry revenues, also determined by an agreed upon formula, but below a maximum percentage of those revenues. See Wood v. National Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954, 957 (2d Cir. 1987). The PRC proposal also eliminated the salary arbitration system and substituted restricted free agency rights for those reserved players previously eligible for salary arbitration. As an alternative to the PRC's proposed salary cap, the Players Association suggested a revenue sharing and luxury "tax" plan that would impose a tax on high-paying clubs. Subsequent proposals reflected disagreement over appropriate tax rates and payroll thresholds above which clubs would be subject to the tax. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 251-52.

The players struck on August 12, and the 1994 baseball season never resumed. On December 22, 1994, the PRC declared an impasse in negotiations and stated that it intended unilaterally to impose a salary cap and to implement other changes in the terms and conditions of employment, including the elimination of salary arbitration. See Silverman , 880 F.2d at 252. The Players Association responded with a unilateral ban on players signing individual contracts with the Clubs.

Thereafter, cross-charges of unfair labor practices were filed with the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB") by the Players Association and the Clubs. The Players Association alleged that the Clubs had engaged in unfair labor practices by unilaterally implementing the salary cap and other terms because the parties were not at an impasse.

On February 3, 1995, counsel for the PRC notified the NLRB General Counsel that the PRC would revoke the implementation of unilateral changes and restore the status quo ante. The General Counsel indicated that the Players Association charges would be dismissed as a result. Counsel for the PRC informed the General Counsel, however, that the PRC did not believe itself obligated to maintain provisions of the Basic Agreement that involved non-mandatory subjects of bargaining. He mentioned salary arbitration in that regard and also suggested that the Clubs might decide to bargain exclusively through the PRC. The NLRB General Counsel declined to offer an advisory opinion on these matters.

Three days later, by memorandum dated February 6, counsel for the PRC notified the Clubs that, until a new collective bargaining agreement was ratified or until further notice, individual clubs had no authority to negotiate contracts with individual players because the PRC was now the Clubs' exclusive bargaining representative. This amounted to an agreement among the Clubs not to hire free agents and thus was a departure from the anti-collusion provision, Article XX(F) of the Basic Agreement. It also amounted to an elimination of salary arbitration, because salary arbitration is a method of arriving at a wage for an individual player contract with a club.

The Players Association thereupon filed a new unfair labor practice charge, and the General Counsel issued a complaint alleging, inter alia , that the Clubs and the PRC had violated Sections 8(a)(1) and (5) of the NLRA by unilaterally eliminating, before an impasse had been reached, competitive bidding for the services of free agents, the anti-collusion provision, and salary arbitration for certain reserved players. The NLRB found that these matters were related to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment and were therefore mandatory subjects for collective bargaining. It then authorized its General Counsel to seek an injunction under NLRA §10(j). On March 27, the NLRB Regional Director filed a petition seeking a temporary injunction restraining the alleged unfair labor practices.

The district court agreed that the NLRB had reasonable cause to conclude that free agency and salary arbitration were mandatory subjects of bargaining and that the Clubs' unilateral actions constituted an unfair labor practice. The district court also concluded that injunctive relief was warranted. This appeal followed. We denied a stay on April 4.

DISCUSSION

The NLRB is authorized under Section 10(j) of the NLRA to petition for temporary injunctive relief from a district court to enjoin ongoing unfair labor practices. 29 U.S.C. § 160(j). If the court has reasonable cause to believe that an unfair labor practice has occurred and that injunctive relief would be just and proper, it should grant appropriate relief. Kaynard v. MMIC, Inc. , 734 F.2d 950, 953 (2d Cir. 1984). The court need not make a final determination that the conduct in question is an unfair labor practice. Kaynard v. Mego Corp. , 633 F.2d 1026, 1033 (2d Cir. 1980). It need find only reasonable cause to support such a conclusion. See id. ; MMIC , 734 F.2d at 953. Appropriate deference must be shown to the judgment of the NLRB, and a district court should decline to grant relief only if convinced that the NLRB's legal or factual theories are fatally flawed. See Mego , 633 F.2d at 1031, 1033; Kaynard v. Palby Lingerie, Inc. , 625 F.2d 1047, 1051 (2d Cir. 1980). In reviewing a district court's grant of injunctive relief pursuant to Section 10(j), a court of appeals must also accord deference to the district court's decision, at least with regard to those aspects that are traditionally left to the district court's discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030.

We turn now to the merits of the regional director's petition. The petition invokes basic principles of labor law. Section 8(d) of the NLRA mandates that employers and unions bargain in good faith over "wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment." 29 U.S.C. § 158(d). These are so-called mandatory subjects of bargaining. Under caselaw, the parties may propose and bargain over, but may not insist upon, permissive subjects of bargaining. NLRB v. Wooster Div. of Borg-Warner Corp. , 356 U.S. 342, 349 (1958). When a collective agreement expires, an employer may not alter terms and conditions of employment involving mandatory subjects until it has bargained to an impasse over new terms. NLRB v. Katz , 369 U.S. 736, 741-43 (1962). Thereafter, it may implement the new terms. Generally, when an agreement expires, an employer need not bargain to an impasse over terms and conditions involving permissive subjects but may alter them upon expiration. Allied Chem. & Alkali Workers v. Pittsburgh Plate Glass Co. , 404 U.S. 157, 187-88 (1971).

Many of the usual issues that arise in impasse cases are not disputed in the instant matter. The parties agree that the PRC, in directing the Clubs to decline to bargain individually with free agents, unilaterally departed from much of Article XX, which provides for a limited form of free agency and forbids collusive behavior by the Clubs in negotiating with free agents. It is also undisputed that the PRC unilaterally departed from the Basic Agreement's provisions with regard to salary arbitration. The PRC does not claim that it had bargained to an impasse over the free agency, the anti-collusion, or the salary arbitration provisions. Finally, it is also agreed that, if those provisions involved mandatory subjects of bargaining, their unilateral abrogation before impasse was a refusal to bargain in good faith. The PRC and the Clubs argue that the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement do not involve mandatory subjects of bargaining and are therefore not subject to the Katz rule that unilateral implementation of new terms is an unfair labor practice unless the employer has bargained to an impasse over these new terms. See Silverman , 880 F. Supp. at 254. The PRC and the Clubs contend that an injunction compelling them to maintain the free agency and anti-collusion provisions undermines their right as a multiemployer group to bargain collectively through an exclusive representative. If so, they would be permissive subjects of bargaining. See Borg Warner , 356 U.S. at 349 . With regard to salary arbitration, the PRC and the Clubs argue that it is the equivalent of interest arbitration -- arbitration of the terms of a new collective agreement -- and thus not a mandatory subject of bargaining. See International Bhd. of Elec. Workers (Collier Elec. Co.) , 296 N.L.R.B. 1095, 1098 (1989).

We are unpersuaded that an injunction compelling the PRC and the Clubs to observe the anti-collusion and free agency provisions of the Basic Agreement infringes on their right as a multiemployer group to bargain through an exclusive representative. Free agency and the ban on collusion are one part of a complex method -- agreed upon in collective bargaining -- by which each major league player's salary is determined under the Basic Agreement. They are analogous to the use of seniority, hours of work, merit increases, or piece work to determine salaries in an industrial context. The PRC and the Clubs describe free agency and the ban on collusion as provisions undermining their right to select a joint bargaining representative because those provisions entail individual contracts with clubs. However, the argument ignores the fact that free agency is simply a collectively bargained method of determining individual salaries for one group of players. The anti-collusion provision is not designed to prevent the PRC from representing the Clubs. Rather, that provision guarantees that free agency will be a reality when permitted by the Basic Agreement. The injunction thus does not in any way prevent the PRC from bargaining as the Clubs' exclusive representative with the Players Association over the elimination of free agency in its entirety or for a modified version of the same, and thereafter from implementing any proposals incorporated into a collective bargaining agreement.

The question, therefore, is whether the free agency, anti-collusion, and reserve issues are -- or there is reasonable cause to believe they are -- otherwise mandatory subjects of bargaining. Section 8(d) of the NLRA defines the duty to bargain as "the obligation . . . to meet . . . and confer in good faith with respect to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment . . . ." In Wood v. Nat'l Basketball Ass'n , 809 F.2d 954 (2d Cir. 1987), we noted that free agency and reserve issues are "at the center of collective bargaining in much of the professional sports industry," id. at 961, and that "it is precisely because of [free agency's] direct relationship to wages and conditions of employment that [it is] so controversial and so much the focus of bargaining in professional sports." Id. at 962.

Wood noted that collective bargaining between professional athletes and leagues raises "numerous problems with little or no precedent in standard industrial relations." Id. at 961. Such is the case with a free agency and reserve system. For the most part, unionized employees in the industrial sector may leave one employer for another without restriction. The employee may have no bargaining rights with regard to the terms of hire by the new employer, which may be set by a collective agreement, but is nevertheless generally free to go from one unionized job to another. [1]  

The professional sports industry has a very different history and very different economic imperatives. Most professional sports leagues have always had some form of what has become known as the reserve system. See Flood v. Kuhn , 407 U.S. 258, 259 n.1 (1972) (baseball); Robertson v. National Basketball Ass'n , 556 F.2d 682, 686 n.6 (2d Cir. 1977) (basketball); Mackey v. National Football League , 543 F.2d 606, 610 (8th Cir. 1976) (football), cert. dismissed , 434 U.S. 801 (1977); McCourt v. California Sports, Inc. , 600 F.2d 1193, 1194 (6th Cir. 1979) (hockey). As noted, this is a system by which the right to a player's services becomes the property of a particular club with limited freedom for the player to seek employment with another club. The reserve system in one form or another has been used in major league baseball for over a century. Until the arbitration decision in 1976, the reserve system prevented players from offering their athletic services to competing teams. A player's services were thus the property of a single team until he was traded or released. In enforcing a complete reserve system, Major League Baseball was exercising monopsony power -- a buyer's monopoly.

However, there are many reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues from players to clubs, why reserve systems exist within professional sports. Fans might not be interested in games between teams that had entirely new lineups for every contest. Moreover, high quality play may require that individuals practice and play with the same teammates for at least some period of time. Teams may also want to recoup what they regard as training costs invested in players while they gained experience. In antitrust litigation, the leagues perennially argue that some form of reserve system is necessary for competitive balance. See Mackey , 543 F.2d at 611. Indeed, even in a system of complete free agency, one would expect to see many long-term agreements binding individual players to particular clubs.

There are also reasons, apart from maximizing the transfer of revenues to players, why a union of professional athletes would seek free agency. It is very difficult to set individual salaries in professional sports through collective bargaining. Although unions of professional athletes may bargain for uniform benefits and minimum salaries, they do not usually follow their industrial counterparts and seek relatively fixed salaries by job description, seniority, or other formulae. Players often play positions requiring very different skills. Moreover, the level of performance and value to a team in attracting fans differs radically among players, with star athletes or popular players being far more valuable than sub-par or nondescript players. Usually, therefore, players unions seek some form of free agency as a relatively simple method of setting individual salaries.

Most importantly, however, both the leagues and the players unions view free agency and reserve issues as questions of what share of revenues go to the clubs or to the players. The more restrictive the reserve system is, the greater the clubs' share. The greater the role of free agency, the greater the players' share.

To hold that there is no reasonable cause for the NLRB to conclude that free agency and reserve issues are mandatory subjects of bargaining would be virtually to ignore the history and economic imperatives of collective bargaining in professional sports. A mix of free agency and reserve clauses combined with other provisions is the universal method by which leagues and players unions set individual salaries in professional sports. Free agency for veteran players may thus be combined with a reserve system, as in baseball, or a rookie draft, as in basketball, see Wood , 809 F.2d at 957, for newer players. A salary cap may or may not be included. See id. To hold that any of these items, or others that make up the mix in a particular sport, is merely a permissive subject of bargaining would ignore the reality of collective bargaining in sports.

Indeed, free agency is in many ways nothing but the flip side of the reserve system. A full reserve system does not eliminate individual bargaining between teams and players. It simply limits that bargaining to one team. If free agency were a permissive subject of collective bargaining, then so would be the reserve system.

With regard to salary arbitration, we will assume, but not decide, that if it is a form of interest arbitration, it may be unilaterally eliminated. See George Koch & Sons, Inc. , 306 N.L.R.B. 834, 839 (1992) (interest arbitration permissive subject of bargaining). Interest arbitration is a method by which an employer and union reach new agreements by sending disputed issues to an arbitrator rather than settling them through collective bargaining and economic force. See New York Typographical Union No. 6 v. Printers League , 919 F.2d 3 n.2 (2d Cir. 1990). The salary arbitration provisions of the Basic Agreement are a method by which salaries for some players who are not eligible for free agency -- those with three to six years of major league service -- are set. The Basic Agreement sets forth criteria by which the arbitrator is to reach a decision. These criteria include the player's performance in the prior year, the length and consistency of career contribution, physical or mental defects, recent performance of the team on the field and at the gate, and salaries of certain comparable players. The Basic Agreement also forbids the arbitrator from considering certain facts that might otherwise be relevant. Finally, the Basic Agreement requires that the arbitrator pick either the club's suggested salary or the player's.

We decline to analogize Article VI(f) of the Basic Agreement to interest arbitration. Salary arbitration provides limited discretion to the arbitrator to set salaries for designated players who are not eligible for free agency. The discretion afforded the arbitrator is arguably less than the discretion afforded arbitrators in grievance arbitration involving disputes arising under an existing collective agreement, which is beyond question a mandatory subject of bargaining. In grievance arbitration, an arbitrator may permissibly imply a term even though the term has no explicit support in the text of the collective agreement. See United Steelworkers of America v. Warrior & Gulf Navigation Co. , 363 U.S. 574, 581-82 (1960) ("The labor arbitrator's source of law is not confined to the express provisions of the contract, as the industrial common law -- the practices of the industry and the shop -- is equally a part of the collective bargaining agreement although not expressed in it."); see also Holly Sugar Corp. v. Distillery, Rectifying, Wine & Allied Workers Int'l Union , 412 F.2d 899, 903 (9th Cir. 1969). Similarly, a term may be implied from past practices even though somewhat inconsistent with the agreement. See International Chem. Workers Union, Local No. 278 v. Imco Container Co. , 78 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2014 (S.D. Ind. 1971). We thus decline to analogize salary arbitration to interest arbitration, and, therefore, we hold that there is reasonable cause to believe that it is a mandatory subject of bargaining.

With regard to whether the granting of relief was "just and proper," 29 U.S.C. § 160(j), we review the district court's determination only for abuse of discretion. Mego , 633 F.2d at 1030; Palby Lingerie , 625 F.2d at 1051. We see no such abuse in the present matter. Given the short careers of professional athletes and the deterioration of physical abilities through aging, the irreparable harm requirement has been met. The unilateral elimination of free agency and salary arbitration followed by just three days a promise to restore the status quo. The PRC decided to settle the original unfair labor practice charges while embarking on a course of action based on a fallacious view of the duty to bargain. We see no reason to relieve it of the consequences of that course.

We therefore affirm.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?