free credit report commercial lyrics car dot where can you get free credit report and score bad debt reporting to credit bureau credit report without mastercard information union obtain credit report judgment debtor 3 free credit reports score credit reports for businesses how to cancel annual credit report pays 31-60 days credit report understanding your credit report canada credit card reporting date how collection agencies report to credit bureaus one time 3 in 1 credit report number report stolen chase credit card capital one checking my credit report dispute inquiry my credit report often does credit report updates credco credit report login how long will foreclosure stay on my credit report letter to creditor disputing negative credit report how many business credit reporting agencies are there my credit reports online free credit report without membership ordering credit report someone else buy credit report score one time how long are charge offs on credit report clean up my credit report myself how does one get a copy of your credit report rental history credit reports remove negative credit items credit report credit report for job interview how to get a really free credit report ce credit report 24.95 address experian dispute credit report dispute experian credit report item most frequently used credit reporting agency how long is a bad debt on credit report uk update your experian credit report national credit reporting organizations 1 time free credit report s and p credit reports safe place get credit report free credit report transunion south africa 10 year old debt credit report can you get free credit report canada consumer what is the real free credit report website whats a good credit report score request my free annual credit report correct error my credit report how do youtube get a totally free credit report free credit report authorized federal government guarantees free annual credit report web site how to remove paid tax lien from credit report get paid collections removed credit report how often should i check my credit report quizzles credit report loan financial consumer agency canada understanding your credit report remove bad report credit report who is the singer in the free credit report commercials free credit report without paying dime get free yearly credit reports experian company credit report companies credit report chexsystems credit report credit suisse analyst report iphone number all three credit reporting agencies sallie mae credit reporting rules where to get all three credit reports get my one free credit report yearly ftc free report video annual credit free credit report from all 3 bureaus how do i order my transunion credit report building a better credit report federal trade commission change employment history on credit report get your free credit report online without a credit card cleaning up your own credit report free credit reporting free credit report commercial nostradamus lyrics free credit report report score how to find your credit score from your credit report privacy matters 123 free credit report how do i get a free credit report canada credit reporting agency limited truro fair credit reporting act consumer report definition credit report used auto insurance order credit report with fico score run credit report potential renters how to make a credit report fake credit report letter request annual free credit report gov i didn;t put a security freeze on my credit report experian business credit report uk contact collection agencies my credit report free credit report once a year aaa membership credit report sample letter request credit reports denied credit report equifax entitled sears credit report login get settled debt off credit report fix my credit report free request my free credit report mail does checking my credit report lower my score experian is annual credit report a legit site 3 credit score report order free copy credit report where to get your credit report free annual agencies 30 days free credit report and score annual credit report experian dispute collection account on credit report free credit report mail transunion can you buy home judgement your credit report can i get a free credit report how to send a letter to credit reporting agencies dispute information on equifax credit report number to call to get free credit report how to clear credit report quickly free credit report instantly experian credit report dispute forms define fair credit reporting free yearly credit report 2016 credit report act credit report reporting deceased family member i have no credit report get your credit report free mail complete best place purchase credit report best way to pull a credit report free credit reporting online number recent inquiries credit bureau report absolutely free credit report without credit cards needed see your credit report without credit card do creditors see credit report check business credit report canada suze orman where to get free credit report best credit score reporting fico free credit report commercials 2012 free credit reports from all three free credit report ads mislead consumers ftc credit report credit score canada free dispute credit report letter sample dispute inaccurate information credit report free credit report no credit cards credit report credit bureau can you get free credit report contacting credit bureau nj credit reporting laws federal government approved credit report certified reporting credit score how long do derogatory accounts stay on your credit report does checking your own credit report hurt my score mni credit report services contact number federal free credit report program on line free credit report free credit report underneath federal law been denied credit free report entitled does amazon store card report credit bureaus best sites to check credit report ftc identity theft credit report how to get rid of kd on credit report how often do credit card companies update credit report credit report before job interview order credit reports and scores how do you actually get a free credit report annual credit report request service atlanta ga get a free credit report australia the names of the largest credit reporting agencies remove credit report really free credit report credit report fix letters letter to remove paid item from credit report order free credit reports online free credit report yearly from the government understanding credit report terms how to get your free credit report every year transunion credit report address who can access my credit report uk what are three credit reporting agencies and why are they important how to remove collection agency from credit report obtaining a free copy of your credit report federal trade commision free annual credit report what credit report is used for auto loans correct employment information credit report chexsystems vs credit report free credit score fair credit reporting act cancel mni credit report experience credit report removing derogatory items from credit report canada i need to check my credit report for free get free copy your report online annual credit ordering free credit report mail how to read an equifax business credit report experian free credit report after being denied credit employment what is the best free credit report credit report judgement satisfied top 10 credit report sites best credit report sites reviewed what is a paid charge off on a credit report get 3 free credit reports all 3 credit reports and score free annual credit report governors website money laundering search my credit report experien credit report free credit report 3 one 3 free credit bureau report credit cards reporting how to free report credit score equifax free equifax credit report score remove tax lien from credit report my free government credit report the annual credit report website credit reporting service reviews who do i call to fix my credit report www credit reports com experian credit report definition credit report service best cleaning up credit report after foreclosure credit report debt to credit ratio best credit report repair service free credit report all three credit reporting agencies read cbc credit reports request copy credit report how do i find out what is on my credit report three credit bureaus reports scores want my yearly free credit report correct credit report problems bad credit report score free government credit report yearly what does transferred to recovery mean on my credit report free credit report vote new band obtain credit report for another person instant access credit reports abc financial credit report how do i get a free credit report each year free consumer credit report score free report ads credit check fha free credit report commercial pirates of the caribbean lyrics how to get your once a year free credit report usaa credit report promo code lender provide copy credit report is there a difference between credit score and credit report federal law free report credit check adding security alert to credit report free credit report due denied credit fcra get free report all 3 bureaus credit score credit report clean up companies lawsuit against credit reporting agencies how can i obtain a free credit report annualcreditreport credco credit report codes how to get free credit report for an online business report my rent to the credit bureaus understanding your credit report credit score government canada credit report 2 pounds annual credit report for free gov best report online free credit score totally free credit report without credit card 3 credit report phone numbers are payday loans reported to the credit bureau letter to remove inquiries from credit report quizzles report loan solutions credit how to fix a wrong credit report the fair credit reporting act summary sample letter to remove negative information from credit report how doo you get your free credit report each year free credit report letters dispute what is the real site to get a free credit report dispute items on credit report what is a beacon score on a credit report request free credit report form credit report all 4 bureaus do need check all three credit reports long does bad credit stay report canada how do i report debt to credit bureau consumer financial protection bureau credit reporting agencies monday citibank ems credit report us government credit report how to view equifax credit report again how long does debt management stay on credit report when does capital one report to credit agencies free credit report australia veda best way monitor credit report how long does credit card charge off stay on credit report free copy all 3 my credit reports employment credit report experian where do i go to get my free credit report annually determine credit score based credit report how to request credit report free buy all 3 credit reports scores only free credit annualcreditreport report get credit report uk sample how to dispute credit report collections transunion login credit report fair credit reporting act 15 usc 1681 how can i obtain a free credit report equifax get your credit reports mail how to update personal info on credit report nilson report credit card debt say disputing items credit report gateway credit union annual report 2010 veda credit check report annual credit reports from the government information credit report gathered what are the 3 credit reports consumer report credit repair agencies single bureau transunion? credit report with vantage score inaccurate credit report statistics define credit report credit union report of officials free credit reports all three bureaus can you fix a charge off on your credit report how to calculate credit score from credit report best place get free annual credit report only real free credit report monitoring wells fargo secured credit card reporting to credit bureaus online credit report india transunion free credit report login transunion canada credit report request all credit report agencies steinbach credit union annual report get free credit report without trial remove collections from credit report canada credit bureau reporting agency canada why do you have to pay for your credit report get your full credit report free federal law regarding free credit report trade summary credit report example credit monitoring consumer reports us gov credit report free how to get rid of defaults on your credit report annual credit report com reviews free credit report pirate commercial lyrics my free credit report trans union how do i report a delinquent account to a credit reporting agency sample letter challenge credit report disability and universal credit report bad credit report fifth third bank credit report get my free credit report without using credit card free credit report government phone number craigslist scams asking for credit report i want to look at my credit report for free can i get a dismissed bankruptcy off my credit report corporate credit report canada tips to improve credit report get free copy credit report online does checking hurt score own credit report equifax free credit report phone number pnc bank credit report official annual credit report example letter request credit report disputing credit report us federal government credit report make sure free credit report not accurate 4th credit reporting agencies opt out credit report fico fair credit reporting act credit reporting laws new york free credit report no credit card information bills get free trans union credit report how long does bankruptcy stay on credit report credit report all three bureau experian 3 credit bureaus report how to get a credit report on someone else how to request a free credit report in canada privacy act credit reporting agencies free experian credit report colorado credit agricole group annual report 2010 new free credit report commercial 2011 free credit score and report all 3 transunion 3 in 1 credit report plus fico where can i buy all three credit reports free annual credit report maine federal government yearly credit report request your free your yearly free credit reports all three credit bureau reports free transunion credit reports online get free copy all three credit reports new jersey resident free credit report free report government online credit scores what is the actual free credit report website credit report for uk companies yearly free credit report from experian how to view your credit report online credit report fico score 3 16 how do you fix credit report errors how to contest things on your credit report consumer credit information report india my free yearly report online credit scores dispute hard inquiries credit report completely free credit reports and scores transunion credit report online free credit report ben stein cancel free credit report online experian quizzle credit report accuracy trans union credit reporting mailing address fair credit reporting act colorado free credit report with score gov how to improve your credit report free improving credit report scores credit report with three fico scores fastest reporting unsecured credit cards free usa credit report removing bankruptcy from credit report after 7 years how long does it take a chapter 7 bankruptcy to come off a credit report 3 free credit score report view credit report line consumer credit reports small business database read transunion employment credit report trw free credit report online free credit report all 3 bureaus score credit suisse reports 2011 fair credit reporting act definition of consumer reporting agency best place to monitor credit report 2011 credit card facts & statistics - free infographic report disputing transunion credit reports online yearly credit reports for free long does take get credit report mail canada request credit reports phone get free credit report all three bureaus how do you obtain a free credit report my yearly free credit reports transunion rebate report if denied credit letter requesting copy credit report free credit report gov fico score real free credit report annual free annual credit report ohio order all 3 credit reports phone legal employer request credit report what roller coaster is in the free credit report commercial annual credit report.com scams how long does it take for a debt to be removed from your credit report police report for stolen credit cards annual credit report service request po get free credit report all 3 does credit report list previous addresses get credit report online now request your free fcac understanding your credit report and credit score government free credit report site rebuild your credit report capital one doesn;t report credit limit free credit reports with fico scores all 3 credit reports free what does kd mean on my experian credit report how to remove a satisfied judgement from credit report free financial report if denied credit transunion annual free credit report equifax credit reporting agency fair credit reporting act under section how to get a collection taken off your credit report how do you get a truly free credit report run my credit report annual report credit suisse annual credit report government i get my free free credit report with no credit card required score check citi credit report login corelogic credit report free credit report songs download transunion credit report dispute online how doo you get your one free credit report per year fair credit reporting act annual credit report fedral new free credit report site free credit history report australia free us government credit reports phone number all credit report dispute project report on credit rating in india how to fix your credit report when does discover card report to credit bureau suze orman credit report free annual report what exactly shows up on your credit report annual free credit report check how to dispute a debt on my credit report getting a free credit report in canada credit report by mail canada often cane you check your credit report free can get car loan repo my credit report cards reporting free credit free report all 3 bureaus without card credit score 3 free credit report and score new free credit report song 2012 what is the phone numbers to the credit bureau for credit reports check your credit score report no credit card free credit report canada free credit report good bad canadian credit report free can really get free credit report only real free credit report experian address free credit report personal info credit report how to update personal information on credit report should you lock your credit report my free credit report usaa phone number call get free credit report credit card debt not on credit report free credit report gov site best place to get a credit report online experian free credit report customer service experian credit report help centre absolutely free credit report score online correct false info credit report how do you dispute a judgement on your credit report dispute transunion credit report getting items removed from credit report can i get credit report from bank statutory credit report from experian
Home BoB Documents 1900 - 1960 1953 - Toolson v New York Yankees

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1146 guests online

Atom RSS

1953 - Toolson v New York Yankees PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 15
PoorBest 
1900 - 1960
Written by Court Ruling   
Monday, 29 November 1999 19:00

U.S. Supreme Court

TOOLSON v. NEW YORK YANKEES, 346 U.S. 356 (1953)

346 U.S. 356

TOOLSON v. NEW YORK YANKEES, INC. ET AL.
CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT. *  
No. 18.
Argued October 13, 1953.
Decided November 9, 1953.

 

The judgments in these cases are affirmed on the authority of Federal Baseball Club of Baltimore v. National League of Professional Baseball Clubs, 259 U.S. 200 , so far as that decision determines that Congress had no intention of including the business of baseball within the scope of the federal antitrust laws. Pp. 356-357.

200 F.2d 198, 202 F.2d 413, 428, affirmed.

 

[ Footnote * ] Together with No. 23, Kowalski v. Chandler, Commissioner of Baseball, et al., argued October 13-14, 1953, and No. 25, Corbett et al. v. Chandler, Commissioner of Baseball, et al., argued October 14, 1953, both on certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.

 

Howard C. Parke argued the cause for petitioner in No. 18. With him on the brief was Gene M. Harris.

 

Frederic A. Johnson argued the cause for petitioner in No. 23 and Seymour Martinson argued the cause for petitioners in No. 25. With them on the briefs were Maurice H. Koodish and Edward Martinson.

 

Norman S. Sterry argued the cause and filed a brief for respondents in No. 18.

Raymond T. Jackson argued the cause for respondents in Nos. 23 and 25. With him on the briefs were Benjamin F. Fiery and Louis F. Carroll.

 

Thomas Reed Powell filed a brief for the Boston American League Base Ball Company in No. 18, as amicus curiae, urging affirmance.

 

PER CURIAM.

 

 

Affirmed.

 

In 1952 the Subcommittee on Study of Monopoly Power, of the House of Representatives Committee on the Judiciary, after extended hearings, issued a report dealing with organized baseball in relation to the Sherman Act. In that report it said:

 

"`Organized baseball' is a combination of approximately 380 separate baseball clubs, operating in 42 different States, the District of Columbia, Canada, Cuba, and Mexico . . . .

. . . . .

 

In the Federal Baseball Club case the Court did not state that even if the activities of organized baseball amounted to interstate trade or commerce those activities were exempt from the Sherman Act. The Court acted on its determination that the activities before it did not amount to interstate commerce. The Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, in that case, in 1920, described a major league baseball game as "local in its beginning and in its end." 4 This Court stated that "The business is giving exhibitions of base ball, which are purely state affairs," and the transportation of players and equipment between states "is a mere incident . . . ." 5 The main thrust of the argument of counsel for organized baseball, both in the Court of Appeals and in this Court, was in support of that proposition. 6 Although counsel did argue that the activities of organized baseball, even if amounting to interstate commerce, did not violate the Sherman Act, 7 the Court significantly refrained from expressing its opinion on that issue.

 

 

The 1952 report of the Congressional Subcommittee previously mentioned also said:

"Under judicial interpretations of this constitutional provision [the commerce clause], the Congress has power to investigate, and pass legislation dealing with professional baseball, or more particularly `organized baseball,' if that business is, or affects, interstate commerce.

. . . . .

 

 

Footnotes

[ Footnote 1 ] Federal Baseball Club v. National League, 259 U.S. 200 .

 

[ Footnote 2 ] Compare Paul v. Virginia, 8 Wall. 168, and Hooper v. California, 155 U.S. 648 , with United States v. South-Eastern Underwriters Assn., 322 U.S. 533 , and Lorain Journal Co. v. United States, 342 U.S. 143 . See also, Times-Picayune Publishing Co. v. United States, 345 U.S. 594 ; United States v. National Assn. of Real Estate Boards, 339 U.S. 485 ; United States v. Crescent Amusement Co., 323 U.S. 173 ; American Medical Assn. v. United States, 317 U.S. 519 .

 

[ Footnote 3 ] H. R. Rep. No. 2002, 82d Cong., 2d Sess. 4, 5.

 

"The primary sources of revenue for baseball clubs are admissions, radio and television, and concessions. The following table indicates the combined revenue of the 16 major-league clubs from these sources for the years 1929, 1939, and 1950.

"Major league revenue

"[In thousands of dollars] --------------------------------------------------------------------- "Source of revenue 1929 1. 1939 1950 --------------------------------------------------------------------- Home games ................... 6,559.1 6,766.6 18,334.8 Road games ................... 2,221.4 2,320.2 4,517.8 Exhibition games ............. 422.6 515.7 911.5 Radio and television ......... 0 884.5 3,365.5 Concessions (net) ............ 582.8 850.3 2,936.3 Other ........................ 733.4 776.0 1,969.6 -------------------------------------- Gross receipts .......... 10,519.5 12,113.3 32,035.5 ---------------------------------------------------------------------

 

"1. Data unavailable for 2 clubs: Chicago, American League; and Pittsburgh, National League.

. . . . .

"The fastest-growing source of revenue for major league clubs is radio and television. Receipts from these media of interstate commerce were nonexistent in 1929. In 1939, 7.3 percent of the clubs' revenue came from this source; and in 1950, this share rose to 10.5 percent.

 

"Portrayed in absolute terms, the growing importance of radio and television becomes even more pronounced. Receipts rose from nothing in 1929 to $884,500 in 1939 and $3,365,500 in 1950. Reported income from primary radio and television contracts for 1951 indicate that this sharp increase is continuing. . . . To this must be added $110,000 for the sale of radio and television rights to the 1951 all-star game and $1,075,000 for the sale of similar rights to the 1951 world series." Id., at 5-6.

 

[ Footnote 4 ] National League v. Federal Baseball Club, 50 App. D.C. 165, 169, 269 F. 681, 685.

 

[ Footnote 5 ] 259 U.S., at 208 , 209.

 

[ Footnote 6 ] See brief for appellants in the Court of Appeals, pp. 45-67; brief for defendants in error in this Court, pp. 45-66.

 

[ Footnote 7 ] See brief for appellants in Court of Appeals, pp. 68-72; brief for defendants in error in this Court, pp. 66-72.

 

[ Footnote 8 ] Hart v. Keith Vaudeville Exchange, 262 U.S. 271, 274 , and see North American Co. v. S. E. C., 327 U.S. 686, 694 .

 

[ Footnote 9 ] In opposing approval of four exclusionary bills then pending, the Subcommittee did not take the stand that organized baseball and other comparable sports, although constituting interstate trade or commerce, already are exempt from the broad coverage of the Sherman Act. On the contrary, it said:

 

 

[ Footnote 10 ] "The reserve clause is popularly believed to be some provision in the player contract which gives to the club in organized baseball which first signs a player a continuing and exclusive right to his services. Commissioner Frick testified that this popular understanding was essentially correct. He pointed out, however, that the reserve clause is not merely a provision in the contract, but also incorporates a reticulated system of rules and regulations which enable, indeed require, the entire baseball organization to respect and enforce each club's exclusive and continuous right to the services of its players." H. R. Rep. No. 2002, 82d Cong., 2d Sess. 111. See also, Section VII, The Reserve Clause, id., at 111-139, and Gardella v. Chandler, 172 F.2d 402.

 

In No. 18 the following specific allegations appear and those in No. 23 are comparable:

"XI.

 

"That the Defendants, and each of them, have entered into or agreed to be bound by a contract in the restraint of Interstate Commerce; that said contract is designated as the Major-Minor League Agreement, dated December 6, 1946, and provides in effect that:

 

"1. All players' contracts in the Major Leagues shall be of one form and that all players' contracts in the Minor Leagues shall be of one form.

 

"2. That all players' contracts in any league must provide that the Club or any assignee thereof shall have the option to renew the player's contract each year and that the player shall not play for any other club but the club with which he has a contract or the assignee thereof.

 

.

"4. That the player shall be bound by any assignment of his contract by the club, and that his remuneration shall be the same as that usually paid by the assignee club to other players of like ability.

 

"5. That there shall be no negotiations between a player and any other club from the one which he is under contract or reservation respecting employment either present or prospective unless the Club with which the player is connected shall have in writing expressly authorized such negotiations prior to their commencement.

 

"6. That in the case of Major League players, the Commissioner of Baseball and in the case of Minor League players, the President of the National Association, may determine that the best interests of the game require a player to be declared ineligible and, after such declaration, no club shall be permitted to employ him unless he shall have been reinstated from the ineligible list.

 

"7. That an ineligible player whose name is omitted from a reserve list shall not thereby be rendered eligible for service unless and until he has applied for and been granted reinstatement.

 

"8. That any player who violates his contract or reservation, or who participates in a game with or against a club containing or controlled by ineligible players or a player under indictment for conduct detrimental to the good repute of professional baseball, shall be considered an ineligible player and placed on the ineligible list.

 

"9. That an ineligible player must be reinstated before he may be released from his contract.

 

"10. That clubs shall not tender contracts to ineligible players until they are reinstated.

 

"11. That no club may release unconditionally an ineligible player unless such player is first reinstated from the ineligible list to the active list.

. . . . .

"XIII.

 

 

The complaint also contains a separate cause of action alleging that the defendants, by virtue of their agreements, have entered into a combination and conspiracy in the restraint of trade or commerce among the several states, and another cause of action alleging that the defendants have, by their agreements, combined to monopolize professional baseball in the United States.

[ Footnote 11 ] E. g., Congress has expressly exempted certain specific activities from the Sherman Act, as in 6 of the Clayton Act, 38 Stat. 731, 15 U.S.C. 17 (labor organizations), in the Capper-Volstead Act, 42 Stat. 388-389, 7 U.S.C. 291, 292 (farm cooperatives), and in the McCarran-Ferguson Act, 59 Stat. 34, 61 Stat. 448, 15 U.S.C. (Supp. V) 1013 (insurance). And see Apex Hosiery Co. v. Leader, 310 U.S. 469, 501 , 512. [346 U.S. 356, 366] 
 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?