free reward credit cards canada chase amazon credit card help applied bank visa business card credit limit top credit cards for students 2013 lowest interest rate credit card philippines can get secured credit card bad credit does paypal accept virtual visa debit cards easiest credit card approval singapore target visa card login credit card scanner application visa black card reviews shoppers drug mart credit card online credit card account number location leaving canada credit card debt free credit card report annual instant long term loans online indusind bank credit cards review who is liable to pay advance tax royal bank visa card exchange rate chevron gas credit card review us credit card for non residents united mileage plus credit card comparison does discover offer a secured credit card best credit card in canada for travel rewards hdfc credit card payment options neft how do they catch credit card fraudsters the best gas credit card rewards and offers 0 apr credit card explained credit cards for good credit what credit cards are owned by mbna hilton credit card authorization form new york student credit card with high limits td canada trust visa travel card apply for walmart mastercard online canada credit card machine rental one day paypal credit card cash advance fee visa cash card avoid cash advance fees credit card visa credit card account number pc financial mastercard credit card contact art van ge credit card payment cash advance loans direct lender no teletrack new direct payday loan lenders 2013 new york and company credit card secure login choosing a credit card processor and drawing some conclusions best usaa credit card for bad credit best time to sign up for credit card capital one credit card uk customer services valero business gas credit card next pay loans bad credit list of catalogues for bad credit starbucks platinum card 2013 best credit card limits cash advance credit card chase capital credit card secured business credit cards without personal guarantee best secured credit cards for very bad credit paypal accept credit cards on website credit card application declined reasons philippines psn credit card information stolen chase credit card approval time hsbc bank apply online for credit card american express platinum travel credit card annual fee western union prepaid credit cards visa best marriott rewards credit card offer facebook account verification credit card business credit card comparison 2012 firestone credit card balance how do visa cash advances work natwest credit card services locked out aadvantage credit card offer 2013 top gas rewards credit card platinum credit card natwest review credit card scanner for laptop paypal can you transfer money from credit card to current account call sears credit card services compare travel miles credit cards toys r us credit card customer service phone number how does a credit card work credit card apply online in chennai first time home loans with bad credit what are the best credit cards to transfer a balance credit card apply now average credit card processing fees for restaurants credit card reader app for windows phone hdfc credit card settlement process india chase bank credit card loans best rewards credit cards 2013 canada how to apply for a hsbc credit card in the philippines average credit card rate uk td visa card expires credit cards for bad credit with no security deposit huntington bank credit card processing is it easy to apply for target credit card apply visa credit card online india best buy credit card no interest for 18 months fake visa credit card number with security code direct payday loans online uk visa card exchange rates india credit card business in india ppt mophie marketplace credit card reader for intuit gopayment iphone 4 fake credit card verification code generator rbc visa cash card granite credit card online login 70 000 mile american express delta credit card cash loans today halo reach credit limit offline secure credit card canada hsbc premier credit card charges abroad ann taylor credit card payment loft best credit card points blog apply for wells fargo student credit card apple credit card reader reviews how to get a bad credit mortgage loan credit card credit score needed personal loans with bad credit in georgia how to get pre approved credit card offers in the mail jcpenney online credit card payment login best small business credit card credit card apr average best credit cards for college students 2013 5000 cash loans for bad credit student credit card for students with bad credit icici credit card helpline india make a payment on bank of america credit cards barclays credit card payment machine which credit card is best in india 2011 credit card apps instant decision credit cards india navy federal credit union jobs paypal credit card account login virgin credit cards uk credit card loan calculator excel american express cash back business cards poor credit rating credit cards uk visa credit card with no annual fee and rewards track sbi credit card status best visa credit card 2013 discover card credit score tracker credit card rewards comparison malaysia contact capital one credit cards barclays apple credit card log in natwest world credit card rewards pay sears credit card with gift card apr 0 credit card offers annual fee free credit cards australia american express platinum travel credit card offers india credit card review philippines cash advance payday loans bad credit ok sygma bank uk creation credit card mastercard annual credit report no credit card credit card finder google best credit card abroad 2011 how do i calculate monthly interest on a credit card what credit cards are good for rebuilding credit what are the best reward credit card programs best travel rewards credit card for small business how to apply for credit card online black card magazine home depot credit card services number chase credit card help college students and credit cards debt airline credit card promotions 2013 british airways credit card deal i want to apply for a orchard bank credit card apply for unsecured credit card with no credit can i apply for a walmart credit card and use it the same day southwest airlines credit card for business hdfc credit card reviews india how long does it take to get credit card once approved hdfc gold credit card travel offers rewards cards australia united airlines credit card good deal credit one visa credit card for bad credit american airlines best credit card deal will a secured credit card help rebuild my credit travel rewards credit cards for good credit how can i increase my chase freedom credit limit credit card machine for iphone reviews disney world credit card login accept credit cards free terminal debt settlement letter to credit card company most popular credit cards uk apple square credit card reader canada balance transfer credit cards for bad credit best credit card processing for very small business how do i apply for a prepaid mastercard alaska airlines credit card canada companion ticket ?5000 loan with bad credit and no guarantor what banks offer visa debit cards canada application status for icici credit card credit card fraud detection system download direct lender online payday loans no credit check credit card charges overseas how do i get a credit card with a high limit barclays platinum card terms and conditions the bay hbc credit card what types of credit cards are issued by american express can you get a loan to pay off credit card debt bad credit card offers best travel rewards credit card bonus best first credit card for young adults with no credit cibc credit card login best card to transfer credit card balance payday loan lenders uk bad credit same day payday loans direct lenders gas credit card for fair credit priceline visa rewards card payment cheapest credit card for overseas purchases best airmiles credit card canada 2010 o2 prepaid credit card ireland hsbc credit cards and ppi itunes credit card fraud can a credit card company garnish your wages in georgia average credit card limit uk apply credit card online best cash reward credit card hdfc credit card loan offers need to apply for a credit card with bad credit how to receive credit card payments on ebay best online cash advances reviews how to calculate monthly interest on credit card balance can you use reloadable visa cards online how do i stop credit card applications credit card bin number search travel credit cards review canada best secured credit cards to rebuild credit 2012 canada capital one online credit card payment credit card 0 balance transfer ireland instant cash loans online south africa free credit score check uk no credit card sbi visa debit card application form pdf credit cards numbers and security code free that work what is the best credit card to have for cash back how to pay credit card bill online cibc low interest rate credit card in india discount tire ge credit card free credit card 100 guaranteed payday loan lenders hsbc premier credit card rewards uk best cashback credit card 2012 singapore credit card number and security code free american express corporate credit card application secured credit cards for bad credit 2013 walmart credit card reviews 2011 wireless credit card machine india free credit report gov uk interest free balance transfer credit card australia secured business credit card 2012 chase freedom card credit limits best credit card promotions in singapore secured canadian credit cards for bad credit best no foreign transaction fee credit cards 2013 standard chartered credit card customer care credit card reader for android phone reviews how does a credit card work in india halifax clarity credit card foreign exchange rate black cardboard boxes nz activate capital one credit card uk credit card cash advance fees explained cash advance payday loan lenders paypal canada credit card fees sbi credit card balance transfer calculator chase advantage credit card login bad credit cards canada travel credit cards australia visa credit cards no credit history shell credit card login in apply for credit cards to rebuild bad credit average credit card processing fees 2012 pay loft ann taylor credit card student credit card for students with no credit history analysis on credit card fraud detection methods low rate balance transfer credit cards australia what age should i get a credit card is closing a credit card bad for your credit score freedom credit card $250 bonus average merchant credit card fees hsbc credit card application form united credit card bonus points american airlines credit card foreign transaction fee credit card bad credit no deposit instant approval best student credit cards 2012 no credit can a credit card company garnish my tax refund capital one prepaid credit card uk canadian travel rewards credit card comparison bad credit loan no broker citibank credit card offers halifax credit card minimum payment calculator westpac credit card insurance claim form best credit card for purchases uk united air miles credit card uk what credit card can i get with poor credit how to prevent credit card fraud in hotels low interest credit cards for good credit chase credit card limit increase request axis bank credit card visa verification vanilla visa card gift card best credit cards to use in the uk chase credit card secure login visa online credit card generator how do i pay icici credit card bill online how do i pay jcpenney credit card online fee free credit cards compare credit card interest rates canada chase request credit limit increase best credit cards bad credit 2012 household credit card login page what is the best description of a credit card top canadian student credit cards home loans with bad credit rating the best prepaid credit cards in canada payday advance cash converters cape town best uk credit cards direct payday lenders no fees fake credit card numbers for testing with cvv personal loans online decision circuit city credit card chase login best credit cards with lowest interest rates free credit card numbers that work 2013 with cvv and expiration date do company credit cards affect credit how many major credit card issuers are there prepaid credit card paypal uk walmart 24 month interest free credit card use us credit card in uk psn how to get credit card numbers with pin neiman marcus credit card payment phone mastercard credit card numbers leaked best balance transfer credit cards 2011 loans pay back weekly credit card bad credit instant decision amazon credit card interest free period pay my us bank credit card bill pnb credit card application form unsecured credit loans for bad credit how to create hdfc virtual credit card government loans to consolidate credit card debt citi aadvantage credit card benefits bad credit personal loans uk lenders credit card fraud punishment in florida icici coral credit card apply online top canadian credit cards 2013 pay monthly catalogues for bad credit i need a credit card to rebuild my credit how to get business credit cards with bad personal credit walmart apply for credit card get off pre-approved credit card list best way to consolidate debt of credit cards credit card for no credit delta credit card offer 50000 free credit card applications for no credit secured credit card credit union guaranteed credit card approval with bad credit best visa credit card offers 2013 best credit card machine for small business uk fast payday loans online direct lenders hdfc credit card helpline kerala sbi credit card cash loan offer hdfc credit cards offers and deals shell gas company credit cards what is a credit card cash advance fee credit card protection plans worth is there a grace period for chase credit card payments free credit card processing software guaranteed credit card approval canada pay tesco online credit card cash loans today no credit check cash advance loans bad credit best canadian cash back credit cards sbi credit card reward points redemption catalogue increasing chase freedom credit limit best corporate credit cards canada best cashback credit cards uk free credit card app for windows phone stop american airlines credit card offers large credit card debt help going over credit limit chase best low interest business credit card easy online payday loans credit card number format in india paying off credit card debt template nedbank visa credit card travel insurance american express credit card offer opt out capital one student credit card does best buy accept visa debit cards online best credit card offers for international travel vanilla mastercard gift card uk ace payday loans reviews are credit card balance transfers a good idea hdfc online credit card payment help desk hsbc visa credit card verification how to consolidate credit card debt yourself american express platinum card consumer finance college students and credit cards barclays credit card online sign in barclay credit card toll free number how to apply for emi in hdfc credit card td canada trust visa international phone number chase credit card cash advance charges hdfc credit card payment types do i need a credit card to open an itunes account citibank american airlines credit card benefits mba credit cards uk rfid credit card protector canada best travel insurance credit cards canada 0 balance transfer credit cards ireland schnucks stores credit card fraud where can i use my go mastercard american express platinum card travel online apply for sbi credit cards in india credit card comparison malaysia 2013 walmart credit card approval time credit score needed for walmart discover card mortgages for bad credit northern ireland chase visa credit card no annual fee does it hurt your credit to apply for multiple credit cards visa credit card charges merchant credit card abroad nationwide chase credit cards login prepaid credit card bank of america best airmiles credit card canada 2011 standard chartered credit card reward points redeem orchard bank credit card bad credit credit card history in the philippines completely free prepaid credit card can i get a chase credit card in canada visa credit cards for college students best small business credit card processor hdfc credit card offer on yatra prepaid visa debit cards uk online bad credit loan direct lenders does applying for a secured credit card hurt your credit discovery credit card fees list of bad credit loan lenders credit cards accepted at neiman marcus stores secured credit card no annual fee no application fee credit card online services rbs va home loans with bad credit high credit limit credit cards in india hsbc balance transfer existing customer anz design my card visa debit online credit card generator with cvv and expiration date 2013 bp gas rebate credit cards metrobank credit card online application form square credit card reader iphone 3gs credit card low interest no annual fee best zero percent balance transfer credit card offers nationwide visa credit card exchange rate credit cards no annual fee no foreign transaction fee pay american airlines citi credit card free virtual credit card us bank of america unsecured credit card for bad credit tata sbi credit card helpline disney chase visa credit card compare frequent flyer credit cards australia credit card verification form sample credit card machines for small business costco go compare interest free credit cards best secured credit card after bankruptcy discharge what is your card number on a visa debit card belk credit card services phone number cibc mastercard credit card login does bad credit affect company credit card how 0 purchase credit cards work prepaid credit card no transaction fee credit card offer on flipkart the risks of transferring a car loan to a credit card where can i get credit card numbers best iphone credit card app what;s the best small business credit card icici gold credit card limit citi vs discover student credit cards icici instant credit card payment best credit card reward points australia paypal credit card reader where to buy hsbc cash advance calculator bank of america credit card instant decision calculating credit card apr formula lloyds tsb platinum purchase credit card walmart credit card a paypal not accepting indian credit cards anz low interest credit card nz walmart store credit card reviews how to get refund on cancelled credit card best credit cards for fair to bad credit guaranteed bad credit car finance capital one unsecured credit cards credit card rate calculator interest why is it so hard to get a credit card today authorize.net ipad credit card reader student credit cards natwest business credit card offers us bank visa rewards card activation bad credit rating credit cards instant decision credit cards no interest no payments top private label credit card issuers best travel reward credit card canada sign up for a credit card no credit loans in el paso tx best credit card with 0 percent interest
Home Maury Brown Breaking Down How Salary Arbitration Functions in MLB

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 900 guests online

Atom RSS

Breaking Down How Salary Arbitration Functions in MLB PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 62
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 30 January 2009 17:09

A Biz of Baseball Original ArticleEach year, hundreds of millions of dollars are doled out to players that are part of the salary arbitration process in Major League Baseball. This year, 111 eligible players filed for salary arbitration, and by mid-February all of them will have reached new contracts either through negotiations with their respective clubs, or through rulings by an arbitration panel.

While many have heard of the process, the details aren’t widely published. With arbitration season in MLB in full swing, here’s a breakdown of the process.

History

Many have said that the breaking of the Reserve Clause is the greatest advancement for the players, but Marvin Miller, the former executive director for the MLB Players Association, has said that salary arbitration did more for advancing the salaries and rights of the players.

Before 1973, players were offered a contract by the clubs they played for, and it was a matter of “take it, or leave it.” In an attempt to challenge the Reserve Clause, as well as leverage higher salaries in this system, players began conducting holdouts on contract renewals. The owners, and then commissioner Bowie Kuhn, realizing the wolves were at the door, opted to allow salary arbitration as a way of stopping the holdouts, and rationalized that in the long run, stop free agency. Only Charlie Finley of the A’s and Dick Meyers of the Cardinals voted in opposition of salary arbitration.

“We’ll be the nation’s biggest assholes if we do this,” Finley said at the time. “You can’t win. You’ll have guys with no baseball background setting salaries. You’ll have a system that drives up the average salary every year. Give them anything they want, but don’t give them [salary] arbitration.”

Meyers, who had experience in arbitration, said it more darkly, “This will be baseball’s ruin.” 1

In this new system, players with over 2 years of major league system could file for salary arbitration, if they were not under long-term contract. If the sides could not come to a contract agreement within a period of time, the club would submit a salary figure for the coming season that they felt the player was worth, while the player would do like wise. If the sides could not reach agreement with the figures submitted, the parties could go before arbitors from the National Labor Relations Board and present their case. The arbitors would then rule on one figure or the other. There would be no middle ground.

The system remains much the same, with a panel of three arbitrators ruling on salary cases.

How the Sides Have Fared

As was often the case, Charlie Finley was right. It was not the doom that Meyers predicted, but players almost exclusively come out ahead.

To date, of the 485 cases that have gone to arbitration hearing, the owners have won 280, while the players have won 208. But, the owners haven’t truly won. Of the 110 players that filed for salary arbitration last season, their average salary increased 120 percent from $1.38 million to $3.04 million. Ryan Howard saw his pay jump 1,011 percent from the year prior when he won his case before the arbitration panel going from $900,000 to $10 million.

Understandably, players and their clubs work to reach agreements in advance of hearings. This year (as it has often been in the past) the deals reached have mostly been 1-year agreements with the base salary for the player being below the mid-point between the club offering and player asking figure (to date, only John Maine’s contract is exactly between the Mets’ offering salary and his asking figure while Justin Duchscherer sees a salary $100,000 higher than the mid-point between the A’s and his figures). Still, with 46 players exchanging figures, 13 contracts that have been reached by players and clubs after salary figures were exchanged (Nick Markakis, Zack Greinke, Maicer Izturis, Jason Kubel, Melkey Cabrera, Justin Duchscherer, Geoff Geary, Wandy Rodriguez, Prince Fielder, Chad Durbin, Jayson Werth, John Maine, and Brian Bruney) sees average salary increase from 2008 to 2009 is 257 percent. In total (single year, and multi-year contracts) these 13 alone account for $151,910,000 in salaries.

As the stakes have grown ever higher, the number of cases that have gone all the way to hearing have dropped. In 1973, the first year of salary arbitration in MLB, 29 cases were heard with the owners winning 16 cases, and players winning 13. Since then, the highwater mark has been 1986 when 35 cases were heard (owners won 20 cases to the players 15). As recently as 2005, only 3 cases were heard (all pitchers): Kyle Lohse and the Twins, Jeremy Affeldt and the Royals, Juan Cruz and the Athletics.

A Peek Inside How Salary Hearings Function

The criteria by which salary arbitration cases are presented are part of the CBA, although from talking to a baseball man that has made a living a salary arbitration for nearly every club, while it is outlined in the CBA, most anything is permissible at hearing, it’s just that what is presented can be easily challenged and undermine your case, should the information presented fall far outside the CBA’s criteria.

Player Comparison – The sides are allowed to use other players with like ML service time as a comparison to make their case. The CBA expresses this as “Major League service not exceeding one annual service group above the Player’s annual service group.”

Player Comparison (Look Backs) – While using a player with more ML service time as a comparison in terms of 2009 salary to 2009 salary, the sides can do a “look back”. So, for example, using Albert Pujols’ numbers and salary for 2009 would not be acceptable in Ryan Howard’s case, but using Pujols’ figures when he had the same ML service time that Howard now has is permissible.

Contract Comparison – In nearly every instance, one-year contracts are used in hearing. Multi-year contracts are not used as they have different structures – frontloaded, backloaded, etc. So, using a 2009 salary figure in a mult-year contract creates issues as the single year salary could be influenced by the overall contract structure.

Position Comparison – For practicality purposes, comparing players at like positions are used. Clearly, attempting to compare a middle infielder to a catcher would not hold much weight with the panel. However, instances of comparing corner outfielders has been used.

Does Advanced Sabermetrics Come Into Play? – As Finley crudely noted, the arbitration panels are not “baseball people”. Therefore, advanced metrics are normally not employed in the hearing process. OBP, OPS, and even OPS+ are making their way into cases being presented, but for the most part, the stats that have filled the boxscores for years are the bread and butter in salary cases.

Intangibles – Clearly, the player’s performance on the field is the largest factor in determining whether the club or player figure is selected in a salary arbitration hearing, but it is not the only one, special qualities of leadership and “public appeal” can be used. A good example is last year when Ryan Howard's team was able to use a "special accomplishments" provision that allowed them to compare players outside of Howard's service time window. This, however, is rarely done. The exception appears to be pitchers, where agents have been able to make a case that on the day their player pitched, attendance and television ratings were higher. The most notable case was when Dick Moss represented Fernando Valenzuela citing “Fernandomania”.

Injuries – The sides can use injuries (or the lack of them) at hearing. A player that has been on the DL more often than a comparative player can be used by management to make their case for the lower offering figure by a club.

What is Not Admissible in Hearing? – The following outlines what is not allowed at salary arbitration hearing, as defined by the current CBA:

(i) The financial position of the Player and the Club;

(ii) Press comments, testimonials or similar material bearing on the performance of either the Player or the Club, except that recognized annual Player awards for playing excellence shall not be excluded;

(iii) Offers made by either Player or Club prior to arbitration;

(iv) The cost to the parties of their representatives, attorneys, etc.;

(v) Salaries in other sports or occupations.

Salary Arbitration and How it Influences MLB

As mentioned at the outset, salary arbitration almost exclusively benefits the players. Contract agreements have been reached outside the door of the hearing room just before a case is going to be presented to the arbitration panel. Hundreds of millions of dollars will be doled out to these players, with nearly all of them seeing massive pay increases. As one team executive said when asked what he liked about salary arbitration, “What’s there to like about it?” Ask the players.

1 – Finley and Meyer quotes from Lords of the Realm by John Helyar

UPDATED SALARY ARBITRATION NEWS

As of publication today, two more salary arbitration eligible players reached deals with their clubs.

Starting pitcher John Maine reached a 1-year, $2.6 million deal with the New York Mets. The right-hander can earn an additional $25,000 if he pitches 200 or more innings. Maine pulled in $450,000 last season so his raise from 2008 to his 2009 figure as a first year salary arbitration eligible player is 478 percent. He had been seeking $3 million while the Mets were offering $2.2 million in salary arbitration. His $2.6 million salary for 2009 is at exactly the mid-point between the two figures.

Reliever Brian Bruney and the New York Yankees reached a 1-year, $1.25 million agreement today, thus avoiding arbitration. Bruney had been seeking $1.55 million while the Yankees were offering $1.1 million. His $1.25 million for 2009 is $75,000 below the mid-point for the two figures. This is Bruney’s first year of salary arbitration eligibility. Last season he made $725,000. His raise to $1.25 million is a 72 percent increase from last season.

FOR MORE ON SALARY ARBITRATION:

Salary Arbitration Filings Tracker

Salary Arbitration Figures Tracker

Arbitration Scorecard


Maury BrownMaury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer. Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

Don't forget to register and log in on The Biz of Baseball site to get updates via your in-box, and see information only logged in members can see.

Subscribe to The Biz of Baseball

Add to GoogleAdd to My Yahoo!

Subscribe in Bloglines


 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?