federal law regarding free credit reports do disputes show on credit report view your credit report freeware once year get your credit report freeware canada transunion credit report agency address identity theft report to credit bureau what is the highest score on a credit report transunion credit report for business free credit report 3 companies fixing your credit report yourself how to build how to establish credit history in canada totally free credit report no credit card needed gov annual credit reports free how to remove irs tax lien from credit report ordering equifax credit report phone 3 free credit reports experian credit report free trial other guys free credit report com commercial violette disputing items on my credit report best credit score reporting company dispute where do you get a free credit report online what is the best website to get a free credit report one credit report free per year how much does a credit report cost credit repair solutions llc often does equifax update credit reports true credit report.com review free credit report dot band wiki how to cancel credit report from transunion fair credit reporting act dispute letters remove paid collection from credit report letter credit repair best airline airline miles credit cards reviews my one free credit report per year get free credit report all bureaus long does consumer proposal stay credit report credit reports 360 bad credit rating lasoo catalogues credit reporting laws florida form letter credit reports dispute consumer complaints agency under fair credit reporting act credit reports and credit scores get my transunion credit report free corporation credit report free equifax credit report login how to get a credit report in canada how to report bad credit landlord 3 credit report free per year one time credit report and credit score equifax phone number order free credit report disclosure and authorization pertaining to consumer reports pursuant to the fair credit reporting act free equifax credit report business free credit report without providing credit card info ordering credit reports by mail do payday loans report to credit bureaus credit report codes difference in credit report and credit score order credit report easy credit credit cards for bad credit credit bureau dispute letter midland credit management credit report how to unfreeze credit report how dog i report a delinquent account to a credit reporting agency unable to view credit report online get free report without card information personal solutions credit reports fair credit report act authorization form restoring how to fix credit after identity theft fair credit credit cards repairing credit report where can i find the free credit report songs who is allowed to see your credit report fair bad credit credit cards canada amex complimentary 30-day credit score & report how to read innovis credit report letter of explanation regarding inquiries on credit report where can i get a credit report best credit reports companies can collection agency remove debt credit report equifax credit report for landlord best credit report providers credit report contact phone numbers consumer consumer report canada magazine credit report problems view all credit reports free equifax phone numbers all credit reporting agencies free annual credit report from all three bureaus corelogic credco credit report equifax free credit report denied credit federal trade commission building better credit report installment loans that report to credit bureau get a credit report without a credit card transunion address for credit report government credit reports free what is the best way to dispute a credit report free annual credit report government approved free credit report for business gov free credit reports and fico scores first american credit reporting agencies where should i go to check my credit score bill me later credit check reporting download free credit report commercials us government credit report free how to get free credit report once a year financial annual credit report security freeze credit report dispute online or. mail where can i get all three credit reports free online capital cash loan reviews how to get how to check credit history in canada get credit reports bankruptcy dismissal and credit report unlimited 3 bureau credit reports get your transunion credit report free 30 days free credit report score where to get your credit report free annual federal section 2.8 of the credit reporting code of conduct equifax canada credit report for business how to view my credit report for free how do you remove negative items from credit report vote new free credit report band free credit report dispute letters how do you get things taken off your credit report how to get your credit report free canada transunion single credit report and score is my employment history on my credit report how to check credit report for business how do i fix my credit report fast obtaining credit report minor child how to see credit report for freeware how to order your credit report by phone free 3 in 1 credit report and triple credit score how to check my credit card balance in hdfc military free credit report govt website free credit report get get free credit report illinois safe request credit report mail credit reporting companies addresses can block access my credit report how do i dispute information on my experian credit report how do you get your credit report in canada annual credit report clark howard add consumer statement credit report where is my credit score on credit report get free credit score report government sample letter remove charge off credit report free credit report commercials 2010 credit card debt help forums credit repair scams canada access my credit report free what is included in a credit report real my free credit report government new credit report laws 2011 ordering a credit report on someone best review your credit report how to unfreeze my equifax credit report will getting my credit report hurt my credit challenge something your credit report credit repair attorney san diego ca experian small business credit reports federal credit report gov ftc facts how to dispute credit report errors fixing your credit report free where can i get a detailed credit report trw credit report wiki news articles about credit reports bankruptcy credit report reading credit reports experian credit report no credit card needed credit suisse wealth report 2012 check credit reports free all rights free credit report affiliate program reporting credit card sales to irs what is the report on public credit in 1790 what are the three major credit report companies templates for dispute letter on credit report credit report how to obtain dispute collection items on credit report potentially negative information credit reports often can request my credit report free credit report commercial new i need all 3 credit reports for free free report business credit scores get copy your credit report free definition of delinquency on credit report best place to purchase credit report best credit report monitoring service consumer report collection agency credit report remove repair your credit jack tv for free reviews can obtain free credit report how to check your credit report in canada fico score and report for all 3 reports personal solutions credit how do you get an actual free credit report credit report error lawsuit consumer credit protection act south africa why did the free credit report band leave consumer reports and credit karma american express corporate card personal credit report fair credit reporting act copy of credit report get my one free credit report actual free credit report once year moody;s credit rating reports how to view your credit report online for free federal credit report annual free order tri bureau credit report usaa credit report service obtain free credit report nj will capital one remove late payments from credit report best way to repair what is the credit score rating scale negative credit report fall off credit score reports do you need credit report rent house sample letter dispute information credit report experian phone number for free credit report advance america cash advance corporate office phone number free credit report gov uk lenders how to dispute an item on your credit report equifax totally free credit report once a year bureaus mailing address experian credit reporting agency state ca free credit report credit report with names of free credit report companies how to report report to credit bureau canada how to check ur credit report a real free credit report annual credit report from transunion small business credit report removing negative information from your credit report place freeze your credit report clean my credit report now detailed credit report scores free debt report after denied credit equifax free capital report experian denied credit fair credit reporting act disclosure statement authorization how to free report credit scores bureaus free credit report phone lyrics how to get a free annual credit report in canada address to dispute experian credit report by mail request free credit report denied credit equifax how to fix your credit history consumer credit reporting how to remove employment history on credit report free credit reports instantly free credit report three one annual credit report login page what does installment debt mean on your credit report expedia credit report contact number equifax credit report email address consumer reports best business credit cards the p&a partnership creditor portal free annual credit report federal credit report for tenant screening free annual credit report information credit report completely free govt website free report credit score credit reports free without credit card reading equifax credit report codes how to get credit report for free experian credit report free online how many years until bankruptcy comes off credit report fair credit reporting act notice how do i pull a credit report on a tenant long do charge offs stay your credit report transunion annual credit report order detailed credit report my actual free credit report check credit card balance chase often do credit reporting agencies update information i need to get my credit report landlord credit report canada how do i get negative information off my credit report when does my credit report get updated free credit report ads consumers catchy what is a credit score what are the major credit reporting agencies how do u get your free credit report each year gov credit report best place buy credit report expirian credit report how to fix a credit score under 500 how long do delinquencies stay on credit report free credit report cheap chase checking account check your credit report do you need credit report government best credit repair information do prepaid credit cards reported to the credit agencies information services credit reporting agencies free credit report.com pirate song lyrics your credit report shows a serious delinquency free credit report sites legit how do i get a free credit report from the government long does late credit card payment stay your credit report consumer reports annual credit report business check my credit score equifax check all 3 credit scores reports annual credit report review can get free credit report canada agencies consumer reports credit reporting agencies free credit repair guide by mail 2 credit bureau report with the 3 credit score option credit report credit score monitoring free credit report employment history transunion credit reporting lawsuit how long is a foreclosure on your credit report how to remove a paid collection item from credit report what is a good credit report score fair credit reporting act agency files credit report without credit card information union loans how to read reading a credit report score best website check credit report best way get credit report canada police credit union annual report 2010 free report commercial lyrics car credit scores free transunion credit reporting credit report help desk derogatory credit report means how do you put a lock on your credit report how to get your credit report corrected how do i get all 3 credit reports ofac alert on credit report equifax free credit report usa top credit report myfico define credit report credit agricole group annual report 2011 difference between credit report credit score credit reports for free no credit card if i dispute credit report 3 bureau credit report addresses instant credit shoe repair findlay ohio does rent a center report to credit agencies free business equifax free annual credit report online experian bad credit personal loans report credit bureaus corporate credit reports canada challenge my credit report ftc free credit report parody change my employer my credit report how long do negative reports stay on credit report what is my credit report score how doo i freeze my credit report prevent paid credit report score free credit federal government report online experian credit report 2 pounds official site get annual free credit report annualcreditreport cash advance no credit no credit check no bank account payday loan what type of information is found on a credit report tri merged credit report unsecured personal bad credit loans dallas tx summary of rights under the federal fair credit reporting act how long does a consumer proposal stay on your credit report does landlord see your credit report poor credit credit reports government free yearly free annual credit report from all 3 bureaus dispute experian credit report by mail credit freeze experian experian mail credit report fair credit reporting act employer investigation dispute experian credit report phone cbcinnovis credit reports annual report federal law credit score free tenant credit report and background check free credit card report without credit card sample letter to request credit reports experian credit report for business how dog you check your credit report free how often to credit reports get updated how to obtain a copy of your credit report for free landlords checking credit reports what information does a credit report contain how long do derogatory accounts stay on your credit report free annual credit report login credit repair organizations act croa us credit report credit repair loan how do i pay off debt on my credit report transunion credit report coupon codes which credit reporting company is better delete negative info credit report request correction of an error in a credit report does capital one report credit how do i get wrong information off of my credit report credit report for a business what is charged off as bad debt on credit report credit report credit score online bad credit history car leasing deals what is the best report monitoring service credit scores free credit report member log in credit report veda the only truly free credit report discount no credit check payday advances how to get free credit reports and scores how to request free credit report credit report fico free dispute credit report online equifax what does government mandated mean free credit report website government mandated annual credit report credit report company should use experian credit reporting service does getting my credit report hurt my score top three credit reporting agency how to remove capital one charge off from credit report credit report.com safe is it illegal to run a credit report on someone else request free credit report experian payday loans not on credit report long does judgment stay my credit report do checking accounts show up on credit reports m ecoa credit report experian login credit report annual credit report transunion login my free report through government each credit how do i order credit reports small cash loans with no credit check credit suisse global wealth report 2010 pdf get free credit bureau report new credit score ranges 2012 how to report a bad tenant to the credit bureaus free credit report band search commercial clear your credit report canada credit report dispute letter addresses contact credit reporting agencies directly certified credit report personal loans get free credit report all three correct credit report errors experian anderson financial credit report 22) what is the timeframe for removing negative credit information with the exception of bankruptcies from a credit report free report business credit scores checks business credit report experian uk corporate credit reporting agencies incorrect information on your credit report equifax international credit reports credit report three free credit report define how to access your cibil credit information report newest free credit report song lyrics does an eviction notice show on your credit report sample letter to remove credit report inquiry equifax credit report phone number how long will a delinquency stay on my credit report hard inquiry credit report removal the only unofficial free credit report free credit report commercial new car dot best free credit score reports remove hard inquiries off credit report get free credit report wikipedia annual credit report website legit entitled one free credit report per year credit report employment fair credit reporting act form accuracy passage home insurance credit report free credit report through irs annualcreditreport safe way get free credit report how to get a free credit report at transunion does credit repair does garcinia cambogia work yahoo answers free credit report experian canada agencies get your yearly credit report free best way to get a copy of credit report what is the free annual credit report website how to get a good credit score free credit report dot songs lyrics is annual credit report online safe review credit report websites capital one credit report limit annual credit report texas free credit report from government annually credit check free online australia letter requesting credit reports only free credit annualcreditreport report get credit report alerts identity theft what is the best credit score report site much does credit report cost what are inquiries on your credit report negative credit report items free landlord credit reports credit karma in canada triple advantage free credit report equifax view credit report again view your experian credit report how do i get free credit report once a year my credit report through government one free how do i read a trans union credit report how do i read my transunion credit report how long before credit report is updated report credit card fraud how to run my own credit report fair reporting act free report major credit free credit report.com band elite hargrave and associates credit repair scam three credit agency report free business my free credit report and score how to get a credit report canada length bankruptcy credit report canada remove closed credit card credit report how do i get free credit report from transunion how do i buy my credit report order credit report over phone three companies credit report best company to monitor credit report consumer reports best credit repair service freecreditreport.com free credit report and credit score online by experian.url get your free credit report / no credit card get free financial report denied credit how do i dispute a debt on my transunion credit report kpmg credit union report
Home Maury Brown Bob Dutton Addresses the BBWAA Inclusion Process

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 823 guests online

Atom RSS

Bob Dutton Addresses the BBWAA Inclusion Process PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 10 December 2007 09:59
A Biz of Baseball ExclusiveBob Dutton, President of the Baseball Writers' Association of America Addresses Process of Credentialing

Before I get started, it’s important to make mention of the incredible willingness that Bob Dutton, president of the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA), has done to address some of the questions about the criteria by which a potential candidate for the BBWAA is granted inclusion, or rather, as it pertains to news on Friday, the non-inclusion of two members. While some of the answers presented may not give what some are looking for, Dutton's willingness to address the questions straight on is commendable.

It should be noted that the full intent of this article is not to make a case for whether Neyer or Law should be members of the BBWAA (although, it is this author’s opinion that they should be), but rather it is an attempt to address some of the questions that have surfaced about the BBWAA’s process. - Maury Brown

It may not have been front page news in the sports section, but it has created a firestorm of debate in baseball circles. The BBWAA agreed to open up its membership to internet-based authors, which on the face of it, is a win for those that produce baseball related content for the internet, and not just for those that work in print, such as newspapers.

16 members were recommended for inclusion into the BBWAA. They are Jim Caple, Jerry Crasnick, Peter Gammons, Tim Kurkjian, Amy Nelson, Buster Olney, and Jayson Stark from ESPN, Scott Miller from CBS Sportsline, Ken Rosenthal from FoxSports.com, Tim Brown, Steve Henson, Jeff Passan, and Dan Wetzel from Yahoo! Sports, and John Donovan, Jon Heyman, and Tom Verducci from Sports Illustrated

Two up for consideration were not recommended for approval. They were ESPN’s Rob Neyer and Keith Law, based upon the BBWAA’s criteria of members being required to attend, what they deem to be a “sufficient number of MLB games.” It is that criteria which is being questioned. It is that non-inclusion of Neyer and Law that have sparked the heated debate.

That debate has raged across the blogsphere, from The Baseball Analysts, to Keith Law’s blog, to Baseball Think Factory, and beyond. It has pulled in members of the BBWAA (one member from the Denver area referenced in Law’s blog posting went as far as calling Law “a liar”) and others (Neyer, for one) have moved into a he said/he said back and forth via comments posted in the aforementioned locations.

After reading through the comments regarding Law and Neyer, it seemed clear that there were a considerable number of questions around the BBWAA’s process, which were not well known.

To attempt to get answers to some of these questions, I contacted Bob Dutton of the Kansas City Star, who is currently the president of the BBWAA.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Here are some replies to questions asked:

Maury Brown for the Business of Sports Network: What is the exact number of games that a prospective member should attend at ballparks to be considered for approval?

Bob Dutton: There is no specific number in our constitution. For years, the traditional number was 100 games, and most full-time beat reporters still cover between 110-130 games.

But a specific number was omitted when we revised our constitution in 1992. The reason, I believe, was an effort to be inclusive. I think it's safe to say, though, that few members would view anything less than 40 games as an acceptable cutoff. That's roughly half of any team's home games. For example, someone who only covers 20 games at big-league parks is going to have trouble convincing many members that they merit a BBWAA credential.

Brown: What are your comments about the members that were included? Some have suggested that those that were approved were more or less grandfathered in. What are your comments for those that are asserting that claim?

Dutton: I assume you mean the new internet members since we usually have a few dozen new members each year from traditional sources.

Our procedure with internet reporters is new this year. The amendment starts the calendar in October and specifies that we exclude MLB.com employees. The amendment also specifies that other internet sites credentialed by MLB for the World Series serve as a starting point for consideration.

The full membership at our World Series meeting is supplied with a list of those sites and has the option of accepting or amending the list either through additions or deletions. This year the list was accepted intact (again, except for MLB.com).

That meant five internet sites were invited to submit candidates by  Dec.1: CBSSportsline.com, ESPN.com, FoxSports.com, SI.com and Yahoo.com.

The requirement was that candidates be full-time employees whose primary ob is to write about baseball. Those candidates would also need to meet he BWAA's general requirements.

The five sites submitted a total of 18 names. The national board of directors is charged with reviewing the list of candidates and submitting a recommendation to the entire membership for consideration at the winter meetings.

The board recommended that 16 of the 18 be accepted for membership. Two candidates were not recommended for membership because the best information available to the board indicated they had not demonstrated a regular presence at big-league parks.

The full membership has the option of approving the board's recommendation or amending it. In this case, a motion was made, seconded and passed to accept the board's recommendations.

Brown: On the “best information available”… There has been quite the back and forth going on about who at ESPN was contacted at the winter meetings, regarding Keith and Rob. There is a stream of conflicting stories (the side that was not included saying that they spoke to an editor at the winter meetings and that he said he did not speak with anyone at the BBWAA, and the BBWAA saying that they did) .

Can we set the record straight once and for all... Who at ESPN was contacted?

Dutton: I won't identify whom I, or any board member, contacted at ESPN or any of the web sites regarding this matter. Or when and where. They were informal conversations and private background checks.

I've been asked by some of those contacted whether I planned to identify them and reveal the nature of their comments. I've told them I wouldn't  do so without their consent. I plan to stick by that.

Brown: Regarding your comments on "40 games being the cutoff"... have you ever known a member of the BBWAA sponsoring a prospective member  for inclusion that was below this threshold? This gets to addressing the chorus of voices that are saying that there's a "good old boy" network at play.

Dutton: The way our membership works is qualifying outlets (newspapers, wire services, etc., and now internet sites) send us a list of candidates. There's no such procedure of a member sponsoring a prospective member.

Also, the 40-game standard is mine. I didn't mean to imply it as an association threshold. It isn't. As I [mentioned] previously, there is no specific standard.

I do doubt, however, many members would recognize someone who attends fewer than 40 games as needing a BBWAA credential.

Brown: Understanding what the prime reasonings behind the BBWAA requesting that writers attend games directly at the ballpark, is there a sense that a shift in this position could occur based on the high degree of coverage for matters such as the HOF vote now receives?

Dutton: The BBWAA is evolving. The new amendment to admit internet reporters shows this. I expect us to evolve further.

Brown: Is there a need to be "at the ballpark" to add value to the BBWAA with the advent of MLB Extra Innings and MLB.TV that allows writers the ability to see games, and therefore, the only difference is physically being at games?

Dutton: Physically being at games, I believe, means more than your question seems to imply unless you see no value in direct contact with players, management, staff, etc.

I believe the access granted to such people through our credential, which is the result of negotiation with MLB and the MLBPA, is the primary benefit most members value.

That is also the main reason the association places a premium on members demonstrating a need to be at ballparks.

Brown: One aspect of the BBWAA that many wonder about is who is exactly a badge member? The BBWAA’s site does not list who is a member.

Dutton: It is not a secret. The names (I believe) are within all the media guides.

(NOTE: After looking through several of this year’s media guides, this is not the case. As an example, the Orioles list the Baltimore/DC area members, but several guides that I examined – Red Sox, Braves, Cubs – did not. On the latter issue of the listing, Dutton made an extra effort to provide me with a listing of all badge members as of May 2007.)

(See the complete BBWAA badge listing here on The Biz of Baseball)

It should be noted that the list currently does not reflect the Hall of Fame voting list, which includes many lifetime members who are no longer active.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

As mentioned at the beginning of this article, on the face of it, the addition of 16 internet-based writers appears to be a clear move forward for alternative media. I will not debate that matter, but it should be noted that more than one member on the list was already listed as part of the BBWAA’s rolls prior. Jeff Passan (2004), Tim Brown (1994), Steve Henson (2005), and Jon Heyman (1988) are all shown as badge members. This appears to show more of a “reclassification” than “new inductee” to the BBWAA’s rolls.

Also, looking at the list sees a bit of a administrative issue that the BBWAA is bumping into, which may or may not, impact how the BBWAA works toward growing membership.

Even before the BBWAA decided to allow internet-based writers to be considered for inclusion, the rolls have been growing at an ever increasing rate. As but one example, 1986 sees 20 members added. Ten years later the figure is very close to the same (18 members), but by 2006, that figure jumps to 58.

As a final commentary, the “number of games to be attended” needs to be addressed.

Understanding the BBWAA’s mandate to attend games, as well as the change in the times to address the increased role that the BBWAA plays in determining awards such as the Hall of Fame induction, MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year, is at a crossroads.

The ability for the BBWAA to adapt their bylaws seems doable to address both issues. There could be methods that would allow a prospective member that does not attend the current requisite number of games in person, yet allow them to add exceptional value to the voting process, in. Some form of logging time in an online system as to when they are actively watching games via MLB Extra Innings or on MLB.TV is a suggestion. Another consideration would be that given the vast number of members on the BBWAA’s rolls, is it not conceivable that there is a considerable BBWAA presence at all MLB ballparks, and therefore, allowing a small percentage of members that add value to the voting process, yet may not attend a large number of games at the ballpark be considered for inclusion?

Lastly, if the BBWAA sees the current system as more than adequate, at the very least, a reconsideration of presenting a clear and exacting number of games to attend should be placed back into the bylaws. It would allow those that will be considered for inclusion in the future a clear number by which they know they have to meet. It will remove all ambiguity and subjectiveness from the current system, and therefore, at least quell some of the criticism surrounding issues such as that which Neyer and Law have butted up against. After all, as each member views the criteria differently, so will the criteria by which members are added. With an ever shifting view of the membership base, it will be impossible for the BBWAA to not be criticized. One year, the figure of “50 games” may be acceptable. The next, it may be “60 games.” As mentioned, this level of subjectivity has to be removed to allow for the selections to be seen as wholly credible.

I am not Mr. Dutton, but believe he would agree, that the BBWAA’s system is far from perfect. It seems that as an organization, they are attempting to shift with the change in how media is being viewed, which is clearly a step in a positive direction.

That may, or may not, be too late for some now. Given the high level of interest in the non-inclusion of Neyer and Law, it seems that moving forward with the status quo will not serve the BBWAA, or those interested in seeing the best analysis given to the many awards that are issued by the BBWAA, its just desserts.

As mentioned, at the very least, there is a sense that times are changing. Could members of Baseball Prospectus, the Hardball Times, or other credible online-only media outlets see some of there members become part of the BBWAA in the future? While only time will tell, there seems to be a window opening for that to happen. Whether the window will be large enough for those in the ever-growing alternative media group to slide through will be but one of the many questions confronting the BBWAA as it moves forward.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?