generica levitra zoloft 50 mg tired buy levitra wholesale desi tashan saraswatichandra written episode prednisone 20 mg bid levitra bayer buy doxycycline generics augmentin bid 100 mg generic levitra ireland lexapro weight disorder erythromycin 200 mg 5 ml mylan generic synthroid viagra bust montreal viagra buy melbourne prednisone 5mg dogs cialis 2.5 mg sverige tadacip brand order buy augmentin patch keflex online sales azithromycin uses for children altace generic release date paxil online price strattera price 40mg cheap zithromax 1.0 gram 1500 mg metformin conceive buy viagra 32 baclofen overdose how much preisvergleich xenical 120 mg aciphex over the counter 20mg heartburn composition cialis 5mg maxalt refill pack orlistat dosage recommended aygestin medication zithromax 250 mg suspension cytotec comprar en costa rica nolvadex cheap cialis super active non perscription countries 100 mg prednisone lymphoma where to get plavix finpecia discount finasteride propecia shoppers drug mart canada post hours edmonton glucophage 850 mg precio diovan online store fast moduretic deleviery doxycycline 50mg generic generic uk paypal myambutol where to buy primatene mist in canada viagra generica farmacias mail order alligator meat cuts cialis 5 mg efecto buy benemid tablets online can metformin help you get pregnant if you have pcos viagra purchase order synthroid 15 mg what are the side effects of haldol buying viagra hongkong generic cialis brazil strattera kopen online wiki generic cialis propecia available generic can you buy viagra over the counter in the uk into buy bactrim pills doxycycline brand name india pharmacies accutane is there anything like viagra for women cialis europe generic generic viagra austrlia levitra bayer 5 mg what are the different types of drugs to relieve pain buy zovirax capsule buy elavil inhaler canada clomid buy generic erexin v efekty utilisation cialis 20 mg how long does it take for allegra to start to work propranolol 40 mg grossesse zestril generic lisinopril lexapro 20 mg medication forzest generic reviews lisinopril hctz 50mg erfahrungen levitra 10mg diflucan dogs online canadian pharmacy eurax viagra 150 mg buy generic glyset buy canada cialis sublingual medication side effects generic ephedraxin us clomid 150mg progesterone propecia generic good us pharmacy online cipro qualitest prednisone 20mg prednisone 20 mgs buy lisinopril 40 mg levitra 100 mg vardenafil propecia australia chemist erythromycin 500mg filmtab can you take cephalexin daily dangers generic wellbutrin generic from zyban celebrex 200 mg contraindications what does the word aleve mean evista canada companies only online cialis nz necesito receta para comprar metformina cialis online pharmacies glyset side effects uk herpes valacyclovir dosage order doxycycline uk cialis online canadese order propecia ireland levitra cheap uk walmart levitra 20mg online viagra test buy topamax 10 silagra uk buy cheap geneirc viagra 100 luvox pill shortage what are prednisone pills used for cytotec 0.2 mg ulotka thuoc atorlip 10 mg buy spray viagra buying diclofenac gel from canada no prescription what is tricor medicine for viagra condom buy how can i buy an asthma inhaler with no prescription glucophage generic lexapro mexico no prescription can you only get suprax on prescription viagra 8 100mg can you buy cystone over the counter priligy dapoxetine buy cheap hydrochlorothiazide pyridium side effects reviews nolvadex order online can you get rogaine 5 generic viagra 50 mg 50 zoloft generic equivalent low albendazole albenza pharmacy buy clomid australia generic zovirax uk tricor pharmacy coupons levitra 20mg anwendung clonidine pharmacy coupons generic crestor wiki can you buy viagra over the counter in uk online levitra cialis viagra 50mg relato nolvadex generic drug american express australia corporate login online prednisone 5mg cheap gerne cialis online viagra real buy cialis super active pills in the us strattera buy find 150 mg viagra generico para viagra alli uk boots cialis 30 mg paypal over the counter zestoretic buy methotrexate cheap celebrex 200 mg capsule risperdal weight gain prevention nolvadex andarimedex cheap cialis generic name in india illegal generic viagra order cialis 40mg lithium online buy canada no prescription for celexa generic valtrex manufacturer ampicillin nombre generico lisinopril 10mg qualitest can you buy grifulvin v online tadalafil cialis generico viagra soft ordering online pharmacy generic cialis sweden prednisone 50 mg bid where can i get some lipitor viagra 100 mg fiyatlari buy generic decadron with bonus thalidomide enantiomers birth defects cialis 200mg wholesale cialis online switzerland azithromycin better than erythromycin acai berry medicine for weight loss canadian online viagra viagra generico postepay viagra online craigslist hongkong buy cialis malegra fxt online in usa 4 motrin pills kamagra online nachnahme 1000 mg of valtrex 2.5 mg lexapro reviews nexium 10 mg copii getting sominex in australia cheap aciclovir 1 200mg 05mg cialis generic viagra cos hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg tab viagra 150.mg finax overnight shipping cheap saw palmetto prices at costco buy tetracycline no prescription delivery xenical international purchases wellbutrin 300 mg kullananlar prescription medication without prescriptions cheap price propecia orlistat online in canada cialis 5mg night cialis 5mg 36 hours arimidex daily use reviews buy zenegra without a script clomid and 50 mg cialis 20 mg identification alternative viagra online diclofenac sodium 100 mg side effects paypal cialis canada order xenical medicine cheap viagra cyprus suhagra discount medications cytotec order online wellbutrin withdrawal 150 mg levitra 10mg works lamictal dosage depression rx sunglasses online cheap generic metformin images prednisolone online uk nogales mexico pharmacies online can you buy over the counter viagra in canada side effects of xenical orlistat cheap 5mg lisinopril lisinopril 10 mg used viagra online free how to get cialis prescription cheapest maxalt tablets uk ordering citalopram india omifin embarazo multiple 2010 viagra 100mg red google kamagra 100 mg cialis online ohio metformin 500 mg e albendazole discount online drugstore lisinopril 20 mg used levitra generico prezzo vermox tablets for sale buy strattera 60 mg augmentin tabletta 625 mg reglan express canada phenergan 25 mg suppository all types shatavari pills how to order desyrel online astelin pas cher crushing cialis 5mg dewalt lithium ion drill sale silagra canadian online levitra buy toronto nexium o generico atacand tablets for sale lisinopril cost 10mg levitra 20 mg org is motilium safe for children alphagan tablets purchase on line elavil best antidepressant cialis 5mg costs generic dutasteride buy minoxidil 5 solution cheap viagra etc online pharmacy uk didronel can you order forzest pharmacies buy combivent 200 mg of synthroid cheapest place to buy cialis super active super dmz rx buy ambien uk augmentin 500 mgs splitting cialis 20 mg generic viagra 20 mg nexium 40 mg flk 100mg viagra sale buy weekend cialis generic speman overnite shipping what medication can i take for anxiety abilify without a prescription from canada 5 mg levitra enough generic form levitra clomid buy generic where to get geriforte syrup pct viagra buy 24 what does trazodone look like canadian family magazine recipes lexapro de 10mg brand minomycin buy boots chemist zyrtec amaryl overnight delivery rx generic cialis pharmacy kamagra online spain zithromax online ordering lexapro bipolar disorder tadalis sx brands india lexapro generic walgreens mumbai india pharmacy confezioni viagra 50 mg ordering doxycycline online blueberry 100 sildenafil does zovirax work for genital herpes requip xl sale risperdal drug class roxithromycin pills sweat what can i mix with augmentin to make it taste better buy effexor xr tablets online ampicillin online in canada fresh pomegranate juice recipe bactrim generic online xenical 120mg capsules 84 cialis genuine uk bentyl us companies only order florinef buy generic synthroid without prescription cheap generic zoloft Levitra 20 mg Buy pain meds for arthritis in neck buy mestinon online from usa ortho tri cyclen without a prescription from australia celebrex de 200 mg us online pharmacy no prescription atacand buy generic clomid best synthroid prices suhagra tablets us online lexapro generic celexa promethazine tablets 25 mg abuse propecia generic online clomid 100mgs canada 40 mg cialis natural testosterone cream reviews bactrim forte 800 mg pure hoodia acai pills can you donate blood if you take an aspirin daily unisom sleeptabs coupons cialis online andorra where can we buy cytotec in the philippines 10 mg ml tetracycline acai hp order hytrin usa sale buy levitra discount 5mg cialis samples buy entocort online pharmacy buy valtrex online generic viagra testimonials generic propecia singapore buy cheap levitra 50 mg doxycycline acne anxiety disorder buspar cialis generic date buy quibron-t cheap can you buy periactin over counter diflucan 100 mg ev amoxil junior 700 mg liquid aricept review paroxetine lawsuit uk strattera 40 mg kullananlar generic cialis fedex cheap cialis store zithromax 500mg philippines digoxin new zealand cialis generico venezuela buying augmentin online colchicine by mail generico de wellbutrin pfizer viagra 200 mg side effects of reglan in dogs is there a drug comparative to lasix buying benzaclin online list of generic drug manufacturers in india cheapest cialis soft paypal diflucan 100 mg whats phenergan buy uk lexapro dosage 15 mg 100mg viagra cut revia order by phone buy viagra germany zoloft online uk trazodone 50 mg tablets costo lasix 25 mg liquid nolvadex mg diflucan 150 mg kapsule .1 mg of synthroid compazine fda approved to buy without prescription diflucan 150 mg vaikutus viagra generica greece can you buy baclofen online buy 80mg strattera generic lexapro cipralex cialis tabletas 20 mgs viagra cheap tesco zyrtec coupons february 2013 what illnesses does biaxin treat strattera 25mg buy amoxil online canada cialis besy buy clomid order online pharmacy technician online program georgia synthroid online from canada without a prescription online viagra rezept purchase lipitor online chinese viagra 800mg synthroid mg tablet cleocin t gel uses over the counter menosan celexa 20 mg tablet lisinopril 5 mg dosage wikipedia cialis generic buy cytotec no prescription fast delivery capoten now retirada generico viagra common side effects of baclofen cialis 10mg 36 hour generic brand for prometrium buy menosan pills online 500 mg amoxil buy alli 120 pack compare prices tab clomid 50mg order metformin 1000 mg propecia 05 mg cipro 500 mg bayer tadacip pill shortage zithromax 500mg buy yasmin online purchase pharmacy has best price chloramphenicol zyvox uk next day delivery generic cia tadalafil 20 mg where do i bactrim in usa where to buy viagra professional online canada nexium 40 mg cpr zoloft 150 mg benefit buy propecia cheap amantadine hydrochloride tablet draft guidance glucotrol xl suppositories buy viagra generic 20 uroxatral generic side effects cheap drugs no script canadian pharmacy generic cymbalta exelon lawsuit bula strattera 25mg cialis generico 40 mg nexium 50mg price detrol la 4mg generic cialis professional new zealand use of augmentin duo syrup cheapest soft viagra viagra generic cvs buy tamoxifen online at canada pharmacy xenical 120 mg erfahrung buying viagra delhi losartan hydrochlorothiazide generic kamagra 100mg chewable zoloft generic reviews powder cialis online how to order brand levitra can you buy finax over the counter why has serpina been discontinued ordering viagra plus pharmacy online drug shop levitra 10 mg kaina antabuse medication over the counter buy rumalaya brand viagra on line in the mexico valtrex results forum best online viagra glucophage de 1000 mg usa generic viagra buy viagra canadian lisinopril 20mg pharmacokinetics levitra generikum 20mg nexium 40 mg pill cialis online ordering genuine bentyl 100mg take 2 100 mg viagra generic valtrex costs 3 generic sildenafil viagra buy kamagra soft boots xalatan shop net isotretinoin nhs dapoxetine buy china buy clomid where metformin al 1000 mg cheap lopressor 40 mg acheter kamagra gel safe 100mg viagra wellbutrin order overnight pharmacy order deltasone us cialis 40mg jual cialis 10mg doxycycline 100mg capsules dose cheap viagra buy cost of diovan 160 mg what is azulfidine for price increase flovent nexium generic india generic zestril 20 mg buy amoxicillin augmentin pregnant 150 mg clomid
Home Maury Brown Analysis: Fantasy Stats Case Appeal Heard

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 946 guests online

Atom RSS

Analysis: Fantasy Stats Case Appeal Heard PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 15 June 2007 07:02

The Biz of Baseball

The following is analysis from Maury Brown, a sports business analyst for the Business of Sports Network  

Yesterday, oral arguments in the appeal of CBC Marketing and Distribution v. MLB Advanced Media took place before three judges for the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in St. Louis. The landmark case revolves around CDM Fantasy Sports’ (who was then owned by CBC Marketing) use of player statistics without a license from MLB Advanced Media. MLBAM and the MLBPA reached a $50 million agreement which, “provides MLBAM the exclusive rights to use, and to sublicense to others, Major League baseball player group rights for the development and creation of on-line games, all other online content, including fantasy baseball and interactive games, as well as all wireless applications including cell-phone enabled games.”

CBC sued MLBAM and the MLBPA arguing that they should be able to conduct the business of fantasy baseball games for-profit without a license and use player names and their associated statistics.

A judgment in US District Court in 2006 agreed.

Attorneys representing the MLB Players Association (MLBPA) and MLB Advanced Media (MLBAM) are urging the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to reverse the lower court judgment from US District Court Judge Mary Ann Medler from August of last year (see the opinion handed down by the court as well as the conclusion here on The Biz of Sports).

The appellant brief filed by the MLBPA and MLBAM reads in part (read the entire brief, along with its associated addendum here):

CBC’s conduct violates Missouri’s publicity rights law, and enforcement of those rights does not affect expressive activity or violate the First Amendment. At the very least, disputed issues of material fact precluded summary judgment for CBC. Alternatively, no federal statute addresses publicity rights and thus federal law does not preempt enforcement of CBC’s state-law contract obligations.

(To listen to the court proceedings, as well as read a partial transcript, select Read More)

Virginia Seitz, representing the MLBPA in oral arguments (listen to the oral arguments from yesterday here), urged the court to reverse the ruling based on right of publicity, stating that while statistics themselves could be used, once an MLB player is associated to those statistics, it breaks with the right of publicity and therefore is not protected by the First Amendment as outlined in the lower court’s judgment.

The judges seemed to be skeptical of that argument when addressing counsel for the MLBPA.

In a sharp exchange between Chief Judge James Luken and Seitz, Judge Luken said:

“So, now we have a limitation (referring to the use of associating a player to their statistics), and now I come around to, ‘This isn’t about statistics’ -- the basic war of the brief .

‘This is about names,' you say. ‘This is about statistics,’ they say.

And I understand the practicality of the war because the statistics are in the public domain.  And it seems to me, it’s clearly a use of public information to figure out that if you’re going to have an ongoing fantasy sports league over the life of a real professional sports league – clearly a collateral market – you have to have an opening set of statistics and evolving statistics that will allow competition and trades and so forth.

And so where do you get those statistics?

Well you can’t take the 1923 Philadelphia Athletics because that doesn’t evolve over a season. So you take these statistics that are in the public domain.

And as I translate the argument in this case.... ‘Well, we won’t argue with that (referring to the use of statistics without player association), but don’t you dare put a name next to those statistics.’

Well, of course that’s ridiculous.

So you are saying that this collateral market can be monopolized by your clients. The statistics – the public statistics – cannot be marshaled and be used for another kind of game without your clients getting a share of the action.”

Seitz then replied:

“Those statistics can appear in newspapers. Those statistics can be published on websites. But what cannot be done is have a player identity – a name – be used as a game piece for identification.”

Judge Luken shot back:

“The only identification is identifying the statistics so that this group of evolving statistics for the second baseman can be followed.”

The name is only to identify the statistics. It’s not to steal the identity of the second baseman.”

Seitz responded:

“The only reason these game are valuable and marketable is precisely because these are major league baseball player names attached to those statistics. If you used ‘Player A’, ‘Player B’, no one would be interested in playing the game. The game is interesting precisely because people feel they are owning and managing real major league players.

In summarizing his points later, Judge Luken said, “Since this is completely tangential to Major League Baseball, and the success of Major League Baseball, I don’t understand where that success and that identity, gives the players – at least I’m having trouble seeing – how it gives the players the right to monopolize an entirely separate entertainment industry.”

Rudy Telscher, lead counsel for CBC said during his 20 minutes that, “There’s not any affidavit from players who say they feel like they have been damaged,” referring to the fantasy baseball gaming industry. He then went on to say that the Phillies front office participated in playing fantasy baseball actively.

Telscher argued that fantasy baseball – in its various forms – have been played for years prior to the dispute between MLBAM and CBC.

“The only thing that my clients did was to create software to automate it.”

Reached for comment on Friday, Charlie Weigert, Vice-President of CDM Marketing said that there was extra pressure knowing that if the case remains in CDM's favor that it will create case law, and leave a lasting legacy.

As to how long he might be willing to pursue the case, Weigert stood behind his convictions.

"I’ll pursue the case as far as it goes," Weigert said. "Hopefully this decision will produce a final opinion and the decision will be as strong as the lower court decision, so if they try to appeal this higher, they are rejected."

A ruling on the appeal is expected from the three-judge panel in three to six months. 

Maury Brown is the founder and president of The Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball and The Biz of Football (full launch coming in July). He is a contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and can be contacted here. 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?