zovirax cream online glucophage tabletas 500 mg levitra 20mg jellies buy kamagra soft pattaya viagra buying 2011 100mg cialis dosage diflucan generic online diflucan 150 mg costo toddler prednisone 5mg cialis 5 mg einnahme propranolol 40 mg dosage cheap cialis ed packungsbeilage viagra 100mg 10 mg phenergan orlistat cheap xenical price generic augmentin illegal buy kamagra wellbutrin 450 mg bipolar prednisone 20mg cancer buy nolvadex walgreens clomid 50mg ovulation comprar viagra 100mg thuoc viagra 25mg priligy purchase online generic wellbutrin doses switching synthroid generic prednisone online purchase amoxil 50 mg buying clomid injection get propranolol online buying viagra shanghai propranolol hcl 20mg viagra generic quality dos generic viagra liquid clomid online cheap pills cialis splitting 20mg cialis buy zithromax prescription 80 mg levitra viagra online rischi propecia cheap finasteride amoxil 500 mg toothache levitra 5 mg ausreichend buy nolvadex dropper generic cialis replacement kamagra 25 mg lexapro 15 mg price augmentin tablets 875mg scherzartikel online viagra took 2 5mg cialis bactrim online cheap cipro xl 500 buy viagra online indian buy 50mg clomid xenical 180 mg relsuts buy bactrim cheap strattera cheaper cialis took 40 mg viagra 250 mg obat erythromycin 250 mg buy zithromax tablet buy viagra price metformin buying buy cytotec ireland buy propecia men lexapro 10mg canada lisinopril 10 mg wiki lexapro 5 mg anxiety buy metformin uk cialis 40 mg sublingual cialis 20mg philippines zoloft dose 250 mg order propecia us propecia online hong cialis generico precio nexium esomeprazole 10mg chinese viagra buy will lexapro generic glucophage forte 850 mg viagra online experience nexium 20 mg nedir cheap online kamagra amoxicillin 500mg amoxil 200 mg generic viagra viagra 50mg dose propecia 1mg review buy cialis venezuela buy lisinopril 40 cvs cialis 5mg buy cialis 2.5 mg bfp 100mg clomid celebrex generic dosage Online Levitra 10 pills lasix 500 mg online durata viagra 100mg clomid challenge 50mg zoloft dosage 400 mg clomid 50 mg tabletki Cialis 5 mg Washington cheap tadalafil cialis valtrex 500 mg valor nexium 20mg esomeprazole cost viagra online hydrochlorothiazide online canada generic lexapro better amoxil 500 mg cost prednisone 20 mg prescription priligy generico 30 mg breaking 20 mg cialis cialis online compare pastile cialis 20mg tlilly cialis 100 mg 30 mg propranolol took 3 5mg cialis viagra 25 mg ceny generic celebrex same cheapgeneric cialis uk dosage cipro 500 mg hay viagra generico cialis 40mg overnight viagra online .au prospecto strattera 25 mg existe clomid 100mg safest viagra online augmentin 625mg uk generic viagra onlineusa zithromax 200 mg 5ml buy viagra trusted viagra 10 pills buy 10 mg cialis online generic viagra hypertension buy lasix pills kamagra 100mg chewable lasix furosemide online drug nexium 40mg buy zithromax brand preisvergleich cialis 20 mg 12 buy dapoxetine online cheap viagra pleasure viagra strength mg 600mg viagra order lasix drug erythromycin tablet 500 mg lisinopril 10mg. interactionn diflucan 150 mg precio viagra online pharmacy diflucan 10 mg walmart zoloft dosage 250 mg cipro 250 mg price viagra online toronto levitra 20mg alberta propecia online kopen levitra cheap achat cialis 10mg buying 40mg cialis buy bactrim liquid generic cialis source valtrex online cheap kamagra manchester buy wellbutrin 900 mg buy viagra america prednisone 7 days 20 mgs natural viagra online propranolol mk 40 mg viagra 50 mg posologie augmentin 652 mg glucophage 1000 mg prezzo buy diflucan 150mg synthroid . 2mg lexapro 5 mgs propranolol dosage 40 mg diflucan 150 mg torrino viagra buy brisbane order levitra mastercard recipe viagra online buy viagra sachets starting citalopram 5mg buy viagra chemist red viagra 600mg lexapro generic medications cheap real cialis propecia generic substitute cheap overnight cialis mg of zithromax 200 mg clomid twins valtrex generic cheapest buy viagra without buy lisinopril 40 mg augmentin 200 mg suspension order Cialis 120 prednisone biogaran 20 mg cap augmentin 625mg 1000 mg amoxil doxycycline 75 mg overdose levitra vs generic cialis wirkung 20mg cialis 40mgvs20mg cialis 10mg forum medikament zoloft 50mg acquistare levitra 5 mg priligy comprar online ferrari viagra 150mg lexapro 20 mg canada generic cialis strattera mg available prednisone streuli 50 mg viagra generico vendita cytotec pharmacy online 100 mg viagra cost glucophage generic metformin buy zovirax online cheap cialis 5mg priligy de 30 mg generic viagra egypt cheap nolvadex 20mg propranolol 10 mg migraines 25 mg zoloft pmdd pastillas levitra 10 mg levitra 20 mg treatment buy zoloft online xenical online philippines Levitra 180 pills Buy viagra de 500 mg cheap cialis 10mg generic versus lexapro merrick generic propecia viagra online discount buying cytotec online buy uk metformin order hydrochlorothiazide online lisinopril dosage generic online levitra rx cialis 2.5mg buy levitra 10mg paypal cipro 750 mg filmtabl cialis 10 mg halbieren nexium 40 mg vademecum 500 mg of valtrex buying levitra australia generic wellbutrin image chip cialis 40 mg bactrim forte 160 mg online shop viagra clomid pct 50mg experience buying cialis buy zovirax amoxil 500mg caps buspar mgs levitra 10mg effects lisinopril buyer safe generic viagra preise viagra 50 mg lexapro 20 mg tablets original lexapro online generic lexapro discount prednisone 5mg ndc viagra buy australia prospect viagra 50 mg strattera mail order cipro tabletki 500 mg 100mg viagra cost propecia order finasteride strattera 10 mg wikipedia 10 mg lisinopril cheap lexapro uk 150 mg clomid multiples levitra europe online buy nolvadex safely cialis canadian generic cialis 5 mg ansia viagra doctors online generic zovirax ingredients generic viagra echeck generic cipro hc generic viagra 10mg metformin hexal 500 mg assunzione levitra 5 mg cytotec 200 mg prix ordering propecia overseas cheap rx cialis 40mg of levitra cialis 5mg rezept xenical generic name cialis generic4all augmentin nombre generico online rezept viagra online viagra now nexium 40mg gastrite prednisone pack 5 mg glucophage 1000 mg compresse cipro cheap online zovirax generic price pet doxycycline 100mg cialis generico chile cialis sklep online cialis generico mx viagra buy tablets generic of cipro lexapro 10 mg tablets prednisone 6 day 10mg nolvadex cheap uk generic cipro 600mg zovirax tabletter 800 mg finasteride propecia 5mg viagra 6800mg levitra not generic zoloft order canada generic viagra website 100 mg kamagra tablets zovirax generic uk clomid generic multiples 2013 wellbutrin generic a 101 buy viagra zimbabwe generico do lisinopril lexapro generic launch metformin generic problems black cialis 3000 mg levitra 20mg achat levitra 20 mg viagra 2 25mg of viagra valtrex 500mg dosage viagra droga generica dreampharmaceuticals online wellbutrin cialis soft 100mg drug online viagra strattera 80 mg effects buying cialis manila cipro 250 mg uti propecia cheapest buy cytotec 100 mg viagra order india glucophage 500 mg lisinopril 10 mg safe viagra quebec online diflucan liquid buy lasix generico levitra 40 mg online viagra paypal 100mg generic viagra anygood diflucan generic buy valtrex 1000 mg dreampharmaceuticals diflucan online jual viagra 100 mg starting 20 mg lexapro buspar 10mg reviews generic strattera india doxycycline 50 mgs kamagra online nachnahme buy prednisone 1 mg cheapest viagra 800mg 20mg cialis coupons wellbutrin retard 300 mg viagra london buy viagra online japan erfahrungen online viagra metformin 500 mg 48 93 clomid online sale dosis celebrex 100 mg will levitra generic buy cialis 50mg cipro 250 mg harnwegsinfekt posologia xenical 120 mg cialis medication online 100mg viagra taking 2 cialis online ads levitra 5 mg fiyati viagra price online buy levitra walmart viagra 50mg erfahrung levitra 20mg dosierung buy 1 diflucan pill 30 mg lexapro breastfeeding wellbutrin generic withdrawal cialis 20 mg china cheap levitra 40mg nexium 20 mg tabletten cialis 20 oder 10 mg cipro online purchase cipro order cialis online no order prescription viagra wellbutrin recall generic cheappfizer viagra 100gm viagra 50 mg expiration generico do bactrim zoloft 50 mg erowid cialis 20 mg gebruik strattera generic available viagra buy can generic cialis recommended prednisone 20 mg taper cialis 20mg .at levitra online clomid 50mg generico do lexapro order zovirax cialis pills 5 mg buy lexapro lundbeck online viagra advice viagra generico c50 purchase erythromycin online generic zithromax walmart lexapro 10mg recreationally nexium 40 mg pdf viagra genericssouth africa augmentin suspension 250 mg acheter cialis generic prednisone 20mg image generic lisinopril cheap clomid 50 mg buy valtrex 500 mg generico diflucan 100mg pret lisinopril 10 mg w 929 viagra 50mg indications cheap propecia cost cheap viagra wholesale viagra 50mg cost viagra 100mg color propranolol 40 mg effects generic cialis quality tapering prednisone 50 mg bactrim 480mg cialis de 20 mgr levitra generic us clomid online drugs patente viagra generico prednisone 20mg rash zoloft 100 mg prezzo about doxycycline 100mg cheapviagrageneric viagra metformin overdose mg viagra 50 mg 2 tablet doxycycline accord 100 mg prednisone 5mg chat generic valtrex wiki viagra online sample generic valtrex manufacturer cheap valtrex 1000mg nolvadex buy canada doxycycline dose 100 mg generic propecia finasteride zovirax buy generic buy levitra packs valtrex generic 1000mg tetracycline 500 mg dosage nexium generic image 10 mg cialis dosage levitra 5 mg bayer levitra 20mg kosten mg of wellbutrin hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg tablet cialis cena 20 mg buy wellbutrin canada cialis 10 mg opinioni buy xenical 84 capsules cialis 20 mg interactions buy doxycycline inj. cialis de 5 mgrs synthroid generic cheap cialis web celebrex cheaper alternative buspar overdose mg celebrex dosage 200 mg zoloft 25 mg price viagra mexico generic prospecto cialis 5 mg order cs viagra viagra no.1 200mg lexapro 10mg paxil generic supplements cialis prednisone 60 mg daily prednisone 7.5 mg daily uk propecia cheap lasix 20 mg tabs zoloft mg overdose valtrex prices generic diflucan available generic lexapro 60 mg dose 150mg viagra online ordering lisinopril cialis lady 20mg cialis tabletas 20 mg viagra buying canada propecia 0.25mg kullananlar cialis lilly 5 mg buspar 30 mg reviews generic medication propecia amoxil 250 mg bula buy clomid legit edmonton viagra buy phenergan tabs 25mg zovirax 400 mg bula prednisone 30 mg online cialis 20mg test generic diflucan 150 mg kamagra 50 mg jelly online viagra cheap buy epistane nolvadex metformin 500mg pcos
Home BoB Documents MLBPA v. Steve Garvey

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 490 guests online

Atom RSS

MLBPA v. Steve Garvey PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 12
PoorBest 
Selection of Docs
Written by Court Ruling   
Tuesday, 19 June 2001 12:00

MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL PLAYERS ASSOCIATION
v.
Steve GARVEY


532 U.S. 1015 (2001)

PER CURIAM.
The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit here rejected an arbitrator's factual findings and then resolved the merits of the parties' dispute instead of remanding the case for further arbitration proceedings. Because the court's determination conflicts with our cases limiting review of an arbitrator's award entered pursuant to an agreement between an employer and a labor organization and prescribing the appropriate remedy where vacation of the award is warranted, we grant the petition for a writ of certiorari and reverse. . . . .

[In the late 1980s, arbitrators found collusion by the Major League Baseball Clubs (Clubs) in the market for free-agent services and damages to the players represented by the petitioner, Major League Baseball Players Association (Association). The Association and Clubs entered into a Global Settlement Agreement (Agreement), which established a $280 million fund to be distributed to injured players. The Association also designed a "Framework" to evaluate the individual player's claims.]
 
The Framework provided that players could seek an arbitrator's review of the distribution plan. The arbitrator would determine "'only whether the approved Framework and the criteria set forth therein have been properly applied in the proposed Distribution Plan.'" Garvey v. Roberts, 203 F.3d 580, 583 (9th Cir. 2000) (Garvey I). The Framework set forth factors to be considered in evaluating players' claims, as well as specific requirements for lost contract-extension claims. Such claims were cognizable "'only in those cases where evidence exists that a specific offer of an extension was made by a club prior to collusion only to thereafter be withdrawn when the collusion scheme was initiated.'" Id., at 584.
 
Respondent Steve Garvey, a retired, highly regarded first baseman, submitted a claim for damages of approximately $3 million. He alleged that his contract with the San Diego Padres was not extended to the 1988 and 1989 seasons due to collusion. The Association rejected Garvey's claim in February 1996, because he presented no evidence that the Padres actually offered to extend his contract. Garvey objected, and an arbitration hearing was held. He testified that the Padres offered to extend his contract for the 1988 and 1989 seasons and then withdrew the offer after they began colluding with other teams. He presented a June 1996 letter from Ballard Smith, Padres' President and CEO from 1979 to 1987, stating that, before the end of the 1985 season, Smith offered to extend Garvey's contract through the 1989 season, but that the Padres refused to negotiate with Garvey thereafter due to collusion.
 
The arbitrator denied Garvey's claim, after seeking additional documentation from the parties. In his award, he explained that "'[t]here exists ... substantial doubt as to the credibility of the statements in the Smith letter.'" Id. at 586. . . . .
 
Garvey moved in Federal District Court to vacate the arbitrator's award, alleging that the arbitrator violated the Framework by denying his claim. The District Court denied the motion.  [The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed by a divided vote, holding that review of the merits of the arbitrator's award was warranted in this case, because the arbitrator "'dispensed his own brand of industrial justice.'" Id. at 589.] . . . . [I]n the court's view, the arbitrator's refusal to credit Smith's letter was "inexplicable" and "border[ed] on the irrational" . .. Id. at 590. . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded with directions to vacate the award.

The District Court then remanded the case to the arbitration panel for further hearings, and Garvey appealed. The Court of Appeals, again by a divided vote, explained that Garvey I established that "the conclusion that Smith made Garvey an offer and subsequently withdrew it because of the collusion scheme was the only conclusion that the arbitrator could draw from the record in the proceedings." Garvey II (unpublished). . . . . The Court of Appeals reversed the District Court and directed that it remand the case to the arbitration panel with instructions to enter an award for Garvey in the amount he claimed.

* * *

Judicial review of a labor-arbitration decision pursuant to such an agreement is very limited. Courts are not authorized to review the arbitrator's decision on the merits despite allegations that the decision rests on factual errors or misinterprets the parties' agreement. Paperworkers v. Misco, Inc., 484 U.S. 29, 36 (1987). We recently reiterated that if an "'arbitrator is even arguably construing or applying the contract and acting within the scope of his authority,' the fact that 'a court is convinced he committed serious error does not suffice to overturn his decision.'" It is only when the arbitrator strays from interpretation and application of the agreement and effectively "dispense [s] his own brand of industrial justice" that his decision may be unenforceable. When an arbitrator resolves disputes regarding the application of a contract, and no dishonesty is alleged, the arbitrator's "improvident, even silly, factfinding" does not provide a basis for a reviewing court to refuse to enforce the award. Misco, 484 U.S. at 39.
 
In discussing the courts' limited role in reviewing the merits of arbitration awards, we have stated that "'courts ... have no business weighing the merits of the grievance [or] considering whether there is equity in a particular claim.'" Id. at 37. When the judiciary does so, "it usurps a function which ... is entrusted to the arbitration tribunal." Consistent with this limited role, we said in Misco that "[e]ven in the very rare instances when an arbitrator's procedural aberrations rise to the level of affirmative misconduct, as a rule the court must not foreclose further proceedings by settling the merits according to its own judgment of the appropriate result." 484 U.S. at 40-41, n. 10. That step, we explained, "would improperly substitute a judicial determination for the arbitrator's decision that the parties bargained for" in their agreement. Ibid. Instead, the court should "simply vacate the award, thus leaving open the possibility of further proceedings if they are permitted under the terms of the agreement." Ibid.

To be sure, the Court of Appeals here recited these principles, but its application of them is nothing short of baffling. The substance of the court's discussion reveals that it overturned the arbitrator's decision because it disagreed with the arbitrator's factual findings, particularly those with respect to credibility. The Court of Appeals, it appears, would have credited Smith's 1996 letter, and found the arbitrator's refusal to do so at worst "irrational" and at best "bizarre." Garvey I, 203 F.3d at 590-591. But even "serious error" on the arbitrator's part does not justify overturning his decision, where, as here, he is construing a contract and acting within the scope of his authority. Misco, supra, at 38.

In Garvey II, the court clarified that Garvey I both rejected the arbitrator's findings and went further, resolving the merits of the parties' dispute based on the court's assessment of the record before the arbitrator. For that reason, the court found further arbitration proceedings inappropriate. But again, established law ordinarily precludes a court from resolving the merits of the parties' dispute on the basis of its own factual determinations, no matter how erroneous the arbitrator's decision. Misco, supra, at 40, n. 10. Even when the arbitrator's award may properly be vacated, the appropriate remedy is to remand the case for further arbitration proceedings. Misco, supra, at 40. The dissent suggests that the remedy described in Misco is limited to cases where the arbitrator's errors are procedural. (Opinion of STEVENS, J.). Misco did involve procedural issues, but our discussion regarding the appropriate remedy was not so limited. If a remand is appropriate even when the arbitrator's award has been set aside for "procedural aberrations" that constitute "affirmative misconduct," it follows that a remand ordinarily will be appropriate when the arbitrator simply made factual findings that the reviewing court perceives as "irrational." The Court of Appeals usurped the arbitrator's role by resolving the dispute and barring further proceedings, a result at odds with this governing law.

For the foregoing reasons, the Court of Appeals erred in reversing the order of the District Court denying the motion to vacate the arbitrator's award, and it erred further in directing that judgment be entered in Garvey's favor. The petition for a writ of certiorari is granted, the judgment of the Court of Appeals is reversed, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

It is so ordered.

Justice GINSBURG, concurring in part and concurring in the judgment.

Justice STEVENS, dissenting.

[Separate opinions are omitted]

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?