taldinafilo best seller how to last longer in bed isoptin 40mg prevacid coupon 5$ diamox sequels patient assistance milanuncios perros buy medicine without prescriptions paxil and pre ejaculation ivermectin dosage for dogs with demodex mange acheter orlistat malaseb dog shampoo antibacterial precios de la pastilla cytotec propranolol order cheap viagra and cialis ramipril side effects altace octreotide acetate injection price ornidazole injection pump combictic global caplet pvt ltd avodart 0.5 mg coupons hytrin medications cialis mexico triamterene hctz 37 5 25 mg tb beconase nasal spray for sale lumigan eye drops side effects eyelashes viagra online indian pharmacy 5 getpharma pakistan newspapers trimetabol dosage for amoxicillin esomeprazole magnesium over the counter magic pharmacy online usa tamoxifen side effects high risk xalatan generic phentermine side effects phentermine information magnesium supplements benefits quinine water amiloride hctz redustat diet pills reviews phenergan dm syrup dosage overstock drugstore pfizer stock symbol lipitor memory loss cholesterol plavix side effects can you buy antibiotics online beprogel lotion source ciprofloxacin hcl 500mg tab dalacin 300mg interactionsdanazol where can buy viagra cheapest price hospital cayetano heredia nefrologia doxycycline hyclate side effects for dogs extenze reviews forum procalisx reviewed and approved cheap viagra online uk medoflucon 50 what is omifin tablets accutane lawsuit settlements 2014 furosemide generic name amoxicillin 875 mg prices for donepezil medication luvox crazy meds levitra canada drug store thuoc amoxicillin fentanyl transdermal system 50 mcg hr cialis soft e20 mexican drugstores without prescription why is mebendazole discontinued buy medroxyprogesterone cialis uk no prescription microcidal vs microstatic antibiotics lotensin pharmacy bactroban nasal ointment generic where do bodybuilders buy clomid que es amantadina clorfenamina paracetamol para que sirve el diclofenaco eprex injection dose provigil weight loss medication regenon side effects clomid australia online no prescription allopurinol drug reactions rhine ink generic viagra site reviews buy clomid pct lesofat vs xenical online cheap levitra for sale precose dosage for melatonin valium overdose amount fluzol 200mg zoloft sildegra tabletop vistaril dosage for nausea famciclovir drug glumetza vs metformin do you need a prescription for cialis thyroxine side effects dose how much is viagra 100mg coreg fpr cheap with no prescription plavix clopidogrel 75 mg levlen 28 reviews clomid for sale uk spedizione sicura ordine viagra strattera reviews for children buy zovirax online tylenol dosage chart for infants estrace 1mg flonase coupons viagra stores in akld buy differin 0 3 uk warfarin for sale order viagras online non prescription erectile dysfunction how much does viagra cost per pill what is metformin hp the little blue pill cheapest propecia tablets star fruit link with estrogen nasonex nasal spray side effects in children buspar information medication oracea doxycycline dose where to buy zithromax advantage multi for dogs coupon cialis from india 40 cialis canadian none prescription micardis side effects medication domperidone illegal singulair cena price of doxycycline at walgreens kamatra gelatin cvs pharmacy job application minocin dosage acne mex select viagra products claritin ingredients children diprosone buy no prescription amoxicillin 500mg tabletki where to get antabuse in massachusetts india buy proventil online accutane long term side effects forum viagra cene u apotekama fungsi obat flagyl contact yahoo androgel testosterone class action lawsuits condyline pret a manger feldene 20mg pain contraceptive pill online uk lopressor medications that cause sun sensitivity online doctor viagra amoxicillin for eye infection in dogs para que sirve el metformin amantadina clorhidrato de tramadol where can i buy orlistat in us us purchasing of furosemide lotrel 5 20 side effects generic sureway construction group zentel albendazole dose in children benazepril side effects medication aprovel irbesartan medicine pravachol side effects dose tizanidine 4mg side effects prime pharmacy buy cyprostol without prescrition zoloft rx chloroquine side effects prinivil blood pressure medication rocaltrol 0.25 mg ciprobay 500mg side effects buy biodramina on line paracetamol in pregnancy glucotrol xl medication floxin otic suspension clomid serophene medicationssertralina walgreens careers career opportunities zyprexa olanzapine medication cheap xanax and viagra uk mirtazapine for cats dose chlamydia trachomatis symptoms comprar viagra levitra e cialis pulmicort nebulizer treatments map of abana river azithromycin 250 mg cephalexin side effects mupirocin uses medication vitamix vs blendtec viagra professional uk buy metformin without doctor abilify weight gain patients rogaine or propecia cabaser dosing calculations optimmune ophthalmic ointment revatio 20 mg cheap buy cialis get viagra free robaxin muscle relaxer side effects buy nolvadex online australia what does cialis for daily use cost walgreens careers hydroxyzine side effects atarax carbimazole dosages nitrazepam vs diazepam 10mg temovate cream 0.05 generika levitra deutschland cialis canada trackable advantage one federal credit union southgate doxazosin cardura dose neurontin for pain nerve oxazepam benzodiazepines buy cheap tadalafil online buying ali diet pills online advantage one federal credit union morrison il voltaren gel dose card print proviron tablets pakistan no perscription lexapro viagra prix pharmacie diamox dosage for pseudotumor cerebri metazole 5 mg purchase prednisone online ic ropinirole hcl side effects 1477 finasteride viagra online sicuro subutex vs suboxone for chronic pain asacol hd 800 mg who is the manufacturer obat celebrex procalisx reviewed by order non generic baclofen pulmicort side effects buying doxycycline for dogs 24hr canadian pharmacy alli weight pills spiriva side effects and glaucoma cialis double dose differin coupon rebates viagra purchase with discover albuterol inhaler side effects in kids hoodia p57 molecule hyaluronic acid side effects lexapro online pharmacy no prescription viagra for sale in australia mometasone furoate ointment usp 0.1 benefits of mentat tablets cardura 2mg tab keftab inforum latest updates on clozaril medication where to buy viagra in karachi xenical orlistat side effects pharmacies in windsor commande seroplex 20 generic viagra no perceription rollbox 46360 claravis reviews effexor reviews by patients arthritis in the knee surgery canada companys that sell viagra buy primatene mist inhaler epinephrine chigualos ejemplos de curriculum fda approved canadian pharmacy eprostol misoprostol abortion thalidomide history wikipedia motilium domperidone side effects flomax for women fda approved application of elimite for scabies hydroxyzine hcl 10mg for dogs ketazol shampoo bowls retirides reviews of 50 ucb keppra patient assistance program sildenafil citrate in philippines buy viagra boots rualis cialis nartea callahan finasteride generic uk dosis de metformina para bajar de peso trimetabol ingredients in tylenol generic propecia online tabletas abortivas trazodone overdose long term effectstretinoin ramipril 5mg capsules price reductil forum chewable viagra pills for sale proventil inhaler coupons combat viagra side effects viagra kaufen auf rechnung prednisone dosage for dogs with allergies best prices for viagra brand non prescription levitra nuvigil vs provigil which is better for adhd cialis australia prices avodart bestellen sildenafil dapoxetine bactrim dosage for children hardon pills medicines viagra online uk next day delivery antabuse cost at walmart no perscriptionpharmacy chinese herbal viagra jia yi jian unisom overdose suicide prinivil side effects medication nebivolol hydrochloride chlamydia discharge color adipex diet pills online prednisone over the counter drug meprate tablet periactin side effects lumigan 0.01 price magnesium sulfate for preeclampsia captopril side effects to report black market predisone buy amoxicillin in australia metoprolol tartrate treatment coversyl plus indian study tofranil pm side effects bystolic medication generic buy zoloft overnight delivery ny mobic medication for pain hoodia gordonii buspirone side effects doctor viagra per meshkuj ventolin without an rx sominex long term use reviews cnadian drug mall isoptin 40mg side effects aciphex medication information active ingredient in maxalt buy atarax hydroxyzine mexico online antibiotics for ear infections in infants canadian neighborhood pharmacy scam prednisona 20 mg piroxicam 10mg for dogs viagra vs cialis vs levitra cost per pill zyprexa relprevv program haloperidol decanoate injection package insert paxil generic epanutin medication identification doxylamine succinate 25mg what is it for canada prescription online valium 5mg compared to xanax microcidal definition of integrity cymbalta antidepressant dose metrotab church chattanooga tn zip code rogaine for women hair regrowth treatment letrozole side effects in men kamagrafast cooking trazodone for insomnia dose cozaar medication picture buy levothroid no prescription tadalafil like fast where to buy la weight loss products anxiety disorder symptoms in kids bactrim pediatrico secure pharmacy luvox dosage for anxiety hyzaar medication generic onlone pharmacy lidoderm pain patches drug allergies voltaren pills dosage viagra online in ireland internet pharmacy suprax cefixime capsule 400 promethazine 25mg medication phenergan tiotropium inhaler generic order priligy online celexa side effects celexa weight gain cipla web flash buy viagra online singapore 255 sildenafil 50 mg prices ibuprofen 800mg and alcohol printable viagra coupons frumil tabs for guitar overnight drug delivery no prescription safe way to buy lavitra generic viagra australia cialis super active 20mg pills cialis sources kamatra sumatra nuovo cialis viagra in sri lanka vilches leon gto knife sheaths aleve ingredients online viagra 25 mg kaufen achat de viagra au micardis medication telmisartan can clotrimazole side effects lexapro weight loss drugs ketazol venezuela news dexamethasone grossir allegra d 24 hour viagra prijs cialis 20mg prices fentanyl pain patch dosage cyrux dosis de amorcytotec triderm cream generic online pharmacy without presciption atacand medication generic antibiotics online reviews virectin ingredients for lasagna serophene 50mg for men avanafil online artane industrial school dublin captopril drug capoten buy xenical online without prescription zovirax canada toprol medication ciales and viagra cheap viagra pe stendra generic cycline enterprise car letrozole 2.5mg bodybuilding tadarise pro 20 shop augmentin proventil inhaler zyrtec side effects fucidin cream antibiotic for boils flagyl antibiotic used to treat yeast infection online pharmacy cod aviane reviews weight gain reglan medication online no rx prevacid solutab cost cialis in usa topiramate side effects in women cytotec abortion risk esomeprazole magnesium trihydrate side effects sildenafil tablet 100mg parlodel drugs parcopa vs sinemet overdose buy delgra 200 mg disgrasil tabletas apple buy pfizer viagra pills australia levitra 20 mg precio arthritis foundation walk medameds medco prescriptions parafortan tabs for crazy bactrim side effects advice on viagra no rx required indian viagras fuenllana centro educativo los prados where to purchase cortisone injections paracetamol mechanism of action doses doxycap capsule wardrobe bioxetin pregnant nolvadex with fast shipping cialis generika deutschland cytotec en panama brand viagra online from mexico price of nexium us medic bey prednisolone at indian pharmacy store nootropil piracetam 800mg clavamox for cats online femara without a prescription ovral birth control side effects buy cialis pay with paypal pcm pharmacy salt lake city famciclovir cost vosteran removal instructions endurexx dianabol reviews malaysian viagra blue pill vgr 100 pfizer cialis 20mg tablets prices black market prednisone norlevo pill bactiver strep throat lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide 20 12 5 mg cialis 2 5 tegretal order from greece amlodipine besylate norvasc dose lotrel medication amlodipine desogestrel ethinyl estradiol reviews on garcinia promethazine 12.5mg pill mesterolone steroid forums prometrium during pregnancy side effects apo prednisone without prescription carafate medication liquid canadian pharmacy tylenol quetiapine and gabapentine interaction aristocort cream 0.1 buy aprovel triamcinolone acetonide cream reglan breastfeeding dosage generic flagyl nolvadex pct dosing robaxin side effects canine levothroid for weight losslicodexon canadian viagra pay by check liposafe gnc store cheap viagra no prescription septra suspension che acyclovir gel order online sales of levita levaquin for sinus infection dosage accutane online reviews lortab 5/325 generic pariet 20 mg cardinal community credit union online banking generic lidoderm patch for back pain 1 mg prednisone no scrip adipex reviews doctor adipex p 102 over the counter ativan antibiotics for bronchitis cialis c20 online kosovarja albania category tirana chat link cialis 20g prednisone dosage for asthma zyvox 600 mg cost clopidogrel bisulfate 75mg medication triam hctz mail order cefadroxil 500mg octreotide infusion doseolanzapine
Home MLB News Supreme Court Denies Rehearing of Fantasy Stats Case

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 580 guests online

Atom RSS

Supreme Court Denies Rehearing of Fantasy Stats Case PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 02 June 2008 07:24

MLBThe U.S. Supreme Court has just released orders that they have denied MLB Advanced Media and the MLB Players Association’s request for a rehearing in C.B.C. Marketing, Inc. v. MLB Advanced Media/Major League Baseball Players Association, or as it has been commonly referred to, the Fantasy Stats case.

The justices made no comment in denying the appeal.

The decision means that those that operate fantasy sports businesses within the U.S. Court of Appeals For The Eighth Circuit (Arkansas, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota) can do so without a license. The ruling will have broad-reaching implications by setting case law.

Reached for comment, lead counsel for CBC, Rudolph Telscher said, “We are very pleased with the Supreme Court's decision. The case against Major League Baseball is completed with no further chances for appeal. The Supreme Court left intact that 8th Circuit decision, which holds that fantasy companies have a first amendment right to use baseball statistics without permission from or payment to Major League baseball. The case serves as precedent for all fantasy sports. It is an important victory for the fantasy industry and fantasy players.”

The MLB Players Association said only that they are considering their options at this time.

MLBAM and the MLBPA reached an agreement in January of 2005 that allowed MLBAM the exclusive rights to use, and to sublicense to others, Major League Baseball player group rights for the development and creation of on-line games, all other online content, including fantasy baseball and interactive games, as well as all wireless applications including cell-phone enabled games.

On Feb. 7, 2005 CDM Fantasy Sports (also called CBC Distribution and Marketing, the parent company of CDM at the time) fought back. After being denied a license renewal, CBC filed a complaint in US District Court, Eastern District of Missouri, against the MLBAM over the right to produce and promote fantasy league games without the licensing of stats through the MLBAM and MLBPA. CDM had been paying a license to MLB, but with the agreement between MLBAM and the MLBPA, the number of licenses went down, and the cost for licenses went up dramatically. 

CDM decided to continue to run their fantasy sports baseball games without a license when they were they granted the option for renewal under the newly reached agreement between the MLBPA and MLBAM. Since CDM sued, the case has been heard under Missouri state law, as CDM was a St. Louis based company.

CDM has argued that the stats, along with player names, are protected under the First Amendment. Baseball has argued that using player names in conjunction with stats is a violation of privacy rights -- the fantasy sports companies are profiting by using the players names with the stats. MLBAM and the MLBPA have argued that fantasy companies can freely use the stats, just not with an MLB player's name; an exploitation of the player by using their name to promote the sales of a fantasy sports product.

CDM has won in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri in St. Louis and it was upheld on appeal the Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.

The case is a blow, not only to Major League Baseball, but other professional sports industries in the U.S., including the NFL, NBA, NHL, NASCAR, WNBA, and the PGA, all of whom filed amicus curiae ("friend of the court") briefs in support of MLBAM and the MLBPA’s case either at the lower court level, or at the U.S. Supreme Court level, which was the case with the NFL.

The agreement between the MLBPA and MLBAM is set to expire at the end of the year. MLBAM's role is one of a licensee of the rights and, as with all prior rulings, deferring to the Players Association.

When we interviewed MLBAM CEO Bob Bowman earlier this year and asked about the agreement, he said, “We’re their partners, but that does not mean that partners don’t build in safeguards in case things happen. It seems like the first thing you do when you enter into an agreement is worry about how you’re going to exit.”

See The Biz of Baseball "Fantasy Stats" Document Archive, which includes 


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted
 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?