how do i get my free experian credit report free credit report.com no credit card required long collections stay credit report define fair credit reporting act how long does a serious delinquency stay on credit report how do i dispute a bankruptcy on my credit report bankruptcy on credit report for 10 years the real free credit report site my credit report without membership how to correct wrong information on credit report free credit report massachusetts consumer credit reporting agencies act ccraa citi identity credit report profit loss paid credit report can you sue for false information on your credit report place lock credit report get free credit report colorado how often do you check your credit report how do you get your one free credit report per year free credit report from transunion by mail challenge things your credit report where can i get my credit report in canada free report federal trade personal solutions credit reports first free credit report song lyrics iphone number all 3 credit reports free credit reports from experian equifax transunion how to dispute credit report in writing free credit report.com songs mp3 original free credit report band is back what is the legitimate free credit report site government free credit report official fair credit reporting act employment background check how to get a free credit report without paying anything credit cards people bad credit report credit bureau how to clean up my credit report on my own how long do negative credit report items stay on report paid off debt but still on credit report how do i get my credit report and score free what is the official free credit report site can get credit report free what is the best place to get your credit report best credit score reporting website they free credit report good bad how can i clean up my credit report free do need credit report does american express report to credit bureaus online credit report dispute all the free credit report songs experian credit report form download who can legally see my credit report how to free credit reports online analysis death credit reporting agency getting a credit report transamerica credit reporting agency who can pull credit reports potential renter credit report mail experian credit report disputes often credit report updates free credit report commercial songs troubadour totally free credit report no credit card required uk credit reports transunion get free canadian credit report best credit report site for landlords 1 time free credit report get your free credit report online now how to get my free annual credit report secured credit card report all three credit bureau which credit report do lenders use most dispute civil judgement credit report bank america privacy assist credit report update 3in1 credit report with score check all credit reports free free business credit reports scores yearly free credit report from experian fcra free credit report website free credit report score transunion get free credit report from credit bureau order credit report online equifax credit rating report india farm credit system annual report federal reserve bank of san francisco your credit report what it says about you know how to report stolen credit card information getting free credit report online annual credit report from government us government free annual credit report credit card companies report all three credit bureaus business credit report law best place to get credit report online credit report 3 fico scores check violations fair credit reporting act what is the fair credit reporting act of 1971 remove hard inquiry on credit report how to update your credit report canada example of credit report experian 3 major credit reporting agencies canada free quizzle credit report free credit report guys real band access experian credit report report number safe credit report canada request free credit report all three bureaus consumer sample letter explanation inquiries your credit report credit information report (cir) 3 companies give free credit reports report to credit agencies death credit report from example of credit report dispute letters credit report company experian sample true credit report experian free credit report after being denied credit most reputable credit report company copy your credit report freeware best way to check credit report for free free report through irs credit scores 3 credit reports score mortgage not reporting credit report after bankruptcy should report credit card theft police best place get detailed credit report how doo you get your free credit report each year top rated credit report sites www.free annual credit report view free annual credit report online commission get all 3 credit reports free without credit card get all three credit reports for free federal law free report credit check how to remove bad credit history from your credit report get your free credit report and credit score how long can a medical collection stay on your credit report removing chapter 7 bankruptcy from credit report consumer report on credit cards how do i remove disputes from my credit report free credit report from transunion comprehensive credit analysis report consumer credit reporting company should use where can i get a sealed credit report credit report landlord california what is the best credit report bureau credit report dispute process real free credit report annual how to request credit report free report on public credit 1790 definition long hard inquiries credit report free report uk credit rating free experian credit score and report credit agricole annual report 2011 pdf free safe credit report triple credit report login credit report without monitoring annual credit report request service phone disputing multiple items credit report get my 1 free credit report how long do derogatory items stay on your credit report business credit report experian mortgage credit report clear credit report after bankruptcy credit report all bureaus transunion can anyone check my credit report without my permission does ordering credit reports hurt credit add personal statement your credit report annual credit report georgia how to report a bad tenant to the credit bureaus free credit report from equifax online whats a good credit report score clean up credit report after divorce how do me get your one free credit report per year how do i get free credit report free credit report score range 3 credit bureau report and scores for free free credit report gov free credit report singer those commercials credit report 3 in 1 long does negative information stay credit report can small business report debt credit bureau pull credit report for tenant difference between credit report and fico score annual credit report order mail cheap credit report score online equifax and free credit report credit report guide free credit report no sign up fees free report experian equifax credit scores get 3 free credit reports year 25 free credit report with no credit card required experian credit report 30 days free trial free 3 company credit report what all shows up on a credit report customer credit management report sap why do companies ask for a credit report in which section of the credit report is a list of all monthly payments can landlord report credit bureau fico score and report for all 3 reports credit rating free credit report ads lyrics annual experian credit report uk login get one time credit report and score reporting possible identity theft credit bureaus credit report uk 3 credit bureau report and scores remove items from credit report before 7 years credit report dispute form equifax only free credit report online monitoring leasing apartment credit report consumer reports best credit card company letter to remove paid items from credit report how to fix your credit report fast annual credit report co uk checking credit reports free can;t view credit report online long does repossessed car stay your credit report free annual credit report scams report bad tenant credit bureau credit card reporting credit agencies credit report help canada where to get a free credit report and score canadian credit reporting rules how long does derogatory credit stay on your credit report report errors your credit report check credit report score online forecast reporting credit history wells fargo credit report monitoring how can i remove a bankruptcy from my credit report get credit report after being denied personal loans colorado credit report free annual credit report service phone number how to clear bad credit report look your credit reports free understanding credit reports and credit scores get paid collection accounts removed credit report credit report commercials lyrics fair credit reporting act colorado really free credit reports how to dispute your credit report by mail collection agency credit reporting laws credit report for all three bureaus really free credit report what is the legitimate credit report site trans credit report canada how to remove dispute comment from credit report how do i find my credit report what happens when i dispute an item on my credit report why did they get a new free credit report band free credit report from experian denied credit how to fix problems on your credit report credit report without triple advantage how to repair my credit report company credit report experian deed lieu foreclosure effect credit report better credit report deed lieu forclosure all 3 credit reports free can you get something removed from your credit report removing paid medical collections from credit report free business credit reports uk i want to see my credit report for free address for iii major credit reporting agencies how long on credit report bad debt fair credit reporting act collection agency fcra mail credit report disputes experian denied credit can get free credit report free federal government annual credit report can get credit report itin best place get credit score credit report medicare credit balance report mailing address when does equifax update your credit report can a collection agency pull my credit report how can i see my credit report without paying free credit report 3 one free credit report driving car lyrics get free credit report no fees credit report monthly fee credit report inquiry removal letter credit reports for free no credit card required how to remove a default judgement from credit report free credit report triple advantage cancel american express credit report ftc approved annual credit report the real free credit report website tenant credit reporting services what you can do to legally improve your credit report all free credit report songs free report transunion free annual credit check how would you report a lost or stolen credit card indiana state tax lien on credit report annual credit report request form mail get equifax credit report only how much does it cost to run a credit report on a tenant oregon employment credit report read your canadian credit report get your report free canada personal solutions credit official free annual credit report fcra credit report.com scams how to check credit reports for tenants consumer reports best credit repair free credit report info phone number free credit report 3 bureau annual credit report equifax online credit report tenant screening dispute credit charge credit report free credit reporting agencies addresses annual credit report site legitimate transunion credit report on tenant pay for credit report remove foreclosure credit report 2010 view all 3 credit reports and scores bureaus experian free report experian canada credit score best free credit report services how to access my free credit report fair credit reporting act form authorization instructions credit inquiries on credit report how long best free credit reports score what is the best free credit report online remove medical collections my credit report official free credit report government where to get credit report online how do i remove an authorized user account from my credit report free credit report annual ftc run landlord credit report how do you order your credit report nationwide consumer credit reporting company best get free credit report annually free credit report 3 reporting agencies experian all three credit reports credit report charge off does mean request free annual report canada check your credit score remove hard inquiries off your credit report can you get free credit report once year get free credit report nj fake credit report sites where can i go to get my credit report for free timeshare foreclosure credit report my free credit report usaa canadian bureau report free personal solutions credit scores credit report dispute online transunion wells fargo uses credit reporting agency get free credit report all three credit bureaus credit karma u.s. credit score climate report where can i get free annual credit reports the fair credit reporting act summary how can i order my credit reports free annual credit scores reports best agency request credit report free credit report from all three major credit bureaus international credit report for individuals order your credit reports how to get negative items off credit report annual no cost credit report annual credit union report can you remove charge off credit report instant ?2 credit reports go online how long does court judgment stay in credit report credit report without mastercard information loans who won the free credit report.com band fair credit reporting act insurance companies what is a good free credit report site ftc free report score personal solutions credit annual credit report request form personal credit reference report how do i erase debt from my credit report free colorado credit report debt credit report 7 years get your free three in one credit report and score with equifax how to remove something from credit report order credit reports online free does chase report authorized users credit bureaus how can i get my credit report free online free credit reports from federal government advanced credit report inc how to get your free credit report online annualcreditreport first report credit checking long do charge offs stay my credit report new free credit report commercial 2011 best place get my credit report free order free credit report canada experian credit report 12.95 how quickly does my credit report update free credit report old band back how to report a non payment to a credit bureau how do you obtain a free copy of your credit report get yearly free credit report who is allowed to see your credit report how to get my free credit report and score letter correcting credit report negative information on credit report time find credit report no cost credit report fair and accurate credit report act free annual credit reports all 3 bureaus free credit score and credit report does an eviction notice show up on a credit report my free credit report free credit report rating india how do i remove negative items from my credit report how to figure out credit score from credit report what number do i call to get my free credit report credit report dispute online vs. mail tim hawkins free credit report dot com spoof lyrics my annual free credit report.gov how report a dispute in my credit report delinquent tenant credit reporting the 3 credit report companies profinity credit report review credit report says charge off what credit reporting agency is the most accurate free credit report.com reviews free annual credit report 3 bureaus credit report agencies addresses for disputes how to remove old items from your credit report how do i request a credit report how to pull tri-merge credit reports credit report fee included apr fastest reporting unsecured credit cards what are the names of credit report agencies consumer credit reporting agencies act can i run a credit report on a tenant free yearly credit report 2012 transunion consumer credit reporting industry deed lieu foreclosure your credit report free annual credit report web site fix credit reports yourself check credit reporting inc difference between credit score and credit report phone number trans union credit reporting agency experian free credit report mailing address credit reports and fico score can anyone request your credit report legitimate free credit report online can you get free credit report canada consumer medical collections credit report 2011 remove debt settlement credit report getting collection removed from credit report delete employment history credit report credit report employment california how do i request a credit report canada tri bureau credit report free credit report triple advantage equifax credit report annual free how long does a bad debt stay on your credit report uk 3 free credit reports contact all 3 credit reporting agencies year credit report free check death credit reporting agency reporting bad creditors experian credit report no score my yearly credit report free transunion free credit report three main national credit report companies canadian credit reports business credit reporting agencies fico score totally free credit report online annualcreditreport update credit report information what is the highest score you can get on your credit report actor in free credit report dot com commercials order all three credit reports online collections on my credit report will a collection agency remove from credit report credit union annual report how to file a credit report dispute online new law regarding access to credit reports can judgments be removed from credit report small claims court judgement credit report credit report update how do you report something to the credit bureau 1 free credit report free credit report credit card charges three credit report one how to get a credit report for free in canada does obtaining a credit report lower your score report theft credit bureaus what information is shown on a credit report how to get a really free credit report how to obtain a copy of credit report how to get your free credit report by mail fact credit report free credit bureau singapore (cbs) report check credit report for free annually get free credit report without trial d&b company credit reports what are credit reports happened guy free credit report commercials eric violette fixing credit report errors annual credit report social security number free credit report gov uk pay how to get your credit score and report for free how to remove collection item from credit report view my experian credit report where to dispute equifax credit report california credit report legislation derogatory credit report canada credit report cost transunion clean up your credit report fast credit report annual check how can i get my credit report by post get 3 credit reports free information credit report gathered fair credit reporting act consumer report employment long can negative information stay credit report small claims court judgment credit report mailing addresses credit reporting agencies free annual credit report with scores request how to request all 3 credit reports how do i get my credit report free free credit reports from all 3 how long does a hard inquiry last on your credit report get all 3 scores and reports free credit
Home All Articles Inside the Numbers: A 6-Year Look at the Forbes Valuations

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1183 guests online

Atom RSS

Inside the Numbers: A 6-Year Look at the Forbes Valuations PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 14
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 27 April 2008 23:00
A Biz of Baseball Exclusive

Each year, Forbes magazine releases its valuation of the 30 clubs within Major League Baseball. And, each year, fans, analysts, and certainly owners, debate the figures with an intensity that might rival a Lou Pinella missed call meltdown. Owners, with some rare exceptions, will say that the valuations are a bunch of hooey (that’s putting it kindly). Of, course, when the numbers work in their favor, you can get someone like George Steinbrenner on record, as he did last year when he said, "I am gratified at the Forbes valuation of the Yankees. We are continuing to build a worldwide brand for the people of New York and Yankee fans everywhere."

Others, such as Marlins president David Samson, would say otherwise. "Every year I continue to be surprised at the absolute inaccuracy that a so-called reputable magazine is willing to print," Samson said after this year's valuations were released. As we will present, if David Samson thinks that the figures for the Marlins are way off, that doesn’t mean that the Marlins aren’t pulling in a decent profit; it just means that the figures may not be completely in-sync with their accounting methods.

How Forbes renders their figures is what differs from MLB’s. Asked why those within MLB continue to say that the Forbes valuations are off, senior editor, and co-author of the valuations Kurt Badenhausen offers up their methodology for the financial estimates of a private industry that guards their money matters vigorously.

“We have been doing this at Forbes for 11 years,” Badenhausen said. “We talk to teams, investment bankers, consultants and other baseball people to help estimate all revenue and expense items as well as the current values of the franchises. There are a lot of ways to calculate these numbers with various holding companies, media properties and other businesses.”

As a specific example on the how MLB’s figures and Forbes’ figures may differ, Bandernhausen cites one baseball’s more lucrative revenue streams: MLB Advanced Media, which includes MLB.com.

“We have MLB’s revenues at $5.5 billion for 2007,” adds Bandernhausen. “MLB says they are more like $6.075 billion, but they are including $450 million or so of MLBAM revenue (whereas each team only got $2 million last year) and from events like the All-Star game. We include non-baseball stadium revenues from things like concerts and other events for those teams that control their stadiums. On the other hand, we deduct interest payments on debt that teams incurred from building new stadiums. Those two things roughly offset each other. We only look at revenues and expenses that the teams incur and baseball has clearly never been healthier from a financial standpoint.”

Another example involves the Seattle Mariners.

As part of the agreement for public funding of Safeco Field, the Mariners are required to release a financial statement to the State of Washington. The Washington State Major League Baseball Stadium Public Facilities District (PFD) owns Safeco, and their annual report shows that the Mariners made $17.8 million in profits.

Forbes lists the Mariners as posting operating income for 2007 at $10.1 million. Why the $7.1 million discrepancy?

“Our Mariners number is actually closer than the $7.7 million when you factor in depreciation, amortization, signing bonuses, non-ballpark expenditures and capital expenditures which we do,” explains Badenhausen. “I believe the number was closer to $15 million. Our operating income is an EBITDA number (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization). The $5 million difference is based on different revenue and expense calculations and estimates.”

So, it’s clear that how valuation figures are calculated can be different. Thus, it’s not wholly untrue that MLB’s figures differ from Forbes, but then, it’s a matter of how the sides are calculating figures. As former MLB COO Paul Beeston said infamously, "I can turn a $4 million profit into a $2 million loss and I can get every national accounting firm to agree with me."

With the differences, I’m not about to quibble with the amounts, per se. The following is more of a look in trends in the valuations within MLB. Looking at the data historically can show us which clubs are valuating upward more thanInside the Forbes Valuations inflation – a sign that ownership is working to maximize the value of the franchise, a new stadium has come online, paying down debt, or other activities that will increase the value of their holdings, on top of the growth that MLB in general is witnessing.

In some instances, when coupled with total player payroll figures, they can show holes in the revenue-sharing system. Overall, the most obvious news is owners are making money, and lots of it. Using the overblown cliché, they are hitting the ball out of the park. There may be disparity between the amounts of revenue clubs are pulling in, but no owner could claim with a straight face that they aren’t making money these days. It’s just that some clubs are making more than others are. As Badenhausen rightly said, “After listening to baseball owners cry poverty for 25 years, the outcries have been relatively few the last couple of years because baseball is in what like Bud Selig likes to call a ‘Golden Age’.”

Select Read More to see a detailed breakdown of the Forbes figures

Before we delve into the historical trends over the last six years, here are some details based around the annual research by Michael Ozanian and Kurt Badenhausen from this year’s valuations (see http://www.forbes.com/baseball/):

  • Total gross revenues for the 30 clubs has increased by 7.7 percent from last year to $5.5 billion (as opposed to the $6.075 billion reported by MLB)
  • The average team is now worth $472 million, 9.5 percent higher than last year and 143 percent more than when Forbes first calculated team values in 1998.
  • The increase in gross revenues has outpaced expenditures in player payroll. This year, 56 percent of revenues were spent on player payroll compared to 66 percent just five years ago.
  • Paid attendance continues to be a driving factor for the incredible increases for MLB. Within that, interleague continues to be exceptionally popular. Last year, interleague averaged 34,900 fans per game, 15 percent more than intraleague contests.
  • The Mets, currently ranked second with a value of $824 million, will also get a new stadium that should push their value close to $1 billion before long. Citigroup, beleaguered by the housing market meltdown, is still planning to pay the Amazins $400 million over 20 years for the stadium's naming rights.

Most Profitable Not Always the Most Valuable

As the thread worn cliché goes, you have to spend money to make money. But, in looking at the this year’s figures, you’ll find that in many cases, it’s not spending money that is allowing some teams that are cellar dwellers in the standings winning the profit game.

Using Forbes’ operating income figures, one measure of profitability, sees several unlikely clubs making more than their higher valued counterparts.

The most notable of these clubs are the Washington Nationals, and the Florida Marlins.

In terms of the Nationals, they are pulling profits based on a very good lease agreement, and new stadium, while in the midst of a rebuilding process with the roster. For the Marlins, it is a matter of setting the player payroll to levels that may redefine the word "stingy". The Marlins Opening Day payroll is at $20 million, a third less than what they spent on player payroll last year. To place it in perspective, that's $5 million less than what the club will receive in revenue-sharing, which is projected to be $25 million.

Below is the top 10 clubs by operating income for this year's Forbes valuations.

Forbes most profitable

 

Who's Making the Least, or "Losing" Money

A clear indication that MLB's financial state is extremely robust, five years ago the Forbes valuations showed 16 clubs with operating income in the red. This year sees 3 clubs, the Blue Jays ($1.8 million), Red Sox ($19.1 million), and Yankees ($47.3 million) posting "losses". In the case of the Yankees posting a considerable operating loss, it is due to their exceptionally high player payroll (a record $218.3 million), and dolling out the vast majority of all funds paid into revenue-sharing ($100 million).

Note, however, that "losses" are in quotes as all three of these clubs have significant stakes in Regional Sports Networks (RSNs) that contribute to their bottom lines, but skirt the edges of what is technically counted as club revenues. As reported by Ozanian and Badenhausen, "For the owners of the Yankees and Red Sox, the huge dividends they get from their unconsolidated cable networks more than make up for the teams' losses. Meanwhile Rogers Communications, which owns the Blue Jays, their stadium and the cable channel that televises its games, derives huge benefits from owning the Blue Jays not reflected on its team's [Profit & Lose] statement."

Below are the clubs showing the least amount of operating income, or in the case of the Blue Jays, Red Sox, and Yankees, operating loss

 

Forbes least profitable

The Yankees Continue To Build an Empire

In the wake of the Red Sox winning two World Series championships in the last four years, some have said that the Red Sox, not the Yankees, are the new “Evil Empire.” While there is little discounting that the Red Sox are healthy in every respect financially, when compared to the Yankees, the Sox are still a distant second.

How far are they behind the Yankees? Consider the following: According to the Forbes valuations when accounting for inflation, the value of the Yankees in 2002 ($857,303,982.31) is greater than what the Red Sox are reported to be worth now ($816 million).

According to Ozanian and Badenhausen, “The Yankee brand (the portion of the team's value attributable to its name) alone is worth $241 million, almost as much as the entire Florida Marlins franchise.”

The value of the Yankees should hit $1.5 billion with the opening of new Yankee Stadium (see information on new Yankee Stadium here) in 2009.

Below shows how the Yankees value is compared to the Red Sox over the last six years (not adjusted for inflation)

Yankees Red Sox Valuations

Value of team based on values, such as current stadium deal (unless new stadium is pending) without deduction for debt (other than stadium debt).

An Angelic Rise in Value

In southern California, there are clear signs that in-part, private ownership has yielded better increases in value than under corporate ownership. Case in point, the incredible rise in value for the Angels.

Since Arte Moreno, the billboard advertiser magnate, purchased the club from the Walt Disney Co. in 2003 for $180 million, there has been a steady increase in the value of the club (see graph below, adjusted for inflation). While most all clubs have seen values increase above inflation, the Angels have climbed in value 48 percent during Moreno’s ownership tenure, when adjusting for inflation from approx $258.1 million to $500 million.

What has been amazing is that the Angels meteoric rise in value has come without a new stadium, or stadium related revenues such as new luxury suites. The Angels also have not seen lavish revenues from full or partial ownership of an RSN, such as the Red Sox or Yankees enjoy.

What Moreno has done is take lessons learned from his advertising background, and applied it to the Angels, most notably through the controversial renaming of the franchise to include the words “Los Angeles”, and gave Scouting and Player Development the flexibility to field competitive teams and sign key free agents.

"When Arte purchased the Angels, he did so with a short-term strategy and a long-term vision," said Angels spokesman, Tim Mead. "Located in the second biggest media market in the country, he emphasized we were a big-market club and would conduct ourselves accordingly."

Mead points out that Moreno's change in direction happened almost immediately.  With changes in branding of the color red, Angels Baseball, and the letter "A" that became focal points for the business side of the organization.   

"Our success is based on the fan experience at Angel Stadium, affordability of tickets, concessions and merchandising, as well as the expectations of our on-field product." 

The graph below outlines how the Angels have continued to climb in value by showing their ranking compared to the other 30 clubs since 2002.  

Angels Valuations

Below are the approx. values by way of Forbes, both non and inflation adjusted

Year
Rank
Value
Inflation Adj.
2002
23rd
$195M
$229,005,858
2003
20th
$225M
$258,044,462
2004
20th
$241M
$271,240,717
2005
17th
$294M
$320,320,585
2006
13th
$368M
$387,761,600
2007
13th
$431M
$431,000,000
2008
6th
$500M
$500,000,00

Are the Rockies Headed Back in the Right Direction?

There’s little denying that the surprise performance of last year’s season was the Colorado Rockies. Defying the odds, the team that hadn’t had a winning season since 2000, and was last seen in the playoffs in 1995, went all the way to the World Series last year before meeting up with the Red Sox and ending their Cinderella run.

The club was in need of the performance as the club has cycled down in value since being so successful after expanding into the league. At the end of March, the club renewed their naming rights deal with Coors Brewing for 10-years, and added in-stadium naming rights to two sections within the ballpark. The premium seats and lounge area behind home plate is now known as the Coors Clubhouse. The picnic area behind centerfield is called Coors Field Picnic Area. The financial terms were not released, but it is bound to continue pulling the Rockies out of their recent valuation slide.

How badly were the winning and naming rights deals needed? Looking at the 6-year set of Forbes data sees the Rockies as the club that has increased in value the least. In fact, the Yankees have increased in value 24 times as much as the team from Colorado.

While the raw figures show an increase in valuation from 2002 to 2008 for the Rockies, when adjusting for inflation, the Rockies are actually worth less today than in 2002 dollars (see image and graph below)

Forbes Rockies

Year
Value
Inflation Adj.
2002
$347M
$408M
2003
$304M
$349M
2004
$285M
$321M
2005
$290M
$316M
2006
$298M
$314M
2007
$317M
$317M
2008
$371M
$371

Bottom Feeders

South Florida has the dubious distinction of being home to not one, but two of the least valuable franchises over the course of the past six years. Both the Marlins and Rays have been in the bottom five in value every year, and to make matters worse, they have ranked at 29th or 30th more than any other clubs. The Marlins have been 29th or 30th three times (30th in 2007 and 2008, and 29th in 2003) while the Rays hold the “very bottom” rankings five times (30th in 2005 and 2006, and 29th in 2007 and 2008).

 The now Tampa Bay Rays (the word "Devil" has been removed, and a complete team rebranding has taken place with both uniforms and logos), have also set eyes on redeveloping Al Lang Field in downtown St. Petersburg. To offset costs, the land (85 acres) where Tropicana Field is located would be redeveloped as a major retail, entertainment, and housing development. (See renderings of the proposed open-air Rays facility and other details, like you see in the image to the right)

In the case of the Marlins, their value has remained low, in part, due to playing in Dolphin Stadium, a substandard facility, and one in which they do not control the revenue streams as former Marlins owner Wayne Huizenga owns the facility. That may change as the Marlins are close to landing funding for a retractable roof stadium on the site of the former Orange Bowl (see renderings of one proposed design). Nevertheless, one of the primary reasons that the Marlins continue slice margins by setting the aforementioned player payroll so exceedingly low. To place this in perspective, the largest increase in value occurred the year after the Marlins won the World Series in 2003. The value increased 26 percent the year after in 2004 but has since declined in each consecutive year.

See graph showing percent of change from the year prior for both the Marlins and Rays:

Year
Marlins
Rays
Value
% of Increase
From Year
Prior
Value
% of Increase
From Year
Prior
2002
$137M
N/A
$142M
1%
2003
$136M
-1%
$145M
2%
2004
$172M
26%
$152M
2%
2005
$206M
19%
$176M
16%
2006
$226M
10%
$209M
19%
2007
$244M
8%
$267M
28%
2008
$256M
5%
$290M
8%

Other Points of Interest

  • Unsurprisingly, the Yankees have been the most valuable of all the franchises during the course of the six years examined.
  • The Mets and Red Sox have jockeyed back and forth in the #2 ranking, with the Red Sox holding the distinction in consecutive years (2004-2006) and the Mets holding the honors in 2002-2003 and 2007-2008.
  • The largest increases in value from 2007 to 2008: Rockies (17%); Nationals, Angels and White Sox (16%); Brewers (15%); Indians, Tigers, and Twins (14%); and Rangers and Red Sox (13%)
  • Largest increase in value for a given year: 114 percent when the then MLB owned Montreal Expos/Washington Nationals were relocated to D.C. in 2005.
  • Largest figures for operating income over the six-year period: Washington Nationals ($43.7 million in 2008), Florida Marlins ($43.3 million, 2007 and $35.6 million in 2008), Cleveland Indians ($34.6 million in 2006) and Baltimore Orioles ($34 million in 2006)
  • Years by clubs reporting a loss by way of operating income (NOTE: Forbes’ 2003 figures shows more than half the league running at a loss): 2008 (3) – Yankees, Red Sox, Blue Jays, 2007 (1) – Yankees, 2006 (5) – Yankees, Red Sox, Mets, Marlins, Angels. 2005 (10) – Yankees, Red Sox, Mets, Dodgers, Mariners, Cardinals, Angels, Rockies, D-Backs, Twins, 2004 (14) – Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Braves, Cardinals, Rangers, Phillies, D-Backs, Angels, Pirates, Marlins, Twins, Expos, 2003 (16) – Red Sox, Dodgers, Rangers, Indians, Astros, Cardinals, D-Backs, Phillies, Tigers, Angels, Pirates, Brewers, Blue Jays, Royals, Marlins, Expos, 2002 (10) – Red Sox, Dodgers, Indians, Rangers, D-Backs, Cardinals, White Sox, Blue Jays, Devil Rays, Expos
  • Largest reported figures for operating at a loss: Yankees (-$50 million in 2006, -$47.3 million in 2008, and $-37.1 million in 2005), Angels (-$30 million in 2005) and Dodgers ($-29.6 million in 2002)

League Averages, By Year

The following shows the average value, 1-year change, debt/value ratio, revenues, and operating income for the league by year of the study. 

League Avgs.: 2002 - 2008
Year
Value
1-Yr Value Change (%)
Debt/
Value
(%)
Rev
($mil)
Op Income ($mil)
2002
$286.3M
11
39.3
119.5
2.5
2003
$290.5M
3
N/A
N/A
-1.3
2004
$292.1M
8.24
43.1
129.3
-1.9
2005
$332M
14.5
39.7
142.3
4.42
2006
376.5
14.9
33.5
157.8
12.06
2007
431.5
14.8
35.2
170.4
16.52
2008
471.6
9.21
32.7
150.4
16.41

Conclusions

The obvious finding in looking at the Forbes figures is that all the clubs are in a healthy state these days. Valuations continue to climb, and fewer and fewer clubs are operating under what Forbes sees as operating loss.

What the figures also show is that often times, the clubs that have cried poverty in the past, or said that they would be unable to compete in the free agency market without considerable assistance by way of revenue-sharing, are, in fact, pulling in healthy profits.

And while one can shrug off that issue by saying all the clubs are making more money, there are signs that the most valuable are growing at a rate faster than their mid-to-low level counterparts. In other words, there is an increasing disparity in valuation.

That would make sense; larger market clubs such as the Yankees, Red Sox, Mets, Dodgers, Angels, Cubs, and White Sox should be in a position to increase their values by way of RSNs, more lucrative sponsorship deals, and increased brand recognition. The good news is that during Selig's tenure, the institution of revenue-sharing, and to a larger extent, the introduction of the Wild Card has allowed more parity in terms of the standings than ever before.

Finally, as mentioned at the outset, Forbes and MLB may come to different figures each year. However, it is clear that until MLB decides to open their books to the public, the Forbes valuations paint a clear picture in terms of trends in the industry. In 2008, when it comes to MLB, business is good.


References:

  • All data referenced, Forbes 
  • NOTE: Use the following link to see all data used for the historical references (2002-2008)
  • Revenues and operating income are for a given season and include revenue sharing.
  • "Value" - Value of team for a given year based on current stadium deal (unless new stadium is pending), without deduction for debt (other than stadium debt).
  • "% of Change" - Current team value compared with most recent transaction.
  • "Debt/Value" - Includes stadium debt.
  • "Operating Income" - earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation.
  • "N/A" - not applicable.

Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the Founder and President of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is contributor to Baseball Prospectus, and is available as a freelance writer.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?