new york and company credit card secure login standard chartered credit card customer care number singapore cash advance loans no credit check australia all credit cards in one place credit card app uk how long does it take to get credit card in the mail alaska airlines credit card canada application disney credit card canada instant payday loans no credit check canada getting a secured credit card bank of america online credit cards canada bank of america credit cards compromised 2013 capital one credit card for high school students capital one online banking credit cards canada hdfc gold credit card cash back offer best credit card rate malaysia barclays credit card ppi complaints apply credit cards online no credit business credit cards for new businesses standard chartered credit card login uae hdfc credit card reward points catalogue gold card best credit cards for business owners fidelity cash back credit card reviews how to get us credit card for foreigners citi vs discover student credit card neiman marcus credit card services phone number new payday loan lenders no brokers sbi international credit card apply capital one credit card cash advance pin visa card services online best credit card travel offers standard bank credit cards application credit card processing how to redeem bonus points of hdfc credit card what credit card should i get if i have no credit uk credit card number wiki tj maxx credit card information stolen bpi credit card application form pdf apply for credit cards online canada is there a credit card app for ipad taking out a loan to pay off credit card debt best low interest credit cards for students walmart credit card application form 0 balance transfer and purchases best cashback credit cards uae chase visa credit card my account best buy rewards zone credit card payment hdfc credit card help desk payment change mastercard securecode college student credit cards visa standard bank online application for credit card credit card debt after death california negotiating with credit card companies to reduce debt uk unsecured business cash advances barclays premier credit card uae best interest free credit card transfers fixed vs variable interest rate credit card chase credit card debt consolidation free credit score check uk no credit card bad credit bank accounts apply online free annual credit report score without credit card cash loans to your door belfast is it possible to get a credit card with bad credit australia major credit card company list kroger visa rewards card login payday loan lenders only no teletrack capital one no credit credit card best student credit card canada 2012 best way to use a credit card to build your credit ps bank credit card application online philippines cash advance payday loans online visa credit card instant approval major credit card companies in canada hsbc credit card reward points pakistan easiest credit card to get approved for granite credit card uk best rewards credit card 2011 consumer reports iphone credit card processing lowest rate 0 balance transfer credit card offers australia best travel credit card bonus offers bank of ireland visa debit card charges business credit cards comparison shopping tips how can a small business accept credit cards online should i close my first premier credit card how to get a credit card with bad credit car loan with bad credit and no cosigner nhs black card code tata sbi credit card online payment fast online cash loans nz amazon credit card security breach good visa credit cards for students mastercard debit card benefits this transaction cannot be processed without a credit card verification number online loan lenders uk how do i redeem my amazon credit card points chevron texaco credit card login anz credit card balance transfer form temporary credit card number visa free company credit card policy template 0 down mortgage loans with bad credit american express compare credit cards free credit check uk no credit card does chase have credit cards for college students united credit card 50000 bonus miles apply for a walmart credit card over the phone low rate credit card comparison wachovia wells fargo credit card rewards american express corporate credit card customer care number corporate credit cards for small business can you pay best buy credit card in store what credit cards are good for rebuilding credit pnb credit card apply online in delhi hsbc credit card reward points catalogue pakistan which credit cards give free travel insurance online long term loans no credit check rbc visa cards canada secure credit card bank of america online credit cards instant approval walmart prepaid visa card best credit card for balance transfers uk instant credit card approval with bad credit canada bank of america airline rewards credit cards credit card logos png pay chase visa card online capital one credit cards review texas business free credit card terminal delta community credit union credit cards uk comparison online credit card payment hdfc best reward travel credit cards accept credit cards by phone no credit check hdfc credit card apply online in mumbai best prepaid credit card canada hsbc credit card online application form india capital one platinum card interest rate icici instant credit card activation credit card minimum payment law 2011 credit card payoff calculator with amortization td bank visa debit card balance equifax credit score i need a bad credit loan not a payday loan best buy credit card login hsbc login net pay advance inc american express gold delta skymiles credit card login business credit card natwest online cibc visa credit card information top 20 payday lenders no brokers visa black card review 2013 best low interest rate credit cards manchester united credit card maybank can you use a visa gift card to get cash back pay as you go credit card processing canada online payday loans bad credit canada hsbc credit cards application online how to accept credit card payments on iphone credit card offer hdfc best preloaded credit cards how long does it take to get a refund on your credit card citi student visa credit card login barclays credit card contact number india 3d secure credit card transactions no fee prepaid visa cards canada unsecured credit cards to build your credit 0 balance transfer credit card poor credit what is a cash advance transaction fee chase credit card protection insurance visa card generator with security code international travel credit card usage visa credit card processing charges us bank credit card login rei real credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date 2013 intuit credit card processing credit card protection plan singapore virgin balance transfer credit card minimum payment best balance transfer credit cards for fair credit apply for sbi credit card online india army navy federal credit union is it safe to apply for a chase credit card online real working credit card numbers and security codes kotak credit card online payment minimum requirements for getting a credit card hilton uk credit card list of online loan sharks banana republic visa credit card rewards us airways credit card 40000 miles no annual fee how to apply for a credit card swipe machine capital one business credit card limit how to cancel bank of america credit card protection unsecured guaranteed credit cards canada trust visa card western union gold card hdfc credit card application form pdf best credit cards usa 2013 sample visa credit card number philippines small business credit card comparison canada my virgin credit card which credit card is easiest to get in india maybank online credit card application philippines instant paypal virtual credit card how to lower credit card interest rate citibank credit card online bill pay ambank credit card balance transfer malaysia apply for best buy credit card over phone mastercard credit card number format how to enhance hdfc credit card limit credit cards applications online india easy department store credit cards with no credit what is a credit card balance transfer can i get a credit card after bankruptcy discharge uk prepaid us credit card outside us nab credit cards travel insurance hdfc bank international credit card charges chase secure deposit credit card amscot payday advance how do credit card annual interest rates work compare travel reward cards canada credit card with no annual fee secured vs unsecured credit card 10 best credit cards to have short term loans online direct lenders barclay credit card number gap visa card services no deposit home loans with bad credit discover credit cards fair credit city union bank credit card online apply hsbc visa card security code mastercard debit card philippines high limit unsecured credit cards bad credit no foreign transaction fee prepaid credit card hsbc student credit card canada chase best buy credit card application make a payment on bank of america credit cards clark howard best rewards credit cards 3 biggest credit card companies go compare the market credit cards chase credit card app for android hsbc amanah credit card balance transfer hsbc corporate credit card singapore credit card credit score requirement prepaid visa debit cards canada paypal not accepting prepaid credit cards allied cash advance careers no interest no payment credit card offers chase secured credit card application 100 online payday loans no phone calls amscot cash advance no checkbook eligibility for platinum credit card hdfc difference between gold and platinum hdfc credit cards icici online credit card application mastercard priceless nights mbna credit card canada review tesco credit card interest free period typical m&s credit card limit virgin credit card balance transfer australia hsbc credit card apply online india applying for a secured credit card with bad credit payday loans with bad credit rating chase credit card payments at branch what are some of the best credit cards to have balance transfer calculator malaysia ford motor company credit card application cancelling credit expert travel credit cards canada review best reward credit cards 2012 uk lowest apr credit card 2012 neiman marcus credit card limit incircle neiman marcus credit card best secured credit cards bank of canada credit card debt chevron texaco credit card payment login southwest airlines credit card free flight 0 interest balance transfer credit cards with no transfer fee bad credit credit cards no deposit required mobile credit card processing reviews uk bank credit cards india linking everyday rewards cards interest on cash advances chase credit card visa or mastercard best credit card canada for bad credit credit cards for bad credit online application cibc aeroplan credit card travel insurance capital one credit card uk review top 10 best secured credit cards icici instant credit card eligibility lowest apr credit cards credit union credit suisse login unsecured credit cards for bad credit not prepaid android credit card payment app how to get a prepaid credit card under 18 bad credit car leasing square credit card approval capital one credit card account restricted santander 123 credit card instant decision redflagdeals compare credit cards secured credit card 10000 limit apply for a loan online instant decision bad credit capital one bank secured credit card valid visa credit card number 2011 visa cash card easy to get credit cards military pcs pay advance credit card comparison qantas points random credit card number generator with security code online how to get rid of credit card debt in canada no fee credit cards with travel rewards does american express gold card improve credit history which credit card is best for me singapore credit card search engine fake credit card numbers that work orchard bank credit card bill pay address icici bank instant platinum credit card review update apple id without credit card south west trains gold card discount gold credit card uk credit card bank numbers wiki hsbc online credit cards australia online direct payday lenders no teletrack learn how credit card processing works credit card debt relief act 2010 southwest airline credit card application easy cash loans online south africa icici bank international credit card ryanair credit card charges bank of america credit card phone number credit card services mbna benefits of visa signature credit cards delta credit card offer 2013 best travel credit cards 2013 uk capital one aspire world credit card best no fee credit card canada 2011 td gold elite visa card requirements sbi visa gold international debit card visa cash advance calculator hsbc personal loan against credit card secured credit card no foreign transaction fee how to get an itunes account without a credit card in uk compare hsbc and citibank credit cards accept credit card payments mobile credit cards after bankruptcy 2013 td bank visa debit card rewards login us bank credit card processing fees reclaim credit card charges from barclaycard credit card frauds in uk anz credit card promotions singapore chase visa reward cards long term loans with bad credit history chase visa credit card services rona advantage credit card payday loan online instant college student credit cards how much money do credit card companies make annually mbna credit card canada phone number united credit card offer small business credit card offers no personal guarantee td canada trust visa debit verified by visa hdfc credit card payment by other bank credit card guaranteed unsecured credit card how to sign up for amazon prime without credit card cibc credit card services contact number how to get a business credit card with bad personal credit canada visa credit card company history how to get a credit card online in nigeria store reward cards app for iphone fast installment loans online going over credit card limit hsbc no credit check payday loans amazon uk credit card login new direct payday loan lenders chase united credit card customer service phone number best reward credit card 2011 uk how to accept credit card payments best credit card for cash advance malaysia hdfc credit card payment online from other bank account 10 top credit cards how to get a black card from american express how do i find my usaa credit card pin easy credit cards to get approved for business suze orman paying off credit card debt prepaid reloadable credit cards no monthly fees average household credit card debt canada ge capital credit card payment phone number anz platinum credit card review first premier bank credit card login ebay hdfc credit card deals my first premier credit card login in best cash reward business credit card best credit card apr best credit card reward system rbs black credit card best credit card rewards program canada 2011 tesco credit card payment date visa credit cards for bad credit with no deposit iphone credit card reader starbucks rbs credit cards online india free reward cards uk apply for business credit card with ein number gnc gold card discount cash back business credit cards canada bdo online credit card application philippines td canada credit card processing can i receive credit card payments via paypal halifax platinum credit card cash back list best credit card processing companies cash advance rate best cash advance credit card check credit history free without credit card small business options for accepting credit card payments best reward credit card offers 2013 guaranteed payday loans direct lenders travel credit card post office ann taylor credit card phone number moneysavingexpert best cashback cards visa credit card 10000 limit free usa virtual credit card low interest credit cards for students hdfc credit card deals and offers get credit card same day gas saving credit card canada apply for credit card with no credit or bad credit apply for bad credit loan by phone how do i cancel my maurices credit card tesco credit card visa mastercard who has the best small business credit card premier credit card manager credit card information form word pay my household credit card online bank of america credit card cash advance check what;s a verification code on a credit card credit card with good rewards program halifax visa card issue number hsbc credit card apply online in delhi credit card fees for merchants comparison bad credit payday loan lenders only top rated credit cards for balance transfers top 50 credit cards citi student credit cards login national cash advance toledo very easy to get credit cards application for credit card hdfc bank best online payday loan direct lenders bank of america credit card fraud department using lloyds tsb platinum credit card abroad how to increase credit card limit hsbc elavon credit card machine rolls apply for halifax credit card online chase credit card apr calculator get a bad credit credit card how to apply credit card in hsbc online philippines will the government help with credit card debt 0 interest credit cards no credit needed bridgestone firestone credit card accepted best credit cards canada no fee bad credit loans direct lenders canada pay citifinancial credit card bill online best credit cards visa black canada credit cards comparison td visa infinite lost card canadian secured visa credit card canada credit cards cash back barclays business credit card us tesco credit card lost best cashback credit card malaysia 2012 department store credit cards issued by capital one do company credit cards affect personal credit lowest balance transfer rate credit card philippines cash loans online instant approval when will aib get visa debit cards credit cards for poor credit with no annual fee what;s the easiest credit card to get approved for with no credit how to claim natwest credit card points virgin credit card log on uk credit card machine for iphone 3gs fake valid credit card numbers expiration dates generate us credit card number http capital one credit cards compare sam;s discover card login credit cards credit card banks usa how to get credit card refund tesco credit card login account chase apply credit card black visa card australia how do i apply for a walmart credit card online credit card application hsbc india pay a walmart credit card payment going over credit limit bank of america starwood preferred guest(r) credit card from american express reloadable credit cards with no fees how to pay bank of america credit card online with chase bp gas credit card balance capital one credit card visa signature test credit card numbers with security code paypal credit cards for bad credit no processing fee credit card authorization form pdf template how does apr work on a secured credit card hdfc credit card helpline number kolkata filing bankruptcy on credit cards debt can a credit card company sue you in california how to get a credit card with bad credit nz mastercard credit card protection credit card debt relief company reviews
Home All Articles Solving Baseball's Financial Inequities

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 527 guests online

Atom RSS

Solving Baseball's Financial Inequities PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
Articles & Opinion
Written by Adam Holzman   
Tuesday, 15 April 2008 19:54

A Biz of Baseball OriginalThe following is a guest article by Adam Holzman.

Since the introduction of free agency in the mid-1970s, the salaries of Major League Baseball players have risen without limit. The abolishment of the reserve clause, which bound a player to his original team for the duration of his career (barring a trade), forced MLB owners to compete with each other in attracting premier players to play for their teams, driving up player salaries. As a result, many small market teams find it difficult to compete in a market where large market teams can offer substantially larger sums of money to free agents. While the reserve clause unfairly restricted the salaries of MLB players, free agency has threatened the competitive balance of the game. However, is a salary cap an appropriate solution to create balance in the playing field?

Certainly, small market teams are disadvantaged in the free agency market. In Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game, author Michael Lewis explains how Doug Pappas, the late, great sabermatrician, measures the quality of a team’s front office by determining the team’s “marginal wins” (all wins above the 49th) and “marginal salary” (all payroll dollars spent above $7 million). Dividing marginal wins by marginal salary gives the team’s financial efficiency for a given year. From 2005 through 2007, the median financial efficiency for MLB teams was $2,265,414.99 per marginal win. In 2007, the minimum number of wins needed to make the playoffs in the American League in 2007 was 94, or 45 marginal wins. (see a detailed breakdown of the 2007 Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll here on The Biz of Baseball). Therefore, a team operating at the average efficiency level would have had to commit to a marginal payroll of $101,943,674.60, or a total payroll of $108,943,674.60. Since most small market teams cannot afford to spend this much on payroll, the general managers of these teams are forced to find ways to operate at higher levels of efficiency in order to compete with large market teams. Clearly, small market teams have an inherent disadvantage in free agency.

Select Read More to see the rest of this orginal article.

However, before we declare that a salary cap is a viable measure to fix the problem of competitive balance, we must consider its feasibility and its consequences. Firstly, the hope that a salary cap will be implemented in the near future is unreasonable. Not only would large market teams be reluctant to concede their financial advantage in the free agency market, but the Major League Baseball Players’ Association (MLBPA), the most powerful union in America, would not accept any measure that would decrease the amount of money being spent on player salaries. If the commissioner’s office were to attempt to install a salary cap, the decision would almost certainly be followed by the most prolonged strike in the history of major league sports.

In addition, the question must be asked: would a salary cap actually provide us with a more entertaining league? In the NFL (which has a salary cap), team quality fluctuates drastically from year to year, and the final standings of each season are almost impossible to predict. I may be in the minority, but I find a league with a greater degree of continuity to be much more entertaining. To me, one of the most appealing aspects of being a fan of a certain team is being able to watch the front office construct a contender or a dynasty from a previously hopeless club. I worry that a strict salary cap, while fixing the problem of competitive balance, would create too much parity throughout the league.

A stronger luxury tax system is most likely the best possible available method for leveling the playing field among large market and small market teams. While large market teams will still have the option to spend higher amounts of revenue on payroll, they will be taxed a certain percentage of their total payroll. This tax revenue will then be distributed amongst teams that do not surpass a predetermined payroll threshold.

However, out of this system of revenue redistribution arises another question: how can MLB administration prevent the owners of small market teams from pocketing the redistributed funds and refusing to spend it on payroll? Contrary to conventional wisdom, an owner’s ultimate goal is not necessarily to construct a winning team, but to make a profit. Because these two goals often go hand in hand (winning teams should increase team popularity and, therefore, team revenues), the distinction is sometimes overlooked.

One must consider the incentives presented to small market team owners in producing winning teams. When a small market team competes with a large market team for a high profile free agent, the small market team would inevitably have to spend a higher percentage of its total revenue in order to win the players’ services. Even if the small market owner decides to make this financial commitment, the financial returns on his investment will be less than what they would have been for the large market team. For argument’s sake, let’s assume that whichever team signs a certain high profile free agent will receive attention from an additional 2% of the team’s metropolitan area. In other words, 2% of the area’s population who previously could’ve cared less about the team now begins to spend money on tickets, jerseys, etc, because of the attraction of the newly-signed player. For a team in New York, this would signal an increase of about 376,370 local fans (2% of 18,818,536 total people in the metropolitan area), while, in Milwaukee, the team would receive increased revenues from only 30,200 additional fans (2% of 1,509,981 total people). If I am the owner of a small market team, why would I invest a greater percentage of my revenues in a player that will produce less increased revenue for my team than he would for a large market team? Small market owners, such as those of the Florida Marlins, are often criticized for a lack of commitment to producing a winning team, but, in reality, there is a lesser amount of financial incentive for the Marlins’ ownership to construct a winner than there is for large market teams.

The solution to the problem produced by the incentive disparity is twofold. Firstly, in addition to the luxury tax threshold described above, a salary “floor” should be implemented. Teams with payrolls below this floor would not be eligible to receive the redistributed luxury tax revenues, creating an incentive for stingy owners to spend more money on payroll. Secondly, the redistributed revenue should act less like a donation and more like an interest free loan. If the owners do not spend the added funds on team payroll by the end of the season, the money will be returned to the commissioner’s office. In other words, if a team receives $8 million in redistributed funds but only spends $5 million on payroll, the owner of the team will not be allowed to retain the extra $3 million. This removes any incentives that small market owners have to restrict team payroll. As a result of this plan, small market teams should become more financially competitive in the free agency market relative to large market teams.

Most importantly, the MLBPA would not be opposed to this plan. While an NFL-style salary cap would reduce the total amount of money spent on player salaries, the luxury tax plan may, in fact, promote increased spending on payroll. Although the ability of large market teams to agree to astronomical contracts would be restricted, small market teams would simultaneously begin to commit more money to team payroll. Because more teams would have a legitimate chance to sign high priced free agents, the competition among owners to sign such free agents would increase. Such competition would increase the negotiating leverage of the players, naturally driving up player salaries. All things considered, this luxury tax system appears to fix the problem of competitive balance between large market and small market teams, preserve the ability of a team to produce a consistent contender, and satisfy the MLBPA’s demands. I doubt that a salary cap would have the same level of success. 


Adam Holzman is a senior at Amity Regional High School in Woodbridge, CT., and is a guest contributor to the Business of Sports Network. He will be attending Yale University in the fall.  



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?