order amoxil online order fosamax online swiss meds so lexapro coupon 2012 femara cheaper buy prednisolone for dogs buy synthroid no prescription needed is healthy man reputable viagra mailed ordered from canada where do i buy cialis propranolol without priscribtion sildenafil citrate in natural form tamoxifen bodybuilding allegra suspension 30mg esomeprazole can i cut augmentin pill in half online pharmacy 365 viagra for sale in usa levitra cheapest price buy dapoxetine with paypal canada celebrex online libido411 finasteride 1 mg mylan atorvastatin recall buy sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg viagra competition where to legally buy barb pills generic levetiracetam buy cytotec online usa cheap canadian meds augmentin cost ireland effexor xr without rx xenical sales australia finapecia o-long 100 oral jelly fincar 5mg prednisone 1 mg buy aricept online australia cialis (tadalafil) 20mg diflucan one pill or two where to purchase viagra diclofenac 150 mg viagra story best legal online site to buy viagra buy prozac china buy aciclovir tablets walgreens vs walmart on viagra topamax 150 mg abilify sales augmentin missed pill e-how viagra zovirax without prescription xenical without script amoxil 1000 mg dosage buy generic viagra overnight shipping best generic cialis no prscription cialis abilify cheap price hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg online meloxidyl without a prescription fedex viagra generic buy metformin online usa buy terbinafine tablets pantoprazole generic price abilify xl price advair where to buy xenical apcalis crestor 40 pill canadian pharmacy india cost of lamictal xr drug cipla product list doxycycline for dogs sale viagra 120 mg order trazodone cheap elocon without a prescription buy manforce sildenafil citrate online for example: viagra pharmacy rx one discount code sildenafil purchase uk pet meds without prescription order actavis online generic paxil mexico viagra 2 day delivery doxycycline 100 mg no prescription dove ordinare viagra augmentin duo forte price cheap viagra online overnight shipping pantoprazole tablet 40 mg imigran cymbalta from canada pharmacy prednisone 5 mg weight gain overnight letrozole zetia 0.5 mg what strength cialis get free levitra tetraciclina kamagra pills paypal buying nizagara on line kamagra 100mg australia orlistat uk where to buy promethazine in singapore viagra no presciption price diovan hct 160 zoloft order canada canadian original viagra canada viagra no script cymbalta generic available 2013 generic plavix usa pfeiffer viagra on line orlistat availability cialis cheap buy propecia online ukraine buy cialis online in canada usa viagra online pharmacy allegra d generic rapharmacy viagra kuala lumpur generic cymbalta still expensive does prednisone get into breast milk price of diovan 80 mg cymbalta copay card buy generic viagra buy online prevacid the safest place to buy levitra on site zoloft online uk why clomid day 3 and not 5 cheap paroxetine online order femara online no prescription strattera vs intuniv andkon donepezil hcl 5 mg tablet cialis online rezeptfrei aus kanada buy fluconazole for humans stdto can i buy tetracycline over the counter wellbutrin generic india zithromax over the counter cvs otc tenormin syntbyroid over the counter levitra super active (generic cialis chewable tablets how to get valtrex for cheap can i take 50 mg of cialis rogaine buy canada flomax generic amitriptyline hcl 150 mg stilnox online buy synthroid levothyroxine warfarin where to buy yasmin pill yasminelle generic simvastatin 2006 buy abilify no prescription 250 mg diamox buy paypal methylprednisolone over the counter best price for viagra 100mg vigora sex tablet woman cialis sample viagra dutasteride 2.5 mg buy estrogen pills uk nolvadex in mexico i ran out of my aciphex buy tadalafil online india trazodone can get you high buy levitra hong kong acquistare propecia price naproxen sodium walmart dapoxetine ssri mifepristone price in south africa lasix no prescription needed buy metformin 500 mg buy viagra online save buy rogaine 2 canada where can i buy avodart spray generic propecia fda approved metformin 500 mg zyd online thai pharmacy generic viagra coupon kamagra kuala lumpur levetiracetam pill baseball five tools trappe tavern cheap levitra online us 2103 cvs std pills viagra us pharmacy fedex delivery very fast delivery on viagra to uk anthony kiedis long hair buy strattera 60mg strattera adults buy phenergan price buy predisone research drugs nolvadex priligy fda approval chloromycetin ointment for sale cialis fast delivery in 3 days abilify tablet yan etkileri buy keppra tablets uk viagra150mg buy levitra online india domperidone 10 mg new zealand phenergan generic drug lasix 40 mg deutsch cheap free shipping cialis sildenafil 100mg levitra vs. staxyn acnetane pills like viagra buy amoxicillin uk no prescription sildenafil generico in farmacia buy prilosec internet taking cialis without ed valacyclovir buy online canada diovan shortage uk buy fluoxitine without a prescription price of doxycycline at walgreens medicare lipitor cost illegal cialis sildenafil pill paroxetine rxlist buy seroquel without prescription simvastatin 80mg tab prednisone for cats no prescription cheap prozac tablets celebrex 100 mg effets secondaires extreme peptides anastrozole get viagra jelly from india now buy diflucan without a prescription order levitra online canada zovirax dosage for herpes price fosamax 35 mg viagra pills mexico buy jumex online nexium 40 mg 28 tablet yan etkileri yasmine pill without script zithromax order toronto drug stor india vytorin novothyral italia avapro without prescription wellbutrin generic prescription finasteride online pharmacy store buy allegra uk nexium 20mg 40mg tablets cheap nexium 40 mg inderal online blue pill pfizer vgr 100 phenergan order singulair price generic tramadol online scams cialis generic online from canada propecia international shipping generic viagra online canada pharmacy generic proscar saw palmetto in hindi nizagara online without prescription cialis pills clomid sale cheap nolvadex in australia tadalafil made in india rx pharmacy ciallis buy generic lexapro overnight finpecia tabletten plavix pill stieva a cream on line cymbalta price pharmacy tramadol online cod payment buying nizoral 2 shampoo best prices on online generic propecia order fosamax canada flonase best price selling cytotec abilify 15 singulair cost buy accutane online europe synthroid 150 blue pill buy prozac pills how to take levitra for best results viagra tablets in pakistan urdu 466 celebrex health canada cialis cost viagra video ampicillin 500 mg vial reconstitution amoxicillin for sale online sweetcheeks augmentin wholesale price clomid no prescription uk indian viagra postal purchase where to order clomid online eutirox 100 precio amoxicillin pills go bad birmingham erectile dysfunction order doxycycline overnight delivery buy omeprazole cap propecia price nz gabapentin generic nexium over the counter price on line pharmacy france sildenafil or viagara cheap name brand viagra pavitra rishta.citizen tv. over the counter oral lamisil citalopram purchase with a mastercard womenssex buy lasix without rx is cialis safe furosemide equine use get cialis without aprescription generic lipitor available in canada isotretinoin products generic acyclovir from india pharmacy outside us canadian drugstore viagra ordering cialis 5mg prescription buy fluoxetine in the uk buy prednisone uk buy phenergan 25 mg online uk vytorin discount canadian health and care mall valacyclovir online canada buy viagra kuala lumpur fosamax cost nz revia medication online no prescription acheter cialis online generic viagra with free shipping vitamin b12 usa cheap cialis, paypal anyone bought viagra online xenical 120 mg capsulas son buenas seroquel off shore simvastatin buy online order nizagara 100mg generic singulair china rogaine 10.00 coupon celebrex medicine viagra price online cialis blood thinner esomeprazole 20 mg order nolvadex cream cheapest nolvadex no perscription lisinoprill best generic viagra visa only cialis free offer voucker avodart generic availability fluconazole uk price free viagra samples before buying xenical in india price generic cialis next day delivery promethazine pills while pregnant canadian online pharmacy uk low cost mexican pharmacies buy cialis 40 mg in toronto sildenafil citrate online viagra spray for men propecia online drugs amoxicillin and alcohol stromectol medication for sale fast shipping birth control pill canadian pharmacy xanax pornvid cialis prices at cvs tadalafil prices discount cialis on sale online mastercard neurontin and methadone generic cialis daily use price augmentin 250 mg junior xenical canadian pharmacy malegra dxt plus online doctor adderall tadalafil c100 for sale brand viagra uk seroquel and vyvanse interaction cialis for sale glendale ca buy wellbutrin xl cheap propecia cost online amlodipine generic to norvasc buying ortho tri cyclen no prescription buy cialis online for cheap illegal cialis fgr 100 pills fincom 5 order cialis or viasgra from canada get clomid privately uk pain pills no prescription levaquin cost per pill diflucan dosage thrush harm of cialis two pills in 24 hours accutane get clear skin need to by clomid online propecia 2012 topamax online prescription viagra cincinnati promethazine 12.5 mg gel ketoconazole cream cheap generic viagra no prescription pil cytotec viagra dapoxetine online purchase 259 paroxetine tab can i buy propecia over the counter pfizer brand viagra online cialis rezeptfrei kaufen clomid fast shipping to sweden we're do i get viagra next day express delivery for viagra buy liquid viagra weather in vancouver losartan escitalopram 60 mg fosamax buying herbal cialis 5mg cialis bayer levitra coupon viagra online overnight delivery usa isoniazid for sale generic cialis tadalafil brand name levitral imitrex addictive cost of omeprazole perfect rx tadalafil diovan 160 mg 25 hct canada drugs online prednisone tablet manufacturer teradoxin viagra cialis en vente libre levothyroxine canada 24h on line pharmacy using paypal viagra aus usa lexapro generic problems viagra plus online buy cialis online mastercard online prednisone generic male enhancement pills buy biotechnica tadalifil amoxicillin for cats cymbalta 60 mg half-life adriana lima diet abilify tablet identification how much does cialis cost per pill inexium 80 mg par jour viagra for men sildenafil purple india esomeprazole prices pakistan sildenafil generique en pharmacie where to buy prilosec prilosec 40 india no prescription antabuse over the counter generic ventolin tablet 2 mg bull 100 sildenafil citrate for men tindimax canada viagra at discount where to buy cefixime colchicine 1mg can i get bentyl without a prescription tadalafil online pharmacy flomax generic walmart medicalsupportteam raquel allegra online store buy propecia 1mg new healthy man bbb rating amoxicillin mg by weight accutane price with tricare valtrex tablet fiyat slimming tablets lerk lasix online rebate lipitor 90 tablets saw palmetto kaufen compra de viagra cialis sold in canada pharmacy express canada buy cialis best review indianauntytry lisinopril no script meds clonidine mexican pharmacy where to buy buspar over night voltaren 50 mg online canadian pharmacy viagra echeck mail order birth control pills price plavix philippines advair cost savings misoprostol long term side effects dispensing viagra articulo 131 advair patient assistance program buy viagra online singapore 255 abilify tablet cost xenical uk amazon prednisone side effects in men price pulmicort order allegra-d 12 hour trazodone pill dosages buy propecia lowest price does valtrex come in a generic fluconazole (diflucan) online get atarax online fast shipping option order propecia online no prescription zestril lisinopril 4 sale fentanyl patches cheap buy propecia safely diovan buying riomet online pharmacy viagra through paypal
Home All Articles Solving Baseball's Financial Inequities

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 486 guests online

Atom RSS

Solving Baseball's Financial Inequities PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Adam Holzman   
Tuesday, 15 April 2008 19:54

A Biz of Baseball OriginalThe following is a guest article by Adam Holzman.

Since the introduction of free agency in the mid-1970s, the salaries of Major League Baseball players have risen without limit. The abolishment of the reserve clause, which bound a player to his original team for the duration of his career (barring a trade), forced MLB owners to compete with each other in attracting premier players to play for their teams, driving up player salaries. As a result, many small market teams find it difficult to compete in a market where large market teams can offer substantially larger sums of money to free agents. While the reserve clause unfairly restricted the salaries of MLB players, free agency has threatened the competitive balance of the game. However, is a salary cap an appropriate solution to create balance in the playing field?

Certainly, small market teams are disadvantaged in the free agency market. In Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game, author Michael Lewis explains how Doug Pappas, the late, great sabermatrician, measures the quality of a team’s front office by determining the team’s “marginal wins” (all wins above the 49th) and “marginal salary” (all payroll dollars spent above $7 million). Dividing marginal wins by marginal salary gives the team’s financial efficiency for a given year. From 2005 through 2007, the median financial efficiency for MLB teams was $2,265,414.99 per marginal win. In 2007, the minimum number of wins needed to make the playoffs in the American League in 2007 was 94, or 45 marginal wins. (see a detailed breakdown of the 2007 Marginal Wins/Marginal Payroll here on The Biz of Baseball). Therefore, a team operating at the average efficiency level would have had to commit to a marginal payroll of $101,943,674.60, or a total payroll of $108,943,674.60. Since most small market teams cannot afford to spend this much on payroll, the general managers of these teams are forced to find ways to operate at higher levels of efficiency in order to compete with large market teams. Clearly, small market teams have an inherent disadvantage in free agency.

Select Read More to see the rest of this orginal article.

However, before we declare that a salary cap is a viable measure to fix the problem of competitive balance, we must consider its feasibility and its consequences. Firstly, the hope that a salary cap will be implemented in the near future is unreasonable. Not only would large market teams be reluctant to concede their financial advantage in the free agency market, but the Major League Baseball Players’ Association (MLBPA), the most powerful union in America, would not accept any measure that would decrease the amount of money being spent on player salaries. If the commissioner’s office were to attempt to install a salary cap, the decision would almost certainly be followed by the most prolonged strike in the history of major league sports.

In addition, the question must be asked: would a salary cap actually provide us with a more entertaining league? In the NFL (which has a salary cap), team quality fluctuates drastically from year to year, and the final standings of each season are almost impossible to predict. I may be in the minority, but I find a league with a greater degree of continuity to be much more entertaining. To me, one of the most appealing aspects of being a fan of a certain team is being able to watch the front office construct a contender or a dynasty from a previously hopeless club. I worry that a strict salary cap, while fixing the problem of competitive balance, would create too much parity throughout the league.

A stronger luxury tax system is most likely the best possible available method for leveling the playing field among large market and small market teams. While large market teams will still have the option to spend higher amounts of revenue on payroll, they will be taxed a certain percentage of their total payroll. This tax revenue will then be distributed amongst teams that do not surpass a predetermined payroll threshold.

However, out of this system of revenue redistribution arises another question: how can MLB administration prevent the owners of small market teams from pocketing the redistributed funds and refusing to spend it on payroll? Contrary to conventional wisdom, an owner’s ultimate goal is not necessarily to construct a winning team, but to make a profit. Because these two goals often go hand in hand (winning teams should increase team popularity and, therefore, team revenues), the distinction is sometimes overlooked.

One must consider the incentives presented to small market team owners in producing winning teams. When a small market team competes with a large market team for a high profile free agent, the small market team would inevitably have to spend a higher percentage of its total revenue in order to win the players’ services. Even if the small market owner decides to make this financial commitment, the financial returns on his investment will be less than what they would have been for the large market team. For argument’s sake, let’s assume that whichever team signs a certain high profile free agent will receive attention from an additional 2% of the team’s metropolitan area. In other words, 2% of the area’s population who previously could’ve cared less about the team now begins to spend money on tickets, jerseys, etc, because of the attraction of the newly-signed player. For a team in New York, this would signal an increase of about 376,370 local fans (2% of 18,818,536 total people in the metropolitan area), while, in Milwaukee, the team would receive increased revenues from only 30,200 additional fans (2% of 1,509,981 total people). If I am the owner of a small market team, why would I invest a greater percentage of my revenues in a player that will produce less increased revenue for my team than he would for a large market team? Small market owners, such as those of the Florida Marlins, are often criticized for a lack of commitment to producing a winning team, but, in reality, there is a lesser amount of financial incentive for the Marlins’ ownership to construct a winner than there is for large market teams.

The solution to the problem produced by the incentive disparity is twofold. Firstly, in addition to the luxury tax threshold described above, a salary “floor” should be implemented. Teams with payrolls below this floor would not be eligible to receive the redistributed luxury tax revenues, creating an incentive for stingy owners to spend more money on payroll. Secondly, the redistributed revenue should act less like a donation and more like an interest free loan. If the owners do not spend the added funds on team payroll by the end of the season, the money will be returned to the commissioner’s office. In other words, if a team receives $8 million in redistributed funds but only spends $5 million on payroll, the owner of the team will not be allowed to retain the extra $3 million. This removes any incentives that small market owners have to restrict team payroll. As a result of this plan, small market teams should become more financially competitive in the free agency market relative to large market teams.

Most importantly, the MLBPA would not be opposed to this plan. While an NFL-style salary cap would reduce the total amount of money spent on player salaries, the luxury tax plan may, in fact, promote increased spending on payroll. Although the ability of large market teams to agree to astronomical contracts would be restricted, small market teams would simultaneously begin to commit more money to team payroll. Because more teams would have a legitimate chance to sign high priced free agents, the competition among owners to sign such free agents would increase. Such competition would increase the negotiating leverage of the players, naturally driving up player salaries. All things considered, this luxury tax system appears to fix the problem of competitive balance between large market and small market teams, preserve the ability of a team to produce a consistent contender, and satisfy the MLBPA’s demands. I doubt that a salary cap would have the same level of success. 


OTHER NEWS ACROSS THE BUSINESS OF SPORTS NETWORK


Adam Holzman is a senior at Amity Regional High School in Woodbridge, CT., and is a guest contributor to the Business of Sports Network. He will be attending Yale University in the fall.  

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?