fasigyn fortessa cheap cialis 20 mg minoxidil in ethiopia actoplus met buy online femara fertility treatment prednisolone acetate eye drops medication what is provera used to treat magnesium chloride ice melt sumycin capsules sizes canada prescriptions online prices how much is periactin appetite stimulant clavaseptin for dogs and kennel cough livial tibolone treatment for eczema cheapest generic levitra no pres best places to buy generic viagra carafate suspension for dogs levitra no rx needed generic viagra pill in usa buspar reviews for anxiety tretinoin cream usp 0.05 rouses pointtricor apodefil es bueno aricept drug classification viagra soft tab are they any good tylenol dosage for infants 2013 donepezil without a prescrib chlamydia trachomatis rna therapy management corporation in hattiesburg ms lasuna jewelry boxes online presdidsone without a rx isoface 20mg the little blue pill healthpoint propecia reviews 2013 forest pharmacy coupons buy alli weight loss pills where can i buy periactin paroxetine medications how much is cialis per pill diet pills review microcidal 500mg amoxicillin buy proscar 5mg finasteride find viagra seroquel for sleep aid pletal side effects medications generic allegra d ciales puerto rico pictures cialis and micardis cheap brand viagra pharmacy online 365 review cipro side effects ciprofloxacin ed drug shop amlodipine besylate 2.5mg ordering cialis 5mg prescription buy generic viagra overnight shipping buy alli refill gabapentin without rx antabus ohne rezept evista and weight gain obat sikotec area surabaya viagra senior minomycin information processing cefadroxil 500 mg capsule albenza 400mg viagra generic release date propranolol buy mastercard unisom side effects drugs carprofen 100mg dogs commande de viagra cialis adalat xl 30mg precio de pastillas cytotec levitra 5 mg prezzo costco superstore pharmacy venta de cytotec en lima 2011 phamacy canada online taxas content validity with both predictive validity and construct validity cialis near me seroquel xr side effects walgreens photo books clonidine hcl 0.1mg uses buy lortabs from canada cialis soft tablet buy viagra online nz zithromax for lyme disease treatment ed shop cialis buy cipla cialis combiben in canada canadian 25 mg viagra lopressor medication prices allegra d 24 hour side effects bentyl medication dosage buy generic viagra india oxybutynin 10 mg er side effects serophene clomiphene citrate fanegada definition of leadership buy ethinyl estradiol online buy cialis europe cialis wanking pastillas para ereccion masculina cialis prescription prices buy neurontin paypal avalide medication generic buy gabapentin no script viagra pay by check clavaseptin antibiotics no presacription acivir dt 800 bar esquina cabo san lucas availability for caffergot how many misoprostol for abortion actavis promethazine for sale blycolin groep sleuyter levoxyl medication ingredients septrin forte treatment nexium 40mg esomeprazole dose marcumar alternative apparel buy metoprolol online cialis c5 nolvadex for men testosterone cheap xenical 120 mg dynamogen drug mart catafast dosage for amoxicillin levitra prices go way up terbutaline side effects pregnancy zoloft withdrawal symptoms duration oral jelly pills similar to viagra vibramycin 100mg capsules adalat 2015 precio cialis chile aricept grom mexico unicure hair conditioner buy plendil where to buy sildensfil citrate online dicyclomine 10 mg capsule myl sildenafil plus cream viagra sold in the us only euroclinix reviews on 50 dexamethasone buy online australia tenormin 50mg remeron medication for sleep legit clomid online ditropan xl 15mg cabergoline side effects dose tadalafil without prescription cheap meds online no prescription insurance institute for highway safety crash ratings buy strattera online cod lamisil pills for sale amazon glipizide and metformin together angela women gingseng comprar antabus venta sildenafilo asturias order pyridium online pfizer viagra from canada hyzaar medication for high blood pressure lanoxin dosage polanprollantus viagra ahnliche produkte buspirone vs xanax bootleg cialis norvasc brand name and generic name cialis 150 mg best diet pills advantage federal credit union michigan sumycin 500mg dutasteride avodart generic what is rizatriptan benzoate tablets fanegada wiki answers citalopram online buy prednisolone tablets 5mg pastillas xerograx fentanyl patch dosage clomid without prescription pills generic viagra suppliers uk cardura 2mg blog septran tablet mupirocin calcium cream 2 30 grams zoloft weight loss zoloft side effects proviron mesterolone side effects promethazine hydrochloride and codeine phosphate viagra indonesia estrace estradiol risk cialis us drugstore parietal lobe function clavaseptin 50mg tramadol get suprax shipped next day depakote er side effects for bipolar mexican pharmacies that ship to us sildenafil china pharmacy express cialis discount online stores kotak mahindra bank night sweats increased urine output irbesartan 300 mg side effects perlutex information system canadian cialis valium and alcohol dose buy viagra online without prescription viagra sales in canada meclizine for vertigo dosage azithromycin tablets with the tamiflu best 10 viagra sites free samples of female viagra tenormin medication atenolol side xanax street prices state by state how to buy cheap abortion pill online anxiety disorder dsm order clomid with echeck ramipril fait il grossir buy estrace tablets spiriva side effects high blood pressure how to buy iv pain med mifepristone buy clavamox dogs dosage tablets clenbuterol for sale online pharmacies in india misoprostol side effects cytotec non prescription 200mg celebrex pil cytotec malaysia prescriptions without a prescription enalapril maleate side effects in cats tadalafil singapore where can i buy cialis cheap insulin injection sites abdomen viagra equivalent in india research chemicals usa viagra levitra cialis a basso costo clomid pregnancy success storiesclozaril how to take prednisone 10mg insurance marketplace medford oregon vitamix soup recipes hydroxyzine pam 50mg piroxicam 20 mg capsule side effects lisinopril hctz side effects medication metformin overseas pharmacy zofran pregnancy birth defects generic adderall buy canada cytoxan side effects canine xenical canadian pharcharmy online amoxicil canadian pharmacy nitrazepam prospective definition flexidol relax accion terapeutica bolilor anxiety definition cialis 200mg online purchase of priligy in malaysia walgreens viagra generic shelf life of prednison tablets prozac for anxiety tadalafil citrate info buy pfizer viagra online elavil for sleep and depression where to get alli orderpharma uk basketball albuterol inhaler dosage medication fedeltry healthcare viagra exelon patch treatment reviewsexnicalexocin prazosin for cats side effects acticin cream best place to order generic viagra 410 pletal medication indications how to tell fake viagra what is diprosone ointment used for metronidazole online cheap lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide strengths acheter propranolol ligne valtrex shingles treatment buy birth control online us orderpharma accutane and alcohol vigrx plus in uk diroton 5mg diazepam safe viagra coumadin clinic locations maryland tetracycline dosage for dogs walgreens employee website employee benefits human pheromones to attract women desyrel side effects medication canadian walgreens online ovral birth control information lincocin 500mg para que sirve baytril dogs antibiotic dosage meprate to start period 2 berodual prezzo piroxicam for dogs side effects achat slimex 15 mg aldactone 50 mg side effects cialis tadalafila manipuladatadalafil amphetamine side effects in children chloroquine for malaria prophylaxis levitra vs staxyn pravachol medication leconfield restaurant petworth azo wintomylon tablets candian rx mercury drug price list of medicines accutane acne treatment review amoxitabs canada malegra reviews why is my alli so expensive levaquin antibiotic brand name viagra 100 mg what is clomid 400mg tablets used periactin 4mg tabperiostat zenegra 100 mg zyprexa relprevv (olanzapine pamoate buto asma inhaler sertraline hydrochloride cialis spedizione anonima malegra 100 side effects cefixime over the counter otc prednisone walmart overnight no prescription pharmacys cheap genuine viagra uk northwest pharmacy free shipping code citrato de sildenafilo marca generica billig viagra kaufen cephalexin 500mg capsule antibiotic for dogs diane keaton hairstyle cyrux medicamento vardenafil maximum dosage adderall xr side effects in children order albendazole online do walmart have clomid legally buy pain medication online lasix generic online soloxine without prescription hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg order on line viagra de from canada cialis rogaine foam reviews for men which country has cheap doxycycline cialis recomended extra dose procalisx ingredients escitalopram oxalate lexapro where to buy prednisone for dogs salbutamol information dose precio de viagra kenacomb otic ointment buy cialis australia paypal nonprescription levitra nebivolol vs bystolic nebivolol 5mg cost drugs med prescription ibuprofen and alcohol use microcidal 125mg lamisil crema pfizer pharmaceuticals philippines nosipren lowest price traffic school donde comprar levitra cialis generika billiger adderall canada pharmacy order amoxicillin from mexico fluconazole diflucan treatment dose acheter du laroxyl kamagra uk next day bupropion online keftab cephalexin 500mg clonidine no presciption walmart pharmacy cialis pills viagra sample garlic mashed potato recipe with sour cream metallica one lyrics you tube asacol medication manufacturer bupropion sr 150 mg side effects buy generic viagra online paypal septra suspension hytrin prostate symptoms whitchurch hockey club benadryl ingredients diphenhydramine hci seroquel medication mail order benicar generic availability cialis dose size buy fluoxetine online no prescription 800 mg motrin ingredients cefalexina 500 mg antibiotico claritin d coupons 2014 metformin and alcohol can evecare heal a viginal discharge leconfield house curzon street cinema kemadrin procyclidine purchase power citalopram 40mg side effects rapid tabs cialis reputable online viagra sales where can i buy cyproheptadine healtyman viagra cialis soft tabs vs cialis viagra on line pharmacy lopressor no rx alli diet pill detrol generic available hytrin prostate clotrimazole troche lozenges dalacin c 300mg capsule diarex pro series silicone molds apcalis jelly 20 mg in uk kwikmed coupon viagra xix chat kosovarja buy revia is generic cialis safe generika drugstore branches in manila cheapest price on levitra therapy 2000 ceu canadian online pet medications coumadin clinic locations in texas detrol generics fasigyn 500mg colchicine 1mg zantac for infants cold and cough mobic 7.5 mg for headaches keftab cephalexin monohydrate 46 online pharmacy dubai where can i find clonazepam generic viagra 130 mg coumadin side effects warfarin famvir medications antivert otc cancer en la prostata sintomas cialias online over night delivery anastrozole 1 mg buy online buy nolvadex overnight ventolin expectorant salbutamol capsule venta de cialis en barcelona zofran medication pregnancy canada meds 365 trental side effects dose shop online cifixime pay with echeck how to get allison harvard eyes viagra 40 pills for 99 $ is duloxetine ototoxic cialis in canada fertility drugs online canada octreotide treatment acromegaly best price cialis 5mg leponex clozapine side effects tiotropium respimat inhaler and the risk of death in copd viagra online canada pharmacy review elavil weight gain side effects floxin otic drops for ears xalatan coupons malene dietich where do you get albendazole ampicillin trihydrate compactedanafranil how to buy viagra on line cheap pharmacy technician jobs in ohio non prescription pharmacy spain amoxicillin flagyl 500mg for sale feldene gel piroxicamfeldene gel .5 .60 buy letrozole online chinese viagra alternative levitra generico prezzo flucomed 150 mg tramadol river pharmacy canada code red 7 reviews rimonabant acomplia india venlafaxine 37.5mg price levitra vs cialis which is better biaxin xl 500mg uses finasteride medication side effects viagra hard on polarmeds reviews on apidexin navidoxine side effects pregnancy symptoms perlutex veterinary clinic cialis pills sale ontario canadian generic cialis reviews vgr 100 blue pill safe on line pharmacy cytotec pills zyprexa 0 dollars 63 cent stamps glucophage xr package insert kemadrin vs mirapex side buy malegra pro 100 septra effect on prostatitis shelf life teva 3109 online canadian viagra paroxetine hcl 20mg street value clonidine 0.2mg tab purepac alli orlistat philippines best launcher android who has the cheapest viagra zyprexa lawsuits order meds online avodart side effects medication z pack 500 mg aggrenox vs plavix study glicerine soap risperdal lawsuit 2013 caffeine in coffee vs energy drinks india cialis online vigra ganaric requip drug manufacturer buy clomid in uk online cymbalta coupons eli lilly & co why cialis cost so much potassium levels cabaser dosage pctv viagra in nepal gabapentin 300mg stromectol scabies reviews sotalex 80 mg ramipril 5mg price at walmart buying nolvadex thailand vicodin withdrawal symptoms detox obat metronidazol
Home Maury Brown Marquee Value for A-Rod or Santana? Nearly Impossible

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 537 guests online

Atom RSS

Marquee Value for A-Rod or Santana? Nearly Impossible PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 4
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Tuesday, 22 January 2008 11:50

Maury BrownOn more than one occasion, authors and analysts have worked to try and assign a value of a player, beyond the wins that they may contribute on the field. Players like Alex Rodriguez, Johan Santana, and others have been talked about in terms of bringing in millions upon millions of dollars based upon their draw as a “star player”, or marquee value. The numbers lofted out have been extraordinary. In the case of Alex Rodriguez, agent Scott Boras said his value to the YES Network could be a half a billion dollars over the life of his contract, a staggering figure.

Books and articles have been written with large sections devoted to placing a figure on this Star Power dynamic. They roll a laundry list of revenue streams into the conversation… merchandising, television, radio, increase in repeat season-ticket purchases, increased concessions, all based upon deriving a figure based on some model (which is rarely revealed) to create some monetary figure. This may sell books, and may make articles that get read, but the problem is, the figures are derived from some overly simplistic model, or created from inaccurate data. The reason it sells is no one questions the methods or figures. Since there is little published on topic, most assume that the mysterious model is correct, and takes it as truth.

Here’s the problem with trying to tackle such a model: It’s vastly complex, and unless you work in the Finance department of some MLB club, or MLB Headquarters, odds are you have never been privy to data that would allow you to begin to get solid figures to work with.

In other words, it’s analysis by dartboard. (Hmm… $100 million sounds about right. I’ll use that).

Let's get into that list of revenue streams... 

Take sale of merchandising. Here’s how it is broken out:

  • Merchandise sold in the park or in a team store within X miles from the park is team local revenue based on retail margin (and subject to revenue sharing), but the team is subject to licensing fees, which are considered centralized (that figure is not subject to revenue sharing). 
  • Merchandise that is sold through MLBAM or team websites is BAM revenue. BAM retains the retail margin but licensing still goes to MLB Properties and then the teams (centralized).
  • Licensed merchandise sold by retailers is retailer's revenue but generates licensing revenue for MLB Properties, which is centralized.
  • In the case of merchandise with a player name on it, a portion of the sale goes to the MLBPA

Got that? Head hurt?

Now, one could determine figures for a player’s marquee value based upon the sale of a jersey with said player’s name on it, but how would you know if a jersey without a name was tied to the star player? Unless there is market research involved, or someone with ESP, it’s impossible to define -- a cacophony of other variables are at play.

What about the value that a player brings by way of television? At least here, we can try and use ratings metrics to begin with. If a star pitcher is taking the mound, one could look to the ratings to see if there are spikes on those days when he is up in the rotation (think Clemens, Schilling, Matsuzaka, etc.). In the case of a position player, the ratings figure become more difficult to associate. Are people watching because of the player? Because of the team he plays on (brand draw)? Because of the match-up? The numbers are flat in that regard. This much is certain: the value of winning is what drives interest. If the player with marquee value is adding wins, then it is the win, along with his star quality that has impact.

For example, let’s look at Alex Rodriguez when he was with the Texas Rangers. According to the Sports Business Journal, the Rangers saw “ratings drop 15 percent on FSN Southwest the season he joined the team as baseball’s highest-paid player. The RSN posted a 2.0 in 2000 and a 1.7 in 2001. Ratings jumped 19 percent the year after Rodriguez left, from a 2.1 in 2003 to a 2.5 in 2004.”

The argument Boras made was that A-Rod had not become iconic at that point. It wasn’t until he arrived with the Yankees that A-Rod’s star appeal was reached.

Maybe.

Now, this isn’t to say that there isn’t more interest when star players wind up on teams. It’s that it is lost in the surrounding noise (other factors that impact individual valuation). Back to the case of Rodriguez and YES Network ratings, ratings for Yankee games have increase 47 percent since he arrived in pinstripes. Now, is that because of A-Rod? The return of Clemens? The fact that the Yankees are the Yankees? Or, winning? It is, of course, all of the above.

Last thing… it’s not as if the day Alex Rodriguez was resigned with the Yankees, or the possible day that Johan Santana arrives on <insert new team’s name> doorstep, that an increase in ratings immediately translates to big bucks based on the deal for carriage. One would certainly see an uptick in terms of advertisement, but in terms of the television deal, by itself, the player would not impact it. That  revenue comes by way of subscriber fees from cable operators that carry the RSN. In the case of YES, according to the SBJ, YES pulls in about “about $2.25 per subscriber per month from operators.” For YES, that means that rate is locked in over the next 7 years. To try and determine how much a player’s value is worth in 7 years would mean trying to dissect that single player out of the winning and losing of the team, the cycling in and out of other possible players with star draw, and factoring brand draw, as but a few examples.

As I said, it’s all this background noise that makes claims of being able to define a distinct value to a player’s worth, outside of their win values on the field, anything but a way to sell books and articles. In some senses, you're double counting. If the player is adding wins (which increases interest in the team), and has marquee draw, then how do you define whether it was the player's win value, or marquee draw? Could be both. Could be one or the other.

There may be an exception. Someone rare. Someone new. Something wholly unique.

There is little denying that the arrival of Jackie Robinson in Major League Baseball was one of these players. A "new factor", which would parlay itself into star draw to the nth degree. Another case might be Fernando Valenzuela and the ensuing “Fernandomania”. Maybe, more recently, it has been Ichiro in Seattle, where the player, in that market, has spiked tourism from abroad to come see him play.

Maybe.

This is, after all, a discussion about the stars amongst the stars. When an author can show me how they derive the figures, and then can apply it to a case like when Wade Boggs went to the Devil Rays, and then it passes the smell test… then I think we’re getting somewhere. Someone may come up with this formula. Someone may actually be willing to publish it. If someone can come up with the data, who isn’t working for a club or MLB Headquarters… now that would be a feat that would rightfully sell some books.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football, The Biz of Basketball and The Biz of Hockey. He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?