dispute equifax credit report getting free credit report without credit card obtain free credit report federal government scores dispute a item on your credit report free credit report commercial remove collection agency report credit report example of a credit report from transunion consumer disputes after resolution on credit report what are cash advances on credit cards credit repair certification lpn programs in tampa florida annual credit report security download free credit report songs cell phone by law free credit report remove consumer statement credit report federal fair credit reporting act background checks how long does it take to get a free credit report experian credit report postal order transunion free credit report colorado free credit report and score online for free how do i remove a closed account from my credit report how to get a free credit report yahoo answers loan i don have a credit card how can i check my credit score my free credit report online remove hard inquiry your credit report can a collection agency pull my credit report what is the government annual credit report website when does american express report late payments to credit bureaus how to read a credit report score does checking account show up credit report affect red flag alert credit report privacy mid credit report free credit report for renters free annually credit report credit report check how long does a foreclosure show on your credit report credit card payments exempt 1099 reporting rental car credit report apartment scams on craigslist credit report fast credit boiler repair companies in texas review credit report websites free irs credit report annual what are the 3 major credit reporting companies the fair credit reporting act imposes civil penalties for which of the following annual credit report forms free credit report dot com song get free federal credit report experian credit report due to denied credit how long does it take to repair credit report how to obtain free annual credit report dispute my credit report free how long does collections stay on credit report annual credit report federal trade commission credit reports free credit report band member names quick payday loans poor credit request free credit report california obtaining a credit report for freeware how do me clean up your credit report for free where can i find a free credit report what is the best 3 bureau credit report equifax transunion equifax or experian credit reports get credit report all 3 agencies ways fix your credit report getting a free credit report from transunion mni credit report services cancel report bad credit credit bureau where to dispute credit report errors small business credit reports free how to put freeze on credit reports free government credit reports scores how to read my experian credit report credit reports bureaus cancel experian credit report online credit report cheap online repair credit reports i want to look at my credit report for free how to repair credit report quickly free credit report reporting agency experian can challenge my credit report everyone entitled one free credit report per year lyrics to the free credit report dot com commercials how to write a dispute letter to credit report agencies get your free 3 in 1 credit report and score with equifax free credit report transunion canada mail can you remove negative items your credit report three bureau report free credit scores rules pulling credit reports request credit report from equifax cma;s sovereign debt credit risk report how to remove credit card from amazon seller 3 credit scores report free credit report with 6 scores gov credit report score best rated top credit cards to have tenant credit reports for landlords contact credit report agencies can you get a credit report from a bank order my credit report equifax how how do i know if i freeze my credit report decide what happens when i dispute my credit report credit report with ii fico scores how to get all 3 how to get all 3 credit reports for free how to request free how to order credit report by mail equifax financial report if denied credit credit report agencies freeze free credit report with no credit card required don cancel letter to dispute credit report info can your get free credit report business credit report trial period federal reserve system monthly report credit liquidity free credit report now fico score long does delinquency stay credit report what is raise my credit score today can employer request your credit report credit check reporting agency no charge at all credit report financial benefits freezing credit report get my free credit report and score equifax blogs books about credit repair fair credit reporting act background checks find my credit report how do i get free copies of my credit reports best credit bureau get report best nationwide consumer credit report company absolutely free credit report and score online credit report by mail form transunion free credit report number free free full credit report online credit report reporting agency their get free credit report without signing up anything how to get a paid tax lien removed from credit report what is my how to check your credit score for free what is a freeze on your credit report how much does the free credit report guy make best credit repair shipping companies australia free report usa online credit scores get free credit report online transunion unlimited international business credit reports citi credit reporting department equifax national consumer credit trends report get credit report free transunion credit report consumer reporting agency can;t find credit report how will i get my credit report in canada for free victoria teachers credit union annual report what phone company does not do credit checks fair credit reporting act 15 usc section 1681 often does citibank report credit bureaus credit check institute of company directors phone number to call to get free credit report how to delete charge offs from your credit report best credit report free credit report commercial youtube lyrics true credit card international credit report companies credit repair nigerian scam australia get my three credit reports free 3 fico scores pay best credit score reporting agency bureaus credit reports score free what is the only free credit report website consumer credit report dispute form free credit report.com commercial irish credit bureau check allowed 1 free credit report per year what is the real free credit report website annual credit report scams how many times can you check your credit score a year cibil credit report example does derogatory public record mean credit report lowell financial credit report fico score usa long does bankruptcy stay credit report after discharge how do i report credit card scams one time only free credit report authorized the three national credit bureaus (credit-reporting agencies) are debt dispute letter credit report free credit reports bureaus credit reporting agencies dispute forms credit report 1800 credit report judgement removal my actual credit report ace cash advance phone number difference between free credit score and free credit report where to get your credit report free annual federal credit report checks free how to get your credit report in canada need payday advance bad credit equifax canada credit report free credit report govenor credit score credit reports agency get credit report now rights under fair credit reporting act how to pull your business credit report annual credit report service request employers checking credit reports annual credit report and score 3in1 credit report one time equifax 3 1 credit report coupon what does claim filed with government mean on my credit report annual credit report service credit suisse research institute;s inaugural global wealth report understanding your credit report credit score financial consumer agency canada mail credit report dispute is annual credit report a legit site order credit report all three bureaus there any truly free credit reports can you remove a charge off from your credit report best way dispute credit report errors credit freeze experian new free credit report commercial band how to obtain free credit report when denied credit free report all 3 bureaus without card credit score annual equifax free business credit report top 3 credit report companies how to get your credit report online free annual file dispute credit report online how to remove court judgement from credit report annual report credit score what are credit reporting agencies free credit report underground federal law checking your credit report online canada credit report freeze how to repair your credit report free credit report security freeze how to run a credit report on a minor credit report company addresses why companies ask for a credit report free annual credit report gov how dog u get a copy of your credit report annual credit report com legitimate federal law free annual credit report official credit bureau reporting software trans report credit card company canada free credit report government-issued identification report stolen credit cards police how to dispute derogatory item on credit report company credit reports us where is the best place to go for a free credit report annualcreditreport free personal credit report australia free background checks online without credit card get all reports free annual credit equifax sample credit score report 3 credit reports monitoring reporting disputed debt credit reporting agency get tenant credit reports experian free credit report cancel membership credit report problems com review denied credit free credit report experian free yearly credit report youtube get free credit report georgia veda personal credit report main credit reporting agencies ohio law free credit report how to access your credit report long does satisfied judgment stay credit report transunion visa report if denied credit american express corporate card credit reporting transunion order credit report checking credit report children bureaus how do you get your free once a year credit report get credit report citibank small business credit card payments quick accurate fix credit repair unlimited credit reports and fico scores read instant merge credit report credit report medical information australia old debt not on credit report credit report business gov annual free free credit reports usa get my fico score credit report transunion credit report meaning citibank credit report dispute buy my credit report online fair credit reporting act background check authorization phone number transunion credit reporting agency free 3in1 credit report scores credit expert credit report voucher code what is charge off on credit report about transunion credit report dispute remove paid charge off credit report how to write a letter to dispute credit report definition consumer protection agency under fair credit reporting act long does take negative items fall off credit report address for 3 credit bureaus how do i get my credit report in canada for free transunion free credit reports from government tips for getting a loan with bad credit national credit reporting san jose ca order credit report over the phone hard inquiry on credit report how many points credit reports from all three agencies mailing address for credit report disputes is there a real free credit report when can collections agency report to credit bureau see all 3 credit reports for free free credit report without using credit card information reading my equifax credit report meaning of credit report numbers requesting your free credit report what information is contained on a credit report dispute inquiry my credit report clean your report free annual credit first report credit checking experian debt report if denied credit are you entitled to one free credit report per year fair credit reporting act disclosure california credit report all 4 agencies how to see credit report for free free credit report no card details chase credit report limit removing experian fraud alert payday advance stores in california do companies check credit report federal free annual credit report how do i run a free credit report get my free credit report from equifax how to pull a credit report for landlords free credit report all three credit reporting agencies score free credit reports in canada equifax explains you can do legally improve your credit report tenant credit report ontario canada free business credit reports fair credit reporting act signed into law what is the highest score you can get on your credit report how to read a credit report government required free credit report annual can call get free credit report free credit reports scores all 3 bureaus get my free credit report without credit card free credit report bands name how do i get my annual credit report from the government cheap credit report score check credit report potential tenant how to credit someone on livejournal 100 free credit report canada what happened to free credit report band remove negative items from credit report after 7 years get report all three credit scores how to get something off of your credit report credit report with all 3 scores 3 1 credit reports fico scores dispute experian credit report information do you get your credit score with annual credit report free credit report new york state 609 of the federal fair credit reporting act how to improve credit report fast online money loans online loans without a bank account letter remove foreclosure credit report credit history report australia free free credit report if you ve been denied credit entitled how do i get my free credit report gov dispute error on credit report free copy credit report walmart money card report credit bureau how to remove from credit report charge off child identity theft credit report sap sd credit management reports fair credit reporting laws equifax credit score only how to clean up my credit report fast free credit report military members how to run a credit report on yourself what is a charge off on a credit report cancel free credit report membership online first american credit reporting agencies remove items paid credit report equifax credit report review get copy of equifax credit report online payday loans for unemployed in the usa credit repair family law attorney richmond va free credit report com cancel online us bank one card credit card login federally mandated free annual credit report transunion review credit report understanding equifax credit reports apollo credit agency same day cash loans online credit reporting agency dispute form free credit report goverment site tax lien credit report paid free credit report equifax experian transunion the annual credit report website tim hawkins free credit report dot lyrics free credit report class action lawsuit letter to remove collections from credit report check your credit report freeware once year credit report business free removed from credit report after 7 years where is the best place to get a free credit report online instant credit repair new social security card online credit report disputing bank of america credit report dispute address credit reports from 3 agencies obtain your free annual credit report veracity dsi credit repair complaints free credit report for landlords cash advance today orem utah newspaper how can i remove a tax lien from my credit report law credit reporting agencies free transunion credit report south africa many years does chapter 7 bankruptcy stay credit report trw business credit reporting services trw credit reporting services what is a charge off on your credit report mean credit repair attorney san diego ca free credit consumer report how do you read a equifax credit report how do i report tenant to credit bureau national credit reporting association annual conference how do i report a bad debt to the credit bureau credit report bankruptcy 7 years free credit report west virginia report credit bureau purchase all 3 credit reports and scores cibil credit report complaints does checking credit report lower score transunion usa credit report what is free credit report most affordable credit repair company often does credit report updates remove closed accounts my credit report requesting a free copy of credit report how do i contact credit report agencies free credit report military online letter credit reporting agency disputing free credit report like credit karma federal gov free annual credit report how to access my free credit report official credit report from government removing paid state tax lien credit report credco credit reports order my experian credit report which free credit report site is really free free three credit reports and scores who are the 3 4 major credit reporting companies how to dispute experian credit report online best credit score report free credit report pirate song lyrics collections reporting credit agencies equifax no longer selling credit reports employment screening free credit report and scores no credit card required fair credit reporting free credit report 1 day late payment credit report name of guy from free credit report commercials pay h and r h&r block emerald advance online application credit rating free credit check for companies three bureau credit report fico score how long does it take to remove an item from credit report negative credit report information what credit reporting agency is the most accurate remove collections my credit report get free credit report california youtube free credit report dot fair credit reporting act+consumer credit long car repo credit report clear your credit report yourself remove unauthorized inquiry credit report credit reporting credit monitoring and identity theft protection how long eviction on credit report equifax denied report personal solutions credit landsafe credit reporting agency what is your credit report based on will checking my credit report lower my scorecard how do i challenge my credit report credit reporting agency uses fico score karma credit report free how to improve my credit report score does private mortgage holder report credit bureau credit report points system how long does it take to remove items from credit report can creditors remove negative information your credit report get paid judgment removed credit report news debt credit reporting agency credit report website safe how to dispute a credit report error with transunion bad credit report duration free canada credit report equifax how to report to credit agencies get credit report canada mail can i get a free credit report from all three agencies top credit report myfico finding check your credit score canada us government mandated free credit report 3 major credit report how to obtain credit reports for landlords california get free credit report military how do i get credit report fixed my credit keeper alternative letter to remove paid collection from credit report how often can i get free credit report credit repair personal injury lawyers toronto how to request free credit report 2012 is national credit report a legit site name three credit report companies credit report order free judgement credit report south africa fair credit reporting act 2010 amendments get nco financial off my credit report how to understand a credit report what is on my credit report view for free
Home All Articles The Clemens Defamation Lawsuit: Proving the Case

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 549 guests online

Atom RSS

The Clemens Defamation Lawsuit: Proving the Case PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 16
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Patrick K. Thornton   
Wednesday, 09 January 2008 07:03

A Biz of Baseball OriginalContrary to what most legal experts believed, Roger Clemens has now filed a defamation lawsuit against his former trainer and friend Brian McNamee.  Lawyers for both sides had been posturing for weeks with McNamee’s lawyers stating several times that McNamee was actually contemplating suing Clemens for defamation.  McNamee’s lawyers have already indicated they will object to jurisdiction in the recent lawsuit filed by Clemens and will attempt to move the case to federal court in Brooklyn.  Where the trial is actually held could prove the deciding factor if the case ever makes it to a jury.

Clemens has repeatedly denied steroid use.  He appeared on 60 Minutes the same day the lawsuit was filed and denied that he has ever used steroids.  The next day he held a press conference where he once again angrily denied any steroid use.  Clemens’s preemptive act of filing a defamation lawsuit has clearly shown he is not going to sit idly by and wait for this matter to resolve itself. He clearly drew a line in the sand when he filed the lawsuit.  McNamee will now have to answer the Clemens lawsuit and will most likely fill a counter-claim against Clemens alleging Clemens defamed him.  Once the parties have filed the initial pleadings McNamee’s lawyer will attempt to have the case moved to New York to be heard by a New York jury.  The discovery phase of the lawsuit should produce some interesting results.  Both parties to the litigation will have to give a deposition which is sworn testimony but not in the presence of a jury or judge.  Deposition testimony is treated just as the same if the witness is testifying in front of a judge or jury.  Clemens will be questioned by the lawyers for McNamee and Clemens’s lawyers will question McNamee.  Both parties to the lawsuit will certainly be subject to hours of intense questioning by opposing lawyers in the lawsuit.   

A trial may be more than two years away and they are many possible land mines for both parties along the way. Litigation always has surprises for the parties in the form of a new found witness or document.  Whatever court the case ends up in will certainly require the parties to attempt to mediate their dispute and try to settle the case.  Most plaintiffs in a defamation case seek damages to recover for loss of reputation but it is uncertain and probably doubtful if McNamee is a collectable defendant if the matter ever ended in a verdict for Clemens for money damages.  If McNamee files a counter-claim and a jury finds in his favor then he might be able to collect damages from Clemens.  Other likely deponents during discovery could include former Yankees manager Joe Torre, Andy Pettitte, former Clemens’s teammates and anyone who may have knowledge about whether Clemens allegedly used steroids.  Former Senator George Mitchell might even be required to give a deposition if the matter is not settled prior to the discovery phase of the lawsuit. 

(Select Read More to see the rest of this original article on The Biz of Baseball)

Richard Emery, one of McNamee’s lawyers, has clearly stated he thinks the lawsuit has no merit:

"I think it's dismissible on its face. I think it's a press release for Clemens and his career.  The case is shoddy at best. The prosecutors acted completely professionally in this case…”

It is strategic that Clemens filed the lawsuit on the same day he appeared on 60 Minutes.  Filing a lawsuit does not necessarily mean however, that he will pursue it to a jury verdict.  He could always agree to dismiss the lawsuit at later date or the parties could settle their dispute and agree that the terms of any agreement be kept confidential.  Interestedly, Clemens did not sue Major League Baseball only McNamee.  He might have argued that MLB published the report and therefore, damaged his reputation as well.  Maybe Clemens’s thought better of it.  Clemens’s lawyer Rusty Hardin was very clear in stating in the press conference on January 7, 2007 that the lawsuit in no way reflected poorly on George Mitchell or his investigation.  He stated several times that the former Senator’s credibility and character was impeccable. 

The fourteen page lawsuit alleges that McNamee’s statements that he injected Clements with steroids are “false and defamatory per se because they are not true, and they injured Clemens’s reputation and exposed him to public hatred, contempt, ridicule, and financial injury.  McNamee made the allegations with actual malice, knowing they were false.”  (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 34). 

The Clemens lawsuit has summarily stated:

“Though McNamee’s allegations comprise only eight pages of a 409-page report, they captured the attention of the nation, fueled rampant speculation, and irreparably tainted the reputation of one of baseball’s hardest working and most talented pitchers.” (Plaintiff's Petition Paragraph 7).

The lawsuit lists fifteen alleged statements made by McNamee to federal investigators all of which Clements claims are “untrue and defamatory.”  The lawsuit alleges that during an interrogation by federal law enforcement authorities in June 2007, “McNamee told others that he repeatedly denied that Clemens had used steroids or HGH.”  (Plaintiff's Petition Paragraph 26).  The lawsuit further alleges that McNamee was facing the threat of federal prosecution so he agreed to speak with the Mitchell Commission.  He then stated he injected Clemens with steroids.

Interestedly, Clemens also notes in his lawsuit that McNamee was once a suspect in a rape investigation in Florida.  (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 20). This will certainly present itself as a credibility problem for McNamee in the Clemens lawsuit.  Lawyers for Clemens will clearly want to note that McNamee has difficulty telling the truth during that investigation. Clemens says he stopped training with McNamee after the 2001 season when he learned McNamee was a suspect.  No formal charges were ever brought against McNamee although Clemens alleged in his lawsuit that McNamee lied to the police in Florida and “refused their requests for evidence in a situation when he denied any wrong-doing…” (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 20).  Sports Illustrated has reported that the St. Petersburg Police has stated McNamee lied to them during the rape investigation.  Sports Illustrated, Police say McNamee lied in 2001, January 8, 2008.  Clemens states that McNamee’s dismissal from the Yankees organization and from Clemens as well left him “embittered”.  (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 20).  Clemens further alleges in his lawsuit that although “McNamee’s explanation was totally at odds with the conclusion of the police officers conducts the investigation,” {sic} Clemens did not know any of these facts so he re-hired McNamee once again. (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 21).

The tort of defamation consists of both libel, defamation by words written or print, or slander, communication by spoken words.  Defamation of character involves wrongfully hurting a person’s good reputation.  The law does improve a general duty on all persons to refrain from making false, defamatory statement of facts about others.  In Texas, where the case is currently pending, to prove a case for defamation a plaintiff must prove:

  1. That the defendant published a statement.  In this case publication would mean communication to a person other than the defamed party.
  2. That the statement was defamatory.
  3. That the defendant acted with “actual malice.”

An individual who is deemed a “public figure” under the law must prove “actual malice” to prevail in a defamation lawsuit.  Public figures generally have some access to a public medium for responding to defeat false statements; private individuals generally do not have such access.  Clemens would most certainly be considered a public figure under the law. To prevail he will have to prove that McNamee “acted with a knowledge of falsity or with a high degree of awareness of probable falsity of the publication at issue”, to prevail on his claim.  New York Times, Inc v. Isaacks, 146 S.W. 3d 144, 165 (Tex. 2004).  It will be a difficult burden for Clemens to prove.  McNamee’s defense will be that he is telling the truth.  If a jury believed he was telling the truth then Clemens’s lawsuit against him will fail. 

In a rather odd twist between the two old friends and new litigants, a seventeen minute phone conversation occurred between Clemens and McNamee on Friday, January 4, 2007.  During the rather emotional conversation McNamee asks Clemens several times “what do you want me to do.”  Clemens noted during the guarded conversation between the two that he just wanted the truth to come out.  Clemens’s lawyers were in the room during the conversation and he was being very careful not to tell McNamee what to say. 

The Mitchell Report was a bombshell and linked many baseball stars to steroid use.  Some stepped forward and admitted use including Clemens’s good friend and teammate Andy Pettitte.  Clemens chose to take the offensive and file a lawsuit.  He has demanded he is innocent and says he should get the benefit of the doubt.  Clemens has now become the face of the Mitchell Report.  Add to the Mitchell Report and the lawsuit a congressional investigation.  Clemens has said he will voluntarily testify in front of Congress.  Andy Pettitte’s lawyer, Jay Reisinger recently said it is “premature” to say whether Pettitte will testify in front of Congress.  McNamee has also said he will testify before Congress as well.

Where does this existing lawsuit go from here?  Could the lawsuit actually end in a jury trial with a parade of star witnesses such as Clemens, Pettitte, George Mitchell, and Barry Bonds testifying?  It is highly improbable that the lawyers or the parties to the lawsuit desire such an outcome.  Lawsuits however have ways of getting a life of their own and when pride becomes a factor for the parties or the lawyers they tend to drag on with no resolution.  The next move is McNamee’s.  It is certainly a tormented dilemma for two very close friends who are now locked in a legal battle in the midst of one of baseball’s ugliest scandals.


Patrick K. Thornton is a Professor at Houston Baptist University where he is the faculty advisor for the MBA in Sports Management.  He also teaches “Baseball and the Law” at the University of Houston Law School and Sports Law at Rice University and South Texas College of Law.
 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?