order apcalis sx uk buy dostinex in usa etodolac discount copay order singulair order meclizine dosage buy valtrex 500 mg rogaine 2 discount nizoral cheap kamagra oral jelly malaysia flagyl er discount diclofenac gel discount zentiva order evista powder female cialis discount how does order innopran xl price cheap hair loss reasons buy bupropion sr libido toradol discount programs cholesterol lowering discount smoothie order calendar buy capoten at walmart abilify discount code cheap muscle relaxant guidelines buy kamagra chewable review buy tofranil reviews buy zithromax canada bystolic discounts order lopid dosage buy accutane us order frumil ls cheap micronase price rumalaya forte discount review buy elavil uk order ginseng seeds buy revatio new york buy toradol dosage buy quetiapinum qtc buy l-tryptophan powder buy rosuvastatin africa cheap female cialis viagra cheap doxazosin prescription buy kamagra oral jelly does it work buy anafranil online buy cheap neurontin buy emsam wholesale diclofenac gel discount or ibuprofen order rogaine 5 biovea mircette discount coupon cheap mevacor lovastatin buy lithium cells cheap hair loss experiences urispas discount card buy clomid testosterone buy ginseng uk buy rogaine 2 foam buy men;s health facebook cheap anti viral avg antivirus buy abilify rid tretinoin 0 05 discount harga buy cabergoline research chemical endep discount order remeron from mexico order hair loss xanax buy zetia you order remeron can cheap elocon buy buy menosan comprime's buy viagra soft europe cheap abilify australia buy diclofenac tablets online order eurax hydrocortisone discount on alli cheap rental new york cheap effexor xr birth defects buy asacol online buy legit accutane buy rogaine 2 canada walmart buy levitra plus the counter exposed skin care order tracking buy rogaine 2 montreal buy nexium online uk prednisone mail order buy generic ventolin cheap lioresal buy shuddha guggulu discount opinie order tadalis sx pharma generic cialis order propecia zimbabwe cheap canon lenses for sale cheap prevacid online female viagra discount nz buy hydrea work buy maxalt online uk order dipyridamole canada order diclofenac gel cvs cheap v gel polish buy lioresal place buy prednisolone acetate cheap fml forte ingredients lasix discount get sleep aid discount counter order benfotiamine the uk cheap femara australia cheap lithium polymer batteries buy calendula oil buy combivent generic order diclofenac zealand cholesterol lowering discount ldl without drugs buy synthroid online pharmacy cheap viagra super active effects order lasix overnight delivery buy ortho tri cyclen emergency contraception buy clomid 100mg online buy viagra plus singapore cheap betoptic bula tenormin discount card buy glucotrol xl dailymed buy zyprexa africa cheap viagra sublingual dosage cheap desyrel high actors names alphabetical order cheap cephalexin yeast buy nexium over the counter buy strattera cheap buy cialis canada buy cymbalta generic online buy minocycline uk buy mentat ds syrup of himalaya buy zetia generic buy mentat tablets cheap cytoxan buy ashwagandha sensoril venlor discount vouchers buy ventolin inhaler order pain relief after tooth extraction cheap cialis sublingual xanax zantac discount buy rhinocort aqua pain relief discount dogs buy nolvadex ireland cheap cytotec jenjarom buy arava the counter buy cheap lamisil order moduretic lek buy alli online cheap nitroglycerin discount buy buy arava vietnam order furosemide lasix cheap wellbutrin sr manufacturer coupons antabuse discount price cheap lotensin generic buy alli boots cheap female cialis for sale cheap casodex buy cheap lanoxin australia cheap paroxetine yawning cialis jelly discount wirkung order levitra professional order tulasi nair buy suhagra duralong buy kamagra from india cheap glucotrol xl half life order glucotrol xl how it works buy cytotec for abortion cheap ginette 35 effects tretinoin 0 05 discount review buy zoloft in usa order meclizine in canada buy zyvox work mango order status arava discount program noroxin discount code aleve discount vouchers discount for viagra order benfotiamine liquid buy bystolic bali buy arava cream cheap lady era rock buy viagra plus gel order effexor xr birth defects order prazosin nightmares buy periactin legal zerit discount vouchers buy tinidazole dosage cheap ortho tri cyclen yahoo answers order mentax tablets viagra pro discount tablette buy glucotrol xl drug class hair loss discount blog cheap neurontin high order zetia australia buy yagara naruto buy dostinex you order alli slimming tablets cheap pletal uk pravachol discount online cheap actoplus met manufacturer coupon buy amitriptyline for cats buy cialis jelly wirkung buy bupropion sr erowid order nitroglycerin order clomid over the counter buy cytotec malaysia grifulvin v discount tablets side effects order requip powder cholesterol lowering discount unclog arteries order weight loss challenge buy viagra soft high street order starlix prescription nizoral discount cheap amitriptyline online buy anafranil in australia wellbutrin sr discount insomnia order cymbalta kong order bystolic samples buy toradol legal order actoplus met medication guide buy bystolic in europe cheap cialis super active information cheap pure acetone buy diclofenac drug cheap hotels in negril jamaica all inclusive ortho tri cyclen discount yasmin order valtrex online buy rosuvastatin from uk order mango earl stevens buy combivent inhaler online buy premarin 0.625 mg buy periactin online order diclofenac gel brand name cheap metformin online buy augmentin bulk cheap penegra zydus januvia cheapest price order accutane dubai buy emsam new york order requip can order tadalis sx tadalis-sx vs tadacip buy pyridium singapore order viagra super active cheap differin jel levitra professional discount cheap generic buy propecia mastercard order anavar buy ditropan vidal buy nitroglycerin vancouver order glucotrol xl gain buy baytril for rats online cheap strattera alternatives buy amaryl online order benfotiamine neuropathy amitriptyline to buy pamelor discount coupon buy levitra super active online buy kamagra with paypal cheap cialis professional nuovo buy coolant order tretinoin 0 05 nuface order serophene wiki buy cardizem next day delivery buy purinethol need order zanaflex safe order wellbutrin sr just once a day order clomid australia pravachol discount get buy urispas zealand cheap alli mexico cheap singulair 10mg buy hydrea usa cheap cholestoplex buy men;s health problems exposed skin care order status buy men;s health xtreme muscle pro order betnovate cream online cafergot discount vouchers buy zithromax paypal order actoplus met loss buy kamagra oral jelly ebay order compazine suppository buy olanzapine uk cheap lady era pills results stromectol discount buy ciprofloxacin eye drops shuddha guggulu discount work cheap real kamagra cheap v gel manjakani order tricor australia order toradol prescription seroflo discount voucher order femara best place ampicillin discount vouchers cheapest strattera online buy shatavari yrtti buy diclofenac potassium online uk order cialis professional lilly cheap imuran cheap apcalis sx oral jelly uk order mango pure cleanse buy generic zovirax tinidazole discount code buy dutas generic online buy antivert angeles order amantadine uk cheap lady era pills review cheap inderal buy buy luvox online order toprol xl quetiapine fumarate buy xalatan from canada buy canadian prednisone cheap avapro irbesartan buy trial erection packs 1 year cheap cialis professional generika order viagra super active wiki buy dapoxetine sweden order brand advair diskus equivalent buy trazodone you cheap ginette 35 india buy famvir you buy myambutol can buy celebrex in canada pain relief discount with shingles buy l tryptophan libido buy xenical and reductil sumycin discount code cheap toprol xl oral dosage buy tricorn buy rogaine 2 the uk buy minocycline acne cheap augmentin online buy aricept veterinary order levitra super active review order wellbutrin sr for anxiety buy cialis daily use online cheap zyloprim online order glucophage online micardis discount generic buy citalopram online viagra jelly discount day delivery buy xenical orlistat cheap cleocin gel reviews acne.org cheap mentat benefits order a bank card buy clindamycin australia isoniazid discount code lexapro discount cards order clozaril cheap viagra super active erfahrung buy tricorder buy erythromycin antibiotics buy cardizem usa buy desyrel online order tadacip avis cheap wellbutrin sr zoloft combination cheap zebeta online cheap erythromycin dosage buy elocon generic discount asthma supplies cheap hytrin uk buy cefixime brisbane cheap diclofenac gel xerostomia buy orlistat australia sleep aid discount xr order deltasone uses cheap bupropion xl rumalaya forte discount gel oxytrol discounts astrazeneca nexium discount card cheap capoten price buy singulair medicine buy myambutol the counter dutas discount program cheap atorlip 10 atorlip atorvastatina 10 mg singular software discount code cheap ventolin hfa buy aceon line order methotrexate illegal buy l tryptophan sleep buy zanaflex kuala lumpur order zanaflex usa cheap vpxl review buy minocycline side cheap prandin a prescription buy clomid new zealand cheap arimidex side order tetracycline online uk order caverta avis buy cymbalta in uk cheap voveran sr pregnancy shuddha guggulu discount how does buy kamagra oral jelly dosage hytrin discount vouchers buy femara cheap order betnovate buy cytotec philippines buy alavert guide order prazosin mail buy genuine xenical online where to buy lipothin with raspberry ketone cheap lamisil tablets buy floxin otic order cleocin gel phosphate buy azulfidine buy saw palmetto dht cheap combivent dosage cheap rumalaya gel price buy atorlip 20 atorlip atorvastatin 20 mg clomid discount card vpxl discount buy hydrea generic online cheap effexor xr yahoo answers order benzac differin cheap effexor xr package insert order baytril online order antivert generic cheap ortho tri cyclen lo cheap cialis soft brasil cheap lithium golf trolley order voting card cialis super active discount vs cialis review buy cheap atarax online cheap hydrochlorothiazide australia cheap flagyl jarabe liv 52 discount liquid abilify to buy viagra best deals buy ventolin australia order hair loss prevention buy hoodia lip gloss buy voveran sr mg dosage cheap lady era heian zyvox discount generic cheap lady erath buy ventolin asthma inhalers order pain relief you can take when pregnant buy clomiphene online safe cheap retino-a cream 0 05 unguento cheap atorlip 10 sirve grifulvin v discount pediatric dosage discount for benicar hct order hair loss wiki buy rosuvastatin legal desyrel discounts order cytotec generic order diclofenac gel in canada buy anti fungal brand buy yasmin uk buy retin-a 0 025 nasal methotrexate back order periactin discount vouchers buy viagra super active viagra buy myambutol tablets viagra discount walmart buy casodex usage buy glucotrol xl bupropion buy tretinoin 0 05 harga vitacid hyaluronic acid discount in skin care cheap trental cleocin gel discount for acne men;s health discount recipe finder cheap celexa online grifulvin v discount micr 500 side effects order cialis over the counter cheap v gel za bolec(ine v mis(icah tofranil buy canada buy kamagra oral jelly in london atacand hct discounts cheap finpecia online buy flonase mail buy viagra plus with mastercard cheap azithromycin online cheap actos overdose order calendar online india buy flonase uk buy finasteride 5mg cheap hytrin a prescription cholesterol lowering discount alternatives to statins order lamisil in canada order revia australia order trandate gravid cheap viagra xanthi pain relief discount crocin order hytrin ovulos buy cholesterol lowering zealand buy motilium new zealand buy lasix from canada cheap ortho tri cyclen breast growth buy viagra plus in singapore cheap hair loss breastfeeding buy topamax and phentermine cheap isoptin wiki viagra soft discount under the tongue buy shatavari kalpa in usa order weight loss food plan buy tenormin angeles order hair loss breastfeeding hydrochlorothiazide discount coupon order brand levitra generic buy zyloprim in australia cheap ortho tri cyclen skip period buy penegra tablet buy naprosyn tablets order avalide
Home All Articles The Clemens Defamation Lawsuit: Proving the Case

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 542 guests online

Atom RSS

The Clemens Defamation Lawsuit: Proving the Case PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 16
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Patrick K. Thornton   
Wednesday, 09 January 2008 07:03

A Biz of Baseball OriginalContrary to what most legal experts believed, Roger Clemens has now filed a defamation lawsuit against his former trainer and friend Brian McNamee.  Lawyers for both sides had been posturing for weeks with McNamee’s lawyers stating several times that McNamee was actually contemplating suing Clemens for defamation.  McNamee’s lawyers have already indicated they will object to jurisdiction in the recent lawsuit filed by Clemens and will attempt to move the case to federal court in Brooklyn.  Where the trial is actually held could prove the deciding factor if the case ever makes it to a jury.

Clemens has repeatedly denied steroid use.  He appeared on 60 Minutes the same day the lawsuit was filed and denied that he has ever used steroids.  The next day he held a press conference where he once again angrily denied any steroid use.  Clemens’s preemptive act of filing a defamation lawsuit has clearly shown he is not going to sit idly by and wait for this matter to resolve itself. He clearly drew a line in the sand when he filed the lawsuit.  McNamee will now have to answer the Clemens lawsuit and will most likely fill a counter-claim against Clemens alleging Clemens defamed him.  Once the parties have filed the initial pleadings McNamee’s lawyer will attempt to have the case moved to New York to be heard by a New York jury.  The discovery phase of the lawsuit should produce some interesting results.  Both parties to the litigation will have to give a deposition which is sworn testimony but not in the presence of a jury or judge.  Deposition testimony is treated just as the same if the witness is testifying in front of a judge or jury.  Clemens will be questioned by the lawyers for McNamee and Clemens’s lawyers will question McNamee.  Both parties to the lawsuit will certainly be subject to hours of intense questioning by opposing lawyers in the lawsuit.   

A trial may be more than two years away and they are many possible land mines for both parties along the way. Litigation always has surprises for the parties in the form of a new found witness or document.  Whatever court the case ends up in will certainly require the parties to attempt to mediate their dispute and try to settle the case.  Most plaintiffs in a defamation case seek damages to recover for loss of reputation but it is uncertain and probably doubtful if McNamee is a collectable defendant if the matter ever ended in a verdict for Clemens for money damages.  If McNamee files a counter-claim and a jury finds in his favor then he might be able to collect damages from Clemens.  Other likely deponents during discovery could include former Yankees manager Joe Torre, Andy Pettitte, former Clemens’s teammates and anyone who may have knowledge about whether Clemens allegedly used steroids.  Former Senator George Mitchell might even be required to give a deposition if the matter is not settled prior to the discovery phase of the lawsuit. 

(Select Read More to see the rest of this original article on The Biz of Baseball)

Richard Emery, one of McNamee’s lawyers, has clearly stated he thinks the lawsuit has no merit:

"I think it's dismissible on its face. I think it's a press release for Clemens and his career.  The case is shoddy at best. The prosecutors acted completely professionally in this case…”

It is strategic that Clemens filed the lawsuit on the same day he appeared on 60 Minutes.  Filing a lawsuit does not necessarily mean however, that he will pursue it to a jury verdict.  He could always agree to dismiss the lawsuit at later date or the parties could settle their dispute and agree that the terms of any agreement be kept confidential.  Interestedly, Clemens did not sue Major League Baseball only McNamee.  He might have argued that MLB published the report and therefore, damaged his reputation as well.  Maybe Clemens’s thought better of it.  Clemens’s lawyer Rusty Hardin was very clear in stating in the press conference on January 7, 2007 that the lawsuit in no way reflected poorly on George Mitchell or his investigation.  He stated several times that the former Senator’s credibility and character was impeccable. 

The fourteen page lawsuit alleges that McNamee’s statements that he injected Clements with steroids are “false and defamatory per se because they are not true, and they injured Clemens’s reputation and exposed him to public hatred, contempt, ridicule, and financial injury.  McNamee made the allegations with actual malice, knowing they were false.”  (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 34). 

The Clemens lawsuit has summarily stated:

“Though McNamee’s allegations comprise only eight pages of a 409-page report, they captured the attention of the nation, fueled rampant speculation, and irreparably tainted the reputation of one of baseball’s hardest working and most talented pitchers.” (Plaintiff's Petition Paragraph 7).

The lawsuit lists fifteen alleged statements made by McNamee to federal investigators all of which Clements claims are “untrue and defamatory.”  The lawsuit alleges that during an interrogation by federal law enforcement authorities in June 2007, “McNamee told others that he repeatedly denied that Clemens had used steroids or HGH.”  (Plaintiff's Petition Paragraph 26).  The lawsuit further alleges that McNamee was facing the threat of federal prosecution so he agreed to speak with the Mitchell Commission.  He then stated he injected Clemens with steroids.

Interestedly, Clemens also notes in his lawsuit that McNamee was once a suspect in a rape investigation in Florida.  (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 20). This will certainly present itself as a credibility problem for McNamee in the Clemens lawsuit.  Lawyers for Clemens will clearly want to note that McNamee has difficulty telling the truth during that investigation. Clemens says he stopped training with McNamee after the 2001 season when he learned McNamee was a suspect.  No formal charges were ever brought against McNamee although Clemens alleged in his lawsuit that McNamee lied to the police in Florida and “refused their requests for evidence in a situation when he denied any wrong-doing…” (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 20).  Sports Illustrated has reported that the St. Petersburg Police has stated McNamee lied to them during the rape investigation.  Sports Illustrated, Police say McNamee lied in 2001, January 8, 2008.  Clemens states that McNamee’s dismissal from the Yankees organization and from Clemens as well left him “embittered”.  (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 20).  Clemens further alleges in his lawsuit that although “McNamee’s explanation was totally at odds with the conclusion of the police officers conducts the investigation,” {sic} Clemens did not know any of these facts so he re-hired McNamee once again. (Plaintiff’s Petition Paragraph 21).

The tort of defamation consists of both libel, defamation by words written or print, or slander, communication by spoken words.  Defamation of character involves wrongfully hurting a person’s good reputation.  The law does improve a general duty on all persons to refrain from making false, defamatory statement of facts about others.  In Texas, where the case is currently pending, to prove a case for defamation a plaintiff must prove:

  1. That the defendant published a statement.  In this case publication would mean communication to a person other than the defamed party.
  2. That the statement was defamatory.
  3. That the defendant acted with “actual malice.”

An individual who is deemed a “public figure” under the law must prove “actual malice” to prevail in a defamation lawsuit.  Public figures generally have some access to a public medium for responding to defeat false statements; private individuals generally do not have such access.  Clemens would most certainly be considered a public figure under the law. To prevail he will have to prove that McNamee “acted with a knowledge of falsity or with a high degree of awareness of probable falsity of the publication at issue”, to prevail on his claim.  New York Times, Inc v. Isaacks, 146 S.W. 3d 144, 165 (Tex. 2004).  It will be a difficult burden for Clemens to prove.  McNamee’s defense will be that he is telling the truth.  If a jury believed he was telling the truth then Clemens’s lawsuit against him will fail. 

In a rather odd twist between the two old friends and new litigants, a seventeen minute phone conversation occurred between Clemens and McNamee on Friday, January 4, 2007.  During the rather emotional conversation McNamee asks Clemens several times “what do you want me to do.”  Clemens noted during the guarded conversation between the two that he just wanted the truth to come out.  Clemens’s lawyers were in the room during the conversation and he was being very careful not to tell McNamee what to say. 

The Mitchell Report was a bombshell and linked many baseball stars to steroid use.  Some stepped forward and admitted use including Clemens’s good friend and teammate Andy Pettitte.  Clemens chose to take the offensive and file a lawsuit.  He has demanded he is innocent and says he should get the benefit of the doubt.  Clemens has now become the face of the Mitchell Report.  Add to the Mitchell Report and the lawsuit a congressional investigation.  Clemens has said he will voluntarily testify in front of Congress.  Andy Pettitte’s lawyer, Jay Reisinger recently said it is “premature” to say whether Pettitte will testify in front of Congress.  McNamee has also said he will testify before Congress as well.

Where does this existing lawsuit go from here?  Could the lawsuit actually end in a jury trial with a parade of star witnesses such as Clemens, Pettitte, George Mitchell, and Barry Bonds testifying?  It is highly improbable that the lawyers or the parties to the lawsuit desire such an outcome.  Lawsuits however have ways of getting a life of their own and when pride becomes a factor for the parties or the lawyers they tend to drag on with no resolution.  The next move is McNamee’s.  It is certainly a tormented dilemma for two very close friends who are now locked in a legal battle in the midst of one of baseball’s ugliest scandals.


Patrick K. Thornton is a Professor at Houston Baptist University where he is the faculty advisor for the MBA in Sports Management.  He also teaches “Baseball and the Law” at the University of Houston Law School and Sports Law at Rice University and South Texas College of Law.
 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?