opt out of credit card offers gov credit card balance transfer calculator excel visa student credit card canada best no fee reward credit cards canada credit card with bad credit no deposit sbi credit card payment login pay ann taylor credit card online capital one no credit credit card hdfc credit card offers for mobiles can you get a payday loan online online visa card number generator visa card application pdf premier credit card reviews credit card cash advance without pin number old navy visa card login rewards cards for department stores prepaid credit card credit builder capital one prepaid credit card uk best cashback credit cards for small business apply credit card online indian bank hsbc credit card charges overseas capital one joint secured credit card amazon credit card payment by phone chase credit card personal loans credit card minimum payments are usually around what percent of the total balance neiman marcus credit card payment phone business credit card bank of america how do they catch credit card fraudsters 0 apr business credit card offers how to get a credit card today and use it today australian average credit card debt best prepaid visa card australia hdfc credit card deals and offers credit card online services icici credit card payment through neft ifsc code cancel home depot credit card canada new credit cards canada 2013 hdfc titanium credit card information check us bank credit card application status virtual us credit card credit card offers 0 balance transfer 12 months hdfc credit card personal loan offers gas saving credit card canada standard chartered platinum credit card malaysia teachers federal credit union secured credit cards bad credit loan companies in georgia credit card offers for bad credit unsecured sbi credit card reward points catalogue 2013 apply for discover credit card student credit card cash advance fee calculator top 5 most popular credit cards cash loans direct lenders uk highest cash back credit card uk lic credit card application form for lic agents credit card numbers 2013 valid prepaid mastercard debit card credit card payoff calculator app ebay hdfc credit card deals premier first credit card login tesco credit card points black cardboard boxes nz prepaid visa credit cards hsbc corporate credit card singapore fast loans with bad credit and no job credit card compare canada who has the best credit card rate 0 percent credit cards with no transfer fee 2012 visa pre approved credit card uk credit card rate comparison iphone mobile credit card processing canada woolworths black credit card online credit card application online for bad credit virtual credit card us billing address southwest credit card business halifax credit card ppi claim rejected discover? card virtual credit card generator best current credit card bonus offers what credit card is best for me cash advance fee capital one store rewards cards app 0 interest credit cards balance transfers no transfer fee credit card calculator payoff date hdfc credit cards offers air ticket visa credit card 5000 limit quick online loans in south africa when making an itunes account do i need a credit card top 10 credit card issuers hdfc credit card interest rate on emi average interest rate on car loans with bad credit how to pay sbi credit card bill online from hdfc virgin prepaid credit card uk is capital one secured credit card good apple credit card declined payday cash advance loans florida apply for credit card canada online best usaa credit card for active duty pre approved credit card opt out no fee american airlines credit card best canada credit cards 2012 agreed credit limit virgin mobile tesco clubcard credit card lost stolen chase freedom credit card foreign transaction fee hdfc credit card status dispatched bad credit personal loans direct lenders only virgin media account credit limit santander 0 balance transfer credit card interest free credit card halifax sacramento payday loan cash advance american airline credit card with no annual fee should i consolidate my credit cards different types of td visa cards capital city bank credit card online payments united chase credit card payments how to get a home loan with bad credit 2013 best travel credit card offers 2011 best buy master credit card login how to improve credit rating chase amazon credit card cash advance sears credit card rewards hsbc unsecured credit cards for bad credit no credit check barclays business credit card limit visa platinum card iphone credit card processing canada travel credit cards best canada generic one time credit card authorization form ltd company credit cards uk no fee prepaid reloadable credit card travel reward credit cards for bad credit pay belk rewards credit card android credit card reader lowest rate prepaid credit cards walmart paypal sample letter to credit card company can;t pay icici credit card settlement cibil what is the best credit card for bad credit unsecured credit card debt canada cashback on credit cards at walmart hdfc credit card reward points offer irctc icici credit card charges real credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date 2013 best credit card protection plan should i get credit card with annual fee should i pay off my student loans or invest make a discover credit card payment chase marriott premier credit card phone number bestbuy credit card visa cards india offers unsecured visa credit cards for fair credit hello kitty credit card visa paypal accept credit cards on website top 10 credit cards in australia coral icici credit card instant no credit check payday loans uk chase toys r us credit card mailing address best credit card points guy what is the best credit card rewards program toys r us rewards credit card login wal mart credit card paypal credit card verification fee icici bank credit cards features standard chartered master credit card payment activate my ge credit card online ebay credit card on file reclaim credit card charges calculator manchester united credit card maybank easy gas credit cards free virtual credit card us bank of america student platinum plus visa credit card interest rate union bank of india credit card application form download how to apply for paypal without credit card fake visa credit card number with security code which credit card charges track barclay credit card application virtual credit cards uk venture capital one credit card no annual fee vision visa prepaid credit card how to best use a credit card to build credit difference between secured and unsecured credit card credit card minimum payment calculator formula no credit history credit cards chase capital credit card login page how to remove credit card off ebay best interest free credit cards balance transfer hdfc credit card helpline karnataka 0 apr balance transfer credit cards canada how do i find my usaa credit card pin bank of america worldpoints rewards for business visa card credit card types gold platinum pay off credit card debt plan which credit card can i get with bad credit credit card payment application when do credit card companies report late payments to credit bureaus does discover credit card work in canada credit card deal finder best payday loans over 3 months new horizon credit union credit card amazon visa rewards card car rental insurance best travel reward credit card deals bank of america visa signature 400 cash back compare credit cards with travel rewards credit card merchant account uk credit card cash advance best balance transfer credit cards 0 transfer fee standard chartered credit card review singapore paypal vs credit card merchant fees how to accept credit cards for my small business wells fargo credit card cash advance ann taylor credit card phone number hsbc mastercard credit card terms and conditions citibank credit card promotions philippines instant credit card number paypal what is a credit card cash advance rate low interest low income credit cards natwest interest free credit card absa gold credit card travel insurance credit cards offers cash back apply for a orchard bank credit card online best credit cards to have 2011 free credit card applications for no credit payday loans online get a fast easy payday loan rbc visa prepaid credit card consolidate credit card debt bad credit coast capital savings prepaid credit cards bad credit credit cards instant approval canada platinum card emirates does paypal accept visa debit cards student credit cards no credit best credit card for money transfer to current account best buy rewards credit cards login how do cash advances work on credit cards cash advances on credit cards means how to negotiate a debt settlement with a credit card company which credit card company offers best rewards credit card transfer offers canada australian credit card comparisons hdfc credit card settlement contact number mastercard credit cards usa sears master credit card canada prepaid credit card to build credit lowest interest credit cards canada secured credit card issuers wireless credit card scanner theft apply for best credit card offer is it illegal to charge customers for credit card processing fees credit cards with cashback rewards wells fargo platinum credit card cash advance are credit card consolidation loans good credit card no annual fee india best 12 months interest free credit cards what is the lowest credit card rate available 10 best credit cards rewards credit card visa or mastercard pay citifinancial credit card bill online direct instant payday loan lender uk british airways credit card 50 000 points credit card comparison chart how to calculate your credit card interest rate cash loans for bad credit and no bank account natwest world credit card interest free best rates for merchant credit card processing uk iphone credit card machine with printer no credit check loans online instant approval australia cash back business credit cards canada bad credit loans guaranteed approval uk square credit card canada review real online loan companies syndicate bank kisan credit card interest rate same day cash online loans firestone credit card login cfna valid credit card numbers with security code 2013 how do criminals get credit card numbers spg amex best credit card jcpenney credit card pay fast payday loans direct lender icici credit card bill payment through other bank debit card online credit card prepaid best credit card processing fees for small business how much does it cost to use tesco credit card abroad minimum requirements for getting a credit card lowest balance transfer rate credit card philippines how to get a bad credit loan without a bank account orchard bank credit card for bad credit apply best visa debit card abroad guaranteed approval credit cards for bad credit canada top 10 canadian travel credit cards calculate credit card interest distributed data mining in credit card fraud detection analysis ieee how to pay hdfc credit card payment options simmons first visa platinum credit cards credit cards for young adults with no credit uk 10 best credit cards to rebuild credit ?3000 loan bad credit instant decision no credit check payday loans online uk dillards credit card payment in store best virtual credit cards amscot payday advance online mail sears credit card payment address gas company credit cards pay my bestbuy credit card discover cash back rewards credit cards mastercard debit card canada which credit card offers the lowest interest rate personal loans online fast pay chase disney credit card finding best credit card rate standard chartered credit card application status check singapore barclay credit card online payment india td canada trust visa infinite rewards credit cards for good credit rating how do i apply for a bp gas credit card who has the lowest interest rate credit card good credit cards for students with no credit history payday online loans no credit check barclay credit card through apple who has the best credit card interest rate travel rewards credit cards australia ocbc credit cards application form rooms to go ge credit card login credit card machines for iphone 4 icici credit card applying online business loans with bad credit rating best credit card offers student credit cards with no credit no income boc credit card business analyst what;s the best way to consolidate credit cards how to block a credit card of sbi capital one virtual credit card number best unsecured credit card after chapter 7 credit card app for ipad pay barclay credit card payment online first cash advance reviews student credit cards with bad credit or no credit how to pay icici credit card bill online through icici net banking bank of america travel credit card unsecured bad credit credit card offers natwest student credit card minimum payment axis bank credit card online application credit card verification service visa credit card numbers and security codes free best zero percent credit cards 2013 best gas credit card deals 2012 a random credit card number that works walgreens prepaid visa credit cards aspire credit card mailing address retail services best buy credit card login chase visa credit card logon can you pay a best buy credit card at the store credit cards with no annual fee for no credit guaranteed credit card canada credit card offers 0 purchases college student credit cards with bad credit virgin credit card balance transfer australia free credit card numbers generator download easy credit card application malaysia best credit cards travel rewards canada payday loans for bad credit direct lenders only who has the most secure credit card post office platinum credit card best credit card deals cashback sbi credit card payment by cheque paypal virtual credit card machine reputable online loan companies paypal take credit card payments over the phone how to increase credit card limit cheapest way to transfer money from credit card how to buy a house with bad credit and low income hsbc credit card apply online india credit card fraud punishment in alabama discover cashback bonus card credit score natwest credit card payment protection claim payday loan lender bad credit icici bank credit card apply online in delhi apply for sears credit card online online cash loans south africa virgin money black credit card south west trains network gold card credit limit increase wells fargo best credit card abroad halifax stolen credit card numbers amazon direct auto loan lenders bad credit free online credit card processing software how to get a credit card instantly online starbucks gold card perks rewards credit card reviews 2011 is fast cash advance payday loans legit best cashback credit cards august 2012 capital one first credit card credit card after bankruptcy uk visa credit cards numbers and security code zero percent interest credit cards frequent flyer credit cards no annual fee hsbc credit card minimum payment cheapest credit card rates nz no credit check credit cards no deposit post office money order pay with credit card premium credit cards canada apply online credit card axis bank 0 credit card deals for existing customers chase credit card poor credit check my credit card score free easy online cash advance travel rewards credit cards canada 2012 credit card interest rates 2012 canada city bank credit card status with reference number household bank credit card sign in credit card transfer balance no interest best credit cards to use abroad 2011 best credit card to get for first time user standard chartered credit card online application status best business credit card offers 2013 citi aadvantage credit card bonus making hdfc credit cards payments what credit score is needed to be approved for a discover card best cashback credit card singapore gold platinum or reserve delta skymiles credit cards renew gold card derbyshire free reloadable visa debit cards how to get credit card with bad credit australia credit card offers with 0 balance transfer fees credit card canada review sears credit card interest rate hike fnb gold credit card pricing best visa credit card 2013 bad credit loans no credit check australia how to negotiate with credit card companies to reduce debt uk clothing store credit cards for bad credit sbi credit card charges credit card debt relief reviews fake valid credit card numbers that work best visa travel card australia application form for sbi credit card credit card debt calculator 6 months interest free credit card australia texas business free credit card terminal chase united credit card customer service phone number iphone credit card reader canada icici bank instant titanium credit card benefits credit cards offering 0 interest on purchases visa credit card company careers key ring reward cards uk td visa debit card canada chase freedom credit card for bad credit best small business credit card 2012 canada best credit card rewards programs australia personal loans online decision credit card bin search australia playstation capital one credit card review credit card validator java program td visa card account login prepaid visa card canada get one credit card balance transfer poor credit history barclay credit card approval virtual credit cards using paypal what is credit card issue number mastercard credit card for small business owners with bad credit standard chartered credit card online payment india how to get mastercard securecode hello kitty credit card designs wells fargo best credit card 0 balance transfer fee different types of credit cards in us canadian visa credit card application freedom credit card categories guaranteed unsecured credit card best airline credit card offer payday loans with guaranteed approval for bad credit credit cards travel rewards reviews united mileage credit card review starwood business credit card offer transfer credit card balance 0 interest unsecured loans with bad credit rating us credit card number fast short term loans online south africa banks that offer credit cards for no credit icici credit card settlement noc southwest airlines credit card free flight best payday loans online no credit check secured business credit card application united credit card 50000 bonus miles are credit card rewards taxable sbi irctc credit card online payment credit card fraud online vs inline american express no annual fee credit card maurices credit card application prepaid credit card reviews usa hdfc credit card online login registration bankruptcy credit cards bank of ireland visa debit card locked instant response credit cards uk magnum cash advance reviews get cash advance credit card will opening new credit cards hurt my credit score tips for getting a secured credit card black cardboard boxes uk best plan to pay off credit card debt who has the lowest credit card rates credit card minimum payment interest ace cash advance payday loans new unsecured bad credit cards how to get credit card with no credit score disney credit card payment login barclays apple credit card login
Home Maury Brown Mitchell Report: Practicality and Due Process Has to Occur

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 812 guests online

Atom RSS

Mitchell Report: Practicality and Due Process Has to Occur PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 10
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 16 December 2007 05:51

Maury BrownSince Thursday, when former Senator George Mitchell released his report on the use of performance-enhancing drugs in Major League Baseball, I’ve been struck by the reactions from the top (that would be you, Commissioner Selig) down to the media, fans and some that study the game. Maybe I have become too practical and pessimistic in my ways, but I’m still of the belief that due process has to occur in this country, and that this report is not the be-all-end-all on the matter. Just because your name is in a “report” does not make you guilty.

Each of the 30 clubs has decided to issue a statement on the report, with most rolling out nothing more than a form letter. The one issued by the Orioles (a team that sees more than a few player names named in the report, by the way) seemed to say what makes a great deal of sense:

As to the information and allegations contained in the Mitchell Report, the Orioles caution observers to resist the temptation to accept collective judgments based upon unsubstantiated allegations.

The Orioles further believe that each Major League player must be treated on an individual basis, must not be judged responsible by mere association, and is innocent of any improper conduct until proven otherwise beyond a reasonable doubt.

It’s not often that I say this about Peter Angelos and the Orioles, but… Bravo.

There are other matters happening that will stymie Bud Selig’s attempt to move forward with the 20 recommendations in the Mitchell Report.

(See the recommendations in the Mitchell Report here)

Removing whether there should or should not be more stringent testing from the equation, the fact is, there are labor laws in this country, and with that, management and labor will have to hash matters out through collective bargaining. Management may wish to enact every one of the 20 recommendations, but the reality is, unless Donald Fehr and the players want to go along for the ride, chances are only a subset of the 20 will happen, and even then, not without alteration. Only someone like Rep. Waxman or Davis and members of Congress could ram something through to back Selig, but even that seems a stretch.

Lastly, the system of suspension works fine in its current state. I bring this up after reading J.C. Bradbury’s Op/Ed in today’s New York Times.

First of all, I applaud the likes of J.C. for looking at the system and saying it could be better. Much like the revenue-sharing system in the CBA, tweaks or complete new methods should be talked of and mentioned. After all, Charlie Finley talked of orange baseballs for night games, and a form of a designated hitter. The orange balls never transpired, but eventually the DH as we know it was added in. Now whether it is good for the game or not is a question for another time; the fact is, fresh ideas are healthy for the game.

Back to the matter at hand, when the rubber meets the road, politics comes into play. We can argue about this, but the system of suspension without pay for analytical positive tests seems more than adequate. Not only does it hurt the player, but by keeping the player at home, it hurts the team – a further incentive that places peer pressure to not get popped in play. Negotiating any kind of a radical shift from the current system would seem difficult at best. As I said, it’s good to see articles talking about such change, and makes for interesting reading, it just isn’t practical politically.

As for non-analytical positives (such as the Radomski list in the Mitchell Report), due process has to occur. As I mentioned in Guillen & Gibbons Suspensions Prelude to Mitchell Report, “Some players will decide to do the time, and apologize, as was the case today with Gibbons. Others will fight the accusations by way of arbitration, as is the case with Guillen.” Well, here we are.

(See all the player names in the Mitchell Report by context)

With Andy Pettitte’s statement yesterday in which he said that he used hGH twice in 2002, we’re seeing the “Gibbons model” take shape. Pettitte could see the 15-day suspension that was doled out to Guillen and Gibbons, do the time, and more forward.

Others may feel that they have been wrong accused and fight back.

Let’s say this, I’m not discounting the findings in the Mitchell Report (or at least not yet).

Finally, let’s not confuse my stance on practicality with some notion that I don’t believe the system could be better. I don’t believe that Dick Pound would like what I have to offer, but neither will Donald Fehr.

Year-round testing needs to occur. Also, a wholly independent firm should do the testing with testers giving no warning to the player or team. Lastly, a continued effort to try and at least keep up with those making the designer drugs has to take place.

On the latter, until there is a clear method of testing for hGH using urine tests, we’re going to have to live with what we are getting. Blood draws bring in privacy rights issues that simply overshadow “the best interests of the game”, in this author’s opinion. Do we need to eradicate the use of hGH from baseball (and all sports, for that matter)? Absolutely. Do you do so while possibly trampling on the Constitution? No. And some may ask whether testing for hGH should occur at all. After all, on page 9 of the Mitchell Report it states:

A number of studies have shown that use of human growth hormone does not increase muscle strength in healthy subjects or well-trained athletes. Athletes who have tried human growth hormone as a training aid have reached the same conclusion. The author of one book targeted at steroid abusers observed that “[t]he most curious aspect of the whole situation is that I’ve never encountered any athlete using HGH to benefit from it, and all the athletes who admit to having used it will usually agree: it didn’t/doesn’t work for them.”

In-between, the fact that names are in some list does not mean that a player used PEDs. It may well be that the players did in fact knowingly use PEDs, but that has to come out of the due process afforded all Americans. Until that time, as so well put in the Orioles press release, we should “resist the temptation to accept collective judgments based upon unsubstantiated allegations.”

MORE ON THE MITCHELL REPORT


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?