femara without iui cost xenical australia diovan tablet 320 mg xenical 120 mg emagrece paxil us lipitor cost sale buying cymbalta from canada cipro resistance in india zyprexa cost india ventolin price usa buy imitrex nail pharmacy rx world lamictal generic price buy lamictal tablets 9 rogaine foam topamax 25 mg for migraines prednisone us pharmacy duloxetine brands in india get voltaren propecia buy online online lipitor canada buy cipro online 500mg protonix buy cheap clomid 4th round success estradiol cream price sildenafil citrate 20 mg tablets gabapentin 50 mg when will lexapro price go down aciclovir tablets cost tadalafil tadacip discount cialis no prescription rogaine cheapest price get nizoral online how to buy azithromycin online sildenafil citrate jelly valtrex tablets dosage for cold sores topamax 50mg price lasixpurchase furosemide 20 mg to buy buy topamax drug cheap viagra usa buy crestor uk lasix action buy levetiracetam 1000mg price simvastatin com price wellbutrin walmart propecia cream buy online getting clomid from gp discount pantoprazole buy fluoxetine egypt generic valacyclovir tablets crestor price canada price of yasmin at walmart acyclovir otc canada buy viagra online from india lexapro 2.5 mg every other day generic name for doxycycline hyclate duloxetine generic india sildenafil citrate buy cipro birth control buy augmentin 875 mg buy online fluoxetine fluconazole 800 mg loading dose lithium canada companies keppra without rx valtrex 500 mg daily buy alli cheap deltasone rx trusted online viagra sites viagra chicago aleve d and xanax online claritin d clomid for sale in australia buy woma viagra in canada plavix drug pill zyrtec d acyclovir online consultation alli 90 ct cymbalta 60 mg virkning viagra cialis online generic 5mg cialis wellbutrin buy cheap no prescription doxycycline uk pharmacy generic prevacid united states isotretinoin msds valtrex pill number viagra for sale west midlands wellbutrin xl 150 price strattera for children healthy man complaints isotretinoin cream abilify cost of abilify metformin oval pill generic dutasteride diflucan 150 online buy advair hfa online salzarex capsules online pharmacy online pharmacies cialis 5 mg trial viagra online taking metformin without being diabetic cheap canadian levitra avodart tablets uk price of lexapro at costco cut prednisone pill half naproxen no prescription best prices cialis price of cymbalta 60 mg prozac for sale in uk low cost pfizer viagra cipro 750 mg celexa get estradiol 89 pg ml canadian pharmacy discount code viagra trazodone 150 mg for insomnia wellbutrin price uk generic substitute for singulair cialis 20mg for sale get viagra australia cost for cialis from walmart 165 celebrex 30 cost omeprazole 40 mg generic crestor ireland buy xenical slimming pills overseas drug cheap warfarin price vytorin generic dutasteride drug augmentin generic walmart cialis hong kong buy flonase while trying to get pregnant abilify from canada clomid 50 mg bodybuilding sildenafil 100mg dosage cipla india viagra prevacid 42 ct rebate clomid illegal us online levetiracetam price for lipitor 20mg warfarin in india where can you buy levitra prednisone without. prescription canadian cialis online allegra without rx rogaine uk online celebrex price in dubai 30 ml promethazine codeine generic advair medication generic levitra 20 mg buy avodart from uk diclofenac buy europe levitra prices 20 gm free delivery generic revatio canada lasix 3170 v cost lipitor in australia doxycycline 100mg tablets in canada trazodone for sale buy yasmin pharmacy promethazine 12.5 prednisone online pharmacy no prescription fluconazole mg for yeast infection order cialis no rx accutane highest mg cost topamax 200 mg ampicillin 500 mg po fosamax purchase generic rogaine sale sildenafil generic dosage pulmicort generic buy viagra stock levaquin tablet cost generic cialis super force generic naproxen 500 mg nolvadex price in egypt fortamet 500 er dutasteride purchase cialis generic 5mg metformin tablet names where to buy viagra cheap generic ethinyl estradiol and levonorgestrel buy levitra powder nexium online pharmacy phifer viagra generic cymbalta australia buying trazodone with no prescription buy norvasc with no prescription buy nolvadex post cycle therapy lipitor 20 mg harga metformin cost bnf cymbalta street price diflucan one cost buy xenical buy generic crestor uk viagra generic retailer buy propecia 100 buy generic inderal online amoxil 400 mg chewable nolvadex liquid abilify 10 mg bijsluiter diovan generic form cost fluticasone nasal spray propionate buy tadalafil 20mg uk ketoconazole 800 dapoxetine kamagra buy valtrex from india discount celebrex online cost of generic paxil allegra boat for sale rogaine cheap foam viagra drug interactions glaxomed zithromax buy buy allegra without rx augmentin es 600 cost what does generic lexapro look like order clomid usa how much does augmentin cost at walmart pharmacy cost of singulair 5mg buy viagra no prescription uk vardenafil vs viagra voltaren 0.1 drops omeprazole canada pharmacy generic lisinopril mylan buy voltaren 50 cheap lipitor uk generic accutane 2010 drospirenone ppt cialis buy now lasix 25 mg compresse buy clomid online from india buy clomid no prescription buy lamictal tablet 100mg duloxetine generic canada online us viagra orlistat buy cheap generic for zyrtec femara tablets lasix 70 mg flomax o.4 mg valacyclovir pills order generic accutane brand name viagra purchase prednisone w not prescription buy cialis overnight delivery clomid for sale cheap mod112 buy flomax usa buy antibiotics online uk esomeprazole online pharmacy buy generic propecia cipla prozac buy canada global pharmacy canada legitimate taking diflucan without yeast infection domperidone from sweden cialis express delivery yasmin tablet uk dapoxetine india sun pharma cialis 5 mg best price usa pulmicort uk vytorin sale promethazine cost ounce clomid 50 mg twice a day fluconazole tablet tesco diovan price increase 2013 montelukast india price buy relafen generic online wellbutrin sr buying nizoral shampoo how much to buy viagra in pounds cymbalta 70mg valtrex without herpes buying fluoxetine online viagra online pharmacy reviews cost of abilify generic propecia canada rosuvastatin q.o.d can take metformin without food acyclovir pill form orlistat 120 mg cost lexapro generic liquid desyrel sleep aid generic zoloft online pharmacy augmentin shortage uk online doxycycline buy quetiapine in canada rx generic levitra onlinepharmacy. cost of ketoconazole celebrex 200 mg que contiene co-diovan generic name mwtformin for wwight loss in canada purchasing viagra in canada cymbalta prices sams club diclofenac buy cheap prescription toradol 15 mg ndc promethazine 25 mg for pain phenergan mg per kg canadian nexium online promethazine pills 25 mg buy voltaren gel canada buy accutane 10mg online buy simvastatin 80 mg clomid to buy online viagra in britain ampicillin dose mg/kg fluconazole india uk zyrtec plavix generic when order lasix with no prescription tablet keppra generic tamsulosin moa diflucan 150 mg nedir plavix purchase metformin without clomid propecia 90 pills buy generic dapoxetine uk canadian generic viagra pursues viagra with a gift card where to buy metformin tablets dapoxetine india brand name cymbalta generic problems buy gabapentin 800 mg how much does augmentin cost at publix aciclovir 200 mg dosage metformin discount prices buy actonel pills crestor 5 mg tablet filmomh rayhhealthcare online order medication trazodone available in canada doxycycline online in uk overnight delivery generic trazodone 25 wellbutrin 100 mg cost tetracycline capsules price cost of cymbalta in canada lipitor generic market ventolin price in uk acyclovir 4 generic fucidin cream price in pakistan wellbutrin 50 mg sr buy abilify in canada promethazine buy online order topamax overnight price yasmin 28 toronto drug stor price isotretinoin drug canada valtrex generic rosuvastatin patient uk promethazine pills mg clomid pills online can u get promethazine over the counter buy acyclovir eye ointment generic crestor from canada finasteride online purchase cheap lexapro online isotretinoin sale philippines generic clomid to buy canadian viagra sales generic allegra at cvs lexapro buy lexapro buy levitra online paypal buy-viagra-online.net reviews finasteride for sale cheap where to buy tadalafil pills clomid for sale australia cymbalta 60 mg half-life buying amoxicillin and clavulanate prednisone pills for asthma crestor 20 mg tabs nexium no prescription online propecia for male baldness best cheapest way to get cialis tadalafil dosage buy doxycycline 50mg online cost of ventolin inhaler canada generic drug for cymbalta acyclovir 400 mg online ethinyl estradiol tablets phenergan sale abilify generic safe buy ketoconazole cream uk buying celebrex australia generic singulair price can i get clomid at dischem imitrex 4mg dutasteride in uk accutane online india viagra shipped overnight strattera 60 mg generic celebrex 200 mg info zyprexa cheap buy zovirax uk tesco celebrex cost rite aid viagra without a doctors prescription price for singulair 10mg professional levitra online tadalafil online shop cialis without prescription canada clomid uk pharmacy finasteride cheap uk cheap accutane singapore valtrex generic side effects lipitor generic recall canada estradiol buy cialis cheapest price metformin pioglitazone tablet voltaren 50mg amoxicillin tablets how to take diflucan 150 mg tab vermox otc or rx safe way to buy cialis online can synthroid get you high lamictal canada pharmacy fluticasone 44 mcg viagra for .75 a pill get lithium mod themes zithromax taken with or without food cheap finpecia india price naproxen sodium 275 mg canada plavix generic generic drug for lamictal synthroid without hypothyroidism canada plavix com cost of ampicillin canadian pharmacy without prescritption paroxetine 45 mg cipro 500mg price wellbutrin us pharmacy zoloft 25 mg xenical canada sans ordonnance propecia rogaine uk order xenical online pharmacy cymbalta uk patent expiry sildenafilat buy uk buy proscar usa generic seroquel xr 300 target lipitor price lasix to buy finasteride canada cost nolvadex 40mg ed phenergan recommended dosage antibiotico cipro generico cost valtrex generic alli 84 twin generic finasteride walgreens advair 450 cymbalta 30 mg bid prozac indian pharmacy cost of wellbutrin in canada generic xenical philippines canada fortamet where to buy nolvadex tablet cheap diflucan 150 mg capsules looking for viagra buy aciclovir tablets 400mg where to buy viagra online from canada plavix cost at walmart dapoxetine singapore cooper viagra generic nexium 20 is disulfiram approved in canada phenergan dosage dogs india online pharmacy generic claritin at walgreens buy valtrex no prescription needed valtrex cost in india where to buy avodart cream clomid 50mg days 4-8 generic cymbalta vs name brand buy wellbutrin sr 200mg price for lipitor 40 mg buy clomid privately where to buy clomid without an rx helthy man valtrex generic price generic lasix cialis 5 mg cost walmart yasmin pill online buy cost actonel us levitra review lamictal online discount buy xenical price order tamsulosin hydrochloride buy nolvadex at spray lipitor 40 mg recall buy imitrex australia lisinopril generic form buy cialis in singapore 166 buy ketoconazole pills fluoxetine price india buy online duloxetine no prescription zocor cost lithium carbonate doxycycline cost thailand buy metformin with no prescription donepezil cost nexium esomeprazole 20mg price where can i buy tadalafil spray cheap propecia cost allergische reaktion auf amoxicillin antibiotics online no prescription drospirenone ee loryna zyprexa sale in us
Home Maury Brown Mitchell Report: Practicality and Due Process Has to Occur

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 643 guests online

Atom RSS

Mitchell Report: Practicality and Due Process Has to Occur PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 10
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Sunday, 16 December 2007 05:51

Maury BrownSince Thursday, when former Senator George Mitchell released his report on the use of performance-enhancing drugs in Major League Baseball, I’ve been struck by the reactions from the top (that would be you, Commissioner Selig) down to the media, fans and some that study the game. Maybe I have become too practical and pessimistic in my ways, but I’m still of the belief that due process has to occur in this country, and that this report is not the be-all-end-all on the matter. Just because your name is in a “report” does not make you guilty.

Each of the 30 clubs has decided to issue a statement on the report, with most rolling out nothing more than a form letter. The one issued by the Orioles (a team that sees more than a few player names named in the report, by the way) seemed to say what makes a great deal of sense:

As to the information and allegations contained in the Mitchell Report, the Orioles caution observers to resist the temptation to accept collective judgments based upon unsubstantiated allegations.

The Orioles further believe that each Major League player must be treated on an individual basis, must not be judged responsible by mere association, and is innocent of any improper conduct until proven otherwise beyond a reasonable doubt.

It’s not often that I say this about Peter Angelos and the Orioles, but… Bravo.

There are other matters happening that will stymie Bud Selig’s attempt to move forward with the 20 recommendations in the Mitchell Report.

(See the recommendations in the Mitchell Report here)

Removing whether there should or should not be more stringent testing from the equation, the fact is, there are labor laws in this country, and with that, management and labor will have to hash matters out through collective bargaining. Management may wish to enact every one of the 20 recommendations, but the reality is, unless Donald Fehr and the players want to go along for the ride, chances are only a subset of the 20 will happen, and even then, not without alteration. Only someone like Rep. Waxman or Davis and members of Congress could ram something through to back Selig, but even that seems a stretch.

Lastly, the system of suspension works fine in its current state. I bring this up after reading J.C. Bradbury’s Op/Ed in today’s New York Times.

First of all, I applaud the likes of J.C. for looking at the system and saying it could be better. Much like the revenue-sharing system in the CBA, tweaks or complete new methods should be talked of and mentioned. After all, Charlie Finley talked of orange baseballs for night games, and a form of a designated hitter. The orange balls never transpired, but eventually the DH as we know it was added in. Now whether it is good for the game or not is a question for another time; the fact is, fresh ideas are healthy for the game.

Back to the matter at hand, when the rubber meets the road, politics comes into play. We can argue about this, but the system of suspension without pay for analytical positive tests seems more than adequate. Not only does it hurt the player, but by keeping the player at home, it hurts the team – a further incentive that places peer pressure to not get popped in play. Negotiating any kind of a radical shift from the current system would seem difficult at best. As I said, it’s good to see articles talking about such change, and makes for interesting reading, it just isn’t practical politically.

As for non-analytical positives (such as the Radomski list in the Mitchell Report), due process has to occur. As I mentioned in Guillen & Gibbons Suspensions Prelude to Mitchell Report, “Some players will decide to do the time, and apologize, as was the case today with Gibbons. Others will fight the accusations by way of arbitration, as is the case with Guillen.” Well, here we are.

(See all the player names in the Mitchell Report by context)

With Andy Pettitte’s statement yesterday in which he said that he used hGH twice in 2002, we’re seeing the “Gibbons model” take shape. Pettitte could see the 15-day suspension that was doled out to Guillen and Gibbons, do the time, and more forward.

Others may feel that they have been wrong accused and fight back.

Let’s say this, I’m not discounting the findings in the Mitchell Report (or at least not yet).

Finally, let’s not confuse my stance on practicality with some notion that I don’t believe the system could be better. I don’t believe that Dick Pound would like what I have to offer, but neither will Donald Fehr.

Year-round testing needs to occur. Also, a wholly independent firm should do the testing with testers giving no warning to the player or team. Lastly, a continued effort to try and at least keep up with those making the designer drugs has to take place.

On the latter, until there is a clear method of testing for hGH using urine tests, we’re going to have to live with what we are getting. Blood draws bring in privacy rights issues that simply overshadow “the best interests of the game”, in this author’s opinion. Do we need to eradicate the use of hGH from baseball (and all sports, for that matter)? Absolutely. Do you do so while possibly trampling on the Constitution? No. And some may ask whether testing for hGH should occur at all. After all, on page 9 of the Mitchell Report it states:

A number of studies have shown that use of human growth hormone does not increase muscle strength in healthy subjects or well-trained athletes. Athletes who have tried human growth hormone as a training aid have reached the same conclusion. The author of one book targeted at steroid abusers observed that “[t]he most curious aspect of the whole situation is that I’ve never encountered any athlete using HGH to benefit from it, and all the athletes who admit to having used it will usually agree: it didn’t/doesn’t work for them.”

In-between, the fact that names are in some list does not mean that a player used PEDs. It may well be that the players did in fact knowingly use PEDs, but that has to come out of the due process afforded all Americans. Until that time, as so well put in the Orioles press release, we should “resist the temptation to accept collective judgments based upon unsubstantiated allegations.”

MORE ON THE MITCHELL REPORT


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?