levitra 20 mg effectiveness cialis buy melbourne buy cheap viagra order cialis us generic cialis sweet cialis 40mg cipla order Cialis 90 clomid 100mg risk cialis priminence 50 mg none generic cialis propranolol sa 80 mg precio diflucan 150 mg propranolol 10mg forum cipro 1000 mg antibiyotik nexium generic omeprazole doxycycline tablets 400mg generic of hydrochlorothiazide 30 mg prednisone 7 days prednisone 20 mg nz levitra 20mg fta 4 tadalafil generic cialis cialis 4o mg buy cialis israel generic lisinopril 2.5 mg levitra 20 mg online viagra online einkaufen lexapro 200mg canada cialis 5mg amoxil 500 mg ml buy zoloft yahoo medicament cipro 500mg levitra 20 mg prezzo diflucan online augmentin 500 mg presentacion augmentin pediatrico 200 mg levitra 20mg 12 tabl cialis lilly 20mgwomwn lily cialis 20mg buy viagra plus cialis cheap Washington 10mg cialis online greenstone generic zoloft buy viagra cuprus lisinopril 5mg price cialis 5 mg wikipedia propecia msd online lexapro 5mg supplier nexium 40 mg argentina lisinopril dosage 50 mg buy cialis softtabs notice cialis 10mg propranolol online order generic viagra coupon generic strattera 80 mg valtrex 1000 mg 21 tablets phenergan dosage 50 mg 2.5 mg of lisinopril viagra 100 mg italia buy zoloft medication has generic lexapro viagra price cheapest cialis 20mg pakistan wellbutrin tablets mg clomid ile mg levitra online sicuro viagra 25 mg satis kamagra canada 50mg the cheapest clomid cialis tadalafil 80mg lisinopril 2.5 mg works 40 mg lasix iv 90 wellbutrin xl 300mg doxycycline hyclate 25 mg pharmacy cialis online 420 mg prednisone withdrawal nexium generico precio pcos clomid 50mg doxycycline 100 mg treatment cialis 2.5 mgm only nolvadex 20 mg filmtabletten augmentin antibiyotik 625 mg diflucan dosage mg prednisone 5 mg qualitest 15 mg of buspar levitra 5 mg kullanimi glucophage 1000mg merck generic cialis 30mg kamagra 100mg cena lisinopril stada 5mg zithromax 600 mg egypt levitra 20 mg precios viagra how 2 buy singapore online viagra cialis 10mg fta lisinopril 40mg wholesale strattera order lexapro tab 20mg viagra 50 mg effetti strattera online india generic augmentin 500mg viagra generic company lisinopril ivax 10mg levitra 20mg used buy viagra thailande viagra sale 25mg propecia kopa online propecia 2mg levitra india buy what mg cialis diflucan 150 mg forum order erythromycin online buy viagra zurich buy propranolol uk viagra 100 mg etkileri levitra 10mg dosage billig kamagra online cialis maxman 1800 mg xenical 120 mg price buy lasix solution order cialis india mims amoxil 500 mg viagra 50 mg prospecto strattera capsules 40 mg online philippines viagra zovirax suspension 200 mg zithromax dosage 600mg buy cheap viagra viagra australia cheap wellbutrin 300 mg high lexapro 5mg price wellbutrin xl mg nolvadex generic online generic24 propecia buy propecia price prednisone 50mg price buy zovirax 200 mg lexapro 10 mg pharmacy medicamento xenical 120mg 20mg cialis boner 5 mg cialis review 80 mg strattera online doxycycline 50 mg australia nexium generic ranbaxy clomid 20 mg cialis 5 mg effect legit clomid online wikipedia cialis generico lisinopril 10 mg indicaciones buying cialis 5mg prednisone 50 mg tab zovirax 800mg dosing viagra 25 mgs viagra 100 mg sale viagra kaufen 25 mg cialis 5mg information viagra 50 mg coupon erythromycin 500mg indications cipro epocrates online levitra 5 mg wirkung doxycycline generic online nexium 80 mg dose strattera lilly 3228 25 mg buy nolvadex ireland kamagra online wellbutrin generic wpi 839 glucophage brand generic medicamento wellbutrin 150 mg viagra online gb levitra 20mg vardenafil celebrex mg prezzo viagra 100 mg buy lasix online metformin 500 mg cm generico do viagra 2011 bactrim de 80 mg generic medicines viagra propranolol gador 40 mg bactrim ds mgs buy 50 mg clomid lisinopril 80 mg viagra 600mg 150 mg clomid follicles cialis 25 mg argentina cheapest bulk viagra viagra difference mg clomid 100mg gemeos prednisone apo 5 mg nexium 10 mg otc generic diflucan reviews cialis 2.5 mg review 2.5mg cialis online mg clomid lisinopril 20 mg bid nexium 20mg posologie nexium 40 mg pregnancy levitra 10 mg orodispersibili generic viagra etkisi buy zithromax 1200 indicacion cialis 5mg cytotec 200 mg pfizer clomid 25 mg online cheap kamagra deals 20 mg propranolol pregnancy took 2 cialis 20 mg 12.5mg viagra amoxil 500 mg 10 days buying viagra thailand online viagra pharmacies 150mg zoloft dosage augmentin bid 100 mg nexium dosage 80 mg buy nolvadex india thuoc glucophage 500mg cialis cheap uk xenical 120 mg avis augmentin 50mg spray cialis buy propranolol 40mg bula kamagra buy manchester order hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg 1000 mg cipro gonorrhea cheapest kamagra tablets nexium ec 40 mg cheap cialis bangkok phenergan tablets 25 mg generic cialis plus kamagra uk generic fake viagra 100mg 10mg of kamagra 200 mg zoloft anxiety periactin 4 mg cyproheptadine generic cialis softtabs generic cialis 100mg order nexium online cipro 500 mg bula generic medicine viagra strattera available generic overview diflucan 150 mg cialis 5 mg citalopram generic viagra revue philippine cialis online cialis 20 mg cut viagra 50 mg 4x nexium 400 mg nedir 5 mg cialis dosage synthroid dosage 0.075mg doxycycline 100 mg wsw generic valtrex wikipedia kamagra 100mg eu bactrim milk 960mg levitra 20mg suppliers augmentin antibiotic 1000 mg cialis online cypress prednisone 5 mg dosing clomid autoimmune disorders propranolol tablete 40 mg buy cheap clomid australian generic viagra 25 mg zoloft effects buy cialis amsterdam levitra online india buy discount levitra 1000 mg of augmentin doxycycline for cheap viagra 100 mg blue viagra 50 mg phuket buy zovirax 400 cialis brasilia buy 75mg viagra cialis 20 mg boite nolvadex for cheap celebrex 100mg tablets buy amoxil generic cialis 20mg 121doc cost 75mg viagra cialis 50 mg price order viagra spain cialis 5mg blind nolvadex 20mg dosering viagra 100mg wholesale kamagra 100mg bijwerkingen nolvadex 20 mg controindicazioni lasix online buy nolvadex 40mg buy viagra generic hinta cipro generic substitute bula lisinopril 20 mg kamagra 100mg qatar vega generic viagra lexapro 80mg cheap authentic viagra prednisone online cheap buying diflucan online oral doxycycline 20mg buy metformin 500 mg zovirax 5 cream generic hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg alcohol xenical 120 mg rezeptfrei cipro uk buy lpr nexium 40mg Online Levitra 30 pills buy clomid au amoxil 500 mg wiki generic lexapro 10 propecia 0.2mg cialis de 2.5 mg lasix 40 mg po order lexapro lexapro doxycycline online mastercard cialis buy dubai clomid 50 mg composition augmentin suspension 600 mg buy now viagra 8080 lexapro ssri generic viagra online opinioni lexapro tablets 20 mg buy doxycycline thailand lisinopril 10mg 1000tab nexium 40 mg kaina xenical 120 mg contraindicaciones doxycycline online europe kegunaan zithromax 500 mg cialis 10 mg etkisi zovirax generic drug viagra generico pt is 40mg cialis clomid 50mg twins 2012 prednisone 1mg shop buy 2.5 mg cialis cialis dublin buy buy periactin 4 mg propecia 5mg prices buy phenergan 25mg prednisone 5 mg doesepak levitra 5mg pris 300 mg doxycycline dosage levitra 40 mg amex myth generic viagra doxycycline 500mg sale glucophage 1000 mg fiyat cialis to buy lexapro 15mg bula antibiotic cipro 500mg recensioni cialis generico zoloft 25 mg alcohol lisinopril 10 mg g 101 buy lisinopril 5 mg amoxil suspension 125 mg 150 or 300 mg wellbutrin prospect celebrex 100mg viagra fta 50 mg lexapro 20 mg ratings cheapest viagra gauranteed mail order zithromax cialis 20 mg torrinomedica kamagra 50 mg 1 tableta buy valtrex australia cipro 500 mg muadili cheap lisinopril 40 mg generic cialis reports metformin buy uk viagra canada cheap 1000 mg of prednisone buy kamagra shops order generic clomid prednisone conversion disorder viagra generico comprare viagra femenina online generic levitra articles euro generic viagra gibraltar xenical 120mg prednisone 5mg pak achat cialis 20mg cialis generic prescription kosten nexium 40 mg lisinopril 10 mg watson generic celebrex 200 mg online apotheken viagra there generic valtrex 99cent generic cialis zoloft 100 mg overdose cialis 5 mg diario cheap xenical thailand astrazeneca nexium 40mg indikasi lisinopril 10 mg xenical online sale augmentin 875 mg dose 100 diflucan mg viagra plus 100 mg. nexium 20 mg dosering glucophage 850 mg forum buy cialis cebu generic brand viagra prednisone 2.5 mg information generic viagra edmonton celebrex 200 mg prijs augmentin 400 mg chewable buy periactin syrup lexapro generic paronia 50 to 100 mg zoloft priligy online italia buspar 5 mg bula cytotec 100mg celebrex 200 mg buy buy propecia 1mg propranolol 40mg ansiedade clomid 50 or 100 mg cytotec 50 mg pfizer uti augmentin 875 mg doxycycline 500mg tablets generic viagra ray taking 150mg viagra testing generic viagra 5 mg lexapro works buy cialis online 40 mg cialis power viagra 800 mg nolvadex 10mg pct buy amoxil england generic viagra alternative cialis 100mg preis valtrex 500 mg prospecto zithromax online australia lisinopril accord 20 mg cialis 5mg x28 cialis buy 5mg phenergan 25 mg tablets cialis philippines online buying viagra counter nexium 40 mg medicamento metformin 1000 mg preis buy kamagra pattaya image lasix 12.5 mg cialis online definition viagra 150 mg cipla 40 mg cialis dosage cipro 1000 mg kullananlar wirkungsweise cialis 5mg dapoxetine cheap uk amoxil 500 mg online viagra profecional 150mg merck generic propecia unmarked nolvadex 20 mg buy cheap viagra 32 viagra online apotheke viagra online saudiarabia cialis 20mg pharmacie lexapro hoeveel mg utilizzo cialis 5 mg prednisone 20 mg cortancyl prednisone 100 mg day order viagra viagra diflucan buy overnight generic cialis symptoms xenical 120 mg comprar levitra 20mg georgien tadalafila cialis 5 mg doxycycline bp 100mg strattera 100mg dosage augmentin 400 mg sciroppo metformin hcl 500 mgs cytotec tablet 200 mg viagra levitra buy cialis 5 mg medline viagra 200 online google levitra 20 mg. 40mg strattera erowid viagra 50 mg drug canada levitra online zovirax generic cost prednisone 20mg bula lexapro 30 mgs amoxil online europe cheap cialis 20mg cialis online beograd lisinopril 5 mg bijwerkingen cialis, 40mg, india cialis meds online cialis nere 800 mg 40 mg citalopram buy nolvadex dianabol propecia cheapest buy zovirax generic about zithromax 1000mg bangkok viagra de 15 mg celebrex generic availability cialis 20 mg tagliare discount viagra order cheap viagra mexico cialis 20mg bula nexium msr 40 mg augmentin generic walmart jual levitra 10mg cialis online accessrx order nexium caps cialis 20 mg pris 25 mg zoloft depression cap doxycycline 100mg cialis 100 mg 2 cialis 20 mg
Home Maury Brown Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 408 guests online

Atom RSS

Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 03 December 2007 07:28

Maury BrownThe results of this year’s Veterans Committee vote has been released, and with that we see former commissioner Bowie Kuhn, former Dodgers owner Walter O'Malley, ex-Pirates owner Barney Dreyfuss and managers Dick Williams and Billy Southworth elected.

Snubbed (again) is Marvin Miller, the former executive director of the MLB Player’s Association, who’s shadow and mark on the game is so large, it staggers the imagination that he’s not been elected prior.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Marvin Miller)

Or, should our minds be boggled?

The time has arrived for the make up of the Veterans Committee to be reevaluated and overhauled. As Miller himself said to Murray Chass of the NY Times this past week:

“People have asked me about it,” Miller said, speaking of the committee’s makeup. “I don’t know why they did this except, other than me, it makes sense to have a group like this because they are a management-oriented group voting on management people.”

And therein is the crux of the problem. Therein lies the travesty.

If the committee’s makeup is wholly management-based (and I'm not talking former players, but rather representatives from the front office of the MLBPA) is to say that the influence of the MLBPA is nothing more than window dressing. At least consider adding someone like Dick Moss to the committee. Even a token member would remove at least a smidgen of what appears to be bias.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Dick Moss)

Shortly after I published this column, a statement by Donald Fehr, the executive director of the MLBPA expressed his disappointment, and placed an exclamation point on what I have expressed here:

“Because he was the Players' voice, and represented them vigorously, Marvin Miller was the owners' adversary. This time around, a majority of those voting were owner representatives, and results of the vote demonstrate the effect that had.  In the last vote, Marvin received 63% of the votes, this time he got 25%.  By contrast, Bowie Kuhn received 17% of the votes last time, but got 83% this time."

"I think it was rigged, but not to keep me out. It was rigged to bring some of these in,'' Miller said by telephone after being informed of the results by The Associated Press. "It's not a pretty picture.''

The interesting sidebar to this is the election of Bowie Kuhn, a man that can best be described as being a reactionary to Miller’s bold entrance and the player’s ascension into the most powerful sports union in history. Arguably, Kuhn was simply a man at a certain place at a certain time. The history was made by almost exclusively by others on his watch (the induction of O’Malley highlights this tremendously), not by the man himself. Kuhn fought tooth and nail against the changes Miller proposed.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Bowie Kuhn)

While it is good to see that at least this vote garnered inductions, Miller’s clear snub will be the focus today and until the time the next vote is conducted. Sadly, given Miller’s age, there are the odds that he will have passed away before then.

Maybe Miller isn’t concerned about not being in the Hall. After all, most anyone that knows the pulse of the game understands the incredible mark he has made on upon it – a mark that continues today. It seems that those on the Veterans Committee have chosen to look the other way, or have no understanding of the pulse of the game today, somehow bitter of Miller's change, or still stuck in the past to the point of ignoring the present.

Given that, it’s time to reevaluate the Veterans Committee makeup (yet, again. See changes made to this year's system from the system prior below). Until such day as key individuals from labor are on the committee, incredible gaffs such as the non-induction of Marvin Miller will continue to take place. Given the enormous influence that the MLBPA has had on the game of baseball, it is imperative that they have a seat at the table on the committee. How Marvin Miller could not be considered part of baseball’s “fame” staggers the imagination.

As Fehr closed in his statement today, “The failure to elect Marvin Miller is an unfortunate and regrettable decision.  Without question, the Hall of Fame is poorer for it.” 

CHANGES TO THE VETERANS COMMITTEE SYSTEM 

PREVIOUS RULE

NEW RULE

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Composite ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members (63) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: Committee of 16 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, executives and historians) cast ballots on a managers/umpires ballot
 

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years (2003, 2005, 2007, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected

Composite ballot: Voted on every four years (2003, 2007, etc.). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected
 

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years, starting in 2009 (2009, 2011, 2013, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Managers/umpires ballot: Voted on every two years in even years, starting in 2008 (2008, 2010, 2012, etc.). Anyone to received votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list was not eligible for consideration Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience, whose careers began in 1943 or later. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list is not eligible for consideration
Pre-World War II Players: Part of Player ballot

 
Pre-World War II Players: Will be reviewed by a Board-appointed committee of 12 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, and historians) every five years beginning in 2009
BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of players to 200

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 60
 

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of players to 20; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers choose five players; list of players to contain 20-25 names, depending on duplicate results

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of managers and umpires to 10

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of players from 200 to 25; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers chose five players; final ballot contained 25-30 names, depending on duplicate results

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 15

The living Hall of Fame members, acting as its own screening committee, narrows list of 25-30, to a final ballot of 10, by paper ballot.

No screening committee for managers and umpires.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?