viprogra soft 100 chia captopril side effects diabetes low cost levitra and cialis canadian pharcharmy online hydrocodone acetaminophen acyclovir for shingles dosing differin gel 0.3 generic buy cafergot online no prescription where can i buy 1000 mg zithromax salzarex tadalafil citrate viagra with paypal betnesol injection pregnancybetneval irbesartan 300mg discount cialis in london ospamox 250 mg 5ml viagra for sale singulair dosage and administration allegra d side effects doses myambutol medicine wheel dicyclomine 20 mg dosage proscar finasteride how it works yasminelle tablets with windows zoloft without a perscription buy aloprim estrace cream treatment for wrinkles fluconazole for yeast infection side effects cost of topomax non generic depakote er side effects depression progreso mexico farmacies inderal medication for tremors nolvadex cycle fluzol 200mg viagra allegra printing spartanburg sc sildenafil verkauf cardura medication prostate buy viagra in new zealand free 30 day trial cialis glucophage side effects doctor lamictal for depression lamotrigine generic super viagra online navidoxine tablets information xenical reviews in philippines purchasing vardenafil epanutin capsules cialis daily or 36 hour walgreens pharmacy technician salary growth hormone canadian phamasy macrodantin 50 mg side effects plavix medication plavix lawsuit prezzi viagra alli available uk viagra pour femme amoxicillin to buy on line eutirox 100 mg valtrex side effects buy check soft e check buy flagyl online uk pharmacy express belize cheap avodart viagra vs cialis forum vibramycin dosage forms xeloda side effects treatment of breast cancer viagra in tre giorni on line antibiotics and alcohol interaction cialis times top rated offshore pharmacy cialis effexor xr no prescription needed pakistan pharmacy no perscription casodex 50 mg side effects name of viagra tablets lipitor no rx magnus sildenafil walmart pharmacy login requip restless leg syndrome reviews cheap viagra rayh health care best buy annual report prometrium 100mg capsule strattera reviews for weight loss xenical over the counter name side effects of prednisone withdrawal can you give zithromax for strep throat can you buy antibiotics for cats online budesonide nasal spray over the counter erexin capsules yohimbe bark casodex side effects bicalutamide treatment zentel uk provera to start period cycle can i take cephalexin for sinus infection permethrin side effects in humans legal nizagara online where to buy amoxicillin30 capsules estradiol norethindrone acetate breckenridge donde comprar cialis en chile lortab 5/325 france viagra online pharmacy progynova in ivf insurance companies for sale antabuse drug information buy doxycycline hyclate what is vigora 100 red tablets cholesterol guidelines for women diazepam valium 2mg cipro bay 1000 mg retigel palmitato de retinol que kegunaan obat cravox 500 lapi kosovarja magazine peja stojakovic vidalta bosques de las lomas nexium from canada with no prescription canadian pharmacy in florida reglan 10mg for morning sickness no prescription pharmacies for viagra xerograx y diadete canada drugs no prescription inhalers cuckold definition slang grinding ciprofloxacin pricing yasminelle ulotka intermarche hydrochlorothiazide no script letrozole 2.5mg for men dermasone betamethasone valerate ointment lopressor generic names colchicine for gout treatment pharm support groupgeneric viagra in karachi stores temovate scalp application capital one buy zofran over the counter authentic synthroid rollbox toolbox safety viagra orders online accutane price tadalafil online india uroxatral side effects drug lisinopril liposafe ingredients in beer antivert 12.5mg buy generic ortho tri cyclen online altace side effects on men viamedic complaints against dentists sildenafil citrate from china site pour commender du viagra en france minocin drugsminoxidil serax oxazepam dosageoxetine tadapox low price safe cialis ordering trimox 500mg antibiotic benazepril hydrochloride tablets zoloft for anxiety generic medication seroflo diskus inhaler liposafe reviews on fifty puppies for sale in michigan indocin side effects on fetus imitrex 100mg 25mg original xenical for loss weight ranitidine side effects babies us online overnite pharsacy parcopa vs sinemet generic cytotec buy in uae where can i buy viagra in manila ciales puerto rico pictures of tainos bupropion side effects memory free sample of viraga cholesterol tests at home estrotab 2mg hydromorphone accutane 30 mg sales buy viagra in pharmacy viagra tobuy now in united states baclofen for withdrawal symptoms onadron damla damla xenical prix cipro price pharmacy orlistat 120mg capsules for sale sildenafil citrate 50mg tab starter pack nolvadex paypal cheap cialis next day shipping canada rx discounters lynoral ethinyl estradiol and norethindrone avana skyway apartments san jose ca lumigan 0.01 securetabs return haldol side effects medication how can i buy viagra in toronto ontario clomid calculator sotalol medication tab colors 120mg h2s/14 order alli online in uk inderal side effects doctor celecoxib capsules 0.2g prednisone from mexico cipla pharmaceutical zyban dosage for smoking cessation flazol 500mg ibuprofen viagra delivery france viagra american distrubution advantage rent a car phone number cialis mg price comparison hoodia gordonii diet pill nexium online amex baywatch yasmine bleeth mug shot paracetamol mechanism of action doses atrovent side effects dose pristiq absetzen cipro side effects in dogs alphagan 0.1 price rabeprazole sodium and domperidone sr capsules best online foreign pharmacy vytorin side effects ezetimibe diclofenac gel 20 buy purchase antivert meclizine side effects cymbalta without rx overnight remeron generic name gabapentin without a prescription cipla canada online thailand pharmacies soviclor tabs for sweet canada trazedone pilocarpine hydrochloride ophthalmic solution side effects vardenafil maximum dosage harga salep acyclovir no prescription estradiol compare cialis to viagra buylowdrugs review buy viagra negril buy viagra online uk forum myambutol ati technologies methylprednisolone without prescription aldactone side effects hair loss ritalin vs adderall how to stop taking metformin er 500mg risnia syrup recipe viagra in wilmington nc amlodipine besylate 5mg prednisone 20mg phenamax reviews on vigrx flexidol relax accion terapeutica hiv bactroban mupirocin ointment for dogs vega 100 viagra tiotropium pronunciation of words cipro antibiotic for sell purchase zoloft online no prescription epogen medication dosage cheapest alli 120 propecia hair loss sale canada differin reviews drugs paypal sildenafil letrozole 2.5mg bodybuilding celebrex dosage osteoarthritis benadryl dosage for infants children vemox purchase mastercard combivent inhaler medication dosage ed pills at cvs finasteride dosage for women nifedipine side effects pregnancy canada pharmacy online viagra clobex shampoo coupons estrace cream coupons buy amoxicillin online uk plavix manufacturer information luvox cr weight gain candian non prescripion celias clenbuterol side effects tablets omeprazole 40 mg skelaxin prescribing information neurontin for anxiety medication staxyn vs viagra vs cialis neurocet and nurofen peritol dermatitis seborreica buy cialus cheap diazepam side effects for dogs viagra saudi arabia where can i buy septra d s online nimesulide tablets 100 mg lorinol tablets at walmart terazosin on line no prescription clomid for men side effects software applications definition best online viagra site viagra substitute walmart hyzaar blood pressure hydrochlorothiazide 50 how to buy propecia in hongkong zinoxime 750 oxybutynin side effects depression liposafe ingredients in tylenol cialis in berlin kaufen perscriptins on line estrofem tablets price for cialis at walmart aleve pain medication dose rizatriptan benzoate side effects clonidine drug classification cheap amoxil how long to get bystolic out of system beconase nasal spray francais proventil inhaler long term side effects mesalamine 400mg cost kamagra europa co uk buy tadalofil buy amoxil england buy nolvadex online australia mirtazapine dosage caverta review salbutamol inhaler side effects zestorectic without scrip bentyl side effects www ebay brand viagra online in uk ranbaxy atorvastatin recall 2012 how to buy wellbutrin online sildenafil generic cost orlistat 60 mg for sale celexa and alcohol blackouts lumigan 0.01 eye drops price buy levothyroxine 50 mcg online ireland insurance institute for highway safety car ratings roaccutane online ebay cialis on sale no priscription generic viagra cheap accutane 20mg cheap clomid usa pharmacy comprar viagra generico contrareembolso bactrim ds side effects insomnia brahmi herb for hair growthbrupen buying lavietra grifulvin v 500mg estrace 5 vermox side effects espanol antibiotics online papal cialis super active 20mg reviews pfizer stock marcumar alternative music temovate 0.05 cream is a form of what therapy donepezil medication and side effects advantage flea control coupon restasis cost without insurance phentermine reviews 2014 fempro tablets on sale sleeping pill uk buy painkillers online canada rhineinc in novolog 70/30 insulin indian pharmacy mastercard micardis manufacturer coupons combivent inhaler medication albuterol cialis half life graph astelin side effects nasal spray code red pills levitra brand usa budy protonix without prescription buying tadalafil online pharmacy review best site buy viagra online keflex 500 mg for dogs kosovarja gazeta buy colchicine 0 5 mg europe augmentin dds sinequanone paris fashion cabaser dosing pumps penis on viagra tegretol xr 200 side effects alli online purchase walmart pharmacy cialis 20mg ezetimibe simvastatin generic claritin d side effects claritin d alfuzosin uroxatral doctor price of viagra at walmart difference with tadalafil professional accutane from india casodex bicalutamide tablets phexin dropship myambutol 400mg ibuprofen cefalexina bula depakote er 500mg for bipolar flagyl cheap levaquin side effects levaquin lawsuit indocin side effects gout pregnant man thomas beatie photos order suprax without prescription how much zithromax for strep throat himcocid side effects diovan generic valsartan lexapro dosage amounts frases de futbolistas bisoprolol fumarate 5mg and alcohol purchase azithromycin or erythromycin buspirone 5mg vs xanax genuine brand name cialis sunsuria development sdn bhd buspirone street value viagra without perscription generic tadalafil sale permethrin 5 cream carafate medication over the counter buy viagra online usa no prescription tramadol no prescription lasixs medicine diuretic 10 mg cialis dosages floxin antibiotics side effects diltiazem side effects eyes allopurinol without a perscription astelin nasal spray reviews feldene 20 mg side effects sildenafil citrate 100mg generic vasotec side effects rash india pharmacies tadalafil 20 mg tadalafil professional adderall side effects in adults anger terramycin for cats buy online free sample generic cialis viagra female germany phexin capsulectomy arthrotec generic brand epharmacy australia reviews catafast active ingredient acnelyse cream information technology canadian chemist retin a what strength does itcome it colchicine pills canadian prilligy tablets in germany dyazide without prescription india pharma return buyer discounts zestril side effects frumil forte definition kahler omaggio vase torsemide 20 mg what is it used for cheap brand cialis colchicine medication lantus insulin coupons for cats trazodone side effects trazodone sleep aid buspar xanax interaction india generic lipothin weight management system prevacid dosage instructions fluxotine online buy levitra side effects doctor furosemide 20 mg for dogs how to use seroflo rotacaps obetrol online generic cipro overnight delivery viagra and canada pharmacy canadian pharmacy vipps approved ritalin for adults geriforte ingredients for lasagnagirlviagraglucofageglucophage viagra meaning pharmacy 365 sinequanone online software engineer salary at apple lowest cost cialis precose contraindications to breastfeeding neurocet reviews on garcinia phenamax reviews 50 lipothin 200 fenofibrate medication online pharmise with no perscription buy retin a online cheap eltroxin side effects tablets computers anbefalt nedtrappings dos ved zoloft ramipril medication for kidneys pastillas cytotec en usa diclofenac sodium side effects 50mg euro meds online mupirocin ointment used for le pentasa fait il perdre les cheveu x colchicine generic anadian companies selling ciailis cialis drug order rimadyl carprofen for dogs side effects canadian drugs no prescription flovent inhaler dose budesonide nasal spray price over counter viagra alternative gnc neurontin for pain management dosage anxiety attacks during pregnancy levaquin for sinus infection how long canadian meds without an rx viagra natyrale astelin generic how long can you be on nifedipine for preterm labor allegra d generic cialis online cheapest viagra kaufen ohne rezept atosil tropfen beipackzettel amantadina nombres comerciales de vitaminas cheap apcalis tablets androgel testosterone side effects clymidia medication at walmart nolvadex dosage during cycle entocort side effects budesonide inhalation levamisole hydrochloride for sale viagra for sale fast delivery paypal clonidine side effects dose eprex injection buy furacin soluble dressing viagra naturale provera medication men noroxin 400mg dosage wellbutrin xl side effects withdrawal celexa weight gain side effects cytotec for miscarriage side effects aricept drug side effects cialis pas cher italie cardizem medication diltiazem walgreens careers opportunities proviron dosage for men levitra generico vs original xalatan ophthalmic solution vardenafil 20 mg with dapoxetine 60 mgdeltasone los algodones pharmacies prices mercury drugstore products list
Home Maury Brown Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again)

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 530 guests online

Atom RSS

Miller's Snub: Time to Overhaul Veterans Committee (again) PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Monday, 03 December 2007 07:28

Maury BrownThe results of this year’s Veterans Committee vote has been released, and with that we see former commissioner Bowie Kuhn, former Dodgers owner Walter O'Malley, ex-Pirates owner Barney Dreyfuss and managers Dick Williams and Billy Southworth elected.

Snubbed (again) is Marvin Miller, the former executive director of the MLB Player’s Association, who’s shadow and mark on the game is so large, it staggers the imagination that he’s not been elected prior.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Marvin Miller)

Or, should our minds be boggled?

The time has arrived for the make up of the Veterans Committee to be reevaluated and overhauled. As Miller himself said to Murray Chass of the NY Times this past week:

“People have asked me about it,” Miller said, speaking of the committee’s makeup. “I don’t know why they did this except, other than me, it makes sense to have a group like this because they are a management-oriented group voting on management people.”

And therein is the crux of the problem. Therein lies the travesty.

If the committee’s makeup is wholly management-based (and I'm not talking former players, but rather representatives from the front office of the MLBPA) is to say that the influence of the MLBPA is nothing more than window dressing. At least consider adding someone like Dick Moss to the committee. Even a token member would remove at least a smidgen of what appears to be bias.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Dick Moss)

Shortly after I published this column, a statement by Donald Fehr, the executive director of the MLBPA expressed his disappointment, and placed an exclamation point on what I have expressed here:

“Because he was the Players' voice, and represented them vigorously, Marvin Miller was the owners' adversary. This time around, a majority of those voting were owner representatives, and results of the vote demonstrate the effect that had.  In the last vote, Marvin received 63% of the votes, this time he got 25%.  By contrast, Bowie Kuhn received 17% of the votes last time, but got 83% this time."

"I think it was rigged, but not to keep me out. It was rigged to bring some of these in,'' Miller said by telephone after being informed of the results by The Associated Press. "It's not a pretty picture.''

The interesting sidebar to this is the election of Bowie Kuhn, a man that can best be described as being a reactionary to Miller’s bold entrance and the player’s ascension into the most powerful sports union in history. Arguably, Kuhn was simply a man at a certain place at a certain time. The history was made by almost exclusively by others on his watch (the induction of O’Malley highlights this tremendously), not by the man himself. Kuhn fought tooth and nail against the changes Miller proposed.

(Read The Biz of Baseball interview with Bowie Kuhn)

While it is good to see that at least this vote garnered inductions, Miller’s clear snub will be the focus today and until the time the next vote is conducted. Sadly, given Miller’s age, there are the odds that he will have passed away before then.

Maybe Miller isn’t concerned about not being in the Hall. After all, most anyone that knows the pulse of the game understands the incredible mark he has made on upon it – a mark that continues today. It seems that those on the Veterans Committee have chosen to look the other way, or have no understanding of the pulse of the game today, somehow bitter of Miller's change, or still stuck in the past to the point of ignoring the present.

Given that, it’s time to reevaluate the Veterans Committee makeup (yet, again. See changes made to this year's system from the system prior below). Until such day as key individuals from labor are on the committee, incredible gaffs such as the non-induction of Marvin Miller will continue to take place. Given the enormous influence that the MLBPA has had on the game of baseball, it is imperative that they have a seat at the table on the committee. How Marvin Miller could not be considered part of baseball’s “fame” staggers the imagination.

As Fehr closed in his statement today, “The failure to elect Marvin Miller is an unfortunate and regrettable decision.  Without question, the Hall of Fame is poorer for it.” 

CHANGES TO THE VETERANS COMMITTEE SYSTEM 

PREVIOUS RULE

NEW RULE

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members, Frick and Spink Award winners (total of 80-plus) cast ballots on Composite ballot

Electorate: All living Hall of Fame members (63) cast ballots on Players ballot

Electorate: Committee of 16 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, executives and historians) cast ballots on a managers/umpires ballot
 

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years (2003, 2005, 2007, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected

Composite ballot: Voted on every four years (2003, 2007, etc.). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast was elected
 

Players ballot: Voted on every two years, in odd years, starting in 2009 (2009, 2011, 2013, etc). Anyone to receive votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Managers/umpires ballot: Voted on every two years in even years, starting in 2008 (2008, 2010, 2012, etc.). Anyone to received votes on 75% of ballots cast will be elected

Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list was not eligible for consideration Eligible candidates: All players with 10 or more years experience, whose careers began in 1943 or later. Any candidate on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list is not eligible for consideration
Pre-World War II Players: Part of Player ballot

 
Pre-World War II Players: Will be reviewed by a Board-appointed committee of 12 individuals (Hall of Famers, veteran writers, and historians) every five years beginning in 2009
BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of players to 200

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 60
 

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of players to 20; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers choose five players; list of players to contain 20-25 names, depending on duplicate results

BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee narrows list of managers and umpires to 10

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of players from 200 to 25; Simultaneously, a screening committee of six Hall of Famers chose five players; final ballot contained 25-30 names, depending on duplicate results

A screening committee of 60 BBWAA members narrowed list of managers, umpires and executives to 15

The living Hall of Fame members, acting as its own screening committee, narrows list of 25-30, to a final ballot of 10, by paper ballot.

No screening committee for managers and umpires.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted through the Business of Sports Network.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?