credit score range quick bad credit loans capital one prepaid credit card usa capital one balance transfer barclays capital credit card login pay barclays credit card phone perks for disney credit card holders best credit card debt consolidation program alaska air miles credit card citibank credit card offer on flight booking how can i pay icici credit card bill online easy payday loans uk pay credit card bank of america online cash converters pay day advance nz secured credit card reviews 2013 can i get a discover credit card with bad credit citibank corporate credit card online payment 6 months interest free on purchases credit card paypal credit card transfer fee hdfc credit card limit information hyatt summerfield suites credit card authorization form credit cards with no transfer fee on balance transfers and 0 interest applying for a visa credit card for the first time bad credit credit cards no annual fee if i pay the minimum payment on my credit card will it affect my credit score credit cards accepted at neiman marcus stores sbi credit card charges what credit card should i get to build credit best credit card offers 2013 for travel chase credit card offers for fair credit cute free prepaid credit cards credit card rate increase opt out canada credit card cash back comparisons credit card verification code fake how to get a cash advance on a bank of america credit card icici platinum credit card online application get credit card bad credit no bank account coast capital us dollar credit card amazon credit card balance transfer fee visa black card available in canada southwest credit card review credit score capital one prepaid credit cards apply for business credit card bank of america quick online loans for students swarovski hello kitty credit card holder citibank sears credit card login credit card pay shell gas credit cards online who do i report credit card fraud to citifinancial credit card customer service number get a credit card without a bank account hdfc credit card rewards catalogue signature british airways credit card uk best credit cards 2013 for bad credit rebuild how to increase credit limit on credit card cash advances definition credit card black and gold card provident hsbc bank bangladesh international credit card best visa credit card no annual fee best credit cards for college students with no credit yahoo want apply visa credit card visa card protection services what does visa cards start with halifax credit card online application hdfc bank titanium credit card limits credit card verification code location apply for capital one secured credit card amazon credit card deals online application for credit card sbi bank major credit card companies in canada can you get cashback on your walmart credit card how does a prepaid credit card work online hdfc titanium credit card international transaction charges invalid credit card numbers for testing instant approval payday loans for bad credit should i consolidate my credit cards best travel rewards credit card canada 2012 credit card no credit check au visa disney credit card best travel credit card compare personal online loans application ulster bank credit card rates ireland household bank best buy reward zone credit card apple credit card scanner united cash loans credit cards wiki best premium travel credit cards international credit card service in bangladesh best secured credit card pay us bank credit card visa credit card number 2013 with cvv chase student credit card requirements best buy credit card application denied ny and company credit card payment apply hsbc credit card online singapore opening new credit cards hurt credit score icici credit card reward points where to get loans with bad credit in singapore pay sears credit cards online cash back credit cards with no foreign transaction fee bank credit cards fair credit compare credit cards for bad credit online payday loan uk 0 balance transfer credit card offers canada standard chartered credit card offers on ebay i have bad credit and need a credit card to rent a car best credit cards to have with fair credit 0 percent interest credit card offers barclays premier credit card insurance fast payday loans today aqua credit card contactless pay bank of america credit card with paypal instant credit card approval australia natwest platinum credit card number credit card fraud detection system pdf british airways visa credit card usa hdfc credit card online application status allied cash advance phone number how do i accept credit cards over the phone high interest rate credit cards for bad credit wireless credit card terminal free gnc gold card membership chase united credit card review paypal adaptive payments with credit card how do amscot payday advances work icici credit card reward points scheme walmart canada credit card online login credit card interest rates comparison calculations pay off credit card debt credit score where can i apply visa credit card unsecured credit cards for bad credit instant approval no deposit credit card advice for young adults 0 credit card transfer no fee can you use best buy gift cards to pay credit card canadian credit cards with travel rewards westpac credit cards apply online best buy credit card login bill pay prepaid credit cards mastercard south africa td visa infinite lost card best credit card consolidation programs first credit card invented in 1950 disney world reward credit card do i need a credit card to rent a car in spain virgin balance transfer credit card minimum payment best buy credit card login usa how long is a visa credit card number mastercard securecode yorkshire bank guaranteed credit cards canada ace cash advance memphis tn very poor credit score credit cards student credit card debt canada credit cards for poor credit unsecured merchant credit card processing companies canada citibank balance transfer credit card visa gift card canada phone number cash loans now farmington nm a fake visa credit card number that work credit card helpline icici visa cards numbers 2012 free prepaid travel credit cards post office best cash back credit card canada 2011 walmart credit card a visa credit card bill payment online student credit cards instant approval no credit visa no credit credit cards apply for mastercard online first credit card company in the world southwest rewards credit card no annual fee apply for capital one credit card uk pay lic premium using credit cards walmart credit card promotions quick online cash advance net credit card protection plan review can you get a joint credit card mastercard uk twitter how do no interest credit cards work best secured credit card usa secured credit cards to build credit no annual fee citibank secured credit cards visa signature cards india apply credit card online hdfc bank what credit cards can i pay at walmart 0 credit card transfer best credit card with no annual fee cash back visa credit card usa contact can you buy prepaid credit cards at walmart in canada walmart discover credit card payment discover student card review credit limit cash advance credit card fees chase best student credit cards with no credit history credit card for business without personal guarantee understanding credit card processing charges compare credit cards india can i get a credit card without a job in india visa credit card verification code 0 balance transfer no fee credit card entropay virtual credit card generator bajaj standard chartered credit card status bad credit need a credit card with no upfront setup fees marriott reward credit card phone number credit card fraudsters arrested best low interest credit cards for good credit royalty free credit card logos sample visa credit card number for testing secure credit card chase apply for old orchard bank credit card online payday loans lenders only bad credit credit card offers no deposit paypal smart connect credit card login how to get a fake credit card number and security code citibank reward credit card citi aadvantage credit card login visa black card credit score requirements nationwide credit card rates abroad how to apply for a hsbc credit card in the philippines barclaycard platinum credit card travel insurance 70 000 mile american express delta credit card hsbc neiman marcus credit card login apply icici international credit card compare credit card terminals uk barclays us credit card review register my american express credit card small business saturday scotia bank secured credit cards canada can i get a settlement figure on my credit card prepaid travel credit cards best visa card abroad uk credit card market 2012 apply visa credit card india policy on use of corporate credit cards paypal credit card verification process standard chartered bank credit card statement get a personal loan with bad credit online instant cash advance online australia prepaid credit card no fees canada first cash advance hours best travel credit card in canada 2013 cibc student credit card application get a credit card online uk how do portable credit card machines work southwest chase visa card login travel rewards credit cards best is it safe to apply for credit card online best credit card to get with no credit history visa credit card transaction history virgin credit cards contact us average credit card debt best low interest no fee credit cards free credit report experian joint credit card company how do cash advances work icici credit card helpline hyderabad are walmart credit cards accepted at sam;s club walmart mastercard credit card free online credit cards apply credit card fraud online shopping best cash back cards india pre approved credit cards no credit check first premier bank mastercard credit card reviews lowest credit card apr compare commonwealth bank credit cards hsbc credit cards online malaysia sentence for credit card fraud uk united bank of india credit card apply online typical credit card fees for merchants free credit card apps for blackberry sbi credit card customer care number trivandrum 100 guaranteed payday loans online rbc visa canada credit card credit cards rewards compare citibank cash back credit card malaysia long term bad credit personal loans best buy credit card payments hsbc icici credit card apply online in bangalore sallie mae cash back visa had a capital 1 credit card you could be owed a refund visa card number validation apply credit card barclays online wireless credit card machines for sale tesco credit card minimum monthly payment is it worth getting a credit card at 18 does western union accept credit cards to send money capital one credit card login to pay bill bmo cashback credit card list of payday lenders australia australian credit card with no international transaction fees maurices credit card direct online payday loan lenders no credit check contact wells fargo credit card services does applying for a credit card affect your credit rating visa credit card no annual fee cash back teflon black credit card holder credit card fraud uk punishment new credit card company rules horizon credit card login best money back credit cards 2011 malaysia credit card review 2013 credit card insurance cpp loan companies for bad credit no brokers credit card with travel rewards points secured credit card credit union juniper barclay credit card application which is the best secured credit card in canada student visa credit card usa credit card for bad credit who accepts visa debit cards how do i pay ebay credit card hdfc credit card apply in bangalore best and worst credit cards for travel insurance blue american express cash advance how to get past credit card verification best business credit cards for small business javascript credit card number validator what happens to credit card debt when you die uk credit union glasgow compare the market cash back credit cards virgin credit card ppi claim form cibc prepaid credit cards canada buy visa gift card online and use instantly want to apply for credit card hsbc virgin atlantic american express credit card uk credit card with 2000 limit no credit check super balance transfer to current account walmart credit card payments online best online credit card payment gateway good credit cards for travel abroad amex credit card merchant fees credit cards explained uk how to commit credit card fraud uk best car loans with bad credit how to get a black card blackberry credit card app uk hdfc credit card helpline number delhi can i get a discover card with no credit history credit card advice for college students chase freedom credit card payment address virgin credit card phone number contact chase credit card services elgin il sbi credit card reward points value citibank credit card payment plan netspend prepaid debit cards prepaid visa cards visa credit cards rewards programs delta skymiles credit card benefits student visa credit card bank of america nationwide credit card charges overseas everyday rewards credit card woolworths credit card minimum repayment calculator australia instant payday loan online new list of payday lenders long term personal loans with bad credit us dollar prepaid credit card canada corporate credit card policy what factors should be considered when choosing a credit card who gives highest credit card limits paypal credit card processing reviews best cash back cards canada 2013 credit card debt settlement actual online payday lenders tata sbi credit card login what are the best credit cards for mileage bad credit card approval australia how does a wireless credit card terminal work orange prepaid credit card top air mile credit cards payday loans with bad credit soft leather iphone & credit card case disney visa credit card uk who has the best credit card for airmiles us bank credit card for bad credit credit card number sample mastercard hdfc credit card bank offers how to get guaranteed credit card approval target visa card balance check hdfc credit card apply online in hyderabad visa card generator how long does it take to get credit card refund chase visa freedom credit card login toys r us credit card login chase bpi credit card online application form can i apply for a lowes credit card online credit card issuers in india fast payday loans uk capital one apply for credit card american express delta credit card reserve what is the best no fee credit card in canada credit card scanner apple store best credit card rates uk credit card rewards best canada credit card merchant services comparison compare interest rates on credit cards in canada natwest credit card online points how many credit cards should i have for a good credit score hsbc credit card promotions 2013 chevron with techron credit card login credit card interest rate calculator per month easiest way to accept credit card payments credit card for poor credit history uk citibank credit card travel insurance cover buy prepaid credit card ireland what credit card can i get with a score of 650 apply mbna credit card canada hdfc credit card settlement process wells fargo payday advance does discover offer a secured credit card how to get credit card numbers off the internet best buy rewards credit cards payment vip cash advance loans ways to pay off credit card debt faster best canadian air miles credit card how many types of credit cards in hdfc bank venture capital credit card review credit expert compare credit cards interest free period hsbc premier credit card rewards point standard chartered credit card payment drop box ahmedabad unsecured credit card debt collection visa us bank credit card lloyds tsb credit card online services mymoneymutualnow.com online cash advance payday loans best southwest credit card promotion discover credit cards for college students what is the best credit card at the moment best australian credit card balance transfers free credit card details that work 2013 instant short term loans online credit card processing via pc how does square credit card app work sell gift cards online without credit card best credit card for college students with no credit 2012 kwik fill / red apple credit card application credit union credit cards canada best credit card balance transfer deals uk credit card rates canada credit score for american express spg card credit card debt advice forum should i apply for apple credit card best rate credit cards canada does costco accept credit cards for gas distributed data mining in credit card fraud detection bibtex credit card payment app for android credit card cash advance icici credit card online apply credit card points comparison canada credit card debt settlement uk cash advance ukraine my capital one credit card login paypal credit card fees canada hsbc credit card online application malaysia chase prepaid credit card bad credit loans no fees no phone calls barclays credit card payment dubai chase slate credit card bad credit citibank credit card rewards card hsbc credit card balance transfer existing customers different types of credit cards and their features online credit card payment system singapore capital one balance transfer card best credit card compare india best pay advance loans how to get a credit card with no credit in canada lloyds tsb student credit card balance transfer best visa credit card 2013 credit cards for low income earners with bad credit payday loans with bad credit rating sears city bank credit card login instant payday advance no credit check how to get out of credit card debt suze orman tata sbi credit card online payment billdesk circuit city credit card chase login compare citibank and hdfc credit cards ann taylor loft credit card customer service compare american express credit cards india what does cashback on credit card mean canada post visa card fees chase visa card lost reduce credit card debt legally how do 0 apr credit cards work account number on visa debit card reclaim credit card charges capital one how to get a bad credit loan without a bank account how do i pay my halifax credit card online approved cash advance greenwood sc best reward credit cards usa short term online loan uk company credit cards canada top credit cards in canada 2011 no fax payday loans direct lenders credit cards that give you cashback on gas compare prepaid credit cards uk post office credit card login uk compare hdfc gold and titanium credit cards can you apply for a walmart credit card over the phone department store easy credit cards 24 hour payday loans online direct lenders credit card rates ireland compare credit card offers usa best visa credit cards 2012 how much to offer credit card settlement aqua credit card limit starting chase credit card history hdfc new credit card status
Home All Articles Why MLB Relocation/Expansion Won't Be Happening Soon

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 1319 guests online

Atom RSS

Why MLB Relocation/Expansion Won't Be Happening Soon PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 5
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Maury Brown   
Saturday, 17 November 2007 21:37

Biz of Baseball articleBud Selig likes to call this the real Golden Age of baseball. We can quibble about that. The postseason is no longer the event that captivates a nation. Note that this year’s World Series was watched by an average of 17,123,000 for the four games. Compare that to the ’78 World Series between the Dodgers and the Yankees which pulled in an average of 44,278,950 for six games. But paid attendance had a fourth consecutive record year (79,502,524), baseball is awash in revenues ($6.075 billion this year), and television ratings at the local and regional level saw ratings up for 21 of the 30 clubs from the year prior.

So, against this backdrop, it’s safe to say that America is back to having its love affair with MLB, and in a big way.

With that, is it any wonder that fans in cities across the US that currently don’t have an MLB team to call their own may want one? Is it any wonder that students enrolled in sports management classes in colleges across the country write papers on this topic?

Case in point, Sam Cohen, a senior at Oregon State University, writes:

For one of my classes I am writing a report about the feasibility of bringing a Major League Baseball team to Portland. 

It seems like the push to bring an MLB team to Portland has declined since the Expos landed in DC after the 2004 season.  I've been to the news links on both the  Portland Baseball Group and the Oregon Stadium Campaign websites, but it doesn't appear that anything has been written on the matter since 2005.  I was just wondering what the  status of the issue was, whether there was still an active campaign to bring a team to Portland, the likelihood of it actually happening, and if it were to happen what kind of timetable we would be looking at?

It should be noted that I was part of the Oregon Stadium Campaign from about 2001 to 2004, and added to Portland’s submission to MLB during the Expos relocation derby. Looking over the above, and where things are now, does the healthy state of MLB make relocation or expansion possible? The answers are, in some ways, astrological.

“When the moon, and the stars, and the planets, and the money are aligned.”

I didn’t coin this phrase. MLB COO Bob DuPuy gets that distinction, with both the Expos and the Marlins stadium efforts. It outlines the extreme difficulties that are involved when MLB wants to get a stadium built, and is looking for all - or the vast majority - of the funding to come from the municipality they are looking to have host the team. The political capital it takes to get stadium funding passed is exceptionally difficult, and even more so if there is a feeling that relocation or expansion is only being spoken of conceptually. It simply makes matters extraordinarily difficult for a city looking to land an MLB team.

For all intents and purposes, the relocation of the Montreal Expos was a situation that offered the best options, should relocation as a last option be offered up for a franchise. MLB owned the club, Montreal did not have the capacity to fund a new stadium, and there were no lucrative media deals associated with them. I bring up the latter, because the notion was lofted out that contraction, not relocation, would be the order of the day for the Expos, with Carl Pohlad offering up the Minnesota Twins as the AL answer to the Expos’ NL – a balancing of the league, as it were. While the Expos were an easier team to talking about contraction with, the notion of the Twins being involved was far from it.

In 2001, the Metropolitan Sports Facilities Commission, who runs the Metrodome, filed an injunction to keep the Twins in the Metrodome through at least 2002. Judge Harry Seymour Crump ordered the injunction (read the injunction here), and in 2002 the injunction was upheld on appeal. To add to this, FOX SportsNet Minnesota sued the Twins over breach of contract, as they had a television agreement that was not set to expire until 2003.

What these issues with the Twins outline is the difficulty in relocating teams, short of some condition similar to what the Expos had. It highlights that municipalities should not be looking at any team offering up relocation to their city as anything more than a leveraging ploy to get a stadium built in the market currently hosting them.

Even with everything pointing to relocation as nothing more than a red herring, some baseball boosters can’t help but try and buy into the concept.

Case in point, the Portland Baseball Group. Although MLB relocation is a far-off notion, and Portland Mayor Tom Potter is cold to any talk of funding, Steve Kanter, President of the Portland Baseball Group was quoted in the Oct. 26, 2007 edition of the Portland Business Journal as saying:

“We're quiet now because no one's moving immediately," he said. "But we remain convinced that someone will move. And I remain in close contact with the Marlins."

I, and a great many others that follow MLB from a business perspective, simply don’t see this occurring. “Someone may move,” but not any time soon.

I followed up this story with an Op/Ed in this week’s Portland Biz Journal (Expansion, not relocation is Portland’s ticket to MLB), part of which reads:

While matters could change, officials with Major League Baseball have placed the development of a new stadium for the Florida Marlins at the site where the aging Orange Bowl now sits as one of, if not the, top priority for the league.

MLB Commissioner Bud Selig has said that he wishes to keep the Marlins in the south Florida market, and believes that only the lack of a new retractable-roof stadium is preventing the franchise from garnering the revenue needed to be successful. This hardly seems like a team ready to relocate.

The same can be said of the current situation with the Tampa Bay Rays. While the team's current stadium, Tropicana Field, is a substandard domed facility for baseball, ownership has invested in capital improvements to make the "Trop" more attractive.

I go on to talk about MLB’s incredibly robust finances these days.

While I say that expansion, not relocation, is what Portland should be thinking of, it is not something that will be happening any time soon.

If you look closely at the last two expansions by MLB, they came at a time of the league being in a depressed state financially. Also, in late 1991, the players and the owners reached a settlement: the owners would surrender $280 million, with the money then distributed to affected players via a complicated (and often lengthy) process over the collusion rulings (see my essay from Rob Neyer’s Big Book of Baseball Blunders on Collusion I, II, and III).

Expansion fees helped off-set the payments on collusion. Those in the Commissioner’s Office would scoff at this (heck, they don’t even acknowledge that there was collusion in the ‘80s), but look how the commissioner of baseball at the time of the collusion rulings (Peter Ueberroth was at the helm when collusion occurred) addresses the issue when I posed the question to Fay Vincent, part of which reads (read the entire Biz of Baseball interview with Fay Vincent):

Q: There is the perception, real or otherwise, that expansion was done to offset the losses incurred over collusion in the ‘80s. What is your perception of that issue?”

Vincent: Well, I think it’s absolutely correct. Indeed, I don’t think there’s any doubt about it. Look, each owner had a $10 million bill and there were about 26 clubs before expansion and 30 at the moment, then $280 million, let’s say $10 million a club – they didn’t have the money. So they did what most would business do, they sold stock, they sold interest in the clubs, in the expansion clubs. In my day two of them - Miami and Denver. And that money, which was vital, paid off their collusion debt. Without it I think baseball would have had a very serious time.

[...] 

I remember one of the owners said, “That’s the single dumbest idea I’ve ever heard!” But what he was really saying is, “We need the money to pay off the union because we colluded.”

Flash forward to 2007, and there is no need for expansion fees. Sure, it wouldn’t hurt, but it hinders more than helps.

Short of northern New Jersey, any other location would be small to mid-market in size. That would most likely mean a taker of revenue sharing, not a payor (or at least not initially).

You also have to account for how a new team, or teams, impact television territories. As I wrote in Television Territories Impact Relocation/Expansion:

When I interviewed Mariners President Chuck Armstrong in Dec. of 2005, he was non-committal on one hand, but clearly the issue of Portland, and the surrounding area needed to create a broadcast territory for Portland, would be something of keen interest. "I really haven’t studied [the issue of relocation or expansion] to Portland", said Armstrong. "We have specifically stayed out of that issue. That’s up to the Commissioner’s Office and the Relocation Committee. I’m sure if that time comes, they would talk to us about it. No one here is on that committee and we’re not involved in that decision."

And all of the US is like this. No team would be impervious to a new, or relocated team anywhere in the US, as all of it is covered by one team or another (in some cases, as is the case with Las Vegas, multiple teams claim television territorial rights. Vegas deals with 5 teams: Angels, Dodgers, Athletics, Padres, and Giants).

For relocation or expansion to happen, teams impacted by the dilution of their television markets would look for compensation. The best example would be how Peter Angelos and the Baltimore Orioles were compensated by the Expos relocating to Washington, D.C. In an article in 2004 on how territorial alignment would prevent the A’s from moving into San Jose – something that did happen (Expos Relocation: No A’s to San Jose), I wrote:

The Orioles’ vast cable market would get sliced up like a Thanksgiving turkey with the addition of a Washington team. That’s the key factor. The Orioles won’t divulge what they currently net with Comcast, but USA Today estimates their total revenue from all local broadcast sources at $21 million for 2002.

To placate Angelos, baseball is reportedly negotiating the following (subject to change):

  • A guarantee that will keep Baltimore’s annual revenues no lower than $130 million. If they do drop below that threshold, MLB will make up the difference;
  • A minimum franchise value for the Orioles at around $360 million; and
  • A 60-percent equity in a proposed new regional sports network (RSN) to the Orioles while the Washington franchise would receive only 40 percent.

So, to the fans and students looking for answers on possible relocation or expansion, the answer is: don’t look for it anytime soon. Relocation seems more remote than expansion, but either way, nothing now seems to point to any cities clamoring for an MLB franchise to land one. The need isn't currently there (read, owners are making a healthy profit, which minimizes talk of expansion), and the political and legal difficulties make relocation even less appealing.

Just go back to DuPuy’s saying. The moon, and the stars, and the planets, and the money just aren’t aligned… right now.


Maury Brown

Maury Brown is the founder and president of the Business of Sports Network, which includes The Biz of Baseball, The Biz of Football and The Biz of Basketball (The Biz of Hockey will be launching shortly). He is also an author for Baseball Prospectus, Basketball Prospectus and is an available writer for other media outlets.

Brown's full bio is here. He looks forward to your comments via email and can be contacted here.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?