credit cards with balance transfer offers with 0 interest intuit ipad credit card reader how to confirm paypal account with credit card canada best credit card points prepaid travel bmo mastercard goodyear credit card sign in visa credit card payment online cash loans liverpool top 10 cash back credit cards canada same day cash advances online virgin barclays credit card login credit card purchase protection under ?100 apply online credit card citibank elavon credit card processing company cash advances on credit cards fees prepaid bank of america credit cards prepaid credit cards international use prepaid credit card credit builder uk american express black card travel insurance 3d secure credit card transactions visa credit cards instant approval paypal vs credit card merchant fees is it bad to apply for multiple credit cards bad credit credit cards instant approval uk barclaycard business credit cards online hdfc master credit card reward points western union gold card contact number capital one credit cards for business quick cash online loans student credit cards with bad credit or no credit credit suisse internship credit score check best credit card to build credit fast bad credit loan lenders no brokers best chase business credit card halo reach credit limit bypass bank of india credit card apply online in india how do i report a lost wells fargo credit card credit cards amscot cash advance extension aspire credit card customer service number bridgestone firestone credit card accepted credit card abroad fees canadian visa credit card application neiman marcus credit card payment list of credit cards used in uk should i pay off my student loans or invest alaska airlines visa? business credit card post office credit card balance transfer existing customers best travel credit card rewards 2012 bad credit loans uk list of subprime credit card issuers virgin credit cards customer service telephone number payday loans online direct lenders no credit checks credit card terminal rental cash rewards citi credit cards credit cards no interest until 2015 payday lenders only bad credit whats the cheapest way to accept credit cards best cashback credit cards usa chase online visa card bank of america world mastercard credit card with worldpoints rewards and paypass disney cruise reward credit card can i get a student credit card with no credit history kroger visa rewards card login citibank platinum credit card no annual fee best marriott rewards credit card offer pay target visa credit card online what is the best credit card to have with bad credit who has the best credit card rate best credit card consolidation 2012 fnb silver credit card interest rates prada credit card holder how can i apply for a paypal mastercard credit card visa number hacked 10 best credit cards for travel how to get a cash advance on your credit card icici instant credit cards interest free balance transfer credit card uk visa cash back cards canada aqua credit card payment protection credit debit card logos uk valid credit card information 2012 hdfc credit card customer care number pune uk credit cards with free travel insurance fake visa credit card number canada natwest business credit card rewards american express credit card customer service number uk apply for ge credit card online credit cards with no annual fees in india toys r us gold card offers monthly apr calculator credit card best credit card promotions in singapore application for credit card limit enhancement free credit check best credit card reward 2013 payday loan cash advance store royal bank of scotland student credit card easy unsecured credit card for bad credit update apple account credit card best credit cards for travel insurance wireless credit card machine costco top cash back credit cards uk td bank visa gift card balance axis bank credit card settlement letter citibank virtual credit card ipad credit card search by score payday loans on benefits direct lenders credit card applications online in india icici credit card online application cash back credit card comparison uk cash loans to your door no credit check td canada trust first class visa rewards does chase have credit cards for college students citibank banamex usa credit card pay as you go credit card apply for valero gas credit card hsbc value city credit card orchard bank credit card automated phone number credit card terminal vanilla visa prepaid debit cards credit card cash advance without pin number new debit visa card canada secured orchard bank credit card chase credit card lost vanquis credit card payment plan virtual prepaid credit card canada visa credit card approval code check status of bank of america credit card application moneysupermarket credit card search premier first credit card login air canada credit card offer typical credit card merchant fees 5 percent cash back credit card best buy credit card application by phone unsecured credit cards fair credit instant approval what is the highest credit card limit i can get air miles visa credit cards canada how to cancel capital one credit card in canada how to calculate credit card interest using excel discover card credit score tracker secured loan bad credit rating payday loans online direct lenders instant approval best credit cards with cash back offers no annual fee credit card offers distributed data mining in credit card fraud detection analysis ieee itunes please enter valid credit card information capital one credit card canada review paypal credit card payment php gold card balance easyjet no credit card fees can credit card companies sue you for debt credit card information security policy check my bank of america credit card application when will aib get visa debit cards chase credit cards customer service rbc visa low interest credit card paypal uk credit card reader best place to get a credit card uk travel credit card reviews usaa cash rewards credit card review how do credit card limits work black cardigan new look fastest cash advance lenders online city bank credit card statement best 0 credit card balance transfer union bank of india credit card application form download low interest credit card balance transfer life can international students apply for credit card in uk best cashback credit card malaysia 2012 bank of america cash reward credit cards black cardigan womens cheap the visa prepaid debit card with 1-2-3 rewards longest interest free credit cards on purchases halifax credit card address for payment virgin credit card bad credit rating td canada trust secured credit card application obama credit card debt relief act anz business visa debit card apply payday loan online no faxing citi credit cards usa halifax credit card ?5 cash back i want to apply for a maurices credit card rbs apply for credit card online no annual fee credit cards for no credit bad credit loans instant decision direct lenders hdfc platinum credit card reward points redemption google credit card comparison rbc low interest rate credit card best credit card processing companies for small business capital one credit card reviews 2010 iphone 4 cases with credit card holder company credit cards for bad credit rooms to go ge credit card payment standard chartered credit card bill payment online canadian tire options credit card interest rate lloyds platinum credit card ppi how do i apply for a bp gas credit card legit fast cash loans online typical m&s credit card limit horizon gold credit card customer service pre approved credit card offers opt out visa credit card bill payment online how to calculate credit card interest rate in excel city bank credit card apply india how to get a us credit card living in canada best cash back no fee credit card canada online application for bpi credit card barclays uae credit card loan united mileage credit card uk how to load paper in verifone credit card machine can you transfer credit card balance from one person to another bmo credit card air miles interest free credit cards compare the market gas rewards credit card reviews apply for capital one secured credit card credit card reward points axis bank chase visa virtual credit card can i claim back credit card insurance hsbc credit card online application status understanding credit and credit cards balance transfer credit card credit union new payday lenders online sbi railway credit card application form best prepaid credit card in canada credit card cash advance rate discovery vitality credit card benefits credit cards travel promotion is it good to consolidate credit cards credit card terminal apple 5 best credit cards for college students manhattan standard chartered credit card payment best credit card balance transfer offers australia discover credit card application phone number do all credit cards have rfid credit cards with no annual fee for students credit cards with no credit check needed how to apply for emi in hdfc credit card bad credit credit cards guaranteed approval canada walmart credit cards online account capital one credit card cashback bonus paying off credit card debt advice hdfc credit card points redemption form first premier credit card phone number cash advance fee capital one 0 percent interest credit card canada quickbooks online processing credit cards credit cards to rebuild your credit rating how do i get a credit card with no credit score swiss air miles and more credit card citibank credit cards pay online pay american airlines credit card apply for credit card with no credit no annual fee pre approved credit card opt out free reward cards uk alaska usa credit card how do credit cards work where can i get a bad credit credit card fake credit card information that works 2013 chase credit cards united visa icici credit card apply online in bangalore what is the best credit card to use in australia prepaid credit cards with overdraft anz platinum card review capital one credit card international atm iphone 5 credit card charger how to get cash from a walmart visa gift card chase business credit card phone number lowest interest credit card australia can i transfer credit card balance to someone else best cashback credit card canada us bank credit card processing charges how old do you have to be to get a prepaid credit card in canada hsbc credit card apply now citibank credit card application status check online india citifinancial credit card contact visa gift cards india credit card protection on purchases over ?100 best us airways credit card offer 2012 accepting credit card payments for small business canada list of payday loan lenders uk no credit check define apr for cash advances credit card payment gateway integration in java paypal credit card number generator best air miles credit card canada compare premium credit cards in india security credit card holder can you use a prepaid credit card on paypal where is the credit card verification code located best capital one student credit card how long between applying for chase credit cards credit card repayment calculator south africa wells fargo health advantage credit card payment 3d secure credit card validation citibank 0 interest credit card malaysia does canadian tire sell prepaid credit cards credit card compare nz list of all credit cards in usa create virtual visa card online first cash advance odessa tx citibank virtual credit card mobile ebay credit card payments paypal credit card with no credit credit limit increase barclaycard sbi platinum credit card credit limit hdfc credit card application status barclay credit card approval odds hsbc credit card minimum payment easy credit cards canada standard chartered credit card travel points is the disney visa card worth it old navy visa credit card interest rate do department store credit cards hurt your credit how does a credit card work yahoo answers credit card bank identification number bin average credit card apr rate everest cash advance reviews is chase credit card a visa or mastercard cash advance credit card credit score payday loans what is cash back credit card rewards prepaid reloadable visa cards canada credit card 0 interest balance transfers 12 months business credit card comparison 2011 prepaid visa cards international $5000 unsecured bad credit loan best credit card reward programme uk facts about credit and credit cards free credit score check uk no credit card best no fee credit cards canada 2011 tips for getting a secured credit card chase freedom visa credit card phone number visa credit card insurance on purchases toys r us gold card offers haven barclay credit card apply online best credit cards and why change apple id to no credit card key ring reward cards iphone how long after graduation to pay student loans pay chase credit card online land bank visa card rewards points unsecured credit card for someone with no credit credit card reward points value major credit card company list orchard bank credit card bill pay address compare credit cards and rewards apply for credit card with no credit instant approval chase credit card protection on purchases best business credit card offer 2013 500 unsecured credit card bad credit paypal credit card account login nissan visa cash card offer brought to you by edmunds com capital 1 credit card payment online no credit check payday loans uk rbc visa debit card canada what is a good apr percentage for a credit card visa debit card application online personal loans with bad credit online compare credit cards canada travel online payday lenders how much will a secured credit card help my credit pay online credit cards for bad credit with no checking account required next payday advance reviews visa credit card travel insurance australia intuit gopayment credit card terminal itunes credit score to apply for walmart credit card royal bank of canada credit card fees apply for a credit card online instant approval philippines prepaid debit visa card reloadable nab interest free credit card transfer platinum card lloyds tsb visa credit cards wiki all unsecured credit cards bad credit kotak credit card helpline number travel rewards cards for students what is a secured credit card capital one credit card student do i need a credit card to hire a car in the uk va home loan with bad credit visa debit gift card cash back delta airlines credit card deal staples business credit card account chase freedom credit card history us bank corporate credit card rewards hsbc credit card student apply online credit card processing chunky black cardigan credit card amortization calculator extra payment how to apply for a credit card if i have no credit sign up for free credit card online how to use stolen credit card numbers union 76 gas credit card orchard credit card login online m&t visa credit card with rewards can you use a credit card to buy a money order at the post office best cash rewards visa credit card credit card with no international service fee fee free credit cards australia barclay credit card online apply chevron texaco credit card login page do prepaid credit cards help rebuild credit what is the best credit card deal at the moment easiest credit card to get in canada with bad credit huge credit card fraud bust in new jersey prepaid credit cards for business bpi credit card online application requirements credit card application online philippines hsbc premier credit card benefits bank of america visa rewards cards uk payday loans with bad credit free fico score no credit card hdfc credit card address change online pay icici credit card bill online through debit card hdfc bank credit cards payment i need a credit card to build my credit do credit card gift cards work online brandsmart usa credit card login what are the best rewards credit cards in canada new business credit card machine business credit card 0 balance transfer credit card approval no credit check online sbi credit card registration online hdfc credit card offers what if you don;t want a credit card anymore mastercard credit cards for no credit history rbs credit card offers for existing customers easiest unsecured credit card to get in canada best gas rewards credit cards 2013 iphone itunes credit card fraud how to pay off us bank credit card hsbc credit card points expire small business credit card offers no personal guarantee reward credit card review canada low limit credit cards for bad credit australia credit cards travel rewards comparison online payday loans no credit check no fax td visa student credit cards pay standard chartered credit card bill online gnc gold card free top credit cards usa do i need a credit card for google play prepaid credit cards canada paypal standard chartered credit card bank statement hdfc credit card customer care toll free number cash advance loans close credit card account credit score discover credit card usa easiest store credit cards to get 2012 credit card online validator v2.11 average credit card limit 2013 no foreign transaction fee credit card citibank american express credit card approval process buy prepaid virtual credit cards travel credit cards canada 2013 no fee transfer balance credit cards how to settle credit card debt with a collection agency amazon credit card payment unsecured loan bad credit instant decision hdfc credit cards rewards point catalogue credit cards deals can you buy prepaid credit cards at walgreens interest rates on car loans with bad credit rating mba credit card canada everyday rewards credit card woolworths citibank premier credit card login quick and easy payday loans bad credit gas cards for not so good credit can you apply for best buy credit card in store how to use hdfc credit card rewards points best cash rewards credit card 2013 best prepaid credit cards australia bank of america secured credit card fees black leather credit card holder best travel rewards cards 2012 how to make standard chartered credit card online payment credit card processing software jp morgan chase credit card settlement navy federal credit union credit cards review what is credit card issue number business credit cards with cash back pay advance form template chase credit card rewards comparison credit card deals 0 balance transfers mastercard credit card foreign exchange rates hdfc bank toll free customer care number credit cards orchard bank credit card bad credit best credit card interest rates australia credit cards for those with very bad credit disney credit card chase bank application for credit card reissue chase credit cards for business one time credit card authorization form template best credit card transfer rates australia credit card debt relief act 2012 what credit card can i apply for without a job lowest apr credit card 2013 mobile credit card processing iphone free credit card terminal iphone best canadian travel visa credit card
Home Ballpark Facility News Cost of New Yankee Stadium Rises Sharply

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 889 guests online

Atom RSS

Cost of New Yankee Stadium Rises Sharply PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 19
Written by Maury Brown   
Friday, 20 July 2007 01:06
New Yankee Stadium

Taxpayer subsidies for New Yankee Stadium have risen $217 million more than first anticipated, according to a report issued by Good Jobs New York, a nonpartisan group.

With the increase, the total cost to the public is now $617 million. That figure is the amount of tax subsidy in today’s dollars, but will increase over time with inflation. As reported by Reuters:

Some $69 million of this rise stems from a decision by the city's Independent Budget Office to hike its estimate of how much tax revenue the city, state and federal government lost by letting the Yankees sell tax-free stadium bonds. The IBO said it took this step after the civic group questioned its figure.

The latest estimate also includes almost $90 million of city and state funds for a new Metro-North station for the stadium. Good Jobs New York applauded this expenditure because it will encourage mass transit.

The report cites former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani and Mayor Michael Bloomberg for the increase in costs. In the case of Giuliani, his firm, Giuliani Security and Safety, was hired as the stadium security consultant court papers show. He also approved a $21 million reduction in rent that the Yankees will have to pay.

"Public faith in government is eroded when private corporations hire former government officials and use their expertise and influence to evade participatory planning and established economic development principles," Good Jobs New York’s report said.

(See high-resolution renderings of the New Yankee Stadium design)

Select Read More to see the Executive Summary by Good Jobs New York, as well as a link to their report 

Executive Summary

To seize public parklands, win rapid permitting, and land massive taxpayer subsidies for their new stadium in the South Bronx, the New York Yankees hired numerous former public officials and benefited from the actions of a few current elected officials to play insider baseball, shutting out Bronx residents and New York City taxpayers. 

In a secretive, undemocratic process that climaxed in a lightning series of events in June 2005, these past and present officials helped the Yankees seize 22 acres of heavily used public parks and win development subsidies exceeding half a billion dollars.  City municipal records, lobbying declarations, legal documents, project plans and corporate filings reveal that the heavy hitters include:

  • Former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, who approved millions of dollars in subsidies to the team including a $21 million rent reduction and whose firm, Giuliani Security and Safety, is listed in court documents as a security consultant for the stadium;
  • Randy Levine, former Commissioner of the Office of Labor Relations and then Deputy Mayor for Economic Development under Mayor Giuliani, and now President of the Yankee organization;
  • Roberto Ramirez, former Bronx Assembly Member and Bronx County Democratic Chair and now of the Mirram Group, who reported lobbying his former colleagues on behalf of the Yankees;
  • Stanley Schlein, a Bronx political operative since the Koch Administration, and an attorney for the Bronx Democratic Party who worked for Assembly Member Rivera while also chairing the civil service commission until Mayor Bloomberg refused to reappoint him after public concerns were raised about his conduct as a judicial appointee.

Numerous other former public servants and officials – once responsible for protecting the public treasury – now work at firms whose priority is the Yankees’ pocketbook. For example:

  • Joseph Seymour, former executive director of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey and now senior vice president at the Community Initiatives Development Corporation (conduit for the garage financing);
  • Bruce Serchuk, a partner at the firm Nixon Peabody (a firm listed in public documents as being retained as bond counsel for both the Yankees and the New York City Industrial Development Agency) and a former senior technical reviewer at the Internal Revenue Service;
  • Howard Safir, Giuliani’s former police commissioner, now of the firm SafirRosetti, is listed in court documents as a security consultant for the project; and
  • Frank Chaney and Melanie Meyers, former officials at the New York City Department of City Planning, now work for the firm Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson which was paid to lobby the Planning Commission and other agencies on behalf of the Yankees.

Together with others, revolving-door players helped the most valuable sports franchise in America score over half a billion dollars in subsidies. With no public hearings and hurried votes in both Albany and New York City, they also ensured the Yankees could abruptly seize 22 acres of Macombs Dam Park and parts of Mullaly Park, popular recreation places in the poorest Congressional district in the United States and one of New York’s highest asthma-rate neighborhoods.

The new Yankee stadium project undermined democratic planning principles and benefited the Yankee’s profit margin over the employment, recreational and public health needs of the community. Despite the opposition of the local community board and a “no” vote from the City Council member representing the neighborhood around the stadium, the project was rammed through so hurriedly that community members were only allowed to weigh in after major decisions had been made.

Providing subsidies for this project, particularly the massive parking garages that have already received $70 million of state funds, dealt a grave blow to the community’s quality of life.  The tree lined Macombs Dam and Mullaly Parks were heavily used by local residents and children from 20 schools. Today, the construction of the stadium is well underway and the former parks are occupied by cranes and bulldozers. Public officials promised interim parks (temporary open space while the replacement parks are constructed) would be opened shortly after construction began in August 2006 but they became a reality only recently.

The deal grossly violates the Bloomberg Administration’s commendable proposals for sustainable development and reduced greenhouse gas emissions as outlined in PlaNYC2030. By destroying open space and subsidizing fans to attend games by automobile (while ignoring a nearby transit station), the new stadium and its huge new garages will increase traffic in a community already plagued by auto-induced asthma.

Taxpayer subsidies for the project are still flowing: the City is offering to further subsidize thousands of stadium parking spaces on the former park lands by allocating $190 million in civic facility bonds. The IDA has held a public hearing on the garage financing but has yet to vote on the project.

Our findings do not suggest any illegal behavior or conflicts of interest.  But they do reveal a large, costly redevelopment project that was rushed through the public approval process without meaningful participation from the community or clearly defined benefits to residents and taxpayers. Public faith in government is eroded when private corporations hire former government officials and use their expertise and influence to evade participatory planning and established economic development principles

To guarantee there’s no replay of the Yankee Stadium fiasco, Good Jobs New York offers policy options to protect residents’ rights.

Honor Land Use Policies and the Community Boards

New York City has a strong democratic planning process on the books (called the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure or ULURP). It should be embraced, not gamed.

Major decisions on this project (the seizure of the park land, the types of public subsidies offered for example) were privately agreed to by the Yankees and public officials in the project’s Memorandum of Understanding (MOU)--a copy is available at Agreements should not be negotiated without the consultation of the local community board and until details of proposals are made available and mandated public hearings are held.

Disclose the Revolving Door

Just as elected officials must reveal the companies or partnerships from which they receive income in financial disclosure statements, developers seeking land use approvals or development subsidies should be required to disclose in applications the names of all former government officials involved in the project (either as direct employees or as consultants or lobbyists), including their public and private positions and dates of public service.

Extend the Cooling-Off Period

To reduce the revolving-door influence problem, the City should extend to three years the time period which former elected officials and agency personnel must wait after leaving office before they can work as lobbyists or with firms involved directly on projects involving their public-sector jobs. Currently, the City’s conflict of interest law has loopholes permitting public officials to immediately go to work at firms that do business with the city. 

Scratch the Parking Garages

City and state officials should act on their stated city-wide commitment to fund public transportation as an alternative to driving. Recently officials pledged funds to build a Metro North train station near the Yankee stadium. With an estimated 10,000 fans per game choosing Metro North to get to games, the number of proposed parking spaces can be substantially cut back and park land restored.

PDF Full Report by Good Jobs New York (PDF)



Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?