Home All Articles Baseball Economics Roundtable - May 2007

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 2205 guests online

Atom RSS

Baseball Economics Roundtable - May 2007 PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 11
PoorBest 
Articles & Opinion
Written by Various Authors   
Wednesday, 02 May 2007 17:00

A Biz of Baseball ExclusiveBaseball is awash with revenues these days. From lucrative television deals at the national and local level, to MLBAM's steady stream of money, to satellite radio deals, naming rights, and new or redeveloped stadiums going online, owners are bathing in the green stuff.

With that, however, are the questions about where the money is flowing, and how to place value on the revenues that are coming in.

The Biz of Baseball decided it would be good early on in the 2007 MLB season to have a roundtable discussion with some of those that follow baseball economics closely. To that end, we've assembled the following panel:

 We'll be talking five different topics:

  • The latest CBA
  • How regional sports networks impact MLB's economic landscape
  • The value of marquee players and the value of club brand
  • Comments on whether MLB should implement a player payroll floor
  • The panelist picks a topic of their liking

Select Read More to read the Baseball Economics Roundtable for 2007


The current CBA works to address some inadequacies with the prior agreement as it pertains to revenue sharing. What are your thoughts on the agreement?

Zimbalist: The new CBA has some strong points and some weak points. If I had my druthers, the fixed component of revenue sharing would be the basis for all sharing, instead of just over a third. It would also be based upon a more objective standard of a team’s potential revenue, not its recent and projected revenue experience. Among other things, the present system still penalizes a team for past success and the larger variable component, although at lower and more uniform rates, penalizes a team for future success. Further, as it stands now, a top-half team’s revenue sharing obligation can go up because the revenue of other top-half teams rises. There are lots of other issues, but, in short, I see the present CBA as an improvement on the previous ones, though it is far from perfect.

Baseball Prospectus Annual Brown: Given the political realities of how the agreement came together, it's a step in the right direction, especially in terms of lowering the marginal tax rate to 31 percent. It's still difficult to grasp that large markets such as Philadelphia or Washington, DC can pull in revenue-sharing, but as I said, tying market size to the system seemed to be an area that was just politically too difficult to reach during collective bargaining.

The addition of a fixed rate component is certainly an interesting and positive step forward and will be interesting to analyze over the life of the agreement. The system also was adjusted to deal with some of the cliff issues within the prior agreement, which created scenarios in which a club that was just above the median after revenue-sharing could actually wind up with less net revenue than a club that was just below the median. There are certainly inadequacies within in it, however. Those at the top of the revenue making scale can be impacted in terms of their percentage of their obligation based on how the revenues of the other high-revenue making clubs grow. It's not perfect, but it's a step in the right direction over the prior agreement (I get into the current CBA in greater detail in the 2007 Baseball Prospectus Annual). Given that MLB is pulling in record revenues, it seems that labor peace won the day over any haggling that might have occurred in the trenches over revenue-sharing. Things certainly might have played out differently if the economics of MLB were in a more depressed state.

Gennaro: From the reports I’ve seen, it appears to be a step in the right direction. The reduction in the marginal tax rate means that there is more of an incentive for teams to invest in revenue growth. However, I’m an advocate of determining revenue sharing payees/payors based on revenue opportunity, rather than actual revenues. Using actual revenues commingles the important structural factors that determine a team’s revenue opportunity (market size, corporate base, etc.) with management capability and results. I think revenue sharing considerations should exclude the latter. Also, I would like to see future revenue sharing provisions include a “bonus payment” for a team’s on-field performance. For example, let’s say the Pirates were to receive $20 million, based on the revenue sharing formula, I would also like to see them be eligible for a bonus of say, $1.5 million for every win they achieve over some minimum (e.g., 80 wins) and capped at some maximum level of wins (e.g., 90 wins). The benefit of this approach is that it would also raise the Pirates’ marginal revenue from winning, providing them with a greater incentive to invest in winning, through the free agent market, or investments in player development, etc.

Silver: Needless to say, I was shocked that a deal got done so quickly, so quietly, and so professionally. My guess—and I’ve heard just a little bit of gossip to support this—is that each side was worried that the other was going to play hardball. The owners were worried that the players felt like they’d lost the last round of negotiations, and that they’d point to all the money the game was making and demand a larger share of the pie. The players were worried that the owners would cite the NHL as a precedent, and that they held the performance-enhancing drugs scandal against the players as a sort of lever in case the negotiations went into the court of public opinion.

And so perhaps each side was very pleasantly surprised when they found out that the other side was going to be reasonable. Of course, there are other things that helped motivate the quick settlement. I think both sides learned from 1994 and 2002 that doing your negotiating the media is pretty much a lose-lose scenario. I think the damage from collusion has finally scabbed over (though not healed up completely). And you have some fresh blood on each side, with people like Fehr probably being involved in the negotiations more by proxy.

In any event, the fact that they were able to broker a deal with a minimum of collateral damage is remarkable, and speaks to some of the ways in which the game has matured. At the same time, I wonder if they didn’t roll the clock too far back in terms of revenue sharing, as the orgy of free agent spending this winter would seem to attest.

Noll: The new agreement cures a huge perversity in the revenue-sharing system that was created by the old CBA. Under the old agreement, teams in low-revenue markets were rewarded financially for making their teams weaker. The new agreement eliminated these anomalies, but in doing so it introduced a great deal of complexity. Financially complex rules typically create unintended loopholes as well as the potential for disagreement about their interpretation. Most likely, the next CBA will have a simpler formula.

Fort: Let’s do the big picture first. Since both players and owners share the goal of maximizing league profits, the CBA is really about dividing up the economic outcome in MLB. Since, in my opinion, really nothing changed between the owners and players in the new CBA, they apparently think life is good, economically speaking.

On the specifics of revenue sharing, the only change I see is that the sharing rate is reduced to 31%. The same target transfer of around $326 million will be funded come out of revenue growth at a lower tax rate. But transferring the same amount of money by lowering tax rates means more money is kept by each team as revenues grow. And as long as revenues grow disproportionately, this is a blow to any move toward maintaining the current level of competitive balance and surely cannot increase competitive balance.

But then nobody ever puts forth a reasoned criterion for judging competitive balance in the first place. So there never are discussions of just what the level of balance needs to be, either during the regular season or during the playoffs. All we hear from the league is that “balance is better” by whatever their chosen measurement happens to be at the time. And all we hear from critics is that there should be more balance. But the alteration in revenue sharing in the current agreement speaks volumes on what the players and owners think about competitive balance relative to what we hear from fan advocates in the press.

Bradbury: There are some provisions designed to reduce the disincentive for winning created by revenue sharing. By cutting the percentage of local revenues shared, small-market teams get to keep more of their own local revenue and can expect fewer handouts.

Supposedly, the CBA includes closer scrutiny of what revenue-sharing recipients can do with the money. I’ve yet to hear exactly what new mechanism is in place. I’m not sure how well MLB can police what these teams choose to do, but I do know that there is some discord among the owners regarding this issue. I think social pressure among owners and changing the tax rates are bigger factors.

Another change in the CBA that will also help weaker franchises is awarding teams compensation picks when drafted players do not sign. The reverse-order draft is supposed to give losing teams a leg up. Because drafted players could previously choose to go to college or to re-enter the draft the following year, draftees had tremendous bargaining power. Clubs do not want to waste a high first-round pick on a player they cannot sign, so small-budget teams had been going after lesser players who are easier to sign. Now, a team that fails to sign its first-round pick is compensated with a similar pick in the following year’s draft. This shifts some bargaining power to teams, with draftees knowing that teams will have a comparable pick in the following draft.

Overall, I am just happy the agreement was reached without a work-stoppage. The owners and players know the stakes involved, so I’m not much bothered by what they come up with.


How do regional sports networks (RSNs) impact MLB’s economic landscape now, and how will they in the future?

Diamond Dollars Gennaro: Team-owned RSNs are dramatically changing the economics of the game, beginning with raising the financial stakes of winning or losing for an MLB team. Unlike a traditional fixed rights fee arrangement with a Fox-Sports type affiliate, by having a stake in a RSN, a team re-connects its broadcast revenues to its on-field performance. Beyond the revenue implications, the RSN is an asset whose value rises and falls, in part, based on the team’s on-field results. In five years, the Yankees have created an asset—the YES Network—valued at nearly $2 billion today. The network is an important part of their economic equation and figures prominently in their willingness to aggressively spend payroll dollars in an effort to win. Besides the direct financial implications, RSNs are a team marketer’s dream as they provide a unique vehicle to build the team brand through team-related programming. It’s also no coincidence that the highest revenue teams are typically the ones with RSNs, as the broadcast rights for these teams are an asset substantial enough to form the basis of a stand alone network.

Noll: RSNs have been around a long time, and local baseball on over-the-air TV has been an endangered species since pay-TV penetration passed 50 percent almost three decades ago. An interesting issue is the effect of pay-TV RSNs (e.g., Fox Sports Network) on revenue disparities between big and small markets. My expectation is that, taking into account revenue sharing, the ratio of net revenues of the wealthiest and poorest teams has diminished, thereby making teams in smaller markets more viable financially.

The most interesting issue surrounding RSNs is the legality of the bundles of RSN telecasts that leagues are putting together as out-of-market national packages. This practice is legally tenuous. Some courts already have concluded that the antitrust exemption for pooling television rights into league packages does not apply to pay-TV, and Congress has held hearings on their legitimacy. If these packages are made illegal, teams will be allowed to sell national pay-TV rights for their games. The likely effect would be to give fans access to many more games, to increase competition in televised sports, to increase disparities among teams in broadcast income, and to reduce total broadcast income for the sport as a whole.

Silver: Any team that doesn’t have its own RSN is leaving money on the table. It’s simply a more efficient way to mine the profits of your broadcasting rights. Undoubtedly, there are a few inefficiencies in play for the time being, since some teams have RSNs while others do not. But I suspect that within a decade, we’ll be talking about 27 or 28 teams having RSNs, and it will become something that’s as standard a practice as building luxury boxes or investing in your farm system.

Zimbalist: Since the late 1980s RSNs have been a powerful force boosting team revenues, particularly those in the larger markets. When the team owners also own the RSNs, it can be a source of an extraordinary revenue advantage.

Bradbury: As much as MLB would like to have a national viewing audience like the NFL, baseball fans want to watch their local teams. MLB has been quick to allow these loyal fans to see their favorite teams play with Extra Innings and via the internet.

There was a lot of dialogue about the potential exclusive arrangement with DirecTV, but MLB won as the cable companies gave in to MLB’s demands. This should tell you something about the value of the local broadcast rights. MLB played hardball, because it knew what its product is worth.

Regional Sports Networks are profitable; there is no doubt about it. As Ted Turner learned, the more people you give a taste of the game, the more they’ll consume it. It’s a lesson that baseball learned with radio as well. By giving fans with geographic ties more opportunities to watch, the fan base grows. Oh yeah, and more importantly the RSN generates quite a bit of revenue on its own. Very nice!

Brown: RSNs are creating more disparity in terms of local revenues between the clubs, and given the ease with which clubs might be sheltering those revenues from the revenue-sharing system, they play a large part in creating the haves and have-nots. Not every owner is going to be in a position to acquire an RSN due to limited content or saturation of content by an existing RSN in a given market. Plainly put, there are only a limited number of YES Networks and NESNs to go around.

Beyond that, they create issues in terms of what is now deemed a "local" territory by way of television household reach, and the ability to tap into what is deemed local through the likes of the Extra Innings deal recently reached. Another good example of how RSNs impact MLB in the overall is how Peter Angelos leveraged television reach by way of the Orioles broadcast area during the Expos relocation to Washington, DC. Through that, he was able to gain a foothold into an even larger regional area via the creation of MASN.

Going forward, RSNs are going to become more of an issue as the revenues for YES and NESN continue to escalate, and those on the outside of the RSN bubble clamor for more shared revenues.

Fort: Two things about Regional Sports Networks seem important to me. First, RSNs generate local revenue rather than national revenue and inequality in the growth of local TV revenue is the major source of the imbalance in potential revenues across teams. Second, the level of competitiveness among RSNs determines the price and quantity of games seen by fans.

So, on the first count, RSNs impact MLB’s economic landscape on the competitive balance dimension. But that’s handled through the local part of revenue sharing just discussed. So, really, on this count, the impact of RSNs on MLB’s economic landscape is up to the owners and players through collective bargaining. And as long as both parties to collective bargaining have the same goal of maximizing league profit, then RSNs will be managed to do so. Indeed, we see precisely how that plays out in the new CBA revenue sharing rates. 

On the second count, technology is such that the idea of an RSN as a geographic organization is just plain wrong. It doesn’t matter where the RSN is located, what matters is its level of competition. And right now that appears to be nil. This suggests fans are paying close to their maximum willingness to pay for the games they do receive. And price discrimination through repackaging for special package offerings on cable and satellite make it clear that the market power of RSNs is being exercised. Of course, MLB is not oblivious to this and is making its own package deals available as well. The upshot seems to me, though, that fans will pay just about the most they are willing to pay, rather than a competitively determined return over and above the actual costs of providing TV games.


In an interview with the Biz of Baseball, David Samson addressed how marquee players and brand can impact the bottom line. At the time, we asked Samson about retaining talent on a limited budget, specifically in retaining Dontrelle Willis.

Samson said, “We’re going to go out there and compete, and we went people to know that they should be cheering for the front of the jersey. And now’s an important time for people to support the Marlins, because without season ticket support or attendance, it’s hard to convince politicians that it really matters.”

The quote begs the question: What is the value of marquee players, the value of team brand and how do each of these impact the bottom line?

Noll: Only owners and league officials believe that people pay to see the jersey instead of the players. Field some great players, draw 3+ million; field a de facto minor league team, draw 700,000. The contribution of marquee players to revenues in the sport continues to grow, although the post-strike revenue-sharing rules have slowed salary growth among the best players.

The Baseball Economist Bradbury: It is hard to convince politicians to dole out welfare to sports franchises. There is no economic justification for a public subsidy to professional sports teams. But even on philosophical grounds, I cannot support taxing citizens to do this. David Sampson runs a good franchise. I wish he would concentrate on marketing the phenomenal product his organization has put on the field, rather than use it as a weapon.

Where are the Marlins going to move? They are in a top-10 MSA that is growing. San Antonio just laughed when Jeffrey Loria threatened to move the team there. Unless the Marlins can convince some city to give them a sweetheart deal—something I don’t see happening— the Marlins threat to move is not credible. If he pulls this off, he should start demanding that supermodels pay for the privilege of sleeping with him.

I don’t think the Marlins fans are too concerned about marquee players. Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis are two of the best players in the game. They have an exciting group of young players who have the potential become All-Stars. As a baseball fan, I think the Marlins have one of the most likable line-ups in the league. One thing we know is that fans want to see a winner, and even the Marlins fans have responded to winning. I think it’s one of the reasons the Marlins have put a lot of effort into putting a good team on the field on a tiny budget.

The main reason that fans have turned against the Marlins is the behavior of the owner. Look at the experience of the Charlotte Hornets in the NBA. The Hornets sold out their arena for a decade—North Carolina is basketball crazy. When owner George Shinn demanded a new facility and threatened to leave, fans stopped supporting the team. When you tell your fans love me or else, they’ll abandon you in a hurry.

Gennaro: I’ve done enough work in this area within baseball—consumer research, focus groups, etc.—to be convinced that each MLB team is a unique brand, with its own “equities”, that have been shaped by many factors, including the team’s on-field performance, their ballpark, fans perceptions of ownership, and the way fans relate to the players. A strong team brand goes hand-in-hand with high fan loyalty and is a strong financial asset, which can cushion attendance declines when the team is playing poorly and offers some extra pricing power when the team is performing well. The amount of focus teams place on “building the brand” often depends on a trade-off between marketing spending to shape the image of the team in the mind of its fans, versus spending dollars on promos to put fans in seats. On the topic of marquee players, there is strong evidence that a team’s high-profile fan favorites can “personalize” the team brand and deepen the emotional connection with its fans—a connection that endures long after the player has moved on.

Silver: I like the work that Vince did on marquee players. Intuitively, I thought his numbers passed the sniff test. Analytically, there wasn’t quite as much empirical backing as I might have liked, but this is something that’s nearly impossible to study empirically; the data set simply isn’t robust enough to account for the attendance effects of individual players. 

In any event, I suspect that Vince is right that the marquee player effect is relatively small, and confined to a relatively few number of players. And ultimately, I think the marquee player question is subsumed in the concept of brand. Brand, among other things, is about managing expectations. It’s about making a certain promise to your consumers and living up to that promise, and it’s when teams tend to break those promises that they get themselves in trouble. What the Seligs did in Milwaukee, for example – promising competitive payrolls in order to get Miller Park built and then reneging on that promise – was very damaging for a couple of years, and I suspect that Brewer attendance would not have recovered to the extent that it has if the Seligs hadn’t sold the club. I did a lot of consulting work in Milwaukee at about the time the Brewers hit rock bottom, and people took all of this very personally.

Anyway, I’m running in circles here, but I suspect that once you get beyond perhaps a dozen or so players – guys in the Derek Jeter, David Ortiz class – fans are less concerned about the name on the back of the uniform as they are having players who can catch, throw and hit. If the Cubs fail to re-sign Carlos Zambrano, that could be problematic for them, but only to the extent that they don’t sign someone of comparable worth to replace him -- if they lost Zambrano but brought in Roy Halladay, nobody would bat an eyelash. To that extent, team payrolls are perhaps a little bit sticky downward; fans may be quicker to punish you for selecting a lower point on the wins-revenue curve than they are to reward you for picking a higher one.

Fort: I read this quote as focusing on the politically determined part of an owner’s bottom line. Fan support impacts revenues directly at the gate, on attendance-related revenue like concessions and parking, on TV, and through merchandise purchases. But fan support also impacts the politically determined part of revenues, that is, subsides through venue construction and lease terms. To the extent that marquee players engender that support through better fortunes for the team, so be it. But Samson is quite correct that general brand name identification—we used to call that fan loyalty, by the way—is related to political support for the team as well. So, it seems to me that marquee players and brand identification are important to both the “business” side of revenues and the “political” side of revenues.

Zimbalist: Theoretically, team brand value is difference between the team's market value and the discounted present value of its future profits. A player's marquee value would be approached similarly, the difference between his salary and his estimated MRP.

Brown: Measuring the value of marquee players is an interesting study that may lend itself to those at the top of the “star player” scale, but across the league it becomes extremely difficult to quantify. Certainly both Nate and Vince have touched on this in Baseball Between the Numbers (Alex Rodriguez) and Diamond Dollars (Babe Ruth).

We can certainly place soft revenues around other players. The most notable player currently would most likely be Daisuke Matsuzaka, where sponsorship, ad revenues, and tourism dollars will impact, not only the Red Sox, but other clubs as well.

But, as mentioned, these are the exceptions. Past the biggest stars in MLB, it becomes more difficult to value a player’s name. If someone can tell me how much Wade Boggs made the Devil Rays in 1999 based on pure name recognition alone, we’d be getting somewhere.

As for placing a value of fan loyalty based on brand recognition, you get into a somewhat similar situation. In the case of clubs such as the Yankees, Red Sox, and Cubs, there is ample evidence that brand loyalty alone can provide steady revenues to buffer losing seasons. Certainly, the Cubs being able to hitch your wagon to the “Lovable Losers” mantra and milking revenues from it is something that doesn’t apply to say, the Royals—it becomes more difficult to measure the further away from the marquee clubs you get.

Much of brand loyalty comes from the history of a club, and therefore, those that have been in existence the longest will have the best chance of taking advantage of brand loyalty. Samson doesn’t have this ability given the short time the club has been in existence. The Yankees can leverage the memorable history of Joe DiMaggio or Mickey Mantle. As time marches on, these newer clubs will create (or hinder) their own brand loyalty based the history they create, and often times, the fan experience of the ballparks they play in.


The latest Forbes franchise valuations for MLB shows that the some of the highest profit making is coming from clubs that have some of the lowest player payrolls in MLB. Is a player payroll floor needed to fully address possible high levels of profit taking from those that also receive revenue-sharing?

Baseball and Billiions Zimbalist: With over $30 million per team coming from MLB’s central fund and some of the bottom teams receiving over $30 million in revenue sharing, a low payroll virtually guarantees teams on baseball’s welfare system a healthy profit. I favor a revenue sharing system that has the proper incentives, rather than one with administrative rules.

Bradbury: I think a salary floor is a bad idea. Yes, it limits the amount of revenue sharing an owner can keep, but paying players isn’t necessarily the best way to manage your franchise, especially for a low-revenue team. There are several clubs winning without spending much money on player salaries. From 2000-2005 the Twins, Marlins, White Sox, and Athletics spent, on average, 32 percent less than the league-average payroll and went to the playoffs ten times and won two World Series. These teams aren’t just sitting home collecting revenue sharing; they generate revenue by putting good teams on the field with low labor costs. The incentives for generating revenue through winning are high enough to limit the “welfare queen” strategy.

It is true that there is a positive relationship between market size and winning, but the disparity between the best and worst franchises is not pure product of financial determinism. Predicting player performance is difficult; therefore, attempting to buy a championship through free agency is expensive and risky. Some teams have exceptional scouting departments that give them an edge. The bigger story though, is that the reserve rules allow teams to pay players far below their actual worth during their first six years in the league. Why not put resources into relatively cheap management/scouting personnel and cast your lot with a huge pot of prospects? Some become stars while others wash out, but no matter what, they didn’t cost you much. Also, the difference between good and bad players is small, so that even teams that can’t hire the best can remain competitive.

The perennial losers like Kansas City and Milwaukee are in small markets, but they also have been horribly managed. Are they at a disadvantage? Yes, but it’s not as big as the small-market owners make it out to be. From 1995-2004, differences in market size explained only about 40 percent of the gap in wins between the Yankees and the Brewers.

Furthermore, the potential remedies for market-size disparities are worse than any of the solution—more revenue sharing (remember the “welfare queen” problem?). The financial disadvantage that some teams face is similar to the disadvantage the Rockies face playing in an extreme altitude. We don’t have 30 localities with identical demographic characteristics to host teams. The disparity exists, but we’ve seen that it’s not too big for teams to overcome. It is part of the game, and may even add some drama. I sure enjoyed watching the Marlins beat the Yankees in 2003. If some teams put as much effort into their development as they do belly-aching, they might have a few playoff appearances to show for it.

Silver: I recently did a piece at Baseball Prospectus that looked at the overall stock of talent within each organization, rating each club from 1 to 30 based on the amount of long-term talent that they’ve compiled. Three of the teams at the top of the list were the Twins, Indians, and Devil Rays, all of which have been accused at one point or another of “profit taking”.

The problem is not that the teams at the bottom are spending too little – it’s that the teams at the top are spending too much. Neil deMause, building on some work I’d done for Baseball Between the Numbers found that probably only 3-4 teams derived a larger marginal gain in revenues than they paid out in payroll, and the fact that there’s such a strong inverse correlation in the Forbes data between payroll and operating income would tend to confirm that. Baseball teams, especially those toward the top of the revenue heap, are remarkably bad at marginal economics. They have the luxury of being sloppy because they’re making too much money.

Gennaro: I’m uncomfortable with player payroll as the sole yardstick of whether a team is re-investing revenue sharing dollars. The teams with the lowest payroll are often the teams with the lowest revenue opportunity. These teams will ultimately fail or succeed based on the strength of their player development system, not their willingness to escalate payroll. Forcing payroll investment may create more Gil Meche-type signings. I would rather see some dual measure that includes investment in player development as an alternative investment option.

Brown: I’m uncomfortable with the way some clubs appear to be using revenue-sharing as welfare—and as I’ve written on this topic, some fans think that reason is good enough to implement a player payroll floor.

However, I don’t see the need for a player payroll floor.

With more clubs getting player contracts under control, the free agent pool has been thinning, and with that, we’ve seen the supply and demand of them increase. That has sent player salaries upward at rates that many low-to-mid level revenue making clubs cannot keep up with.

With the change, the ability to develop players from within becomes a higher priority, and with that, forcing investment of those revenues directly at the MLB player level is counterintuitive.

Clubs need to be able to invest in player development—be that scouting, academies outside the US, et al. While some clubs continue to take advantage of the revenue-sharing system, implementing a player payroll floor would have unintended consequences and further upset competitive balance.

Noll: The theory behind a floor on salary expenditures is that if a team is forced to spend money, it will bite the bullet and field a decent team. There are two major problems with this theory. One is that the only cause of weak teams is low salary budgets. Another cause is bad management. Forcing teams to spend more will cause poorly managed teams to overpay their players even more than they do now. In addition, teams can improve themselves by spending more on player development and evaluation, as exemplified by Minnesota and Oakland. Why should these teams be punished financially when they now can field above-average teams with below-average budgets? One should be very careful about implementing central planning in any sport because it inevitably reduces the efficiency of team management.

Sports Economics Fort: First, Forbes only guesses at profits using some data that can be roughly verified, team revenues, and some data that can’t be verified, team costs. But even if one takes the Forbes guesses at face value, it is also true that some of the highest profit making is coming from clubs that have some of the highest player payrolls. So I don’t see why there should be any conclusions at all drawn on the profit statements from Forbes.

The intent of the observation about the Forbes data seems to be that if smaller-revenue owners spent their net revenue sharing proceeds on talent, then profit margins would be smaller. And that somehow these margins are “too high” given the intent of revenue sharing. But there is no way to know this from the Forbes data, even if it is correct, since fans will pay more for higher quality even though payrolls went up.

But let’s talk directly about the rationale behind a payroll floor and not worry about the Forbes data. Enough people already think that smaller-owners are violating the intent of revenue sharing so let’s just take it as given.

In my opinion, there’s no need for a payroll floor in order to meet the league’s goals for two reasons. First, unless MLB’s choice of the equal 31% sharing rule has truly perverse impacts on the return to investing in talent, then all teams will put all of their revenue sharing proceeds back into team quality of their own accord. Second, even if this isn’t true, MLB could always choose to focus just on the competitive balance tax and remove any need for a payroll floor in the first place.

The issue of a payroll floor arises as follows. Revenue sharing is just a form of tax—all owners pay 31% of local revenues into the tax pot. Now, suppose MLB just burned the collected 31%. The equally proportionate take from all teams would have no impact at all on relative ability to spend on talent! The price of talent would fall but teams would hire roughly the same amount. So I would not expect competitive balance to change if tax receipts were taken out of owners’ operations considerations.

But the league has decided to redistribute these tax revenues in equal shares, but not equal amounts, back to all owners. Smaller-revenue owners thus get back more than they put in. Larger-revenue owners get back less than they put in. Now, the question becomes, “What do we expect owners to do with their revenue sharing proceeds?” And there are two possibilities.

Scenario 1: If the return on investment in baseball talent has fallen, not the price but the return, then owners will take their revenue sharing proceeds and spend it outside of baseball. But this would be just as true for larger-revenue owners as for smaller-revenue owners. And remember that this action would not change the level of competitive balance in baseball.

Scenario 2: If the return on investment in baseball talent has remained the same or increased, then owners will take their revenue sharing proceeds and put that money back into talent purchases. After all, baseball talent drew that spending before the tax and if the return hasn’t changed, or rises, the same would be true after the tax. Now, after-tax revenues are lower for larger-revenue owners than their pre-tax revenues and after-tax revenues are higher for smaller-revenue owners than their pre-tax revenues. So, the return on baseball talent leads to lower spending by higher-revenue owners and higher spending by smaller-revenue owners so that after-sharing competitive balance would be expected to improve.

So which is more likely, Scenario 1 or Scenario 2? If the latter, as I think should be the case since MLB wouldn’t choose a path that lowers the return to talent investment, then there is no need for a payroll floor. After-tax payrolls will see all net revenue sharing proceeds spent on all of the teams in MLB, larger- and smaller-revenue alike.

And here’s another reason for skepticism about the need for a floor. Without any other mechanisms, the competitive balance (luxury) tax currently operational in MLB, carefully chosen, can take care of both the over-investment in talent issue that might confront a league and the issue of obtaining the level of competitive balance that maximizes league profits. The competitive balance tax lowers the marginal value of talent to larger-revenue owners. They buy less talent and competition among players then reduces the price of talent. Smaller-revenue owners buy the talent that is released as the price of talent falls. And it all happens without any spending requirements at all. Indeed, MLB has taken luxury tax revenues completely out of the operations picture by spending it on “growing the game” here and abroad.

Thus, at least from the perspective of getting the league’s view of its profit-maximizing result, there is no need for any requirement of a payroll floor under revenue sharing because they could accomplish the same goals just with a luxury tax that doesn’t require any payroll floor either.

And in the off chance that some sort of unforeseen contingency might lead an owner to bleed a team, the Commissioner has explicit power to levy revenue sanctions. Admittedly, whether the incentive to do so is strong is questionable but, under the preceding logic, the need for such an exercise of power would be infrequent at most.

Thus, at least from the perspective of getting the league’s view of its profit-maximizing result, there is no need for any requirement of a payroll floor under revenue sharing because they could accomplish the same goals just with a luxury tax that doesn’t require any payroll floor either.

And in the off chance that some sort of unforeseen contingency might lead an owner to bleed a team, the Commissioner has explicit power to levy revenue sanctions.  Admittedly, whether the incentive to do so is strong is questionable but, under the preceding logic, the need for such an exercise of power would be infrequent at most.


Lastly, pick a topic that has yet to be covered that faces MLB or clubs from an economics perspective, and expand on it.

Brown:  I’m surprised at the emotional responses that relate to the decline of the number of African-Americans in MLB; none of which seem to take into account the economics of the situation. On one hand there are articles that claim MLB to be racist on some level, while some writers wish to claim the decline is a myth—both of which are incorrect.

With picks in the draft coming in the reverse order of finish in the standings, and large bonuses attached to high draft picks, the clubs that have lower revenues to work from often times wind up with these selections. With the lower revenues, the extra stress of scouting talent that will turn into a quality player becomes greater for these clubs than a club with more revenues to work from.

The ability to acquire quality international players outside of the draft process is economically more effective. Quality players can be procured less expensively, and with that we now see all MLB clubs with development academies in Dominican Republic, and a third of the clubs have academies in Venezuela.

While the racial diversity of MLB has grown, this unintended economic impact of the draft plays a large part in number of American born players coming into MLB, and with that, the level of African-Americans have declined to half of what it was ten years ago.

Gennaro: There is an interesting transformation taking place within MLB teams towards a more disciplined, analytical approach to making decisions. That’s not to say that an intuitive approach based on years of baseball experience doesn’t have value, but it’s a very different business than it was 20 years ago. Today, signing a free agent contract is often a $50+ million decision. Teams are faced with complex issues as diverse as where to invest scouting resources throughout the globe and how to deploy the internet to cultivate a relationship with fans, to mention just a few of the newer challenges. One impetus for the transformation is the sale of franchises, not just because new ownership brings new thinking, but also because the cost basis of these purchases are in a different league than a franchise that was bought even 10 years ago. With a $700 million cost for the Red Sox (including a stake in NESN), to an even potentially steeper price tag for the Cubs, new ownership groups need to find innovative ways to create financial value to justify their investment. Add to the higher cost basis a heavy load of debt service and it’s easy to see why teams are more inclined to take a more strategic approach to sourcing talent, take a global view of their brand, and are constantly seeking to develop related assets in which additional value can be created.

Noll: Baseball has not yet found an effective way to exploit business opportunities internationally.  The same can be said of other American pro sports, but baseball probably has the largest unrealized potential for international play.  In the immediate future, the greatest opportunity is for a genuine baseball World Cup among national teams, featuring mainly players from Major League Baseball.  But in a decade or so, rising incomes in Latin America and Asia could make “major leagues” (with some teams equivalent in quality to MLB) feasible there, in which case an international club championship, like the Champions League in European soccer, also would become attractive.  Does MLB have the entrepreneurial capability to take the lead on these issues?  Based on its feeble attempt at a baseball world championship in the spring of 2006, baseball seems in danger of missing these opportunities.

Baseball Between the Numbers Silver: I’ll be fascinated to see what MLB Advanced Media does in the area of mobile technology.  I was at a wedding recently where someone had rigged up a Slingbox to his Palm Piolt – we were all watching a football game during the reception.  Nobody wants to recreate the mistake of the ESPN Phone, but once the technology has advanced by another couple of years, and you’re able to transmit streaming video to mobile devices in a way that’s relatively cheap to everyone involved, it’s going to be a big hit with affluent consumers.

In fact, I almost wonder if the technology isn’t so good that it’s going to start to take away from the ballpark experience.  I’ve caught myself wondering a couple of times recently if I should go to a ballgame, when I can watch six or seven games at once using MLB Mosaic.  I’d rather watch a game in person than on TV, but if I can flip back and forth between a half-dozen games on TV, and track my favorite players and favorite teams in the meantime, that might be a different story.  Plus, the beer is a lot cheaper at 7-Eleven. 

Bradbury: Major League Baseball’s monopoly status is overblown. Fans and policy makers have little reason to be concerned about baseball’s market power. Sports leagues are unique markets that will almost always evolve to a single-seller. In the 1970s, economists began to take a closer look at competitive pressures and explored new models of monopoly.  What we have learned is that a little competitive pressure goes a long way, and I think the evidence is that MLB seems to be well-governed by market forces.

First, the antitrust exemption appears to be benign. MLB behaves no different than the other major sports leagues, which lack an exemption.  Second, early in its history MLB learned that trying to restrict quantity and raise prices, something that standard monopoly theory predicts, results in entry by competitors. Thus, MLB expands to provide the baseball fans want before competitive leagues spring up, and this is key to its existence.  And third, if MLB is a monopoly—it certainly has some market power—it is a price-discriminating monopolist, which harms society far less than a standard monopoly. If fans are willing to pay price for baseball that exceeds the cost of producing it, owners have every incentive to provide it.

Fort: Everything that confronts MLB and its member owners (clubs don’t do anything, owners do) has to do with profitability—how to get profits and how to grow them over time.  To me, the interesting problem confronting the league is its best response to the increase in substitutes available to fans.  MLB is following its tried and true approach of monopolizing the flow of value from talent in areas like the movement of games from over-the-air and cable to satellite.  It pursues the same approach to other media values through MLBAM, most notably recently the attempt to dictate terms in the fantasy baseball market.  These seem to represent an ever-increasing competitive challenge to all sports leagues.   Invariably, this type of competition seems to me to threaten their ability to make much of an abnormal return into the future.

(Andrew Zimbalist passed on this topic) 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?
 


credit score uk calculator fico credit scores chart my 3 credit scores how to get 3 credit reports check all 1 credit reports view credit report free no credit card national credit-reporting agencies uk free credit reports online instantly experian ii credit reports free trial my credit report free south africa all 3 reports in one credit scores order all 3 credit reports mail equifax how to raise your credit score 100 points credit reports for private companies experian credit report free annual credit report instant tenant credit reports background how do i get free credit reports online free credit reports for small businesses all 3 credit reports for free what are the 3 credit scores annual credit reports canada free credit reports from all 3 bureaus 5 free credit reports without credit card all three credit reports same 11 major credit reports free canadian business credit reports online all 3 credit scores free credit reports and scores once a year credit report uk gov tsp free credit monitoring free credit reports and scores with no credit card credit reporting service ratings credit report agencies for landlords best company credit reports check 5 free credit reports no credit card 3 credit reporting bureaus good credit scores loan free credit reports for experian equifax transunion credit scores matters review average credit scores by city difference between 11 major credit reports get credit report free no credit card improve your credit score how to raise your credit score in 30 days what is triple advantage credit monitoring best credit reports companies what are the 11 credit reports free annual credit report free credit report business credit report credit reporting agencies dispute contact information quick credit score boost us gov free credit reports free credit reports for businesses all credit reports same equifax free credit report free credit score free credit reports in canada safe free credit reports gov consumer credit scores range 2011 get credit report free ii credit reports in 1 4 free credit reports per year dispute credit report experian free credit reports us government they all three credit reports and scores free 3 major credit report agencies should i check all 3 credit reports and scores free reports without card uk credit check equifax consumer credit reports credit score check get credit report for someone else mortgages for low credit scores and bankruptcy three free credit reports per year 3 16 free credit reports free credit reports by law free credit card reports online credit score ratings range get 360 waves free credit reports credit score scale canada how to get credit report free in canada totally free reports online credit score 3 in 1 reports and scores credit monitoring how do i get my annual credit reports for free get 5 free credit reports reports and scores free 3 credit bureaus usaa credit monitoring service how to read consumer credit reports how to check all 3 credit reports all 3 credit reports fico scores bureaus credit score ratings chart 2012 credit score ratings chart free reports in canada credit score how to read equifax credit reports free annual credit report best place to get 3 credit reports myfico credit score what is debix credit monitoring get three free credit reports all reports and scores free 3 bureau credit free business credit reports online equifax when do credit card companies update credit reports free instant credit report online no credit card credit reports used employment applicants 2 free credit reports and scores annual credit report equifax 2 credit reports and scores one time fee 3 free annual credit reports how to get all credit reports true credit report contact number order 3 bureau credit reports tips for improving credit scores bills improve your credit score fast transunion credit score range credit scores free online free credit reports without credit cards see credit report free online 3 free credit reports per year 6 free credit reports annual credit monitoring analysis consumer credit reporting agency uk iii major credit reports agencies 3 bureau free reports credit scores credit reporting companies list credit scores explained uk credit report freeze texas bad credit scores range business credit reports scores how many free credit reports in georgia difference between consumer credit reports government site free annual credit reports free reports us credit score business credit reporting how to raise your credit score overnight check all 6 credit reports 11 credit reports and scores free credit scores free check credit report government free credit reports in canada.ca review free credit reports by lawyers totally free credit reports online agencies view all 3 credit reports free experian credit report experian uk business credit reports best credit reports websites ii free credit reports yearly transunion credit score 990 quick credit score review transunion credit score ratings all 3 major credit reports statutory credit report my 3 free credit reports card credit reporting bureaus canada check credit report free once credit reporting bureaus contact free credit reports in canada review all 3 reports and scores free get credit check credit report gov what is a good credit score number get 3 free credit reports bureaus all iii free credit reports and scores order all 3 credit reports scores experian how do i order all 3 reports for free credit scores how many free credit reports per year in georgia dispute credit report information credit reporting bureaus- identity theft free credit reports for landlords tenant screening consumer credit reporting 3 reports scores monthly credit monitoring direct to consumer credit reports credit reports 3 day free trial equifax vs. experian credit scores best credit reporting agency get credit report from all three bureaus block credit report access understanding credit scores work how to read experian credit reports sample transunion credit score totally free credit reports score how to read experian credit reports codes what is a good credit score equifax experian credit scores and what they mean canadian company credit reports equifax credit reports for businesses 3 free credit reports each year best free credit report company 1 free credit reports yearly experian credit score explained check my credit score without a credit card free credit reports without credit card info fees canadian credit score chart experian credit report free state credit report access reviews how to get a free credit score 3 free credit reports phone number get 1 free credit reports credit monitoring arrangement free credit report no credit card required uk experian credit reports free credit reports us act what is the best credit monitoring service check all 3 reports free credit check all 3 credit reports daily free credit reports without credit card needed credit reporting agency canada how to get free reports in canada credit score free credit reports without credit card 5 free credit reports annual my credit report free online my credit report free yearly annual credit report free credit report free annual credit report annual credit report.co.uk review 3 credit reports free credit report credit reporting agency limited how to read credit bureau reports credit score scale guide credit score chart uk check all 11 credit reports for free 3 free credit reports a years eve how doo i get free credit reports online 4 credit reports scores monthly 8 free credit reports each year annual credit report uk review credit score calculator south africa all 3 free credit reports online credit score scale good to bad all 3 credit scores free rels credit reporting service free credit monitoring trial three free credit reports no credit card free credit monitoring for military 3 in 1 credit reports and scores company credit reports online experian credit reports for businesses 3 bureau free reports credit monitoring free credit reports instantly review monitoring experian credit reports login free credit reports instantly without credit card view all 3 credit reports and score transunion free credit reports without using credit card fees transunion credit reporting credit reports money saving expert credit score matters cancellation what is a good credit score range how to raise your credit score 40 points experian credit monitoring reviews free trial 3 in 1 credit reports equifax complete credit reports for landlords review applicant what is a good credit score for a mortgage how many free credit reports per year in georgia also entitled dispute credit report free ii free credit reports annual all reports and scores 3 bureau credit best way to get all 3 credit reports debt citi credit monitoring services equifax credit reports address free credit reports government site ftc free credit reports no credit card best way check all 4 credit reports credit scores explained order all 3 credit reports free credit score calculator for car loans get credit report by post annual credit report free experian national credit report free trial meaning of credit scores range are all credit reports done by the federal government prepaid credit card that reports to credit bureau free annual credit reports from all three bureaus order all 3 credit reports scores best site get all three credit reports free credit reports without credit card info consent usaa credit check monitoring promo code free reports in canada ca review credit score best 3 credit reports scores bureaus credit score free fico credit scores same credit score matters contact number free credit report free online credit report credit report experian free 3 credit scores no membership how to raise your credit score quickly equifax free credit report company credit reports china experian credit report dispute statutory credit report money saving expert access free credit reports online authorized free credit monitoring free credit score all 3 reports yearly free credit report a.m. best credit reports check all iii credit reports for free good credit scores canada 3 major credit reports order transunion credit report 3 major credit reports free experian check all 2 credit reports free credit monitoring countrywide business credit reports canada annual credit card reports credit score free annual how to get credit scores free consumer reports free credit check credit scores range from free credit reports instantly uk find peace of mind view your free instant credit report and score free credit reports in canada ca agencies check my credit score government reports without card info free credit score aaa experian credit monitoring what is credit monitoring unsecured credit cards for bad credit scores mortgage credit score calculator annual credit report experian credit reports canada credit reports for businesses in canada consumer transunion credit report phone number fight false credit reporting credit reports 30 day free trial cancel 3 credit reports and scores monthly monitoring credit score range 2012 free credit reports without mastercard information bank of america credit score monitoring personal credit scores range what are the average credit scores unlimited access to all 3 credit reports and scores monitor free statutory credit report false credit reporting penalty credit reports massachusetts tenant screening fico credit scores same thing all 3 credit reports online transunion easy free reports online all credit bureaus free reports without trial membership credit scores transunion credit report free online what is a good transunion credit score improve credit score free credit reports without mastercard needed free credit reports in canada ca equifax all 3 credit reports absolutely free credit reports no trial offer best place get your free credit reports group credit reports company accounts can i sue for false credit reporting check all 4 credit reports for free trw credit report phone number annual credit report gov tips for improving credit scores credit limit credit scores range explained average experian credit scores my credit report free uk 3 in on credit reports equifax equifax business credit report instant credit reports tenant screening annual credit report free credit reports 3 credit reports monthly check your credit score free credit monitoring arrangement format-download free 3 1 credit reports score trial empirica credit score chart instant credit report ?2 consumer credit reports for small business ii major credit reports experian free credit report free credit monitoring psn what are they 3 bureau credit reports credit score ratings trw credit report trans union my credit report free no credit card free credit reports government program credit scores free reports what is a trw credit report understanding credit scores chart government free credit reports once a year 3 free credit reports online free credit reports gove small business pulling credit reports free credit reports government site check all three credit reports free better business bureau free credit reports 11 major credit reports agencies credit report free trial credit reports for free no credit card equifax free credit report free trial how to view your credit report free best credit score reports credit card reports irs safe credit score check free company credit check report gov site for free credit reports credit score free usa true credit report contact see my credit report free credit card reviews consumer reports free trial 3 in 1 credit reports identity get free credit reports online credit scores free 3 credit reports online absolutely free credit reports no trial don credit reports for canadian companies online purchase all 3 credit reports and scores free credit reports all 4 agencies best credit reports uk privacy matters 123 free credit report understanding credit scores and reports credit reporting agency notification all 3 credit reports cheap scores free credit card reports improve your credit score quickly what is the difference between experian equifax and transunion credit reports free 3 credit reports online ii credit reports and scores one time fee ii free credit reports once a year ii free credit reports each year best credit reports for landlords accept absolutely free credit reports & scores free credit monitoring transunion company reports south africa credit check true credit report experian 2 free credit reports in georgia best reports uk credit check which of the three credit scores matters most free credit score uk how can i check my credit score free credit scores .com free annual credit reports canada 3 credit scores one time fee credit reporting bureaus phone # how do i order all 3 credit reports for free credit reporting agency secured credit card reports 3 bureaus get all three credit reports my fico credit scores free business credit reports uk monitoring credit card reviews consumer reports canada check my credit score for free uk free credit reports graydon international check all 3 credit reports annualcreditreport free credit reports not trial memberships credit scores range fico mortgages for bad credit scores understanding credit scores ranges free 3 bureau reports credit score experian credit report by post what is a good credit score in 2012 credit monitoring services citibank 3 free credit reports a year absolutely free credit reports and scores credit reports for small businesses payment business reports uk credit checks free credit reports non trial what are the 3rd credit reports truly free credit scores free credit reports in canada ca transunion experian credit scores accurate totally free credit reports online equifax experian fico credit scores wiki all 3 credit reports in 1 having good credit scores makes credit score ratings chart canada free reports from all 3 bureaus credit scores government credit report free once a year 3 free credit reports a year entitled credit report experian dispute bank of america privacy source credit monitoring improve credit score 20 points free credit reports required by law agencies false credit reporting free credit reports us credit score calculator canada free credit reports government good credit scores for college students average credit scores check credit report free 3 types of credit reports experian best nationwide consumer credit reporting companies credit reports instantly bureaus government credit score check how to read d&b credit reports 3 free credit reports online annualcreditreport best place to get all 3 credit reports get free credit reports government 3 bureau credit reports freeware understanding credit scores reports dispute credit report online online company credit reports three major credit report companies capital one free equifax credit reports get my credit report free uk check credit report online absolutely free credit reports instantly view your credit report free canada free credit reports with scores consumer credit reports credit reports uk government all 3 credit reports free and scores free see all 3 credit reports improve credit score for mortgage all 3 credit reports fico scores help annual free credit reporting credit card reports all three credit bureaus credit scores range equifax all 3 credit reports fico scores compare where can i get all 3 credit reports for free experian 3 in 1 credit report credit report freeze experian obtain tenant credit reports credit scores for mortgage approval best credit monitoring canada experian credit score bands 4 credit reports and scores monthly free gov t credit reports bureaus credit monitoring canada credit scores matters free business credit reports online 3 credit score reports free what is a good credit score for a car loan free consumer credit reports online consumer credit reports for businesses best place for free credit reports my true credit report credit scores ranges good credit score check bank of america purchase all 3 reports credit scores equifax free credit report toll free number free 3 major credit reports order 3 credit reports online instant credit report free online credit cards for average credit scores credit scores ratings chart free credit scores ratings free credit reports all 2 agencies access free credit reports online totally free credit reports online no credit card get 3 credit reports 2 credit reports and scores without membership best way check all 8 credit reports what are the 11 credit reports agencies where can i get all 3 credit scores free credit reports in canada transunion statutory credit report call credit best company credit reports should 2 credit reports monthly lock all credit reports get all 3 reports credit score 4 free credit reports a year free credit reports without credit card number get iii free credit reports 3 credit reports and scores experian credit report free ways to improve credit score credit reporting uk credit monitoring analysis-wikipedia equifax small business credit reports credit reports for businesses in canada bureau credit score free canada order tenant credit reports tips for improving credit scores improve credit score 3 free reports without credit card information why your credit report matters quick credit score 6 free credit reports per year get free credit report experian free credit report no sign up business credit report companies free annual credit reports gov how to read credit reports scores top 3 credit report companies should i check all ii credit reports what is bad and good credit scores consumer credit reporting uk what are the iii credit reports credit report agencies contact information free credit report no credit card needed uk are credit reports freeware fico credit scores lenders credit reports for landlords get free credit reports government annualcreditreport credit scores ranges 2010 best place get 3 credit reports scores fico real free credit reports online credit report free online without credit card european company credit reports comprehensive 3 credit reporting agencies dispute how to run credit reports for landlords average credit score ratings can i sue a company for false credit reporting what are the 3 major credit reporting bureaus put credit report freeze noodle credit reports 3 credit reports scores monthly identity theft protection where can i get all three credit reports free what are the 5 free credit reports best way to check credit report do all credit reports have same information best 3 credit reports experian credit score chart usa free fico credit scores credit scores ratings explained fico credit scores good 3 free credit reports annual bureaus free business uk company credit reports check credit report free india credit score ratings chart fico scores free annual credit reports all 3 bureaus 2 free credit reports a year company credit scores explained view all 3 credit reports experian united states government credit report free .org annual credit report or free credit report transunion credit score vs fico score order all 3 credit reports three major credit reports my credit report uk quick credit score complaints 2 free credit reports no credit card 4 free credit reports uncheck all 3 credit reports instant credit report tenant all 3 credit reports free no credit card bureaus understanding credit scores canada good credit scores range what are the credit score ratings citi credit monitoring 4.95 equifax free credit report free report get 3 credit reports and scores check all 2 credit reports and scores all 3 reports same credit bureaus dispute credit report equifax credit report free online check how to raise your credit score uk request free annual credit reports what are the third free credit reports best credit reports and scores citi credit monitoring trial experian credit report r3 all 3 credit reports freeware no credit card cheap credit score check transunion credit score free fastest way to improve credit score check all three credit reports where can i find a true credit report for free free credit reports without debit card number free credit reports from all 4 bureaus credit score check uk ii free credit reports and scores 3 major credit reporting bureaus credit monitoring services canada your access to free capital reports at ftc gov credit tips for improving credit scores credit history free trial 3 1 credit reports credit card reports india credit reports for businesses credit reports free gov experian credit report free annual credit report without card details trw credit reporting agency all 3 credit reports monitoring free scores see all three credit reports get all 3 free credit reports credit score scale lenders get all 3 credit scores and reports free 3 free credit reports credit cards for low credit scores uk good credit score range table how to read credit reports codes free business credit report online consumer credit reports small business bank of america credit monitoring login view all 3 credit reports for free check all ii credit reports get all iii free credit reports see your 3 credit reports free credit reporting companies what is a good experian credit score credit score free equifax experian credit reports canada formerly all 3 credit reports free no credit card suze orman how to get free credit reports order all 3 credit reports mail scores what is a good credit score uk how to get all 3 credit reports free how to raise your credit score in 6 months furnish free annual credit reports credit scores range wikipedia 3 bureau credit reports score credit reports required by law free copy order free credit reports online get 3 free credit reports a year equifax get all 11 free credit reports free trial 3 in 1 credit reports equifax credit reports matter pull free credit report for life all three credit scores free free annual credit report government website can you sue for false credit reporting free credit reports no credit card required consumer reports get free credit report which credit score matters steps to improve credit score experian credit report monthly fee free credit report no credit card citi credit report monitoring instant credit score free view all credit reports free experian credit score only 3 different credit scores how do i order all 3 reports for free credit bureaus what are the 3 credit reports agencies fico best consumer credit reporting companies understanding credit scores how many free credit reports per year in georgia borrow free credit score gov credit monitoring analysis format excel trial 3 in 1 reports free credit score lock all 3 credit reports experian credit report equifax 4 major credit reports free free annual credit reports us federal experian trw credit report get all three free credit reports your access to free fico reports at ftc gov credit is free reports in canada safe credit score credit scores ratings mean credit report uk experian credit report free online uk what is transunion credit score get all credit reports how to get your 3 free credit reports annual credit report free transunion 4 major credit reports agencies free online credit reports uk what are the 3 types of credit reports experian free credit report usa business credit reports canada customers free equifax credit reports and scores credit reporting services canada credit report experian login all 3 bureau credit reports transunion consumer credit reports definition tips for improving credit scores credit report free trial 3 in 1 credit reports free trial 3 1 credit reports matters address for equifax credit reporting agency business credit reports us credit reporting service three free credit reports once a year how to get credit report free by mail 4 free credit reports and scores free instant credit report no credit card required monitor all 3 credit reports score order all 3 credit reports experian what are the 3 free credit reports experian free credit report uk free credit reports without credit card required trial what are the 2 free credit reports all three credit reports and scores credit scores ratings lenders free reports government agency annual credit fico credit scores range transunion credit report free 3 in 1 reports and scores credit bureaus transunion credit score lower than others how to get credit report free without credit card free company credit reports order 3 credit reports and scores free reports in canada legit credit bureaus difference between 3 major credit reports free true credit report best credit reports on businesses free online credit report no credit card required uk get free annual credit reports different credit scores ratings 3in1 credit report free trial instant credit report for landlords are there free credit reports in canada bank of america credit monitoring reviews 3 credit reports free trial membership chase credit monitoring annual free credit reports in texas my free annual credit reports experian credit report experian credit reports free annualcreditreport equifax credit reports for business dun and bradstreet uk credit reports experian business credit reports credit report companies-experian credit report agencies reviews dun and bradstreet reports business credit instant credit report online credit report monitoring services reviews get credit report online credit monitoring services capital one my credit report free annually unlimited bureau credit reports all three free credit reports fico score credit reporting agency australia difference between 3 major credit reports experian and transunion free credit reports government ftc gov estimated credit score calculator true credit report online best 3 credit reports equifax credit report uk business how can i get all 3 credit reports free online credit report free no credit card statutory credit report online get all 3 credit reports in one best company credit reports like best 3 in one credit reports pulling credit reports for landlords trw credit report online 3 credit report agencies transunion credit score range 2012 credit score calculator for auto loan lastpass free credit monitoring 3 major credit reports free fair equifax credit report request unlimited credit report access i want to check my credit score 3 credit reports in 11 best free credit reports online free credit report instantly annual credit report free government site prbc credit reporting agency credit reports for landlords free background fico credit scores calculated get free credit report annual credit report understanding credit scores transunion how do i get all three credit reports credit report free trial 30 days all 3 reports free credit scores how do you get your three free credit reports experian credit report uk is equifax free credit report free mortgage rate credit score calculator three free credit reports each year graydon international credit reports credit reporting can you get free reports in canada credit rating experian credit report codes company credit reports online trusted good experian credit score best place get 3 credit reports scores experian free credit report commercial credit reports us government bureaus free credit reports equifax transunion business credit reports mexico free credit reporting online company reports credit risk usaa credit check monitoring 3 credit scores explained access free credit reports online experian graydon credit reports best free credit reports online authorized mortgages for people with poor credit scores business credit report experian what are the 4 free credit reports experian credit monitoring phone number 2 free credit reports without credit card all 3 credit reports canada free credit reports without credit card information how do you order all 3 credit reports my credit report free government credit report free no credit card uk fair credit reporting act violations experian credit report freeze compare credit monitoring services experian good credit score range free business credit reports suing for false credit reporting equifax credit score chart free credit score no trial how to get free credit reports from all 3 annual credit reports by law free copy three free credit reports a year online credit reports tenant screening services 3 1 free reports credit scores best site free credit reports equifax free credit reports canada credit reports for landlords using consumer secured credit card reports 3 credit bureaus equifax credit report codes codes experian credit reports free reports uk company credit check all 2 free credit reports and scores 2 major credit bureau reports us gov free reports credit scoring what does trw in credit report stand for secured credit card reports all three credit score matters contact details cheap credit reports for landlords what are the 3 credit reports agencies 2 free credit reports once a year how do i request my free credit report through the annual credit report request service quick credit score free how to get all three credit reports and scores for free experian credit score promotional code credit score uk improve credit score calculator lenders best credit monitoring services credit reports free trial best 3 credit reports transunion free credit report gov uk three free annual credit reports free quick credit score experian credit score voucher credit report companies house equifax credit report canada order all credit reports for free gov site for free credit reports annualcreditreport quick credit score increase free credit report without putting card details free credit score usa 5 credit reports in 1 credit report agencies wiki best way to get 3 credit reports scores buy transunion credit score credit reports for landlords review tenant screening free business credit reports check uk free credit reports by law consumers credit reporting services for small business free credit reports without credit cards needed get credit scores free free credit reporting bureau how to get free reports in canada credit rating international business reports credit decisions get all 3 credit reports online learn how to read reports credit education best rewards credit card 2011 consumer reports buy 3 credit scores best credit monitoring service consumer reports free credit reports and scores no credit card credit monitoring services reviews consumer reports annual credit report scam credit reports canada tenant screening what are the three free credit reports iii major credit bureau reports has best credit reports credit card reports transunion best credit reports free credit reports in canada equifax agencies free annual credit reports free cancel usaa credit monitoring free annual credit reports+government all 3 free reports credit bureaus free credit reports in canada legit equifax consumer credit reports for business get my three free credit reports credit monitoring services review consumer reports 2 major bureaus collect information create credit reports view your credit report free credit score explained experian all three credit reports free experian credit score scale experian credit report phone number government credit report free website 3 credit score reports experian credit monitoring 4.95 credit score scale range free credit reports without debit card information 3 reports and scores free credit history canadian business credit reports customers improve credit score uk all 3 credit reports and scores without membership 3 credit reports and scores free order all 4 free credit reports free reports instantly review credit scores what is triple alert credit monitoring company credit reports us checks credit reports free no credit card required credit reports graydon america monitor 3 credit reports and scores my 3 free credit reports check all get free credit reports government consumers government free credit reporting best credit cards for bad credit scores credit scores ranges canada credit scores ranges credit reporting service businesses get 3 credit score reports free credit reports without credit card uk apr usaa credit monitoring promo code understanding reports uk credit check average credit scores in us best credit reports review my credit report free credit report usaa credit check monitoring login credit score uk scale free company credit reports online credit reports used lenders fico scores how to get free experian credit report can you get free credit reports in canada equifax get your credit report free uk free quick credit scores are free credit reports online safe ftc credit card reports monthly credit score free no trial uk credit monitoring bank of america all credit reports free online credit monitoring reviews credit scores ranges explained commercial tenant credit reports best 3 credit reports scores know 3 credit reports free annually who has the best credit reports free credit reports without debit card needed all 11 free credit reports and scores credit reporting companies mortgage brokers all credit reports done federal government what is the best credit monitoring service to use free business credit reports own buy all 3 credit reports fico score 3 main credit report companies iii credit reports and scores free improve your credit score canada home mortgages for low credit scores 3 credit scores one time best way check all 5 credit reports equifax credit report freeze tips for improving credit scores credit scoring instant free credit card reports annual credit report review free credit reports no trial get average credit score by state annual free credit score 2 credit reports scores monthly how do i check my credit score consumer credit reporting reform act how to read experian credit reports services credit reports for businesses in canada free credit reports without credit card instantly view 1 free credit reports annual average credit score increase per month best credit score monitoring service consumer reports annual free credit reports gov attorney general three free credit reports and scores check all 5 credit reports dun and bradstreet credit reports getting free credit reports by law my business credit report why doo companies ask for credit reports transunion credit score only 3 free credit reports annual commission 2 free credit reports per year how to get free credit reports equifax free credit report free credit report free credit score ratings 2012 contact number for experian credit reports tx bank of america credit score check view 3 credit reports monthly which secured credit card reports to all three credit bureaus secured credit card reports all three bureaus free credit report government approved free experian credit report free 2 credit reports and scores monthly how to read experian credit reports online 3 credit reports improve credit score fast how to join the credit reporting bureaus free annual credit report the fair credit reporting act all reports free 3 credit bureaus dispute credit report form free credit report no credit card needed completely free 3 credit reports experian credit scores uk equifax online credit reports bank of america credit monitoring program absolutely free credit reports no credit cards free credit reports without trial membership anytime credit report uk government free credit reports without credit card use lock all three credit reports best company get free credit report florida laws on credit reporting 3 in 1 credit report monitoring all 3 credit reports online transunion credit report codes get free credit reports without credit card fees best free reports online credit scores iii major bureaus collect information create credit reports free credit reports no trial card information check all 11 credit reports and scores cancel experian credit monitoring best place to get 3 credit reports free credit reports uk check my credit score one time 3 1 free credit reports bureau free business credit reports uk graydon credit reports for mortgage companies provider international credit reports uk business information 3 credit reports and scores easy d & b personal credit reports experian credit reports canada quebec 3 credit scores only free credit reports without credit card information fees credit reports for landlords ontario is free credit reports in canada safe 3 credit reports free trial 3 credit reports fico score credit reports for canadian companies check equifax credit report application form average credit score mortgage reports and scores cheap 3 bureau credit 3 free reports per year credit score free annual credit report federal government credit report companies in canada order all 3 credit reports phone equifax mortgages for lower credit scores free 3 credit reports annual provider international us business credit information credit reports order all three credit reports free instant credit report without credit card transunion small business credit reports 3 free credit reports without debit card absolutely free credit reports with no credit card required trw credit report contact annual free equifax credit reports free consumer credit reports credit report uk ?2 best way to improve credit score credit scores canada usa get free credit reports online consumers credit report access.co.uk credit monitoring arrangement meaning absolutely free credit reports not trial how to raise your credit score instantly best sites for free credit reports best site get all 3 credit reports credit reports free a summary of your rights under the fair credit reporting act usaa credit monitoring check promo code get credit report canada business credit reporting bureaus federal government free credit reports 2 major credit reports free instant online credit report how to get free credit reports online noddle free credit report equifax free annual credit report free best way check all 11 credit reports consumer credit reports for landlords screening online credit report uk 3 free credit reports government card get 3 credit reports for free equifax mailing address for credit reports true credit report reviews trw credit report best way to get all 3 credit reports credit reporting agency limited truro annual credit report uk annual credit reports free what is the average credit score equifax credit reports usa check my credit score for free credit reports explained determine average credit scores 2012 promo code credit monitoring usaa experian credit reports reviews annualcreditreport reports without trial membership free credit score credit scores range what are all the credit reports understanding credit scores numbers how to get free credit reports yearly where can i get all 3 reports for free credit scores usaa credit monitoring promo code 2012 transunion business credit reports by lawyers free credit reports yearly improve your credit score in 90 days credit report access information how to get free credit reports in canada experian all 3 credit reports free experian credit report agencies uk absolutely free consumer credit reports credit scores explained canada totally free credit reports uk credit reports matter agents 5 free credit reports yearly credit score chart canada experian credit score free how to raise your credit score 200 points credit reports us government 3 credit reports free online tenant reports for realtors credit check true credit report phone number how often should i check my credit score annual credit card reports . com check credit report free once year business credit reports equifax credit monitoring canada false credit reporting lawsuit credit report experian equifax and transunion all 4 free credit reports and scores credit monitoring reviews 2012 free credit reports without credit card info bills get your credit score free annual credit reports transunion how to read credit reports on equifax analyze 2 credit reports and scores cheap my credit scores free credit reports us government into by law free credit reports yearly fcra company credit reports free order tenant credit reports bureau improve credit score tips improve your credit score credit score range uk credit monitoring arrangement+ppt small business credit report canada credit score explained unlimited 3 bureau credit reports free company credit reports uk instant agency credit reports company accounts get 3 bureau reports equifax credit dispute credit report letter experian credit reports reviews monitoring free credit reports required by lawyers all 11 free credit reports can youtube get free credit reports in canada annual free credit reports by law credit scores range transunion all 3 credit reports cheap bureaus experian should i check all iii credit reports annual credit report usa reports without card needed free credit score consumer credit reporting opt out how long to improve credit score hsbc credit score range credit reporting companies phone numbers free credit reports in canada equifax consumer check all 3 credit reports for freeware show credit score chart how do i get my annual free credit reports instant credit report canada average credit scores consumers free credit reports from transunion equifax and experian how to get 3 credit reports for free free credit reports no trial memberships free 3 in 1 credit report and score tenant credit reports massachusetts criminal how to check my credit score free credit score reports online free credit reports no trial what are the ii free credit reports us average credit score order credit reports tenant screening credit reporting service should use buy all 3 credit reports and scores free credit reports government agency how to pull business credit reports free annual credit reports 11 credit reports scores monthly company credit reports ireland check credit report without credit card ii credit reports free annually check my credit report free uk get 3 bureau credit reports credit monitoring analysis format unlimited 3 bureau credit reports transunion transunion credit report uk 3 free credit reports without credit card bureaus 3 free credit reports a year agencies average credit score uk free credit reports instantly without debit card how to improve credit scores in india iii credit reports and scores online credit report freeze georgia equifax credit report promotion code credit card reports experian check credit report free online experian credit report ?2 how to get all 3 credit reports and scores free credit reports without mastercard number are credit reports free yours totally free credit reports and scores true credit report tv what is the credit score range average credit score by age free credit monitoring bank of america how to check credit report 3 credit reports scores monthly reference usa credit scores excellent credit score range get free credit reports without credit card trial good credit scores usa all 3 credit reports and scores free experian canada credit scores explained free credit reports without credit required card information free reports in canada ca credit score how to get free credit reports in canada equifax free credit score free how to get free credit reports in georgia quick credit score fixes secured credit card reports to all three equifax credit reports how to read absolutely free credit reports no trial fair ii free credit reports a year purchase 3 credit reports and scores annual free credit reports by law federal equifax free credit report canada all credit reports and scores credit reporting companies which is best free 3 reports and scores credit history cheap tenant credit reports background checks credit report companies reviews how to get all 3 credit reports in one free credit reports online without credit card information top three credit reporting bureaus what is the best credit score monitoring site credit cards for poor credit scores uk 3 1 free credit reports equifax trilegiant credit information hotline company credit reports+south africa credit monitoring arrangement’ format rbi citi credit monitoring identity all 3 bureau credit reports how to get free credit reports and scores ii credit reports scores monthly understanding equifax credit report credit monitoring credit rating scores in india my annual credit report free credit report 3 credit reports and scores help credit monitoring analysis report equifax statutory credit report credit score range how to check credit report free free credit reports required by law free credit reports instantly without credit card information should i request all 3 credit reports at the same time poor credit score range free credit reports without credit needed card information what are the 3 credit reports 5 free credit reports government annual credit report free credit report good credit scores explained usaa credit monitoring premium ii free credit reports per year cancel credit monitoring usaa 3 free reports yearly credit score good fico credit scores canadian business credit reports best credit monitoring reviews three free credit reports in one average credit score credit cards credit reports 60 day free trial 4 free credit reports government what are credit scores ratings free credit score report annual credit report government best place get all 3 credit reports online credit reports uk checks credit score check free ii major credit reports agencies free credit reports once a year how doo you order all 3 credit reports experian credit report free denied credit best credit reports uk equifax 4 free credit reports each year 3 types of credit scores check all ii credit reports for free credit reporting agency definition free 3 credit reports and scores trial transunion credit report request form experian credit reports codes 3 credit reports equifax free credit score no credit card best way check all 3 credit reports sue false credit reporting how to get free credit reports in canada agencies credit monitoring arrangement data get free credit reports government copy check credit report equifax business credit report law do all three credit reports have same information what is a good credit score in 2011 credit report all 3 free credit reports and scores 3 bureau online credit reports and score 3 credit reports and scores equifax government free credit reports and scores get my credit report free how to improve your credit score fast fair credit reporting act canada free instant credit report difference between ii major credit reports buy all 3 credit reports best credit monitoring service 2012 consumer reports credit score matters number how do i order all 3 credit reports for free option iii credit reports in 1 3 credit reports in q free 3 in 1 credit report experian credit monitoring login best site for all 3 credit reports bureaus three free credit reporting agencies usaa credit monitoring best way to get 3 credit reports tenant credit reports how to improve your credit score instant online credit report access credit reports used hiring employers credit reports for landlords freeware experian consumer credit reports secured credit card reports to credit report as regular how to get free credit reports from all 3 credit beacon credit score range average credit scores in america totally free credit report no credit card required uk free annual credit reports and scores average credit score usa transunion credit score chart free credit reports us citizens agencies your access to free visa reports at ftc gov credit all 3 credit reports same where can i get my free annual credit reports purchase all 3 credit reports get 2 free credit reports free credit reports required by law consumer cheap credit reports tenant screening my annual credit report free transunion credit score explained free 3 bureau reports credit scores credit card company reports irs business credit report equifax experian credit reports address credit reporting services reviews credit reports for international companies countries 3 credit reports free all bureaus 3 major credit reports agencies experian bank of america online credit monitoring best free credit reports online federal credit reporting service for landlords credit card reports annual credit report government site my 5 free credit reports free credit reports no trial really equifax free credit card reports online 3 free credit reports online transunion business credit reporting companies credit report experian annual free credit report uk credit monitoring services uk understanding fico credit scores get 3 credit reports in 1 credit report agencies in canada free credit reports and scores tenant reports canada credit checks annual credit reports only through annualcreditreport view your credit report free online fico credit scores credit reporting agency rules three credit score reports credit report 2012 experian credit reports reviews credit reports us interest rate credit score chart federal laws on credit reporting what are the 3 major credit reports are there credit reports for businesses annual credit report wiki experian credit report telephone number best place get 3 credit reports and scores free business reports uk online credit how to prepare credit monitoring analysis what is credit monitoring assessment transunion credit score meaning credit card reports equifax true credit report cancel credit reports 15 day free trial all my credit reports different how long does it take to improve your credit score consumer credit card reports 3 annual credit reports free best place to get 3 credit reports check security credit report freeze top credit report agencies free credit scores uk one off credit report ?2 canadian business credit reports now all 3 credit reports freeware view all 3 credit reports and score equifax what is credit monitoring services how do i get all three credit reports free all 3 credit reports online free meaning credit monitoring analysis credit reporting bureaus my space free credit reports are free credit reports online safe aaa credit reporting services my 3 free reports credit score credit reporting bureaus addresses company credit reports canada access 3 credit reports and scores online contact number for experian credit reports address reports uk credit rating experian credit scores credit score reports canada credit report freeze indiana three free credit reports annually free credit reports without credit card number know check all 3 credit reports and scores picture top three free credit reports business credit reports usa trw credit report equifax consumer credit report agencies free instant credit report uk credit score checking credit score calculator india should i check my credit score best site for all 3 credit reports scores usaa credit monitoring review consumer credit reporting agencies act check credit report free canada free credit score experian credit reports canada trans union experian credit scores explained statutory credit report explained credit reports us check credit report companies best equifax free credit report free credit report experian credit reports address trw credit report uk without credit card annual credit score free 3 in 1 credit reports equifax credit reports phone number government free credit reports annually 11 credit reports and scores one time fee experian credit score chart how to get 3 credit reports online credit score ratings scale consumer credit reporting agency equifax credit report free trial credit reports for small businesses check credit report for free once citi credit monitoring login tax credit reporting service free credit reports without credit card information consent all 4 free credit reports credit scores needed for mortgage approval free credit reports without credit card information bills order 3 credit reports phone free credit reports without trial membership card needed what are all the free credit reports how to raise your credit score 50 points 11 major bureaus collect information create credit reports free credit reports without mastercard required trw credit report usa view credit scores free 1 free credit reports no credit card free credit reports and scores all 3 bureaus consumer reports canada credit cards average credit scores by age group free credit reports in canada ca checking get all three credit reports canada 3 free credit reports equifax free credit reports from experian equifax pay to improve credit score get all 2 free credit reports clark howard annual credit report free annual credit report free federal government credit reports for free no credit card required credit reports used credit card reports companies where do i check my credit score view all 3 credit reports equifax check credit report canada check credit report tenant 3 free credit scores purchase all 3 credit scores three annual credit reports free business credit reports transunion how to obtain credit reports for small business free credit reports instantly online company credit report free how to read reports on equifax major credit dispute credit report uk learn how to read credit reports equifax free credit report uk good credit scores creditors 11 credit reports monthly get all 3 credit scores best credit card rewards consumer reports company credit reports freeware 3 credit reports in one equifax credit report phone number credit card for average credit score 5 1 free credit reports dispute credit report sample letter 5 free credit reports each year free instant credit report and score iii credit reports free annually