how do i order a credit report on someone free credit report guy eric violette check credit score and report for free premier credit report address for the 3 credit reporting agencies gov how to buy a home with a foreclosure on your credit report service free annual credit reports receive how to read credit report experian how do i get a credit report from transunion addresses 3 major credit reporting agencies statistics bad debt credit reporting agency best place to get my credit report is there a free credit report free annual credit report no score top rated companies free credit report consumer free credit report can view my credit report online how do i contact experian credit reporting agency phone tcr tcr total credit repair 3 major credit reporting agencies us how to dispute negative credit report fix bad credit reports free new free report commercial cell phone credit check how do i find my credit report 3 credit reports and scores cheap complete credit reports and scores free fair credit reporting act july 2011 how long does it take to fix my credit score how do i freeze myspace report free credit credit suisse report wealth free annual 4 credit bureau reports discover card free credit report free report transunion itc credit checks best place to get free annual credit report transworld systems credit reporting free credit report score 3 agencies free credit report no credit card information tools what is the average credit score in canada red flag rules fair credit reporting act what is credit report used for what are promotional inquiries on credit report definition consumer reporting agency under fair credit reporting act applicable all 3 free credit reports and scores credit report disputes online free credit report bands name how will i get a free credit report without a credit card in canada negative information credit reports stays long who can how to check your credit report oregon credit report employment updating personal information credit reports remove identity theft your credit report transunion free credit report number report possible identity theft credit bureaus free copy credit report once per year check corporation credit report credit report with social security number credit report with no credit card annual credit report complaints annual free credit report from experian credit report score 3 agencies good credit report veda credit report new zealand experian smart business credit reports credit agency reporting laws how long do 30 day late payments stay on your credit report credit report experian yearly free federal credit report us government what ismandated free credit report denied credit report from experian visa lost credit card reporting usaa credit monitoring cancel your rights under the fair credit reporting act long negative information credit report get free once year credit report corporate credit reports canada how to clean up how to clean your credit report fast how to fix credit reports experian credit report wikipedia totally free credit report without credit card required credit repair group garden grove california dispute credit report transunion address best credit reporting service 2010 collections on credit report how to clear removing medical debt from credit report fix bad credit report repair three credit reporting companies best get your free 3 in 1 credit report and score with equifax how to read a digital experian credit bureau report get your credit report for free once a year official credit report score checking credit report children free credit report and score from all 3 bureaus improving credit score tips new free credit report commercial band unsecured credit cards reporting to credit bureaus how to get rid of negative information on credit report do payday loans appear on credit report credit bureau report singapore free credit reports credit bureau free annual credit report for small business best site credit score reports federal law requires free annual credit report fair credit reporting act disclosures consent form free copy my transunion credit report credit union reports real site free credit reports phone number order equifax credit report get free 3 credit bureau report consumers obtain credit reports scores get credit reports free dispute information transunion credit report how doo you check your credit report free clear judgement your credit report south africa top rated credit report sites equifax 3 in 1 credit report remove collections off your credit report annual free credit report suze orman transunion credit report for landlords how do i get a credit report mailed to me how do i order my annual free credit report credit karma report when are you entitled to a free copy of your credit report credit reporting agencies trw the only real free credit report monitoring how can i get a free credit report without signing up for anything bank of america credit report service remove paid items off credit report anual free credit report credit karma credit climate report legal credit report law enforcement systems on credit report order all three credit reports scores how to remove a freeze on your credit report mortgage credit reporting agencies get your credit history report free how to repair how to increase your credit score quickly how to get a collection removed from credit report how to clear my credit report what is credit credit history and credit score equifax credit report free fair credit reporting act (fcra) disclosure statement and authorization how to really get credit report for free how to unfreeze your credit report free credit report dispute experian how to get a free yearly credit report how to get your yearly free credit report couldn fast credit elevator repair companies in texas get your complete credit report where can i get all three credit reports and scores transunion credit report dispute mailing address united states government free credit report how long does a satisfied judgement stay on credit report remove credit report security freeze is my rental history on my credit report does collection agency report credit bureau free report federally mandated credit card craigslist rental scams credit report how to get cash loans fast best report service 2010 credit card free credit report cancellation phone number order experian credit report removing items from your credit report name all credit reporting agencies annual credit report request service form who is the band in the free credit report commercials usaa report lost credit card long can judgment stay credit report fair credit reporting act consumer reporting agency cras improving credit how to raise credit score in one year delete employment history credit report credit bureau reports singapore important annual credit report score free credit bureau reports singapore banks best 3 credit reporting agencies credit report history years how to get my business credit report 72 hour latest credit repair system free credit report.co free credit reports equifax experian transunion free instant credit report without credit card the free credit report songs removing paid state tax lien from credit report free credit report commercials wiki 10 percent free credit report no credit card needed does chexsystems affect your credit report free credit report cancel credit card reporting to credit agencies what does it mean when your credit report says account charged off canadian credit reports business get free credit report without card details bank america free credit report offer my free credit report get charge offs removed your credit report removing errors on credit reports disputes on credit report mortgage credit reporting company review free annual credit report three bureaus free credit report and score without credit card us gov free annual credit report online who can request a credit report federal reserve consumer;s guide to credit reports and credit scores annual credit report phone number for customer service forms dispute items credit report what is the best way to dispute something on your credit report consumer credit information report canadian credit report free my free credit report gov free credit report all three bureau free once year credit report gov consumer info.com credit report how do i freeze my credit report equifax how to report identity theft to credit agencies how do i get a free credit card report what are the three credit reporting agencies and why are they important new credit report laws 2011 all 3 credit report addresses credit report google search footprint obtain free credit report without paying yearly credit report 2012 free copy equifax canada credit report request date of last activity on your credit report often do you get free credit report quizzle how to dispute credit report equifax how to get rid of credit cards without hurting your credit score where do i get my free credit report annual sample credit report removal letter contact information for all credit reporting agencies transunion consumer credit report government website for free credit report credit report credit card debt best credit report repair services what is the free credit report site best way to check tenant credit score how do you get your credit report fixed how do i obtain my free yearly credit report cancel my free credit report account should i get all three credit reports at once how to find good credit score on equifax my credit reports scores credit report and employment background check report on credit appraisal has best report service credit history how to get free credit report more than once a year report all three credit bureaus how can i view credit report for free experian free credit report sign in read canadian credit report equifax business credit report free credit score and report from 6 bureaus what are the three credit report companies uk removing medical bill credit report how to order free credit reports by phone official free annual credit report agencies government credit report online no credit card needed always free core logic credit report view experian free credit report uk dispute transunion credit report item annual free credit reports scores credit report company most accurate website for free credit annual credit report federal law requires free credit report bureaus get free credit reports all three free credit credit report login do free credit reports affect your credit score addresses of the three credit reporting agencies remove paid-off collection accounts from credit report online money loans where can i borrow money without a credit check get monthly credit report order all 3 credit reports remove negative report credit report question something your credit report rapid credit reports glendale post bankruptcy credit report cleanup collection agency remove from credit report damages violations fair credit reporting act willful credit report federal free consumer address for the 3 credit reporting agencies major national free credit report.com cell phone song and lyrics easy online cash advance loans hard inquiry on credit report how many points routing number for e and a credit union my free credit report massachusetts annual report credit suisse 2006 credit bureau reports different address on file 3 main credit reporting companies landlord credit report form equifax credit reports for business dave ramsey credit report dispute what is a suit or judgement on credit report cheap credit repair attorney seattle ea free credit best hard disk repair software 2013 free three in one credit report with scores bureau removing old debt from credit report tenant credit report ontario canada free credit report car commercial lyrics credit report for free without credit card find out credit reports major credit reporting agencies in canada free credit report yearly law three in one credit report with scores bureaus government site for credit report remove security freeze my credit report free yearly credit report 2009 experian contact number human respa credit reporting requirements form bad debt credit reporting agency amex free corporate credit report settlement vs. paid in full credit report your signal federal credit union kensington md get my credit report australia free credit report underneath federal law best credit report 2011 monitoring services wells fargo secured credit card report to credit bureaus free credit report online dispute free tenant screening credit report equifax credit report free yearly how do i improve my credit rating singapore fair credit reporting act lawyers bankruptcy credit report years best credit reporting websites free credit report no sign up uk contesting credit report online request free equifax credit report mail get my free experian credit report landlord credit reports tenant how to fix your credit after a major setback put red flag my credit report 3 credit reporting agencies wiki equifax free credit report ga free credit report colorado free capital report if denied credit equifax experian annual credit report login what is a credit card cash advance check citi credit report score state ga free credit report capital one lost credit card reporting clean up your credit report fast what information is contained in a credit report how do i request my yearly credit report what information is on your credit report obtain your free credit reports federal trade commission free annual credit report authorized transunion address to dispute credit report credit reports different information usa free credit report online payday loan direct lenders only bad credit payday loans bad credit no fees business credit cards with no guarantor read credit report history safe request free credit report free canadian credit report government been denied credit report free copy free credit report usa gov credit report federal reserve bank credit report repair department of human services in dallas texas false credit reporting act free credit reports on companies business reporting to credit agencies experian dispute mailing address credit report errors will getting a credit card help my credit check your company credit report legally improve your credit report credit report credit expert from experian credit report job offer myfico fico credit scores get free credit report online transunion credit free report clean up my credit report fast how to successfully dispute credit report remove bankruptcy your credit report after 7 years how do i get a paid charge-off off of my credit report free credit report experian denied credit get credit rating report australia cibil totally free credit score check inaccurate credit report uk credit card credit report not mine how do i fix incorrect information on my credit report entitled to one free credit report each year monitor credit report how do you find out your credit rating nz freezing credit report with equifax free credit report canada review do free credit report companies make money credit report without credit card info fair credit reporting act proof debt order free credit report from experian credit suisse report india dispute wrong information credit report free credit report uk no credit card free credit report no membership fee free credit report uk without credit card details how to raise your credit how to increase credit score in 30 days how to obtain credit reports for small business need gateway credit union annual report 2010 debt credit repair for dummies if the information on your credit report is in dispute you are entitled to what does a credit score of 0 mean charge off credit report mortgage credit reports matter remove transferred closed credit report free credit report no trial offer government of canada credit card comparison foreclosure on credit report remove credit report 30 days late cheap credit report online tri-merge credit report providers how to erase a collection on credit report annual credit reports free gov how can i get my credit report for freeware how do i log back into annual credit report transunion order credit report credit report credit bureau singapore credit reporting dispute letters how often should i run my credit report how long does a late credit card payment stay on your credit report credit repair specialists belgrade montana schools checking credit report potential tenant business credit reports usa leading get credit report without monitoring service best poor credit car finance telephone number transunion credit report how to delete inquiries on my credit report best way to dispute credit report items consent run credit report form get paid collections off credit report removing negative items from credit report after 7 years how do i order my free annual credit report free canadian credit reports without credit card unlimited access to 3 credit reports compare 10 the best credit repair companies fair credit credit reporting act long does negative credit stay your report free online credit report india how do you request your free yearly credit report checking credit report hurt score report credit card stolen wells fargo clark howard free credit report website transunion free credit report yearly getting your free credit reports how to remove a paid charge-off from your credit report how to obtain free credit report online free credit report with no strings attached cancel free equifax credit report update your experian credit report credit repair arlington tx annual credit report member sign in how can i obtain a free credit report request transunion how can i get my credit report without paying can checking your report hurt your score own credit consumer reports credit reporting agencies how to get a free credit report when you;ve been denied credit credit reporting agencies dispute forms free credit report customer service phone free annual credit report from federal government run free credit report tenant see my credit report score when is the best time to pull your credit report fact act annual credit report bad credit car loans instant approval car loans with bad how to get a loan with bad credit and no cosigner uw credit union free credit report first advantage credit report how to request free credit reports by mail wells fargo credit reporting dispute best company request your credit report experian credit report compared others how to read equifax credit report your credit score experian credit report all free credit report commercials lyrics privacy (credit reporting information) regulations how to dispute errors on your credit report best website checking credit report equifax free credit report phone number canada fake best free credit report sites what happens when you dispute an item on your credit report website obtain free annual credit report top rated free credit report sites monitoring report creditor harassment phone calls statistics debt credit reporting agency band members free credit report commercials how do red get your credit report free thin credit file car loan free credit report from all 3 credit bureaus credit report dispute letter 3 credit reports transunion how many times can i dispute my credit report how to get your credit report from equifax free credit checks free shipping from target free credit report best deal credit reporting companies for landlords how can i get my annual credit report free experience free credit report uk online sample letter to remove credit report inquiry federal trade commission building better credit report what is credit report used for have been denied rebate do get my free credit report company credit reports employer credit report illinois 3 bureau credit report & scores credit reporting agencies address change equifax example of credit report guaranteed bad credit car loans australia
Home Media News Extra Innings Deal Makes Poor Long-Term Business Sense

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 628 guests online

Atom RSS

Extra Innings Deal Makes Poor Long-Term Business Sense PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 23
PoorBest 
Written by Maury Brown   
Wednesday, 28 March 2007 06:21

Maury BrownYesterday saw several principle players in the Extra Innings saga testify before the US Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation at a hearing entitled Exclusive Sports Programming: Examining Competition and Consumer Choice. Rob Jacobson President and Chief Executive Officer for iN DEMAND Networks, Bob DuPuy President and Chief Operating Officer for Major League Baseball, Chase Carey Chief Executive Officer for DIRECTV Group, Inc., and Carl Vogel President & Vice Chairman EchoStar Satellite L.L.C. all had time at the microphone.

As the prepared statements provided here on The Biz of Baseball show, there are some key facets—namely the upcoming The Baseball Channel—that are creating the impasse on getting all the incumbents in a place to carry Extra Innings.

In a nutshell, DirecTV has offered to pay for the rights to show The Baseball Channel up-front, and now. Given the fact that ratings for NFL Network have not exactly been stellar (the heavily hyped debut game on the fledgling network pulled an averaged 4.2 million total viewers and a 2.3 household rating according to Nielsen, nearly one-third what Monday Night Football pulls on ESPN), you might understand why Robert Jacobson of iN Demand offered up a compromise deal in his opening statement. “If The Baseball Channel launches in 2009, we would give MLB the right to cancel the Extra Innings deal if it cannot reach a satisfactory agreement for carriage of the new channel with our owners,” Jacobson said. “This would put off the issue of The Baseball Channel until it actually launches and ensure that for the next two years at least, all baseball fans will have access to the Extra Innings package.”

After the statement was made, Sen. John Kerry (D-MA) asked Bob DuPuy, “"What's the matter with that?”

Well, here’s what’s the matter with that: If MLB re-negotiates with iN Demand, MLB has to renegotiate with DirecTV, and possibly EchoStar if they get onboard. The exclusive deal takes the risk off MLB and places it on DirecTV. As mentioned, if ratings for the NFL Network are not high by comparison to games shown on ESPN, how will MLB fair? After all, the NFL enjoys a vastly more popular product. Also, by DirecTV offering an up-front payment as opposed to iN Demand’s offer make The Baseball Channel available on a per subscriber basis, MLB has those funds available for any start-up costs involved in launching The Baseball Channel.

(Select Read More to view the rest of Maury Brown's article) 

Back to iN Demand, it seemed more than a bit ironic that they played themselves up as the “good guys” in this deal. After all, there are exclusive deals for cable that involve the Mets, White Sox, Padres and Phillies. As reported by Richard Sandomir of the NY Times in late February:

The owners will also have their own interests at heart. The Mets are partners in SNY with two cable operators, Time Warner and Comcast; the White Sox and Cubs are also partners with Comcast in Chicago. The Atlanta Braves are caught between being sold by Time Warner, which owns cable networks like TBS, to Liberty Media, which is taking over DirecTV.

The Padres' cable games are not licensed to satellite, so if their local fans switch to DirecTV to continue to watch Extra Innings, they will not get their own team's games unless they buy both services.

Comcast SportsNet in Philadelphia is not delivered by satellite as most regional sports networks like YES and SNY are, which leaves 300,000 or more DirecTV subscribers (at least 50 percent more than total national cable subscribership to Extra Innings) in that market without access to those cable games. Comcast's refusal to put its sports network on satellite has been challenged by DirecTV and EchoStar but affirmed by the federal government.

So, it’s not as if cable isn’t playing a roll in the exclusivity matter, as well. It should be interesting if you live in San Diego, have to watch the Padres on cable due to an exclusive deal with Cox, and you want to watch Extra Innings. In that instance, it appears you’ll have to have DirecTV, AND cable.

As for DirecTV, Chase Carey provided some analysis by dartboard. “DIRECTV estimates that there are relatively few viewers – no more than three percent of the cable segment (approximately 180,000 Extra Innings subscribers) – who cannot receive DIRECTV service,” Carey said in his opening statement. “This translates to roughly 5,000 subscribers – each of whom can access the games over the Internet.”

This is analogous to saying, “When a breeze blows through pile of leaves, 5,000 of them will be displaced.” It’s wholly arbitrary. How Carey and DirecTV came about this figure had to come with sticking their finger in the wind, but it did, none the less, create a case where the figure will be published and the myth will, in time, become engrained as revisionist history.

The other issue that got a lot of play regarded MLB’s willingness to offer a 20% ownership equity in The MLB Channel to DirecTV, while not giving this same offer to the incumbents. As Carl Vogel of EchoStar said, “However, in its entirety must be apples to apples, which will require EchoStar to acquire a pro-rata ownership of The MLB Channel,” Carey said in his opening statement. “In a letter dated March 22nd, from Major League Baseball, they state they are not in a position to offer any equity in connection with this ‘opt-in’ opportunity without DirecTV’s consent. It will be interesting to see whether that consent is forthcoming, and with what conditions, as DirecTV reconciles whether it wears its ownership hat for the MLB Channel or its hat as a competitive distributor.”

While DISH has seemed almost a secondary player in all of this, word came late yesterday by way of the Sports Business Journal, that EchoStar has offered up, what they feel, matches MLB’s terms as it pertains to financials, and distribution. For the deal to fly, EchoStar is asking for an ownership stake in The Baseball Channel, as well. The sides were reportedly mulling the offer over.

The biggest question is, what is MLB’s endgame in all of this?

As I’ve reported before, the exclusive deal does not make good long-term business sense. Limiting viewers is a poor growth model, beyond the ill-will that has been created in this process. No matter how many times you turn the deal over in your head, one asks if by not making the deal exclusive, if MLB would have come out financially in the long run.

iN Demand offered $70 million per-year in a non-exclusive arrangement. If DirecTV offered half of what they are offering in an exclusive arrangement ($50 million), MLB would come out $20 million a year ahead of where they are now, and that’s without DISH in play. Maybe it’s a matter of driving consumers to MLB.TV. After all Bob DuPuy said yesterday, “If iN Demand and Dish choose not to step up to the plate as DirecTV has done, fans will still have several options.  They can switch to DirecTV, they can subscribe to MLB.TV and watch the games on the Internet, and they can watch the roughly 400 games that every fan in every Major League market has available without the out-of-market package.” That’s convenient. MLB will pull in revenues from the displaced through their online offering. Still, is it going to be enough to offset the revenues that could have been pulled in by keeping all the incumbents in the fold?

Added to this, there is more of the “ill-will” factor as it pertains to the relationship that MLB needs to keep with cable. Is it simply not a matter of time before MLB comes to cable looking to get The MLB Channel carried?

So, to repeat, the deal makes poor long-term business sense, outside of fan ill-will.

Lastly, I should note (once again) that I’ve been a DirecTV subscriber for some time and chose to do so for reasons outside of Extra Innings. Still, I’ve subscribed to EI in the past, and will continue to do so in the future. With that, and the season on the cusp, I looked up the schedule. Sunday, there was a limited slate of games on tap. Now, DirecTV is showing a more complete slate of games to choose from. At least that’s one less matter to be critical of in what might be deemed “ExtraInningsGate”.

 Maury Brown is the founder and president of The Biz of Baseball and an author for Baseball Prospectus. He can be contacted here. 

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?