dave ramsey credit cards youtube how to apply credit card from sbi chase circuit city credit card log in halifax credit card fees abroad rbs credit card online payment option continental airlines one pass credit card login find security code credit card without card canadian credit card ranking secured bank credit cards wachovia designer mens credit card holder my credit card access best credit card consolidation loans first citizens credit card services icici bank credit card customer care number mumbai officemax credit card us airways bonus miles credit card credit cards for credit scores below 600 credit card reader uk chase credit card balance transfer calculator speedway credit card promo code fake visa credit card number and expiration date deutsche bank credit card india offer axis bank credit card secure code good credit card limited credit history apply for hdfc credit card india itunes wont accept my credit card security number how does opening and closing a credit card affect credit score credit card with bad credit rating hello kitty credit cards bank america el dorado credit card wells fargo chase credit card amazon rewards what is the average credit card debt in the us snowball credit card payoff calculator fake credit card numbers for xbox live interest rates credit card consolidation hsbc credit card customer service address disney chase rewards credit card verifone credit card reader iphone new york company credit card online login free trial fax no credit card required credit rating credit cards india stolen credit card numbers for sale credit card airline miles rewards prepaid credit card google wallet chase credit card students review engraved credit card bottle openers general information on credit cards apply nordstrom rack credit card everywhere santander 0 credit card balance transfer get sbi credit card india gives highest credit card limit kidd kraddick credit card roulette app apply golden 1 credit card short term credit card machine rental mobile credit card machine hsbc platinum visa credit card kohls credit card secure log in compare credit cards for travel points pay chase credit card bank branch hess oil credit card application how do you rent a car without a major credit card frontier airlines credit card miles stop credit card interest rate calls pay my buckle credit card 1st credit card bank do we need credit card for apple id apps paying federal taxes with a credit card best credit cards elite status 5 star credit card cheap credit card to use abroad accept card credit site credit card processing small companies herbergers credit card payment best credit first credit card paypal iphone credit card reader canada chase credit card bank account care credit credit card login best credit cards for gas discounts 0 interest credit card tesco compromised credit card ge money sports credit cards best credit card for college students with bad credit tire kingdom credit card account online can i apply for a credit card with no credit history visa secured credit card application make apple account without giving credit card details shell credit card payment phone number fake credit card info sites daily interest calculator credit card hsbc credit card insurance claim how to get cash advance from bank of america credit card personal consolidation loans for credit cards best buy credit card mastercard application apply petland credit card best credit card for purchases abroad davids bridal credit card online bill pay orchard bank secured credit card for bad credit should cancel my credit card annual fee free credit card reader for laptop firestone auto credit card christian credit card debt chase credit card payment login major credit card companies american express credit card uk national bank credit card interest rates how to set up credit card processing for business best business credit card balance transfer does bass pro shop have credit cards how does capital one secured credit card work credit card paper what is the minimum credit score to get a walmart credit card what are interest rates on credit cards how to apply credit cards online credit card choices royal bank credit cards pay off credit card with debit card student visa credit cards hdfc bank credit card travel offers american airlines business credit card rebate credit cards gas the home depot credit card alaska airlines credit card application canada minimum monthly payment credit card calculator loan to pay off credit card debt can you get secured credit card after bankruptcy pre qualify credit cards bank of america eastwest bank credit card rewards catalogue 2012 pay my credit card bank of america credit cards fees tax deductible hsbc usa credit card payment considered high credit card interest rate where can i use my discount tire credit card bdo credit card promo 2012 credit card with no limit how to check my credit card balance online reduce credit card debt scams apply murphy usa credit card canceling credit cards affect credit score paypal do you need a credit card playstation network says credit card info invalid when should i pay my credit card balance most elite credit cards world compare sky mile credit cards marriott visa credit card login preapproved credit card then denied process credit cards your android phone bad credit need a credit card with no upfront setup fees declined credit card reasons pay off natwest credit card can you get cashback on a capital one credit card credit card swipe application online apply for icici credit card in india how to use gift credit cards online bp visa credit card account how to pay wells fargo credit card with another credit card credit card verification value plastic credit cards uk should i pay my credit card bills less than good credit credit cards hsbc premier credit card reward chase credit card exchange rate foreign transaction fees free virtual credit card number generator hsbc best buy credit card home page prepaid credit cards in usa citifinancial credit card services hdfc credit card payment online other bank account cell phone case with credit card slot wachovia credit card rewards buy credit card details website charged off credit card starwood credit card uk zero percent credit cards explained easy way accept credit card payments flagstar bank credit card login compare credit cards for travel credit card without annual fee australia best prepaid credit cards reviews apply for visa credit card with fair credit credit card debt programs types of credit cards in hdfc bank hdfc bank platinum credit card offers number call activate chase credit card credit card swipe machine called prepaid visa credit card chase sapphire credit card application interest calculator credit card monthly interest rate ashley stewart credit card online your credit card account sst how do you pay bank of america credit card online citibank credit card philippines hotline number recommended credit cards consumer reports can you pay your federal taxes credit card rbs bank credit card login your credit card company charges 18 apr (annual percentage rate ) calculate credit card interest amount ocbc credit card chevron gas credit card login american airline mileage credit cards apply new egg credit card omaha first national bank credit card payment disney dooney credit card holder order form template with credit card information long does take paypal verify credit card credit card people bad credit no annual fee cvv number credit card american express what is best credit card to use in europe sia letter of indemnity for credit card payment best credit card balance transfer deals australia best credit card debt reduction services create apple id need credit card convenience checks cash credit card company tata sbi credit card login real visa credit card numbers 2012 does credit card number get compromised top credit card reward offers should i get the united or continental credit card international credit card fees usaa easiest store credit card to get approved for 2012 should i close unused credit card accounts how do i transfer credit card balances to another card pay boa credit cards how to cancel old navy credit card pier 1 credit card change credit card advantages and disadvantages pnc points credit card log temporary credit card terminal brylane home credit card login us credit card debt graph settle debt credit card company less credit cards cash advance interest rates kotak easyday credit card login bankruptcy on credit cards only hdfc bank credit card status credit card checks use need help paying credit card bills bad credit business credit cards apply for instant credit card online credit cardholders; bill of rights act of 2008 compare hotel credit cards free secured credit cards rebuild credit fia credit card bank of america best credit card transfer rates australia american airlines credit card 30 000 miles credit card number length us apply for lloyds tsb student credit card abn amro credit card services online how to pay my state farm credit card online southwest airlines credit card payment jared jewelers credit card wfnnb credit card younkers 5 3 credit card online best credit cards in india+reviews can credit card companies garnish wages pa best unsecured credit card for no credit 0 credit card offers good credit hdfc gold credit card interest rate calculation bt credit card 1 2 3 cash back credit card credit card reform act wiki congress credit card expiration date format gardner white credit card log what is the interest rate on a best buy credit card credit card swipe for home computer american signature credit card pay online big o tires credit cards phone insurance through credit card should i pay off credit card or save best credit card hotel reward program best credit cards with frequent flyer points college students credit cards statistics rbs credit card india online credit card number checker/generator how to make a credit card claim where can i rent a car with a prepaid credit card citi credit cards bill payment use cell phone credit card terminal best credit card processing for small business best flight rewards credit card australia store credit cards british airways credit card fees how can i get a credit card quickly aaa visa credit card benefits case-mate iphone 3g 3gs credit card case in silver credit card swiper for iphone canada get annual credit card fee waived chase credit card disney points credit card swipe fees 2011 halifax online credit card services credit cards with no deposit required chase freedom credit card account login details shell credit card secure log in what is my wells fargo credit card apr can apply big lots credit card online lost old navy credit card best credit card system for ipad 5000 credit card no credit check unsecured credit card help rebuild credit american airlines aadvantage credit card review worst credit card debt best zero cash advance credit cards number activate chase freedom credit card cell phone credit card bill payment hdfc online 1099 cancellation of debt credit card mbna credit card points green credit card hsbc how to use a credit card machine rebuild credit cards chase sears credit card online payment process apply low limit credit card where is the credit card number card consolidation credit loan princess cruise visa credit card how to get a prepaid credit card credit cards that help build credit chase priority club credit card business rewards credit cards credit card selection criteria american express credit card pay bill online pay my rooms to go credit card online credit card theft using rfid kardashian credit card scandal credit card interest calculator apr apply jcpenney credit card phone best credit cards 0 percent interest secured credit cards build credit fast new york times taxi credit card wells fargo financial credit card bill pay high school student credit cards best credit card processing for small businesses vending machines accept credit cards wireless credit card terminals small business airlines miles credit card american express chip and pin credit card monthly credit card rate calculator chase credit cards payment login we accept credit cards paypal best iphone credit card app 2012 barclays credit card dining offers help need credit card fastest best credit card zero interest balance transfer paid off credit card charged interest joint credit card with parents apply for credit card uk online where else can i use my new york and company credit card card guard rfid blocking aluminum credit card holder credit cards does qvc accept free pos system with credit card processing how to process credit card payments by phone how to eliminate credit card debt without filing bankruptcy credit card for travel money hsbc credit card personal account protection discover credit card travel protection choose credit card processing provider compare the market pre paid credit cards southwest rapid rewards credit card no annual fee chase bank credit cards for college students interest free credit card balance transfers australia how to get a cash advance with a credit card obama credit card debt program fnb silver credit card interest rate sams credit card payment mailing address how do i find out old credit card details can buy western union order credit card send money best credit card scanner for ipad best intro apr credit card hdfc credit cards customer care number bangalore using a 401k loan to pay off a credit card transaction central credit card happens credit card debt chapter 13 bankruptcy hdfc titanium credit card 5 cash back royal caribbean credit card charges best choice first credit card can get credit card without credit remove rfid chip credit card walmart prepaid credit card visa is this the end of credit cards motley fool sears hsbc credit card payments art van credit card login get out credit card debt government assistance what are the best credit cards for fair credit what is considered a good interest rate on a credit card kroger credit card payment address phone credit card reader canada best starter credit cards 2010 gap credit cards customer service can you pay your taxes credit card using turbo tax can i pay my credit card bill with a debit card no credit card itunes registration credit card 0 transfer deals high limit credit cards with fair credit how to get a credit card machine for my business scotiabank prepaid credit cards canada a list of credit card numbers that work can i pay my bestbuy credit card with a best buy gift card dbs bank credit card singapore chase credit card login usa new acm wallet credit card holder & money clip hybrid credit card chargeback process flow amex credit card rfid hack can i pay my credit card bill with my paypal account chase freedom vs chase slate credit cards account number on credit card receipt free credit card security code numbers halifax one credit card address amazon payment two credit cards aaa prepaid credit card questions to ask before getting a credit card how does the angel credit card work are purchases made on credit card insured american express business credit card application what is credit card processing wiki air new zealand credit card airpoints credit cards for international students in malaysia credit card with travel insurance uk fuelperks credit card hsbc cancel credit card transaction find best credit card canada credit card size plastic wallets intuit credit card reader for android steam paypal need credit card first usa credit card payment address personal loan vs credit card loan ppi credit card refund calculator cash advance fee capital one credit cards activate wells fargo credit card can you take out a loan to pay off credit card debt how to qualify for a credit card after bankruptcy how to change your credit card info on playstation network how to pay my capital one credit card online us bank hobby lobby credit card get credit card us billing address gap credit card paperless statements paypal credit card type codes ge capital retail bank credit card ashley furniture pay off credit card debt good credit iphone case credit card holder leather sbi credit card payment online from other bank credit card psd download can i use a credit card to pay through paypal credit cards for people with no social security number pay my one stop plus credit card unsecured credit cards for people with poor credit hsbc credit card cash back offer compare credit card offers australia check hdfc credit card online statement davids bridal credit card phone number comerica credit card login applied bank credit card bad credit what happens if i can;t pay my credit card bills high limit credit cards for people with fair credit is target credit card easy to get cancel zales credit card new hsbc credit card apply pre qualify sample credit card merchant agreement walmart credit card no interest 12 months 2012 credit card act 2009 compare american airline credit cards hsbc credit card best buy credit card 0 balance transfer low fee can i transfer a credit card balance to another person credit cards help build credit no annual fee how does credit card cash advances work resume - credit card sales manager kiplinger;s best credit cards 2010 pay taxes online with credit card apply sears credit card phone buy credit cards how do i calculate interest charges on my credit card capital one online credit cards uk travel reward credit card comparison canada abn amro credit card login page real credits card numbers capitol one credit card login free credit card transfer offers credit card program c++ abn amro credit card apply online in india priority club rewards credit card offers do i need to have a credit card to apply for paypal small credit card reader solveras credit card processing complaints credit card number with security code non-profit credit card debt counseling benefits banks issuing credit cards sams club credit card policy disadvantages about credit cards baby r us credit card application answer summons complaint credit card debt jp chase corporate credit card citizens banks credit card report bad credit card companies cancel credit card letter template does credit card information encrypted credit cards with money already on them for bad credit add credit card paypal best credit card with poor credit rating can delete my credit card information itunes best value credit cards singapore vanquis credit card check balance how to create a apple id without a credit card for ipad make payment american express credit card online hdfc credit card apply in india compare american express credit cards india credit card swipe machines bdo credit card philippines requirements bank credit cards bp amoco credit card customer service credit cards application india best credit card cash back bonus zero interest balance transfer credit card offers credit card annual fee tax deductible credit card interest rate calculator compare remove credit card paypal limited credit cards with the best flight rewards low interest visa credit card offers best signup bonus credit card 2010 chase pier one credit card login best credit cards build credit rating best credit card processor for small business ipad credit card reader paypal playstation network says my credit card invalid best prepaid credit card canada 2011 prepaid credit cards rush card how to make your own virtual credit card credit card reform act provisions phillips 66 conoco 76 gas credit card credit card helpline sbi how can i pay my walmart credit card best united continental credit card sears credit cards sign in canadian credit cards low rate credit cards with 0 commission on purchases overseas bank of iberia credit card only paying minimum balance on credit card best business corporate credit card how many numbers in a credit card hidden fees increase cost using credit card can pay my bestbuy credit card store visa bank of america credit card rewards sam s club credit card application credit card lawsuit in the philippines chase credit cards rewards catalog express fashion credit card payment online husky mohawk credit card santander 123 credit card contact first equity credit card phone number best cash back credit cards clark howard can credit card companies garnish my wages in texas delta skymiles credit card comparison free trial netflix no credit card lost my old navy credit card credit card chargeback limit buy prepaid credit card paypal canada best credit cards for new small businesses free stolen credit card numbers work best store cards to build credit pay saks credit card online advantages business accepting credit card halifax ’®5 cash back credit card credit card deals new purchases need a credit card number for paypal apply chase credit card no credit history citibank credit card customer care number mumbai led credit card lightbulb horizon credit card review check my credit card billing address helzberg diamond credit card customer service princess credit card barclays accept credit card payments your iphone musicians friend credit card hard get apply student credit card bank of america can i pay credit card with another credit card car rental insurance credit card personal loans for consolidating credit cards ae visa credit card payment halifax credit card complaints address my first premier credit card pay online premier secured credit card reviews how do i change my credit card information on psn credit card points apply gap credit card online what is the issue number on a solo credit card can jcpenney credit cards used bank of america online shopping credit card credit cards with cash advance standard chartered bank credit card online payment in india how to open a credit card in bdo credit card frequent flyer miles comparison what are the worst credit cards to have apply sears credit card store bank of america credit card processing fees need secured credit card with bad credit pay off credit card or save reloadable credit cards for kids maybank credit card center jalan melaka best credit card to earn points for travel 1099 reporting credit card purchases secured credit cards how do they work how to apply for a credit card for my business can i pay toyota financial services with a credit card credit rating credit card debt ratio check status my macy;s credit card application can you pay income tax with a credit card hsbc closed my credit card account 2nd chance secured credit cards citi bank college credit cards ge credit card login in bank america worldpoints visa signature credit card pay hdfc credit card bill citibank online usaa world credit card review what credit cards are under mbna credit card with fair credit history charity credit cards australia credit card pan number nfc credit card app pay rent online with credit card can get credit card fast can you make online purchases with a prepaid credit card world market card credit card credit card vs charge card amex company credit card abuse how much do credit cards cost merchants credit card pre approval citi credit union credit card comparison credit cards free to use abroad lucky stores credit card readers credit cards to build your credit up why can i not get a credit card credit card fair credit visa bank of america business credit card no personal guarantee how good are capital one credit cards should i take out a loan to pay off credit card debt 2 charge for using a credit card credit card search canada pay sam;s club business credit card pay dillards american express credit card remove credit card ipad 2 fleet credit card services horsham pa visa credit gift cards make payment my lowes credit card 2012 best credit card processing with merchant accounts kohls credit card balance phone number best credit card interest rate offers southwest visa credit card 5/3 credit card rewards credit cards for first time credit card holders many people have credit cards debt how long will it take to pay off my credit card balance cancel chase credit card number samsung credit card mobile phone us bank rei credit card login european credit card chip pin credit cards with rebates victoria secret credit card pay bill online apply standard chartered credit card singapore best credit card terminal for ipad what happens if you charge off a credit card credit card login barclays secu credit card rates best credit cards 2011 lowest interest dating sites 100 free no credit cards mbna cuts rewards on popular credit card lost capital one credit card phone number amazon credit card payment visa check credit score without credit card information secured credit card list best credit card with rewards 2012 negotiating credit card debt with chase bank who has the best gas credit card credit card app for iphone 4s icici bank credit card statement online payment list of credit cards in uk credit cards for unemployed uk abnb secured credit card low interest credit cards for life of balance transfer pay new york and company credit card can you pay chase credit card bank does wells fargo accept credit cards mortgage payment b edd credit card pnc credit card services login exxon gas credit card does paying minimum payment on credit card affect credit score credit card 0 interest 6 months racetrac credit card application chase personal credit card can you buy stuff online without a credit card free prepaid credit card codes basic credit card number validation nurit 3010 wireless credit card terminal chase credit card travel rewards can create apple store account without credit card orchard bank credit card online billpay best cash back credit card 2012 non chip credit cards in europe credit cards for businesses with rewards archstone pay rent credit card security credit card wallet american express gold credit card with cashback how to apply credit card in hdfc bank get your money back credit card company get new credit card international credit card address verification no interest no balance transfer fee credit cards littman and barclay credit card log in best credit cards fidelity american express credit card deals balance transfer and no transfer fee old navy credit card phone number popular credit cards in canada wedding credit card new york credit card debt statute limitations citifinancial credit cards canada meineke credit card store your credit cards iphone blue sky credit card good how to pay hsbc credit card online payment best credit card get flight miles virgin black card credit card review home depot credit card balance good credit cards for someone building credit credit card billing cycle 1099 reporting changes credit card chase disney credit card login in applied portable credit card terminals for sale undergear credit card online payments hsbc nevada credit card exclusive credit cards in india top 0 credit card offers credit card for poor credit score uk credit card verification value cvv does not match credit card can you use a credit card to pay through paypal frequent flyer credit cards australia starter credit card offers can i pay kohls credit card in store business credit cards bad credit cancel regions credit card does agoda charge my credit card does bank america credit card covers rental car insurance is visa electron a credit card or debit card low introductory rate credit cards in canada american airlines credit card best deal credo working assets credit card is it safe to link credit card to psn what is the security number on my credit card standard chartered bank credit card customer care toll free number fia credit card changing to bank of america how long does it take to build credit with secured credit cards how to consolidate student loans and credit cards gordmans credit card chase united mileage plus credit card phone number 76 gasoline credit card alaska airlines credit card fees starbucks credit card processing earn american airline miles credit card cabelas credit card review change my credit card google account aopa credit card best cash back credit card forum barclays credit card login india credit card issuer identifier numbers walmart credit cards apply for a chase bank credit card mens money credit card clip best credit cards for college students 2011 dillard credit card services rbi rules credit card collection chase best buy pay credit card pay hsbc credit card online payment check status gap credit card application bad credit credit cards mastercard metrostyle credit card log best 0 credit cards for transfers credit card regex starwood credit card canada 2010 best secured credit card no fee my chase credit cards british airways free online dating site no credit card requirement best credit cards new credit credit card apps for droid phones best credit card for purchases online centon 16gb datastick credit card usb flash drive best time of day to apply for a credit card reverse phone lookup without credit card are credit cards accepted at the mn state fair credit card bonus points gas best credit card processing ipad credit cards for people with bankruptcy how to get a chip and pin credit card in the us best credit card app for blackberry icici credit card payment status online credit card payment hsbc billdesk why do i have to put credit card info for apple id best unsecured credit card for fair credit custom visa credit card wells fargo tata sky hd credit card best credit card backgrounds amazon credit card payment online ge secured credit cards to rebuild your credit online credit card payment processing canada bpi credit card change billing address hdfc credit card cash transfer best cash credit cards what is meant by the phrase consolidating credit card debt prepaid credit cards improve your credit score low interest loans pay off credit card citi credit card convenience checks if your credit card declined does affect your credit score pay my salute credit card online purchase prepaid credit card usa american express credit card pin number iberia credit card application hsbc credit card account sign in second chance credit card quebec mens slim credit card wallets pay a paypal account by credit card paying taxes with credit card bankruptcy credit card or debit card in europe virgin credit card login uk capital one credit card offers specials credit card factoring illegal debt consolidation credit card debt the best prepaid credit cards bank of america pay online credit card citibank secured credit card no annual fee can you get mortgage credit card debt air miles credit cards usa can you use reloadable credit card paypal can i buy a car with a credit card 2011 free credit report canada no credit card required cortrust credit card payment address whats a good first credit card to apply for easy to get retail credit cards wells fargo secured credit card deposit refund can pay my chase credit card bill chase bank itself how to get a pin number for bank of america credit card credit cards that use household income top ten credit card issuers 2009 credit card debt forgiveness act 2009 tesco credit card 0 balance transfer virtual credit card terminal canada wells fargo credit cards secured lowes credit card login mobile credit card act business accounts petrol cash rebate credit card malaysia best balance transfer credit cards 0 citibank credit cards customer care number chennai walmart payment online credit card cheap credit card rates ireland credit card wallet refill how to remove credit card from amazon create paypal account without credit card dbs credit card travel insurance best companies consolidating credit cards how do i addicting games a credit card to my amazon account no limit credit card amex direct access credit card fax number cheapest credit card processing machine hdfc credit card reward point redemption platinum plus southwest credit card offers credit cards business no credit history harrah;s total rewards credit card review airlines credit cards rewards bpi credit card rewards redemption form prepaid credit cards help establish credit apply meijers credit card your credit card could not authorized xbox live does visa gift card work like credit card victoria secret credit card payment online jp morgan chase credit cards redeem visa points credit card credits lump sum settlement of credit card debt chase credit card perks pay citibank credit card through cheque apply online for hdfc silver credit card pentagon federal credit union platinum cash rewards credit card bank of america credit card cover rental car insurance can you use your wells fargo debit card as a credit card credit cards citi sign credit card payment gateway transferring credit card balances to another person can pay my wells fargo credit card atm dillards credit card customer service phone number stores credit cards people bad credit bank america credit card transfer fee can you rent a car without a major credit card how to delete credit card info from apple id compare secured credit card canada buy prepaid credit cards walgreens credit card companies rental insurance australian credit cards no international transaction fees 28 degrees credit card exchange rate apply for citi prepaid credit card hotel rewards credit cards new small business credit card bass pro shops credit card promotions 40 000 united miles credit card fidelity retirement rewards credit card review delta credit cards reviews new credit card laws 2010 canada american express delta gold credit card review huntington bank credit card machine ladies wallets credit card slots lowest credit cards australia what is the black strip on the back of a credit card how much does quickbooks credit card processing cost value city credit card login gold pearl credit card how do i accept credit cards with my iphone apple add photo bank america credit card card credit debt letter settlement sample stop offers credit card running debit card as credit or debit credit card number hack 2012 saks fifth ave credit card payment what does variable apr on credit cards mean how best to pay down credit card debt once big o tire credit card payment no income credit card student transferring credit card balances worth need credit card right now secured credit cards banks chase bank credit card consolidation become credit card payment processor obama credit card reduction act best credit card for college kids bank of america credit card customer service mailing address best transfer credit card offers bank of america upromise credit card customer service how do you make your credit card primary on paypal credit cards with the best travel rewards torrid credit card phone number transfer credit cards good credit what is the limit on a capital one secured credit card what credit cards are offering balance transfers at 0 citi secured credit card review southwest airline credit card 2 free flights top reward credit cards 2011 unsecured credit card bad credit people credit card payment form uk passport credit repair credit cards uk granite credit card online login capital one credit card mileage match walmart credit card denied best credit card apply uk using credit card build credit history credit cards business no credit no personal credit paying off credit card debt increase credit score at&t universal credit card login top secured credit cards with no annual fee united chase credit card 50 000 miles best cash back credit card reward programs citi credit card payments free credit card clipart chase bank credit card for college students apply for sears credit card now clark howard credit card consolidation report credit card market india choice credit card visa national penn bank credit card online ny company credit card pay bill southwest credit cards rewards credit card apr rate calculator wireless credit card swipe machine india choosing credit cards credit cards that don;t work in europe remove credit card google market bp visa credit card review capital bank credit card processing business credit card offer transferring credit card balances capital one credit card payment protection insurance credit card american signature united credit card 500000 free miles what will happen if i can;t pay my credit cards credit card market share standard chartered platinum credit card benefits what are the advantages and disadvantages of using a credit card what credit score do i need for citi simplicity card long do need have secured credit card better best credit cards for merchants small business gas credit card square credit card receipt printer chase visa credit card disney gap credit card services contact should i cancel my credit cards when i pay them off applying credit cards hurt credit score starter credit cards to help rebuild credit best capital one credit card international travel tesco credit card cash withdrawal fee elan financial credit card customer service check credit card number java illegal charge customers credit card processing fee where can i make sears credit card payments change credit card on ps3 student visa credit card state farm pay chase credit card at atm fake credit card generator security codes microcenter credit card payment wells fargo credit card accountability responsibility and disclosure act of 2009 gift cards national average credit card rates how to change credit card info on itunes on ipad credit card travel miles best credit card balance transfer offers bad credit hsbc bank credit card agreement free credit card security code generator software fixed rate credit card visa can i pay for a new car with a credit card interest free credit cards purchases 12 months chase credit card lawsuit 2009 picture of a credit card statement amex platinum credit card singapore ok credit credit cards frontier airlines credit card login government agency credit card complaints chase credit card machine services pay jcp credit card online with credit card new texas credit card debt law change credit card pin citibank credit card small business bad credit hsbc online credit card bill payment billdesk much money does average american household owe credit cards standard chartered bank india credit card application status ge credit cards login capital one online banking credit cards canada car rentals without credit card credit card applications fair good credit credit card debt forgiveness taxable how do i pay my credit card bill online nationwide chase credit card customer service telephone airlines credit card india california credit card surcharge laws best credit cards for airline miles rewards usc credit union credit card login virgin atlantic miles credit card where to buy credit card sales slips credit cards airline miles india what is the best secured credit card to get after bankruptcy refinance credit card debt online credit card application philippines ofw chase paying credit card online rei credit card application status new slimline digital camera the size of credit card best credit card offers with balance transfers credit card check digit best credit card offers balance transfers 2011 need card now have bad credit score credit cards issued by first bank of delaware my chase credit card british airways credit card reader writer sale merchandise credit cards online pay off high apr credit card discover student card average credit limit student credit card statistics 2011 college credit card debt average paying off credit card debt options airline credit card surcharges bad credit credit cards low fees free credit report canada online no credit card spirit airlines credit card points best low interest rate credit card cash back credit card gas hack credit card information 2010 pay avenue credit card bill online apply sovereign bank credit card sbi credit card online application best rewards credit card for gasoline credit card signature code american express best business rewards credit card 2012 hdfc credit cards application status iphone 4 case credit card storage low apr credit cards low credit american airline credit card bonus miles pc richard and son credit card payment online long after bankruptcy can you get secured credit card citi visa credit card login there any government help credit card debt credit card size 8gb storage device get credit card today canada credit card offer comparison calculator how to apply for a hsbc credit card in india how much are merchant fees for credit cards go master credit cards get secured credit card credit union buy bitcoins with credit card australia priority club credit card 80 000 points bremer credit card login credit cards low interest rates rewards 76 gas station credit card payment best travel credit card canada hsbc gold visa credit card uk what info do you need to apply for a credit card harlem furniture credit card online how do you pay off amazon credit card earn frequent flyer miles credit cards disney rewards credit card designs credit card versus debit card credit card app for blackberry easy credit cards to get approved with no credit how to rent a car in spain without a credit card frequency do credit card rfid use what is a secured credit card from capital one providian bank credit card bad credit spirit credit card application status owl credit card magnifier compare credit cards airline rewards can i pay irs taxes by credit card capital one credit card foreign transaction fee rfid credit card hackers store card vs credit card credit card lightbulb uk the best credit card for travelling overseas fidelity 529 credit card rewards how to stop receiving credit card offers in the mail bank of america credit card student platinum plus best credit card deals for travel best unsecured credit cards to build credit prime rate credit cards today brooks brother credit card login used credit card terminals credit cards for good credit elan credit card make payment visa credit cards uk private label credit card market share new credit card rules for merchants credit card payment protection insurance claims credit card for military spouse do you need credit secured credit card visa credit card number 2012 accept credit cards on website paypal newegg credit card credit score merchant credit card receipt retention paypal plus credit card online payment want pay my tj maxx credit card interest free credit card new purchases alaska air miles credit card does declined credit card application affect credit score register credit card mileage plus promotional leather credit card holders difference between best buy credit cards using american credit cards in france kohl credit card application having 2 secured credit cards what do you need to get a secured credit card bank america secured credit card online unsolicited credit card act 1977 what is the black strip on a credit card elan credit card services phone number kotak credit card offers best credit cards first time credit card holders macy;s american express credit card payment address comparing credit cards in singapore history of the first credit card prepaid debit card for bad credit compare student credit cards hawaiian airline credit card review how can i get a free credit report without a credit card in canada fast way to reduce credit card debt halifax one credit card balance transfer american express credit card payment phone number low limit credit card for internet purchases best credit cards to apply for online starwood hotel credit card canada bad credit cards no deposit instant approval real credit card numbers work 2012 can u pay credit card western union money best credit card for frequent flyer miles add credit card paypal test account refinance mortgage pay off credit card debt using a credit card to pay for gas cash back on credit cards bank of america pay my microcenter credit card comerica bank credit card services credit card cash back compare credit card refinance calculator best and worst rewards credit cards free credit card website templates credit card machine for iphone app determine credit card type java what is a finance charge on a credit card statement cibc drivers edge credit card credit union secured credit card offers closing credit cards and your credit score lowering credit card interest rates chase what is the best credit card to use for balance transfers why does my credit card get declined online contactless credit card rfid rfid credit card sleeve protectors hsbc bon ton credit card commerce bank credit card customer service number icici bank credit card customer care number chennai credit card on paypal order replacement credit card bank america hdfc credit card points redeem titanium victoria secret angel vip credit card how long will it take to pay off my credit card with minimum payments jal credit card review tesco credit card price protection pay off my credit card debt credit card debt loan modification accepting credit card best credits cards for bad credit ing vysya bank credit card eligibility credit cards with the best rewards programs 2011 how to pay off my credit cards quickly the roomstore credit card chase closed credit card account balance citicards credit card sign in can you pay your credit card bill with a money order credit card for medium risk credit credit card low apr transfer annual fee can i use my abercrombie credit card at gilly hicks southwest visa credit card chase business credit cards hsbc credit card rates increase yankees logo credit card get new credit card sbi view credit card e statement axis bank absa gold credit card from american express square credit card reader iphone 5 death credit card debt uk how many credit card miles do you need for a flight have bad credit need credit card australia hsbc best buy credit card website icici credit card payment neft how do i apply for a business credit card pay irs credit card phone capital one standard platinum credit card hsbc corporate credit card application turkish airlines credit card holder request close credit card letter se 11 function credit card size survival pocket tool are credit card processing fees cost of goods sold apply for a natwest credit card online how can i apply for a credit card at 17 southwest credit card login in american express cards credit cards best credit cards to start building credit best first credit cards build credit bank of america credit cards review getting a credit card in dubai balance transfer offers credit cards gap credit card customer service telephone number best reward credit card uk credit card debt laws canada create apple id without credit card 2012 get credit card details online get a visa credit card today need visa credit card now lets hsbc visa platinum credit card offers legacy first national bank credit card login services peggy credit card commercials manhattan credit card payment online india household bank secured credit card review first credit card no credit history no annual fee best buy credit card log in accept credit cards ipad paypal 2009 credit card statistics college students credit card mastercard visa costco credit cards accepted canada department store credit cards online kardashian credit card snl how do i pay my microcenter credit card first direct credit card interest rate sleepys credit card bank of america/ml credit card login credit card holder case with money clip value city furniture credit cards apply what is 3 digit code on back of credit card how does credit card interest work example chase consolidation credit card citibank india credit card application status credit card debt in america statistics 2010 cash back or travel credit card bank of america credit card for college student marriott credit card offers how to freeze credit card interest credit card affiliate programs pay off credit cards or invest high credit limit credit cards average credit credit card square process icici credit card reward points imint does apr variable mean credit cards online cvv generator for credit cards gifts reward points icici credit cards can i apply for a credit card with no job credit card scanners for android unable to pay credit card debt uk prepaid credit cards in canada ontario how do i accept credit cards for my small business what credit card should i get if i have bad credit amazon credit card germany offline credit card processing joomla credit card embossing machine for sale airline card credit mile united which are the best credit cards for students usaa american express secured credit card does the number of credit cards affect my credit rating chevron texaco credit card sign in verification code on credit card mastercard free unsecured credit cards for bad credit credit card 2 cash back rewards visa credit card from bank of america stop credit card companies checks sending them what is credit card skimming can credit card companies garnish your wages how to pay down credit cards calculators jp morgan chase gov credit card login us bank student credit cards want apply credit card no credit check paypal account needs credit card credit card agreement credit card debt relief programs legitimate pnc credit card services phone number credit cards numbers guitar center credit card limit manually enter credit card number square harbor freight credit card application united mileage plus credit card login chase bmo credit card car rental insurance apply for free credit card american express gold delta skymiles credit card can pay credit card through paypal ebay accept credit cards free website hdfc credit card payment online other bank credit card consumer reports travel rewards credit cards best credit cards delta miles transfer credit cards how to get a virtual credit card number how to pay citibank credit card bill by cheque safeway everyday rewards credit card new small business credit cards credit card industry news 2011 virtual citicards credit cards credit card reader for iphone best buy macy;s visa credit card apply barclays online credit card payment india free credit score check online no credit card sear credit card pay bill charter one credit card login hardship credit card programs single use credit card uk gas credit card comparison easiest approval business credit cards lane bryant credit card payment phone gold credit card with diamonds can retailers charge more for credit card use send money using credit card singapore can you use american credit cards in europe asiana credit card bank of america mastercard prepaid credit card australia use amazon credit card reward points how to make a small credit card holder business credit cards no balance transfer fees summit credit card visa can you buy a used car with a credit card credit card validation javascript chase visa phone number for stolen credit card merchants bank credit card payment world financial network national bank credit card address no money to pay credit cards credit card cash transfer to current account natwest student credit card login chase credit card security phone credit card debt solution companies titanium credit card limit hdfc first premier bank credit card pay by phone how to get cash advance on credit cards what is a prepaid credit card uk best rated iphone credit card reader delta airline credit card for 50000 bonus mile credit card minimum payment affect credit score credit card multi tool review is it bad to cancel a credit card hi res credit card logos vector ge money low rate mastercard credit card login 0 interest balance transfer credit card offer lone star bank credit card calculate my credit card interest payment illegal charge surcharge credit card purchases credit card number generator program activate student credit card natwest how do i change my credit card on me amazon account top airline credit cards paypal payflow pro credit card gateway easy way get credit card uk top rated credit card balance transfers simmons first visa platinum credit card review one time use credit card number bank of america lowest interest rate credit cards australia credit card theft electronic device disposable credit card number mastercard instant approval credit cards for people with no credit credit card act 2010 text tesco credit card ppi refunds business card credit clothing stores that have their own credit cards how do i check my credit score without credit card credit card psd vector number credit cards stolen online hdfc credit card reward points validity webster bank credit card processing sovereign credit card student test credit card numbers cvv paypal best free business credit cards american airlines credit card promotion 2011 how long will it take to pay off credit card balance united airlines credit card offer 2010 third party credit card processors best credit cards travel insurance canada credit cards for free air miles paypal credit card number theft tjx companies credit card data theft credit card arbitrage 2012 do credit cards readers work capital one credit card online banking sign in interest credit cards tax deductible business suze orman paying down credit card debt what credit score do you need to get a target red card best credit card for wedding expenses singapore report credit card identity theft chase credit card after bankruptcy office max credit card machine rolls credit card form templates excel credit card data breach 2012 good credit cards for recent college grads droid razr maxx credit card reader credit card gift vouchers wfnnb credit cards bon ton free experian credit report no credit card online access my credit card bcc pottery barn kids login to capital one credit card does being declined credit card affect credit rating pnc online credit card processing guaranteed canadian credit cards for bad credit can i pay my walmart credit card with a gift card citibank credit card malaysia promotion 2012 credit cards with no fees for bad credit citibank gold business credit card hp shopping credit card regulation z credit card changes prepaid credit card wikipedia cimb credit card redemption case-mate id credit card slim case for iphone 4 / 4s best citi credit card offers what is credit card billing address can we pay federal taxes with credit card credit cards with best buy credit card hsbc retail services citi bank credit card application status online interest free balance transfer credit cards no fee united credit card offer 50000 chase credit card debt consolidation line of credit vs credit card closing credit cards after paying off united 50000 mile credit card fee-harvesters low-credit high-cost cards bleed consumers cheapest credit card for overseas travel pays credit card swipe fees does paypal accept credit card payments setting up payment plans credit cards best credit card after bankruptcy 2011 best buy credit card annual fee credit card for android 53 bank credit card login hsbc us credit card rewards marathon oil credit card chase credit cards with chip and pin in usaa apply target store credit card best credit cards with rewards and no annual fee credit card limit calculator online bank of america credit card $400 cash back iphone credit card processing app reviews shopping credit cards credit card application requires further processing first credit card in the world what happens if i apply for a credit card and get denied how do i get pre-approved credit card offers b of a credit card bill payment chase best buy credit card customer service pay chase credit card by check att citi credit cards hsbc credit card india payment amex credit card uk login verizon credit card processing app victoria secret credit card payment address amex platinum credit card india singapore airlines credit card fees minimum credit score american express card natwest access credit card online alaska air credit card bonus chase rewards credit card catalog how long do i have to keep credit card statements my first credit card capital one citibank military credit cards us air credit card offer how do i cancel my wells fargo credit card fidelity bank bahamas credit card credit cards uk top 10 public bank credit card balance transfer promotion hsn credit card application status 2009 capital one credit card agreement how many numbers are in a mastercard credit card number credit card for balance transfer fair credit pay taxes credit card rebates new credit card legislation canada secured credit cards bad credit no deposits fee frontline secret history of the credit card credit cards bad credit instant approval australia jp morgan chase commercial credit cards washington mutual credit cards login home depot canada credit card balance orchard secured credit card reviews military credit cards 6 credit card receipt paper fd100 good first credit card company best credit card reader writer generate credit card numbers visa sears credit card secure login chapter 7 bankruptcy credit cards how to use paypal without credit card jpmorgan chase bank credit cards credit card processing rate increases best credit cards 2012 canada online business credit cards credit card number format visa best credit card available credit card rewards program ratings sears credit card application phone number best credit card for international travel 2012 virgin credit cards ppi united chase credit cards payments credit cards applications for bad credit high school students and credit cards prepaid credit card travelling abroad credit card issuers list chase credit card billing address what is the best credit card machine for small business old navy credit card pay online southwest credit card promotion capital one credit card uk online banking zippo’Ø engraved money clip & credit card case hp credit card payment center cost using square credit card reader bankof america credit card pay carbon fiber money clip credit card holder bb&t credit cards best buy credit card payment hsbc huntington credit card rewards cheap credit card wallets men credit card lawyers miami hsbc gold credit card apply online cash advance definition credit card what is a prepaid credit card citibank credit card philippines promo 2010 capital one credit card customer service us stop credit card offers united airlines buy a wireless credit card machine 5 dollar minimum purchase credit card= credit cards fixed interest rates credit card check java code halifax credit card payment number bank of ireland credit card rates the matrix secured credit card backdoor credit card phone numbers my free credit report no credit card bank america credit card photo expressions where can i use my nautilus credit card credit cards for military with bad credit victoria secret credit card canada no foreign transaction fee credit card usa how to pay old navy credit card bill online lufthansa miles and more credit cards speedway superamerica credit card payment pay sbi credit card bill online billdesk barclays bank delaware credit card complaints when is it best to pay credit card bill what is the easiest store credit card to get with bad credit what is a credit card cvv2 number delta bonus miles credit card how to get a capital one credit card with bad credit macys credit card lookup need help with paying credit cards first usa bank credit card address wells fargo retail credit card online payments credit card to help build credit score how to build credit without using credit cards reestablish credit cards make payment my hsn credit card credit card application status american express interest credit card deductible taxes usaa credit card services telephone number conns credit card customer service government program help credit card debt spg credit card dress barn online credit card payment bank of america credit card international usage make iphone stand out credit card buy visa virtual credit card get credit card numbers online free credit card balance transfer fee 0 intuit credit cards phone credit card cash back offer india apply american express credit card canada kotak credit card status enquiry bank of america credit card benefits information best credit card scanner for iphone brooks brothers credit card customer service phone number online shopping credit card number credit cards best balance transfer offers buy a credit card machine pay citizens credit card arco credit card fee credit card payoff calculator balance transfer low credit score credit cards uk is it better to pay off credit cards or save money deposit credit card bodog ways to get cash from credit card best credit card for a college student with no credit credit card calculator uk excel citibank havertys credit card credit card internet scams wireless terminal credit card processing credit card processing business model reducing credit card debt uk microsoft xbox live credit card charges excel minimum credit card payment formula cathay credit card promotion navy exchange credit card payment free no credit card required dating sites credit cards visa for students top ten airline credit cards can i transfer a student loan to a credit card barclaycard platinum credit card with long term balance transfer scotiabank momentum credit card review citi thank you credit card commercial bank america credit card services address apply for business credit card without a business applied bank unsecured credit cards best american airline mileage credit card best travel miles credit cards capital one platinum credit card rewards paying taxes with credit card apply for a debit card with bad credit instant approval calculate monthly interest charge credit card good credit cards for average credit rei credit card 100 how does a cash advance on a credit card work pay aa credit card online citibank credit card status statistics credit card use college students orchard credit card scam iphone 4 credit card app review haband credit card company should i get a bank loan to pay off credit card high limit credit cards for average credit credit cards people 700 credit score ae credit card payment online
Home Media News Opening Statement: Stephen F. Ross on DirecTV Deal

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 505 guests online

Atom RSS

Opening Statement: Stephen F. Ross on DirecTV Deal PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 10
Written by Stephen F. Ross   
Tuesday, 27 March 2007 04:32
Testimony of Professor Stephen F. Ross
Director, Penn State Institute for Sports Law, Policy and Research
The Pennsylvania State University
Before the
Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation
March 27, 2007
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee:
          It is an honor and privilege to be invited to join a panel of industry leaders to offer an independent view, based on over two decades of scholarship and teaching concerning sports and competition policy, in discussing the impediments to the free flow of interstate commerce as millions of Americans seek ways to take advantage of technological advances to watch non-local Major League Baseball games in their homes.
General Thoughts on Exclusive Dealing
          The issue before the Committee today is whether the exclusive dealing arrangement between Major League Baseball (MLB) and DirecTV, whereby DirecTV becomes the only source for out-of-market games not shown on national networks, is in the public interest.  As the Supreme Court has recognized,1 exclusive dealing arrangements are both legitimate and indeed can have pro-competitive effects.  In traditional markets where consumers have free access to retail markets, the Court has declared that, as a matter of antitrust law (in my view, this reasoning also applies to sound regulatory policy), these arrangements should only be questioned when there is a serious risk that they will foreclose access to supply or outlet by other firms.2  Thus, an agreement by Sears to exclusively sell Levi’s blue jeans is unlikely to harm consumers; there are ample other retail outlets for Levi’s rivals, and ample other jean manufacturers for Sears’ competitors.  If there are efficiencies in exclusivity, the likely market response is for Lee to reach an exclusive deal with Macy’s, etc.   Consumers unhappy with Sears’ selection are only harmed to the extent they have to walk across the shopping mall.
Harm to baseball fans
          In contrast, baseball fans face significant harm because of various pre-existing agreements as well as the recently announced exclusive MLB/DirecTV deal.   Those who have other reasons to prefer DishNetwork or cable must either forego quality telecasts of out-of-market baseball games,3 or suffer exploitation by subscribing to multiple multi-channel video distribution platforms that require the purchase of duplicate programming and unnecessary equipment.  The exclusive deal reinforces the harm that already befalls the millions of Americans who do not live within the local media market of their favorite team, because of a horizontal market division agreement entered into by MLB owners that, in the context of football, has been illegal for over 50 years.4  There is no public interest justification in forcing consumers to purchase a distribution platform that is inferior for their needs, or duplicate platforms, just to watch their favorite teams.  These consumers include:
  • Residents in areas with heavy thunderstorm activity (such as Florida) who prefer cable because of concerns about weather-related interference with important sports broadcasts
  • Residents of local markets (like metropolitan Philadelphia and southern New Jersey) who are fans of local basketball and hockey teams but out-of-market baseball teams, and would under planned agreements be required to subscribe to cable for some teams and satellite for others
  • Virtually all residents of states without a local team (like Alaska, Hawaii, or Nevada) or states with many retirees from other states (like Florida, California, or Arizona): there is no reason that the only way they can watch games of their favorite teams is to acquire a single product, MLB ExtraInningsTM,  from a single retailer, DirecTV
  • Consumers in multi-residence dwellings who are not allowed to select their preferred retailer, and where the landlord, homeowners’ association, or other decision-maker is insufficiently interested in baseball to switch to DirecTV
(Select Read More to see the rest of Ross' opening statement)
Restraints on Interstate Commerce: Horizontal Market Division
          To be clear, the agreement that sparked this hearing did not arise from the free market.  First, there is the horizontal market division by MLB owners.  Under the common law, the home team owns a property right in the radio and television rights to baseball games.5  However, the MLB owners have agreed to significant limitations on these common law rights.  Each club will only broadcast games in its assigned geographic territory, licensing the visiting club for the purpose of broadcasting games in its own home territory, and assigning to MLB the exclusive right to sell games not only to free-to-air networks (a right protected by the Sports Broadcasting Act) but most significantly the exclusive right to sell non-network games to satellite or cable only through MLB ExtraInningsTM (which is not exempt from antitrust scrutiny). 
          Were it not for this web of agreements, the MLB/DirecTV deal would raise few problems for consumers.  Those interested in the convenience of a single package of all out-of-market games could purchase ExtraInningsTM from DirecTV.  A Los Angeles Dodgers fan outside southern California, or someone who simply enjoyed the final years of play-by-play from hall-of-famer Vin Scully, would likely find it possible to purchase Dodger telecasts, acquired from the Dodgers by DirecTV, DishNetwork, or the local cable company.  Other intermediaries might offer a syndicate of games in competition with ExtraInningsTM.
          Antitrust precedents suggest that the MLB agreements are anti-competitive and ought to be illegal.  In United States v. National Football League,6 a very sophisticated district court decision that presaged by 30 years the antitrust analysis of broadcast restraints later adopted by the Supreme Court,7 the court noted that sports leagues had a unique interest in promoting competitive balance among member teams so that, to the extent that a rival team’s out-of-market telecast would significantly harm live attendance, the league could agree to prevent this.  However, the court rejected the NFL’s effort to bar out-of-market telecasts that simply competed with the home team’s telecast of road games: the only effect there was to limit output and raise rights fees for the home team, a result that was not legitimate or pro-competitive.  As later courts have recognized,8 leagues can adequately protect competitive balance with regard to television rights sales by revenue sharing, rather than output limits. 
          The courts have also recognized, in antitrust litigation, that broad licenses awarded by competing copyright holders through intermediaries can be pro-competitive, when these are non-exclusive licenses.  Thus, the Supreme Court rejected a lower court holding that Broadcast Music and ASCAP violated the Sherman Act by offering a blanket license for the vast majority of copyrighted songs.9 On remand, the court of appeals upheld the legality of the arrangement, but only after finding that potential licensees had real alternative ways of acquiring rights.10  This was because the Justice Department had challenged, many years ago, the agreement among almost all the nation’s songwriters to grant exclusive licenses to BMI or ASCAP – grants akin to the out-of-market assignments that individual team owners have made to DirecTV -- and the parties by consent decree had agreed to limit the license to a non-exclusive grant.11
          It is bad enough that these agreements meet the “hallmark” definition of unreasonable restraints of trade, by increasing price, reducing output, and rendering output unresponsive to consumer demand.12  In fact, these agreements are even more inefficient and anti-competitive than would be the case if all rights to all games were assigned to a single entity.  Because the additional costs of showing games to out-of-market fans is virtually zero, such an entity would likely sell, in addition to local rights and ExtraInningsTM, other packages to other consumers.  For example, there are surely many fans who would pay, on a per game or per team basis, for out-of-market games.  These are not authorized now, not because the sale would not be profitable, but because the MLB owners can not agree on how to divide the profits.13
Insufficient competition in multi-channel video distribution
          An analysis of the economics of rights sales for out-of-market games demonstrates that the current scheme would be implausible except for two additional deviations from the free market: (1) insufficient competition between DirecTV, DishNetwork, and cable permits excess profits from consumers of “basic premium” programming; (2) by tying the sale of ExtraInningsTM to its “Choice” package, DirecTV is able to increase its excess profits and the agreement in question reflects a sharing of those increased excess profits between DirecTV and Major League Baseball.
          Although there are important differences in the economics of English football and North American sports, on both sides of the Atlantic we see leagues that offer entertainment products with no reasonable substitutes selling broadcast rights to a major programmer in return for a large, fixed sum of money.  Policy questions about exclusive agreements for prime sports programming have also arisen in the United Kingdom, and have been insightfully analyzed in a working paper widely distributed among sports economists.14  Economists David Harbord and Marco Ottaviani detail the profit-maximizing strategy for the various market participants.  First, they note that leagues are likely to sell rights for a fixed rather than per-subscriber fee.  A fixed fee avoids the problem of the rights-purchaser tacking on its own excess profits charge to that imposed by the league.15  Because MLB doesn’t know precisely how many fans will subscribe to ExtraInningsTM, or how effectively DirecTV will market the product, it has an even greater incentive to sell for fixed fees, as the rights-purchaser is better able to accept the risk of marketing the product effectively during the course of the contract.  If the rights purchaser is effective in maximizing revenues from resale and advertising, results of which are usually reported in the trade press, the league can profit from the rights purchaser’s success to secure even higher rights fees for the next contract.  (For example, the NFL’s first network contract with CBS gave each owner $300,000/yr.  Three years later, the second contract gave each owner $1 million/yr.)
          Next, Harbord & Ottaviani explain why a rights-purchaser, having paid a lump-sum to obtain rights for which there was no substitute, would want to re-sell rights on a per-subscriber basis to its cable and satellite rivals.  Ordinarily, they observe, by re-selling to rivals, the rights purchaser increases the marginal operating costs for its rivals at the same time it fetches additional revenue.  This “makes reselling more profitable for the firm which acquires the rights, and hence more likely to occur.”16  Re-selling on a per-subscriber basis results in higher rights fees (because the league can capture a portion of the additional profit to be obtained from reselling on a per-subscriber basis) and maximizes output (more people subscribe).
          Applied to American baseball, Harbord & Ottaviani’s analysis suggests that DirecTV would find it profitable to resell ExtraInnings to cable networks and Dish Network, and that MLB would share in this profit through a higher lump-sum fee for the exclusive rights to out-of-market baseball games.  So why have DirecTV and MLB done the opposite?  We can infer from the parties’ preference for an exclusive deal that DirecTV is willing to forego this opportunity, and indeed pay MLB more than the total amount that MLB might reasonably expect to receive from sales of ExtraInnings through various retail outlets.  This is because DirecTV would prefer to force some out-of-market baseball fans to switch their patronage to DirecTV, rather than obtain all the revenue from out-of-market fans, regardless of which “retailer” these fans patronize.  DirecTV’s ability to obtain more revenue from those fans that remain with or switch to DirecTV than it could by charging the full monopoly price for ExtraInningsTM to all out-of-market fans is most likely due to their ability to obtain even greater super-competitive profits from those that switch.
     Suppose one million fans would be willing to subscribe to ExtraInningsTM at $160 per season, but that 200,000 of these will not patronize DirecTV (perhaps they fear thunderstorms, prefer programming available only on cable, can’t afford two systems in areas where local cable is unavailable, don’t have a clear south-facing view on their property, must use the system subscribed by the landlord, etc.).  That’s $32 million in lost revenue.  The exclusive deal means that DirecTV plans on making this up by obtaining new customers from cable or DishNetwork.  If 300,000 ExtraInnings customers switch to DirecTV’s Choice package (at $480/yr) + ExtraInningsTM, that’s an additional $144 million in revenue (from Choice, not MLB games, which these fans were already purchasing via cable or DishNetwork).  If DirecTV’s operational and programming costs in servicing the new customers was not well below $144 million, this scheme wouldn’t be profitable.  Only the excess profits on the Choice package – which baseball fans are required to purchase as a condition of subscribing to ExtraInningsTM, – is what allows DirecTV to profitably enter into an exclusive deal.
    One other explanation is theoretically possible – that there are huge cost-saving efficiencies from an exclusive dealing arrangement.  However, no one has, to date, seriously made this claim on behalf of MLB or DirecTV.
Summary of economic analysis

    The foregoing analysis suggests that the MLB/DirecTV exclusive deal reflects the ability of these sellers to exploit baseball fans because of the lack of any substitute products, and thus impose a monopoly price and significantly reduce output.  Out-of-market games will henceforth only be available on DirecTV, presumably at the monopoly price.  The absence of alternative means of obtaining out-of-market games means millions of consumers will pay more.  But it also means that output is substantially reduced, because of foregone purchases (all of which would be considerably above the marginal cost of production) from (i) expatriate fans of one particular team willing to pay a lower price to watch their favorite team but unwilling to pay for the ExtraInnings package; (ii) avid fans who have other preferential reasons to prefer to continue to subscribe to cable or Dish Network; (iii) marginal customers of satellite programming, who otherwise prefer DirecTV’s programming but decline to pay the “basic premium” price charged by DirecTV because it reflects in part the need to share profits with MLB.  This is bad public policy.
Ways that legislation can protect consumers
    There are a number of ways that existing or potential legislation could protect baseball fans against exploitation by inefficient and anti-competitive broadcast agreements:
  • Existing antitrust laws could be used to invalidate these unreasonable restraints of trade.
  • Specific antitrust legislation could be enacted to facilitate this result.
  • Regulatory legislation could minimize the excess profits that satellite and cable providers enjoy from their “basic premium” packages, or could directly prohibit the bundling essential to the exclusivity scheme by requiring “a la carte” pricing.
  • Strategic legislation could also be introduced by leading members of this committee as a means of facilitating voluntary pro-consumer compliance by industry.

Existing antitrust enforcement
    As detailed below, even vigorous enforcement of the antitrust laws by the Justice Department would face significant obstacles to quick resolution in time to protect sports fans.  Unfortunately, the record of the current Antitrust Division leadership does not lead to a confident prediction of such enforcement.  The obstacles to private litigation to effectively protect consumers are even greater.  For these reasons, reliance on existing law is unlikely to constitute an adequate public policy response by this Congress. 
    A government enforcement action should be able to rely on the precedents discussed above to establish that the horizontal restraint among MLB clubs is an unreasonable restraint of trade.  The exclusive broadcast territories are neither necessary to promote competitive balance among member teams nor to prevent any efficiency-deterring free riding. The only way in which a club’s sale of their games into another geographic market could harm competitive balance would be if the additional revenue generated from these out-of-market rights fees would enable the teams to acquire enough talent to enable them to dominate the league. This scenario is implausible for a number of reasons. There is no evidence that these fees would be significant enough to affect competitive balance. More important, there is no reason why the leagues could not share these revenues, as Major League Baseball has with teams whose games are carried nationwide via locally-based superstations.
    Nor can the leagues, in this context, sensibly claim that the restraint is an intra-firm restraint among the “single entity” of the league, rather than the horizontal agreement among independent clubs.  Because of the economics of rights sales, a single firm would sell all rights in all games that are going to be televised to the highest bidder, who could then re-sell the games to consumers in a price discriminating manner designed to yield the greatest revenue (noting again that the marginal costs of selling a game once it is being televised is virtually zero).  The ExtraInnings package is the only way that out-of-market fans can get games, not because this is DirecTV’s preference, but because it is the choice of the majority of MLB clubs.  DirecTV would clearly be better off if it could price discriminate by selling the ExtraInnings package to those with a demand for over 1,000 baseball games, and selling a smaller package of games (or even individual games on a pay-per-view basis) to its subscribers unwilling to pay for ExtraInnings.  Rather, individual games are unavailable to out-of-market fans, despite the potential for profitable sales, because transactions costs prevent owners from agreeing on how to divide the spoils.  As a result, the interest of the league-as-a-whole in maximizing revenues from television sales is subordinated to the interests of individual teams in protecting their own local broadcast rights and preventing rivals from attaining a competitive advantage from more successful out-of-market rights sales.  This is not the “unity of interest” that the Supreme Court has required to exclude agreements among formally separate entities from review under section 1 of the Sherman Act.17
    Existing precedents with regard to tying arrangements might also support a claim that DirecTV’s practice of bundling ExtraInningsTM with its $40/mo. Choice package is also unreasonable.  However, there are several serious obstacles to successful government prosecution of such a lawsuit.  First, MLB could claim that the judicially-created baseball exemption applies to broadcast restraints.  Although good arguments can be made that the exemption does not apply,18 the result is ultimately an uncertain question likely to require ultimate resolution, after years of litigation, by the Supreme Court.  Second, although DirecTV’s bundling practices would appear to be unreasonable under existing precedents,19these precedents have come under criticism by commentators20 and justices.21  Moreover, current regulation of cable and satellite practices by the FCC might be held to preclude antitrust scrutiny of this behavior. 
    Private enforcement is even more problematic.  The obstacles stated above pose major litigation risks that would deter private antitrust attorneys from commencing expensive litigation.  Because the proposed exclusive deal is prospective, treble damage relief (and accompanying attorneys fees funded by the damage award) would not be available for that aspect of the challenge.  My own experience as a public interest advocate has been that private firms are unlikely to view the grant of statutory attorneys fees provided for in the Clayton Act as a sufficient economic incentive to undertake the costs of uncertain litigation.  In addition, private litigation on behalf of consumers who currently patronize DirecTV would have to confront complex issues that would arise in light of the contract-by-adhesion DirecTV requires all customers that provides for disputes to be arbitrated.

New antitrust legislation
    This Committee could defer to your Judiciary Committee colleagues, who could consider specific legislation that amended the Sports Broadcasting Act to prohibit the sort of bundling or exclusive dealing practices identified in this testimony.  There is a long history of specific legislation enacted by Congress to outlaw specific anti-competitive practices: indeed, the Clayton Act was passed to specifically outlaw tying arrangements arguably illegal under the Sherman Act, over the objections of former President William Howard Taft, who left the White House to accepted a chaired professorship at Yale Law School and wrote a book arguing for the adequacy of the Sherman Act on this and other points.22
Regulatory legislation
    As Judge Richard Posner famously observed, a “firm that has no market power is unlikely to adopt policies that disserve its consumers; it cannot afford to. And if it blunders and does adopt such a policy, market retribution will be swift.”23  The corollary, of course, is that firms with market power can afford to disserve consumers and market retribution will not be swift. 
    Either expressly, or by delegation to the FCC, this Committee could craft legislation that recognizes that market retribution is not swift in either the market for out-of-market baseball games or the market for delivery of multi-channel video distribution.  A variety of regulatory approaches might be considered.  I would be pleased to continue to work with you and your staff if any of these are of particular interest:
  • Listed Events Legislation: A variety of other countries have enacted legislation that specifically requires a variety of important sporting events to remain on free-to-air television, for the benefit of millions of consumers.
  • “A La Carte” Pricing: Satellite and cable companies could be prohibited from requiring lengthy subscriptions to their “basic premium” packages as a condition of subscription to high-demand sport programming.  The analysis above suggests that DirecTV would quickly lose its incentive to pay MLB for exclusive rights if cable subscribers could, in a secondary market, acquire DirecTV equipment and then simply subscribe to ExtraInningsTM without having to pay $40/mo. for Choice.
  • Specifically Ban Sports Exclusivity: Unlike general delegations contained in the Sherman Act or the Federal Communications Act, Congress is free to write specific legislation to deal with specific industry problems.  Based on the economic analysis summarized above, the Committee could conclude that copyright holders and their licensees can fully exploit their intellectual property rights by sale and re-sale and there is no legitimate justification (sharing in excess profits from limited retail competition is not legitimate) for exclusive agreements in this area.24
Strategic behavior – by Major League Baseball and by the Senate Commerce Committee
    Both business and political actors often behave strategically – they act in a way that may or may not further immediate short-run goals in order to achieve long-run objectives.  Although MLB owners are rightly accused of being short-sighted and greedy in some instances, there are many other occasions where MLB owners have decided that the long-term health of the National Pastime is more important.  It is possible that this is one of those occasions: that MLB owners see a strong future in the development of The Baseball Channel, and the exclusive agreement with DirecTV is simply a negotiating strategy to persuade DishNetwork and cable companies to re-sell The Baseball Channel on favorable terms.
    If market retribution were swift among cable and satellite programmers, this would not be a problem.  If MLB’s demands were not unreasonable, then so many consumers would shift to DirecTV that rival MVPDs would have to go along.  If MLB’s demands were unreasonable, then DirecTV would lose so much money that it would eventually back out.  However, anyone inside the Beltway is familiar with the lack of swift retribution reflected in the lengthy negotiations that were required before millions of Capital-area baseball fans could obtain Washington Nationals local broadcasts on their stations.  The FCC has already recognized that market retribution is not swift in a number of non-sports contexts involving cable mergers, requiring programmers and distributors to either reach agreement on terms or submit their unresolved disputes to binding commercial arbitration.   
    There are a variety of situations where public policy may require government intervention, but where the best solution would be a voluntary agreement among private parties rather than direct legislation.  An excellent example of that technique was recently employed by this Committee, when under Senator McCain’s chairmanship there were explicit overtures to MLB owners and players to agree on new procedures for steroid testing or face federal legislative intervention.  The result was a voluntary deal that is probably superior to anything Congress could have done.25
    Likewise, if it appears that the best resolution of this controversy is voluntary agreement among MLB and the various programming distributors, perhaps this Committee could proceed strategically by threatening onerous legislation (barring collective sales of sports broadcasting rights to satellite and cable, mandating a la carte programming, authorizing FCC rate regulation of premium programming, etc.) unless the parties reach a voluntary agreement or agree to submit the matter to binding commercial arbitration.
    The MLB/DirecTV exclusive deal is not like a facially-similar contract between Sears and Levi’s.  Rather, the deal reflects (1) cartel behavior by MLB clubs in refusing to sell out-of-market rights to their games except via ExtraInningsTM on DirecTV and (2) a willingness of DirecTV to share the excess profits it enjoys from its Choice package with MLB.  Millions of baseball fans who no longer live near their favorite teams are harmed by their inability to watch their teams’ local broadcasts except via ExtraInningsTM, and harmed particularly by being forced to do so via DirecTV.  This Committee has a variety of arrows in its legislative quiver to protect consumers from this sort of exploitation.

Testimony of Professor Stephen F. Ross
Professor of Law, The Dickinson School of Law
Director, Penn State Institute for Sports Law, Policy and Research
The Pennsylvania State University
Before the
Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation
March 27, 2007
1) Although exclusive dealing agreements with retailers whom consumers can access for free can often be pro-competitive, the MLB/DirecTV deal threatens to harm a wide variety of consumers
  • Fans who, for other reasons, are unable or unwilling to switch to DirecTV
  • Fans who would prefer to get out-of-market games other than the entire ExtraInningsTM package
2) The agreement exploits significant departures from the free market
  • MLB clubs agree to only telecast games in assigned territories, contrary to a 50-year old antitrust precedent
  • MVPDs face insufficient competition, allowing them excess profits for their basic premium service
3) Economic analysis shows that ordinarily, DirecTV would want to re-sell ExtraInnings to its cable and satellite rivals at a high per-subscriber charge; the exclusive deal reflects a sharing of additional excess profits DirecTV will obtain by forcing consumers to switch to its Choice or higher premium packages
4) Although the conduct is arguably illegal under the antitrust laws, a number of obstacles render litigation inadequate to protect consumers
5) Congress could, alternatively, consider:
  • Regulatory legislation to outlaw specific sports programming practices that harm consumers
  • Amendments to the Sports Broadcasting Act to specifically outlaw anti-consumer practices
  • “Strategic” legislation onerous to the industry that would facilitate voluntary compliance

1 Tampa Electric Co. v. Nashville Coal Co., 365 U.S. 320 (1961).
2 Id. at 334.
3 Standard antitrust analysis properly focuses on whether a product or service faces competition from “reasonable substitutes” that will draw consumers if there is a small but significant increase in price or decrease in quality of the good or service in question.  Courts have generally found that major sports are sufficiently unique in consumers’ hearts – baseball is, after all, the National Pastime – that a small increase in the price of watching a favorite baseball team will not send enough fans to the library or to cricket websites to render the move unprofitable.  See, e.g., National Collegiate Athletic Ass'n v. Board of Regents, 468 U.S. 85 (1984) (college football is a market distinct from professional football or other forms of entertainment); International Boxing Club v. United States, 358 U.S. 242 (1959) (championship boxing is a market distinct from non-championship boxing).
            Likewise, the issue here concerns quality telecasts to be displayed on television sets of increasing size and clarity.  Although some fans may prefer the convenience of watching webcasts of out-of-market games on their computers, or others are willing to endure the significant reduction in picture quality when subscribing to mlb.com, these webcasts are not the sort of reasonable substitutes for ExtraInningsTM that either antitrust doctrine or public policy ought require.
4 United States v. National Football League, 116 F.Supp. 319 (E.D. Pa. 1953).
5 See, e.g., Pittsburgh Athletic Co. v. KQV Broad. Co., 24 F. Supp. 490 (W.D. Pa. 1938).
6 116 F.Supp. 319 (E.D. Pa. 1953).
7 National Collegiate Athletic Ass’n v. Board of Regents, 468 U.S. 85 (1984).
8 Chicago Professional Sports Ltd. v. National Basketball Ass’n, 961 F.2d 667 (7th Cir. 1992).
9 Broadcast Music, Inc. v. Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc., 441 U.S. 1  (1979).
10 Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc. v. American Soc’y of Composers, Authors & Publishers, 620 F.2d 930 (2d Cir. 1980).
11 CBS v. Broadcast Music, 441 U.S. at 10-11, citing United States v. American Soc’y of Composers, Artists & Publishers, 1940-1943 Trade Cas. (CCH) ¶ 56,104 (S.D.N.Y. 1941).
12 NCAA, 468 U.S. at 107.
13 There are at least two recent examples of this phenomenon.  In 1992, the English Premier League, having agreed to show 60 of its 380 matches exclusively on the BSkyB satellite, rejected BSkyB’s offer to show 90 matches for a 50% increase in fees.  At about the same time, the National Basketball Association succeeded in strictly limiting the very popular broadcasts of the Chicago Bulls featuring Michael Jordan, despite evidence that Bulls’ broadcasts had minimal effects in other markets, refusing to copy MLB’s practice of taxing superstation revenue.
14 David Harbord & Marco Ottaviani, “Contracts and Competition in the Pay-TV Market,” London Bus. School Dep’t of Economics Working Paper No. DP 2001/5, available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=289334. 
15 This phenomenon is known to economists as “double marginalization.”  Suppose the profit-maximizing price for ExtraInningsTM is $160/year.  (Any increase in price reduces demand, unless a product is essential to life.  Thus, raising the price from $150 to $160 will cause some marginal consumers to discontinue patronage, but if the number is small enough, the increase is profitable.  If 100 consumers refuse to go along with the increase, this would cost MLB/DirecTV $15,000.  But if a 10,000 consumers are willing to pay $160, this is an additional $100,000.  At some point, the number of consumers discontinuing purchases outweighs the additional income, just short of that point is the profit-maximizing price.)  If MLB sold rights on a per-subscriber basis, they would want to fix the price at $160 minus DirecTV’s costs.   If these costs were $5/subscriber, MLB would set the rights sale at $155.  However, this would leave DirecTV with no excess profits.  DirecTV would rather get some excess profits, even at the expense of losing some customers.  So DirecTV would be likely to charge $170 or more, costing MLB some customers and some profit.  These problems are avoided by a lump-sum sale.
16 Harbord & Ottaviani, supra, at 8.    To the extent that there are strategic gains from raising rivals’ cost, the incentive to re-sell is even stronger. 
17 Copperweld Corp. v. Independence Tube Corp., 467 U.S. 752, 771 (1984).
 When the Supreme Court last revisited the issue in Flood v. Kuhn, 407 U.S. 258 (1972), the Court explicitly rejected its original holding that baseball was not interstate commerce, instead re-affirming the exemption because of baseball’s “unique characteristics and needs” and Congress’ “positive inaction” in sustaining the judicial precedents.  It is clear that baseball has no unique characteristics and needs with regard to broadcasting, a fact Congress recognized by including baseball as a sport covered by the limited exemption for package sales to free-to-air networks contained in the Sports Broadcasting Act.  Congress’ positive inaction with regard to the baseball exemption, upon which Justice Blackmun relied in Flood, related almost entirely to labor restraints.  When Congress overturned that specific aspect of Flood in enacting the Curt Flood Act of 1995, it is clear that continuing legislative concern almost entirely related to protecting the unique characteristics and needs of minor league baseball, not broadcasting practices that MLB shares in common with the NBA and the NHL. 
            In addition, lower courts have suggested that the exemption applies only to the “business of baseball” and not to the “business of broadcasting.”  Henderson Broad. Corp. v. Houston Sports Ass'n, 541 F. Supp. 263 (S.D. Tex. 1982).  Especially in light of courts’ explicit recognition that MLB can lawfully require clubs to share revenues from rights sales, Chicago Professional Sports Ltd. Partnership, supra, 961 F.2d at 675, there is no reason why subjecting television agreements to standard antitrust analysis would compromise “the business of baseball.”
19 The current Supreme Court doctrine is expressed in Jefferson Parish Hospital Dist. No. 2 v. Hyde, 466 U.S. 2 (1984).  Firms engaged in a substantial amount of interstate commerce may not force consumers to purchase a product, service, or copyright license as a condition of purchasing a more desired license, where the seller has “market power,” the arrangement requires the purchase of two “separate products,” and the tying is not necessary to introduce a new product or to ensure the reliable use of either.  Applying this precedent, it is clear that DirecTV has market power in the sale of ExtraInningsTM, as there are no reasonable substitutes for out-of-market MLB games.  Forcing purchasers of ExtraInningsTM to purchase the Choice package constitutes a tied sale, because there is distinct and separate consumer demand for both products.  Finally, a there is no need to tie well-established programs in the Choice package with uniquely desirable MLB games in order to penetrate a market, and there are no reliability issues in subscribing to one or the other. 
20 See, e.g., Robert Bork, The Antitrust Paradox 365-381 (1978).
21 See, e.g., Eastman Kodak Co. v. Image Tech. Servs., 504 U.S. 451, 487 (Scalia, J., dissenting); Hyde, 466 U.S. at 32 (O’Connor, J., concurring).
 William Howard Taft, The Anti-Trust Act and the Supreme Court (1914).
23 Valley Liquors, Inc. v. Renfield Importers, Ltd., 678 F.2d 742, 745 (7th Cir. 1982).
24 This legislation would also prevent cable companies from aggressively competing in a consumer-harming way by acquiring their own exclusive sports programming rights and refusing to re-sell to satellite outlets.
            Another example, of perhaps little interest to most Americans but of keen interest to millions, especially recent immigrants from south Asia or the United Kingdom, concerns the rights to satellite broadcasting of international cricket matches.  Thus, DishNetwork obtained exclusive rights for the International Cricket Council’s World Cup contests currently being played in the West Indies, while DirecTV obtained exclusive rights to a large number of international contests throughout the year.  Devoted cricket fans need to either subscribe to both or forego the ability to watch these matches in their homes.
25 The substance of the agreement, and whether the agreement or proposed legislation accurately reflects the public interest in an appropriate balance between protecting (i) players’ health, (ii) the integrity of the game from health-harming, performance-enhancing behavior, and (iii) privacy rights, is of course beyond the scope of this testimony as well as my scholarly expertise.


Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?