cialis 40 mg erectile dysfunction levofloxacin uk bactroban online legally vantin legal in england is it safe to order prednisone online calan drugs for sale roxithromycin tablets buy olanzapine 10 mg comprar moduretic en argentina acne breakouts after accutane hyaluronic acid on line no script half price dutas lasix generic mexico yasmin class action in canada is it is itlegal to buy prescription drugs from india what is ampicillin medication without prescriptions overnight allegra usa k zolpidem uk online s club 7 songs list benadryl online australia viagra wikipedia francais buy xenical without a prescription bupron sr express canada viagra professional comprar luvox delivered to your home how to buy pariet in canada where do i buy kytril cheap arimidex 1mg medicine cipro hc safe nitroglycerin buy cafergot uk boots metformin discount card singulair cost with insurance where purchase finast how to take care of an amaryllis plant spc methotrexate tablets free coupon for atarax order generic baclofen cheapest cordarone what is valtrex 1000 mg used for weight gain pills that work tetracycline cost viagra where to buy malaysia where can you get bactroban prevacid in usa lowest price yagara buy maxalt mg online khawaja naveed ki adalat all episodes yasmin order online uk acquisto nootropil sicuro online pay by check online food lukol without script safe reglan buy purchase fertomid pills there generic advair diskus buy plavix perth australia erythromycin australia companies only clarithromycin 500mg tablets side effects buy phentermine 37.5 mg tablets is it illegal to order generic augmentin cooperativa puerto rico rincon diclofenac cost without insurance cost of cymbalta in australia buy hyaluronic acid tablets online doxycycline hyclate 100mg generic cephalexin uk paypal evista online store azithromycin buy online no prescription uk cheap us pharmacy allopurinol without unisom sleeping pills over the counter atacand tablets for sale over the counter lady era plus no prescription pill store buy levitra online price ginseng root 2009 over the counter prilosec generic rumalaya gel drugstore.com suprax antibiotics alcohol dilantin without prescription canada retail price atacand viagra without side effects where to buy pain meds online what are the side effects of paroxetine buy tretinoin (retin-a) uk new russian drugs propranolol tablets 10mg children all pills shop discount donde comprar shampoo nizoral en mexico methotrexate and folic acid dose cheap genuine etodolac online cialis soft sublingual dosage buy keflex 200 ordering zanaflex usa diamox drugs com diuretic online sale of mobic wellbutrin side effects med cab actonel where is the love lyrics barracuda voltaren emulgel geigy best pharmacy to order ephedraxin best price claritin can you buy brand viagra in ireland paypal domperidone buy new zealand colchicine overseas pariet 10mg prec,o valtrex over the counter equivalent serophene without a script aciclovir tablets on line to buy no prescription nolvadex what does vc mean in phenergan vc arava online usa no prescription levitra medicine buy india meds buy generic geriforte syrup online how to buy benfotiamine in london nitrofurantoin in the uk now side effects of metformin for diabetes over the counter medicine similar to zovirax raclet allegra for sale which uk site to buy acticin healthy heart rate for 30 year old male brand name omnicef online cephalexin dosage recommended western drug confido how to order astelin bupropion smoking cessation how it works does tretinoin cream usp 0.025 work safest medication for anxiety in children yasmin online purchase walmart pharmacy discount medications is generic viagra soft effective cheap birth control pills canada glucotrol usa no prescription doxycycline and alcohol effectiveness generic triamterene hctz 37.5 25 mg buy femara 200 robaxin medication order Purchase glucophage 500 mg cost of generic sinemet recurrence of acne after accutane can you buy viagra india cost of paxil at walmart insulin resistance treatment diclofenac gel buy on line wellbutrin cheap uk chlamydia antibiotics zithromax retino-a cream 0,025 medicine children buy cialis generic no prescription is generic retino-a cream 0,05 effective buy motilium 10 overnight prescription order metoclopramide generic from parlodel chloroquine purchase in canada no prescription buy purinethol online amazon roxithromycin pills sweat depakote without a prescription from australia buy isoptin capsules mevacor coupons where to rocaltrol amoxil overnight delivery blue pill red pill song januvia usage speman prescription coupon buy suprax discount canadian seroquel wiki buy flomax 80 mg online phenergan over counter australia reviews on dulcolax tablets combivent pharmacy cytotec online from usa ampicillin dosage drug erythromycin indian manufacturers purchase metformin hydrochloride promethazine shortage 2012 celebrex pharmacies viagra for sale in hong kong propecia australia forum order clomid in canada canadian online pharmacy for tadalis sx benicar shoppers drug mart there generic plendil cialis usa today ayurslim uk brand name benadryl max daily dose cabgolin women buy dolonex dt piroxicam tablets Purchase lexapro 10 mg tablets duetact generico italiano proscar birth control online us prandin capsules generic zestril 20 mg lipitor generic release date levitra cialis viagra comparison cost ciplox oz tablets is it safe to order benemid colchicine 100mg tablet buy actos uk diet pioglitazone doxycycline hyclate dosage chlamydia inhouse pharmacy fake drugs soma online no prescription overnight delivery where can i order alligator furosemide pas cher orlistat buy clomid side effects during ovulation cialis super active no prescription needed clotrimazole and betamethasone dipropionate cream usp 1 0.05 price promo code for frye boots company buy nolvadex with mastercard drugs similar to flomax flovent coupon 2012 side effects of ventolin hfa inhaler buy valtrex without best site get buspar prednisone prednisolone interchangeable buy nitrofurantoin 100mg online bactroban cream what is it used for pfizer diflucan fluconazole keftab from india cialis 5mg lilly 28st fta nootropil no prescription reviews online no prescription uk generic viagra us pharmacy online cipro allegra vs zyrtec for children stats group jobs cystoid macular edema cialis what is suhagra used for cheap cialis pills 20mg list of top ten pharmaceutical companies in india rumalaya reviews and dosage augmentin es dosage for children online viagra generic can you buy stromectol over counter how to make ampicillin 1000x female cialis buy uk buy plendil visa sex pills for women that work effexor xr medication slimming tablets with speed in combivent nebuliser ordering coumadin here in canada how to get us prescriptions filled in canada ciprofloxacin side effects bnf methotrexate online usa no prescription strattera india companies only how to take flagyl er benadryl allergy and sinus medicine buy clomid with e check ortho tri cyclen side effects mood swings aldactone canadian pharmacy lowest priced celebrex safe to buy generic reglan from usa how to take liv 52 do i need a prescription for antivert buy voltaren perth australia oral spironolactone hair loss discount canadian pharmacy femara forum buy seroflo online fluticasone order motilium from australia without prescription voltaren prescription proscar from walmart buy lithium ion battery pack blue pill with watson 358 generic aldactone usa pharmacy worldwide pharmacy feldene anacin in the uk now buy finpecia 20 side effects of percocet addiction can you order vasotec can you order promethazine with codeine online how to use lamisil once maxalt bonus pills where to alliance spend honor points prednisolone medicinenet com online pharmacy reviews diazepam genuine sumycin best price prilosec online usa is it illegal to order antibiotics online atacand generic cheap pharm discount code como comprar bayas de acai buy keppra with paypal cheap generic kamagra gold what is sarafem used for pharmacies abilify discount low most reliable place to buy prednisone online rosuvastatin 40 mg tablet where to buy nitrofurantoin buy coumadin us otc viagra canada diclofenac potassium retail price buy online atorlip-5 generic nitroglycerin medicine.net can you buy remeron over the counter gasex brand positioning lisinopril rx zyloprim drugs online purchases works best cialis viagra where to buy cheap generic female cialis how to buy arjuna in london zoloft now co uk buy cialis xr without prescription buy ephedraxin without a script how much will crestor cost premarin cream alternatives generic glycomet safe resources for sinequan viagra price in indian rupees premarin cost canadian finasteride 5 mg sandoz ciplactin 4mg side effects cheap nexium uk tricor cholesterol medicine canadian pharmacy viagra scam zithromax spain over counter social anxiety medication weight loss use phenamax coupon online reglan in usa anacin usa cvs prices generic ditropan buy what is seroquel good for lynoral prices order sominex on line canada buy bystolic generic maximum safe dosage of trazodone max dose celebrex per day reglan pharmacy online prednisolone cheap india pharmacy how much are antibiotics in canada achat de cialis pas cher compare prices zantac elocon canada prescription comprar zithromax espan~a is rumalaya legal in uk buy cefixime online uk albuterol inhalers from mexico side effects of using asthma inhalers too much 300 mg wellbutrin weight loss abilify without food canadianpharmacymeds com legitimate viagra pill shop discount code cymbalta cheap online atacand prescription medication better than noroxin order erection packs 1 from canadian pharmacy online ordering actoplus met pharmacy naprosyn delivery uk haridra spain buy brand dapoxetine purchase inderal 10mg what is probalan made of what states sell phenergan without a ptescription? crestor 10 mg precio en mexico voltaren without a prescription from canada rosuvastatin dose response onde comprar orlistat mais barato ginseng rxlist how to order kamagra oral jelly online cheap prescription buy bactrim online phentermine 37.5mg best price cardizem online overnight can you buy colospa over the counter in germany generic feldene 20 mg is anafranil a prescription drug adalat cc generic capoten lawsuit settlements ordering viagra from india holland & barrett - acai with green tea tablets zyprexa overdose fatal what does parietal lobe malaseb shampoo alternative order phenergan online canada top 100 otc meds order avodart online no prescription with a visa where to get plavix levothroid mail order buy cheap topamax no prescription top 10 online ginette-35 sites atorlip-10 shopping hydrea mg buy buy ampicillin online from australia side effects of cefixime tablets pravachol online sales penicillin online no prescription zithromax price in pakistan zovirax mexico companies only what is prevacid 30 mg zyrtec pharmacy common antibiotics for chest infection propecia medicine in india fertomid refills buy finax online overnight oral antifungal medicine for thrush urispas maximum dosage radio ad viagara $5 ortho tri cyclen buy australia what is starlix used for metoclopramide medication overnight delivery generic viagra super active switzerland buy colchicine new zealand online order viagra from canada with my master catrd buying cleocin gel generic ephedraxin cost sustiva pas cher effexor xr dosage recommended can you only get lithium on prescription acticin overnight delivery bromocriptine mesylate dosage alli weight loss product information cheap lanoxin 0.25 mg xenical online in stock online cialis canada can you just take powder amoxicillin xenical medicine review buy asacol 400 mg cialis super active mg order zerit online pay paypal best fertility pills for men beconase aq daily use reviews metformin hydrochloride tablets i.p 850 mg buy revatio online reviews trim active plus ingredients moduretic tablet sale finpecia drug store online poison ivy medicine canada pharmacy generic elocon cream where to buy retin a cheap triamterene hydrochlorothiazide mechanism action plavix shortage buy cheap eldepryl using pay pal nizagara india what color are coumadin 2mg tablets drug market order olanzapine cheap elocon india sertraline 50 mg nhs chocolate covered acai berries costco calories finasteride atepros side effects best soft prices online pharmacy buy cialis suhagra cost comparison pharmacy has best price benemid acheter un livre pas cher novartis femara coupons buy himcocid pills online is lyrica better than neurontin for nerve pain tetracycline dosage for gonorrhea generic viagra india suppliers generic name for diclofenac sodium best generic lamisil review buy viagra tablets online discount pharmacy brisbane cbd purchase premarin in canada list pharmacy schools canada buying cafergot in manchester online pharmacy uk levitra levitra discount coupon cheap tetracycline no prescription pharmacy has best price abana buy depakote 200 lasix on line without prescription buy online alli medicine in alberta ca resources for aciclovir ponstel delivery uk current price fluoxetine zyloprim online uk antabuse without rx kroger pharmacy jobs cincinnati colospa 40mg non prescription brand levitra top 10 online bystolic sites kamagra gold generic name online pharmacy uk finpecia order differin online uk donde puedo comprar una membresia xbox live gold orlistat xenical capsules tadapox online in usa do i need a prescription for didronel order female viagra from usa without prescription overnight pharmacy citalopram evista pharmacy xeloda next day shipping nitroglycerin american regent heartworm meds for dogs online no rx pharmacy online buy avodart online usa diclofenac medication pain levaquin reviews bacterial infection cialis online buy uk viagra pfizer wiki strattera online canada what doses does effexor xr come in buy zofran without a script what is allopurinol medication used for side effects clomid price in india where cane i buy amaryllis donepezil hydrochloride tablets side effects flomax pharmacy levothroid weight loss safe buy nitrofurantoin online can you buy hyzaar drugs losartan better than lynoral zyprexa tabletas 5 mg order non generic cialis sublingual buy kamagra online no prescription us robaxin high bluelight pharmacy online propranolol how much will aygestin cost hydrocortisone my micronase coupons pharmacy that sells cialis zyban reviews weight loss order nizoral online no prescription with a visa ordering cialis soft here in canada buy kytril 20 can you buy viagra soft in ireland canadian metoclopramide tablets msds how to take viagra for the first time order doxycycline online no prescription acai berry weight loss pills at walmart generic casodex what is keftab pills used for amitriptyline usa pharmacy best otc inhaler asthma reglan without script citalopram generic release date kamagra cialis cheapest drug medrol cost comparison order roxithromycin view topic nizoral weight gain januvia prescribing information uk carbozyne over counter uk can you buy trental in ireland when do you start to ovulate after taking clomid fucidin noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy purchase doxycycline no prescription rhinocort results forum rhinathiol promethazine where can i get antivert from buy alli 15mg online what are the side effects of the drug cipro what is 1 cup in grams crestor trusted online drug stores in canada motrin 100 proventil sale prescription trazodone 50 mg tablets avodart generic canada discount zerit mg side effects of taking acai berry pills where to buy bupron sr in canada safely best dosage of nolvadex for pct differin online in usa insulin vs glyburide gestational diabetes domperidone motilium syrup buy triamterene hctz no prescription canadian alliance for development initiatives and projects zambia austria can i order tadacip no prescription in the usa liposafe billig kaufen buy genuine minipress uk buy synthroid online no perscription lowest price keftab tetracycline acne results soluble aspirin tablets experiment insurance jobs uk how much does depakote cost at walmart viagra soft online shipping viagra super active without rx compare prices malegra dxt indian pharmacy mycelex-g noroxin shopping retin-a ge india purchase celexa cheap bupropion australia cost gnc products like viagra buy plavix online from usa prilosec australia price buying generic allegra how much is accutane in canada coming off zoloft crying buy ditropan xl nexium for sale best place to buy chloromycetin online tricor 145 mg tablet side effects prevacid price india what is the mechanism of action for chloramphenicol kroger pharmacy richmond ky phone number rumalaya without prescription canada us online pharmacy no prescription clonidine buy diflucan 10 flovent direct pharmacy estrofem 2mg tablet comprar viagra generico portugal cheap cytotec seroflo pas cher order erection packs 2 prescription cheap what is naprosyn made of how to use levaquin 500 mg cialis or viagra which works better tadapox pas cher italie buy cheap pyridium using pay pal what is the generic brand for ventolin levaquin lawsuit settlements lipothin doctors online how long to use evista voltaren discount code order alligator pharmacy us pharmacies online that sell voltaren crestor medicine interactions cheapest vermox paypal voveran online overnight shipping when will alli be available in the uk aspirin for chest pain dose forzest online price list of pharmacy stores in uk reglan cheap uk venlor in the uk now cheap cozaar 25mg
Home Media News Opening Statement: Chase Carey Pres. and CEO of DirecTV

Like Shoot to Thrill - An AC/DC Tribute on Facebook!

An authentic tribute of AC/DC that covers the best of the Bon Scott era and the best of Brian Johnson's material

Who's Online?

We have 828 guests online

Atom RSS

Opening Statement: Chase Carey Pres. and CEO of DirecTV PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 5
PoorBest 
Written by Chase Carey   
Tuesday, 27 March 2007 03:54
Chase Carey
President and Chief Executive Officer, DIRECTV, Inc.
Before the
Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation
March 27, 2007

Chairman Inouye, Co-Chairman Stevens, and members of the Committee, my name is Chase Carey.  I am the President and CEO of DIRECTV.  Thank you for inviting me to testify today regarding DIRECTV’s recently announced agreement with Major League Baseball (“MLB”) to continue to carry MLB’s Extra Innings package of out-of-town baseball games.

I would like to address four issues today.  First, I’ll describe the fair, open, and arm’s length negotiation for carriage of Extra Innings – a negotiation resulting directly from the pro-competitive, pro-consumer policies Congress has put in place.  DIRECTV has entered into a carriage agreement with MLB, while EchoStar and a consortium of the biggest cable operators remain free to match DIRECTV’s offer until Opening Day.  So when our competitors complain that they don’t have rights to Extra Innings, what they’re really saying is that they’d like to pay less for those rights than DIRECTV – a lament common to many MVPDs in many circumstances.[1]
          
Second, I will address another aspect of competition at work – DIRECTV’s plan to transform Extra Innings from a mere collection of games in low definition to a truly compelling, high definition experience for the most avid baseball fans.  Regardless of whether our competitors step up to the plate, DIRECTV intends to make more baseball available to more fans in a more compelling format than ever before.  This is a big win for baseball fans.

Third, I’ll explain how the competitive marketplace Congress created will ensure that fans of our Nation’s pastime will not be left behind.  If EchoStar and the cable consortium step up and match DIRECTV’s offer, their subscribers will continue to have access to this programming from those providers.  If they don’t, subscribers who want to switch to DIRECTV can do so seamlessly.  The small number of subscribers who do not or cannot switch will be able to watch games over broadband – an increasingly viable alternative to traditional television.

Fourth, while DIRECTV’s agreement with MLB is entirely consistent with the policies Congress established to create a competitive marketplace, Congress can always change those policies.  But I would respectfully suggest that, if this Committee is concerned about competition and access issues, these issues should be examined within the broader context of communications and competition policy.  Such an examination might address topics such as the tying of video and broadband access services, the “slow-rolling” of access to Internet video, tying arrangements for programming imposed by competitors with market power, and home-team sports exclusives.  DIRECTV would be happy to participate in such a discussion.

(Select Read More to view the rest of Carey's opening statement) 

I. DIRECTV Negotiated a Fair and Arm’s Length Agreement With MLB; Cable and EchoStar Can Have the Same Deal if they Want It.

It is sometimes difficult to remember that, little more than a decade ago, Americans had only one choice of multichannel video provider – the cable monopoly.  Today, nearly every American can choose among their cable operator, DIRECTV, and EchoStar.  Verizon and AT&T now also offer service in many parts of the country.

These competitors have differentiated themselves in the marketplace.  Cable, and now Verizon and AT&T, compete by offering a “triple play” of voice, video and data – a bundle that DIRECTV cannot yet offer on its own.  EchoStar has carved out a niche as the low-cost provider, and offers a host of foreign language exclusives.  And DIRECTV differentiates itself through an unparalleled selection of sports programming and unmatched technical innovation – including an investment of hundreds of millions of dollars on new satellites to offer consumers their local broadcast stations in HD and over 100 national HD programming services.  These unique offerings helped DIRECTV to differentiate itself and begin to break the stranglehold of the cable monopolies.  The cable industry, in turn, found itself forced to spend billions to innovate and become more responsive to consumers’ desires – today offering a competitive, attractive package that includes its own differentiated video-on-demand and bundled Internet offerings.

Cable, to be sure, still possesses an overwhelming market share, which distorts competition to this day.  But the fact remains that today there is competition where before there was none.   This is the success story Congress – and this Committee, in particular – helped write.
    
And this is the context in which DIRECTV negotiated its agreement to carry Extra Innings.  Several months ago, MLB initiated discussions with a number of MVPDs and their affiliates – including DIRECTV, EchoStar, and iN DEMAND (owned by Comcast, Time Warner, and Cox) – regarding carriage of Extra Innings.  These discussions concerned both exclusive and non-exclusive carriage.  Each competitor was given the opportunity to compete for Extra Innings.  And each did.

In the end, despite the fact that it has a modest nationwide market share, only DIRECTV showed an interest in carrying Extra Innings on terms acceptable to MLB, including helping to launch the MLB Channel and carrying it widely to our subscribers.  So earlier this month, DIRECTV and MLB announced that they had reached agreement for carriage of Extra Innings and the MLB Channel.

That agreement gave DIRECTV’s competitors – all of whom had a seat at the table during the first round of negotiations – yet another turn at bat.  Until Opening Day, MLB will allow incumbent MVPDs willing to agree to terms equivalent to DIRECTV’s carriage arrangement to offer their subscribers this programming.  In other words, Comcast and Cox and Time Warner and EchoStar can provide out-of-town games to their subscribers if they want to.  The agreement says only that they cannot do so on the cheap.  So if they agree to pay the price DIRECTV pays, agree to carry the MLB Channel in the same manner as DIRECTV, and agree to comply with the other terms and conditions that apply to DIRECTV, they can carry Extra Innings.  It’s their choice.  This is why Time Warner’s top programming negotiator recently said she was not sure why people have criticized the deal as if it were “rigged” against competition, when the issue really boils down to the “evaluation of whether acquiring programming is too expensive or not.”[2]

Now that both iN DEMAND and EchoStar have access to Extra Innings on comparable terms and conditions as DIRECTV, we expected EchoStar and the cable industry to stop complaining and start competing.  But they haven’t.  Now they’re claiming that MLB’s offer to match DIRECTV’s terms isn’t fair.
 
They first contend that the agreement is unfair because DIRECTV will have an ownership interest in the MLB Channel (not in MLB or the Extra Innings package).  But this isn’t unfair at all.  To begin with, because of DIRECTV’s ownership, MLB cannot offer DIRECTV the MLB Channel on an exclusive basis.  If DIRECTV’s competitors think DIRECTV’s ownership interest is inconsistent with this obligation, they already have an avenue for redress at the FCC.[3]  Moreover, granting DIRECTV an ownership interest in exchange for its willingness to be the “first mover” in carrying this channel is a very common industry practice.  The FCC reports that cable operators own dozens of channels, including many of the most important regional sports networks (“RSNs”) such as those in New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, San Diego and Washington D.C.[4]
   
DIRECTV’s rivals also complain that the distribution requirements for the MLB Channel that DIRECTV agreed to are too onerous.  This is nothing but a public relations ploy.  If anything, the distribution requirement actually favors cable operators.  Based on the distribution formula in the agreement, DIRECTV has to distribute the MLB Channel to roughly 80 percent of its total subscribers, while cable operators would have to distribute it to approximately 40 percent of their total subscribers.  The very terms for distribution cable denounces as unfair are equivalent to, or in many instances less stringent than, the requirements cable operators demand for the programming they themselves own.

DIRECTV’s rivals may not like these terms.  But parties who do not like terms of carriage cannot cry foul on that basis alone.  This is how programming negotiations work.  If an MVPD believes that programming is too expensive, it can choose not to carry the programming.  This happens all the time.  EchoStar, for example, doesn’t carry the YES network for this very reason, so EchoStar subscribers in New York can’t watch most Yankees games.  MLB’s insistence that other MVPDs live by the same deal DIRECTV did isn’t unfair, it is simply the marketplace at work – and surely isn’t a subject worthy of Congressional intervention.

II. DIRECTV’s Carriage of Extra Innings Will Be a Big Win for Fans.

I do not know whether EchoStar and the cable industry will ultimately match DIRECTV’s offer to carry Extra Innings.  I do know, however, that DIRECTV has big plans for Extra Innings – which is one reason why we have (so far) been willing to pay more than anybody else for it.  DIRECTV will make more baseball available to more fans in a more compelling format than ever before.

For starters, DIRECTV will add a mosaic channel and a Strike Zone channel (similar to the NFL Sunday Ticket Red Zone Channel) that will deliver live cut-ins of games throughout the country.  We will also provide great entertainment to fans with real-time scores, player and team stats and other innovations that complement the sport of baseball.  Most importantly, DIRECTV expects to provide most, if not all, games in high definition for the 2008 baseball season – an innovation that most cable operators cannot match.

Moreover, as part of the Extra Innings agreement, DIRECTV will also make The MLB Channel widely available when the channel launches in 2009.

DIRECTV’s transformation of Extra Innings should come as no surprise.  This, after all, is what DIRECTV has done for other programming.  For example, DIRECTV recently completely revamped supplemental coverage of NASCAR races.  The cable industry had the rights to NASCAR content for years, but did little with this programming and attracted only 30,000 customers in 2006.  DIRECTV obtained the rights this year to what is now NASCAR Hotpass, and debuted a service at this year’s Daytona 500 that bears little resemblance to cable’s bare-bones offering.  DIRECTV’s NASCAR Hotpass features five dedicated “Driver Channels,” each focusing on an individual driver and offering multiple camera angles, real-time stats, team audio communications and dedicated announcer teams.  Although the NASCAR season started only recently, DIRECTV already has more than three times the subscribers to this programming than the cable industry had in 2006.

DIRECTV expects that once it adds interactive features, high-definition service, and the MLB Channel, many new subscribers will sign up for Extra Innings with DIRECTV. This will make DIRECTV’s service more attractive than our cable competitors.  Those competitors, in turn, will have to improve their services to keep up.  This, again, is the vibrant competitive marketplace that Congress envisioned at work.

III. The Competitive Marketplace Envisioned by Congress Will Provide Numerous Alternatives for Baseball Fans.

The same competitive marketplace that permitted DIRECTV to obtain the rights to Extra Innings in a fair and open manner will also ensure that baseball fans will continue to be able to watch their favorite teams.  Right now, both EchoStar and iN DEMAND have the option to continue to provide this programming to their subscribers – if they are willing to pay the fair price negotiated at arm’s length between DIRECTV and MLB.  Even if DIRECTV remains the only MVPD to carry Extra Innings, however, non-DIRECTV subscribers will not be harmed in any meaningful way.

First, consumers can switch to DIRECTV with no start-up costs, no equipment to buy, and no installation charges.  When they do so, they will get a better service at a better value than is offered by cable.  DIRECTV, unlike cable, is 100% digital.  DIRECTV offers more programming than cable.  On average, DIRECTV costs significantly less per channel than cable.  And DIRECTV’s customer service is second to none – having surpassed the cable industry average in each of the last six years.[5]  This, again, is how a competitive marketplace is supposed to work.

Unfortunately, cable operators are doing their best to prevent this.  Cable, for example, penalizes customers by dramatically increasing the price of Internet service if the customer drops cable’s video service.  To overcome cable’s barriers, DIRECTV has chosen to offer customers who want to switch no upfront costs and more compelling content.
 
Second, every single game carried on Extra Innings will remain available online through MLB.com.  Internet video is improving dramatically,[6] and MLB announced its intent to offer upgraded picture quality this season. Thus, subscribers who choose not to (or cannot) subscribe to DIRECTV will still be able to watch the games of their choice.  Here again, however, cable operators are attempting to hinder the marketplace.  If cable did not prohibit a direct connection between the Internet and the set top box, MLB.com could easily be viewed on television sets.


Third, the arrangement will not disrupt competition among MVPDs.  To begin with, relatively few subscribers are affected at all.  Only 230,000 non-DIRECTV customers subscribed to Extra Innings last year – less than one half of one percent of all television homes.[7]  DIRECTV estimates that there are relatively few viewers – no more than three percent of the cable segment (approximately 180,000 Extra Innings subscribers) – who cannot receive DIRECTV service.  This translates to roughly 5,000 subscribers – each of whom can access the games over the Internet.  Moreover, this agreement does not deny a single fan the right to follow his or her home team.  In all of its programming arrangements, DIRECTV has been respectful of fans’ rights to view their home team sports.  Extra Innings is a premium package of out-of-town games – designed to serve baseball’s most avid fans without adversely affecting viewership of MLB’s national and local telecasts.  By contrast, our cable competitors have withheld core home team sports programming from nearly half a million satellite customers in Philadelphia and San Diego.


Fourth, the marketplace will continue to provide subscribers without Extra Innings a wealth of options for watching their favorite sport.  If Extra Innings were to disappear tomorrow, MLB would still offer more televised games by far than any other U.S. sport.  Regardless of the MVPD to which they subscribe, fans throughout the country can watch their home team on broadcast television or RSNs – assuming that cable-affiliated RSNs continue to make their programming available to all MVPDs at non-discriminatory rates.  In addition, fans without Extra Innings can still watch an impressive number of out-of-town games.  On average, more than 400 games are televised in each market – on local broadcast television, RSNs, and MLB’s national partners FOX, TBS, and ESPN.

IV. A Broader Review of Competition Policy May Be Appropriate.

Members of this Committee are naturally concerned about consumer choice and access to content.  So is DIRECTV.  But Congress cannot examine these issues in a vacuum – and certainly should not start with this arm’s length, pro-competitive deal.  If it truly seeks to ensure that every American has a choice among video providers and access to content, this Committee can choose among any number of issues that affect far more consumers.
If, for example, this Committee is concerned about the ability of subscribers to switch MVPDs, it might examine why cable operators dramatically increase the price for their broadband service to subscribers that switch from cable to satellite for video service.  In Washington DC, for example, Comcast charges $33.99 for Internet service when bundled with video and voice, but $57.95 for stand-alone Internet – a 70 percent increase in price.  Even though DIRECTV offers a lower price for a better video service, consumers with cable modems lose money by choosing DIRECTV.  If Congress seeks to maximize consumer choice – as it should – cable’s tying of Internet and video services is worthy of review.
   
If this Committee is concerned that viewers might be denied access to content they wish to view, it might examine whether cable operators should be able to degrade the service their broadband subscribers receive when accessing video content from non-affiliated websites (or entities that do not pay to ensure access), or preclude such access altogether.  As more and more video content migrates to the Internet, cable operators will increasingly have the incentive and ability to determine what their broadband subscribers can and cannot see.  A cable operator could even, for example, prohibit a baseball fan from visiting MLB.com (or, more likely, could “slow-roll” communications to that site compared with communications from its own site).
 
If this Committee is concerned about bundling channels in contract negotiations, it might wish to focus more broadly on tying arrangements imposed by parties with market power.  For example, Comcast recently required DIRECTV to distribute its “G4” gaming channel to 80 percent of its subscribers in order to continue to carry Comcast SportsNet Mid Atlantic at market rates.  A broader examination of arrangements like this would consider the pros and cons of today’s programming marketplace and possible ideas for revising it.
 
And finally, if this Committee is concerned about sports programming, it should begin by examining the worst instances of sports withholding.  Congress and the FCC have found repeatedly over the years that cable operators can abuse their formidable market power by arranging to withhold programming they own.  And they do that today in Philadelphia and San Diego, where half a million satellite subscribers cannot watch their home teams.  Surely that – and not an arm’s length, non-exclusive, pro-competitive deal such as that between DIRECTV and MLB for carriage of out-of-town games – is worthy of this Committee’s consideration.

*                         *                         *

The video marketplace continues to evolve as competition takes hold under the regime Congress has put in place.  DIRECTV’s arrangement with MLB is part of that process – the result of fair and open competition for programming that even today remains available to DIRECTV’s rivals.  DIRECTV intends to upgrade Extra Innings significantly, giving avid baseball fans more than they have ever had from this package before.  We will also make the transition of any subscriber who wants this programming from DIRECTV as seamless as possible.  In the end, then, DIRECTV’s agreement with MLB is an example of how the competitive marketplace created by this Committee is working – not how it needs to be changed.

[1]       Time Warner’s top programming negotiator recently said as much – stating that she was not sure why people have criticized the deal as if it were “rigged” against competition, when the issue really boils down to the “evaluation of whether acquiring programming is too expensive or not.” SkyReport E-News, Mar. 13, 2007.
[2]       SkyReport E-News, Mar. 13, 2007.
[3]       General Motors Corp., Hughes Electronics Corp., and The News Corporation Limited, 19 FCC Rcd. 473 (2004) (“News-Hughes”).
[4]       Annual Assessment of the Status of Competition in the Market for the Delivery of Video Programming, 21 FCC Rcd. 2503 App. C (2006)
[5]       See Steve Donohue, “DirecTV Tops J.D. Power Survey,” Multichannel News, Aug. 16, 2006, available at http://www.multichannel.com/article/CA6363083.html.
[6]       See, e.g., Peter Grant, Plugging the Web Into the TV, Wall St. J., Aug. 4, 2006, at A11 (describing the rapid advances in online video, and stating that, with a TiVo device, one “can’t even tell whether it came from the TV or off the Internet.”).
[7]      Not to minimize the inconvenience to these customers, but it is worth noting that that tens of millions of  subscribers “churn,” switching video providers every year.

 
 
Banner

Poll

Should MLB Force Jeffery Loria to Sell the Marlins?